Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Biden’s national poll lead remains and the swing state surveys are looking positive – politicalbetti

1567911

Comments

  • Sorry Casino I normally agree with you but can't here. Necessity is the mother of invention, if we had gone into May's deal the customs union would have been permanent as we'd never get the differentials digitised. Without it being necessary it would never happen.

    It is only because of the deadline that this is becoming real.
    I think we would. That aspiration was written into the WA and would have been governed by the joint committee.

    My Brexit is based on realpolitik and tough but fair compromises of economic convenience/disruption versus independence/freedom that work in the real world.

    But, I ended up falling down the middle between the two warring extremes.

    (Doesn't help that Theresa May couldn't sell water to a man dying of thirst either)
  • rcs1000 said:

    There is one enormous difference between now and 2016: the national poll picture.

    On September 23rd 2016, Ms Clinton was averaging 42.5% in the 538 poll of polls.

    On September 23rd 2018, Mr Biden is eight points ahead of that at 50.5%.
    The key question for me is this. If we cannot rely on the state polls (they may err in favour of Trump, or in favour of Biden, or a mix from vendor to vendor) then what is the maximum national poll deficit that Trump can concede and still have a shot at winning the Electoral College?
  • FlatlanderFlatlander Posts: 4,918
    edited September 2020
    DougSeal said:

    Dido is music for people who don't like music.
    Dunno, I quite like Purcell, although he's probably a bit old fashioned for some.
  • The Government are trying to scream blue murder at the public in the hope this changes behaviour so no further official tightening is necessary.

    Trouble is that even if it's 90% effective it probably won't be enough as just a small handful of superspreaders can transmit it to hundreds in days.
    The other trouble is it will take at least 2-3 weeks to know if this week's messages are working. Even if they do work then can the Government hold its nerve for that long?
  • DougSeal said:

    You also promised in your manifesto that 80 per cent of UK trade would be covered by free trade agreements by the end of 2022, starting with the USA, Australia, New Zealand and Japan. That promise was disingenuous at best.

    The only way to get to 80% of our trade being covered by FTAs is through an FTA with the EU. Because if we don't, then even if we sign FTA's with the rest of the planet then we only have 55-60% of our trade covered - the missing 40-45% being with the EU - unless we more than halve the trade we have with the EU. That sort of massive realignment cannot happen in three years without wholesale disruption that loses votes.

    Anyway, we're nearly a third of the way through the three year period and, of the listed countries, only Japan is in the bag, 2% of our trade. Only 78% to go and you are trashing more than half of that.

    Some would say that governing should be about the preserving the peace and welfare of the governed - not about cherry picking promises from manifestos in order to make culture war points.
    To be fair the Government is trying to do that and pursuing FTAs with all of those at present.

    It's also agreed continuity agreements with more than you list including South Africa, East Africa, Switzerland etc.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 54,198
    UK cases - by specimen date -

    image
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 54,198
    UK cases by specimen date, and scaled to 100K population

    image
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,714
    DougSeal said:

    You also promised in your manifesto that 80 per cent of UK trade would be covered by free trade agreements by the end of 2022, starting with the USA, Australia, New Zealand and Japan. That promise was disingenuous at best.

    The only way to get to 80% of our trade being covered by FTAs is through an FTA with the EU. Because if we don't, then even if we sign FTA's with the rest of the planet then we only have 55-60% of our trade covered - the missing 40-45% being with the EU - unless we more than halve the trade we have with the EU. That sort of massive realignment cannot happen in three years without wholesale disruption that loses votes.

    Anyway, we're nearly a third of the way through the three year period and, of the listed countries, only Japan is in the bag, 2% of our trade. Only 78% to go and you are trashing more than half of that.

