Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Ceremonies – politicalbetting.com

1356789

Comments

  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 28,871
    GIN1138 said:

    Dialup said:

    I don't believe the Monarchy is any more Tory than Labour.

    Labour has been in government many times, never once tried to change or touch the monarchy. Indeed Blair did a lot to save it after Diana.

    It's rumoured that after Churchill, Harold Wilson was the Late Her Majesty's favourite PM while her relations with Maggie were often "frosty" lol.
    She must have liked Cameron or she wouldn't have PURRRRRED down the phone at him.
  • DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 28,443

    Seems like quite a low turnout crowd-wise. Weather or zeitgeist?

    Highlights of the ceremony for me: the 6th century bible and Zadok the Priest. Both genuinely awesome.

    Re turnout, probably both but there were also reports of people being turned away, and the route is quite a short one. If I'd wanted to go, I'd probably have been put off by the practicalities.

    But there is not the popular enthusiasm there was for, say, Charles & Diana's wedding, where there were miles of crowds because St Paul's is miles from the Palace.

    As I've posted before, there was not much effort to explain the point of the coronation, and what there was probably came too late. Even the supermarkets looked a bit drab, with crisps and biscuits in souvenir tins but not much to say this is potentially a once in a lifetime event.
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,806
    IanB2 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    What planet are you on? Those military parades of infantry and cavalry are really not going to register one iota with Putin.
    The days when soldiers ran away in terror at the sound of Malc on his bagpipes are over?
    With apols for the repost, it was good to see Malc putting on his finest for the service this morning:

    image
  • theakestheakes Posts: 935
    I went for petrol during the Coronation Service. The roads were packed, people at the bus stop and the shops all open with a steady flow of folk, people going about their normal lives.
    A totally different picture to the one painted by the media.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,036
    Hip hip. Hooray!
  • StillWatersStillWaters Posts: 8,476

    DavidL said:

    Lordy, could you be more careful: "potentially" running an "avoidance" scheme. Is running avoidance schemes not what accountants do and isn't it perfectly legal?

    Thin gruel for those of us who have so far been enjoying this luxurious feast put on by the SNP for general amusement. Must do better.
    Dan Neidle’s version pulls fewer punches: https://www.taxpolicy.org.uk/2023/05/06/schoolfees/
    It’s also totally unnecessary.

    Much simpler:

    - issue non voting B shares to the children
    - Differential dividend rights that can be declared by the board
    - Live 7 years to take those shares out of the estate for inheritance tax purposes

    The tax saving basically arises from moving from a 39% tax rate to using the personal allowance and dividend allowance for the kids (about £14k) and then paying a lower rate of tax on the balance

  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,690
    Okay if you want to get someone to do a proper 3 cheers then get the military. That was pretty awesome.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,036
    edited May 2023
    Dura_Ace said:

    I assume the flypast will still be on, hard to tell from the TV footage but cloudbase is what 1,000 - 1,500ft?

    Dura Ace may be able to help there, I think, with the view from a cockpit veteran.
    I've only ever done one and that was 1,000' over DC. The military can pretty much sanction anything with the tacit understanding that there will be a ruthless cauldron of blame for the most junior officer involved if anything goes wrong. They would be mental to do it of they didn't have the normal VFR minima for low level flight. 1,000' vertical, 1500m horizontal to cloud and 5km flight visibility.
    Do the mil use the 500’ rule, that is the law for us civvies?

    Presumably, anything with a single engine needs to remain within gliding range of the river?
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,690
    theakes said:

    I went for petrol during the Coronation Service. The roads were packed, people at the bus stop and the shops all open with a steady flow of folk, people going about their normal lives.
    A totally different picture to the one painted by the media.

    Yawn.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,987
    edited May 2023
    Dialup said:

    I don't believe the Monarchy is any more Tory than Labour.

    Labour has been in government many times, never once tried to change or touch the monarchy. Indeed Blair did a lot to save it after Diana.

    Tory voters are about twice as likely to back the monarchy as Labour voters. LD voters in between
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,713
    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    What's wrong with power and might?

    It's part of the pageantry. The command of the monarchy. It's reach.

    I think having British guards carrying every flag of the Commonwealth, and the procession being led by the mounties, is a powerful symbol of unity and inclusion that isn't quite as imperial as you think.

    More a family that shares values.
  • TimSTimS Posts: 13,217

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Not really.

    Loving it in our house. We are bouncing along , toasting and cheering.

    It's one hell of a show.
    Overall it seems much less impressive than the Queen's funeral to me. Fine in itself, well-executed, beautiful music but not quite on the same level.

    Glad it all appears to have gone off safely though - all credit to the security services.
    It depends how it moves you. This moves me just as deeply. The historical resonance of it.

    And there are even more troops for this one. So the spectacle is just as strong.
    I’m with the others. The parade has nothing like the same resonance as the coronation service. It’s just much more anachronistic because it’s not timeless: it’s rooted in the 18th and 19th centuries.

    The coronation itself is of a different order. It’s a ceremony from deep time, mediaeval Norman at root but with hints of tradition going back further. Even the more modern Zadok the priest doesn’t upset this sense of a ritual stretching back epochs. Watching the crowning there was a feeling of the deep history of the island.

    The military parades are impressive in their own way but on a very different level.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 56,606
    edited May 2023

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    Exactly what I was going to post ; the emphasis on huge parades is really a holdover from imperial times, when it was a necessary show to adversaries.

    I think that the future of these ceremonies should be tasteful and grand, with some mystical elements ; but also smaller. If Charles has any sense with his slimming-down plans, this should be included, because it also sends an important message about the role of the monarchy and its awareness of its place in society.
    It works for funerals. It was tremendous for QE2. The coffin on the gun carriage

    But for more positive events - weddings, jubilees and coronations (however serious) somettjg more joyous is needed
    Like @Jonathan said you are a luvvie.

