Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » The pollsters got the big picture at GE2015 absolutely righ

24

Comments

  • Tim_BTim_B Posts: 7,669
    MTimT said:

    The wife just made me laugh. The TV is going on about creative cures for cabin fever. She said "that's easy - go outside and do something" I said, "But they're advising everyone to stay in." Wife "That's we we're a national of fat useless people!"

    Joke from ABC7 in Washington -

    what do you get when you cross a snowstorm with a vampire?

    - frost bite
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034
    LOL
    Speedy said:

    MTimT said:

    Danny565 said:

    Speedy said:


    Trump 43
    Hillary 39
    Deez Nuts (fictional candidate) 10

    !!!
    So, when asked hypotheticals this far out from the election, responds have a sense of humour.
    Yeah, 10% would vote Bloomberg for president.
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    edited 2016 23
    Danny565 said:

    Speedy said:


    Trump 43
    Hillary 39
    Deez Nuts (fictional candidate) 10

    !!!
    .
  • Tim_BTim_B Posts: 7,669
    edited 2016 23
    An even worse joke from ABC7 -

    where does a snowman keep his money?

    - in a snow bank.

    Sorry :blush:
  • another_richardanother_richard Posts: 26,998
    Sean_F said:

    FPT constituencies with big Muslim populations. Bear in mind these are mostly inner city seats filled with all sorts of groups that favour Labour - eg university workers, social housing tenants, public sector workers, people working in arts, design, media etc. The rise in the Labour vote won't just have come from Muslims.

    Public sector workers and social housing tenants certainly but there weren't any real 'trendy lefty' constituencies in that list. None of those constituencies would have voted YEStoAV for example.

    The list was only to show that the claim that there had been a big fall in ethnic minority support for Labour in 2015 was rubbish.

    If anyone has a list of the top 10 Afro-Caribbean and top 10 Hindu/Sikh constituencies it would be interesting to see the electoral change in those in 2015.

  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Depressing interactive map for Jezza

    The rise & fall of communism, 1917-present. https://t.co/R4SocmYLQJ
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @JL_Baseball: #Blizzard2016 @OHnewsroom "You know what we call #blizzard2016 in Cleveland? February."
    @CLillstrungNH
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 72,365

    BBC Spin Room
    Caption contest. What is Jez thinking? https://t.co/hu6M23iA1r

    Another holiday with Diane...

    Ugh. Pass the mind bleach. That's an image I never want to have again.
  • RodCrosbyRodCrosby Posts: 7,737
    edited 2016 23
    Tim_B said:

    when the second order autoregressive component is taken into consideration.

    I have no idea what this means but I'm going to use it - sounds fantastic.

    Basically the model postulates that the voters have memory of the previous two election results, with a natural tendency towards change after two consecutive victories for one party.

    Ergo, knowing the previous two results goes a long way in being able to predict the next, although there is still uncertainty, which must be captured by another variable.

    The actual outcomes will depend on:-

    i) the point in the cycle - it's easier to win a second term than a third, etc...
    ii) the scale of the previous two outcomes - landslides will offer somewhat of a cushion for next time...
    iii) the short-term indicator, namely PM approval - which can "disturb" the regularity of the autoregressive process, keeping a party in office for longer/shorter than would otherwise be expected...
  • surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    edited 2016 23

    Sean_F said:

    FPT constituencies with big Muslim populations. Bear in mind these are mostly inner city seats filled with all sorts of groups that favour Labour - eg university workers, social housing tenants, public sector workers, people working in arts, design, media etc. The rise in the Labour vote won't just have come from Muslims.

    Public sector workers and social housing tenants certainly but there weren't any real 'trendy lefty' constituencies in that list. None of those constituencies would have voted YEStoAV for example.

    The list was only to show that the claim that there had been a big fall in ethnic minority support for Labour in 2015 was rubbish.

    If anyone has a list of the top 10 Afro-Caribbean and top 10 Hindu/Sikh constituencies it would be interesting to see the electoral change in those in 2015.

