The cabinet are revolting as they prepare to get their Johnson out. – politicalbetting.com
Some in No 10 braced for further ministerial resignations. Tory allies of the PM feeling inevitability, this could be the end. Many not as bullish as they have been at previous crisis moments.
only note of caution is that when this happened to Gordon Brown he kept replacing ministers who resigned with new, less good ministers, and the ship - holed below the waterline - kept on going https://twitter.com/PickardJE/status/1544378746312048641
Reading the letters again, they are interestingly different.
Javid opens by reminding Boris he was asked back into Cabinet, then spends 3 paragraphs on self congratulatory NHS wank. Then there is one long paragraph summed up by the idea they should be competent even if not popular. Followed by thanking Boris for seeing of Corbyn, and laughable claim to have been a friend to Boris. He doesn't actually talk directly about resigning until the 4th paragraph.
Sunak by contast opens with his resignation. He then plays the martyr a bit about it being a difficult time to stand down, probably to jsutify why he did nothing before now. One paragraph about lack of competence with more martyr talk about it being his last job perhaps, then overwrought protestation that he had been loyal boss. Interestingly he admits to disagreeing privately on things he defended publicly, probably a signal of his intention to go in a new direction, which he builds on in the next paragraph.
only note of caution is that when this happened to Gordon Brown he kept replacing ministers who resigned with new, less good ministers, and the ship - holed below the waterline - kept on going https://twitter.com/PickardJE/status/1544378746312048641
So did May - she really ran out of options by the end. Although she also started out with Boris...
Reading the letters again, they are interestingly different.
Javid opens by reminding Boris he was asked back into Cabinet, then spends 3 paragraphs on self congratulatory NHS wank. Then there is one long paragraph summed up by the idea they should be competent even if not popular. Followed by thanking Boris for seeing of Corbyn, and laughable claim to have been a friend to Boris. He doesn't actually talk directly about resigning until the 4th paragraph.
Sunak by contast opens with his resignation. He then plays the martyr a bit about it being a difficult time to stand down, probably to jsutify why he did nothing before now. One paragraph about lack of competence with more martyr talk about it being his last job perhaps, then overwrought protestation that he had been loyal boss. Interestingly he admits to disagreeing privately on things he defended publicly, probably a signal of his intention to go in a new direction, which he builds on in the next paragraph.
Sunak's looks more of a leadership pitch to me.
I thought Sunak's was a bit Me Me whereas Javid's had a bit more gravitas.
So the Foreign Secretary, the Home Secretary, the Defence Secretary, the Deputy PM, the Business Secretary and now the Education Secretary have now all confirmed their loyalty to the PM.
So far from being co ordinated across Cabinet it seems Sunak and Javid were outliers. To survive Johnson will now shift to rally the right and the ERG behind him, he will say this is a coup by Remainers to row back from Brexit and those on the left of the party who want to raise taxes and only he can stop them!
I think Truss has killed off her chances this evening. Tory MPs aren’t going to give one of the Boris bunker holdouts a place in the final two.
Sajid has timed his sprint well. Puts him in contention. Hunt is irrelevant. Mordaunt the Major/Starmer style compromise candidate. Rishi too little too late but could be the winner’s CoE.
Out of that lot the most likely to repair our relations and reputation abroad is probably Javid.
Looks like the end. What the hell took them so long? It's not as though we've learnt anything about Boris this week that we didn't know last month, or last year, or in 2019 when he was chosen as leader.
Still, it's progress. Getting rid of him is the necessary first stage - but only the first stage - of putting things right.
Yes, back to opposition, probably for at least a decade if not more.
Last time the Tories toppled an election winning PM, Thatcher in 1990, they lost 3 out of 4 of the following general elections and it took them until Boris in 2019 to win a big majority again
Johnson is not Thatcher.
He's a corrupt twat who has no compunction about burning the Conservative Party to the ground, in order to cling to office a few days longer.
He has no loyalty to the Conservative Party, and they should have none to him.
This is the real problem for the party now imho. Thatcher DID step aside and that meant John Major could go on to win, famously, in 1992 with the largest vote by any party in British history. I mention that last bit for HY's benefit.
So does Johnson drag down the party now? Or give them at least a fighting chance at the next GE?
Major also then led the Tories to their worst landslide defeat since 1832 in 1997 however and the bitterness of Thatcher's toppling helped wreck his government and keep the Tories in opposition for a decade
Large numbers of Conservatives admired Thatcher. Few people admired Major, but many liked him.
