Ok, if the Russian rout and Putin Untergang come to pass, is it worth having a market on which PBer is the first to turn to a quivering mass of jelly at the prospect of nuclear armageddon?
Apparently the ground on which the Oval is built belongs to the Duchy of Cornwall. And they have made exactly the right decision. And England are off to a flyer too. Football called this wrong but in fairness it wasn't the easiest thing to do.
Michael Atherton: "the authorities are desperate to not do the wrong thing."
Which is precisely why it should have been made clear to them well beforehand that they should carry on as normal unless there are specific practical issues.
The FA have zillions in cash, can buy in all the advice they need on PR.
They can work it out themselves.
These guys - https://www.greatriverrace.org.uk/ - put up a notice saying they were thinking about it. Then decided to turn it into a commerative event. Which I think strikes the right balance for everyone.
@Nigelb its like the Tet Offensive in its use of partisan warfare/sabotage behind American lines, all synchronised superbly with an outright attack on the front
Tet came as a total shock to the USA, at a time when the Americans complacently thought the war was quietening down with no major moves
In many ways thereafter the Tet was a failure for Hanoi and the Yanks pushed the VC back quite easily
But Tet broke the American will to fight. It showed Americans at home the war was unwinnable and the North would never give up, and would endure any cost. From that moment Saigon 73 was inevitable
This is a good interview of Noam Chomsky regarding his views on the war in Ukraine. His assessment of Putin and the causes of the war were pretty accurate, I thought. The surprising aspect of his views are that he condemns the invasion of Ukraine, and agrees that we should be aiding Ukraine in its defence, with military support. But surely that is pretty much exactly what we are doing?
The latter part of the interview was more disappointing, he trots out his more usual positions about everything America doing being bad and takes a benevolent stance to China, Iran etc.
His main message is just to seek out opposing perspectives and think for yourself, something I completely agree with. He is certainly someone who shouldn't just be dismissed as a propogandist etc.
The Ukrainian Kharkiv adventure get ever more spectacular in the speed of their advance.
When the picture was shown with them on the very outskirts of Kupyansk I treated it with caution it deserved. Now they have photos from the centre of town.
The rumour (I don't believe it) is that the Russians are preparing a withdrawal not only from Izyum, but Lyman.
Perhaps the rumour just a few days ahead of the curve.
Izyum has fallen. This is developing into a major Russian rout.
More like abandoned. But how many thousands are going to be left behind as the rout continues? Huge numbers of POWs coming up, equipment and amunition abandoned and a complete collapse in morale.
Why have we got Catherine Deneuve running the show?
Belle De Jour is one of the best films ever made. If you've a strong stomach try Repulsion too. Been meaning to try The Umbrellas Of Cherbourg too.
I presume you are commenting on her likeness to Penny Mordaunt? She is the official face of Marianne the goddess of liberty.
Yes, Mordaunt. Talk about the starring role. It seemed to be all about her.
And in another shudder moment for me I realized, since I suppose it was due to her being LOTH, that it could have been Mogg. I actually couldn't have watched it then.
Due to her being Lord President of the Council, but as it's been combined with Leader of the House of Commons since 2015 that's a distinction without a difference.
I think Starmer's looked quite impressive during this time. Talk about a Liz T bounce, that could be cancelled out by a Starmer bounce.
I dont think the VI will be much changed by how theyve responded, and best PM is a curious one. Starmer has looked statesmanlike at times so may bounce in that but Truss actually is being PM during this crisis and thus may also bounce.... VI im not sure. There will be those that think CoL is being ignored but there will also be a drive behind small c conservatism because of all the tradition on display. Latent patriotism. Im not sure who benefits most from that.
I understand all energy companies will have written to consumers shortly explaining the new cap of £2,500 from 1st October together with affirmation of the £66 per month discount for 6 months, together with the £650 extra payment to those in need and the £300 additional winter fuel allowance for pensioners
It follows that by early October energy consumers will be aware of the scheme and discounts
I was a bit disappointed that Penny Mordaunt didn't read out a list of candidates for Lord High Executioner.
We never had one. The common hangman of London (and Middlesex) usually did the job.
Common Hangman Of Middlesex sounds like one of those antique ministerial positions, like Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster or Lord Privy Seal, generally reserved for the party chairman.
Apparently the ground on which the Oval is built belongs to the Duchy of Cornwall. And they have made exactly the right decision. And England are off to a flyer too. Football called this wrong but in fairness it wasn't the easiest thing to do.
I don't know about Scotch L&T law but that doesn't entitle English landlords to dictate to their tenants what they do with their land. And all land in E&W belongs to Charlie now anyway.
Apparently the ground on which the Oval is built belongs to the Duchy of Cornwall. And they have made exactly the right decision. And England are off to a flyer too. Football called this wrong but in fairness it wasn't the easiest thing to do.
The FA were reasonable but wrong. Not the end of the world. And we are all feeling our way a bit here.
“If Ukraine were dependent on Germany within the framework of a European defense policy, it would no longer exist today - Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki in an interview with Der Spiegel.”
Out of curiosity I went back and read the first dedicated PB thread after the initial Russian invasion. I am somewhat impressed by our measured, resolute and prescient commentary. Quite a few PB-ers were predicting energy crises right from the start. Nobody really embarrasses themselves. Well done us
But I did find an absolute stone cold classic from @Roger
His first reaction to the Ukraine war?
“Time for NATO to disband.“
I recall him saying, as he headed to Cannes (I think) that the mood there would be very down, since a number of people had lost their yachts as a result of sanctions.
Bless him, he’s been Totally Wrong About Everything since the summer of 1908
“Time for NATO to disband” is a keeper, tho
Rogerdamus, he’s not been around for a while.
That NATO one was a zinger.
Just be grateful he didn't predict a Russian defeat.
I was a bit disappointed that Penny Mordaunt didn't read out a list of candidates for Lord High Executioner.
We never had one. The common hangman of London (and Middlesex) usually did the job.
Common Hangman Of Middlesex sounds like one of those antique ministerial positions, like Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster or Lord Privy Seal, generally reserved for the party chairman.
The sort of job you could imagine giving to JRM, except he would blanch at doing anything with the word "common" in it.
The Ukrainian Kharkiv adventure get ever more spectacular in the speed of their advance.
When the picture was shown with them on the very outskirts of Kupyansk I treated it with caution it deserved. Now they have photos from the centre of town.
The rumour (I don't believe it) is that the Russians are preparing a withdrawal not only from Izyum, but Lyman.
Perhaps the rumour just a few days ahead of the curve.
Izyum has fallen. This is developing into a major Russian rout.
