Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Boris backs Brexit but will it have an impact if he’s not g

123468

Comments

  • Options
    Boris Johnson sounds genuinely tortured. His current position will satisfy no one, including himself.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @VickiYoung01: Press team for @NicolaSturgeon currently watching Twitter in horror. No one likes a minister fixing their own interviews @afneil
  • Options
    Charles said:

    OK I feel like facing a dilemma that I never imagined and genuinely no longer know how to vote or who to support. I'm feeling turned off by everyone.

    I can't stand the argument to stay in the EU so that Parliament can't decide on social issues and we keep unproductive socialist 'rights'. Parliament should be sovereign.
    I can't stand the argument to leave the EU to stop immigration, I think reciprocal free movement between developed economies is a good thing.

    I've despised "obsessed about Europe" Tories since the 90's. I couldn't stand IDS or Redwood. I could never imagine wanting to Leave. But Gove's leave argument was very convincing and well written and I really am not sure whether or why I want to Remain anymore.

    Ultimately I am currently thinking that the absolute worst case scenario is a narrow Remain win that keeps this like an open sore. Better either a Remain landslide (over 60%) or any Leave victory that makes Parliament sovereign and closes this once and for all. I'm genuinely no longer sure which I prefer though.

    Feels very weird not to be sure how to vote during a campaign.

    Vote Leave, then. We should be free to determine what we want. I suspect we will end up in EFTA anyway, meaning that there will be a reasonable amount of immigration in any event
    On the big picture it see the risk of a return to 1990s obsession with Europe as a bigger risk to the country than the EU outvoting us in QMV areas that apply to the EU but not to the EFTA.

    I want this referendum to be decisive not a neverendum. I don't want the country to vote remain, I vote leave and have my vote taken as carte blanch to continue banging on about Europe.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,797
    Scott_P said:

    @VickiYoung01: Press team for @NicolaSturgeon currently watching Twitter in horror. No one likes a minister fixing their own interviews @afneil

    Maybe so, but her position is so strong and secure, and she able enough, that I doubt it rises to the level of horror. To borrow a Trumpism, she could shoot someone in the face and not lose support at the moment.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @adamboultonSKY: Boris trying to revive @odysseanproject 's double referendum ploy - ruled out by DC and EU Council.
  • Options

    Boris Johnson sounds genuinely tortured. His current position will satisfy no one, including himself.

    Bit bitter are we?
  • Options
    MarkHopkinsMarkHopkins Posts: 5,584

    The Germans benefit from running the Euro and the trade in goods.

    The French benefit from CAP.

    Spain and Italy benefit from a stabilising influence on their economies.

    And a host of smaller countries benefit by being part of the club.

    I can see why everyone else likes the EU, but they don't seem to want to reciprocate. Indeed they want to make decisions that benefit the Euro at the expense of our major industry (finance).

    I don't see anything that changes this, so what is the point of being shackled to the EU? Boris may be hoping for a better a deal (don't we all), I just don't see it happening.

  • Options
    TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 40,124
    edited February 2016
  • Options
    CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    Cyclefree said:

    Gerard Lyons ‎@DrGerardLyons
    "3/ Chief Exec of CityUK praised the deal ... I am on the board of CityUK & thought deal far from what City wanted or needed"

    Yes, but for the most part the deal has been well received by the City.

    What we really need is a heavyweight report by City lawyers on the effect on the City of the three options (Remain, Leave/EEA, Leave/Something else). I expect there will be some such reports over the next couple of months.
    There have been loads of such reports already. They ping into my inbox on a daily basis.

    He means a report that agrees with him
  • Options
    O/T An embarrassed mayor in Germany.
    https://www.rt.com/news/333119-german-mayor-porn-bdsm/
  • Options
    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @politicshome: Nigel Farage challenges Nicola Sturgeon to EU debate in Scotland: https://t.co/eCuEuDRUWQ https://t.co/ZVVrX0jOry
  • Options

    Boris Johnson sounds genuinely tortured. His current position will satisfy no one, including himself.

    Bit bitter are we?
    Not at all. As anyone who has read my posts on this over the last two days would know, I think he's made the right choice for him. He needs to lead though.
  • Options
    hunchmanhunchman Posts: 2,591
    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    RobD said:

    Scott_P said:

    @JohnRentoul: Boris's column in Telegraph is up https://t.co/EHr5tfOaSL

    "..all EU history shows that they only really listen to a population when it says No."

    He's in the 2nd referendum to get a better deal camp, then.
    I doubt the other EU leaders will be pleased if they are forced to go through another round of negotiations. I'm of the view this is as good as it gets.
    Who knows?
    I think the EU.

    If I truly believed the collective body of EU bureaucrats and the leaders who support them were capable of reform, under any circumstance, I would still be a Remainer. I can picture some being willing to take another look at a whole range of issues in panic as they realise we are heading for the exit, but I don't think collectively they would be capable of agreeing that as a position, especially as sizable portions of their populations would be telling us to get stuffed, even if their politicians told them losing us for real would be worth extra concessions (if not to get us to change our minds, which would be to late to achieve I think, then at least to prevent the possibility of others joining us). We already hear ad naseum that the EU is sick of us whining, and there's a reason for that - even if it is an exaggeration, their populations support the EU and its current path, and most don't like how far we push even on the points they have sympathy on, so if we left, chances are just as high they would double down on things people don't like and dare others to join us in the exit as they would be to try to fix things to stop the contagion

    So while they won't shrug and move on like nothing happens, even if some of them think they could, I just do not see how any action they would be able to take would change things significantly. It's in its bones.
    The EU bureaucrats are more interested in maintaining their own jobs in Brussels above anything else. All the measures to try to prop up the Euro simply aren't going work, absent of a consolidation of the debts of eurozone members. You can't create confidence in a currency by adopting measures such as negative interest rates against the wishes of people. At the end of the day, the value of money derives from the confidence of the people using it, in the expectation that everyone will accept using it too. That confidence in the euro is not far off breaking point.
  • Options

    Scott_P said:

    @tnewtondunn: Boris: the plot thickens. Strong suggestion in his Telegraph column he'll Vote Leave for a better deal to Remain; https://t.co/m3XtoWcyEH

    BoJo has managed to shoot himself in the foot with his first act

    Boris appears to be advocating doing the hokey cokey...
    He thus wants to stay in the EU. This all goes to again show show that even with a leave vote then the arguments will only just be beginning.
    Any guesses what that will do to shares, the stock exchange, investment, jobs?
    Jobs? Investment? Yes I hear you all sneer. Well not immediately but inevitably yes. The arguments would only just start. Gawd help us.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @adamboultonSKY: Boris #Brexit case seems to be the wonderful deal rEU would give UK to come back in - Cripes!

