Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

WH2020: Key state turnout as percentage of votes cast – politicalbetting.com

2456711

Comments

  • Andy_CookeAndy_Cooke Posts: 5,005
    Roy_G_Biv said:

    Things I'd like to see in this impossible world

    1. How well have the SAGE estimates of the growth rate of the epidemic matched up to reality? We now have many weeks of calculations from SAGE of the daily & weekly growth rate. When integrated over time, how do these predictions actually compare against cases reported? I understand the growth in testing makes this a little more difficult, but this is still not a hard calculation to do.

    (I am not one of those who think SAGE has done well, but this is more based on overall impression that their pronouncements lack 'scientific' common sense rather than hard analysis).

    2. How well have the many model predictions from Ferguson, from King's College, from Washington, and so on, fared when matched with the data. I understand this is a bit harder, as the politicians and policy models respond to the models, so all scenarios are liable to being falsified by events in one way or another. Also, I think the main aim of the models is understanding -- rather than predictions -- but if policy makers use the models to inform policy, then some benchmarking of which models are trustworthy is needed.

    Unless there is some attempt to understand which models have performed well (with respect to the past), or whether SAGE has performed well (with respect to the past), then there is no way of evaluating the reliability of their current advice or their predictions.

    I also am not one who is interested in the blame game, here. I think it is absolutely inevitable that scientists predicting the behaviour of a still largely unknown disease will make some mistakes.

    You hit the nail on the head with "Also, I think the main aim of the models is understanding -- rather than predictions".
    The major difficulty is that projections are not forecasts, but that distinction is lost on a great number of people. Better work could be done communicating this stuff to the public, but the old maxim about leading a horse to water applies. And worse, there are some who will wilfully misunderstand science in order to discredit someone because of ideological axe-grinding.

    In complex human systems, the very act of making a forecast can change the outcome. An exponential graph might scare people into lowering their risk exposure, reducing the spread, nullifying the forecast. Then everybody goes crazy about how the "prediction" was wrong, because they didn't understand the nature of the forecast.
    And the main takeaway from the Ferguson modelling earlier in the year, is that it far underestimated the number of deaths in the UK.

    He said that he hoped we could keep it below 20,000. We blew past that figure, added another 20,000, and kept going for another 10,000 more.

    I've seen people saying "Ah, the models and scenarios are way too low, real deaths and cases are far higher," and nodded, but then they seem to take a leap that eludes me to apparently saying, or at least trying to imply, "So we should not do anything."

    At which point, I'm all "Um, you lost me there."
  • contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818
    The foreign secretary was only yesterday going into bat for Johnson's tiering policy, saying it was the right choice blah blah blah.

    Goodness knows how he feels today.
  • Scott_xPScott_xP Posts: 36,001

    If these are for the whole country, will this have to go to a parliamentary vote?

    that seems to be the case, yes
  • contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818
    Scott_xP said:
    Is there any evidence the Welsh lockdown worked?
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    In Valencia, a total of seven people, including a minor, have been arrested after participating in the Plaza del Ayuntamiento in an unauthorized protest against the Government's measures to stop the pandemic, which resulted in altercations and five police officers. the National Police injured, according to Europa Press. The city of Valencia thus joins Barcelona, Santander and Burgos, which also registered riots after demonstrations against the curfew.

    Limited at the moment, not sure why they are protesting maybe they think it’s 5G that’s the problem.
  • Scott_xPScott_xP Posts: 36,001

    The foreign secretary was only yesterday going into bat for Johnson's tiering policy, saying it was the right choice blah blah blah.

    Goodness knows how he feels today.

    There is no member of cabinet left who hasn't gone on TV to defend a policy that was simultaneously being ditched by the petulant teenagers running the show
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 71,221

    Joe Buying, according to OGH

    TBF, he has outspent Trump.
  • dr_spyndr_spyn Posts: 11,300

    Cyclefree said:

    Well, things are going absolutely swimmingly:-

    1. A second wave likely more deadly than the first.
    2. An economic recession, if we’re lucky, a depression if not.
    3. The Oompa Loompa re-elected next week (I very much fear) or him finagling his way out of defeat.
    4. An exit from a Brexit transition into God knows what, for which few are prepared.
    5. Islamist nutters slaughtering the innocent.

    Have I missed anything?

    Is there any joy to be had anywhere?

    That's about the strength of it.

    Strictly's on tonight, though.
    Enough to make me pick up a whisky bottle and revolver.
  • contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818

    Cyclefree said:

    Well, things are going absolutely swimmingly:-

    1. A second wave likely more deadly than the first.
    2. An economic recession, if we’re lucky, a depression if not.
    3. The Oompa Loompa re-elected next week (I very much fear) or him finagling his way out of defeat.
    4. An exit from a Brexit transition into God knows what, for which few are prepared.
    5. Islamist nutters slaughtering the innocent.

    Have I missed anything?

    Is there any joy to be had anywhere?

    You should be ashamed of yourself.

    Oompa Loompa's are hard working, in awful conditions with extremely poor H & S. Their contracts are undoubtedly unfair.

    Comparing Donald Trump to them is grotesque punching down.

    I wonder if number 10 really wants a Trump victory.

    A Trump victory would also be a massive victory for the anti-lockdown lobby. We'll be looking across the water, watching Americans getting on with their lives, watching their economy growing, watching them creat jobs, as the winter rain pelts down. Deaths? a statistic

    What political party in its right mind thinks it can carry on for long like that? What political party thinks it can run a country like that into the future and still exist?
  • Scott_xP said:

    The foreign secretary was only yesterday going into bat for Johnson's tiering policy, saying it was the right choice blah blah blah.

    Goodness knows how he feels today.

    There is no member of cabinet left who hasn't gone on TV to defend a policy that was simultaneously being ditched by the petulant teenagers running the show
    JRM? Is he still insisting MPs travel back and forth to Westminster super spreading?
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 71,221
    MaxPB said:

    kle4 said:

    MaxPB said:

    Once again, nobody has explained what lockdown 2 is going to solve. We're run by a government of c***s. Absolutely fucking clueless and they're going to destroy what's left of the economy and we will be back where we are today a few weeks after it ends or in a more realistic scenario it doesn't end in 4 weeks, it ends in April because the government haven't got a clue.