    A right-wing luvvie, to be sure, but still a luvvie.
    Coz I don’t get physically aroused by regiments of men marching fairly pointlessly along a road, albeit with immaculate timing? Whatever

    I’m a royalist. I loved the coronation. I can do without the horsey bits
  • DialupDialup Posts: 561
    Just been out for a run in SW London.

    I saw a total of two flags.

    Standard.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,981

    IanB2 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    What planet are you on? Those military parades of infantry and cavalry are really not going to register one iota with Putin.
    The days when soldiers ran away in terror at the sound of Malc on his bagpipes are over?
    With apols for the repost, it was good to see Malc putting on his finest for the service this morning:

    image
    Why is the bloke in the red kilt wearing Cthulhu on the front of his kilt.
  • StillWatersStillWaters Posts: 8,476

    Leon said:

    The music is the absolute star of this. Followed by the architecture and pageantry. A bit too much churchiness… and I don’t mind churchiness


    But on the whole: Splendidly done. This is us. A strange and very ancient and almost unconquerable people. We will endure

    And God Save King Chuck

    Why can't God save the rest of us plebs? Stupid national "anthem".
    It’s the second verse that matters

    May he defend our laws
    And always give us cause
    To shout with one heart and voice
    God save the King

    It’s a duty he is taking on, rewarded by a conditional pledge of loyalty by the people
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,806
    Dialup said:

    Just been out for a run in SW London.

    I saw a total of two flags.

    Standard.

    What was the other one?
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,045
    Dialup said:

    Just been out for a run in SW London.

    I saw a total of two flags.

    Standard.

    You are Lady Nugee and I claim my
    2p. :)
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,987

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    Genuine question, why would Putin take note of our parades, no matter how well choreographed they are?
    See his own military parades, demos of military strength matter to power projection
  • theakes said:

    I went for petrol during the Coronation Service. The roads were packed, people at the bus stop and the shops all open with a steady flow of folk, people going about their normal lives.
    A totally different picture to the one painted by the media.

    Yawn.
    Round here, I was the only one doing any work! It wasn't raining, but no usual Saturday morning lawn mowing or DIY. So I suppose they were all watching the telly.
  • Dura_AceDura_Ace Posts: 13,778
    Forgot to say, Crab Air don't have the best track record on this sort of caper. They mid-aired two Phenoms while "practicing" for the RAF 100th anniversary flypast.

    Still better than Iran (and Venezuela) they've both crashed fucking all sorts doing mass fly pasts.
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,806

    IanB2 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    What planet are you on? Those military parades of infantry and cavalry are really not going to register one iota with Putin.
    The days when soldiers ran away in terror at the sound of Malc on his bagpipes are over?
    With apols for the repost, it was good to see Malc putting on his finest for the service this morning:

    image
    Why is the bloke in the red kilt wearing Cthulhu on the front of his kilt.
    I think you'll have to file a pubic information request to find out what it is.
  • WhisperingOracleWhisperingOracle Posts: 9,260
    TimS said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Not really.

    Loving it in our house. We are bouncing along , toasting and cheering.

    It's one hell of a show.
    Overall it seems much less impressive than the Queen's funeral to me. Fine in itself, well-executed, beautiful music but not quite on the same level.

    Glad it all appears to have gone off safely though - all credit to the security services.
    It depends how it moves you. This moves me just as deeply. The historical resonance of it.

    And there are even more troops for this one. So the spectacle is just as strong.
    I’m with the others. The parade has nothing like the same resonance as the coronation service. It’s just much more anachronistic because it’s not timeless: it’s rooted in the 18th and 19th centuries.

    The coronation itself is of a different order. It’s a ceremony from deep time, mediaeval Norman at root but with hints of tradition going back further. Even the more modern Zadok the priest doesn’t upset this sense of a ritual stretching back epochs. Watching the crowning there was a feeling of the deep history of the island.

    The military parades are impressive in their own way but on a very different level.
    Excellent post.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,987
    IanB2 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Ah, the North Korean bit!

    Monarchy = Socialism! :lol:

    No state control of the economy = Socialism


    Monarchy is the essence of Toryism
    If god-given monarchy had anything going for it, your Santa-Claus-for-adults would deliver some sunny weather on a day like this.
    Why? It usually rains in Britain
  • DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 28,443
    GIN1138 said:

    Foxy said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Wonder if Harry is already on his way back to LA?

    He is in Court Wednesday, so probably not.
    The rumour was he was going back to LA today for Archie's birthday but who knows?

    Must say I have a lot of sympathy for "H" today. As well as walking into the lions den, on his own, he has had to watch the old bag who, along with his father, caused his late mother so much pain and heartache crowned Queen and will henceforth now have to bow before her whenever they meet. I don't think that's something I could do.

    I hope he can now find some peace and happiness with Meghan and his family.
    Yes, it must be odd for Prince Harry. But please bear in mind that it is little different from any child whose parents have broken up and perhaps remarried. Woe is him but his situation is commonplace for millions.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 52,156
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    Genuine question, why would Putin take note of our parades, no matter how well choreographed they are?
    See his own military parades, demos of military strength matter to power projection
    North Korea has the best military choreography.

    MONARCHY = SOCIALISM!
  • LeonLeon Posts: 56,606
    TimS said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Not really.

    Loving it in our house. We are bouncing along , toasting and cheering.

    It's one hell of a show.
    Overall it seems much less impressive than the Queen's funeral to me. Fine in itself, well-executed, beautiful music but not quite on the same level.

    Glad it all appears to have gone off safely though - all credit to the security services.
    It depends how it moves you. This moves me just as deeply. The historical resonance of it.

    And there are even more troops for this one. So the spectacle is just as strong.
    I’m with the others. The parade has nothing like the same resonance as the coronation service. It’s just much more anachronistic because it’s not timeless: it’s rooted in the 18th and 19th centuries.