    Ealing-Southall [ Hindu / Sikh ] : Labour vote went up by 14% ?
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    For our CIA fans

    ICYMI:
    CIA #Museum AotW: #Pigeon #Camera
    Pigeon missions are still classified, but...
    https://t.co/WAb6FckI57 https://t.co/eDC7DUQ3Nq
  • Tim_BTim_B Posts: 7,669

    For our CIA fans

    ICYMI:
    CIA #Museum AotW: #Pigeon #Camera
    Pigeon missions are still classified, but...
    https://t.co/WAb6FckI57 https://t.co/eDC7DUQ3Nq

    These folks do pigeon too (probably)

    http://www.ciachef.edu/google-nb/?gclid=CPOnj-i9wMoCFYElgQodg70Dpw
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,756

    Dearie me Part 94

    Scottish Resistance protest outside Tunnock's in Uddingston https://t.co/PwlifFBSbi

    Dear Dear
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,234
    malcolmg said:

    Dearie me Part 94

    Scottish Resistance protest outside Tunnock's in Uddingston https://t.co/PwlifFBSbi

    Dear Dear
    I wonder if they are protesting about those Tunnock mine fields that the government is suppressing :D
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    :smiley:
    Tim_B said:

    For our CIA fans

    ICYMI:
    CIA #Museum AotW: #Pigeon #Camera
    Pigeon missions are still classified, but...
    https://t.co/WAb6FckI57 https://t.co/eDC7DUQ3Nq

    These folks do pigeon too (probably)

    http://www.ciachef.edu/google-nb/?gclid=CPOnj-i9wMoCFYElgQodg70Dpw
  • LadyBucketLadyBucket Posts: 590
    ydoethur said:

    BBC Spin Room
    Caption contest. What is Jez thinking? https://t.co/hu6M23iA1r

    Another holiday with Diane...

    Ugh. Pass the mind bleach. That's an image I never want to have again.
    Sorry, but I can't find the picture of JC and DA even remotely funny. I just find the pair of them extremely dangerous.

    At the moment, I don't think the british people are in the mood to accept more immigration. It just feels as though the whole thing is going to blow up and no-one has even got a handle on it.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 97,052
    edited 2016 23

    Depressing interactive map for Jezza

    The rise & fall of communism, 1917-present. https://t.co/R4SocmYLQJ

    Is it correct? I mean, how many of the communist countries today are actually communist in policy?

    If anyone knows of the number of communist run countries that were not also dictatorships, or which were turned into dictatorships, that would be interesting too.
  • Hertsmere_PubgoerHertsmere_Pubgoer Posts: 3,476

    For our CIA fans

    ICYMI:
    CIA #Museum AotW: #Pigeon #Camera
    Pigeon missions are still classified, but...
    https://t.co/WAb6FckI57 https://t.co/eDC7DUQ3Nq

    Dick Dastardly tried ever so hard to stop these missions
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    edited 2016 23
    Speaking of National Review

    National Review doesn't understand all the subscription cancellations

    "Broken Hearted"
    https://t.co/mdU7elqRcu
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,739

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 53,244
    kle4 said:

    Former New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg – a onetime moderate Republican who has crusaded on gun control -- is considering throwing $1 billion of his vast fortune into an independent, stop-Donald Trump bid for president, according to a person familiar with his plans.

    Read more: http://www.politico.com/story/2016/01/michael-bloomberg-presidential-run-plans-report-218140#ixzz3y5OHEKsS

    The comments are hardly supportive. If he doesn't think better of it his campaign could be his most expensive mistake.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,234

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,933
    edited 2016 23
    ydoethur said:

    BBC Spin Room
    Caption contest. What is Jez thinking? https://t.co/hu6M23iA1r

    Another holiday with Diane...

    Ugh. Pass the mind bleach. That's an image I never want to have again.
    Can't the two of them stay in the camp for a few days? Let them see how friendly and welcoming it is at night to a couple of Brits with a camera crew.
  • Tim_BTim_B Posts: 7,669
    Several places in DC, Maryland and northern VA now reporting snowfall totals of 30 inches.
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    :smiley:

    For our CIA fans

    ICYMI:
    CIA #Museum AotW: #Pigeon #Camera
    Pigeon missions are still classified, but...
    https://t.co/WAb6FckI57 https://t.co/eDC7DUQ3Nq

    Dick Dastardly tried ever so hard to stop these missions
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,933
    Another few candidates for cuts in public spending. I wonder how many more they can find?
    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/womens-politics/12117232/Fat-cat-sisterhood-part-two-I-name-the-Empress-of-Excess.html
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,739
    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,234
    edited 2016 23

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    "Mr Aeschi and Guthlaugur Thor Thordarson, of Iceland’s Independence Party, invited Britain to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA), of which the UK was a founding member."

    I only see one member (Iceland), and the two people aren't in government, and aren't associated with EFTA. Am I missing something?


    Edit: Ah Mr Aeschi is from a Swiss party, also not in government.
  • another_richardanother_richard Posts: 26,998

    Sean_F said:

    FPT constituencies with big Muslim populations. Bear in mind these are mostly inner city seats filled with all sorts of groups that favour Labour - eg university workers, social housing tenants, public sector workers, people working in arts, design, media etc. The rise in the Labour vote won't just have come from Muslims.

