Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » A Brexit Carol – how last time is shaping views of GE2019

1235

Comments

  • Options
    BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 31,762
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Posts saying 'at this point in the 2017 campaign the Tories were 15 points ahead' seem to have dried up :)

    I've been away at a wedding and am now just catching up.

    Current Tory lead is 11.0%. It was 17.8% at this stage of GE2017.
    That was before the dementia tax disaster Boris will not repeat and with the Brexit Party included which was not the case in 2017
    True, but the Tory vote share only fell by 3% in the period D-31 to Election Day.

    And the current polls are showing it averaging c. 39%, so 4.5% lower than the GE 2017 result (both exc. NI).

    The Tory vote fell by 4% in favour of Labour post dementia tax, the UKIP vote also collapsed in Labour's favour, the Brexit Party are now going hard in Labour areas
    When was the dementia tax announced?
    Thursday 18th May 2017
    Looking forward to the manifestos this time round :smile:
  • Options
    alb1onalb1on Posts: 698
    RobCL said:

    Flick Drummond elected cons PPC Meon Vallet

    Oh dear. Nothing to do with her politics. My wife knew her in the early 90s when she (Drummond) was the leading light in the Winchester branch of the National Childbirth Trust. My wife is not a political animal or one to make enemies easily but she described Drummond as the most obnoxious individual she ever came across. She described her as a cross between Penelope Keith in her role from 'To the manor born' and Margaret Thatcher.
  • Options
    rural_voterrural_voter Posts: 2,038

    Ishmael_Z said:

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    del.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't get everything that they want by the fact of him standing anywhere, since not everyone agrees on cui bono why are you certain the Tories are the ones who will, even if they did have discussions with him what difference does that make as either they swayed him to step down or he chose to, and it leads to the same outcome. So really, what's with all this 'hmm'ing where its presented as some tremendous potential reveltation if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    There is some prospect of a Boris pivot to the centre if he gets a decent majority. The Trump pivot never happened because Trump is an authentically mad bastard seriously invested in his own delusions. Boris is only invested in the success of Boris, and even if he is elected by right wing bastards he is likely to be more comfortable governing as a cuddly, one nation, Cameron before the crash style tory if his party will let him get away with it.
    Your optimistic! I don't believe all the one nation stuff BJ comes out with, just as I never believed the one nation bluster that came from Cameron. What is one nation about cutting disability benefits or freezing JSA whilst borrowing money to reduce capital gains tax?
    There hasn't been a One Nation Tory PM since Ted Heath. John Major tried his best but was surrounded by, er, bastards.
  • Options
    JonathanJonathan Posts: 20,902

    Ishmael_Z said:

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-



    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't getnce not everyone agrees on cui bono why are y It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    There is some prospect of a Boris pivot to the centre if he gets a decent majority. The Trump pivot never happened because Trump is an authentically mad bastard seriously invested in his own delusions. Boris is only invested in the success of Boris, and even if he is elected by right wing bastards he is likely to be more comfortable governing as a cuddly, one nation, Cameron before the crash style tory if his party will let him get away with it.
    Your optimistic! I don't believe all the one nation stuff BJ comes out with, just as I never believed the one nation bluster that came from Cameron. What is one nation about cutting disability benefits or freezing JSA whilst borrowing money to reduce capital gains tax?
    What is one nation about Brexit, the most divisive issue of our time?

    Not difficult to see which part of the nation will pay the largest part of the cost.
    +1 BJ and the Tories are not One Nation Tories! It is just a slogan used to trick people into believing they are governing in everyone's interests instead of the top 30% Income households.
    Yes, it’s an empty phrase now.
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    Relax cycle free, it’s a bit of unthoughthrough election fluff from Boris that will not happen either because of the far greater impact trying to put NI terrorists away who will be saved under this change, or, where Boris caveated with “unless new evidence comes to light” that caveat is used in 100% of future cases. If there was further detail it would clear both those points up, but at same time further detail render this election promise a deceit.
  • Options
    viewcodeviewcode Posts: 18,935

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't get everything that they want by the fact of him standing anywhere, since not everyone agrees on cui bono why are you certain the Tories are the ones who will, even if they did have discussions with him what difference does that make as either they swayed him to step down or he chose to, and it leads to the same outcome. So really, what's with all this 'hmm'ing where its presented as some tremendous potential reveltation if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    The nation in question being Anglosphere loyalists who would cheerfully nuke the UK if they thought it would add a penny to their diversified trust fund.

  • Options
    I guess this is what Farage wanted. Him being seen as the one responsible for stopping a 2nd ref:

    https://twitter.com/AllieHBNews/status/1194008205157904391
  • Options
    But he probably doesn't like this one:

    https://twitter.com/AllieHBNews/status/1194008999135498240
  • Options

    Ishmael_Z said:

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    del.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't get everything that they want by the fact of him standing anywhere, since not everyone agrees on cui bono why are you certain the Tories are the ones who will, even if they did have discussions with him what difference does that make as either they swayed him to step down or he chose to, and it leads to the same outcome. So really, what's with all this 'hmm'ing where its presented as some tremendous potential reveltation if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    There is some prospect of a Boris pivot to the centre if he gets a decent majority. The Trump pivot never happened because Trump is an authentically mad bastard seriously invested in his own delusions. Boris is only invested in the success of Boris, and even if he is elected by right wing bastards he is likely to be more comfortable governing as a cuddly, one nation, Cameron before the crash style tory if his party will let him get away with it.
    Your optimistic! I don't believe all the one nation stuff BJ comes out with, just as I never believed the one nation bluster that came from Cameron. What is one nation about cutting disability benefits or freezing JSA whilst borrowing money to reduce capital gains tax?
    There hasn't been a One Nation Tory PM since Ted Heath. John Major tried his best but was surrounded by, er, bastards.
    The definition of a 'One Nation' government is a government which takes from 'people like them' and gives to 'people like us'.
  • Options
    The_TaxmanThe_Taxman Posts: 2,979
    nico67 said:

    Bozo decided a Cobra meeting would look good optics .

    More faux empathy and concern designed to dupe people into thinking he gives two hoots .