Johnson is neither admired, nor liked, by many Conservatives, now. The views of non-Conservatives can easily be guessed. No one will be bitter over his departure. He is an embarrassment to his MP's.
Some of the redwallers still voting Tory are only doing so because Johnson is leader however.
All that shows is sadly, large swathes of the British electorate need educating on current affairs
HYUFD may be right that some redwallers are only voting Tory because Boris is leader. But he has always been weirdly pessimistic about anyone else even having a chance of winning them over.
only note of caution is that when this happened to Gordon Brown he kept replacing ministers who resigned with new, less good ministers, and the ship - holed below the waterline - kept on going https://twitter.com/PickardJE/status/1544378746312048641
Does anyone still remember people like Hazel Blears and James Purnell?
So the Foreign Secretary, the Home Secretary, the Defence Secretary, the Deputy PM, the Business Secretary and now the Education Secretary have now all confirmed their loyalty to the PM.
So far from being co ordinated across Cabinet it seems Sunak and Javid were outliers. To survive Johnson will now shift to rally the right and the ERG behind him, he will say this is a coup by Remainers to row back from Brexit and those on the left of the party who want to raise taxes and only he can stop them!
It doesn't worry you that the two clearly most competent ministers have gone?
There is only Wallace left who can be considered to have ability beyond one cabinet.
Looks like the end. What the hell took them so long? It's not as though we've learnt anything about Boris this week that we didn't know last month, or last year, or in 2019 when he was chosen as leader.
Still, it's progress. Getting rid of him is the necessary first stage - but only the first stage - of putting things right.
Yes, back to opposition, probably for at least a decade if not more.
Last time the Tories toppled an election winning PM, Thatcher in 1990, they lost 3 out of 4 of the following general elections and it took them until Boris in 2019 to win a big majority again
Oh, I think it's very likely that the Conservatives will be very, very unpopular for a long time. But you're putting the blame in the wrong place. It's Boris who has wrecked the party, and it's going to take a very long time for it to be forgotten. As I wrote on the day he became leader:
The party is no longer recognisable as the pragmatic, business-friendly, economically-sound, reality-based party of government which I have supported for decades. It will justifiably get the electoral blame for the consequences of the disastrous course it has chosen, and will probably never be forgiven by younger voters.
The Tory Party is not just the political wing of the CBI and the City of London. It also has to reach working class and lower middle class voters to win, Thatcher managed to do so as did Boris
Apart from everything else, Boris is a clear and present danger to the Union. He is total anti-catnip to Scots, and the SNP use him as a recruiting tool, and they mentioned him by name when announcing "Sindyref" 2. One person who will be really praying he survives is Sturgeon
Surely you can see this? You're a unionist
Boris can just refuse an indyref2 still and nothing the SNP can do to change Scotland's status in the union without UK government consent. Legally and constitutionally therefore it does not matter how unpopular the PM is in Scotland if they have a majority at Westminster to refuse indyref2.
Only if they grant an indyref2 does the UK PM's popularity matter in Scotland
FPT: here's a nice brazil nut.
BTW you do realise there are Tory constituencies in Scotland, with actual live Tory MPs in them?
Michael Gove is key, I think. Maybe Boris can survive if he can persuade him to become CoE, but Gove hasn't been conspicuous with his support recently.
Wallace is right to stay as Her Majesty's defence minister, given the Ukraine situation. We really can't afford any discontinuity there.
So the Foreign Secretary, the Home Secretary, the Defence Secretary, the Deputy PM, the Business Secretary and now the Education Secretary have now all confirmed their loyalty to the PM.
So far from being co ordinated across Cabinet it seems Sunak and Javid were outliers. To survive Johnson will now shift to rally the right and the ERG behind him, he will say this is a coup by Remainers to row back from Brexit and those on the left of the party who want to raise taxes and only he can stop them!
Sunak was not a remainer - do you honestly believe his resignation could be termed a coup by remainers?
Andrew Bridgen has just said that the Government has more vacancies than an out of season seaside boarding house! He could have said any soft fruits farm in the UK without any EU labour.
Michael Gove is key, I think. Maybe Boris can survive if he can persuade him to become CoE, but Gove hasn't been conspicuous with his support recently.
