Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Biden moves to an 84% chance of victory on the exchanges as the scale of his likely victory becomes

145679

Comments

  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,342

    Ohio as a bellwether looks to have gone

    Bellwethers change.
    Dartford used to be ours.
    And Greater London used to be the bellwether region.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,873

    As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Only seems likely if Labour don't win out right, since like Trudeau I'm sure they will find other things to do once they actually win.
  • Foxy said:

    Ohio as a bellwether looks to have gone

    Indeed i

    Foxy said:

    Kamala Harris was a shit choice for VP. I reckon she cost the Democrats a lot of ground.

    Possibly so. A bit too Black, Indian, Female, and Californian for the swing voters.

    She may well be a very good VP though. She seems quite feisty and intelligent.

    Campaigning skill correlates very poorly, perhaps even inversely, with skill at governing.
    I think the bigotry stuff is an excuse. Obama had no problems there.

    Democrats really need to STOP seeing everything through the prism of race, gender and sexuality.

    It really pisses a lot of people off and is BS.
    If you think racial, sexuality and gender are no longer issues arousing prejudice in America, then perhaps you need to get out of your bubble and meet more ordinary folk.
    I'm not the one in a bubble mate.

    I know way more about this stuff than you do.
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,477
    Chris said:

    I see Nate Silver is now classing Arizona and Nevada as "Likely Biden", Pennsylvania as "Lean Biden", Georgia as "Tossup" (or "Lean Biden" if forced to choose) and North Carolina as "Likely Trump".

    That's an exact match of the Democratic campaign chief – although she didn't explicitly mention NV and AZ when briefing CNN
  • kle4 said:

    As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Only seems likely if Labour don't win out right, since like Trudeau I'm sure they will find other things to do once they actually win.
    Frankly I agree based on history so for that recent in 2024 I am hoping for a Hung Parliament as long term that will deliver the change we need. Labour has to be forced into it, then so be it.
  • Genuinely think it's a distinct possibility Biden gets over 300

    I would love it if it was 306 as that was my prediction (albeit with a slightly different roster of states).
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 32,171
    A lot of commentators are saying Trump would have won without Covid-19. I don't agree, I don't think it made much difference to how people voted.
  • 306 with a large victory in the popular vote would IMHO be a pretty decisive rejection of Trump.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,428

    Foxy said:

    Ohio as a bellwether looks to have gone

    Indeed i

    Foxy said:

    Kamala Harris was a shit choice for VP. I reckon she cost the Democrats a lot of ground.

    Possibly so. A bit too Black, Indian, Female, and Californian for the swing voters.

    She may well be a very good VP though. She seems quite feisty and intelligent.

    Campaigning skill correlates very poorly, perhaps even inversely, with skill at governing.
    I think the bigotry stuff is an excuse. Obama had no problems there.

    Democrats really need to STOP seeing everything through the prism of race, gender and sexuality.

    It really pisses a lot of people off and is BS.
    If you think racial, sexuality and gender are no longer issues arousing prejudice in America, then perhaps you need to get out of your bubble and meet more ordinary folk.
    I'm not the one in a bubble mate.

    I know way more about this stuff than you do.
    You’re the one pushing identity politics, AGAIN. Over 50% of Americans have just voted for the people talking about race, sexuality, and gender. A majority. So who’s in the bubble?

    Both side need to seek common ground. This is not simply about “city folk” having to pander to those in the towns.
  • Foxy said:

    Kamala Harris was a shit choice for VP. I reckon she cost the Democrats a lot of ground.

    Possibly so. A bit too Black, Indian, Female, and Californian for the swing voters.

    She may well be a very good VP though. She seems quite feisty and intelligent.

    Campaigning skill correlates very poorly, perhaps even inversely, with skill at governing.
    I think the bigotry stuff is an excuse. Obama had no problems there.

    Democrats really need to STOP seeing everything through the prism of race, gender and sexuality.

    It really pisses a lot of people off and is BS.
    A majority of Americans have voted for them.
    Well, exactly. So there are clearly Americans who must not be put off.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 51,320
    Andy_JS said:

    A lot of commentators are saying Trump would have won without Covid-19. I don't agree, I don't think it made much difference to how people voted.

    Both statements can be true. It didn't make much difference, but the difference it did make may have been decisive.
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 22,153

    As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Oh god we're not going to spend the next four years debating the virtues of FPTP Vs AV Vs PR again are we? :D
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 48,480

    Foxy said:

    Ohio as a bellwether looks to have gone

    Indeed i

    Foxy said:

    Kamala Harris was a shit choice for VP. I reckon she cost the Democrats a lot of ground.

    Possibly so. A bit too Black, Indian, Female, and Californian for the swing voters.

