Skip to content

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » New Ipsos MORI polling finds that we’re struggling to remain p

1234689

Comments

  • stodgestodge Posts: 15,323
    Evening all :)

    Oddly enough, I think the worst may have passed - not necessarily in terms of cases and deaths but in terms of the Government and people running round like headless chickens.

    Action is being taken, a policy has been set - whether it's the right policy or whether it could or should have been put in place earlier are questions for another day. For now, decision has replaced indecision, action has replaced inaction, trust has replaced mistrust.

    I share the concern of those who fear a premature lifting of restrictions will fire up the cases - we need to ensure the virus fire is fully extinguished.

    Speaking to colleagues talking to councils large and small today, there's a huge gulf of expectation and opinion over how and when restrictions will be lifted. One key date might be the VE or will that be called VC Day celebrations on May 8th. There's a view Johnson will want the country back to normal to have a right party but there's a big risk attached.

    One colleague thinks lock-down will continue for 3 months while another thinks it could be a year before all restrictions are lifted.

    Where will the current largesse leave funding for local Government in 2022-23 and beyond? What about funding for adult social care and care for vulnerable children? There's a fear deep austerity will return in the second half of this Parliament as Sunak faces the bill he has been forced to run up to try to cushion the severity of the short-term recession.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983
    RobD said:

    7 days ago Boris said

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    How much has testing increased in past 7 days

    Is it lower than 5,000?
    Last week average was higher than first 2 days this week according to Jeremy Hunt who says we are not increasing fast enough.

    You are the one who needs to justify the response your saying its wonderful. I think its 6.5/10 whats your score 10.5/10
  • eristdooferistdoof Posts: 5,089
    Died at the age of 37, someone who still had many years of service to give to the UK. Where are the "It's just normal flu" brigade now?
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,729

    RobD said:

    7 days ago Boris said

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    How much has testing increased in past 7 days

    Is it lower than 5,000?
    Last week average was higher than first 2 days this week according to Jeremy Hunt who says we are not increasing fast enough.

    You are the one who needs to justify the response your saying its wonderful. I think its 6.5/10 whats your score 10.5/10
    Where am I saying it is wonderful? I just find it extremely hard to believe they aren't trying to ramp up testing as fast as possible.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 80,129
    I sincerely hope AZA20Y flying in from Rome to Heathrow is a repatriation flight.
  • 21 year old woman with no underlying conditions has died from the virus according to Sky.
  • MattWMattW Posts: 29,884
    ydoethur said:

    ydoethur said:

    How will they control the panic buying of antibody test kits?

    Remind people that they will be being touched, bought and therefore kept in a queue with a load of people who have coronavirus?
    not if you buy via Amazon.
    So they will have been touched by a load of people working crazy hours handling goods from China and Italy while not wearing gloves because their bosses are a mix of loons and lowlifes?

    Yeah, that’s much safer.
    Just put it in quarantine for 3 days when it arrives, or wipe it with surgical spirit.

    If you are @eadric you can use your Absinthe stock instead, as long as it is 60-70% alcohol.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 75,279
    MattW said:

    ydoethur said:

    ydoethur said:

    How will they control the panic buying of antibody test kits?

    Remind people that they will be being touched, bought and therefore kept in a queue with a load of people who have coronavirus?
    not if you buy via Amazon.
    So they will have been touched by a load of people working crazy hours handling goods from China and Italy while not wearing gloves because their bosses are a mix of loons and lowlifes?

    Yeah, that’s much safer.
    Just put it in quarantine for 3 days when it arrives, or wipe it with surgical spirit.

    If you are @eadric you can use your Absinthe stock instead, as long as it is 60-70% alcohol.
    Eadric drinks things that are as low as 60% alcohol?!
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983
    edited March 2020
    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"
  • FloaterFloater Posts: 14,207

    21 year old woman with no underlying conditions has died from the virus according to Sky.

    And a young lad according to facebook
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 56,395
    ydoethur said:

    MattW said:

    ydoethur said:

    ydoethur said:

    How will they control the panic buying of antibody test kits?

    Remind people that they will be being touched, bought and therefore kept in a queue with a load of people who have coronavirus?
    not if you buy via Amazon.
    So they will have been touched by a load of people working crazy hours handling goods from China and Italy while not wearing gloves because their bosses are a mix of loons and lowlifes?

    Yeah, that’s much safer.
    Just put it in quarantine for 3 days when it arrives, or wipe it with surgical spirit.

    If you are @eadric you can use your Absinthe stock instead, as long as it is 60-70% alcohol.
    Eadric drinks things that are as low as 60% alcohol?!
    Not before posting.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 52,841
    edited March 2020
    TGOHF666 said:

    Boris said 7 days ago

    RobD said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    I would give the Govt response 6.5 / 10

    Testing next week will move that number up or down depending if they materialize

    Everyone who is admitted to hospital is tested - sounds like the current “have you got it” test has limited use beyond that now.

    We need the “have you had it” test.
    NHS staff not getting have you got it test. That is i would have thought a massive problem.
    You would have to test them every day - is that a good use of resources ?
    No you wouldnt

    FU will explain and Foxy too

    but if you were going into hospital would you be happy to be treated by staff who must have a higher chance than the general population of having this by the very nature of their work

    Even worse you need to go to hospital but you cant because NHS and ambulance staff were at home self isolating because they havent been tested
    hence needing an *accurate* antibody test.
    BJO is disgusted Boris hasn’t knocked 3 million up in his kitchen overnight.
    Party members first. :)
    its not a laughing matter Rob surprised you have stooped to TGHOF level
    You can't test everybody.

    Testing with current "have you got it " test at high levels eventually has diminishing returns.

    The CMO does not want to start with antibody tests until the performance has been verified as sound.
    And when the antibody test is available, surely it makes sense to have some of priority order for testing large groups. Having flaky writers and every worried pensioner queuing outside the chemist for a test they objectively don’t need would just be dumb. We should ensure we get a good random sample but otherwise go for something like:

    - all NHS staff
    - Timpsons staff
    - care workers
    - army and police
    - supermarket workers
    - posties and delivery drivers
    - NHS volunteers
    - PB article writers

    Etc.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 80,129
    @twistedfirestopper What's your workload like about now ? Quiet or busy on the fire front.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 56,982

    ydoethur said:

    Crete was perfectly defensible - if the clown in charge had bothered to read the detailed ULTRA based reports given him. They gave him the entire German plan - pretty much down to how many spare pocket handkerchiefs the paratroops would be carrying and what colours.

    This included the detail that since the German parachute design was particularly stupid, they would be landing armed only with pistols. Everything else, including rifles would be in parachuted containers.

    Trying to defend Crete at the cost of securing Libya was utterly indefensible. It was Churchill’s posturing at its worst, and most costly.

    That’s not forgetting Gallipoli either.
    I don't think doing both was impossible.

    Crete destroyed the German airborne units. It should have been a complete defeat for them.
    But the airfields weren't retaken quickly enough to prevent German reinforcements being flown in.
    If Freyberg had actually gone with the detailed invasion plan he was given - which he didn't do even after they proven to be perfectly accurate by the first wave, then the airfields wouldn't have been lost.

    Hell, the locals could have pitchforked all the German paras to death if they had been given a bit of notice - as it was civilians killed a substantial number of these elite troops.
  • stodgestodge Posts: 15,323
    The situation on the Underground has eased slightly today with the welcome news a number of construction companies have agreed to close their sites for the duration of the lock down.

