Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » At this critical time a look at matters of Confidence in the p

123457

Comments

  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,823
    Sean_F said:

    dixiedean said:

    Sean_F said:


    As far as I can tell, there is only one poll that puts No Deal against Revoke, from Survation, in December. Helpfully, it's 49% to 51%.

    Landslide! Will of the People ;)
    The latest Survation poll also has 47% Leave, 53% Remain, so it's an almost perfect match.
    However, Matthew Goodwin reports a poll from Opinium showing 46% support No Deal, as opposed to 39% who support a delay to Brexit.
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,285

    "Un no-deal".

    L'Acadamie Francaise ain't gonna like that!
    They weren't happy about the phrase "Fake News" if I remember correctly.
  • Options
    AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    O/T

    I misread this as "a gammon bias" the first time I saw it, but in fact it's the precise opposite.

    https://twitter.com/DegenRolf/status/1107938899677057024
  • Options
    eekeek Posts: 24,964
    edited March 2019

    eek said:

    148grss said:

    https://petitionmap.unboxedconsulting.com/?petition=241584

    I do find this map very interesting; some constituencies have upto 5% signing the petition, which isn't too bad.

    University towns. Snowflakes, Woke Remoaners. Actually "The correlation between the percentage of voters who voted Remain and the proportion of the electorate who have signed the petition is extremely high (r=0.93). There’s little to cut against the idea that this petition comes from people who lost and are unhappy about the result."
    https://medium.com/@chrishanretty/are-we-bremorseful-yet-e0506c826ad2
    Keep referencing an old survey about a different petition if it makes you feel happier...
    Since you must have missed the first time it was posted...

    https://mobile.twitter.com/chrishanretty/status/1108701393836302336
    I will quote this from that thread.

    https://twitter.com/chrishanretty/status/1108703939350929408

    My interest in the petition is that it we have 3 options that need to be reduced to 2 yesterday (and should have been reduced to 2 back in December).

    I don't care which of the options is removed this petition allows a vote on revoke which when made will either win or leave 2 options left on the table.

    All most people want is an actual decision - most MPs still seem to think the fact they have ruled out No Deal doesn't stop No Deal occuring in just over 8 days times.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    Cicero said:

    1000000+ on the petition.

    16.4 million to go - and it would still be just a petition even then.

    1000000+ on the petition.

    16.4 million to go - and it would still be just a petition even then.
    Yes "just a petition", but I think it would be incredibly stupid not to recognize that opinion has shifted and may well shift still further against Brexit. A second referendum would probably crush leave.

    So Leavers should be very careful. At the current rate, and despite the site collapsing under the weight of demand there are millions of people who are very, very angry and concerned. I suspect that the demonstration on Saturday could be one of the biggest ever seen in London, maybe even THE biggest... sure "its only a demonstration", but if so many people feel that they were simply ignored by the Conservatives, then the hatred dished out to May will make the loathing of Tony Blair look like a storm in a tea cup.

    There is a backlash coming against the Party that has taken us to the brink of the precipice. If Tories are seeing what I'm seeing on the doorsteps then they must be white with fear. I'm getting lifetime Tories who can barely speak their name without rage.
    How cute.
  • Options
    Pro_RataPro_Rata Posts: 4,807
    edited March 2019
    The mapping looks to correspond decently to lower uptake in urban Labour voting leave areas, but more support across most of the south, Inc places like Cornwall, and the rural north, e.g N. Yorks. May be something or may just reflect lower Leave majorities originally in this areas.

    Also Scotland looks far less of an outlier from England than in 2016.

    Just impressions.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They would be eagerly anticipating it getting to 101.
  • Options
    CD13CD13 Posts: 6,351
    Parliament's problem is that it wants to revoke or get another referendum without leaving its fingerprints on the deed. Mrs May's insistence on her/the EU's deal is thwarting them, and her criticism is highlighting that fact.
  • Options
    _Anazina__Anazina_ Posts: 1,810

    What could this mean? Government of National Unity?

    https://twitter.com/SebastianEPayne/status/1108748072744636416

    Looks like it.

    I'm surprised this hasn't been considered sooner.
    I have been saying for weeks that it's time to embrace the gnu.
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,105

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,823
    AndyJS said:

    O/T

    I misread this as "a gammon bias" the first time I saw it, but in fact it's the precise opposite.

    https://twitter.com/DegenRolf/status/1107938899677057024

    In an odd way, it's a very mid-Victorian attitude.
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,105

    148grss said:

    https://petitionmap.unboxedconsulting.com/?petition=241584

    I do find this map very interesting; some constituencies have upto 5% signing the petition, which isn't too bad.