    Some would say that governing should be about the preserving the peace and welfare of the governed - not about cherry picking promises from manifestos in order to make culture war points.
    HYUFD went into there are no tanks mode some time back.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 54,198
    UK Cases summary

    image
    image
    image
  • The key question for me is this. If we cannot rely on the state polls (they may err in favour of Trump, or in favour of Biden, or a mix from vendor to vendor) then what is the maximum national poll deficit that Trump can concede and still have a shot at winning the Electoral College?
    I think Trump can lose the popular vote by 4% and still win the electoral college.

    4% would require near perfect vote distribution, but a 2-3% deficit should see him home.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 54,198
    UK Hospitals

    image
    image
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 127,038
    edited September 2020
    rcs1000 said:

    There is one enormous difference between now and 2016: the national poll picture.

    On September 23rd 2016, Ms Clinton was averaging 42.5% in the 538 poll of polls.

    On September 23rd 2018, Mr Biden is eight points ahead of that at 50.5%.
    On September 23rd 2016 Trump was averaging just 39% with 538

    Today Trump is averaging 45.9% with 538 ie 7% ahead of where he was in 2016
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 55,180
    Omnium said:

    Nice that you've nailed that down so conclusively.
    Not so sure what the nose painting is about. Maybe you had to be there.
  • DougSealDougSeal Posts: 12,746

    To be fair the Government is trying to do that and pursuing FTAs with all of those at present.

    It's also agreed continuity agreements with more than you list including South Africa, East Africa, Switzerland etc.
    Great, that gets us to 60% at absolute maximum, not the promised/indicated 80%.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 54,198
    UK deaths

    image
    image
    image
    image
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 127,038
    DougSeal said:

    Trafalgar has Biden up by 3 in PA this time round.
    True but Trafalgar still has Trump ahead in Michigan and also has Trump ahead in Wisconsin
  • The key question for me is this. If we cannot rely on the state polls (they may err in favour of Trump, or in favour of Biden, or a mix from vendor to vendor) then what is the maximum national poll deficit that Trump can concede and still have a shot at winning the Electoral College?
    I don't understand how Trump is even in contention in the marginals considering how far behind he is in the national polls.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 127,038
    DougSeal said:

    You also promised in your manifesto that 80 per cent of UK trade would be covered by free trade agreements by the end of 2022, starting with the USA, Australia, New Zealand and Japan. That promise was disingenuous at best.

    The only way to get to 80% of our trade being covered by FTAs is through an FTA with the EU. Because if we don't, then even if we sign FTA's with the rest of the planet then we only have 55-60% of our trade covered - the missing 40-45% being with the EU - unless we more than halve the trade we have with the EU. That sort of massive realignment cannot happen in three years without wholesale disruption that loses votes.

    Anyway, we're nearly a third of the way through the three year period and, of the listed countries, only Japan is in the bag, 2% of our trade. Only 78% to go and you are trashing more than half of that.

    Some would say that governing should be about the preserving the peace and welfare of the governed - not about cherry picking promises from manifestos in order to make culture war points.
    Governing is about winning an election to deliver your manifesto mainly, not about creating universal utopia
  • Scott_xPScott_xP Posts: 38,111
    DougSeal said:

    Dido is music for people who don't like music.

    Still better than Radiohead...
  • MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 39,820

    The Government are trying to scream blue murder at the public in the hope this changes behaviour so no further official tightening is necessary.

    Trouble is that even if it's 90% effective it probably won't be enough as just a small handful of superspreaders can transmit it to hundreds in days.
    This is why we need to start talking about separation rather than isolation. Even if the government pays people £60 or £70 per day in separation it's going to be seriously more effective than self certified isolation after a positive result. That case in Bolton should have had alarm bells ringing because he isn't alone in ignoring isolation due to "feeling fine".
  • Scott_xP said:

    Still better than Radiohead...
    Oh, you're inviting a stare off with the ban hammer with language like that.
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,884
    The worrying thing about the Scottish CV19 case figures is that today's big jump is due in large part to Glasgow, where the current national no household mixing rule was already in place. Suggests maybe a low level of compliance in parts of that city?
  • I think we would. That aspiration was written into the WA and would have been governed by the joint committee.

