Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Johnson’s opposition to Sunak could have the reverse effect – politicalbetting.com

12346»

Comments

  • EndillionEndillion Posts: 4,976
    nova said:

    There's a difference between providing access to historical books no matter how offensive, and honouring a historical figure by naming the library after them.
    Sure there is, and I for one totally believe that bowing to pressure on the latter will absolutely not ultimately lead to movement on the former.

    They're the same issue.
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 44,620
    IshmaelZ said:

    Boris is a Catholic on paper. just means he is recused from choosing bishops. This guy needs to keep up.
    Unionist, and (at least formerly) UUP, so possibly - but not at all certainly - Presbyterian so I wondered if he had ever been consistent and complained about the lack of non-CoE bishop-analogues in the lords.

    But no mention in Wiki, though some other stuff of, erm, interest, such as the fact that 'Taylor had previously been labelled an "old racist dinosaur" by Piers Morgan', which I thought was particularly unkind, and 'During the Euro 2021 football competition, Taylor posted remarks on Twitter criticising the Spain national football team for not singing their national anthem at the start of football matches. Commentators responded by pointing out that the Spanish national anthem does not, in fact, have any lyrics.[29]'


    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Taylor,_Baron_Kilclooney
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    IanB2 said:

    We don’t need all this academic studying, when we have Leon.
    I was born with a marked deficiency of brain iron in my basal ganglia regions.
  • MoonRabbitMoonRabbit Posts: 14,073

    Seems she's worried she doesn't have the numbers. I suspect she's right. I think she'll finish third.

    Neither Sunak not Truss will lend votes to the other to push Mordaunt out, because neither have enough to lend.

    But between Braverman and Badenoch I think Truss has more support than Mordaunt does.
    You are presuming too much about the Badenoch votes all piling on Truss to sneak her over the line.

    Truss is untrusted. She bombed. She is already out mate.

    PM is PM because the polls of voters, Tory members and focus groups of working class voters on red wall all prefer her to both Sunak and Starmer, there is no stopping that sort of momentum.

    I know all this because I told I so.
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    Selebian said:

    I seem to recall a post from Robert confirming that Misty was very much present when Contrarian was posting. Could be my bad memory though.
    That was my point...
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 56,022
    Pulpstar said:

    Who, aside from Gove, are the Badenoch - Sunak switchers ?
    You’d think that most of the Badenoch vote goes to Truss, rather than Sunak.

    A fair amount of the Braverman vote probably goes to Badenoch then to Truss, rather than to Truss directly in the next round too.
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 44,620
    MattW said:

    BJ was born RC, and became Anglican at school aiui.

    Has he de-converted back?

    You can't conclude from his marriage at Westminster Cathedral unless there has been a specific statement. The RC Church have no problem with Protestants being married in an RC Church, but I think they may expect the children to be RC.
    Doesn't need to be baptised again, which is what counts.

    Another issue AIUI is the prior marriage(s). It's not possible to marry as a divorcee in a RC church without, de facto and perhaps de jure, wirting off the earlier marriages as invalid, which means signing up to RC doctrine.
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 9,264
    IshmaelZ said:

    That was my point...
    Ah. Whoosh!
  • No_Offence_AlanNo_Offence_Alan Posts: 4,984
    dixiedean said:

    Am well aware of that. I was brought up to know I could aspire to be anything in the UK.
    Except marry a royal or be PM. That was illegal.
    Thankfully we've moved on.
    Or most of us anyways.
    The royal family should be allowed to marry whoever they want.
    They should also be able to divorce whoever they like, which is a sticking point.
  • moonshinemoonshine Posts: 5,814
    By the way I am belatedly on the Kemi train having watched some of her recent q&a’s on YouTube. Intriguing that the ERG are split. There’s got to be a chance that Kemi storms the debates, edges out Truss and then takes down one of Sunak or Mordaunt into the final two. From there I think she beats whoever is against her.
  • MoonRabbitMoonRabbit Posts: 14,073

    The LibDems certainly seem to have a higher ceiling than Lab for swings. It'll be interesting to see what happens after the new Con leader is chosen.
    Despite being midterm and everything anti Tory going on, the Tory vote all this year does seem a bit sticky in the redwall and hard for Labour to grab back. There is enough evidence to say that without anyone disagreeing with me isn’t there?
  • numbertwelvenumbertwelve Posts: 7,305

    Kemi has a very narrow path.