    Yup, he is a massive boon the OUT IN camp
  • Options

    chestnut said:

    More like a £66 billion UK deficit on goods and services with the EU during the last year:

    The extent of Cameron's failure is in that number.

    They make a £66bn profit out of us - we are a fantastic customer - and still they won't meet our needs.

    Put the money on the line.
    It will be even more than that:

    £66bn trade & services deficit + UK tourism deficit with EU + UK net contribution to EU

    Its probably approaching £100bn per year. And growing.
    All the data for the balance of payments that you are referring to is released each October 30th as The Pink Book by the ONS.

    The last one covering 2014 shows we have a current account deficit with the rest of the EU for the year of £107 billion
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @faisalislam: Mayor's article rather expands on what he said to me outside his house: - Vote leave to get a better deal
    https://t.co/23DxuoxVda

    @georgeeaton: Boris's implicit backing for second referendum based on expectation he could hold it as PM.
  • Options
    FensterFenster Posts: 2,115
    edited February 2016
    I'm not surprised that Boris is equivocal in his Telegraph piece.

    I don't buy this self-interest stuff. Boris is a smart cookie who wants to be PM. He'll know that a hard line Eurosceptic stance may well win him the Tory leadership but - given the way the polls are, and the lack of affection for the Conservatives in general - not Downing Street.

    As Casino alluded to below, I suspect Boris has reluctantly gone with his principles because he feels the deal is underwhelming. The difficulty now is, if he indeed he believes he could one day negotiate a better deal, convincing us voters that the other EU countries are willing to sign-up to dramatic, UK-benefiting changes. They aren't. Boris isn't really in a great spot.
  • Options
    hunchman said:

    I really don't like what I'm seeing in Germany right now, particularly cheering the misfortune of others when its life threatening:

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-35625595

    The hysteria has been whipped up so what do you expect.
    Just wait til Trump gets going.
  • Options
    MarkHopkinsMarkHopkins Posts: 5,584

    Scott_P said:

    @tnewtondunn: Boris: the plot thickens. Strong suggestion in his Telegraph column he'll Vote Leave for a better deal to Remain; https://t.co/m3XtoWcyEH

    BoJo has managed to shoot himself in the foot with his first act

    Boris appears to be advocating doing the hokey cokey...
    He thus wants to stay in the EU. This all goes to again show show that even with a leave vote then the arguments will only just be beginning.
    Any guesses what that will do to shares, the stock exchange, investment, jobs?
    Jobs? Investment? Yes I hear you all sneer. Well not immediately but inevitably yes. The arguments would only just start. Gawd help us.

    We survived the Battle of Britain, the Cold War, and even the big freeze of 1963.

    I think we'll cope.

  • Options
    runnymederunnymede Posts: 2,536
    The EU is about as open to reform as the French Ancien Regime or the medieval papacy was.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @steverichards14: Boris Tel column shows he is not for 'out'. Instead he argues the rest of the EU will 'listen' if UK votes 'out'.. An unconvincing Third Way

    The most prominent outer, is not an outer...

    Is Cameron the luckiest PM in history?
  • Options
    Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Are you feeling warm and fuzzy now?

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



  • Options
    Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Jeez, this is beyond tiresome.

    Doesn't he have another tune?
    Scott_P said:

    @politicshome: Nigel Farage challenges Nicola Sturgeon to EU debate in Scotland: https://t.co/eCuEuDRUWQ https://t.co/ZVVrX0jOry

  • Options
    I don't think Johnsonnis arguing vote Leave to Remain. I think his new relationship means a trade deal outside the EU.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @ShippersUnbound: Boris's article makes clear he still wants to have his cake and eat it - a no vote to get concessions. It is au revoir to Brussels not adieu
  • Options
    AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    Scott_P said:

    @politicshome: Nigel Farage challenges Nicola Sturgeon to EU debate in Scotland: https://t.co/eCuEuDRUWQ https://t.co/ZVVrX0jOry

    Will he run away if she says yes like when Salmond agreed?
  • Options
    Scott_P said:

    @steverichards14: Boris Tel column shows he is not for 'out'. Instead he argues the rest of the EU will 'listen' if UK votes 'out'.. An unconvincing Third Way

    The most prominent outer, is not an outer...

    Is Cameron the luckiest PM in history?

    Yes, he means they will listen as we negotiate a new trade oriented relationship. I don't know why people are struggling with this.
  • Options
    FensterFenster Posts: 2,115
    edited February 2016

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    The horrible bastard has dedicated a decade of his life trying to transform the lives of people living in generational poverty, when any fool knows giving them handouts and no prospect of a job is a better answer.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @ShippersUnbound: Boris is backing a No vote but not necessarily Brexit. Last February he told me he wanted to lead the renegotiation. He still does.

    @EdConwaySky: Boris column underlines biggest problem facing the Leave camp: there is still no coherent policy on what happens next after a Brexit vote
  • Options

    Scott_P said:

    @tnewtondunn: Boris: the plot thickens. Strong suggestion in his Telegraph column he'll Vote Leave for a better deal to Remain; https://t.co/m3XtoWcyEH

    BoJo has managed to shoot himself in the foot with his first act

    Boris appears to be advocating doing the hokey cokey...
    He thus wants to stay in the EU. This all goes to again show show that even with a leave vote then the arguments will only just be beginning.
    Any guesses what that will do to shares, the stock exchange, investment, jobs?
    Jobs? Investment? Yes I hear you all sneer. Well not immediately but inevitably yes. The arguments would only just start. Gawd help us.

    We survived the Battle of Britain, the Cold War, and even the big freeze of 1963.

    I think we'll cope.

    And the ERM
  • Options
    flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903
    edited February 2016
    Charles said:

    OK I feel like facing a dilemma that I never imagined and genuinely no longer know how to vote or who to support. I'm feeling turned off by everyone.

    I can't stand the argument to stay in the EU so that Parliament can't decide on social issues and we keep unproductive socialist 'rights'. Parliament should be sovereign.
    I can't stand the argument to leave the EU to stop immigration, I think reciprocal free movement between developed economies is a good thing.