Wallace is right to stay as Her Majesty's defence minister, given the Ukraine situation. We really can't afford any discontinuity there.
only note of caution is that when this happened to Gordon Brown he kept replacing ministers who resigned with new, less good ministers, and the ship - holed below the waterline - kept on going https://twitter.com/PickardJE/status/1544378746312048641
Does anyone still remember people like Hazel Blears and James Purnell?
Looks like the end. What the hell took them so long? It's not as though we've learnt anything about Boris this week that we didn't know last month, or last year, or in 2019 when he was chosen as leader.
Still, it's progress. Getting rid of him is the necessary first stage - but only the first stage - of putting things right.
Yes, back to opposition, probably for at least a decade if not more.
Last time the Tories toppled an election winning PM, Thatcher in 1990, they lost 3 out of 4 of the following general elections and it took them until Boris in 2019 to win a big majority again
Oh, I think it's very likely that the Conservatives will be very, very unpopular for a long time. But you're putting the blame in the wrong place. It's Boris who has wrecked the party, and it's going to take a very long time for it to be forgotten. As I wrote on the day he became leader:
The party is no longer recognisable as the pragmatic, business-friendly, economically-sound, reality-based party of government which I have supported for decades. It will justifiably get the electoral blame for the consequences of the disastrous course it has chosen, and will probably never be forgiven by younger voters.
The Tory Party is not just the political wing of the CBI and the City of London. It also has to reach working class and lower middle class voters to win, Thatcher managed to do so as did Boris
Apart from everything else, Boris is a clear and present danger to the Union. He is total anti-catnip to Scots, and the SNP use him as a recruiting tool, and they mentioned him by name when announcing "Sindyref" 2. One person who will be really praying he survives is Sturgeon
Surely you can see this? You're a unionist
Boris can just refuse an indyref2 still and nothing the SNP can do to change Scotland's status in the union without UK government consent. Legally and constitutionally therefore it does not matter how unpopular the PM is in Scotland if they have a majority at Westminster to refuse indyref2.
Only if they grant an indyref2 does the UK PM's popularity matter in Scotland
FPT: here's a nice brazil nut.
BTW you do realise there are Tory constituencies in Scotland, with actual live Tory MPs in them?
Even if the Tories won 0 seats in Scotland in 2019 they would still have had a majority of 68
So the Foreign Secretary, the Home Secretary, the Defence Secretary, the Deputy PM, the Business Secretary and now the Education Secretary have now all confirmed their loyalty to the PM.
So far from being co ordinated across Cabinet it seems Sunak and Javid were outliers. To survive Johnson will now shift to rally the right and the ERG behind him, he will say this is a coup by Remainers to row back from Brexit and those on the left of the party who want to raise taxes and only he can stop them!
Andrew Bridgen has just said even arch former Johnson loyalists on the backbenchers want him gone and he will be by the summer recess
I was going to say what about if the Tories do even worse if Boris goes, which you are predicting, but he's safe even then.
That said, for a man who pretends to constitutionalism, he knows damn well that PMs do not get a personal mandate under our system - he has talked such talk before, and far from being a conservative he appears to be an extreme radical, evne revolutionary, in his perception of the British system.
If Boris goes and Wallace gets to the final 2 he would beat all opponents with the membership, including Mordaunt, based on yesterday's Conhome surveys
So the Foreign Secretary, the Home Secretary, the Defence Secretary, the Deputy PM, the Business Secretary and now the Education Secretary have now all confirmed their loyalty to the PM.
So far from being co ordinated across Cabinet it seems Sunak and Javid were outliers. To survive Johnson will now shift to rally the right and the ERG behind him, he will say this is a coup by Remainers to row back from Brexit and those on the left of the party who want to raise taxes and only he can stop them!
Sunak was not a remainer - do you honestly believe his resignation could be termed a coup by remainers?
Truth doesn’t matter. It can be be manipulated as and when required.
Loyalty is the only thing that matters.
The bastards are running the show. They’re destroying their party, and the country.
The lies over Pincher seemed so unnecessary, almost trivial compared to so much else, but the straw that breaks the camel’s back doesn’t have to be very heavy.
Now we wait to see how long Johnson thinks he can ride a camel with a broken back…
Looks like the end. What the hell took them so long? It's not as though we've learnt anything about Boris this week that we didn't know last month, or last year, or in 2019 when he was chosen as leader.
Still, it's progress. Getting rid of him is the necessary first stage - but only the first stage - of putting things right.
Yes, back to opposition, probably for at least a decade if not more.