    The coronation itself is of a different order. It’s a ceremony from deep time, mediaeval Norman at root but with hints of tradition going back further. Even the more modern Zadok the priest doesn’t upset this sense of a ritual stretching back epochs. Watching the crowning there was a feeling of the deep history of the island.

    The military parades are impressive in their own way but on a very different level.
    Also it happens every year - the Trooping of the colour - or maybe every day - changing the guard to buck house

    A coronation for the first time in 70 years? Wow
  • HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    Genuine question, why would Putin take note of our parades, no matter how well choreographed they are?
    See his own military parades, demos of military strength matter to power projection
    Ours don't project power. We don't have missile launchers trundling past behind the royal carriage. Ours show just how good we are at the pageantry.
  • WhisperingOracleWhisperingOracle Posts: 9,260
    edited May 2023
    Dura_Ace said:

    I assume the flypast will still be on, hard to tell from the TV footage but cloudbase is what 1,000 - 1,500ft?

    Dura Ace may be able to help there, I think, with the view from a cockpit veteran.
    I've only ever done one and that was 1,000' over DC. The military can pretty much sanction anything with the tacit understanding that there will be a ruthless cauldron of blame for the most junior officer involved if anything goes wrong. They would be mental to do it of they didn't have the normal VFR minima for low level flight. 1,000' vertical, 1500m horizontal to cloud and 5km flight visibility.
    What's the visibility today ?
    Also, doing a flypast over Washington D.C. sounds like fun.
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,779
    IanB2 said:

    TOPPING said:

    There was a camera angle from above as a detachment of the Blue and Royals was trit-trotting through which was pretty much exactly like those photos of 1953 or perhaps Churchill's funeral.

    Perhaps it was the rain rendering everything colourless and the navy tunics accentuating the monochrome. It was a just a moment but one of a past age.

    I assume that when the BBC said it was the biggest military procession for seventy years, it was Churchill’s funeral that holds the record?
    ?

    Churchill's funeral was only 58 years ago.

    The Queen's coronation was 70 years ago.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,164
    edited May 2023
    IanB2 said:

    TimS said:

    A

    Carnyx said:

    Dialup said:

    The Met Police.

    Being attacked in the streets? Bike nicked? Can't help mate.

    Placard - to the Tower with you

    I am a monarchist but preventing lawful protests by Republicans is wrong on so many levels. Stupid action by Government enacting the laws and stupid action by the police in enforcing them this way.
    I don't see the PB Wokefinders for Freedom lamenting this. Just wait for the anti-woke protests under a Labour government. Labour have been given absolute carte blanche to deal with them in the same way.
    New Labour had people arrested for holding up, in silence, a placard saying “Remember Tibet”

    Wearing a t-shirt with “Bollocks to Blair” on it would get you stopped by the police along Whitehall.

    The cabinet secretary justified the arrest of an opposition MP on the grounds that the leaks to the said MP had upset the spin doctors lies to the press.

    Labour has always been authoritarian. Not understanding that the LibDems are serious about civil liberties has long confused relations between the two parties.
    It’s the main reason I’m a Lib Dem.
    In my long experience as a councillor, I found it a real mental block when dealing with Labour councillors. So often, if the object of a proposal was of merit they simply couldn’t understand why we were concerned with how it was to be done. And we couldn’t understand why they couldn’t understand that how things are done very often matters just as much as the outcome.
    Example conversation:

    Labour councillors: This project looks really good, let’s get it done!

    LibDem councillors: We agree. Why not consult residents in the area to see what they think?

    Labour: But anyone can see this is a good idea, let’s just go for it!

    LibDem: But if we ask local people what they think, most of them will probably agree with us and will feel more involved in, and more grateful for, the project when we implement it, and the minority that have criticisms might help us find ways to improve the proposal or avoid some pitfall that we haven’t spotted? And if something unexpected happens and it doesn’t work out as we hope, it would be good to have the backing of those affected before we go ahead.

    Lab: Yes, but consulting people will delay things by X months and cost £X, so we should just get it done now. We are the councillors, do we really care what local people think?
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,690
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    Genuine question, why would Putin take note of our parades, no matter how well choreographed they are?
    See his own military parades, demos of military strength matter to power projection
    In case you missed it, his parades tend to be full of big beasts of rockets and tanks. Ours are horses and carriages. Now I really like the parades for their ceremonial and glitz but the idea that anyone opposed to our country looks at these paraes we do and has a moment's pause is laughable.
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,806
    Sandpit said:

    Dura_Ace said:

    I assume the flypast will still be on, hard to tell from the TV footage but cloudbase is what 1,000 - 1,500ft?

    Dura Ace may be able to help there, I think, with the view from a cockpit veteran.
    I've only ever done one and that was 1,000' over DC. The military can pretty much sanction anything with the tacit understanding that there will be a ruthless cauldron of blame for the most junior officer involved if anything goes wrong. They would be mental to do it of they didn't have the normal VFR minima for low level flight. 1,000' vertical, 1500m horizontal to cloud and 5km flight visibility.
    Do the mil use the 500’ rule, that is the law for us civvies?

    Presumably, anything with a single engine needs to remain within gliding range of the river?

    The army helicopters practising over the Blackmore Vale don't - often lower than the downs the other side of the valley.
  • Dura_AceDura_Ace Posts: 13,778

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    What's wrong with power and might?

    It's part of the pageantry. The command of the monarchy. It's reach.

    I think having British guards carrying every flag of the Commonwealth, and the procession being led by the mounties, is a powerful symbol of unity and inclusion that isn't quite as imperial as you think.

    More a family that shares values.
    You've changed your tune.

    https://vf.politicalbetting.com/discussion/comment/4123233#Comment_4123233
  • Dura_AceDura_Ace Posts: 13,778
    Sandpit said:

    Dura_Ace said:

    I assume the flypast will still be on, hard to tell from the TV footage but cloudbase is what 1,000 - 1,500ft?

