Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » A special referendum election morning PB/Polling Matters po

15678911»

Comments

  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @Coral: If anyone fancies a topical bet today, 'Brexit' is an outsider in the 6:10 Newbury...

    https://t.co/TsIUBexvHa https://t.co/Xl75MboJMr

    ...and an outsider in the main event...
  • Scrapheap_as_wasScrapheap_as_was Posts: 10,069

    Populus online

    Remain 55

    Leave 45

    Sample 4,700

    Fieldwork 21st/22nd June

    which is spot on what I've been predicting since the start of this nightmare period.. but it's only a poll..
  • David_EvershedDavid_Evershed Posts: 6,506
    weejonnie said:

    Suppose Mr Cameron stands outside No 10 and says (following a narrow Leave win)( as he is fully entitled to do).

    "The results of the referendum are inconclusive. I therefore feel that as it is in the best interests of the Country, I will not be invoking article 50."

    More realistically he will go back to the EU, negotiate some more meaningless concessions and have another referendum.
  • John_N4John_N4 Posts: 553
    edited June 2016

    Mortimer said:


    Order in council? Doesn't that need a meeting of PC?

    Dave signs something.

    A bit like the signing of The Treaty of Lisbon, our PM just signs it.
    In practice, yes. I can't see an ambassador, the monarch or the cabinet objecting when even 50% plus 1 vote in the referendum would give Cameron a clear popular mandate for invoking it.
  • PlatoSaidPlatoSaid Posts: 10,383

    IanB2 said:

    Blueberry said:

    Just voted. Was surprised the ballots are done on white, photocopier paper, black ink. The ballot papers for our work bake-off are more secure than that.

    Your bake-off ballot papers are all individually serial-numbered on the back, perforated by a pattern of dots kept secret until the day, and counted out and back to balance the count with the number issued? And you keep a complete record of which numbered paper went to which voter? Impressive stuff indeed....
    Our antiquated polling system works very well indeed. It would be very hard - some might say impossible - to game it to a large degree.

    Widespread modern postal voting is less so, although I doubt PV fraud is as widespread as some think.

    In comparison, electronic voting is untrustworthy with current technology. And that goes for both EV-at-polling-station as well as EV-from-home systems.
    Welcome back - hope you're in finer fettle.
  • Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 62,080
    Mr. Evershed, an alternative is that Cameron invokes Article 50, negotiates a ****ing awful 'deal' and then has a referendum on that, or staying in after all.
  • Richard_NabaviRichard_Nabavi Posts: 30,822
    Scott_P said:

    @PolhomeEditor: EXCL: Heathrow runway decision 'in two weeks' https://t.co/sEedJKOLov https://t.co/lgerT9k2im

    Actually that's a rather important point in terms of what might happen in any reshuffle (assuming a Remain result). It would give a good excuse for Boris to be out of government, voluntarily or not. It could also lead to further problems for Cameron with a group of Leaver/anti-Heathrow malcontents gathered around Boris.
  • WandererWanderer Posts: 3,838
    SeanT said:

    Jobabob said:

    I ended at the polling station this morning where I began in February - bitterly torn, heart saying one thing, the head saying another, and irritated and annoyed that we're having a vote at this time on this question, and feeling let down by the Prime Minister, who ultimately is responsible for this, his hopeless renegotiation and for the fallout that follows whatever the outcome.

    I voted Remain, I know many on here will be dismayed by that, in truth I am a little myself, but the "head" won out. Cool hard economic reasoning (and a degree of self-interest) over emotion. I did at least hover over the boxes rather than my usual confident crossing of a box without a moment's hesitation. I even felt a bit choked.

    I just want this all to be over, and let's get on with our lives again...!

    Hear hear.

    NEVER AGAIN.
    This is bollocks. All this bleating, mewling crap about the referendum being awful, divisive, nasty, blah blah. This is democracy, it is rough and ready. This vote is especially rough because we, as a nation, are deciding our future. But WE are deciding. The people. As it should be.

    The alternative: of smooth, technocratic consensus, where even the most fundamental decisions are taken by an elite, is what they have in North Korea.
    I think this question, and other big constitutional questions, need to be decided by referendum. I very much want us to remain a representative democracy though, not one where bullshit "propositions" are subject to plebiscites every ten minutes.
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 43,993

    IanB2 said:

    Blueberry said:

    Just voted. Was surprised the ballots are done on white, photocopier paper, black ink. The ballot papers for our work bake-off are more secure than that.

    Your bake-off ballot papers are all individually serial-numbered on the back, perforated by a pattern of dots kept secret until the day, and counted out and back to balance the count with the number issued? And you keep a complete record of which numbered paper went to which voter? Impressive stuff indeed....
    Our antiquated polling system works very well indeed. It would be very hard - some might say impossible - to game it to a large degree.

    Widespread modern postal voting is less so, although I doubt PV fraud is as widespread as some think.

