politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Now Corbyn could be coming under pressure
Comments
-
I think Jezza played a blinder. When General Thornberry and Labour's Lemming Brigade charged to the cliff, calling to their supporters to follow, he hung back a little. "I'll just stay with Captain Mann, he seems to know what he's doing."
A wise general, even if by accident0 -
Hannan should be offered the Whitney seat for the by-election fight.0
-
You had the EEC, but you wouldn't let it lie, would you? You wouldn't let it lie....weejonnie said:In effect, if the EU had remained a trading block of the richest European countries, mutually co-operating in removing tariffs and encouraging free trade then we would still be in.
But they didn't.0 -
Why spoil good sport Scott ? Your the heir to James Kelly :-)Scott_P said:
So ignore it.Alanbrooke said:and yet you come on here daily and post non-stop drivel
You'll be much happier0 -
They won't need to admit that they made a mistake. They'll just turn on the people who told them it would all be ok.Danny565 said:I think the idea of "buyers' remorse" is wishful thinking from Remainers.
The public are too stubborn to ever admit that they got a decision wrong, atleast not for a very long time afterwards.0 -
I think Boris is the man to beat and if Gove backs him (in exchange for the Chancery) he will be pretty much unstoppable. A remainer is not going to get it and the tories are not daft enough to go back to IDS.Lennon said:Are we agreed that Boris is pretty unlikely to become Tory Leader / PM or am I missing something? I just don't see how he gets to the final 2 given his soured relationship with the Remain section of the party.
On the other hand, I have just had a virtual stand-up argument in the office with people who were going 'obviously it'll be Boris - they'd be mad to pick anyone else'. (Amusingly followed by 'But he's the betting favourite')0 -
As I've suggested before: Rory Stewart. He's a remainer, but he's generally kept his head down and explained his reasons well.peter_from_putney said:Leaving aside the three front runners of Boris, Mrs. May and Michael Gove none of whom I believe has the required attributes to be Prime Minister and discounting also the chances of 3 previously favoured potential candidates, being Messrs. Osborne, Hammond and Javid all of whom have fallen away for one reason or another, who else, including current unknowns, do PBers consider might emerge from the pack over the next couple of months - I must admit I'm struggling to find anyone.
Edit bit: for Morris - please don't suggest your long time favourite and my MP, Ms. Greening, she has absolutely no chance!
I'm probably wrong though.0 -
Rees-Mogg the Lord Home of our times.Omnium said:
Well I've long advocated Rees-Mogg (and I win a massive amount if he gets the gig - it's me backing him on BF, and I just hope it's not Mr RM himself laying the betspeter_from_putney said:Leaving aside the three front runners of Boris, Mrs. May and Michael Gove none of whom I believe has the required attributes to be Prime Minister and discounting also the chances of 3 previously favoured potential candidates, being Messrs. Osborne, Hammond and Javid all of whom have fallen away for one reason or another, who else, including current unknowns, do PBers consider might emerge from the pack over the next couple of months - I must admit I'm struggling to find anyone.
Edit bit: for Morris - please don't suggest your long time favourite and my MP, Ms. Greening, she has absolutely no chance!. Leadsome is a possibility, and there are off-radar choices too. Some people seem to favour Crabb, but I can't see it really)
Edit: Priti Patel is not impossible.0 -
Cameron hasn't said he's leaving parliament.David_Evershed said:Hannan should be offered the Whitney seat for the by-election fight.
0 -
Very true. I predicted that 'would have happened anyway' and 'wrong type of Brexit' would soon become common refrains.Danny565 said:I think the idea of "buyers' remorse" is wishful thinking from Remainers.
The public are too stubborn to ever admit that they got a decision wrong, atleast not for a very long time afterwards.0 -
God, that probably means Chris Grayling gets another job as well. Oh lord. Can anyone think of anything pretty much unbreakable?DavidL said:
I think Boris is the man to beat and if Gove backs him (in exchange for the Chancery) he will be pretty much unstoppable. A remainer is not going to get it and the tories are not daft enough to go back to IDS.Lennon said:Are we agreed that Boris is pretty unlikely to become Tory Leader / PM or am I missing something? I just don't see how he gets to the final 2 given his soured relationship with the Remain section of the party.
On the other hand, I have just had a virtual stand-up argument in the office with people who were going 'obviously it'll be Boris - they'd be mad to pick anyone else'. (Amusingly followed by 'But he's the betting favourite')0 -
Given that there is no realistic way for Dan Hannan or Ruthie to be on the list I too am struggling, and am wondering if the Tories would want to go back to a "safe pair of hands" type leader. If only Hague hadn't stepped down last year...peter_from_putney said:Leaving aside the three front runners of Boris, Mrs. May and Michael Gove none of whom I believe has the required attributes to be Prime Minister and discounting also the chances of 3 previously favoured potential candidates, being Messrs. Osborne, Hammond and Javid all of whom have fallen away for one reason or another, who else, including current unknowns, do PBers consider might emerge from the pack over the next couple of months - I must admit I'm struggling to find anyone.
Edit bit: for Morris - please don't suggest your long time favourite and my MP, Ms. Greening, she has absolutely no chance!0 -
Why would we sign such a deal?FF43 said:
That's not the EEA. It be an FTA that covers the sectors in this table marked in green (cars, aerospace, food, chemicals and machinery) where we have a trade deficit and most not cover the sectors marked in red or orange (finance, insurance and professional services) where we have a surplus. A trade deal that markedly favours the EU in other wordsChelyabinsk said:
Then why has he suggested Britain "opt out of the non-economic aspects of membership, such as foreign affairs, agriculture, fisheries, social policy, environmental law, immigration and citizenship" and argued "We shall control our domestic affairs: taxation, employment law, social policy, defence, farming, fishing, immigration"? Seems pretty clear he doesn't want freedom of movement, even if he might tolerate it.Scott_P said:
He wants Free Movement.Fenster said:I bet Hannan won over more centre left voters than any other Tory on the Leave side. His campaigning and oratory was brilliant. Positive, hopeful, clear and without any hint of malice or fear.