    Dura Ace may be able to help there, I think, with the view from a cockpit veteran.
    I've only ever done one and that was 1,000' over DC. The military can pretty much sanction anything with the tacit understanding that there will be a ruthless cauldron of blame for the most junior officer involved if anything goes wrong. They would be mental to do it of they didn't have the normal VFR minima for low level flight. 1,000' vertical, 1500m horizontal to cloud and 5km flight visibility.
    Do the mil use the 500’ rule, that is the law for us civvies?

    Presumably, anything with a single engine needs to remain within gliding range of the river?
    It depends on location, aircraft, crew experience, objectives, etc. Generally, pay attention in the brief!
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 18,916

    IanB2 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    What planet are you on? Those military parades of infantry and cavalry are really not going to register one iota with Putin.
    The days when soldiers ran away in terror at the sound of Malc on his bagpipes are over?
    With apols for the repost, it was good to see Malc putting on his finest for the service this morning:

    image
    Why is the bloke in the red kilt wearing Cthulhu on the front of his kilt.
    KCIII likes to style himself as Defender of the Faiths. Can't be picking and choosing these days.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,164
    theakes said:

    I went for petrol during the Coronation Service. The roads were packed, people at the bus stop and the shops all open with a steady flow of folk, people going about their normal lives.
    A totally different picture to the one painted by the media.

    I took the dog for a quick walk during a break in the rain, towards the end of the religious dirge, and there were a lot of other people about.
  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 28,871
    ...
    Dura_Ace said:

    Forgot to say, Crab Air don't have the best track record on this sort of caper. They mid-aired two Phenoms while "practicing" for the RAF 100th anniversary flypast.

    Still better than Iran (and Venezuela) they've both crashed fucking all sorts doing mass fly pasts.

    RAF new recruitment slogan nailed.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,713
    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    Exactly what I was going to post ; the emphasis on huge parades is really a holdover from imperial times, when it was a necessary show to adversaries.

    I think that the future of these ceremonies should be tasteful and grand, with some mystical elements ; but also smaller. If Charles has any sense with his slimming-down plans, this should be included, because it also sends an important message about the role of the monarchy and its awareness of its place in society.
    It works for funerals. It was tremendous for QE2. The coffin on the gun carriage

    But for more positive events - weddings, jubilees and coronations (however serious) somettjg more joyous is needed
    Like @Jonathan said you are a luvvie.

    A right-wing luvvie, to be sure, but still a luvvie.
    Coz I don’t get physically aroused by regiments of men marching fairly pointlessly along a road, albeit with immaculate timing? Whatever

    I’m a royalist. I loved the coronation. I can do without the horsey bits
    Yeah, you're a bit wet and gaylord ponceyboots.
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,690
    edited May 2023
    IanB2 said:

    TOPPING said:

    There was a camera angle from above as a detachment of the Blue and Royals was trit-trotting through which was pretty much exactly like those photos of 1953 or perhaps Churchill's funeral.

    Perhaps it was the rain rendering everything colourless and the navy tunics accentuating the monochrome. It was a just a moment but one of a past age.

    I assume that when the BBC said it was the biggest military procession for seventy years, it was Churchill’s funeral that holds the record?
    Churchill's funral ppparently involved around 2,500 military personnel. This one was apparently 6,000.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,036
    The Met Police have obviously been practicing filling the Mall with people. Looks very well organised.
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,806
    edited May 2023
    "Flypast scaled down due to weather - MoD
    We've just received some breaking news from the Ministry of Defence in the last few moments.

    It relates to the flypast which is still expected to take place in 30 minutes or so.

    A statement says: "Due to unsuitable weather conditions, the Coronation flypast will now be formed of helicopters and the Royal Air Force aerobatic team The Red Arrows."

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-65474712
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,164

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    Genuine question, why would Putin take note of our parades, no matter how well choreographed they are?
    See his own military parades, demos of military strength matter to power projection
    In case you missed it, his parades tend to be full of big beasts of rockets and tanks. Ours are horses and carriages. Now I really like the parades for their ceremonial and glitz but the idea that anyone opposed to our country looks at these paraes we do and has a moment's pause is laughable.
    The problem we have is that HY has sent all our tanks up to the Scottish border.

    A mistake surely on a par with the Germans not sending their panzer divisions to Normandy?
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,036
    London City airport, cloudbase 1,300’
    https://metar-taf.com/EGLC

    Heathrow is IMC, cloudbase 800’
    https://metar-taf.com/EGLL

    Could be touch-and-go if they need 1,000’
  • EabhalEabhal Posts: 8,955

    Sandpit said:

    Dura_Ace said:

    I assume the flypast will still be on, hard to tell from the TV footage but cloudbase is what 1,000 - 1,500ft?

    Dura Ace may be able to help there, I think, with the view from a cockpit veteran.
    I've only ever done one and that was 1,000' over DC. The military can pretty much sanction anything with the tacit understanding that there will be a ruthless cauldron of blame for the most junior officer involved if anything goes wrong. They would be mental to do it of they didn't have the normal VFR minima for low level flight. 1,000' vertical, 1500m horizontal to cloud and 5km flight visibility.
    Do the mil use the 500’ rule, that is the law for us civvies?

    Presumably, anything with a single engine needs to remain within gliding range of the river?

    The army helicopters practising over the Blackmore Vale don't - often lower than the downs the other side of the valley.
    Once had a Puma buzz past in dense fog, gale force winds half way up a Corbett near Applecross. Genuinely impressed by the bravery/lunacy - was unbelievably low.
  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 42,168

    So, I think I've found the answer to the question I posed a few days ago. Tories on here don't seem to like the current Conservative party very much, and certainly not that keen on the current leadership, so I asked: Who do you want?

    Clearly, she's been found. Mordaunt.

    The moment she says JK Rowling may have a point over trans issues, you’ll know Mordaunt is on it like a car bonnet.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,713
    Dura_Ace said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    What's wrong with power and might?

    It's part of the pageantry. The command of the monarchy. It's reach.

