politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Frontrunners Sanders and Warren get the edge in the latest Dem
Comments
-
I work in finance so the pot I am paid out of is essentially in USD. A weaker GBP as a result of Brexit means I will probably get paid more in GBP terms, and in real terms since a lot of my consumption basket is domestic services. Of course it is possible that Brexit is such a clusterfuck that I lose my job. I suspect that is more likely if Corbyn gets in, but I will still vote Labour because I think they will do more to help the less well off and I can probably look after myself.Byronic said:
Am I allowed to ask how Brexit will financially benefit you? Genuinely curious.
It's not that hard to see why Brexit was funded by many people in this sector, they are all short GBP by the nature of having USD revenues and GBP costs (plus they want more freedom to do whatever they want and think that is more likely outside of the EU). Bamford is similar, as I believe they sell mostly outside the EU and so the loss of market access issue is not such a problem for them, unlike the auto sector.0 -
She was a one world globalist. Trump would have thought she was the devil.HYUFD said:
Thatcher would been pro BrexitThe_Taxman said:
I was thinking the same just yesterday! They are also all against No Deal Brexit and certainly pre TM against any Brexit...stodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?0 -
The psychiatric wards are full of men who claim to be Napoleon, or who believe that Thatcher would have been pro-Brexit.HYUFD said:
Thatcher would been pro BrexitThe_Taxman said:
I was thinking the same just yesterday! They are also all against No Deal Brexit and certainly pre TM against any Brexit...stodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?0 -
Thatcher, Callaghan, Wilson, Heath, and Douglas-Home were all alive in 1995stodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?0 -
So age and wisdom gets the result.SouthamObserver said:
Because they voted Leave!!!Alanbrooke said:
why do you think jobs and the economy arrent important to older people ?noneoftheabove said:
The people in charge of society 10-15 years ago are the same people I am complaining about!! It was not up to me, my cohort or those younger than me who tended to vote remain, because jobs and the economy are important to our future.Alanbrooke said:
youre simply suffering the penalties for the mistakes made 10-15 years ago and which the people you vote for implemented. the Breo party has graped the nettle.noneoftheabove said:
How exactly? Pensio anything and nothing happens.Alanbrooke said:
then maybe you should have spent more time listening to the other demographics and you would have avoided the problem.noneoftheabove said:
If by middle classes you mean anyone working for a living then yes we have had enough of being squeezed further at the expense of those relying on state support, especially the demographic that is far richer than us, owns acres of land, voted for Brexit and now want us to fully compensate them for their loss in income from Brexit whilst our jobs become more risky and stressful.Alanbrooke said:
the middle classes are having a tantrum because the electorate is saying they doint like policies which only favour the middle classes.kinabalu said:
The peasants may well be revolting but so is middle England and the whole thing is led by the nobs.Alanbrooke said:the whole of Brexit was totally avoidable if UK politicans had not ignored large slices of the electorate. This is simply the modern version of the Peasants revolt.
To me, Brexit is above all a project of the reactionary right of politics. Its core appeal is to identity not economics - hence its power.
They are even planning to bring down the court system to stop paying a tv license they can perfectly well afford. How would that help law and order which they claim to care about?
Older people voted for Brexit for a wide range of reasons, but common to many is that the economic case was secondary to the emotional and political case.
-1 -
Fake news. The last occasion was 1995.HYUFD said:
Early 1980s, Macmilan, Home, Wilson, Heath, Callaghanstodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?0 -
@rcs1000 is a fine gentleman who makes many interesting YouTubes that I will one day watch and who kindly approves my articles, so I will not hear a word against him.Byronic said:
Simplistic. How does a Leaver like Rob Smithson, of this manor, fit into any of those categories?viewcode said:
If Goodwin is correct, Leave was a coalition between the poor, the retired, and wealthy social conservatives. Two by themselves is not enough, all three had to be present.HYUFD said:
The upper middle classes voted Remain and the lower middle classes were split, it was working class C2 and DE voters who won the referendum for Leavenoneoftheabove said:
If by middle classes you mean anyone working for a living then yes we have had enough of being squeezed further at the expense of those relying on state support, especially the demographic that is far richer than us, owns acres of land, voted for Brexit and now want us to fully compensate them for their loss in income from Brexit whilst our jobs become more risky and stressful.Alanbrooke said:
the middle classes are having a tantrum because the electorate is saying they doint like policies which only favour the middle classes.kinabalu said:
The peasants may well be revolting but so is middle England and the whole thing is led by the nobs.Alanbrooke said:the whole of Brexit was totally avoidable if UK politicans had not ignored large slices of the electorate. This is simply the modern version of the Peasants revolt.
To me, Brexit is above all a project of the reactionary right of politics. Its core appeal is to identity not economics - hence its power.
However if you do wish to complain about Goodwin's categories, Matthew Goodwin does have his own Twitter and I assume he would respond.0 -
The people I have supported lost the last 3 elections, they were certainly promising to do most of those things.Alanbrooke said:
I sincerely doubt Leave are the only people who have billionaires backing them, Remain based on the corporate vote have more than their fair share. As for the policies you support that;s fine, but the people you are supporting arent implementing them. Its just as easy to say you have been duped and lied to by well off corporatists.OnlyLivingBoy said:
That's bollocks. Your average middle class Remainer is much more concerned about the poor than the billionaire disaster capitalist funders of the Leave campaign, who simply saw them as useful idiots that could be convinced to vote for their project on the basis of xenophobia and lies. Look at the Dominic Cummings quote on the Tories, poor people and the NHS - the mask slipped for a second there. Stand by for turbocharged Thatcherism in the event of no deal - and a repeat of the increase in inequality that happened then.Alanbrooke said:
and didnt give a shit about themYBarddCwsc said:
There are very few "far richer than us", owning "acres of land". Not enough to account for 52 per cent of the Referendum vote.noneoftheabove said:
If by middle classe and stressful.Alanbrooke said:
the middle classes are having a tantrum because the electorate is saying they doint like policies which only favour the middle classes.kinabalu said:
The peasants may well be revolting but so is middle England and the whole thing is led by the nobs.Alanbrooke said:the whole of Brexit was totally avoidable if UK politicans had not ignored large slices of the electorate. This is simply the modern version of the Peasants revolt.
To me, Brexit is above all a project of the reactionary right of politics. Its core appeal is to identity not economics - hence its power.
To win the referendum, Leave had to get the votes of the poor.
Middle class remainers lost because they forgot how many poor people there are.
I have always supported policies to help the less well off, like a more generous safety net, better public services, more social housing, higher minimum wages and higher taxes on the better off to pay for it. Much more effective than scapegoating immigrants and trashing the economy.
Brexit will probably make me better off financially. So don't pretend that Remainers are all motivated by some kind of middle class self interest. I am anti Brexit because (a) I think it is a project designed to screw the poor and (b) I don't think liars should prosper.0 -
I can remember when MacMillan died in 1986. So back then we still presumably had him, Wilson, Heath, Sunny Jim and Douglas-Home as living pre-Thatcher former PMs.stodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?0 -
A Leaver relative of mine claimed, the other day, that the Brexit vote was “a vote against London” and I think she was on to something.SouthamObserver said:
The middle class in the South East largely voted Leave, didn't it?YBarddCwsc said:
Ebbw Vale is the main town in Blaenau Gwent, the most Leaver-y constituency in the country.noneoftheabove said:
I have no problem with those who voted leave who have been left out of the econony and society over the last 20 years and unlike others I dont think they will be the worst hit by Brexit. An orderly Brexit need not even be a disaster but no deal will be.
I do have a problem with those who have benefitted enormously through their life with free university education, opportunities to work and live abroad, generous final salary pensions, govt led asset boom boosted further by QE and govt subsidies, then wanting to take all of those opportunities, to study, to build up assets, to have a secure retirement, to be able to work and live abroad away from the next generations because of how they feel.
It is hard to find somewhere there with GCSEs, let alone BAs and MAs from a "free university education."