    In comparison, electronic voting is untrustworthy with current technology. And that goes for both EV-at-polling-station as well as EV-from-home systems.
    Welcome back JJ. Really good to see you on here. Hope the health is still improving.
    Thanks. Sadly not. Have emerged from my hovel for the fun 'n games today and tonight, after which I might re-lurk.
    Good to see you back JJ, I wondered about you yesterday. How is the sprog?
    He's in fine fettle thanks - he's two next week. I've been getting lots of help from my family and in-laws, so he's very spoilt with attention.

    It's fascinating seeing to watch his character developing. He seems both similar to his parents (e.g. he is an explorer and never sits still), yet also undoubtedly an individual.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,429

    NEW THREAD NEW THREADO

  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,295

    Disraeli said:

    TOPPING said:

    OllyT said:

    The big fight today is between those who want to leave the EU - and those who want to leave the EU but are too scared of the consequences.

    The number of people who want to stay in the EU because it is wonderful are tiny.

    I would estimate about 20-25% positively want to stay, particularly at the younger end of the spectrum. I would also say that most people don't have a scooby doo about the EU. The ignorance and misinformation is appalling when you hear Joe Public being interviewed. It has become the convenient scapegoat to blame for all their problems. That's why Leave is doing so well, they can project everyone's concerns on the EU and promise them everything will be better if we just leave.

    Of course if we do leave within a year everyone will be blaming all their woes on Brexit.

    I am sanguine about the result, fortunate enough not to be affected either way but I am expecting the buyer's remorse to swift and harsh if we leave, particularly once we opt for a solution that maintains freedom of movement as I am certain we will.
    I'm also expecting buyer's remorse to be swift and harsh if we vote to Remain! The EU has been walking on egg-shells, saying nothing that could rock the boat for a couple of months. There's going to be pent-up stuff coming out that will get more than a few people spitting nails...
    I'm sure.

    And then, Dave produces his piece of paper saying: No Ever Closer Union.

    And PUUFFFFFFFFFT! All that pent-up stuff will be repelled.
    Ah! The old "Holding up a piece of paper with a solemn promise on it" tactic.

    Remind me again how well that worked out for Neville Chamberlain.
    Actually it worked out very well for both Chamberlain and the country. It did not stop WW2 of course, but it bought enough time for the UK to rearm and especially for Fighter Command to get in place Radar (as it became known) and to build enough modern fighters to enable the Battle of Britain to be won.

    Chamberlain, by then very ill with terminal cancer, was forced to step down after the Norway fiasco but nonetheless played a very important part in keeping Churchill in power against the machinations of the surrender monkey, Lord Halifax.

    Chamberlain has been the victim of shocking bad press, much of which is undeserved.
    Indeed. And of course he was very popular with most Tories at the time - indeed one Winston Churchill faced a vote of censure from his own constituency party, which he only defeated by a single vote, for his outspoken opposition to Chamberlain's foreign policy
  • John_N4John_N4 Posts: 553

    Sean_F said:

    FTSE up over 1.5%, someone thinks Remain will win.

    The city boys clearly seeing polling / info we aren't, that shows Remain way ahead.
    No, they're reacting to the public polling. There's no Holy Grail of absolutely accurate private polling that only insiders have access to.

    There's a hell of a lot of very ropey private polling.
    The polls are showing a statistical tie and are unproven at best.

    Google predicts Brexit win.
    Source please. That company certainly has its fingers on a lot of information.
  • BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 8,797

    IanB2 said:

    Blueberry said:

    Just voted. Was surprised the ballots are done on white, photocopier paper, black ink. The ballot papers for our work bake-off are more secure than that.

    Your bake-off ballot papers are all individually serial-numbered on the back, perforated by a pattern of dots kept secret until the day, and counted out and back to balance the count with the number issued? And you keep a complete record of which numbered paper went to which voter? Impressive stuff indeed....
    Our antiquated polling system works very well indeed. It would be very hard - some might say impossible - to game it to a large degree.

    Widespread modern postal voting is less so, although I doubt PV fraud is as widespread as some think.

    In comparison, electronic voting is untrustworthy with current technology. And that goes for both EV-at-polling-station as well as EV-from-home systems.
    My problem with electronic voting is not the security - after all we use electronic banking. It is the ease of electronic voting that worries me.

    It debases the vote to clicking on "like" or vote up, vote down. It trivialises it. I like the drama and seriousness of going to the polling station and marking your cross with a pencil. It is serious stuff - not to be dumbed down.
  • ArtistArtist Posts: 1,893
    Seeing as it's their first poll in this campaign, we have nothing to compare that Populus with really.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 61,261
    Mortimer said:

    Been telling for 90 minutes now at a polling station in Hart. Steady flow of voters. 2-3 every 2-3 minutes.

    About seven or eight very enthusiastic Leavers keen to tell me they're Leave, giving encouragement and thumbs up.

