Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » EU Referendum punters unmoved by by drop in REMAIN phone po

1356

Comments

  • isam said:

    tlg86 said:

    Football tip:

    Chelsea for the Champions League @ 25/1 e-w (1/2 1-2)

    Tough draw against PSG, but they are now playing much more like the side they were supposed to be.

    You mean they beat Newcastle 5-1...
    Unbeaten since Hiddink took over (lots of draws, mind). Won 1-0 away at the champions-elect.
    Havent worked it out but logically I think you might be better of smashing into the 6/4 they qualify from this round
    It's all going to come down to the draw - there's two relatively soft quarter-finalists already.
  • IndigoIndigo Posts: 9,966
    DavidL said:

    I agree. The degree of smug arrogance that could have resulted in Cameron trying to sell his current renegotiation is frankly stupefying. I still find it incredible that such a clever man and successful politician could have made such a misjudgement. I really don't know how he redeems it now. Even if he did produce a rabbit out of the hat it would have an air of desperation, not triumph.

    As Iain Martin observes, the trick will be producing a rabbit that survives the Sunday papers, the chances of it being more than window dressing are low considering how insubstantial the current text is. If anything it is likely to be something terribly impressive, but hedge around with some many other countries needing to agree before we can do it as to be practically worthless.

  • tlg86 said:

    tlg86 said:

    Football tip:

    Chelsea for the Champions League @ 25/1 e-w (1/2 1-2)

    Tough draw against PSG, but they are now playing much more like the side they were supposed to be.

    You mean they beat Newcastle 5-1...
    Unbeaten since Hiddink took over (lots of draws, mind). Won 1-0 away at the champions-elect.
    Beating Arsenal is what Chelsea do - I wouldn't read too much into it. That said, they might beat PSG and if the draw fell kindly they might make the final.
    Well it is 25/1 :-) And Chelsea have been pretty good at beating superior sides in Europe.
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    Time to get rid of the monarchy if they want to interfere in politics.
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    FTPT

    Report on Scottish House prices

    https://www.ros.gov.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0003/34194/RoS-statistical-report-Oct-Dec-2015.pdf

    The biggest looser was Shetland, Aberdeen did see a annual price fall but only 1.8 percent compared to Shetland's 13.3% drop.

    The large Aberdeenshire area had no change.

    Aberdeen City had a massive drop in the volume of sales.
  • isamisam Posts: 41,902
    x

    isam said:

    tlg86 said:

    Football tip:

    Chelsea for the Champions League @ 25/1 e-w (1/2 1-2)

    Tough draw against PSG, but they are now playing much more like the side they were supposed to be.

    You mean they beat Newcastle 5-1...
    Unbeaten since Hiddink took over (lots of draws, mind). Won 1-0 away at the champions-elect.
    Havent worked it out but logically I think you might be better of smashing into the 6/4 they qualify from this round
    It's all going to come down to the draw - there's two relatively soft quarter-finalists already.
    I used to have a program that worked that out... Yes there is a sneaky way through to the semis for someone
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    edited February 2016
    DavidL said:

    Cyclefree said:

    DavidL said:

    The expectation is that the government, the Labour party, the Lib Dems, the nationalists and even the Greens are going to stand up and back Remain. The expectation is that a majority of the City and business will do likewise. On the media while some of the shoutier papers will be for Out the BBC will undoubtedly be very much for In.

    Very unusually, indeed uniquely, this came up at lunch today. Apart from me every other person at the table found the idea that we might vote for Leave simply bewildering. Incomprehensible even. Having spent time on here where Leave tends to dominate it was a strange but not unique experience. I had the same experience recently at dinner with a generally left of centre group of friends. Once again there was a reluctance to accept this was even a possibility.

    With his truly lousy, indeed embarrassing, renegotiation Cameron has made the job of Remain harder and damaged his own credibility to boot. Notwithstanding that I fear the odds are rational and Remain remains the most likely winner.

    I tend to agree. I think there are two interesting questions: (1) how big will the Leave vote be and where will it be found. That could affect both EU and UK politics in ways we might not yet anticipate. (2) Could there be an upset, similar to what happened in France over the EU Constitution (or was it Nice?) where the "Non" side surprised everyone?

    There is a mood to give the establishment a kicking: Trump, Sanders, Corbyn etc. In some ways, the best thing for the EU and the political establishment here - including all those you mention - would be an almighty kick up the backside from a UK "No" Vote. They really all need their arses slapped and hard, they really do.
    I agree. The degree of smug arrogance that could have resulted in Cameron trying to sell his current renegotiation is frankly stupefying. I still find it incredible that such a clever man and successful politician could have made such a misjudgement. I really don't know how he redeems it now. Even if he did produce a rabbit out of the hat it would have an air of desperation, not triumph.

    It is tragic that Leave is such an incoherent, leaderless mob with no clear alternative in mind. They should have been a contender.
    It's only a misjudgement if he either loses or exacerbates an irreconcilable divide in the Party.

    If he wins then steps like this will be as memorable as pastygate was at 10pm on 7 May.
  • Makes me want to rewatch The Fast Show now.

    Former UN Secretary-General Boutros Boutros-Ghali dies

    Chris Waddle

  • Sean_F said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Godfrey Bloom on Emma Thompson

    May I volunteer to be the first to spank her silly bottom?
    Something her mother should have done years ago.

    Jesus: if only UKIP would STFU. Emma T is entitled to her view. And to express it. Why does he have to play the stereotype of the sort of man who thinks women who express a view a man disagrees with are silly children who should be punished?

    Note to @CasinoRoyale (re your question on last night's thread): If you want to know why women may find Leave unattractive here is one answer.

    Fortunately, I don't think he's in UKIP anymore.
    Indeed - the former MEP Godfrey Bloom, quit UKIP because it was too "politically correct".
    I thought he sought asylum in Bongo Bongo-Land
  • John_MJohn_M Posts: 7,503
    edited February 2016
    Sandpit said:

    Cyclefree said:

    Godfrey Bloom on Emma Thompson

    May I volunteer to be the first to spank her silly bottom?
    Something her mother should have done years ago.

    Jesus: if only UKIP would STFU. Emma T is entitled to her view. And to express it. Why does he have to play the stereotype of the sort of man who thinks women who express a view a man disagrees with are silly children who should be punished?

    Note to @CasinoRoyale (re your question on last night's thread): If you want to know why women may find Leave unattractive here is one answer.