    The momentum toward lockdown was enormous before deaths ramped up, so whether they think it the best option or not I don't think the government can hold out.
    It's not about holding out it's about making the correct policy moves. I've been through this about a thousand times on here, it is possible to prevent people who have the virus from interacting with those that don't. Even now we can do it with 550k cases in the country. Whether isolation is done in hotels, by GPS tracking or by random daily door knocks (or a combination) that's the key to resolving this, making sure people who have the virus stay away from people who don't. Lockdown only does this whole lockdown is on and not very well either.
    Agreed.
    And that is a key element of how countries who succeeded in controlling the virus did it.

    It’s not impossible, even though we’re starting from a much harder place.

    Test and isolate are far more important than trace - which at these levels we can’t do anyway.
  • Scott_xP said:
    If these are for the whole country, will this have to go to a parliamentary vote?



    Wouldn't matter if Labour back it-probably not if they abstain. It would get through.

    BoJo's position as Conservative leader might be more vulnerable- though who is the person to take over in a coronation?

    The thing to look for is whether "Delivering letters to the Chairman of the 1922 Committee" is declared a non-essential job, forbidden under lockdown.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 71,221
    Apparently reported without irony.

    China shocked to discover the developed world views it in a negative light
    https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2020/10/27/commentary/world-commentary/china-developed-world-negative-sentiment/
  • alex_alex_ Posts: 7,518

    Scott_xP said:
    Is there any evidence the Welsh lockdown worked?
    Nobody can actually say yet if the Welsh lockdown "worked". Nor in fact whether the Tier system is "working". They haven't been in place long enough to feed into the data that the scientists are working with.

    All the data given to the Government in recent days basically predates the Tier system. When they say it isn't working that comes out of a belief that it wouldn't work that they stated 2-3 weeks ago. But it's not based on any new data. We do know that the official Govt "R" numbers are falling. But this inconvienient statistic is ignored.

    And as the Govt scientists control the data, they can make it say whatever they want.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 51,697

    Cyclefree said:

    Well, things are going absolutely swimmingly:-

    1. A second wave likely more deadly than the first.
    2. An economic recession, if we’re lucky, a depression if not.
    3. The Oompa Loompa re-elected next week (I very much fear) or him finagling his way out of defeat.
    4. An exit from a Brexit transition into God knows what, for which few are prepared.
    5. Islamist nutters slaughtering the innocent.

    Have I missed anything?

    Is there any joy to be had anywhere?

    You should be ashamed of yourself.

    Oompa Loompa's are hard working, in awful conditions with extremely poor H & S. Their contracts are undoubtedly unfair.

    Comparing Donald Trump to them is grotesque punching down.

    I wonder if number 10 really wants a Trump victory.

    A Trump victory would also be a massive victory for the anti-lockdown lobby. We'll be looking across the water, watching Americans getting on with their lives, watching their economy growing, watching them creat jobs, as the winter rain pelts down. Deaths? a statistic

    What political party in its right mind thinks it can carry on for long like that? What political party thinks it can run a country like that into the future and still exist?
    You can't vote to make the pandemic go away.
  • Scott_xP said:
    So they are going to come out of lockdown having no idea if it worked, and with cases in Welsh hospitals obviously still rising quickly, brave....
  • Beibheirli_CBeibheirli_C Posts: 8,163
    Roger said:

    Isn't it extraordinary that you can read a sentence like this "and of course ongoing suggestions that Trump will try to steal the election in some form".

    The arrogance the UK show to countries like Zimbabwe and even Hong Kong while our political class crawl into bed with the self styled leader of the free world!

    One consolation is that it looks like the EU's time has come. A power block of well intentioned nations with the humanitarian and democratic values the US have long since abandoned. Just a pity that the UK threw in its hand at the wrong time

    The UK was misled by a bunch of lying opportunists who think Trump is their path to riches
  • contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818
    alex_ said:

    Scott_xP said:
    Is there any evidence the Welsh lockdown worked?
    Nobody can actually say yet if the Welsh lockdown "worked". Nor in fact whether the Tier system is "working". They haven't been in place long enough to feed into the data that the scientists are working with.

    All the data given to the Government in recent days basically predates the Tier system. When they say it isn't working that comes out of a belief that it wouldn't work that they stated 2-3 weeks ago. But it's not based on any new data. We do know that the official Govt "R" numbers are falling. But this inconvienient statistic is ignored.

    And as the Govt scientists control the data, they can make it say whatever they want.
    So how can Van Tam claim the tiering policy is not working?
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 71,221

    The foreign secretary was only yesterday going into bat for Johnson's tiering policy, saying it was the right choice blah blah blah.

    Goodness knows how he feels today.

    Much the same as usual I expect.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,205
    Two friends tested positive for covid, mild symptons but a vulnerable family member amongst them. Felt good about the covid secure enviroment of Butlins a week ago...
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 33,463
    Scott_xP said:
    How are things going in Wales after the first week?
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468
    alex_ said:

    Scott_xP said:
    Is there any evidence the Welsh lockdown worked?
    Nobody can actually say yet if the Welsh lockdown "worked". Nor in fact whether the Tier system is "working". They haven't been in place long enough to feed into the data that the scientists are working with.

    All the data given to the Government in recent days basically predates the Tier system. When they say it isn't working that comes out of a belief that it wouldn't work that they stated 2-3 weeks ago. But it's not based on any new data. We do know that the official Govt "R" numbers are falling. But this inconvienient statistic is ignored.

    And as the Govt scientists control the data, they can make it say whatever they want.
    Yes they have. The North East has been in what is Tier 2 for 6 weeks and counting. Other areas also.
  • alex_ said:

    Scott_xP said:
    Is there any evidence the Welsh lockdown worked?
    Nobody can actually say yet if the Welsh lockdown "worked". Nor in fact whether the Tier system is "working". They haven't been in place long enough to feed into the data that the scientists are working with.

    All the data given to the Government in recent days basically predates the Tier system. When they say it isn't working that comes out of a belief that it wouldn't work that they stated 2-3 weeks ago. But it's not based on any new data. We do know that the official Govt "R" numbers are falling. But this inconvienient statistic is ignored.