More like abandoned. But how many thousands are going to be left behind as the rout continues? Huge numbers of POWs coming up, equipment and amunition abandoned and a complete collapse in morale.
Lyman seems to have fallen also, about 35km from Izyum. The whole front seems to have been ripped open. Looks like the beginning of panic on the Russian side. As President Ilves said, this is Mukden or Tsushima. Catastrophic Russian defeat.
Re Mordaunt and Cahtherine Deneuve, the name Mordaunt is of French Norman origin, and as a result I've always thought the rather beautiful Penny looked a touch French.
The Ukrainian Kharkiv adventure get ever more spectacular in the speed of their advance.
When the picture was shown with them on the very outskirts of Kupyansk I treated it with caution it deserved. Now they have photos from the centre of town.
The rumour (I don't believe it) is that the Russians are preparing a withdrawal not only from Izyum, but Lyman.
Perhaps the rumour just a few days ahead of the curve.
Izyum has fallen. This is developing into a major Russian rout.
More like abandoned. But how many thousands are going to be left behind as the rout continues? Huge numbers of POWs coming up, equipment and amunition abandoned and a complete collapse in morale.
Lyman seems to have fallen also, about 35km from Izyum. The whole front seems to have been ripped open. Looks like the beginning of panic on the Russian side. As President Ilves said, this is Mukden or Tsushima. Catastrophic Russian defeat.
May this see the end of the war criminals including Putin and a chance for peace
Ok, if the Russian rout and Putin Untergang come to pass, is it worth having a market on which PBer is the first to turn to a quivering mass of jelly at the prospect of nuclear armageddon?
Nah, thought not.
Been muttering about that for more than a fortnight already. Its not a negligible risk.
What seems to be happening in Ukraine is that Russian soldiers, who were previously scared of the consequences of being the first soldier to run away, are now scared of the consequences of being the last soldier to run away. The psychology has completely flipped.
I must say I find Charlie’s uxoriousness quite endearing, I think that’s at least twice he’s specifically mentioned his beloved wife.
At least he hasn’t said he wishes he was a tampon so he could spend all day in her.
If you knew anything about this aspect of a woman's life, you'd know how ignorant - unhygienic and potentially dangerous - such a statement is, as well as a bit oafish, frankly.
He loves her and is happy with her and is saying so publicly. What on earth is wrong with that?
What people say in private to each other - especially about their sexual passion for each other - is unlikely to make any of us, including you, I suspect, look dignified. So cut it out, eh.
Apparently the ground on which the Oval is built belongs to the Duchy of Cornwall. And they have made exactly the right decision. And England are off to a flyer too. Football called this wrong but in fairness it wasn't the easiest thing to do.
The King needs something to watch in between quiet events this weekend too.
For comparison, the U.S. housing bubble saw home prices drop 27% between 2006 and 2012. Show this thread FORTUNE @FortuneMagazine · 13h 3) Even though Goldman Sachs has Australia, Canada, and New Zealand in the housing crash (or almost crash) camp, it’s less pessimistic about other G10 countries:
👉France (-6%) 👉 U.K. (remain the same) 👉 U.S. (+1.8%)
One of the mysteries of the world is how New Zealand has house prices more than double those in the UK.
Quite an astonishing group of people there, pretty much every living senior figure in the country.
There have never been seven living PMs before, and here they are all in the same room.
The funeral, and the coronation to follow, will be even more astonishing in their attendance.
That struck me too. A bomb there could in one stroke have eliminated the ... Nigel Farage voice ... "polidical clarse".
Have others been watching Designated Survivor on Netflix? Basically exactly that scenario (in the US).
I'm not sure I could quite handle that and I'm not even American.
I mentioned to someone yesterday that if they wanted an escape from the wall to wall HMQ coverage they might want to try the 2nd series of House Of Cards.
Ok, if the Russian rout and Putin Untergang come to pass, is it worth having a market on which PBer is the first to turn to a quivering mass of jelly at the prospect of nuclear armageddon?
Nah, thought not.
Been muttering about that for more than a fortnight already. Its not a negligible risk.
It probably isn’t but I sense you’re not the quivering jelly type.
The Ukrainian Kharkiv adventure get ever more spectacular in the speed of their advance.
When the picture was shown with them on the very outskirts of Kupyansk I treated it with caution it deserved. Now they have photos from the centre of town.
The rumour (I don't believe it) is that the Russians are preparing a withdrawal not only from Izyum, but Lyman.
Perhaps the rumour just a few days ahead of the curve.
Izyum has fallen. This is developing into a major Russian rout.
More like abandoned. But how many thousands are going to be left behind as the rout continues? Huge numbers of POWs coming up, equipment and amunition abandoned and a complete collapse in morale.
Lyman seems to have fallen also, about 35km from Izyum. The whole front seems to have been ripped open. Looks like the beginning of panic on the Russian side. As President Ilves said, this is Mukden or Tsushima. Catastrophic Russian defeat.
May this see the end of the war criminals including Putin and a chance for peace
I remember commenting in an email to a Russian back in February that this war ends in Putin’s death: either in a bunker / against a Kremlin wall, or in a nuclear blast as the whole Northern hemisphere goes up in smoke.
The Ukrainian Kharkiv adventure get ever more spectacular in the speed of their advance.
When the picture was shown with them on the very outskirts of Kupyansk I treated it with caution it deserved. Now they have photos from the centre of town.
The rumour (I don't believe it) is that the Russians are preparing a withdrawal not only from Izyum, but Lyman.
Perhaps the rumour just a few days ahead of the curve.
Izyum has fallen. This is developing into a major Russian rout.
More like abandoned. But how many thousands are going to be left behind as the rout continues? Huge numbers of POWs coming up, equipment and amunition abandoned and a complete collapse in morale.
Lyman seems to have fallen also, about 35km from Izyum. The whole front seems to have been ripped open. Looks like the beginning of panic on the Russian side. As President Ilves said, this is Mukden or Tsushima. Catastrophic Russian defeat.
May this see the end of the war criminals including Putin and a chance for peace
I remember commenting in an email to a Russian back in February that this war ends in Putin’s death: either in a bunker / against a Kremlin wall, or in a nuclear blast as the whole Northern hemisphere goes up in smoke.
The Ukrainian Kharkiv adventure get ever more spectacular in the speed of their advance.
When the picture was shown with them on the very outskirts of Kupyansk I treated it with caution it deserved. Now they have photos from the centre of town.
The rumour (I don't believe it) is that the Russians are preparing a withdrawal not only from Izyum, but Lyman.
Perhaps the rumour just a few days ahead of the curve.
