Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

By election betting – politicalbetting.com

13567

Comments

  • StuartDicksonStuartDickson Posts: 12,146

    I reckon it's best to wait until the New Year to start taking anything concrete from the polls. There will definitely be a Truss lag and possibly a Sunak honeymoon. It will need a few months to settle down.

    Agreed.

    But let’s enjoy them sweat.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,924

    I was surprised tonight that he has overtaken Starmer as best PM
    I wasn't
  • Heathener said:

    I've just seen the Redfield & Wilton poll. So that's two polls with fieldwork taken since Rishi became PM showing Labour with 28% and now 32% leads.

    I was expecting at least some sort of honeymoon bounce. This shows nothing as yet.

    The back benches could start to become discontented if this continues, which I think it may.

    It shows Rishi as best PM to Starmer at 39%/38% which is surprising in such a short time

    Maybe wait until the Autumn statement on the 17th November and the reaction to a very important event for most everyone
  • HeathenerHeathener Posts: 7,085

    it is too early to expect a substantial bounce
    Why? I've never heard of such a thing before.

    I'm afraid they are in real trouble. Rishi is not relatable. He was part of the whole lockdown sleaze. For some he is the one who stabbed their beloved Boris. The economic situation is dire. The tories trashed their reputation for economic competence. We're about to enter austerity. He may not even guarantee the pension triple lock. And he has made some shockingly bad appointments to the cabinet, showing his weakness.

    The tories are going to get trounced next time. There is nothing they can do to avert it.
  • StuartDicksonStuartDickson Posts: 12,146
    Jonathan said:

    I bet you would not have said that if the polls had been more agreeable.
    Ho ho. Valid point Sir!
  • kjhkjh Posts: 12,509

    Drive a steam train? Maybe fly a glider (the heights thing doesn't really kick in).
    Done gliders. Even landed in a field (well the instructor did) when the winch launch went horribly wrong. In my ignorance I thought it was going rather smoothly as it was less vicious than normal. The instructor behind had rather different emotions going through him as he took over.

    Height is only an issue if I'm not enclosed, hence rolls and barrel rolls in a Pitts Special was ok (other than feeling sick)

    Steam train is a great idea - thank you.
  • wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 10,061
    Heathener said:

    I've just seen the Redfield & Wilton poll. So that's two polls with fieldwork taken since Rishi became PM showing Labour with 28% and now 32% leads.

    I was expecting at least some sort of honeymoon bounce. This shows nothing as yet.

    The back benches could start to become discontented if this continues, which I think it may.

    YouGov was a nine point movement. Redfiekds red wall poll yesterday was a 12 point movement.
    This Redfield is on its own thus far showing no movement outside MoE (though Tories are up 4 this week with them). Lets see what the rest do.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,924

    You could turn up and pretend to be another poster.
    I pretended to be Nigel 4 England once.

    Would've got away with it if I hadn't forgotten to take my don't blame me I voted Jezza badge off!!
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,917

    Good try, but he will take the full 2 years and I would caution Labour from being over confident

    2 years is a long time in politics
    What I mean is that the problems facing any incoming prime minister are so challenging that in the longer term it's going to require something a lot more substantial than media coverage of Sunak grinning a lot, surrounded by applauding people he's just given jobs to, for the Tories to stand any chance of winning an election.
  • Heathener said:

    I've just seen the Redfield & Wilton poll. So that's two polls with fieldwork taken since Rishi became PM showing Labour with 28% and now 32% leads.

    I was expecting at least some sort of honeymoon bounce. This shows nothing as yet.

    The back benches could start to become discontented if this continues, which I think it may.

    If I were a Conservative Backbencher I'd STFU. Sunak is their best chance, probably their only one.
  • DriverDriver Posts: 5,560
    Heathener said:

    Why? I've never heard of such a thing before..
    See the other recent posts in the thread. You're creating a falsely high barrier for the Tories and then gloating when they don't clear it.
  • Jonathan said:

    I bet you would not have said that if the polls had been more agreeable.
    I have repeatedly said that and if you check my posts I have consistently said it will be next Spring before the polls are more reflective of the political climate
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,782
    Trying to make an AI avatar that captures the times
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,782
    That's not bad
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,924
    Chris said:

    What I mean is that the problems facing any incoming prime minister are so challenging that in the longer term it's going to require something a lot more substantial than media coverage of Sunak grinning a lot, surrounded by applauding people he's just given jobs to, for the Tories to stand any chance of winning an election.
    Sunak deliberately didn't grin did he?

    Thought he was trying to look all serious in light of the state of everything.
  • kjhkjh Posts: 12,509
    kinabalu said:

    Ooo no. I have a mental image of all posters, as I said this morning, and kjh is handsome and distinguished.
    That is very kind of you, although sadly you have not met me to spoil that image. I'm going to spoilt that now, as apparently I look a bit like Boris Johnson. Years ago that mistake would be difficult as I had black hair, but its all gone white now except for the eyebrows.