    And as the Govt scientists control the data, they can make it say whatever they want.
    I am guessing that what has forced their hand is that SAGE produced a model of how the whole winter would pan out and that the data so far is exceeding this.
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 28,381
    Scott_xP said:
    Thank goodness we got rid of that zombie parliament that couldn't get a vote through without relying on the support of some opposition MPs.
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 62,766
    Scott_xP said:
    GNU the price for Starmer's support?
  • YBarddCwscYBarddCwsc Posts: 7,172
    dr_spyn said:

    Laura K, has posted a range of projections from several teams re deaths.

    https://twitter.com/bbclaurak/status/1322471602680987653

    There is quite difference between groups' projections, though I can't easily work out the pale ranges above and below the tracked lines.

    Laura K's tweet may make more sense in the context of the presentation from which it was taken. In isolation, it looks like it is comparing apples with cabbages. A typically useless intervention from the journalists.

    IMO, this would be useful. All the groups involved in the modelling (Laura K's plot has Imperial, Warwick, Cambridge/PHE, RWCS, LSHTM) should start with the English, Scottish, Welsh & NI data from March 2020.

    They can also use the information on the dates of lockdowns, firebreaks, Tier level restrictions in the modelling. That is, they are free to model as best they can the policy that was actually implemented in the 4 countries.

    What are the predictions for R or number of cases for tomorrow? Which of these models can forward model the data, with the known interventions in policy, to provide a good prediction for the situation now in E, S, W & NI.

    It is a very common problem in research that a whole bunch of people with different codes and different models get completely different predictions. And you solve it by setting model problems for which the answer is known, and which all groups tackle. This really should be a priority for the modellers.

    (My guess is that this is a really tough challenge, and if any group can do this for all 4 countries & get the answer within even 95 per cent confidence limits -- they will have bragging rights for the rest of time.)
  • MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 38,868
    Nigelb said:

    MaxPB said:

    kle4 said:

    MaxPB said:

    Once again, nobody has explained what lockdown 2 is going to solve. We're run by a government of c***s. Absolutely fucking clueless and they're going to destroy what's left of the economy and we will be back where we are today a few weeks after it ends or in a more realistic scenario it doesn't end in 4 weeks, it ends in April because the government haven't got a clue.

    The momentum toward lockdown was enormous before deaths ramped up, so whether they think it the best option or not I don't think the government can hold out.
    It's not about holding out it's about making the correct policy moves. I've been through this about a thousand times on here, it is possible to prevent people who have the virus from interacting with those that don't. Even now we can do it with 550k cases in the country. Whether isolation is done in hotels, by GPS tracking or by random daily door knocks (or a combination) that's the key to resolving this, making sure people who have the virus stay away from people who don't. Lockdown only does this whole lockdown is on and not very well either.
    Agreed.
    And that is a key element of how countries who succeeded in controlling the virus did it.

    It’s not impossible, even though we’re starting from a much harder place.

    Test and isolate are far more important than trace - which at these levels we can’t do anyway.
    To my mind the biggest failure of our system is isolation, but that's closely followed by the testing system being geared towards waiting for the virus to come to it rather than going out and finding it. The ONS study is probably the only thing we're doing that goes out and finds the virus, but even that just gives us a global view of regional levels rather than specific people.

    Waiting for the virus to find us is never going to work, we need to be going out there with rapid tests and giving contacts results on the spot and then isolating them if they are positive with a follow up PCR test.
  • MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 38,868

    Scott_xP said:
    GNU the price for Starmer's support?
    Why would Starmer want to get involved with this rabble, better to let Boris own all of these bad decisions.
  • RH1992RH1992 Posts: 788
    edited October 2020
    Roger said:

    Isn't it extraordinary that you can read a sentence like this "and of course ongoing suggestions that Trump will try to steal the election in some form".

    The arrogance the UK show to countries like Zimbabwe and even Hong Kong while our political class crawl into bed with the self styled leader of the free world!

    One consolation is that it looks like the EU's time has come. A power block of well intentioned nations with the humanitarian and democratic values the US have long since abandoned. Just a pity that the UK threw in its hand at the wrong time

    Was with you until the last paragraph. The EU is still too divided to have a coherent foreign policy and it while it has potential, the member states either can't agree, or they're pushing through policies at home which makes them look like hypocrites. Take Poland and abortion/LGBT free zones as an example of the latter, and for the former there's countless examples just this year. Probably the biggest is Cyprus blocking sanctions against Belarus because they wanted Turkey to face sanctions too. (Both need sanctions in my view, but take one and then work on the other rather than the perceived paralysis).

    Sadly, it doesn't look like competent, reasonable, global liberal economic and social policy has a strong state champion at the minute.
  • alex_ said:

    Scott_xP said:
    Is there any evidence the Welsh lockdown worked?
    Nobody can actually say yet if the Welsh lockdown "worked". Nor in fact whether the Tier system is "working". They haven't been in place long enough to feed into the data that the scientists are working with.

    All the data given to the Government in recent days basically predates the Tier system. When they say it isn't working that comes out of a belief that it wouldn't work that they stated 2-3 weeks ago. But it's not based on any new data. We do know that the official Govt "R" numbers are falling. But this inconvienient statistic is ignored.

    And as the Govt scientists control the data, they can make it say whatever they want.
    I am guessing that what has forced their hand is that SAGE produced a model of how the whole winter would pan out and that the data so far is exceeding this.
    Whitty and Vallance produced a graph as well.

    It predicted over 200k infections a day by now.

    As we're currently running at 10% of that doesn't that mean the tier system is working ?
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,096
    edited October 2020
    MaxPB said:

    Nigelb said:

    MaxPB said:

    kle4 said:

    MaxPB said:

    Once again, nobody has explained what lockdown 2 is going to solve. We're run by a government of c***s. Absolutely fucking clueless and they're going to destroy what's left of the economy and we will be back where we are today a few weeks after it ends or in a more realistic scenario it doesn't end in 4 weeks, it ends in April because the government haven't got a clue.

    The momentum toward lockdown was enormous before deaths ramped up, so whether they think it the best option or not I don't think the government can hold out.
    It's not about holding out it's about making the correct policy moves. I've been through this about a thousand times on here, it is possible to prevent people who have the virus from interacting with those that don't. Even now we can do it with 550k cases in the country. Whether isolation is done in hotels, by GPS tracking or by random daily door knocks (or a combination) that's the key to resolving this, making sure people who have the virus stay away from people who don't. Lockdown only does this whole lockdown is on and not very well either.
    Agreed.
    And that is a key element of how countries who succeeded in controlling the virus did it.