    University towns. Snowflakes, Woke Remoaners. Actually "The correlation between the percentage of voters who voted Remain and the proportion of the electorate who have signed the petition is extremely high (r=0.93). There’s little to cut against the idea that this petition comes from people who lost and are unhappy about the result."
    https://medium.com/@chrishanretty/are-we-bremorseful-yet-e0506c826ad2
    Losers do love a petition.....
  • Options
    logical_songlogical_song Posts: 9,709

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
    The petitions are a little bit cleverer than that - you can see the results broken down into constituencies on a map of the UK.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    199 hours to go to a possible clean Brexit.
  • Options
    ChrisChris Posts: 11,119
    edited March 2019
    Retrait? Ceci n'est pas un retrait. C'est un avance triomphale!
  • Options
    SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 20,598
    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    eek said:

    AndyJS said:

    Chris Hanretty, Professor of Politics, Royal Holloway.


    "Unfortunately for bremainers, the constituencies which have been most supportive of this petition are also the places that voted most strongly for Remain. I’ve been able to remap the results of last Thursday’s referendum onto Westminster constituencies (currently for England and Wales only). Using that, I can work out the association between the percentage voting to leave, and the percentage of the electorate who have signed the petition.

    The correlation between the percentage of voters who voted Remain and the proportion of the electorate who have signed the petition is extremely high (r=0.93). There’s little to cut against the idea that this petition comes from people who lost and are unhappy about the result."

    https://medium.com/@chrishanretty/are-we-bremorseful-yet-e0506c826ad2

    But that is a 3 year old article that you are pretending is about today's petition. Good try but zero bananas.

    In other news buy bananas now - future supplies are unknown...
    There's a 0.96 r correlation between the 2nd ref and revoke petitions. The idea there is a whole heap of leavers for revoke out there is for the birds.
    So just me and Wor Lass then? Both signed the Revoke petition.
    Who is "Wor Lass" xD ?!
    She's a member of the Green Party!
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 60,976
    Mr. JS, I remember reading something similar some years ago. I think it was called the Women Are Wonderful effect.

    It's a combination of prejudice, statistical innumeracy, and fashionable idiocy.

    Another facet is that woe that disproportionately affects women gets gendered (even with stuff like "Climate change affects women more") whereas woe that affects mostly men does not (homelessness [90%] and suicide [75%] being prime examples, although the latter has had some attention lately).

    Men are often estimated to be 35-45% of domestic abuse victims but the funding for refuges for them is far lower, relatively, than for women.

    Society today, despite its flaws, is perhaps the most equal and fair it's ever been, yet some bleat about the patriarchy as if it's the 12th century. That not only ignores anti-male bigotry and mostly male problems (I was amused when numpty Clegg whined about the number of women in prison when there are more than 20 men incarcerated for every 1 woman), it also fetishises victimhood, as if women are subject to far more sexism than they are (it still exists but to a much lesser degree than in the past and with significant legal safeguards).

    /endramble
  • Options
    TrèsDifficileTrèsDifficile Posts: 1,729

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
    The petitions are a little bit cleverer than that - you can see the results broken down into constituencies on a map of the UK.
    It also lists, in the .json file linked on the petition page, all of the locations outside of the UK where it has been 'signed' and the numbers of signatories in each country. France had a greater total (c9000) than any UK constituency the last time I looked.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,961

    eek said:

    148grss said:

    https://petitionmap.unboxedconsulting.com/?petition=241584

    I do find this map very interesting; some constituencies have upto 5% signing the petition, which isn't too bad.

    University towns. Snowflakes, Woke Remoaners. Actually "The correlation between the percentage of voters who voted Remain and the proportion of the electorate who have signed the petition is extremely high (r=0.93). There’s little to cut against the idea that this petition comes from people who lost and are unhappy about the result."
    https://medium.com/@chrishanretty/are-we-bremorseful-yet-e0506c826ad2
    Keep referencing an old survey about a different petition if it makes you feel happier...
    Apologies - I thought it was relevant. I accept that the current petition is gaining signatures fast. I wonder whether the geographic split will be similar?
    He's commented on the new petition too:

    https://twitter.com/chrishanretty/status/1108701393836302336
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,052
    edited March 2019

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
    The petitions are a little bit cleverer than that - you can see the results broken down into constituencies on a map of the UK.
    It also lists, in the .json file linked on the petition page, all of the locations outside of the UK where it has been 'signed' and the numbers of signatories in each country. France had a greater total (c9000) than any UK constituency the last time I looked.
    That's logical given that more British people live in France than in any single constituency and they have a direct stake in the outcome of Brexit.
  • Options
    TrèsDifficileTrèsDifficile Posts: 1,729

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
    The petitions are a little bit cleverer than that - you can see the results broken down into constituencies on a map of the UK.
    It also lists, in the .json file linked on the petition page, all of the locations outside of the UK where it has been 'signed' and the numbers of signatories in each country. France had a greater total (c9000) than any UK constituency the last time I looked.
    That's logical given that more British people live in France than in any single constituency and they have a more direct stake in the outcome of Brexit.
    Indeed. But it doesn't make the total number of signatories recorded "a little bit cleverer" than anything, as claimed by Mr L.Song
  • Options
    DougSealDougSeal Posts: 11,137

    199 hours to go to a possible clean Brexit.