    I've despised "obsessed about Europe" Tories since the 90's. I couldn't stand IDS or Redwood. I could never imagine wanting to Leave. But Gove's leave argument was very convincing and well written and I really am not sure whether or why I want to Remain anymore.

    Ultimately I am currently thinking that the absolute worst case scenario is a narrow Remain win that keeps this like an open sore. Better either a Remain landslide (over 60%) or any Leave victory that makes Parliament sovereign and closes this once and for all. I'm genuinely no longer sure which I prefer though.

    Feels very weird not to be sure how to vote during a campaign.

    Vote Leave, then. We should be free to determine what we want. I suspect we will end up in EFTA anyway, meaning that there will be a reasonable amount of immigration in any event
    Ha !
    What a joke of a comment.

    I sympathise with Mr Thompson. But when Boris says he is voting leave only to want to remain then you know how fractured leave are.
    The one ukip mp seems to have been silenced.
    The main aim of one slice of leave is to settle old scores and another to urge the Tories to split.
    I am not being led up any of those garden paths but everyone has to decide for themselves
  • Options
    runnymederunnymede Posts: 2,536
    Boris's article makes clear he still wants to have his cake and eat it - a no vote to get concessions

    So that's the 'instant rebuttal' spin line, is it? pathetic
  • Options
    Y0kelY0kel Posts: 2,307
    edited February 2016

    Scott_P said:

    @tnewtondunn: Boris: the plot thickens. Strong suggestion in his Telegraph column he'll Vote Leave for a better deal to Remain; https://t.co/m3XtoWcyEH

    BoJo has managed to shoot himself in the foot with his first act

    Boris appears to be advocating doing the hokey cokey...
    He thus wants to stay in the EU. This all goes to again show show that even with a leave vote then the arguments will only just be beginning.
    Any guesses what that will do to shares, the stock exchange, investment, jobs?
    Jobs? Investment? Yes I hear you all sneer. Well not immediately but inevitably yes. The arguments would only just start. Gawd help us.

    We survived the Battle of Britain, the Cold War, and even the big freeze of 1963.

    I think we'll cope.

    The UK is a truly great country, it has long looked outward and will continue to do so, EU member or not.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @DPJHodges: George Osborne will be keeping Boris' "I want to vote out to stay in" article in a glass case on his desk. To be broken in emergencies.
  • Options

    Didn't think much of that, was bored halfway through.

    Still glad he's added weight to VoteLeave

    Scott_P said:

    @JohnRentoul: Boris's column in Telegraph is up https://t.co/EHr5tfOaSL

    Why am I not surprised. Stick to the box sets.
  • Options
    isamisam Posts: 40,930
    Scott_P said:

    @ShippersUnbound: Boris is backing a No vote but not necessarily Brexit. Last February he told me he wanted to lead the renegotiation. He still does.

    @EdConwaySky: Boris column underlines biggest problem facing the Leave camp: there is still no coherent policy on what happens next after a Brexit vote

    What does the Rees Mogg parody account have to say?
  • Options
    Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/feb/21/carwyn-jones-says-welsh-labour-will-distance-itself-from-jeremy-corbyn
    Jones said the tactic on doorsteps would be to emphasise that candidates represent Welsh Labour, not the UK party. “It’s a Welsh election,” he said. “This is Welsh Labour, which in terms of policy is autonomous. We develop our own policies, our own laws – there’s no influence from London at all”
  • Options

    Didn't think much of that, was bored halfway through.

    Still glad he's added weight to VoteLeave

    Scott_P said:

    @JohnRentoul: Boris's column in Telegraph is up https://t.co/EHr5tfOaSL

    Why am I not surprised. Stick to the box sets.
    You are truly deranged!
  • Options

    Scott_P said:

    @tnewtondunn: Boris: the plot thickens. Strong suggestion in his Telegraph column he'll Vote Leave for a better deal to Remain; https://t.co/m3XtoWcyEH

    BoJo has managed to shoot himself in the foot with his first act

    Boris appears to be advocating doing the hokey cokey...
    He thus wants to stay in the EU. This all goes to again show show that even with a leave vote then the arguments will only just be beginning.
    Any guesses what that will do to shares, the stock exchange, investment, jobs?
    Jobs? Investment? Yes I hear you all sneer. Well not immediately but inevitably yes. The arguments would only just start. Gawd help us.
    Why don't we just abolish democracy and let Osborne be Chancellor for Life as that will eliminate uncertainty too.
  • Options
    SMukeshSMukesh Posts: 1,650
    Tories at war...what not to like...
  • Options
    runnymederunnymede Posts: 2,536
    'Gawd help us'

    Certainly if we have to listen to your increasingly hysterical outpourings
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,285
    edited February 2016

    http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/feb/21/carwyn-jones-says-welsh-labour-will-distance-itself-from-jeremy-corbyn

    Jones said the tactic on doorsteps would be to emphasise that candidates represent Welsh Labour, not the UK party. “It’s a Welsh election,” he said. “This is Welsh Labour, which in terms of policy is autonomous. We develop our own policies, our own laws – there’s no influence from London at all”
    The Welsh Labour Party with the fantastic record on NHS, education, etc? By fantastic, I mean shitter than England.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,797
    Y0kel said:

    Scott_P said:

    @tnewtondunn: Boris: the plot thickens. Strong suggestion in his Telegraph column he'll Vote Leave for a better deal to Remain; https://t.co/m3XtoWcyEH

    BoJo has managed to shoot himself in the foot with his first act

    Boris appears to be advocating doing the hokey cokey...
    He thus wants to stay in the EU. This all goes to again show show that even with a leave vote then the arguments will only just be beginning.
    Any guesses what that will do to shares, the stock exchange, investment, jobs?
    Jobs? Investment? Yes I hear you all sneer. Well not immediately but inevitably yes. The arguments would only just start. Gawd help us.

    We survived the Battle of Britain, the Cold War, and even the big freeze of 1963.

    I think we'll cope.

    The UK is a truly great country, it has long looked outward and will continue to do so, EU member or not.
    I agree, and it's one reason why despite uncertainty I think we'll be fine if we leave, although of course there will be difficulties. But oddly, it's one area Hannan and some others don't agree. I recall getting to the end of his book, which had talked about how great we were, in essence, how much overcome, and then seemed to end oddly flatly with 'but the EU is too much for us', strangely pessimistic. I don't think we should have to overcome it, but if we are to stay in, we'll struggle through.
    SMukesh said:

    Tories at war...what not to like...