    Public sector workers and social housing tenants certainly but there weren't any real 'trendy lefty' constituencies in that list. None of those constituencies would have voted YEStoAV for example.

    The list was only to show that the claim that there had been a big fall in ethnic minority support for Labour in 2015 was rubbish.

    If anyone has a list of the top 10 Afro-Caribbean and top 10 Hindu/Sikh constituencies it would be interesting to see the electoral change in those in 2015.

    A quick look shows that heavily Hindu constituencies - Brent N, Harrow E, Harrow W - had little change between 2010 and 2015.

    Whereas those which had the highest Sikh populations - Feltham, Hayes and especially Ealing Southall - had strong swings to Labour.

    The constituencies with the highest Afro-Caribbean voters also had significant increases in the Labour vote, although lower than in the highest Muslim constituencies. However these high Afro-Caribbean constituencies also tend to the ones most associated with 'trendy lefties' so what the breakdown of that Labour vote increase was is unsure.

  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 53,244

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    The Mayor is not very sympathetic towards pro-migrant protesters judging by her comments on Twitter.
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    The Mayor is not very sympathetic towards pro-migrant protesters judging by her comments on Twitter.
    Were they flooding in to see Corbyn or was he promising them instant access?
  • Moses_Moses_ Posts: 4,865

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    This cannot be allowed to continue. If the conditions are bad which no one is really in any doubt that they are, it is for the French to deal with it. These people have also crossed many safe countries before arriving at Calais. If they wanted asylum they should have claimed in any one of them and they are presently sitting in a country known as a holiday destination.

    If they were truly under threat then they would have been happy in any one of those they crossed. I can only presume they are not true asylum seekers or they are selective in where they want to go for other reasons which is effectively the same thing.

    http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2016/01/23/17/3081D89000000578-3413566-image-a-12_1453571877153.jpg

  • Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 62,138
    Good evening, everyone.

    Edward III would sort the Calais camp out.
  • another_richardanother_richard Posts: 26,998

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    How many of the 50 are male and 18-35 years old ?

  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,933

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    Please say that Corbyn and Abbot are stuck there! Pretty please!
  • GeoffMGeoffM Posts: 6,071
    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    "Mr Aeschi and Guthlaugur Thor Thordarson, of Iceland’s Independence Party, invited Britain to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA), of which the UK was a founding member."

    I only see one member (Iceland), and the two people aren't in government, and aren't associated with EFTA. Am I missing something?


    Edit: Ah Mr Aeschi is from a Swiss party, also not in government.
    Countries are members of EFTA and other alliances, not governments.

    Doing it the other way around could be fun though. We could come to an arrangement that we were only members of the EU when we elect a Labour govt and drop out whilst under a Tory one?
  • Moses_Moses_ Posts: 4,865

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    The Mayor is not very sympathetic towards pro-migrant protesters judging by her comments on Twitter.
    Were they flooding in to see Corbyn or was he promising them instant access?
    Corbyn said this today... You would think he was talking about a refugee camp in the middle of a war zone. Nope this is Northern France so why are the French not attending to these people? I presume we have to give them all this here is what he means.

    "'Also, there are the human needs of people. We have got people here who have been here for months, if not longer than that, with no proper education, no access to doctors, no access to dentists, limited access to food - in very cold, very wet conditions"

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3413566/Port-Calais-closed-migrants-storm-harbour-make-Spirit-Britain-ferry-desperate-bid-reach-UK.html#ixzz3y5ooA0r3
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,234
    GeoffM said:

    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    "Mr Aeschi and Guthlaugur Thor Thordarson, of Iceland’s Independence Party, invited Britain to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA), of which the UK was a founding member."

    I only see one member (Iceland), and the two people aren't in government, and aren't associated with EFTA. Am I missing something?


    Edit: Ah Mr Aeschi is from a Swiss party, also not in government.
    Countries are members of EFTA and other alliances, not governments.

    Doing it the other way around could be fun though. We could come to an arrangement that we were only members of the EU when we elect a Labour govt and drop out whilst under a Tory one?
    I was pointing out they have little influence, and aren't directly related to EFTA. The headline could be read as suggesting someone from EFTA invited us.

    For instance, me inviting the US to join the EU should not warrant the headline "United States invited to join the European Union".
  • Moses_Moses_ Posts: 4,865

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    How many of the 50 are male and 18-35 years old ?

