politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » And before the big Question Time event here’s Marf
Comments
-
The UKIP vote is about as close to UNS as we've got (which is why on 15% they'd still win virtually no seats). If the Tories squeeze UKIP successfully, it will result in holds and gains. The great majority of voters in the great majority of seats vote on their perceptions of parties, leaders and policies.MikeSmithson said:
Unlike the Israeli election where everything is decided on national vote shares same doesn't apply here. This is about 650 separate contest under FPTP.HYUFD said:IOS If it wasn't for UKIP the Tories would be well over 40%, if Cameron squeezes that vote he will certainly lead the largest party, his EU referendum pledge tonight and Miliband's dismissal of it will help, Netanyahu squeezed rightwing parties votes in Israel to move ahead in the final days without winning any over from the Israeli Labour Party, Cameron could do the same
0 -
I think that the Tories will end up with most votes. I'm not so sure about most seats. So much at the margin down to the ground ops in maybe 20 key seats and the evidence is that LAB doing better there.bigjohnowls said:
0 -
The entire campaign process appears to have done nothing. People pick and choose polls based on the results they like, but if we aggregate the numbers we see the bigger picture
In the first 7 days of the campaign we have 16 polls, with a total sample size of 25,425, combined this resulted in Con 33.26%, Lab 33.89%
In the last 7 days we've had 20 polls with a total sample of 30,043, combined this resulted in Con 33.55%, Lab 33.57% (tonight's Yougov will push the labour lead very slightly).
Nothing has changed, there is no huge blue momentum, it's a statistical dead heat. I don't expect this to change over the last 6 days. The tory media have already flung (both) kitchen sinks at Milliband. Hasn't worked.0 -
There is only one meaningful definition of winning or losing for Labour or the Tories: it's ending on the Treasury Bench or not.bigjohnowls said:0 -
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.GeoffM said:
If you don't like the result then fiddle the system, eh?Monty said:Let's hope this the last FPTP election. No longer fit for purpose.
I have supported PR for 30 years.0 -
Hanretty:
Con 279
Lab 270
SNP 48
LD 27
An absolute clusterfuck post election.0 -
I predict a second election this year.SeanT said:After tonight..... I stand by my prediction.
I believe Miliband will win a tiny tiny plurality and become PM (or PM of a party that is slightly smaller than the Tories (this latter statement is not my original prediction)).
He will need SNP support and this will collapse by Holyrood 2016 under the weight of contradictions (not least the SNP demanding a new referendum).
Miliband's government will fall in 2016 and the Tories will sweep back into power.
Miliband might become PM but he might refuse SNP support to kill the SNP scare stories in practice and then go for a second election in the autumn like Wilson in 1974.0 -
There won't be a wasted vote in the whole of Scotland, and perhaps not the Southwest eitherMonty said:
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.GeoffM said:
If you don't like the result then fiddle the system, eh?Monty said:Let's hope this the last FPTP election. No longer fit for purpose.
I have supported PR for 30 years.0 -
OGH True, but if UKIP voters back the Tories in key marginals the same principle applies0
-
The Guardian ICM poll had 397 Lab voters to 341 Con voters in the Pre QT VI0
-
We have very little evidence of polls being tested in recent elections. I'm pointing to the three biggest.chestnut said:
What relevance does London have? It isn't anything like the rest of the UK.MikeSmithson said:
Not correct. Top pollster at 2012 London mayoral election was Opinium. YouGov 2nd.Danny565 said:YouGov was also the only pollster who predicted the 2012 mayoral election to be as close as it was.
*clutches onto straws for dear life*
The worst poll by a long distance at Boris's last election was the only phone survey.
0 -
And on a totally different subject there's not a Yorkshire cricket match between Wednesday 29/04/15 and Sunday 10/05/15:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/teams/yorkshire/fixtures
Does the ECB really think this is good scheduling ?
0 -
Grow upMonty said:
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.GeoffM said:
If you don't like the result then fiddle the system, eh?Monty said:Let's hope this the last FPTP election. No longer fit for purpose.
I have supported PR for 30 years.0 -
There will be millions of wasted votes. That's the current system.Pulpstar said:
There won't be a wasted vote in the whole of Scotland, and perhaps not the Southwest eitherMonty said:
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.GeoffM said:
If you don't like the result then fiddle the system, eh?Monty said:Let's hope this the last FPTP election. No longer fit for purpose.
I have supported PR for 30 years.0 -
LD Manifesto P132 We will: "Work with the broadcasters to formalise the process for Leaders' Debates in General Elections, helping ensure they happen and setting a clear threshold for those eligible to participate."Monty said:
I hope they are now a permanent fixture. But the format needs to be settled and inclusive.SeanT said:Can we now - at least - agree that the Debates, in some form, are a permanent part of our political furniture, and that, by accident, we may have stumbled over the best format of all?
What we just saw was by a distance the best 90 minutes of political questioning in this election. All 3 leaders looked uncomfortable, at times, all got a proper interrogation by ordinary people.
The BBC did an excellent job. The only flaw was the absence of Farage. He would have livened it up no end after the non-event of Clegg.
Green manifesto P.62 we would" Give fair representation to political parties in televised debates"
Couldn't find anything in the Con, UKIP or Lab manifestos with a quick search I think we'll be in for another fudge. But at least the broadcasters should be more prepared.0 -
Fuck knows who is on those benches at this point.david_herdson said:
There is only one meaningful definition of winning or losing for Labour or the Tories: it's ending on the Treasury Bench or not.bigjohnowls said:0 -
Cameron is more popular than his party, Milliband less popular than this.TheScreamingEagles said:The Guardian ICM poll had 397 Lab voters to 341 Con voters in the Pre QT VI
This is known.0 -
Tory minority best bet by miles.SeanT said:After tonight..... I stand by my prediction.