The people who voted Out don't
http://2ihmoy1d3v7630ar9h2rsglp.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/150306_Open_Europe_Brexit_table.png0 -
Listening to Boris and Gove they do not look like they are at ease with the position they are in. The problems labelled 'project fear' are all materialising today and the leavers seem to have no plan of what to do. This is beginning to look far more serious then many acknowledged and I do not see any leader who has the ability and leadership that can deal with this. I wonder if in a few days time many leavers will be having many regrets. I am worried at how this crisis will pan out0
-
Lamy: City will lose its Financial Passport to rest of EU. Frankfurt will pick up0
-
Scott_P said:
@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.
0 -
Oh, but the temerity. The temerity....of DEMOCRACY! It's just not how EU do things....peter_from_putney said:
How is it possible to shake with rage as a result of 17 million honest to goodness British citizens having voted in a way which they believe is genuinely best for their country?David_Evershed said:
Any pictures or link?GIN1138 said:BBC News: EU Official shaking [with rage] when the result came through this morning...
0 -
Cameron should stay, sit at the back, laughing his socks off with Osborne, as every one of their financial warnings comes to pass.Omnium said:
Cameron hasn't said he's leaving parliament.David_Evershed said:Hannan should be offered the Whitney seat for the by-election fight.
0 -
Absolutely, and I hope he's looking forward to the redundancy that he asked of usFenster said:
I bet Hannan won over more centre left voters than any other Tory on the Leave side. His campaigning and oratory was brilliant. Positive, hopeful, clear and without any hint of malice or fear.Indigo said:
Hannan could, he is conspicuously a right-wing communitarian at heart, Gove maybe he is strong associated with the "Good Right" movement, Johnson not so much.Fenster said:The same applies to the Tories, of course. But can Gove, Johnson et al, extend that olive branch as convincingly and winningly as the Labour party could?
Labour as a grassroots movement need to ditch the hectoring SJW types and promote councillors from the WWC areas to be MPs. Let the Coopers and the Thornberrys join the Greens if that's the price for connecting with the working people, the people that just showed up in big numbers to stick two fingers up at the political class.0 -
Cabinet office.DavidL said:
God, that probably means Chris Grayling gets another job as well. Oh lord. Can anyone think of anything pretty much unbreakable?DavidL said:
I think Boris is the man to beat and if Gove backs him (in exchange for the Chancery) he will be pretty much unstoppable. A remainer is not going to get it and the tories are not daft enough to go back to IDS.Lennon said:Are we agreed that Boris is pretty unlikely to become Tory Leader / PM or am I missing something? I just don't see how he gets to the final 2 given his soured relationship with the Remain section of the party.
On the other hand, I have just had a virtual stand-up argument in the office with people who were going 'obviously it'll be Boris - they'd be mad to pick anyone else'. (Amusingly followed by 'But he's the betting favourite')0 -
He didn't say he'd stand down as PM if he lost either, but here we are.Omnium said:
Cameron hasn't said he's leaving parliament.David_Evershed said:Hannan should be offered the Whitney seat for the by-election fight.
0 -
Do you seriously think that these large companies are interested in taking 'revenge' on anybody. They'll be making hard headed decisions on what they think is best for their companies.Stark_Dawning said:
Well, 'Project Fear' is now redundant, so are we soon going to get 'Project Revenge' - the beastly elite punishing Britain for it's plucky stance for independence.Scott_P said:@chrisshipitv: Just heard this rumour in the City: both @BNPParibas and @jpmorgan planning to relocate to Paris #BrexitVote
Oh, and then there is this...
Tata Steel, Britain’s biggest steel producer, said the decision to leave the EU could damage the chances of it maintaining its operations in the UK, according to a person close to the company.0 -
SNP reporting a surge in membership applications.0
-
Who?rottenborough said:Lamy: City will lose its Financial Passport to rest of EU. Frankfurt will pick up
0 -
Duchy of Lancaster?DavidL said:
God, that probably means Chris Grayling gets another job as well. Oh lord. Can anyone think of anything pretty much unbreakable?DavidL said:
I think Boris is the man to beat and if Gove backs him (in exchange for the Chancery) he will be pretty much unstoppable. A remainer is not going to get it and the tories are not daft enough to go back to IDS.Lennon said:Are we agreed that Boris is pretty unlikely to become Tory Leader / PM or am I missing something? I just don't see how he gets to the final 2 given his soured relationship with the Remain section of the party.
On the other hand, I have just had a virtual stand-up argument in the office with people who were going 'obviously it'll be Boris - they'd be mad to pick anyone else'. (Amusingly followed by 'But he's the betting favourite')0 -
remove his train franchises then. Bombardier in Derby will be delighted with the businessMarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.0 -
The Country was warned by these Companies. It is not revenge it is businessMarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.0 -
Because it is better than nothing. Total trade matters as well as trade balances.MaxPB said:
Why would we sign such a deal?FF43 said:
That's not the EEA. It be an FTA that covers the sectors in this table marked in green (cars, aerospace, food, chemicals and machinery) where we have a trade deficit and most not cover the sectors marked in red or orange (finance, insurance and professional services) where we have a surplus. A trade deal that markedly favours the EU in other wordsChelyabinsk said:
Then why has he suggested Britain "opt out of the non-economic aspects of membership, such as foreign affairs, agriculture, fisheries, social policy, environmental law, immigration and citizenship" and argued "We shall control our domestic affairs: taxation, employment law, social policy, defence, farming, fishing, immigration"? Seems pretty clear he doesn't want freedom of movement, even if he might tolerate it.Scott_P said:
He wants Free Movement.Fenster said:I bet Hannan won over more centre left voters than any other Tory on the Leave side. His campaigning and oratory was brilliant. Positive, hopeful, clear and without any hint of malice or fear.
