politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Who will be Sir Keir Starmer’s successor?

My 25/1 tip as next Labour leader.
Comments
-
Already considering Sir Kier's replacement?
In the words of Blue Eyes - You're riding high in April, shot down in May.
That's Life!1 -
More money to be made laying David Miliband?0
-
I don't believe he said all of Sweden, he said parts e.g. Stockholm.ukpaul said:
https://mrc-ide.github.io/covid19estimates/#/details/SwedenAndy_JS said:"Stockholm will reach 'herd immunity' within weeks
Claim comes amid bitter debate over success of Sweden's relaxed approach
Sweden's infectious diseases chief has said parts of the country could achieve "herd immunity" as early as next month as debate rages over the rising death toll." (£)
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/04/18/stockholm-will-reach-herd-immunity-within-weeks
Estimated at 11% a few days ago.0 -
FPT Absolutely agree with that Floater
My hospital now has 26 of 32 ventilators in use and has had 63 deaths in last 3 weeks
High point was 13/4/20 when only 1 vent was spare
The pre Covid Vent capacity was 22 so still using some of boosted Capacity
These people who obsess about ending the already looser than some countries "lockdown" have their priorities completely wrong.2 -
I'm not being greedy, there's only so many times you can milk a (cash) cow.Sandpit said:More money to be made laying David Miliband?
Why do you think I'm not laying Hillary Clinton anymore for the Dem nomination?0 -
I posted about this 2-3 days ago. A BBC blue checkmark tweeted about how something strange going on there, and a US based Chinese journalist (who is anti CCP) also talking about it.Floater said:1 -
FPT:
Before we all got caught up in the current panic, there was a huge news story about the Indian government's attempts to re-register everyone. There's at least tens of millions of Indians who have no record of their life anywhere official. It could actually turn out to be hundreds of millions of completely undocumented people.IshmaelZ said:Sigh, can't get the quotes straight. I said:
I didn't say that, it's a quoting cockup. And i entirely agree with you. I read somewhere reasonably authoritative that 30 % of all deaths in India are not formally recorded anywhere, and only 25% have the cause of death certified by a doctor.
HYUFD has never been anywhere in the third world. He doesn't realise that they do things differently there.0 -
Nandy at 18/1 worth a punt also I think.0
-
Is the more important split in the Tory party not between Leave and Remain but between China hawks and doves?
https://twitter.com/dailymailuk/status/1251824117482913797?s=210 -
-
So nearly 22,000 tests yesterday but Capacity is now approaching 40,000. Time for all those NHS staff treating Covid 19 patients to get their tests whether or not they are symptomatic0
-
Andy Burnham or Dan Jarvis.0
-
Has anyone seen Roger on here lately? I assume he's self-isolating in one of his twelve mansions?1
-
Boris who?Scott_xP said:0 -
We defintely need to start treating more non Covid patients who must he suffering nowbigjohnowls said:FPT Absolutely agree with that Floater
My hospital now has 26 of 32 ventilators in use and has had 63 deaths in last 3 weeks
High point was 13/4/20 when only 1 vent was spare
The pre Covid Vent capacity was 22 so still using some of boosted Capacity
These people who obsess about ending the already looser than some countries "lockdown" have their priorities completely wrong.0 -
I don't think we have heard from him since before the GE. He didn't even do his usual (and one time a year where his predictions are worth taking notice of) Oscars piece.GIN1138 said:Has anyone seen Roger on here lately? I assume he's self-isolating in one of his twelve mansions?
1 -
The former for meCorrectHorseBattery said:Andy Burnham or Dan Jarvis.
The contrast in the performance of the 2 mayors is stark0 -
Oh hope he's OK. Maybe OGH can send him an email.FrancisUrquhart said:
I don't think we have heard from him since before the GE. He didn't even do his usual (and one time a year where his predictions are worth taking notice of) Oscars piece.GIN1138 said:Has anyone seen Roger on here lately? I assume he's self-isolating in one of his twelve mansions?
0 -
Another question for WWII UK military procurement -
What is the connection between cigarettes and an African tropical disease?
This time £5 to charity of choice - it's an easier question.0 -
Not great news for anyone hoping for medical kit from China...FrancisUrquhart said:
I posted about this 2-3 days ago. A BBC blue checkmark tweeted about how something strange going on there, and a US based Chinese journalist (who is anti CCP) also talking about it.Floater said:
0 -
There's a big problem heading the NHS's way later this summer and into the Autumn. Backlog of elective surgery. Cancellation of "non-urgent" operations that WILL have to be recategorized as urgent in six months time. Huge numbers of doctors and nurses who will have basically gone months without a holiday needing to be given time off. Oh, and the standard winter crisis.NerysHughes said:
We defintely need to start treating more non Covid patients who must he suffering nowbigjohnowls said:FPT Absolutely agree with that Floater
My hospital now has 26 of 32 ventilators in use and has had 63 deaths in last 3 weeks
High point was 13/4/20 when only 1 vent was spare
The pre Covid Vent capacity was 22 so still using some of boosted Capacity
These people who obsess about ending the already looser than some countries "lockdown" have their priorities completely wrong.
Oh, and COVID-19 second wave...
0 -
It might be that the first level of lockdown reduction - after the COVID19 numbers have gone down and testing allows you to declare *some* hospitals COVID19 free - would be to start to work through the medical backlog.alex_ said:
There's a big problem heading the NHS's way later this summer and into the Autumn. Backlog of elective surgery. Cancellation of "non-urgent" operations that WILL have to be recategorized as urgent in six months time. Huge numbers of doctors and nurses who will have basically gone months without a holiday needing to be given time off. Oh, and the standard winter crisis.NerysHughes said:
We defintely need to start treating more non Covid patients who must he suffering nowbigjohnowls said:FPT Absolutely agree with that Floater
My hospital now has 26 of 32 ventilators in use and has had 63 deaths in last 3 weeks
High point was 13/4/20 when only 1 vent was spare
The pre Covid Vent capacity was 22 so still using some of boosted Capacity
These people who obsess about ending the already looser than some countries "lockdown" have their priorities completely wrong.