    It's only fair given the fun they've been having for half a year.
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,001
    Scott_P said:

    @ShippersUnbound: Boris's article makes clear he still wants to have his cake and eat it - a no vote to get concessions. It is au revoir to Brussels not adieu

    I have just managed to lose all the respect for Boris Johnson that I'd just gained...

    Out is out.
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,285
    edited February 2016
    Boris Johnson Dancing to the Hokey Cokey

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OMxbGOHU29U
  • Options
    Just read Boris's article. I don't agree with the second referendum meme he genuinely seems convinced that leaving is right because there's no end to the ratchet. I imagine his talk of a better alternative to be along the lines of EFTA not a second remain vote.
  • Options
    foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    edited February 2016
    Fenster said:

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    The horrible bastard has dedicated a decade of his life trying to transform the lives of people living in generational poverty, when any fool knows giving them handouts and no prospect of a job is a better answer.
    Universal Credit does rather seem like the Chillcott report or TSE's legendary magnum opus. Waiting for Godot.
  • Options

    Just read Boris's article. I don't agree with the second referendum meme he genuinely seems convinced that leaving is right because there's no end to the ratchet. I imagine his talk of a better alternative to be along the lines of EFTA not a second remain vote.

    Perhaps he will enlightened in next weeks exciting installment.
  • Options
    Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Ditto. Let's hope 99.999% of the population don't read that.
    rcs1000 said:

    Scott_P said:

    @ShippersUnbound: Boris's article makes clear he still wants to have his cake and eat it - a no vote to get concessions. It is au revoir to Brussels not adieu

    I have just managed to lose all the respect for Boris Johnson that I'd just gained...

    Out is out.
  • Options

    Fenster said:

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    The horrible bastard has dedicated a decade of his life trying to transform the lives of people living in generational poverty, when any fool knows giving them handouts and no prospect of a job is a better answer.
    Universal Credit does rather seem like the Chillcott report or TSE's legendary magnum opus. Waiting for Godot.
    Except UC has already started.
  • Options
    FensterFenster Posts: 2,115

    Fenster said:

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    The horrible bastard has dedicated a decade of his life trying to transform the lives of people living in generational poverty, when any fool knows giving them handouts and no prospect of a job is a better answer.
    Universal Credit does rather seem like the Chillcott report or TSE's legendary magnum opus.
    Yeah but I at least give him credit for trying to tackle an awfully complex, emotive problem. And one that has genuinely ruined hundreds of thousands of young lives.

    As a leader though, he was spectacularly shite.
  • Options
    Oh Boris, what have you done?
  • Options

    Charles said:

    OK I feel like facing a dilemma that I never imagined and genuinely no longer know how to vote or who to support. I'm feeling turned off by everyone.

    I can't stand the argument to stay in the EU so that Parliament can't decide on social issues and we keep unproductive socialist 'rights'. Parliament should be sovereign.
    I can't stand the argument to leave the EU to stop immigration, I think reciprocal free movement between developed economies is a good thing.

    I've despised "obsessed about Europe" Tories since the 90's. I couldn't stand IDS or Redwood. I could never imagine wanting to Leave. But Gove's leave argument was very convincing and well written and I really am not sure whether or why I want to Remain anymore.

    Ultimately I am currently thinking that the absolute worst case scenario is a narrow Remain win that keeps this like an open sore. Better either a Remain landslide (over 60%) or any Leave victory that makes Parliament sovereign and closes this once and for all. I'm genuinely no longer sure which I prefer though.

    Feels very weird not to be sure how to vote during a campaign.

    Vote Leave, then. We should be free to determine what we want. I suspect we will end up in EFTA anyway, meaning that there will be a reasonable amount of immigration in any event
    Ha !
    What a joke of a comment.

    I sympathise with Mr Thompson. But when Boris says he is voting leave only to want to remain then you know how fractured leave are.
    The one ukip mp seems to have been silenced.
    The main aim of one slice of leave is to settle old scores and another to urge the Tories to split.
    I am not being led up any of those garden paths but everyone has to decide for themselves
    Have you got anything positive to say about the EU?

    I've been waiting all night, Philip had a couple of points that were batted away easier than an Ashley Giles straight arm ball, if you have any bouncers to chuck at me then bring it on.
  • Options

    chestnut said:

    More like a £66 billion UK deficit on goods and services with the EU during the last year:

    The extent of Cameron's failure is in that number.

    They make a £66bn profit out of us - we are a fantastic customer - and still they won't meet our needs.

    Put the money on the line.
    It will be even more than that:

    £66bn trade & services deficit + UK tourism deficit with EU + UK net contribution to EU

    Its probably approaching £100bn per year. And growing.
    All the data for the balance of payments that you are referring to is released each October 30th as The Pink Book by the ONS.

    The last one covering 2014 shows we have a current account deficit with the rest of the EU for the year of £107 billion
    Indeed we do, it has steadily increased from only £3bn in 2001:

    http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/datasets-and-tables/data-selector.html?cdid=L87C&dataset=pb&table-id=9.2

    Thanks for the info.

  • Options
    SMukesh said:

    Tories at war...what not to like...

    The fact that as long as Corbyn is Labour leader they win the next general election easily.

  • Options
    perdixperdix Posts: 1,806
    edited February 2016

    Are you feeling warm and fuzzy now?

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    @mwjfrome 17 Let's hear your arguments for or against policy, not merely smearing people because you have no arguments.

  • Options

    Charles said:

    OK I feel like facing a dilemma that I never imagined and genuinely no longer know how to vote or who to support. I'm feeling turned off by everyone.

    I can't stand the argument to stay in the EU so that Parliament can't decide on social issues and we keep unproductive socialist 'rights'. Parliament should be sovereign.
    I can't stand the argument to leave the EU to stop immigration, I think reciprocal free movement between developed economies is a good thing.

    I've despised "obsessed about Europe" Tories since the 90's. I couldn't stand IDS or Redwood. I could never imagine wanting to Leave. But Gove's leave argument was very convincing and well written and I really am not sure whether or why I want to Remain anymore.

    Ultimately I am currently thinking that the absolute worst case scenario is a narrow Remain win that keeps this like an open sore. Better either a Remain landslide (over 60%) or any Leave victory that makes Parliament sovereign and closes this once and for all. I'm genuinely no longer sure which I prefer though.