    I actually have my head in my hands right now.
    Why on Earth are both sides STILL doing their level best to alienate floating voters?

    Today we have a UKIP mysoginist on one side and Gordon Brown on the other. The PM also needs to get everyone involved in the EU and foreign politicians to STFU once the referendum is announced, there is absolutely nothing that Junker or Shulz can say that will draw people to the Remain camp in the closing weeks.
    Bloom was kicked out of UKIP in 2014. He's still an idiot. Thomson is entitled to her view, and more than entitled to express it.
  • AndyJS said:

    Time to get rid of the monarchy if they want to interfere in politics.

    The Duke was presenting awards to members of the Foreign Office's Diplomatic Academy and gave a speech commending the foreign office and Britain’s historic role in foreign affairs. - Gordon Rayner for the Telegraph claims this “signals support for Britain staying in the EU”.

    I’ve read the prince’s speech, Rayner is talking bollox.
  • IndigoIndigo Posts: 9,966
    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.
  • pbr2013pbr2013 Posts: 649

    Blue_rog said:

    Not sure if I agree with HRH Duke of Cambridge making comments about the EU referendum
    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/eureferendum/12159067/David-Cameron-in-last-ditch-EU-referendum-talks-to-secure-deal-before-Friday-live.html

    Especially as it's for remain :grin:

    That's clearly been choreographed by the Government. Trying to tickle the tummies of Shire Tory loyalists who go all gooey for HM.

    Very unwise to bring the Royal Family into an issue that splits the country right down the middle.

    It brings out my inner Republican (which I usually never have unless I hear Charles speak)
    *Groan* Wills has been talking to his dad about his constitutional position.
  • Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    Given that an opinion poll in a thread header recently gave Tory voters at a 45% remain/48% leave split which is margin of error from 50:50 and before Cameron starts campaigning properly for Remain why would we expect 2/3rds for Leave?
  • IndigoIndigo Posts: 9,966
    edited February 2016

    Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    Given that an opinion poll in a thread header recently gave Tory voters at a 45% remain/48% leave split which is margin of error from 50:50 and before Cameron starts campaigning properly for Remain why would we expect 2/3rds for Leave?
    For the same reason that polls told us we would have a Labour government and we don't.

    If you anticipate peace and tranquillity in the Tory party after a narrow vote IN or OUT, I admire your confidence ;)
  • runnymederunnymede Posts: 2,536
    Thomson is entitled to her view, and more than entitled to express it.

    Indeed, luvvie airheads should be encouraged to express their views on this topic. It only illustrates how vacuous the Remain campaign is.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 38,819
    Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    If two thirds of Conservatives vote Out, then Leave will have won by a comfortable margin.
  • Indigo said:

    Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    Given that an opinion poll in a thread header recently gave Tory voters at a 45% remain/48% leave split which is margin of error from 50:50 and before Cameron starts campaigning properly for Remain why would we expect 2/3rds for Leave?
    For the same reason that polls told us we would have a Labour government and we don't
    Because they underestimated Cameron's strengths? If anything that would make us expect 2/3rds for REMAIN surely.
  • isamisam Posts: 41,902
    Sean_F said:

    Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    If two thirds of Conservatives vote Out, then Leave will have won by a comfortable margin.
    I thought right about now its 50/50
  • Idi Amin's heir ?

    Police arrested a 35-year-old Longmont resident early Monday on suspicion of DUI despite the man's claim that he is the King of Scotland and therefore has diplomatic immunity that should bar his arrest.

    Nicholas Baron James, who, according to a Longmont police report, is also known as "Heir to the Throne of Scotland" and "King Solomon," also faces drug-possession, traffic and violation of protective order charges.

    http://www.timescall.com/news/ci_29509065/dui-suspect-tells-longmont-police-hes-king-of-scotland-demands-diplomatic-immunity-
  • Sean_F said:

    Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    If two thirds of Conservatives vote Out, then Leave will have won by a comfortable margin.
    Agreed. I'd probably be one of them to vote Out too in that scenario as would many other Cameroon Tories here.
  • pbr2013pbr2013 Posts: 649

    Iain Martin on what went wrong with Cameron's team.
    "But the diplomatic bubble can be a dangerously seductive environment, especially when the inhabitants of Downing Street – the Tory leadership ......are used to people around them agreeing that they are brilliant and their deal all makes sense. This makes it difficult for those involved to stand back and say: hold on, how did this end up hinging on child benefit indexation for new immigrants ..... that do nothing to restore sovereignty or border control? Think about it. Number 10 has become hypnotised by its own drawn out process and cannot see how ridiculous its deal looks outside the gates of Downing Street..... ."
    http://capx.co/why-david-cameron-got-it-so-wrong-on-renegotiation/

    The perils of surrounding yourself with nodding dogs as someone in these parts said the other week.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 38,819
    isam said:

    Sean_F said:

    Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    If two thirds of Conservatives vote Out, then Leave will have won by a comfortable margin.
    I thought right about now its 50/50
    Broadly speaking, although edging towards a lead Leave, I think. In fact, Conservative voters' opinions are very similar to those of the country as a whole,.
  • Trump Joins Radio Ally To Fuel Scalia Murder Conspiracy Theory

    Trump Tells Michael Savage: "They Found A Pillow On His Face, Which Is A Pretty Unusual Place"

    http://mediamatters.org/blog/2016/02/16/trump-joins-radio-ally-to-fuel-scalia-murder-co/208604
  • Indigo said:

    Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    Given that an opinion poll in a thread header recently gave Tory voters at a 45% remain/48% leave split which is margin of error from 50:50 and before Cameron starts campaigning properly for Remain why would we expect 2/3rds for Leave?
    For the same reason that polls told us we would have a Labour government and we don't.

    If you anticipate peace and tranquillity in the Tory party after a narrow vote IN or OUT, I admire your confidence ;)
    Just saw your edited in line. I don't anticipate a narrow vote, I expect Remain to achieve between 60% to 66%.

