Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Starting at 7pm the BBC QuestionTime special which sees four p

1234568

Comments

  • Options
    Black_RookBlack_Rook Posts: 8,905
    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    But doesn't the electorate (or, at any rate, a very large fraction of it) believe that all politicians are liars?

    In which case, why should veracity be any sort of criterion for determining which one they least despise?
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,991
    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    Yes, but I don't think it means as much as you think it does. Corbyn and Boris both have people who passionately hate them or distrust them, yet millions upon millions will vote for both, and each has people who passionately adore them and trusts them. We'll find out who has more of those, and how many are willing to stomach them, in a few weeks, but there's absolutely no reason to get excited because an audience reacts badly to either of them. That's no more logical than finding a clip of people cheering them and using that as proof they are beloved.
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,139
    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    You think Corbyn an unproven liar?

    It's a view.
  • Options
    ChrisChris Posts: 11,138

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That far fewer of the audience voted for Brexit than the 52% nationally?
    I think some of them may not really have been members of the Conservative Party.
  • Options
    CookieCookie Posts: 11,503

    Cookie said:

    Listening to the 9.30 radio news. Main headline is Corbyn staying neutral on Brexit, together with confirmation that Lib Dems would revoke, cons would GBD and Scot Nats favour independence feom the UK. Not sure if this represents a PR win for anyone or not.

    3 out of 4 have got their preferred message out.

    1 of the 4's preferred message has shot them in the foot but c'est la vie.
    But what is Lab's preferred message on Brexit? It appears to be to negotiate a deal so terrible and lacking in advantage and anything that any Brexit voter at all wanted that it gets defeated in a referendum. This is a difficult sell to either Remainers or Leavers. In the circumstances, a soundbite of remaining neutral is possibly the least bad way of putting it.
  • Options
    wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 7,109
    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,927
    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
  • Options
    Flashy5Flashy5 Posts: 42
    edited November 2019
    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    The audience not worried about the economy, unemployment, defence, human rights or getting Brexit done under Boris - their only concern is his shagging.

    Shows how unconcerned they are about competence.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,358
    edited November 2019
    nichomar said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    Yes Leavers will vote positively for Boris, Remainers will not vote positively for Corbyn and on that performance not really for Swinson either
    Swinsons performance was fine what did she do wrong? Every question was loaded against her and she defended well tell us what was wrong with her performance
    I thought she was almost abused by the audience and did cope well with it but at times I thought she wanted to be anywhere but there. The revoke policy was an unnecessary mistake of immense proportions not helped by her proclaiming she would be PM

    I actually think she is a decent person but is unlikely to revive the lib dems
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    Floater said:

    egg said:

    Floater said:

    HYUFD said:

    humbugger said:

    HYUFD said:

    nico67 said:

    HYUFD said:

    nico67 said:

    This crowd are brutal , shame for Bozo he’s on last . More people will be watching .

    Many will have turned over for Corrie but he is doing very well anyway
    This is desperate spin , he started off okay and has gone downhill ever since .
    It is not desperate spin, the only desperate spin is coming from leftwingers desperately trying and failing to undermine Boris
    Indeed. And none of then citing specifics.
    What did he say about longest waiting lists worst ever A&E numbers worst ever cancer numbers that he was asked.

    Fook All
    He is putting in more money and will have more money to put in further still when we get Brexit done
    9 years of cuts whilst top rate taxpayers have a bonanza.

    Real Change is needed.
    Destruction of the economy is real change I suppose.

    But no thanks
    Would every Labour government always wreck the economy?
    In my lifetime they have always left it in a mess - but this time they going full on mental socialism.

    Because that always works right.
    The charge is always laid against them that they will wreck the economy. I think the reality is there have been some hideous self made recessions and bad mistakes made under the conservatives to. But it’s a very long argument, pointing out the 10 years of Blair economy seemed okay but mistakes probably made then that created the crash people on labour side try to say was banks and sub prime in US and not wholly U.K. government fault, likewise problems labour had in seventies was inheriting an over heating economy they poured heat onto to fulfil election promises when really they should have cooled it down. So we will argue, but not come to a conclusive answer, Imo
  • Options
    nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    What a wonderful progressive future you are predicting bring back Jim Davidson and Benny hill, why stop at that also the black and white minstrels
  • Options
    nunu2nunu2 Posts: 1,453
    The Tory campaign hasn't really got started, yet.

    Getting a bit complacent?
  • Options
    XtrainXtrain Posts: 338

    nichomar said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    Yes Leavers will vote positively for Boris, Remainers will not vote positively for Corbyn and on that performance not really for Swinson either
    Swinsons performance was fine what did she do wrong? Every question was loaded against her and she defended well tell us what was wrong with her performance
    I thought she was almost abused by the audience and did cope well with it but at times I thought she wanted to be anywhere but there. The revoke policy was an unnecessary mistake of immense proportions not helped by her proclaiming she would be PM

    I actually think she is a decent person but is unlikely to revive the lib dems</blockquot

    I only saw a short clip but felt really bad for her and I'm not a fan.
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749

    nichomar said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    Yes Leavers will vote positively for Boris, Remainers will not vote positively for Corbyn and on that performance not really for Swinson either
    Swinsons performance was fine what did she do wrong? Every question was loaded against her and she defended well tell us what was wrong with her performance
    I thought she was almost abused by the audience and did cope well with it but at times I thought she wanted to be anywhere but there. The revoke policy was an unnecessary mistake of immense proportions not helped by her proclaiming she would be PM

    I actually think she is a decent person but is unlikely to revive the lib dems
    Why didn’t they just stick with 2nd ref rather than revoke? Revoke is too much like don’t care about uniting the country or being fair to 17 million voters, just exploit the division for a nice haul of seats.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,991
    nunu2 said:

    The Tory campaign hasn't really got started, yet.

    Getting a bit complacent?

    I suspect its more that last time their campaigning and manifesto seemed to make things worse (if not in reducing poll share, in seeing Corbyn rise). Even if that was more down to Corbyn than them, I think they want to do as little as possible to impact what is currently a good score.
  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,894
    nunu2 said:

    The Tory campaign hasn't really got started, yet.

    Getting a bit complacent?

    The Conservative manifesto launch on Sunday will presumably the moment the Con campaign cranks up a couple of gears...
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    nichomar said:

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    What a wonderful progressive future you are predicting bring back Jim Davidson and Benny hill, why stop at that also the black and white minstrels
    And the goodies with black face and jazz hands
  • Options
    nunu2 said:

    The Tory campaign hasn't really got started, yet.

    Getting a bit complacent?

    If only they had a set-piece event lined up for Sunday which they get to trial in all of the Sundays; and then see discussed again on Monday.
  • Options
    olmolm Posts: 125
    edited November 2019

    neutral WTF kind of leadership is that?

    Commendable leadership so he can get two best possible options (remain and a trade with EU) and put them to the public. He understands the country is split.

    He reasonably feels that will be the most unifying approach.