The people who voted Out don't
http://2ihmoy1d3v7630ar9h2rsglp.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/150306_Open_Europe_Brexit_table.png0 -
Equally there is a very big difference between saying today 'we're going to see what happens before making any further decisions' and 'screw you - we're leaving'logical_song said:
Do you seriously think that these large companies are interested in taking 'revenge' on anybody. They'll be making hard headed decisions on what they think is best for their companies.Stark_Dawning said:
Well, 'Project Fear' is now redundant, so are we soon going to get 'Project Revenge' - the beastly elite punishing Britain for it's plucky stance for independence.Scott_P said:@chrisshipitv: Just heard this rumour in the City: both @BNPParibas and @jpmorgan planning to relocate to Paris #BrexitVote
Oh, and then there is this...
Tata Steel, Britain’s biggest steel producer, said the decision to leave the EU could damage the chances of it maintaining its operations in the UK, according to a person close to the company.0 -
Bosses of large companies don't do 'revenge', why should they?MarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.0 -
Let me try this again. Why, if he supports free movement of people, has he specifically said that immigration is one of the areas over which Britain should seek to re-establish control?FF43 said:
That's not the EEA.Chelyabinsk said:
Then why has he suggested Britain "opt out of the non-economic aspects of membership, such as foreign affairs, agriculture, fisheries, social policy, environmental law, immigration and citizenship" and argued "We shall control our domestic affairs: taxation, employment law, social policy, defence, farming, fishing, immigration"? Seems pretty clear he doesn't want freedom of movement, even if he might tolerate it.Scott_P said:
He wants Free Movement.Fenster said:I bet Hannan won over more centre left voters than any other Tory on the Leave side. His campaigning and oratory was brilliant. Positive, hopeful, clear and without any hint of malice or fear.
The people who voted Out don't
0 -
That's beneath them by a long way, and anyway their worst imaginings are unlikely to come to pass.rottenborough said:
Cameron should stay, sit at the back, laughing his socks off with Osborne, as every one of their financial warnings comes to pass.Omnium said:
Cameron hasn't said he's leaving parliament.David_Evershed said:Hannan should be offered the Whitney seat for the by-election fight.
0 -
I agree. Maybe there will be some kind of step back in a few months time. Maybe after a GE.Big_G_NorthWales said:Listening to Boris and Gove they do not look like they are at ease with the position they are in. The problems labelled 'project fear' are all materialising today and the leavers seem to have no plan of what to do. This is beginning to look far more serious then many acknowledged and I do not see any leader who has the ability and leadership that can deal with this. I wonder if in a few days time many leavers will be having many regrets. I am worried at how this crisis will pan out
Frankfurt now rubbing its hands with glee as it becomes the new main financial centre in EU.0 -
They don't need to admit the got the decision wrong, they just correct their recollections of how they voted.Danny565 said:I think the idea of "buyers' remorse" is wishful thinking from Remainers.
The public are too stubborn to ever admit that they got a decision wrong, atleast not for a very long time afterwards.0 -
Agreed, but is there an unknown gem in there somewhere, who is preferably liked and respected on both sided of the great divide?DavidL said:
I think Boris is the man to beat and if Gove backs him (in exchange for the Chancery) he will be pretty much unstoppable. A remainer is not going to get it and the tories are not daft enough to go back to IDS.Lennon said:Are we agreed that Boris is pretty unlikely to become Tory Leader / PM or am I missing something? I just don't see how he gets to the final 2 given his soured relationship with the Remain section of the party.
On the other hand, I have just had a virtual stand-up argument in the office with people who were going 'obviously it'll be Boris - they'd be mad to pick anyone else'. (Amusingly followed by 'But he's the betting favourite')0 -
Yes. That was my greatest fear - I don't trust the current crop of jokers to sort anything out, let alone a catastrophic mess of their own making.Big_G_NorthWales said:Listening to Boris and Gove they do not look like they are at ease with the position they are in. The problems labelled 'project fear' are all materialising today and the leavers seem to have no plan of what to do. This is beginning to look far more serious then many acknowledged and I do not see any leader who has the ability and leadership that can deal with this. I wonder if in a few days time many leavers will be having many regrets. I am worried at how this crisis will pan out
0 -
On the petition itself, it's not in itself a terrible idea for a referendum to be decided by a bit more than 50% +1 vote (turnout limit they suggest way too high though) - but stable doors, horses bolted and all that, too late to rerun on new rules.Scott_P said:Oh FFS
@PaulBrandITV: Looks like we'll have a parliamentary debate on a second EU referendum then. #neverendum #neverendumstory https://t.co/DR8zw63xSn0 -
"Je ne regret rien"Jobabob said:Remain 48%
Leave 40%
Regret 12%
http://theweek.com/speedreads/632139/some-brexit-supporters-now-say-already-regret-voting-leave-eu
A Brexiter.0 -
Because he's an opportunistic professional politician.Chelyabinsk said:
Let me try this again. Why, if he supports free movement of people, has he specifically said that immigration is one of the areas in which Britain should seek to re-establish control?FF43 said:
That's not the EEA.Chelyabinsk said:
Then why has he suggested Britain "opt out of the non-economic aspects of membership, such as foreign affairs, agriculture, fisheries, social policy, environmental law, immigration and citizenship" and argued "We shall control our domestic affairs: taxation, employment law, social policy, defence, farming, fishing, immigration"? Seems pretty clear he doesn't want freedom of movement, even if he might tolerate it.Scott_P said:
He wants Free Movement.Fenster said:I bet Hannan won over more centre left voters than any other Tory on the Leave side. His campaigning and oratory was brilliant. Positive, hopeful, clear and without any hint of malice or fear.