    "Clean"
  • Options
    Would willingly sign a petition to revoke Alex McLeish.
  • Options
    CD13CD13 Posts: 6,351
    Mr Glenn,

    "That's logical."

    Especially as many they weren't allowed to vote in the original referendum. Perhaps they could make it past 17.4 million with a bit more encouragement?

  • Options
    nico67nico67 Posts: 4,502
    On the face of it the Opinium poll shows people less worried about no deal .

    The problem is the forced choice between two options only.

    Leave with no deal or second EU vote . What if you want a different deal and a delay .

    As a Remainer I’m not into a second vote but don’t want no deal .
  • Options
    Pro_RataPro_Rata Posts: 4,807
    RobD said:

    eek said:

    148grss said:

    https://petitionmap.unboxedconsulting.com/?petition=241584

    I do find this map very interesting; some constituencies have upto 5% signing the petition, which isn't too bad.

    University towns. Snowflakes, Woke Remoaners. Actually "The correlation between the percentage of voters who voted Remain and the proportion of the electorate who have signed the petition is extremely high (r=0.93). There’s little to cut against the idea that this petition comes from people who lost and are unhappy about the result."
    https://medium.com/@chrishanretty/are-we-bremorseful-yet-e0506c826ad2
    Keep referencing an old survey about a different petition if it makes you feel happier...
    Apologies - I thought it was relevant. I accept that the current petition is gaining signatures fast. I wonder whether the geographic split will be similar?
    He's commented on the new petition too:

    https://twitter.com/chrishanretty/status/1108701393836302336
    Yes, my eye of the beholder did not fool. The Labour seat trend line sits below the Tory seat trend line (lower participation in politics) and at the top end, as the graph scatters, a lot of SNP seats well below the trend line (ex-Labour seatss plus, stuff it, independence it is then?)
  • Options
    TrèsDifficileTrèsDifficile Posts: 1,729

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
    The petitions are a little bit cleverer than that - you can see the results broken down into constituencies on a map of the UK.
    It also lists, in the .json file linked on the petition page, all of the locations outside of the UK where it has been 'signed' and the numbers of signatories in each country. France had a greater total (c9000) than any UK constituency the last time I looked.
    That's logical given that more British people live in France than in any single constituency and they have a direct stake in the outcome of Brexit.
    The total number of UK citizens living in France is about 150k. What's the population of Islington South and Finsbury, where the signatory count is 4,500?
  • Options
    dyedwooliedyedwoolie Posts: 7,786
    edited March 2019
    Currently cringing at Kay Burleys 'how did you get to be such an amazing lover' interview with the French ambassador on Sky

    'Why is French food so much better than any other in Europe?' Lmfao
  • Options
    AnneJGPAnneJGP Posts: 2,869
    AndyJS said:

    O/T

    I misread this as "a gammon bias" the first time I saw it, but in fact it's the precise opposite.

    https://twitter.com/DegenRolf/status/1107938899677057024

    What kind of spell-checker changes effect to efect?

    Good evening, everybody. Still lurking in case something happens ....
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,052

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
    The petitions are a little bit cleverer than that - you can see the results broken down into constituencies on a map of the UK.
    It also lists, in the .json file linked on the petition page, all of the locations outside of the UK where it has been 'signed' and the numbers of signatories in each country. France had a greater total (c9000) than any UK constituency the last time I looked.
    That's logical given that more British people live in France than in any single constituency and they have a direct stake in the outcome of Brexit.
    The total number of UK citizens living in France is about 150k. What's the population of Islington South and Finsbury, where the signatory count is 4,500?
    The electorate of Islington South and Finsbury is 67,613.
  • Options
    kjhkjh Posts: 10,620

    199 hours to go to a possible clean Brexit.

    Depends what you mean by clean. Can you tell me what my carnet requirements are in April or do I just stop working? Academic actually as I have stopped working anyway, but the Govt doesn't know that and nobody has told me what to do. I guess the info is out there and it may be my lack of current need, but the comments by Govt that they have contacted businesses is tosh. As far as the Govt is concerned my company is still active with up to date Companies house, Corporation tax and Vat returns. I have received zippo info.
  • Options
    El_CapitanoEl_Capitano Posts: 3,870

    199 hours to go to a possible clean Brexit.

    TBH they've never managed to beat "Mozart's House".

    .....oh, you said Clean Brexit.
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,952
    OT. TIL, between 1908 and 1938 we halved the number of prisoners in this country.
    Not sure what this proves, but was surprising. No one set out any kind of plan to do so.
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,823
    nico67 said:

    On the face of it the Opinium poll shows people less worried about no deal .

    The problem is the forced choice between two options only.

    Leave with no deal or second EU vote . What if you want a different deal and a delay .

    As a Remainer I’m not into a second vote but don’t want no deal .

    The full survey is not yet up on their website, it may have more detail.
  • Options
    AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    "Petitions is down for maintenance
    We know about it and we're working on it.