    BJ is just doing what every Government does, which is using the state apparatus for political gain. It projects power if he can go on the TV and say "we pledge £xx Million to the communities affected by the recent floods".
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    Remainers might think a rampant farage is sign Brexit is in the ascendency, but a farage humiliated like this is sign brexit is in the balance. But look whose humiliated him, Cummings, not remainers. 🙂

    But hang on! Is the real talking point here what Boris said in his video?

    He ruled out extending the transition period for Brexit beyond 2020. But it’s not that because nobody believes he will stick to this deadline, impractical with the amount of work still needed to be done, hence Boris in the video talking up his genius as negotiator how quickly he got the new brexit deal, which is a lie, he put Mays deal in a saucepan, heated it up, and threw in a bit of surrender on northern island May refused to do. So many factors out of Boris control to trust such a promise.

    But in his video Boris said Britain would aim for a free trade agreement ‘on the model of a super Canada-plus arrangement’. Wow. That is remarkably specific in the middle of an election campaign, RIPPING UP THE CURRENT POLITICAL DECLARATION to get Farage to back you. A very clear statement of intent for anyone hoping for a softer brexit in the end, remainers, even brexiteers who wanted softer brexit than that, wondering today to stick with Conservatives in the GE because they could get a softer brexit in the end. Doesn’t look like that’s an option for you now, does it?

    Move another 15 seats from Tory to Libdem imo
  • Options
    JasonJason Posts: 1,614

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
  • Options
    nico67 said:

    Bozo decided a Cobra meeting would look good optics .

    More faux empathy and concern designed to dupe people into thinking he gives two hoots .

    Will we see him in a helicopter with a biggles helmet like Gordon Brown did when he wanted to show some faux empathy designed to dupe people into thinking he gave two hoots ?
  • Options
    viewcodeviewcode Posts: 18,935

    Ishmael_Z said:

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:



    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't get everything that they want by the fact of him standing anywhere, since not everyone agrees on cui bono why are you certain the Tories are the ones who will, even if they did have discussions with him what difference does that make as either they swayed him to step down or he chose to, and it leads to the same outcome. So really, what's with all this 'hmm'ing where its presented as some tremendous potential reveltation if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    There is some prospect of a Boris pivot to the centre if he gets a decent majority. The Trump pivot never happened because Trump is an authentically mad bastard seriously invested in his own delusions. Boris is only invested in the success of Boris, and even if he is elected by right wing bastards he is likely to be more comfortable governing as a cuddly, one nation, Cameron before the crash style tory if his party will let him get away with it.
    Your optimistic! I don't believe all the one nation stuff BJ comes out with, just as I never believed the one nation bluster that came from Cameron. What is one nation about cutting disability benefits or freezing JSA whilst borrowing money to reduce capital gains tax?
    There hasn't been a One Nation Tory PM since Ted Heath. John Major tried his best but was surrounded by, er, bastards.
    The definition of a 'One Nation' government is a government which takes from 'people like them' and gives to 'people like us'.
    Yup. I would use less polite terms, but I think your version is more palatable.
  • Options

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Single figures?

    ELBOW week-ending 3rd November = 11.25% lead
    ELBOW week-ending 10th November = 10.75% lead
  • Options
    olmolm Posts: 125
    edited November 2019

    Floater said:

    kle4 said:

    Good grief it's Groundhog Day here again today...

    That picture of Corbyn. Which crap films are, or are not, Christmas films. The rubbish mural. Pineapple pizza. AV.

    We're caught in a constant loop.

    With Labour and the Tories going to trawl through facebook and twitter accounts for old scandals to mine, old issues are going to be bumped up time and again even more than usual, and I'm helpless but to respond. Lack of impulse control.

    Frankly the mural one I think could so easily be dropped since Corbyn apologised and provided an explanation (whether one accepts it or not), so it really should have no legs left as a political issue, but for some reason people love to carry on the fight he decided not to have. I'm not sure who that is supposed to benefit. It's not him, because he conceded that one years ago!
    Corbyn agreed it was anti semitic - some of his candidate mp's and posters on here seem not to have got the message.
    They are defending him by calling him a liar.
    No. Lying is deliberate deceit.
    If you (or Corbyn for that matter) believe it is anti-semitic, and I believe it isn't, there's not necessarily a lie there. Either view can be wrong without lying.
  • Options
    Well done to Wulfrun Phil for correctly predicting Farage's climbdown.
  • Options
    RobCLRobCL Posts: 23
    JohnO said:

    RobCL said:

    Flick Drummond elected cons PPC Meon Vallet

    Another former moderate (campaigned for Remain in 2016) MP selected for safe seat.
    She was the least moderate of the three on offer

  • Options
    The_TaxmanThe_Taxman Posts: 2,979
    edited November 2019

    nico67 said:

    Bozo decided a Cobra meeting would look good optics .

    More faux empathy and concern designed to dupe people into thinking he gives two hoots .

    Will we see him in a helicopter with a biggles helmet like Gordon Brown did when he wanted to show some faux empathy designed to dupe people into thinking he gave two hoots ?
    Gordon Brown on manoeuvres?

    https://greenreading.files.wordpress.com/2008/07/gordon-brown-gun404_691842c.jpg
  • Options

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't get everything that they want by the fact of him standing anywhere, since not everyone agrees on cui bono why are you certain the Tories are the ones who will, even if they did have discussions with him what difference does that make as either they swayed him to step down or he chose to, and it leads to the same outcome. So really, what's with all this 'hmm'ing where its presented as some tremendous potential reveltation if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    The PM is very much a One Nation Conservative.

    People should stop confusing One Nation with Remainer. They are not synonyms.
  • Options
    Modern capitalism: outsource your distribution to a company that can't manage to pay its employees what little it has agreed to pay them and consequently face a strike crippling your distribution during your busiest period of trading. Good work! Bonuses all round!

    https://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/morrisons-supermarkets-across-scotland-could-be-hit-by-food-shortages-in-the-run-up-to-christmas-1-5043101
  • Options

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
  • Options
    MysticroseMysticrose Posts: 4,688
    edited November 2019
    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    olm said:

    Floater said:

    kle4 said:

    Good grief it's Groundhog Day here again today...

    That picture of Corbyn. Which crap films are, or are not, Christmas films. The rubbish mural. Pineapple pizza. AV.

    We're caught in a constant loop.

    With Labour and the Tories going to trawl through facebook and twitter accounts for old scandals to mine, old issues are going to be bumped up time and again even more than usual, and I'm helpless but to respond. Lack of impulse control.