It is hard to find someone who enjoyed "working and living abroad" (like so many of the Remainers). Many in Ebbw Vale will have never been abroad at all.
It is hard to find someone with any assets. They are the people that prominent Remainers on this board (Gardenwalker) sneeringly refer to as living in "Valleys dunghills".
The problems in our country have been building for many, many years.
The Referendum simply and finally and irrevocably brought the problems to the attention of the middle class in the South East, who have largely been immune from such matters.
Out of interest, what percentage of the 16 million plus Remain voters do you think have lived and worked abroad?
For decades non-Londoners have had to sit there and grin as Londoners got obscenely wealthy simply by owning London property. Brexit was, in part, a howl of outrage at the unfairness.0 -
I take it you live in London\South East ?OnlyLivingBoy said:
I work in finance so the pot I am paid out of is essentially in USD. A weaker GBP as a result of Brexit means I will probably get paid more in GBP terms, and in real terms since a lot of my consumption basket is domestic services. Of course it is possible that Brexit is such a clusterfuck that I lose my job. I suspect that is more likely if Corbyn gets in, but I will still vote Labour because I think they will do more to help the less well off and I can probably look after myself.Byronic said:
Am I allowed to ask how Brexit will financially benefit you? Genuinely curious.
It's not that hard to see why Brexit was funded by many people in this sector, they are all short GBP by the nature of having USD revenues and GBP costs (plus they want more freedom to do whatever they want and think that is more likely outside of the EU). Bamford is similar, as I believe they sell mostly outside the EU and so the loss of market access issue is not such a problem for them, unlike the auto sector.0 -
Age, for sure. As for wisdom, we'll see. The first three years of our Brexit journey have not exactly been triumphant.Alanbrooke said:
So age and wisdom gets the result.SouthamObserver said:
Because they voted Leave!!!Alanbrooke said:
why do you think jobs and the economy arrent important to older people ?noneoftheabove said:
The people in charge of society 10-15 years ago are the same people I am complaining about!! It was not up to me, my cohort or those younger than me who tended to vote remain, because jobs and the economy are important to our future.Alanbrooke said:
youre simply suffering the penalties for the mistakes made 10-15 years ago and which the people you vote for implemented. the Breo party has graped the nettle.noneoftheabove said:
How exactly? Pensio anything and nothing happens.Alanbrooke said:
then maybe you should have spent more time listening to the other demographics and you would have avoided the problem.noneoftheabove said:
If by middle classes you mean anyone working for a living then yes we have had enough of being squeezed further at the expense of those relying on state support, especially the demographic that is far richer than us, owns acres of land, voted for Brexit and now want us to fully compensate them for their loss in income from Brexit whilst our jobs become more risky and stressful.Alanbrooke said:
the middle classes are having a tantrum because the electorate is saying they doint like policies which only favour the middle classes.kinabalu said:
The peasants may well be revolting but so is middle England and the whole thing is led by the nobs.Alanbrooke said:the whole of Brexit was totally avoidable if UK politicans had not ignored large slices of the electorate. This is simply the modern version of the Peasants revolt.
To me, Brexit is above all a project of the reactionary right of politics. Its core appeal is to identity not economics - hence its power.
They are even planning to bring down the court system to stop paying a tv license they can perfectly well afford. How would that help law and order which they claim to care about?
Older people voted for Brexit for a wide range of reasons, but common to many is that the economic case was secondary to the emotional and political case.
-
0 -
-
Yes. To the poor, the retired, and the wealthy social conservatives, we must add the ideological libertarians, the disaster capitalists, and the pound speculators.OnlyLivingBoy said:
I work in finance so the pot I am paid out of is essentially in USD. A weaker GBP as a result of Brexit means I will probably get paid more in GBP terms, and in real terms since a lot of my consumption basket is domestic services. Of course it is possible that Brexit is such a clusterfuck that I lose my job. I suspect that is more likely if Corbyn gets in, but I will still vote Labour because I think they will do more to help the less well off and I can probably look after myself.Byronic said:
Am I allowed to ask how Brexit will financially benefit you? Genuinely curious.
It's not that hard to see why Brexit was funded by many people in this sector, they are all short GBP by the nature of having USD revenues and GBP costs (plus they want more freedom to do whatever they want and think that is more likely outside of the EU). Bamford is similar, as I believe they sell mostly outside the EU and so the loss of market access issue is not such a problem for them, unlike the auto sector.
These last three are too small to represent clear demographic groupings, and certainly too small to be polled, but they appear to be largely driving Brexit now.0 -
you forgot about the JewsGardenwalker said:
Yes. To the poor, the retired, and the wealthy social conservatives, we must add the ideological libertarians, the disaster capitalists, and the pound speculators.OnlyLivingBoy said:
I work in finance so the pot I am paid out of is essentially in USD. A weaker GBP as a result of Brexit means I will probably get paid more in GBP terms, and in real terms since a lot of my consumption basket is domestic services. Of course it is possible that Brexit is such a clusterfuck that I lose my job. I suspect that is more likely if Corbyn gets in, but I will still vote Labour because I think they will do more to help the less well off and I can probably look after myself.Byronic said:
Am I allowed to ask how Brexit will financially benefit you? Genuinely curious.
It's not that hard to see why Brexit was funded by many people in this sector, they are all short GBP by the nature of having USD revenues and GBP costs (plus they want more freedom to do whatever they want and think that is more likely outside of the EU). Bamford is similar, as I believe they sell mostly outside the EU and so the loss of market access issue is not such a problem for them, unlike the auto sector.
These last three are too small to represent clear demographic groupings, and certainly too small to be polled, but they appear to be largely driving Brexit now.1 -
My username should give a clueAlanbrooke said:
Then you need to vote for people who would change that.noneoftheabove said:
I have no problem with those who voted leave who have been left out of the econony and society over the last 20 years and unlike others I dont think they will be the worst hit by Brexit. An orderly Brexit need not even be a disaster but no deal will be.YBarddCwsc said:
There are very few "far richer than us", owning "acres of land". Not enough to account for 52 per cent of the Referendum vote.noneoftheabove said:
If by middle classes you mean anyone working for a living then yes we have had enough of being squeezed further at the expense of those relying on state support, especially the demographic that is far richer than us, owns acres of land, voted for Brexit and now want us to fully compensate them for their loss in income from Brexit whilst our jobs become more risky and stressful.Alanbrooke said:
the middle classes are having a tantrum because the electorate is saying they doint like policies which only favour the middle classes.kinabalu said:
The peasants may well be revolting but so is middle England and the whole thing is led by the nobs.Alanbrooke said:the whole of Brexit was totally avoidable if UK politicans had not ignored large slices of the electorate. This is simply the modern version of the Peasants revolt.
To me, Brexit is above all a project of the reactionary right of politics. Its core appeal is to identity not economics - hence its power.
To win the referendum, Leave had to get the votes of the poor.
Middle class remainers lost because they forgot how many poor people there are.
I do have a problem with those who have benefitted enormously through their life with free university education, opportunities to work and live abroad, generous final salary pensions, govt led asset boom boosted further by QE and govt subsidies, then wanting to take all of those opportunities, to study, to build up assets, to have a secure retirement, to be able to work and live abroad away from the next generations because of how they feel.
can you point out who they are, Id like to vote for them too ?0 -
The interesting point is what sort of Brexit in that case would she have been in favour of executing? I suspect given her involvement in creating the Single Market she might have wanted to have stayed a member of that. One can only speculate of course but I think she would have wanted out of the political structures. I wonder if she would have gone for the Customs Union as well? Sadly she was not in command of her faculties in the closing part of her life. I always remember her taking the oath in the H of L in her last few years and she did not seem well at all...HYUFD said:
Thatcher would been pro BrexitThe_Taxman said:
I was thinking the same just yesterday! They are also all against No Deal Brexit and certainly pre TM against any Brexit...stodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?