    She may well be a very good VP though. She seems quite feisty and intelligent.

    Campaigning skill correlates very poorly, perhaps even inversely, with skill at governing.
    I think the bigotry stuff is an excuse. Obama had no problems there.

    Democrats really need to STOP seeing everything through the prism of race, gender and sexuality.

    It really pisses a lot of people off and is BS.
    If you think racial, sexuality and gender are no longer issues arousing prejudice in America, then perhaps you need to get out of your bubble and meet more ordinary folk.
    I'm not the one in a bubble mate.

    I know way more about this stuff than you do.
    Well, doesn't seem like it from what you post here.
  • Foxy said:

    Ohio as a bellwether looks to have gone

    Indeed i

    Foxy said:

    Kamala Harris was a shit choice for VP. I reckon she cost the Democrats a lot of ground.

    Possibly so. A bit too Black, Indian, Female, and Californian for the swing voters.

    She may well be a very good VP though. She seems quite feisty and intelligent.

    Campaigning skill correlates very poorly, perhaps even inversely, with skill at governing.
    I think the bigotry stuff is an excuse. Obama had no problems there.

    Democrats really need to STOP seeing everything through the prism of race, gender and sexuality.

    It really pisses a lot of people off and is BS.
    If you think racial, sexuality and gender are no longer issues arousing prejudice in America, then perhaps you need to get out of your bubble and meet more ordinary folk.
    I'm not the one in a bubble mate.

    I know way more about this stuff than you do.
    Ooh a good old fashioned PB norm-off! These are always so entertaining.
  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lm-_A9LVYi8

    I thought May was terrible but this is just rude.

    Theresa seems an infinitely better politician after losing the premiership than she did throughout her entire career before and during it. The guarded, bot-like mien that was her hallmark for decades has vanished.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 49,774

    Alistair said:

    Luzerne County

    Voted 58%/38% for Trump in 2016

    VBM
    70% Biden
    30% Trump

    Westmoreland 64/32 for Trump
    VBM
    68% Biden
    31% Trump

    Postal vote are flowing to Biden for every corner of the state.

    Wow. Just wow.

    Biden just mentioned PA in his speech.

    They've won it I think.
    I bored everyone on Zoom with my Pennsylvania model, which doesn't really work because it can't differentiate by mode of voting - but, it peaked at an implausible Trump win by 400k when the on the day vote results came in, and has been falling by around 40k for every 4% of the vote that comes in since then. If that holds for the remainder, Trump wins the state by 3000 votes. I don't think that's right, I think Biden has it. But it is going to the wire.
    Fox has Reps on who think they have PA
  • I'm strongly of the view that to win in 2024 we will not be engaging in a culture war but I do agree with the fundamental statement that in many cases - not all - so-called culture wars are invented out of thin air to rile people up and find something to argue about.
  • paulyork64paulyork64 Posts: 2,507
    Georgia 5/6 each with paddys now.
  • As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Not checking everything with SNP which will be your reality
  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lm-_A9LVYi8

    I thought May was terrible but this is just rude.

    Theresa seems an infinitely better politician after losing the premiership than she did throughout her entire career before and during it. The guarded, bot-like mien that was her hallmark for decades has vanished.
    The Ed Milliband effect
  • Foxy said:

    Kamala Harris was a shit choice for VP. I reckon she cost the Democrats a lot of ground.

    Possibly so. A bit too Black, Indian, Female, and Californian for the swing voters.

    She may well be a very good VP though. She seems quite feisty and intelligent.

    Campaigning skill correlates very poorly, perhaps even inversely, with skill at governing.
    I think the bigotry stuff is an excuse. Obama had no problems there.

    Democrats really need to STOP seeing everything through the prism of race, gender and sexuality.

    It really pisses a lot of people off and is BS.
    A majority of Americans have voted for them.
    But barely scraped through where it mattered and went backwards in other areas. And don't forget Hillary won the national vote too.

    Humility is needed.
    The Electoral Kindergarten is just a mechanism for national vote losers to steal the White House! Sad!
  • Mal557Mal557 Posts: 662

    306 with a large victory in the popular vote would IMHO be a pretty decisive rejection of Trump.

    To get to 306 Biden needs Georgia, I suspect hes going to fall agonisingly short, which would be a shame. But it's still possible of course. NC is too much of a stretch
  • As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Not checking everything with SNP which will be your reality
    SNP support PR. Or if they don't want to support Labour they're most welcome to explain why they put the Tories back into Government.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,873
    Scott_xP said:
    "Diverse coalition of white people in militias and white people NOT in militias"

    Pretty good, although apparently he did diversify his vote a bit.