    Unfortunately, that doesn't apply to all and contradictory messages from Hancock and Gove haven't helped at all. The notion one can apply social distancing while working outdoors on a building site is one thing but if all the workers are cheek by jowl on the tube going and coming back it's not going to make much difference.

    While Khan hasn't played this well, I do think not enforcing a shutdown of construction sites last week was a mistake. I see any number of construction workers covering the gamut of trades on the tube platform of an early morning - keeping them at home and safe and keeping the tube purely for key workers must be the solution.

    I also note the exhortation not to travel, while prominent on the Transport for London website, is not on the South Western Railways site for example. I suspect the more white collar travellers coming up from Surrey and Hampshire have been absent these past days.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,729

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 87,690
    Still no numbers for today...is this the latest so far?
  • Pulpstar said:

    @twistedfirestopper What's your workload like about now ? Quiet or busy on the fire front.

    About the same, mate. Roads are quieter though! We'll see how people drinking more at home pans out very soon I guess.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,729

    Still no numbers for today...is this the latest so far?

    I think that's right. We'll see how many days behind Italy we are soon enough.
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    eek said:

    Wetherspoons may have a slight reprieve https://twitter.com/TomWitherow/status/1242859437527830529

    Oh, turns out they do have some money then. They were just choosing not to pay it.
  • tysontyson Posts: 6,123
    Pulpstar said:

    I sincerely hope AZA20Y flying in from Rome to Heathrow is a repatriation flight.

    I don't think Rome is too bad...I'd be more worried as an Italian about the return flight....

    I was supposed to be flying to Pisa tomorrow for a week in Italy....

    And...my friend in Tuscany sent me some pics today....there is about 10cm of snow that has fallen
  • geoffwgeoffw Posts: 9,245
    IanB2 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    Boris said 7 days ago

    RobD said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    I would give the Govt response 6.5 / 10

    Testing next week will move that number up or down depending if they materialize

    Everyone who is admitted to hospital is tested - sounds like the current “have you got it” test has limited use beyond that now.

    We need the “have you had it” test.
    NHS staff not getting have you got it test. That is i would have thought a massive problem.
    You would have to test them every day - is that a good use of resources ?
    No you wouldnt

    FU will explain and Foxy too

    but if you were going into hospital would you be happy to be treated by staff who must have a higher chance than the general population of having this by the very nature of their work

    Even worse you need to go to hospital but you cant because NHS and ambulance staff were at home self isolating because they havent been tested
    hence needing an *accurate* antibody test.
    BJO is disgusted Boris hasn’t knocked 3 million up in his kitchen overnight.
    Party members first. :)
    its not a laughing matter Rob surprised you have stooped to TGHOF level
    You can't test everybody.

    Testing with current "have you got it " test at high levels eventually has diminishing returns.

    The CMO does not want to start with antibody tests until the performance has been verified as sound.
    And when the antibody test is available, surely it makes sense to have some of priority order for testing large groups. Having flaky writers and every worried pensioner queuing outside the chemist for a test they objectively don’t need would just be dumb. We should ensure we get a good random sample but otherwise go for something like:

    - all NHS staff
    - Timpsons staff
    - care workers
    - army and police
    - supermarket workers
    - posties and delivery drivers
    - NHS volunteers
    - PB article writers

    Etc.
    Surely both random sample and for key workers. They serve different purposes.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983
    IanB2 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    Boris said 7 days ago

    RobD said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    I would give the Govt response 6.5 / 10

    Testing next week will move that number up or down depending if they materialize

    Everyone who is admitted to hospital is tested - sounds like the current “have you got it” test has limited use beyond that now.

    We need the “have you had it” test.
    NHS staff not getting have you got it test. That is i would have thought a massive problem.
    You would have to test them every day - is that a good use of resources ?
    No you wouldnt

    FU will explain and Foxy too

    but if you were going into hospital would you be happy to be treated by staff who must have a higher chance than the general population of having this by the very nature of their work

    Even worse you need to go to hospital but you cant because NHS and ambulance staff were at home self isolating because they havent been tested
    hence needing an *accurate* antibody test.
    BJO is disgusted Boris hasn’t knocked 3 million up in his kitchen overnight.
    Party members first. :)
    its not a laughing matter Rob surprised you have stooped to TGHOF level
    You can't test everybody.

    Testing with current "have you got it " test at high levels eventually has diminishing returns.

    The CMO does not want to start with antibody tests until the performance has been verified as sound.
    And when the antibody test is available, surely it makes sense to have some of priority order for testing large groups. Having flaky writers and every worried pensioner queuing outside the chemist for a test they objectively don’t need would just be dumb. We should ensure we get a good random sample but otherwise go for something like:

    - all NHS staff
    - Timpsons staff
    - care workers
    - army and police
    - supermarket workers
    - posties and delivery drivers
    - NHS volunteers
    - PB article writers

    Etc.
    Timpson Joke count up to 6 in past 5 hrs Its the new EICIPM!!
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 87,690
    Floater said:

    Russian numbers beginning to increase big time

    Russia 658 +163 3 +2

    "official" figures anyway

    No problem is Russia....just Putin going around in a full chemical weapons hazmat suit.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 56,982

    IanB2 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    Boris said 7 days ago

    RobD said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    I would give the Govt response 6.5 / 10

    Testing next week will move that number up or down depending if they materialize

    Everyone who is admitted to hospital is tested - sounds like the current “have you got it” test has limited use beyond that now.

    We need the “have you had it” test.
    NHS staff not getting have you got it test. That is i would have thought a massive problem.
    You would have to test them every day - is that a good use of resources ?
    No you wouldnt

    FU will explain and Foxy too

    but if you were going into hospital would you be happy to be treated by staff who must have a higher chance than the general population of having this by the very nature of their work

    Even worse you need to go to hospital but you cant because NHS and ambulance staff were at home self isolating because they havent been tested
    hence needing an *accurate* antibody test.
    BJO is disgusted Boris hasn’t knocked 3 million up in his kitchen overnight.
    Party members first. :)
    its not a laughing matter Rob surprised you have stooped to TGHOF level
    You can't test everybody.

    Testing with current "have you got it " test at high levels eventually has diminishing returns.

    The CMO does not want to start with antibody tests until the performance has been verified as sound.
    And when the antibody test is available, surely it makes sense to have some of priority order for testing large groups. Having flaky writers and every worried pensioner queuing outside the chemist for a test they objectively don’t need would just be dumb. We should ensure we get a good random sample but otherwise go for something like:

    - all NHS staff
    - Timpsons staff
    - care workers
    - army and police
    - supermarket workers
    - posties and delivery drivers
    - NHS volunteers
    - PB article writers

    Etc.
    Timpson Joke count up to 6 in past 5 hrs Its the new EICIPM!!
    You missed Albanian Taxi drivers. Again
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 68,007

    ydoethur said:

    Crete was perfectly defensible - if the clown in charge had bothered to read the detailed ULTRA based reports given him. They gave him the entire German plan - pretty much down to how many spare pocket handkerchiefs the paratroops would be carrying and what colours.

    This included the detail that since the German parachute design was particularly stupid, they would be landing armed only with pistols. Everything else, including rifles would be in parachuted containers.