    If TT drops before the next round (after TV debates) and she gets 60% of Braverman and 40% of Tug's (and Truss only gets 20% of each) then you get:

    Rishi Sunak 109
    Penny Mordaunt 92
    Liz Truss 77
    Kemi Badenoch 78

    Somewhat unlikely.

    If she did though she'd make it to the final and the members because the Truss votes would go disproportionately to her, not Mordaunt or Sunak.

    I wouldn’t expect 40% of TT to break to Kemi. Some maybe, but they don’t strike me as being particularly aligned from a candidate profile. PM seems much more transfer friendly re TT.

    More likely IMHO is the ERG don’t follow Baker, Braverman and Francois to Truss, and Braverman’s backers instead heavily break for Kemi. You end up with Truss-Kemi in the mid-high 60s apiece, so close to each other that it gives Badenoch the momentum to push above Truss in the next round as the right desert her and see she can’t win.

    Plausible with a barnstorming set of debate performances from Kemi and a car crash from Liz, which must at least be possible.


  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 44,620
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 9,264

    The question that Penny MUST answer.



    Looney appears to have missed the religion of the current pm 'if' the UK.

    Two out of the three are valid questions, to be fair (although not in any way contingent on the religion or otherwise of the PM).
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 19,161

    If your life was 'ruined' by the Covid rules for two years, then I'd argue it might be a problem with your 'life'. The Covid restrictions were sh*t, but there was still lots to do. True, it might not be quite what you would ordinarily do, but there was still stuff to do. Heck, I had a five/six-year old to homeschool, and I don't appear to have found it as a challenging as you.

    And if it saved a few hundred thousand people (not just oldies either), then fair enough. Especially for the first lockdown, where we were unsure what the heck we were facing. Sometimes you just have to knuckle down and get on with things.

    I really don't understand how you can say your life was 'ruined'. And before you say, I like going out. I like doing things. I like visiting places. But when I could not do these, I adapted. I even found some new things I enjoyed.
    I'm actually quite an insular person. My favourite hobbies are things like knitting and walking, which weren't affected by lockdown. I expected to sail through it. There were a few jokes along the lines of, "this is what we've been training for."

    But it really was monumentally awful. I find it so much harder to leave the house at all now. And I was lucky in where I spent my lockdowns and with whom. I don't think it does to underestimate the sacrifice made.

    And then there really should be a quid pro quo for such sacrifices, given the age profile of who the disease killed. But Max is right. Not only did the young give up their freedom to save the old, they're now being expected to pay for the privilege.

    I don't go as far as Max and day that I'd kill all the old if I had my time in the pandemic over again. But I can't disagree that the old are talking the piss.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 56,022
    moonshine said:

    By the way I am belatedly on the Kemi train having watched some of her recent q&a’s on YouTube. Intriguing that the ERG are split. There’s got to be a chance that Kemi storms the debates, edges out Truss and then takes down one of Sunak or Mordaunt into the final two. From there I think she beats whoever is against her.

    Yes, it’s a narrow path but she can definitely still win. A genuinely impressive candidate, as David Cameron was in 2005.

    She certainly has little to lose at this stage, should go all-in with lots of interviews and hustings.
  • RazedabodeRazedabode Posts: 3,106
    Just watching the conservative home debate - interesting how confident Rishi comes across
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 44,620
    Selebian said:

    Two out of the three are valid questions, to be fair (although not in any way contingent on the religion or otherwise of the PM).
    Exactly, which is why I was wondering if he had raised them before.
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    https://twitter.com/AlastairMeeks/status/1547911588333572097

    "Oof. Wrong to leave EU now 53%, a new high, right to leave 35%, a new low. Meanwhile the Tory leadership candidates compete to show their Brexit purity.

    The Brexit boat is close to capsizing. The point is rapidly approaching where the consensus is that Brexit is a mistake to be mitigated. The politicians are well behind this curve."

    I think he is right.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,939
    Does anyone who isn't a supporter of Kemi Badenoch see any plausible way she wins this contest?
  • numbertwelvenumbertwelve Posts: 7,305
    Pulpstar said:

    Who, aside from Gove, are the Badenoch - Sunak switchers ?
    Do we think Gove is a Badenoch-Sunak switcher? Genuinely curious on this one. I guess it makes sense given they were in government together and Sunak is not the continuity Boris candidate, but what of PM? She’s a Brexiteer and a bit Cameroony which is of course the wing of the party Gove started out on. I have no insight into their relationship however.