I believe Miliband will win a tiny tiny plurality and become PM (or PM of a party that is slightly smaller than the Tories (this latter statement is not my original prediction)).
He will need SNP support and this will collapse by Holyrood 2016 under the weight of contradictions (not least the SNP demanding a new referendum).
Miliband's government will fall in 2016 and the Tories will sweep back into power.0 -
Every seat is in play in Scotland !Monty said:
There will be millions of wasted votes. That's the current system.Pulpstar said:
There won't be a wasted vote in the whole of Scotland, and perhaps not the Southwest eitherMonty said:
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.GeoffM said:
If you don't like the result then fiddle the system, eh?Monty said:Let's hope this the last FPTP election. No longer fit for purpose.
I have supported PR for 30 years.0 -
Don't dispute that but the disproportionate move by 2010 LDs to LAB in key battlegrounds could be decisive and more than trump the kipper returners.HYUFD said:OGH True, but if UKIP voters back the Tories in key marginals the same principle applies
0 -
As an Eastleigh resident i am stunned by the lack of the feeling of an election in this area. I always felt this was the lib dems safest seat, yet I have not received a single piece of election literature from them and neither have my work colleagues who also live in Eastleigh . It's very odd . The Tories seem to be the only ones who are making an effort. I'm very confused.IOS said:Anyway - how many people have voted already - at least 15% of the people that are going to vote I reckon.
Not sure there are many people to shift in the center - just about getting out your core.
Step forward the ground game.0 -
One thing changed.asjohnstone said:The entire campaign process appears to have done nothing. People pick and choose polls based on the results they like, but if we aggregate the numbers we see the bigger picture
In the first 7 days of the campaign we have 16 polls, with a total sample size of 25,425, combined this resulted in Con 33.26%, Lab 33.89%
In the last 7 days we've had 20 polls with a total sample of 30,043, combined this resulted in Con 33.55%, Lab 33.57% (tonight's Yougov will push the labour lead very slightly).
Nothing has changed, there is no huge blue momentum, it's a statistical dead heat. I don't expect this to change over the last 6 days. The tory media have already flung (both) kitchen sinks at Milliband. Hasn't worked.
The SNP have gone from high 40s to low 50s, quite a significant bump over the campaign.0 -
Pulpstar
That is very easy. Ed is PM. I would take that in a second.
Cherio Dave.0 -
It is the value play right now for sure.nigel4england said:
Tory minority best bet by miles.SeanT said:After tonight..... I stand by my prediction.
I believe Miliband will win a tiny tiny plurality and become PM (or PM of a party that is slightly smaller than the Tories (this latter statement is not my original prediction)).
He will need SNP support and this will collapse by Holyrood 2016 under the weight of contradictions (not least the SNP demanding a new referendum).
Miliband's government will fall in 2016 and the Tories will sweep back into power.0 -
In 1992 the polls were wrong because of wrong demographic weighting, they based their weightings on the 1981 census rather than the 1991 one, because it wasn't yet published, instead they used their own estimates which were fairly wrong.Tykejohnno said:The well respected lib dem -
Stephen Tall @stephentall
Watching the #bbcqt coverage, I'm starting to get a 1992 feeling about this election. (Tho no Tory maj this time.)
Once the 1991 census was published and the pollsters used it, it revealed that the Tories were ahead all along for years before 1992 and had never lost their lead.0 -
That's the high level of political debate I love here.NoEasyDay said:
Grow upMonty said:
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.GeoffM said:
If you don't like the result then fiddle the system, eh?Monty said:Let's hope this the last FPTP election. No longer fit for purpose.
I have supported PR for 30 years.
I'm amazed that the Tories still stand by FPTP. A triumph of hope over expectation.
And nothing to do with fairness or democracy.0 -
Well no one took up my last charity challenge so here is another one. Do you believe that the SNP will win 58 or more seats. If so are you willing to enter a charity wager of £50. I believe that they won't get that many; if I am wrong I pay a charity of your choice £50, and if I am right you pay £50 to mine. First person to accept only. Must be a UK wide charity and not a religious one. My nominated charity is the Cure Parkinsons Trust.
Please accept this in the sporting spirit in which it is intended, irrespective of political opinions.
0 -
Agreed, but as there hasn't been a fall off in overall labour scores, we must assume they have gained ground in england whilst this has been happening in Scotland.Dair said:
One thing changed.asjohnstone said:The entire campaign process appears to have done nothing. People pick and choose polls based on the results they like, but if we aggregate the numbers we see the bigger picture
In the first 7 days of the campaign we have 16 polls, with a total sample size of 25,425, combined this resulted in Con 33.26%, Lab 33.89%
In the last 7 days we've had 20 polls with a total sample of 30,043, combined this resulted in Con 33.55%, Lab 33.57% (tonight's Yougov will push the labour lead very slightly).
Nothing has changed, there is no huge blue momentum, it's a statistical dead heat. I don't expect this to change over the last 6 days. The tory media have already flung (both) kitchen sinks at Milliband. Hasn't worked.
The SNP have gone from high 40s to low 50s, quite a significant bump over the campaign.
The SNP wipe out of the Scottish Lib Dems may turn out to be the most important event of the night0 -
There's a difference between a good bet and what's likeliest to happen. Con minority at 5/1 is excellent value but Lab minority rightly still favourite.nigel4england said:
Tory minority best bet by miles.SeanT said:After tonight..... I stand by my prediction.
I believe Miliband will win a tiny tiny plurality and become PM (or PM of a party that is slightly smaller than the Tories (this latter statement is not my original prediction)).
He will need SNP support and this will collapse by Holyrood 2016 under the weight of contradictions (not least the SNP demanding a new referendum).
Miliband's government will fall in 2016 and the Tories will sweep back into power.0 -
Quite. If not before now, why would it? Some thought people would see the light about one side or the other by now, but what movement there has been has not been significant enough.asjohnstone said:The entire campaign process appears to have done nothing...Nothing has changed, there is no huge blue momentum, it's a statistical dead heat. I don't expect this to change over the last 6 days. .