    Trying to defend Crete at the cost of securing Libya was utterly indefensible. It was Churchill’s posturing at its worst, and most costly.

    That’s not forgetting Gallipoli either.
    I don't think doing both was impossible.

    Crete destroyed the German airborne units. It should have been a complete defeat for them.
    But the airfields weren't retaken quickly enough to prevent German reinforcements being flown in.
    It has been said that one reason FDR went off Churchill by Yalta was the Americans had to keep bailing out the British after Winston's adventurism and his repeated failure to grasp logistics and reinforcements.
    I read the other day that Stalin partly wanted it at Yalta because he was scared of flying.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 87,690

    IanB2 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    Boris said 7 days ago

    RobD said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    I would give the Govt response 6.5 / 10

    Testing next week will move that number up or down depending if they materialize

    Everyone who is admitted to hospital is tested - sounds like the current “have you got it” test has limited use beyond that now.

    We need the “have you had it” test.
    NHS staff not getting have you got it test. That is i would have thought a massive problem.
    You would have to test them every day - is that a good use of resources ?
    No you wouldnt

    FU will explain and Foxy too

    but if you were going into hospital would you be happy to be treated by staff who must have a higher chance than the general population of having this by the very nature of their work

    Even worse you need to go to hospital but you cant because NHS and ambulance staff were at home self isolating because they havent been tested
    hence needing an *accurate* antibody test.
    BJO is disgusted Boris hasn’t knocked 3 million up in his kitchen overnight.
    Party members first. :)
    its not a laughing matter Rob surprised you have stooped to TGHOF level
    You can't test everybody.

    Testing with current "have you got it " test at high levels eventually has diminishing returns.

    The CMO does not want to start with antibody tests until the performance has been verified as sound.
    And when the antibody test is available, surely it makes sense to have some of priority order for testing large groups. Having flaky writers and every worried pensioner queuing outside the chemist for a test they objectively don’t need would just be dumb. We should ensure we get a good random sample but otherwise go for something like:

    - all NHS staff
    - Timpsons staff
    - care workers
    - army and police
    - supermarket workers
    - posties and delivery drivers
    - NHS volunteers
    - PB article writers

    Etc.
    Timpson Joke count up to 6 in past 5 hrs Its the new EICIPM!!
    You missed Albanian Taxi drivers. Again
    Isn't he busy at the moment in his new job processing CV tests?
  • tysontyson Posts: 6,123
    On the Gwent hotspot.....has anyone made the connection to the Stereophonics concert on the 15th March?

    A leading scientist ion Italy is convinced that the Bergamo hotpspot was fuelled by bus loads of fans being transported to the San Siro to watch Atlanta play Valencia in early March
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    Alistair said:

    eek said:

    Wetherspoons may have a slight reprieve https://twitter.com/TomWitherow/status/1242859437527830529

    Oh, turns out they do have some money then. They were just choosing not to pay it.
    I believe several of their pubs have been vandalized so maybe it helped change his mind
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 56,314

    The toning down of the effects of COVID 19 on the UK and the NHS in this article are amazing compared to what was being said just 2 days ago:

    https://www.newscientist.com/article/2238578-uk-has-enough-intensive-care-units-for-coronavirus-expert-predicts/

    It’s almost as if social distancing is an effective way to mitigate a pandemic...
    From that article:
    "His comments come as a team at the University of Oxford released provisional findings of a different model that they say shows that up to half the UK population could already have been infected. The model is based on different assumptions to those of Ferguson and others involved in advising the UK government.
    Most importantly, it assumes that most people who contract the virus don’t show symptoms and that very few need to go to hospital. “I don’t think that’s consistent with the observed data,” Ferguson told the committee."

    We don't currently know which model is nearest the truth because we haven't done enough testing.
    That Oxford study doesn't even purport to be a model of what's actually happening, and as Prof Ferguson said, it doesn't fit the data that we already have. We don't need any more testing to know that it's wrong.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 56,982
    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    For some reason I am reminded of people being surprised that if a politician gives a speech, all the promises are not actually delivered at the full stops.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 56,982

    Pulpstar said:

    @twistedfirestopper What's your workload like about now ? Quiet or busy on the fire front.

    About the same, mate. Roads are quieter though! We'll see how people drinking more at home pans out very soon I guess.

    Domestic violence goes up - is my sad, sad thought.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,729

    The toning down of the effects of COVID 19 on the UK and the NHS in this article are amazing compared to what was being said just 2 days ago:

    https://www.newscientist.com/article/2238578-uk-has-enough-intensive-care-units-for-coronavirus-expert-predicts/

    It’s almost as if social distancing is an effective way to mitigate a pandemic...
    From that article:
    "His comments come as a team at the University of Oxford released provisional findings of a different model that they say shows that up to half the UK population could already have been infected. The model is based on different assumptions to those of Ferguson and others involved in advising the UK government.
    Most importantly, it assumes that most people who contract the virus don’t show symptoms and that very few need to go to hospital. “I don’t think that’s consistent with the observed data,” Ferguson told the committee."

    We don't currently know which model is nearest the truth because we haven't done enough testing.
    That Oxford study doesn't even purport to be a model of what's actually happening, and as Prof Ferguson said, it doesn't fit the data that we already have. We don't need any more testing to know that it's wrong.
    It seemed to me to be nothing more than a "what if".
  • tysontyson Posts: 6,123
    nichomar said:

    Alistair said:

    eek said:

    Wetherspoons may have a slight reprieve https://twitter.com/TomWitherow/status/1242859437527830529

    Oh, turns out they do have some money then. They were just choosing not to pay it.
    I believe several of their pubs have been vandalized so maybe it helped change his mind
    And someone probably told him about getting his knighthood.....
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983
    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    "We have plenty" of the have you got it type according to the CMO at todays briefing

    Its OK Rob if you dont want to score the Government effort out of 10 I will presume your a 10.5 until you get back to me. You dont get drummed out of the PB Tory club unless you score less than 9.9/10 you know

    You are not even a tiny bit disappointed in the testing numbers thats fine
  • FloaterFloater Posts: 14,207
    tyson said:

    On the Gwent hotspot.....has anyone made the connection to the Stereophonics concert on the 15th March?

    A leading scientist ion Italy is convinced that the Bergamo hotpspot was fuelled by bus loads of fans being transported to the San Siro to watch Atlanta play Valencia in early March

    “In Gwent, we are seeing a rapidly rising increase in the number of cases of coronavirus in all our communities and a daily increase in the number of people being admitted to hospital and the number of people dying from the virus,” Dr Sarah Aitken said.

    “The pattern we are seeing in Gwent is the same pattern as was seen in Italy, where their healthcare system is now overwhelmed.

    “Without a huge effort by all of us, we are heading for the moment in Gwent where our NHS will be overwhelmed too.

    “We won’t have enough hospital beds for everyone who needs life-saving ventilators and intensive care.”

    She urged people to stay at home to give the health board “essential time” to bring more doctors and nurses into the workforce, as well as extra ventilators and additional intensive care beds.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,729

    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    "We have plenty" of the have you got it type according to the CMO at todays briefing

    Its OK Rob if you dont want to score the Government effort out of 10 I will presume your a 10.5 until you get back to me. You dont get drummed out of the PB Tory club unless you score less than 9.9/10 you know

    You are not even a tiny bit disappointed in the testing numbers thats fine
    How about engaging on the point, rather than having a go at me. If it was feasible to up testing by that much so quickly, don't you think they would have done it already?
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 52,841

    IanB2 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    Boris said 7 days ago

    RobD said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    I would give the Govt response 6.5 / 10

    Testing next week will move that number up or down depending if they materialize

    Everyone who is admitted to hospital is tested - sounds like the current “have you got it” test has limited use beyond that now.