    Please try again later."

    https://petition.parliament.uk
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,612
    Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    dixiedean said:

    Sean_F said:


    As far as I can tell, there is only one poll that puts No Deal against Revoke, from Survation, in December. Helpfully, it's 49% to 51%.

    Landslide! Will of the People ;)
    The latest Survation poll also has 47% Leave, 53% Remain, so it's an almost perfect match.
    However, Matthew Goodwin reports a poll from Opinium showing 46% support No Deal, as opposed to 39% who support a delay to Brexit.
    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1108760249631211520?s=21
  • Options
    viewcodeviewcode Posts: 18,722
    TOPPING said:

    Endillion said:

    Off topic, but there seem to be a number of (other) gamers on here, and I thought this was fascinating:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/resources/idt-sh/top_scores_video_game_music

    On topic, Sterling taking a bath again.

    Range bound 1.30-1.33. Deal is upside to 1.45-1.48. Downside? Pick your number.
    Ive seen projections of 1.15 USD and 1EUR. Although that might have been internet bollocks. I wish I could remember where I saw it... :(
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 60,976
    Good afternoon, Miss JGP.

    Mr. Dean, what happened to the general demography of the nation over that period? I imagine WWI and the Spanish flu had a statistically significant impact upon the number of young men (the main demographic that ends up in prison).
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,195
    Who gives a f what date they agree. The WA aint passing next week.
  • Options
    TrèsDifficileTrèsDifficile Posts: 1,729

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
    The petitions are a little bit cleverer than that - you can see the results broken down into constituencies on a map of the UK.
    It also lists, in the .json file linked on the petition page, all of the locations outside of the UK where it has been 'signed' and the numbers of signatories in each country. France had a greater total (c9000) than any UK constituency the last time I looked.
    That's logical given that more British people live in France than in any single constituency and they have a direct stake in the outcome of Brexit.
    The total number of UK citizens living in France is about 150k. What's the population of Islington South and Finsbury, where the signatory count is 4,500?
    The electorate of Islington South and Finsbury is 67,613.
    The 150,000 includes under 18s, and the electorate of IS&F does not include residents of the UK unable to vote in elections though entitled to sign. So that figure isn't helpful.
  • Options
    Pro_RataPro_Rata Posts: 4,807
    edited March 2019
    DougSeal said:

    199 hours to go to a possible clean Brexit.

    "Clean"
    You had sixteen pints and a curry, hit your girlfriend, she left you, you repeatedly shat the bed, but hey, you had a shower, closed the bedroom door after some air freshener, and are sitting in the peace watching the footy.

    CLEEEEEAAN
  • Options
    kjhkjh Posts: 10,620

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
    The petitions are a little bit cleverer than that - you can see the results broken down into constituencies on a map of the UK.
    It also lists, in the .json file linked on the petition page, all of the locations outside of the UK where it has been 'signed' and the numbers of signatories in each country. France had a greater total (c9000) than any UK constituency the last time I looked.
    That's logical given that more British people live in France than in any single constituency and they have a direct stake in the outcome of Brexit.
    The total number of UK citizens living in France is about 150k. What's the population of Islington South and Finsbury, where the signatory count is 4,500?
    I think the British residents in France might just be a little more concerned about Brexit don't you?
  • Options

    Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    dixiedean said:

    Sean_F said:


    As far as I can tell, there is only one poll that puts No Deal against Revoke, from Survation, in December. Helpfully, it's 49% to 51%.

    Landslide! Will of the People ;)
    The latest Survation poll also has 47% Leave, 53% Remain, so it's an almost perfect match.
    However, Matthew Goodwin reports a poll from Opinium showing 46% support No Deal, as opposed to 39% who support a delay to Brexit.
    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1108760249631211520?s=21
    Those are very worrying - no deal growing
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    edited March 2019
    DougSeal said:

    199 hours to go to a possible clean Brexit.

    "Clean"
    http://www.macmillandictionary.com/amp/dictionary/british/a-clean-break
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,917

    Who gives a f what date they agree. The WA aint passing next week.
    This is helpful information for people voting in the Commons though.
  • Options
    SquareRootSquareRoot Posts: 7,095

    Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    dixiedean said:

    Sean_F said:


    As far as I can tell, there is only one poll that puts No Deal against Revoke, from Survation, in December. Helpfully, it's 49% to 51%.

    Landslide! Will of the People ;)
    The latest Survation poll also has 47% Leave, 53% Remain, so it's an almost perfect match.
    However, Matthew Goodwin reports a poll from Opinium showing 46% support No Deal, as opposed to 39% who support a delay to Brexit.
    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1108760249631211520?s=21
    That isn't true of course as taking into account extremes of margin of error, opinion might not have moved at all.
  • Options
    nico67nico67 Posts: 4,502
    If you’re a Labour MP in a leave area worried about no deal but you don’t want to vote for the deal then doesn’t the current impasse give you the chance to support the Kyle/Wilson amendment .

    You stop no deal and ask for the public to ratify the deal .
  • Options
    FloaterFloater Posts: 14,195
    kjh said:

    199 hours to go to a possible clean Brexit.