0 -
The ECB is incompetent. Just like the RFU. And the FA.another_richard said:And on a totally different subject there's not a Yorkshire cricket match between Wednesday 29/04/15 and Sunday 10/05/15:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/teams/yorkshire/fixtures
Does the ECB really think this is good scheduling ?0 -
Amazing. I'm seriously beginning to wonder if Ashcroft Question ONE might be the correct one.currystar said:
As an Eastleigh resident i am stunned by the lack of the feeling of an election in this area. I always felt this was the lib dems safest seat, yet I have not received a single piece of election literature from them and neither have my work colleagues who also live in Eastleigh . It's very odd . The Tories seem to be the only ones who are making an effort. I'm very confused.IOS said:Anyway - how many people have voted already - at least 15% of the people that are going to vote I reckon.
Not sure there are many people to shift in the center - just about getting out your core.
Step forward the ground game.0 -
The rerun of the 1970s meme.Speedy said:
I predict a second election this year.SeanT said:After tonight..... I stand by my prediction.
I believe Miliband will win a tiny tiny plurality and become PM (or PM of a party that is slightly smaller than the Tories (this latter statement is not my original prediction)).
He will need SNP support and this will collapse by Holyrood 2016 under the weight of contradictions (not least the SNP demanding a new referendum).
Miliband's government will fall in 2016 and the Tories will sweep back into power.
Miliband might become PM but he might refuse SNP support to kill the SNP scare stories in practice and then go for a second election in the autumn like Wilson in 1974.
0 -
David
Problem with that is the Tories aren't even trying to win a majority.!0 -
You can't have it both ways, whining about lack of balance when the dear leader gets gyp from a "biased" audience, then whining when they take steps to balance the audience.MikeK said:Sad story of the night.
MissLeahMarie @LittleMissUKIP 4h4 hours ago
The BBC are disgusting. Decided to tell everyone WHEN WE GOT THERE that only some of us are allowed in for "balance" reasons. BBC bastards.0 -
That's what happens when a county plays a touring side, another county doesn't have a match as long as we have an even numbered number of counties.another_richard said:And on a totally different subject there's not a Yorkshire cricket match between Wednesday 29/04/15 and Sunday 10/05/15:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/teams/yorkshire/fixtures
Does the ECB really think this is good scheduling ?0 -
SeanT IOS Mandelson will arrange Miliband's assassination before he gets to do any deals with the SNP if Labour is second on seats0
-
Yes, but the big unknown here is all the minor parties. We haven't had a GE were so many parties are scoring significant percentages. The polls might be getting all the weighting etc correct, we don't know at the moment.Speedy said:
In 1992 the polls were wrong because of wrong demographic weighting, they based their weightings on the 1981 census rather than the 1991 one, because it wasn't yet published.Tykejohnno said:The well respected lib dem -
Stephen Tall @stephentall
Watching the #bbcqt coverage, I'm starting to get a 1992 feeling about this election. (Tho no Tory maj this time.)
Once the 1991 census was published and the pollsters used it, it revealed that the Tories were ahead all along for years before 1992 and had never lost their lead.0 -
@MrHarryCole: I can't wait for all the left wing hot takes tomorrow on why it doesn't matter that the future PM can't walk.0
-
If it is sincere, then it is not plain wrong to use it. Don't people ask for more sincerity in politics?tyson said:@Plato
All I'm saying is that you don't use something as personal as this in politics. If a stranger said something deeply personal to you it would make you feel uncomfortable.
For a politician to do this is just plain wrong.
Hearing him mention it does make me uncomfortable in point of fact, but that says more than me than Cameron I think, if we accept his sincerity i feel.
0 -
Every vote is an expression of preference and as such, matters. The fact that not all votes contribute to the election of an MP is beside the point. Why should they? If that was the prime objective you'd have a single national list giving virtually no accountability over individual MPs or meaningful connection between localities and parliament.Monty said:
There will be millions of wasted votes. That's the current system.Pulpstar said:
There won't be a wasted vote in the whole of Scotland, and perhaps not the Southwest eitherMonty said:
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.GeoffM said:
If you don't like the result then fiddle the system, eh?Monty said:Let's hope this the last FPTP election. No longer fit for purpose.
I have supported PR for 30 years.
FWIW, I favour PR given the number of effective parties we now have but I don't regard any vote as wasted.0 -
Scott
You still gonna post - sorry I mean reprint - here when Ed is PM?
Of course you are! Its going to be great for you. Lots of tweets to copy and paste away all day long ...0 -
I have a special youtube video to post here in case Labour gets most seats next Thursday, and it is a 1970's one, just to show the similarities.another_richard said:
The rerun of the 1970s meme.Speedy said:
I predict a second election this year.SeanT said:After tonight..... I stand by my prediction.
I believe Miliband will win a tiny tiny plurality and become PM (or PM of a party that is slightly smaller than the Tories (this latter statement is not my original prediction)).
He will need SNP support and this will collapse by Holyrood 2016 under the weight of contradictions (not least the SNP demanding a new referendum).
Miliband's government will fall in 2016 and the Tories will sweep back into power.
Miliband might become PM but he might refuse SNP support to kill the SNP scare stories in practice and then go for a second election in the autumn like Wilson in 1974.0 -
Fair point, but a vote that is a tiny part of a party's vote share and nothing else is a big factor in the disengagement with politics by the populace.david_herdson said:
Every vote is an expression of preference and as such, matters. The fact that not all votes contribute to the election of an MP is beside the point. Why should they? If that was the prime objective you'd have a single national list giving virtually no accountability over individual MPs or meaningful connection between localities and parliament.Monty said:
There will be millions of wasted votes. That's the current system.Pulpstar said:
There won't be a wasted vote in the whole of Scotland, and perhaps not the Southwest eitherMonty said:
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.GeoffM said:
If you don't like the result then fiddle the system, eh?Monty said:Let's hope this the last FPTP election. No longer fit for purpose.