  • moonshinemoonshine Posts: 5,814
    Sandpit said:

    Yes, it’s a narrow path but she can definitely still win. A genuinely impressive candidate, as David Cameron was in 2005.

    She certainly has little to lose at this stage, should go all-in with lots of interviews and hustings.
    She’s one of the few uk politicians that you might be arsed to sit through a Joe Rogan length free range interview. The key is her taking down Truss. Tommy Tug described her on LBC as a personal friend, so you never know how things might play out with the debates. Might we see a Kemi-gasm among Tory MPs?
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,939

    Do we think Gove is a Badenoch-Sunak switcher? Genuinely curious on this one. I guess it makes sense given they were in government together and Sunak is not the continuity Boris candidate, but what of PM? She’s a Brexiteer and a bit Cameroony which is of course the wing of the party Gove started out on. I have no insight into their relationship however.

    Gove's a crafty git.
    The ideal place to be to exert maximum influence is to back the fourth placed candidate.
  • You are presuming too much about the Badenoch votes all piling on Truss to sneak her over the line.

    Truss is untrusted. She bombed. She is already out mate.

    PM is PM because the polls of voters, Tory members and focus groups of working class voters on red wall all prefer her to both Sunak and Starmer, there is no stopping that sort of momentum.

    I know all this because I told I so.
    She isn't out yet and may still win.

    I gave my numbers earlier. I'm not assuming that all Badenoch votes pile on Truss, if you did then she'd come first by a landslide.

    I estimated 60% of Badenoch and Braverman's votes transfer to Truss, and 60% of Tugendhat's to Mordaunt. With Sunak getting 30% of everyone's.

    That's just a finger in the air guesstimate but that leaves Mordaunt languishing in third by just a few votes.

    But she could come first, second or third depending upon how things play out. Nothing is certain.
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830

    I'm actually quite an insular person. My favourite hobbies are things like knitting and walking, which weren't affected by lockdown. I expected to sail through it. There were a few jokes along the lines of, "this is what we've been training for."

    But it really was monumentally awful. I find it so much harder to leave the house at all now. And I was lucky in where I spent my lockdowns and with whom. I don't think it does to underestimate the sacrifice made.

    And then there really should be a quid pro quo for such sacrifices, given the age profile of who the disease killed. But Max is right. Not only did the young give up their freedom to save the old, they're now being expected to pay for the privilege.

    I don't go as far as Max and day that I'd kill all the old if I had my time in the pandemic over again. But I can't disagree that the old are talking the piss.
    Really, you can't say that sort of thing about "the old" any more than you can say it about "the Jews." This is not a quibble: in both cases you are labelling a whole class whose membership of that class is determined 100% by accident of birth. I am not sure if I am old or not - I'm 60 - but I am as appalled as anyone by the loading of NI on to working age people.
  • Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 62,481
    Mr. Dean, perhaps, but Gove had no way of knowing that Badenoch would end up as fourth favourite.

    It's amusing that her odds have stayed pretty much the same (barring a brief leap out to 38 or so) through the rounds.
  • dixiedean said:

    Gove's a crafty git.
    The ideal place to be to exert maximum influence is to back the fourth placed candidate.
    There's a rumour that Gove wants Sunak to win and is pushing Badenoch to split the opposition on the right, knowing Badenoch would lose.

    Cynical rumour, but he's one person Machiavellian enough that it might actually be true!
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 62,309
    dixiedean said:

    Does anyone who isn't a supporter of Kemi Badenoch see any plausible way she wins this contest?

    Outlined earlier. She needs to be utterly brilliant and Truss to totally bomb, and she needs Tugendhat to endorse her.

    Prob 7-8% chance at best.
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 45,367

    I'm actually quite an insular person. My favourite hobbies are things like knitting and walking, which weren't affected by lockdown. I expected to sail through it. There were a few jokes along the lines of, "this is what we've been training for."

    But it really was monumentally awful. I find it so much harder to leave the house at all now. And I was lucky in where I spent my lockdowns and with whom. I don't think it does to underestimate the sacrifice made.