    We need the “have you had it” test.
    NHS staff not getting have you got it test. That is i would have thought a massive problem.
    You would have to test them every day - is that a good use of resources ?
    No you wouldnt

    FU will explain and Foxy too

    but if you were going into hospital would you be happy to be treated by staff who must have a higher chance than the general population of having this by the very nature of their work

    Even worse you need to go to hospital but you cant because NHS and ambulance staff were at home self isolating because they havent been tested
    hence needing an *accurate* antibody test.
    BJO is disgusted Boris hasn’t knocked 3 million up in his kitchen overnight.
    Party members first. :)
    its not a laughing matter Rob surprised you have stooped to TGHOF level
    You can't test everybody.

    Testing with current "have you got it " test at high levels eventually has diminishing returns.

    The CMO does not want to start with antibody tests until the performance has been verified as sound.
    And when the antibody test is available, surely it makes sense to have some of priority order for testing large groups. Having flaky writers and every worried pensioner queuing outside the chemist for a test they objectively don’t need would just be dumb. We should ensure we get a good random sample but otherwise go for something like:

    - all NHS staff
    - Timpsons staff
    - care workers
    - army and police
    - supermarket workers
    - posties and delivery drivers
    - NHS volunteers
    - PB article writers

    Etc.
    Timpson Joke count up to 6 in past 5 hrs Its the new EICIPM!!
    Well it was my fault, I believe, describing them as key workers in the first place.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983

    Floater said:

    Russian numbers beginning to increase big time

    Russia 658 +163 3 +2

    "official" figures anyway

    No problem is Russia....just Putin going around in a full chemical weapons hazmat suit.
    Yes i saw that it was funny. I thought he was meant to be the hard man.
  • FloaterFloater Posts: 14,207
    Spot the slightly worrying caveat

    Jérôme Salomon has announced the latest coronavirus figures. There are now 25,233 confirmed cases in France 1,331 deaths, of which 86% were people aged over 70 years. The death rate rose by 231 in 24 hours. These are hospital deaths only, not those in retirement homes or outside hospitals.

    There are currently 11,539 people in French hospitals with the coronavirus, 2,827 in intensive care.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 87,690
    edited March 2020
    The government need to be putting this kind of stuff everywhere...this is a "mild" case....we need to scare the public shit-less now.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=12ZhdYCpJ90
  • eristdooferistdoof Posts: 5,089
    IanB2 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    Boris said 7 days ago

    RobD said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    I would give the Govt response 6.5 / 10

    Testing next week will move that number up or down depending if they materialize

    Everyone who is admitted to hospital is tested - sounds like the current “have you got it” test has limited use beyond that now.

    We need the “have you had it” test.
    NHS staff not getting have you got it test. That is i would have thought a massive problem.
    You would have to test them every day - is that a good use of resources ?
    No you wouldnt

    FU will explain and Foxy too

    but if you were going into hospital would you be happy to be treated by staff who must have a higher chance than the general population of having this by the very nature of their work

    Even worse you need to go to hospital but you cant because NHS and ambulance staff were at home self isolating because they havent been tested
    hence needing an *accurate* antibody test.
    BJO is disgusted Boris hasn’t knocked 3 million up in his kitchen overnight.
    Party members first. :)
    its not a laughing matter Rob surprised you have stooped to TGHOF level
    You can't test everybody.

    Testing with current "have you got it " test at high levels eventually has diminishing returns.

    The CMO does not want to start with antibody tests until the performance has been verified as sound.
    And when the antibody test is available, surely it makes sense to have some of priority order for testing large groups. Having flaky writers and every worried pensioner queuing outside the chemist for a test they objectively don’t need would just be dumb. We should ensure we get a good random sample but otherwise go for something like:

    - all NHS staff
    - Timpsons staff
    - care workers
    - army and police
    - supermarket workers
    - posties and delivery drivers
    - NHS volunteers
    - PB article writers

    Etc.
    One exception to this would be to test almost everyone from a sample which is fairly representative of the UK population, so that we get a good idea of how many were exposed to the virus but had no symptoms / minor symptoms etc.

    It makes a massive difference to the easing off strategy if we know that 10% or 60% have had Corona.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    tyson said:

    On the Gwent hotspot.....has anyone made the connection to the Stereophonics concert on the 15th March?

    A leading scientist ion Italy is convinced that the Bergamo hotpspot was fuelled by bus loads of fans being transported to the San Siro to watch Atlanta play Valencia in early March

    And reciprocally in Valencia which sparked that hot spot.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    tyson said:

    On the Gwent hotspot.....has anyone made the connection to the Stereophonics concert on the 15th March?

    A leading scientist ion Italy is convinced that the Bergamo hotpspot was fuelled by bus loads of fans being transported to the San Siro to watch Atlanta play Valencia in early March

    And reciprocally in Valencia which sparked that hot spot.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 87,690
    Lets hope they still have many more hidden away somewhere secure.
  • CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,751
    MattW said:

    @Cyclefree Gardening Corner.
    Today's question is about Microveg grown indoors in my conservatory.

    Two weeks ago I planted a seed tray with Spring Onions (LHS in pic below), and Parskey (RHS), using seeds from last year though still in date. The compost was the last from last year.

    The Parsley is fine, but the Spring Onions are growing fungus. Is that likely to be the seeds or the compost, and do I need to throw that half of the tray away, and start again - I have both new seeds and new compost?

    Thanks

    https://twitter.com/mattwardman/status/1242799620775907330

    Other trays are doing better, though the next one of these needs more dense planting:

    https://twitter.com/mattwardman/status/1242800241797206017



    As others have said, throw out the tray with the fungus, clean it thoroughly, get clean fresh potting compost and start again.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 87,690
    edited March 2020
    Can make 5000 a week of these apparently....bit concerned he is from Oxford though, be happier if it was Cambridge bod ;-)

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xdZtMgpxnPI
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,729

    Lets hope they still have many more hidden away somewhere secure.
    Reassuring that they had 25 million gloves on hand.
  • JohnLilburneJohnLilburne Posts: 7,200

    ydoethur said:

    Crete was perfectly defensible - if the clown in charge had bothered to read the detailed ULTRA based reports given him. They gave him the entire German plan - pretty much down to how many spare pocket handkerchiefs the paratroops would be carrying and what colours.

    This included the detail that since the German parachute design was particularly stupid, they would be landing armed only with pistols. Everything else, including rifles would be in parachuted containers.

    Trying to defend Crete at the cost of securing Libya was utterly indefensible. It was Churchill’s posturing at its worst, and most costly.

    That’s not forgetting Gallipoli either.
    I don't think doing both was impossible.