I have supported PR for 30 years.
FWIW, I favour PR given the number of effective parties we now have but I don't regard any vote as wasted.0 -
Which he does how, precisely?Speedy said:
I predict a second election this year.SeanT said:After tonight..... I stand by my prediction.
I believe Miliband will win a tiny tiny plurality and become PM (or PM of a party that is slightly smaller than the Tories (this latter statement is not my original prediction)).
He will need SNP support and this will collapse by Holyrood 2016 under the weight of contradictions (not least the SNP demanding a new referendum).
Miliband's government will fall in 2016 and the Tories will sweep back into power.
Miliband might become PM but he might refuse SNP support to kill the SNP scare stories in practice and then go for a second election in the autumn like Wilson in 1974.
If Miliband becomes PM, I'd expect him to remain in office until at least Autumn 2016 and probably Spring 2017. It's not in the interests of the other parties to bring him down before then. He has to be seen to fail.0 -
It is an odd one. I live in a safe Tory seat and received nothing from them yet, classic taking the seat for granted behaviour (I am sure I will get something in the final week as a token effort), but I've had 4 leaflets from the LDs already even though they were 20 pts behind last time, and so will likely be a lot further behind this time. Either they are targeting their resources poorly, or they have some enthusiastic locals near to my location at least.currystar said:
As an Eastleigh resident i am stunned by the lack of the feeling of an election in this area. I always felt this was the lib dems safest seat, yet I have not received a single piece of election literature from them and neither have my work colleagues who also live in Eastleigh . It's very odd . The Tories seem to be the only ones who are making an effort. I'm very confused.IOS said:Anyway - how many people have voted already - at least 15% of the people that are going to vote I reckon.
Not sure there are many people to shift in the center - just about getting out your core.
Step forward the ground game.0 -
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.Monty said:
That's the high level of political debate I love here.NoEasyDay said:
Grow upMonty said:
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.GeoffM said:
If you don't like the result then fiddle the system, eh?Monty said:Let's hope this the last FPTP election. No longer fit for purpose.
I have supported PR for 30 years.
I'm amazed that the Tories still stand by FPTP. A triumph of hope over expectation.
And nothing to do with fairness or democracy.
I want world peace and no hunger in world where everyone loves everyone.....oh and where there are no wasted votes. And i vote socks with sandals are banned, Will my vote make make that happen
Are you ten years old.0 -
Tabman
"Have you not heard of Haute la Garenne?"
I don't think anything has been established0 -
My problem with the SNP is not some of the actions but the holier than thou attitude. The SNP have made some tough decisions some of which worked and some which were pretty poor. I run a company that makes medical kits amongst other things. We sell them across the UK but not in Scotland where they would rather buy cheap poor quality kits from China with instruments that are not sharp and made by workers on below poverty wages. Now the SNP suggest they will impose a living wage on our company. Total hypocrisy.Dair said:
So you don't support replacing managers in the NHS with clinical staff?hamiltonace said:
You mean allowing a woman who had been made redundant by the Scottish NHS under Nicola's reign and then ignored when she tried to commit suicide to ask a question was unfair. Don't worry Dair maybe she is not Scottish. I am sure she is really British or even English!!Dair said:Desperate hatchet job by BBC Scotland on Nicola Sturgeon.
Even the woman herself was embarrassed to say her former job title (it was something like Educational Outreach Project Manager)
0 -
Farage going on HIV again.0
-
Indeed I think this has been overlooked.asjohnstone said:
Agreed, but as there hasn't been a fall off in overall labour scores, we must assume they have gained ground in england whilst this has been happening in Scotland.Dair said:
One thing changed.asjohnstone said:The entire campaign process appears to have done nothing. People pick and choose polls based on the results they like, but if we aggregate the numbers we see the bigger picture
In the first 7 days of the campaign we have 16 polls, with a total sample size of 25,425, combined this resulted in Con 33.26%, Lab 33.89%
In the last 7 days we've had 20 polls with a total sample of 30,043, combined this resulted in Con 33.55%, Lab 33.57% (tonight's Yougov will push the labour lead very slightly).
Nothing has changed, there is no huge blue momentum, it's a statistical dead heat. I don't expect this to change over the last 6 days. The tory media have already flung (both) kitchen sinks at Milliband. Hasn't worked.
The SNP have gone from high 40s to low 50s, quite a significant bump over the campaign.
The SNP wipe out of the Scottish Lib Dems may turn out to be the most important event of the night
Throughout their days in the wilderness in the 50s, 60s and 70s it was those heartland Liberal seats in the Highlands that kept the Liberal Party alive. Without those seats, their future as a party of any consequence at all is in genuine jeaopardy.0 -
Neither did FDR, but he made a great president.Scott_P said:@MrHarryCole: I can't wait for all the left wing hot takes tomorrow on why it doesn't matter that the future PM can't walk.
0 -
@SkyNews: THE INDEPENDENT FRONT PAGE: "Miliband: I will not do deal with the SNP to become PM" #skypapers http://t.co/im5LfHEUij0
-
I would prefer if we used the SNP tactic of "Vote for me and I will blackmail the government to give you more money".KentRising said:Farage going on HIV again.
0 -
Are you if Cameron is still PM?IOS said:Scott
You still gonna post - sorry I mean reprint - here when Ed is PM?