    My absolute worst-case scenario is a 51% Remain vote. I'd rather a 51% Leave vote than that. I think a narrow Out vote will have relative peace as the matter will be over then.
  • IndigoIndigo Posts: 9,966
    isam said:

    Sean_F said:

    Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    If two thirds of Conservatives vote Out, then Leave will have won by a comfortable margin.
    I thought right about now its 50/50
    Actually, I don't care. I am just bored with the six month run of complacent smugness we have had to endure from certain sections of this board. I agree with CycleFree a crushing defeat on almost anything is long overdue, to dislodge some heads from backsides, both in the government and elsewhere.. and I say this as a Conservative voter and former member.
  • Blue_rog said:

    Not sure if I agree with HRH Duke of Cambridge making comments about the EU referendum
    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/eureferendum/12159067/David-Cameron-in-last-ditch-EU-referendum-talks-to-secure-deal-before-Friday-live.html

    Especially as it's for remain :grin:

    Captain Darling: I'm as British as Queen Victoria!

    Captain Blackadder: So your father's German, you're half German, and you married a German!
  • Sean_F said:

    Cyclefree said:

    DavidL said:

    The expectation is that the government, the Labour party, the Lib Dems, the nationalists and even the Greens are going to stand up and back Remain. The expectation is that a majority of the City and business will do likewise. On the media while some of the shoutier papers will be for Out the BBC will undoubtedly be very much for In.

    Very unusually, indeed uniquely, this came up at lunch today. Apart from me every other person at the table found the idea that we might vote for Leave simply bewildering. Incomprehensible even. Having spent time on here where Leave tends to dominate it was a strange but not unique experience. I had the same experience recently at dinner with a generally left of centre group of friends. Once again there was a reluctance to accept this was even a possibility.

    With his truly lousy, indeed embarrassing, renegotiation Cameron has made the job of Remain harder and damaged his own credibility to boot. Notwithstanding that I fear the odds are rational and Remain remains the most likely winner.

    I tend to agree. I think there are two interesting questions: (1) how big will the Leave vote be and where will it be found. That could affect both EU and UK politics in ways we might not yet anticipate. (2) Could there be an upset, similar to what happened in France over the EU Constitution (or was it Nice?) where the "Non" side surprised everyone?

    There is a mood to give the establishment a kicking: Trump, Sanders, Corbyn etc. In some ways, the best thing for the EU and the political establishment here - including all those you mention - would be an almighty kick up the backside from a UK "No" Vote. They really all need their arses slapped and hard, they really do.
    My best guess is that Leave will win about 45% of the vote.

    I think most voters over 50, and most working class voters will vote Leave. I think that Conservative voters will vote about 50-55% for Leave, and UKIP voters will vote about 90% for Leave. About 25-30% of the rest will vote Leave.

    I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else.
    Are you going to be (are you already?) playing an active part in the campaign?

    I always found your UKIP (and earlier, Tory) reports from the battlegrounds to be very insightful.
  • Idi Amin's heir ?

    Police arrested a 35-year-old Longmont resident early Monday on suspicion of DUI despite the man's claim that he is the King of Scotland and therefore has diplomatic immunity that should bar his arrest.

    Nicholas Baron James, who, according to a Longmont police report, is also known as "Heir to the Throne of Scotland" and "King Solomon," also faces drug-possession, traffic and violation of protective order charges.

    http://www.timescall.com/news/ci_29509065/dui-suspect-tells-longmont-police-hes-king-of-scotland-demands-diplomatic-immunity-

    I went to Longmont in 2011, wasn't too far from Boulder.
  • isam said:

    Sean_F said:

    Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    If two thirds of Conservatives vote Out, then Leave will have won by a comfortable margin.
    I thought right about now its 50/50
    I think 60/40. Key I believe are Labour voters. They are less concerned about the economic arguments and more concerned with immigration, they just have to do what Scots did and abandon the Labour party.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 38,819

    Sean_F said:

    Cyclefree said:

    DavidL said:

    The expectation is that the government, the Labour party, the Lib Dems, the nationalists and even the Greens are going to stand up and back Remain. The expectation is that a majority of the City and business will do likewise. On the media while some of the shoutier papers will be for Out the BBC will undoubtedly be very much for In.

    Very unusually, indeed uniquely, this came up at lunch today. Apart from me every other person at the table found the idea that we might vote for Leave simply bewildering. Incomprehensible even. Having spent time on here where Leave tends to dominate it was a strange but not unique experience. I had the same experience recently at dinner with a generally left of centre group of friends. Once again there was a reluctance to accept this was even a possibility.

    With his truly lousy, indeed embarrassing, renegotiation Cameron has made the job of Remain harder and damaged his own credibility to boot. Notwithstanding that I fear the odds are rational and Remain remains the most likely winner.

    I tend to agree. I think there are two interesting questions: (1) how big will the Leave vote be and where will it be found. That could affect both EU and UK politics in ways we might not yet anticipate. (2) Could there be an upset, similar to what happened in France over the EU Constitution (or was it Nice?) where the "Non" side surprised everyone?

    There is a mood to give the establishment a kicking: Trump, Sanders, Corbyn etc. In some ways, the best thing for the EU and the political establishment here - including all those you mention - would be an almighty kick up the backside from a UK "No" Vote. They really all need their arses slapped and hard, they really do.
    My best guess is that Leave will win about 45% of the vote.

    I think most voters over 50, and most working class voters will vote Leave. I think that Conservative voters will vote about 50-55% for Leave, and UKIP voters will vote about 90% for Leave. About 25-30% of the rest will vote Leave.

    I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else.
    Are you going to be (are you already?) playing an active part in the campaign?

    I always found your UKIP (and earlier, Tory) reports from the battlegrounds to be very insightful.
    It's certainly my intention to help whichever organisation is designated as the official Leave campaign group. I expect I'll be delivering a ton of leaflets in Luton, a town where Leave may do quite well, given that Kelvin Hopkins will be campaigning for Leave.
  • pbr2013pbr2013 Posts: 649

    AndyJS said:

    Time to get rid of the monarchy if they want to interfere in politics.

    The Duke was presenting awards to members of the Foreign Office's Diplomatic Academy and gave a speech commending the foreign office and Britain’s historic role in foreign affairs. - Gordon Rayner for the Telegraph claims this “signals support for Britain staying in the EU”.

    I’ve read the prince’s speech, Rayner is talking bollox.
    Thank you for the clarification. Hacks!
  • SquareRootSquareRoot Posts: 7,095
    One thing punters certainly should pay no heed to is the anti Cameron bile poured out on here day after day. its certainly not representative.
  • runnymede said:

    Thomson is entitled to her view, and more than entitled to express it.

    Indeed, luvvie airheads should be encouraged to express their views on this topic. It only illustrates how vacuous the Remain campaign is.