Izyum has fallen. This is developing into a major Russian rout.
More like abandoned. But how many thousands are going to be left behind as the rout continues? Huge numbers of POWs coming up, equipment and amunition abandoned and a complete collapse in morale.
Lyman seems to have fallen also, about 35km from Izyum. The whole front seems to have been ripped open. Looks like the beginning of panic on the Russian side. As President Ilves said, this is Mukden or Tsushima. Catastrophic Russian defeat.
As I said early this morning the troops doing this learned their skills on the Salisbury plain. Which is a bit ironic given where Putin ordered murder on our soil.
On the subject of Ukraine, my personal view is that the one thing the Russians cannot afford is for thousands - or tens of thousands - of their troops to be captured.
Dead. Injured. These can be hidden, at least in the short term.
But captured troops in Ukraine is a massive problem. Because those troops can speak. And their mothers will agitate for their return.
If there are mass captures, then I think Putin's days are numbered.
You’ve been suggesting a possible Russian collapse for a couple of weeks. You made me sit up and read, and realise you could be right. So: chapeau
As I recall various commentators were saying that the Russians had one more offensive of reserves left.
They were jeered at by the usual suspects.
The Russians had their offensive.
This is the Ukrainian counter offensive.
100 Days Offensive comes to mind…
As the much maligned Haig said in January 1918, well in advance of Michael, 'the Germans would do well to hesitate before committing to a major offensive, for if it failed their position would be critical.'
Germany probably had no choice but to roll the dice on last time. Austria Hungary and the Ottoman Empire were coming apart at the seams.
Ok, if the Russian rout and Putin Untergang come to pass, is it worth having a market on which PBer is the first to turn to a quivering mass of jelly at the prospect of nuclear armageddon?
Nah, thought not.
It would be a silly market. Like the bookie who took a huge bet on nuclear weapons being used over Cuba. When asked why he didn't lay the bet, he replied, 'well, if it's a winner I won't be around to pay out.'
The Ukrainian Kharkiv adventure get ever more spectacular in the speed of their advance.
When the picture was shown with them on the very outskirts of Kupyansk I treated it with caution it deserved. Now they have photos from the centre of town.
The rumour (I don't believe it) is that the Russians are preparing a withdrawal not only from Izyum, but Lyman.
Perhaps the rumour just a few days ahead of the curve.
Izyum has fallen. This is developing into a major Russian rout.
More like abandoned. But how many thousands are going to be left behind as the rout continues? Huge numbers of POWs coming up, equipment and amunition abandoned and a complete collapse in morale.
Lyman seems to have fallen also, about 35km from Izyum. The whole front seems to have been ripped open. Looks like the beginning of panic on the Russian side. As President Ilves said, this is Mukden or Tsushima. Catastrophic Russian defeat.
May this see the end of the war criminals including Putin and a chance for peace
I remember commenting in an email to a Russian back in February that this war ends in Putin’s death: either in a bunker / against a Kremlin wall, or in a nuclear blast as the whole Northern hemisphere goes up in smoke.
Videos on twitter of Russian troops on the move around Moscow. Could be a very newsy day.
I was a bit disappointed that Penny Mordaunt didn't read out a list of candidates for Lord High Executioner.
We never had one. The common hangman of London (and Middlesex) usually did the job.
Common Hangman Of Middlesex sounds like one of those antique ministerial positions, like Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster or Lord Privy Seal, generally reserved for the party chairman.
The sort of job you could imagine giving to JRM, except he would blanch at doing anything with the word "common" in it.
Do I get accused of bad taste if I suggest Mogg would be better suited to being a client?
Quite an astonishing group of people there, pretty much every living senior figure in the country.
There have never been seven living PMs before, and here they are all in the same room.
The funeral, and the coronation to follow, will be even more astonishing in their attendance.
That struck me too. A bomb there could in one stroke have eliminated the ... Nigel Farage voice ... "polidical clarse".
Have others been watching Designated Survivor on Netflix? Basically exactly that scenario (in the US).
Ha yes, in the US they actually make a point of some people not being there at key events.
Presumably there were a handful of the current cabinet missing this morning, to proclaim King George if the very worst had happened?
Nah, we’ve got 650 MPs, and even more Lords, George could have picked from as needed. Not that the PM even needs to be in either House. The inherent flexibility of our system means it would always be fine.
The Ukrainian Kharkiv adventure get ever more spectacular in the speed of their advance.
When the picture was shown with them on the very outskirts of Kupyansk I treated it with caution it deserved. Now they have photos from the centre of town.
The rumour (I don't believe it) is that the Russians are preparing a withdrawal not only from Izyum, but Lyman.
Perhaps the rumour just a few days ahead of the curve.
Izyum has fallen. This is developing into a major Russian rout.
More like abandoned. But how many thousands are going to be left behind as the rout continues? Huge numbers of POWs coming up, equipment and amunition abandoned...
i have discovered the hilarity of Russia-supporting Military Twitter. Hahahahah
Meltdown
Absolute johnny come lately. You needed to be there 2 months ago when they were convincing themselves that their 1-metre a week advance in the East was the pinnacle of military strategy and that all HIMARS launchers had been destroyed.
Coming in now is like turning on the radio for the final movement of a Rachmaninoff symphony.
Without the buildup all this pure copium would just feel forced and excessive.
On the subject of Ukraine, my personal view is that the one thing the Russians cannot afford is for thousands - or tens of thousands - of their troops to be captured.
Dead. Injured. These can be hidden, at least in the short term.
But captured troops in Ukraine is a massive problem. Because those troops can speak. And their mothers will agitate for their return.
If there are mass captures, then I think Putin's days are numbered.
You’ve been suggesting a possible Russian collapse for a couple of weeks. You made me sit up and read, and realise you could be right. So: chapeau
As I recall various commentators were saying that the Russians had one more offensive of reserves left.
They were jeered at by the usual suspects.
The Russians had their offensive.
This is the Ukrainian counter offensive.
100 Days Offensive comes to mind…
As the much maligned Haig said in January 1918, well in advance of Michael, 'the Germans would do well to hesitate before committing to a major offensive, for if it failed their position would be critical.'
Germany probably had no choice but to roll the dice on last time. Austria Hungary and the Ottoman Empire were coming apart at the seams.
Apart from an (evidently obligatory in US publication) catastrophising paragraph about the current state of the UK a quite perceptive analysis of what the late Queen got right - and how politicians greatly under appreciate our soft power:
"Ukrainian forces were on the verge of trapping thousands of Russian soldiers in an encirclement that, if successful, would be Moscow’s worst battlefield defeat since the Second World War."