    It’s not impossible, even though we’re starting from a much harder place.

    Test and isolate are far more important than trace - which at these levels we can’t do anyway.
    To my mind the biggest failure of our system is isolation, but that's closely followed by the testing system being geared towards waiting for the virus to come to it rather than going out and finding it. The ONS study is probably the only thing we're doing that goes out and finds the virus, but even that just gives us a global view of regional levels rather than specific people.

    Waiting for the virus to find us is never going to work, we need to be going out there with rapid tests and giving contacts results on the spot and then isolating them if they are positive with a follow up PCR test.
    And yet still, still, even though it looks like new lockdown incoming, Christmas and Easter holidays are not bring ruled out....total madness...we need to make it clear right now, you don't go doing foreign travel unless essential and we test / quarantine all new arrivals.

    The other thing the government still don't seem to have decided on...what to do about students. They need to announce whatever the policy is, either mass test them or staged release, or even have to stay in place. Whatever it is, they need to decide now.
  • Dan’s got a lot of time on his hands, after the downfall of the Jezziah.

    Good to see he’s found a new pot to stir.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,421
    edited October 2020

    Scott_xP said:
    GNU the price for Starmer's support?
    He’d be mad to, and he isn’t mad. At the moment, he can put forward proposals knowing that if he’s proved right everyone will be awed by his prescience and if he’s wrong everyone will be worrying about something else. Win/win.

    And in any case, the price for a GNU should at the very least be Johnson’s job and Cummings’ prosecution, and Johnson will not agree to that.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,410
    Good morning.
    A swing to Labor in Queensland l see.
    Continuing the trend seen in NZ, BC and Saskatchewan. All seeing the incumbents gaining.
    I pray this streak is broken in US. Hopefully the relative CV performance will factor.
  • algarkirkalgarkirk Posts: 12,551
    Scott_xP said:

    If these are for the whole country, will this have to go to a parliamentary vote?

    that seems to be the case, yes
    It could use the same parliament bypassing powers under the 1984 Public Health Act that it used for the first lockdown. Some say that a legal challenge to this use could succeed but I don't think it's been tried.

    Politically I doubt if that can be done as too many MPs are in denial about some aspect of this insoluble Rubik's cube to let this happen.

  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,036

    Cyclefree said:

    Well, things are going absolutely swimmingly:-

    1. A second wave likely more deadly than the first.
    2. An economic recession, if we’re lucky, a depression if not.
    3. The Oompa Loompa re-elected next week (I very much fear) or him finagling his way out of defeat.
    4. An exit from a Brexit transition into God knows what, for which few are prepared.
    5. Islamist nutters slaughtering the innocent.

    Have I missed anything?

    Is there any joy to be had anywhere?

    Where the F does the RFU think International players come from?
    Public schools?
  • Scott_xPScott_xP Posts: 36,001

    Laura K's tweet may make more sense in the context of the presentation from which it was taken. In isolation, it looks like it is comparing apples with cabbages. A typically useless intervention from the journalists.

    Maybe it would be helpful if, instead of leaking to favoured journalists, the Government were honest with people, and held televised briefings with the PM and the scientists where this stuff could be questioned...

    Just a thought
  • not_on_firenot_on_fire Posts: 4,449
    JACK_W said:

    I note Jon Ralston has, in terms, called Nevada for Biden and from his report I have adjusted my numbers for the state from Biden +5/7 to +6/8 points. Clinton won by 2.5

    Also today Anne Selzer (rated A+) will release her final Iowa poll. Her last poll was tied. Trump won by 9 points in 2016.

    I see 538 and Trafalgar have come to an “arrangement”.

    I've also noticed they have been supplying some cross tabs, not really informative but better than the useless PowerPoint graphs they only gave previously (they are not alone with that however).
    The crosstabs don't overly help them however, some trying to show 30% of Dems voting for trump and 25% Blacks also voting Trump etc.... Still maybe they have tapped into something no-one else at all has seen, though I suspect not.
    I get the impression that Silver is a bit nervous that his model is underestimating Trump’s chances. Including Trafalgar polls presumably helps Trump’s win percentage
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,410
    Don't see that. Tough decisions is what an 80 seat majority is for. Not sure of the polling but the Welsh experience suggests it won't be wildly unpopular.
    And I don't perceive a truly credible alternative plan readily available from opponents.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,096
    edited October 2020
    Scott_xP said:

    Laura K's tweet may make more sense in the context of the presentation from which it was taken. In isolation, it looks like it is comparing apples with cabbages. A typically useless intervention from the journalists.

    Maybe it would be helpful if, instead of leaking to favoured journalists, the Government were honest with people, and held televised briefings with the PM and the scientists where this stuff could be questioned...

    Just a thought
    We have done that and the media just waste an hour asking about if i set up a business and employ my family on zero hour contracts can we have a business meeting at my home on Christmas day....or Prof Peston talking absolute horseshit about chemical engineering.
  • Dura_AceDura_Ace Posts: 13,677
    Roy_G_Biv said:

    Scott_xP said:
    Seems to me there's no trust left to damage. Even Conservatives on here are sick of Johnson. Is there anyone left in the bunker other than HYUFD?
    Remember when MothyMark took a break from pulling the head off it over pictures of Carrie to give the government a solid 'B+' on its handling of the pandemic. Seems like a different world.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,421
    Scott_xP said:
    From the makers of Lockdown and Lockdown 2: Lockdown Less Hard comes Lockdown 3: lockdown with a vengeance. A Christmas disaster movie.

    After the failure of his plans in Lockdown 2, Prime Minister played by A ‘Massive’ Johnson must decide whether to put the whole country in deep freeze for six months. He knows that Co. Vid, played by sinister hard man Don Trump, will kill every man woman and child in the country if he doesn’t. What can stop him? Only our hero, Michelle Pfizer, who has the goods on Co Vid and will go one to one in hand to hand combat.