    Sorry about bursting the bubble.
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 44,620
    Ishmael_Z said:

    The last Crimean war was so productive - cardigans, balaclavas, raglan sleeves - I am hoping for some really innovative cold weather cosies to emerge from this coming winter. Like the Apollo program being great because we got cordless screwdrivers.
    Valenki will become fashionable?

    https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/1136284065/rubber-sole-felted-woolen-full-boots-100?external=1&ref=market_collection_recs-1-listing-0&external_collection=&page_type=cl_market_page
  • boulayboulay Posts: 6,154
    Heathener said:

    Why? I've never heard of such a thing before.

    I'm afraid they are in real trouble. Rishi is not relatable. He was part of the whole lockdown sleaze. For some he is the one who stabbed their beloved Boris. The economic situation is dire. The tories trashed their reputation for economic competence. We're about to enter austerity. He may not even guarantee the pension triple lock. And he has made some shockingly bad appointments to the cabinet, showing his weakness.

    The tories are going to get trounced next time. There is nothing they can do to avert
    it.

    You are ruling out the possibility - however wild it might be - that Sunak nails it, massively limits the economic damage, keeps various voters happy with their pet wants, and that people might warm to him in his tiggerish enthusiasm. It might just be a slow burn which would possibly have more depth to it - something about “the star that burns the brightest burns the shortest” (no pun intended) but in reverse.

    It’s just far too early to tell and people will be very wary about being enthused by the Tories right now.
  • Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981
    Heathener said:

    I've just seen the Redfield & Wilton poll. So that's two polls with fieldwork taken since Rishi became PM showing Labour with 28% and now 32% leads.

    I was expecting at least some sort of honeymoon bounce. This shows nothing as yet.

    The back benches could start to become discontented if this continues, which I think it may.

    The 28% lead was Yougov, with Lab -5 and Con +4. how is that not "at least some sort of honeymoon bounce"? I mean, I find it as tragicomic as the next man that a 9 point bounce still leaves them 23-51 but you must not misrepresent polls here.
  • StuartDicksonStuartDickson Posts: 12,146
    Heathener said:

    Why? I've never heard of such a thing before.

    I'm afraid they are in real trouble. Rishi is not relatable. He was part of the whole lockdown sleaze. For some he is the one who stabbed their beloved Boris. The economic situation is dire. The tories trashed their reputation for economic competence. We're about to enter austerity. He may not even guarantee the pension triple lock. And he has made some shockingly bad appointments to the cabinet, showing his weakness.

    The tories are going to get trounced next time. There is nothing they can do to avert it.
    If you’re right, Lab Maj at 2.36 is astonishingly good value.

    More than double your money in 24 months? Even horrendous inflation can’t take the shine off that.

    But I’m not a buyer.
  • paulyork64paulyork64 Posts: 2,507

    And non-stick saucepans I believe.
    Wasnt WD40 a space race spin-off?
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 45,359
    kjh said:

    Done gliders. Even landed in a field (well the instructor did) when the winch launch went horribly wrong. In my ignorance I thought it was going rather smoothly as it was less vicious than normal. The instructor behind had rather different emotions going through him as he took over.

    Height is only an issue if I'm not enclosed, hence rolls and barrel rolls in a Pitts Special was ok (other than feeling sick)

    Steam train is a great idea - thank you.
    Walk a national trail. There's a variety, from the classic-but-hard Pennine Way (although that has had many of its teeth removed over the years) to the wonderful but easy Thames Path.
  • Heathener said:

    Why? I've never heard of such a thing before.

    I'm afraid they are in real trouble. Rishi is not relatable. He was part of the whole lockdown sleaze. For some he is the one who stabbed their beloved Boris. The economic situation is dire. The tories trashed their reputation for economic competence. We're about to enter austerity. He may not even guarantee the pension triple lock. And he has made some shockingly bad appointments to the cabinet, showing his weakness.

    The tories are going to get trounced next time. There is nothing they can do to avert it.
    He leads Starmer tonight and frankly, and with respect, your posts are entirely your own hopes and expectations projected as certaintity which in politics is never a good place to be
  • wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 10,061
    edited October 2022
    There is sn Ominisis, People Polling, Techne and possibly deltapoll due by tomorrow so we should have plenty of 'bounce' evidence or evidence of lack soon
  • First PM Sunak poll, by YouGov, the only pollster to correctly weigh geographical sub-samples:

    London
    Lab 64%
    Con 16%
    LD 9%
    Ref 7%
    Grn 4%

    ... snip ...

    Scotland
    SNP 46%
    Lab 25%
    Con 19%
    LD 5%
    Grn 3%
    Ref 1%

    (YouGov / The Times; Sample Size: 1646; Fieldwork: 25-26 October 2022)

    Tories more popular in Scotland than London.
  • It shows Rishi as best PM to Starmer at 39%/38% which is surprising in such a short time

    Maybe wait until the Autumn statement on the 17th November and the reaction to a very important event for most everyone
    Nothing surprising about the best PM figures. Starmer doesn't get much exposure and is famously uncharismatic.