    The Tory approach will take MUCH longer - the withdrawal agreement is only the start, we haven't started down the thorny road of trade deals whilst keeping the ERG on side.
  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,894
    Mind you when was the last time Con was actually perceived to have won an election campaign? 1983?

    Even in 1987 and 1992 the general consensus was that Labour "won" the campaign even if they lost the election...
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    edited November 2019
    nunu2 said:

    The Tory campaign hasn't really got started, yet.

    Getting a bit complacent?

    Really? I am already halfway through delivering 4000 Tory leaflets across Epping and am canvassing again in Chingford tomorrow where teams are out across the day.

    Boris is campaigning across the country and the Tory social media operation is also far better than 2017
  • Options
    olm said:

    neutral WTF kind of leadership is that?

    Commendable leadership so he can get two best possible options and put them to the public. He understands the country is split. He reasonably feels that will be the most unifying approach.
    Even you can't possibly believe that 😂
  • Options
    welshowlwelshowl Posts: 4,460
    Sean_F said:

    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
    Quite. Boris is not the Messiah he’s a naughty boy to borrow a phrase. Personally in my fantasy world Boris would bulldoze Brexit through and we’d then have 15 years of pretty centerist PM Rory Stewart ( I know, I know).

    However, I am sitting here looking at the opinion polls judging whether to send money out of the country big time ( for me ) if I judge Corbyn walking down Downing St on Dec 13 is possible. No bullshit, I’ve set it up ready to go at one command. Because I’m fucking scared. I’m sure I’m not alone.
  • Options
    peter_from_putneypeter_from_putney Posts: 6,875
    edited November 2019
    On the spreads today, Labour are up by 4 seats, having gained 2 from the Tories and 2 from the LibDems who hit a new low point. I'm not sure whether these movements took place before, during or after tonight's so-called TV debate.
    Based on Spreadex's mid-spread for the Tories of 342 seats, they are anticipating an overall majority for the Blue Team of 34 seats.
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    Flashy5 said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    The audience not worried about the economy, unemployment, defence, human rights or getting Brexit done under Boris - their only concern is his shagging.

    Shows how unconcerned they are about competence.
    It’s not the shagging, though “wiki says you number of children is 5 or 6, can you clear that up please” would be a good question from audience member.

    No it’s not the shagging.

    It’s the bus.
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,927

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    That's where the swing votes are.
  • Options
    wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 7,109
    nichomar said:

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    What a wonderful progressive future you are predicting bring back Jim Davidson and Benny hill, why stop at that also the black and white minstrels
    Nonsense. I'm merely pointing out who is going to decide this election and it's not the cringingly woke right on brigade. I'm not sure why you assume 'progressive' is in some way better, in fact so called progressives tend to be very draconian in their approach to free speech and thought. On a wider note, the race to be as hideously right on as possible and show one is an 'ally' to everyone imaginable (and always that bit more so than the next guy) is what brings us to women with penises demanding access to women's refuges. It is utterly repugnant. We can be tolerant and accepting of (for example) trans issues without allowing third wave radical bullshit
  • Options
    SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 20,691
    Loved it when Swinson went into full-on teacher mode, telling the class how to correctly label their bar charts.
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    welshowl said:

    Sean_F said:

    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
    Quite. Boris is not the Messiah he’s a naughty boy to borrow a phrase. Personally in my fantasy world Boris would bulldoze Brexit through and we’d then have 15 years of pretty centerist PM Rory Stewart ( I know, I know).

    However, I am sitting here looking at the opinion polls judging whether to send money out of the country big time ( for me ) if I judge Corbyn walking down Downing St on Dec 13 is possible. No bullshit, I’ve set it up ready to go at one command. Because I’m fucking scared. I’m sure I’m not alone.
    I think Corbyn getting his turn in number ten has a sort of symmetry to it the way brexit has been going.
  • Options
    welshowlwelshowl Posts: 4,460
    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    Sean_F said:

    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
    Quite. Boris is not the Messiah he’s a naughty boy to borrow a phrase. Personally in my fantasy world Boris would bulldoze Brexit through and we’d then have 15 years of pretty centerist PM Rory Stewart ( I know, I know).

    However, I am sitting here looking at the opinion polls judging whether to send money out of the country big time ( for me ) if I judge Corbyn walking down Downing St on Dec 13 is possible. No bullshit, I’ve set it up ready to go at one command. Because I’m fucking scared. I’m sure I’m not alone.
    I think Corbyn getting his turn in number ten has a sort of symmetry to it the way brexit has been going.
    Out it would then go.

    At least 2017 warned me so I’ve done something about it 😁
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    HYUFD said:

    nunu2 said:

    The Tory campaign hasn't really got started, yet.

    Getting a bit complacent?

    Really? I am already halfway through delivering 4000 Tory leaflets across Epping and am canvassing again in Chingford tomorrow where teams are out across the day.

    Boris is campaigning across the country and the Tory social media operation is also far better than 2017
    How marginal is ching ford feeling?
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    edited November 2019
    GIN1138 said:

    Mind you when was the last time Con was actually perceived to have won an election campaign? 1983?

    Even in 1987 and 1992 the general consensus was that Labour "won" the campaign even if they lost the election...

    The Tories won the 2005 campaign though they lost the election, they also clearly won the 2015 campaign
  • Options
    egg said:

    nichomar said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    Yes Leavers will vote positively for Boris, Remainers will not vote positively for Corbyn and on that performance not really for Swinson either
    Swinsons performance was fine what did she do wrong? Every question was loaded against her and she defended well tell us what was wrong with her performance
    I thought she was almost abused by the audience and did cope well with it but at times I thought she wanted to be anywhere but there. The revoke policy was an unnecessary mistake of immense proportions not helped by her proclaiming she would be PM

    I actually think she is a decent person but is unlikely to revive the lib dems
    Why didn’t they just stick with 2nd ref rather than revoke? Revoke is too much like don’t care about uniting the country or being fair to 17 million voters, just exploit the division for a nice haul of seats.
    Absolutely. And they could have made huge progress
  • Options

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    I wouldn't give a shit what he'd written if it hadn't led directly to women getting attacked in the street. Joe average will get a rude awakening a few years into this government of Etonians who - guess what - really don't care about Joe average. I am getting so tired of this culture war nonsense, it's just like Trump, appealing to uneducated white men by thinly coded attacks on women and minorities. Pathetic that people can't see how they're being manipulated.
  • Options
    MattWMattW Posts: 18,701
    Listening to the Jo Swinson segment.

    Is she trying to do Tony Blair style "pretty straight sorta girl standing alongside" thing?

    "I geddit. We got stuff wrong. And we in the future, going forward, are determined we're gonna get it right".

    Try reading it in an estuary accent.
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,804
    Xtrain said:

    Boris's faults are priced in.
    The fact is people believe he will deliver Brexit and that's why they'll vote for him.

