Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

No more polls after tomorrow in the French election – politicalbetting.com

15791011

Comments

  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 44,087
    dixiedean said:

    It is hailstoning hard now. Bitter wind.
    Grim.

    Nice evening sun here
  • OmniumOmnium Posts: 11,467

    You seem unfamiliar with the various meanings of colony and there is no point pursuing this argument further.
    That's fine GW. Do let me know how you get on with the OED.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 53,637
    edited April 2022
    IshmaelZ said:

    "To get there, her campaign has homed in on one central pledge: to put more money in French pockets amid fears of inflation and rising living costs linked to the war in Ukraine." it says here. Substitute English for French and I can relate to that as a rosbif.

    Also, who doesn't hate waiting on railway station platforms?
    "Un homme dans une gare isolée
    Une valise à ses côtés
    Deux yeux fixes et froids
    Montrent de la peur lorsqu'il
    Se tourne pour se cacher"
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    malcolmg said:

    YOU blew it at the end there by adding Gollum as good, that moron could not run a bath.
    I didn’t say he was good, but he can at least find the fucking taps.
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830

    Depends on the (ultimate) destination I guess..
    Chilling but good point

    To lighten the tone let me recomend Barra gin, if you are a gin drinker. Excellent both in dry martinis and with tonic. Whereas I find the Harris stuff distinctly meh.
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    Leon said:

    So fucking tedious

    I’m trying to get inside the minds of 50.3% French people who are apparently willing to vote for Le Pen, on the latest poll

    Do you think more than half the French are Fascists?

    No. Nor do I

    So why are they apparently voting for her?

    The loathe Macron
    They want real change
    They are praying she has detoxed
    They detest the Parisian elite
    They are worried by migration
    They are worried about inflation and security
    They are willing to thrust Ukraine from their minds
    They look at all the other alternatives and despair

    Put it all together and it is extremely similar to Brexit
    So what you are saying is that Brexit and fascism are kindred spirits?

    Interesting.
  • noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 24,254

    What is not clear to me -- and, I suspect, to many others -- is how large the gap is between what Le Pen is saying now, and what she believes.

    That question is routine for politicians. For example, during the Obama administration, I thought I could predict what he would do, by assuming he would govern as far to the left -- as he could get away with. So, for example, he claimed he was opposed to gay marriage for religious reasons while that was the predominant view in the electorate. (He actually followed Biden's lead on the subject.)

    Were she elected, would she do something similar, getting as close to actual fascism as she could get away with? Would she, for example, weaken NATO, but not withdraw from it?

    Would she have working majorities in the National Assembly and the Senate?

    Given her political journey so far, is the opposite move towards the mainstream just as likely?
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,936
    Putin seems to have miraculously brought agreement between Pakistan and India.
    In abstaining.
  • boulayboulay Posts: 6,154

    Why the difference in jab combinations?
    Having been pulled up on it I’ve checked about some other female acquaintances- it seems all women in a rough age bracket here were given Px3 after a certain date.

    I have been told of two more women who had Az Pfizer combo who had a bad time but they both also had their jabs early in the process.

    As I said - it’s not scientific but I found it interesting that it was such a strong split although a very small sample.
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,661
    If Le Pen wins, would that increase the chance of a Socialist victory next time round?

    Hopefully we don't get the chance to find out.
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 35,295
    boulay said:

    I can announce the results of my very scientific study of covid amongst my friendship group (ok not really very scientific).

    I surveyed 19 of my circle of friends who have had covid since December as everyone had three jabs by then.

    9 men (aged between 40 and 55) all had AZ/AZ/Pf and all had grim symptoms of various kinds.

    9 women (aged between 36 and 53) all had P/P/P and none had symptoms more than a light cold.

    1 woman aged 38 had A/A/P and has evil symptoms.

    None have any particular underlying conditions of note.

    Now it could be fluke or coincidence or a different effect by sex (and the one woman with A/A/P was just a strange situation) but I thought it was interesting anyway.

    And there was I, patting myself on the back for having had AZ/AZ/Pf.

    Thanks!
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    boulay said:

    Having been pulled up on it I’ve checked about some other female acquaintances- it seems all women in a rough age bracket here were given Px3 after a certain date.

    I have been told of two more women who had Az Pfizer combo who had a bad time but they both also had their jabs early in the process.

    As I said - it’s not scientific but I found it interesting that it was such a strong split although a very small sample.
    Where's here?
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 35,295
    Dipped into PB for a few minutes and what do I find? ...@Leon wants to vote for Le Pen.

    Shocked I am, truly shocked! Never saw that coming, no not at all.
  • OmniumOmnium Posts: 11,467

    And there was I, patting myself on the back for having had AZ/AZ/Pf.

    Thanks!
    I'm Pfizer*3 - male, 58, central-ish London. (Two of the jabs were at Lord's - I rather liked that)
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,745
    boulay said:

    Having been pulled up on it I’ve checked about some other female acquaintances- it seems all women in a rough age bracket here were given Px3 after a certain date.

    I have been told of two more women who had Az Pfizer combo who had a bad time but they both also had their jabs early in the process.

    As I said - it’s not scientific but I found it interesting that it was such a strong split although a very small sample.
    My stepmother has just had covid. She’s a cancer survivor - barely - and severely immunocompromised. So we all thought “eeek”

    But it was like a mild flu and she has now tested negative 🤷‍♂️

    Triple jabbed of course
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,661
    HYUFD said:

    Personally I would vote for Pecresse and if she failed to make the runoff, as is likely, Macron over Le Pen or Melenchon.