    Remain lady next to us hasn't got any of that but about half of people are just staring at their feet, or ignoring both sides, and walking straight into the polling station.

    Are you actually telling - i.e. collecting polling numbers? Impressive GOTV operation if so.
    No, neither Remain nor Leave are. There are two Leavers and one Remainer.

    We are just smiling and showing a presence, and keeping a broad tally of turnout rate.
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 22,451
    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
  • AnorakAnorak Posts: 6,621
    edited June 2016
    Mortimer said:

    Mortimer said:

    @Mortimer There's a base percentage of people in polls who think that X should resign no matter what the reason. In that context, only 40% wanting the Prime Minister to resign if Leave win is surprisingly low.

    I can't see him hanging around too long in the event of a Leave win, mind.

    'Spose.

    TBH if Leave win, I wouldn't necessarily want him to resign straight away. Announce his intention to, sure, but not actually go to the palace.
    I've urged Dave to do this in the event of a Leave victory.

    https://twitter.com/TSEofPB/status/745731968025911296/photo/1
    Leaving aside whether this would be the right thing to do, how is article 50 invoked?

    Order in council? Doesn't that need a meeting of PC?
    It's invoked by sending a Spitfire painted in the Unition Jack, and piloted by a cigar-smoking bulldog, to circle Brussels. Said aircraft is fitted with colossal speakers belting out Rule Britannia and some Vera Lynn classics. Leaflets on how to make a proper roast dinner, with spotted dick and custard for afters are dropped every 30 minutes.
  • old_labourold_labour Posts: 3,238

    Scott_P said:

    @PolhomeEditor: EXCL: Heathrow runway decision 'in two weeks' https://t.co/sEedJKOLov https://t.co/lgerT9k2im

    Actually that's a rather important point in terms of what might happen in any reshuffle (assuming a Remain result). It would give a good excuse for Boris to be out of government, voluntarily or not. It could also lead to further problems for Cameron with a group of Leaver/anti-Heathrow malcontents gathered around Boris.
    I think Nicola supports Heathrow expansion.
  • HurstLlamaHurstLlama Posts: 9,098

    IanB2 said:

    Blueberry said:

    Just voted. Was surprised the ballots are done on white, photocopier paper, black ink. The ballot papers for our work bake-off are more secure than that.

    Your bake-off ballot papers are all individually serial-numbered on the back, perforated by a pattern of dots kept secret until the day, and counted out and back to balance the count with the number issued? And you keep a complete record of which numbered paper went to which voter? Impressive stuff indeed....
    Our antiquated polling system works very well indeed. It would be very hard - some might say impossible - to game it to a large degree.

    Widespread modern postal voting is less so, although I doubt PV fraud is as widespread as some think.

    In comparison, electronic voting is untrustworthy with current technology. And that goes for both EV-at-polling-station as well as EV-from-home systems.
    Welcome back JJ. Really good to see you on here. Hope the health is still improving.
    Thanks. Sadly not. Have emerged from my hovel for the fun 'n games today and tonight, after which I might re-lurk.
    Wotcha, Mr. Jessup, great that you can join us for this day at least. Your contributions to the Site have been sadly missed. Get well soon, old boy and best wishes to the nipper and your good lady.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,554
    All over bar the voting....
  • Scrapheap_as_wasScrapheap_as_was Posts: 10,069
    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Bombshell

    Mike Smithson ‏@MSmithsonPB · 26s27 seconds ago

    Note the final Populus poll with the 10% REMAIN lead was online

  • Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 62,080
    Mr. Eagles, no link to the new thread at the top of the page.
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 43,993
    Nu thread disappearo.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663

    NEW THREAD NEW THREADO

    WHERE
  • Richard_NabaviRichard_Nabavi Posts: 30,822
    SeanT said:

    The alternative: of smooth, technocratic consensus, where even the most fundamental decisions are taken by an elite, is what they have in North Korea.

    To be fair, the smooth technocratic consensus is periodically shaken up by gruesome public executions of randomly-selected technocrats.
  • BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 8,797

    Scott_P said:

    @PolhomeEditor: EXCL: Heathrow runway decision 'in two weeks' https://t.co/sEedJKOLov https://t.co/lgerT9k2im

    Actually that's a rather important point in terms of what might happen in any reshuffle (assuming a Remain result). It would give a good excuse for Boris to be out of government, voluntarily or not. It could also lead to further problems for Cameron with a group of Leaver/anti-Heathrow malcontents gathered around Boris.
    I think Nicola supports Heathrow expansion.
    The SNP is neutral over the third runway - "whatever is best for Scotland".
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,734
    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
  • DaemonBarberDaemonBarber Posts: 1,626
    404 city man....
  • JobabobJobabob Posts: 3,807
    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    Is the Euro even a realistic prospect?
  • PongPong Posts: 4,693
    Leave out to 10s
  • DanSmithDanSmith Posts: 1,215
    Jobabob said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    Is the Euro even a realistic prospect?
    If we're going to be in the EU, lets do it properly. The full works.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663
    Jobabob said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    Is the Euro even a realistic prospect?
    I do hope so.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,295
    edited June 2016
    PlatoSaid said:

    Presumably Conservative, Labour, Lib Dem and Green are using their party systems for the REMAIN Get Out The Vote process.