    See for yourself

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3413566/Port-Calais-closed-migrants-storm-harbour-make-Spirit-Britain-ferry-desperate-bid-reach-UK.html
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Old Holborn
    Twitter is going to be awful tonight

    https://t.co/2JRaW3Btf7

    The Moon is waxing. Full moon occurs at 01:46:20, 24 Jan 2016 GMT.
  • Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 62,138
    Mr. Moses, same day as Corbyn visits. He has timing...
  • SimonStClareSimonStClare Posts: 7,976
    edited 2016 23
    "We have got people here who have been here for months, if not longer than that, with no proper education, no access to doctors, no access to dentists, limited access to food - in very cold, very wet conditions"

    Perhaps the migrants are right not seeking asylum – Northern France sounds like a hell hole.
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 23,109

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    If the people in question were in two of the governments of EFTA then your statement "It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us" would be accurate.

    If I understand correctly, they are not.
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Lolz

    Weird: Serbian language crime drama where someone asks for a Cameron haircut. Gets told. https://t.co/wgUNOvaKHD https://t.co/hjGWCSqkm9
  • Hertsmere_PubgoerHertsmere_Pubgoer Posts: 3,476
    Moses_ said:

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    How many of the 50 are male and 18-35 years old ?

    See for yourself

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3413566/Port-Calais-closed-migrants-storm-harbour-make-Spirit-Britain-ferry-desperate-bid-reach-UK.html
    All of them by the looks of the photos.
  • LucyJonesLucyJones Posts: 651
    edited 2016 23

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    How many of the 50 are male and 18-35 years old ?

    To a fool, these fit young Muslim men may appear well dressed and well fed. But a wise man such as Your Majesty can easily see that they are desperate starving refugees in rags.
  • john_zimsjohn_zims Posts: 3,399
    edited 2016 23
    @MikeSmithson

    'The narrowest leader rating gap at GE2015 was Cameron leading Miliband by 7% - exactly the same as the GB vote share margin.'


    But the same pollsters that got the result so badly wrong kept on telling us that unlike previous elections leader ratings and economic competence didn't matter as they were not being picked up in their polls !
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,346
    edited 2016 23
    Up to now I've been sceptical of the notice people have been taking of Corbyn. I know his ratings are shockingly bad and it's been one thing after another but I'm not sure how much Syria and Trident resonate with the electorate.

    His decision to visit the migrant camp in Calais, however, will very much resonate with the electorate. This shows where his priorities lie, and it's not with the people of Britain. As was suggested up thread, the question that should be asked of Corbyn is "why do these people want to leave socialist France to come to capitalist Britain?"
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    edited 2016 23
    Right Forward

    Imagine how we would have been in 1940 if our young men had buggered off to safety and left their wives and children to get on with it?
    LucyJones said:

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    How many of the 50 are male and 18-35 years old ?

    To a fool, these fit young Muslim men may appear well dressed and well fed. But a wise man such as Your Majesty can easily see that they are desperate starving refugees in rags.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 53,244
    Going back to a comment from a few threads ago about the number of Nigerians entering Europe via Italy, as members of the Commonwealth they'd have the right to vote in our General Election if they came to live here...
  • Moses_Moses_ Posts: 4,865
    LucyJones said:

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    How many of the 50 are male and 18-35 years old ?

    To a fool, these fit young Muslim men may appear well dressed and well fed. But a wise man such as Your Majesty can easily see that they are desperate starving refugees in rags.
    I did rather like the fact that the selfies they were taking with Corbyn today were on I phones.....

    Priorities n'all.
  • Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091

    Sean_F said:

    FPT constituencies with big Muslim populations. Bear in mind these are mostly inner city seats filled with all sorts of groups that favour Labour - eg university workers, social housing tenants, public sector workers, people working in arts, design, media etc. The rise in the Labour vote won't just have come from Muslims.

    Public sector workers and social housing tenants certainly but there weren't any real 'trendy lefty' constituencies in that list. None of those constituencies would have voted YEStoAV for example.

    The list was only to show that the claim that there had been a big fall in ethnic minority support for Labour in 2015 was rubbish.

    If anyone has a list of the top 10 Afro-Caribbean and top 10 Hindu/Sikh constituencies it would be interesting to see the electoral change in those in 2015.

    A quick look shows that heavily Hindu constituencies - Brent N, Harrow E, Harrow W - had little change between 2010 and 2015.

    Whereas those which had the highest Sikh populations - Feltham, Hayes and especially Ealing Southall - had strong swings to Labour.

    The constituencies with the highest Afro-Caribbean voters also had significant increases in the Labour vote, although lower than in the highest Muslim constituencies. However these high Afro-Caribbean constituencies also tend to the ones most associated with 'trendy lefties' so what the breakdown of that Labour vote increase was is unsure.