    With cameos from Richy the Snake, Keir Less Starmer and the director, Dom Fucker Cummings, who drove past the camera during one of his legendary eye tests.

    Coming to a cinema near you - 1st Jan 2021.
  • Scott_xP said:

    Laura K's tweet may make more sense in the context of the presentation from which it was taken. In isolation, it looks like it is comparing apples with cabbages. A typically useless intervention from the journalists.

    Maybe it would be helpful if, instead of leaking to favoured journalists, the Government were honest with people, and held televised briefings with the PM and the scientists where this stuff could be questioned...

    Just a thought
    Boris and the scientist do have televised briefings and are questioned
  • not_on_firenot_on_fire Posts: 4,449

    Scott_xP said:

    kle4 said:

    The public have never been against lockdown and they must know that so I cannot think that's the reason.

    BoZo thinks the public are against lockdown, which is why he is against lockdown
    To be fair to him (why???) it is against his natural instincts. It's not quite everyone for themselves win his worldview, but the fewer controls, moral or otherwise, the better..
    I think most people are "for" lockdown - at least when asked.

    However, most of them want to go on a holiday, meet friends at the pub, family party etc.

    So it's Lockdown Supermax II - apart from "I need to do what I want"
    It’s another of those irregular verbs...

    *They* are ignoring the rules spreading the virus
    *You* need to stay at home
    *I* am going down the pub
  • Scott_xPScott_xP Posts: 36,001
    Except...

    Dominic Cummings, addressing staff gathered in “mission control” on Tuesday morning, was blunt about the motivation behind Downing Street’s new outpost in the heart of the Cabinet Office.

    The response to the Covid-19 crisis had too often been a “shitshow”, he said. This new unit would try to put an end to any “miscommunication” between the political and administrative arms of government.
  • YBarddCwscYBarddCwsc Posts: 7,172
    ydoethur said:

    Scott_xP said:
    GNU the price for Starmer's support?
    He’d be mad to, and he isn’t mad. At the moment, he can put forward proposals knowing that if he’s proved right everyone will be awed by his prescience and if he’s wrong everyone will be worrying about something else. Win/win.

    And in any case, the price for a GNU should at the very least be Johnson’s job and Cummings’ prosecution, and Johnson will not agree to that.
    Yes. A great time to be in opposition.

    In the RoI, Sinn Fein have hit the jackpot -- with all 3 parties (Greens, FF and FG) tarred with the problems of governing.
  • stjohnstjohn Posts: 1,861

    Scott_xP said:
    GNU the price for Starmer's support?
    They say every man has his price. I think in Starmer’s case though, he’d want more than an antelope. Anyway, where would he put it?
  • BluestBlueBluestBlue Posts: 4,556
    From the Guardian's live news feed:


    Germany has set a new record for new daily coronavirus cases, reporting 19,059 infections. This breaks Germany’s previous highest daily increase of 18,681, set the day before.

    Europe has listed more than 10 million Covid-19 cases to date since the virus first appeared, with the continent’s death tally at about 275,000.

    The US appears to have set a daily record for new infections on Friday, with different sources placing the increase between 94,000 and 100,000 in 24 hours according – just one day after the previous high of 91,000.

    Ukraine also registered a daily Covid-19 record, recording 8,752 new cases, up from the 8,312 new cases announced on Friday.

    France has reported 49,215 new coronavirus cases over the past 24 hours, compared with 47,637 on Thursday. The total number of infections rose to 1,331,984 while the death tally went up by 256 over 24 hours to 36,565.


    Parochial types: why is Britain the only country suffering from the coronavirus?
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,421
    Scott_xP said:

    Except...

    Dominic Cummings, addressing staff gathered in “mission control” on Tuesday morning, was blunt about the motivation behind Downing Street’s new outpost in the heart of the Cabinet Office.

    The response to the Covid-19 crisis had too often been a “shitshow”, he said. This new unit would try to put an end to any “miscommunication” between the political and administrative arms of government.
    I don’t know what’s weirdest about Cummings - his bizarre imagination, his total inability to understand anything more complex than how much a ten pound note is worth or his utter lack of self awareness.
  • kinabalukinabalu Posts: 42,218

    alex_ said:

    Scott_xP said:
    Is there any evidence the Welsh lockdown worked?
    Nobody can actually say yet if the Welsh lockdown "worked". Nor in fact whether the Tier system is "working". They haven't been in place long enough to feed into the data that the scientists are working with.

    All the data given to the Government in recent days basically predates the Tier system. When they say it isn't working that comes out of a belief that it wouldn't work that they stated 2-3 weeks ago. But it's not based on any new data. We do know that the official Govt "R" numbers are falling. But this inconvienient statistic is ignored.

    And as the Govt scientists control the data, they can make it say whatever they want.
    I am guessing that what has forced their hand is that SAGE produced a model of how the whole winter would pan out and that the data so far is exceeding this.
    Yes. And the only way to test the projection is by not acting and seeing if it happens. But since the "it" is calamitous we have to act to stop it happening. Thus the projection cannot be tested. It is in practice not so much a projection as a tool to trigger action. With coronavirus the very act of projecting changes what is being projected. This is the nature of the beast and it leaves much space for conspiracy theory and denialism - space which has become full to overflowing.
  • RogerRoger Posts: 19,914
    edited October 2020
    Scott_xP said:
    Now that's funny! Johnson storming around Downing Street in his bakers outfit. He must know the leaker's Govey....doesn't he listen to Dead Ringers?
  • contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818

    Scott_xP said:
    GNU the price for Starmer's support?
    New massive borrowing programme.

  • MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 38,868

    From the Guardian's live news feed:


    Germany has set a new record for new daily coronavirus cases, reporting 19,059 infections. This breaks Germany’s previous highest daily increase of 18,681, set the day before.

    Europe has listed more than 10 million Covid-19 cases to date since the virus first appeared, with the continent’s death tally at about 275,000.

    The US appears to have set a daily record for new infections on Friday, with different sources placing the increase between 94,000 and 100,000 in 24 hours according – just one day after the previous high of 91,000.

    Ukraine also registered a daily Covid-19 record, recording 8,752 new cases, up from the 8,312 new cases announced on Friday.

    France has reported 49,215 new coronavirus cases over the past 24 hours, compared with 47,637 on Thursday. The total number of infections rose to 1,331,984 while the death tally went up by 256 over 24 hours to 36,565.