    They will, but they will still hate him. He is in for a torrid time in government, and will be a bigger pariah than Blair.
  • Options
    ThomasNasheThomasNashe Posts: 5,012

    egg said:

    nichomar said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    Yes Leavers will vote positively for Boris, Remainers will not vote positively for Corbyn and on that performance not really for Swinson either
    Swinsons performance was fine what did she do wrong? Every question was loaded against her and she defended well tell us what was wrong with her performance
    I thought she was almost abused by the audience and did cope well with it but at times I thought she wanted to be anywhere but there. The revoke policy was an unnecessary mistake of immense proportions not helped by her proclaiming she would be PM

    I actually think she is a decent person but is unlikely to revive the lib dems
    Why didn’t they just stick with 2nd ref rather than revoke? Revoke is too much like don’t care about uniting the country or being fair to 17 million voters, just exploit the division for a nice haul of seats.
    Absolutely. And they could have made huge progress
    They could still. The election hasn’t happened yet. FWIW, I think the vacuum in the middle will help: many will regard both Johnson and Corbyn as unacceptable PMs, so it’s a question of opting for the only available alternative.
  • Options
    wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 7,109
    edited November 2019

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    I wouldn't give a shit what he'd written if it hadn't led directly to women getting attacked in the street. Joe average will get a rude awakening a few years into this government of Etonians who - guess what - really don't care about Joe average. I am getting so tired of this culture war nonsense, it's just like Trump, appealing to uneducated white men by thinly coded attacks on women and minorities. Pathetic that people can't see how they're being manipulated.
    However the truly pathetic thing is the 3 and a half years of politicians and the Lawyer Boy and Gina Millers of this world doing everything they can to overturn the referendum. The Boris govt will deliver it and if, after that, they abandon the voters that put them there theyll get booted in 2024.
  • Options
    Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 26,907
    Flashy5 said:
    The audiences are always awful these days. (You can tell I'm not seeking votes from anyone).
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    Sean_F said:

    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
    Quite. Boris is not the Messiah he’s a naughty boy to borrow a phrase. Personally in my fantasy world Boris would bulldoze Brexit through and we’d then have 15 years of pretty centerist PM Rory Stewart ( I know, I know).

    However, I am sitting here looking at the opinion polls judging whether to send money out of the country big time ( for me ) if I judge Corbyn walking down Downing St on Dec 13 is possible. No bullshit, I’ve set it up ready to go at one command. Because I’m fucking scared. I’m sure I’m not alone.
    I think Corbyn getting his turn in number ten has a sort of symmetry to it the way brexit has been going.
    Out it would then go.

    At least 2017 warned me so I’ve done something about it 😁
    One thing I would warn you though, when the reds took control of Russia in 1920s there was money to be made from the change. When people start pouring money in, heating things up, the initial impacts won’t be Venezuela today, the bankruptcy and burying valuables in bottom of the garden in Bolton comes later. Remember when brown tried to prevent recession by throwing money at it there was bargains for shoppers? Make the most of the easy money and giveaways and keep an eye out for ugly downturn. If they are slung out after 4 years it might not even be that bad overall. Mind you, what I say may be true, but it’s not the message Cummings wants out there
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    edited November 2019

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    I wouldn't give a shit what he'd written if it hadn't led directly to women getting attacked in the street. Joe average will get a rude awakening a few years into this government of Etonians who - guess what - really don't care about Joe average. I am getting so tired of this culture war nonsense, it's just like Trump, appealing to uneducated white men by thinly coded attacks on women and minorities. Pathetic that people can't see how they're being manipulated.
    Boris gives far more concern for the views of the average man on the street than the average Islington diehard Remainer
  • Options
    Sky headlining Corbyn going neutral and having a hard time on anti semitism and a second referendum which may well cause Corbyn problems

    They said that the conservatives were very pleased as they feel they can gain votes on Corbyn's fence sitting
  • Options
    olmolm Posts: 125
    edited November 2019

    olm said:

    neutral WTF kind of leadership is that?

    Commendable leadership so he can get two best possible options and put them to the public. He understands the country is split. He reasonably feels that will be the most unifying approach.
    Even you can't possibly believe that 😂
    Really, which bit can't I believe, and care to set-out why so?

    A referendum with a real outcome is necessary (rather than a lie telling people there'd be an easy deal, loads of money, and single market as people were falsely told). The Tory government had more than 3 years, and got a deal and expected parliament to agree it in 3 days or crash out.

    If you're inferring Corbyn also has his own and political reasoning, then I concede that bit. But regardless, the Lab/Green/SNP/PC/SF/ALL/SDLP position (and to an extent the LD position) is a far far better position than the Tories, far better for the economy and far better for Northern Ireland and far better for avoiding a worse decline into ongoing 'dithering' about Brexit and economic harm - the Tories plan would mean years of wrangling. We have no clue what actual long-term plan they have - only the withdrawal agreement which is just the start.


  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Mind you when was the last time Con was actually perceived to have won an election campaign? 1983?

    Even in 1987 and 1992 the general consensus was that Labour "won" the campaign even if they lost the election...

    The Tories won the 2005 campaign though they lost the election, they also clearly won the 2015 campaign
    Tories also won the 92 campaign.
  • Options
    JonathanJonathan Posts: 20,904
    Foxy said:

    Xtrain said:

    Boris's faults are priced in.
    The fact is people believe he will deliver Brexit and that's why they'll vote for him.

    They will, but they will still hate him. He is in for a torrid time in government, and will be a bigger pariah than Blair.
    Tories seem to think that their victory will end things, that we will come together under Boris’s leadership and get Brexit done.

    Every bump in the road, every hiccup, every setback will be owned by him and his party. It will be brutal.
  • Options

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    I wouldn't give a shit what he'd written if it hadn't led directly to women getting attacked in the street. Joe average will get a rude awakening a few years into this government of Etonians who - guess what - really don't care about Joe average. I am getting so tired of this culture war nonsense, it's just like Trump, appealing to uneducated white men by thinly coded attacks on women and minorities. Pathetic that people can't see how they're being manipulated.
    However the truly pathetic thing is the 3 and a half years of politicians and the Lawyer Boy and Gina Millers of this world doing everything they can to overturn the referendum. The Boris govt will deliver it and if, after that, they abandon the voters that put them there theyll get booted in 2024.
    If the leavers had a plan for delivering Brexit in a way that didn't fuck the economy it would have happened by now. The plan is now to fuck the economy in the first year of a five year term and spend the next four years hoping things improve. The economy is already in trouble, the flash PMI surveys for November were dire.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    egg said:

    HYUFD said:

    nunu2 said:

    The Tory campaign hasn't really got started, yet.

    Getting a bit complacent?

    Really? I am already halfway through delivering 4000 Tory leaflets across Epping and am canvassing again in Chingford tomorrow where teams are out across the day.

    Boris is campaigning across the country and the Tory social media operation is also far better than 2017
    How marginal is ching ford feeling?
    I will tell you tomorrow, the British Italian conservatives are coming too.