Of course you are! Its going to be great for you. Lots of tweets to copy and paste away all day long ...0 -
Given that I'm personally helping out in campaigns directly aimed at winning Morley & Outwood and Wakefield, I'd dispute that!IOS said:David
Problem with that is the Tories aren't even trying to win a majority.!0 -
What a pleasant person you are. Do you abuse because you can't form an argument or is it just for fun?NoEasyDay said:
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.Monty said:
That's the high level of political debate I love here.NoEasyDay said:
Grow upMonty said:
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.GeoffM said:
If you don't like the result then fiddle the system, eh?Monty said:Let's hope this the last FPTP election. No longer fit for purpose.
I have supported PR for 30 years.
I'm amazed that the Tories still stand by FPTP. A triumph of hope over expectation.
And nothing to do with fairness or democracy.
I want world peace and no hunger in world where everyone loves everyone.....oh and where there are no wasted votes. And i vote socks with sandals are banned, Will my vote make make that happen
Are you ten years old.0 -
The only thing I can take from the polls over the last two weeks is that the Tories biggest leads have been 5-6% whereas labours biggest leads have been 2-3%. I don't know if this means anything . I do wonder if the polling narrative would be different if you gov was weekly not daily. You gov are asking the same people over and over and reporting daily. If you gov was weekly then I think Cameron would be favourite in the betting to be next pmkle4 said:
Quite. If not before now, why would it? Some thought people would see the light about one side or the other by now, but what movement there has been has not been significant enough.asjohnstone said:The entire campaign process appears to have done nothing...Nothing has changed, there is no huge blue momentum, it's a statistical dead heat. I don't expect this to change over the last 6 days. .
0 -
Eastleigh was a 3 way split at the by election. Since then then the LD vote has slipped further and I cannot see UKIP doing any where like the same. I think the Cons are value.Pulpstar said:
Amazing. I'm seriously beginning to wonder if Ashcroft Question ONE might be the correct one.currystar said:
As an Eastleigh resident i am stunned by the lack of the feeling of an election in this area. I always felt this was the lib dems safest seat, yet I have not received a single piece of election literature from them and neither have my work colleagues who also live in Eastleigh . It's very odd . The Tories seem to be the only ones who are making an effort. I'm very confused.IOS said:Anyway - how many people have voted already - at least 15% of the people that are going to vote I reckon.
Not sure there are many people to shift in the center - just about getting out your core.
Step forward the ground game.0 -
@JGForsyth: The stage is now set for a late Tory surge, but the question is can they make it happen http://t.co/QmaXhHQQAe0
-
Won't Yorkshire be playing the West Indies at that time?TheScreamingEagles said:
That's what happens when a county plays a touring side, another county doesn't have a match as long as we have an even numbered number of counties.another_richard said:And on a totally different subject there's not a Yorkshire cricket match between Wednesday 29/04/15 and Sunday 10/05/15:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/teams/yorkshire/fixtures
Does the ECB really think this is good scheduling ?0 -
@PeteWishart: Important front page in the National tomorrow. This is only going to get bigger. All over for Lab, methinks. https://t.co/t3upVzfxGV0
-
Cameron got the better of tonight but will it move many votes? I doubt it. I still think that Cameron made a serious mistake in not debating Miliband head to head. He thought it was the safe thing to do because swing back was going to deliver this election to him on a plate.
The truth was very far from these now discredited models. The truth was that it was the Tories that had to take the chances and swing from the hip to have any chance of delivering a win. A major misjudgement based on the models has resulted in a series of too cautious decisions. It is only in the last week or so the Tories have started to appreciate how much they were always up against it.
Who will be the largest party is still too close to call but even after tonight who will be able to win a vote of confidence in Parliament is not.0 -
Is there a council election at the same time? If do that's your answer.kle4 said:
It is an odd one. I live in a safe Tory seat and received nothing from them yet, classic taking the seat for granted behaviour (I am sure I will get something in the final week as a token effort), but I've had 4 leaflets from the LDs already even though they were 20 pts behind last time, and so will likely be a lot further behind this time. Either they are targeting their resources poorly, or they have some enthusiastic locals near to my location at least.currystar said:
As an Eastleigh resident i am stunned by the lack of the feeling of an election in this area. I always felt this was the lib dems safest seat, yet I have not received a single piece of election literature from them and neither have my work colleagues who also live in Eastleigh . It's very odd . The Tories seem to be the only ones who are making an effort. I'm very confused.IOS said:Anyway - how many people have voted already - at least 15% of the people that are going to vote I reckon.
Not sure there are many people to shift in the center - just about getting out your core.
Step forward the ground game.0 -
There is a possibility if scores are around 280 con 270 lab that neither party forms a government because of unwillingness to deal with SNP or with libs if they refuse EU referendum that we end up with an immediate second GESeanT said:After tonight..... I stand by my prediction.
I believe Miliband will win a tiny tiny plurality and become PM (or PM of a party that is slightly smaller than the Tories (this latter statement is not my original prediction)).
He will need SNP support and this will collapse by Holyrood 2016 under the weight of contradictions (not least the SNP demanding a new referendum).
Miliband's government will fall in 2016 and the Tories will sweep back into power.0 -
Miliband can orchestrate a loss on a vote of confidence in order to trigger an election, he might even instruct his own party to vote against the government in order to ensure a second election if needed, and he will explain it as such under the Fixed Parliaments Act.david_herdson said:
Which he does how, precisely?Speedy said:
I predict a second election this year.SeanT said:After tonight..... I stand by my prediction.
I believe Miliband will win a tiny tiny plurality and become PM (or PM of a party that is slightly smaller than the Tories (this latter statement is not my original prediction)).
He will need SNP support and this will collapse by Holyrood 2016 under the weight of contradictions (not least the SNP demanding a new referendum).
Miliband's government will fall in 2016 and the Tories will sweep back into power.
Miliband might become PM but he might refuse SNP support to kill the SNP scare stories in practice and then go for a second election in the autumn like Wilson in 1974.
If Miliband becomes PM, I'd expect him to remain in office until at least Autumn 2016 and probably Spring 2017. It's not in the interests of the other parties to bring him down before then. He has to be seen to fail.