    But only UKIP using their party system for the LEAVE GOTV process.

    Disadvantage LEAVE.

    The Tory Party is officially neutral - I don't think they can use central data at all. Not sure about a local party email list etc
    They are (edit/ reply to original post) - but I would be surprised if this data was being shared between the parties, or with any central campaign, for reasonably obvious reasons. Each party will concentrate on its own known supporters, or in some areas I believe informal agreements have been made on who leads the campaign in each ward.
  • TheWhiteRabbitTheWhiteRabbit Posts: 12,454
    IanB2 said:

    PlatoSaid said:

    Presumably Conservative, Labour, Lib Dem and Green are using their party systems for the REMAIN Get Out The Vote process.

    But only UKIP using their party system for the LEAVE GOTV process.

    Disadvantage LEAVE.

    The Tory Party is officially neutral - I don't think they can use central data at all. Not sure about a local party email list etc
    They are - but I would be surprised if this data was being shared between the parties, or with any central campaign, for reasonably obvious reasons. Each party will concentrate on its own known supporters, or in some areas I believe informal agreements have been made on who leads the campaign in each ward.
    A friend who campaigns for Remain says they haven't got access to the usual Tory data. (I believe Labour are sharing theirs though)
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 43,993
    Barnesian said:

    IanB2 said:

    Blueberry said:

    Just voted. Was surprised the ballots are done on white, photocopier paper, black ink. The ballot papers for our work bake-off are more secure than that.

    Your bake-off ballot papers are all individually serial-numbered on the back, perforated by a pattern of dots kept secret until the day, and counted out and back to balance the count with the number issued? And you keep a complete record of which numbered paper went to which voter? Impressive stuff indeed....
    Our antiquated polling system works very well indeed. It would be very hard - some might say impossible - to game it to a large degree.

    Widespread modern postal voting is less so, although I doubt PV fraud is as widespread as some think.

    In comparison, electronic voting is untrustworthy with current technology. And that goes for both EV-at-polling-station as well as EV-from-home systems.
    My problem with electronic voting is not the security - after all we use electronic banking. It is the ease of electronic voting that worries me.

    It debases the vote to clicking on "like" or vote up, vote down. It trivialises it. I like the drama and seriousness of going to the polling station and marking your cross with a pencil. It is serious stuff - not to be dumbed down.
    You make a good point. But do think that electronic banking is a red herring - and it is not as if ebanking is exactly secure as it is.

    The main problems with evoting IMO are:
    1) It introduces opportunities to commit massive, widescale fraud that cannot be easily committed with our current system.
    2) Detecting fraudulent voting is much, much harder.
    3) It reduces confidence in the system (a similar argument can be made for increasing PV participation).
  • I voted unselfishly today. Remain is better for me, wealthy and City based. Leave will lead to market chaos in the short term (thank GO for egging this on instead of pouring cold water) and political strife. My own livelihood will be affected.

    But Remain is a betrayal of the UK in the long-term. We are not in the Euro, but its failure pours out victims to our shore and loony Merkel welcomes the diaspora of the Middle East too.

    Wages for the poor are held down and our economic productivity has fallen as low wages mean companies investment as they can make profits with 0% interest rates and falling wages bills.

    Meanwhile, house prices rise and pressure on services grows, all for people who can't afford an alternative.

    Hoping my 5-1 leave bet comes off, but we'll see soon!
  • John_N4John_N4 Posts: 553
    weejonnie said:

    Suppose Mr Cameron stands outside No 10 and says (following a narrow Leave win)( as he is fully entitled to do).

    "The results of the referendum are inconclusive. I therefore feel that as it is in the best interests of the Country, I will not be invoking article 50."

    One scenario would be an immediate confidence vote in the Commons - not in the government, but in Cameron. Labour abstains and Cameron loses.
  • JobabobJobabob Posts: 3,807
    Jesus wept, Leave is out beyond 9...
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 22,451
    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    REMAIN leads have been getting incrementally bigger as the polls have appeared... Could well finish at 60/40 or better for REMAIN.

    Euro is back on the agenda after today for sure.
  • eekeek Posts: 28,797
    Pulpstar said:

    Jobabob said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    Is the Euro even a realistic prospect?
    I do hope so.
    Why? Give me one economic reason to tie our economy with the rest of europe in a way that means you cannot escape a perpetual recession....