    And then there really should be a quid pro quo for such sacrifices, given the age profile of who the disease killed. But Max is right. Not only did the young give up their freedom to save the old, they're now being expected to pay for the privilege.

    I don't go as far as Max and day that I'd kill all the old if I had my time in the pandemic over again. But I can't disagree that the old are talking the piss.
    I'm sorry you went through that, but my argument is with use of the word 'ruined'. The people whose lives were ruined were those who died, or who lost loved ones. Max, you and I still have our lives.

    As an aside, we were blooming lucky during this pandemic in one regard: it did not affect the young as much. Imagine how much more hideous it would have been if the ambulances had been filled with people under 18, rather than those over 50.
  • bondegezoubondegezou Posts: 13,709

    Kemi has a very narrow path.

    If TT drops before the next round (after TV debates) and she gets 60% of Braverman and 40% of Tug's (and Truss only gets 20% of each) then you get:

    Rishi Sunak 109
    Penny Mordaunt 92
    Liz Truss 77
    Kemi Badenoch 78

    Somewhat unlikely.

    If she did though she'd make it to the final and the members because the Truss votes would go disproportionately to her, not Mordaunt or Sunak.

    40% of Tug’s seems very unlikely.
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 19,161
    dixiedean said:

    Am well aware of that. I was brought up to know I could aspire to be anything in the UK.
    Except marry a royal or be PM. That was illegal.
    Thankfully we've moved on.
    Or most of us anyways.
    You could marry a Royal, it's just that they'd have given up their place in the succession to do so. I think someone in the Queen's family did that.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 83,509
    Coronavirus continues to have an impact overseas, and it's been reported that China's economy contracted sharply in the second quarter of this year as widespread lockdowns hit businesses and consumers.

    Gross domestic product (GDP) fell by 2.6% in the three months to the end of June from the previous quarter.
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    edited July 2022

    You could marry a Royal, it's just that they'd have given up their place in the succession to do so. I think someone in the Queen's family did that.
    All or most of the Duke of Kent's grandchildren, who would otherwise be in the high 20s I think, have poped themselves out of contention (by converting, not marrying).
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 54,215
    edited July 2022

    The Dollar is strong, not weak.

    The rate at which natural gas wells/trains are coming back on line in the US is quite impressive.

    The next bottleneck is LNG ships.
    Malmsy^

    Me

    The problem when the mini thread goes wrong (the last block quote doesn’t work) it sneaks other people words into your bit, probably why so many deleted posts below - the weak dollar bit not my line.

    But RCS did post stuff the other day convincing me the crisis could ease quite quickly. Indeed, that was the original prediction before it came, up sharply down sharply wasn’t it?

    Related to Penny as our new PM, voters will see her come into power and inflation fall, cost of living under control, and she is sure to get all the credit to increase her popularity with the electorate ahead of the general election, isn’t she?

    The bottleneck will soon be LNG tankers. Invest in South Korean shipyard stocks - they will be working 3 shifts.
  • DM_AndyDM_Andy Posts: 1,241
    dixiedean said:

    Does anyone who isn't a supporter of Kemi Badenoch see any plausible way she wins this contest?

    If Truss completely bombs at the tv hustings, Kemi does excellently, then she only needs a few Truss supporters to switch to be in 3rd place on Monday. Makes the final two with Truss votes and beats Rishi. Maybe 10% chance?

  • Daveyboy1961Daveyboy1961 Posts: 4,505
    I'd like to know why all the broadcasters are giving free political advertising to the conservatives with these tv debates etc. I know a new PM is being discovered, but surely the tv commentators should be asking less about who can beat who and can appeal to 200,000 superannuated well off old fossils and 3 or 4 newspaper proprietors, and more about how they are going to deal with the crisis of the cost of living in this country affecting many millions?
  • MoonRabbitMoonRabbit Posts: 14,073

    She isn't out yet and may still win.

    I gave my numbers earlier. I'm not assuming that all Badenoch votes pile on Truss, if you did then she'd come first by a landslide.

    I estimated 60% of Badenoch and Braverman's votes transfer to Truss, and 60% of Tugendhat's to Mordaunt. With Sunak getting 30% of everyone's.

    That's just a finger in the air guesstimate but that leaves Mordaunt languishing in third by just a few votes.