Oh, and COVID-19 second wave...0 -
There will have to be a rapid re-assessment of what constitutes urgent and non-urgent treatment, just because of the medium-term (at least) reduction in capacity.alex_ said:
There's a big problem heading the NHS's way later this summer and into the Autumn. Backlog of elective surgery. Cancellation of "non-urgent" operations that WILL have to be recategorized as urgent in six months time. Huge numbers of doctors and nurses who will have basically gone months without a holiday needing to be given time off. Oh, and the standard winter crisis.NerysHughes said:
We defintely need to start treating more non Covid patients who must he suffering nowbigjohnowls said:FPT Absolutely agree with that Floater
My hospital now has 26 of 32 ventilators in use and has had 63 deaths in last 3 weeks
High point was 13/4/20 when only 1 vent was spare
The pre Covid Vent capacity was 22 so still using some of boosted Capacity
These people who obsess about ending the already looser than some countries "lockdown" have their priorities completely wrong.
Oh, and COVID-19 second wave...
I suspect that anyone waiting for a hip replacement, for example, and who lacks the means to go private is going to be left in pain for years.1 -
But cases have been declining for a full 10 minutes now...bigjohnowls said:FPT Absolutely agree with that Floater
My hospital now has 26 of 32 ventilators in use and has had 63 deaths in last 3 weeks
High point was 13/4/20 when only 1 vent was spare
The pre Covid Vent capacity was 22 so still using some of boosted Capacity
These people who obsess about ending the already looser than some countries "lockdown" have their priorities completely wrong.
Seriously - good luck to you.0 -
I have just been out on Cannock Chase on my bike ride.
Lockdown is over. I’ve only ever twice seen it busier.
And with the car parks shut, they’ve just parked on the roads.0 -
Nice to have Scott and his twitter barrage back. He did some decent self isolating of his own after losing the election.Scott_xP said:1 -
On topic, Mr Eagles, you’re right.
It is far too early to be considering Starmer’s likely successor.0 -
"re-register" - in fact to register people in the first place.Sandpit said:FPT:
Before we all got caught up in the current panic, there was a huge news story about the Indian government's attempts to re-register everyone. There's at least tens of millions of Indians who have no record of their life anywhere official. It could actually turn out to be hundreds of millions of completely undocumented people.IshmaelZ said:Sigh, can't get the quotes straight. I said:
I didn't say that, it's a quoting cockup. And i entirely agree with you. I read somewhere reasonably authoritative that 30 % of all deaths in India are not formally recorded anywhere, and only 25% have the cause of death certified by a doctor.
HYUFD has never been anywhere in the third world. He doesn't realise that they do things differently there.0 -
@ TSE I think we need a thread on the various voting systems so that we can understand your comment "the flawless alternative vote system" fully and in context. Could you rustle something up for us?0
-
I’ll try and get said piece written for next weekend.TimT said:@ TSE I think we need a thread on the various voting systems so that we can understand your comment "the flawless alternative vote system" fully and in context. Could you rustle something up for us?
0 -
-
My wife works as an anaesthetist in a rural US hospital. They are re-starting urgent non-elective surgeries after about a month of just non-elective surgeries. So far, they've only had 4 confirmed COVID cases, all of whom survived and have been discharged.Black_Rook said:
There will have to be a rapid re-assessment of what constitutes urgent and non-urgent treatment, just because of the medium-term (at least) reduction in capacity.alex_ said:
There's a big problem heading the NHS's way later this summer and into the Autumn. Backlog of elective surgery. Cancellation of "non-urgent" operations that WILL have to be recategorized as urgent in six months time. Huge numbers of doctors and nurses who will have basically gone months without a holiday needing to be given time off. Oh, and the standard winter crisis.NerysHughes said:
We defintely need to start treating more non Covid patients who must he suffering nowbigjohnowls said:FPT Absolutely agree with that Floater
My hospital now has 26 of 32 ventilators in use and has had 63 deaths in last 3 weeks
High point was 13/4/20 when only 1 vent was spare
The pre Covid Vent capacity was 22 so still using some of boosted Capacity
These people who obsess about ending the already looser than some countries "lockdown" have their priorities completely wrong.
Oh, and COVID-19 second wave...
I suspect that anyone waiting for a hip replacement, for example, and who lacks the means to go private is going to be left in pain for years.0 -
Perhaps a companion piece on the Epicurian perfection of pineapple on pizza?TheScreamingEagles said:
I’ll try and get said piece written for next weekend.TimT said:@ TSE I think we need a thread on the various voting systems so that we can understand your comment "the flawless alternative vote system" fully and in context. Could you rustle something up for us?
0 -
TheScreamingEagles said:
I’ll try and get said piece written for next weekend.TimT said:@ TSE I think we need a thread on the various voting systems so that we can understand your comment "the flawless alternative vote system" fully and in context. Could you rustle something up for us?
0 -
More frontline symptomatic is the next expansion.bigjohnowls said:So nearly 22,000 tests yesterday but Capacity is now approaching 40,000. Time for all those NHS staff treating Covid 19 patients to get their tests whether or not they are symptomatic
0 -
I've eaten a lot of pizza in my time and have never been tempted to put pineapple on it. I find it a rather odd idea, frankly.Malmesbury said:
Perhaps a companion piece on the Epicurian perfection of pineapple on pizza?TheScreamingEagles said:
I’ll try and get said piece written for next weekend.TimT said:@ TSE I think we need a thread on the various voting systems so that we can understand your comment "the flawless alternative vote system" fully and in context. Could you rustle something up for us?
1 -
I think Keir could be with us for a long time yet 10-15 years. Too many variables for me. Putting your money in Shell for that sweet 10-11% dividend and hoping their promises of diversification bear fruit might be a little less risky.0
-
A small research project by Stanford using antibody testing concluded that California's true COVID exposure is 50-100 x the reported positives from testing. I take that as good news - it means we'll get to herd immunity quicker and that, even if the implication is that the R0 is higher than previously calculated, that the social distancing is working despite that higher R0Pulpstar said:
More frontline symptomatic is the next expansion.bigjohnowls said:So nearly 22,000 tests yesterday but Capacity is now approaching 40,000. Time for all those NHS staff treating Covid 19 patients to get their tests whether or not they are symptomatic
0 -
Is it simply the product of very nice weather and nothing else to do?ydoethur said:I have just been out on Cannock Chase on my bike ride.