    My Brexit is based on realpolitik and tough but fair compromises of economic convenience/disruption versus independence/freedom that work in the real world.

    But, I ended up falling down the middle between the two warring extremes.

    (Doesn't help that Theresa May couldn't sell water to a man dying of thirst either)
    Agreed about May. With a tougher leader from the outset compromises may have been possible from the start but it needed someone to show leadership on our side. In the vacuum May left both extremes took it upon themselves to set their stalls out and would only be happy once they'd vanquished the other. Which ended up happening.

    I have more optimism for compromises to be agreed now with Europe, precisely because Parliament-wise the UK is finally more united. The hard leavers vanquished the die hard Remainers, from Grieve through TIG and even the LDs lost their leader and have abandoned being pro Remain.
  • DougSeal said:

    Great, that gets us to 60% at absolute maximum, not the promised/indicated 80%.
    It's Government policy to get a trade deal with the EU.
  • DougSeal said:

    Dido is music for people who don't like music.
    It's not so bad.

    Not so bad.
  • HYUFD said:

    The government is simply applying the same points system to EU immigrants as to non EU immigrants when the implementation period ends and that was exactly what the Tories 2019 manifesto promised to do
    There will be no change then. The big deception has always been that the Conservatives when in government have had full control over 50% of immigration even when we were part of the EU, ie. non-EU migration. They did nothing to control it then. Now we have the most incompetent Conservative Government in history, I cannot see it improving. We will probably just have more immigrants from the Indian subcontinent and less from Poland.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 20,170
    Tip for those stockpiling: Morrisons is selling Filippo Berio Extra Virgin Olive Oil for £3.50 per 750ml. Fill your boots.
  • UK cases - by specimen date -

    image

    The North/South divide remains and is extraordinary
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,714

    Dunno, I quite like Purcell, although he's probably a bit old fashioned for some.
    The Dido we're talking about is to management what Hannan is to intellectuals.
  • contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818
    FF43 said:

    The worrying thing about the Scottish CV19 case figures is that today's big jump is due in large part to Glasgow, where the current national no household mixing rule was already in place. Suggests maybe a low level of compliance in parts of that city?

    or the measures are total boll8x....
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 43,703
    FF43 said:

    The worrying thing about the Scottish CV19 case figures is that today's big jump is due in large part to Glasgow, where the current national no household mixing rule was already in place. Suggests maybe a low level of compliance in parts of that city?

    Or a transmission method that isn't to do with that. Schools perhaps.

    Opening the schools was always going to increase case incidence and so it has come to pass.

    The key is for the govt(s) to be upfront with the public.

    Their policy (which as I said I have applauded) of opening schools will have knock on effects elsewhere. They need to explain what these knock on effects will be.

    Rather than blaming the public for non-conformance of the rules/guidance/law/regulation.
  • OmniumOmnium Posts: 11,480

    The Home Counties' answer to the DMZ.
    Nobody's going to fight to get into Kent!

    Even William the Conqueror decided that it could be circumvented. I've no idea how many lorries were parked there at the time, but enough is enough. Those early SatNavs though were quite bad. The Spanish finished up in the Americas when all they wanted was to seize the Isle of Wight. Thus imagining total primitives they were a bit shocked!
  • Off topic, it's no wonder there's a crisis in care homes.

    I went to one this afternoon (it's a direct neighbour) to hand deliver a letter to the manager about an overhanging tree on my property.

    The security was as lax as fuck. No gate to the drive. Front door totally unlocked (and open) just a printer sign saying voters weren't to walk in (I could easily have done so).

    I followed arrows round the back (where visitors are supposed to go) got totally lost and found two cleaners/carers having a fag and a laugh out the side of a garden room - sharing phones and pictures on them - no masks. No visors. Nothing. I asked them politely and they kindly took my letter.