0 -
Normally a week before an election Eastleigh turns orange with the number of lib dem banners and posters. Not this time.foxinsoxuk said:
Eastleigh was a 3 way split at the by election. Since then then the LD vote has slipped further and I cannot see UKIP doing any where like the same. I think the Cons are value.Pulpstar said:
Amazing. I'm seriously beginning to wonder if Ashcroft Question ONE might be the correct one.currystar said:
As an Eastleigh resident i am stunned by the lack of the feeling of an election in this area. I always felt this was the lib dems safest seat, yet I have not received a single piece of election literature from them and neither have my work colleagues who also live in Eastleigh . It's very odd . The Tories seem to be the only ones who are making an effort. I'm very confused.IOS said:Anyway - how many people have voted already - at least 15% of the people that are going to vote I reckon.
Not sure there are many people to shift in the center - just about getting out your core.
Step forward the ground game.0 -
Safe tory seat - why should they bombard you with leaflets 4 weeks ago? I got mine a couple of days ago. V safe sear.kle4 said:
It is an odd one. I live in a safe Tory seat and received nothing from them yet, classic taking the seat for granted behaviour (I am sure I will get something in the final week as a token effort), but I've had 4 leaflets from the LDs already even though they were 20 pts behind last time, and so will likely be a lot further behind this time. Either they are targeting their resources poorly, or they have some enthusiastic locals near to my location at least.currystar said:
As an Eastleigh resident i am stunned by the lack of the feeling of an election in this area. I always felt this was the lib dems safest seat, yet I have not received a single piece of election literature from them and neither have my work colleagues who also live in Eastleigh . It's very odd . The Tories seem to be the only ones who are making an effort. I'm very confused.IOS said:Anyway - how many people have voted already - at least 15% of the people that are going to vote I reckon.
Not sure there are many people to shift in the center - just about getting out your core.
Step forward the ground game.
What do leaflets tell you.0 -
Given the stage is set so because they have failed to maintain a surge to date (significant enough to alter things at any rate), that's not much of a comment from Mr Forsyth. Of course the stage is set for a late Tory surge, they've failed to prevent that from becoming their only hope!Scott_P said:@JGForsyth: The stage is now set for a late Tory surge, but the question is can they make it happen http://t.co/QmaXhHQQAe
Possibly. The near certainty that any significant movement elsewhere will be offset by YouGov does seem to have a diminishing effect on the general mood.currystar said:
The only thing I can take from the polls over the last two weeks is that the Tories biggest leads have been 5-6% whereas labours biggest leads have been 2-3%. I don't know if this means anything . I do wonder if the polling narrative would be different if you gov was weekly not daily. You gov are asking the same people over and over and reporting daily. If you gov was weekly then I think Cameron would be favourite in the betting to be next pmkle4 said:
Quite. If not before now, why would it? Some thought people would see the light about one side or the other by now, but what movement there has been has not been significant enough.asjohnstone said:The entire campaign process appears to have done nothing...Nothing has changed, there is no huge blue momentum, it's a statistical dead heat. I don't expect this to change over the last 6 days. .
0 -
David
You know very well then the Tories aren't taking that seat seriously.0 -
I did think of making that point.david_herdson said:
Won't Yorkshire be playing the West Indies at that time?TheScreamingEagles said:
That's what happens when a county plays a touring side, another county doesn't have a match as long as we have an even numbered number of counties.another_richard said:And on a totally different subject there's not a Yorkshire cricket match between Wednesday 29/04/15 and Sunday 10/05/15:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/teams/yorkshire/fixtures
Does the ECB really think this is good scheduling ?
Annoying so many of our lot being subs out there.0 -
Translation: "We need a late Tory surge to win"Scott_P said:@JGForsyth: The stage is now set for a late Tory surge, but the question is can they make it happen http://t.co/QmaXhHQQAe
0 -
Good old Scott has found a Tory surge...!0
-
Remember 1992!
One week to go - LAB clear by 5%!!
GE1992 - CON clear by 7%!!!
CON 38 - LAB 28 real possibility next week!!!!0 -
Strange that with such inferior equipment the Scottish Health Service does not have worse mortality rates than England or Wales.hamiltonace said:
My problem with the SNP is not some of the actions but the holier than thou attitude. The SNP have made some tough decisions some of which worked and some which were pretty poor. I run a company that makes medical kits amongst other things. We sell them across the UK but not in Scotland where they would rather buy cheap poor quality kits from China with instruments that are not sharp and made by workers on below poverty wages. Now the SNP suggest they will impose a living wage on our company. Total hypocrisy.Dair said:
So you don't support replacing managers in the NHS with clinical staff?hamiltonace said:
You mean allowing a woman who had been made redundant by the Scottish NHS under Nicola's reign and then ignored when she tried to commit suicide to ask a question was unfair. Don't worry Dair maybe she is not Scottish. I am sure she is really British or even English!!Dair said:Desperate hatchet job by BBC Scotland on Nicola Sturgeon.
Even the woman herself was embarrassed to say her former job title (it was something like Educational Outreach Project Manager)
Maybe you are right and the Scottish Health Service should be buying overpriced equipment from you but it seems that the results don't bear out your claims of shoddy equipment. Personally it seems to me the Scottish Health Service are getting this right.