    Depends what you mean by clean. Can you tell me what my carnet requirements are in April or do I just stop working? Academic actually as I have stopped working anyway, but the Govt doesn't know that and nobody has told me what to do. I guess the info is out there and it may be my lack of current need, but the comments by Govt that they have contacted businesses is tosh. As far as the Govt is concerned my company is still active with up to date Companies house, Corporation tax and Vat returns. I have received zippo info.
    I would hope active companies would be a little more proactive tbh.
  • Options
    logical_songlogical_song Posts: 9,709

    Who gives a f what date they agree. The WA aint passing next week.
    OK, so TMay resigns and her Deal is dust. That might make it easier to break the logjam.
  • Options
    TrèsDifficileTrèsDifficile Posts: 1,729
    kjh said:

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
    The petitions are a little bit cleverer than that - you can see the results broken down into constituencies on a map of the UK.
    It also lists, in the .json file linked on the petition page, all of the locations outside of the UK where it has been 'signed' and the numbers of signatories in each country. France had a greater total (c9000) than any UK constituency the last time I looked.
    That's logical given that more British people live in France than in any single constituency and they have a direct stake in the outcome of Brexit.
    The total number of UK citizens living in France is about 150k. What's the population of Islington South and Finsbury, where the signatory count is 4,500?
    I think the British residents in France might just be a little more concerned about Brexit don't you?
    How many of them have lived outside the UK for 15 years plus? They don't get a vote
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,052

    kjh said:

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
    The petitions are a little bit cleverer than that - you can see the results broken down into constituencies on a map of the UK.
    It also lists, in the .json file linked on the petition page, all of the locations outside of the UK where it has been 'signed' and the numbers of signatories in each country. France had a greater total (c9000) than any UK constituency the last time I looked.
    That's logical given that more British people live in France than in any single constituency and they have a direct stake in the outcome of Brexit.
    The total number of UK citizens living in France is about 150k. What's the population of Islington South and Finsbury, where the signatory count is 4,500?
    I think the British residents in France might just be a little more concerned about Brexit don't you?
    How many of them have lived outside the UK for 15 years plus? They don't get a vote
    The franchise for any second referendum would be decided by legislation. Perhaps we should give them a vote.
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,952

    Good afternoon, Miss JGP.

    Mr. Dean, what happened to the general demography of the nation over that period? I imagine WWI and the Spanish flu had a statistically significant impact upon the number of young men (the main demographic that ends up in prison).

    I do not know. Fair point, but it would not have halved the number. On the other side, many would have come back traumatised, and there was also the worst depression in modern times, which logic would suggest may lead to more crimes.
    So, no idea.
  • Options
    TrèsDifficileTrèsDifficile Posts: 1,729

    kjh said:

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
    The petitions are a little bit cleverer than that - you can see the results broken down into constituencies on a map of the UK.
    It also lists, in the .json file linked on the petition page, all of the locations outside of the UK where it has been 'signed' and the numbers of signatories in each country. France had a greater total (c9000) than any UK constituency the last time I looked.
    That's logical given that more British people live in France than in any single constituency and they have a direct stake in the outcome of Brexit.
    The total number of UK citizens living in France is about 150k. What's the population of Islington South and Finsbury, where the signatory count is 4,500?
    I think the British residents in France might just be a little more concerned about Brexit don't you?
    How many of them have lived outside the UK for 15 years plus? They don't get a vote
    The franchise for any second referendum would be decided by legislation. Perhaps we should give them a vote.
    When we No Deal out of there, they're probably best off applying for French citizenship and forgetting about voting here.
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 60,976
    Mr. Glenn, changing the franchise from the last referendum to the next would be a fantastic way to make the result even more contentious and politics more fractious.
  • Options
    TrèsDifficileTrèsDifficile Posts: 1,729
    7 of my facebook friends have shared the revoke petition. I wonder how quickly that would drop if I shared the No Deal petition!
  • Options
    Nigel_ForemainNigel_Foremain Posts: 13,781

    Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    dixiedean said:

    Sean_F said:


    As far as I can tell, there is only one poll that puts No Deal against Revoke, from Survation, in December. Helpfully, it's 49% to 51%.

    Landslide! Will of the People ;)
    The latest Survation poll also has 47% Leave, 53% Remain, so it's an almost perfect match.
    However, Matthew Goodwin reports a poll from Opinium showing 46% support No Deal, as opposed to 39% who support a delay to Brexit.
    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1108760249631211520?s=21
    Those are very worrying - no deal growing
    Collective insanity in evidence. The stupidity of the crowd
  • Options
    RobCRobC Posts: 398

    Who gives a f what date they agree. The WA aint passing next week.
    Well perhaps it should. I voted remain but I can't see the point of precipitating a no deal. More remainer MPs need to follow the lead of Tissue Price's adversary in 2017 in Don Valley Caroline Flint and back the Deal not out of love of the Tories or the Deal but because No Deal is a very bad idea that will cause significant and unnecessary disruption to their constituents lives.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,052

    Mr. Glenn, changing the franchise from the last referendum to the next would be a fantastic way to make the result even more contentious and politics more fractious.