    Crete destroyed the German airborne units. It should have been a complete defeat for them.
    But the airfields weren't retaken quickly enough to prevent German reinforcements being flown in.
    It has been said that one reason FDR went off Churchill by Yalta was the Americans had to keep bailing out the British after Winston's adventurism and his repeated failure to grasp logistics and reinforcements.
    I read the other day that Stalin partly wanted it at Yalta because he was scared of flying.
    He certainly went everywhere by train. One of the attractions of the Stalin Museum in Gori, his home town in Georgia, is one of his trains. Along with the wooden cottage he was allegedly born in, and a wonderfully kitsch museum full of Uncle Joe hagiography and memorabilia
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 87,690
    RobD said:

    Lets hope they still have many more hidden away somewhere secure.
    Reassuring that they had 25 million gloves on hand.
    Makes you wonder how long they have been hiding these away. Thought it was rather revealing it was the army delivering them.
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 56,395
    Have to say before this I didn’t rate Hancock at all but he has done really well.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983
    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    "We have plenty" of the have you got it type according to the CMO at todays briefing

    Its OK Rob if you dont want to score the Government effort out of 10 I will presume your a 10.5 until you get back to me. You dont get drummed out of the PB Tory club unless you score less than 9.9/10 you know

    You are not even a tiny bit disappointed in the testing numbers thats fine
    How about engaging on the point, rather than having a go at me. If it was feasible to up testing by that much so quickly, don't you think they would have done it already?
    I dont know you would have thought so but why arent they rising rapidly as promised? The Government is doing well in some stuff like the ramping up of the Lockdown but IMO falling short on rapid ramp up of tests

    Why wont you engage with rating the Government effort rather than put a smiley face on a stupid comment that BJO thinks Boris should make 3 million in his kitchen.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983
    English number yet anyone?
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 52,841

    ydoethur said:

    Crete was perfectly defensible - if the clown in charge had bothered to read the detailed ULTRA based reports given him. They gave him the entire German plan - pretty much down to how many spare pocket handkerchiefs the paratroops would be carrying and what colours.

    This included the detail that since the German parachute design was particularly stupid, they would be landing armed only with pistols. Everything else, including rifles would be in parachuted containers.

    Trying to defend Crete at the cost of securing Libya was utterly indefensible. It was Churchill’s posturing at its worst, and most costly.

    That’s not forgetting Gallipoli either.
    I don't think doing both was impossible.

    Crete destroyed the German airborne units. It should have been a complete defeat for them.
    But the airfields weren't retaken quickly enough to prevent German reinforcements being flown in.
    It has been said that one reason FDR went off Churchill by Yalta was the Americans had to keep bailing out the British after Winston's adventurism and his repeated failure to grasp logistics and reinforcements.
    I read the other day that Stalin partly wanted it at Yalta because he was scared of flying.
    He certainly went everywhere by train. One of the attractions of the Stalin Museum in Gori, his home town in Georgia, is one of his trains. Along with the wooden cottage he was allegedly born in, and a wonderfully kitsch museum full of Uncle Joe hagiography and memorabilia
    I somehow doubt that there is a Hitler museum in Austria.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,729

    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    "We have plenty" of the have you got it type according to the CMO at todays briefing

    Its OK Rob if you dont want to score the Government effort out of 10 I will presume your a 10.5 until you get back to me. You dont get drummed out of the PB Tory club unless you score less than 9.9/10 you know

    You are not even a tiny bit disappointed in the testing numbers thats fine
    How about engaging on the point, rather than having a go at me. If it was feasible to up testing by that much so quickly, don't you think they would have done it already?
    I dont know you would have thought so but why arent they rising rapidly as promised? The Government is doing well in some stuff like the ramping up of the Lockdown but IMO falling short on rapid ramp up of tests

    Why wont you engage with rating the Government effort rather than put a smiley face on a stupid comment that BJO thinks Boris should make 3 million in his kitchen.
    I don't know, because of the difficulties in procuring the materials necessary for them, confounded by the fact that every other country on the face of the Earth is also looking for them?

    I don't think the government are dragging their heels on this at all, but you seem to be suggesting that they are somehow.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 52,841

    Can make 5000 a week of these apparently....bit concerned he is from Oxford though, be happier if it was Cambridge bod ;-)

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xdZtMgpxnPI

    Indeed. The Oxford one would work in theory, but it would be better to have a Cambridge one that works in practice.
  • RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    "We have plenty" of the have you got it type according to the CMO at todays briefing

    Its OK Rob if you dont want to score the Government effort out of 10 I will presume your a 10.5 until you get back to me. You dont get drummed out of the PB Tory club unless you score less than 9.9/10 you know

    You are not even a tiny bit disappointed in the testing numbers thats fine
    How about engaging on the point, rather than having a go at me. If it was feasible to up testing by that much so quickly, don't you think they would have done it already?
    I dont know you would have thought so but why arent they rising rapidly as promised? The Government is doing well in some stuff like the ramping up of the Lockdown but IMO falling short on rapid ramp up of tests

    Why wont you engage with rating the Government effort rather than put a smiley face on a stupid comment that BJO thinks Boris should make 3 million in his kitchen.
    https://twitter.com/chelsearob1992/status/1242862550485786628?s=20
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 87,690
    IanB2 said:

    Can make 5000 a week of these apparently....bit concerned he is from Oxford though, be happier if it was Cambridge bod ;-)

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xdZtMgpxnPI

    Indeed. The Oxford one would work in theory, but it would be better to have a Cambridge one that works in practice.
    I think they need to get somebody from a superior institution to come and double check it...we know how shoddy a lot of the work from there can be, picks up copy of today's FT...
  • JonathanDJonathanD Posts: 2,400
    DavidL said:

    Have to say before this I didn’t rate Hancock at all but he has done really well.
    Pandemic planning should be something the NHS is very good at and part of their routine functions. Also they have had 2 months notice of the potential for this to start spreading here.

    If anything I am surprised at how slow they are in dealing with some of the basics - PPE and ramping up the testing rate in particular. Is it lack of domestic suppliers that is the problem. Definitely something for the Public Inquiry to look at.
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    RobD said:

    FF43 said:

    FF43 said:

    All those screaming at Boris for the original strategy...Chief modelling egg-head thought it was good idea,

    https://twitter.com/Smyth_Chris/status/1242761739332190209?s=20

    I don't think this is correct. Prof Ferguson produced the paper that convinced the government to change its policy. Ferguson does appear to have been sceptical earlier that containment policies would actually reduce the infection rate and that may have influenced government policy. He seems to have revised his mortality estimates downwards. I doubt know whether that's because the containment methods are effective or due to a better understanding of the epidemic after a couple of weeks.
    Incidentally the information about the Italian mortality and serious illness rates that informed Ferguson's paper was available earlier to the UK government at the EU COVID19 information sharing meeting, but the government wasn't aware of it due to it boycotting that meeting for reasons of Brexit ideology.
    Is there a source for the claim that this information was only shared at this meeting, and not more widely? Seems a bit strange to keep information like this secret.
    I'm also intrigued that such a fan of the EU is implicating our European friends and partners in the death of a large number of British citizens.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 87,690
    edited March 2020

    Wonder where they have get all the spare beds from? Are a massive amount warehoused away somewhere, "just in case"?
    Again makes you wonder if somebody has quietly been doing that for a while. This Excel plan clearly isn't out of the blue and NEC / G-Mex made it clear they are next up if required.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983
    IanB2 said:

    Can make 5000 a week of these apparently....bit concerned he is from Oxford though, be happier if it was Cambridge bod ;-)

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xdZtMgpxnPI

    Indeed. The Oxford one would work in theory, but it would be better to have a Cambridge one that works in practice.
    Bloke this morning reckoned they could manufacture loads but the supply chain for components was the pinch point
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 87,690
    Jérôme Salomon, the director general of the French health service, has announced the latest coronavirus figures. There are now 25,233 confirmed cases in France, 1,331 deaths, of which 86% were people aged over 70 years. The death rate rose by 231 in 24 hours. These are hospital deaths only, not those in retirement homes or outside hospitals.
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 37,525
    edited March 2020

    21 year old woman with no underlying conditions has died from the virus according to Sky.