    Rishi has had a lot of favourable Press, and is if nothing else 'better than what you had before'.
  • kjhkjh Posts: 12,509
    Carnyx said:

    Arbroath smokie; baby gannet; North Ronaldsay sheep; samphire ...
    On that front I do have some medlars (and know where to get more) and have never cooked with them before. Suggestions? Have seen lots of recipes, but don't know what to go for. I don't want to make jam.
  • Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981

    Walk a national trail. There's a variety, from the classic-but-hard Pennine Way (although that has had many of its teeth removed over the years) to the wonderful but easy Thames Path.
    GR20 for me next May.
  • StuartDicksonStuartDickson Posts: 12,146

    Tories more popular in Scotland than London.
    Tories less unpopular in Scotland than London.

    Fixed that for you 😄

    In all seriousness, it is not the London numbers that ought to terrify the Tories, it is these ones:

    Rest of South
    Lab 46%
    Con 29%
    LD 14%
    Ref 6%
    Grn 4%

    Midlands and Wales
    Lab 53%
    Con 25%
    Ref 6%
    LD 6%
    PC 5%
    Grn 3%

    North
    Lab 60%
    Con 20%
    Ref 8%
    LD 6%
    Grn 4%

    (YouGov / The Times; Sample Size: 1646; Fieldwork: 25-26 October 2022)
  • RogerRoger Posts: 20,452
    Does anyone in the UK outside of a section of Northern Ireland support Donaldson and the DUP?
  • wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 10,061
    We might even get a comedy Kantar poll with a smaller lead and 'hey guys, whats been happenin?'
  • There is sn Ominisis, People Polling, Techne and possibly deltapoll due by tomorrow so we should have plenty of 'bounce' evidence or evidence of lack soon

    You really need to give is a week or so.

    I'll hazard a guess that within a fortnight the lead will be down to about 25 points. After that, it depends how things go.

    The November statement will be big, and I expect we'll have had the next Suella scandal by then.
  • Nothing surprising about the best PM figures. Starmer doesn't get much exposure and is famously uncharismatic.

    Rishi has had a lot of favourable Press, and is if nothing else 'better than what you had before'.
    Isn't there also a noticable bias towards the incumbent PM on "best PM" questions? Basically, we don't have to imagine them as PM becuase they are PM.

    In which case, a 1 point lead isn't all that.
  • TimSTimS Posts: 14,932
    edited October 2022
    The polls for Rishi are a bit like my MPG in the car. I want to achieve over 40 for a decent length journey.

    He needs to get up to near parity in the polls by 2024 - he doesn’t need to lead, the typical understatement of Tories ahead of elections will sort that out - but he needs to be in touching distance. He also needs to lead Starmer by a few % on best leader.

    To end 2024 at near parity he needs a big surge now, like the MPG which goes up to 50+ on a long downhill stretch knowing I have a few hills and red traffic lights to take the average down before the destination.

    Feels like he’s been freewheeling down the hill and the fuel economy is ticking up but it may not hit 35 let alone the 45mpg he needs to allow for the revving to come.
  • StuartDicksonStuartDickson Posts: 12,146
    Roger said:

    Does anyone in the UK outside of a section of Northern Ireland support Donaldson and the DUP?

    I think the Tories would dearly love to get rid of them completely, but supporting Irish reunification formally is too honest for them. They’re doing it in their standard underhand way.
  • HeathenerHeathener Posts: 7,085

    He leads Starmer tonight and frankly, and with respect, your posts are entirely your own hopes and expectations projected as certaintity which in politics is never a good place to be
    No. Some of my most successful bets have been entirely against my own hopes. For instance I won a load on Brexit and also on David Cameron in 2015.

    I see this objectively. And you simply don't come back from this. You say he leads Starmer tonight but that's after wall-to-wall coverage for several days and positive pages.

    When the economy bites more and people lose the first flush, those 32% Labour leads will grow even further.

    This is 1997 all over again only worse for the tories because then the economy was in great shape. This time it is awful.

    Anyone who thinks otherwise is utterly deluded and straw-clutching.
  • paulyork64paulyork64 Posts: 2,507
    Ishmael_Z said:

    GR20 for me next May.
    Had to Google that. Sounds great.
  • HeathenerHeathener Posts: 7,085
    boulay said:


    You are ruling out the possibility [...] It’s just far too early to tell
    I am and it isn't.

    It's over.

    The only question is the scale of the Conservative losses.
  • We might even get a comedy Kantar poll with a smaller lead and 'hey guys, whats been happenin?'

    Their previous effort showed the Conservatives just 4 points adrift, so I expect they will have them ahead now.
  • TimSTimS Posts: 14,932
    edited October 2022

    Isn't there also a noticable bias towards the incumbent PM on "best PM" questions? Basically, we don't have to imagine them as PM becuase they are PM.