    But she could come first, second or third depending upon how things play out. Nothing is certain.
    It is certain though, Truss campaign bombed, the Tory right are in disarray and don’t actual rate her. It’s not about maths Bart, she is languishing where she is because her natural voter base thinks she is rubbish, just like everyone everywhere thinks she’s rubbish. She delivered her campaign launch off her mobile phone reading half a line at a time, and then couldn’t even find her way out the room.

    Truss is like a bad actress in a bad drive in movie. Even if she takes her clothes off it won’t redeem the time invested in her.

    Meanwhile Penny is UKs next PM, this was decided days ago. It’s all over as a contest except the formalities.

    The media and the country at large have chosen Penny to replace Boris. It was all over days ago as a live contest.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 83,509
    edited July 2022
    CRYSTAL PALACE have sent a depleted squad on their pre-season tour with a number of un-jabbed players denied entry into Singapore. The Eagles face Liverpool in Singapore on Friday but Patrick Vieira will have just eight senior players to call on.

    Your bunch of wankers anti-vaxxers...
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,359
    .

    I'd like to know why all the broadcasters are giving free political advertising to the conservatives with these tv debates etc. I know a new PM is being discovered, but surely the tv commentators should be asking less about who can beat who and can appeal to 200,000 superannuated well off old fossils and 3 or 4 newspaper proprietors, and more about how they are going to deal with the crisis of the cost of living in this country affecting many millions?

    How much do you want to bet that cost of living won’t come up in the debates?
  • DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 30,192
    IshmaelZ said:

    I don't know. as I say, it would be great if those making the allegations would set out the evidence. Al looks very smeary at the moment. Agree about Truss and Cass.
    It's probably been said already (as I'm a couple of hours behind on this thread) but Liz Truss is also Minister for Women & Equalities.
    https://www.gov.uk/government/ministers
  • @LostPassword I am sorry to read that, I am hear if you need me having had my own struggles through lockdown, especially with mental health. I know how difficult it can be, I too thought I would sail through it but these things build up inside you over time.

    I will never tell you what to do because it isn't my place but counselling was a massive help for me, have you looked into this at all?
  • FlannerFlanner Posts: 437
    MattW said:

    BJ was born RC, and became Anglican at school aiui.

    Has he de-converted back?

    You can't conclude from his marriage at Westminster Cathedral unless there has been a specific statement. The RC Church have no problem with Protestants being married in an RC Church, but I think they may expect the children to be RC.
    There's a TON of confusions here:
    1. Carrie's Catholic, and their son Wilfrid was baptised a Catholic.
    2. Under Catholic doctrine, Johnson never became Anglican. He just dallied with a heretical religion in his youth - a sin, but not an act of self-excommunication.
    3. So there'd be no novelty about Penny being PM and a Catholic. Nor would there be any constitutional issues: it'd just raise the kind of admin complications that not having one of those written constitution nonsenses makes it a doddle to handle. Anglican episcopal nominations just get made by a tame official and passed on to Buckingham and Lambeth Palaces.

    Kilclooney's just another trouble-making Ulster Unionist spouting anything he can dream up to rubbish Papes. His Wiki entry is an extraordinary list of pig-ignorance and gratuitously offensive remarks against anyone he thinks might not share his views.
  • https://twitter.com/nadinebh_/status/1547889790040694787

    Penny Mordaunt tells Beth Rigby she believes cis-women have the right to exclude trans-women from single-sex spaces
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 19,161
    Sandpit said:

    You’d think that most of the Badenoch vote goes to Truss, rather than Sunak.

    A fair amount of the Braverman vote probably goes to Badenoch then to Truss, rather than to Truss directly in the next round too.
    I think some of the Badenoch vote will go to Mordaunt, as being a fresh start from the Johnson Cabinet.

    Given how lacklustre the numbers for Sunak and Truss have both been, and the early failure of other Cabinet contenders like Javid and Zahawi, I think the chances of a Truss/Sunak final two must be very slim. It will be Mordaunt vs another in my view, unless the debates shake things up
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,798
    IshmaelZ said:

    https://twitter.com/AlastairMeeks/status/1547911588333572097

    "Oof. Wrong to leave EU now 53%, a new high, right to leave 35%, a new low. Meanwhile the Tory leadership candidates compete to show their Brexit purity.

    The Brexit boat is close to capsizing. The point is rapidly approaching where the consensus is that Brexit is a mistake to be mitigated. The politicians are well behind this curve."

    I think he is right.