    I think having British guards carrying every flag of the Commonwealth, and the procession being led by the mounties, is a powerful symbol of unity and inclusion that isn't quite as imperial as you think.

    More a family that shares values.
    You've changed your tune.

    https://vf.politicalbetting.com/discussion/comment/4123233#Comment_4123233
    Were they carrying all the flags of the Commonwealth then?

    I have no problem with imperial scenes either which way but you seem peculiarly obsessed by what others say and weirdly quick to research what they've said /unsaid in the past, which I have no idea how to do.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,164
    So now we are reduced to Deborah Meaden and Anton du Beke opining on the day’s happenings
  • kinabalukinabalu Posts: 42,679

    Dialup said:

    I don't believe the Monarchy is any more Tory than Labour.

    Labour has been in government many times, never once tried to change or touch the monarchy. Indeed Blair did a lot to save it after Diana.

    Wilson was the QEII's favourite PM, closely followed by Callaghan, who said going to see her was like "seeking a solving of your problems by a psychiatrist." The Queen and Thatcher, famously, couldn't stand each other.

    From a liberal point of view, in its best moments the British monarchy can represent some of the more enlightened noblesse oblige and consensus spirit of the wartime and postwar era. Certainly preferable to aggressive populist conservatism, for me, and I suspect many others.
    Very little in this world is not preferable to aggressive populist conservatism imo.
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 18,916
    IanB2 said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    Genuine question, why would Putin take note of our parades, no matter how well choreographed they are?
    See his own military parades, demos of military strength matter to power projection
    In case you missed it, his parades tend to be full of big beasts of rockets and tanks. Ours are horses and carriages. Now I really like the parades for their ceremonial and glitz but the idea that anyone opposed to our country looks at these paraes we do and has a moment's pause is laughable.
    The problem we have is that HY has sent all our tanks up to the Scottish border.

    A mistake surely on a par with the Germans not sending their panzer divisions to Normandy?
    I thought our tanks were heading towards the Azov Sea coast?
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,713

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    Genuine question, why would Putin take note of our parades, no matter how well choreographed they are?
    See his own military parades, demos of military strength matter to power projection
    North Korea has the best military choreography.

    MONARCHY = SOCIALISM!
    This argument was boring the first of the thousand times you posted it Sunil.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,164

    IanB2 said:

    TOPPING said:

    There was a camera angle from above as a detachment of the Blue and Royals was trit-trotting through which was pretty much exactly like those photos of 1953 or perhaps Churchill's funeral.

    Perhaps it was the rain rendering everything colourless and the navy tunics accentuating the monochrome. It was a just a moment but one of a past age.

    I assume that when the BBC said it was the biggest military procession for seventy years, it was Churchill’s funeral that holds the record?
    Churchill's funral ppparently involved around 2,500 military personnel. This one was apparently 6,000.
    So what happened seventy years ago?
  • numbertwelvenumbertwelve Posts: 6,927
    IanB2 said:

    So now we are reduced to Deborah Meaden and Anton du Beke opining on the day’s happenings

    The BBC always do this. I don’t know why they always think we need the opinions of minor celebrities.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,164

    "Flypast scaled down due to weather - MoD
    We've just received some breaking news from the Ministry of Defence in the last few moments.

    It relates to the flypast which is still expected to take place in 30 minutes or so.

    A statement says: "Due to unsuitable weather conditions, the Coronation flypast will now be formed of helicopters and the Royal Air Force aerobatic team The Red Arrows."

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-65474712

    As I was saying…
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,713

    theakes said:

    I went for petrol during the Coronation Service. The roads were packed, people at the bus stop and the shops all open with a steady flow of folk, people going about their normal lives.
    A totally different picture to the one painted by the media.

    Yawn.
    Go easy on them. The miserable self-centred party-poopers need something to cleave to.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,045
    IanB2 said:

    IanB2 said:

    TOPPING said:

    There was a camera angle from above as a detachment of the Blue and Royals was trit-trotting through which was pretty much exactly like those photos of 1953 or perhaps Churchill's funeral.

    Perhaps it was the rain rendering everything colourless and the navy tunics accentuating the monochrome. It was a just a moment but one of a past age.

    I assume that when the BBC said it was the biggest military procession for seventy years, it was Churchill’s funeral that holds the record?
    Churchill's funral ppparently involved around 2,500 military personnel. This one was apparently 6,000.
    So what happened seventy years ago?
    Elizabeth’s coronation?
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 52,156

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    Genuine question, why would Putin take note of our parades, no matter how well choreographed they are?
    See his own military parades, demos of military strength matter to power projection
    North Korea has the best military choreography.

    MONARCHY = SOCIALISM!
    This argument was boring the first of the thousand times you posted it Sunil.
    Yeah, these military parades are fucking boring, aren't they?
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 43,049

    IanB2 said:

    TOPPING said:

    There was a camera angle from above as a detachment of the Blue and Royals was trit-trotting through which was pretty much exactly like those photos of 1953 or perhaps Churchill's funeral.

    Perhaps it was the rain rendering everything colourless and the navy tunics accentuating the monochrome. It was a just a moment but one of a past age.

    I assume that when the BBC said it was the biggest military procession for seventy years, it was Churchill’s funeral that holds the record?
    Churchill's funral ppparently involved around 2,500 military personnel. This one was apparently 6,000.
    7,000.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,036

    So, I think I've found the answer to the question I posed a few days ago. Tories on here don't seem to like the current Conservative party very much, and certainly not that keen on the current leadership, so I asked: Who do you want?

    Clearly, she's been found. Mordaunt.

    The moment she says JK Rowling may have a point over trans issues, you’ll know Mordaunt is on it like a car bonnet.
    If Penny hadn’t got caught up with Stonewall, she could have been PM for the past eight months.
  • StillWatersStillWaters Posts: 8,476

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight
    Genuine question, why would Putin take note of our parades, no matter how well choreographed they are?
    Cos that’s one of the things that has always been important to Russian Tzars Presidents
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,164

    So, I think I've found the answer to the question I posed a few days ago. Tories on here don't seem to like the current Conservative party very much, and certainly not that keen on the current leadership, so I asked: Who do you want?