    Frankly the mural one I think could so easily be dropped since Corbyn apologised and provided an explanation (whether one accepts it or not), so it really should have no legs left as a political issue, but for some reason people love to carry on the fight he decided not to have. I'm not sure who that is supposed to benefit. It's not him, because he conceded that one years ago!
    Corbyn agreed it was anti semitic - some of his candidate mp's and posters on here seem not to have got the message.
    1) Corbyn agreeing that, whether for pragmatic reasons, or not, doesn't make or prove it anti-semitic.
    2) Since you're likely to be including me when referring to 'posters on here', I have to repeat, my point is that the mural is not *obviously* anti-semitic.
    3) Since you appear to think it is, it would be interesting to know what exactly about it is anti-semitic about it and apparent?
    I think that mural is anti Semitic because “the few” deciding the fate of the many clearly painted with the characteristics of Jewish people.
  • Options
    JasonJason Posts: 1,614
    Talking about Wishful Thinking - my word listen to this brilliance from some of Liverpool's very finest -

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r1J8NBSoUgk
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    It’s illegal to sell a peerage? But not illegal to trade one for electoral pacts?
  • Options
    MysticroseMysticrose Posts: 4,688

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
  • Options
    olmolm Posts: 125
    edited November 2019
    kle4 said:

    olm said:

    And so it goes on .......

    Labour Candidate Claimed Mural Isn't Anti-Semitic https://t.co/E43W05NOtT

    It isn't clearly anti-semitic.
    If you think it is, can you explain?
    I never get tired of this classic. Even some otherwise very sensible people use it. Butpeople claiming it wasn't clearly anti-semitic should ask this chap about that:

    Jeremy Corbyn has expressed "sincere regret" at failing to look more closely at an allegedly anti-Semitic mural in London before questioning its removal...

    In a statement, Mr Corbyn said he had intended to make a "general comment" about the removal of public art on the grounds of freedom of speech.

    He added: "I sincerely regret that I did not look more closely at the image I was commenting on, the contents of which are deeply disturbing and anti-Semitic.


    https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-43523445

    Now, not everything Mr Corbyn says is true. But unless he was lying because he is weak, he at least thinks it was clearly anti-semitic since it was only because of poor attention that he did not spot that immediately. I think it highly unlikely he would defend himself on the grounds of poor attention being given if it was credible to use another defence.
    I don't expect Corbyn was lying; perhaps misconceived, which is very different.
    I never get tired of this classic 'the mural was anti-semitic' with still no explanation as to why. (Corbyn's view of it being anti-semitic is not an explanation why). I'm happy to be illuminated otherwise if I'm misconceived and missed something?
  • Options

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.
    Tories aren't starting to get a bit jittery.

    Tories have been jittery since 22:00 on 08/06/17 [DavidL and others got jittery before then] and will be jittery until 22:00 on 12/12/19 whatever the polls say.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
    One of those is a week old.
  • Options
    Ave_itAve_it Posts: 2,411
    We will have a clearer idea in 31 days time!

    I won't relax until Dimbleby says 'and the exit poll says CON overall majority' (or maybe not :fearful: )
  • Options
    SunnyJimSunnyJim Posts: 1,106
    Placed my first bet this evening laying Con maj for £250.

    My plan is to place 3 more lays of the same size weekly in the lead up to the election.

    I suspect 1.67 may be the lowest priced lay of the 4 but we will see.
  • Options

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.
    I'm curious as to why you think the lead is in single figures.

    According to wiki the last four poll leads were 12%, 13%, 12% and 10%:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_for_the_2019_United_Kingdom_general_election

    Are there some polls I don't know about ?
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    I agree with big G. All polling companies have to have Labour within 5 points in the last week of the campaign to justify that sort of excitement.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985
    Ave_it said:

    We will have a clearer idea in 31 days time!

    I won't relax until Dimbleby says 'and the exit poll says CON overall majority' (or maybe not :fearful: )

    BONG.

    Oops, I should have put a trigger warning.
  • Options
    CookieCookie Posts: 11,501

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't get everything that they want by the fact of him standing anywhere, since not everyone agrees on cui bono why are you certain the Tories are the ones who will, even if they did have discussions with him what difference does that make as either they swayed him to step down or he chose to, and it leads to the same outcome. So really, what's with all this 'hmm'ing where its presented as some tremendous potential reveltation if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    The PM is very much a One Nation Conservative.

    People should stop confusing One Nation with Remainer. They are not synonyms.
    Yes, very much so. Similarly, there is often a lazy belief that dry as dust economically = socially conservative = Eurosceptic. And sometimes it does. But often it doesn't. Calling anyone Eurosceptic right-wing is confusing and unhelpful. There are members of all parties who fall into one of these categories.
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,137

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Single figures?

    ELBOW week-ending 3rd November = 11.25% lead
    ELBOW week-ending 10th November = 10.75% lead
    Someone who doesn't know their arse from their ELBOW......
  • Options
    JonathanJonathan Posts: 20,902
    edited November 2019

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't get everything that they want by the fact of him standing anywhere, since not everyone agrees on cui bono why are you certain the Tories are the ones who will, even if they did have discussions with him what difference does that make as either they swayed him to step down or he chose to, and it leads to the same outcome. So really, what's with all this 'hmm'ing where its presented as some tremendous potential reveltation if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    The PM is very much a One Nation Conservative.

    People should stop confusing One Nation with Remainer. They are not synonyms.
    ROFL. Boris in a one Johnson Conservative.
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    edited November 2019
    RobD said:

    Ave_it said:

    We will have a clearer idea in 31 days time!

    I won't relax until Dimbleby says 'and the exit poll says CON overall majority' (or maybe not :fearful: )

    BONG.

    Oops, I should have put a trigger warning.
    No Dimbleby this time. Huw Edwards?

    Apart from that your spot on Ave it.
  • Options

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
    You need to compare like-for-like with pollsters to eliminate house effects. Those are margin of error changes from the prior poll of each and net averages to no movement in the polls. One has the lead increasing by 1% and the other decreasing by 1%.
  • Options

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.
    It does not appear to be in single figures.