Telegraph
This is all putting a smile on my face. Go Ukraine.
Lyman and Izyum seem to have been surrendered without a fight. The Ukrainians are on the pursuit. Within about 7 miles of the border apparently. Having a beer in Riga Central Market, has made up for yesterday's delayed flight.
I understand Russian bloggers are comparing it to the Third Battle of Kharkov, in Spring 1943. That was Germany's last big victory on the Eastern front.
On the subject of Ukraine, my personal view is that the one thing the Russians cannot afford is for thousands - or tens of thousands - of their troops to be captured.
Dead. Injured. These can be hidden, at least in the short term.
But captured troops in Ukraine is a massive problem. Because those troops can speak. And their mothers will agitate for their return.
If there are mass captures, then I think Putin's days are numbered.
You’ve been suggesting a possible Russian collapse for a couple of weeks. You made me sit up and read, and realise you could be right. So: chapeau
As I recall various commentators were saying that the Russians had one more offensive of reserves left.
They were jeered at by the usual suspects.
The Russians had their offensive.
This is the Ukrainian counter offensive.
100 Days Offensive comes to mind…
As the much maligned Haig said in January 1918, well in advance of Michael, 'the Germans would do well to hesitate before committing to a major offensive, for if it failed their position would be critical.'
Germany probably had no choice but to roll the dice on last time. Austria Hungary and the Ottoman Empire were coming apart at the seams.
So was Germany!
Yes, the impact of the Royal Naval blockade was pretty grim by then.
For comparison, the U.S. housing bubble saw home prices drop 27% between 2006 and 2012. Show this thread FORTUNE @FortuneMagazine · 13h 3) Even though Goldman Sachs has Australia, Canada, and New Zealand in the housing crash (or almost crash) camp, it’s less pessimistic about other G10 countries:
👉France (-6%) 👉 U.K. (remain the same) 👉 U.S. (+1.8%)
One of the mysteries of the world is how New Zealand has house prices more than double those in the UK.
Constraints on building plus lots of Kiwis buying from abroad/returning plus foreign investors.
Working in IT in London, a common theme for people who have come here for work is buying/building a house back home with the money. One Bulgarian lady was buying a new flat in the suburbs of Sofia every year….
i have discovered the hilarity of Russia-supporting Military Twitter. Hahahahah
Meltdown
Absolute johnny come lately. You needed to be there 2 weeks ago when they were convincing themselves that their 1-metre a week advance in the East was the pinnacle of military strategy and that all HIMARS launchers had been destroyed.
Coming in now is like turning on the radio for the final movement of a Rachmaninoff symphony.
Without the buildup all this pure copium would just feel forced and excessive.
"Ukrainian forces were on the verge of trapping thousands of Russian soldiers in an encirclement that, if successful, would be Moscow’s worst battlefield defeat since the Second World War."
Telegraph
This is all putting a smile on my face. Go Ukraine.
Lyman and Izyum seem to have been surrendered without a fight. The Ukrainians are on the pursuit. Within about 7 miles of the border apparently. Having a beer in Riga Central Market, has made up for yesterday's delayed flight.
I understand Russian bloggers are comparing it to the Third Battle of Kharkov, in Spring 1943. That was Germany's last big victory on the Eastern front.
Yes, I'm uneasy with comparisons to Soviet defeats in WWII because they did win the war.
However, against that they were part of a major alliance that kept them going with weapons, especially motor transport, and the Germans were trying to conquer the whole empire up to the Urals. If they had stopped at Rostov and offered Stalin peace terms on that basis, they might just have got away with it, at any rate for a time.
Stalin probably wouldn't have accepted but he might finally have been removed or shot himself anyway under those circumstances.
Apart from an (evidently obligatory in US publication) catastrophising paragraph about the current state of the UK a quite perceptive analysis of what the late Queen got right - and how politicians greatly under appreciate our soft power:
With their attacks on the BBC and the international aid budget, and opposition to vaccine sharing, some politicians not only underestimate Britain's soft power, they go out of their way to undermine it.
There must be a huge row going on behind the scenes over the date of the funeral. A bank holiday has been declared which rules out Saturday. The for-gods-sake-get-it-over-with party are presumably campaigning for Friday while the we-need-an-extra-72-hours-to-get-ready party are holding out for Monday. Time is on their side.
i have discovered the hilarity of Russia-supporting Military Twitter. Hahahahah
Meltdown
Putin still has this worshipper:
Will Schryver @imetatronink · 12h Here at the end of the day the reality of an overwhelming and devastatingly punishing Russian victory is even more apparent than it was 10 hours ago.
The Russian-held part of Balakleya was never taken; neither Kupyansk nor Izyum are threatened; AFU casualties are catastrophic.
Will Schryver @imetatronink · 7h It's going to be fascinating to observe how #CultusUkraini deals with the creeping realization that the erstwhile #GloriousCounterOffensive has become the most decisively shattering defeat of this disastrous war.
i have discovered the hilarity of Russia-supporting Military Twitter. Hahahahah
Meltdown
Putin still has this worshipper:
Will Schryver @imetatronink · 12h Here at the end of the day the reality of an overwhelming and devastatingly punishing Russian victory is even more apparent than it was 10 hours ago.
The Russian-held part of Balakleya was never taken; neither Kupyansk nor Izyum are threatened; AFU casualties are catastrophic.
Will Schryver @imetatronink · 7h It's going to be fascinating to observe how #CultusUkraini deals with the creeping realization that the erstwhile #GloriousCounterOffensive has become the most decisively shattering defeat of this disastrous war.
This is real, though. https://mobile.twitter.com/UAWeapons/status/1568552147821764610 As the AFU advances in #Kharkiv Oblast we can finally see the results of HIMARS strikes; at least 2 Tigr-M IMVs, 2 R-149MA1, 1 R-145BM1 command and staff vehicle, 2 9T244 Tor AD system transloaders, armored KAMAZ & many more cargo trucks were obliterated.
On the subject of Ukraine, my personal view is that the one thing the Russians cannot afford is for thousands - or tens of thousands - of their troops to be captured.
Dead. Injured. These can be hidden, at least in the short term.
But captured troops in Ukraine is a massive problem. Because those troops can speak. And their mothers will agitate for their return.
If there are mass captures, then I think Putin's days are numbered.
You’ve been suggesting a possible Russian collapse for a couple of weeks. You made me sit up and read, and realise you could be right. So: chapeau
As I recall various commentators were saying that the Russians had one more offensive of reserves left.
They were jeered at by the usual suspects.
The Russians had their offensive.
This is the Ukrainian counter offensive.