    I think you're right. The IPSOS MORI polls for ethnic minority votes look much more plausible:

    Labour: 65% (+5 from 2010)
    Conservatives: 23% (+7)
    Lib Dems: 4% (-16)
    Greens: 3%
    UKIP: 2%
  • SimonStClareSimonStClare Posts: 7,976
    BBC drip feeding the Calais story – will be interesting to see if they use the D’Mail photo.

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-35393423

    [update] They've gone for a photo of the protesters in support of the migrants. #Natch.
  • another_richardanother_richard Posts: 26,998
    Moses_ said:

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    How many of the 50 are male and 18-35 years old ?

    See for yourself

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3413566/Port-Calais-closed-migrants-storm-harbour-make-Spirit-Britain-ferry-desperate-bid-reach-UK.html
    Are they the engineers, doctors and scientists we've been told the refugees consist of ?
  • david_herdsondavid_herdson Posts: 18,034
    Speedy said:

    MTimT said:

    Danny565 said:

    Speedy said:


    Trump 43
    Hillary 39
    Deez Nuts (fictional candidate) 10

    !!!
    So, when asked hypotheticals this far out from the election, responds have a sense of humour.
    Yeah, 10% would vote Bloomberg for president.
    It's telling that a serious contender polls no better than a made-up name. Trump, Cruz, Sanders and Hillary may provide a very weak ballot paper between them but it looks as if the public have no mood for Bloomberg either. Would that change if he actually launched a campaign? Perhaps, but I can't see a Wall St billionaire finding a place in the hearts of middle America.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 97,052

    BBC drip feeding the Calais story – will be interesting to see if they use the D’Mail photo.

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-35393423

    [update] They've gone for a photo of the protesters in support of the migrants. #Natch.

    Ok, I stick up for the BBC from what are usually overly sensitive, hyperbolic complaints from right wingers, but that is a really odd choice for the lead photo to use on the story (at least the initial lead photo), as it really is very little to do with the main story at all. As part of a longer piece, part way down, sure, the earlier show of support and a photo of that is certainly relevant, but in 'best summary of story' terms, that's an odd one.
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903
    Moses_ said:

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    The Mayor is not very sympathetic towards pro-migrant protesters judging by her comments on Twitter.
    Were they flooding in to see Corbyn or was he promising them instant access?
    Corbyn said this today... You would think he was talking about a refugee camp in the middle of a war zone. Nope this is Northern France so why are the French not attending to these people? I presume we have to give them all this here is what he means.

    "'Also, there are the human needs of people. We have got people here who have been here for months, if not longer than that, with no proper education, no access to doctors, no access to dentists, limited access to food - in very cold, very wet conditions"

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3413566/Port-Calais-closed-migrants-storm-harbour-make-Spirit-Britain-ferry-desperate-bid-reach-UK.html#ixzz3y5ooA0r3
    You are right. This is a problem for France. Its unfortunate for France, but its their responsibility. it seems to be a good pointer to how a Corbyn government would behave.
  • NorfolkTilIDieNorfolkTilIDie Posts: 1,268
    I am deeply uncomfortable with electoral campaigns in this country being financed by American big banks. I wonder if the in campaign will regret taking the money in time.
  • JonnyJimmyJonnyJimmy Posts: 2,548
    edited 2016 23
    Has a poll ever asked respondents whether they're voting for their MP, a party, or a prime minister? Edit, or for particular policies
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 125,154
    edited 2016 23
    Speedy said:

    http://morningconsult.com/2016/01/new-poll-could-bloomberg-win/

    Trump 37
    Hillary 36
    Bloomberg 13

    http://www.publicpolicypolling.com/pdf/2015/PPP_Release_NC_12016.pdf

    N.Carolina

    Trump 45
    Hillary 43

    Trump 41
    Hillary 40
    Bloomberg 10

    Trump 43
    Hillary 39
    Deez Nuts (fictional candidate) 10

    Usually independent candidates start in the high teens or low 20's before collapsing as the campaign goes on, Bloomberg is doing half of what Perot what doing when he started in 1992, and worse than Anderson in 1980 :

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_polling_for_U.S._Presidential_elections#United_States_presidential_election.2C_1992

    Anderson started with 21%, he ended up at 8.
    Perot in 1992 started at 24, peaked at 39, ended with 19.
    Perot in 1996 started at 16, ended up with 8.