The people who voted Out don't0 -
You say revenge. They say rational business decision based on risk and uncertainty.MarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.0 -
weve been telling you that all this campaign, it's why they've prgressively wound down their UK operations and see us simply as a sales outlet. If they contribute nothing why should they have the benefits of our economy ?logical_song said:
Do you seriously think that these large companies are interested in taking 'revenge' on anybody. They'll be making hard headed decisions on what they think is best for their companies.Stark_Dawning said:
Well, 'Project Fear' is now redundant, so are we soon going to get 'Project Revenge' - the beastly elite punishing Britain for it's plucky stance for independence.Scott_P said:@chrisshipitv: Just heard this rumour in the City: both @BNPParibas and @jpmorgan planning to relocate to Paris #BrexitVote
Oh, and then there is this...
Tata Steel, Britain’s biggest steel producer, said the decision to leave the EU could damage the chances of it maintaining its operations in the UK, according to a person close to the company.0 -
Yes, that sounds safe, ish. Hopefully his collection of photos were only of the previous incumbents.Lennon said:
Duchy of Lancaster?DavidL said:
God, that probably means Chris Grayling gets another job as well. Oh lord. Can anyone think of anything pretty much unbreakable?DavidL said:
I think Boris is the man to beat and if Gove backs him (in exchange for the Chancery) he will be pretty much unstoppable. A remainer is not going to get it and the tories are not daft enough to go back to IDS.Lennon said:Are we agreed that Boris is pretty unlikely to become Tory Leader / PM or am I missing something? I just don't see how he gets to the final 2 given his soured relationship with the Remain section of the party.
On the other hand, I have just had a virtual stand-up argument in the office with people who were going 'obviously it'll be Boris - they'd be mad to pick anyone else'. (Amusingly followed by 'But he's the betting favourite')0 -
they haven't gone yet.Big_G_NorthWales said:
The Country was warned by these Companies. It is not revenge it is businessMarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.0 -
Should have been 2/3 majority.kle4 said:
On the petition itself, it's not in itself a terrible idea for a referendum to be decided by a bit more than 50% +1 vote (turnout limit they suggest way too high though) - but stable doors, horses bolted and all that, too late to rerun on new rules.Scott_P said:Oh FFS
@PaulBrandITV: Looks like we'll have a parliamentary debate on a second EU referendum then. #neverendum #neverendumstory https://t.co/DR8zw63xSn0 -
The psychology of this has been well documented. People refuse to accept they were wrong even when faced with evidence. Instead a different justification is switched to. Humans are narcissists.Danny565 said:I think the idea of "buyers' remorse" is wishful thinking from Remainers.
The public are too stubborn to ever admit that they got a decision wrong, atleast not for a very long time afterwards.
0 -
If the EU treats the UK with spite and vengeance then all it will do is stiffen the resolve of the British people. It would be a ridiculous thing to do because it would prove the 'anti democratic' slurs were true.
It'll be interesting to see if the EU brings in its beloved Tobin Tax now we are gone.
I bet they won't.0 -
Like that thinking! Not sure how long Dave will stay around though, he's only 50 and might fancy a few years on the back benches to annoy the Leavers in Parliament!David_Evershed said:Hannan should be offered the Whitney seat for the by-election fight.
0 -
I say they don't want to reward their client states for going against them, because they know it'll spread.matt said:
You say revenge. They say rational business decision based on risk and uncertainty.MarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.
They don't own us.0 -
And only 1% of the population would have to get such remorse. this wasn't 55:45edmundintokyo said:
They don't need to admit the got the decision wrong, they just correct their recollections of how they voted.Danny565 said:I think the idea of "buyers' remorse" is wishful thinking from Remainers.
The public are too stubborn to ever admit that they got a decision wrong, atleast not for a very long time afterwards.0 -
Maybe ambassador to someone we are really seriously unlikely to go to war with, no matter what he does.MaxPB said:
Cabinet office.DavidL said:
God, that probably means Chris Grayling gets another job as well. Oh lord. Can anyone think of anything pretty much unbreakable?DavidL said:
I think Boris is the man to beat and if Gove backs him (in exchange for the Chancery) he will be pretty much unstoppable. A remainer is not going to get it and the tories are not daft enough to go back to IDS.Lennon said:Are we agreed that Boris is pretty unlikely to become Tory Leader / PM or am I missing something? I just don't see how he gets to the final 2 given his soured relationship with the Remain section of the party.
On the other hand, I have just had a virtual stand-up argument in the office with people who were going 'obviously it'll be Boris - they'd be mad to pick anyone else'. (Amusingly followed by 'But he's the betting favourite')0 -
Spanish stockmarket down 12.5%
Italian market down 10.5%
French market down 8.5%
German market down 7.0%
UK market down 4.0%
I bet the continentals wish they had offered more concessions in the renegotiation now.0 -
Just economics. You know, what those experts who were ignored mentioned a few times.MarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.0 -
That's a really great question. I'd bet they won't too.Fenster said:If the EU treats the UK with spite and vengeance then all it will do is stiffen the resolve of the British people. It would be a ridiculous thing to do because it would prove the 'anti democratic' slurs were true.