100 Days Offensive comes to mind…
As the much maligned Haig said in January 1918, well in advance of Michael, 'the Germans would do well to hesitate before committing to a major offensive, for if it failed their position would be critical.'
Germany probably had no choice but to roll the dice on last time. Austria Hungary and the Ottoman Empire were coming apart at the seams.
So was Germany!
Well, not really. They had defeated Russia, and had several hundred thousand troops free from that, the Americans were only present in small numbers and green, while the French army had mutinied in 1917. There was a possibility of allied collapse in 1918 too, and it nearly happened.
In a curious bit of symmetry it was the Serbian offensive on the Salonika front that kicked off the final collapse.
On the subject of Ukraine, my personal view is that the one thing the Russians cannot afford is for thousands - or tens of thousands - of their troops to be captured.
Dead. Injured. These can be hidden, at least in the short term.
But captured troops in Ukraine is a massive problem. Because those troops can speak. And their mothers will agitate for their return.
If there are mass captures, then I think Putin's days are numbered.
You’ve been suggesting a possible Russian collapse for a couple of weeks. You made me sit up and read, and realise you could be right. So: chapeau
As I recall various commentators were saying that the Russians had one more offensive of reserves left.
They were jeered at by the usual suspects.
The Russians had their offensive.
This is the Ukrainian counter offensive.
100 Days Offensive comes to mind…
As the much maligned Haig said in January 1918, well in advance of Michael, 'the Germans would do well to hesitate before committing to a major offensive, for if it failed their position would be critical.'
Germany probably had no choice but to roll the dice on last time. Austria Hungary and the Ottoman Empire were coming apart at the seams.
The Haig the butcher stuff was a later invention. When he died, the crowds of veterans at his funeral were huge.
Kitchener and he turned out to be right - they both said it would take 3 years to raise, train and equip an army of the scale of the Germans. Then the Germans would be outnumbered and lose.
Being serious for a moment I haven't seen anything quite as ridiculous for years. I've been involved in some whacky ads in some strange places but this has set a new bar
The Ukrainian Kharkiv adventure get ever more spectacular in the speed of their advance.
When the picture was shown with them on the very outskirts of Kupyansk I treated it with caution it deserved. Now they have photos from the centre of town.
The rumour (I don't believe it) is that the Russians are preparing a withdrawal not only from Izyum, but Lyman.
Perhaps the rumour just a few days ahead of the curve.
Izyum has fallen. This is developing into a major Russian rout.
More like abandoned. But how many thousands are going to be left behind as the rout continues? Huge numbers of POWs coming up, equipment and amunition abandoned and a complete collapse in morale.
Lyman seems to have fallen also, about 35km from Izyum. The whole front seems to have been ripped open. Looks like the beginning of panic on the Russian side. As President Ilves said, this is Mukden or Tsushima. Catastrophic Russian defeat.
May this see the end of the war criminals including Putin and a chance for peace
I remember commenting in an email to a Russian back in February that this war ends in Putin’s death: either in a bunker / against a Kremlin wall, or in a nuclear blast as the whole Northern hemisphere goes up in smoke.
Videos on twitter of Russian troops on the move around Moscow. Could be a very newsy day.
On the subject of Ukraine, my personal view is that the one thing the Russians cannot afford is for thousands - or tens of thousands - of their troops to be captured.
Dead. Injured. These can be hidden, at least in the short term.
But captured troops in Ukraine is a massive problem. Because those troops can speak. And their mothers will agitate for their return.
If there are mass captures, then I think Putin's days are numbered.
You’ve been suggesting a possible Russian collapse for a couple of weeks. You made me sit up and read, and realise you could be right. So: chapeau
As I recall various commentators were saying that the Russians had one more offensive of reserves left.
They were jeered at by the usual suspects.
The Russians had their offensive.
This is the Ukrainian counter offensive.
100 Days Offensive comes to mind…
As the much maligned Haig said in January 1918, well in advance of Michael, 'the Germans would do well to hesitate before committing to a major offensive, for if it failed their position would be critical.'
Germany probably had no choice but to roll the dice on last time. Austria Hungary and the Ottoman Empire were coming apart at the seams.
So was Germany!
Well, not really. They had defeated Russia, and had several hundred thousand troops free from that, the Americans were only present in small numbers and green, while the French army had mutinied in 1917. There was a possibility of allied collapse in 1918 too, and it nearly happened.
In a curious bit of symmetry it was the Serbian offensive on the Salonika front that kicked off the final collapse.
The German army was still functioning.
Rather less so the German economy. Small issue with trying to import anything.
Sounds like there's a bit of a ruckus in the east end. Republican march had been planned and the police pulled the plug. Which hasn't gone down terribly well.
On the subject of Ukraine, my personal view is that the one thing the Russians cannot afford is for thousands - or tens of thousands - of their troops to be captured.
Dead. Injured. These can be hidden, at least in the short term.
But captured troops in Ukraine is a massive problem. Because those troops can speak. And their mothers will agitate for their return.
If there are mass captures, then I think Putin's days are numbered.
You’ve been suggesting a possible Russian collapse for a couple of weeks. You made me sit up and read, and realise you could be right. So: chapeau
As I recall various commentators were saying that the Russians had one more offensive of reserves left.
They were jeered at by the usual suspects.
The Russians had their offensive.
This is the Ukrainian counter offensive.
100 Days Offensive comes to mind…
As the much maligned Haig said in January 1918, well in advance of Michael, 'the Germans would do well to hesitate before committing to a major offensive, for if it failed their position would be critical.'
Germany probably had no choice but to roll the dice on last time. Austria Hungary and the Ottoman Empire were coming apart at the seams.
The Haig the butcher stuff was a later invention. When he died, the crowds of veterans at his funeral were huge.
Kitchener and he turned out to be right - they both said it would take 3 years to raise, train and equip an army of the scale of the Germans. Then the Germans would be outnumbered and lose.
Also, of course, Haig was the person who oversaw many profound innovations in tactics, particularly the one when he saw Monash's plans for using tanks and aircraft to support substantial infantry advances acting in concert, immediately ordered that they be made the standard throughout the army. That played no small part in the Hundred Days in itself.
For comparison, the U.S. housing bubble saw home prices drop 27% between 2006 and 2012. Show this thread FORTUNE @FortuneMagazine · 13h 3) Even though Goldman Sachs has Australia, Canada, and New Zealand in the housing crash (or almost crash) camp, it’s less pessimistic about other G10 countries:
👉France (-6%) 👉 U.K. (remain the same) 👉 U.S. (+1.8%)
One of the mysteries of the world is how New Zealand has house prices more than double those in the UK.
i have discovered the hilarity of Russia-supporting Military Twitter. Hahahahah
Meltdown
Absolute johnny come lately. You needed to be there 2 weeks ago when they were convincing themselves that their 1-metre a week advance in the East was the pinnacle of military strategy and that all HIMARS launchers had been destroyed.