Lockdown is over. I’ve only ever twice seen it busier.
And with the car parks shut, they’ve just parked on the roads.
So long as all those people aren't clustering in groups, organising football matches or staging an impromptu mock-up of Glastonbury then it really shouldn't make much difference.
FWIW I reckon it's maybe marginally, but not significantly, busier around here. Probably saw a few more cars about when I was out running this morning than could be plausibly accounted for by folk driving up the heath to do walks and exercise their dogs, especially since it was too early for the shops to be open, but no obvious widespread disobedience. Certainly I can see most of the railway station car park from my flat and there's only one car parked in it.
Based on this and on the levels of traffic I saw out on Easter Day, I reckon there are some people out and about because they can't resist the urge to visit family and friends, but not particularly large numbers.0 -
596, how does that compare to a fortnight last saturday (Last sat was bank holiday sat so not a fair comparison)0
-
He’s 57. I give him two general elections at most. More likely, if he loses the next one he resigns about a year afterwards.MightyAlex said:I think Keir could be with us for a long time yet 10-15 years. Too many variables for me. Putting your money in Shell for that sweet 10-11% dividend and hoping their promises of diversification bear fruit might be a little less risky.
That, of course, is another consideration. If Labour are in office, or seem close to it, back a centrist as they try to make that last heave. If they’re in opposition and feel they’re likely to stay there, back them to pick the most self-indulgent candidate imaginable.0 -
Can't resist an open goal, and TSE obviously needed someone to say it.ydoethur said:
You just had to open your big keyboard, didn’t you?TimT said:@ TSE I think we need a thread on the various voting systems so that we can understand your comment "the flawless alternative vote system" fully and in context. Could you rustle something up for us?
0 -
Small leaks over time sink big shipsBlack_Rook said:
Is it simply the product of very nice weather and nothing else to do?ydoethur said:I have just been out on Cannock Chase on my bike ride.
Lockdown is over. I’ve only ever twice seen it busier.
And with the car parks shut, they’ve just parked on the roads.
So long as all those people aren't clustering in groups, organising football matches or staging an impromptu mock-up of Glastonbury then it really shouldn't make much difference.
FWIW I reckon it's maybe marginally, but not significantly, busier around here. Probably saw a few more cars about when I was out running this morning than could be plausibly accounted for by folk driving up the heath to do walks and exercise their dogs, especially since it was too early for the shops to be open, but no obvious widespread disobedience. Certainly I can see most of the railway station car park from my flat and there's only one car parked in it.
Based on this and on the levels of traffic I saw out on Easter Day, I reckon there are some people out and about because they can't resist the urge to visit family and friends, but not particularly large numbers.0 -
Traffic levels also significantly up in my small bit of the US, despite us having a cold snap atm, and MD being quite a few weeks behind NY in the pandemic. That said, people's behaviour has definitely 'improved' in relation to following social distancing and face mask guidelines.Black_Rook said:
Is it simply the product of very nice weather and nothing else to do?ydoethur said:I have just been out on Cannock Chase on my bike ride.
Lockdown is over. I’ve only ever twice seen it busier.
And with the car parks shut, they’ve just parked on the roads.
So long as all those people aren't clustering in groups, organising football matches or staging an impromptu mock-up of Glastonbury then it really shouldn't make much difference.
FWIW I reckon it's maybe marginally, but not significantly, busier around here. Probably saw a few more cars about when I was out running this morning than could be plausibly accounted for by folk driving up the heath to do walks and exercise their dogs, especially since it was too early for the shops to be open, but no obvious widespread disobedience. Certainly I can see most of the railway station car park from my flat and there's only one car parked in it.
Based on this and on the levels of traffic I saw out on Easter Day, I reckon there are some people out and about because they can't resist the urge to visit family and friends, but not particularly large numbers.0 -
Yet we never reach herd immunity if the worries from the WHO yesterday turn out to be accurate.TimT said:
A small research project by Stanford using antibody testing concluded that California's true COVID exposure is 50-100 x the reported positives from testing. I take that as good news - it means we'll get to herd immunity quicker and that, even if the implication is that the R0 is higher than previously calculated, that the social distancing is working despite that higher R0Pulpstar said:
More frontline symptomatic is the next expansion.bigjohnowls said:So nearly 22,000 tests yesterday but Capacity is now approaching 40,000. Time for all those NHS staff treating Covid 19 patients to get their tests whether or not they are symptomatic
0 -
Missed it. Is that the worry that asymptomatic and paucisymptomatic persons are not developing high antibody titres?ManchesterKurt said:
Yet we never reach herd immunity if the worries from the WHO yesterday turn out to be accurate.TimT said:
A small research project by Stanford using antibody testing concluded that California's true COVID exposure is 50-100 x the reported positives from testing. I take that as good news - it means we'll get to herd immunity quicker and that, even if the implication is that the R0 is higher than previously calculated, that the social distancing is working despite that higher R0Pulpstar said:
More frontline symptomatic is the next expansion.bigjohnowls said:So nearly 22,000 tests yesterday but Capacity is now approaching 40,000. Time for all those NHS staff treating Covid 19 patients to get their tests whether or not they are symptomatic
0 -
Well, yes, but if enough of them do it deciding it’s a ‘reasonable excuse,’ lockdown is over.Black_Rook said:
Is it simply the product of very nice weather and nothing else to do?ydoethur said:I have just been out on Cannock Chase on my bike ride.
Lockdown is over. I’ve only ever twice seen it busier.
And with the car parks shut, they’ve just parked on the roads.
So long as all those people aren't clustering in groups, organising football matches or staging an impromptu mock-up of Glastonbury then it really shouldn't make much difference.
FWIW I reckon it's maybe marginally, but not significantly, busier around here. Probably saw a few more cars about when I was out running this morning than could be plausibly accounted for by folk driving up the heath to do walks and exercise their dogs, especially since it was too early for the shops to be open, but no obvious widespread disobedience. Certainly I can see most of the railway station car park from my flat and there's only one car parked in it.
Based on this and on the levels of traffic I saw out on Easter Day, I reckon there are some people out and about because they can't resist the urge to visit family and friends, but not particularly large numbers.