    Anyone watch C4 News interview yesterday with Mark E. Smith ? He was very un pc for a cultural icon.
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    edited February 2016
    NBC tracking poll:

    Trump 38 (+3)
    Cruz 18 (-2)
    Rubio 14 (-3)
    Carson 8 (+1)
    Kasich 7 (+4)
    Bush 4 (+1)

    Clinton 50 (-1)
    Sanders 40 (+1)

    http://floridapolitics.com/archives/201870-donald-trump-hillary-clinton-maintain-sizable-leads-in-national-nbc-news-tracking-poll
  • One thing punters certainly should pay no heed to is the anti Cameron bile poured out on here day after day. its certainly not representative.

    Cameron is a loyal EU toady :)

    You mean like the above? :lol:
  • TCPoliticalBettingTCPoliticalBetting Posts: 10,819
    edited February 2016

    One thing punters certainly should pay no heed to is the anti Cameron bile poured out on here day after day. its certainly not representative.

    Not so much bile, more sad disappointment.
  • taffystaffys Posts: 9,753

    One thing punters certainly should pay no heed to is the anti Cameron bile poured out on here day after day. its certainly not representative.

    What about the anti Cameron bile poured out by the Mail, Express and Sun? (or Guardian, come to think of it).
  • taffys said:

    One thing punters certainly should pay no heed to is the anti Cameron bile poured out on here day after day. its certainly not representative.

    What about the anti Cameron bile poured out by the Mail, Express and Sun? (or Guardian, come to think of it).
    True. How have Cameron's ratings changed?
  • isamisam Posts: 41,902

    isam said:

    Sean_F said:

    Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    If two thirds of Conservatives vote Out, then Leave will have won by a comfortable margin.
    I thought right about now its 50/50
    I think 60/40. Key I believe are Labour voters. They are less concerned about the economic arguments and more concerned with immigration, they just have to do what Scots did and abandon the Labour party.
    Oh sorry I meant amongst Con voters
  • AndyJS said:

    Time to get rid of the monarchy if they want to interfere in politics.

    The Duke was presenting awards to members of the Foreign Office's Diplomatic Academy and gave a speech commending the foreign office and Britain’s historic role in foreign affairs. - Gordon Rayner for the Telegraph claims this “signals support for Britain staying in the EU”.

    I’ve read the prince’s speech, Rayner is talking bollox.
    Peston was tweeting along the same lines. He seems to have completely lost the plot recently.
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    edited February 2016
    "I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else."

    Leave surely has a good chance of carrying some of the metropolitan boroughs that surround the big cities like Walsall, Dudley, Rotherham, Bolton, Wigan, Gateshead, South Tyneside, Barnsley, Doncaster, etc.
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @ChrisMasonBBC: A man who was pulled over for allegedly driving under the influence in the US state of Colorado claimed to be the King of Scotland.

    @campbellclaret: @ChrisMasonBBC anyone seen Salmond lately?
  • perdixperdix Posts: 1,806
    pbr2013 said:

    Iain Martin on what went wrong with Cameron's team.
    "But the diplomatic bubble can be a dangerously seductive environment, especially when the inhabitants of Downing Street – the Tory leadership ......are used to people around them agreeing that they are brilliant and their deal all makes sense. This makes it difficult for those involved to stand back and say: hold on, how did this end up hinging on child benefit indexation for new immigrants ..... that do nothing to restore sovereignty or border control? Think about it. Number 10 has become hypnotised by its own drawn out process and cannot see how ridiculous its deal looks outside the gates of Downing Street..... ."
    http://capx.co/why-david-cameron-got-it-so-wrong-on-renegotiation/

    The perils of surrounding yourself with nodding dogs as someone in these parts said the other week.
    Ian Martin has never been a level-headed writer.

  • IndigoIndigo Posts: 9,966
    edited February 2016

    One thing punters certainly should pay no heed to is the anti Cameron bile poured out on here day after day. its certainly not representative.

    Only in your dreams.

    I was on the phone to Mrs Indigo (Senior) earlier today, a traditional blue-rinse party member if ever there was one, who felt that the recent shenanigans after returning from the renegotiation were a bit of an embarrassment. She is firmly of the view that he would have been much better forgetting the renegotiations and pitching the EU on its merits, which would have had the air of respectability, rather than coming home and channelling Neil Kinnock at Sheffield, what frankly made him look a bit of a fool.
  • AndyJS said:

    Time to get rid of the monarchy if they want to interfere in politics.

    The Duke was presenting awards to members of the Foreign Office's Diplomatic Academy and gave a speech commending the foreign office and Britain’s historic role in foreign affairs. - Gordon Rayner for the Telegraph claims this “signals support for Britain staying in the EU”.

    I’ve read the prince’s speech, Rayner is talking bollox.
    May be this is just Foreign Office spin to the hacks as to how they should interpret the words they gave to the Prince to read out. The Palace have swiftly denied the interpretation.
  • Alistair said:

    FTPT

    Report on Scottish House prices

    https://www.ros.gov.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0003/34194/RoS-statistical-report-Oct-Dec-2015.pdf

    The biggest looser was Shetland, Aberdeen did see a annual price fall but only 1.8 percent compared to Shetland's 13.3% drop.

    The large Aberdeenshire area had no change.

    Aberdeen City had a massive drop in the volume of sales.

    East Ayrshire boom - Malky's neighbours selling up?
  • RoyalBlueRoyalBlue Posts: 3,223
    Sean_F said:

    Cyclefree said:

    DavidL said:

    The expectation is that the government, the Labour party, the Lib Dems, the nationalists and even the Greens are going to stand up and back Remain. The expectation is that a majority of the City and business will do likewise. On the media while some of the shoutier papers will be for Out the BBC will undoubtedly be very much for In.

    Very unusually, indeed uniquely, this came up at lunch today. Apart from me every other person at the table found the idea that we might vote for Leave simply bewildering. Incomprehensible even. Having spent time on here where Leave tends to dominate it was a strange but not unique experience. I had the same experience recently at dinner with a generally left of centre group of friends. Once again there was a reluctance to accept this was even a possibility.

    With his truly lousy, indeed embarrassing, renegotiation Cameron has made the job of Remain harder and damaged his own credibility to boot. Notwithstanding that I fear the odds are rational and Remain remains the most likely winner.