    But, never put your parents in one of those - ever - unless you have absolutely no alternative. They'll bankrupt you but, most importantly, they're simply not safe.
  • There will be no change then. The big deception has always been that the Conservatives when in government have had full control over 50% of immigration even when we were part of the EU, ie. non-EU migration. They did nothing to control it then. Now we have the most incompetent Conservative Government in history, I cannot see it improving. We will probably just have more immigrants from the Indian subcontinent and less from Poland.
    That's just not true. Non EU migration has been under draconian controls for a long time. Even British citizens living overseas married for decades with children have major hoops to jump through if they want to move here with their spouse.
  • Nigelb said:

    The Dido we're talking about is to management what Hannan is to intellectuals.
    She is to management effectiveness what Boris Johnson is to honesty and statesmanship lol.
  • kjhkjh Posts: 12,509

    Tip for those stockpiling: Morrisons is selling Filippo Berio Extra Virgin Olive Oil for £3.50 per 750ml. Fill your boots.

    Oh yuk, that will be very messy.
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670

    6,178!

    Dan Hodges will be polishing a graph as we speak.
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    DavidL said:

    Maybe the Scottish figures are not so out of line after all. Which just might be good news for the schools.

    Locally it is the return of students that is being blamed. A Freshers party at St Andrews seems to have caused a fairly significant outbreak, Glasgow University is bad and Abertay here in Dundee has cases in the student population as well.
    My wife has crunched the numbers and it looks like this week's surge is being driven by very specifically 18 and 19 year olds.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,714

    Tip for those stockpiling: Morrisons is selling Filippo Berio Extra Virgin Olive Oil for £3.50 per 750ml. Fill your boots.

    Odd thing to do with olive oil.
  • October, which is next week.
    The Halloween gear is on the supermarket shelves, though HMG may by then have banned trick or treating, even with masks.
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 34,563
    edited September 2020

    Agreed about May. With a tougher leader from the outset compromises may have been possible from the start but it needed someone to show leadership on our side. In the vacuum May left both extremes took it upon themselves to set their stalls out and would only be happy once they'd vanquished the other. Which ended up happening.

    I have more optimism for compromises to be agreed now with Europe, precisely because Parliament-wise the UK is finally more united. The hard leavers vanquished the die hard Remainers, from Grieve through TIG and even the LDs lost their leader and have abandoned being pro Remain.
    One can't be Remain; we've left, so someone will, once some semblance of normal politics returns, campaign for Sanity and Rejoin.
  • kjhkjh Posts: 12,509
    Nigelb said:

    Odd thing to do with olive oil.
    Snap
  • Alistair said:

    My wife has crunched the numbers and it looks like this week's surge is being driven by very specifically 18 and 19 year olds.
    It isn't schools.

    It isn't households mingling.

    It is Freshers Flu.
  • contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818
    Bloomberg saying planned UK budget this autumn is cancelled.

    Because many tory MPs would not vote for it???
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,714
    kjh said:

    Snap
    You squelch around, too ?
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 121,664
    edited September 2020
    Alistair said:

    Dan Hodges will be polishing a graph as we speak.
    Will it be impressive as the inevitable Alistair Hames trend line showing no uptick but a decline?
  • eekeek Posts: 29,735

    Bloomberg saying planned UK budget this autumn is cancelled.

    Because many tory MPs would not vote for it???

    I thought we knew that - as I'm sure I posted that last week - it's delayed until the Spring by which time they may have a clue WTF is going on.
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,884
    Scott_xP said:
    Once he becomes Dear Leader, the independent state previously known as Kent will be renamed Faragia
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,714

    It isn't schools.

    It isn't households mingling.

    It is Freshers Flu.
    First confirmed case in my wife's primary school today.
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670

    The key question for me is this. If we cannot rely on the state polls (they may err in favour of Trump, or in favour of Biden, or a mix from vendor to vendor) then what is the maximum national poll deficit that Trump can concede and still have a shot at winning the Electoral College?
    How realistic do you want it? I have a spreadsheet dubbed "The Nightmare Scenario" where Biden has a 7 point national lead and due to over performance in California, New York and Georgia (but falling short) combined with underperformance in the Rust Belt Trump wins.