    Feels very weird not to be sure how to vote during a campaign.

    Vote Leave, then. We should be free to determine what we want. I suspect we will end up in EFTA anyway, meaning that there will be a reasonable amount of immigration in any event
    Ha !
    What a joke of a comment.

    I sympathise with Mr Thompson. But when Boris says he is voting leave only to want to remain then you know how fractured leave are.
    The one ukip mp seems to have been silenced.
    The main aim of one slice of leave is to settle old scores and another to urge the Tories to split.
    I am not being led up any of those garden paths but everyone has to decide for themselves
    Have you got anything positive to say about the EU?

    I've been waiting all night, Philip had a couple of points that were batted away easier than an Ashley Giles straight arm ball, if you have any bouncers to chuck at me then bring it on.
    Batted away? Even committed Leavers agreed there is no way to guarantee the French would not be spiteful and prevent us getting a free trade deal. If you want to put your head in the sand and just wish away the risks then that doesn't make you right or bright.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453

    Oh Boris, what have you done?

    How are all the Boris cheerleaders feeling now?
  • Options
    Fenster said:

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    The horrible bastard has dedicated a decade of his life trying to transform the lives of people living in generational poverty, when any fool knows giving them handouts and no prospect of a job is a better answer.
    Sorry, are you serious. Really. A decade of his life. As far as I know he'd been an MP, a shadow minister, Leader of the Opposition (the quiet man) and then Cabinet minister. Selfless. Even though he was once party leader he is most famous for shafting his then Prime Minister over Maastricht. And who was responsible for this generational poverty. Closing the mines, the steel plants, the ship building capacity overnight and replacing with the odd call centre. Who was that. His heroine. Selling off council housing. How did that work our for social mobility? The drug and alcohol problems that followed on. Do you ever wonder what the costs have been of these policies rather than the perceived costs of having communities in work. No. You don't.
  • Options
    FensterFenster Posts: 2,115

    SMukesh said:

    Tories at war...what not to like...

    The fact that as long as Corbyn is Labour leader they win the next general election easily.

    Beat me to it.. Corbyn's leadership has, ironically, enabled the Tory party to appear as fractured as it likes.... with immunity.
  • Options
    runnymede said:

    'Gawd help us'

    Certainly if we have to listen to your increasingly hysterical outpourings

    Sorry but that line won't work. The hysterics are plain to see and its all Leave.
    I can't stop you living on your sad little dream world but a read SMukesh's little comment and I can see what the anti Tories hope to get out of the referendum. Unlike some conservatives on here I am clearly not brainless and can see what conservative opponents hope for.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    This is just the headline he was looking for...

    @PolhomeEditor: Boris Johnson hints Britain could remain in EU even after Leave vote https://t.co/zcfsvsqT2O https://t.co/9E2D4l3VhX
  • Options

    Just read Boris's article. I don't agree with the second referendum meme he genuinely seems convinced that leaving is right because there's no end to the ratchet. I imagine his talk of a better alternative to be along the lines of EFTA not a second remain vote.

    Leave's free movement problem is a major one. Do they want to end it or not? I guess it depends who you ask, but it's Boris and the Tories who will be doing the negotiating.

  • Options

    Charles said:

    OK I feel like facing a dilemma that I never imagined and genuinely no longer know how to vote or who to support. I'm feeling turned off by everyone.

    I can't stand the argument to stay in the EU so that Parliament can't decide on social issues and we keep unproductive socialist 'rights'. Parliament should be sovereign.
    I can't stand the argument to leave the EU to stop immigration, I think reciprocal free movement between developed economies is a good thing.

    I've despised "obsessed about Europe" Tories since the 90's. I couldn't stand IDS or Redwood. I could never imagine wanting to Leave. But Gove's leave argument was very convincing and well written and I really am not sure whether or why I want to Remain anymore.

    Ultimately I am currently thinking that the absolute worst case scenario is a narrow Remain win that keeps this like an open sore. Better either a Remain landslide (over 60%) or any Leave victory that makes Parliament sovereign and closes this once and for all. I'm genuinely no longer sure which I prefer though.

    Feels very weird not to be sure how to vote during a campaign.

    Vote Leave, then. We should be free to determine what we want. I suspect we will end up in EFTA anyway, meaning that there will be a reasonable amount of immigration in any event
    Ha !
    What a joke of a comment.

    I sympathise with Mr Thompson. But when Boris says he is voting leave only to want to remain then you know how fractured leave are.
    The one ukip mp seems to have been silenced.
    The main aim of one slice of leave is to settle old scores and another to urge the Tories to split.
    I am not being led up any of those garden paths but everyone has to decide for themselves
    Have you got anything positive to say about the EU?

    I've been waiting all night, Philip had a couple of points that were batted away easier than an Ashley Giles straight arm ball, if you have any bouncers to chuck at me then bring it on.
    Batted away? Even committed Leavers agreed there is no way to guarantee the French would not be spiteful and prevent us getting a free trade deal. If you want to put your head in the sand and just wish away the risks then that doesn't make you right or bright.
    To begin with the French are just one out of 26, however if they do want to impose a trade tariff then fine, there will be a reciprocal arrangement. We would be forced into protectionism of their making, no bad thing. We cannot lose given the trade deficit.

    Fancy a game of poker?
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @SarahbaxterSTM: Boris wants us to vote out - so he can be PM and renegotiate for us to stay in?! https://t.co/ADwPqS606S
  • Options
    CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    Fenster said:

    taffys said:

    The fact is nobody really knows what the City would look like after Brexit. Losing the single market would be a big hit to euro denominated business, probably, but there could be offsetting benefits in less aggressively socialist, controlling regulation. And the euro business might come back.

    In the end, its a judgement call.

    Apologies for my lack of knowledge on this bit what would happen to the EU if we left?

    And given the issues around the CAP, would farming in this country benefit from Brexit?

    RE: farming, we could design a farm subsidy system (if any) that was tailored to UK needs (eg supporting marginal hill farmers vs Lincolnshire agribusinesses). And the cost of food would probably fall for consumers.
  • Options
    foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548

    chestnut said:

    More like a £66 billion UK deficit on goods and services with the EU during the last year:

    The extent of Cameron's failure is in that number.

    They make a £66bn profit out of us - we are a fantastic customer - and still they won't meet our needs.