    The BBC are reporting differently, saying "it is not known whether she had any underlying health conditions".
  • TGOHF666TGOHF666 Posts: 2,052
    IanB2 said:

    IanB2 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    Boris said 7 days ago

    RobD said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    I would give the Govt response 6.5 / 10

    Testing next week will move that number up or down depending if they materialize

    Everyone who is admitted to hospital is tested - sounds like the current “have you got it” test has limited use beyond that now.

    We need the “have you had it” test.
    NHS staff not getting have you got it test. That is i would have thought a massive problem.
    You would have to test them every day - is that a good use of resources ?
    No you wouldnt

    FU will explain and Foxy too

    but if you were going into hospital would you be happy to be treated by staff who must have a higher chance than the general population of having this by the very nature of their work

    Even worse you need to go to hospital but you cant because NHS and ambulance staff were at home self isolating because they havent been tested
    hence needing an *accurate* antibody test.
    BJO is disgusted Boris hasn’t knocked 3 million up in his kitchen overnight.
    Party members first. :)
    its not a laughing matter Rob surprised you have stooped to TGHOF level
    You can't test everybody.

    Testing with current "have you got it " test at high levels eventually has diminishing returns.

    The CMO does not want to start with antibody tests until the performance has been verified as sound.
    And when the antibody test is available, surely it makes sense to have some of priority order for testing large groups. Having flaky writers and every worried pensioner queuing outside the chemist for a test they objectively don’t need would just be dumb. We should ensure we get a good random sample but otherwise go for something like:

    - all NHS staff
    - Timpsons staff
    - care workers
    - army and police
    - supermarket workers
    - posties and delivery drivers
    - NHS volunteers
    - PB article writers

    Etc.
    Timpson Joke count up to 6 in past 5 hrs Its the new EICIPM!!
    Well it was my fault, I believe, describing them as key workers in the first place.
    Could combine with the dockside hooker meme to cover other quay workers.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 87,690
    edited March 2020
    Andy_JS said:

    21 year old woman with no underlying conditions has died from the virus according to Sky.

    The BBC are reporting differently, saying "it is not known whether she had any underlying health conditions"
    Have to be a bit careful e.g. the Spainish guy who was 21 who died, they found he actually had leukaemia and didn't know.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983
    JonathanD said:

    DavidL said:

    Have to say before this I didn’t rate Hancock at all but he has done really well.
    Pandemic planning should be something the NHS is very good at and part of their routine functions. Also they have had 2 months notice of the potential for this to start spreading here.

    If anything I am surprised at how slow they are in dealing with some of the basics - PPE and ramping up the testing rate in particular. Is it lack of domestic suppliers that is the problem. Definitely something for the Public Inquiry to look at.
    It said that the NHS Pandemic Plan contained no mention of needing more Ventilators.

    Whoever was responsible for that oversight ought not to go near a future planning exercise imo
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 34,288

    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    "We have plenty" of the have you got it type according to the CMO at todays briefing

    Its OK Rob if you dont want to score the Government effort out of 10 I will presume your a 10.5 until you get back to me. You dont get drummed out of the PB Tory club unless you score less than 9.9/10 you know

    You are not even a tiny bit disappointed in the testing numbers thats fine
    How about engaging on the point, rather than having a go at me. If it was feasible to up testing by that much so quickly, don't you think they would have done it already?
    I dont know you would have thought so but why arent they rising rapidly as promised? The Government is doing well in some stuff like the ramping up of the Lockdown but IMO falling short on rapid ramp up of tests

    Why wont you engage with rating the Government effort rather than put a smiley face on a stupid comment that BJO thinks Boris should make 3 million in his kitchen.
    I am off work at Boris' request, earning diddly squat, and eager for tomorrow's announcement. yet Halfords and off licences are now off the closed list with a blind eye turned to any random construction project. The Government's advice has changed/ been diluted, call it what you will about going to work. I know this because Piers Morgan told me this morning on GMB. Morgan confronted Jenrick, implying a capitulation. The worst side effect of the whole crisis is I now agree with Piers Morgan.

    For all the Boris cheerleaders on PB this is not a party political point as the Labour Party have disappeared from sight.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983

    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    "We have plenty" of the have you got it type according to the CMO at todays briefing

    Its OK Rob if you dont want to score the Government effort out of 10 I will presume your a 10.5 until you get back to me. You dont get drummed out of the PB Tory club unless you score less than 9.9/10 you know

    You are not even a tiny bit disappointed in the testing numbers thats fine
    How about engaging on the point, rather than having a go at me. If it was feasible to up testing by that much so quickly, don't you think they would have done it already?
    I dont know you would have thought so but why arent they rising rapidly as promised? The Government is doing well in some stuff like the ramping up of the Lockdown but IMO falling short on rapid ramp up of tests

    Why wont you engage with rating the Government effort rather than put a smiley face on a stupid comment that BJO thinks Boris should make 3 million in his kitchen.
    https://twitter.com/chelsearob1992/status/1242862550485786628?s=20
    Indeed and we know what happened to him in 1945. KSICIPM
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983
    Has the bloke who counts Englands numbers gone off with Coronavirus
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 34,288

    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    "We have plenty" of the have you got it type according to the CMO at todays briefing

    Its OK Rob if you dont want to score the Government effort out of 10 I will presume your a 10.5 until you get back to me. You dont get drummed out of the PB Tory club unless you score less than 9.9/10 you know

    You are not even a tiny bit disappointed in the testing numbers thats fine
    How about engaging on the point, rather than having a go at me. If it was feasible to up testing by that much so quickly, don't you think they would have done it already?
    I dont know you would have thought so but why arent they rising rapidly as promised? The Government is doing well in some stuff like the ramping up of the Lockdown but IMO falling short on rapid ramp up of tests

    Why wont you engage with rating the Government effort rather than put a smiley face on a stupid comment that BJO thinks Boris should make 3 million in his kitchen.
    https://twitter.com/chelsearob1992/status/1242862550485786628?s=20
    Indeed and we know what happened to him in 1945. KSICIPM
    ...or RLBICIPM! Bearing in mind Starmer's supporters are still waiting the arrival of their ballot papers. Jenny Formby rocks!
  • stodgestodge Posts: 15,323
    DavidL said:


    Have to say before this I didn’t rate Hancock at all but he has done really well.

    I disagree - his jibe at Sadiq Khan was unnecessary and his comments about construction workers continuing to need to work have only exacerbated problems.