0 -
What proportion of Londoners are born and bred in London?Byronic said:
A Leaver relative of mine claimed, the other day, that the Brexit vote was “a vote against London” and I think she was on to something.SouthamObserver said:
The middle class in the South East largely voted Leave, didn't it?YBarddCwsc said:
Ebbw Vale is the main town in Blaenau Gwent, the most Leaver-y constituency in the country.noneoftheabove said:
I have no problem with those who voted leave who have been left out of the econony and society over the last 20 years and unlike others I dont think they will be the worst hit by Brexit. An orderly Brexit need not even be a disaster but no deal will be.
I do have a problem with those who have benefitted enormously through their life with free university education, opportunities to work and live abroad, generous final salary pensions, govt led asset boom boosted further by QE and govt subsidies, then wanting to take all of those opportunities, to study, to build up assets, to have a secure retirement, to be able to work and live abroad away from the next generations because of how they feel.
It is hard to find somewhere there with GCSEs, let alone BAs and MAs from a "free university education."
It is hard to find someone who enjoyed "working and living abroad" (like so many of the Remainers). Many in Ebbw Vale will have never been abroad at all.
It is hard to find someone with any assets. They are the people that prominent Remainers on this board (Gardenwalker) sneeringly refer to as living in "Valleys dunghills".
The problems in our country have been building for many, many years.
The Referendum simply and finally and irrevocably brought the problems to the attention of the middle class in the South East, who have largely been immune from such matters.
Out of interest, what percentage of the 16 million plus Remain voters do you think have lived and worked abroad?
For decades non-Londoners have had to sit there and grin as Londoners got obscenely wealthy simply by owning London property. Brexit was, in part, a howl of outrage at the unfairness.
Many of us, like Norman Tebbit’s father, “got on our bikes”.0 -
Londoners like Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn have got extremely wealthy on the back of property. That does not apply to most Londoners, though. The London reality is very different to the London perception. But I do agree that the perception is widely held.Byronic said:
A Leaver relative of mine claimed, the other day, that the Brexit vote was “a vote against London” and I think she was on to something.SouthamObserver said:
The middle class in the South East largely voted Leave, didn't it?YBarddCwsc said:
Ebbw Vale is the main town in Blaenau Gwent, the most Leaver-y constituency in the country.noneoftheabove said:
I have no problem with those who voted leave who have been left out of the econony and society over the last 20 years and unlike others I dont think they will be the worst hit by Brexit. An orderly Brexit need not even be a disaster but no deal will be.
I do have a problem with those who have benefitted enormously through their life with free university education, opportunities to work and live abroad, generous final salary pensions, govt led asset boom boosted further by QE and govt subsidies, then wanting to take all of those opportunities, to study, to build up assets, to have a secure retirement, to be able to work and live abroad away from the next generations because of how they feel.
It is hard to find somewhere there with GCSEs, let alone BAs and MAs from a "free university education."
It is hard to find someone who enjoyed "working and living abroad" (like so many of the Remainers). Many in Ebbw Vale will have never been abroad at all.
It is hard to find someone with any assets. They are the people that prominent Remainers on this board (Gardenwalker) sneeringly refer to as living in "Valleys dunghills".
The problems in our country have been building for many, many years.
The Referendum simply and finally and irrevocably brought the problems to the attention of the middle class in the South East, who have largely been immune from such matters.
Out of interest, what percentage of the 16 million plus Remain voters do you think have lived and worked abroad?
For decades non-Londoners have had to sit there and grin as Londoners got obscenely wealthy simply by owning London property. Brexit was, in part, a howl of outrage at the unfairness.
0 -
Very interesting. Thanks. I don’t believe leavers are quite as selfishly scheming as all that, but it’s an intriguing perspectiveOnlyLivingBoy said:
I work in finance so the pot I am paid out of is essentially in USD. A weaker GBP as a result of Brexit means I will probably get paid more in GBP terms, and in real terms since a lot of my consumption basket is domestic services. Of course it is possible that Brexit is such a clusterfuck that I lose my job. I suspect that is more likely if Corbyn gets in, but I will still vote Labour because I think they will do more to help the less well off and I can probably look after myself.Byronic said:
Am I allowed to ask how Brexit will financially benefit you? Genuinely curious.
It's not that hard to see why Brexit was funded by many people in this sector, they are all short GBP by the nature of having USD revenues and GBP costs (plus they want more freedom to do whatever they want and think that is more likely outside of the EU). Bamford is similar, as I believe they sell mostly outside the EU and so the loss of market access issue is not such a problem for them, unlike the auto sector.0 -
You should be able to tell exactly where I live from my name on here, unless you are unaware of the work of CarterUSM!Alanbrooke said:
I take it you live in London\South East ?OnlyLivingBoy said:
I work in finance so the pot I am paid out of is essentially in USD. A weaker GBP as a result of Brexit means I will probably get paid more in GBP terms, and in real terms since a lot of my consumption basket is domestic services. Of course it is possible that Brexit is such a clusterfuck that I lose my job. I suspect that is more likely if Corbyn gets in, but I will still vote Labour because I think they will do more to help the less well off and I can probably look after myself.Byronic said:
Am I allowed to ask how Brexit will financially benefit you? Genuinely curious.
It's not that hard to see why Brexit was funded by many people in this sector, they are all short GBP by the nature of having USD revenues and GBP costs (plus they want more freedom to do whatever they want and think that is more likely outside of the EU). Bamford is similar, as I believe they sell mostly outside the EU and so the loss of market access issue is not such a problem for them, unlike the auto sector.
I am not from London and the South East though.0 -
No she wasn't, she backed the common market but post Bruges Group speech became increasingly anti EC and anti EU, hence why she backed IDS over Ken Clarke in 2001 when Major and Heath backed Clarkewilliamglenn said:
She was a one world globalist. Trump would have thought she was the devil.HYUFD said:
Thatcher would been pro BrexitThe_Taxman said:
I was thinking the same just yesterday! They are also all against No Deal Brexit and certainly pre TM against any Brexit...stodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?0 -
I resent the implication.Alanbrooke said:
you forgot about the JewsGardenwalker said:
Yes. To the poor, the retired, and the wealthy social conservatives, we must add the ideological libertarians, the disaster capitalists, and the pound speculators.OnlyLivingBoy said:
I work in finance so the pot I am paid out of is essentially in USD. A weaker GBP as a result of Brexit means I will probably get paid more in GBP terms, and in real terms since a lot of my consumption basket is domestic services. Of course it is possible that Brexit is such a clusterfuck that I lose my job. I suspect that is more likely if Corbyn gets in, but I will still vote Labour because I think they will do more to help the less well off and I can probably look after myself.Byronic said:
Am I allowed to ask how Brexit will financially benefit you? Genuinely curious.
It's not that hard to see why Brexit was funded by many people in this sector, they are all short GBP by the nature of having USD revenues and GBP costs (plus they want more freedom to do whatever they want and think that is more likely outside of the EU). Bamford is similar, as I believe they sell mostly outside the EU and so the loss of market access issue is not such a problem for them, unlike the auto sector.
These last three are too small to represent clear demographic groupings, and certainly too small to be polled, but they appear to be largely driving Brexit now.0 -
Mrs Thatcher would probably have favoured something like the Cameron deal (if you can call it that): in the EU for the single market but with various opt-outs from the rest.HYUFD said:
Thatcher would been pro BrexitThe_Taxman said:
I was thinking the same just yesterday! They are also all against No Deal Brexit and certainly pre TM against any Brexit...stodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?
Mrs Thatcher grew up politically in the 1960s when Britain was not prospering outside the EEC, far from it, and was desperate to join. Mrs Thatcher might not have been keen on the social chapter but she helped create the single market.