    If Brexit is not about blood and soil nationalism, why not give EU citizens resident in the UK a vote? Brexit campaigners could try to appeal to them with their visions of the Brexit sunlit uplands.
  • Options
    Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981
    dixiedean said:

    OT. TIL, between 1908 and 1938 we halved the number of prisoners in this country.
    Not sure what this proves, but was surprising. No one set out any kind of plan to do so.

    Source?
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,917
    Big news in the @Pulpstar household, my other half has signed the revocation petition.
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,952

    How pleased will the revokers be if their petition reaches 100 million signatures?

    They will be delighted at the solidarity from North Korea and Western Sahara......
    The petitions are a little bit cleverer than that - you can see the results broken down into constituencies on a map of the UK.
    It also lists, in the .json file linked on the petition page, all of the locations outside of the UK where it has been 'signed' and the numbers of signatories in each country. France had a greater total (c9000) than any UK constituency the last time I looked.
    That's logical given that more British people live in France than in any single constituency and they have a direct stake in the outcome of Brexit.
    The total number of UK citizens living in France is about 150k. What's the population of Islington South and Finsbury, where the signatory count is 4,500?
    The electorate of Islington South and Finsbury is 67,613.
    The 150,000 includes under 18s, and the electorate of IS&F does not include residents of the UK unable to vote in elections though entitled to sign. So that figure isn't helpful.
    Latest estimate for Islington is 235 000. IS+F would be approximately half that.
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,592
    Pulpstar said:

    Big news in the @Pulpstar household, my other half has signed the revocation petition.

    Is she a bot? or are you feeling peer presurre? :)
  • Options
    tpfkartpfkar Posts: 1,546
    Pulpstar said:

    Big news in the @Pulpstar household, my other half has signed the revocation petition.

    So has mine. That is not normal - she usually avoids politics like the plague, and is resentful to the number of Council meetings I have to go to.
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,952
    RobC said:

    Who gives a f what date they agree. The WA aint passing next week.
    Well perhaps it should. I voted remain but I can't see the point of precipitating a no deal. More remainer MPs need to follow the lead of Tissue Price's adversary in 2017 in Don Valley Caroline Flint and back the Deal not out of love of the Tories or the Deal but because No Deal is a very bad idea that will cause significant and unnecessary disruption to their constituents lives.
    Caroline Flint hasn't backed the deal.
  • Options
    Pro_RataPro_Rata Posts: 4,807
    Pulpstar said:

    Big news in the @Pulpstar household, my other half has signed the revocation petition.

    It's not mutually exclusive with also hoping the deal gets passed, you know.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,917
    Foxy said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Big news in the @Pulpstar household, my other half has signed the revocation petition.

    Is she a bot? or are you feeling peer presurre? :)
    I've backed the petition to pass May's deal, we're up to 52 signatures but the petitiuon has now crashed !
  • Options
    Tissue_PriceTissue_Price Posts: 9,039
    dixiedean said:

    RobC said:

    Who gives a f what date they agree. The WA aint passing next week.
    Well perhaps it should. I voted remain but I can't see the point of precipitating a no deal. More remainer MPs need to follow the lead of Tissue Price's adversary in 2017 in Don Valley Caroline Flint and back the Deal not out of love of the Tories or the Deal but because No Deal is a very bad idea that will cause significant and unnecessary disruption to their constituents lives.
    Caroline Flint hasn't backed the deal.
    https://twitter.com/CarolineFlintMP/status/1108684142143852544
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,917
    Pro_Rata said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Big news in the @Pulpstar household, my other half has signed the revocation petition.

    It's not mutually exclusive with also hoping the deal gets passed, you know.
    Sure, I might consider signing it after the MV has failed.
  • Options
    FloaterFloater Posts: 14,195
    lol - look at the headline not the url

    https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2019/03/21/markets-latest-news-pound-euro-ftse-100-no-deal-worries-grip/

    bit of a handbrake turn there......
  • Options
    Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091

    dixiedean said:

    RobC said:

    Who gives a f what date they agree. The WA aint passing next week.
    Well perhaps it should. I voted remain but I can't see the point of precipitating a no deal. More remainer MPs need to follow the lead of Tissue Price's adversary in 2017 in Don Valley Caroline Flint and back the Deal not out of love of the Tories or the Deal but because No Deal is a very bad idea that will cause significant and unnecessary disruption to their constituents lives.
    Caroline Flint hasn't backed the deal.
    https://twitter.com/CarolineFlintMP/status/1108684142143852544
    And she voted for the deal last week too.

    Though she also voted for the Spelman amendment to take No Deal "off the table" forever.
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,195

    Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    dixiedean said:

    Sean_F said:


    As far as I can tell, there is only one poll that puts No Deal against Revoke, from Survation, in December. Helpfully, it's 49% to 51%.