    Also apparently that movie is 155 minutes long, which is news to me.
  • Foxy said:

    Ohio as a bellwether looks to have gone

    Indeed i

    Foxy said:

    Kamala Harris was a shit choice for VP. I reckon she cost the Democrats a lot of ground.

    Possibly so. A bit too Black, Indian, Female, and Californian for the swing voters.

    She may well be a very good VP though. She seems quite feisty and intelligent.

    Campaigning skill correlates very poorly, perhaps even inversely, with skill at governing.
    I think the bigotry stuff is an excuse. Obama had no problems there.

    Democrats really need to STOP seeing everything through the prism of race, gender and sexuality.

    It really pisses a lot of people off and is BS.
    If you think racial, sexuality and gender are no longer issues arousing prejudice in America, then perhaps you need to get out of your bubble and meet more ordinary folk.
    I'm not the one in a bubble mate.

    I know way more about this stuff than you do.
    LOL
  • Alistair said:

    Trump takes WI/MI/PA by fractions of a percent : Truly a man of the people with a unique bond with blue collar America.
    Biden take WI/MI/PA by fractions of a percent: out of touch costal elite flukes victory

    Good story.

    Isn't this just classic PB right wing hypocrisy? Just let it happen
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 48,480

    Genuinely think it's a distinct possibility Biden gets over 300

    I would love it if it was 306 as that was my prediction (albeit with a slightly different roster of states).
    If Biden wins all the remaining states (not impossible, but unlikely) then I called 49/50 States correctly in my forecast on Monday, missing only Florida, and I did pause over that one.

    Rather regretting my pre dawn reverse ferret on Biden EV now.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,428
    This applies to the right as well as the left.
    https://twitter.com/joebiden/status/1324112939310264322?s=21
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,873

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lm-_A9LVYi8

    I thought May was terrible but this is just rude.

    Theresa seems an infinitely better politician after losing the premiership than she did throughout her entire career before and during it. The guarded, bot-like mien that was her hallmark for decades has vanished.
    Some people are just not up to the top job. It's a tough job. But it's good that she seems to have learned something from her time at the top (probably about trusting Boris).
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 51,320
    The 2024 election could be between the two extremes but represented by younger candidates. An AOC vs a to-be-determined carrier of the Trump flame.
  • I wonder if in years gone by when people were fighting for gay rights, or the rights of women, whether people sat around and said we should just shut up and stop seeing politics through the prism of these pointless culture wars
  • YBarddCwscYBarddCwsc Posts: 7,172

    It is often claimed polling error see-saws from one election to the next, as pollsters over-compensate for the errors of the previous election.

    That hasn't happened here. The polls were wrong last time, and in the same direction and by roughly the same magnitude.

    I also suspect most polls are conducted by firms that are less pro-Trump than the average voter.

    Of course, all polling firms are really trying to get it right — their businesses will suffer if they have a consistent bias.

    But, if you think Trump “should” do substantially worse than last election, and your polls are coming out that way, you will be less likely to question them than if you expected Trump to be doing well.

    It all comes back to Dick Feynman, "The first principle is that you must not fool yourself –- and you are the easiest person to fool."
  • The 2024 election could be between the two extremes but represented by younger candidates. An AOC vs a to-be-determined carrier of the Trump flame.

    AOC is incredibly likeable it must be said, not sure her politics will appeal though
  • EPGEPG Posts: 6,644

    Hopefully, Pelosi will go. She and her acid tongue and San Francisco liberalism has been a huge turnoff for the Dems in the House.

    https://thehill.com/homenews/house/524503-centrist-democrats-talk-leadership-changes-after-negative-election-results?amp#click=https://t.co/x1QzSgT7Jb

    Another woman who in your private reality is an election loser.
  • Pagan2Pagan2 Posts: 9,848

    As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Want pr put it to a referendum and watch it die in a fire
  • Mal557Mal557 Posts: 662

    Chris said:

    I see Nate Silver is now classing Arizona and Nevada as "Likely Biden", Pennsylvania as "Lean Biden", Georgia as "Tossup" (or "Lean Biden" if forced to choose) and North Carolina as "Likely Trump".

    That's an exact match of the Democratic campaign chief – although she didn't explicitly mention NV and AZ when briefing CNN
    Those sound about right, once that first 200,000 drop in Maricopa come in around 9pm local time, unless Trump does really well with them I'd be surprised if the other networks dont follow ABCs early lead and call it for Biden
  • As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Not checking everything with SNP which will be your reality
    SNP support PR. Or if they don't want to support Labour they're most welcome to explain why they put the Tories back into Government.
    SNP only support themselves! That's why they wiped your party out in Scotland 2015 😀
  • If parties in 2024 stand on PR in their manifestos and they are able to form a government then no referendum is needed to deliver it. Just implement it.
  • I'd almost forgot about the looming National Lockdown with all this fun.