    That's quite a jump in a week. The only thing that might have caused that psychological shift is Boris leaving. Anything else?

  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 45,367

    CRYSTAL PALACE have sent a depleted squad on their pre-season tour with a number of un-jabbed players denied entry into Singapore. The Eagles face Liverpool in Singapore on Friday but Patrick Vieira will have just eight senior players to call on.

    Your bunch of wankers anti-vaxxers...

    Apparently three million adults remain unvaxxed in the UK
    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-62138545

    I fear expressing my views on them might get me a permaban...
  • DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 30,192
    Foxy said:

    Leicester will be pretty bad. We are a long way from the coast, and the city sits in a shallow bowl, with no wind and a petrochemical haze when we get a high pressure sitting over us. The hospital isn't air-conditioned (apart from a few management offices and the operating theatres). It will be pretty hellish...
    Leave some of these new AI stethoscopes in the waiting room and get the patients to diagnose themselves.

    FDA clears way for an AI stethoscope to detect heart disease
    Algorithm proves better than primary care doctors at recognizing signs of heart trouble

    https://www.theregister.com/2022/07/14/us_fda_approves_first_ai/
  • numbertwelvenumbertwelve Posts: 7,305
    DM_Andy said:

    If Truss completely bombs at the tv hustings, Kemi does excellently, then she only needs a few Truss supporters to switch to be in 3rd place on Monday. Makes the final two with Truss votes and beats Rishi. Maybe 10% chance?

    Yes that’s definitely the cleanest way through for her. The route is through a Truss collapse and significant Suella transfers, not through TT (IMHO).
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830

    It's probably been said already (as I'm a couple of hours behind on this thread) but Liz Truss is also Minister for Women & Equalities.
    https://www.gov.uk/government/ministers
    Thanks, good point

    The report itself says it was commissioned by NHS England, which I suppose is what gives wiggle room about who was "really behind it."
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,798
    A Mordaunt v Badenoch final would be ideal. Two plausible, persuasive, interesting candidates
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    Leon said:

    That's quite a jump in a week. The only thing that might have caused that psychological shift is Boris leaving. Anything else?
    First wave back from euro hols and pissed off about passport queues?

    Or outlier of course.
  • This Tory leadership contest seems to be designed to make the party look even more out of touch.

    The public want to know about CoL, they are fed up with Brexit and they think in hindsight it was a mistake.

    So the Tory leadership contest focusses on trans people and how great Brexit is.

    Anyone getting 2005 "are you thinking what we're thinking" vibes?
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 33,255
    MaxPB said:

    Maths, the known costs of healthcare, care and other costs (pensions, benefits) of keeping someone over 80 alive for an additional year is very high, multiply that by a big number and you get a huge ongoing saving.

    My contention that they are ungrateful is based on the polling support among the old for an NI rise they stand to benefit from which is being reaped from working age people. They are stealing from our generation because they don't want to stand the cost of their own care and healthcare. Fewer of them means less need for the theft.
    Utter bollocks. Given that there is little in the way of tax changes being considered or suggested by either Government that would affect the retired as much as it would affect those of working age all you are actually saying is that pensioners are terrible because they think taxes should rise. By wishing people dead simply because you have to pay a bit more tax you are a fuckwit of the first order. Maybe we should be hoping you will die before you get to retirement age so you can ease the burden on future generations.
  • Liz Truss commits to reversing the corporation tax hikes - that's far further than she's gone before and costs around £16bn a year

    She also announces a 'temporary moratorium' on the green energy levy on energy bills - she says that would save people £153 a year

    https://twitter.com/Steven_Swinford/status/1547922864380133376

    Oh look the magic money tree is back, if Labour announced this they would be rightly ripped to shreds.
  • RazedabodeRazedabode Posts: 3,106
    Leon said:

    That's quite a jump in a week. The only thing that might have caused that psychological shift is Boris leaving. Anything else?