    Parochial types: why is Britain the only country suffering from the coronavirus?

    No one is saying that.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,096
    edited October 2020

    From the Guardian's live news feed:


    Germany has set a new record for new daily coronavirus cases, reporting 19,059 infections. This breaks Germany’s previous highest daily increase of 18,681, set the day before.

    Europe has listed more than 10 million Covid-19 cases to date since the virus first appeared, with the continent’s death tally at about 275,000.

    The US appears to have set a daily record for new infections on Friday, with different sources placing the increase between 94,000 and 100,000 in 24 hours according – just one day after the previous high of 91,000.

    Ukraine also registered a daily Covid-19 record, recording 8,752 new cases, up from the 8,312 new cases announced on Friday.

    France has reported 49,215 new coronavirus cases over the past 24 hours, compared with 47,637 on Thursday. The total number of infections rose to 1,331,984 while the death tally went up by 256 over 24 hours to 36,565.


    Parochial types: why is Britain the only country suffering from the coronavirus?

    Remember when Anders Tegnell said we have to plan for 2 years of this, there is no point comparing responses after a few weeks and everybody tried to dismiss him and said they could solve it with a short lockdown.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468

    Scott_xP said:
    GNU the price for Starmer's support?
    New massive borrowing programme.

    As opposed to the current massive borrowing programme?
  • Dura_Ace said:

    Roy_G_Biv said:

    Scott_xP said:
    Seems to me there's no trust left to damage. Even Conservatives on here are sick of Johnson. Is there anyone left in the bunker other than HYUFD?
    Remember when MothyMark took a break from pulling the head off it over pictures of Carrie to give the government a solid 'B+' on its handling of the pandemic. Seems like a different world.
    They've done some things very well - testing, furloughs, support for business, sorting PPE.

    But failures as well - the most imbecilic being the encouragement of foreign holidays.
  • RH1992RH1992 Posts: 788

    ydoethur said:

    Scott_xP said:
    GNU the price for Starmer's support?
    He’d be mad to, and he isn’t mad. At the moment, he can put forward proposals knowing that if he’s proved right everyone will be awed by his prescience and if he’s wrong everyone will be worrying about something else. Win/win.

    And in any case, the price for a GNU should at the very least be Johnson’s job and Cummings’ prosecution, and Johnson will not agree to that.
    Yes. A great time to be in opposition.

    In the RoI, Sinn Fein have hit the jackpot -- with all 3 parties (Greens, FF and FG) tarred with the problems of governing.
    I know it's early and could be honeymoon period polling (although how this happens in a pandemic is beyond me), but Ireland seems to have bucked the trend of the junior partner always getting the flak. FG are well up on their GE performance and FF have nosedived, despite having the most seats and the Taoiseach. SF seem steady.
  • contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818

    Scott_xP said:
    GNU the price for Starmer's support?
    New massive borrowing programme.

    As opposed to the current massive borrowing programme?
    LOL
  • algarkirkalgarkirk Posts: 12,551
    dixiedean said:

    Don't see that. Tough decisions is what an 80 seat majority is for. Not sure of the polling but the Welsh experience suggests it won't be wildly unpopular.
    And I don't perceive a truly credible alternative plan readily available from opponents.
    I sympathise with Dan Hodges view as this particular mess looks like one which is simple to comprehend (Sage advice in September was clear), undeniable and avoidable. However right at the top of the list of further events the long suffering public don't want, along with 10 feet of snow and beans on toast with your mother in law for Christmas, is a General Election.

    At that point emigration to Tristan da Cunha begins to look a serious and balanced option.

    But a Jeremy Hunt character as PM begins to have its attractions...

  • YBarddCwscYBarddCwsc Posts: 7,172
    Scott_xP said:

    Laura K's tweet may make more sense in the context of the presentation from which it was taken. In isolation, it looks like it is comparing apples with cabbages. A typically useless intervention from the journalists.

    Maybe it would be helpful if, instead of leaking to favoured journalists, the Government were honest with people, and held televised briefings with the PM and the scientists where this stuff could be questioned...

    Just a thought
    You are incredibly optimistic if you think a televised briefing and a journalist's question and answer session is likely to shed any light on the matter. Most journalists will fail the Monty Hall Problem :blush:

    The most useful think might be the Royal Society trying to set up a large group of experts to scrutinise the scientific work in an open and honest fashion and to make some recommendations on the next steps to the Governemnet.
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 53,858
    MaxPB said:

    DavidL said:

    MaxPB said:

    Once again, nobody has explained what lockdown 2 is going to solve. We're run by a government of c***s. Absolutely fucking clueless and they're going to destroy what's left of the economy and we will be back where we are today a few weeks after it ends or in a more realistic scenario it doesn't end in 4 weeks, it ends in April because the government haven't got a clue.

    What it is presumably meant to solve is a crisis in the NHS once again as the number of hospitalisations increases sharply and wards get close to capacity. For me, this is something that lockdowns are justified for, as an emergency break when we are being overwhelmed. Looking at the charts from yesterday that must be imminent.

    The government is trying to mitigate economic damage within that parameter. Acknowledging that further restrictions are likely or inevitable causes damage of itself and depresses activity. I am not at all surprised or even disappointed that Ministers say that they have no plans to do things until they have to. I don't really see an alternative.

    This is all enormously frustrating and difficult but I think your criticism of the government is way overdone.
    The government has had months to solve the actual problem of people who have the virus interacting with people who don't. It has done nothing to solve it and believes the only way to prevent that is with a lockdown, either local or national. The government has had months to build a testing and tracking system that can seek out the virus, yet we're still waiting for people to become symptomatic and book a test. We're still allowing people to self certify their isolation and quarantine.

    The government has had enough time to resolve these issues and honestly, I don't give a fuck about how European countries have also failed. We shouldn't be aiming to be just as bad as everyone else.
    I think that you are being a bit ridiculous. The government threw billions at a track and trace system for the reasons you described. It doesn't work. It doesn't work for a variety of reasons. Off the top of my head these include our reluctance to allow ourselves to be adequately traced, the very bad advice the government got from the scientists about the need for testing to be pretty much 100% accurate before it was any good, the complexity and uncertainty of what is needed for infection to occur (is sitting on a bus for 10 mins enough, sitting 2 tables away in a cafe, etc etc), an increasing disregard for the rules with far more house parties and groupings than in the first wave which are far more likely to be indoors as the weather has changed, I could go on all day.