Wage rates are far too low in the UK, a higher minimum wage is needed and would not impact employment just as it didn't impact employment when first introduced (despite all the warnings of catastrophe from "business leaders". If there is a case for subsidising employment from general taxes, there are more efficient ways of doing it than doing it through private companies.0 -
This Farage debate seems very boring and sterile compared to the QT one. My Sky box cut it out as its got a recording clash with the Mentalist finale and The Last Leg on +1 and frankly I don't intend to cancel either of them to continue watching this boring thing.0
-
Tories revenge -
PoliticsHome @politicshome · 4 mins4 minutes ago
Nick Clegg "talking crap" on tuition fees? Ex-No 10 adviser says DPM was "keen" on fee rise http://polho.me/1OK1pGH
0 -
Agreeddavid_herdson said:
Every vote is an expression of preference and as such, matters. The fact that not all votes contribute to the election of an MP is beside the point. Why should they? If that was the prime objective you'd have a single national list giving virtually no accountability over individual MPs or meaningful connection between localities and parliament.Monty said:
There will be millions of wasted votes. That's the current system.Pulpstar said:
There won't be a wasted vote in the whole of Scotland, and perhaps not the Southwest eitherMonty said:
No. I want a system that represents the will of the people and where there are no wasted votes and no need for tactical voting.GeoffM said:
If you don't like the result then fiddle the system, eh?Monty said:Let's hope this the last FPTP election. No longer fit for purpose.
I have supported PR for 30 years.
FWIW, I favour PR given the number of effective parties we now have but I don't regard any vote as wasted.
The election is and should be fought constituency by constiuency
Would be like saying Man City should be champions because they scored the most goals in aggregate over the season
0 -
I completely agree David. The public want to see our politicians take more risks in campaigns. This one has been a little boring. Which is amazing considering how close it is.DavidL said:Cameron got the better of tonight but will it move many votes? I doubt it. I still think that Cameron made a serious mistake in not debating Miliband head to head. He thought it was the safe thing to do because swing back was going to deliver this election to him on a plate.
The truth was very far from these now discredited models. The truth was that it was the Tories that had to take the chances and swing from the hip to have any chance of delivering a win. A major misjudgement based on the models has resulted in a series of too cautious decisions. It is only in the last week or so the Tories have started to appreciate how much they were always up against it.
Who will be the largest party is still too close to call but even after tonight who will be able to win a vote of confidence in Parliament is not.0 -
No council election either. It's weird. I don't really want to decide who to vote for on my 'who put the most effort in' factor (assuming the parties cannot convince me some other way in the next 6 days, but I cannot see that happening) based on leafleting, but it may end up being all I have to go on.Tabman said:
Is there a council election at the same time? If do that's your answer.kle4 said:
It is an odd one. I live in a safe Tory seat and received nothing from them yet, classic taking the seat for granted behaviour (I am sure I will get something in the final week as a token effort), but I've had 4 leaflets from the LDs already even though they were 20 pts behind last time, and so will likely be a lot further behind this time. Either they are targeting their resources poorly, or they have some enthusiastic locals near to my location at least.currystar said:
As an Eastleigh resident i am stunned by the lack of the feeling of an election in this area. I always felt this was the lib dems safest seat, yet I have not received a single piece of election literature from them and neither have my work colleagues who also live in Eastleigh . It's very odd . The Tories seem to be the only ones who are making an effort. I'm very confused.IOS said:Anyway - how many people have voted already - at least 15% of the people that are going to vote I reckon.
Not sure there are many people to shift in the center - just about getting out your core.
Step forward the ground game.
0 -
I do remember 1992, I just explained further down that it was the demographic weighting being based on the 1981 census rather than the 1991 that made the pollsters go wrong back then.Ave_it said:Remember 1992!
One week to go - LAB clear by 5%!!
GE1992 - CON clear by 7%!!!
CON 38 - LAB 28 real possibility next week!!!!
Not much of an issue this year.0 -
Would it though? There may well be at least the possibility that Cameron might form a government if Labour had kicked their own party out of office on a tactic.Speedy said:
Miliband can orchestrate a loss on a vote of confidence in order to trigger an election, he might even instruct his own party to vote against the government in order to ensure a second election if needed, and he will explain it as such under the Fixed Parliaments Act.david_herdson said:
Which he does how, precisely?Speedy said:
I predict a second election this year.SeanT said:After tonight..... I stand by my prediction.
I believe Miliband will win a tiny tiny plurality and become PM (or PM of a party that is slightly smaller than the Tories (this latter statement is not my original prediction)).
He will need SNP support and this will collapse by Holyrood 2016 under the weight of contradictions (not least the SNP demanding a new referendum).
Miliband's government will fall in 2016 and the Tories will sweep back into power.
Miliband might become PM but he might refuse SNP support to kill the SNP scare stories in practice and then go for a second election in the autumn like Wilson in 1974.
If Miliband becomes PM, I'd expect him to remain in office until at least Autumn 2016 and probably Spring 2017. It's not in the interests of the other parties to bring him down before then. He has to be seen to fail.0 -
You misunderstand. It's not the lack of Tory leaflets that surprises me (as you say, it's a safe seat, why would they bother), it's that the LDs are bombarding me in comparison, when they have no chance.Flightpath1 said:
Safe tory seat - why should they bombard you with leaflets 4 weeks ago? I got mine a couple of days ago. V safe sear.kle4 said:
It is an odd one. I live in a safe Tory seat and received nothing from them yet, classic taking the seat for granted behaviour (I am sure I will get something in the final week as a token effort), but I've had 4 leaflets from the LDs already even though they were 20 pts behind last time, and so will likely be a lot further behind this time. Either they are targeting their resources poorly, or they have some enthusiastic locals near to my location at least.currystar said:
As an Eastleigh resident i am stunned by the lack of the feeling of an election in this area. I always felt this was the lib dems safest seat, yet I have not received a single piece of election literature from them and neither have my work colleagues who also live in Eastleigh . It's very odd . The Tories seem to be the only ones who are making an effort. I'm very confused.IOS said:Anyway - how many people have voted already - at least 15% of the people that are going to vote I reckon.
Not sure there are many people to shift in the center - just about getting out your core.
Step forward the ground game.