  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663
    Can "Remain" keep itself under 54.5 pretty please.........
  • David_EvershedDavid_Evershed Posts: 6,506
    SCENARIO

    - Most people registering late were not new young electors but dupliclates of existing voters

    - Young people turning up to vote less than they told the pollsters because on holiday or lazy

    - Older people made more determined to vote by the bitter campaign

    - Shy LEAVE voters too ashamed about Jo Cox to admit it to pollsters

    - Rain causes luke warm REMAIN supporters not to bother to vote

    - Postal votes were cast at the time LEAVE were well ahead

    - UKIP repeat their GOTV operation when they won the European elections

    RESULT. LEAVE win 55/45.
  • JobabobJobabob Posts: 3,807

    SeanT said:

    The alternative: of smooth, technocratic consensus, where even the most fundamental decisions are taken by an elite, is what they have in North Korea.

    To be fair, the smooth technocratic consensus is periodically shaken up by gruesome public executions of randomly-selected technocrats.
    Indeed. It's called representative democracy and it's a terrible system but it's better than anything else anyone has ever come up with. Especially referendums, which are bloody awful.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,295
    Pong said:

    Leave out to 10s

    The FTSE climbed until 0930 and has been treading water since, the £/$ climbed thru 1030 and has slipped back a little since...
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 43,993

    IanB2 said:

    Blueberry said:

    Just voted. Was surprised the ballots are done on white, photocopier paper, black ink. The ballot papers for our work bake-off are more secure than that.

    Your bake-off ballot papers are all individually serial-numbered on the back, perforated by a pattern of dots kept secret until the day, and counted out and back to balance the count with the number issued? And you keep a complete record of which numbered paper went to which voter? Impressive stuff indeed....
    Our antiquated polling system works very well indeed. It would be very hard - some might say impossible - to game it to a large degree.

    Widespread modern postal voting is less so, although I doubt PV fraud is as widespread as some think.

    In comparison, electronic voting is untrustworthy with current technology. And that goes for both EV-at-polling-station as well as EV-from-home systems.
    Welcome back JJ. Really good to see you on here. Hope the health is still improving.
    Thanks. Sadly not. Have emerged from my hovel for the fun 'n games today and tonight, after which I might re-lurk.
    Wotcha, Mr. Jessup, great that you can join us for this day at least. Your contributions to the Site have been sadly missed. Get well soon, old boy and best wishes to the nipper and your good lady.
    Cheers. Hope you are in good health as well.

    (And to everyone else, leaver or remainer, Labour or Conservative. But no-one else. ;) )
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663
    eek said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Jobabob said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    Is the Euro even a realistic prospect?
    I do hope so.
    Why? Give me one economic reason to tie our economy with the rest of europe in a way that means you cannot escape a perpetual recession....
    Less exchange difference for accountants to journal.
  • david_herdsondavid_herdson Posts: 18,001
    Leave has now traded as high as 10.5 .

    In other betfair news, the implied expected turnout from that market is 71-72%, which would be the biggest UK poll since at least the 1997 GE (which was 71.3%).
  • DanSmithDanSmith Posts: 1,215

    SCENARIO

    - Most people registering late were not new young electors but dupliclates of existing voters

    - Young people turning up to vote less than they told the pollsters because on holiday or lazy

    - Older people made more determined to vote by the bitter campaign

    - Shy LEAVE voters too ashamed about Jo Cox to admit it to pollsters

    - Rain causes luke warm REMAIN supporters not to bother to vote

    - Postal votes were cast at the time LEAVE were well ahead

    - UKIP repeat their GOTV operation when they won the European elections

    RESULT. LEAVE win 55/45.

    Keep an eye on postal votes, I think they will make this a lot closer than the polling of the last couple of days suggests.
  • Nu thread disappearo.

    Great to see you back JJ - just yesterday I was wishing it could be so and then, as if by magic, you appear!
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,734
    GIN1138 said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    REMAIN leads have been getting incrementally bigger as the polls have appeared... Could well finish at 60/40 or better for REMAIN.

    Euro is back on the agenda after today for sure.
    No, final yougov 51/49 Remain, final Mori 52/48 even final Comres 54/46, final Survation Remain 1% ahead and TNS and Opinium had Leave narrowly ahead. With higher older voter turnout, even with ABC1s for Remain I expect it to be around 52/48, not one poll is anywhere near 60%+ Remain
  • LennonLennon Posts: 1,784
    Jobabob said:

    Jesus wept, Leave is out beyond 9...

    What price was Scottish Indie on the day - as long as 9's / 10's?
  • John_N4John_N4 Posts: 553
    Jobabob said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    Is the Euro even a realistic prospect?
    I wish it were. Britain should have joined the euro years ago. But you might as well ask whether tearing up the opt-out from "ever closer union" is a realistic prospect.
  • My twitter timeline and facebook feed running at 99% Remain, so based on indyref weightings - expect Leave to win.