It'll be interesting to see if the EU brings in its beloved Tobin Tax now we are gone.
I bet they won't.0 -
I think it's quite clear from what I've read here and the dreadful tw@tter that the Remainers are PRAYING for a recession so that they can say 'told you'. Worse sour grapes than the general election.0
-
And lets hope they don't but I am concerned that the new cabinet won't be in place until October as the economy drifts or worseAlanbrooke said:
they haven't gone yet.Big_G_NorthWales said:
The Country was warned by these Companies. It is not revenge it is businessMarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.0 -
Should have been a 1/4 majority. Not for any good reason of course, but I can pull numbers out of the air as well as you can.rottenborough said:
Should have been 2/3 majority.kle4 said:
On the petition itself, it's not in itself a terrible idea for a referendum to be decided by a bit more than 50% +1 vote (turnout limit they suggest way too high though) - but stable doors, horses bolted and all that, too late to rerun on new rules.Scott_P said:Oh FFS
@PaulBrandITV: Looks like we'll have a parliamentary debate on a second EU referendum then. #neverendum #neverendumstory https://t.co/DR8zw63xSn0 -
Governor of the South Sandwich Islands? Can't see the penguins getting too rebellious no matter what...DavidL said:
Maybe ambassador to someone we are really seriously unlikely to go to war with, no matter what he does.MaxPB said:
Cabinet office.DavidL said:
God, that probably means Chris Grayling gets another job as well. Oh lord. Can anyone think of anything pretty much unbreakable?DavidL said:
I think Boris is the man to beat and if Gove backs him (in exchange for the Chancery) he will be pretty much unstoppable. A remainer is not going to get it and the tories are not daft enough to go back to IDS.Lennon said:Are we agreed that Boris is pretty unlikely to become Tory Leader / PM or am I missing something? I just don't see how he gets to the final 2 given his soured relationship with the Remain section of the party.
On the other hand, I have just had a virtual stand-up argument in the office with people who were going 'obviously it'll be Boris - they'd be mad to pick anyone else'. (Amusingly followed by 'But he's the betting favourite')0 -
I'm getting a pretty serious case of buyers remorse. Leaving the EU just seems to be sacrificing a lot for very little. The one upside I can see right now is that we may not have the FTT while the rest of Europe has it.
I'm also pretty worried about Scotland potentially leaving, really don't want that to happen.0 -
His TV series, founded on the thesis that Hadrians wall created an artificial border followed by a potted history of a dozen kingdoms that straddled the wall without any issue, made me doubt his acumen.JosiasJessop said:
As I've suggested before: Rory Stewart. He's a remainer, but he's generally kept his head down and explained his reasons well.peter_from_putney said:Leaving aside the three front runners of Boris, Mrs. May and Michael Gove none of whom I believe has the required attributes to be Prime Minister and discounting also the chances of 3 previously favoured potential candidates, being Messrs. Osborne, Hammond and Javid all of whom have fallen away for one reason or another, who else, including current unknowns, do PBers consider might emerge from the pack over the next couple of months - I must admit I'm struggling to find anyone.
Edit bit: for Morris - please don't suggest your long time favourite and my MP, Ms. Greening, she has absolutely no chance!
I'm probably wrong though.
Also a Scottish leader may well become rapidly untenable.0 -
Why would it be better than nothing? It probably wouldn't be given the huge deficit we have.FF43 said:
Because it is better than nothing. Total trade matters as well as trade balances.MaxPB said:
Why would we sign such a deal?FF43 said:
That's not the EEA. It be an FTA that covers the sectors in this table marked in green (cars, aerospace, food, chemicals and machinery) where we have a trade deficit and most not cover the sectors marked in red or orange (finance, insurance and professional services) where we have a surplus. A trade deal that markedly favours the EU in other wordsChelyabinsk said:
Then why has he suggested Britain "opt out of the non-economic aspects of membership, such as foreign affairs, agriculture, fisheries, social policy, environmental law, immigration and citizenship" and argued "We shall control our domestic affairs: taxation, employment law, social policy, defence, farming, fishing, immigration"? Seems pretty clear he doesn't want freedom of movement, even if he might tolerate it.Scott_P said:
He wants Free Movement.Fenster said:I bet Hannan won over more centre left voters than any other Tory on the Leave side. His campaigning and oratory was brilliant. Positive, hopeful, clear and without any hint of malice or fear.
The people who voted Out don't
http://2ihmoy1d3v7630ar9h2rsglp.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/150306_Open_Europe_Brexit_table.png0 -
Well if Ruth was in Parliament...but she is not and having her and Boris in the same cabinet just might get complicated.peter_from_putney said:
Agreed, but is there an unknown gem in there somewhere, who is preferably liked and respected on both sided of the great divide?DavidL said:
I think Boris is the man to beat and if Gove backs him (in exchange for the Chancery) he will be pretty much unstoppable. A remainer is not going to get it and the tories are not daft enough to go back to IDS.Lennon said:Are we agreed that Boris is pretty unlikely to become Tory Leader / PM or am I missing something? I just don't see how he gets to the final 2 given his soured relationship with the Remain section of the party.
On the other hand, I have just had a virtual stand-up argument in the office with people who were going 'obviously it'll be Boris - they'd be mad to pick anyone else'. (Amusingly followed by 'But he's the betting favourite')0 -
I really doubt Bombardier in Derby have the capacity. They've just won an order for about 100 new EMU carriages, and from my admittedly flawed memory turned down a large contract last year (or the year before) as they were too busy.Alanbrooke said:
remove his train franchises then. Bombardier in Derby will be delighted with the businessMarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.