    Put the money on the line.
    It will be even more than that:

    £66bn trade & services deficit + UK tourism deficit with EU + UK net contribution to EU

    Its probably approaching £100bn per year. And growing.
    All the data for the balance of payments that you are referring to is released each October 30th as The Pink Book by the ONS.

    The last one covering 2014 shows we have a current account deficit with the rest of the EU for the year of £107 billion
    Indeed we do, it has steadily increased from only £3bn in 2001:

    http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/datasets-and-tables/data-selector.html?cdid=L87C&dataset=pb&table-id=9.2

    Thanks for the info.

    From 2001, co-inciding with the start of the Euro.
  • Options
    malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 41,993
    Fenster said:

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    The horrible bastard has dedicated a decade of his life trying to transform the lives of people living in generational poverty, when any fool knows giving them handouts and no prospect of a job is a better answer.
    Cuckoo
  • Options
    runnymederunnymede Posts: 2,536
    Johnson said 'It is time to seek a new relationship, in which we manage to extricate ourselves from most of the supranational elements'

    I think almost all LEAVERS and most of the public would agree with that. And voting LEAVE is certainly the only way to get it.
  • Options
    CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    stodge said:

    Charles said:


    So you think it would be right to carry on integrating without asking permission from the People?

    Provision for a referendum on a treaty change already exists. This isn't a treaty change. This is the Conservative Party trying to exorcise its own demons of its own volition.
    The people voted for it in General Election.

    They get what they want.
  • Options
    isamisam Posts: 40,930
    The most popular politician in the country campaigns for Brexit... What a disaster say the in spin
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    edited February 2016

    To begin with the French are just one out of 26, however if they do want to impose a trade tariff then fine, there will be a reciprocal arrangement. We would be forced into protectionism of their making, no bad thing. We cannot lose given the trade deficit.

    Fancy a game of poker?

    We can lose as you are proposing a game of Russian Roulette not Poker. The fact that protectionism would hurt them does not mean it won't hurt us too. Plus since the French and others have shown themselves to not be economically rational it is naive to assume they won't do the wrong thing.
  • Options
    Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Are you secretly working for Leave?

    Your patronising superior being persona is quite remarkable.

    runnymede said:

    'Gawd help us'

    Certainly if we have to listen to your increasingly hysterical outpourings

    Sorry but that line won't work. The hysterics are plain to see and its all Leave.
    I can't stop you living on your sad little dream world but a read SMukesh's little comment and I can see what the anti Tories hope to get out of the referendum. Unlike some conservatives on here I am clearly not brainless and can see what conservative opponents hope for.
  • Options
    chestnutchestnut Posts: 7,341
    Scott_P said:

    @DPJHodges: George Osborne will be keeping Boris' "I want to vote out to stay in" article in a glass case on his desk. To be broken in emergencies.

    Boris says. "Dave's deal is a Dud"

  • Options
    GeoffMGeoffM Posts: 6,071
    edited February 2016

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    [snippety snip]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    Have you considered returning to just lurking?

    You really are a spectacularly unpleasant individual.
  • Options

    Charles said:

    OK I feel like facing a dilemma that I never imagined and genuinely no longer know how to vote or who to support. I'm feeling turned off by everyone.

    I can't stand the argument to stay in the EU so that Parliament can't decide on social issues and we keep unproductive socialist 'rights'. Parliament should be sovereign.
    I can't stand the argument to leave the EU to stop immigration, I think reciprocal free movement between developed economies is a good thing.

    I've despised "obsessed about Europe" Tories since the 90's. I couldn't stand IDS or Redwood. I could never imagine wanting to Leave. But Gove's leave argument was very convincing and well written and I really am not sure whether or why I want to Remain anymore.

    Ultimately I am currently thinking that the absolute worst case scenario is a narrow Remain win that keeps this like an open sore. Better either a Remain landslide (over 60%) or any Leave victory that makes Parliament sovereign and closes this once and for all. I'm genuinely no longer sure which I prefer though.

    Feels very weird not to be sure how to vote during a campaign.

    Vote Leave, then. We should be free to determine what we want. I suspect we will end up in EFTA anyway, meaning that there will be a reasonable amount of immigration in any event
    Ha !
    What a joke of a comment.

    I sympathise with Mr Thompson. But when Boris says he is voting leave only to want to remain then you know how fractured leave are.
    The one ukip mp seems to have been silenced.
    The main aim of one slice of leave is to settle old scores and another to urge the Tories to split.
    I am not being led up any of those garden paths but everyone has to decide for themselves
    Have you got anything positive to say about the EU?

    I've been waiting all night, Philip had a couple of points that were batted away easier than an Ashley Giles straight arm ball, if you have any bouncers to chuck at me then bring it on.
    Batted away? Even committed Leavers agreed there is no way to guarantee the French would not be spiteful and prevent us getting a free trade deal. If you want to put your head in the sand and just wish away the risks then that doesn't make you right or bright.
    To begin with the French are just one out of 26, however if they do want to impose a trade tariff then fine, there will be a reciprocal arrangement. We would be forced into protectionism of their making, no bad thing. We cannot lose given the trade deficit.

    Fancy a game of poker?
    Good laugh that coming from someone who wants to play with my money, well anyone's except his own.
  • Options

    To begin with the French are just one out of 26, however if they do want to impose a trade tariff then fine, there will be a reciprocal arrangement. We would be forced into protectionism of their making, no bad thing. We cannot lose given the trade deficit.

    Fancy a game of poker?

    We can lose as you are proposing a game of Russian Roulette not Poker. The fact that protectionism would hurt them does not mean it won't hurt us too. Plus since the French and others have shown themselves to not be economically rational it is naive to assume they won't do the wrong thing.
    Explain to me what we lose?
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @STJamesl: Not sure the pro-having cake, pro-eating it pose looks great tonight https://t.co/fuiqpRfF0e
  • Options
    FensterFenster Posts: 2,115
    edited February 2016



    Sorry, are you serious. Really. A decade of his life. As far as I know he'd been an MP, a shadow minister, Leader of the Opposition (the quiet man) and then Cabinet minister. Selfless. Even though he was once party leader he is most famous for shafting his then Prime Minister over Maastricht. And who was responsible for this generational poverty. Closing the mines, the steel plants, the ship building capacity overnight and replacing with the odd call centre. Who was that. His heroine. Selling off council housing. How did that work our for social mobility? The drug and alcohol problems that followed on. Do you ever wonder what the costs have been of these policies rather than the perceived costs of having communities in work. No. You don't. -

    -------'---------------'---------------------------------------------------------------
    LOL. I live in one of those communities.