    Then the BBC news starts on about it. :anguished:
  • As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Not checking everything with SNP which will be your reality
    SNP support PR. Or if they don't want to support Labour they're most welcome to explain why they put the Tories back into Government.
    SNP only support themselves! That's why they wiped your party out in Scotland 2015 😀
    SNP would have supported Labour in 2015 but I agree with you that Labour is dead in Scotland. Such is the reality, hence why we will have to get back in Wales (going well) and England (also going well).
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,873
    Scott_xP said:
    I know his lawyers will be making more technical arguments around eligble votes and so on, and obviously those questions will get answers from other lawyers, but his whole message really does seem to be the (not unpredicted) 'The TV showed me leading before, not it is not, that is wrong'.
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,586
    edited November 2020
    Alistair said:

    Trump takes WI/MI/PA by fractions of a percent : Truly a man of the people with a unique bond with blue collar America.
    Biden take WI/MI/PA by fractions of a percent: out of touch costal elite flukes victory

    Good story.

    Also, the Rep President is 'claiming' states he has either already lost or which have not been fully counted and he's not predicted to win...

    ...and yet it's the Dems that need to show more humility?

    I'm looking at you @Casino_Royale.
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    Pulpstar said:

    Alistair said:

    Mal557 said:

    I think someone on here, Alistair? was projecting about a 150K win for Biden in PA. Seems Bidens team are now thinking the same,,,,great minds :)
    https://twitter.com/BresPolitico/status/1324098012172439552

    I said 60K earlier this morning. Looks like Alistair was on the nail. We will see.
    I feel a lot of people though I was taking the piss when I said Biden by 180k a few hours ago.
    I think it was more that people didn't dare believe it.
    Dems not as short to win Pa as they were an hour ago. 365 1/3 from 1/5.
    Unless something very odd is about to happen with the remaining vote to come in that should win. I'm on anyway.
    Getting on at 3.85 has saved my night.
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 48,480

    This applies to the right as well as the left.
    https://twitter.com/joebiden/status/1324112939310264322?s=21

    One of Grandpa Joes best features is his genuine desire for consensus. Perhaps because his formative years predate the current culture war. They were of course forged in an equally divisive time of desegregation and Vietnam War protests.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 77,894
    edited November 2020
    The remaining vote needs to come in at Biden +29.5 to draw level in PA.
    There's way more mail compared to in person, the mail has so far averaged Biden + 57.5
  • Joe Biden, the Gordon Brown of American politics, hmm
  • kicorsekicorse Posts: 434
    Foxy said:

    Ohio as a bellwether looks to have gone

    Indeed i

    Foxy said:

    Kamala Harris was a shit choice for VP. I reckon she cost the Democrats a lot of ground.

    Possibly so. A bit too Black, Indian, Female, and Californian for the swing voters.

    She may well be a very good VP though. She seems quite feisty and intelligent.

    Campaigning skill correlates very poorly, perhaps even inversely, with skill at governing.
    I think the bigotry stuff is an excuse. Obama had no problems there.

    Democrats really need to STOP seeing everything through the prism of race, gender and sexuality.

    It really pisses a lot of people off and is BS.
    If you think racial, sexuality and gender are no longer issues arousing prejudice in America, then perhaps you need to get out of your bubble and meet more ordinary folk.
    Yep. And it's really frustrating to read Casino_Royale post that. I think he sometimes makes good points about prejudices on my side of politics (e.g. the Magna "Carter" stuff). But I'm going to be wary of agreeing with anything said by someone who claims that one president with African heritage demonstrates that bigotry is just an excuse.
  • For goodness sake people in the USA spent years arguing Obama wasn't an American citizen
  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lm-_A9LVYi8

    I thought May was terrible but this is just rude.

    His office apologised - he had an appointment (and was as usual clueless)
  • Pagan2Pagan2 Posts: 9,848

    If parties in 2024 stand on PR in their manifestos and they are able to form a government then no referendum is needed to deliver it. Just implement it.

    ALL constitutional changes should go through a referendum. It is the peoples political system it doesnt belong to politicians. I would not have supported leaving the eu because a party with it in their manifesto won just because they had a majority either.

    People vote for a party for a lot of reasons and usually dont agree with every policy, To make sweeping changes to our electoral system you absolutely need to have a specific mandate
  • FrankBoothFrankBooth Posts: 9,708

    Foxy said:

    Kamala Harris was a shit choice for VP. I reckon she cost the Democrats a lot of ground.