    That Morning Consult poll has Bloomberg getting 18% of independents, 8% of Republicans and 8% of Democrats, so he actually draws equally from both parties, though hurts Hillary by drawing from independents and young voters. If Sanders were the Democratic nominee I would expect more centrist Dems who backed Hillary to switch to Bloomberg and that would likely increase Bloomberg's score above 20%, if Hillary is the Dem nominee I doubt he would bother to run
    http://morningconsult.com/2016/01/new-poll-could-bloomberg-win/
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903
    viewcode said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    If the people in question were in two of the governments of EFTA then your statement "It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us" would be accurate.

    If I understand correctly, they are not.
    Is there a requirement to be in EFTA to also be part of the EEA?
  • pbr2013pbr2013 Posts: 649

    viewcode said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    If the people in question were in two of the governments of EFTA then your statement "It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us" would be accurate.

    If I understand correctly, they are not.
    Is there a requirement to be in EFTA to also be part of the EEA?
    No.
  • richardDoddrichardDodd Posts: 5,472
    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,346

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    That can be rectified.
  • Hertsmere_PubgoerHertsmere_Pubgoer Posts: 3,476

    I am deeply uncomfortable with electoral campaigns in this country being financed by American big banks. I wonder if the in campaign will regret taking the money in time.

    Doubt it.

    The end will justify the means.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 72,365

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    We'll be fair, the best he could have got in Geography is E at A level. And that was in 1964 when you could get a pass just by being at the right school. It's not totally surprising if he doesn't understand the concepts of islands and national borders.
  • EPGEPG Posts: 6,693

    Right Forward

    Imagine how we would have been in 1940 if our young men had buggered off to safety and left their wives and children to get on with it?
    LucyJones said:

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    How many of the 50 are male and 18-35 years old ?

    To a fool, these fit young Muslim men may appear well dressed and well fed. But a wise man such as Your Majesty can easily see that they are desperate starving refugees in rags.


    They are being attacked by their own government. The migrants are more comparable to the Jews of Europe than young British conscripts.
    Stick to rebroadcasting Tory Twitter
  • MonikerDiCanioMonikerDiCanio Posts: 5,792

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    I don't think he regards them as a problem, they're an opportunity to boost Labour's vote.
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 23,109
    edited 2016 23

    I am deeply uncomfortable with electoral campaigns in this country being financed by American big banks. I wonder if the in campaign will regret taking the money in time.

    At about the same time as "out" regrets taking money from Putin, I should imagine...

    (ducks,run for cover).. ;)
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    I don't think he regards them as a problem, they're an opportunity to boost Labour's vote.
    Once again he is mistaken then.
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 23,109
    edited 2016 23
    Quick check for smileys

    :-) :) ;-) ;)

    [edit: ah, ok, you gotta make sure it's preceded by a space]
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034
    Tim_B said:

    Several places in DC, Maryland and northern VA now reporting snowfall totals of 30 inches.

    Lisa reporting snow on the drive is too deep for the John Deere to plough - usually happens around the 24-30" mark. This despite the fact she ploughed at 4am. Winds here are around 20mph, so there's a lot of drifting.

    I've spent the last hour out with the snowblower and not made much of a dent, only to see where I started getting drifted over again ... Feel a little like Sisyphus.
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903
    ydoethur said:

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    We'll be fair, the best he could have got in Geography is E at A level. And that was in 1964 when you could get a pass just by being at the right school. It's not totally surprising if he doesn't understand the concepts of islands and national borders.
    He knows how to read East German Road signs though.
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903
    pbr2013 said:

    viewcode said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    If the people in question were in two of the governments of EFTA then your statement "It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us" would be accurate.

    If I understand correctly, they are not.
    Is there a requirement to be in EFTA to also be part of the EEA?
    No.
    So this EFTA business is a dead issue then
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Ewww
    Horror as gangs of migrants 'assault female swimmers and masturbate in hot tub'

    Other migrants were caught "emptying their bowels" in the children's pool and masturbating in a hot tub, according to reports.

    They are thought to have been caught on CCTV before laughing at pool staff when challenged about their behaviour.

    Following the allegations, the historic Johannisbad baths in Zwickau, Saxony has banned migrants from the premises until further notice.
    http://www.express.co.uk/news/world/637276/Johannisbad-baths-Rainer-Kallweit-Zwickau-Saxony-Germany
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,354
    This is interesting but it is also a sample of 1. Do we have comparable data for previous elections and does it show the same trend?

    Presumably the people giving these opinions were also the people who had an excess weighting to Labour distorting the voting intention polls. If so that surely makes Cameron's lead even more significant but the choice will not always be between a solid PM and a muppet, even if 2020 looks like it might be.
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,739
    edited 2016 23
    viewcode said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    If the people in question were in two of the governments of EFTA then your statement "It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us" would be accurate.