    Perhaps I'm clutching at straws, but all this Remain excitement does seem a bit bubble-ish.
    My bubble is pretty much all middle class types. My right wing Tory mate has finally plumped for out but that's it. However, parents of these people are strongly pro Leave. Lovely sunny day in Scotland, polling station was quiet at 7am, turnout might not be above GE levels in Scotland.
  • Scrapheap_as_wasScrapheap_as_was Posts: 10,069
    We need a 'good' margin I think as otherwise all the 'rigging' and cheating complaints will just become mega-nat..

    Damian Thompson ‏@holysmoke · 14s15 seconds ago
    These men have played every dirty trick in the book to keep us in the corrupt, collapsing EU. They can get stuffed.

  • AnorakAnorak Posts: 6,621
    SeanT said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Much as I mistrust the europhile traitors who govern us, there really WON'T be a campaign to join the euro tomorrow, and probably not in our lifetimes, either.

    For a start such a thing means a Referendum. I think people using the R word in government in the next five-ten years will be sent to manage penguins in West Falklands.
    Well you've got 45% (Leavers) + a healthy chunk of the Remainers would vote against the Euro. It would sink 80:20 in any referendum.
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 22,451
    SeanT said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Much as I mistrust the europhile traitors who govern us, there really WON'T be a campaign to join the euro tomorrow, and probably not in our lifetimes, either.

    For a start such a thing means a Referendum. I think people using the R word in government in the next five-ten years will be sent to manage penguins in West Falklands.
    They don't have to do it with a referendum... And I suspect when we eventually do join the Euro it will be via a general election manifesto commitment.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,734
    Jobabob said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    Is the Euro even a realistic prospect?
    No, I will vote Remain today, I would vote Leave if the Euro was ever proposed and I suspect at least half of Remain voters would too, if not more!
  • RobCRobC Posts: 398
    edited June 2016
    Populus is extraordinary. Have northern Labour brexiters everyone was panicking about 10 days ago decamped en masse to Remain after the Cox murder? Or more likely is it just the last minute swingback everyone predicted?
  • Scrapheap_as_wasScrapheap_as_was Posts: 10,069
    GIN1138 said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    REMAIN leads have been getting incrementally bigger as the polls have appeared... Could well finish at 60/40 or better for REMAIN.

    Euro is back on the agenda after today for sure.
    I'm a dripping wet Tory and it's not on my agenda.
  • LucyJonesLucyJones Posts: 651
    edited June 2016
    weejonnie said:

    Anecdote.

    Found it very difficult to get response from VoteLeave website.

    I got response from the website after a couple of weeks - they phoned me up and gave me the contact details of our local organiser - Claire Pearsall, Conservative Councillor for Sevenoaks, I'm looking at you! Who said "Thanks a lot - I'll be in touch soon". Never got back to me again, despite being prompted several times.

    Quite hacked off, to be honest and feeling quite guilty. Wishing I had done a Casino_Royale and just done something independently.
  • ArtistArtist Posts: 1,893
    If remain does win comfortably, politically it will have been very generous of Labour to have helped save Osborne and Cameron in these last few weeks.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663
    Will either side top 100,000 votes in Sunderland council area..........
  • kjohnwkjohnw Posts: 1,456
    GIN1138 said:

    SeanT said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Much as I mistrust the europhile traitors who govern us, there really WON'T be a campaign to join the euro tomorrow, and probably not in our lifetimes, either.

    For a start such a thing means a Referendum. I think people using the R word in government in the next five-ten years will be sent to manage penguins in West Falklands.
    They don't have to do it with a referendum... And I suspect when we eventually do join the Euro it will be via a general election manifesto commitment.
    but we have the referendum lock enshrined in law
  • Richard_NabaviRichard_Nabavi Posts: 30,822
    edited June 2016
    Yes, welcome back JJ. It's been great to see some of our old friends/adversaries reappearing, such as the excellent Yellow Submarine, AndyJS and others. Let's hope JackW too is well enough to pop in and tell us how it's all going to turn out.
  • DanSmithDanSmith Posts: 1,215
    HYUFD said:

    Jobabob said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    Is the Euro even a realistic prospect?
    No, I will vote Remain today, I would vote Leave if the Euro was ever proposed and I suspect at least half of Remain voters would too, if not more!
    60/40 would be a clear mandate for the UK to press on with full integration into the EU project, this was your chance to vote out, you didn't take it.
  • Scrapheap_as_wasScrapheap_as_was Posts: 10,069
    RobC said:

    Populus is extraordinary. Have northern Labour brexiters everyone was panicking about decamped en masse to Remain after the Cox murder? Or more likely is it just the last minute swingback everyone predicted?

    I've always assumed the latter and it was this pattern which led me to lump in to the Betfair market when Remain broke 1.6 last week as that was the classic 'wobble bottom' moment as I think I posted once or twice.
  • AndrewAndrew Posts: 2,900
    Pulpstar said:

    Can "Remain" keep itself under 54.5 pretty please.........

    I think you'll be OK :-) Not by much mind.

