Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

The vaccine wars shouldn’t surprise us given how COVID has blighted life around the world – politica

SystemSystem Posts: 11,685
edited January 2021 in General
imageThe vaccine wars shouldn’t surprise us given how COVID has blighted life around the world – politicalbetting.com

The increasingly bitter political wrangling going on about vaccines reminds me of the plot in what’s regarded as the greatest movie ever made “The Third Man”. This it will be recalled was based on the Graham Green novel and was set in post-war Vienna. It was about the murder of a racketeer who was exploiting the shortage of penicillin supplies of which could lead to people living rather than dying.

Read the full story here

«13456789

Comments

  • Options
    IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    First, two ahead of Orson Welles.
  • Options
    RogerRoger Posts: 18,891
    edited January 2021
    OT. While reading about United's gloomiest day i came across this on Sky which is part of the online abuse debate and I thought it was surprisingly well done and powerful

    'Hate won't stop us'

    https://www.skysports.com/football/news/11667/12201010/tuanzebe-racially-abused-after-sheffield-united-defeat
  • Options
    MortimerMortimer Posts: 13,945
    IshmaelZ said:

    First, two ahead of Orson Welles.

    Third, like the man himself (after Greene).
  • Options
    IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    edited January 2021
    The Third Man

    edit Curse you!
  • Options
    That reminds me -- I've never watched The Third Man, even though I have the dvd.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,311
    16th like Diane Abbott

    (the old ones are the good ones)
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,311

    That reminds me -- I've never watched The Third Man, even though I have the dvd.

    I saw it in Shanghai many years ago. You haven't lived until you've seen and heard Wilfred Hyde-White speak mandarin.
  • Options
    ydoethurydoethur Posts: 67,242
    edited January 2021

    That reminds me -- I've never watched The Third Man, even though I have the dvd.

    Amazing film. Easily the best film Orson Welles and Joseph Cotten ever made.

    (And yes, I have seen Citizen Kane as well.)

    Worth it just for the zither soundtrack, especially at the end, but there's so much more to enjoy.
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 31,997
    Good morning everybody, from a slightly more positive OKC.

    "Increasingly bitter"????

    The BBC is reporting that
    'The EU and the UK-based Covid vaccine maker AstraZeneca have vowed to work together to resolve a bitter row over supply shortages to the 27-member bloc'
  • Options

    That reminds me -- I've never watched The Third Man, even though I have the dvd.

    You lucky bar steward! Get to it..
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,190
    The prospect of a vaccine be able to stop it happening is so enticing that political leaders will go to any lengths to ensure that their home markets are supplied. Their future electoral prospects could be dependent on it.

    I think that should be "some political leaders" and some don't face elections...
  • Options

    That reminds me -- I've never watched The Third Man, even though I have the dvd.

    Watch it now!
  • Options
    SlackbladderSlackbladder Posts: 9,704
    Someone throw a life jacket to Starmer..he's drowning.
    https://twitter.com/paulwaugh/status/1354722974591569926
  • Options
    The Third Man was the second finest performance in the career of Orson Wells

    Obviously him being the voice of Unicron in Transformers: The Movie was number one.

    Shut up, I was 7 at the time, and I was am obsessed with Transformers.
  • Options
    ydoethurydoethur Posts: 67,242

    Someone throw a life jacket to Starmer..he's drowning.
    https://twitter.com/paulwaugh/status/1354722974591569926

    Age might be fair.

    Vulnerability - bit different.

    The issue though, whatever happens to teachers, remains parents, so I hope TSE's friend is in a position to clear that up for us.

    Once vulnerable over-40s have been vaccinated I don't think anyone will be too worried about schools going back.
  • Options
    RochdalePioneersRochdalePioneers Posts: 27,233
    edited January 2021
    Apologies for off-topic, but yesterday's business trip revealed a stark lack of non-UK trucks on the M1. Saw a literal handful of EU trucks and the same low single-digit haul of Irish trucks.
  • Options
    felixfelix Posts: 15,124
    TOPPING said:

    16th like Diane Abbott

    (the old ones are the good ones)

    or 3s or -2s or.....
  • Options
    TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 40,114
    edited January 2021
    On topic, wasn’t Lime selling ineffective, tainted penicillin on the black market? Pretty sure that there will be that type of racket over the next year.
  • Options
    felixfelix Posts: 15,124

    That reminds me -- I've never watched The Third Man, even though I have the dvd.

    It is one of my top dozen - absolutely superb.
  • Options
    squareroot2squareroot2 Posts: 6,354
    ... and the EU machine was too slow to order, arguing amongst themselves. I feel sorry for the people of the EU , but am not surprised this has happened. The French have been making our lives very difficult with their petty rules about Covid tests, now they have to come cap in hand.
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,420

    On topic, wasn’t Lime selling ineffective, tainted penicillin on the black market? Pretty sure that there will be that type of racket over the next year.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-55811161
    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-55577426
  • Options
    felixfelix Posts: 15,124

    Good morning everybody, from a slightly more positive OKC.

    "Increasingly bitter"????

    The BBC is reporting that
    'The EU and the UK-based Covid vaccine maker AstraZeneca have vowed to work together to resolve a bitter row over supply shortages to the 27-member bloc'

    The statement for the Greek EU Commissioner was much more emollient strongly suggesting the blether and bluster of the past few days had achieved nothing. Not surprising as there is no 'magic vaccine tree' to coin a phrase.
  • Options
    ydoethurydoethur Posts: 67,242

    On topic, wasn’t Lime selling ineffective, tainted penicillin on the black market? Pretty sure that there will be that type of racket over the next year.

    He watered it down, as it was worth £70 a tube. Made it highly toxic.

    I have a horrible feeling you might be right about vaccines...
  • Options
    geoffwgeoffw Posts: 8,166

    Apologies for off-topic, but yesterday's business trip revealed a stark lack of non-UK trucks on the M1. Saw a literal handful of EU trucks and the same low single-digit haul of Irish trucks.

    Were they Dinky trucks in your literal handful?
  • Options
    squareroot2squareroot2 Posts: 6,354

    Good morning everybody, from a slightly more positive OKC.

    "Increasingly bitter"????

    The BBC is reporting that
    'The EU and the UK-based Covid vaccine maker AstraZeneca have vowed to work together to resolve a bitter row over supply shortages to the 27-member bloc'

    A load of meaningless words
  • Options
    Sort of on topic, I know we laugh at America but people like this are our QAnon, it is utterly horrific viewing for so many reasons.

    Police are calling for public assistance in tracking down a man who was allegedly part of a group Covid deniers who tried to drag an elderly patient out of critical care at East Surrey Hospital.

    Tobe Hayden Leigh, 45, believed to be from Kent, is wanted in connection with a public nuisance offence after videos posted on social media showed a group entering the hospital to visit a family member on Thursday.

    After entering the critical care Covid ward, police say they were abusive to hospital staff who asked them to wear masks and refused to leave when asked to do so.