    Clearly, she's been found. Mordaunt.

    The moment she says JK Rowling may have a point over trans issues, you’ll know Mordaunt is on it like a car bonnet.
    Had the Tories gambled on Mordaunt, things might have panned out quite differently.

    Now, they won’t be in power again until our HY is retired.
  • EabhalEabhal Posts: 8,955

    IanB2 said:

    So now we are reduced to Deborah Meaden and Anton du Beke opining on the day’s happenings

    The BBC always do this. I don’t know why they always think we need the opinions of minor celebrities.
    I want historians instead, competing to come up with the most obscure/bizarre fact about the coronation.

    I think Leon et al are right - the service itself was fascinating but all the stuff afterwards is diluting its power.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 52,156

    Dura_Ace said:

    Leon said:

    Jonathan said:

    Leon said:

    I love an ancient, mystical British ritual dating back to 7,000BC but I just can’t be arsed with military parades. In the drizzle. Yawn

    I know it’s all very impressively choreographed but Meh

    I know what you mean, unlike the ancient rituals the military parade is strangely anachronistic.
    Yes, it’s all about British imperial might, which is fairly laughable now. The French version on bastille day is no better. It’s vulgar, sad and bombastic

    That said I find all parades pretty boring, anywhere in the world - unless they are bacchanals like mayday in padstow or Jouverr in Trini carnival
    What's wrong with power and might?

    It's part of the pageantry. The command of the monarchy. It's reach.

    I think having British guards carrying every flag of the Commonwealth, and the procession being led by the mounties, is a powerful symbol of unity and inclusion that isn't quite as imperial as you think.

    More a family that shares values.
    You've changed your tune.

    https://vf.politicalbetting.com/discussion/comment/4123233#Comment_4123233
    Were they carrying all the flags of the Commonwealth then?
    A majority of whom are republics...
  • StillWatersStillWaters Posts: 8,476
    GIN1138 said:

    Foxy said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Wonder if Harry is already on his way back to LA?

    He is in Court Wednesday, so probably not.
    The rumour was he was going back to LA today for Archie's birthday but who knows?

    Must say I have a lot of sympathy for "H" today. As well as walking into the lions den, on his own, he has had to watch the old bag who, along with his father, caused his late mother so much pain and heartache crowned Queen and will henceforth now have to bow before her whenever they meet. I don't think that's something I could do.

    I hope he can now find some peace and happiness with Meghan and his family.
    Why so much bitterness and hatred for someone you have never met.

    Divorces happen. Marriages break down. I am glad that the King has found love again and has a supporter and helpmate.
  • Dura_AceDura_Ace Posts: 13,778

    "Flypast scaled down due to weather - MoD
    We've just received some breaking news from the Ministry of Defence in the last few moments.

    It relates to the flypast which is still expected to take place in 30 minutes or so.

    A statement says: "Due to unsuitable weather conditions, the Coronation flypast will now be formed of helicopters and the Royal Air Force aerobatic team The Red Arrows."

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-65474712

    VFR minima are less for RW below 140kts. Red Arrows will do it no matter what in desperate search for relevance and redemption following the drink soaked shenanigans of the last year.
  • VerulamiusVerulamius Posts: 1,550

    DavidL said:

    Lordy, could you be more careful: "potentially" running an "avoidance" scheme. Is running avoidance schemes not what accountants do and isn't it perfectly legal?

    Thin gruel for those of us who have so far been enjoying this luxurious feast put on by the SNP for general amusement. Must do better.
    Dan Neidle’s version pulls fewer punches: https://www.taxpolicy.org.uk/2023/05/06/schoolfees/
    It’s also totally unnecessary.

    Much simpler:

    - issue non voting B shares to the children
    - Differential dividend rights that can be declared by the board
    - Live 7 years to take those shares out of the estate for inheritance tax purposes

    The tax saving basically arises from moving from a 39% tax rate to using the personal allowance and dividend allowance for the kids (about £14k) and then paying a lower rate of tax on the balance

    That is likely to fall foul of Chapter 5 Part 5 ITTOIA 2005 (settlements regime).
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 49,147
    IanB2 said:

    theakes said:

    I went for petrol during the Coronation Service. The roads were packed, people at the bus stop and the shops all open with a steady flow of folk, people going about their normal lives.
    A totally different picture to the one painted by the media.

    I took the dog for a quick walk during a break in the rain, towards the end of the religious dirge, and there were a lot of other people about.
    I popped to the shop for some cooking ingredients mid coronation. Not the only one there.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,164
    edited May 2023
    Eabhal said:

    IanB2 said:

    So now we are reduced to Deborah Meaden and Anton du Beke opining on the day’s happenings

    The BBC always do this. I don’t know why they always think we need the opinions of minor celebrities.
    I want historians instead, competing to come up with the most obscure/bizarre fact about the coronation.

    I think Leon et al are right - the service itself was fascinating but all the stuff afterwards is diluting its power.
    PB rule number one: Leon is never right.

    Or, at least not until after the event.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 52,156

    GIN1138 said:

    Foxy said:

    GIN1138 said:

    Wonder if Harry is already on his way back to LA?

    He is in Court Wednesday, so probably not.
    The rumour was he was going back to LA today for Archie's birthday but who knows?

    Must say I have a lot of sympathy for "H" today. As well as walking into the lions den, on his own, he has had to watch the old bag who, along with his father, caused his late mother so much pain and heartache crowned Queen and will henceforth now have to bow before her whenever they meet. I don't think that's something I could do.

    I hope he can now find some peace and happiness with Meghan and his family.
    Why so much bitterness and hatred for someone you have never met.