Which is what I saw on Cannock Chase.0 -
...ydoethur said:
Well, yes, but if enough of them do it deciding it’s a ‘reasonable excuse,’ lockdown is over.Black_Rook said:
Is it simply the product of very nice weather and nothing else to do?ydoethur said:I have just been out on Cannock Chase on my bike ride.
Lockdown is over. I’ve only ever twice seen it busier.
And with the car parks shut, they’ve just parked on the roads.
So long as all those people aren't clustering in groups, organising football matches or staging an impromptu mock-up of Glastonbury then it really shouldn't make much difference.
FWIW I reckon it's maybe marginally, but not significantly, busier around here. Probably saw a few more cars about when I was out running this morning than could be plausibly accounted for by folk driving up the heath to do walks and exercise their dogs, especially since it was too early for the shops to be open, but no obvious widespread disobedience. Certainly I can see most of the railway station car park from my flat and there's only one car parked in it.
Based on this and on the levels of traffic I saw out on Easter Day, I reckon there are some people out and about because they can't resist the urge to visit family and friends, but not particularly large numbers.
Which is what I saw on Cannock Chase.0 -
It's ghastly.kinabalu said:
I've eaten a lot of pizza in my time and have never been tempted to put pineapple on it. I find it a rather odd idea, frankly.Malmesbury said:
Perhaps a companion piece on the Epicurian perfection of pineapple on pizza?TheScreamingEagles said:
I’ll try and get said piece written for next weekend.TimT said:@ TSE I think we need a thread on the various voting systems so that we can understand your comment "the flawless alternative vote system" fully and in context. Could you rustle something up for us?
I am more interested by discovering that bacon on pizza is heresy, according to the Italians.
Don't they know everything is better with bacon?0 -
I may be wrong, but the essence of what I read was there is no certainty that you cannot catch the virus more than once.TimT said:
Missed it. Is that the worry that asymptomatic and paucisymptomatic persons are not developing high antibody titres?ManchesterKurt said:
Yet we never reach herd immunity if the worries from the WHO yesterday turn out to be accurate.TimT said:
A small research project by Stanford using antibody testing concluded that California's true COVID exposure is 50-100 x the reported positives from testing. I take that as good news - it means we'll get to herd immunity quicker and that, even if the implication is that the R0 is higher than previously calculated, that the social distancing is working despite that higher R0Pulpstar said:
More frontline symptomatic is the next expansion.bigjohnowls said:So nearly 22,000 tests yesterday but Capacity is now approaching 40,000. Time for all those NHS staff treating Covid 19 patients to get their tests whether or not they are symptomatic
0 -
Yes, reports out of South Korea are worrying in that regard. And there have been reports from the UK that those with no or low symptoms are not developing antibody immunity (and hence could be open to re-infection). But this study was using antibody tests, so the people they viewed as having been exposed are contributing to herd immunity - unless the antibodies are themselves promoting infection - something that has been known to happen with other coronaviruses.ManchesterKurt said:
I may be wrong, but the essence of what I read was there is no certainty that you cannot catch the virus more than 1.ydoethur said:
Well, yes, but if enough of them do it deciding it’s a ‘reasonable excuse,’ lockdown is over.Black_Rook said:
Is it simply the product of very nice weather and nothing else to do?ydoethur said:I have just been out on Cannock Chase on my bike ride.
Lockdown is over. I’ve only ever twice seen it busier.
And with the car parks shut, they’ve just parked on the roads.
So long as all those people aren't clustering in groups, organising football matches or staging an impromptu mock-up of Glastonbury then it really shouldn't make much difference.
FWIW I reckon it's maybe marginally, but not significantly, busier around here. Probably saw a few more cars about when I was out running this morning than could be plausibly accounted for by folk driving up the heath to do walks and exercise their dogs, especially since it was too early for the shops to be open, but no obvious widespread disobedience. Certainly I can see most of the railway station car park from my flat and there's only one car parked in it.
Based on this and on the levels of traffic I saw out on Easter Day, I reckon there are some people out and about because they can't resist the urge to visit family and friends, but not particularly large numbers.
Which is what I saw on Cannock Chase.2 -
Lots of nurses are having more time off now than they have ever had, lack of patients, massive overstaffing, cancellation of overtime and bank work.alex_ said:
There's a big problem heading the NHS's way later this summer and into the Autumn. Backlog of elective surgery. Cancellation of "non-urgent" operations that WILL have to be recategorized as urgent in six months time. Huge numbers of doctors and nurses who will have basically gone months without a holiday needing to be given time off. Oh, and the standard winter crisis.NerysHughes said:
We defintely need to start treating more non Covid patients who must he suffering nowbigjohnowls said:FPT Absolutely agree with that Floater
My hospital now has 26 of 32 ventilators in use and has had 63 deaths in last 3 weeks
High point was 13/4/20 when only 1 vent was spare
The pre Covid Vent capacity was 22 so still using some of boosted Capacity
These people who obsess about ending the already looser than some countries "lockdown" have their priorities completely wrong.
Oh, and COVID-19 second wave...0 -
-
Never been too enamoured of Jarvis. Having a leader from the Northern heartlands who has been in the paras would clearly be absolutely fantastic for blowing away the notion of Labour these days being a party for Guardian reading North London dwelling poncipoops (like me) but my suspicion is that his appeal does mainly boil down to that.CorrectHorseBattery said:Andy Burnham or Dan Jarvis.
0 -
Whereabouts? Many US states are vast and very sparsely populated - Montana, for example, is larger than Germany yet is home to only about a million people, has no cities bigger than Norwich and is very remote from all of the States' major metropolitan areas. It would be no surprise if somewhere like that got off more lightly than New Zealand and without the need for anything more than the most rudimentary movement in the direction of social distancing.TimT said:
My wife works as an anaesthetist in a rural US hospital. They are re-starting urgent non-elective surgeries after about a month of just non-elective surgeries. So far, they've only had 4 confirmed COVID cases, all of whom survived and have been discharged.Black_Rook said:
There will have to be a rapid re-assessment of what constitutes urgent and non-urgent treatment, just because of the medium-term (at least) reduction in capacity.alex_ said:
There's a big problem heading the NHS's way later this summer and into the Autumn. Backlog of elective surgery. Cancellation of "non-urgent" operations that WILL have to be recategorized as urgent in six months time. Huge numbers of doctors and nurses who will have basically gone months without a holiday needing to be given time off. Oh, and the standard winter crisis.NerysHughes said:
We defintely need to start treating more non Covid patients who must he suffering nowbigjohnowls said:FPT Absolutely agree with that Floater
My hospital now has 26 of 32 ventilators in use and has had 63 deaths in last 3 weeks
High point was 13/4/20 when only 1 vent was spare
The pre Covid Vent capacity was 22 so still using some of boosted Capacity
These people who obsess about ending the already looser than some countries "lockdown" have their priorities completely wrong.