    Videos posted online by a YouTube account in Mr Hayden Leigh’s name appear to show an ICU doctor decrying the group for apparently removing the oxygen from the elderly patient.

    The doctor pleads: “My main concern is his safety and at the moment you are making him unsafe. You have taken his oxygen off, he is going to die if we don’t put it back on!”

    The patient appears to suggest he wants to leave the hospital, arguing with doctors that he won’t die if his oxygen is taken off.

    “If you go home, you will die,” the doctor says, later telling the group the patient will “last about half an hour” if he leaves hospital.

    Surrey and Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust say they allow any patient who has capacity to make decisions about their care to do so, including leaving hospital.

    The man livestreaming the incident then argues with the exasperated doctors, telling them the gravely ill patient should be put on the unproven treatment of “Vitamin C, Vitamin D and Zinc” if he is unhappy.

    Standing in the Covid ward he challenges doctors to “define coronavirus”, claiming it “hasn’t been proven to exist” and is “no longer a highly contagious infectious disease”.


    https://www.lbc.co.uk/news/covid-denier-nhs-east-surrey-hospital-police-hunt-elderly-man-tobe-hayden-leigh/
  • Options
    FloaterFloater Posts: 14,195
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 31,997
    ydoethur said:

    On topic, wasn’t Lime selling ineffective, tainted penicillin on the black market? Pretty sure that there will be that type of racket over the next year.

    He watered it down, as it was worth £70 a tube. Made it highly toxic.

    I have a horrible feeling you might be right about vaccines...
    Sadly, I am sure you both will be. There are some VERY nasty people about.
  • Options
    This sounds character building if the character you’re building is a perv.

    https://twitter.com/otto_english/status/1354706298588319745?s=21
  • Options
    DougSealDougSeal Posts: 11,139

    Apologies for off-topic, but yesterday's business trip revealed a stark lack of non-UK trucks on the M1. Saw a literal handful of EU trucks and the same low single-digit haul of Irish trucks.

    That's funny - taking our dog along to the vet yesterday on a short stretch of the M20 was surprised how many EU trucks I saw. Didn't notice any from Ireland admittedly was keeping an eye out in light of your many comments on here.
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,420
    ydoethur said:

    On topic, wasn’t Lime selling ineffective, tainted penicillin on the black market? Pretty sure that there will be that type of racket over the next year.

    He watered it down, as it was worth £70 a tube. Made it highly toxic.

    I have a horrible feeling you might be right about vaccines...
    Not so much toxic as ineffective. Unless the watering down contaminated it.

    And he would have been helping to create anti-biotic resistance.
  • Options
    kingbongokingbongo Posts: 393
    felix said:

    Good morning everybody, from a slightly more positive OKC.

    "Increasingly bitter"????

    The BBC is reporting that
    'The EU and the UK-based Covid vaccine maker AstraZeneca have vowed to work together to resolve a bitter row over supply shortages to the 27-member bloc'

    The statement for the Greek EU Commissioner was much more emollient strongly suggesting the blether and bluster of the past few days had achieved nothing. Not surprising as there is no 'magic vaccine tree' to coin a phrase.
    I think a grown-up had had a word and explained to her that she was embarrassing herself, the EU and Cyprus with her inchoherent rants
  • Options

    BREAKING NEWS

    Following a tearful plea from Ursula von der Leyen, Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has authorised the transfer of vaccine doses from Scotland to its needy EU allies.

    Ms Sturgeon said: “As we move along our pathway to Independence and rejoining the EU it’s so important that we Scots show solidarity with our European brethren.

    “It’s heart-breaking to hear how that callous English bounder Boris Johnson elbowed his way to the head of the queue and ran off with all the doses.

    “We Scots are made of better stuff and I look forward to the fond embraces of Ursula, Michel, Emmanuel, Angela and all my pals over there just as soon as I am able to hop over the German Sea and join them in Brussels for a fish supper.”

    Don’t give up the day job.
  • Options
    eekeek Posts: 24,981
    I think this highlights what the issue is

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/1354722391495221249

    The few £bns that we spent throwing money at the plausible options seems money well spent - while the Eu by messing around are between 3 to 9 months behind us and as they need more possibly even further behind.

    Remember scaling manufacturing isn't instant and it's blooming hard.
  • Options
    geoffwgeoffw Posts: 8,166

    ydoethur said:

    On topic, wasn’t Lime selling ineffective, tainted penicillin on the black market? Pretty sure that there will be that type of racket over the next year.

    He watered it down, as it was worth £70 a tube. Made it highly toxic.

    I have a horrible feeling you might be right about vaccines...
    Not so much toxic as ineffective. Unless the watering down contaminated it.

    And he would have been helping to create anti-biotic resistance.
    But unknowingly as it was not a thing in 1949.

  • Options
    ydoethurydoethur Posts: 67,242
    Floater said:
    Head

    Desk

    Thump

    No wonder the Darwin Awards have been suspended.
  • Options
    BurgessianBurgessian Posts: 2,447

    BREAKING NEWS

    Following a tearful plea from Ursula von der Leyen, Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has authorised the transfer of vaccine doses from Scotland to its needy EU allies.

    Ms Sturgeon said: “As we move along our pathway to Independence and rejoining the EU it’s so important that we Scots show solidarity with our European brethren.

    “It’s heart-breaking to hear how that callous English bounder Boris Johnson elbowed his way to the head of the queue and ran off with all the doses.

    “We Scots are made of better stuff and I look forward to the fond embraces of Ursula, Michel, Emmanuel, Angela and all my pals over there just as soon as I am able to hop over the German Sea and join them in Brussels for a fish supper.”

    Don’t give up the day job.
    Don't worry, wasn't planning to. Will be interesting to see how Boris gets on today, eh?
  • Options
    ydoethurydoethur Posts: 67,242

    ydoethur said:

    On topic, wasn’t Lime selling ineffective, tainted penicillin on the black market? Pretty sure that there will be that type of racket over the next year.

    He watered it down, as it was worth £70 a tube. Made it highly toxic.

    I have a horrible feeling you might be right about vaccines...
    Not so much toxic as ineffective. Unless the watering down contaminated it.

    And he would have been helping to create anti-biotic resistance.
    Quote from the film:

    'The lucky ones died. The unlucky ones went off their heads.'

    Not sure how accurate it was, but I remember reading in an article about the film a few years ago that two doctors working with the British army in Vienna, who had provided penicillin to locals in the belief they were helping, were so upset by one scene they had to leave the cinema.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,311
    edited January 2021
    fpt re gamestop
    Charles said:
    Not necessarily.

    Because the rampers (ramping is abuse, of course, but these are individuals, not one party - unless the exchange/platform knows otherwise) are just buying the stock.

    It then went up because of the short squeeze as the hedgies tried to cover.

    They were just capitalising on supply shortage, not spreading rumours.