    You may want to blindside yourself to it but as Sunhil says the average is 10.75

    Do not fall into fake news
  • Options
    MysticroseMysticrose Posts: 4,688

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't get everything that they want by the fact of him standing anywhere, since not everyone agrees on cui bono why are you certain the Tories are the ones who will, even if they did have discussions with him what difference does that make as either they swayed him to step down or he chose to, and it leads to the same outcome. So really, what's with all this 'hmm'ing where its presented as some tremendous potential reveltation if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    The PM is very much a One Nation Conservative.

    People should stop confusing One Nation with Remainer. They are not synonyms.
    I think ascribing any over-arching ethos or belief system to Boris Johnson is epistemologically and ontologically unsound.

    Johnson has only one driving philosophy:

    Narcissism

    Nothing else matters beside that. Anything can be bent to its desire. It's all about 'me.'
  • Options
    The_TaxmanThe_Taxman Posts: 2,979

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    The PM is very much a One Nation Conservative.

    People should stop confusing One Nation with Remainer. They are not synonyms.
    What is one nation about giving an average £6,000 tax cut to those on the highest income by increasing Government borrowing according to a piece in the Boris supporting Daily Telegraph recently? I have been around politics long enough to see leading politicians for what they represent rather than what they project. BJ does not fool me! He is not One Nation and paradoxically given his completely unpredictable and reckless nature our old friend Peter Hitchens will probably denounce him at some point as not being Conservative! :wink:
  • Options
    viewcodeviewcode Posts: 18,935
    edited November 2019

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't get everything that they want by the fact of him standing anywhere, since not everyone agrees on cui bono why are you certain the Tories are the ones who will, even if they did have discussions with him what difference does that make as either they swayed him to step down or he chose to, and it leads to the same outcome. So really, what's with all this 'hmm'ing where its presented as some tremendous potential reveltation if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    The PM is very much a One Nation Conservative.
    I don't think he is. I think he would throw me and mine into the fire if he could get one more point in the polls. He's in the game for him and his, and the rest of us can go hang. And I'll thank you not to project your fantasies onto such an unprepossessing canvas.
  • Options
    egg said:

    olm said:

    Floater said:

    kle4 said:

    Good grief it's Groundhog Day here again today...

    That picture of Corbyn. Which crap films are, or are not, Christmas films. The rubbish mural. Pineapple pizza. AV.

    We're caught in a constant loop.

    With Labour and the Tories going to trawl through facebook and twitter accounts for old scandals to mine, old issues are going to be bumped up time and again even more than usual, and I'm helpless but to respond. Lack of impulse control.

    Frankly the mural one I think could so easily be dropped since Corbyn apologised and provided an explanation (whether one accepts it or not), so it really should have no legs left as a political issue, but for some reason people love to carry on the fight he decided not to have. I'm not sure who that is supposed to benefit. It's not him, because he conceded that one years ago!
    Corbyn agreed it was anti semitic - some of his candidate mp's and posters on here seem not to have got the message.
    1) Corbyn agreeing that, whether for pragmatic reasons, or not, doesn't make or prove it anti-semitic.
    2) Since you're likely to be including me when referring to 'posters on here', I have to repeat, my point is that the mural is not *obviously* anti-semitic.
    3) Since you appear to think it is, it would be interesting to know what exactly about it is anti-semitic about it and apparent?
    I think that mural is anti Semitic because “the few” deciding the fate of the many clearly painted with the characteristics of Jewish people.
    It's debatable. It is indisputably bad art though. The artist has pulled together a bunch of stereotypes in an incoherent way. The semite theme is just one of these, and is offensive, but more because of its brainlessness than its racism.

    Its antisemitism is a by-product of its muddled ineptitude.
  • Options
    MysticroseMysticrose Posts: 4,688

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.
    It does not appear to be in single figures.

    You may want to blindside yourself to it but as Sunhil says the average is 10.75

    Do not fall into fake news
    There's no such thing as average polling

    The last two polls have the tory lead at +7 and +8

    Bleat away my tory sheep, but it's the facts
  • Options

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
    ComRes fieldwork is nearly a week old.
  • Options
    CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,221
    JohnO said:

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    As tonight’s selection of Flick Drummond goes to show. The third moderate former MP to be chosen in a safe seat.
    With the greatest respect they are being chosen to follow a leadership and policies which are profoundly unconservative and damaging. And if they don’t they will be turfed out as real One Nation Conservatives such as Rory Stewart, David Gauke and Ken Clarke have been.

    So fool yourself that they’re “moderate” (just like all those “moderate” Labour MPs in Corbyn’s Labour) but from the outside it looks like UKIP/TheBrexit Party have done a successful reverse takeover of the Tories, aided and abetted by people who will say any old rubbish just so they can get to put “MP” after their name.
  • Options
    nunu2nunu2 Posts: 1,453
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.
    It does not appear to be in single figures.

    You may want to blindside yourself to it but as Sunhil says the average is 10.75

    Do not fall into fake news
    There's no such thing as average polling

    The last two polls have the tory lead at +7 and +8

    Bleat away my tory sheep, but it's the facts
    What's so special about those two polls? One is even a week old!
  • Options
    DruttDrutt Posts: 1,093

    JohnO said:

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't get everything that they want by the fact of him standing anywhere, since not everyone agrees on cui bono why are you certain the Tories are the ones who will, even if they did have discussions with him what difference does that make as either they swayed him to step down or he chose to, and it leads to the same outcome. So really, what's with all this 'hmm'ing where its presented as some tremendous potential reveltation if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    As tonight’s selection of Flick Drummond goes to show. The third moderate former MP to be chosen in a safe seat.
    Laura Trott in Sevenoaks (even though it was the most Leave constituency in Kent, if I recall correctly).
    Very disappointed to learn that someone called Flick Drummond is not an Aussie soap character.

    Also disappointed to learn that Laura Trott is the other Laura Trott and not the Laura Trott I was thinking of.
  • Options
    MysticroseMysticrose Posts: 4,688

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
    ComRes fieldwork is nearly a week old.
    The Golden Rule of opinion polling. Dismiss the one you don't like.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
    ComRes fieldwork is nearly a week old.
    The Golden Rule of opinion polling. Dismiss the one you don't like.
    Aren't you doing the same?
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,137
    Drutt said:


    Very disappointed to learn that someone called Flick Drummond is not an Aussie soap character.

    Also disappointed to learn that Laura Trott is the other Laura Trott and not the Laura Trott I was thinking of.