    Though yes Le Pen is benefiting from much the same nationalist backlash against globalisation that produced Brexit, Trump and Orban. While Melenchon is getting the same populist left backing against inequality Corbyn got
    And what if there was a Plaid Cymru candidate on the ballot?
  • RogerRoger Posts: 20,442
    OT. I gave Labour £100 a few months ago in the hope it would encourage them to get an agency who would give them some guidance and direction. What I got were a lot of emails from Owen Jones this being the latest.

    roger, even for the Tory Party, this hypocrisy is breath-taking.

    Rishi Sunak has put your family’s taxes up 15 times.

    But does his family pay less?


    Independent Headline


    "Rishi Sunak needs to come clean on his and his family's tax affairs".

    Just yesterday, he clobbered nearly every single working person in the country with another damaging tax rise.

    This is at a time when energy bills are through the roof, prices are soaring and wages are through the floor.

    The reality couldn’t be clearer: the Tories think it’s one rule for them and another for the rest of us.

    roger, don't let them get away with it.............

    In my opinion they're going for the wrong target. HIS donation to an elite public school was a story with legs. It told you about his priorities and everything that is dislikable about the philosophy of senior Tories and their party.

    That he married a rich feckless tax avoider (if that's what she is) just makes the fair minded feel sorry for him
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203

    Dipped into PB for a few minutes and what do I find? ...@Leon wants to vote for Le Pen.

    Shocked I am, truly shocked! Never saw that coming, no not at all.

    I love how, in his thought experiment, he wrote off Hidalgo as a “failed mayor”.

    Admittedly her campaign for president was a complete non-starter, but she’s been a very successful mayor.
  • RattersRatters Posts: 1,297
    Le Pen winning would be truly depressing. Like an Orban winning power at the heart of Europe, just across the channel from us.

    And the trouble with fascist-sympathisers winning power is that they tend to do all they can to not let it go.
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 44,617

    And what if there was a Plaid Cymru candidate on the ballot?
    Don't you mean Strollad Breizh/Parti Breton?
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,745

    So what you are saying is that Brexit and fascism are kindred spirits?

    Interesting.
    I don’t believe Le Pen is a fascist. Not judging by her policies and statements in the last decade.

    Could she be a secret fascist? Yes. But you could make such claims - he secretly believes this! - of many politicians

    She’s an ethnocentric populist nationalist. A left wing Farage perhaps, although british and French traditions are so different maybe there is no good comparison
  • TimTTimT Posts: 6,468
    My contribution to the gender conversation:

    https://parentinfluence.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/1-43.jpg
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    People who claim a Le Pen win would be no great shakes, are wrong.

    It would send destabilise the EU, NATO, and the fragile alliance against Putin that Boris, to his credit, has actually had a leading role in bringing about.
  • WhisperingOracleWhisperingOracle Posts: 9,938
    edited April 2022
    Curious goings-on in the war today, A sad-faced Peskov talking about "significant Russian losses", and that he's very "sorry that Russia has been thrown of the Human Rights Council", and Lukashenko simultaneously apparently making his discontent clear, both by trying to insert himself into any negotiation, and talking about "the countries, mainly the West, trying to rope us into continuation of this war."
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,745

    Dipped into PB for a few minutes and what do I find? ...@Leon wants to vote for Le Pen.

    Shocked I am, truly shocked! Never saw that coming, no not at all.

    *weary sigh*

    No, I didn’t. I played a thought experiment to find a circumstance where it might be possible to vote for her.

    You have to remove Macron. Who for all his faults is a much stronger more reliable candidate

    You also have to remove Putin’s invasion of Ukraine. Right now anything that helps Putin cannot be tolerated

    You have nonetheless to keep the rest of the line up of political dwarves, cranks and weirdos - from Mélenchon to Zemmour

    Then she becomes a possibility

    But you do you
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 18,624
    kle4 said:

    A solution looking for a problem perhaps.
    What counts as not in play? The time from a ball going out to the throw coming in? That’s normally not added on. Stoppages for injuries are.
    Seems wrong. I’d love to know what the current stats are by the definition they are using.
  • TimTTimT Posts: 6,468

    That's true. Röpcke has generally had good sources though so I assume it's reliable information.

    Incidentally, one interesting thing that's become clear from following the debate in Germany is that hawkishness on Russia was considered a 'low status' opinion, associated with people who read the Bild Zeitung. That helps explain why so many people were able to rationalise away the obvious issues with their Ostpolitik.
    Naive sophistication is the term I learned the other day ...
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,745

    I love how, in his thought experiment, he wrote off Hidalgo as a “failed mayor”.

    Admittedly her campaign for president was a complete non-starter, but she’s been a very successful mayor.
    She’s trashed the city and she’s polling at 1% for president. Lol
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830

    So what you are saying is that Brexit and fascism are kindred spirits?

    Interesting.
    Um, he is saying they are not.

    Interesting.
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    Leon said:

    I don’t believe Le Pen is a fascist. Not judging by her policies and statements in the last decade.