Last time the Tories toppled an election winning PM, Thatcher in 1990, they lost 3 out of 4 of the following general elections and it took them until Boris in 2019 to win a big majority again
Oh, I think it's very likely that the Conservatives will be very, very unpopular for a long time. But you're putting the blame in the wrong place. It's Boris who has wrecked the party, and it's going to take a very long time for it to be forgotten. As I wrote on the day he became leader:
The party is no longer recognisable as the pragmatic, business-friendly, economically-sound, reality-based party of government which I have supported for decades. It will justifiably get the electoral blame for the consequences of the disastrous course it has chosen, and will probably never be forgiven by younger voters.
The Tory Party is not just the political wing of the CBI and the City of London. It also has to reach working class and lower middle class voters to win, Thatcher managed to do so as did Boris
Apart from everything else, Boris is a clear and present danger to the Union. He is total anti-catnip to Scots, and the SNP use him as a recruiting tool, and they mentioned him by name when announcing "Sindyref" 2. One person who will be really praying he survives is Sturgeon
Surely you can see this? You're a unionist
Boris can just refuse an indyref2 still and nothing the SNP can do to change Scotland's status in the union without UK government consent. Legally and constitutionally therefore it does not matter how unpopular the PM is in Scotland if they have a majority at Westminster to refuse indyref2.
Only if they grant an indyref2 does the UK PM's popularity matter in Scotland
FPT: here's a nice brazil nut.
BTW you do realise there are Tory constituencies in Scotland, with actual live Tory MPs in them?
Even if the Tories won 0 seats in Scotland in 2019 they would still have had a majority of 68
If that meteor hadn't hit Yucatan 65myrs ago, you wouldn't be posting this stuff.
The lies over Pincher seemed so unnecessary, almost trivial compared to so much else, but the straw that breaks the camel’s back doesn’t have to be very heavy.
Now we wait to see how long Johnson thinks he can ride a camel with a broken back…
That’s not a very polite way of referring to Carrie.
ALSO: has any PM survived the resignation of a COTE? For more than a few weeks, anyway?
Nothing fundamental has changed. Johnson will reshuffle and carry on.
The cabinet won't get rid of him. Too many of them know their ministerial careers are over five minutes after a change of leadership. It will take a large majority of the backbenchers to conclude that Johnson is an electoral liability and force him out through a change of rules and another confidence vote. So long as they are split, dithering and wetting their knickers, he's perfectly safe.
Looks like the end. What the hell took them so long? It's not as though we've learnt anything about Boris this week that we didn't know last month, or last year, or in 2019 when he was chosen as leader.
Still, it's progress. Getting rid of him is the necessary first stage - but only the first stage - of putting things right.
Yes, back to opposition, probably for at least a decade if not more.
Last time the Tories toppled an election winning PM, Thatcher in 1990, they lost 3 out of 4 of the following general elections and it took them until Boris in 2019 to win a big majority again
Oh, I think it's very likely that the Conservatives will be very, very unpopular for a long time. But you're putting the blame in the wrong place. It's Boris who has wrecked the party, and it's going to take a very long time for it to be forgotten. As I wrote on the day he became leader:
The party is no longer recognisable as the pragmatic, business-friendly, economically-sound, reality-based party of government which I have supported for decades. It will justifiably get the electoral blame for the consequences of the disastrous course it has chosen, and will probably never be forgiven by younger voters.
The Tory Party is not just the political wing of the CBI and the City of London. It also has to reach working class and lower middle class voters to win, Thatcher managed to do so as did Boris
Apart from everything else, Boris is a clear and present danger to the Union. He is total anti-catnip to Scots, and the SNP use him as a recruiting tool, and they mentioned him by name when announcing "Sindyref" 2. One person who will be really praying he survives is Sturgeon
Surely you can see this? You're a unionist
Boris can just refuse an indyref2 still and nothing the SNP can do to change Scotland's status in the union without UK government consent. Legally and constitutionally therefore it does not matter how unpopular the PM is in Scotland if they have a majority at Westminster to refuse indyref2.
Only if they grant an indyref2 does the UK PM's popularity matter in Scotland
FPT: here's a nice brazil nut.
BTW you do realise there are Tory constituencies in Scotland, with actual live Tory MPs in them?
Even if the Tories won 0 seats in Scotland in 2019 they would still have had a majority of 68
If that meteor hadn't hit Yucatan 65myrs ago, you wouldn't be posting this stuff.