Oh, and COVID-19 second wave...
I suspect that anyone waiting for a hip replacement, for example, and who lacks the means to go private is going to be left in pain for years.
We don't have their advantages. It could be years before the healthcare system returns to something resembling normality.0 -
He could well win in coalition in 5 years so thats the first 10 out the way. Betting on one hopeful out of many with no visible end-point and in a hugely uncertain time seems folly if you're betting to win. Where is the edge?ydoethur said:
He’s 57. I give him two general elections at most. More likely, if he loses the next one he resigns about a year afterwards.MightyAlex said:I think Keir could be with us for a long time yet 10-15 years. Too many variables for me. Putting your money in Shell for that sweet 10-11% dividend and hoping their promises of diversification bear fruit might be a little less risky.
That, of course, is another consideration. If Labour are in office, or seem close to it, back a centrist as they try to make that last heave. If they’re in opposition and feel they’re likely to stay there, back them to pick the most self-indulgent candidate imaginable.0 -
Page 22 of the Sunday Times points out that the Wuhan death toll increased by exactly 50% (to the nearest whole number) from 2,579 to 3,869 which seems rather suspicious.0
-
Rather ridiculous thread header given Starmer has only been in the job less than a month.
If Starmer loses the next general election then it would suggest one more heave was not enough and David Miliband could make a return or Liz Kendall or even Chuka Umunna could defect back again if Labour was desperate for a Blairite to take them back to power after a Brownite failed to deliver as the Corbynites had not.
If Starmer ends up PM after the next general election then whoever holds the senior Cabinet posts will be favourite0 -
As long as groups of people from the same household stay 2 metres apart from each other I can't see the problem.ydoethur said:I have just been out on Cannock Chase on my bike ride.
Lockdown is over. I’ve only ever twice seen it busier.
And with the car parks shut, they’ve just parked on the roads.0 -
Our once-a-day outdoor exercise excuse for escape from house arrest has been there since the outset. Hence, if that's all they're doing, then they're acting within the rules not flouting them.ydoethur said:
Well, yes, but if enough of them do it deciding it’s a ‘reasonable excuse,’ lockdown is over.Black_Rook said:
Is it simply the product of very nice weather and nothing else to do?ydoethur said:I have just been out on Cannock Chase on my bike ride.
Lockdown is over. I’ve only ever twice seen it busier.
And with the car parks shut, they’ve just parked on the roads.
So long as all those people aren't clustering in groups, organising football matches or staging an impromptu mock-up of Glastonbury then it really shouldn't make much difference.
FWIW I reckon it's maybe marginally, but not significantly, busier around here. Probably saw a few more cars about when I was out running this morning than could be plausibly accounted for by folk driving up the heath to do walks and exercise their dogs, especially since it was too early for the shops to be open, but no obvious widespread disobedience. Certainly I can see most of the railway station car park from my flat and there's only one car parked in it.
Based on this and on the levels of traffic I saw out on Easter Day, I reckon there are some people out and about because they can't resist the urge to visit family and friends, but not particularly large numbers.
Which is what I saw on Cannock Chase.0 -
On my walk earlier saw very few people about and those that were about were very much keeping their social distanceBlack_Rook said:
Is it simply the product of very nice weather and nothing else to do?ydoethur said:I have just been out on Cannock Chase on my bike ride.
Lockdown is over. I’ve only ever twice seen it busier.
And with the car parks shut, they’ve just parked on the roads.
So long as all those people aren't clustering in groups, organising football matches or staging an impromptu mock-up of Glastonbury then it really shouldn't make much difference.
FWIW I reckon it's maybe marginally, but not significantly, busier around here. Probably saw a few more cars about when I was out running this morning than could be plausibly accounted for by folk driving up the heath to do walks and exercise their dogs, especially since it was too early for the shops to be open, but no obvious widespread disobedience. Certainly I can see most of the railway station car park from my flat and there's only one car parked in it.
Based on this and on the levels of traffic I saw out on Easter Day, I reckon there are some people out and about because they can't resist the urge to visit family and friends, but not particularly large numbers.0 -
Firstly I have been to the third world, Nablus in the Palestinian authority is third world on any definition as are some of the less salubrious parts of Mauritius.Sandpit said:FPT:
Before we all got caught up in the current panic, there was a huge news story about the Indian government's attempts to re-register everyone. There's at least tens of millions of Indians who have no record of their life anywhere official. It could actually turn out to be hundreds of millions of completely undocumented people.IshmaelZ said:Sigh, can't get the quotes straight. I said:
I didn't say that, it's a quoting cockup. And i entirely agree with you. I read somewhere reasonably authoritative that 30 % of all deaths in India are not formally recorded anywhere, and only 25% have the cause of death certified by a doctor.
HYUFD has never been anywhere in the third world. He doesn't realise that they do things differently there.
Second, Isam can say what he likes he still has zero evidence for his theory that Covid 19 mortality is highest depending on the life expectancy of the country in question rather than with over 80s across the board, in fact all the evidence suggests the opposite0 -
Oh I did see a guy sunbathing in his rather small front garden - I imagine the Po Po would feel his collar if they saw him.0
-
Well, yes, that obviously works. Bacon is a close relative of the thing without which a pizza is not really a pizza - pepperoni.Malmesbury said:
It's ghastly.kinabalu said:
I've eaten a lot of pizza in my time and have never been tempted to put pineapple on it. I find it a rather odd idea, frankly.Malmesbury said:
Perhaps a companion piece on the Epicurian perfection of pineapple on pizza?TheScreamingEagles said:
I’ll try and get said piece written for next weekend.TimT said:@ TSE I think we need a thread on the various voting systems so that we can understand your comment "the flawless alternative vote system" fully and in context. Could you rustle something up for us?