Coming in now is like turning on the radio for the final movement of a Rachmaninoff symphony.
Without the buildup all this pure copium would just feel forced and excessive.
On the subject of Ukraine, my personal view is that the one thing the Russians cannot afford is for thousands - or tens of thousands - of their troops to be captured.
Dead. Injured. These can be hidden, at least in the short term.
But captured troops in Ukraine is a massive problem. Because those troops can speak. And their mothers will agitate for their return.
If there are mass captures, then I think Putin's days are numbered.
You’ve been suggesting a possible Russian collapse for a couple of weeks. You made me sit up and read, and realise you could be right. So: chapeau
As I recall various commentators were saying that the Russians had one more offensive of reserves left.
They were jeered at by the usual suspects.
The Russians had their offensive.
This is the Ukrainian counter offensive.
100 Days Offensive comes to mind…
As the much maligned Haig said in January 1918, well in advance of Michael, 'the Germans would do well to hesitate before committing to a major offensive, for if it failed their position would be critical.'
Germany probably had no choice but to roll the dice on last time. Austria Hungary and the Ottoman Empire were coming apart at the seams.
So was Germany!
Well, not really. They had defeated Russia, and had several hundred thousand troops free from that, the Americans were only present in small numbers and green, while the French army had mutinied in 1917. There was a possibility of allied collapse in 1918 too, and it nearly happened.
In a curious bit of symmetry it was the Serbian offensive on the Salonika front that kicked off the final collapse.
The Germans were running out of soldiers and industry was failing, slowly but surely. Hence the inability to build tanks, for example.
The French mutiny was caused by stupid generals insisting on futile attacks, the mutineers were quite clear about their support for the war.
Part of the reason for kicking off Michael was that the Americans were starting to show up on the battlefield. The Germans knew that if they waited till 1919 they would be facing a vast American army as well as the British and French.
The Reformation stands. The King has promised to defend and secure the Protestant religion in both England and Scotland not return us to Rome and the Vatican
Symbolic
Slightly more than symbolic. 'Protestant' is an archaic word but not an archaic concept. It just means 'Catholic but not Roman Catholic'. And 'catholic church' just means 'universal church' - of which the CoE modestly claims to be a little part.
The word is archaic and should be dropped because the 'protest' ceased a few centuries ago. As Father Jack would correctly say, it is now 'an ecumenical matter'.
The Church of Scotland affirmation of baptism includes the words “ I believe in the Holy Spirit, the holy catholic Church, the communion of saints, the forgiveness of sins, the resurrection of the body and the life everlasting.”
There must be a huge row going on behind the scenes over the date of the funeral. A bank holiday has been declared which rules out Saturday. The for-gods-sake-get-it-over-with party are presumably campaigning for Friday while the we-need-an-extra-72-hours-to-get-ready party are holding out for Monday. Time is on their side.
The Reformation stands. The King has promised to defend and secure the Protestant religion in both England and Scotland not return us to Rome and the Vatican
Symbolic
Slightly more than symbolic. 'Protestant' is an archaic word but not an archaic concept. It just means 'Catholic but not Roman Catholic'. And 'catholic church' just means 'universal church' - of which the CoE modestly claims to be a little part.
The word is archaic and should be dropped because the 'protest' ceased a few centuries ago. As Father Jack would correctly say, it is now 'an ecumenical matter'.
The Church of Scotland affirmation of baptism includes the words “ I believe in the Holy Spirit, the holy catholic Church, the communion of saints, the forgiveness of sins, the resurrection of the body and the life everlasting.”
On the subject of Ukraine, my personal view is that the one thing the Russians cannot afford is for thousands - or tens of thousands - of their troops to be captured.
Dead. Injured. These can be hidden, at least in the short term.
But captured troops in Ukraine is a massive problem. Because those troops can speak. And their mothers will agitate for their return.
If there are mass captures, then I think Putin's days are numbered.
You’ve been suggesting a possible Russian collapse for a couple of weeks. You made me sit up and read, and realise you could be right. So: chapeau
As I recall various commentators were saying that the Russians had one more offensive of reserves left.
They were jeered at by the usual suspects.
The Russians had their offensive.
This is the Ukrainian counter offensive.
100 Days Offensive comes to mind…
As the much maligned Haig said in January 1918, well in advance of Michael, 'the Germans would do well to hesitate before committing to a major offensive, for if it failed their position would be critical.'
Germany probably had no choice but to roll the dice on last time. Austria Hungary and the Ottoman Empire were coming apart at the seams.
So was Germany!
Well, not really. They had defeated Russia, and had several hundred thousand troops free from that, the Americans were only present in small numbers and green, while the French army had mutinied in 1917. There was a possibility of allied collapse in 1918 too, and it nearly happened.
In a curious bit of symmetry it was the Serbian offensive on the Salonika front that kicked off the final collapse.
The German army was still functioning.
Rather less so the German economy. Small issue with trying to import anything.
Which is why spring 1918 was their last chance.
In other echos of that denouement, revolution is now brewing in St Petersberg and Moscow.
"With the continuous progress of the Ukrainian army in the Kharkiv region, the Ukrainian fighters stumbled upon a large warehouse that had previously been destroyed by "HIMARS" strikes, which was used by the Russian army to hide its vehicles."
I think the proclamation is the best part of it all. I just love the idea of the news being spread throughout the Kingdom by heralds and the announcement being read out in front of cathedrals, churches and town halls in every corner of the realm. I wonder how long it took for the news to become universal before there were the railways, let alone the telegraph, telephone and internet.
On the subject of Ukraine, my personal view is that the one thing the Russians cannot afford is for thousands - or tens of thousands - of their troops to be captured.
Dead. Injured. These can be hidden, at least in the short term.
But captured troops in Ukraine is a massive problem. Because those troops can speak. And their mothers will agitate for their return.
If there are mass captures, then I think Putin's days are numbered.
You’ve been suggesting a possible Russian collapse for a couple of weeks. You made me sit up and read, and realise you could be right. So: chapeau
As I recall various commentators were saying that the Russians had one more offensive of reserves left.
They were jeered at by the usual suspects.
The Russians had their offensive.
This is the Ukrainian counter offensive.
100 Days Offensive comes to mind…
As the much maligned Haig said in January 1918, well in advance of Michael, 'the Germans would do well to hesitate before committing to a major offensive, for if it failed their position would be critical.'