  • TheWhiteRabbitTheWhiteRabbit Posts: 12,454
    DanSmith said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jobabob said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    Is the Euro even a realistic prospect?
    No, I will vote Remain today, I would vote Leave if the Euro was ever proposed and I suspect at least half of Remain voters would too, if not more!
    60/40 would be a clear mandate for the UK to press on with full integration into the EU project, this was your chance to vote out, you didn't take it.
    What a load of crap. The idea that the UK is now going to federalise is just utter rubbish.
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    edited June 2016
    If Gibraltar is the first area to be declared tonight, it'll be amusing watching the betting market overreacting to the result.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,295

    SCENARIO

    - Most people registering late were not new young electors but dupliclates of existing voters

    - Young people turning up to vote less than they told the pollsters because on holiday or lazy

    - Older people made more determined to vote by the bitter campaign

    - Shy LEAVE voters too ashamed about Jo Cox to admit it to pollsters

    - Rain causes luke warm REMAIN supporters not to bother to vote

    - Postal votes were cast at the time LEAVE were well ahead

    - UKIP repeat their GOTV operation when they won the European elections

    RESULT. LEAVE win 55/45.

    Possible. Equally:

    - the youngsters would otherwise have been unable to vote
    - early indications of turnout suggest GE levels or better
    - older people are risk-averse and some may be drifting away from Leave
    - shy Remain voters in Essex and elsewhere have wisely kept their heads down
    - the rain is falling mostly on Leave areas south and east of London
    - most postal voters weren't going to change their minds anyway
    - as well as the elderly, PVs include lots of students, ethnic minorities, and EU ex-pats
    - GE evidence is that UKIP gets stretched in nationwide contests and is no match for the established parties
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663
    AndyJS said:

    If Gibraltar is the first area to be declared tonight, it'll be amusing watching the betting market overreacting to the result.

    Isn't Gibrltar a Friday dec ?
  • DanSmithDanSmith Posts: 1,215

    DanSmith said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jobabob said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    Is the Euro even a realistic prospect?
    No, I will vote Remain today, I would vote Leave if the Euro was ever proposed and I suspect at least half of Remain voters would too, if not more!
    60/40 would be a clear mandate for the UK to press on with full integration into the EU project, this was your chance to vote out, you didn't take it.
    What a load of crap. The idea that the UK is now going to federalise is just utter rubbish.
    The people have spoken...
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,734
    DanSmith said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jobabob said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    Is the Euro even a realistic prospect?
    No, I will vote Remain today, I would vote Leave if the Euro was ever proposed and I suspect at least half of Remain voters would too, if not more!
    60/40 would be a clear mandate for the UK to press on with full integration into the EU project, this was your chance to vote out, you didn't take it.
    It won't be 60/40
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,164
    DanSmith said:

    DanSmith said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jobabob said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @PopulusPolls: Populus Final Pre-Ref Poll (4700, Online) 55% REMAIN: 45% LEAVE. Fieldwork 21-06-16 to midnight 22-06-16. https://t.co/QuYl5dSwle

    A landslide for REMAIN on the cards at this rate?

    Campaign to get us into the Euro starts tomorrow...
    Even 55%-45% would be the same as Scotland, needs 60%+ Remain for the Euro to be even considered
    Is the Euro even a realistic prospect?
    No, I will vote Remain today, I would vote Leave if the Euro was ever proposed and I suspect at least half of Remain voters would too, if not more!
    60/40 would be a clear mandate for the UK to press on with full integration into the EU project, this was your chance to vote out, you didn't take it.
    What a load of crap. The idea that the UK is now going to federalise is just utter rubbish.
    The people have spoken...
    With the remain side saying we have an opt out of further integration.
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 64,150
    Leavers keep referring to the weather being helpful but hasn't large parts of the south east been flooded. Just seen on Sky a couple in Essex flooded, at one time knee deep. This could effect leavers as well. If your home is flooded you may have bigger priorities.
  • FrankBoothFrankBooth Posts: 10,001
    I've always planned on voting Remain but I don't really want to win by 10 points.
  • PlatoSaidPlatoSaid Posts: 10,383

    I voted unselfishly today. Remain is better for me, wealthy and City based. Leave will lead to market chaos in the short term (thank GO for egging this on instead of pouring cold water) and political strife. My own livelihood will be affected.

    But Remain is a betrayal of the UK in the long-term. We are not in the Euro, but its failure pours out victims to our shore and loony Merkel welcomes the diaspora of the Middle East too.

    Wages for the poor are held down and our economic productivity has fallen as low wages mean companies investment as they can make profits with 0% interest rates and falling wages bills.

    Meanwhile, house prices rise and pressure on services grows, all for people who can't afford an alternative.

    Hoping my 5-1 leave bet comes off, but we'll see soon!