    Could she be a secret fascist? Yes. But you could make such claims - he secretly believes this! - of many politicians

    She’s an ethnocentric populist nationalist. A left wing Farage perhaps, although british and French traditions are so different maybe there is no good comparison
    One of the things I can’t get my head around is that while Brexit is the preserve of the old and middle-aged, Le Penisme (fascist or no) is more of a youth movement.

    So while the two phenoms look so similar on the surface, I wonder if they are motivated by quite different things, albeit appealing against the same time-honoured folk devils.
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 34,295

    If Le Pen wins, would that increase the chance of a Socialist victory next time round?

    Hopefully we don't get the chance to find out.

    There's also the parliamentary election in June where Le Pen's party is unlikely to do well.
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    Ratters said:

    Le Pen winning would be truly depressing. Like an Orban winning power at the heart of Europe, just across the channel from us.

    And the trouble with fascist-sympathisers winning power is that they tend to do all they can to not let it go.

    Whereas, what, politicians of any other persuasion are notably chilled as to whether they stay in office or don't?
  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 43,320
    IshmaelZ said:

    Chilling but good point

    To lighten the tone let me recomend Barra gin, if you are a gin drinker. Excellent both in dry martinis and with tonic. Whereas I find the Harris stuff distinctly meh.
    Gone off gin a bit recently, maybe warmer weather will reignite my thirst. The Harris stuff was ok but the bottle was the real bit of marketing genius. I'll give the Barra stuff a try next time I buy a bottle.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,370

    Macron has a bit of technocratic polish, but is he really less inept than Johnson? He has a litany of failures on his record, particularly on foreign policy. His handling of covid wasn't any more impressive and arguably nothing was more malign than deliberately trashing the AstraZeneca vaccine.
    Unlike his predecessors, Macron has actually managed to make it easier for French firms to let workers go, and began increasing the age of retirement for civil servants.

    He has not managed to get a grip on France's ridiculous "social charges" that make hiring people on lower incomes prohibitively expensive.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 54,539

    Gone off gin a bit recently, maybe warmer weather will reignite my thirst. The Harris stuff was ok but the bottle was the real bit of marketing genius. I'll give the Barra stuff a try next time I buy a bottle.
    For a treat, try it on Barra....
  • noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 24,254

    What counts as not in play? The time from a ball going out to the throw coming in? That’s normally not added on. Stoppages for injuries are.
    Seems wrong. I’d love to know what the current stats are by the definition they are using.
    Ball in play is literally just that. It is different to injury time.

    Varies from about 40 mins to 70 mins per match.
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 18,624
    dixiedean said:

    It is hailstoning hard now. Bitter wind.
    Grim.

    Had the unusual experience of being hailed on inside this afternoon. Roof above our building not well sealed (it’s glass) and hail stones came in as I was talking in the corridor...
  • IshmaelZ said:

    Whereas, what, politicians of any other persuasion are notably chilled as to whether they stay in office or don't?
    Tim Farron.
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    Leon said:

    She’s trashed the city and she’s polling at 1% for president. Lol
    Trashed the city?

    She’s made the “15-minute city” concept globally famous. Paris is considered the world leader for urban innovation, in a way Boris the biker only dreamt of.

    She may be woke, I don’t know, but she’s won twice, already, even if Paris mayor (which has a lot more power than London mayor) is the summit of her achievement.
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 18,624
    IshmaelZ said:

    This sounds a bit like that coin tossing game at the beginning of R & G Are Dead. If vaccines are not gender-segregated how on earth does it happen that you know 9 blokes who all got one set of stuff and 9 women who got another?
    The blood clots issue. Rules changed.
  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 43,320

    For a treat, try it on Barra....
    Would like to but my annual Hebridean trip buddies have all fallen out, so that's a 20 year tradition assaulted by Covid and finally killed off :( Will have to try stuff on my own initiative, so maybe Barra this year.
  • CookieCookie Posts: 14,798
    Leon said:

    Here’s an interesting thought experiment. Take away Macron, who would you vote for, of the leading candidates

    For me, it probably would be Le Pen

    Melenchon is Corbyn: no way
    Pecresse seems totally feeble
    Zemmour is almost a Nazi, and mad
    Hidalgo is a woke joke and terrible mayor of Paris

    Who is going to stand up for France, is also sane, and a patriot, and would make an interesting change?

    Hold your nose: Le Pen? And pray she really has detoxed


    So @noneoftheabove makes a valid point, in a sense. There are circs where she gets support


    Edit to add: this is a mind game where Putin has NOT invaded Ukraine
    Pecresse, I suppose. With absolutely no enthusiasm.
    Le Pen has, to my mind, absolutely nothing going for her.
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 18,624
    IshmaelZ said:

    This sounds a bit like that coin tossing game at the beginning of R & G Are Dead. If vaccines are not gender-segregated how on earth does it happen that you know 9 blokes who all got one set of stuff and 9 women who got another?
    The blood clots issue. Rules changed.
  • RogerRoger Posts: 20,442

    I think that is fair; a French President most remembered for having the pipework on the outside!

    We may have some shite politicians here but at least none has been reduced to house arrest with an ankle bracelet.

    Yet.
    You're not suggesting with a straight face any can compete with Johnson when it comes to being unfit for office?
  • OmniumOmnium Posts: 11,467

    Trashed the city?

    She’s made the “15-minute city” concept globally famous. Paris is considered the world leader for urban innovation, in a way Boris the biker only dreamt of.