    Flick Drummond should be Biggles' wingman.

    Two Laura Trotts
    There's only two Laura Trotts.......
  • Options

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.
    It does not appear to be in single figures.

    You may want to blindside yourself to it but as Sunhil says the average is 10.75

    Do not fall into fake news
    There's no such thing as average polling

    The last two polls have the tory lead at +7 and +8

    Bleat away my tory sheep, but it's the facts
    Tories and Liverpool both 8 points in the lead?

    I'd take that thank you.
  • Options
    Hang on - which ComRes?
  • Options
    another_richardanother_richard Posts: 25,127
    edited November 2019

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
    ComRes fieldwork is nearly a week old.
    The Golden Rule of opinion polling. Dismiss the one you don't like.
    Is that why you are ignoring YouGov, DeltaPoll, Opinium and Panelbase ?
  • Options
    olmolm Posts: 125

    olm said:

    Jason said:

    kle4 said:

    Jason said:

    Hypothetical here. For arguments sake, the Tories fall short again. Is there any circumstance where anyone could see either the SNP or the Dims propping up a Tory government? Or would that be impossible to conceive?

    The LDs at least claim they will not prop up any kind of government, and while I feel something would have to give in the event they were true kingmakers, their hope of replacing Labour would I think take a hit propping up the Tories again, and what price could be extracted to make it worthwhile?

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    Indeed. It does likely help them more than it hurts by turning off tory remainers and encouraging remain alliances (that would probably happen anyway), but his very existence at this point is a needless worry for them, so while his decision has aided them, it's not like it is a complete pact.
    I wonder if Swinson could be bought. I think there's a bit of Tory in there somewhere (excuse the pun), Brexit aside. Maybe the offer of a referendum on PR or such like?
    Other than the fact some Tories have defected to her party, what is Tory about Jo Swinson?
    Some consider her economically conservative, and her positions on welfare and state-ownership are fairly 'conservative', as is her voting record.
    I’m not seeing anything but traditional soft Left Lib Dem views in both her policy and her voting record.
    Voted for: privatising Royal Mail + Forestry Commission, fracking, legal aid restriction, fare rises, academy schools, corporation tax reduction, bedroom tax, council tax support reduction. Against: investment in renewables, gambling regs, mansion tax, bankers bonus tax, increase in higher tax rate, inflation increases in welfare, higher disability benefits, non-tied leases for pub landlords.

    Cherry-picked slightly, + she was in Coalition Gov, but still she has one of the poorest LibDem voting records on CO emissions. Perhaps this record is a match for 'soft Left Lib Dem' but her envir and welfare views don't appear to be.
  • Options
    JasonJason Posts: 1,614

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.
    Tories aren't starting to get a bit jittery.

    Tories have been jittery since 22:00 on 08/06/17 [DavidL and others got jittery before then] and will be jittery until 22:00 on 12/12/19 whatever the polls say.
    This is very true. When you're in a winning position it could all go tits up. BUT, that's a million times better than being 10 points behind and relying on a repeat of a pretty unique set of circumstances in the previous election campaign. I would gladly take a Tory majority of one if it stopped that bastard Corbyn and his demented acolytes getting their hands within a million miles of the levers of power.
  • Options
    MysticroseMysticrose Posts: 4,688

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.


    Are there some polls I don't know about ?
    Yes

    Since when has Wikipedia become the go-to?! @BritainElects is much quicker out the trap.

    The last two polls to be published are:

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193256433585922048?s=20

  • Options
    sarissasarissa Posts: 1,799

    ydoethur said:

    ydoethur said:

    kle4 said:

    kle4 said:

    HYUFD said:
    Fair play to you for not just posting food news stories for the Tories.

    I guess Boles is the counterpart to Woodcock and Austin, although not going for the main opponent of the person he despises.
    Good news stories. I cannot recall HYUFD posting food news stories.
    If he did it would be a turnip for the books.
    The swede smell of success!
    Now you’ve mangold my awesome pun.
    Give up. Beet surrender.
    North England Election Poster Stumped!
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.


    Are there some polls I don't know about ?
    Yes

    Since when has Wikipedia become the go-to?! @BritainElects is much quicker out the trap.

    The last two polls to be published are:

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193256433585922048?s=20

    Both of which are on the wikipedia table, but the ComRes one is so out of date it is easy to miss.
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Single figures?

    ELBOW week-ending 3rd November = 11.25% lead
    ELBOW week-ending 10th November = 10.75% lead
    The trend is always the friend.

    Except on those occasions where total wipeout moves to near total wipe out within a margin of error of total wipe out and pretty near total wipe out.

    I have given you all the best out of bubble honesty I can today, I need to go and recharge some more.
  • Options
    ThomasNasheThomasNashe Posts: 5,005
    edited November 2019
    olm said:

    kle4 said:

    olm said:

    And so it goes on .......

    Labour Candidate Claimed Mural Isn't Anti-Semitic https://t.co/E43W05NOtT

    It isn't clearly anti-semitic.
    If you think it is, can you explain?
    I never get tired of this classic. Even some otherwise very sensible people use it. Butpeople claiming it wasn't clearly anti-semitic should ask this chap about that:

    Jeremy Corbyn has expressed "sincere regret" at failing to look more closely at an allegedly anti-Semitic mural in London before questioning its removal...

    In a statement, Mr Corbyn said he had intended to make a "general comment" about the removal of public art on the grounds of freedom of speech.

    He added: "I sincerely regret that I did not look more closely at the image I was commenting on, the contents of which are deeply disturbing and anti-Semitic.


    https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-43523445

    Now, not everything Mr Corbyn says is true. But unless he was lying because he is weak, he at least thinks it was clearly anti-semitic since it was only because of poor attention that he did not spot that immediately. I think it highly unlikely he would defend himself on the grounds of poor attention being given if it was credible to use another defence.
    I don't expect Corbyn was lying; perhaps misconceived, which is very different.
    I never get tired of this classic 'the mural was anti-semitic' with still no explanation as to why. (Corbyn's view of it being anti-semitic is not an explanation why). I'm happy to be illuminated otherwise if I'm misconceived and missed something?
    See posts downthread at 9.31 and 9.58 for explanation.
  • Options
    NigelbNigelb Posts: 62,788

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't get everything that they want by the fact of him standing anywhere, since not everyone agrees on cui bono why are you certain the Tories are the ones who will, even if they did have discussions with him what difference does that make as either they swayed him to step down or he chose to, and it leads to the same outcome. So really, what's with all this 'hmm'ing where its presented as some tremendous potential reveltation if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    The PM is very much a One Nation Conservative...
    On the grounds that his policies will encourage the other three home nations to seek independence ?