    In which case, a 1 point lead isn't all that.
    Yes, he needs to lead by 10 points or more. May well still happen but given the almost universal positive coverage so far the bounce
    is not great.

    I do think the average voter is of a mind to give the other lot a go next time.
  • wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 10,061

    You really need to give is a week or so.

    I'll hazard a guess that within a fortnight the lead will be down to about 25 points. After that, it depends how things go.

    The November statement will be big, and I expect we'll have had the next Suella scandal by then.
    Agreed but i think 20 rather than 25.......
  • Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981

    Had to Google that. Sounds great.
    TBF it's a bit of a brag until I have actually done it, very very tough by all accounts.
  • Heathener said:

    No. Some of my most successful bets have been entirely against my own hopes. For instance I won a load on Brexit and also on David Cameron in 2015.

    I see this objectively. And you simply don't come back from this. You say he leads Starmer tonight but that's after wall-to-wall coverage for several days and positive pages.

    When the economy bites more and people lose the first flush, those 32% Labour leads will grow even further.

    This is 1997 all over again only worse for the tories because then the economy was in great shape. This time it is awful.

    Anyone who thinks otherwise is utterly deluded and straw-clutching.
    With respect many would say your last sentence applies to yourself to be fair

    You may well be right but equally you could be wrong

    Anyway we know you will continue on this path so maybe we should agree to disagree
  • HeathenerHeathener Posts: 7,085
    kle4 said:

    I guess no one gets much of a honeymoon anymore.
    Not if you're a Conservative right now.

    They trashed the country and trashed their reputation. That's the perception.

    They will come back from this but it won't be until 2035 at the earliest.
  • wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 10,061
    edited October 2022

    Isn't there also a noticable bias towards the incumbent PM on "best PM" questions? Basically, we don't have to imagine them as PM becuase they are PM.

    In which case, a 1 point lead isn't all that.
    That depends where the snapshot is taken in the 'bounce'. Has it just hit the floor and reversed or is it at its highest rebound? We don't yet know
  • Had to Google that. Sounds great.
    Cotswold Way is great for softees. Feel free to drop in here when you pass through Winchcombe.
  • Wulfrun_PhilWulfrun_Phil Posts: 4,780

    First PM Sunak poll, by YouGov, the only pollster to correctly weigh geographical sub-samples:

    London
    Lab 64%
    Con 16%
    LD 9%
    Ref 7%
    Grn 4%

    ... snip ...

    Scotland
    SNP 46%
    Lab 25%
    Con 19%
    LD 5%
    Grn 3%
    Ref 1%

    (YouGov / The Times; Sample Size: 1646; Fieldwork: 25-26 October 2022)

    I never noticed you post details of the previous poll by YouGov, the only pollster to correctly weigh geographical sub-samples, which had:
    Scotland
    SNP 41%
    Lab 35%
    Con 9%
    LD 8%
    Grn 4%
    Ref 2%

    Was it because the SNP lead had shrunk to 6% and you're posting only those YouGov polls that you like?


  • Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981
    Heathener said:

    I am and it isn't.

    It's over.

    The only question is the scale of the Conservative losses.
    The trick was to realise and say that when Lab Maj was at 6. But you have got there.
  • wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 10,061

    Their previous effort showed the Conservatives just 4 points adrift, so I expect they will have them ahead now.
    Con gain Bootle nailed on
  • FairlieredFairliered Posts: 5,595

    I pretended to be Nigel 4 England once.

    Would've got away with it if I hadn't forgotten to take my don't blame me I voted Jezza badge off!!
    @HYUFD wouldn’t have been happy about you impersonating him.
  • With respect many would say your last sentence applies to yourself to be fair

    You may well be right but equally you could be wrong

    Anyway we know you will continue on this path so maybe we should agree to disagree
    Well I maybe wouldn't go as far as Heathener, but I certainly think 2.38 is great value on a Labour Majority.
  • DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 30,168
    edited October 2022
    Leon said:

    HELP

    MASSIVE JET LAG

    Have to wake up for a meeting in a pub which I can't miss

    Four coffees have not helped. Still nodding off?

    And PB Brains Trust Advice?

    Clean your teeth (seriously).

    ETA after taking a nap if you have time.
  • HeathenerHeathener Posts: 7,085
    I remember chatting to Michael Heseltine in early 1997 and he knew. People on the inside just did.

    Same now.

    I don't mind if some of you on the right wish to straw clutch and pin your hopes on any little flutter of wind you think you can find but I'm afraid it is sheer delusion. The latest I see is that we should wait for, erm, that statement on austerity.