    I know lots of people who chose not to work because they were better off on benefits - a lot of those people are now in work. I know everything in life is Thatcher's fault, including Wales's failure to beat a depleted Ireland side on the 6 Nations opener, but living in a mining village I can tell that paying people to be better off not working is not the answer.
  • Options
    Fenster said:

    SMukesh said:

    Tories at war...what not to like...

    The fact that as long as Corbyn is Labour leader they win the next general election easily.

    Beat me to it.. Corbyn's leadership has, ironically, enabled the Tory party to appear as fractured as it likes.... with immunity.

    That might give a level of hope to Jezza's successor - if, and it's a big if given we're talking about the Stupid Party here, the person concerned is relatively mainstream.

  • Options

    To begin with the French are just one out of 26, however if they do want to impose a trade tariff then fine, there will be a reciprocal arrangement. We would be forced into protectionism of their making, no bad thing. We cannot lose given the trade deficit.

    Fancy a game of poker?

    We can lose as you are proposing a game of Russian Roulette not Poker. The fact that protectionism would hurt them does not mean it won't hurt us too. Plus since the French and others have shown themselves to not be economically rational it is naive to assume they won't do the wrong thing.
    Explain to me what we lose?
    Free trade. We lose on exports that we lose due to their Tariffs, we lose on imports that are made more expensive by our own Tariffs. Lose, lose.
  • Options
    Chris_AChris_A Posts: 1,237
    edited February 2016
    You only have to consider how ranting many of the Tories are on this EU issue from this quoted in the Guardian

    Lisa Parker, a councillor from Rugby who said she was disgusted by how the party was dealing with the European issue.

    “We’ve had to consult 27 countries just to talk about reform. We’ve sold this country out and we’re being ruled by the European Union – by people who hate us, who loathe us. I’ll be voting out, and campaigning every weekend. For the first time in my life I’m questioning if this is the party for me,” she said.


    No the Europeans do not loathe us or hate us, and neither are we being ruled by the EU, and only someone who's seriously lost the plot can believe this nonsense.
  • Options
    MP_SEMP_SE Posts: 3,642
    edited February 2016
    Interesting research from the Guardian. If Guido's numbers are to be believed it could be possible to have close to or slightly over 50% of Tory MPs back Brexit. If a majority of members are also in favour of Brexit this could spell trouble for Remain and Cameron. He would be at odds with not only Tory MPs but also Tory members.
    Of almost 70 constituency parties contacted, only two reported a majority of party members are in favour of remaining in the European Union. Many others were reluctant to hazard a guess as to the how opinion divided in their constituency parties, but among those who did offer breakdowns, more than half a dozen reported a 50/50 split and 17 a majority in favour of leaving.
    http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/feb/21/how-tory-grassroots-split-eu-party-constituency-cameron
  • Options
    GaiusGaius Posts: 227

    hunchman said:

    I really don't like what I'm seeing in Germany right now, particularly cheering the misfortune of others when its life threatening:

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-35625595

    The hysteria has been whipped up so what do you expect.
    Just wait til Trump gets going.
    Do you really think that its only hysteria that has been whipped up?

    You must be a bear of very little brain.

    Ordinary people see an invading horde of muslims swamping the indigenous culture.

    They see their childrens education suffer as teachers focus on the non German speakers.

    They see their parents having to wait longer for medical attention.

    They see their women and children being raped and assualted whist the authorities turn a blind eye.

    They know the invaders have an average IQ of 85 meaning they will never be able to hold down a job in a civilisied society.

    They know their taxes will rocket up to pay for all this.

    And if they speak out they get abused as rayyyyyyycist.

    And you think its whipped up hysteria.

  • Options
    DadgeDadge Posts: 2,038
    The EU campaign has proved itself capable of surprise. First, Cameron did emerge from his meetings with positive noises from the other countries that he could spin as something that was more than nothing. Then, as soon as the starting gun was fired, it was his own allies who changed the nature of the campaign by so many of them coming out against him despite all his efforts. So, all bets are off, so to speak. I still trust the phone polls much more than the online polls, so I think YES has a big lead (10%). But all the momentum is with the NO narrative, so unless the YES campaign goes for the nuclear option and scares everyone sh*tless at the prospect of leaving, I think YES lead will narrow between now and June.
  • Options
    foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548

    Fenster said:

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    The horrible bastard has dedicated a decade of his life trying to transform the lives of people living in generational poverty, when any fool knows giving them handouts and no prospect of a job is a better answer.
    Universal Credit does rather seem like the Chillcott report or TSE's legendary magnum opus. Waiting for Godot.
    Except UC has already started.
    Years late and way over budget. At the current rate it will be 495 years before it is universal!

    http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/jun/25/labour-says-universal-credit-will-take-495-years-to-roll-out-as-costs-rise-3bn
  • Options
    Fenster said:



    Sorry, are you serious. Really. A decade of his life. As far as I know he'd been an MP, a shadow minister, Leader of the Opposition (the quiet man) and then Cabinet minister. Selfless. Even though he was once party leader he is most famous for shafting his then Prime Minister over Maastricht. And who was responsible for this generational poverty. Closing the mines, the steel plants, the ship building capacity overnight and replacing with the odd call centre. Who was that. His heroine. Selling off council housing. How did that work our for social mobility? The drug and alcohol problems that followed on. Do you ever wonder what the costs have been of these policies rather than the perceived costs of having communities in work. No. You don't.

    LOL. I live in one of those communities.

    I know lots of people who chose not to work because they were better off on benefits - a lot of those people are now in work. I know everything in life is Thatcher's fault, including Wales's failure to beat a depleted Ireland side on the 6 Nations opener, but living in a mining village I can tell that paying people to be better off not working is not the answer.


    Sorry I didn't realise you lived in one of those ex-mining villages that were full of jobs. My bad.
  • Options
    FensterFenster Posts: 2,115
    edited February 2016
    malcolmg said:

    Fenster said:

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    The horrible bastard has dedicated a decade of his life trying to transform the lives of people living in generational poverty, when any fool knows giving them handouts and no prospect of a job is a better answer.
    Cuckoo
    You'd know all about generational poverty in Scotland.

    I've been to Glasgow..fuck me, my area is like the Bellagio in comparison.
  • Options
    MortimerMortimer Posts: 13,946

    Boris Johnson sounds genuinely tortured. His current position will satisfy no one, including himself.