According to the latest Rail, the orders for new UK 'trains' (meaning individual carriages) at the beginning of 2016 were as follows:
Bombardier : 886
Siemens : 1,440
Hitachi : 893
CAF : 75
New orders in 2016 have been:
CAF : 407
Bombardier : 92
Hitachi : 95
I doubt Bombardier has anywhere near the capacity to make Siemens' trains, yet alone the others, within the timescales in which they are required. I think in the case of Hitachi they don't even have a product.0 -
75 vs 38 Labour controlled councils voted Leave0
-
Quite. Remind me, how did threatening the British public work out over the last few weeks ?brokenwheel said:
I say they don't want to reward their client states for going against them, because they know it'll spread.matt said:
You say revenge. They say rational business decision based on risk and uncertainty.MarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.
They don't own us.0 -
Turnout thresholds and super majority requirements are terrible. They were terrible in '79, they are terrible now.rottenborough said:
Should have been 2/3 majority.kle4 said:
On the petition itself, it's not in itself a terrible idea for a referendum to be decided by a bit more than 50% +1 vote (turnout limit they suggest way too high though) - but stable doors, horses bolted and all that, too late to rerun on new rules.Scott_P said:Oh FFS
@PaulBrandITV: Looks like we'll have a parliamentary debate on a second EU referendum then. #neverendum #neverendumstory https://t.co/DR8zw63xSn0 -
That's karma, Chameleon.Chameleon said:I'm getting a pretty serious case of buyers remorse. Leaving the EU just seems to be sacrificing a lot for very little. The one upside I can see right now is that we may not have the FTT while the rest of Europe has it.
0 -
So Siemens is no more than a policy arm of the German government. Ok.brokenwheel said:
I say they don't want to reward their client states for going against them, because they know it'll spread.matt said:
You say revenge. They say rational business decision based on risk and uncertainty.MarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.
They don't own us.
0 -
He doesn't want freedom of movement, so that rules out membership of the EU (which I think Hannan was talking about retaining) as well as membership of the EEA. So you are left with a Korean style Free Trade AgreementChelyabinsk said:
Let me try this again. Why, if he supports free movement of people, has he specifically said that immigration is one of the areas over which Britain should seek to re-establish control?FF43 said:
That's not the EEA.Chelyabinsk said:
Then why has he suggested Britain "opt out of the non-economic aspects of membership, such as foreign affairs, agriculture, fisheries, social policy, environmental law, immigration and citizenship" and argued "We shall control our domestic affairs: taxation, employment law, social policy, defence, farming, fishing, immigration"? Seems pretty clear he doesn't want freedom of movement, even if he might tolerate it.Scott_P said:
He wants Free Movement.Fenster said:I bet Hannan won over more centre left voters than any other Tory on the Leave side. His campaigning and oratory was brilliant. Positive, hopeful, clear and without any hint of malice or fear.
The people who voted Out don't0 -
EXPERTS ARRRGH !!!!!!!Thrak said:
Just economics. You know, what those experts who were ignored mentioned a few times.MarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.
The experts in the ad and spin world were assured us they would crush Leave - They didn't
The experts in polling called it for Remain by some margin - totally wrong
The experts in the City have just lost billions of investors money this week when they got it wrong
Experts they know bugger all frankly.0 -
Yeah.Danny565 said:I think the idea of "buyers' remorse" is wishful thinking from Remainers.
The public are too stubborn to ever admit that they got a decision wrong, atleast not for a very long time afterwards.
But joining the EEA or similar might be a way to offer reassurance without actually admitting a mistake. That's what former Remainers need to be focused on promoting.
(Though Labour remainers are more interested in knifing Corbyn, it seems)0 -
Yes, that's the only thing that worries me, dragging this out to October is going to drag on the uncertainty. I think we need the government to lay out what our plan is, do we go EFTA or do we go WTO and then negotiate from outside. I think either can be made to work, and businesses can invest on the basis of either plan, not knowing is worse right now.Big_G_NorthWales said:
And lets hope they don't but I am concerned that the new cabinet won't be in place until October as the economy drifts or worseAlanbrooke said:
they haven't gone yet.Big_G_NorthWales said:
The Country was warned by these Companies. It is not revenge it is businessMarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.0 -
Thank you.FF43 said:
He doesn't want freedom of movementChelyabinsk said:
Let me try this again. Why, if he supports free movement of people, has he specifically said that immigration is one of the areas over which Britain should seek to re-establish control?FF43 said:
That's not the EEA.Chelyabinsk said:
Then why has he suggested Britain "opt out of the non-economic aspects of membership, such as foreign affairs, agriculture, fisheries, social policy, environmental law, immigration and citizenship" and argued "We shall control our domestic affairs: taxation, employment law, social policy, defence, farming, fishing, immigration"? Seems pretty clear he doesn't want freedom of movement, even if he might tolerate it.Scott_P said:
He wants Free Movement.Fenster said:I bet Hannan won over more centre left voters than any other Tory on the Leave side. His campaigning and oratory was brilliant. Positive, hopeful, clear and without any hint of malice or fear.
The people who voted Out don't
0 -
If this is true and it is a surge comparable to post-IndyRef then it's done.rottenborough said:SNP reporting a surge in membership applications.
Farewell rUK, it was nice knowing you. I'll still come to visit my relatives.0 -
Grayling.peter_from_putney said:Leaving aside the three front runners of Boris, Mrs. May and Michael Gove none of whom I believe has the required attributes to be Prime Minister and discounting also the chances of 3 previously favoured potential candidates, being Messrs. Osborne, Hammond and Javid all of whom have fallen away for one reason or another, who else, including current unknowns, do PBers consider might emerge from the pack over the next couple of months - I must admit I'm struggling to find anyone.