    With a 7 point national deficit.
  • FeersumEnjineeyaFeersumEnjineeya Posts: 4,761
    edited September 2020

    Agreed about May. With a tougher leader from the outset compromises may have been possible from the start but it needed someone to show leadership on our side. In the vacuum May left both extremes took it upon themselves to set their stalls out and would only be happy once they'd vanquished the other. Which ended up happening.

    I have more optimism for compromises to be agreed now with Europe, precisely because Parliament-wise the UK is finally more united. The hard leavers vanquished the die hard Remainers, from Grieve through TIG and even the LDs lost their leader and have abandoned being pro Remain.
    The LDs didn't "abandon" being pro Remain; they lost the battle to remain. Big difference! The LDs are, of course, still of the opinion that Brexit will be little short of disastrous for the UK, but there is little that they can do now other than to be ready to help with picking up the pieces of a shattered economy.
  • kjhkjh Posts: 12,509
    Nigelb said:

    You squelch around, too ?
    I mean what else would you do with Olive Oil?
  • eekeek Posts: 29,735

    It isn't schools.

    It isn't households mingling.

    It is Freshers Flu.
    Too early for that - outside of Scotland, Freshers week only started on Monday (of this week)
  • isamisam Posts: 41,317
    Scott_xP said:
    3/1 against I'd say, rather than 3/1 on

  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 79,227
    eek said:

    Too early for that - outside of Scotland, Freshers week only started on Monday (of this week)
    Pre-freshers
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 43,703

    It isn't schools.

    It isn't households mingling.

    It is Freshers Flu.
    All part of education of young people.

    The question is what will the government say must be given up in exchange? And will they give us a straight answer.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,714
    Scott_xP said:
    Still strangely fond of gambling, apparently.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 20,170
    @kjh and @Nigelb touché. :D

    I should have said “fill your avocado and quinoa salads”.
  • OmniumOmnium Posts: 11,480

    One can't be Remain; we've left, so someone will, once some semblance of normal politics returns, campaign for Sanity and Rejoin.
    Sanity and rejoining seem somewhat estranged to me.

    The UK can't rejoin, number one because the EU's broken bits are quite how the UK described them, and number 2 because the UK has blown its bridges to the good bits,

    (My guess) The EU will fail. A slightly less arsy EU will then emerge and succeed.
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    FF43 said:

    The worrying thing about the Scottish CV19 case figures is that today's big jump is due in large part to Glasgow, where the current national no household mixing rule was already in place. Suggests maybe a low level of compliance in parts of that city?

    University of Glasgow Fresher's Week 12th September-18th September
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 20,170
    edited September 2020
    Scott_xP said:
    Nah @Philip_Thompson seems to think Italy are queuing up to copy our test and trace system instead, as it’s the best.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,714

    @kjh and @Nigelb touché. :D

    I should have said “fill your avocado and quinoa salads”.

    That would still be firkin ridiculous.
  • Nigelb said:

    First confirmed case in my wife's primary school today.
    Precisely. It may hit schools but the numbers are miniscule so far there.

    It's Freshers Flu I bet. Students have moved into accomodation and this happens every damn year. Not their fault, but I bet it's what is behind the bulk of it.

    It matches the figures saying young adults, not children, are behind the spike. The Government would be well advised to tell students who are living on campus to stay on campus until the end of term and to try not to go home for weekends.
  • It isn't schools.

    It isn't households mingling.

    It is Freshers Flu.
    A bit early for students to have caught the virus, developed the disease and been tested, isn't it? When did they go back? I thought it was last week or even this.
  • kjhkjh Posts: 12,509

    @kjh and @Nigelb touché. :D

    I should have said “fill your avocado and quinoa salads”.