    The real question, and the only one, is just how many seats they are going to lose. Election night will be carnage and a few brave tory souls will tour the tv studios and they will talk back to autumn 2022 as the moment when the rout began. They will be right to.
  • kjhkjh Posts: 12,509

    Walk a national trail. There's a variety, from the classic-but-hard Pennine Way (although that has had many of its teeth removed over the years) to the wonderful but easy Thames Path.
    I'm not a fan of walking. I find it boring (sorry). I also have flat feet so it hurts after a few miles. I do like cycling and have cycled several Greenways in France. I tend to do 400 - 600 km trips staying in B&Bs. Planning it is fun. It also seems to have the advantage of taking the wildlife by surprise more often than when you walk, so I think you see more. I tend to look for flat routes as my not so svelte body struggles on hills. My wife likes walking. We aren't compatible in so many ways.
  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 30,812
    rcs1000 said:

    Are there more videos on-line of men masturbating, or women?
    I think the point here is that if it was a woman, dressed as a woman, the Tweet would have referred to the fact. By process of elimination, that only leaves it being a man dressed as a woman.
  • FairlieredFairliered Posts: 5,595
    Roger said:

    Does anyone in the UK outside of a section of Northern Ireland support Donaldson and the DUP?

    The 19% of Scottish voters who vote Conservative.
  • Clean your teeth (seriously).
    Agreed.

    That also works when you are dieting.
  • algarkirkalgarkirk Posts: 14,012
    Roger said:

    Does anyone in the UK outside of a section of Northern Ireland support Donaldson and the DUP?

    No. They are impossible to support outside their internal echo chamber for the simple reason that while we are repeatedly told what they don't want we have yet to hear from the DUP a worked out, non unicorn description of what they actually want and how anyone would go about achieving it.

    The extent to which other UK politicians and the media let them get away with this must be deliberate because it is so obvious, but I am unclear why.
  • Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981
    Keir Starmer faces the awful truth: Labour’s policy cupboard is bare – Rishi Sunak’s stolen them all

    https://www.independent.co.uk/independentpremium/voices/keir-starmer-rishi-sunak-labour-party-b2211959.html

    John Rentoul, not a natural Tory fanboi.
  • wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 10,061
    Heathener said:

    I remember chatting to Michael Heseltine in early 1997 and he knew. People on the inside just did.

    Same now.

    I don't mind if some of you on the right wish to straw clutch and pin your hopes on any little flutter of wind you think you can find but I'm afraid it is sheer delusion. The latest I see is that we should wait for, erm, that statement on austerity.

    The real question, and the only one, is just how many seats they are going to lose. Election night will be carnage and a few brave tory souls will tour the tv studios and they will talk back to autumn 2022 as the moment when the rout began. They will be right to.

    Yeah none of us had a clue in early 1997, it needed insider info from Michael Heseltine.
  • Heathener said:

    No. Some of my most successful bets have been entirely against my own hopes. For instance I won a load on Brexit and also on David Cameron in 2015.

    I see this objectively. And you simply don't come back from this. You say he leads Starmer tonight but that's after wall-to-wall coverage for several days and positive pages.

    When the economy bites more and people lose the first flush, those 32% Labour leads will grow even further.

    This is 1997 all over again only worse for the tories because then the economy was in great shape. This time it is awful.

    Anyone who thinks otherwise is utterly deluded and straw-clutching.
    Another John Major echo.

    The Conservatives did slowly, painfully haul themselves back from their nadir in summer 1995. Their polling average then was about 24%, and they got back to 31% in 1997. And that was with the economy (as the posters said) "Booming".

    Beyond a certain point, a lot of voters stop listening. Not all of them; 31 is bigger than 24. But as with people, political parties eventually annoy others so much that the apologies aren't heard, and anything that goes well is uncreditied.

    I thought that ditching Johnson would be enough to get the Conservatives back on the same pitch as the other lot. Turns out that, fairly or not, the public anger with the Conservatives goes wider than that.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,782
    Much as it dismays me, I am forced to agree with @Heathener

    The people have decided. They want the Tories gone. Sunak should reduce the scale of the disaster and maybe even reduce PM starmer to leading a NOM Govt, but even that is wildly optimistic

    There is one caveat. A black swan. And right now black swans are quite plentiful. Unfortunately
  • Ishmael_Z said:

    The trick was to realise and say that when Lab Maj was at 6. But you have got there.
    In fairness, Ish, one would have needed to predict the Trussterfuckup, and few could have foreseen its full scale.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,782

    Clean your teeth (seriously).
    Done. Now I’m going to try a dry martini
  • Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981
    Heathener said:

    I remember chatting to Michael Heseltine in early 1997 and he knew. People on the inside just did.

    Same now.

    I don't mind if some of you on the right wish to straw clutch and pin your hopes on any little flutter of wind you think you can find but I'm afraid it is sheer delusion. The latest I see is that we should wait for, erm, that statement on austerity.

    The real question, and the only one, is just how many seats they are going to lose. Election night will be carnage and a few brave tory souls will tour the tv studios and they will talk back to autumn 2022 as the moment when the rout began. They will be right to.

    Yes. None of the rest of us had any idea.
  • Heathener said:

    I remember chatting to Michael Heseltine in early 1997 and he knew. People on the inside just did.