    She may be woke, I don’t know, but she’s won twice, already, even if Paris mayor (which has a lot more power than London mayor) is the summit of her achievement.
    Paris is a pain as regards transport in my one recent visit. (Admittedly there was some sort of a strike on one day of the three I was there)

    London is better.
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    Omnium said:

    Paris is a pain as regards transport in my one recent visit. (Admittedly there was some sort of a strike on one day of the three I was there)

    London is better.
    Do tell.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,745

    Trashed the city?

    She’s made the “15-minute city” concept globally famous. Paris is considered the world leader for urban innovation, in a way Boris the biker only dreamt of.

    She may be woke, I don’t know, but she’s won twice, already, even if Paris mayor (which has a lot more power than London mayor) is the summit of her achievement.
    Yes. Of course


    “It’s a rubbish bin’: Parisians fight for the soul of their blighted city”

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/feb/05/sacre-bleu-has-beautiful-paris-now-turned-into-the-city-of-blight

    February 2022

    Meanwhile she’s such a good mayor, even Parisians won’t vote for her as president, as she’s done such a great job? It’s quite hard to get just 1% of the polls if you govern the capital city of many millions

    This 1% also means any French person who has been to Paris in the last few years has looked at it and thought: Pas Hidalgo
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 54,539
    edited April 2022

    Would like to but my annual Hebridean trip buddies have all fallen out, so that's a 20 year tradition assaulted by Covid and finally killed off :( Will have to try stuff on my own initiative, so maybe Barra this year.
    Sad to hear. My biennial trip to Barra got canned last year when my trip buddy's father had a stroke. Hoping we can resurrect it (if not him) next year.
  • WhisperingOracleWhisperingOracle Posts: 9,938
    edited April 2022
    According to this, and some other posters I've seen, Le Pen would want to withdraw France from at least some, or all the structures of NATO.

    https://twitter.com/KaiKochmann/status/1511625880073822221

    If Trump got back in at the same time, things could get "interesting".
  • OmniumOmnium Posts: 11,467

    Do tell.
    Well in London you generally get where you want to relatively swiftly and other than some time in the morning you'll not be a sardine.

    In Paris the metro was often over-crowded, and quite slow - just a function of the density of stations. It really shows its age.

    25 years ago it would have been the reverse. Back then the tube was pretty awful, and the metro pretty great.
  • MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 39,817

    Trashed the city?

    She’s made the “15-minute city” concept globally famous. Paris is considered the world leader for urban innovation, in a way Boris the biker only dreamt of.

    She may be woke, I don’t know, but she’s won twice, already, even if Paris mayor (which has a lot more power than London mayor) is the summit of her achievement.
    By that measure Sadiq Khan is a world beater which we know not to be the case.
  • TimTTimT Posts: 6,468
    Getting my second booster later today. 3x Pfizer, now a Moderna for #4
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,745

    According to this, and some other posters I've seen, Le Pen would want to withdraw France from at least some, or all the structures of NATO.

    https://twitter.com/KaiKochmann/status/1511625880073822221

    If Trump got back in at the same time, things could get "interesting"..

    i think several of the candidates have quite anti-NATO positions. It’s not a unique “Le Pen” thing

    Anti NATOism (a proxy for French detestation of Anglo Saxon hegemony) is a big tradition in France; De Gaulle did it too
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    edited April 2022
    MaxPB said:

    By that measure Sadiq Khan is a world beater which we know not to be the case.
    I don’t recall Khan making anything famous, nor positioning London as the world leader in anything.

    Tho he’s slightly gone up in my estimates since Dick fell on her sword.
  • WhisperingOracleWhisperingOracle Posts: 9,938
    edited April 2022
    Leon said:

    i think several of the candidates have quite anti-NATO positions. It’s not a unique “Le Pen” thing

    Anti NATOism (a proxy for French detestation of Anglo Saxon hegemony) is a big tradition in France; De Gaulle did it too
    A bit different in April 2022, and when you have a specific backstory of advocating for Putin, though.

    Anti-NATOism is traditional on the Portugese, Italian and Greek left, too, for instance - except that their main parties are actually currently supporting the NATO sanctions and action.
  • CookieCookie Posts: 14,798
    Omnium said:

    Paris is a pain as regards transport in my one recent visit. (Admittedly there was some sort of a strike on one day of the three I was there)

    London is better.
    I haven't been to Paris for 20 years, so my views may be out of date. But I thought the metro was shit.
    1) It didn't go anywhere directly. Each line meanders all over the place. From a transport planning point of view, not great.
    2) Full of nutters and flashers and other neer-do-wells.
    3) most of the trains ran on rubber tyres. What's that all about?
    4) dirty and unkempt. Made London look like Singapore.
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    Omnium said:

    Well in London you generally get where you want to relatively swiftly and other than some time in the morning you'll not be a sardine.

    In Paris the metro was often over-crowded, and quite slow - just a function of the density of stations. It really shows its age.

    25 years ago it would have been the reverse. Back then the tube was pretty awful, and the metro pretty great.
    I think the last time I was in Paris was late 2018, a while ago. What I do know is there’s been quite significant expansion into the suburbs as part of the Grand Paris Express project - twice as large as Crossrail.
  • CookieCookie Posts: 14,798
    Cookie said:

    Pecresse, I suppose. With absolutely no enthusiasm.
    Le Pen has, to my mind, absolutely nothing going for her.
    Thinking about this again, with regards Macton, never has 'best if a bad lot' been more appropriate. What an absolute shower of jokers is lined up against him.