Mrs Thatcher was not a Brexiteer.0 -
Ha ha how charmingly naive.Byronic said:
Very interesting. Thanks. I don’t believe leavers are quite as selfishly scheming as all that, but it’s an intriguing perspectiveOnlyLivingBoy said:
I work in finance so the pot I am paid out of is essentially in USD. A weaker GBP as a result of Brexit means I will probably get paid more in GBP terms, and in real terms since a lot of my consumption basket is domestic services. Of course it is possible that Brexit is such a clusterfuck that I lose my job. I suspect that is more likely if Corbyn gets in, but I will still vote Labour because I think they will do more to help the less well off and I can probably look after myself.Byronic said:
Am I allowed to ask how Brexit will financially benefit you? Genuinely curious.
It's not that hard to see why Brexit was funded by many people in this sector, they are all short GBP by the nature of having USD revenues and GBP costs (plus they want more freedom to do whatever they want and think that is more likely outside of the EU). Bamford is similar, as I believe they sell mostly outside the EU and so the loss of market access issue is not such a problem for them, unlike the auto sector.0 -
Not entirely as we are still leaving the single market and ending free movementGardenwalker said:
Yes. To the poor, the retired, and the wealthy social conservatives, we must add the ideological libertarians, the disaster capitalists, and the pound speculators.OnlyLivingBoy said:
I work in finance so the pot I am paid out of is essentially in USD. A weaker GBP as a result of Brexit means I will probably get paid more in GBP terms, and in real terms since a lot of my consumption basket is domestic services. Of course it is possible that Brexit is such a clusterfuck that I lose my job. I suspect that is more likely if Corbyn gets in, but I will still vote Labour because I think they will do more to help the less well off and I can probably look after myself.Byronic said:
Am I allowed to ask how Brexit will financially benefit you? Genuinely curious.
It's not that hard to see why Brexit was funded by many people in this sector, they are all short GBP by the nature of having USD revenues and GBP costs (plus they want more freedom to do whatever they want and think that is more likely outside of the EU). Bamford is similar, as I believe they sell mostly outside the EU and so the loss of market access issue is not such a problem for them, unlike the auto sector.
These last three are too small to represent clear demographic groupings, and certainly too small to be polled, but they appear to be largely driving Brexit now.0 -
it has simply highlighted how utterly useless our political class is at present. It strikes me that if the same people are so bad at managing Europe now, then just how bad were their decisions over the last 40 years ?SouthamObserver said:
Age, for sure. As for wisdom, we'll see. The first three years of our Brexit journey have not exactly been triumphant.Alanbrooke said:
So age and wisdom gets the result.SouthamObserver said:
Because they voted Leave!!!Alanbrooke said:
why do you think jobs and the economy arrent important to older people ?noneoftheabove said:
The people in charge of society 10-15 ye important to our future.Alanbrooke said:
youre simply suffering the penalties for the mistakes made 10-15 years ago and which the people you vote for implemented. the Breo party has graped the nettle.noneoftheabove said:
How exactly? Pensio anything and nothing happens.Alanbrooke said:
then maybe you should have spent more time listening to the other demographics and you would have avoided the problem.noneoftheabove said:
If by middle classesand stressful.Alanbrooke said:
the middle classes are having a tantrum because the electorate is saying they doint like policies which only favour the middle classes.kinabalu said:
The peasants may well be revolting but so is middle England and the whole thing is led by the nobs.Alanbrooke said:the whole of Brexit was totally avoidable if UK politicans had not ignored large slices of the electorate. This is simply the modern version of the Peasants revolt.
To me, Brexit is above all a project of the reactionary right of politics. Its core appeal is to identity not economics - hence its power.
They are even planning to bring down the court system to stop paying a tv license they can perfectly well afford. How would that help law and order which they claim to care about?
Older people voted for Brexit for a wide range of reasons, but common to many is that the economic case was secondary to the emotional and political case.
-0 -
YBarddCwsc said:
Ebbw Vale is the main town in Blaenau Gwent, the most Leaver-y constituency in the country.noneoftheabove said:
I have no problem with those who voted leave who have been left out of the econony and society over the last 20 years and unlike others I dont think they will be the worst hit by Brexit. An orderly Brexit need not even be a disaster but no deal will be.
I do have a problem with those who have benefitted enormously through their life with free university education, opportunities to work and live abroad, generous final salary pensions, govt led asset boom boosted further by QE and govt subsidies, then wanting to take all of those opportunities, to study, to build up assets, to have a secure retirement, to be able to work and live abroad away from the next generations because of how they feel.
It is hard to find somewhere there with GCSEs, let alone BAs and MAs from a "free university education."
It is hard to find someone who enjoyed "working and living abroad" (like so many of the Remainers). Many in Ebbw Vale will have never been abroad at all.
It is hard to find someone with any assets. They are the people that prominent Remainers on this board (Gardenwalker) sneeringly refer to as living in "Valleys dunghills".
The problems in our country have been building for many, many years.
The Referendum simply and finally and irrevocably brought the problems to the attention of the middle class in the South East, who have largely been immune from such matters.
I said I have no problem with the left behind who voted for brexit. In other parts of the country there are millions of the lifestyle I have described that did vote for brexit.0 -
Also 1923-24: Bonar Law, Lloyd George, Asquith, Balfour, RoseberyHYUFD said:
Early 1980s, Macmilan, Home, Wilson, Heath, Callaghanstodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?
Granted that's not especially 'recent times.'
In 1964-65 Churchill, Attlee, Eden, Macmillan and Home were all still alive.
So it's not that uncommon.
A rarer event is only one former PM left alive. March-July 1945 (Baldwin only) 1896-1902 and again from 1902-1905 (Rosebery only) 1881-1885 (no Prime Minister living other than Gladstone) 1878-80 (Gladstone only) but after that I really begin to struggle.0 -
And before Eden died in 1977 there were also 5 -Eden, MacMillan, Home, Wilson & Heath.Stark_Dawning said:
I can remember when MacMillan died in 1986. So back then we still presumably had him, Wilson, Heath, Sunny Jim and Douglas-Home as living pre-Thatcher former PMs.stodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?
Though we did not have 5 in good health in either 1977 or 1986 - Eden was not well, arguably, even when he was PM, and Wilson was suffering from dementia by 1986 even though he lived until 1995.0 -
and will get on your bikes again to get out of the dump and live somewhere else in a real sized house.Gardenwalker said:
What proportion of Londoners are born and bred in London?Byronic said:
A Leaver relative of mine claimed, the other day, that the Brexit vote was “a vote against London” and I think she was on to something.SouthamObserver said:
The middle class in the South East largely voted Leave, didn't it?YBarddCwsc said:
Ebbw Vale is the main town in Blaenau Gwent, the most Leaver-y constituency in the country.noneoftheabove said:
I have no problem with those who voted leave who have been left out of the econony and society over the last 20 years and unlike others I dont think they will be the worst hit by Brexit. An orderly Brexit need not even be a disaster but no deal will be.
I do have a problem with those who have benefitted enormously through their life with free university education, opportunities to work and live abroad, generous final salary pensions, govt led asset boom boosted further by QE and govt subsidies, then wanting to take all of those opportunities, to study, to build up assets, to have a secure retirement, to be able to work and live abroad away from the next generations because of how they feel.
It is hard to find somewhere there with GCSEs, let alone BAs and MAs from a "free university education."
It is hard to find someone who enjoyed "working and living abroad" (like so many of the Remainers). Many in Ebbw Vale will have never been abroad at all.
It is hard to find someone with any assets. They are the people that prominent Remainers on this board (Gardenwalker) sneeringly refer to as living in "Valleys dunghills".
The problems in our country have been building for many, many years.
The Referendum simply and finally and irrevocably brought the problems to the attention of the middle class in the South East, who have largely been immune from such matters.
Out of interest, what percentage of the 16 million plus Remain voters do you think have lived and worked abroad?
For decades non-Londoners have had to sit there and grin as Londoners got obscenely wealthy simply by owning London property. Brexit was, in part, a howl of outrage at the unfairness.