    Same now.

    I don't mind if some of you on the right wish to straw clutch and pin your hopes on any little flutter of wind you think you can find but I'm afraid it is sheer delusion. The latest I see is that we should wait for, erm, that statement on austerity.

    The real question, and the only one, is just how many seats they are going to lose. Election night will be carnage and a few brave tory souls will tour the tv studios and they will talk back to autumn 2022 as the moment when the rout began. They will be right to.

    You constantly refer to conservatives on the right, but most of us who back Rishi are far from being on the right and it seems it is your way of trying to discredit decent and honest conservatives who rejected Johnson and Truss but who now see in Rishi a professional grown up politician who in the fulness of time will confound your views

  • CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 60,422
    Scholz:

    Pleased to speak with @Bundeskanzler Olaf Scholz this afternoon.

    I'm looking forward to working closely with him, as we did as finance ministers, to ensure we maintain pressure on Putin, support Ukraine and safeguard our energy security for the future.


    https://twitter.com/RishiSunak/status/1585677102124339203
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 54,833
    Sunak now has a lead on best PM against Starmer.

    https://twitter.com/redfieldwilton/status/1585665169195237377
  • Well I maybe wouldn't go as far as Heathener, but I certainly think 2.38 is great value on a Labour Majority.
    Unfortunately I do not understand betting odds would you believe but NOM seems to be about the same as a Labour majority and at present NOM seems a likely outcome, but then the question that will become clearer in time is Rishi the new Blair and if so all bets are off
  • wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 10,061
    Leon said:

    Much as it dismays me, I am forced to agree with @Heathener

    The people have decided. They want the Tories gone. Sunak should reduce the scale of the disaster and maybe even reduce PM starmer to leading a NOM Govt, but even that is wildly optimistic

    There is one caveat. A black swan. And right now black swans are quite plentiful. Unfortunately

    I dont disagree, but there is everything to play for in terms of being placed to come back in one parliament vs 15 years in the wilderness
  • I think we will see the Labour lead shrink to single figures. A Tory lead is an outside chance.

    But Sunak's popularity won't last, he has shown himself to be continuously hopeless at politics, I've been saying this since early 2020.

    Is he better than Truss, yes of course. And I am glad he is there - but he is not good at politics whatsoever.
  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 30,812

    Scholz:

    Pleased to speak with @Bundeskanzler Olaf Scholz this afternoon.

    I'm looking forward to working closely with him, as we did as finance ministers, to ensure we maintain pressure on Putin, support Ukraine and safeguard our energy security for the future.


    https://twitter.com/RishiSunak/status/1585677102124339203

    What on earth has Britain's energy security got to do with Germany, or vice versa?
  • Leon said:

    Much as it dismays me, I am forced to agree with @Heathener

    The people have decided. They want the Tories gone. Sunak should reduce the scale of the disaster and maybe even reduce PM starmer to leading a NOM Govt, but even that is wildly optimistic

    There is one caveat. A black swan. And right now black swans are quite plentiful. Unfortunately

    It grieves me to do so, my flintknapping friend, but I have to agree.

    We had a nice political chat with some US friends in the pub recently and even they pointed out that us Brits like to rotate our bastards from time to time, and it just has that kind of feel about it. The Tories have been around too long, and that will do for them if nothing else does.

    Black swans notwithstanding of course.
  • wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 10,061

    I think we will see the Labour lead shrink to single figures. A Tory lead is an outside chance.

    But Sunak's popularity won't last, he has shown himself to be continuously hopeless at politics, I've been saying this since early 2020.

    Is he better than Truss, yes of course. And I am glad he is there - but he is not good at politics whatsoever.

    Maybe with Opinium but i think it wont drop below an average 15 point lead for now unless 'something' happens
  • 6/ So when you compare Starmer / Sunak net favourables to Lab / Con you get:

    Net favourability
    Starmer: +2
    Labour: +2
    Sunak: -4
    Cons: -36

    So there is clearly a disconnect between brand Sunak and brand Tory... at the moment...

    https://twitter.com/keiranpedley/status/1585670271565824001

    Sunak has essentially got to do what Corbyn tried and failed to do prior to GE2019. It's an outside chance.

    Have a good evening
  • wooliedyedwooliedyed Posts: 10,061

    Sunak now has a lead on best PM against Starmer.

    https://twitter.com/redfieldwilton/status/1585665169195237377

    Truss got to 4 ahead at best, thats the first benchmark
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,917
    Heathener said:

    No. Some of my most successful bets have been entirely against my own hopes. For instance I won a load on Brexit and also on David Cameron in 2015.

    I see this objectively. And you simply don't come back from this. You say he leads Starmer tonight but that's after wall-to-wall coverage for several days and positive pages.

    When the economy bites more and people lose the first flush, those 32% Labour leads will grow even further.

    This is 1997 all over again only worse for the tories because then the economy was in great shape. This time it is awful.