    I think you should take the credit. You set it up nicely for us.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 20,170

    A bit early for students to have caught the virus, developed the disease and been tested, isn't it? When did they go back? I thought it was last week or even this.
    This week OR next week.
  • NY POST - MAN HAS KEPT NIXON'S HALF-EATEN SANDWICH FOR 60 YEARS

    Steve Jenne, from the small town of Sullivan [Illinois], was a 14-year-old Boy Scout when the then-vice president made a campaign stop to Jenne’s hometown on Sept. 22, 1960.

    Ahead of a speech at Wyman Park, Nixon was served a barbecue buffalo sandwich on a paper plate during a cookout and when he was finished, Jenne snatched up the leftovers.

    “He took a couple of bites and commented on how tasty, how good it was,” Jenne, whose Boy Scout troop was asked to serve as an honor guard for Nixon during the cookout, told the [Decatur, IL] Herald & Review.

    “Once he left, I just looked down at the picnic table and everybody else was gone and that half-eaten sandwich was still on the paper plate,” Jenne recalled.

    “I looked around and thought, ‘If no one else was going to take it, I am going to take it,’” he told the news outlet.

    With Nixon’s half-eaten sandwich in tow, Jenne hopped on his bicycle and sped home to show his mom his unique souvenir.

    “I ran in the door and I said, ‘Mom, I got the sandwich that Nixon took a couple bites out of,’ and she was surprised and said, ‘So, what do you want me to do with it?’ So I said, ‘Freeze it,’” Jenne explained.

    Jenne’s mother, “in her infinite wisdom,” then wrapped up the sandwich in a plastic bag, put it inside a Musselman’s apple sauce jar and “stuck it in the freezer,” he said.

    “And that’s the way it still is today,” said Jenne, who now lives in Springfield.

    Ever since, Jenne has kept the Nixon-eaten sandwich frozen — and it once earned him a guest appearance on an episode of the “Tonight Show” with television legend Johnny Carson in 1988.

    Jenne even published a book this year called “The Sandwich That Changed My Life!” about the wacky story.

    “As long as I am living, that sandwich will be stored in my freezer in a container that is labeled, ‘Save, don’t throw away,’ ” Jenne said.

    https://nypost.com/2020/09/22/man-has-kept-richard-nixons-half-eaten-sandwich-for-60-years/
  • TOPPING said:

    All part of education of young people.

    The question is what will the government say must be given up in exchange? And will they give us a straight answer.
    Perhaps nothing should be given up, except trips home. Deal with the issue and burn it out. The students are pretty safe, they need to be helped to stay contained in their accomodation and not spread it far and wide.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,714

    Precisely. It may hit schools but the numbers are miniscule so far there...
    And you know this how ?

  • This week OR next week.
    I think Scotland students went back 2 weeks ago
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,939
    Nigelb said:

    First confirmed case in my wife's primary school today.
    Youngest tells me his is the only high school in the county without a positive.
    Not sure of the veracity, but that schools are playing no part seems a bold conclusion.
  • eek said:

    Too early for that - outside of Scotland, Freshers week only started on Monday (of this week)
    A lot of students move into accomodation weeks before Freshers Week. In my town they moved in a few weeks ago despite it only starting this week.
  • isamisam Posts: 41,317
    My Dad had a cancer op last Oct, became a Grandfather for the first time in Nov, and got Sepsis in Dec. Obviously he was in the vulnerable group during lockdown.

    He says being with his Grandson has made him happier than he has ever been in his life (bit of a diss on his son), and he comes round at every opportunity to take him for a walk. So what do we do, tell him to stay away?
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 20,170

    Precisely. It may hit schools but the numbers are miniscule so far there.

    It's Freshers Flu I bet. Students have moved into accomodation and this happens every damn year. Not their fault, but I bet it's what is behind the bulk of it.

    It matches the figures saying young adults, not children, are behind the spike. The Government would be well advised to tell students who are living on campus to stay on campus until the end of term and to try not to go home for weekends.
    Only 1st year students tend to live in student accommodation. Otherwise they live amongst the community. In Jesmond or Heaton in Newcastle, in Edgebaston or Selly Oak in Birmingham, in Fallowfield or Withington in Manchester. Clearly you don’t know what you’re talking about.
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,884
    edited September 2020
    Omnium said:

    Sanity and rejoining seem somewhat estranged to me.