    I think he's very poor in all honesty.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 55,898
    DavidL said:

    Have to say before this I didn’t rate Hancock at all but he has done really well.
    He has stepped up.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983

    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    "We have plenty" of the have you got it type according to the CMO at todays briefing

    Its OK Rob if you dont want to score the Government effort out of 10 I will presume your a 10.5 until you get back to me. You dont get drummed out of the PB Tory club unless you score less than 9.9/10 you know

    You are not even a tiny bit disappointed in the testing numbers thats fine
    How about engaging on the point, rather than having a go at me. If it was feasible to up testing by that much so quickly, don't you think they would have done it already?
    I dont know you would have thought so but why arent they rising rapidly as promised? The Government is doing well in some stuff like the ramping up of the Lockdown but IMO falling short on rapid ramp up of tests

    Why wont you engage with rating the Government effort rather than put a smiley face on a stupid comment that BJO thinks Boris should make 3 million in his kitchen.
    https://twitter.com/chelsearob1992/status/1242862550485786628?s=20
    Indeed and we know what happened to him in 1945. KSICIPM
    ...or RLBICIPM! Bearing in mind Starmer's supporters are still waiting the arrival of their ballot papers. Jenny Formby rocks!
    Formby too busy suspending AS members presumably to issue ballot papers to MPs who have raised 100 complaints of AS a day!!

    Her days are numbered i predict SKS will sack her before the 2020 Conference
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 27,230
    Someone mentioned sporcle the other day. This is a very good one:

    https://www.sporcle.com/games/teedslaststand/leaders-of-millions
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 61,457
    eadric said:

    rcs1000 said:

    Italy numbers

    Borrelli has fever today. He is at home.
    We got two new men reading the numbers.

    Currently positive: 57.521 (+3.491) including 3.489 (+93) in UCI
    Deaths: 7.503 (+683)
    Healed: 9.362 (+1.036)

    Total new cases +5.210

    So, the currently positive number in Italy grew 7.5%, its lowest number since the beginning of the crisis.

    There's more positive news in there. Italy performed the highest number of tests of any day of the outbreak, 27,481 - which is 28% up on yesterday. Despite this big increase in testing, the number of new cases dropped slightly to 5,210.

    In Lombardy, where the virus started, new cases were 1,643. That's almost exactly half of the peak level of 3,241.

    In summary, the numbers are coming down quickly in Lombardy now, and are slowly declining for Italy as a whole. The positive percentage for tests also fell below 20%. Bear in mind that a week ago it was in the 30s.

    If there is a concern, it is that the overall numbers are not dropping rapidly yet. But so long as the rest of Italy is just following Lombardy by four or five days, then the numbers are pretty encouraging.
    I look forward to your positive analysis every day. Sincerely. Thankyou.

    On a less promising note did you see that Hong Kong saw a quite rapid doubling of numbers (in a week) as soon as they relaxed restrictions?

    That’s going to be the 2nd test. When and how do you let it surge again. Warm weather seemingly does not help that much.
    We don't yet know how to relax measures well. It has to be in the context of better treatment and mass (250k+/day) tests.

    And it's OK to see numbers rise after removing the lockdown. We just need to see the numbers increase slowly. If it goes from 10 cases/day to 20/day over the course of two weeks - and that's the doubling pace, then that's OK.

    If it goes 10/day to 20/day to 40/day to 80/day over the course of two weeks, then that's not OK.

  • JonathanDJonathanD Posts: 2,400
    edited March 2020

    JonathanD said:

    DavidL said:

    Have to say before this I didn’t rate Hancock at all but he has done really well.
    Pandemic planning should be something the NHS is very good at and part of their routine functions. Also they have had 2 months notice of the potential for this to start spreading here.

    If anything I am surprised at how slow they are in dealing with some of the basics - PPE and ramping up the testing rate in particular. Is it lack of domestic suppliers that is the problem. Definitely something for the Public Inquiry to look at.
    It said that the NHS Pandemic Plan contained no mention of needing more Ventilators.

    Whoever was responsible for that oversight ought not to go near a future planning exercise imo
    Interesting, I hadn't heard that. I had a sense that the initial government response and modelling seemed to fixate on a ' flu' pandemic rather than a sars type and I wonder if that's where we went wrong.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 56,982
    MikeL said:

    Beth Rigby (Sky News) in a packaged report (ie not said off the cuff) just said there are 1.7 million self-employed people in the UK.

    Basic common sense would suggest that figure has to be too low - just checked and per ONS the figure is actually 5.03 million.

    So she's got the most simple, basic information wrong about the very question she asked the PM today.

    It's absolutely hopeless - but it's a familiar story - anything requiring any attention to detail and / or involving numbers and the chances are even supposedly reputable people in high profile positions will get it wrong.

    The media seem to regard hard facts as unfriendly. Hence this old joke -

    https://aviationhumor.net/journalists-guide-to-aircraft-identification/

  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 34,288

    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    "We have plenty" of the have you got it type according to the CMO at todays briefing

    Its OK Rob if you dont want to score the Government effort out of 10 I will presume your a 10.5 until you get back to me. You dont get drummed out of the PB Tory club unless you score less than 9.9/10 you know

    You are not even a tiny bit disappointed in the testing numbers thats fine
    How about engaging on the point, rather than having a go at me. If it was feasible to up testing by that much so quickly, don't you think they would have done it already?
    I dont know you would have thought so but why arent they rising rapidly as promised? The Government is doing well in some stuff like the ramping up of the Lockdown but IMO falling short on rapid ramp up of tests

    Why wont you engage with rating the Government effort rather than put a smiley face on a stupid comment that BJO thinks Boris should make 3 million in his kitchen.
    https://twitter.com/chelsearob1992/status/1242862550485786628?s=20
    Indeed and we know what happened to him in 1945. KSICIPM
    ...or RLBICIPM! Bearing in mind Starmer's supporters are still waiting the arrival of their ballot papers. Jenny Formby rocks!
    Formby too busy suspending AS members presumably to issue ballot papers to MPs who have raised 100 complaints of AS a day!!

    Her days are numbered i predict SKS will sack her before the 2020 Conference
    I genuinely hope you are right. I have this nagging feeling that in 10 days time we will be 'celebrating' RLBs marginal victory over Starmer.

    The people running the circus are so corrupt, if he does win Starmer needs to drain the swamp.

    At a time of national crisis we have no opposition.
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 68,007

    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    "We have plenty" of the have you got it type according to the CMO at todays briefing

    Its OK Rob if you dont want to score the Government effort out of 10 I will presume your a 10.5 until you get back to me. You dont get drummed out of the PB Tory club unless you score less than 9.9/10 you know

    You are not even a tiny bit disappointed in the testing numbers thats fine
    How about engaging on the point, rather than having a go at me. If it was feasible to up testing by that much so quickly, don't you think they would have done it already?
    I dont know you would have thought so but why arent they rising rapidly as promised? The Government is doing well in some stuff like the ramping up of the Lockdown but IMO falling short on rapid ramp up of tests

    Why wont you engage with rating the Government effort rather than put a smiley face on a stupid comment that BJO thinks Boris should make 3 million in his kitchen.
    https://twitter.com/chelsearob1992/status/1242862550485786628?s=20
    Indeed and we know what happened to him in 1945. KSICIPM
    ...or RLBICIPM! Bearing in mind Starmer's supporters are still waiting the arrival of their ballot papers. Jenny Formby rocks!
    Formby too busy suspending AS members presumably to issue ballot papers to MPs who have raised 100 complaints of AS a day!!

    Her days are numbered i predict SKS will sack her before the 2020 Conference
    I genuinely hope you are right. I have this nagging feeling that in 10 days time we will be 'celebrating' RLBs marginal victory over Starmer.

    The people running the circus are so corrupt, if he does win Starmer needs to drain the swamp.