    Possibly so. A bit too Black, Indian, Female, and Californian for the swing voters.

    She may well be a very good VP though. She seems quite feisty and intelligent.

    Campaigning skill correlates very poorly, perhaps even inversely, with skill at governing.
    I think the bigotry stuff is an excuse. Obama had no problems there.

    Democrats really need to STOP seeing everything through the prism of race, gender and sexuality.

    It really pisses a lot of people off and is BS.
    A majority of Americans have voted for them.
    Well, exactly. So there are clearly Americans who must not be put off.
    It may be a majority but is it good enough? Against such an abominable president? They ought to feel they should have won much more convincingly.
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,586
    Foxy said:

    This applies to the right as well as the left.
    https://twitter.com/joebiden/status/1324112939310264322?s=21

    One of Grandpa Joes best features is his genuine desire for consensus. Perhaps because his formative years predate the current culture war. They were of course forged in an equally divisive time of desegregation and Vietnam War protests.
    He's also a man who has know significant personal loss in his life. I think that makes him more empathetic and a better man.
  • TimTTimT Posts: 6,456
    Foxy said:

    This applies to the right as well as the left.
    https://twitter.com/joebiden/status/1324112939310264322?s=21

    One of Grandpa Joes best features is his genuine desire for consensus. Perhaps because his formative years predate the current culture war. They were of course forged in an equally divisive time of desegregation and Vietnam War protests.
    That desire for consensus was the root of his greatest regret - not letting more witness speak against Clarence Thomas in the confirmation hearings.
  • As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Not checking everything with SNP which will be your reality
    SNP support PR. Or if they don't want to support Labour they're most welcome to explain why they put the Tories back into Government.
    SNP only support themselves! That's why they wiped your party out in Scotland 2015 😀
    SNP would have supported Labour in 2015 but I agree with you that Labour is dead in Scotland. Such is the reality, hence why we will have to get back in Wales (going well) and England (also going well).
    Wales? Drakeford? Going well? Good luck with that.

    But I admire your enthusiasm. When I was young I was LAB too.
  • Pagan2 said:

    If parties in 2024 stand on PR in their manifestos and they are able to form a government then no referendum is needed to deliver it. Just implement it.

    ALL constitutional changes should go through a referendum. It is the peoples political system it doesnt belong to politicians. I would not have supported leaving the eu because a party with it in their manifesto won just because they had a majority either.

    People vote for a party for a lot of reasons and usually dont agree with every policy, To make sweeping changes to our electoral system you absolutely need to have a specific mandate
    So presumably you supported a referendum on Johnson's deal after he won the election?
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,873
    edited November 2020
    What will this victory mean for the next season of the Netflix show Space Force, where the, unseen, president was clearly meant to be a Trumpesque figure? That's the important question.

    (show was only ok, it seemed a bit confused to me about whether it was meant to be zaney or not)
  • CorrectHorseBatteryCorrectHorseBattery Posts: 21,436
    edited November 2020

    As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Not checking everything with SNP which will be your reality
    SNP support PR. Or if they don't want to support Labour they're most welcome to explain why they put the Tories back into Government.
    SNP only support themselves! That's why they wiped your party out in Scotland 2015 😀
    SNP would have supported Labour in 2015 but I agree with you that Labour is dead in Scotland. Such is the reality, hence why we will have to get back in Wales (going well) and England (also going well).
    Wales? Drakeford? Going well? Good luck with that.

    But I admire your enthusiasm. When I was young I was LAB too.
    Erh yes, Labour is projected to win a landslide in Wales based on current polling.

    No need to condescend me either thank you, I haven't condescended you.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,342

    I wonder if in years gone by when people were fighting for gay rights, or the rights of women, whether people sat around and said we should just shut up and stop seeing politics through the prism of these pointless culture wars

    Absolutely they did.
    There is some strange idea culture wars are modern.
    We had a Civil War over one.
    And it was pretty much the dividing line between Whig/Tory thereafter.
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,477

    The 2024 election could be between the two extremes but represented by younger candidates. An AOC vs a to-be-determined carrier of the Trump flame.

    AOC is hardly an extremist. She would be a moderate Labourite were she in the UK.
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 48,480

    The 2024 election could be between the two extremes but represented by younger candidates. An AOC vs a to-be-determined carrier of the Trump flame.