    The UK can't rejoin, number one because the EU's broken bits are quite how the UK described them, and number 2 because the UK has blown its bridges to the good bits,

    (My guess) The EU will fail. A slightly less arsy EU will then emerge and succeed.
    I don't think either that the UK will rejoin the EU or that it will fail. Sullen "Vassal State" status is the most likely medium to long term outurn IMO. Constantly fighting the EU is too tiring and damaging so we will just go along with it, while resenting them telling us what to do. It's really not a good place to have got into.

    Having said that, it is a genuinely fascinating conundrum about how the Brexit contradiction gets resolved, if it ever does.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,714

    NY POST - MAN HAS KEPT NIXON'S HALF-EATEN SANDWICH FOR 60 YEARS

    Steve Jenne, from the small town of Sullivan [Illinois], was a 14-year-old Boy Scout when the then-vice president made a campaign stop to Jenne’s hometown on Sept. 22, 1960.

    Ahead of a speech at Wyman Park, Nixon was served a barbecue buffalo sandwich on a paper plate during a cookout and when he was finished, Jenne snatched up the leftovers.

    “He took a couple of bites and commented on how tasty, how good it was,” Jenne, whose Boy Scout troop was asked to serve as an honor guard for Nixon during the cookout, told the [Decatur, IL] Herald & Review.

    “Once he left, I just looked down at the picnic table and everybody else was gone and that half-eaten sandwich was still on the paper plate,” Jenne recalled.

    “I looked around and thought, ‘If no one else was going to take it, I am going to take it,’” he told the news outlet.

    With Nixon’s half-eaten sandwich in tow, Jenne hopped on his bicycle and sped home to show his mom his unique souvenir.

    “I ran in the door and I said, ‘Mom, I got the sandwich that Nixon took a couple bites out of,’ and she was surprised and said, ‘So, what do you want me to do with it?’ So I said, ‘Freeze it,’” Jenne explained.

    Jenne’s mother, “in her infinite wisdom,” then wrapped up the sandwich in a plastic bag, put it inside a Musselman’s apple sauce jar and “stuck it in the freezer,” he said.

    “And that’s the way it still is today,” said Jenne, who now lives in Springfield.

    Ever since, Jenne has kept the Nixon-eaten sandwich frozen — and it once earned him a guest appearance on an episode of the “Tonight Show” with television legend Johnny Carson in 1988.

    Jenne even published a book this year called “The Sandwich That Changed My Life!” about the wacky story.

    “As long as I am living, that sandwich will be stored in my freezer in a container that is labeled, ‘Save, don’t throw away,’ ” Jenne said.

    https://nypost.com/2020/09/22/man-has-kept-richard-nixons-half-eaten-sandwich-for-60-years/

    Do we know what happened to the Milliband butty ?
    Of far greater historical significance.
  • Bloomberg saying planned UK budget this autumn is cancelled.

    Because many tory MPs would not vote for it???

    No.
  • FeersumEnjineeyaFeersumEnjineeya Posts: 4,761
    edited September 2020

    Perhaps nothing should be given up, except trips home. Deal with the issue and burn it out. The students are pretty safe, they need to be helped to stay contained in their accomodation and not spread it far and wide.
    Many students have part-time jobs alongside their studies. A concrete step might be to pay them to stay away from work, but I doubt that the government is sufficiently well organised to take actual action.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 51,106

    Sorry Casino I normally agree with you but can't here. Necessity is the mother of invention, if we had gone into May's deal the customs union would have been permanent as we'd never get the differentials digitised. Without it being necessary it would never happen.