    Divorces happen. Marriages break down. I am glad that the King has found love again and has a supporter and helpmate.
    The rain gods weren't happy! :lol:
  • pigeonpigeon Posts: 4,840

    IanB2 said:

    So now we are reduced to Deborah Meaden and Anton du Beke opining on the day’s happenings

    The BBC always do this. I don’t know why they always think we need the opinions of minor celebrities.
    They all do this. They need waffle to fill in the gaps when there's nothing happening.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,164
    edited May 2023
    Dura_Ace said:

    "Flypast scaled down due to weather - MoD
    We've just received some breaking news from the Ministry of Defence in the last few moments.

    It relates to the flypast which is still expected to take place in 30 minutes or so.

    A statement says: "Due to unsuitable weather conditions, the Coronation flypast will now be formed of helicopters and the Royal Air Force aerobatic team The Red Arrows."

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-65474712

    VFR minima are less for RW below 140kts. Red Arrows will do it no matter what in desperate search for relevance and redemption following the drink soaked shenanigans of the last year.
    Yet they’ve already cancelled their planned follow on flypast over Bournemouth
  • numbertwelvenumbertwelve Posts: 6,927
    We are so lucky we got Penny as Chief Sword Holder rather than JRM.
  • DialupDialup Posts: 561
    Sadiq Khan apparently is "desperately beatable".

    So beatable the Tories had to change the electoral system.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,164

    We are so lucky we got Penny as Chief Sword Holder rather than JRM.

    She can keep it erect for much longer than the chief wimp could have done.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,981
    Agree with Paddy


  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 50,164
    pigeon said:

    IanB2 said:

    So now we are reduced to Deborah Meaden and Anton du Beke opining on the day’s happenings

    The BBC always do this. I don’t know why they always think we need the opinions of minor celebrities.
    They all do this. They need waffle to fill in the gaps when there's nothing happening.
    It’s been four hours now and the only real thing that has happened is the crown landing on Charlie Three’s bonce.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 52,303
    The Carolean aesthetic is off to a good start.

    image
  • Stark_DawningStark_Dawning Posts: 9,714
    How did the public swearing of the oath go? (This was going to bring about the end of the monarchy a few days ago.)
  • DialupDialup Posts: 561
    Thought we might get something like Johnny English where somebody dropped from the ceiling and was crowned by mistake. What a shame
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 51,177
    Chris said:

    A

    Carnyx said:

    Dialup said:

    The Met Police.

    Being attacked in the streets? Bike nicked? Can't help mate.

    Placard - to the Tower with you

    I am a monarchist but preventing lawful protests by Republicans is wrong on so many levels. Stupid action by Government enacting the laws and stupid action by the police in enforcing them this way.
    I don't see the PB Wokefinders for Freedom lamenting this. Just wait for the anti-woke protests under a Labour government. Labour have been given absolute carte blanche to deal with them in the same way.
    New Labour had people arrested for holding up, in silence, a placard saying “Remember Tibet” ...
    Yes, of course that makes it OK. How could anyone have doubted it?
    You're missing the point. The precedents are already there.

    Incidentally, the bizarre, and often illegal, infiltration tactics used at that time against harmless protest groups (such as the tree climbing swampy types) are still going through the courts.
  • .
    IanB2 said:

    pigeon said:

    IanB2 said:

    So now we are reduced to Deborah Meaden and Anton du Beke opining on the day’s happenings

    The BBC always do this. I don’t know why they always think we need the opinions of minor celebrities.
    They all do this. They need waffle to fill in the gaps when there's nothing happening.
    It’s been four hours now and the only real thing that has happened is the crown landing on Charlie Three’s bonce.
    And thousands of male Tories have thrashed off to Mordaunt holding a sword. Funny old day.
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 49,147
    Phil said:

    Sandpit said:

    So, I think I've found the answer to the question I posed a few days ago. Tories on here don't seem to like the current Conservative party very much, and certainly not that keen on the current leadership, so I asked: Who do you want?

    Clearly, she's been found. Mordaunt.

    The moment she says JK Rowling may have a point over trans issues, you’ll know Mordaunt is on it like a car bonnet.
    If Penny hadn’t got caught up with Stonewall, she could have been PM for the past eight months.
    If the Tory membership ditched their best candidate over this issue perhaps that says more about them than anything else: obsessed with culture war issues at the expense of real world problems does absolutely sum up the current state of the Conservatives tbh.
    Penny lost my respect when she changed her tune and lied about her past views. She should have stuck to her guns.

  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,690
    It is a very Slavic look. I wonder if that was intentional as well.
  • ThomasNasheThomasNashe Posts: 5,331

    IanB2 said:

    So now we are reduced to Deborah Meaden and Anton du Beke opining on the day’s happenings

    The BBC always do this. I don’t know why they always think we need the opinions of minor celebrities.
    David Olusoga was on before them, and was genuinely interesting.
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 18,916
    Phil said:

    Sandpit said:

    So, I think I've found the answer to the question I posed a few days ago. Tories on here don't seem to like the current Conservative party very much, and certainly not that keen on the current leadership, so I asked: Who do you want?

    Clearly, she's been found. Mordaunt.

    The moment she says JK Rowling may have a point over trans issues, you’ll know Mordaunt is on it like a car bonnet.
    If Penny hadn’t got caught up with Stonewall, she could have been PM for the past eight months.
    If the Tory membership ditched their best candidate over this issue perhaps that says more about them than anything else: obsessed with culture war issues at the expense of real world problems does absolutely sum up the current state of the Conservatives tbh.
    Leadership in politics is about persuading people and winning their support.

    Penny Mordaunt's failure to win an election within her own party doesn't scream excellence in political leadership to me, particularly when the other leading candidates were Liz Truss and a teetotaler who comes across as an overeager teenager. Same argument as Rory Stewart.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 52,156

    .