    I tend to agree. I think there are two interesting questions: (1) how big will the Leave vote be and where will it be found. That could affect both EU and UK politics in ways we might not yet anticipate. (2) Could there be an upset, similar to what happened in France over the EU Constitution (or was it Nice?) where the "Non" side surprised everyone?

    There is a mood to give the establishment a kicking: Trump, Sanders, Corbyn etc. In some ways, the best thing for the EU and the political establishment here - including all those you mention - would be an almighty kick up the backside from a UK "No" Vote. They really all need their arses slapped and hard, they really do.
    My best guess is that Leave will win about 45% of the vote.

    I think most voters over 50, and most working class voters will vote Leave. I think that Conservative voters will vote about 50-55% for Leave, and UKIP voters will vote about 90% for Leave. About 25-30% of the rest will vote Leave.

    I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else.
    I think geographically this is broadly right with the exception of Welsh-speaking Wales. North and West Wales are some of the most insular parts of the mainland; I can't see them voting for continued membership.
  • IndigoIndigo Posts: 9,966
    edited February 2016

    Just saw your edited in line. I don't anticipate a narrow vote, I expect Remain to achieve between 60% to 66%.

    My absolute worst-case scenario is a 51% Remain vote. I'd rather a 51% Leave vote than that. I think a narrow Out vote will have relative peace as the matter will be over then.

    With Immigration being the top concern with the public, and 76% of people wanting less immigration, and 52% wanting "much" less, and Dave not giving them even a token reduction, its going to be an interesting circle to square. They are certainly not going to buy any bullshit about "emergency brakes".
  • Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    If 2/3 of Con vote Out then Leave probably wins. Based on current opinion polls

    e.g.

    Con 39 x 2/3 = 26
    Lab 29 x 1/3 = 9.3
    UKIP 16 x 9/10 = 14.2
    LD 7 x 1/4 = 1.8
    SNP 5 x 1/4 = 1.2
    Grn 3 x 1/3 = 1
    Oth 1 x 1/2 = 0.5

    Total 54.

    UKIP might not get quite that high a proportion but then Labour might be higher. But even if it's only 80% of UKIP voters going Leave then if 2/3 of Tories do, that's still nearly 40% in the bag for Leave with nearly 45% of the electorate to go at.
  • isamisam Posts: 41,902
    edited February 2016

    Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    If 2/3 of Con vote Out then Leave probably wins. Based on current opinion polls

    e.g.

    Con 39 x 2/3 = 26
    Lab 29 x 1/3 = 9.3
    UKIP 16 x 9/10 = 14.2
    LD 7 x 1/4 = 1.8
    SNP 5 x 1/4 = 1.2
    Grn 3 x 1/3 = 1
    Oth 1 x 1/2 = 0.5

    Total 54.

    UKIP might not get quite that high a proportion but then Labour might be higher. But even if it's only 80% of UKIP voters going Leave then if 2/3 of Tories do, that's still nearly 40% in the bag for Leave with nearly 45% of the electorate to go at.
    I would use Euro election results as well to see how it fits... when I did that it came to about 51% LEAVE I think... prob why I did it haha!
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    Sounds like something from Dave's "Nudge Unit". The plebs can't be trusted with the truth so they have to be manipulated.
  • SeanT said:

    What kind of REMAIN win will "settle it for a generation"? I think REMAIN has to win at least 60/40, and win squarely in England, most of all.

    Anything else (let alone a LEAVE victory) and the arguments will return quite quickly.

    Indeed the arguments will return anyway, once the EZ Federalises. But a close vote will accelerate things.

    Completely agreed, again.
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    edited February 2016
    Austria reports rise in crime after Germany begins rejecting one in ten migrants at the border... turning some areas into 'no-go' zones for women

    It comes after Berlin approved a series of measures aimed at making Germany less attractive, particularly to economic migrants.

    The move includes classifying Morocco, Tunisia and Algeria as 'safe' origin countries – a category which means their citizens would not usually gain asylum.

    Instead they are being sent back to the places where they crossed. Those being turned back at the border also include those who have tried to get into Germany with stolen or fake passports.
    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3449493/Austria-reports-rise-crime-Germany-begins-rejecting-one-ten-arrivals-border-turning-areas-no-zones-women.html
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    edited February 2016
    "Emma Thompson has been called an "overpaid, leftie luvvie" after warning it would be "madness" for the UK to vote to leave the European Union.

    The Love Actually actress was speaking at the Berlin Film Festival when she said a vote for an exit was a "crazy idea". She described living in "a tiny little cloud-bolted, rainy corner of sort-of Europe ... a cake-filled misery-laden grey old island"."


    http://news.sky.com/story/1642973/thompson-branded-leftie-luvvie-over-eu-remark
  • Mr. T, also worth considering fear of immigration.

    If you're a very wealthy person living in Swankyville, migration's cool. It means the chap who does work on your house charges less.

    If you're a tradesman, migration can mean you're undercut, or fear being undercut.
  • isamisam Posts: 41,902

    Austria reports rise in crime after Germany begins rejecting one in ten migrants at the border... turning some areas into 'no-go' zones for women
    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3449493/Austria-reports-rise-crime-Germany-begins-rejecting-one-ten-arrivals-border-turning-areas-no-zones-women.html

    Who would have possibly forseen this?
  • AndyJS said:

    NBC tracking poll:

    Trump 38 (+3)
    Cruz 18 (-2)
    Rubio 14 (-3)
    Carson 8 (+1)
    Kasich 7 (+4)
    Bush 4 (+1)

    Clinton 50 (-1)
    Sanders 40 (+1)

    http://floridapolitics.com/archives/201870-donald-trump-hillary-clinton-maintain-sizable-leads-in-national-nbc-news-tracking-poll

    Is Kasich going to prove the dark horse of the campaign? On one level, 7% is piss poor. On another, if he knocks out Bush then he's well-placed to pick up most of his support, particularly if Rubio is dropping back too.

    Or is this missing the wood for the trees; the wood being that Trump is strolling towards the nomination?
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,970
    SeanT said:

    AndyJS said:

    "I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else."

    Leave surely has a good chance of carrying some of the metropolitan boroughs that surround the big cities like Walsall, Dudley, Rotherham, Bolton, Wigan, Gateshead, South Tyneside, Barnsley, Doncaster, etc.

    LEAVE will do brilliantly in any town where there's been large scale immigration from Slovakia, Bulgaria, Poland, etc. Especially Roma immigration. Sad but true.