  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,125

    Good morning everybody, from a slightly more positive OKC.

    "Increasingly bitter"????

    The BBC is reporting that
    'The EU and the UK-based Covid vaccine maker AstraZeneca have vowed to work together to resolve a bitter row over supply shortages to the 27-member bloc'

    A load of meaningless words
    A tad harsh on BBC reporting.

    Although.....
  • Options

    BREAKING NEWS

    Following a tearful plea from Ursula von der Leyen, Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has authorised the transfer of vaccine doses from Scotland to its needy EU allies.

    Ms Sturgeon said: “As we move along our pathway to Independence and rejoining the EU it’s so important that we Scots show solidarity with our European brethren.

    “It’s heart-breaking to hear how that callous English bounder Boris Johnson elbowed his way to the head of the queue and ran off with all the doses.

    “We Scots are made of better stuff and I look forward to the fond embraces of Ursula, Michel, Emmanuel, Angela and all my pals over there just as soon as I am able to hop over the German Sea and join them in Brussels for a fish supper.”

    Don’t give up the day job.
    Don't worry, wasn't planning to. Will be interesting to see how Boris gets on today, eh?
    If ever a man could combine charm and offensive...
  • Options
    DougSeal said:

    Apologies for off-topic, but yesterday's business trip revealed a stark lack of non-UK trucks on the M1. Saw a literal handful of EU trucks and the same low single-digit haul of Irish trucks.

    That's funny - taking our dog along to the vet yesterday on a short stretch of the M20 was surprised how many EU trucks I saw. Didn't notice any from Ireland admittedly was keeping an eye out in light of your many comments on here.
    The M20 should be crawling in EU trucks. That they appear to have largely disappeared elsewhere was interesting too see. If - as keeps being reported - the EU hauliers are largely refusing to serve the UK then either UK hauliers find sufficient backhaul under the new restrictions to make the trip viable, or stuff isn't coming in any more in volume by truck.
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,680
    edited January 2021
    eek said:

    I think this highlights what the issue is

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/1354722391495221249

    The few £bns that we spent throwing money at the plausible options seems money well spent - while the Eu by messing around are between 3 to 9 months behind us and as they need more possibly even further behind.

    Remember scaling manufacturing isn't instant and it's blooming hard.

    I'm not sure they've actually ordered it:

    12th January 2021
    Today, the European Commission concluded exploratory talks with the pharmaceutical company Valneva with a view to purchasing its potential vaccine against COVID-19. The envisaged contract with Valneva would provide for the possibility for all EU Member States to purchase together 30 million doses, and they could further purchase up to 30 million more doses.


    https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_21_51
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,420
    ydoethur said:

    ydoethur said:

    On topic, wasn’t Lime selling ineffective, tainted penicillin on the black market? Pretty sure that there will be that type of racket over the next year.

    He watered it down, as it was worth £70 a tube. Made it highly toxic.

    I have a horrible feeling you might be right about vaccines...
    Not so much toxic as ineffective. Unless the watering down contaminated it.

    And he would have been helping to create anti-biotic resistance.
    Quote from the film:

    'The lucky ones died. The unlucky ones went off their heads.'

    Not sure how accurate it was, but I remember reading in an article about the film a few years ago that two doctors working with the British army in Vienna, who had provided penicillin to locals in the belief they were helping, were so upset by one scene they had to leave the cinema.
    I remember that quote about the doctors. Someone told Greene that, IIRC.
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,125

    BREAKING NEWS

    Following a tearful plea from Ursula von der Leyen, Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has authorised the transfer of vaccine doses from Scotland to its needy EU allies.

    Ms Sturgeon said: “As we move along our pathway to Independence and rejoining the EU it’s so important that we Scots show solidarity with our European brethren.

    “It’s heart-breaking to hear how that callous English bounder Boris Johnson elbowed his way to the head of the queue and ran off with all the doses.

    “We Scots are made of better stuff and I look forward to the fond embraces of Ursula, Michel, Emmanuel, Angela and all my pals over there just as soon as I am able to hop over the German Sea and join them in Brussels for a fish supper.”

    Don’t give up the day job.
    Ms Sturgeon has no intention of giving up the day job.

    Mr Salmond has other ideas.
  • Options
    BBC News - Covid: UK vaccine supplies 'won't be interrupted' - Gove
    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-55838272

    Given its Gove, that means we should expect widespread disruption.
  • Options
    ydoethurydoethur Posts: 67,242

    BBC News - Covid: UK vaccine supplies 'won't be interrupted' - Gove
    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-55838272

    Given its Gove, that means we should expect widespread disruption.

    Speaking of which - duty calls.

    See you later.
  • Options
    RogerRoger Posts: 18,891

    MaxPB said:

    It haggled over price

    Over a vaccine that was being sold not for profit.....

    BTW, Bild has picked up on your point that if the EU shuts down vaccine export, other countries will shut down materials export, stopping all EU vaccine production.....
    An example of why cooperation is better than competition and why leaving the EU was such a stupid idea. What's the point of vaccinating in the UK if our neighbours aren't being vaccinated? They close their borders we close ours and we're all fucked.
  • Options
    MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 37,607

    MaxPB said:

    It haggled over price

    Over a vaccine that was being sold not for profit.....

    BTW, Bild has picked up on your point that if the EU shuts down vaccine export, other countries will shut down materials export, stopping all EU vaccine production.....
    It's a simple consequence that doesn't take a genius to work out. The EU pharmaceutical industry is highly dependent on the UK and Switzerland (and vice versa) any move by one party to freeze out the others would be a disaster. It's a negative sum game, not even a zero sum one because you have a manufacturing site previously pumping out 80m doses per month now doing nothing, it's global capacity that would be going unused while the pharma companies adjust their supply chains and bail out of the EU.

    If the EU really does walk this path then it shatters the western alliance and they wave goodbye to their pharma industry almost overnight.
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,420
    TOPPING said:

    fpt re gamestop

    Charles said:
    Not necessarily.

    Because the rampers (ramping is abuse, of course, but these are individuals, not one party - unless the exchange/platform knows otherwise) are just buying the stock.

    It then went up because of the short squeeze as the hedgies tried to cover.

    They were just capitalising on supply shortage, not spreading rumours.


    If the reports that the shorts are naked and over 100% are correct, the market abuse is the short sellers. Not those holding contracts and shares.

    The suggestion that shares should be loaned without the consent of the owner, just so that the hedges can play with them, is particularly risible.
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,680
    Roger said:

    MaxPB said:

    It haggled over price

    Over a vaccine that was being sold not for profit.....

    BTW, Bild has picked up on your point that if the EU shuts down vaccine export, other countries will shut down materials export, stopping all EU vaccine production.....
    An example of why cooperation is better than competition and why leaving the EU was such a stupid idea. What's the point of vaccinating in the UK if our neighbours aren't being vaccinated? They close their borders we close ours and we're all fucked.
    You would rather have the EU's vaccine roll out than ours?