I am more interested by discovering that bacon on pizza is heresy, according to the Italians.
Don't they know everything is better with bacon?
And of course you have the ritual of plucking each piece off and eating it with your fingers first. Anybody who says they don't do that is a person of very dubious character indeed.1 -
Can you please stop peddling this herd immunity, wishful thinking nonsense.....it's a vaccine, or a gamechanging anti-viral, or massive testing and contact tracing that gets us out of this....TimT said:
Missed it. Is that the worry that asymptomatic and paucisymptomatic persons are not developing high antibody titres?ManchesterKurt said:
Yet we never reach herd immunity if the worries from the WHO yesterday turn out to be accurate.TimT said:
A small research project by Stanford using antibody testing concluded that California's true COVID exposure is 50-100 x the reported positives from testing. I take that as good news - it means we'll get to herd immunity quicker and that, even if the implication is that the R0 is higher than previously calculated, that the social distancing is working despite that higher R0Pulpstar said:
More frontline symptomatic is the next expansion.bigjohnowls said:So nearly 22,000 tests yesterday but Capacity is now approaching 40,000. Time for all those NHS staff treating Covid 19 patients to get their tests whether or not they are symptomatic
0 -
This might well serve as the perfect example of a mug's bet.MightyAlex said:
He could well win in coalition in 5 years so thats the first 10 out the way. Betting on one hopeful out of many with no visible end-point and in a hugely uncertain time seems folly if you're betting to win. Where is the edge?ydoethur said:
He’s 57. I give him two general elections at most. More likely, if he loses the next one he resigns about a year afterwards.MightyAlex said:I think Keir could be with us for a long time yet 10-15 years. Too many variables for me. Putting your money in Shell for that sweet 10-11% dividend and hoping their promises of diversification bear fruit might be a little less risky.
That, of course, is another consideration. If Labour are in office, or seem close to it, back a centrist as they try to make that last heave. If they’re in opposition and feel they’re likely to stay there, back them to pick the most self-indulgent candidate imaginable.0 -
-
But Italians will tell you bacon on pizza is a crime almost as bad as pineapple...kinabalu said:
Well, yes, that obviously works. Bacon is a close relative of the thing without which a pizza is not really a pizza - pepperoni.Malmesbury said:
It's ghastly.kinabalu said:
I've eaten a lot of pizza in my time and have never been tempted to put pineapple on it. I find it a rather odd idea, frankly.Malmesbury said:
Perhaps a companion piece on the Epicurian perfection of pineapple on pizza?TheScreamingEagles said:
I’ll try and get said piece written for next weekend.TimT said:@ TSE I think we need a thread on the various voting systems so that we can understand your comment "the flawless alternative vote system" fully and in context. Could you rustle something up for us?
I am more interested by discovering that bacon on pizza is heresy, according to the Italians.
Don't they know everything is better with bacon?
And of course you have the ritual of plucking each piece off and eating it with your fingers first. Anybody who says they don't do that is a person of very dubious character indeed.0 -
Well that is undoubtedly a good thing. The pandemic is being controlled better than we could have hoped. Well done Boris, well done NHS!NerysHughes said:
Lots of nurses are having more time off now than they have ever had, lack of patients, massive overstaffing, cancellation of overtime and bank work.alex_ said:
There's a big problem heading the NHS's way later this summer and into the Autumn. Backlog of elective surgery. Cancellation of "non-urgent" operations that WILL have to be recategorized as urgent in six months time. Huge numbers of doctors and nurses who will have basically gone months without a holiday needing to be given time off. Oh, and the standard winter crisis.NerysHughes said:
We defintely need to start treating more non Covid patients who must he suffering nowbigjohnowls said:FPT Absolutely agree with that Floater
My hospital now has 26 of 32 ventilators in use and has had 63 deaths in last 3 weeks
High point was 13/4/20 when only 1 vent was spare
The pre Covid Vent capacity was 22 so still using some of boosted Capacity
These people who obsess about ending the already looser than some countries "lockdown" have their priorities completely wrong.
Oh, and COVID-19 second wave...0 -
Apart from the fact that if you cough you project Covid microbes up to 8 meters away....it only takes one of these little fellas to fuck you up.....and put you on the trajectory of a ventilator and a ghastly lonely death in a matter of weeks....Andy_JS said:
As long as groups of people from the same household stay 2 metres apart from each other I can't see the problem.ydoethur said:I have just been out on Cannock Chase on my bike ride.
Lockdown is over. I’ve only ever twice seen it busier.
And with the car parks shut, they’ve just parked on the roads.
0 -
Was he supposed to chair them? Sounds like he wasn't.Scott_xP said:0 -
Late last year I wrote the greatest polling analysis in history, it featured Hawaiian pizzas.Malmesbury said:
Perhaps a companion piece on the Epicurian perfection of pineapple on pizza?TheScreamingEagles said:
I’ll try and get said piece written for next weekend.TimT said:@ TSE I think we need a thread on the various voting systems so that we can understand your comment "the flawless alternative vote system" fully and in context. Could you rustle something up for us?
Hypothetical polls are a lot like Hawaiian pizzas, they should be avoided at all costs by right thinking people everywhere.
https://www7.politicalbetting.com/index.php/archives/2019/12/01/your-regular-reminder-that-hypothetical-polls-can-be-as-accurate-as-an-american-war-film/0 -
It is not "wishing thinking nonsense". It is a possibility that we will get there a lot quicker because so many of us have had it asymptomatically, or perhaps have natural immunity.tyson said:
Can you please stop peddling this herd immunity, wishful thinking nonsense.....it's a vaccine, or a gamechanging anti-viral, or massive testing and contact tracing that gets us out of this....TimT said:
Missed it. Is that the worry that asymptomatic and paucisymptomatic persons are not developing high antibody titres?ManchesterKurt said:
Yet we never reach herd immunity if the worries from the WHO yesterday turn out to be accurate.TimT said:
A small research project by Stanford using antibody testing concluded that California's true COVID exposure is 50-100 x the reported positives from testing. I take that as good news - it means we'll get to herd immunity quicker and that, even if the implication is that the R0 is higher than previously calculated, that the social distancing is working despite that higher R0Pulpstar said:
More frontline symptomatic is the next expansion.bigjohnowls said:So nearly 22,000 tests yesterday but Capacity is now approaching 40,000. Time for all those NHS staff treating Covid 19 patients to get their tests whether or not they are symptomatic
That hypothesis may turn out to be wrong, but isn't nonsense.0 -
This is politicalbetting dot com, we're doing what it says on the tin.HYUFD said:Rather ridiculous thread header given Starmer has only been in the job less than a month.