    That's quite a lot of towns. Mostly Labour voting.
    I forecast Leave will do badly in Primrose Hill, Hampstead, St Johns Wood, and Camden.
  • SeanT said:

    AndyJS said:

    "I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else."

    Leave surely has a good chance of carrying some of the metropolitan boroughs that surround the big cities like Walsall, Dudley, Rotherham, Bolton, Wigan, Gateshead, South Tyneside, Barnsley, Doncaster, etc.

    LEAVE will do brilliantly in any town where there's been large scale immigration from Slovakia, Bulgaria, Poland, etc. Especially Roma immigration. Sad but true.

    That's quite a lot of towns. Mostly Labour voting.
    There was a interesting documentary on the other day called Keeping up with the Khans about Eastern European (mainly Roma) immigration into an Asian area of Sheffield. It highlighted to me there are probably quite a few ethnic minority voters who wouldn't dream of voting UKIP but might well vote to leave.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 79,523

    AndyJS said:

    NBC tracking poll:

    Trump 38 (+3)
    Cruz 18 (-2)
    Rubio 14 (-3)
    Carson 8 (+1)
    Kasich 7 (+4)
    Bush 4 (+1)

    Clinton 50 (-1)
    Sanders 40 (+1)

    http://floridapolitics.com/archives/201870-donald-trump-hillary-clinton-maintain-sizable-leads-in-national-nbc-news-tracking-poll

    Is Kasich going to prove the dark horse of the campaign? On one level, 7% is piss poor. On another, if he knocks out Bush then he's well-placed to pick up most of his support, particularly if Rubio is dropping back too.

    Or is this missing the wood for the trees; the wood being that Trump is strolling towards the nomination?
    Donald J Trump looks very well set.
  • SeanT said:

    What kind of REMAIN win will "settle it for a generation"? I think REMAIN has to win at least 60/40, and win squarely in England, most of all.

    Anything else (let alone a LEAVE victory) and the arguments will return quite quickly.

    Indeed the arguments will return anyway, once the EZ Federalises. But a close vote will accelerate things.

    If it's 60-40 overall then that will be a square win in England. Even if Scotland and Wales go 80-20 then assuming equal turnouts, it'd mean about 57-43 in England, and a 16% lead is a fairly comfortable gap.
  • Indigo said:

    If the expectation is that somewhere around 2/3 of Conservatives are going to vote OUT, it follows that 2/3 of Conservatives are going to be extremely pissed off with Dave and George if their farting around eventually conjurers up a REMAIN. Difficult to stay at the top of a party where two thirds of your voters, and probably more of your activists are pissed off with you... especially when you have been going around telling your MPs to ignore their activists and associations...

    It's an even stranger way to "secure your legacy", especially if the EU manages to tear itself to pieces in the next few years and everyone wonders that all the contortions were about, and why he went to so much effort to "dock" us to a doomed entity. Worse still if the EU federalises rapidly as many have suggested it is going to and the position of non-Euro countries becomes untenable.

    If 2/3 of Con vote Out then Leave probably wins. Based on current opinion polls

    e.g.

    Con 39 x 2/3 = 26
    Lab 29 x 1/3 = 9.3
    UKIP 16 x 9/10 = 14.2
    LD 7 x 1/4 = 1.8
    SNP 5 x 1/4 = 1.2
    Grn 3 x 1/3 = 1
    Oth 1 x 1/2 = 0.5

    Total 54.

    UKIP might not get quite that high a proportion but then Labour might be higher. But even if it's only 80% of UKIP voters going Leave then if 2/3 of Tories do, that's still nearly 40% in the bag for Leave with nearly 45% of the electorate to go at.
    If 2/3rds of Tories vote Leave, I'd expect way more than 1/3rd of Labour to do so too. Labour voters (as opposed to their leadership) are just as likely to be bothered by immigration etc and are more likely to be undercut by it than Tories are I suspect.
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    edited February 2016

    SeanT said:

    What kind of REMAIN win will "settle it for a generation"? I think REMAIN has to win at least 60/40, and win squarely in England, most of all.

    Anything else (let alone a LEAVE victory) and the arguments will return quite quickly.

    Indeed the arguments will return anyway, once the EZ Federalises. But a close vote will accelerate things.

    If it's 60-40 overall then that will be a square win in England. Even if Scotland and Wales go 80-20 then assuming equal turnouts, it'd mean about 57-43 in England, and a 16% lead is a fairly comfortable gap.
    Wales looks like behaving more like provincial England than either Scotland or London according to recent polls.
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    John Rentoul
    Spectator tally of Tory MPs. In 86, Out 68, Not declared 176 https://t.co/pdbqd9ZIMm HT @realhansard
  • John Rentoul
    Spectator tally of Tory MPs. In 86, Out 68, Not declared 176 https://t.co/pdbqd9ZIMm HT @realhansard

    Cameron represents the Party far more than Redwood does.
  • John Rentoul

    Consensus in room 7 is that there is no provision for a recount in event of a close result in EU referendum & a tie means UK stays in.
  • AndyJS said:

    SeanT said:

    What kind of REMAIN win will "settle it for a generation"? I think REMAIN has to win at least 60/40, and win squarely in England, most of all.

    Anything else (let alone a LEAVE victory) and the arguments will return quite quickly.

    Indeed the arguments will return anyway, once the EZ Federalises. But a close vote will accelerate things.

    If it's 60-40 overall then that will be a square win in England. Even if Scotland and Wales go 80-20 then assuming equal turnouts, it'd mean about 57-43 in England, and a 16% lead is a fairly comfortable gap.
    Wales looks like behaving more like provincial England than either Scotland or London according to recent polls.
    Yes, I'd agree with that. I was just making the point that if the overall result produces as big a margin as 60-40 then England *has* to have gone that way too, by some distance. In fact, as you say, the probability is that the England result will be even closer to the UK one because of Wales.
  • So what would be the odds on a tie on the EURef?
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,475

    John Rentoul

    Consensus in room 7 is that there is no provision for a recount in event of a close result in EU referendum & a tie means UK stays in.

    The tie rule is used elsewhere, but it is very unlikely to happen.
  • rcs1000 said:

    SeanT said:

    AndyJS said:

    "I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else."

    Leave surely has a good chance of carrying some of the metropolitan boroughs that surround the big cities like Walsall, Dudley, Rotherham, Bolton, Wigan, Gateshead, South Tyneside, Barnsley, Doncaster, etc.