    IanB2 said:

    pigeon said:

    IanB2 said:

    So now we are reduced to Deborah Meaden and Anton du Beke opining on the day’s happenings

    The BBC always do this. I don’t know why they always think we need the opinions of minor celebrities.
    They all do this. They need waffle to fill in the gaps when there's nothing happening.
    It’s been four hours now and the only real thing that has happened is the crown landing on Charlie Three’s bonce.
    And thousands of male Tories have thrashed off to Mordaunt holding a sword. Funny old day.
    And not just the Tories :blush:
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 51,177
    pm215 said:

    HYUFD said:


    I expect Putin will take more notice on the military parades we and the French put on than the great ceremony we just witnessed however.

    Just coming back from Whitehall now in the drizzle, we caught a glimpse of the new King and Queen in their coach on the way back. Will watch the full ceremony on iplayer tonight

    Genuine question, why would Putin take note of our parades, no matter how well choreographed they are?
    Not enough missiles and tanks for Russian tastes, I imagine.
    The Russian army is back to.the T-55s now. Not enough T-34 left to do much with, so they will be pretty interested in managing horses, soon.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 51,177
    IanB2 said:

    TimS said:

    A

    Carnyx said:

    Dialup said:

    The Met Police.

    Being attacked in the streets? Bike nicked? Can't help mate.

    Placard - to the Tower with you

    I am a monarchist but preventing lawful protests by Republicans is wrong on so many levels. Stupid action by Government enacting the laws and stupid action by the police in enforcing them this way.
    I don't see the PB Wokefinders for Freedom lamenting this. Just wait for the anti-woke protests under a Labour government. Labour have been given absolute carte blanche to deal with them in the same way.
    New Labour had people arrested for holding up, in silence, a placard saying “Remember Tibet”

    Wearing a t-shirt with “Bollocks to Blair” on it would get you stopped by the police along Whitehall.

    The cabinet secretary justified the arrest of an opposition MP on the grounds that the leaks to the said MP had upset the spin doctors lies to the press.

    Labour has always been authoritarian. Not understanding that the LibDems are serious about civil liberties has long confused relations between the two parties.
    It’s the main reason I’m a Lib Dem.
    In my long experience as a councillor, I found it a real mental block when dealing with Labour councillors. So often, if the object of a proposal was of merit they simply couldn’t understand why we were concerned with how it was to be done. And we couldn’t understand why they couldn’t understand that how things are done very often matters just as much as the outcome.
    The ends do not justify the means. The means, however, illuminate the morality of the ends.
  • DialupDialup Posts: 561

    .

    IanB2 said:

    pigeon said:

    IanB2 said:

    So now we are reduced to Deborah Meaden and Anton du Beke opining on the day’s happenings

    The BBC always do this. I don’t know why they always think we need the opinions of minor celebrities.
    They all do this. They need waffle to fill in the gaps when there's nothing happening.
    It’s been four hours now and the only real thing that has happened is the crown landing on Charlie Three’s bonce.
    And thousands of male Tories have thrashed off to Mordaunt holding a sword. Funny old day.
    And not just the Tories :blush:
    You still voting Starmer?
  • DialupDialup Posts: 561
    I love how you were prime minister for such a short time that even you feel the need to prove you have an invite

    https://twitter.com/JimMFelton/status/1654838817059160184
  • LeonLeon Posts: 56,606
    IanB2 said:

    So now we are reduced to Deborah Meaden and Anton du Beke opining on the day’s happenings

    If you so obviously loathe it and find it laughable - why the fucking fucketty fuck are you watching a single minute of coverage?!

    People like you are plastic republicans. You secretly love royalty, but you are too socially insecure to admit this because you associate monarchism with lower class people from Wolverhampton wearing Union Jack hats on the Mall
  • LeonLeon Posts: 56,606

    The Carolean aesthetic is off to a good start.

    image

    Ooooooofff
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,036

    Chris said:

    A

    Carnyx said:

    Dialup said:

    The Met Police.

    Being attacked in the streets? Bike nicked? Can't help mate.

    Placard - to the Tower with you

    I am a monarchist but preventing lawful protests by Republicans is wrong on so many levels. Stupid action by Government enacting the laws and stupid action by the police in enforcing them this way.
    I don't see the PB Wokefinders for Freedom lamenting this. Just wait for the anti-woke protests under a Labour government. Labour have been given absolute carte blanche to deal with them in the same way.
    New Labour had people arrested for holding up, in silence, a placard saying “Remember Tibet” ...
    Yes, of course that makes it OK. How could anyone have doubted it?
    You're missing the point. The precedents are already there.

    Incidentally, the bizarre, and often illegal, infiltration tactics used at that time against harmless protest groups (such as the tree climbing swampy types) are still going through the courts.
    Must have been a pretty horrible day for the security services and the police, to be honest. Thankfully, everything appears so far to have passed off peacefully.

    It’s difficult to know where to draw the line with protestors, given the number of major events that have been seriously disrupted in the past year. People should have been able to wave banners protesting the King or the monarchy.

    King and Queen now on the balcony!
  • WhisperingOracleWhisperingOracle Posts: 9,260
    edited May 2023
    In other random twitter news, someone has performed a coronation ceremony for their dog, meaning that it is now officially king of the U.K..

    https://twitter.com/buitengebieden/status/1654821347812585473
  • StillWatersStillWaters Posts: 8,476
    Chris said:

    IanB2 said:

    TOPPING said:

    There was a camera angle from above as a detachment of the Blue and Royals was trit-trotting through which was pretty much exactly like those photos of 1953 or perhaps Churchill's funeral.

    Perhaps it was the rain rendering everything colourless and the navy tunics accentuating the monochrome. It was a just a moment but one of a past age.

    I assume that when the BBC said it was the biggest military procession for seventy years, it was Churchill’s funeral that holds the record?
    ?

    Churchill's funeral was only 58 years ago.

    The Queen's coronation was 70 years ago.
    Isn’t that just saying that Churchill’s funeral was the largest *since* the last coronation?
This discussion has been closed.