    Anyone who thinks otherwise is utterly deluded and straw-clutching.
    And if he could afford to ditch people like Braverman I'm sure he would be better placed, but he can't. A lot of people had been assuming he couldn't even be elected by his own party. Of course keeping his own party happy is going to be a huge part of the challenges facing him over the next two years, and surely it must be obvious after the events of the last couple of months that keeping the lunatic wing of the Tory party happy is an aim pretty much diametrically opposed to pleasing the electorate.
  • Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981

    In fairness, Ish, one would have needed to predict the Trussterfuckup, and few could have foreseen its full scale.
    I was expecting a (narrow) lab maj even under Johnson on the basis he was going to crash and burn, his replacement wouldn't be much better, we have had 12 years of tories, and crucially because the strongest argument against was always the very weak one that No one has overturned that big a majority since nineteen something. Which without context never looks much of an argument to me.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 54,197

    The same happened in Newton Abbot, Devon.
    My American relatives are nonplussed by the lack of action or reaction over Rishi.

    Apparently we should have impromptu armies of Hindus and racists fighting pitch battles in the streets or something.
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 51,232

    Clean your teeth (seriously).

    ETA after taking a nap if you have time.
    A tactical 40 winks is good. Remember to set an alarm though.
  • StuartDicksonStuartDickson Posts: 12,146

    You really need to give is a week or so.

    I'll hazard a guess that within a fortnight the lead will be down to about 25 points. After that, it depends how things go.

    The November statement will be big, and I expect we'll have had the next Suella scandal by then.
    Giving in to the ERG on Day One has probably sunk his chances. Which were extremely slim anyway.
  • Leon said:

    That's not bad

    Probably best if that's NOT the way you're looking today for your interview?

    Unless of course trying out for role of Eliza Doolittle in VERY surrealist/psychedelic/intergalactic production of "My Fair Lady"!
  • MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,772
    It seems somewhat amusing that Betfair has listed Kwasi Kwarteng 2nd in their list of names for next Con leader and 3rd in their list for next PM.

    It's surely hard to think of anyone (amongst well known names) less likely to win. I mean I know things can change in politics but after the last few weeks the idea of Kwasi as next leader feels beyond inconceivable.
  • Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981

    My American relatives are nonplussed by the lack of action or reaction over Rishi.

    Apparently we should have impromptu armies of Hindus and racists fighting pitch battles in the streets or something.
    That's my counties of birth, and residence. Makes one slightly proud.
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 45,359

    What on earth has Britain's energy security got to do with Germany, or vice versa?
    'Security' can mean several things, including security of supply. We may have a shortage of gas in the near future due to Putin's shittiness, and many countries are going after relatively few non-pipeline gas supplies (e.g. ships, LNG terminals).

    As another example: Germany going back to using Russian gas would be a disaster for Europe, and also our 'security'.
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 51,232

    6/ So when you compare Starmer / Sunak net favourables to Lab / Con you get:

    Net favourability
    Starmer: +2
    Labour: +2
    Sunak: -4
    Cons: -36

    So there is clearly a disconnect between brand Sunak and brand Tory... at the moment...

    https://twitter.com/keiranpedley/status/1585670271565824001

    Sunak has essentially got to do what Corbyn tried and failed to do prior to GE2019. It's an outside chance.

    Have a good evening

    More likely that Sunak contaminates his brand...
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 54,550

    Wasnt WD40 a space race spin-off?
    Developed by the Rocket Chemical Company in 1953.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 54,550

    My American relatives are nonplussed by the lack of action or reaction over Rishi.

    Apparently we should have impromptu armies of Hindus and racists fighting pitch battles in the streets or something.
    Tell them to give it time.....
  • StuartDicksonStuartDickson Posts: 12,146
    Did he actually just say that ...?

    Tory MP Giles Watling argues 'the likes of Mel Gibson' are responsible for increasing support for Scottish independence 🤦‍♀️

    https://twitter.com/scotnational/status/1585573113781256199?s=46&t=UYkitfH-yxs9iNB1xKUlCA
  • CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 60,422
    Predicament for Nicola Sturgeon. If she withdraws whip from 9 who voted against/abstained on GRR, she loses her majority and is in hock to Greens. If she doesn't act, she loses authority in group. Whatever, she is no longer omnipotent. Interesting.

    https://twitter.com/DalgetySusan/status/1585676800302235648
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 22,100

    Did he actually just say that ...?

    Tory MP Giles Watling argues 'the likes of Mel Gibson' are responsible for increasing support for Scottish independence 🤦‍♀️

    https://twitter.com/scotnational/status/1585573113781256199?s=46&t=UYkitfH-yxs9iNB1xKUlCA

    He’s clearly not a fan of the Lethal Weapon films
  • rjkrjk Posts: 72

    What on earth has Britain's energy security got to do with Germany, or vice versa?
    Perhaps this is code for selling more expensive North Sea gas to Germany now that cheap Russian gas isn't an option?
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,924
    Sunak not going to COP27

    Found out he would be on the back row on the photoshoot behind Greta and realised he would be totally obscured!
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 19,161
    One of the things that I think hurt Labour after 2010 was that a lot of their MPs who had been seen as big figures for the future decided that years of opposition wasn't for them and they'd rather find something more fun to do.