If Starmer loses the next general election then it would suggest one more heave was not enough and David Miliband could make a return or Liz Kendall or even Chuka Umunna could defect back again if Labour was desperate for a Blairite to take them back to power after a Brownite failed to deliver as the Corbynites had not.
If Starmer ends up PM after the next general election then whoever holds the senior Cabinet posts will be favourite
Heck we were discussing the 2012 Presidential nominees before Obama was even elected in 2008.0 -
I agree - the Brexit debate (in the Tory party at least) is over - and this split does focus on traditional Tory concerns - the economy and national security.williamglenn said:Is the more important split in the Tory party not between Leave and Remain but between China hawks and doves?
https://twitter.com/dailymailuk/status/1251824117482913797?s=210 -
Excellent Ch4 series on Putin - which I think sums him up well - he's a weak man whose only focus is hanging on to power. He must be terrified by the knowledge that nothing lasts forever.
https://www.channel4.com/programmes/putin-a-russian-spy-story/on-demand/69173-0010 -
Who missed five meetings?Scott_xP said:0 -
Quite.rottenborough said:
It is not "wishing thinking nonsense". It is a possibility that we will get there a lot quicker because so many of us have had it asymptomatically, or perhaps have natural immunity.tyson said:
Can you please stop peddling this herd immunity, wishful thinking nonsense.....it's a vaccine, or a gamechanging anti-viral, or massive testing and contact tracing that gets us out of this....TimT said:
Missed it. Is that the worry that asymptomatic and paucisymptomatic persons are not developing high antibody titres?ManchesterKurt said:
Yet we never reach herd immunity if the worries from the WHO yesterday turn out to be accurate.TimT said:
A small research project by Stanford using antibody testing concluded that California's true COVID exposure is 50-100 x the reported positives from testing. I take that as good news - it means we'll get to herd immunity quicker and that, even if the implication is that the R0 is higher than previously calculated, that the social distancing is working despite that higher R0Pulpstar said:
More frontline symptomatic is the next expansion.bigjohnowls said:So nearly 22,000 tests yesterday but Capacity is now approaching 40,000. Time for all those NHS staff treating Covid 19 patients to get their tests whether or not they are symptomatic
That hypothesis may turn out to be wrong, but isn't nonsense.
(I was going to add "what do you think testing is supposed to achieve … ?" … )
0 -
The German Wuhan...had 15%....Lombardy has 10%...these are with blood tests samples that show the population affected....and at best it is 15%rottenborough said:
It is not "wishing thinking nonsense". It is a possibility that we will get there a lot quicker because so many of us have had it asymptomatically, or perhaps have natural immunity.tyson said:
Can you please stop peddling this herd immunity, wishful thinking nonsense.....it's a vaccine, or a gamechanging anti-viral, or massive testing and contact tracing that gets us out of this....TimT said:
Missed it. Is that the worry that asymptomatic and paucisymptomatic persons are not developing high antibody titres?ManchesterKurt said:
Yet we never reach herd immunity if the worries from the WHO yesterday turn out to be accurate.TimT said:
A small research project by Stanford using antibody testing concluded that California's true COVID exposure is 50-100 x the reported positives from testing. I take that as good news - it means we'll get to herd immunity quicker and that, even if the implication is that the R0 is higher than previously calculated, that the social distancing is working despite that higher R0Pulpstar said:
More frontline symptomatic is the next expansion.bigjohnowls said:So nearly 22,000 tests yesterday but Capacity is now approaching 40,000. Time for all those NHS staff treating Covid 19 patients to get their tests whether or not they are symptomatic
That hypothesis may turn out to be wrong, but isn't nonsense.
We know what happens when this virus hits a hotspot.....Bergamo, New York, Madrid....
0 -
Herd immunity - supported by partial lockdown and social distancing (its not an either/or) - is the only method we can actually rely on now, as well, as the vaccine don't exist, a cure-all treatment don't exist and people don't seem to quite grasp the differences between different types of testing. The most useful one? don't exist.1
-
I think herd immunity is a real Plan Z. It costs 3m hospital admissions and 250k lives.ManchesterKurt said:
Yet we never reach herd immunity if the worries from the WHO yesterday turn out to be accurate.TimT said:
A small research project by Stanford using antibody testing concluded that California's true COVID exposure is 50-100 x the reported positives from testing. I take that as good news - it means we'll get to herd immunity quicker and that, even if the implication is that the R0 is higher than previously calculated, that the social distancing is working despite that higher R0Pulpstar said:
More frontline symptomatic is the next expansion.bigjohnowls said:So nearly 22,000 tests yesterday but Capacity is now approaching 40,000. Time for all those NHS staff treating Covid 19 patients to get their tests whether or not they are symptomatic
Social distancing and partial lockdown until vaccine, I fear.0 -
We (the UK) are not counting countless thousands dying in care homes...so pot calling kettle springs to mind....Sandpit said:
Chinese reported figures are suspicious, who'd have thought that?Andy_JS said:Page 22 of the Sunday Times points out that the Wuhan death toll increased by exactly 50% (to the nearest whole number) from 2,579 to 3,869 which seems rather suspicious.
1 -
"Suspicious" is a gross understatement.Sandpit said:
Chinese reported figures are suspicious, who'd have thought that?Andy_JS said:Page 22 of the Sunday Times points out that the Wuhan death toll increased by exactly 50% (to the nearest whole number) from 2,579 to 3,869 which seems rather suspicious.
1 -
In 2023 maybe it might be appropriate, not 4 years before Starmer's first general electionTheScreamingEagles said:
This is politicalbetting dot com, we're doing what it says on the tin.HYUFD said:Rather ridiculous thread header given Starmer has only been in the job less than a month.
If Starmer loses the next general election then it would suggest one more heave was not enough and David Miliband could make a return or Liz Kendall or even Chuka Umunna could defect back again if Labour was desperate for a Blairite to take them back to power after a Brownite failed to deliver as the Corbynites had not.