    Landslide! Will of the People ;)
    The latest Survation poll also has 47% Leave, 53% Remain, so it's an almost perfect match.
    However, Matthew Goodwin reports a poll from Opinium showing 46% support No Deal, as opposed to 39% who support a delay to Brexit.
    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1108760249631211520?s=21
    Those are very worrying - no deal growing
    Collective insanity in evidence. The stupidity of the crowd
    I am once again reminded of the words of HL Mencken.
  • Options
    nico67nico67 Posts: 4,502

    Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    dixiedean said:

    Sean_F said:


    As far as I can tell, there is only one poll that puts No Deal against Revoke, from Survation, in December. Helpfully, it's 49% to 51%.

    Landslide! Will of the People ;)
    The latest Survation poll also has 47% Leave, 53% Remain, so it's an almost perfect match.
    However, Matthew Goodwin reports a poll from Opinium showing 46% support No Deal, as opposed to 39% who support a delay to Brexit.
    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1108760249631211520?s=21
    Those are very worrying - no deal growing
    Collective insanity in evidence. The stupidity of the crowd
    I think it’s a case of some just being fed up and wanting it to end . The issue with the poll is just two choices . The Ipsos Mori shows more support a delay. Much depends on how you word these things .

  • Options
    FloaterFloater Posts: 14,195
    dixiedean said:

    RobC said:

    Who gives a f what date they agree. The WA aint passing next week.
    Well perhaps it should. I voted remain but I can't see the point of precipitating a no deal. More remainer MPs need to follow the lead of Tissue Price's adversary in 2017 in Don Valley Caroline Flint and back the Deal not out of love of the Tories or the Deal but because No Deal is a very bad idea that will cause significant and unnecessary disruption to their constituents lives.
    Caroline Flint hasn't backed the deal.
    Cough - err you sure?
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 60,976
    Mr. Dean, that's a good point.

    Mr. Glenn, giving citizens of other EU countries a say on whether the UK can leave or not is nuts, and would only make a result more open to dispute. Rather suspecting you're being a tinker on purpose, you naughty sausage.
  • Options
    brokenwheelbrokenwheel Posts: 3,352
    edited March 2019
    Scott_P said:
    Christ, Pob is the last person we need.
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,195

    Who gives a f what date they agree. The WA aint passing next week.
    OK, so TMay resigns and her Deal is dust. That might make it easier to break the logjam.
    I dont think she will resign. She will press on, believing only she can handle the No Deal chaos.

    Get rid. VNOC or Cabinet and men in suits urgently needed. She has become deluded.
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,952
    dixiedean said:

    RobC said:

    Who gives a f what date they agree. The WA aint passing next week.
    Well perhaps it should. I voted remain but I can't see the point of precipitating a no deal. More remainer MPs need to follow the lead of Tissue Price's adversary in 2017 in Don Valley Caroline Flint and back the Deal not out of love of the Tories or the Deal but because No Deal is a very bad idea that will cause significant and unnecessary disruption to their constituents lives.
    Caroline Flint hasn't backed the deal.
    Oops! Looks like I am Fake News. Sorry.
  • Options
    FloaterFloater Posts: 14,195
    nico67 said:

    If you’re a Labour MP in a leave area worried about no deal but you don’t want to vote for the deal then doesn’t the current impasse give you the chance to support the Kyle/Wilson amendment .

    You stop no deal and ask for the public to ratify the deal .

    And where do you get the time for that?
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 60,976
    Mr. Wheel, better Gove than May.

    I'm aware that's quite a backhanded compliment. Excepting Corbyn and probably Boris, almost anyone else would be better.
  • Options
    BudGBudG Posts: 711
    Does Dictator May have the final say as to whether we intend to hold European Elections in May, or would that decision have to come from Parliament?
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,823
    nico67 said:

    Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    dixiedean said:

    Sean_F said:


    As far as I can tell, there is only one poll that puts No Deal against Revoke, from Survation, in December. Helpfully, it's 49% to 51%.

    Landslide! Will of the People ;)
    The latest Survation poll also has 47% Leave, 53% Remain, so it's an almost perfect match.
    However, Matthew Goodwin reports a poll from Opinium showing 46% support No Deal, as opposed to 39% who support a delay to Brexit.
    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1108760249631211520?s=21
    Those are very worrying - no deal growing
    Collective insanity in evidence. The stupidity of the crowd
    I think it’s a case of some just being fed up and wanting it to end . The issue with the poll is just two choices . The Ipsos Mori shows more support a delay. Much depends on how you word these things .

    That's true. You can produce majorities for and against a second referendum, depending on the wording of the question.
  • Options
    TrèsDifficileTrèsDifficile Posts: 1,729
    Pulpstar said:

    Foxy said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Big news in the @Pulpstar household, my other half has signed the revocation petition.

    Is she a bot? or are you feeling peer presurre? :)
    I've backed the petition to pass May's deal, we're up to 52 signatures but the petitiuon has now crashed !
    I was 58, and it crashed at 59
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,952
    Ishmael_Z said:

    dixiedean said:

    OT. TIL, between 1908 and 1938 we halved the number of prisoners in this country.
    Not sure what this proves, but was surprising. No one set out any kind of plan to do so.