    You might have a point there.
  • Options
    The_TaxmanThe_Taxman Posts: 2,979
    Nothing new in that story. When I worked at CCHQ I heard a story about a large donation or benefit in kind assisting an individual in getting the tory candidature in a seat. I thought it was disgusting and somebody very senior warned me off ever making the information public!
  • Options
    AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 20,127

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
    There does appear to have been a slight tightening, but I’m assuming it’s just noise at this stage.
  • Options
    Ave_itAve_it Posts: 2,411
    Here's a poll for all the CORBYNISTAS on here!

    Ave it research - taken somewhere on my keyboard

    LAB 99%
    CON 0%
    OTH 1%
    There you go Corbynistas make the most of it! :lol:
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,137
    nunu2 said:
    Brexit Party polling is likely to fall off a cliff over the next week.

    Or at least a ha-ha.....
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,123

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
    ComRes fieldwork is nearly a week old.
    The Golden Rule of opinion polling. Dismiss the one you don't like.
    Even Comres would see the Tories gain 24 Labour seats, they only need 8 net gains for a Tory majority
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
    There does appear to have been a slight tightening, but I’m assuming it’s just noise at this stage.
    The tightening is real, will it continue is another question entirely.
  • Options
    CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,221
    Anyway, on BBC4 at 10:30 there is the documentary about PQ17 - The Arctic Convoy. An absolute must see.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985
    Ave_it said:

    Here's a poll for all the CORBYNISTAS on here!

    Ave it research - taken somewhere on my keyboard

    LAB 99%
    CON 0%
    OTH 1%
    There you go Corbynistas make the most of it! :lol:

    Have you Baxter'd that?
  • Options
    RobD said:

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.


    Are there some polls I don't know about ?
    Yes

    Since when has Wikipedia become the go-to?! @BritainElects is much quicker out the trap.

    The last two polls to be published are:

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193256433585922048?s=20

    Both of which are on the wikipedia table, but the ComRes one is so out of date it is easy to miss.
    ComRes was 30th Oct to 31st Oct, surely?
  • Options

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.


    Are there some polls I don't know about ?
    Yes

    Since when has Wikipedia become the go-to?! @BritainElects is much quicker out the trap.

    The last two polls to be published are:

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193256433585922048?s=20

    Opinium gives CON a 12% lead!
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,137
    sarissa said:

    ydoethur said:

    ydoethur said:

    kle4 said:

    kle4 said:

    HYUFD said:
    Fair play to you for not just posting food news stories for the Tories.

    I guess Boles is the counterpart to Woodcock and Austin, although not going for the main opponent of the person he despises.
    Good news stories. I cannot recall HYUFD posting food news stories.
    If he did it would be a turnip for the books.
    The swede smell of success!
    Now you’ve mangold my awesome pun.
    Give up. Beet surrender.
    North England Election Poster Stumped!
    Tatty attempt.
  • Options

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.


    Are there some polls I don't know about ?
    Yes

    Since when has Wikipedia become the go-to?! @BritainElects is much quicker out the trap.

    The last two polls to be published are:

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193256433585922048?s=20

    So as evidence that the lead is in single figures you copy a poll showing a lead of 12%.

    :smiley:
  • Options
    Ave_itAve_it Posts: 2,411
    RobD said:

    Ave_it said:

    Here's a poll for all the CORBYNISTAS on here!

    Ave it research - taken somewhere on my keyboard

    LAB 99%
    CON 0%
    OTH 1%
    There you go Corbynistas make the most of it! :lol:

    Have you Baxter'd that?
    LAB hold Bootle :smiley:
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,123
    edited November 2019

    JohnO said:

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was saying the same thing earlier, and it seems like a bizarre obsession to me. What difference does it make if they did? They don't get everything that they want by the fact of him standing anywhere, since not everyone agrees on cui bono why are you certain the Tories are the ones who will, even if they did have discussions with him what difference does that make as either they swayed him to step down or he chose to, and it leads to the same outcome. So really, what's with all this 'hmm'ing where its presented as some tremendous potential reveltation if the Tories and Farage did discuss things with him? It's positive or negatives depending on what side you stand aren't affected either way, yet its presented like this would be a killer fact.

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    As tonight’s selection of Flick Drummond goes to show. The third moderate former MP to be chosen in a safe seat.
    Laura Trott in Sevenoaks (even though it was the most Leave constituency in Kent, if I recall correctly).
    Gravesham was 65% Leave and was the most Leave constituency in Kent, Sevenoaks was 54% Leave
  • Options
    ThomasNasheThomasNashe Posts: 5,005
    Ave_it said:

    Here's a poll for all the CORBYNISTAS on here!

    Ave it research - taken somewhere on my keyboard

    LAB 99%
    CON 0%
    OTH 1%
    There you go Corbynistas make the most of it! :lol:

    In conjunction with the Evo Morales Polling Solutions company.
  • Options

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
    ComRes fieldwork is nearly a week old.
    The Golden Rule of opinion polling. Dismiss the one you don't like.
    ComRes fieldwork was 30th Oct to 31st Oct?
    https://www.comresglobal.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ComRes_Sunday-Express_Opinion-Poll_Nov19_Tables.pdf
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,783
    Cookie said:

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    The PM is very much a One Nation Conservative.

    People should stop confusing One Nation with Remainer. They are not synonyms.
    Yes, very much so. Similarly, there is often a lazy belief that dry as dust economically = socially conservative = Eurosceptic. And sometimes it does. But often it doesn't. Calling anyone Eurosceptic right-wing is confusing and unhelpful. There are members of all parties who fall into one of these categories.
    Yes put me in that category. Bone dry economically, a real hater of debt, fairly socially conservative, and Europhile. There is no party where I neatly fit.
  • Options
    RobCLRobCL Posts: 23
    Cyclefree said:

    JohnO said:

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    As tonight’s selection of Flick Drummond goes to show. The third moderate former MP to be chosen in a safe seat.
    With the greatest respect they are being chosen to follow a leadership and policies which are profoundly unconservative and damaging. And if they don’t they will be turfed out as real One Nation Conservatives such as Rory Stewart, David Gauke and Ken Clarke have been.