What do leaflets tell you.0 -
Funniest tweet of the night -
Alastair Campbell @campbellclaret · Apr 28
One of the many reasons to want @Ed_Miliband to win is that it will show it can be done in the face of enormous corrupt media bias
0 -
Two thingsScott_P said:@PeteWishart: Important front page in the National tomorrow. This is only going to get bigger. All over for Lab, methinks. https://t.co/t3upVzfxGV
1. Milliband must be very worried about how the SNP issue is playing on the doorstep to keep going on about this.
2. How does he explain getting a queens speech through, with what must be a deal with the SNP.
0 -
PB is such a Tory-dominated place. Look who's been posting tonight: IOS, Roger, tyson, Jonathan, compouter2, FrankBooth, Smarmeron, Dair, surbiton, bigjohnowls, the place is stuffed full of Tories.0
-
I was meeting with a travelling med rep today. In the interest of PB posterwatch I asked whether he had seen any on his travels. He said that he had seen a few in Cheshire but not really anywhere else.currystar said:
Normally a week before an election Eastleigh turns orange with the number of lib dem banners and posters. Not this time.foxinsoxuk said:
Eastleigh was a 3 way split at the by election. Since then then the LD vote has slipped further and I cannot see UKIP doing any where like the same. I think the Cons are value.Pulpstar said:
Amazing. I'm seriously beginning to wonder if Ashcroft Question ONE might be the correct one.currystar said:
As an Eastleigh resident i am stunned by the lack of the feeling of an election in this area. I always felt this was the lib dems safest seat, yet I have not received a single piece of election literature from them and neither have my work colleagues who also live in Eastleigh . It's very odd . The Tories seem to be the only ones who are making an effort. I'm very confused.IOS said:Anyway - how many people have voted already - at least 15% of the people that are going to vote I reckon.
Not sure there are many people to shift in the center - just about getting out your core.
Step forward the ground game.
Keith Vaz now has a fair few up. I alsa saw a Labour minibus heading along the A47 in the direction. I think just passing through Rutland on the way to Peterborough.
I have now had 2 leaflets. 1 Con and 1 LD. Nill from the others with 1 week to go.0 -
If Cameron could then he would have done it already by then just after the election.david_herdson said:
Would it though? There may well be at least the possibility that Cameron might form a government if Labour had kicked their own party out of office on a tactic.Speedy said:
Miliband can orchestrate a loss on a vote of confidence in order to trigger an election, he might even instruct his own party to vote against the government in order to ensure a second election if needed, and he will explain it as such under the Fixed Parliaments Act.david_herdson said:
Which he does how, precisely?Speedy said:
I predict a second election this year.SeanT said:After tonight..... I stand by my prediction.
I believe Miliband will win a tiny tiny plurality and become PM (or PM of a party that is slightly smaller than the Tories (this latter statement is not my original prediction)).
He will need SNP support and this will collapse by Holyrood 2016 under the weight of contradictions (not least the SNP demanding a new referendum).
Miliband's government will fall in 2016 and the Tories will sweep back into power.
Miliband might become PM but he might refuse SNP support to kill the SNP scare stories in practice and then go for a second election in the autumn like Wilson in 1974.
If Miliband becomes PM, I'd expect him to remain in office until at least Autumn 2016 and probably Spring 2017. It's not in the interests of the other parties to bring him down before then. He has to be seen to fail.
This is on the event that Cameron can't form a majority after this election, Miliband becomes PM and then Miliband triggers a second election by forcing a loss in a vote of confidence in order to bypass the Fixed Parliaments Act.0 -
Lots of tax credit recipients (on child tax credit rather than working tax credit) aren't paying any income related tax.FrancisUrquhart said:
Tax Credits...I wish a politician would have the balls to stand up and say, yes we will cut them...rather than us taxing you, you filling in a load of forms and then us giving some of it back to you...tell you what, we will let you keep it in the first place.0 -
LAB posters getting wound up on here!
#losers #labourlol #gobacktoyourkitchensmiliband0 -
asjohnstone said:
The entire campaign process appears to have done nothing. People pick and choose polls based on the results they like, but if we aggregate the numbers we see the bigger picture
In the first 7 days of the campaign we have 16 polls, with a total sample size of 25,425, combined this resulted in Con 33.26%, Lab 33.89%
In the last 7 days we've had 20 polls with a total sample of 30,043, combined this resulted in Con 33.55%, Lab 33.57% (tonight's Yougov will push the labour lead very slightly).
Nothing has changed, there is no huge blue momentum, it's a statistical dead heat. I don't expect this to change over the last 6 days. The tory media have already flung (both) kitchen sinks at Milliband. Hasn't worked.
That's been my view for a long time (since around October). I think the Tories have picked up a couple of points recently, but the overall position remains close to a tie, with fluctuations from poll to poll. Election campaigns very rarely shift opinion decisively.IOS said:Anyway - how many people have voted already - at least 15% of the people that are going to vote I reckon.
Not sure there are many people to shift in the center - just about getting out your core.
Step forward the ground game.
No - the YG policy of drawing on a stable panel has reduced the random fluctuation that you get from sampling from a much larger pool. It would only be wrong if the people in that smaller pool are behaving differently in some way from people politically and demogfraphically similar in the rest of the country.Purseybear said:
Don't hold your breath. They've not given tories a lead for 8 months.Danny565 said:Populus will be the test tomorrow. Even as stable as they usually are, surely there'll be a Tory lead or atleast a tie if there genuinely has been movement this week.
YG static & dead as a floorboard. Can we all agree to bin YG? Regardless of opinions no polling 7 days a week should have this little movement. Somethings badly wrong there.
I do think that the remaining undecideds are coming off the fence, to Lab/Con/won't vote, but not in sufficient numbers to change very much.
0 -
Which one?IOS said:David
You know very well then the Tories aren't taking that seat seriously.0 -
#edhaveyoucheckeditwithsnp0
-
Farage doing well. Getting an easier ride from the audience than the big 3. Several of the questioners seem to be UKIP supporters0