  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,125
    MaxPB said:

    This is why we left the EU. An unaccountable executive body that never admits it's mistakes. The commission completely and utterly fucked up the vaccine procurement process. It haggled over price, was slow and bureaucratic at a time where speed was important and cost irrelevant.

    Now when countries which moved quickly are seeing the fruits of that labour with rapid vaccination of their vulnerable and short timelines for everyone else they have realised just how badly they fucked it.

    The difference is that in 2024 the British people can make Boris pay for all of the fuck ups and more that 100k deaths that are on his hands. Who in Europe will pay for the extra hundreds of thousands that will die because there's no vaccines. No one. The national politicians will pass the buck and the commission is impossible to sack.

    Leave voters were lambasted time and again for pointing out just how undemocratic the EU is and now handily, just after we've left, we have an example of it, one that is undermining the western alliance with threats of export bans.

    This, to me, goes beyond just vaccines. It shows that a political class that isn't under pressure from voters is inherently worse than one that is. The EU commission is a technocratic body that has failed at basic competence on almost everything to do with the virus and now they are trying to shift the blame into AZ and the UK government.

    It is not democracy if there is no mechanism for voters to remove those failures from power.

    It's not even as if there is any groundswell of outrage in the EU Parliament. The EU's one thing to rejoice is that Farage no longer sits there. Imagine the hay he would have made....
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,285
    edited January 2021
    Of course the EU f##king up vaccine procurement is just the latest in a series of f##k ups, remember similar PPE and ventilator schemes suffering the same issues.

    When Czechia started to really struggle in the autumn they asked the EU for all the ventilators they could send from this scheme...they got 30.
  • Options
    BurgessianBurgessian Posts: 2,447

    BREAKING NEWS

    Following a tearful plea from Ursula von der Leyen, Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has authorised the transfer of vaccine doses from Scotland to its needy EU allies.

    Ms Sturgeon said: “As we move along our pathway to Independence and rejoining the EU it’s so important that we Scots show solidarity with our European brethren.

    “It’s heart-breaking to hear how that callous English bounder Boris Johnson elbowed his way to the head of the queue and ran off with all the doses.

    “We Scots are made of better stuff and I look forward to the fond embraces of Ursula, Michel, Emmanuel, Angela and all my pals over there just as soon as I am able to hop over the German Sea and join them in Brussels for a fish supper.”

    Don’t give up the day job.
    Ms Sturgeon has no intention of giving up the day job.

    Mr Salmond has other ideas.
    Uncanny...

    https://www.pressandjournal.co.uk/fp/opinion/columnists/alex-bell/2849884/team-sturgeon-switches-indy-policy-as-salmond-smells-a-political-comeback/
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,125
    ydoethur said:

    Floater said:
    Head

    Desk

    Thump

    No wonder the Darwin Awards have been suspended.
    Give it 10 days before the Sun headline "Infection sprouts in Brussels"?
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,420

    I've been as enthusiastic at slagging off Dominic Cummings as the next man over the last year, but a thought occurred to me last night following our discussion here on the Vaccine Task Force. This initiative is, by a country mile, the very best ting this government has done, probably in fact the only thing it has done well. Not just 'well' in the normal sense of good governance, but something beyond what you can normally expect governments to achieve. Not only has it put us in an excellent position in terms of Covid vaccine availability, but it has also positioned the UK extremely well for what will undoubtedly be a renewed world emphasis on vaccine technology and production. And it has done it super-fast.

    And how was it achieved? I find it awkward to admit this, but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Cummings was behind it. It has all the hallmarks of his approach: by-passing the cumbersome workings of the normal Civil Service approach and instead get a small, talented, goal-focused team to super-charge the initiative. Of course it's an approach with great risks, but in this case also with an even greater pay-off.

    Of course virtually the entire media coverage last year on the Vaccine Task Force was devoted to garbage about 'cronies' and 'sleaze'. The fact that this was a spectacular success was lost in the deluge of faux-indignation.

    We might owe Cummings an apology...

    The ramping up of testing was actually quite similar - the existing organisational structure/management said that they couldn't expand beyond a few multiples. Which was taken to mean that mass testing was impossible, by the same people.

    Then the Lighthouse Labs project came in.
  • Options
    ydoethur said:

    ydoethur said:

    On topic, wasn’t Lime selling ineffective, tainted penicillin on the black market? Pretty sure that there will be that type of racket over the next year.

    He watered it down, as it was worth £70 a tube. Made it highly toxic.

    I have a horrible feeling you might be right about vaccines...
    Not so much toxic as ineffective. Unless the watering down contaminated it.

    And he would have been helping to create anti-biotic resistance.
    Quote from the film:

    'The lucky ones died. The unlucky ones went off their heads.'

    Not sure how accurate it was, but I remember reading in an article about the film a few years ago that two doctors working with the British army in Vienna, who had provided penicillin to locals in the belief they were helping, were so upset by one scene they had to leave the cinema.
    Probably the scene in the children’s ward with kids who’d been treated with Lime’s penicillin dying of meningitis. One of the great things about the film is it’s ability to combine expressionism & film noir with a good bit of realism.

    On checking Wiki (sorry) it seems that Lime’s cuckoo clock speech was added by Welles himself. Must be up with Rutger Hauer’s bit in Bladerunner as memorable script contributions by actors.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,311
    edited January 2021


    If the reports that the shorts are naked and over 100% are correct, the market abuse is the short sellers. Not those holding contracts and shares.

    The suggestion that shares should be loaned without the consent of the owner, just so that the hedges can play with them, is particularly risible.

    Ah. I haven't been following particularly closely, just saw @Charles' post - and thought the issue was the ramping of the stock. If they were naked shorts then yes of course that's illegal.
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,125
    edited January 2021

    eek said:

    I think this highlights what the issue is

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/1354722391495221249

    The few £bns that we spent throwing money at the plausible options seems money well spent - while the Eu by messing around are between 3 to 9 months behind us and as they need more possibly even further behind.

    Remember scaling manufacturing isn't instant and it's blooming hard.

    I'm not sure they've actually ordered it:

    12th January 2021
    Today, the European Commission concluded exploratory talks with the pharmaceutical company Valneva with a view to purchasing its potential vaccine against COVID-19. The envisaged contract with Valneva would provide for the possibility for all EU Member States to purchase together 30 million doses, and they could further purchase up to 30 million more doses.


    https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_21_51
    Well, if they do order it, that's Bulgaria and Romania taken care of.....

    France, Spain, Germany, Italy - not so much.
  • Options

    I've been as enthusiastic at slagging off Dominic Cummings as the next man over the last year, but a thought occurred to me last night following our discussion here on the Vaccine Task Force. This initiative is, by a country mile, the very best ting this government has done, probably in fact the only thing it has done well. Not just 'well' in the normal sense of good governance, but something beyond what you can normally expect governments to achieve. Not only has it put us in an excellent position in terms of Covid vaccine availability, but it has also positioned the UK extremely well for what will undoubtedly be a renewed world emphasis on vaccine technology and production. And it has done it super-fast.