    So fool yourself that they’re “moderate” (just like all those “moderate” Labour MPs in Corbyn’s Labour) but from the outside it looks like UKIP/TheBrexit Party have done a successful reverse takeover of the Tories, aided and abetted by people who will say any old rubbish just so they can get to put “MP” after their name.
    I think the most depressing thing for me was the blind conversion of all candidates to a leave even without a deal mantra. No nuance, no thought as to the effect but just parroting the lines they felt they needed to to appease the audience / head office. There was certainly no understanding of the exit process and the transition.
  • Options
    AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    Reading threads and posts from the morning of the 8th June 2017, we were all so innocent then.

    Favourite so far is

    Any predictions for Theresas post-election purge?

    I can't recall a campaign (other than brexit) where so many on an incumbent PM's own side have made enemies of themselves.

    Timothy and Hill will have drawn up their hitlist.

    The executions will commence at dawn.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
    ComRes fieldwork is nearly a week old.
    The Golden Rule of opinion polling. Dismiss the one you don't like.
    ComRes fieldwork was 30th Oct to 31st Oct?
    https://www.comresglobal.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ComRes_Sunday-Express_Opinion-Poll_Nov19_Tables.pdf
    No, I think this one was a special poll for a remain alliance group.
  • Options
    ReggieCideReggieCide Posts: 4,312
    Cyclefree said:

    Anyway, on BBC4 at 10:30 there is the documentary about PQ17 - The Arctic Convoy. An absolute must see.

    I had missed this - it's now on record. Thanks
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    Alistair said:

    Reading threads and posts from the morning of the 8th June 2017, we were all so innocent then.

    Favourite so far is

    Any predictions for Theresas post-election purge?

    I can't recall a campaign (other than brexit) where so many on an incumbent PM's own side have made enemies of themselves.

    Timothy and Hill will have drawn up their hitlist.

    The executions will commence at dawn.

    Bang! Bang!
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,955

    Some selective quoting there but the principle is the same - Labour added a lot of votes last time around after this point in the campaign
    Sure did. I'll bet the Tories won't be comfortable no matter the lead until around 4am on Friday 13th as a result.
    nico67 said:

    Bozo decided a Cobra meeting would look good optics .

    More faux empathy and concern designed to dupe people into thinking he gives two hoots .

    Well probably, although I am curious what the difference would be if it was sincere empathy and concern - how would we know?
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749

    Ave_it said:

    Here's a poll for all the CORBYNISTAS on here!

    Ave it research - taken somewhere on my keyboard

    LAB 99%
    CON 0%
    OTH 1%
    There you go Corbynistas make the most of it! :lol:

    In conjunction with the Evo Morales Polling Solutions company.
    Now for the Lib Dem bar chart shows them winning 😆
  • Options
    Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981
    olm said:

    kle4 said:

    olm said:

    And so it goes on .......

    Labour Candidate Claimed Mural Isn't Anti-Semitic https://t.co/E43W05NOtT

    It isn't clearly anti-semitic.
    If you think it is, can you explain?
    I never get tired of this classic. Even some otherwise very sensible people use it. Butpeople claiming it wasn't clearly anti-semitic should ask this chap about that:

    Jeremy Corbyn has expressed "sincere regret" at failing to look more closely at an allegedly anti-Semitic mural in London before questioning its removal...

    In a statement, Mr Corbyn said he had intended to make a "general comment" about the removal of public art on the grounds of freedom of speech.

    He added: "I sincerely regret that I did not look more closely at the image I was commenting on, the contents of which are deeply disturbing and anti-Semitic.


    https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-43523445

    Now, not everything Mr Corbyn says is true. But unless he was lying because he is weak, he at least thinks it was clearly anti-semitic since it was only because of poor attention that he did not spot that immediately. I think it highly unlikely he would defend himself on the grounds of poor attention being given if it was credible to use another defence.
    I don't expect Corbyn was lying; perhaps misconceived, which is very different.
    I never get tired of this classic 'the mural was anti-semitic' with still no explanation as to why. (Corbyn's view of it being anti-semitic is not an explanation why). I'm happy to be illuminated otherwise if I'm misconceived and missed something?
    It walks, talks and squawks very like a duck. You seem curiously over-invested in the point that nobody has conclusively shown its anatid affinities at the DNA level. I think most of us are happy to go with our overall impression, and move on to wondering why this is so important to you.
  • Options
    Foxy said:

    Cookie said:

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    The PM is very much a One Nation Conservative.

    People should stop confusing One Nation with Remainer. They are not synonyms.
    Yes, very much so. Similarly, there is often a lazy belief that dry as dust economically = socially conservative = Eurosceptic. And sometimes it does. But often it doesn't. Calling anyone Eurosceptic right-wing is confusing and unhelpful. There are members of all parties who fall into one of these categories.
    Yes put me in that category. Bone dry economically, a real hater of debt, fairly socially conservative, and Europhile. There is no party where I neatly fit.
    But every financial asset is someone else's debt. It's how the system works.
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,783
    RobD said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Sorry that is wrong. The last 5 polls on wiki frommthis weekend give 12-13-12-10-8.

    You are in danger of becoming a bit over excited
    The last two are +7 and +8

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193986028727668737?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20
    ComRes fieldwork is nearly a week old.
    The Golden Rule of opinion polling. Dismiss the one you don't like.
    ComRes fieldwork was 30th Oct to 31st Oct?
    https://www.comresglobal.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/ComRes_Sunday-Express_Opinion-Poll_Nov19_Tables.pdf
    No, I think this one was a special poll for a remain alliance group.
    Rather than electoral pacts, why not have a system of voting where people can express approval for several parties on the ballot, placing them in order of preference. If only someone could come up with such a system!
  • Options
    ReggieCideReggieCide Posts: 4,312
    Foxy said:

    Cookie said:

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    The PM is very much a One Nation Conservative.