    AOC is incredibly likeable it must be said, not sure her politics will appeal though
    AOC is a star, she is very eloquent and with good political antennae. One to watch certainly.
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 32,171
    edited November 2020

    This applies to the right as well as the left.
    https://twitter.com/joebiden/status/1324112939310264322?s=21

    Democrats made the right decision at the primaries. Bernie Sanders would have got more support at rallies and lost the election.
  • NickPalmerNickPalmer Posts: 21,503
    edited November 2020
    Toms said:

    I've a soft spot for Pennsylvania. My grandad and his wife designed their farmhouse and barn with the help of an itinerant carpenter in the late 1800s. They used hickory sourced from their woods and milled down the valley. Both still stand and appear in good shape. If you look in either of two directions you can see mountain ridges. Their rising spring never dries up.

    https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@39.9506175,-78.5038855,3a,75y,137.38h,96.85t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s-PNHGiBi8AE__aY4yNr1yQ!2e0!7i3328!8i1664?hl=en

    I remember staying there for the World Boardgames Convention a few years ago. The local paper stacked for guests at reception was called Intercourse News. I laughed involuntarily, and the receptionist looked baffled - weird Brit laughs at a local paper? I muttered an apology and actually felt bad - some Americans are endearingly innocent, and why not?
  • Hopefully, Pelosi will go. She and her acid tongue and San Francisco liberalism has been a huge turnoff for the Dems in the House.

    https://thehill.com/homenews/house/524503-centrist-democrats-talk-leadership-changes-after-negative-election-results?amp#click=https://t.co/x1QzSgT7Jb

    How the fiddle an octogenarian multi-millionaire is going to reach out to Dem voters defeats me.

    On the bright side, Joe is the youngest of the Joe-Nancy-Mitch triumverate
  • It's VERY STRANGE all these Bidenistas coming on here now when at 0300 on here they were crying.

    Well done to Biden he's not my sort of thing but he's ok 👍😊
  • Mal557Mal557 Posts: 662
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 49,774
    MikeL said:

    I'm no fan of Fox News but it should be noted they haven't gone out of their way to help Trump - calling AZ well before other networks and calling WI and MI in line with other networks.

    They could have created more mood music of uncertainty in these states - they have chosen not to.

    I have been pleasantly surprised by their coverage, if not by the adverts. Although right now they are starting to slip back toward wall to wall crazies shouting at the moon.
  • It's VERY STRANGE all these Bidenistas coming on here now when at 0300 on here they were crying.

    Well done to Biden he's not my sort of thing but he's ok 👍😊

    Well I never made a prediction but I do think those who said it would be a landslide should hold their hands up.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,342

    The 2024 election could be between the two extremes but represented by younger candidates. An AOC vs a to-be-determined carrier of the Trump flame.

    AOC is incredibly likeable it must be said, not sure her politics will appeal though
    Nor that she'll be only 35.
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,477
    Nevada

    GOP


    5.1
  • alex_alex_ Posts: 7,518
    CNN: "Trump bleeding GOP support" over his antics and bizarre behaviour.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,873
    Pagan2 said:

    If parties in 2024 stand on PR in their manifestos and they are able to form a government then no referendum is needed to deliver it. Just implement it.

    ALL constitutional changes should go through a referendum. It is the peoples political system it doesnt belong to politicians. I would not have supported leaving the eu because a party with it in their manifesto won just because they had a majority either.

    People vote for a party for a lot of reasons and usually dont agree with every policy, To make sweeping changes to our electoral system you absolutely need to have a specific mandate
    In our system defining what would be a constitutional issue would not always be so straightforward I suspect. I don't see what 'the people's political system' has to do with implementing electoral system changes after an election win.

    I'd be in favour of minimum turnout, perhaps a threshold above 50% for the big stuff, as many countries do, but having not had those for Sindy or Brexit I think trying it for future ones would be hard to defend.
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_xP said:
    48.1% of the national vote is way above what the polls were saying. 48.5% might have been enough. But it's not that, so he will have to vacate the White House.
    It's going down way below that. The West coast is just getting warmed up.
    Oh god, please say there is more 2016 style Clinton to win popular vote @1.05 36 hours after the election going on.
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,477
    GOP turning in on itself now – briefing the press that Trump's behaviour is unacceptable: it's "an ambulance-chasing routine".
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,586

    It's VERY STRANGE all these Bidenistas coming on here now when at 0300 on here they were crying.

    Well done to Biden he's not my sort of thing but he's ok 👍😊

    You make a fair point. I was feeling very down when I went to bed just after 3:00am. I honestly expected to wake up to wall to wall "Trump Wins Again" coverage.

    Happily not! :lol:
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,873

    The 2024 election could be between the two extremes but represented by younger candidates. An AOC vs a to-be-determined carrier of the Trump flame.

    AOC is hardly an extremist. She would be a moderate Labourite were she in the UK.
    Political extremism may be country dependent. I don't say that she is, but that she would be a moderate Labourite here doesn't mean she couldn't be on the political extreme in the US.
  • YBarddCwscYBarddCwsc Posts: 7,172
    edited November 2020



    Erh yes, Labour is projected to win a landslide in Wales based on current polling.