    LEAVE will do brilliantly in any town where there's been large scale immigration from Slovakia, Bulgaria, Poland, etc. Especially Roma immigration. Sad but true.

    That's quite a lot of towns. Mostly Labour voting.
    I forecast Leave will do badly in Primrose Hill, Hampstead, St Johns Wood, and Camden.
    And Islington :)
  • PongPong Posts: 4,693
    edited February 2016

    So what would be the odds on a tie on the EURef?


    Exact vote tie?

    I'm feeling generous. I'll lay 5/1 if you're interested?
  • IndigoIndigo Posts: 9,966

    If it's 60-40 overall then that will be a square win in England. Even if Scotland and Wales go 80-20 then assuming equal turnouts, it'd mean about 57-43 in England, and a 16% lead is a fairly comfortable gap.

    Then in six months time the Eurozone introduces some banking changes to deal with the Greek (and possibly Italian) situation, the UK waves it's renegotiation promises, the French complain and take it to the ECJ, and the ECJ laughs and says that political promises even "legally binding" ones cannot overrule the treaties, and its will all have been for nothing, all that political capital, all that time and Dave will be a laughing stock, if he is lucky.

    Incidentally the ECJ has ruled against UN Security Council resolutions that had already been adopted by the Council of Europe (Kadi & Al Barakaat v. Council of the EU & EC Commission) because they conflict with the treaties, so legally binding political promises have no chance.
  • Lovely bit of historical chicanery here:
    https://twitter.com/LettersDesk/status/698189915318779904
  • RobD said:

    John Rentoul

    Consensus in room 7 is that there is no provision for a recount in event of a close result in EU referendum & a tie means UK stays in.

    The tie rule is used elsewhere, but it is very unlikely to happen.
    The odds of a tie have to be miniscule. Something tells me we'd have a rerun before too long if it was remotely close let alone a tie.
  • In the event of a tie, the enormo-haddock will pulverise the pathetic eurocrats and seize power!
  • RobD said:

    John Rentoul

    Consensus in room 7 is that there is no provision for a recount in event of a close result in EU referendum & a tie means UK stays in.

    The tie rule is used elsewhere, but it is very unlikely to happen.
    The odds of a tie have to be miniscule. Something tells me we'd have a rerun before too long if it was remotely close let alone a tie.
    Yes, Pong's 5/1 isn't very generous. I'll go 9/1 to any reputable poster.
  • Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:



    My best guess is that Leave will win about 45% of the vote.

    I think most voters over 50, and most working class voters will vote Leave. I think that Conservative voters will vote about 50-55% for Leave, and UKIP voters will vote about 90% for Leave. About 25-30% of the rest will vote Leave.

    I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else.

    Are you going to be (are you already?) playing an active part in the campaign?

    I always found your UKIP (and earlier, Tory) reports from the battlegrounds to be very insightful.
    It's certainly my intention to help whichever organisation is designated as the official Leave campaign group. I expect I'll be delivering a ton of leaflets in Luton, a town where Leave may do quite well, given that Kelvin Hopkins will be campaigning for Leave.
    Thanks.

    I'm surprised you haven't started yet, in a way. Do you think you might have already if the organisation hadn't been so poor?
  • isamisam Posts: 41,902

    RobD said:

    John Rentoul

    Consensus in room 7 is that there is no provision for a recount in event of a close result in EU referendum & a tie means UK stays in.

    The tie rule is used elsewhere, but it is very unlikely to happen.
    The odds of a tie have to be miniscule. Something tells me we'd have a rerun before too long if it was remotely close let alone a tie.
    Yes, Pong's 5/1 isn't very generous. I'll go 9/1 to any reputable poster.
    20s here
  • pbr2013pbr2013 Posts: 649
    SeanT said:

    AndyJS said:

    "I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else."

    Leave surely has a good chance of carrying some of the metropolitan boroughs that surround the big cities like Walsall, Dudley, Rotherham, Bolton, Wigan, Gateshead, South Tyneside, Barnsley, Doncaster, etc.

    LEAVE will do brilliantly in any town where there's been large scale immigration from Slovakia, Bulgaria, Poland, etc. Especially Roma immigration. Sad but true.

    That's quite a lot of towns. Mostly Labour voting.
    I can't see Crewe voting remain.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,475

    In the event of a tie, the enormo-haddock will pulverise the pathetic eurocrats and seize power!

    Ah, the much-vaunted Third Way.
  • pbr2013 said:

    SeanT said:

    AndyJS said:

    "I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else."

    Leave surely has a good chance of carrying some of the metropolitan boroughs that surround the big cities like Walsall, Dudley, Rotherham, Bolton, Wigan, Gateshead, South Tyneside, Barnsley, Doncaster, etc.

    LEAVE will do brilliantly in any town where there's been large scale immigration from Slovakia, Bulgaria, Poland, etc. Especially Roma immigration. Sad but true.

    That's quite a lot of towns. Mostly Labour voting.
    I can't see Crewe voting remain.
    I think the large number of Poles in Crewe might want to...
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 56,022
    Pong said:

    So what would be the odds on a tie on the EURef?


    Exact vote tie?

    I'm feeling generous. I'll lay 5/1 if you're interested?
    It's got to be closer to 500/1. In fact in the last five general elections since 1997 there's only been one result close to a tie, so in reality it's more like 3000/1. No I'm not offering to lay at that price ;)
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 38,819
    AndyJS said:

    "I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else."

    Leave surely has a good chance of carrying some of the metropolitan boroughs that surround the big cities like Walsall, Dudley, Rotherham, Bolton, Wigan, Gateshead, South Tyneside, Barnsley, Doncaster, etc.

    On reflection, yes, there's a good chance.
  • pbr2013pbr2013 Posts: 649

    pbr2013 said:

    SeanT said:

    AndyJS said:

    "I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else."

    Leave surely has a good chance of carrying some of the metropolitan boroughs that surround the big cities like Walsall, Dudley, Rotherham, Bolton, Wigan, Gateshead, South Tyneside, Barnsley, Doncaster, etc.

    LEAVE will do brilliantly in any town where there's been large scale immigration from Slovakia, Bulgaria, Poland, etc. Especially Roma immigration. Sad but true.

    That's quite a lot of towns. Mostly Labour voting.
    I can't see Crewe voting remain.
    I think the large number of Poles in Crewe might want to...
    They don't get to vote on this.
  • Sandpit said:

    Pong said:

    So what would be the odds on a tie on the EURef?