    The advantage of Le Pen, I suppose, is that some people with whom I tend to disagree dislike her. This is a seductive but ridiculous trap to fall into however.
    If I was to find something positive to say about Le Pen is that she does at least recognise some of the problems facing France which Macron appears not to. But I don't agree with her solutions to them.
  • RattersRatters Posts: 1,297
    IshmaelZ said:

    Whereas, what, politicians of any other persuasion are notably chilled as to whether they stay in office or don't?
    They are much less likely to rig the rules of the game in their favour until what is left can no longer be called a democracy.

    Putin. Orban. Trump. Le Pen. They're all dangers to democracy at home and abroad, and we should treat them as such regardless of how far down the path they have trodden.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,745
    One aspect of the French elex we are ignoring is Islam/Islamism

    The French are much more agitated about it than we are, because of the Bataclan, Charlie Hebdo, and Nice attacks, plus the murder of the teacher (even if the UK has suffered plentiful atrocities as well). France also has the largest Muslim population in the West

    Le Pen is seen as tougher on all this than Macron, even tho, ironically, Macron has triangulated so hard to the right he now *appears* harsher than her

    If you are worried by Islamism in France, she is perhaps the obvious choice.

    Doesn’t explain why she is popular with the young however. Tho the NYTimes did a good article showing how the Right in France was now expert at social media - better than the Left
  • OmniumOmnium Posts: 11,467

    I think the last time I was in Paris was late 2018, a while ago. What I do know is there’s been quite significant expansion into the suburbs as part of the Grand Paris Express project - twice as large as Crossrail.
    Well let's hope it's better than Crossrail. Not doubting you for a moment but Crossrail claims to be the biggest engineering project in the universe or some such. The slowest certainly.
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    Cookie said:

    I haven't been to Paris for 20 years, so my views may be out of date. But I thought the metro was shit.
    1) It didn't go anywhere directly. Each line meanders all over the place. From a transport planning point of view, not great.
    2) Full of nutters and flashers and other neer-do-wells.
    3) most of the trains ran on rubber tyres. What's that all about?
    4) dirty and unkempt. Made London look like Singapore.
    I love the metro.

    You can hop and skip down to the platforms very easily, because it’s so close to the surface, and the “meandering” nature you bemoan actually means you get to all sorts of places quite quickly rather than just east west or north south.

    It’s no more dirty than London, station for station (compare with the New York subway, which is effectively a sewer with a mass transit built into it).

    As for the nutters and flashers and ne’er-do-wells —- this is Paris, ffs.
  • OmniumOmnium Posts: 11,467

    I love the metro.

    You can hop and skip down to the platforms very easily, because it’s so close to the surface, and the “meandering” nature you bemoan actually means you get to all sorts of places quite quickly rather than just east west or north south.

    It’s no more dirty than London, station for station (compare with the New York subway, which is effectively a sewer with a mass transit built into it).

    As for the nutters and flashers and ne’er-do-wells —- this is Paris, ffs.
    GW, I've no idea what it was like in 2018, but it's very run down now - at least in the central stops.
  • WhisperingOracleWhisperingOracle Posts: 9,938
    edited April 2022
    Leon said:

    One aspect of the French elex we are ignoring is Islam/Islamism

    The French are much more agitated about it than we are, because of the Bataclan, Charlie Hebdo, and Nice attacks, plus the murder of the teacher (even if the UK has suffered plentiful atrocities as well). France also has the largest Muslim population in the West

    Le Pen is seen as tougher on all this than Macron, even tho, ironically, Macron has triangulated so hard to the right he now *appears* harsher than her

    If you are worried by Islamism in France, she is perhaps the obvious choice.

    Doesn’t explain why she is popular with the young however. Tho the NYTimes did a good article showing how the Right in France was now expert at social media - better than the Left

    Now what does that remind you of..

    I agree that there are very specific huge social problems in France. Very avowed state secularism and the largest, often socially disenfranchised-feeling Muslim population in Europe are not a good mix.

    LePen will only rub salt in the wounds and make it all worse, though.
  • CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,651
    More reports from Ukraine of people - this time doctors and patients - being "deported" to Russia.

    Given what we have learnt about Russian treatment of Ukrainian civilians, "deported" is, to me, starting to sound like the Germans talking about "resettlement" of Jews.
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 44,617

    I love the metro.

    You can hop and skip down to the platforms very easily, because it’s so close to the surface, and the “meandering” nature you bemoan actually means you get to all sorts of places quite quickly rather than just east west or north south.

    It’s no more dirty than London, station for station (compare with the New York subway, which is effectively a sewer with a mass transit built into it).

    As for the nutters and flashers and ne’er-do-wells —- this is Paris, ffs.
    AIUI the rubber tyres were to reduce vibration impact, espl. with it so close to the surface.
  • RogerRoger Posts: 20,442
    Cookie said:

    I haven't been to Paris for 20 years, so my views may be out of date. But I thought the metro was shit.
    1) It didn't go anywhere directly. Each line meanders all over the place. From a transport planning point of view, not great.
    2) Full of nutters and flashers and other neer-do-wells.
    3) most of the trains ran on rubber tyres. What's that all about?
    4) dirty and unkempt. Made London look like Singapore.
    It is odd that there is so much wrong with France yet they manage to attract the most visitors in the world by quite a considerable distance.

    https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=world+tourism+rankings
  • MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 39,817

    I think the last time I was in Paris was late 2018, a while ago. What I do know is there’s been quite significant expansion into the suburbs as part of the Grand Paris Express project - twice as large as Crossrail.
    And yet most Parisian suburbs are a mixture of hellholes and shitholes.