    Your criticism seems to imply that there is an easy or even difficult solution here that the government is wilfully ignoring. There isn't. There just isn't. So we need to muddle along as well as we can and pray for a vaccine. In that muddle many of the short term tactical decisions can be criticised, too late, too early, to severe, not severe enough but the reality is that we cannot operate as a society with this virus in our community anywhere like we did before without huge numbers of deaths and a complete crisis in the NHS. That is where we are and swearing at the government really doesn't change a thing.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 50,364

    alex_ said:

    Scott_xP said:
    Is there any evidence the Welsh lockdown worked?
    Nobody can actually say yet if the Welsh lockdown "worked". Nor in fact whether the Tier system is "working". They haven't been in place long enough to feed into the data that the scientists are working with.

    All the data given to the Government in recent days basically predates the Tier system. When they say it isn't working that comes out of a belief that it wouldn't work that they stated 2-3 weeks ago. But it's not based on any new data. We do know that the official Govt "R" numbers are falling. But this inconvienient statistic is ignored.

    And as the Govt scientists control the data, they can make it say whatever they want.
    I am guessing that what has forced their hand is that SAGE produced a model of how the whole winter would pan out and that the data so far is exceeding this.
    Whitty and Vallance produced a graph as well.

    It predicted over 200k infections a day by now.

    As we're currently running at 10% of that doesn't that mean the tier system is working ?
    image

    Note: the ONS data is up to the 17th
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,676

    From the Guardian's live news feed:


    Germany has set a new record for new daily coronavirus cases, reporting 19,059 infections. This breaks Germany’s previous highest daily increase of 18,681, set the day before.

    Europe has listed more than 10 million Covid-19 cases to date since the virus first appeared, with the continent’s death tally at about 275,000.

    The US appears to have set a daily record for new infections on Friday, with different sources placing the increase between 94,000 and 100,000 in 24 hours according – just one day after the previous high of 91,000.

    Ukraine also registered a daily Covid-19 record, recording 8,752 new cases, up from the 8,312 new cases announced on Friday.

    France has reported 49,215 new coronavirus cases over the past 24 hours, compared with 47,637 on Thursday. The total number of infections rose to 1,331,984 while the death tally went up by 256 over 24 hours to 36,565.


    Parochial types: why is Britain the only country suffering from the coronavirus?

    Whataboutery

    Tbh this latest leak won’t have any effect on public trust in the government because it’s been non-existent for months now apart from you Phil and HYUFD
  • Dura_AceDura_Ace Posts: 13,677
    Scott_xP said:
    They've got to the get the fat hunchbacked fuck out of the fridge first.
  • stjohnstjohn Posts: 1,861

    Scott_xP said:
    GNU the price for Starmer's support?
    New massive borrowing programme.

    Are antelopes expensive?
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 50,364
    Nigelb said:

    Apparently reported without irony.

    China shocked to discover the developed world views it in a negative light
    https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2020/10/27/commentary/world-commentary/china-developed-world-negative-sentiment/

    A Ghanaian friend commented that the Chinese had managed to achieve the level of hatred in Africa in a decade that it took the British etc hundreds of years to get to.
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 42,882
    Scott_xP said:

    Laura K's tweet may make more sense in the context of the presentation from which it was taken. In isolation, it looks like it is comparing apples with cabbages. A typically useless intervention from the journalists.

    Maybe it would be helpful if, instead of leaking to favoured journalists, the Government were honest with people, and held televised briefings with the PM and the scientists where this stuff could be questioned...

    Just a thought
    You mean, like the ones in Scotland which the Tories, SLAB and the BBC hated and/or tried to stamp out?
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,410
    ydoethur said:

    Scott_xP said:

    Except...

    Dominic Cummings, addressing staff gathered in “mission control” on Tuesday morning, was blunt about the motivation behind Downing Street’s new outpost in the heart of the Cabinet Office.

    The response to the Covid-19 crisis had too often been a “shitshow”, he said. This new unit would try to put an end to any “miscommunication” between the political and administrative arms of government.
    I don’t know what’s weirdest about Cummings - his bizarre imagination, his total inability to understand anything more complex than how much a ten pound note is worth or his utter lack of self awareness.
    For me it's the shape of his head.
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 53,858
    Nigelb said:

    MaxPB said:

    kle4 said:

    MaxPB said:

    Once again, nobody has explained what lockdown 2 is going to solve. We're run by a government of c***s. Absolutely fucking clueless and they're going to destroy what's left of the economy and we will be back where we are today a few weeks after it ends or in a more realistic scenario it doesn't end in 4 weeks, it ends in April because the government haven't got a clue.

    The momentum toward lockdown was enormous before deaths ramped up, so whether they think it the best option or not I don't think the government can hold out.
    It's not about holding out it's about making the correct policy moves. I've been through this about a thousand times on here, it is possible to prevent people who have the virus from interacting with those that don't. Even now we can do it with 550k cases in the country. Whether isolation is done in hotels, by GPS tracking or by random daily door knocks (or a combination) that's the key to resolving this, making sure people who have the virus stay away from people who don't. Lockdown only does this whole lockdown is on and not very well either.
    Agreed.
    And that is a key element of how countries who succeeded in controlling the virus did it.

    It’s not impossible, even though we’re starting from a much harder place.

    Test and isolate are far more important than trace - which at these levels we can’t do anyway.
    How on earth does this work when the majority who have it don't even know? The wife of a colleague of mine who works as a physiotherapist got a positive test result this week. She was absolutely shocked. She had no idea and was completely asymptomatic. Everyone in her department is now being tested again but no one there had any manifest symptoms.