Germany probably had no choice but to roll the dice on last time. Austria Hungary and the Ottoman Empire were coming apart at the seams.
The Haig the butcher stuff was a later invention. When he died, the crowds of veterans at his funeral were huge.
Kitchener and he turned out to be right - they both said it would take 3 years to raise, train and equip an army of the scale of the Germans. Then the Germans would be outnumbered and lose.
Yes, the 60s “oh what a lovely war” and 80s Blackadder myth have gone on too long. People forget, or just don’t realise, that the First World War was a just war and one we won. We started unprepared but we always do.
There must be a huge row going on behind the scenes over the date of the funeral. A bank holiday has been declared which rules out Saturday. The for-gods-sake-get-it-over-with party are presumably campaigning for Friday while the we-need-an-extra-72-hours-to-get-ready party are holding out for Monday. Time is on their side.
On the subject of Ukraine, my personal view is that the one thing the Russians cannot afford is for thousands - or tens of thousands - of their troops to be captured.
Dead. Injured. These can be hidden, at least in the short term.
But captured troops in Ukraine is a massive problem. Because those troops can speak. And their mothers will agitate for their return.
If there are mass captures, then I think Putin's days are numbered.
You’ve been suggesting a possible Russian collapse for a couple of weeks. You made me sit up and read, and realise you could be right. So: chapeau
As I recall various commentators were saying that the Russians had one more offensive of reserves left.
They were jeered at by the usual suspects.
The Russians had their offensive.
This is the Ukrainian counter offensive.
100 Days Offensive comes to mind…
As the much maligned Haig said in January 1918, well in advance of Michael, 'the Germans would do well to hesitate before committing to a major offensive, for if it failed their position would be critical.'
Germany probably had no choice but to roll the dice on last time. Austria Hungary and the Ottoman Empire were coming apart at the seams.
The Haig the butcher stuff was a later invention. When he died, the crowds of veterans at his funeral were huge.
Kitchener and he turned out to be right - they both said it would take 3 years to raise, train and equip an army of the scale of the Germans. Then the Germans would be outnumbered and lose.
Also, of course, Haig was the person who oversaw many profound innovations in tactics, particularly the one when he saw Monash's plans for using tanks and aircraft to support substantial infantry advances acting in concert, immediately ordered that they be made the standard throughout the army. That played no small part in the Hundred Days in itself.
The quotes about machine guns and tanks that get trotted out miss the following
1) artillery was the big weapon of WWI - not machine guns. Which were effective if not supersede by sufficient artillery.
2) Haig was skeptical of tanks when he saw the original plans. After the first usage proved they actually worked he asked for them to be built with a higher priority than artillery. Which was highest praise possible from a Western Front commander.
Sounds like there's a bit of a ruckus in the east end. Republican march had been planned and the police pulled the plug. Which hasn't gone down terribly well.
I think the proclamation is the best part of it all. I just love the idea of the news being spread throughout the Kingdom by heralds and the announcement being read out in front of cathedrals, churches and town halls in every corner of the realm. I wonder how long it took for the news to become universal before there were the railways, let alone the telegraph, telephone and internet.
I think the proclamation is the best part of it all. I just love the idea of the news being spread throughout the Kingdom by heralds and the announcement being read out in front of cathedrals, churches and town halls in every corner of the realm. I wonder how long it took for the news to become universal before there were the railways, let alone the telegraph, telephone and internet.
A living history lesson. Beautiful and daft in equal terms. Our silly old country at once full of sorrow and pageant.There is nowhere else like it. Even in the depth of decline we are magnificent.
Stop the War Coalition here hosting an event on Ukraine with no Ukrainians and speakers who have explicitly defended Russian aggression in Ukraine. STWC are anti-Ukraine and pro-Russia, and they are organising on the basis of halting weapons transfers to Ukraine. It’s pure evil.
On the subject of Ukraine, my personal view is that the one thing the Russians cannot afford is for thousands - or tens of thousands - of their troops to be captured.
Dead. Injured. These can be hidden, at least in the short term.
But captured troops in Ukraine is a massive problem. Because those troops can speak. And their mothers will agitate for their return.
If there are mass captures, then I think Putin's days are numbered.
You’ve been suggesting a possible Russian collapse for a couple of weeks. You made me sit up and read, and realise you could be right. So: chapeau
As I recall various commentators were saying that the Russians had one more offensive of reserves left.
They were jeered at by the usual suspects.
The Russians had their offensive.
This is the Ukrainian counter offensive.
100 Days Offensive comes to mind…
As the much maligned Haig said in January 1918, well in advance of Michael, 'the Germans would do well to hesitate before committing to a major offensive, for if it failed their position would be critical.'
Germany probably had no choice but to roll the dice on last time. Austria Hungary and the Ottoman Empire were coming apart at the seams.
The Haig the butcher stuff was a later invention. When he died, the crowds of veterans at his funeral were huge.
Kitchener and he turned out to be right - they both said it would take 3 years to raise, train and equip an army of the scale of the Germans. Then the Germans would be outnumbered and lose.
Yes, the 60s “oh what a lovely war” and 80s Blackadder myth have gone on too long. People forget, or just don’t realise, that the First World War was a just war and one we won. We started unprepared but we always do.
Just reading Corrigan's Mud, Blood and Poppycock. Very much on that revisionist approach, though a little bit too much reminiscent of the British Army officer he was for his objectivity as a *historian* to be entirely convincing - even so, it's possible to allow for that. Rather interesting, though the Germans also evolved with their Stosstrupp tactics.
The change from 1953 to 2022 is immense, of course. But from 1837 to 1901 it was pretty major too.
Arguably more so. In 1837 railways were still new and not numerous and many people still travelled by stagecoach. Steamships were deemed an impossibility by most for long distance travel, until the Great Western proved them wrong.
In 1901 you have not only cars and telephones as well as reliable ocean liners but are only two years away from powered heavier than air flight.
And just think about all the changes in medicine, in the locations people lived in, in technology.
@Nigelb its like the Tet Offensive in its use of partisan warfare/sabotage behind American lines, all synchronised superbly with an outright attack on the front
Tet came as a total shock to the USA, at a time when the Americans complacently thought the war was quietening down with no major moves
In many ways thereafter the Tet was a failure for Hanoi and the Yanks pushed the VC back quite easily
But Tet broke the American will to fight. It showed Americans at home the war was unwinnable and the North would never give up, and would endure any cost. From that moment Saigon 73 was inevitable
Comments
Nah, thought not.
They can work it out themselves.