    No need to condescend me either thank you, I haven't condescended you.

    The very first thing you need to realise about Wales is that it will have 10 less constituencies next time.

    Labour now have 28/40.

    Next time they won't get 28/30.

    Labour may proportionately increase their vote in Wales next GE, but it is baked in that the absolute number of Labour seats in Wales will go down.
  • As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Not checking everything with SNP which will be your reality
    SNP support PR. Or if they don't want to support Labour they're most welcome to explain why they put the Tories back into Government.
    SNP only support themselves! That's why they wiped your party out in Scotland 2015 😀
    SNP would have supported Labour in 2015 but I agree with you that Labour is dead in Scotland. Such is the reality, hence why we will have to get back in Wales (going well) and England (also going well).
    Wales? Drakeford? Going well? Good luck with that.

    But I admire your enthusiasm. When I was young I was LAB too.
    Erh yes, Labour is projected to win a landslide in Wales based on current polling.

    No need to condescend me either thank you, I haven't condescended you.
    I would never condescend you. You are one of my favourite posters.
  • Johnson will be left deeply exposed now, RIP USA trade deal, it's Brexit capitulation or economic disaster with No Deal on the way. What will he choose?

    His friend in the world gone, populism rejected fairly decisively so far this year, he's a dying breed.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 51,320

    The 2024 election could be between the two extremes but represented by younger candidates. An AOC vs a to-be-determined carrier of the Trump flame.

    AOC is hardly an extremist. She would be a moderate Labourite were she in the UK.
    True, she's probably the best person to use in the example. What I mean is a candidate with a clear ideology, as opposed to just a centrist who isn't Trump, vs an ideologically-driven Trumpite, as opposed to Trump himself.
  • Joe Biden, the Gordon Brown of American politics, hmm

    No it is Trump who is reluctant to leave the building after a defeat.
  • As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Not checking everything with SNP which will be your reality
    SNP support PR. Or if they don't want to support Labour they're most welcome to explain why they put the Tories back into Government.
    SNP only support themselves! That's why they wiped your party out in Scotland 2015 😀
    SNP would have supported Labour in 2015 but I agree with you that Labour is dead in Scotland. Such is the reality, hence why we will have to get back in Wales (going well) and England (also going well).
    Wales? Drakeford? Going well? Good luck with that.

    But I admire your enthusiasm. When I was young I was LAB too.
    Erh yes, Labour is projected to win a landslide in Wales based on current polling.

    No need to condescend me either thank you, I haven't condescended you.
    I would never condescend you. You are one of my favourite posters.
    I took the age comment to be fairly condescending but no worries.
  • MysticroseMysticrose Posts: 4,688
    Foxy said:

    Genuinely think it's a distinct possibility Biden gets over 300

    I would love it if it was 306 as that was my prediction (albeit with a slightly different roster of states).
    If Biden wins all the remaining states (not impossible, but unlikely) then I called 49/50 States correctly in my forecast on Monday, missing only Florida, and I did pause over that one.

    Rather regretting my pre dawn reverse ferret on Biden EV now.
    I had a rush of terrifying visceral fear when I came in on Biden's ECV 262 at 2.30am. Everything at that moment seemed to be sliding away and it felt like, 'oh no, not again.' I bet with my head not my heart. When I hit 'buy' it was a massive adrenaline rush.

    Ironically it was Florida which convinced me, a State that I got totally wrong at state level. But the counties were showing significant swings to Biden from Clinton: 5% or more. The suburbs were voting for Biden. If that was replicated then eventually it had to pull him through in other battleground states. So I bought in the 260's.

    I got lucky. It has offset some other errors: over excitement on some Senate races and Texas and Florida at State level, although I never thought Biden would win Texas. My tips on Bollier and Ossoff proved way out, although Perdue might not win that race outright by the time final tallies are in.

    And on that subject, Republican Senators have outperformed Donald Trump.
  • alex_alex_ Posts: 7,518
    What news on what's been happening in state legislature races?
  • CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 60,216
    edited November 2020
    Not sure I buy this, but its a well informed source.

    https://twitter.com/Mij_Europe/status/1324114540238409728?s=20
  • Puerto Rico voted for statehood.
  • New covid infections update:

    France
    04/11 40,558
    28/10 36,437
    21/10 26,676
    14/10 22,591
    07/10 18,746

    Germany
    04/11 20,218
    28/10 16,202
    21/10 10,457
    14/10 6,063
    07/10 3,994

    Italy
    04/11 30,550
    28/10 24,989
    21/10 15,198
    14/10 7,331
    07/10 3,678