If Starmer ends up PM after the next general election then whoever holds the senior Cabinet posts will be favourite
Heck we were discussing the 2012 Presidential nominees before Obama was even elected in 2008.0 -
alterego said:
"Suspicious" is a gross understatement.Sandpit said:
Chinese reported figures are suspicious, who'd have thought that?Andy_JS said:Page 22 of the Sunday Times points out that the Wuhan death toll increased by exactly 50% (to the nearest whole number) from 2,579 to 3,869 which seems rather suspicious.
Our fatality figures are very suspicious too....thousands dying in care homes....0 -
Looking at the graph of case reports and deaths, by far the steepest curve of any country is now Russia, with the outbreak centered on Moscow - another city that's very densely populated.CarlottaVance said:Excellent Ch4 series on Putin - which I think sums him up well - he's a weak man whose only focus is hanging on to power. He must be terrified by the knowledge that nothing lasts forever.
https://www.channel4.com/programmes/putin-a-russian-spy-story/on-demand/69173-0010 -
I'm seeing moderately more around, but still tiny numbers.Floater said:
On my walk earlier saw very few people about and those that were about were very much keeping their social distanceBlack_Rook said:
Is it simply the product of very nice weather and nothing else to do?ydoethur said:I have just been out on Cannock Chase on my bike ride.
Lockdown is over. I’ve only ever twice seen it busier.
And with the car parks shut, they’ve just parked on the roads.
So long as all those people aren't clustering in groups, organising football matches or staging an impromptu mock-up of Glastonbury then it really shouldn't make much difference.
FWIW I reckon it's maybe marginally, but not significantly, busier around here. Probably saw a few more cars about when I was out running this morning than could be plausibly accounted for by folk driving up the heath to do walks and exercise their dogs, especially since it was too early for the shops to be open, but no obvious widespread disobedience. Certainly I can see most of the railway station car park from my flat and there's only one car parked in it.
Based on this and on the levels of traffic I saw out on Easter Day, I reckon there are some people out and about because they can't resist the urge to visit family and friends, but not particularly large numbers.
I have seen exactly one chipshop open.0 -
did they manage to ask former KGB man Putin if he was weak?CarlottaVance said:Excellent Ch4 series on Putin - which I think sums him up well - he's a weak man whose only focus is hanging on to power. He must be terrified by the knowledge that nothing lasts forever.
https://www.channel4.com/programmes/putin-a-russian-spy-story/on-demand/69173-001
maybe they did, but we'd never know.0 -
We are counting them!!!! They are published weekly, hospital deaths are published daily and as a cohort enable analysis and reaction more quickly.tyson said:
We (the UK) are not counting countless thousands dying in care homes...so pot calling kettle springs to mind....Sandpit said:
Chinese reported figures are suspicious, who'd have thought that?Andy_JS said:Page 22 of the Sunday Times points out that the Wuhan death toll increased by exactly 50% (to the nearest whole number) from 2,579 to 3,869 which seems rather suspicious.
2 -
I like Allin- Khan. She is one of only a handful of MPs who's stock is genuinely on the ascent during this crisis.TheScreamingEagles said:
This is politicalbetting dot com, we're doing what it says on the tin.HYUFD said:Rather ridiculous thread header given Starmer has only been in the job less than a month.
If Starmer loses the next general election then it would suggest one more heave was not enough and David Miliband could make a return or Liz Kendall or even Chuka Umunna could defect back again if Labour was desperate for a Blairite to take them back to power after a Brownite failed to deliver as the Corbynites had not.
If Starmer ends up PM after the next general election then whoever holds the senior Cabinet posts will be favourite
Heck we were discussing the 2012 Presidential nominees before Obama was even elected in 2008.
At the GE she did blot her copybook somewhat, by ripping-off Boris' hilarious Love Actually spoof before he did his.0 -
No, he is criticized for not wanting to do ANYTHING that looks like work himself...CarlottaVance said:We get a PM who delegates and he's criticised for not being a control freak who does everything himself.
0 -
the media have always had a 'throw enough shit' strategy.CarlottaVance said:1 -
My duties are to run a skeleton non covid service for the urgent stuff. We have plenty of capacity to do so, and have adapted things for maximum safety. The hard bit is getting the patients to turn up, they are so shit-scared.Malmesbury said:
It might be that the first level of lockdown reduction - after the COVID19 numbers have gone down and testing allows you to declare *some* hospitals COVID19 free - would be to start to work through the medical backlog.alex_ said:
There's a big problem heading the NHS's way later this summer and into the Autumn. Backlog of elective surgery. Cancellation of "non-urgent" operations that WILL have to be recategorized as urgent in six months time. Huge numbers of doctors and nurses who will have basically gone months without a holiday needing to be given time off. Oh, and the standard winter crisis.NerysHughes said:
We defintely need to start treating more non Covid patients who must he suffering nowbigjohnowls said:FPT Absolutely agree with that Floater
My hospital now has 26 of 32 ventilators in use and has had 63 deaths in last 3 weeks
High point was 13/4/20 when only 1 vent was spare
The pre Covid Vent capacity was 22 so still using some of boosted Capacity
These people who obsess about ending the already looser than some countries "lockdown" have their priorities completely wrong.
Oh, and COVID-19 second wave...
Mind you, we did get one the other day that flustered sister a bit. Had positive Covid-19 swabs 12 days prior that no one had told him about. Took a while to clean up the waiting area.
As Dr Rosena says in her tweets above, we are terrible at isolating cases for the 14 days required (7 days in UK for some unknown reason). It is going to be very hard to get R below 1 without isolating cases.0 -
Those are included in the ONS figures. Are you really comparing the two?tyson said:
We (the UK) are not counting countless thousands dying in care homes...so pot calling kettle springs to mind....Sandpit said:
Chinese reported figures are suspicious, who'd have thought that?Andy_JS said:Page 22 of the Sunday Times points out that the Wuhan death toll increased by exactly 50% (to the nearest whole number) from 2,579 to 3,869 which seems rather suspicious.
0 -
Yes, the best leaders and managers know how to delegate eg Churchill, Blair and Reagan and Boris.CarlottaVance said:
Control freaks like Nixon, May and Brown rarely prosper in the top job.
0