    I have no idea why you seem to like Paris, it's a dump with not very good food. France has got so much to offer, Paris isn't even close to the top of their list.
  • SeaShantyIrish2SeaShantyIrish2 Posts: 17,559
    Cookie said:

    I can think of exactly one poster who might describe himself as keen on authoritarianism/nationalism/protectionism - and even he might express some reservations about Le Pen.
    Many of us think Macron's a dick. Possibly even relish his discomfort a little. That absolutely doesn't equate to wanting Le Pen to win.
    Personally think there is a section of French electorate that wants to send Macron & establishment a message, by voting for Le Pen in 1st round, but plans to switch to Marcon in 2nd round.

    Which is rather different from previous voter psychology, methinks, when may voters (including some of the above) were afraid/leery of voting for Le Pen at all.

    Partly the change reflects softening of her image & message, but think mostly because of increased anti-establishment public opinion, even among folks who are generally pro-establishmentarians.

    That's my theory, anyway, and sticking to it for now.

    BTW, I have used the same logic with my own vote in past primaries, particularly when it seemed certain that what you might call my ultimate choice would make the general election ballot.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 54,189
    Ratters said:

    They are much less likely to rig the rules of the game in their favour until what is left can no longer be called a democracy.

    Putin. Orban. Trump. Le Pen. They're all dangers to democracy at home and abroad, and we should treat them as such regardless of how far down the path they have trodden.
    Le Pen is more like the Jörg Haider, I think, than a Trump. A threat from inside the system - she would seek to create a world where FascistLite French Presidents are... normal.
  • SeaShantyIrish2SeaShantyIrish2 Posts: 17,559
    edited April 2022
    US Senate just confirmed KBJ 53 to 47
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    MaxPB said:

    And yet most Parisian suburbs are a mixture of hellholes and shitholes.

    I have no idea why you seem to like Paris, it's a dump with not very good food. France has got so much to offer, Paris isn't even close to the top of their list.
    Yes, Paris is known far and wide as a “dump with not very good food”.

    Do you think you might be over-egging the omelette?
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,745
    Cookie said:

    I haven't been to Paris for 20 years, so my views may be out of date. But I thought the metro was shit.
    1) It didn't go anywhere directly. Each line meanders all over the place. From a transport planning point of view, not great.
    2) Full of nutters and flashers and other neer-do-wells.
    3) most of the trains ran on rubber tyres. What's that all about?
    4) dirty and unkempt. Made London look like Singapore.
    If you want to see public transport horror, look at recent videos of the Los Angeles metro


    https://twitter.com/jennygshao/status/1511435186239541248?s=21&t=XAFNmqc3-W-QXzdojEwIDQ

    https://twitter.com/streetpeoplela/status/1509302063125082113?s=21&t=XAFNmqc3-W-QXzdojEwIDQ

    Incroyable
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    Roger said:

    It is odd that there is so much wrong with France yet they manage to attract the most visitors in the world by quite a considerable distance.

    https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=world+tourism+rankings
    Presumably all the Brexiters are too busy holidaying in Cleethorpes to worry about “dumps with not very good food”.

    That’s fine. I’ve no urgent need to share Paris (or France) with the sort of people who complain about “shit-ache” mushrooms.
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 44,617

    Presumably all the Brexiters are too busy holidaying in Cleethorpes to worry about “dumps with not very good food”.

    That’s fine. I’ve no urgent need to share Paris (or France) with the sort of people who complain about “shit-ache” mushrooms.
    HYUFD was quite lyrical on PB recently about the potential for holidays in places such as Skegness post_Brexit, interestingly. (Though I am rather fond of Whitby and Scarborough myself.)
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    Leon said:

    If you want to see public transport horror, look at recent videos of the Los Angeles metro


    https://twitter.com/jennygshao/status/1511435186239541248?s=21&t=XAFNmqc3-W-QXzdojEwIDQ

    https://twitter.com/streetpeoplela/status/1509302063125082113?s=21&t=XAFNmqc3-W-QXzdojEwIDQ

    Incroyable
    Looks like New York, but cleaner.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,745
    MaxPB said:

    And yet most Parisian suburbs are a mixture of hellholes and shitholes.

    I have no idea why you seem to like Paris, it's a dump with not very good food. France has got so much to offer, Paris isn't even close to the top of their list.
    I love a bit of frog-bashing, but this is absurd. Paris is a magnificent city, going through some social problems - not unlike London

    I prefer London as it is more interesting and exhilarating (and probably has better food, now), but Paris is still uniquely glorious at its best
  • darkagedarkage Posts: 5,398
    edited April 2022
    I don't share the fear about Le Pen winning.
    If it happens, it would be the outcome of a democratic process - as was the election of Donald Trump in 2016, and as was Brexit.
    The real problem is that there is an attempt to cast lots of popular political movements as being toxic, extreme, barbaric - indicative of a descent into fascism and a new dark age.
    But these movements often represent the views of something like 50% of the population, who have the same fears about the direction of society under supposedly liberal, enlightened governments.
    Until such point as both sides can coexist and work with each other, we are in deep trouble, and will never get out of the self destructive polarisation.
    Whilst we are obviously not voting in the French election, both my wife and I were pretty impressed by Zemmour - we could see exactly why educated people would vote for him or Le Pen.
    I would probably vote for Macron if I had to choose, but it would be mainly because of the links between Le Pen/Zemmour and Putin, which are in my view intolerable, given what has gone on in Ukraine.
  • MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 39,817

    Yes, Paris is known far and wide as a “dump with not very good food”.