    If I understand correctly, they are not.
    You are wrong I am afraid. They are. Both parties are currently the largest in their respective countries and both are part of their respective governments.
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,739
    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    "Mr Aeschi and Guthlaugur Thor Thordarson, of Iceland’s Independence Party, invited Britain to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA), of which the UK was a founding member."

    I only see one member (Iceland), and the two people aren't in government, and aren't associated with EFTA. Am I missing something?


    Edit: Ah Mr Aeschi is from a Swiss party, also not in government.
    Wrong. Both parties are in Government.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 72,365

    ydoethur said:

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    We'll be fair, the best he could have got in Geography is E at A level. And that was in 1964 when you could get a pass just by being at the right school. It's not totally surprising if he doesn't understand the concepts of islands and national borders.
    He knows how to read East German Road signs though.
    Or he and Abbott may have got lost in two senses of the word on that trip...
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,739
    edited 2016 23

    pbr2013 said:

    viewcode said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    If the people in question were in two of the governments of EFTA then your statement "It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us" would be accurate.

    If I understand correctly, they are not.
    Is there a requirement to be in EFTA to also be part of the EEA?
    No.
    So this EFTA business is a dead issue then
    No. There is a requirement to be in EFTA to be in the EEA. However not all members of EFTA have to be in the EEA.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,234
    edited 2016 23

    viewcode said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    If the people in question were in two of the governments of EFTA then your statement "It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us" would be accurate.

    If I understand correctly, they are not.
    You are wrong I am afraid. They are. Both parties are currently the largest in their respective countries and both are part of their respective governments.
    As far as I can tell, neither of the two gentlemen are in government, so they can't exactly speak in an official capacity as to their countries position on the matter.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 125,154

    I am deeply uncomfortable with electoral campaigns in this country being financed by American big banks. I wonder if the in campaign will regret taking the money in time.

    The Leave campaign will have plenty of cash from multi millionaire businessmen and financiers
  • Hertsmere_PubgoerHertsmere_Pubgoer Posts: 3,476
    ydoethur said:

    ydoethur said:

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    We'll be fair, the best he could have got in Geography is E at A level. And that was in 1964 when you could get a pass just by being at the right school. It's not totally surprising if he doesn't understand the concepts of islands and national borders.
    He knows how to read East German Road signs though.
    Or he and Abbott may have got lost in two senses of the word on that trip...
    The STASI reports of their trip would make interesting reading.
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,739
    edited 2016 23
    RobD said:

    viewcode said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    If the people in question were in two of the governments of EFTA then your statement "It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us" would be accurate.

    If I understand correctly, they are not.
    You are wrong I am afraid. They are. Both parties are currently the largest in their respective countries and both are part of their respective governments.
    As far as I can tell, neither of the two gentlemen are in government, so they can't exactly speak in an official capacity as to their countries position on the matter.
    Wrong again. Thomas Aeschi is probably in a better position to speak than almost anyone else from Switzerland given not only is he part of the Swiss Government but he is also one of Switzerland's EFTA/EEA representatives.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 72,365

    ydoethur said:

    ydoethur said:

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    We'll be fair, the best he could have got in Geography is E at A level. And that was in 1964 when you could get a pass just by being at the right school. It's not totally surprising if he doesn't understand the concepts of islands and national borders.
    He knows how to read East German Road signs though.
    Or he and Abbott may have got lost in two senses of the word on that trip...
    The STASI reports of their trip would make interesting reading.
    I pity anyone who had the night shift! Even the Staasi didn't quite deserve that.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,234
    edited 2016 23

    RobD said:

    viewcode said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    If the people in question were in two of the governments of EFTA then your statement "It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us" would be accurate.

    If I understand correctly, they are not.
    You are wrong I am afraid. They are. Both parties are currently the largest in their respective countries and both are part of their respective governments.
    As far as I can tell, neither of the two gentlemen are in government, so they can't exactly speak in an official capacity as to their countries position on the matter.
    Wrong again. Thomas Aeschi is probably in a better position to speak than almost anyone else from Switzerland given not only is he part of the Swiss Government but he is also one of Switzerland's EFTA/EEA representatives.
    Well it is actually my first time being wrong! My apologies, I was going off of his rather barren Wikipedia page.

    Still, this is not a formal invitation as the headline suggests.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,883

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    He wants new Labour voters, to replace those he's alienated.
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Rob Hutton
    The Guardian comments thread - where it's impossible to tell if people are being sarcastic. https://t.co/T0kQNzdcp8
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,739
    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    viewcode said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    If the people in question were in two of the governments of EFTA then your statement "It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us" would be accurate.