These guys - https://www.greatriverrace.org.uk/ - put up a notice saying they were thinking about it. Then decided to turn it into a commerative event. Which I think strikes the right balance for everyone.
And they are minnows compared to the FA.
I went through an obsessive period when I devoured whole libraries on the war, because I was travelling in Indochina all the time
This is a good interview of Noam Chomsky regarding his views on the war in Ukraine.
His assessment of Putin and the causes of the war were pretty accurate, I thought.
The surprising aspect of his views are that he condemns the invasion of Ukraine, and agrees that we should be aiding Ukraine in its defence, with military support.
But surely that is pretty much exactly what we are doing?
The latter part of the interview was more disappointing, he trots out his more usual positions about everything America doing being bad and takes a benevolent stance to China, Iran etc.
His main message is just to seek out opposing perspectives and think for yourself, something I completely agree with.
He is certainly someone who shouldn't just be dismissed as a propogandist etc.
It follows that by early October energy consumers will be aware of the scheme and discounts
“If Ukraine were dependent on Germany within the framework of a European defense policy, it would no longer exist today - Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki in an interview with Der Spiegel.”
https://twitter.com/ukraine_world/status/1568536573909639169?s=21&t=2KwJh9wgJMyWyZme9uPhFw
He loves her and is happy with her and is saying so publicly. What on earth is wrong with that?
What people say in private to each other - especially about their sexual passion for each other - is unlikely to make any of us, including you, I suspect, look dignified. So cut it out, eh.
https://twitter.com/tamsellicsoniii/status/1568337366405758977?s=21&t=a7CNV-iRFSkQWIeTRyLpEw
I mentioned to someone yesterday that if they wanted an escape from the wall to wall HMQ coverage they might want to try the 2nd series of House Of Cards.
Meltdown
Presumably there were a handful of the current cabinet missing this morning, to proclaim King George if the very worst had happened?
https://mobile.twitter.com/SmartUACat/status/1568550901350031360
Correction now
32 - 5
https://mobile.twitter.com/AbraxasSpa/status/1568547974023712771
Coming in now is like turning on the radio for the final movement of a Rachmaninoff symphony.
Without the buildup all this pure copium would just feel forced and excessive.
https://www.theatlantic.com/culture/archive/2022/09/queen-elizabeth-ii-death-british-monarchy-identity/671392/
As it happens, I didn't notice Kwarteng there, though I did recognise the new Foreign Secretary.
We have deleted our tweet of allegedly Ukrainian troops marching in Kharkiv Oblast previously reposted by multiple Ukrainian media as it shows an airsoft event.
https://mobile.twitter.com/EuromaidanPress/status/1568545399559933952
This may not last the three days...
Now I've said that, SA nailed on for 600.
Working in IT in London, a common theme for people who have come here for work is buying/building a house back home with the money. One Bulgarian lady was buying a new flat in the suburbs of Sofia every year….
However, against that they were part of a major alliance that kept them going with weapons, especially motor transport, and the Germans were trying to conquer the whole empire up to the Urals. If they had stopped at Rostov and offered Stalin peace terms on that basis, they might just have got away with it, at any rate for a time.
Stalin probably wouldn't have accepted but he might finally have been removed or shot himself anyway under those circumstances.
Will Schryver
@imetatronink
·
12h
Here at the end of the day the reality of an overwhelming and devastatingly punishing Russian victory is even more apparent than it was 10 hours ago.
The Russian-held part of Balakleya was never taken; neither Kupyansk nor Izyum are threatened; AFU casualties are catastrophic.
https://twitter.com/imetatronink/status/1568370298373967872?cxt=HHwWgMDU7cGe_MMrAAAA
Will Schryver
@imetatronink
·
7h
It's going to be fascinating to observe how #CultusUkraini deals with the creeping realization that the erstwhile #GloriousCounterOffensive has become the most decisively shattering defeat of this disastrous war.
https://twitter.com/imetatronink/status/1568448430602878978?cxt=HHwWhIDUqbTin8QrAAAA
https://mobile.twitter.com/UAWeapons/status/1568552147821764610
As the AFU advances in #Kharkiv Oblast we can finally see the results of HIMARS strikes; at least 2 Tigr-M IMVs, 2 R-149MA1, 1 R-145BM1 command and staff vehicle, 2 9T244 Tor AD system transloaders, armored KAMAZ & many more cargo trucks were obliterated.
In a curious bit of symmetry it was the Serbian offensive on the Salonika front that kicked off the final collapse.
Kitchener and he turned out to be right - they both said it would take 3 years to raise, train and equip an army of the scale of the Germans. Then the Germans would be outnumbered and lose.
Rather less so the German economy. Small issue with trying to import anything.
https://twitter.com/JuliaDavisNews/status/1568310989149605888?ref_src=twsrc^tfw|twcamp^tweetembed|twterm^1568310989149605888|twgr^81bcf99501bd30aaca450f4f9c985d5d1d39d046|twcon^s1_&ref_url=https://www.dailykos.com/story/2022/9/9/2121902/-Ukraine-Invasion-Day-199-possible-encirclement-ahead-fight-flight-and-give-up-materiel-again
The French mutiny was caused by stupid generals insisting on futile attacks, the mutineers were quite clear about their support for the war.
Part of the reason for kicking off Michael was that the Americans were starting to show up on the battlefield. The Germans knew that if they waited till 1919 they would be facing a vast American army as well as the British and French.
the resurrection of the body and the life everlasting.”
In other echos of that denouement, revolution is now brewing in St Petersberg and Moscow.
https://twitter.com/JuliaDavisNews/status/1568442191848030210?t=oc6_IB1wM9xO3YBTHBM5gg&s=19
"With the continuous progress of the Ukrainian army in the Kharkiv region, the Ukrainian fighters stumbled upon a large warehouse that had previously been destroyed by "HIMARS" strikes, which was used by the Russian army to hide its vehicles."
https://twitter.com/alrakad_M/status/1568555770656051201
1) artillery was the big weapon of WWI - not machine guns. Which were effective if not supersede by sufficient artillery.
2) Haig was skeptical of tanks when he saw the original plans. After the first usage proved they actually worked he asked for them to be built with a higher priority than artillery. Which was highest praise possible from a Western Front commander.
https://www.thenational.scot/news/21253605.glasgows-bristol-bar-unveils-tribute-queen-elizabeth-following-death/
As for the march, green (Irish) republican or Green(eco) republican or plain republican republican? Can't find it anywhere.
Other opinions are available
In 1901 you have not only cars and telephones as well as reliable ocean liners but are only two years away from powered heavier than air flight.
And just think about all the changes in medicine, in the locations people lived in, in technology.