    It will swing 5% more votes behind leave.

    After reading the actual agreement, all I can say is thank god.
  • Options

    Fenster said:

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    The horrible bastard has dedicated a decade of his life trying to transform the lives of people living in generational poverty, when any fool knows giving them handouts and no prospect of a job is a better answer.
    Universal Credit does rather seem like the Chillcott report or TSE's legendary magnum opus. Waiting for Godot.
    Except UC has already started.
    Years late and way over budget. At the current rate it will be 495 years before it is universal!

    http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/jun/25/labour-says-universal-credit-will-take-495-years-to-roll-out-as-costs-rise-3bn
    Try a report that isn't incredibly dodgy based on a Labour press release with their ludicrous spin and that isn't nearly a year out of date.
  • Options
    Not a great day...
  • Options

    chestnut said:

    More like a £66 billion UK deficit on goods and services with the EU during the last year:

    The extent of Cameron's failure is in that number.

    They make a £66bn profit out of us - we are a fantastic customer - and still they won't meet our needs.

    Put the money on the line.
    It will be even more than that:

    £66bn trade & services deficit + UK tourism deficit with EU + UK net contribution to EU

    Its probably approaching £100bn per year. And growing.
    All the data for the balance of payments that you are referring to is released each October 30th as The Pink Book by the ONS.

    The last one covering 2014 shows we have a current account deficit with the rest of the EU for the year of £107 billion
    Indeed we do, it has steadily increased from only £3bn in 2001:

    http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/datasets-and-tables/data-selector.html?cdid=L87C&dataset=pb&table-id=9.2

    Thanks for the info.

    From 2001, co-inciding with the start of the Euro.
    And in 2001 UK government debt stood at £329 by 2015 it was £1606bn:

    http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/datasets-and-tables/data-selector.html?cdid=HF6W&dataset=pusf&table-id=PSA1

    Now I wonder where much of that borrowed money flowed to.
  • Options
    isam said:

    The most popular politician in the country campaigns for Brexit... What a disaster say the in spin

    Will he be campaigning? We know he won't be debating. Interviews look like they'll be off limits too. The odd column, some jolly photos, the odd speech ... Others will be doing the heavy lifting. And Boris has raised all kinds of questions about what a Leave vote actually means.

  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,074
    runnymede said:

    Johnson said 'It is time to seek a new relationship, in which we manage to extricate ourselves from most of the supranational elements'

    I think almost all LEAVERS and most of the public would agree with that. And voting LEAVE is certainly the only way to get it.

    I can see why Cameron would be furious because Johnson is clearly saying 'Vote Out, Get A Second Deal', which undermines the whole platform on which Cameron wants to build the In case.
  • Options
    foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548

    Fenster said:

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    The horrible bastard has dedicated a decade of his life trying to transform the lives of people living in generational poverty, when any fool knows giving them handouts and no prospect of a job is a better answer.
    Universal Credit does rather seem like the Chillcott report or TSE's legendary magnum opus. Waiting for Godot.
    Except UC has already started.
    Years late and way over budget. At the current rate it will be 495 years before it is universal!

    http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/jun/25/labour-says-universal-credit-will-take-495-years-to-roll-out-as-costs-rise-3bn
    Try a report that isn't incredibly dodgy based on a Labour press release with their ludicrous spin and that isn't nearly a year out of date.
    I actually quite like the idea of UC. But it shows that IDS is pretty incompetent at implementation, amongst many other flaws.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    BoJo is Vicky Pollard...

    Yeah, but, No, but...
  • Options
    isamisam Posts: 40,930

    isam said:

    The most popular politician in the country campaigns for Brexit... What a disaster say the in spin

    Will he be campaigning? We know he won't be debating. Interviews look like they'll be off limits too. The odd column, some jolly photos, the odd speech ... Others will be doing the heavy lifting. And Boris has raised all kinds of questions about what a Leave vote actually means.

    So say the headlines

    And as he is the most popular politician in the country, that will probably be enough for the overwhelming number of people who aren't really interested in politics

    You only have to see how many times Scott P has tried to make it seem bad news for Leave to know its a major plus for them
  • Options
    WandererWanderer Posts: 3,838

    Fenster said:

    As for IDS saying that staying in EU would leave us more vulnerable to 'Paris style attacks' is beneath contempt. Just an old fashioned Enoch Powell style piece of claptrap.

    IDS married Elizabeth "Betsy" Fremantle, daughter of the 5th Baron Cottesloe, in 1982. The couple have four children, and live in a country house belonging to his father-in-law's estate in Swanbourne, Buckinghamshire.

    Obviously some tough life choices there.

    I dont mind that he does not have a high level of academic achievement as I don't either. I don't lie abut mine.

    According to the BBC, Duncan Smith's biography on the Conservative Party website and his entry in Who's Who originally stated that he had studied at the University of Perugia in Italy. A BBC investigation in 2002 found this statement to be untrue.[7] In response to the BBC story, Duncan Smith's office stated that he had in fact attended the Università per Stranieri, a different institution in Perugia, for a year.[7] He did not complete his course of study, sit exams, or gain any qualifications there. Duncan Smith's biography, on the Conservative Party website, also stated that he was "educated at Dunchurch College of Management" but his office later confirmed that he did not gain any qualifications there either, that he completed six separate courses lasting a few days each, adding up to about a month in total.[7] Dunchurch was the former staff college for GEC Marconi, for whom Duncan Smith worked in the 1980s.[7]

    PS I hate IDS and all he stands for.



    The horrible bastard has dedicated a decade of his life trying to transform the lives of people living in generational poverty, when any fool knows giving them handouts and no prospect of a job is a better answer.
    Universal Credit does rather seem like the Chillcott report or TSE's legendary magnum opus. Waiting for Godot.
    Except UC has already started.
    Years late and way over budget. At the current rate it will be 495 years before it is universal!

    http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/jun/25/labour-says-universal-credit-will-take-495-years-to-roll-out-as-costs-rise-3bn
    Try a report that isn't incredibly dodgy based on a Labour press release with their ludicrous spin and that isn't nearly a year out of date.
    I actually quite like the idea of UC. But it shows that IDS is pretty incompetent at implementation, amongst many other flaws.
    He's completely useless. He's only in the Cabinet for party unity and as an act of charity.
This discussion has been closed.