    Though from the canvassing I have had the only Tories defecting have been to the LDs, I have yet to find one moving to Corbyn Labour, on the whole Leavers are behind IDS though especially now the Brexit Party are not standing Momentum are pushing it hard
  • Options
    welshowlwelshowl Posts: 4,460
    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    Sean_F said:

    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
    Quite. Boris is not the Messiah he’s a naughty boy to borrow a phrase. Personally in my fantasy world Boris would bulldoze Brexit through and we’d then have 15 years of pretty centerist PM Rory Stewart ( I know, I know).

    However, I am sitting here looking at the opinion polls judging whether to send money out of the country big time ( for me ) if I judge Corbyn walking down Downing St on Dec 13 is possible. No bullshit, I’ve set it up ready to go at one command. Because I’m fucking scared. I’m sure I’m not alone.
    I think Corbyn getting his turn in number ten has a sort of symmetry to it the way brexit has been going.
    Out it would then go.

    At least 2017 warned me so I’ve done something about it 😁
    One thing I would warn you though, when the reds took control of Russia in 1920s there was money to be made from the change. When people start pouring money in, heating things up, the initial impacts won’t be Venezuela today, the bankruptcy and burying valuables in bottom of the garden in Bolton comes later. Remember when brown tried to prevent recession by throwing money at it there was bargains for shoppers? Make the most of the easy money and giveaways and keep an eye out for ugly downturn. If they are slung out after 4 years it might not even be that bad overall. Mind you, what I say may be true, but it’s not the message Cummings wants out there
    Listen if Jezza wants to seriously implement his bat shit crazed policies, exchange controls are on the cards, not that that’ll appear in the manifesto. I remember the 50 quid limit in the 70’s. It was fuck all even then.

    I will take no chances.
  • Options
    nunu2nunu2 Posts: 1,453
    The polls should narrow this coming Saturday evening, however the key question is will they widen again after the Tory manifesto is released on Sunday?

    We just have to wait.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    egg said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Mind you when was the last time Con was actually perceived to have won an election campaign? 1983?

    Even in 1987 and 1992 the general consensus was that Labour "won" the campaign even if they lost the election...

    The Tories won the 2005 campaign though they lost the election, they also clearly won the 2015 campaign
    Tories also won the 92 campaign.
    Major did certainly
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,291
    edited November 2019
    I missed all the fun and games. Sounds like another ranty shouty more heat than light type of event.

    I have just come back from dinner with a former big Corbyn fan / Team Red all their life / Remainer. They are of course still going to vote Labour, but now have little to say about Jezza and Brexit, the response was I'm sick of it, just get it done now. When I said, what about Labour's re-re-renegotiation followed by a 2nd referendum...lets just say the response was unpublishable.
  • Options

    egg said:

    nichomar said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    Yes Leavers will vote positively for Boris, Remainers will not vote positively for Corbyn and on that performance not really for Swinson either
    Swinsons performance was fine what did she do wrong? Every question was loaded against her and she defended well tell us what was wrong with her performance
    I thought she was almost abused by the audience and did cope well with it but at times I thought she wanted to be anywhere but there. The revoke policy was an unnecessary mistake of immense proportions not helped by her proclaiming she would be PM

    I actually think she is a decent person but is unlikely to revive the lib dems
    Why didn’t they just stick with 2nd ref rather than revoke? Revoke is too much like don’t care about uniting the country or being fair to 17 million voters, just exploit the division for a nice haul of seats.
    Absolutely. And they could have made huge progress
    Indeed. The LibDems made 2 massive strategic errors with the revoke policy and the PM Swinson meme which seem likely to cost them their opportunity to make serious inroads against Corbyn's extremists.
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,804

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    So you think he has the misogynist and racist vote sewed up? I think so too.
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,927
    egg said:

    HYUFD said:

    nunu2 said:

    The Tory campaign hasn't really got started, yet.

    Getting a bit complacent?

    Really? I am already halfway through delivering 4000 Tory leaflets across Epping and am canvassing again in Chingford tomorrow where teams are out across the day.

    Boris is campaigning across the country and the Tory social media operation is also far better than 2017
    How marginal is ching ford feeling?
    I think Chingford will be a pretty comfortable Conservative hold.
  • Options
    olm said:

    olm said:

    neutral WTF kind of leadership is that?

    Commendable leadership so he can get two best possible options and put them to the public. He understands the country is split. He reasonably feels that will be the most unifying approach.
    Even you can't possibly believe that 😂
    Really, which bit can't I believe, and care to set-out why so?

    A referendum with a real outcome is necessary (rather than a lie telling people there'd be an easy deal, loads of money, and single market as people were falsely told). The Tory government had more than 3 years, and got a deal and expected parliament to agree it in 3 days or crash out.

    If you're inferring Corbyn also has his own and political reasoning, then I concede that bit. But regardless, the Lab/Green/SNP/PC/SF/ALL/SDLP position (and to an extent the LD position) is a far far better position than the Tories, far better for the economy and far better for Northern Ireland and far better for avoiding a worse decline into ongoing 'dithering' about Brexit and economic harm - the Tories plan would mean years of wrangling. We have no clue what actual long-term plan they have - only the withdrawal agreement which is just the start.


    If you think we should Remain then say so, not stay neutral.

    If you think we should Leave then say why and what benefits we'll get from Leaving, not stay neutral.

    What benefits will we get from Corbyn's Leave but remain in single market, remain in customs union and keep free movement deal?
  • Options
    Only saw Swinson and Bo-Jo. What a Momentum packed audience. Swinson has the hardest time, thought she stood her ground well. Boris had a bit easier time, he was a bit blustery but not as bad I had feared.
  • Options
    Jonathan said:

    Foxy said:

    Xtrain said:

    Boris's faults are priced in.
    The fact is people believe he will deliver Brexit and that's why they'll vote for him.

    They will, but they will still hate him. He is in for a torrid time in government, and will be a bigger pariah than Blair.
    Tories seem to think that their victory will end things, that we will come together under Boris’s leadership and get Brexit done.

    Every bump in the road, every hiccup, every setback will be owned by him and his party. It will be brutal.
    I can live with that.
  • Options
    squareroot2squareroot2 Posts: 6,368
    Andy_JS said:

    Flashy5 said:
    The audiences are always awful these days. (You can tell I'm not seeking votes from anyone).
    I felt b4 the debate started that nothing would come of it.. not far wrong either...
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,291
    edited November 2019
    What did I say about the Lib Dem revoke policy when they announced it....

    All they had to do is say I think we should have a referendum on the deal, put out some sensible middle of the road orange book type policies and hoover up all those middle class liberal type votes.
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    HYUFD said:

    egg said:

    HYUFD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Mind you when was the last time Con was actually perceived to have won an election campaign? 1983?

    Even in 1987 and 1992 the general consensus was that Labour "won" the campaign even if they lost the election...

    The Tories won the 2005 campaign though they lost the election, they also clearly won the 2015 campaign
    Tories also won the 92 campaign.
    Major did certainly
    Patton master minded the three whammy tax bombshell.
  • Options
    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    Sean_F said:

    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
    Quite. Boris is not the Messiah he’s a naughty boy to borrow a phrase. Personally in my fantasy world Boris would bulldoze Brexit through and we’d then have 15 years of pretty centerist PM Rory Stewart ( I know, I know).