Many of us, like Norman Tebbit’s father, “got on our bikes”.0 -
would it have been better if I said the Welsh ?Gardenwalker said:
I resent the implication.Alanbrooke said:
you forgot about the JewsGardenwalker said:
Yes. To the poor, the retired, and the wealthy social conservatives, we must add the ideological libertarians, the disaster capitalists, and the pound speculators.OnlyLivingBoy said:
I work in finance so the pot I am paid out of is essentially in USD. A weaker GBP as a result of Brexit means I will probably get paid more in GBP terms, and in real terms since a lot of my consumption basket is domestic services. Of course it is possible that Brexit is such a clusterfuck that I lose my job. I suspect that is more likely if Corbyn gets in, but I will still vote Labour because I think they will do more to help the less well off and I can probably look after myself.Byronic said:
Am I allowed to ask how Brexit will financially benefit you? Genuinely curious.
It's not that hard to see why Brexit was funded by many people in this sector, they are all short GBP by the nature of having USD revenues and GBP costs (plus they want more freedom to do whatever they want and think that is more likely outside of the EU). Bamford is similar, as I believe they sell mostly outside the EU and so the loss of market access issue is not such a problem for them, unlike the auto sector.
These last three are too small to represent clear demographic groupings, and certainly too small to be polled, but they appear to be largely driving Brexit now.0 -
She was as she was anti EU and opposed the Maaastricht Treaty, she backed the single market before it included free movement from Eastern Europe and so many ECJ regulations, she would have been happy with the Canada style FTA Boris wants with the EUDecrepitJohnL said:
Mrs Thatcher would probably have favoured something like the Cameron deal (if you can call it that): in the EU for the single market but with various opt-outs from the rest.HYUFD said:
Thatcher would been pro BrexitThe_Taxman said:
I was thinking the same just yesterday! They are also all against No Deal Brexit and certainly pre TM against any Brexit...stodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?
Mrs Thatcher grew up politically in the 1960s when Britain was not prospering out side the EEC, far from it, and was desperate to join. Mrs Thatcher might not have been keen on the social chapter but she helped create the single market.
Mrs Thatcher was not a Brexiteer.0 -
So she would have been a Brexiteers once senility had begun to set in. Thanks for making that clear. Interesting that you personally didn’t find the arguments quite so compelling though.HYUFD said:
No she wasn't, she backed the common market but post Bruges Group speech became increasingly anti EC and anti EU, hence why she backed IDS over Ken Clarke in 2001 when Major and Heath backed Clarkewilliamglenn said:
She was a one world globalist. Trump would have thought she was the devil.HYUFD said:
Thatcher would been pro BrexitThe_Taxman said:
I was thinking the same just yesterday! They are also all against No Deal Brexit and certainly pre TM against any Brexit...stodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?
0 -
NEW THREAD
0 -
Yes. Increasingly my peer set are looking for options to take their talents (and tax) away from the U.K.Alanbrooke said:
and will get on your bikes again to get out of the dump and live somewhere else in a real sized house.Gardenwalker said:
What proportion of Londoners are born and bred in London?Byronic said:
A Leaver relative of mine claimed, the other day, that the Brexit vote was “a vote against London” and I think she was on to something.SouthamObserver said:
The middle class in the South East largely voted Leave, didn't it?YBarddCwsc said:
Ebbw Vale is the main town in Blaenau Gwent, the most Leaver-y constituency in the country.noneoftheabove said:
I have no problem with those who voted leave who have been left out of the econony and society over the last 20 years and unlike others I dont think they will be the worst hit by Brexit. An orderly Brexit need not even be a disaster but no deal will be.
I do have a problem with those who have benefitted enormously through their life with free university education, opportunities to work and live abroad, generous final salary pensions, govt led asset boom boosted further by QE and govt subsidies, then wanting to take all of those opportunities, to study, to build up assets, to have a secure retirement, to be able to work and live abroad away from the next generations because of how they feel.
It is hard to find somewhere there with GCSEs, let alone BAs and MAs from a "free university education."
It is hard to find someone who enjoyed "working and living abroad" (like so many of the Remainers). Many in Ebbw Vale will have never been abroad at all.
It is hard to find someone with any assets. They are the people that prominent Remainers on this board (Gardenwalker) sneeringly refer to as living in "Valleys dunghills".
The problems in our country have been building for many, many years.
The Referendum simply and finally and irrevocably brought the problems to the attention of the middle class in the South East, who have largely been immune from such matters.
Out of interest, what percentage of the 16 million plus Remain voters do you think have lived and worked abroad?
For decades non-Londoners have had to sit there and grin as Londoners got obscenely wealthy simply by owning London property. Brexit was, in part, a howl of outrage at the unfairness.
Many of us, like Norman Tebbit’s father, “got on our bikes”.0 -
That might be the case if I didn’t personally KNOW a fair selection of Leave donors and politicians.OnlyLivingBoy said:
Ha ha how charmingly naive.Byronic said:
Very interesting. Thanks. I don’t believe leavers are quite as selfishly scheming as all that, but it’s an intriguing perspectiveOnlyLivingBoy said:
I work in finance so the pot I am paid out of is essentially in USD. A weaker GBP as a result of Brexit means I will probably get paid more in GBP terms, and in real terms since a lot of my consumption basket is domestic services. Of course it is possible that Brexit is such a clusterfuck that I lose my job. I suspect that is more likely if Corbyn gets in, but I will still vote Labour because I think they will do more to help the less well off and I can probably look after myself.Byronic said:
Am I allowed to ask how Brexit will financially benefit you? Genuinely curious.
It's not that hard to see why Brexit was funded by many people in this sector, they are all short GBP by the nature of having USD revenues and GBP costs (plus they want more freedom to do whatever they want and think that is more likely outside of the EU). Bamford is similar, as I believe they sell mostly outside the EU and so the loss of market access issue is not such a problem for them, unlike the auto sector.
They might be horribly misguided, there might be secondary hopes for personal gain, but they all genuinely believe a self governing Britain will ultimately do better outside the EU0 -
More to the point, why don't older people think jobs and the economy aren't important?Alanbrooke said:
why do you think jobs and the economy arrent important to older people ?noneoftheabove said:
The people in charge of society 10-15 years ago are the same people I am complaining about!! It was not up to me, my cohort or those younger than me who tended to vote remain, because jobs and the economy are important to our future.Alanbrooke said:
youre simply suffering the penalties for the mistakes made 10-15 years ago and which the people you vote for implemented. the Breo party has graped the nettle.noneoftheabove said:
How exactly? Pensioners have never been richer, yet they want to trash the economy? They have a triple lock, own a bigger a share of assets than ever before, own huge stocks of residential housing which those working and under 50 have to rent from them as well as pay their taxes. What else should we have done to improve the lives of pensioners further? If we try to fund care properly, as govts have flirted with, pensioners go up in arms over them paying anything and nothing happens.Alanbrooke said:
then maybe you should have spent more time listening to the other demographics and you would have avoided the problem.noneoftheabove said:
If by middle classes you mean anyone working for a living then yes we have had enough of being squeezed further at the expense of those relying on state support, especially the demographic that is far richer than us, owns acres of land, voted for Brexit and now want us to fully compensate them for their loss in income from Brexit whilst our jobs become more risky and stressful.Alanbrooke said:
the middle classes are having a tantrum because the electorate is saying they doint like policies which only favour the middle classes.kinabalu said:
The peasants may well be revolting but so is middle England and the whole thing is led by the nobs.Alanbrooke said:the whole of Brexit was totally avoidable if UK politicans had not ignored large slices of the electorate. This is simply the modern version of the Peasants revolt.
To me, Brexit is above all a project of the reactionary right of politics. Its core appeal is to identity not economics - hence its power.
They are even planning to bring down the court system to stop paying a tv license they can perfectly well afford. How would that help law and order which they claim to care about?
Older people voted for Brexit for a wide range of reasons, but common to many is that the economic case was secondary to the emotional and political case.