Edit bit: for Morris - please don't suggest your long time favourite and my MP, Ms. Greening, she has absolutely no chance!
0 -
How about a Labservative government?0
-
actually that's got more truth in it than you might thinkmatt said:
So Siemens is no more than a policy arm of the German government. Ok.brokenwheel said:
I say they don't want to reward their client states for going against them, because they know it'll spread.matt said:
You say revenge. They say rational business decision based on risk and uncertainty.MarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.
They don't own us.0 -
@BBC_Joe_Lynam: Morgan Stanley says it's begun a process to relocate 2,000 key Investment banking staff from London to either Dublin or Frankfurt0
-
A reminder for those entering via vanillaforums who may not see all the way to the bottom of a header (or the earlier mentions), a donate button to help support site infrastructure is up if anyone feels so inclined following monetary success last night.0
-
Can't they make him Cabinet Minister for Hugging Huskies?DavidL said:
Yes, that sounds safe, ish. Hopefully his collection of photos were only of the previous incumbents.Lennon said:
Duchy of Lancaster?DavidL said:
God, that probably means Chris Grayling gets another job as well. Oh lord. Can anyone think of anything pretty much unbreakable?DavidL said:
I think Boris is the man to beat and if Gove backs him (in exchange for the Chancery) he will be pretty much unstoppable. A remainer is not going to get it and the tories are not daft enough to go back to IDS.Lennon said:Are we agreed that Boris is pretty unlikely to become Tory Leader / PM or am I missing something? I just don't see how he gets to the final 2 given his soured relationship with the Remain section of the party.
On the other hand, I have just had a virtual stand-up argument in the office with people who were going 'obviously it'll be Boris - they'd be mad to pick anyone else'. (Amusingly followed by 'But he's the betting favourite')0 -
If you're going to make that comparison you need to use a single currency: Most of the UK stock market decline is in the drop in value of the token it's denominated in.David_Evershed said:Spanish stockmarket down 12.5%
Italian market down 10.5%
French market down 8.5%
German market down 7.0%
UK market down 4.0%
I bet the continentals wish they had offered more concessions in the renegotiation now.
But no, there's nothing the rest of the EU could reasonably offered Britain that would have swung enough voters to change the outcome. I mean, they could have said Britain would have a veto on Turkish membership, but it already has one.0 -
Oh, and perhaps I should think about changing my plans for a Portugar getaway in the autumn.0
-
Quite the opposite actually...matt said:
So Siemens is no more than a policy arm of the German government. Ok.brokenwheel said:
I say they don't want to reward their client states for going against them, because they know it'll spread.matt said:
You say revenge. They say rational business decision based on risk and uncertainty.MarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.
They don't own us.
That's your globalisation.0 -
LibDemNewswire @LibDemNewswire
Tim Farron has broken the news that 1,000 people have joined Lib Dems already today.
Time for a resurrection?0 -
Quite. The FTSE is now back up to the level it was about a week ago. This is the end of the world? It seems somewhat quiet.Alanbrooke said:
EXPERTS ARRRGH !!!!!!!Thrak said:
Just economics. You know, what those experts who were ignored mentioned a few times.MarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.
The experts in the ad and spin world were assured us they would crush Leave - They didn't
The experts in polling called it for Remain by some margin - totally wrong
The experts in the City have just lost billions of investors money this week when they got it wrong
Experts they know bugger all frankly.0 -
About 1500 posts ago, @another_richard posted this
" There will be plenty of the metropolitan 'elite' looking down the list of places which voted Leave and asking "where are these places?"
I couldn't agree more. And they've blown a giant raspberry at them.
Well done.0 -
Short term perhaps, but if Siemens are saying theyre pulling out its an opportunity for those who want to stay to get more businessJosiasJessop said:
I really doubt Bombardier in Derby have the capacity. They've just won an order for about 100 new EMU carriages, and from my admittedly flawed memory turned down a large contract last year (or the year before) as they were too busy.Alanbrooke said:
remove his train franchises then. Bombardier in Derby will be delighted with the businessMarkHopkins said:Scott_P said:@jo_makel: Siemens boss says future investment and expansion of business in the #Humber is now under threat. More on @looknorthBBC, BBC One 13.45
The revenge begins.
According to the latest Rail, the orders for new UK 'trains' (meaning individual carriages) at the beginning of 2016 were as follows:
Bombardier : 886
Siemens : 1,440
Hitachi : 893
CAF : 75
New orders in 2016 have been:
CAF : 407
Bombardier : 92
Hitachi : 95
I doubt Bombardier has anywhere near the capacity to make Siemens' trains, yet alone the others, within the timescales in which they are required. I think in the case of Hitachi they don't even have a product.
when that fact registers with Siemens they;ll stop talking nonsense.0 -
My reading of Hannan is that he believes that the basis of a society is found in its institutions, and that for the British society to be successful those institutions have to be in the control of the British people, so that they feel pride in their ownership. I think he probably wants EEA style free movement (ie people with jobs), but it is more important to him that the British people get the level of immigration that they feel comfortable with at any moment in time, because that it good for social cohesion.FF43 said:
He doesn't want freedom of movement, so that rules out membership of the EU (which I think Hannan was talking about retaining) as well as membership of the EEA. So you are left with a Korean style Free Trade AgreementChelyabinsk said:
Let me try this again. Why, if he supports free movement of people, has he specifically said that immigration is one of the areas over which Britain should seek to re-establish control?FF43 said:
That's not the EEA.Chelyabinsk said:
Then why has he suggested Britain "opt out of the non-economic aspects of membership, such as foreign affairs, agriculture, fisheries, social policy, environmental law, immigration and citizenship" and argued "We shall control our domestic affairs: taxation, employment law, social policy, defence, farming, fishing, immigration"? Seems pretty clear he doesn't want freedom of movement, even if he might tolerate it.Scott_P said:
He wants Free Movement.Fenster said:I bet Hannan won over more centre left voters than any other Tory on the Leave side. His campaigning and oratory was brilliant. Positive, hopeful, clear and without any hint of malice or fear.