    However, I am sitting here looking at the opinion polls judging whether to send money out of the country big time ( for me ) if I judge Corbyn walking down Downing St on Dec 13 is possible. No bullshit, I’ve set it up ready to go at one command. Because I’m fucking scared. I’m sure I’m not alone.
    I think Corbyn getting his turn in number ten has a sort of symmetry to it the way brexit has been going.
    Out it would then go.

    At least 2017 warned me so I’ve done something about it 😁
    One thing I would warn you though, when the reds took control of Russia in 1920s there was money to be made from the change. When people start pouring money in, heating things up, the initial impacts won’t be Venezuela today, the bankruptcy and burying valuables in bottom of the garden in Bolton comes later. Remember when brown tried to prevent recession by throwing money at it there was bargains for shoppers? Make the most of the easy money and giveaways and keep an eye out for ugly downturn. If they are slung out after 4 years it might not even be that bad overall. Mind you, what I say may be true, but it’s not the message Cummings wants out there
    Listen if Jezza wants to seriously implement his bat shit crazed policies, exchange controls are on the cards, not that that’ll appear in the manifesto. I remember the 50 quid limit in the 70’s. It was fuck all even then.

    I will take no chances.
    How would exchange controls even operate in the more electronically linked world of 2019?
  • Options
    HYUFD said:

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    I wouldn't give a shit what he'd written if it hadn't led directly to women getting attacked in the street. Joe average will get a rude awakening a few years into this government of Etonians who - guess what - really don't care about Joe average. I am getting so tired of this culture war nonsense, it's just like Trump, appealing to uneducated white men by thinly coded attacks on women and minorities. Pathetic that people can't see how they're being manipulated.
    Boris gives far more concern for the views of the average man on the street than the average Islington diehard Remainer
    Give over. Plenty of "men in the street" are Remainers. Some of them even live in Islington. Johnson doesn't give a monkeys about ordinary people, he just wants to have a whiff of power and a regular supply of iffy shags.
  • Options
    wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 7,109
    Foxy said:

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    So you think he has the misogynist and racist vote sewed up? I think so too.
    It's that sort of offhand, sneering dismissal of the working class vote that will make the utter trashing of labour and the idiot Swinsonites an utter joy
  • Options
    madmacs said:

    Only saw Swinson and Bo-Jo. What a Momentum packed audience. Swinson has the hardest time, thought she stood her ground well. Boris had a bit easier time, he was a bit blustery but not as bad I had feared.

    Isn't it amusing how Momentum types hate splitters within the Labour movement [and by extension the Lib Dems since they view them as splitters too] more than they hate the Tories themselves.
  • Options
    Black_RookBlack_Rook Posts: 8,905

    egg said:

    nichomar said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    Yes Leavers will vote positively for Boris, Remainers will not vote positively for Corbyn and on that performance not really for Swinson either
    Swinsons performance was fine what did she do wrong? Every question was loaded against her and she defended well tell us what was wrong with her performance
    I thought she was almost abused by the audience and did cope well with it but at times I thought she wanted to be anywhere but there. The revoke policy was an unnecessary mistake of immense proportions not helped by her proclaiming she would be PM

    I actually think she is a decent person but is unlikely to revive the lib dems
    Why didn’t they just stick with 2nd ref rather than revoke? Revoke is too much like don’t care about uniting the country or being fair to 17 million voters, just exploit the division for a nice haul of seats.
    Absolutely. And they could have made huge progress
    They could still. The election hasn’t happened yet. FWIW, I think the vacuum in the middle will help: many will regard both Johnson and Corbyn as unacceptable PMs, so it’s a question of opting for the only available alternative.
    When it comes to who will be PM there is no alternative to Johnson and Corbyn, and that's the Lib Dems' major problem. All those voters who might otherwise be inclined to back them but won't, because Jo Swinson is obviously not a realistic prospect for PM, and they're afraid that voting for her party will simply end up empowering whichever of the two actual candidates they detest the most.

    So yes, there are plenty of voters who believe both men are unfit for high office. But almost all of those voters think one of them is vastly more unfit than the other, and will therefore back whichever man they merely distrust in order to attempt to thwart the one of which they are terrified.
  • Options
    olmolm Posts: 125
    Sturgeon presented best, though wasn't tackled as much as the others.

    Corbyn was clear, made the right points, and answered (most of) the actual questions, far better than the bumbling, fact-less and inarticulate Johnson, the only one who couldn't even remember each question when a series was put.

    The presenter pulled up Johnson and Corbyn well, though when it got to Johnson the audience didn't *seem* to get as many follow-ons/come-backs as with the others.

    Even Swinson was better, though she was either attacked more, or perhaps dealt worse with it (by actually being more responsive).

    Yet again Johnson relies on his bumbling 'charisma' to push on. I regret that many watching may go for the personality before the (lack of) policy.

    Corbyn seems to take days or weeks to take positions on issues that are obviously going to come up and need clarifying. Issues he could deal with immediately, but instead he seems to let them fester (out of stubbornness) until they become sores; by which time it is too little too late.

  • Options
    BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 31,777
    welshowl said:

    Sean_F said:

    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
    Quite. Boris is not the Messiah he’s a naughty boy to borrow a phrase. Personally in my fantasy world Boris would bulldoze Brexit through and we’d then have 15 years of pretty centerist PM Rory Stewart ( I know, I know).

    However, I am sitting here looking at the opinion polls judging whether to send money out of the country big time ( for me ) if I judge Corbyn walking down Downing St on Dec 13 is possible. No bullshit, I’ve set it up ready to go at one command. Because I’m fucking scared. I’m sure I’m not alone.
    I am not a fan of Corbyn but I really, genuinely, find it totally incomprehensible that seemingly rational people treat the prospect of him becoming PM in such 'end of days' ways.

    Just think about it for a minute. Corbyn as PM will never be able to implement anything more more left-wing than the kind of social democracy seen on and off acros much of western Europe since the war. He will be moderated by rebel soft-left Labour MPs, not to mention his almost certain need to bring along coalition partners.

    A Corbyn-led government may not be what you'd choose life will go on, unchanged for many, a bit better for some, a bit worse for others.
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    HYUFD said:

    egg said:

    HYUFD said:

    nunu2 said:

    The Tory campaign hasn't really got started, yet.

    Getting a bit complacent?

    Really? I am already halfway through delivering 4000 Tory leaflets across Epping and am canvassing again in Chingford tomorrow where teams are out across the day.

    Boris is campaigning across the country and the Tory social media operation is also far better than 2017
    How marginal is ching ford feeling?
    I will tell you tomorrow, the British Italian conservatives are coming too.