    At a time of national crisis we have no opposition.
    If Starmer doesn't win, and I am not convinced this hasn't been rigged, then the Labour will split.
  • guybrushguybrush Posts: 265

    The guidance quietly changed from only key workers go to work to all go to work unless they can work at home. This is not a proper lockdown at all. It's a half measure that will cost lives and help the virus spread. #botchedlockdown pic.twitter.com/yvxp3j44CV

    — Stephen Mumford (@SDMumford) March 24, 2020
    Blimey, have I missed something here?
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 23,392
    Report from this evening's walk to the gate to put the bin out:

    Four people walking, two with dogs, two without. All at least 20m apart.

    Riverford delivery included sausages. Which was nice.

    Running low on milk, but we should be getting some on Friday.
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 68,007
    Daily Mail:

    "Coronavirus crisis could cause a loneliness epidemic in older adults: Study shows cutting off over-50s from transport, retail and leisure facilities increases feelings of isolation and depression"

    No shit Sherlock...
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 37,525
    "Europe's odd man out: Sweden refuses to bring in lockdowns despite 2,272 infections, keeps bars open and even encourages people to go out
    Primary schools, restaurants and bars open encouraging people to go outside"

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8151111/Swedish-people-disregarding-Covid-19-lockdown-going-pint.html
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983

    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Shouldnt over promise

    Ramping UP rather suggests rapid increase in tests particularly as that what was said

    Hunt thinks its disappointing whats your score?

    ONCE AGAIN THE EXACT QUOTE ON 18.3.20 WAS

    "We're massively increasing the testing to see whether you have it now and ramping up daily testing from 5,000 a day, to 10,000 to 25,000 and then up at 250,000,"

    You think he can just click his fingers and magic up the stuff necessary for these testing kits?
    "We have plenty" of the have you got it type according to the CMO at todays briefing

    Its OK Rob if you dont want to score the Government effort out of 10 I will presume your a 10.5 until you get back to me. You dont get drummed out of the PB Tory club unless you score less than 9.9/10 you know

    You are not even a tiny bit disappointed in the testing numbers thats fine
    How about engaging on the point, rather than having a go at me. If it was feasible to up testing by that much so quickly, don't you think they would have done it already?
    I dont know you would have thought so but why arent they rising rapidly as promised? The Government is doing well in some stuff like the ramping up of the Lockdown but IMO falling short on rapid ramp up of tests

    Why wont you engage with rating the Government effort rather than put a smiley face on a stupid comment that BJO thinks Boris should make 3 million in his kitchen.
    https://twitter.com/chelsearob1992/status/1242862550485786628?s=20
    Indeed and we know what happened to him in 1945. KSICIPM
    ...or RLBICIPM! Bearing in mind Starmer's supporters are still waiting the arrival of their ballot papers. Jenny Formby rocks!
    Formby too busy suspending AS members presumably to issue ballot papers to MPs who have raised 100 complaints of AS a day!!

    Her days are numbered i predict SKS will sack her before the 2020 Conference
    I genuinely hope you are right. I have this nagging feeling that in 10 days time we will be 'celebrating' RLBs marginal victory over Starmer.

    The people running the circus are so corrupt, if he does win Starmer needs to drain the swamp.

    At a time of national crisis we have no opposition.
    They are not very good at being corrupt in a left supporting way.

    The top nominated BAME NEC bloke and 2 other highly nominated Left Wing NEC Candidates all been suspended in last 7 days. All 3 were Momentum Candidates.

    SKS will rid the Party of Milne and others in Corbyns team, I would be surprised if Formby doesnt go too. He will win on first ballot. I am looking forward to seeing how he performs he really does have a golden pass with the Virus
  • TGOHF666TGOHF666 Posts: 2,052
    Andy_JS said:

    "Europe's odd man out: Sweden refuses to bring in lockdowns despite 2,272 infections, keeps bars open and even encourages people to go out
    Primary schools, restaurants and bars open encouraging people to go outside"

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8151111/Swedish-people-disregarding-Covid-19-lockdown-going-pint.html

    They probably have this right.

    It's not really kicked off north of the Alps.
  • GideonWiseGideonWise Posts: 1,123
    TGOHF666 said:

    Andy_JS said:

    "Europe's odd man out: Sweden refuses to bring in lockdowns despite 2,272 infections, keeps bars open and even encourages people to go out
    Primary schools, restaurants and bars open encouraging people to go outside"

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8151111/Swedish-people-disregarding-Covid-19-lockdown-going-pint.html

    They probably have this right.

    It's not really kicked off north of the Alps.
    A natural baseline level of social distancing built in.
  • FloaterFloater Posts: 14,207
    TGOHF666 said:

    Andy_JS said:

    "Europe's odd man out: Sweden refuses to bring in lockdowns despite 2,272 infections, keeps bars open and even encourages people to go out
    Primary schools, restaurants and bars open encouraging people to go outside"

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8151111/Swedish-people-disregarding-Covid-19-lockdown-going-pint.html

    They probably have this right.

    It's not really kicked off north of the Alps.
    Sure about that?
  • MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,810
    edited March 2020
    In approx 48 hours, the US should be leading the Coronavirus league table (for total number of cases).

    US is currently:

    - 11,000 behind Italy and catching up at approx 5,000 per day

    - 18,000 behind China and catching up at approx 10,000 per day
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 18,271
    Charles said:

    RobD said:

    FF43 said:

    FF43 said:

    All those screaming at Boris for the original strategy...Chief modelling egg-head thought it was good idea,

    https://twitter.com/Smyth_Chris/status/1242761739332190209?s=20

    I don't think this is correct. Prof Ferguson produced the paper that convinced the government to change its policy. Ferguson does appear to have been sceptical earlier that containment policies would actually reduce the infection rate and that may have influenced government policy. He seems to have revised his mortality estimates downwards. I doubt know whether that's because the containment methods are effective or due to a better understanding of the epidemic after a couple of weeks.
    Incidentally the information about the Italian mortality and serious illness rates that informed Ferguson's paper was available earlier to the UK government at the EU COVID19 information sharing meeting, but the government wasn't aware of it due to it boycotting that meeting for reasons of Brexit ideology.
    Is there a source for the claim that this information was only shared at this meeting, and not more widely? Seems a bit strange to keep information like this secret.
    I'm also intrigued that such a fan of the EU is implicating our European friends and partners in the death of a large number of British citizens.
    Don't worry, Charles, I said no such thing.
  • TGOHF666TGOHF666 Posts: 2,052
    Floater said:

    TGOHF666 said:

    Andy_JS said:

    "Europe's odd man out: Sweden refuses to bring in lockdowns despite 2,272 infections, keeps bars open and even encourages people to go out
    Primary schools, restaurants and bars open encouraging people to go outside"

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8151111/Swedish-people-disregarding-Covid-19-lockdown-going-pint.html

    They probably have this right.

    It's not really kicked off north of the Alps.
    Sure about that?
    Latitudes
    Wuhan 30.6
    Madrid 40.4
    New York 40.7
    Milan 45.4

    Munich 48
    London 51
    Stockholm 59

    Maybe it's a southern disease ?

  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983
    We will overtake S Korea this week unless England reporting bloke continues failing to report like today
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,983
    Bill Gates says we can’t restart the economy soon and simply “ignore that pile of bodies over in the corner”
This discussion has been closed.