    And how was it achieved? I find it awkward to admit this, but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Cummings was behind it. It has all the hallmarks of his approach: by-passing the cumbersome workings of the normal Civil Service approach and instead get a small, talented, goal-focused team to super-charge the initiative. Of course it's an approach with great risks, but in this case also with an even greater pay-off.

    Of course virtually the entire media coverage last year on the Vaccine Task Force was devoted to garbage about 'cronies' and 'sleaze'. The fact that this was a spectacular success was lost in the deluge of faux-indignation.

    We might owe Cummings an apology...

    Good points in the first two paragraphs, wrong conclusions in the second two. It seems very plausible and perhaps even likely that Cummings was integral to the early speedy actions of the vaccine task force. He has strengths and weaknesses just like everyone else does, and this plays to his strengths. On plenty of other things his approach caused mayhem, division and inaction.

    Cronies, sleaze and ethics really do matter too though. We owe him no apology, but if he was involved in this we should thank him for that part of his service.
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,680

    I've been as enthusiastic at slagging off Dominic Cummings as the next man over the last year, but a thought occurred to me last night following our discussion here on the Vaccine Task Force. This initiative is, by a country mile, the very best ting this government has done, probably in fact the only thing it has done well. Not just 'well' in the normal sense of good governance, but something beyond what you can normally expect governments to achieve. Not only has it put us in an excellent position in terms of Covid vaccine availability, but it has also positioned the UK extremely well for what will undoubtedly be a renewed world emphasis on vaccine technology and production. And it has done it super-fast.

    And how was it achieved? I find it awkward to admit this, but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Cummings was behind it. It has all the hallmarks of his approach: by-passing the cumbersome workings of the normal Civil Service approach and instead get a small, talented, goal-focused team to super-charge the initiative. Of course it's an approach with great risks, but in this case also with an even greater pay-off.

    Of course virtually the entire media coverage last year on the Vaccine Task Force was devoted to garbage about 'cronies' and 'sleaze'. The fact that this was a spectacular success was lost in the deluge of faux-indignation.

    We might owe Cummings an apology...

    From Kate Bingham in the VTF report:

    We should recognise the flexibility and nimbleness of the civil service and the Ministers who balanced appropriate oversight and governance measures with respect to spending taxpayer money, with the making of big, difficult decisions at pace. Without this streamlining of decision making, it is unlikely that the VTF could have delivered this successful range of outcomes in such a short time.
  • Options

    I've been as enthusiastic at slagging off Dominic Cummings as the next man over the last year, but a thought occurred to me last night following our discussion here on the Vaccine Task Force. This initiative is, by a country mile, the very best ting this government has done, probably in fact the only thing it has done well. Not just 'well' in the normal sense of good governance, but something beyond what you can normally expect governments to achieve. Not only has it put us in an excellent position in terms of Covid vaccine availability, but it has also positioned the UK extremely well for what will undoubtedly be a renewed world emphasis on vaccine technology and production. And it has done it super-fast.

    And how was it achieved? I find it awkward to admit this, but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Cummings was behind it. It has all the hallmarks of his approach: by-passing the cumbersome workings of the normal Civil Service approach and instead get a small, talented, goal-focused team to super-charge the initiative. Of course it's an approach with great risks, but in this case also with an even greater pay-off.

    Of course virtually the entire media coverage last year on the Vaccine Task Force was devoted to garbage about 'cronies' and 'sleaze'. The fact that this was a spectacular success was lost in the deluge of faux-indignation.

    We might owe Cummings an apology...

    The ramping up of testing was actually quite similar - the existing organisational structure/management said that they couldn't expand beyond a few multiples. Which was taken to mean that mass testing was impossible, by the same people.

    Then the Lighthouse Labs project came in.
    The big mistake the government made with testing was they got from 10k to 100k with help of the man from Delmonte...then they sent him back and the pace of increase slowed. So they got caught short in the autumn....before refocusing again and real push for massive capacity.

    With vaccine roll out, they have to keep expanding capacity, no let up. There is a not insignificant chance that by the time we get through the population, we might well have to go round again with a new vaccine for all these mutate versions.
  • Options
    MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 37,607
    TOPPING said:


    If the reports that the shorts are naked and over 100% are correct, the market abuse is the short sellers. Not those holding contracts and shares.

    The suggestion that shares should be loaned without the consent of the owner, just so that the hedges can play with them, is particularly risible.

    Ah. I haven't been following particularly closely, just saw @Charles' post - and thought the issue was the ramping of the stock. If they were naked shorts then yes of course that's illegal.
    Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,420
    TOPPING said:


    If the reports that the shorts are naked and over 100% are correct, the market abuse is the short sellers. Not those holding contracts and shares.

    The suggestion that shares should be loaned without the consent of the owner, just so that the hedges can play with them, is particularly risible.

    Ah. I haven't been following particularly closely, just saw @Charles' post - and thought the issue was the ramping of the stock. If they were naked shorts then yes of course that's illegal.
    Well, it depends how they did it. It gets technical, but they seem to have done an end run around the rules.
  • Options

    I've been as enthusiastic at slagging off Dominic Cummings as the next man over the last year, but a thought occurred to me last night following our discussion here on the Vaccine Task Force. This initiative is, by a country mile, the very best ting this government has done, probably in fact the only thing it has done well. Not just 'well' in the normal sense of good governance, but something beyond what you can normally expect governments to achieve. Not only has it put us in an excellent position in terms of Covid vaccine availability, but it has also positioned the UK extremely well for what will undoubtedly be a renewed world emphasis on vaccine technology and production. And it has done it super-fast.

    And how was it achieved? I find it awkward to admit this, but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Cummings was behind it. It has all the hallmarks of his approach: by-passing the cumbersome workings of the normal Civil Service approach and instead get a small, talented, goal-focused team to super-charge the initiative. Of course it's an approach with great risks, but in this case also with an even greater pay-off.

    Of course virtually the entire media coverage last year on the Vaccine Task Force was devoted to garbage about 'cronies' and 'sleaze'. The fact that this was a spectacular success was lost in the deluge of faux-indignation.

    We might owe Cummings an apology...

    As I mentioned last night, wasn’t some of the briefing against Bingham coming from within the No 10 Stavka?
  • Options
    eekeek Posts: 24,981

    Of course the EU f##king up vaccine procurement is just the latest in a series of f##k ups, remember similar PPE and ventilator schemes suffering the same issues.

    When Czechia started to really struggle in the autumn they asked the EU for all the ventilators they could send from this scheme...they got 30.

    I think the difference is that last time it wasn't quite as visible to the general public as lack of vaccine appointments are.