    Do you think you might be over-egging the omelette?
    The perception and reality are somewhat disconnected, but they are aligning. Its reputation has been sliding for years and there's no sign of improvement.
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    Carnyx said:

    HYUFD was quite lyrical on PB recently about the potential for holidays in places such as Skegness post_Brexit, interestingly. (Though I am rather fond of Whitby and Scarborough myself.)
    Well Max was pointing out the other day that the UK’s tourism receipts have collapsed, so Skegness needs you more than ever.
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,661

    US Senate just confirmed KBJ 53 to 47

    King Boris Johnson? Didn't see that coming!
  • SeaShantyIrish2SeaShantyIrish2 Posts: 17,559
    Politico.com - Local conservatives revolt against Trump House favorite
    The former president endorsed a 26-year-old who lives hours away from the congressional district he's running in.

    https://www.politico.com/news/2022/04/07/north-carolina-house-donald-trump-00023643

    . . . Through newspaper advertisements, email blasts and door-knocking, some local Republicans are trying to spread the word that Hines, Trump’s favored candidate in the 13th Congressional District, is a carpetbagger. In their view, the former president was misguided in endorsing Hines over homegrown conservatives invested in local party politics.

    The revolt against Trump by conservatives who adore him, while rare, isn’t the first of its kind this year. Trump has issued scores of midterm endorsements, in some cases for candidates who are all but unknown to local GOP officials and activists.

    “It feels like it’s incumbent on us to make sure everybody understands that Bo Hines may be a fine fellow — I don’t know him — but the truth of it is he’s not a resident of the district,” said Linwood Parker, chair of the Johnston County Republican Men’s Organization and former mayor of Four Oaks. “He’s coming in, just trying to cherry pick a district he can win.” . . .

    The conservative men’s group, which formed last fall and meets in an outbuilding behind a Four Oaks gas station on the second Saturday of the month, is not endorsing any particular candidate in the race. Parker cited three other Republicans on the primary ballot who are from the district, who he believes would better represent voters’ interests.

    Trump is set to appear in the eastern North Carolina county this weekend to rally on behalf of Hines and two other endorsed candidates ahead of the state’s May 17 primary. For Senate, Trump’s support is behind Rep. Ted Budd, who struggled in recent months to take the lead over former Gov. Pat McCrory, but has turned a corner as outside spending has skyrocketed in his favor. Also booked for the rally is Rep. Madison Cawthorn, the freshman congressman from the western part of the state who has angered top House Republicans after talking about orgies and cocaine. . . .

    Who wants to be, that 45's carpetbagging pride & joy is also a Putinist giving aid & comfort NOT to Ukraine?



  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    Leon said:

    If you want to see public transport horror, look at recent videos of the Los Angeles metro


    https://twitter.com/jennygshao/status/1511435186239541248?s=21&t=XAFNmqc3-W-QXzdojEwIDQ

    https://twitter.com/streetpeoplela/status/1509302063125082113?s=21&t=XAFNmqc3-W-QXzdojEwIDQ

    Incroyable
    Why would you smoke fentanyl? It's bloody cracking IV.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 54,539
    Roger said:

    You're not suggesting with a straight face any can compete with Johnson when it comes to being unfit for office?
    Well, Mitterand then Chirac then Sarkozy takes some beating anywhere on the planet for a run of corrupt top men.
  • CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,651
    Endillion said:

    That's my point. If you believe that, it's incompatible with the idea that Sunak is somehow responsible for his spouse's financial affairs. What's he supposed to do, order her to change her status? Beat her if she refuses?
    Isn't the issue here that she has a choice every year whether or not to have her income, wherever it comes from, taxed in the U.K. or only on a remittance basis? She is actively choosing the latter and her husband knows this, I assume, and is benefiting from the fact that his family's wealth is therefore larger than it would otherwise have been.

    If Sunak did not have such a tin ear for how people feel at the moment about inflation, rising taxes, increasing bills etc, this might have less traction.
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 44,617

    Well Max was pointing out the other day that the UK’s tourism receipts have collapsed, so Skegness needs you more than ever.
    Not sure that it was a major destination for, say, the average Parisian or Chinese visitor (as opposed, in the case of the latter, to Banbury shopping village - quite an eye opener to be on a Sunday morning train from Maryelobone to Oxford a few years back along the Princes Risborough line btw). So not sure how Skegness is doing even worse than it was.
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 18,624

    Presumably all the Brexiters are too busy holidaying in Cleethorpes to worry about “dumps with not very good food”.