    Though from the canvassing I have had the only Tories defecting have been to the LDs, I have yet to find one moving to Corbyn Labour, on the whole Leavers are behind IDS though especially now the Brexit Party are not standing Momentum are pushing it hard
    You have the Italians because they are good at making voters offers they can’t refuse?
  • Options
    squareroot2squareroot2 Posts: 6,368

    HYUFD said:

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    I wouldn't give a shit what he'd written if it hadn't led directly to women getting attacked in the street. Joe average will get a rude awakening a few years into this government of Etonians who - guess what - really don't care about Joe average. I am getting so tired of this culture war nonsense, it's just like Trump, appealing to uneducated white men by thinly coded attacks on women and minorities. Pathetic that people can't see how they're being manipulated.
    Boris gives far more concern for the views of the average man on the street than the average Islington diehard Remainer
    Give over. Plenty of "men in the street" are Remainers. Some of them even live in Islington. Johnson doesn't give a monkeys about ordinary people, he just wants to have a whiff of power and a regular supply of iffy shags.
    Weak weak weak
  • Options
    olm said:

    Sturgeon presented best, though wasn't tackled as much as the others.

    Corbyn was clear, made the right points, and answered (most of) the actual questions, far better than the bumbling, fact-less and inarticulate Johnson, the only one who couldn't even remember each question when a series was put.

    The presenter pulled up Johnson and Corbyn well, though when it got to Johnson the audience didn't *seem* to get as many follow-ons/come-backs as with the others.

    Even Swinson was better, though she was either attacked more, or perhaps dealt worse with it (by actually being more responsive).

    Yet again Johnson relies on his bumbling 'charisma' to push on. I regret that many watching may go for the personality before the (lack of) policy.

    Corbyn seems to take days or weeks to take positions on issues that are obviously going to come up and need clarifying. Issues he could deal with immediately, but instead he seems to let them fester (out of stubbornness) until they become sores; by which time it is too little too late.

    Sturgeon is a decent politician, at a time when there is lots of dross. She also has the advantage of not being exposed weekly in the way leaders of Tories / Labour where every decisions, every utterance, etc is picked up and splashed across the media.
  • Options

    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    Sean_F said:

    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
    Quite. Boris is not the Messiah he’s a naughty boy to borrow a phrase. Personally in my fantasy world Boris would bulldoze Brexit through and we’d then have 15 years of pretty centerist PM Rory Stewart ( I know, I know).

    However, I am sitting here looking at the opinion polls judging whether to send money out of the country big time ( for me ) if I judge Corbyn walking down Downing St on Dec 13 is possible. No bullshit, I’ve set it up ready to go at one command. Because I’m fucking scared. I’m sure I’m not alone.
    I think Corbyn getting his turn in number ten has a sort of symmetry to it the way brexit has been going.
    Out it would then go.

    At least 2017 warned me so I’ve done something about it 😁
    One thing I would warn you though, when the reds took control of Russia in 1920s there was money to be made from the change. When people start pouring money in, heating things up, the initial impacts won’t be Venezuela today, the bankruptcy and burying valuables in bottom of the garden in Bolton comes later. Remember when brown tried to prevent recession by throwing money at it there was bargains for shoppers? Make the most of the easy money and giveaways and keep an eye out for ugly downturn. If they are slung out after 4 years it might not even be that bad overall. Mind you, what I say may be true, but it’s not the message Cummings wants out there
    Listen if Jezza wants to seriously implement his bat shit crazed policies, exchange controls are on the cards, not that that’ll appear in the manifesto. I remember the 50 quid limit in the 70’s. It was fuck all even then.

    I will take no chances.
    How would exchange controls even operate in the more electronically linked world of 2019?
    Ask the Greeks. They had capital controls from 2015 until this year.
  • Options
    maaarshmaaarsh Posts: 3,391
    Jonathan said:

    Foxy said:

    Xtrain said:

    Boris's faults are priced in.
    The fact is people believe he will deliver Brexit and that's why they'll vote for him.

    They will, but they will still hate him. He is in for a torrid time in government, and will be a bigger pariah than Blair.
    Tories seem to think that their victory will end things, that we will come together under Boris’s leadership and get Brexit done.

    Every bump in the road, every hiccup, every setback will be owned by him and his party. It will be brutal.
    Which stage of grief would you say this is?
  • Options
    welshowlwelshowl Posts: 4,460

    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    Sean_F said:

    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
    Quite. Boris is not the Messiah he’s a naughty boy to borrow a phrase. Personally in my fantasy world Boris would bulldoze Brexit through and we’d then have 15 years of pretty centerist PM Rory Stewart ( I know, I know).

    However, I am sitting here looking at the opinion polls judging whether to send money out of the country big time ( for me ) if I judge Corbyn walking down Downing St on Dec 13 is possible. No bullshit, I’ve set it up ready to go at one command. Because I’m fucking scared. I’m sure I’m not alone.
    I think Corbyn getting his turn in number ten has a sort of symmetry to it the way brexit has been going.
    Out it would then go.

    At least 2017 warned me so I’ve done something about it 😁
    One thing I would warn you though, when the reds took control of Russia in 1920s there was money to be made from the change. When people start pouring money in, heating things up, the initial impacts won’t be Venezuela today, the bankruptcy and burying valuables in bottom of the garden in Bolton comes later. Remember when brown tried to prevent recession by throwing money at it there was bargains for shoppers? Make the most of the easy money and giveaways and keep an eye out for ugly downturn. If they are slung out after 4 years it might not even be that bad overall. Mind you, what I say may be true, but it’s not the message Cummings wants out there
    Listen if Jezza wants to seriously implement his bat shit crazed policies, exchange controls are on the cards, not that that’ll appear in the manifesto. I remember the 50 quid limit in the 70’s. It was fuck all even then.

    I will take no chances.
    How would exchange controls even operate in the more electronically linked world of 2019?
    Fair point, but I have no intention of having to find out,
  • Options
    RogerRoger Posts: 18,894
    One lesson from tonight is that a six week campaign shows that simple soundbites aren't everything. Swinson's revoke hasn't stood the test of time. Boris Johnson's Get Brexit Done sounds demented. Three more weeks and we'll all be pulling our hair out. Labour who were derided for having a more nuanced stance has turned out to be the only one with legs. Maybe the electorate aren't simpletons?
  • Options
    olmolm Posts: 125
    If anyone else, for example Corbyn or Farage, had said 'tank top bum boys' 'watermelon smiles' 'letterboxes' and 'picanninies' they would be on the racks.
    Johnson couldn't even bring himself to say he could understand how people could find it offensive.
  • Options
    wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 7,109

    What did I say about the Lib Dem revoke policy when they announced it....

    All they had to do is say I think we should have a referendum on the deal, put out some sensible middle of the road orange book type policies and hoover up all those middle class liberal type votes.

    It's not just the actual policy, it's her triumphal 'on day one we will revoke' stuff. Like, 17.4 million can feck off on day one of my overlordship
  • Options
    Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 25,519

    What did I say about the Lib Dem revoke policy when they announced it....

    All they had to do is say I think we should have a referendum on the deal, put out some sensible middle of the road orange book type policies and hoover up all those middle class liberal type votes.