    Source?
    Ishmael_Z said:

    dixiedean said:

    OT. TIL, between 1908 and 1938 we halved the number of prisoners in this country.
    Not sure what this proves, but was surprising. No one set out any kind of plan to do so.

    Source?
    A professor of criminology speaking on R5L this afternoon. He was governor of Wormwood Scrubs. No reason to doubt him.
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,195

    eristdoof said:

    philiph said:

    Andrew said:

    eristdoof said:

    Thinking aloud, is there anything that May can threaten to make the consequences of not passing MV3 totally unacceptable to All conservatives and the DUP? I. e. the neuclear option.

    For the Tories: expel any MPs who vote against MV3, and then call a GE.
    Just withdraw the whip of any who do not vote for the deal for 3 weeks or so.

    Fanatics on both siders (ERG and Remain) will no longer be able to take part in the activities of the Tory party in Westminster.
    At which point May no longer has a majority for anything and gets VONCed faster than you can say "Oh, Jeremy Corbyn".
    Doesn't may remain primeminister for two weeks even if she is VoNCd?
    I think it is "upto" two weeks. iirc if her Majesty is persuaded, through the usual channels, that someone else can command confidence, then the cars are heading to the palace.
    If May refuses to resign how can Her Majesty be persuaded? That seems to be a bit of a legal grey area.
    Presumably someone else can propose a vote of confidence in an alternative administration before then?
    That's what seems to be confusing. The law says 'an early general election is held, unless the House of Commons subsequently resolves "That this House has confidence in Her Majesty's Government". '

    So its not a vote of confidence in a potential alternative administration but in the Government. If May doesn't resign and suggest that Her Majesty calls Corbyn [for example] I don't see how the issue gets forced? The Act doesn't really address that point.
    Yet more reasons why the FTPA is a disaster. Another fine mess from Cameron.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    edited March 2019
    deleted
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,195

    Brief trumpet blow. :smiley:

    This is my 20,000th post!

    Time well spent hopefully.

    Well done. It is a milestone
    Cheers Big_G.

    Good to see you posting again. Hope family is coping with recent events.
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 7,988
    Pulpstar said:

    Big news in the @Pulpstar household, my other half has signed the revocation petition.

    Following your lead?
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,823
    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6817095/Italian-prosecutors-probe-death-Moroccan-model-33-gave-evidence-bunga-bunga-trial.html

    Far worse atrocities take place around the world, but I do find this particularly depressing. Poison is just such a callous way to murder someone.
  • Options
    NigelbNigelb Posts: 62,538
    She is not really a contender, but even so, these are terrible numbers for Gillibrand:
    https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/435119-poll-gillibrand-de-blasio-have-favorable-ratings-under-30-percent-among-new

    (And rather good for Biden.)
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,952
    dixiedean said:

    Ishmael_Z said:

    dixiedean said:

    OT. TIL, between 1908 and 1938 we halved the number of prisoners in this country.
    Not sure what this proves, but was surprising. No one set out any kind of plan to do so.

    Source?
    Ishmael_Z said:

    dixiedean said:

    OT. TIL, between 1908 and 1938 we halved the number of prisoners in this country.
    Not sure what this proves, but was surprising. No one set out any kind of plan to do so.

    Source?
    A professor of criminology speaking on R5L this afternoon. He was governor of Wormwood Scrubs. No reason to doubt him.
    This chap https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Wilson_(criminologist)
  • Options
    El_CapitanoEl_Capitano Posts: 3,870
    Just seen on Facebook:

    "Has anyone heard from the People's Vote leadership about whether the time is right yet, or whether we should still be waiting a bit?"
  • Options
    mattmatt Posts: 3,789
    RobC said:

    Who gives a f what date they agree. The WA aint passing next week.
    Well perhaps it should. I voted remain but I can't see the point of precipitating a no deal. More remainer MPs need to follow the lead of Tissue Price's adversary in 2017 in Don Valley Caroline Flint and back the Deal not out of love of the Tories or the Deal but because No Deal is a very bad idea that will cause significant and unnecessary disruption to their constituents lives.
    I should have thought that this soft(ish) exit provides, depending on where one sits, either (a) a platform from which it’s relatively easy to rejoin the EU if (if!) Brexit is suboptimal; or (b) the first step on a straightforward journey to disentangle oneself from a sclerotic and undemocratic blob.

    There’s disdain of Trump in the U.K. (and rightly so) but MPs seem to have adopted, without reservation, his simpleminded view of negotiating as a zero sum, binary game.
  • Options
    _Anazina__Anazina_ Posts: 1,810
    Scott_P said:
    Gove is a tit but would be preferable to MayDay, The Ludicrous Cox, Quarterwit Truss, or most of the other selection of jokers, birdbrains and arch-twatfaces boosterised from time to time.
This discussion has been closed.