    Chapeau, Sir.
  • Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 62,080
    Mr. Smith, I didn't see an option to join the eurozone on the ballot paper.
  • CD13CD13 Posts: 6,367
    edited June 2016
    Never been convinced by an EU army. The UN forces always seem to be ineffectual and having several nationalities together isn't a recipe for efficiency.

    And I'd better not mention the old joke about Italian tanks. Oh, alright, I will. Four reverse gears, and one forward - just in case they're attacked from behind.

    I'm now assuming Juncker will be celebrating tomorrow.

    if Remain win. Congratulations. We'll survive, and tomorrow is another day.
  • DanSmithDanSmith Posts: 1,215

    Mr. Smith, I didn't see an option to join the eurozone on the ballot paper.

    Neither do I, but that's why I'm voing Leave, a big, huge, crushing Remain win gives them a mandate to carry us a long way into the EU project, to a point where joining the Euro is inevitable.
  • weejonnieweejonnie Posts: 3,820

    Barnesian said:

    IanB2 said:

    Blueberry said:

    Just voted. Was surprised the ballots are done on white, photocopier paper, black ink. The ballot papers for our work bake-off are more secure than that.

    Your bake-off ballot papers are all individually serial-numbered on the back, perforated by a pattern of dots kept secret until the day, and counted out and back to balance the count with the number issued? And you keep a complete record of which numbered paper went to which voter? Impressive stuff indeed....
    Our antiquated polling system works very well indeed. It would be very hard - some might say impossible - to game it to a large degree.

    Widespread modern postal voting is less so, although I doubt PV fraud is as widespread as some think.

    In comparison, electronic voting is untrustworthy with current technology. And that goes for both EV-at-polling-station as well as EV-from-home systems.
    My problem with electronic voting is not the security - after all we use electronic banking. It is the ease of electronic voting that worries me.

    It debases the vote to clicking on "like" or vote up, vote down. It trivialises it. I like the drama and seriousness of going to the polling station and marking your cross with a pencil. It is serious stuff - not to be dumbed down.
    You make a good point. But do think that electronic banking is a red herring - and it is not as if ebanking is exactly secure as it is.

    The main problems with evoting IMO are:
    1) It introduces opportunities to commit massive, widescale fraud that cannot be easily committed with our current system.
    2) Detecting fraudulent voting is much, much harder.
    3) It reduces confidence in the system (a similar argument can be made for increasing PV participation).
    Read "The Stainless Steel Rat Runs for President" - Harry Harrison (SF). Not great literature but a real dig at US presidential elections.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,295
    Artist said:

    If remain does win comfortably, politically it will have been very generous of Labour to have helped save Osborne and Cameron in these last few weeks.

    I suspect that comment displays a certain ignorance of the mood within the Tory Party....
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 43,993
    Thanks for the good wishes, everyone.
  • Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 62,080
    New thread appears to be up now.
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 64,150
    Just had an e mail from Paddy Ashdown urging me to vote. I have no contact with Lib Dems, are they sharing databases?
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,295

    Leave has now traded as high as 10.5 .

    In other betfair news, the implied expected turnout from that market is 71-72%, which would be the biggest UK poll since at least the 1997 GE (which was 71.3%).

    The new registration system (IER) will add a percent or two by dint of removing from registers large numbers of people who have moved away or died, plus some who should be on the register but probably wouldn't have voted anyway.
  • weejonnieweejonnie Posts: 3,820

    Just had an e mail from Paddy Ashdown urging me to vote. I have no contact with Lib Dems, are they sharing databases?

    If they are they had better have your permission or they are committing an offence under the DPA.
  • SCENARIO

    - Most people registering late were not new young electors but dupliclates of existing voters

    - Young people turning up to vote less than they told the pollsters because on holiday or lazy

    - Older people made more determined to vote by the bitter campaign

    - Shy LEAVE voters too ashamed about Jo Cox to admit it to pollsters

    - Rain causes luke warm REMAIN supporters not to bother to vote

    - Postal votes were cast at the time LEAVE were well ahead

    - UKIP repeat their GOTV operation when they won the European elections

    RESULT. LEAVE win 55/45.

    And in other news..,.Birmingham City win the Champions League.
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    Lennon said:

    Jobabob said:

    Jesus wept, Leave is out beyond 9...

    What price was Scottish Indie on the day - as long as 9's / 10's?
    About 6-7. Then then the 10pm Yougov came out and it headed off to the stratosphere.z
  • timmotimmo Posts: 1,469
    Has anybody got the link to the dpreadsheet that was posted here awhile back showing the projected paritys for individual boroughs

    Presumably Conservative, Labour, Lib Dem and Green are using their party systems for the REMAIN Get Out The Vote process.

    But only UKIP using their party system for the LEAVE GOTV process.

    Disadvantage LEAVE.

    Nope. The Tory party is neutral.
    Do you really think that Cameron and the remain campaign aren't using votesource? You need to see somebody if you do.
This discussion has been closed.