    People should stop confusing One Nation with Remainer. They are not synonyms.
    Yes, very much so. Similarly, there is often a lazy belief that dry as dust economically = socially conservative = Eurosceptic. And sometimes it does. But often it doesn't. Calling anyone Eurosceptic right-wing is confusing and unhelpful. There are members of all parties who fall into one of these categories.
    Yes put me in that category. Bone dry economically, a real hater of debt, fairly socially conservative, and Europhile. There is no party where I neatly fit.
    Confused - a definite LibDem
  • Options
    eggegg Posts: 1,749
    edited November 2019
    kle4 said:

    Some selective quoting there but the principle is the same - Labour added a lot of votes last time around after this point in the campaign
    Sure did. I'll bet the Tories won't be comfortable no matter the lead until around 4am on Friday 13th as a result.
    nico67 said:

    Bozo decided a Cobra meeting would look good optics .

    More faux empathy and concern designed to dupe people into thinking he gives two hoots .

    Well probably, although I am curious what the difference would be if it was sincere empathy and concern - how would we know?
    Friday 13th!!!!! Whose idea to count the votes on Friday 13th!!!
  • Options
    Foxy said:

    Cookie said:

    Cyclefree said:



    kle4 said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Today has brought 2 more depressing reasons for hoping the Tories don’t succeed:-

    1. Farage giving them a free run in some seats.
    2. The Tories proposal to renege on what has been agreed with the Irish government about prosecuting soldiers for crimes committed during the Troubles. Bad law, bad policy, morally repulsive and shows Ireland and others that the word of the British government cannot be relied upon.

    Yuck, yuck.

    Meanwhile Labour’s vote share creeps up.

    More yuck.

    If only they could both lose.

    I’m not sure the Tories are in charge of Farage’s decision.
    I am more cynical than you. Cui bono? The consensus seems to be the Tories. And I’m supposed to believe the Tories had absolutely nothing to do with it at all. Hmm....

    Jonathon was

    Not presenting it as some killer fact merely my opinion that the Conservative party as was has died and been replaced by Brexit/UKIP. I find that depressing because there was something to admire about the genuine Conservative party. Whereas what has replaced it is mean-minded, incoherent and seems to value nothing about what is best about Britain.
    The reports of the death of the Conservative Party have been greatly exaggerated.

    The new intake will be very much One Nation Conservatives.
    The PM is very much a One Nation Conservative.

    People should stop confusing One Nation with Remainer. They are not synonyms.
    Yes, very much so. Similarly, there is often a lazy belief that dry as dust economically = socially conservative = Eurosceptic. And sometimes it does. But often it doesn't. Calling anyone Eurosceptic right-wing is confusing and unhelpful. There are members of all parties who fall into one of these categories.
    Yes put me in that category. Bone dry economically, a real hater of debt, fairly socially conservative, and Europhile. There is no party where I neatly fit.
    Bone dry economically, real hater of debt, very socially liberal, formerly-Europhile but now Eurosceptic.
  • Options
    GMFGMF Posts: 13
    Cambridge (Betfair)

    LD 4/9
    Labour 13/8

    Labour nearing value.
  • Options
    CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,221

    Cyclefree said:

    Anyway, on BBC4 at 10:30 there is the documentary about PQ17 - The Arctic Convoy. An absolute must see.

    I had missed this - it's now on record. Thanks
    There are some very good documentaries to watch on the Beeb at the moment plus Dr Strangelove - one of the top 5 funniest films ever made.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,955
    edited November 2019
    olm said:

    kle4 said:

    olm said:

    And so it goes on .......

    Labour Candidate Claimed Mural Isn't Anti-Semitic https://t.co/E43W05NOtT

    It isn't clearly anti-semitic.
    If you think it is, can you explain?
    I never get tired of this classic. Even some otherwise very sensible people use it. Butpeople claiming it wasn't clearly anti-semitic should ask this chap about that:

    Jeremy Corbyn has expressed "sincere regret" at failing to look more closely at an allegedly anti-Semitic mural in London before questioning its removal...

    In a statement, Mr Corbyn said he had intended to make a "general comment" about the removal of public art on the grounds of freedom of speech.

    He added: "I sincerely regret that I did not look more closely at the image I was commenting on, the contents of which are deeply disturbing and anti-Semitic.


    https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-43523445

    Now, not everything Mr Corbyn says is true. But unless he was lying because he is weak, he at least thinks it was clearly anti-semitic since it was only because of poor attention that he did not spot that immediately. I think it highly unlikely he would defend himself on the grounds of poor attention being given if it was credible to use another defence.
    I don't expect Corbyn was lying; perhaps misconceived, which is very different.
    I never get tired of this classic 'the mural was anti-semitic' with still no explanation as to why. (Corbyn's view of it being anti-semitic is not an explanation why). I'm happy to be illuminated otherwise if I'm misconceived and missed something?
    I don't see the point when as a political issue it is dead. Why are you so concerned about it? It cannot even be used to attack Corbyn anymore as he's nullied it.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,955

    Jason said:

    Jason said:

    I too remain concerned that at some point there will be a polling panic as Labour starts to rise in the polls. Probably for no particular reason....

    However, the level of hostility towards Corbyn and his band of mad-hatter, unsavoury Marxists is now profound, widespread and deeply felt across much of the country, even amongst Labour voters. I really struggle to see what is going to change that in 4 weeks. People have had three YEARS to reach their conclusions. Corbyn is no longer a blank canvass. I cant see what is going to change.

    But happy to hear suggestions....



    Labour are entering a phase where wishful thinking is starting to replace reality.

    Hardly. The tory lead seems now to be in single figures. They will take that at this stage.
    Comparing two graphs from completely different elections with completely different circumstances and pinning your electoral strategy on it is wishful thinking.
    I haven't compared anything, thanks. Haven't looked at any graphs.

    I'm just pointing out that with a month to go the tory lead seems to be in single figures.

    Labour will take that quite happily right now.

    Forgive me for saying so, but I do get the impression that tories are starting to get a bit jittery. I'm seeing it 'out there' and I'm seeing it on this site.


    Are there some polls I don't know about ?
    Yes

    Since when has Wikipedia become the go-to?! @BritainElects is much quicker out the trap.

    The last two polls to be published are:

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193936113242648577?s=20

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1193256433585922048?s=20

    So as evidence that the lead is in single figures you copy a poll showing a lead of 12%.

    :smiley:
    And ones which were already in the single figures rather than latest movement taking them into single figures.
This discussion has been closed.