    It is only because of the deadline that this is becoming real.
    Still a better outcome than where we appear headed
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 43,703

    Perhaps nothing should be given up, except trips home. Deal with the issue and burn it out. The students are pretty safe, they need to be helped to stay contained in their accomodation and not spread it far and wide.
    Perhaps you are right. But do you think Boris will opt for that, or to lockdown the country?
  • Only 1st year students tend to live in student accommodation. Otherwise they live amongst the community. In Jesmond or Heaton in Newcastle, in Edgebaston or Selly Oak in Birmingham, in Fallowfield or Withington in Manchester. Clearly you don’t know what you’re talking about.
    I know what I'm talking about. And it's many of those ones in the community who will have moved into their (often shared) accomodation weeks ago too.

    Perhaps I misphrased things by emphasising campus which I didn't mean to do. I meant those living away from home. Eg a student who has moved from their home town to student accomodation in Manchester should probably be advised to stay in Manchester and not travel back home for the weekend.
  • MangoMango Posts: 1,031
    MaxPB said:

    Honestly, this is exactly the kind of shit Trump lives for. A British establishment figure that no one really likes any more chatting shit about the US election. This is exactly like Obama telling the UK about being at the back of the queue etc... It's just completely counterproductive.
    Strange then that the Telegraph is shouting it so loudly, unless...
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 43,703
    isam said:

    My Dad had a cancer op last Oct, became a Grandfather for the first time in Nov, and got Sepsis in Dec. Obviously he was in the vulnerable group during lockdown.

    He says being with his Grandson has made him happier than he has ever been in his life (bit of a diss on his son), and he comes round at every opportunity to take him for a walk. So what do we do, tell him to stay away?

    Blimey the fact that he has come through sepsis is cause for celebration on its own - very pleased to hear that.

    As for your question? He is a grown up and I have no doubt he will make the best decision for him as to whether he prefers to be with his family or on his own.

    As should be the case more widely.

    Of course, the absolute tragedy (as we have seen very sadly this morning with @Dura_Ace) is that places which are supposed to be safe and where such a decision process should not be necessary - ie a hospital - are fucking well not.
  • Bloomberg saying planned UK budget this autumn is cancelled.

    Because many tory MPs would not vote for it???

    The numbers are so bad that Rishi doesn't want to read them out.
  • Government clarification: "Chauffeur-driven cars will be exempt from the laws enforcing passengers to wear masks in taxis"

    Well thank feck for that.
  • DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 30,171
    edited September 2020
    isam said:

    My Dad had a cancer op last Oct, became a Grandfather for the first time in Nov, and got Sepsis in Dec. Obviously he was in the vulnerable group during lockdown.

    He says being with his Grandson has made him happier than he has ever been in his life (bit of a diss on his son), and he comes round at every opportunity to take him for a walk. So what do we do, tell him to stay away?

    Add him to your bubble; put the boy in the pram/buggy yourself; IANAQuack.

    ETA the buggy means they are socially-distanced anyway so just ban hugging, kissing and nappy-changing!
  • The UK may be 'weeks behind' its target of 500,000 tests a day due to a shortage of vital chemicals and analysing machines, it has been revealed.

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8764767/Boris-Johnsons-target-carrying-500-000-coronavirus-tests-day-threat.html

    Reagent shortage again. Apparently US test turnaround times have slowed to a crawl because of this.
  • Only 1st year students tend to live in student accommodation. Otherwise they live amongst the community. In Jesmond or Heaton in Newcastle, in Edgebaston or Selly Oak in Birmingham, in Fallowfield or Withington in Manchester. Clearly you don’t know what you’re talking about.
    There is no community in many of those areas. Just student lets. Essentially a terraced hall of residence.
  • isam said:

    My Dad had a cancer op last Oct, became a Grandfather for the first time in Nov, and got Sepsis in Dec. Obviously he was in the vulnerable group during lockdown.

    He says being with his Grandson has made him happier than he has ever been in his life (bit of a diss on his son), and he comes round at every opportunity to take him for a walk. So what do we do, tell him to stay away?

    No. Meet up with him outside and allow them to have time together (where curtain twitching neighbours can't see you).
This discussion has been closed.