Comments
As in “go fourth and multiply, Boris”.
Not that he really needs any encouragement to do the latter.
"I know you’re all avidly in favour of tax cuts and tonight’s events might make that a bit easier to deliver"
https://twitter.com/christiancalgie/status/1544378339758116865
https://twitter.com/PickardJE/status/1544378746312048641
As the Ragin Cajun once said: "I want to come back in the next life as the bond markets".
Javid opens by reminding Boris he was asked back into Cabinet, then spends 3 paragraphs on self congratulatory NHS wank. Then there is one long paragraph summed up by the idea they should be competent even if not popular. Followed by thanking Boris for seeing of Corbyn, and laughable claim to have been a friend to Boris. He doesn't actually talk directly about resigning until the 4th paragraph.
Sunak by contast opens with his resignation. He then plays the martyr a bit about it being a difficult time to stand down, probably to jsutify why he did nothing before now. One paragraph about lack of competence with more martyr talk about it being his last job perhaps, then overwrought protestation that he had been loyal boss. Interestingly he admits to disagreeing privately on things he defended publicly, probably a signal of his intention to go in a new direction, which he builds on in the next paragraph.
Sunak's looks more of a leadership pitch to me.
I think I published about 12 threads in 12 hours, certainly felt like it.
Mogg always has his finger on the pulse.
#PinchGate #BorisMustGo https://twitter.com/samcoatessky/status/1544374357442584576
Bridgen MP.
So far from being co ordinated across Cabinet it seems Sunak and Javid were outliers. To survive Johnson will now shift to rally the right and the ERG behind him, he will say this is a coup by Remainers to row back from Brexit and those on the left of the party who want to raise taxes and only he can stop them!
Sajid has timed his sprint well. Puts him in contention. Hunt is irrelevant. Mordaunt the Major/Starmer style compromise candidate. Rishi too little too late but could be the winner’s CoE.
Out of that lot the most likely to repair our relations and reputation abroad is probably Javid.
Has there been some interesting developments?
https://twitter.com/SamCoatesSky/status/1544374357442584576?s=20&t=rRwD-qbCc3wMInUksbCG_A
There is only Wallace left who can be considered to have ability beyond one cabinet.
BTW you do realise there are Tory constituencies in Scotland, with actual live Tory MPs in them?
https://twitter.com/RMCunliffe/status/1544379921664966657
Wallace is right to stay as Her Majesty's defence minister, given the Ukraine situation. We really can't afford any discontinuity there.
@RishiSunak
and
@sajidjavid
have done the right thing.
https://twitter.com/DavidGHFrost/status/1544379667133734917?s=20&t=iKLPp_fivQasI0IyRzvPsQ
July 5th: Britain celebrates its independence from Boris?
https://twitter.com/estwebber/status/1544380470162513920
https://twitter.com/MrHarryCole/status/1544380538194214915
Harry Cole
@MrHarryCole
Michael Gove is NOT resigning - aide
6:59 PM · Jul 5, 2022·Twitter Web App
ALSO: has any PM survived the resignation of a COTE? For more than a few weeks, anyway?
That said, for a man who pretends to constitutionalism, he knows damn well that PMs do not get a personal mandate under our system - he has talked such talk before, and far from being a conservative he appears to be an extreme radical, evne revolutionary, in his perception of the British system.
Dorries much more likely to end up as Health Secretary.
Unless he brings back Hancock.
Edit - Thorneycroft resigned on 6th Jan 1958.
Loyalty is the only thing that matters.
The bastards are running the show. They’re destroying their party, and the country.
Neither are innocent in all this. Nobody would argue surely.
Now we wait to see how long Johnson thinks he can ride a camel with a broken back…
Can't think why.
https://sports.ladbrokes.com/event/politics/uk/uk-politics/next-conservative-party-leader/228826373/all-markets https://twitter.com/LadPolitics/status/1544381935601975296/photo/1
Anyone accepting a role in Boris's reshuffled Cabinet has a very short career ahead of them.
The cabinet won't get rid of him. Too many of them know their ministerial careers are over five minutes after a change of leadership. It will take a large majority of the backbenchers to conclude that Johnson is an electoral liability and force him out through a change of rules and another confidence vote. So long as they are split, dithering and wetting their knickers, he's perfectly safe.
He'd be head dinosaur!
Good luck to those staying loyal trying to stick it out