    They could never have implemented leaving had Leave won again. Their policy would have been a farce like the Greens' - hold EUref 2 but if it's Leave, don't implement it. In that much, at least the Lib Dem policy is crudely honest.
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,804
    MattW said:

    Listening to the Jo Swinson segment.

    Is she trying to do Tony Blair style "pretty straight sorta girl standing alongside" thing?

    "I geddit. We got stuff wrong. And we in the future, going forward, are determined we're gonna get it right".

    Try reading it in an estuary accent.

    BoZo copied her answer concerning austerity. The Overton window has sharply moved Left.
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    nunu2 said:

    The polls should narrow this coming Saturday evening, however the key question is will they widen again after the Tory manifesto is released on Sunday?

    We just have to wait.

    After the Labour manifesto it may seem an open goal for Tories to shoot into. I would urge caution. Tax cuts funded by more borrowing and big investment in state services funded by Brexit dividend is likely to be savaged by IFS and fair minded fact checks. Lets be honest, tax cuts funded by borrowing and give aways based on imaginary Brexit dividend wouldn’t even pass the Conservative parties own fact checkers handful of years ago, would it? So what it would mean, the ball towards the open goal is missed, out come the “£350M a week for Tory Tax cuts, vote brexit*” banners, and the breakthrough the Tories need in seats they didn’t take last time will be gone.

    *yes, the irony of such a banner is it is a lie.
  • Options
    olm said:

    If anyone else, for example Corbyn or Farage, had said 'tank top bum boys' 'watermelon smiles' 'letterboxes' and 'picanninies' they would be on the racks.
    Johnson couldn't even bring himself to say he could understand how people could find it offensive.

    At least he's honest. He isn't sorry, he doesn't care, and as we have learned here it goes down well with loveable flat capped racists anyway.
  • Options
    Betfair

    Con maj 1.55
    NOM 3.1
  • Options
    ByronicByronic Posts: 3,578

    I'm slightly amazed to report that Richard Leonard may have done a zinger. Well, approaching the foothills of the Zingerania range.

    https://twitter.com/LabourRichard/status/1197969717622984705?s=20

    Speaking as a male model, I have to say you write dry, spry and elegant English. Dura Ace has a good turn of phrase, as well.

    A poignant plight for a Nat. To be so skilled in the tongue of your colonial English conquerors.
  • Options

    olm said:

    If anyone else, for example Corbyn or Farage, had said 'tank top bum boys' 'watermelon smiles' 'letterboxes' and 'picanninies' they would be on the racks.
    Johnson couldn't even bring himself to say he could understand how people could find it offensive.

    At least he's honest. He isn't sorry, he doesn't care, and as we have learned here it goes down well with loveable flat capped racists anyway.
    That's a bit rich when Labour voters are prepared to sell out the victims of antisemitism for a bit of free broadband...
  • Options
    Roger said:

    One lesson from tonight is that a six week campaign shows that simple soundbites aren't everything. Swinson's revoke hasn't stood the test of time. Boris Johnson's Get Brexit Done sounds demented. Three more weeks and we'll all be pulling our hair out. Labour who were derided for having a more nuanced stance has turned out to be the only one with legs. Maybe the electorate aren't simpletons?

    😂😂😂😂😂

    I'll have some of what he's drinking. 🍷
  • Options
    Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 25,519

    Jonathan said:

    Foxy said:

    Xtrain said:

    Boris's faults are priced in.
    The fact is people believe he will deliver Brexit and that's why they'll vote for him.

    They will, but they will still hate him. He is in for a torrid time in government, and will be a bigger pariah than Blair.
    Tories seem to think that their victory will end things, that we will come together under Boris’s leadership and get Brexit done.

    Every bump in the road, every hiccup, every setback will be owned by him and his party. It will be brutal.
    I can live with that.
    Own the setbacks, own the successes.
  • Options
    maaarshmaaarsh Posts: 3,391

    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    Sean_F said:

    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
    Quite. Boris is not the Messiah he’s a naughty boy to borrow a phrase. Personally in my fantasy world Boris would bulldoze Brexit through and we’d then have 15 years of pretty centerist PM Rory Stewart ( I know, I know).

    However, I am sitting here looking at the opinion polls judging whether to send money out of the country big time ( for me ) if I judge Corbyn walking down Downing St on Dec 13 is possible. No bullshit, I’ve set it up ready to go at one command. Because I’m fucking scared. I’m sure I’m not alone.
    I think Corbyn getting his turn in number ten has a sort of symmetry to it the way brexit has been going.
    Out it would then go.

    At least 2017 warned me so I’ve done something about it 😁
    One thing I would warn you though, when the reds took control of Russia in 1920s there was money to be made from the change. When people start pouring money in, heating things up, the initial impacts won’t be Venezuela today, the bankruptcy and burying valuables in bottom of the garden in Bolton comes later. Remember when brown tried to prevent recession by throwing money at it there was bargains for shoppers? Make the most of the easy money and giveaways and keep an eye out for ugly downturn. If they are slung out after 4 years it might not even be that bad overall. Mind you, what I say may be true, but it’s not the message Cummings wants out there
    Listen if Jezza wants to seriously implement his bat shit crazed policies, exchange controls are on the cards, not that that’ll appear in the manifesto. I remember the 50 quid limit in the 70’s. It was fuck all even then.

    I will take no chances.
    How would exchange controls even operate in the more electronically linked world of 2019?
    Even easier. Who is going to want to give a Brit much value for their electronic pounds when the underlying banks are under orders not to transfer any real asset to support it.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    edited November 2019
    Foxy said:

    MattW said:

    Listening to the Jo Swinson segment.

    Is she trying to do Tony Blair style "pretty straight sorta girl standing alongside" thing?

    "I geddit. We got stuff wrong. And we in the future, going forward, are determined we're gonna get it right".

    Try reading it in an estuary accent.

    BoZo copied her answer concerning austerity. The Overton window has sharply moved Left.
    It has moved right on immigration, the EU and crime, it has moved left on public spending and taxing the rich.

    On taxing average earners it has stayed the same
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,291
    edited November 2019
    I have to say Maureen Lipman's attack ad is very good. Better than the crap the actual political parties put out.
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,804

    Foxy said:

    Sean_F said:

    BluerBlue said:

    Jason said:

    I can see why Boris's enemies hate him so much. There seems to be a mountain of ammunition against him for many reasons, some legitimate, some not, but however he responds, he is utterly compelling in a way that none of the other politicians can reproduce. And therein lies Labour's problem with those millions of leave voters who are going to exact a bloody revenge against them. They'll hold their nose and vote for Boris in a way that millions of Tory remainers will not vote for Corbyn.