    Or the public is generally sick and tired of the divisiveness in politics / in general with the EU (who on the whole we need good relations with)

    Hence why if the ERG and their love in with Frosty get their way and choose a candidate based on their “purist” Brexit agenda, they will be doomed at the next election

  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    This thread has

    rethought its position on Self ID

  • kjhkjh Posts: 12,520
    Leon said:

    I KNOW

    I'm already about 42 IQ points smarter than you when I'm a pathetic alky

    Imagine how embarrassing the gulf would be if I ever sobered up. Scary
    It is a well known fact that alcohol makes you think you are significantly better at stuff, whereas the reality is you are much worse. Sorry that +42 on the IQ is really a -42.
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 19,161
    edited July 2022
    IshmaelZ said:

    Really, you can't say that sort of thing about "the old" any more than you can say it about "the Jews." This is not a quibble: in both cases you are labelling a whole class whose membership of that class is determined 100% by accident of birth. I am not sure if I am old or not - I'm 60 - but I am as appalled as anyone by the loading of NI on to working age people.
    s/old/a majority of the old/gc
    And go fuck yourself for a meaningless nitpick over a shorthand. Especially a nitpick that tries to associate me with antisemitism.
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 19,161

    @LostPassword I am sorry to read that, I am hear if you need me having had my own struggles through lockdown, especially with mental health. I know how difficult it can be, I too thought I would sail through it but these things build up inside you over time.

    I will never tell you what to do because it isn't my place but counselling was a massive help for me, have you looked into this at all?

    I am speaking to a professional, yes. Thanks for checking.
  • DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 30,192

    I think Penny will just squeeze through, but some or all of the following probably need to happen:

    1. Some possible softness creeping in re Rishi’s support. She’d be in a much better place if she can tempt 5 or so switchers to come over from his campaign.

    2. Absorbing a lot of TT support. I’d be aiming for his endorsement.

    3. A strong performance at the debate.

    4. An ERG split between Kemi/Liz would be much more preferable than Liz absorbing Cruella’s votes. In the next round keeping second place is going to be very important psychologically.

    Honestly though I am hopeful that Tory MPs realise over the weekend that a final 2 without Penny in it risks PM Truss under the influence of the ERG, and that is a situation they have to avoid at all costs.
    No, a final two with Truss in it is what risks Truss winning.
  • DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 30,192

    It’s definitely not impossible.

    He’s 19 short. People are assuming he can pick those up from the TT campaign but let’s say the lions share goes to PM, he is then relying on some Kemi and Suella switchers in the same way as Penny is.

    In the meantime let’s say he has some poor debates and some more sub-optimal polling lands over the weekend.

    Do a few MPs get nervous? Maybe start looking for a different horse?

    Liz v Penny appears to me to be a perfectly possible end result. A bit of a shocker, but it wouldn’t take much to happen.


    Not much of a shocker. Rishi is 1/3 to make the final two, so 3/1 to miss out, or a 25 per cent chance in new money.
  • I’m at my mate’s where I’ve been helping with gardening again (I’ve been here pretty much every weekend since I got home from my holiday in April) and I realised I hadn’t delighted you all with a report on my progress for a while

    The potatoes and onions have grown well and are now being eaten; there should be enough to last until at least the end of September. We’ve also got fifteen tomato plants that have all got their first fruit nearly ready, thirty pea plants that we’ve had a load of mange tout from and some peas nearly there, three kinds of courgette (two each of normal, yellow and “8-ball”), about a hundred spring onions, and ten runner beans. We’ve also got various salad leaves, a couple of cucumbers and a few kinds of squash/pumpkin that I didn’t bother getting pictures of.

    I’d suggest MorrisDancing if anyone wants to reply to me to avoid repeating the photos!









  • X on next thread
  • DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 30,192
    dixiedean said:

    Does anyone who isn't a supporter of Kemi Badenoch see any plausible way she wins this contest?

    Truss implodes during the debates and her backers switch to Kemi. Or Kemi takes the Mrs Thatcher route of being elected by mistake if enough people use her as a protest or message vote.

    Is Kemi the new Nigel Farage? A charismatic and persuasive speaker with firm opinions about things they know nothing about.
  • FlatlanderFlatlander Posts: 4,922

    Thinking longer term about temperature in buildings: For some years I have argued that it would make economic sense -- in some buildings and some climates -- to have roofs that became reflective in hot weather, and absorbent in cold weather. I can think of several ways to do that, but have never tried to go beyond the basic concept because I don't have the technical knowledge to explore them, and don't want to take months out of my retirement to acquire it.

    But if you do, feel free to use this "chameleon roof" idea.

    I suspect (no calculations) that using solar roof tiles to power a reversible heat pump would be more effective.

    These are actually a thing now although they aren't cheap.
This discussion has been closed.