    Exact vote tie?

    I'm feeling generous. I'll lay 5/1 if you're interested?
    It's got to be closer to 500/1. In fact in the last five general elections since 1997 there's only been one result close to a tie, so in reality it's more like 3000/1. No I'm not offering to lay at that price ;)
    You should be. It's more like 1,000,000/1
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 38,819

    Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:



    My best guess is that Leave will win about 45% of the vote.

    I think most voters over 50, and most working class voters will vote Leave. I think that Conservative voters will vote about 50-55% for Leave, and UKIP voters will vote about 90% for Leave. About 25-30% of the rest will vote Leave.

    I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else.

    Are you going to be (are you already?) playing an active part in the campaign?

    I always found your UKIP (and earlier, Tory) reports from the battlegrounds to be very insightful.
    It's certainly my intention to help whichever organisation is designated as the official Leave campaign group. I expect I'll be delivering a ton of leaflets in Luton, a town where Leave may do quite well, given that Kelvin Hopkins will be campaigning for Leave.
    Thanks.

    I'm surprised you haven't started yet, in a way. Do you think you might have already if the organisation hadn't been so poor?
    Yes. At this stage, I don't know who to assist.
  • Sandpit said:

    Pong said:

    So what would be the odds on a tie on the EURef?


    Exact vote tie?

    I'm feeling generous. I'll lay 5/1 if you're interested?
    It's got to be closer to 500/1. In fact in the last five general elections since 1997 there's only been one result close to a tie, so in reality it's more like 3000/1. No I'm not offering to lay at that price ;)
    You should be. It's more like 1,000,000/1
    I'll have a fiver. :lol:
  • So what would be the odds on a tie on the EURef?

    Several million to one.
  • Sandpit said:

    Pong said:

    So what would be the odds on a tie on the EURef?


    Exact vote tie?

    I'm feeling generous. I'll lay 5/1 if you're interested?
    It's got to be closer to 500/1. In fact in the last five general elections since 1997 there's only been one result close to a tie, so in reality it's more like 3000/1. No I'm not offering to lay at that price ;)
    You should be. It's more like 1,000,000/1
    I think Sandpit would be closer. I can't see it being beyond 100k/1
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 38,819

    One thing punters certainly should pay no heed to is the anti Cameron bile poured out on here day after day. its certainly not representative.

    Cameron gets more support here than among the public generally.
  • PongPong Posts: 4,693
    edited February 2016

    Sandpit said:

    Pong said:

    So what would be the odds on a tie on the EURef?


    Exact vote tie?

    I'm feeling generous. I'll lay 5/1 if you're interested?
    It's got to be closer to 500/1. In fact in the last five general elections since 1997 there's only been one result close to a tie, so in reality it's more like 3000/1. No I'm not offering to lay at that price ;)
    You should be. It's more like 1,000,000/1
    You can't blame me for trying.
  • pbr2013pbr2013 Posts: 649

    Sandpit said:

    Pong said:

    So what would be the odds on a tie on the EURef?


    Exact vote tie?

    I'm feeling generous. I'll lay 5/1 if you're interested?
    It's got to be closer to 500/1. In fact in the last five general elections since 1997 there's only been one result close to a tie, so in reality it's more like 3000/1. No I'm not offering to lay at that price ;)
    You should be. It's more like 1,000,000/1
    Is there a technical definition of a tie? Unless there is some rounding then it has to be millions to one.
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    Sean_F said:

    AndyJS said:

    "I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else."

    Leave surely has a good chance of carrying some of the metropolitan boroughs that surround the big cities like Walsall, Dudley, Rotherham, Bolton, Wigan, Gateshead, South Tyneside, Barnsley, Doncaster, etc.

    On reflection, yes, there's a good chance.
    At the same time Remain may carry some middle-class commuter districts near big cities like Harrogate, Solihull, Oadby & Wigston, etc.
  • isamisam Posts: 41,902
    x

    Sandpit said:

    Pong said:

    So what would be the odds on a tie on the EURef?


    Exact vote tie?

    I'm feeling generous. I'll lay 5/1 if you're interested?
    It's got to be closer to 500/1. In fact in the last five general elections since 1997 there's only been one result close to a tie, so in reality it's more like 3000/1. No I'm not offering to lay at that price ;)
    You should be. It's more like 1,000,000/1
    If we had kept our mouths shut I reckon Pong would've been on at 1/9 or bigger the other side
  • Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:



    My best guess is that Leave will win about 45% of the vote.

    I think most voters over 50, and most working class voters will vote Leave. I think that Conservative voters will vote about 50-55% for Leave, and UKIP voters will vote about 90% for Leave. About 25-30% of the rest will vote Leave.

    I think Remain will carry Scotland by a big margin, Greater London, Surrey, Berkshire, Hertfordshire, all the big cities and Metropolitan boroughs, Merseyside, Welsh-speaking Wales, Northern Ireland, and Leave will carry everywhere else.

    Are you going to be (are you already?) playing an active part in the campaign?

    I always found your UKIP (and earlier, Tory) reports from the battlegrounds to be very insightful.
    It's certainly my intention to help whichever organisation is designated as the official Leave campaign group. I expect I'll be delivering a ton of leaflets in Luton, a town where Leave may do quite well, given that Kelvin Hopkins will be campaigning for Leave.
    Thanks.

    I'm surprised you haven't started yet, in a way. Do you think you might have already if the organisation hadn't been so poor?
    Yes. At this stage, I don't know who to assist.
    You should come up with a plan to lock up the likes of Farage and John Redwood in a shed until after the referendum is over.
  • Sean_F said:

    One thing punters certainly should pay no heed to is the anti Cameron bile poured out on here day after day. its certainly not representative.

    Cameron gets more support here than among the public generally.
    Really? General public he has over 30% support from memory. He doesn't seem to have that much here. General public Tories he has about 80% from memory, on here I'd estimate more than 1/5th of Tories don't like him.
  • John Rentoul

    Consensus in room 7 is that there is no provision for a recount in event of a close result in EU referendum & a tie means UK stays in.

    The tie rule is, in a sense, fair enough: the principle of 'change needs a majority' is well-established. However, to have no provision for a re-count is bloody ridiculous.
  • pbr2013pbr2013 Posts: 649
    Oh God, could we get a hanging chads thing?
This discussion has been closed.