-0 -
Project fear fails again. The pound was only the second weakest currency last year.
https://twitter.com/EdConwaySky/status/11558776274183700490 -
May 1995 prior to Harold Wilson's death when we hadstodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?
Harold Wilson
Alec Douglas-Home
James Callaghan
Edward Heath
Margaret Thatcher.0 -
thats the thing with hot money, it never stays putGardenwalker said:
Yes. Increasingly my peer set are looking for options to take their talents (and tax) away from the U.K.Alanbrooke said:
and will get on your bikes again to get out of the dump and live somewhere else in a real sized house.Gardenwalker said:
What proportion of Londoners are born and bred in London?Byronic said:
A Leaver relative of mine claimed, the other day, that the Brexit vote was “a vote against London” and I think she was on to something.SouthamObserver said:
The middle class in the South East largely voted Leave, didn't it?YBarddCwsc said:
Ebbw Vale is the main town in Blaenau Gwent, the most Leaver-y constituency in the country.noneoftheabove said:
I have no problem with those who voted leave who have been left out of the econony and society over the last 20 years and unlike others I dont think they will be the worst hit by Brexit. An orderly Brexit need not even be a disaster but no deal will be.
I do have a problem with those who have benefitted enormously through their life with free university education, opportunities to work and live abroad, generous final salary pensions, govt led asset boom boosted further by QE and govt subsidies, then wanting to take all of those opportunities, to study, to build up assets, to have a secure retirement, to be able to work and live abroad away from the next generations because of how they feel.
It is hard to find somewhere there with GCSEs, let alone BAs and MAs from a "free university education."
It is hard to find someone who enjoyed "working and living abroad" (like so many of the Remainers). Many in Ebbw Vale will have never been abroad at all.
It is hard to find someone with any assets. They are the people that prominent Remainers on this board (Gardenwalker) sneeringly refer to as living in "Valleys dunghills".
The problems in our country have been building for many, many years.
The Referendum simply and finally and irrevocably brought the problems to the attention of the middle class in the South East, who have largely been immune from such matters.
Out of interest, what percentage of the 16 million plus Remain voters do you think have lived and worked abroad?
For decades non-Londoners have had to sit there and grin as Londoners got obscenely wealthy simply by owning London property. Brexit was, in part, a howl of outrage at the unfairness.
Many of us, like Norman Tebbit’s father, “got on our bikes”.0 -
Ive yet to meet an oldie in that categoryRecidivist said:
More to the point, why don't older people think jobs and the economy aren't important?Alanbrooke said:
why do you think jobs and the economy arrent important to older people ?noneoftheabove said:
The people in charge of society 10- to our future.Alanbrooke said:
youre simply suffering the penalties for the mistakes made 10-15 years ago and which the people you vote for implemented. the Breo party has graped the nettle.noneoftheabove said:
How exactly? Pensioners have never been richer, yet they want to trash the economy? They have a triple lock, own a bigger a share of assets than ever before, own huge stocks of residential housing which those working and under 50 have to rent from them as well as pay their taxes. What else should we have done to improve the lives of pensioners further? If we try to fund care properly, as govts have flirted with, pensioners go up in arms over them paying anything and nothing happens.Alanbrooke said:
then maybe you should have spent more time listening to the other demographics and you would have avoided the problem.noneoftheabove said:
If by middle classes you mean anyone working for a living then yes we have had enough of being squeezed further at the expense of those relying on state support, especially the demographic that is far richer than us, owns acres of land, voted for Brexit and now want us to fully compensate them for their loss in income from Brexit whilst our jobs become more risky and stressful.Alanbrooke said:
the middle classes are having a tantrum because the electorate is saying they doint like policies which only favour the middle classes.kinabalu said:
The peasants may well be revolting but so is middle England and the whole thing is led by the nobs.Alanbrooke said:the whole of Brexit was totally avoidable if UK politicans had not ignored large slices of the electorate. This is simply the modern version of the Peasants revolt.
To me, Brexit is above all a project of the reactionary right of politics. Its core appeal is to identity not economics - hence its power.
They are even planning to bring down the court system to stop paying a tv license they can perfectly well afford. How would that help law and order which they claim to care about?
Older people voted for Brexit for a wide range of reasons, but common to many is that the economic case was secondary to the emotional and political case.
-0 -
But that wealth has been gained mainly by older people living in London at the expense of younger people who live or want to live in London. If you have no intention of ever living in London, which presumably the London haterz don't, then it's kind of dumb of them to resent it. In fact it is people like me - who live in an expensive London house that they actually had to pay for - who should be most pissed off!Byronic said:
A Leaver relative of mine claimed, the other day, that the Brexit vote was “a vote against London” and I think she was on to something.SouthamObserver said:
The middle class in the South East largely voted Leave, didn't it?YBarddCwsc said:
Ebbw Vale is the main town in Blaenau Gwent, the most Leaver-y constituency in the country.noneoftheabove said:
I have no problem with those who voted leave who have been left out of the econony and society over the last 20 years and unlike others I dont think they will be the worst hit by Brexit. An orderly Brexit need not even be a disaster but no deal will be.
I do have a problem with those who have benefitted enormously through their life with free university education, opportunities to work and live abroad, generous final salary pensions, govt led asset boom boosted further by QE and govt subsidies, then wanting to take all of those opportunities, to study, to build up assets, to have a secure retirement, to be able to work and live abroad away from the next generations because of how they feel.
It is hard to find somewhere there with GCSEs, let alone BAs and MAs from a "free university education."
It is hard to find someone who enjoyed "working and living abroad" (like so many of the Remainers). Many in Ebbw Vale will have never been abroad at all.
It is hard to find someone with any assets. They are the people that prominent Remainers on this board (Gardenwalker) sneeringly refer to as living in "Valleys dunghills".
The problems in our country have been building for many, many years.
The Referendum simply and finally and irrevocably brought the problems to the attention of the middle class in the South East, who have largely been immune from such matters.
Out of interest, what percentage of the 16 million plus Remain voters do you think have lived and worked abroad?
For decades non-Londoners have had to sit there and grin as Londoners got obscenely wealthy simply by owning London property. Brexit was, in part, a howl of outrage at the unfairness.0 -
-
Random observation. I don't know anyone who supports leave who actually has a job.Alanbrooke said:
Ive yet to meet an oldie in that categoryRecidivist said:
More to the point, why don't older people think jobs and the economy aren't important?Alanbrooke said:
why do you think jobs and the economy arrent important to older people ?noneoftheabove said:
The people in charge of society 10- to our future.Alanbrooke said:
youre simply suffering the penalties for the mistakes made 10-15 years ago and which the people you vote for implemented. the Breo party has graped the nettle.noneoftheabove said:
How exactly? Pensioners have never been richer, yet they want to trash the economy? They have a triple lock, own a bigger a share of assets than ever before, own huge stocks of residential housing which those working and under 50 have to rent from them as well as pay their taxes. What else should we have done to improve the lives of pensioners further? If we try to fund care properly, as govts have flirted with, pensioners go up in arms over them paying anything and nothing happens.Alanbrooke said:
then maybe you should have spent more time listening to the other demographics and you would have avoided the problem.noneoftheabove said:
If by middle classes you mean anyone working for a living then yes we have had enough of being squeezed further at the expense of those relying on state support, especially the demographic that is far richer than us, owns acres of land, voted for Brexit and now want us to fully compensate them for their loss in income from Brexit whilst our jobs become more risky and stressful.Alanbrooke said:
.kinabalu said:
The peasants may well be revolting but so is middle England and the whole thing is led by the nobs.Alanbrooke said:the whole of Brexit was totally avoidable if UK politicans had not ignored large slices of the electorate. This is simply the modern version of the Peasants revolt.
To me, Brexit is above all a project of the reactionary right of politics. Its core appeal is to identity not economics - hence its power.
They are even planning to bring down the court system to stop paying a tv license they can perfectly well afford. How would that help law and order which they claim to care about?
Older people voted for Brexit for a wide range of reasons, but common to many is that the economic case was secondary to the emotional and political case.