    That’s fine. I’ve no urgent need to share Paris (or France) with the sort of people who complain about “shit-ache” mushrooms.
    Really? You’re taking a joke from a sketch show as a reality for Brexit voters?
  • MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 39,817
    Leon said:

    I love a bit of frog-bashing, but this is absurd. Paris is a magnificent city, going through some social problems - not unlike London

    I prefer London as it is more interesting and exhilarating (and probably has better food, now), but Paris is still uniquely glorious at its best
    But that's the problem it hasn't been at its best for ages. It's like San Francisco, a reputation that it no longer deserves and slowly the reality is catching up. Paris is smelly, dirty and everyone contends with petty crime, and it gets much worse as soon as you're out of the centre.

    Head out to the suburbs of London and it's still safe, boring, but safe. The same can't be said for Paris.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 59,745

    Looks like New York, but cleaner.
    Is NYC that bad??

    Christ

    There’s one image from this week of a naked guy lying dead - apparently - of an OD in a LA Metro train. Americans just don’t DO public transport

    I remember once trying to persuade a rich American that the best way from Heathrow to central London was via a public train. 15 minutes. Then jump in a cab, be in Claridge’s in another 15 minutes?

    He just couldn’t get his head around it, and insisted on taking a black cab from LHR all the way, which probably took three times as long as cost twice as much, excluding tip
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 127,013
    Carnyx said:

    HYUFD was quite lyrical on PB recently about the potential for holidays in places such as Skegness post_Brexit, interestingly. (Though I am rather fond of Whitby and Scarborough myself.)
    Given prices of flights and foreign holidays at the moment and squeezed savings due to cost of living, British seaside holiday resorts could see a bumper year this summer
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    MaxPB said:

    The perception and reality are somewhat disconnected, but they are aligning. Its reputation has been sliding for years and there's no sign of improvement.
    My main issue with Paris is that it’s become globally gentrified in the twenty years since I’ve known it, and the centre is ever more a kind of cleaned-up disneyfied ghetto for the very rich.

    That’s true of a lot of places, though.

    I dunno if Paris’s reputation has been sliding. I think it lost ground against London for many years as the “place to be” in Europe, but like I said the stuff Hidalgo has been pioneering is considered a testing ground for urban innovation.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 53,637
    Roger said:

    It is odd that there is so much wrong with France yet they manage to attract the most visitors in the world by quite a considerable distance.

    https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=world+tourism+rankings
    Same thing with McDonald's at Westfield food court :lol:

    Shite food but the longest queues!
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 127,013

    Well Max was pointing out the other day that the UK’s tourism receipts have collapsed, so Skegness needs you more than ever.
    Foreigners coming to London may have declined post Brexit but British people holidaying at home has increased post Covid
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203

    Really? You’re taking a joke from a sketch show as a reality for Brexit voters?
    I’m glad you got the reference.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 127,013
    edited April 2022
    Leon said:

    i think several of the candidates have quite anti-NATO positions. It’s not a unique “Le Pen” thing

    Anti NATOism (a proxy for French detestation of Anglo Saxon hegemony) is a big tradition in France; De Gaulle did it too
    Indeed, Melenchon and Zemmour are even more anti NATO than Le Pen
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 18,624

    I’m glad you got the reference.
    I did and it’s absurd.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 54,819

    I dunno if Paris’s reputation has been sliding. I think it lost ground against London for many years as the “place to be” in Europe, but like I said the stuff Hidalgo has been pioneering is considered a testing ground for urban innovation.

    If only the French presidency were determined by the urban innovation community it sounds like she would walk it (or e-scooter it).
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 44,617
    Cyclefree said:

    Isn't the issue here that she has a choice every year whether or not to have her income, wherever it comes from, taxed in the U.K. or only on a remittance basis? She is actively choosing the latter and her husband knows this, I assume, and is benefiting from the fact that his family's wealth is therefore larger than it would otherwise have been.

    If Sunak did not have such a tin ear for how people feel at the moment about inflation, rising taxes, increasing bills etc, this might have less traction.
    Perhaps as much to the point, it is made possible by the powers to be to have the non-dom setup at all to pamper people who are living in the UK more than half the time.

    Moreover, was it not the Conservative Party who brought in the current modification of the system a few years back?

    Neither of which is good optics in the current climate.
  • OmniumOmnium Posts: 11,467

    Same thing with McDonald's at Westfield food court :lol:

    Shite food but the longest queues!
    McDonald's food really isn't that bad. It's never been bad.
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,203
    Leon said:

    Is NYC that bad??

    Christ

    There’s one image from this week of a naked guy lying dead - apparently - of an OD in a LA Metro train. Americans just don’t DO public transport

    I remember once trying to persuade a rich American that the best way from Heathrow to central London was via a public train. 15 minutes. Then jump in a cab, be in Claridge’s in another 15 minutes?

    He just couldn’t get his head around it, and insisted on taking a black cab from LHR all the way, which probably took three times as long as cost twice as much, excluding tip
    Ok, maybe your second tweet was pretty out there, but the NYC subway makes you want to fumigate after you’ve used it.

    Just the other day I travelled from the “tony” UES into Midtown (one of the better lines) and this black guy was lying on the bench opposite me peering at a woman a few seats to my right, moaning lasciviously,

    “Hey Mama”
    “Hey Mama”
    “Hey Pretty White Lady”
    “Hey Mama”
    “Wanna Fuck Me Mama?”

    I don’t remember that on Tooting Broadway.
This discussion has been closed.