    I think it's because when people look at Boris they see a flawed human being who won't judge them, whereas Corbyn is an even more flawed human being who will...
    That's a very good point.
    Plus for all the woke millenial outrage over what he has written the swing votes this time are the northern and Midlands working classes who, for example, might attend bawdy comedy nights in working men's clubs and dont give a shit about how hurty some words were. Straight talking spade is a spade get Brexit done voters
    Time for Joe average to take charge and the permanently woke and offended, politico brigade to shut their yaks and take our government for 5 years
    So you think he has the misogynist and racist vote sewed up? I think so too.
    It's that sort of offhand, sneering dismissal of the working class vote that will make the utter trashing of labour and the idiot Swinsonites an utter joy
    It is you that stereotyped the working class as throwback to the Wheeltappers and Shunters Social Club, not me.
  • Options
    NigelbNigelb Posts: 62,792

    Ok, Ken Burns country documentary on now, au revoir.

    Sensible.

    I’m reading a history of the Korean War as light relief from politics.
    Which has thrown up a memorably bad acronym; UNTCOK ... the UN temporary commission on Korea.
  • Options
    welshowl said:

    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    Sean_F said:

    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
    Quite. Boris is not the Messiah he’s a naughty boy to borrow a phrase. Personally in my fantasy world Boris would bulldoze Brexit through and we’d then have 15 years of pretty centerist PM Rory Stewart ( I know, I know).

    However, I am sitting here looking at the opinion polls judging whether to send money out of the country big time ( for me ) if I judge Corbyn walking down Downing St on Dec 13 is possible. No bullshit, I’ve set it up ready to go at one command. Because I’m fucking scared. I’m sure I’m not alone.
    I think Corbyn getting his turn in number ten has a sort of symmetry to it the way brexit has been going.
    Out it would then go.

    At least 2017 warned me so I’ve done something about it 😁
    slung out after 4 years it might not even be that bad overall. Mind you, what I say may be true, but it’s not the message Cummings wants out there
    Listen if Jezza wants to seriously implement his bat shit crazed policies, exchange controls are on the cards, not that that’ll appear in the manifesto. I remember the 50 quid limit in the 70’s. It was fuck all even then.

    I will take no chances.
    How would exchange controls even operate in the more electronically linked world of 2019?
    Fair point, but I have no intention of having to find out,
    This is how Wikipedia describes what happened in 2015:

    As a result, the Greek government was forced to immediately close Greek banks for almost 20 days and to implement controls on bank transfers from Greek banks to foreign banks, and limits on cash withdrawals (only €60 per day permitted), to avoid an uncontrolled bank run and a complete collapse of the Greek banking system. The capital controls were gradually minimized until their complete removal on the 1st of September 2019.

    If it happened there would not be a lot of warning.
  • Options
    BluerBlue said:

    olm said:

    If anyone else, for example Corbyn or Farage, had said 'tank top bum boys' 'watermelon smiles' 'letterboxes' and 'picanninies' they would be on the racks.
    Johnson couldn't even bring himself to say he could understand how people could find it offensive.

    At least he's honest. He isn't sorry, he doesn't care, and as we have learned here it goes down well with loveable flat capped racists anyway.
    That's a bit rich when Labour voters are prepared to sell out the victims of antisemitism for a bit of free broadband...
    https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/nov/22/jewish-voting-labour-antisemitism-progressive-government
  • Options
    Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 26,907
    "Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab and Labour's Andy McDonald face off after Sky News interview"

    https://news.sky.com/video/dominic-raab-attacks-andy-mcdonald-over-antisemitism-in-the-labour-party-11867643
  • Options
    BTW, who thought putting the event on on a Friday evening was a good idea. Most people have far better things plans for such an evening than watching a load of politicians bullshit for 2hrs.
  • Options
    wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 7,109

    olm said:

    If anyone else, for example Corbyn or Farage, had said 'tank top bum boys' 'watermelon smiles' 'letterboxes' and 'picanninies' they would be on the racks.
    Johnson couldn't even bring himself to say he could understand how people could find it offensive.

    At least he's honest. He isn't sorry, he doesn't care, and as we have learned here it goes down well with loveable flat capped racists anyway.
    That's it, everyone that doesn't worship at the altar of progressive bollocks is a flat cap racist. And theres the sneering superiority of the 'progressives' and why theyll never understand, get, or appeal to normal human beings
  • Options
    NickPalmerNickPalmer Posts: 21,361
    Andy_JS said:

    Flashy5 said:
    The audiences are always awful these days. (You can tell I'm not seeking votes from anyone).
    I thought the 10 o'clock news overdid the "they're all awful" stuff, almost as though they wanted to encourage disillusionment. Both Johnson and Corbyn had some sympathetic questions which were airbrushed out - both of them have a decent number of real support, so why in fairness not interview some of them too?
  • Options
    Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 26,907
    Roger said:

    One lesson from tonight is that a six week campaign shows that simple soundbites aren't everything. Swinson's revoke hasn't stood the test of time. Boris Johnson's Get Brexit Done sounds demented. Three more weeks and we'll all be pulling our hair out. Labour who were derided for having a more nuanced stance has turned out to be the only one with legs. Maybe the electorate aren't simpletons?

    "Get Brexit Done" risks being the 2019 version of "Strong and Stable Government".
  • Options
    BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 31,777
    welshowl said:

    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    egg said:

    welshowl said:

    Sean_F said:

    Roger said:

    Brom said:

    Roger said:

    EVERY single question to johnson is about trust accompanied by cheers from the audience. Doesn't that say something?

    That the audience hates Boris?
    No. That that they think he's a proven liar
    The point is, Roger, nobody other than committed Labour voters, cares. Swing voters may distrust Johnson, but they fear Corbyn.
    Quite. Boris is not the Messiah he’s a naughty boy to borrow a phrase. Personally in my fantasy world Boris would bulldoze Brexit through and we’d then have 15 years of pretty centerist PM Rory Stewart ( I know, I know).

    However, I am sitting here looking at the opinion polls judging whether to send money out of the country big time ( for me ) if I judge Corbyn walking down Downing St on Dec 13 is possible. No bullshit, I’ve set it up ready to go at one command. Because I’m fucking scared. I’m sure I’m not alone.
    I think Corbyn getting his turn in number ten has a sort of symmetry to it the way brexit has been going.
    Out it would then go.

    At least 2017 warned me so I’ve done something about it 😁
    One thing I would warn you though, when the reds took control of Russia in 1920s there was money to be made from the change. When people start pouring money in, heating things up, the initial impacts won’t be Venezuela today, the bankruptcy and burying valuables in bottom of the garden in Bolton comes later. Remember when brown tried to prevent recession by throwing money at it there was bargains for shoppers? Make the most of the easy money and giveaways and keep an eye out for ugly downturn. If they are slung out after 4 years it might not even be that bad overall. Mind you, what I say may be true, but it’s not the message Cummings wants out there
    Listen if Jezza wants to seriously implement his bat shit crazed policies, exchange controls are on the cards, not that that’ll appear in the manifesto. I remember the 50 quid limit in the 70’s. It was fuck all even then.

    I will take no chances.
    How would exchange controls even operate in the more electronically linked world of 2019?
    Fair point, but I have no intention of having to find out,
    Sounds like you have a severe dose of survivalism...

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivalism
This discussion has been closed.