-0 -
They’ll have some serious thinking to do in around 3 months thenAlanbrooke said:
Ive yet to meet an oldie in that categoryRecidivist said:
More to the point, why don't older people think jobs and the economy aren't important?Alanbrooke said:
why do you think jobs and the economy arrent important to older people ?noneoftheabove said:
The people in charge of society 10- to our future.Alanbrooke said:
youre simply suffering the penalties for the mistakes made 10-15 years ago and which the people you vote for implemented. the Breo party has graped the nettle.noneoftheabove said:
How exactly? Pensioners have never been richer, yet they want to trash the economy? They have a triple lock, own a bigger a share of assets than ever before, own huge stocks of residential housing which those working and under 50 have to rent from them as well as pay their taxes. What else should we have done to improve the lives of pensioners further? If we try to fund care properly, as govts have flirted with, pensioners go up in arms over them paying anything and nothing happens.Alanbrooke said:
then maybe you should have spent more time listening to the other demographics and you would have avoided the problem.noneoftheabove said:
If by middle classes you mean anyone working for a living then yes we have had enough of being squeezed further at the expense of those relying on state support, especially the demographic that is far richer than us, owns acres of land, voted for Brexit and now want us to fully compensate them for their loss in income from Brexit whilst our jobs become more risky and stressful.Alanbrooke said:
the middle classes are having a tantrum because the electorate is saying they doint like policies which only favour the middle classes.kinabalu said:
The peasants may well be revolting but so is middle England and the whole thing is led by the nobs.Alanbrooke said:the whole of Brexit was totally avoidable if UK politicans had not ignored large slices of the electorate. This is simply the modern version of the Peasants revolt.
To mepower.
They are even planning to bring down the court system to stop paying a tv license they can perfectly well afford. How would that help law and order which they claim to care about?
Older people voted for Brexit for a wide range of reasons, but common to many is that the economic case was secondary to the emotional and political case.
-
0 -
@Byronic is not being naive at all. In fact, quite the opposite.OnlyLivingBoy said:
Ha ha how charmingly naive.
Perhaps you don't know many Leavers. I do - a lot. Many of the people I know are Conservative-voting, relatively wealthy or at least comfortable, approaching retirement or retired, living in a lovely part of the South-East in mostly nice, detached houses. A lot of them voted Leave, for various reasons. Not a single one is selfish, scheming, or doesn't care about the economy or jobs for young people - in fact, they are extremely concerned about the latter. What's more, although I can think of a couple of exceptions, almost none of them are xenophobic, little-Englanders or racists or bigoted in any way.
You have fallen into the classic error of the left of ascribing bad motivation to people whose political views you disagree with.
If I were to generalise, what I would say is that the economic dangers of Brexit, and now no-deal Brexit, are not very obvious to some of those amongst this group. That is because they have had little direct contact with how the economy operates in the twenty-first century.1 -
I know lots of remainers who dont have one eitherRecidivist said:
Random observation. I don't know anyone who supports leave who actually has a job.Alanbrooke said:
Ive yet to meet an oldie in that categoryRecidivist said:
More to the point, why don't older people think jobs and the economy aren't important?Alanbrooke said:
why do you think jobs and the economy arrent important to older people ?noneoftheabove said:
The people in charge of society 10- to our future.Alanbrooke said:
youre simply suffering the penalties for the mistakes made 10-15 years ago and which the people you vote for implemented. the Breo party has graped the nettle.noneoftheabove said:
How exactly? Pensioners have never beeional and political case.Alanbrooke said:
then maybe you should have spent more time listening to the other demographics and you would have avoided the problem.noneoftheabove said:
If by middle classes you mean anyone working for a living then yes we have had enough of being squeezed further at the expense of those relying on state support, especially the demographic that is far richer than us, owns acres of land, voted for Brexit and now want us to fully compensate them for their loss in income from Brexit whilst our jobs become more risky and stressful.Alanbrooke said:
.kinabalu said:
The peasants may well be revolting but so is middle England and the whole thing is led by the nobs.Alanbrooke said:the whole of Brexit was totally avoidable if UK politicans had not ignored large slices of the electorate. This is simply the modern version of the Peasants revolt.
To me, Brexit is above all a project of the reactionary right of politics. Its core appeal is to identity not economics - hence its power.
-0 -
Life is good when the taxpayer has made you very, very wealthy.stodge said:Afternoon all
At a particularly tedious meeting this morning, I was musing on the notion we currently have FIVE ex-Prime Ministers still alive and seemingly all in rude health:
John Major
Tony Blair
Gordon Brown
David Cameron
Theresa May
When was the last occasion in recent times there were as many as five ex Prime Ministers still alive?0 -
bit late theyll have done that 3 years ago,alex. said:
They’ll have some serious thinking to do in around 3 months thenAlanbrooke said:
Ive yet to meet an oldie in that categoryRecidivist said:
More to the point, why don't older people think jobs and the economy aren't important?Alanbrooke said:
why do you think jobs and the economy arrent important to older people ?noneoftheabove said:
The people in charge of society 10- to our future.Alanbrooke said:
youre simply suffering the penalties for the mistakes made 10-15 years ago and which the people you vote for implemented. the Breo party has graped the nettle.noneoftheabove said:
How exactly? Pensioners have never been anything and nothing happens.Alanbrooke said:
then maybe you should have spent more time listening to the other demographics and you would have avoided the problem.noneoftheabove said:
If by middle classes you mean anyone working frisky and stressful.Alanbrooke said:
the middle classes are having a tantrum because the electorate is saying they doint like policies which only favour the middle classes.kinabalu said:
The peasants may well be revolting but so is middle England and the whole thing is led by the nobs.Alanbrooke said:the whole of Brexit was totally avoidable if UK politicans had not ignored large slices of the electorate. This is simply the modern version of the Peasants revolt.
To mepower.
They are even planning to bring down the court system to stop paying a tv license they can perfectly well afford. How would that help law and order which they claim to care about?
Older people voted for Brexit for a wide range of reasons, but common to many is that the economic case was secondary to the emotional and political case.
-0 -
Except that middle aged Londoners are cashing in and moving out and settling all over the country.OnlyLivingBoy said:
But that wealth has been gained mainly by older people living in London at the expense of younger people who live or want to live in London. If you have no intention of ever living in London, which presumably the London haterz don't, then it's kind of dumb of them to resent it. In fact it is people like me - who live in an expensive London house that they actually had to pay for - who should be most pissed off!Byronic said:
A Leaver relative of mine claimed, the other day, that the Brexit vote was “a vote against London” and I think she was on to something.SouthamObserver said:
The middle class in the South East largely voted Leave, didn't it?YBarddCwsc said:
Ebbw Vale is the main town in Blaenau Gwent, the most Leaver-y constituency in the country.noneoftheabove said:
I have no problem with those who voted leave who have been left out of the econony and society over the last 20 years and unlike others I dont think they will be the worst hit by Brexit. An orderly Brexit need not even be a disaster but no deal will be.
I do have a problem with those who have benefitted enormously through their life with free university education, opportunities to work and live abroad, generous final salary pensions, govt led asset boom boosted further by QE and govt subsidies, then wanting to take all of those opportunities, to study, to build up assets, to have a secure retirement, to be able to work and live abroad away from the next generations because of how they feel.
It is hard to find somewhere there with GCSEs, let alone BAs and MAs from a "free university education."
It is hard to find someone who enjoyed "working and living abroad" (like so many of the Remainers). Many in Ebbw Vale will have never been abroad at all.
It is hard to find someone with any assets. They are the people that prominent Remainers on this board (Gardenwalker) sneeringly refer to as living in "Valleys dunghills".
The problems in our country have been building for many, many years.
The Referendum simply and finally and irrevocably brought the problems to the attention of the middle class in the South East, who have largely been immune from such matters.
Out of interest, what percentage of the 16 million plus Remain voters do you think have lived and worked abroad?