    This is an interesting read on how the EU got themselves into the mess they are in https://www.politico.eu/article/europe-coronavirus-vaccine-struggle-pfizer-biontech-astrazeneca/

    Price and liability are not things to talk about when you need manufacturing capacity and rapid delivery.

    Capacity, speed and price are 3 sides of a triangle on which you can select only 2. And they picked the wrong one to insist upon (before being late to start the project in the first place).

    The more I read that article the more I'm surprised the EU have any vaccines at the moment in time.
  • Options
    MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 37,607

    TOPPING said:


    If the reports that the shorts are naked and over 100% are correct, the market abuse is the short sellers. Not those holding contracts and shares.

    The suggestion that shares should be loaned without the consent of the owner, just so that the hedges can play with them, is particularly risible.

    Ah. I haven't been following particularly closely, just saw @Charles' post - and thought the issue was the ramping of the stock. If they were naked shorts then yes of course that's illegal.
    Well, it depends how they did it. It gets technical, but they seem to have done an end run around the rules.
    Even if it is done legally through some odd quirk of rules, it doesn't make it not completely stupid.
  • Options

    I've been as enthusiastic at slagging off Dominic Cummings as the next man over the last year, but a thought occurred to me last night following our discussion here on the Vaccine Task Force. This initiative is, by a country mile, the very best ting this government has done, probably in fact the only thing it has done well. Not just 'well' in the normal sense of good governance, but something beyond what you can normally expect governments to achieve. Not only has it put us in an excellent position in terms of Covid vaccine availability, but it has also positioned the UK extremely well for what will undoubtedly be a renewed world emphasis on vaccine technology and production. And it has done it super-fast.

    And how was it achieved? I find it awkward to admit this, but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Cummings was behind it. It has all the hallmarks of his approach: by-passing the cumbersome workings of the normal Civil Service approach and instead get a small, talented, goal-focused team to super-charge the initiative. Of course it's an approach with great risks, but in this case also with an even greater pay-off.

    Of course virtually the entire media coverage last year on the Vaccine Task Force was devoted to garbage about 'cronies' and 'sleaze'. The fact that this was a spectacular success was lost in the deluge of faux-indignation.

    We might owe Cummings an apology...

    The ramping up of testing was actually quite similar - the existing organisational structure/management said that they couldn't expand beyond a few multiples. Which was taken to mean that mass testing was impossible, by the same people.

    Then the Lighthouse Labs project came in.
    And people moaned that it wasn't within the pre-existing NHS structure.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,311

    TOPPING said:


    If the reports that the shorts are naked and over 100% are correct, the market abuse is the short sellers. Not those holding contracts and shares.

    The suggestion that shares should be loaned without the consent of the owner, just so that the hedges can play with them, is particularly risible.

    Ah. I haven't been following particularly closely, just saw @Charles' post - and thought the issue was the ramping of the stock. If they were naked shorts then yes of course that's illegal.
    Well, it depends how they did it. It gets technical, but they seem to have done an end run around the rules.
    I will take a look sounds interesting.
  • Options
    RogerRoger Posts: 18,891

    I've been as enthusiastic at slagging off Dominic Cummings as the next man over the last year, but a thought occurred to me last night following our discussion here on the Vaccine Task Force. This initiative is, by a country mile, the very best ting this government has done, probably in fact the only thing it has done well. Not just 'well' in the normal sense of good governance, but something beyond what you can normally expect governments to achieve. Not only has it put us in an excellent position in terms of Covid vaccine availability, but it has also positioned the UK extremely well for what will undoubtedly be a renewed world emphasis on vaccine technology and production. And it has done it super-fast.

    And how was it achieved? I find it awkward to admit this, but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Cummings was behind it. It has all the hallmarks of his approach: by-passing the cumbersome workings of the normal Civil Service approach and instead get a small, talented, goal-focused team to super-charge the initiative. Of course it's an approach with great risks, but in this case also with an even greater pay-off.

    Of course virtually the entire media coverage last year on the Vaccine Task Force was devoted to garbage about 'cronies' and 'sleaze'. The fact that this was a spectacular success was lost in the deluge of faux-indignation.

    We might owe Cummings an apology...

    I think you might find that one of the quietest choruses you've ever heard
  • Options
    Richard_NabaviRichard_Nabavi Posts: 30,820
    edited January 2021


    Good points in the first two paragraphs, wrong conclusions in the second two. It seems very plausible and perhaps even likely that Cummings was integral to the early speedy actions of the vaccine task force. He has strengths and weaknesses just like everyone else does, and this plays to his strengths. On plenty of other things his approach caused mayhem, division and inaction.

    Cronies, sleaze and ethics really do matter too though. We owe him no apology, but if he was involved in this we should thank him for that part of his service.

    I don't disagree with your first paragraph, but, still, after all the slagging off, we should balance it with a bit of un-slagging.

    On cronies and sleaze - yes, sure, if it's real. But most of the coverage was garbage, with tenuous connections blown up out of all proportion.
  • Options
    JonathanDJonathanD Posts: 2,400
    eek said:

    Of course the EU f##king up vaccine procurement is just the latest in a series of f##k ups, remember similar PPE and ventilator schemes suffering the same issues.

    When Czechia started to really struggle in the autumn they asked the EU for all the ventilators they could send from this scheme...they got 30.


    The more I read that article the more I'm surprised the EU have any vaccines at the moment in time.

    The benefit of being such a large power is that even when in the wrong, they can still get their way to some degree.
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,125
    Roger said:

    MaxPB said:

    It haggled over price

    Over a vaccine that was being sold not for profit.....

    BTW, Bild has picked up on your point that if the EU shuts down vaccine export, other countries will shut down materials export, stopping all EU vaccine production.....
    An example of why cooperation is better than competition and why leaving the EU was such a stupid idea. What's the point of vaccinating in the UK if our neighbours aren't being vaccinated? They close their borders we close ours and we're all fucked.
    No. They close their borders and they are still fucked. We close our borders to them because they might still generate a mutant strain in their unvaxxed population that undoes all the good work the UK has done. But we can shortly return to the pre-Covid unfucked social life of going to family, restaurants, pubs, theatre, concerts, night clubs....
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,125
    MaxPB said:

    TOPPING said:


    If the reports that the shorts are naked and over 100% are correct, the market abuse is the short sellers. Not those holding contracts and shares.

    The suggestion that shares should be loaned without the consent of the owner, just so that the hedges can play with them, is particularly risible.

    Ah. I haven't been following particularly closely, just saw @Charles' post - and thought the issue was the ramping of the stock. If they were naked shorts then yes of course that's illegal.
    Well, it depends how they did it. It gets technical, but they seem to have done an end run around the rules.
    Even if it is done legally through some odd quirk of rules, it doesn't make it not completely stupid.
    Cummings' time has come after he has gone. The curse of the true visionary....
  • Options
    SlackbladderSlackbladder Posts: 9,704
    Roger said:

    I've been as enthusiastic at slagging off Dominic Cummings as the next man over the last year, but a thought occurred to me last night following our discussion here on the Vaccine Task Force. This initiative is, by a country mile, the very best ting this government has done, probably in fact the only thing it has done well. Not just 'well' in the normal sense of good governance, but something beyond what you can normally expect governments to achieve. Not only has it put us in an excellent position in terms of Covid vaccine availability, but it has also positioned the UK extremely well for what will undoubtedly be a renewed world emphasis on vaccine technology and production. And it has done it super-fast.