The people who voted Out don't0 -
Scenario:
Cameron pulled the speed brake with is "lets have a new leader first" ploy. That gives months for the Ignorant and Racist contagion to sweep Europe. Podemos take power in Spain, half of Western Europe have demands for their own Leave votes, Schengen folds for good, the banks fall to their knees under the strain.
Eurocrat types realise the jig is up and start looking at plans for a slower looser confederation. With the EU as was collapsing anyway, and the UK being sucked into the black hole of Doom by the markets, PM Boris offers a new vote on membership of the new European Confederation (or "EC" for short), which with the view over the precipice looking large in voters windows, they vote to join the refounded EC.
Do NOT bank on the EU as is continuing.0 -
or Sayeeda Warsi or Kelly Tolhurst?Alanbrooke said:
as much as Sarah Woollaston?Omnium said:
How much would you like at 20? I think I can facilitate most requests at that price, although in fairness there are now better offers available on Betfair.rottenborough said:
Soubry dropped to 20 from around 350 (on BF)Omnium said:So the funniest thing I have ever heard on the BBC
Polly Toynbee would put money on Anna Soubry
I can barely see through the tears of mirth
Soubry has totally wrecked her career this morning.0 -
Who are the Lib Dems?rottenborough said:LibDemNewswire @LibDemNewswire
Tim Farron has broken the news that 1,000 people have joined Lib Dems already today.
Time for a resurrection?0 -
They had loads join after the GE, it hasn't led to anything yet - but if not now, when? Maybe they could be the 'let's reapply to join' party, has to be more than 4-6% people now.rottenborough said:LibDemNewswire @LibDemNewswire
Tim Farron has broken the news that 1,000 people have joined Lib Dems already today.
Time for a resurrection?0 -
SJW? Explain?Sandpit said:
Absolutely, and I hope he's looking forward to the redundancy that he asked of usFenster said:
I bet Hannan won over more centre left voters than any other Tory on the Leave side. His campaigning and oratory was brilliant. Positive, hopeful, clear and without any hint of malice or fear.Indigo said:
Hannan could, he is conspicuously a right-wing communitarian at heart, Gove maybe he is strong associated with the "Good Right" movement, Johnson not so much.Fenster said:The same applies to the Tories, of course. But can Gove, Johnson et al, extend that olive branch as convincingly and winningly as the Labour party could?
Labour as a grassroots movement need to ditch the hectoring SJW types and promote councillors from the WWC areas to be MPs. Let the Coopers and the Thornberrys join the Greens if that's the price for connecting with the working people, the people that just showed up in big numbers to stick two fingers up at the political class.0 -
1001 members is hardly a force to be reckoned with...rottenborough said:LibDemNewswire @LibDemNewswire
Tim Farron has broken the news that 1,000 people have joined Lib Dems already today.
Time for a resurrection?0 -
Any calculations floating around on the effect on Exchequer of losing City revenues like this?Scott_P said:@BBC_Joe_Lynam: Morgan Stanley says it's begun a process to relocate 2,000 key Investment banking staff from London to either Dublin or Frankfurt
0 -
MY one betting regret is that no numbnut backed up their jaw flapping on the whole "Scotland will vote just like the rest of the UK" proposition.0
-
ProbableRochdalePioneers said:S
Do NOT bank on the EU as is continuing.
Nope. It'll change after we leave, or too late to stop it, not before, and Boris or others will not be given an offer even if they wanted to reconsiderRochdalePioneers said:Scenario:
Eurocrat types realise the jig is up and start looking at plans for a slower looser confederation. With the EU as was collapsing anyway, and the UK being sucked into the black hole of Doom by the markets, PM Boris offers a new vote on membership of the new European Confederation (or "EC" for short), which with the view over the precipice looking large in voters windows, they vote to join the refounded EC.
.0 -
http://theweek.com/speedreads/632139/some-brexit-supporters-now-say-already-regret-voting-leave-eu
Democracy in action.
We should of had a mock run of the vote with the consequences after so people knew what they were voting for. Just think all those elites, and establishments and experts....turned out they knew what they were talking about after all.
Shame it is all too late and ignorance and racism has plunged the UK into a crisis.0 -
Is that a scenario or a plan? Leave has been missing a plan from the start and it is getting rather urgent.RochdalePioneers said:Scenario:
Cameron pulled the speed brake with is "lets have a new leader first" ploy. That gives months for the Ignorant and Racist contagion to sweep Europe. Podemos take power in Spain, half of Western Europe have demands for their own Leave votes, Schengen folds for good, the banks fall to their knees under the strain.
Eurocrat types realise the jig is up and start looking at plans for a slower looser confederation. With the EU as was collapsing anyway, and the UK being sucked into the black hole of Doom by the markets, PM Boris offers a new vote on membership of the new European Confederation (or "EC" for short), which with the view over the precipice looking large in voters windows, they vote to join the refounded EC.
Do NOT bank on the EU as is continuing.0 -
I see Feldman will fall on his sword when Cameron's replacement is chosen.
Good.0