    My opponent in court yesterday went to Spain in August. When he came back he and his wife were tested privately. They were told that they had both had it. They really don't know when. And they are both in their 60s.
  • Scott_xP said:
    And of course the journalist fails to.mention a key problem with the circuit breaker model presented to the government....as a piece of research it was bullshit.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,676
    Where is Philip when you need him for reassurance.
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 33,463

    Dura_Ace said:

    Roy_G_Biv said:

    Scott_xP said:
    Seems to me there's no trust left to damage. Even Conservatives on here are sick of Johnson. Is there anyone left in the bunker other than HYUFD?
    Remember when MothyMark took a break from pulling the head off it over pictures of Carrie to give the government a solid 'B+' on its handling of the pandemic. Seems like a different world.
    They've done some things very well - testing, furloughs, support for business, sorting PPE.

    But failures as well - the most imbecilic being the encouragement of foreign holidays.
    Testing should left out of that list. Too much going wrong. And VAT on PPE hasn't a great look ATM.
  • YBarddCwscYBarddCwsc Posts: 7,172
    RH1992 said:

    ydoethur said:

    Scott_xP said:
    GNU the price for Starmer's support?
    He’d be mad to, and he isn’t mad. At the moment, he can put forward proposals knowing that if he’s proved right everyone will be awed by his prescience and if he’s wrong everyone will be worrying about something else. Win/win.

    And in any case, the price for a GNU should at the very least be Johnson’s job and Cummings’ prosecution, and Johnson will not agree to that.
    Yes. A great time to be in opposition.

    In the RoI, Sinn Fein have hit the jackpot -- with all 3 parties (Greens, FF and FG) tarred with the problems of governing.
    I know it's early and could be honeymoon period polling (although how this happens in a pandemic is beyond me), but Ireland seems to have bucked the trend of the junior partner always getting the flak. FG are well up on their GE performance and FF have nosedived, despite having the most seats and the Taoiseach. SF seem steady.
    Who ended up with most of the blame for Golf-gate? FF?
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,421
    Ridiculous to suggest he’s lost it.

    That would imply there was a time he had it.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,676

    Scott_xP said:
    And of course the journalist fails to.mention a key problem with the circuit breaker model presented to the government....as a piece of research it was bullshit.
    Whats your solution?
  • RogerRoger Posts: 19,914

    Roger said:

    Isn't it extraordinary that you can read a sentence like this "and of course ongoing suggestions that Trump will try to steal the election in some form".

    The arrogance the UK show to countries like Zimbabwe and even Hong Kong while our political class crawl into bed with the self styled leader of the free world!

    One consolation is that it looks like the EU's time has come. A power block of well intentioned nations with the humanitarian and democratic values the US have long since abandoned. Just a pity that the UK threw in its hand at the wrong time

    The UK was misled by a bunch of lying opportunists who think Trump is their path to riches
    Without Trump it's easy to see Johnson looking pretty isolated if not faintly ridiculous. The little fat boy who never gets invited to anyone's gathering
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 50,364

    Scott_xP said:

    kle4 said:

    The public have never been against lockdown and they must know that so I cannot think that's the reason.

    BoZo thinks the public are against lockdown, which is why he is against lockdown
    To be fair to him (why???) it is against his natural instincts. It's not quite everyone for themselves win his worldview, but the fewer controls, moral or otherwise, the better..
    I think most people are "for" lockdown - at least when asked.

    However, most of them want to go on a holiday, meet friends at the pub, family party etc.

    So it's Lockdown Supermax II - apart from "I need to do what I want"
    It’s another of those irregular verbs...

    *They* are ignoring the rules spreading the virus
    *You* need to stay at home
    *I* am going down the pub
    Yes
  • RazedabodeRazedabode Posts: 3,028
    So I think today is the day Johnson's surpassed May's record for incompetence.

  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 18,425
    DavidL said:

    MaxPB said:

    Once again, nobody has explained what lockdown 2 is going to solve. We're run by a government of c***s. Absolutely fucking clueless and they're going to destroy what's left of the economy and we will be back where we are today a few weeks after it ends or in a more realistic scenario it doesn't end in 4 weeks, it ends in April because the government haven't got a clue.

    What it is presumably meant to solve is a crisis in the NHS once again as the number of hospitalisations increases sharply and wards get close to capacity. For me, this is something that lockdowns are justified for, as an emergency break when we are being overwhelmed. Looking at the charts from yesterday that must be imminent.

    The government is trying to mitigate economic damage within that parameter. Acknowledging that further restrictions are likely or inevitable causes damage of itself and depresses activity. I am not at all surprised or even disappointed that Ministers say that they have no plans to do things until they have to. I don't really see an alternative.

    This is all enormously frustrating and difficult but I think your criticism of the government is way overdone.
    I agree with Max.

    Lockdown, as an emergency measure to prevent collapse of the health service, only becomes necessary because of a massive failure in ensuring that the infectious are isolating

    This failure is so massive that the government doesn't even measure what proportion of people are isolating. There are no statistics on this from the £12bn we have spent on track and trace.

    The entire point of that £12bn is that the infectious will isolate, but we have no idea to what extent it is falling. Success is literally impossible.
  • Boris Johnson calling Sir Keir Starmer 'Captain Hindsight' turns out to be like the time Gordon Brown tried to portray David Cameron as Gene Hunt, that worked out well for both PMs.
  • Scott_xPScott_xP Posts: 36,001

    So I think today is the day Johnson's surpassed May's record for incompetence.

    That was in March, the day he didn't sack Cummings
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,676

    Scott_xP said:
    And of course the journalist fails to.mention a key problem with the circuit breaker model presented to the government....as a piece of research it was bullshit.
    Journalists clearly arent good at spotting bullshit really as they fail to call out the King of Bullshit PM daily

    Nor are the Tories who believed Boris would make a good PM and had an oven ready deal.

    DBMIVL (Dont blame me I voted Labour)

  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,096
    edited October 2020

    Scott_xP said:
    And of course the journalist fails to.mention a key problem with the circuit breaker model presented to the government....as a piece of research it was bullshit.
    Whats your solution?
    If you are going to lockdown, you have to do it for more than 2 weeks, it that simple. It is why France, Germany etc are saying its going to be a month for starters, then we will review it.

    My solutions have for a long time being along th3 following lines...

    #1 shut the f##king border. All new arrivals quarantine like Australia. No foreign travel for pleasure.
    #2 forced isolation as described by Max...you have to go into hotel type accommodation.
    #3 set of long term restrictions across the country that are in place until full deployment of a vaccine e.g none of this open / closing pubs.
    ...
This discussion has been closed.