    And how was it achieved? I find it awkward to admit this, but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Cummings was behind it. It has all the hallmarks of his approach: by-passing the cumbersome workings of the normal Civil Service approach and instead get a small, talented, goal-focused team to super-charge the initiative. Of course it's an approach with great risks, but in this case also with an even greater pay-off.

    Of course virtually the entire media coverage last year on the Vaccine Task Force was devoted to garbage about 'cronies' and 'sleaze'. The fact that this was a spectacular success was lost in the deluge of faux-indignation.

    We might owe Cummings an apology...

    I think you might find that one of the quietest choruses you've ever heard
    Cummings had lots of great ideas, just that he had a lot of bad ones, and was an total arsehole. With a better and more diligent PM, a lot of the proposals had merit and could have been refined to be much better and workable.
  • Options
    Richard_NabaviRichard_Nabavi Posts: 30,820
    edited January 2021

    I've been as enthusiastic at slagging off Dominic Cummings as the next man over the last year, but a thought occurred to me last night following our discussion here on the Vaccine Task Force. This initiative is, by a country mile, the very best ting this government has done, probably in fact the only thing it has done well. Not just 'well' in the normal sense of good governance, but something beyond what you can normally expect governments to achieve. Not only has it put us in an excellent position in terms of Covid vaccine availability, but it has also positioned the UK extremely well for what will undoubtedly be a renewed world emphasis on vaccine technology and production. And it has done it super-fast.

    And how was it achieved? I find it awkward to admit this, but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Cummings was behind it. It has all the hallmarks of his approach: by-passing the cumbersome workings of the normal Civil Service approach and instead get a small, talented, goal-focused team to super-charge the initiative. Of course it's an approach with great risks, but in this case also with an even greater pay-off.

    Of course virtually the entire media coverage last year on the Vaccine Task Force was devoted to garbage about 'cronies' and 'sleaze'. The fact that this was a spectacular success was lost in the deluge of faux-indignation.

    We might owe Cummings an apology...

    As I mentioned last night, wasn’t some of the briefing against Bingham coming from within the No 10 Stavka?
    Oh, no doubt. He's a hell of a disruptive and unpleasant figure.

    Edit: Sorry, misread your post!
  • Options
    eekeek Posts: 24,981

    TOPPING said:


    If the reports that the shorts are naked and over 100% are correct, the market abuse is the short sellers. Not those holding contracts and shares.

    The suggestion that shares should be loaned without the consent of the owner, just so that the hedges can play with them, is particularly risible.

    Ah. I haven't been following particularly closely, just saw @Charles' post - and thought the issue was the ramping of the stock. If they were naked shorts then yes of course that's illegal.
    Well, it depends how they did it. It gets technical, but they seem to have done an end run around the rules.
    One of the bits I noticed was that most brokers insist on the right to allow them to lend shares to be shorted.

    So one of the tricks the buyers are doing is revoking that right as they purchase their shares making it even harder for the short sellers as the risk of having naked shorts no longer attached to valid shares gets greater and greater.
  • Options

    I've been as enthusiastic at slagging off Dominic Cummings as the next man over the last year, but a thought occurred to me last night following our discussion here on the Vaccine Task Force. This initiative is, by a country mile, the very best ting this government has done, probably in fact the only thing it has done well. Not just 'well' in the normal sense of good governance, but something beyond what you can normally expect governments to achieve. Not only has it put us in an excellent position in terms of Covid vaccine availability, but it has also positioned the UK extremely well for what will undoubtedly be a renewed world emphasis on vaccine technology and production. And it has done it super-fast.

    And how was it achieved? I find it awkward to admit this, but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Cummings was behind it. It has all the hallmarks of his approach: by-passing the cumbersome workings of the normal Civil Service approach and instead get a small, talented, goal-focused team to super-charge the initiative. Of course it's an approach with great risks, but in this case also with an even greater pay-off.

    Of course virtually the entire media coverage last year on the Vaccine Task Force was devoted to garbage about 'cronies' and 'sleaze'. The fact that this was a spectacular success was lost in the deluge of faux-indignation.

    We might owe Cummings an apology...

    From Kate Bingham in the VTF report:

    We should recognise the flexibility and nimbleness of the civil service and the Ministers who balanced appropriate oversight and governance measures with respect to spending taxpayer money, with the making of big, difficult decisions at pace. Without this streamlining of decision making, it is unlikely that the VTF could have delivered this successful range of outcomes in such a short time.
    Absolutely 100% this.

    Some people, I won't name names, have been relentlessly attacking the government and Bingham etc for not religiously abiding by oversight rules during the pandemic. But you can't and do it right.

    Now it is coming home to roost. As was said last year when discussing this: you can have it cheap, right or fast - pick two out of three.

    This needed to be done quickly, it needed to be done right. So by series of elimination ...
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,929
    What the EU actually needs to be doing NOW is throwing money at pharma companies to expand manufacturing capability within the EU itself. The plants don't come for free, but compared to the overall EU budget a few billion chucked at Sanofi for the express purpose of vaccine manufacture of say Pfizer under license would be incredibly well spent.
    I know Sanofi are shifting existing capability to do this already, but throwing money at them to duplicate this effort in say Poland - it wouldn't have an immediate return but further down the line they'd have vaccine robustness.
  • Options
    SlackbladderSlackbladder Posts: 9,704

    Roger said:

    MaxPB said:

    It haggled over price

    Over a vaccine that was being sold not for profit.....

    BTW, Bild has picked up on your point that if the EU shuts down vaccine export, other countries will shut down materials export, stopping all EU vaccine production.....
    An example of why cooperation is better than competition and why leaving the EU was such a stupid idea. What's the point of vaccinating in the UK if our neighbours aren't being vaccinated? They close their borders we close ours and we're all fucked.
    No. They close their borders and they are still fucked. We close our borders to them because they might still generate a mutant strain in their unvaxxed population that undoes all the good work the UK has done. But we can shortly return to the pre-Covid unfucked social life of going to family, restaurants, pubs, theatre, concerts, night clubs....
    Borders won't be opening in any meaningful way anytime soon. Even if we get the vaccine well underway, the risks are too much, especially in the developing world which will take years and years to get this thing under control. You better look forward to your hols in Skeggy much more Roger!
  • Options
    Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 26,651
    Roger said:

    MaxPB said:

    It haggled over price

    Over a vaccine that was being sold not for profit.....