    Poland
    04/11 24,962
    28/10 18,820
    21/10 10,040
    14/10 6,526
    07/10 3,003

    Spain
    04/11 25,177
    28/10 19,765
    21/10 18,138
    14/10 15,409
    07/10 11,985

    UK
    04/11 25,177
    28/10 24,701
    21/10 26,684
    14/10 19,722
    07/10 14,162

    I wonder if the UK's tier system was beginning to work.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 77,894
    Andy_JS said:

    This applies to the right as well as the left.
    https://twitter.com/joebiden/status/1324112939310264322?s=21

    Democrats made the right decision at the primaries. Bernie Sanders would have got more support at rallies and lost the election.
    What happened in Miami Dade would have happened... everywhere with Sanders.
  • Pagan2Pagan2 Posts: 9,848

    Pagan2 said:

    If parties in 2024 stand on PR in their manifestos and they are able to form a government then no referendum is needed to deliver it. Just implement it.

    ALL constitutional changes should go through a referendum. It is the peoples political system it doesnt belong to politicians. I would not have supported leaving the eu because a party with it in their manifesto won just because they had a majority either.

    People vote for a party for a lot of reasons and usually dont agree with every policy, To make sweeping changes to our electoral system you absolutely need to have a specific mandate
    So presumably you supported a referendum on Johnson's deal after he won the election?
    The constitutional change was leaving the eu, johnsons deal or lack of is merely a trade treaty. For the record I think he has done an appalling job. However the difference is that trade deal can be amended by a new government in 2024 if they wish. Leaving the eu changing our voting system cant. The second can't is because picture it labour gets in next one is on pr, tories win next one is fptp.

    Leaving the eu and the voting system are both by their nature long term changes that cant be changed easily by the next parliament. Long term changes need specific consent. I have absolutely no doubt pr would get about the same in a referendum as av even if a majority voted for parties with pr in their manifesto.

    Sane people realise all pr does is allow parties to decide what their actual manifesto is after we have cast our vote and then use our votes to pretend they had a mandate.


  • Erh yes, Labour is projected to win a landslide in Wales based on current polling.

    No need to condescend me either thank you, I haven't condescended you.

    The very first thing you need to realise about Wales is that it will have 10 less constituencies next time.

    Labour now have 28/40.

    Next time they won't get 28/30.

    Labour may proportionately increase their vote in Wales next GE, but it is baked in that the absolute number of Labour seats in Wales will go down.
    If they got 70% of the seats with a drop that still be a landslide but I take the point.

    I will be interested to see if the constituency reduction does make a difference, I am not convinced.
  • MysticroseMysticrose Posts: 4,688
    They are fighting for the soul of their party.

    As well as to be relevant over the next 4 years.

    For all of HYUFD's praise of Trump, it's not easy to lose as incumbent President. It's only happened three times before today.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,873
    edited November 2020

    Johnson will be left deeply exposed now, RIP USA trade deal, it's Brexit capitulation or economic disaster with No Deal on the way. What will he choose?

    His friend in the world gone, populism rejected fairly decisively so far this year, he's a dying breed.

    The pushing of the idea of his friendship with Trump is rather overblown I think. He's said things against Trump in the past, other world leaders have praised or at least feted Trump just as much or more, because he was President of the United States and that's what you do. Edit: It was even claimed in a clip from last year that Boris, Macron and Trudeau were all having a good laugh mocking Trump together at a NATO summit.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,342



    Erh yes, Labour is projected to win a landslide in Wales based on current polling.

    No need to condescend me either thank you, I haven't condescended you.

    The very first thing you need to realise about Wales is that it will have 10 less constituencies next time.

    Labour now have 28/40.

    Next time they won't get 28/30.

    Labour may proportionately increase their vote in Wales next GE, but it is baked in that the absolute number of Labour seats in Wales will go down.
    Thought it was 32?
  • MangoMango Posts: 1,017
    GIN1138 said:

    As a former Corbyn supporter, I think 2019 here and 2020 in the USA proves to me beyond doubt that what the public want is competence and good governance and something that won't scare them. Go on Keir, I have faith

    Good luck Keir. Will be 2nd 2024
    Technically, we can come second in 2024 and still become the government, quite possible in that case we have a government which over 50% voted for and then we can have a proper PR system implemented.

    Honestly for me in 2024, that is the priority, ending FPTP.
    Oh god we're not going to spend the next four years debating the virtues of FPTP Vs AV Vs PR again are we? :D
    Nope. FPTP is shite, AV is 90% shite, and STV is the first step to the UK fixing its structural issues.

    We'll keep FPTP, and be fucked as a result.

    Debate done.
This discussion has been closed.