For decades non-Londoners have had to sit there and grin as Londoners got obscenely wealthy simply by owning London property. Brexit was, in part, a howl of outrage at the unfairness.0 -
You are right, I know almost nobody who voted Leave. Even my working class made good Tory granny voted Remain just before she died, a result of having lived in Spain for many years I imagine, plus perhaps the memory of the War. I don't know any of the demographic you describe.Richard_Nabavi said:
@Byronic is not being naive at all. In fact, quite the opposite.OnlyLivingBoy said:
Ha ha how charmingly naive.
Perhaps you don't know many Leavers. I do - a lot. Many of the people I know are Conservative-voting, relatively wealthy or at least comfortable, approaching retirement or retired, living in a lovely part of the South-East in mostly nice, detached houses. A lot of them voted Leave, for various reasons. Not a single one is selfish, scheming, or doesn't care about the economy or jobs for young people - in fact, they are extremely concerned about the latter. What's more, although I can think of a couple of exceptions, almost none of them are xenophobic, little-Englanders or racists or bigoted in any way.
You have fallen into the classic error of the left of ascribing bad motivation to people whose political views you disagree with.
If I were to generalise, what I would say is that the economic dangers of Brexit, and now no-deal Brexit, are not very obvious to some of those amongst this group. That is because they have had little direct contact with how the economy operates in the twenty-first century.
I was speaking specifically about some of the very wealthy people who bankrolled the Leave campaign, where I think there is a strong element of self interest at work. Sometimes indirectly, eg their dislike of the EU often stems from times it prevented them making more money.
I think the habit of ascribing bad motivations to people you disagree with is fairly universal to be honest.
I do struggle to see how anyone can imagine leaving the EU will help any young person get a job, except via reduced immigration. And opposition to immigration is frequently motivated by xenophobia. But you know your milieu better than I do, and so I will accept your account of their motivations, if you can accept that not all London based Remainers just want a cheap nanny.0 -
Thus spreading the wealth by increasing other people's house prices.IanB2 said:
Except that middle aged Londoners are cashing in and moving out and settling all over the country.OnlyLivingBoy said:
But that wealth has been gained mainly by older people living in London at the expense of younger people who live or want to live in London. If you have no intention of ever living in London, which presumably the London haterz don't, then it's kind of dumb of them to resent it. In fact it is people like me - who live in an expensive London house that they actually had to pay for - who should be most pissed off!Byronic said:
A Leaver relative of mine claimed, the other day, that the Brexit vote was “a vote against London” and I think she was on to something.SouthamObserver said:
The middle class in the South East largely voted Leave, didn't it?YBarddCwsc said:
Ebbw Vale is the main town in Blaenau Gwent, the most Leaver-y constituency in the country.noneoftheabove said:
I have no problem with those who voted leave who have been left out of the econony and society over the last 20 years and unlike others I dont think they will be the worst hit by Brexit. An orderly Brexit need not even be a disaster but no deal will be.
I do have a problem with those who have benefitted enormously through their life with free university education, opportunities to work and live abroad, generous final salary pensions, govt led asset boom boosted further by QE and govt subsidies, then wanting to take all of those opportunities, to study, to build up assets, to have a secure retirement, to be able to work and live abroad away from the next generations because of how they feel.
It is hard to find somewhere there with GCSEs, let alone BAs and MAs from a "free university education."
It is hard to find someone who enjoyed "working and living abroad" (like so many of the Remainers). Many in Ebbw Vale will have never been abroad at all.
It is hard to find someone with any assets. They are the people that prominent Remainers on this board (Gardenwalker) sneeringly refer to as living in "Valleys dunghills".
The problems in our country have been building for many, many years.
The Referendum simply and finally and irrevocably brought the problems to the attention of the middle class in the South East, who have largely been immune from such matters.
Out of interest, what percentage of the 16 million plus Remain voters do you think have lived and worked abroad?
For decades non-Londoners have had to sit there and grin as Londoners got obscenely wealthy simply by owning London property. Brexit was, in part, a howl of outrage at the unfairness.0 -
1. That was based on one day, not one year.Recidivist said:Project fear fails again. The pound was only the second weakest currency last year.
https://twitter.com/EdConwaySky/status/1155877627418370049
2. 1.34% is quite a lot for a one day currency move, but it's far from a crash
3. Someone doesn't know how to use a Bloomberg terminal: Palladium, as far as I know, is not a currency0 -
I don't think that's the case. Unless I'm mistaken, and admittedly I haven't enquired upon it, the probability of being a Leaver does not increase with being Jewish, and arguably decreases.Alanbrooke said:
you forgot about the JewsGardenwalker said:
Yes. To the poor, the retired, and the wealthy social conservatives, we must add the ideological libertarians, the disaster capitalists, and the pound speculators.OnlyLivingBoy said:
I work in finance so the pot I am paid out of is essentially in USD. A weaker GBP as a result of Brexit means I will probably get paid more in GBP terms, and in real terms since a lot of my consumption basket is domestic services. Of course it is possible that Brexit is such a clusterfuck that I lose my job. I suspect that is more likely if Corbyn gets in, but I will still vote Labour because I think they will do more to help the less well off and I can probably look after myself.Byronic said:
Am I allowed to ask how Brexit will financially benefit you? Genuinely curious.
It's not that hard to see why Brexit was funded by many people in this sector, they are all short GBP by the nature of having USD revenues and GBP costs (plus they want more freedom to do whatever they want and think that is more likely outside of the EU). Bamford is similar, as I believe they sell mostly outside the EU and so the loss of market access issue is not such a problem for them, unlike the auto sector.
These last three are too small to represent clear demographic groupings, and certainly too small to be polled, but they appear to be largely driving Brexit now.0 -
You might like to look at the discussion philip-thompson and I had last night. Insofar as we came to a conclusion, the pound has fallen, in both the recent and distant past, but the implications of such are open to debate.rcs1000 said:
1. That was based on one day, not one year.Recidivist said:Project fear fails again. The pound was only the second weakest currency last year.
https://twitter.com/EdConwaySky/status/1155877627418370049
2. 1.34% is quite a lot for a one day currency move, but it's far from a crash
3. Someone doesn't know how to use a Bloomberg terminal: Palladium, as far as I know, is not a currency0 -
LOL , savaged by a dead lambMysticrose said:
Where? Can you post the link please. I follow the BBC carefully and haven't seen any such comment this morning about the pound rebounding.Big_G_NorthWales said:
BBC on lineMysticrose said:
Can you post the link to where the BBC mentioned 'rebound.'?Big_G_NorthWales said:
Can we get this right.Mysticrose said:
I don't normally bet on currency markets but I'm prepared to bet a tenner with BIG G that the pound will be lower than its current value one month from now. My point being, that claiming a 0.1% rise at 9.55am, which has already evaporated, really pays no attention to the short and medium sterling trend. Which we all should know ... is south.Benpointer said:
Honestly Big_G, I think calling a 0.1% rise a 'rebound' is pushing it a bit.Big_G_NorthWales said:From BBC Business
Eurozone economic growth halves and inflation slows
Eurozone grows by 0.2% in second quarter
Fed expected to cut rates for first time in a decade
Pound rebounds from 28-month low
I did not do anything than post a 'BBC business' headline.
Additionally I do not bet and I have no idea where the currency will be in three months time anymore than anyone else
It depends on far too many variables
And can we get this right. This is a betting site. Variables are our metier.
I notice that Malcolmg has risen up in your support (presumably still not forgiving me for calling him out over his SNP-driven hatred of all things Jo Swinson) but if you're going to post something as fact, and then castigate others on here for questioning your position and stating 'don't shoot me, I'm only the messenger' you need to be sure of your facts.
So can we take it that, in fact, the BBC did not report that the pound has "rebounded?" I'd genuinely like you to correct me. So please do.0 -
Ladbrokes are offering 6/1 on the turnout being 60%+ which I think is cracking value.0