    BTW, Bild has picked up on your point that if the EU shuts down vaccine export, other countries will shut down materials export, stopping all EU vaccine production.....
    An example of why cooperation is better than competition and why leaving the EU was such a stupid idea. What's the point of vaccinating in the UK if our neighbours aren't being vaccinated? They close their borders we close ours and we're all fucked.
    Hopefully we can all cooperate to vaccinate the most vulnerable people both in Europe and elsewhere. But Europe hasnt even approved the AZ vaccine yet so its a bit strange demanding that we hand it over at this time.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,770
    I have never heard of the third man.
    HYUFD said:
    Thanks for this. Love this stuff.
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,125
    On Gamestop, wouldn't know be a great time for the company to issue US$100m of shares - at say 50% of the prior closing price? They get capitalised and out of a hole, the shorters can grab these shares to mitigate some of their massive losses, the share price recovers because they are now cash rich so those playing the shorters don't lose their shirt....
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,929

    I've been as enthusiastic at slagging off Dominic Cummings as the next man over the last year, but a thought occurred to me last night following our discussion here on the Vaccine Task Force. This initiative is, by a country mile, the very best ting this government has done, probably in fact the only thing it has done well. Not just 'well' in the normal sense of good governance, but something beyond what you can normally expect governments to achieve. Not only has it put us in an excellent position in terms of Covid vaccine availability, but it has also positioned the UK extremely well for what will undoubtedly be a renewed world emphasis on vaccine technology and production. And it has done it super-fast.

    And how was it achieved? I find it awkward to admit this, but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Cummings was behind it. It has all the hallmarks of his approach: by-passing the cumbersome workings of the normal Civil Service approach and instead get a small, talented, goal-focused team to super-charge the initiative. Of course it's an approach with great risks, but in this case also with an even greater pay-off.

    Of course virtually the entire media coverage last year on the Vaccine Task Force was devoted to garbage about 'cronies' and 'sleaze'. The fact that this was a spectacular success was lost in the deluge of faux-indignation.

    We might owe Cummings an apology...

    As I mentioned last night, wasn’t some of the briefing against Bingham coming from within the No 10 Stavka?
    Oh, no doubt. He's a hell of a disruptive and unpleasant figure.
    I've looked through the hit pieces, and stuff like she's a disruptor and so forth seem - well that's how stuff had to get done.

    Can you work out what the PR contracts might have been about ? That's small beer to the overall success of the project but seemed a reasonable point from the hit pieces back in November.
    Greasing the wheels with various global drug companies perhaps ?
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,770
    I'm amazed vaccine wars took this long. I expected it the instant the first ones started.
  • Options
    SKS thinks that there’s nothing more essential than defending the Union. Never doubted it for a minute.

    https://twitter.com/rosscolquhoun/status/1354737588939194375?s=21
  • Options
    LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 15,268
    Yes, the government's performance on vaccinations is great. Taken in the round, when considering the investments made in development, it arguably merits the description of "world-leading".

    However, I do worry that, because the government made such a mess of other aspects of the pandemic - self-isolation, contact-tracing, quarantine - that we have now created the ideal conditions (a high infection rate and people with partial vaccine-acquired immunity) for the virus to mutate to evade the vaccine.

    Maybe we will get lucky. I certainly hope so.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,770

    Good morning everybody, from a slightly more positive OKC.

    "Increasingly bitter"????

    The BBC is reporting that
    'The EU and the UK-based Covid vaccine maker AstraZeneca have vowed to work together to resolve a bitter row over supply shortages to the 27-member bloc'

    It says bitter right in their report and as we know from Brexit saying something is constructive etc does not make it so, so denials of bitterness dont erase what has been said and alleged in recent days.
  • Options
    Northern_AlNorthern_Al Posts: 7,541

    I've been as enthusiastic at slagging off Dominic Cummings as the next man over the last year, but a thought occurred to me last night following our discussion here on the Vaccine Task Force. This initiative is, by a country mile, the very best ting this government has done, probably in fact the only thing it has done well. Not just 'well' in the normal sense of good governance, but something beyond what you can normally expect governments to achieve. Not only has it put us in an excellent position in terms of Covid vaccine availability, but it has also positioned the UK extremely well for what will undoubtedly be a renewed world emphasis on vaccine technology and production. And it has done it super-fast.

    And how was it achieved? I find it awkward to admit this, but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Cummings was behind it. It has all the hallmarks of his approach: by-passing the cumbersome workings of the normal Civil Service approach and instead get a small, talented, goal-focused team to super-charge the initiative. Of course it's an approach with great risks, but in this case also with an even greater pay-off.

    Of course virtually the entire media coverage last year on the Vaccine Task Force was devoted to garbage about 'cronies' and 'sleaze'. The fact that this was a spectacular success was lost in the deluge of faux-indignation.

    We might owe Cummings an apology...

    The ramping up of testing was actually quite similar - the existing organisational structure/management said that they couldn't expand beyond a few multiples. Which was taken to mean that mass testing was impossible, by the same people.

    Then the Lighthouse Labs project came in.
    The big mistake the government made with testing was they got from 10k to 100k with help of the man from Delmonte...then they sent him back and the pace of increase slowed. So they got caught short in the autumn....before refocusing again and real push for massive capacity.

    With vaccine roll out, they have to keep expanding capacity, no let up. There is a not insignificant chance that by the time we get through the population, we might well have to go round again with a new vaccine for all these mutate versions.
    Surely the big mistake with testing was the focus on the volume of tests to the exclusion of a similar focus on ensuring that those tested positive took self-isolation seriously, along with their (traced) contacts. The scaling up of testing was indeed magnificent, but it was not matched by the rigour to ensure self-isolation; most evidence shows only around 20% complied fully with self-isolation rules. The enforcement of self-isolation would have been better suited to local health teams than to the man from Delmonte, but there would have been no lucrative private sector contracts in this. And so the virus continued to spread despite all the testing.
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,680
    eek said:

    Of course the EU f##king up vaccine procurement is just the latest in a series of f##k ups, remember similar PPE and ventilator schemes suffering the same issues.

    When Czechia started to really struggle in the autumn they asked the EU for all the ventilators they could send from this scheme...they got 30.

    I think the difference is that last time it wasn't quite as visible to the general public as lack of vaccine appointments are.

    This is an interesting read on how the EU got themselves into the mess they are in https://www.politico.eu/article/europe-coronavirus-vaccine-struggle-pfizer-biontech-astrazeneca/

    Price and liability are not things to talk about when you need manufacturing capacity and rapid delivery.

    Capacity, speed and price are 3 sides of a triangle on which you can select only 2. And they picked the wrong one to insist upon (before being late to start the project in the first place).

    The more I read that article the more I'm surprised the EU have any vaccines at the moment in time.
    A delayed order, Bancel said, “is not going to limit the total amount, but it is going to slow down delivery."

    Do you think they've learned that yet?
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,125
    "Doh! It just get's worse and worse!"
This discussion has been closed.