    It's an understandable reaction, but it's the sort of thing which can make it harder for a new opposition, and isn't great for politics overall.

    Though deciding which MPs are worth having stick around, and which are best cleared out, is bound to be a subject of some contention.

    I think that's one of the risks for the Tories now. If the capable sensible people decide to find more interesting things to do, and only the committed ideologically inflexible types hang around, it will make it much harder for them to become a good opposition.

    So one of the tasks Sunak has to achieve, if we assume that election victory is beyond him, is to keep the spirits up and encourage the best Tory MPs to want to stick around. A bit like trying hard to put together some tail-end partnerships on the fifth morning of a Test Match, so that the team's spirits aren't too crushed when it comes to the next match in the series.
  • Peter_the_PunterPeter_the_Punter Posts: 14,636
    edited October 2022

    Unfortunately I do not understand betting odds would you believe but NOM seems to be about the same as a Labour majority and at present NOM seems a likely outcome, but then the question that will become clearer in time is Rishi the new Blair and if so all bets are off
    It's easy arithmetic and worth learning. Turn the odds into percentages - so 100/2.38 = 42%. So the odds are saying both Lab Maj and NOM have about the same probability of 42%.

    Now the first thing a punter with no emotional attachment to any Party would say about that is that it implies a 16% chance of 'something else'. Since the real chances of that something else happening are vanishingly small, the odds must be out of kilter somewhere.

    Frankly I'd say that 'somewhere' is bleeding obvious. When one Party is 30 points clear within two years of an election it is going to take something remarkable to stop them getting an Overall Majority. My own estimate is that it is an even money chance (50%) at worst. So from a betting perspective if you take the 2.38 you have about an 8% margin in your favour.

    That would be enough to tempt me in, if I were punting. (I'm not. I'm retired, but that's how you figure it if you are playing seriously.)

    You may of course disagree with my assessments of probability but the method is correct, and I rather suspect that amongst the serious punters on here a majority would reckon I'm understating the advantage in backing an OM here.
  • It's easy arithmetic and worth learning. Turn the odds into percentages - so 100/2.38 = 42%. So the odds are saying both Lab Maj and NOM have about the same probability of 42%.

    Now the first thing a punter with no emotional attachment to any Party would say about that is that it implies a 16% chance of 'something else'. Since the real chances of that something else happening are vanishingly small, the odds must be out of kilter somewhere.

    Frankly I'd say that 'somewhere' is bleeding obvious. When one Party is 30 points clear within two years of an election it is going to take something remarkable to stop them getting an Overall Majority. My own estimate is that it is an even money chance (50%) at worst. So from a betting perspective if you take the 2.38 you have about an 8% margin in your favour.

    That would be enough to tempt me in, if I were punting. (I don't. I'm retrired, but that's how you figure it if you are playing seriously.)

    You may of course disagree with my assessments of probability but the method is correct, and I rather suspect that amongst the serious punters on here a majority would reckon I'm understating the advantage in backing an OM here.
    Thank you for that and I would not disagree with your comments which seem completely logical
  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 30,812
    rjk said:

    Perhaps this is code for selling more expensive North Sea gas to Germany now that cheap Russian gas isn't an option?
    Perhaps; if so I don't think it's a great idea. We need to keep energy cheap for domestic use. I never realised before the sheer disparity in the price of energy between us and America. It is quite literally the power behind their economy.
  • Predicament for Nicola Sturgeon. If she withdraws whip from 9 who voted against/abstained on GRR, she loses her majority and is in hock to Greens. If she doesn't act, she loses authority in group. Whatever, she is no longer omnipotent. Interesting.

    https://twitter.com/DalgetySusan/status/1585676800302235648

    what a ridiculous thing to threaten withdrawal of the whip on
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,378

    What on earth has Britain's energy security got to do with Germany, or vice versa?
    I would have thought there's a reasonable amount we can do together.

    Let me give you an example. If Germany has ordered an LNG cargo, and their storage is full, it is better than cargo gets diverted to the UK, and then the ship can head off back to Qatar or Texas, than it currently sits off the coast waiting to be delivered. (Which is happening, btw, there are about half a dozen LNG ships sitting outside European harbours unable to deliver due to lack of storage.)
  • RogerRoger Posts: 20,452

    Nothing surprising about the best PM figures. Starmer doesn't get much exposure and is famously uncharismatic.

    Rishi has had a lot of favourable Press, and is if nothing else 'better than what you had before'.
    A completely new broom might have helped 'New!' is always a good selling point. I haven't seen any analysis on 'retreads'
This discussion has been closed.