    If I understand correctly, they are not.
    You are wrong I am afraid. They are. Both parties are currently the largest in their respective countries and both are part of their respective governments.
    As far as I can tell, neither of the two gentlemen are in government, so they can't exactly speak in an official capacity as to their countries position on the matter.
    Wrong again. Thomas Aeschi is probably in a better position to speak than almost anyone else from Switzerland given not only is he part of the Swiss Government but he is also one of Switzerland's EFTA/EEA representatives.
    Well it is actually my first time being wrong! My apologies, I was going off of his rather barren Wikipedia page.

    Still, this is not a formal invitation as the headline suggests.
    Sorry. The 'again' was my confusion as I had answered the same question from Viewpoint.
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 23,109

    viewcode said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    If the people in question were in two of the governments of EFTA then your statement "It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us" would be accurate.

    If I understand correctly, they are not.
    You are wrong I am afraid. They are. Both parties are currently the largest in their respective countries and both are part of their respective governments.
    Unless I'm mistaken, they are not in the governments, as follows
    * They are in the parliaments (assemblys, whatever)
    * They are members of the parties that are in[1] government
    * But they are not themselves in the government

    A British example would be Liam Fox
    * He is in the UK Parliament
    * He is a member of the party that is in government
    * He was a member of the government when he was SecState4Defence
    * But he is no longer and now cannot be said to be in the government

    [1] insofar as a party can be in government...
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 72,365
    edited 2016 23
    Sean_F said:

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    He wants new Labour voters, to replace those he's alienated.
    He needs replacements, not new Labour voters. We all know he hates New Labour voters, they're just Tories, he's going to win without them - somehow - even though by 2020 it will be 50 years since a Labour leader other than Blair got over 40% of the vote.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,883
    LucyJones said:

    50 reported to be on-board a ferry

    The Port of Calais has been temporarily closed due to a migrant invasion, as soon as they are cleared the Port will re-open

    How many of the 50 are male and 18-35 years old ?

    To a fool, these fit young Muslim men may appear well dressed and well fed. But a wise man such as Your Majesty can easily see that they are desperate starving refugees in rags.
    Very aggressive young men, with a huge sense of entitlement.
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Only alchemy will create the voters Labour needs now.
    ydoethur said:

    Sean_F said:

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    He wants new Labour voters, to replace those he's alienated.
    He needs replacements, not new Labour voters. We all know he hates New Labour voters, they're just Tories, he's going to win without them - somehow - even though by 2020 it will be 50 years since a Labour leader other than Blair got over 40% of the vote.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 125,154
    edited 2016 23
    ydoethur said:

    Sean_F said:

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    He wants new Labour voters, to replace those he's alienated.
    He needs replacements, not new Labour voters. We all know he hates New Labour voters, they're just Tories, he's going to win without them - somehow - even though by 2020 it will be 50 years since a Labour leader other than Blair got over 40% of the vote.
    His only hope is enough Tory votes go off to UKIP post EU ref to allow him to scrape through the backdoor in a deal with the Greens and SNP, Plaid and Farron's LDs, though it is highly unlikely
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 72,365

    Only alchemy will create the voters Labour needs now.

    ydoethur said:

    Sean_F said:

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    He wants new Labour voters, to replace those he's alienated.
    He needs replacements, not new Labour voters. We all know he hates New Labour voters, they're just Tories, he's going to win without them - somehow - even though by 2020 it will be 50 years since a Labour leader other than Blair got over 40% of the vote.
    This is the famous stone
    Which turneth all to gold;
    For that which doth its name impart
    Cannot for less be told.

    But since it has eluded the finest minds since time immemorial I somehow doubt that Corbyn will succeed where Flamel, Jabir and Lord Percy Percy have failed, I don't rate Corbyn's chances very highly....
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 23,109

    Sorry. The 'again' was my confusion as I had answered the same question from Viewpoint.


    Ah, so it's a walkoff, huh?... ;)

    Actually, I may have edged it. From his webpage

    WELCOME TO THE WEBSITE OF MEMBER OF PARLIAMENT THOMAS AESCHI, SWITZERLAND

    Thomas Aeschi has been a member of the Swiss House of Representatives (Nationalrat) since 2011, representing the Canton of Zug as a member of the Swiss People’s Party (SVP). He is a member of the committee on economics and taxation, as well as the EFTA/EU-delegation. He is also a consultant with a leading international management and strategy consulting firm. Previously, Thomas was an analyst in mergers and acquisitions at a leading Swiss bank in Zurich and Melbourne. In 2014, he was nominated by the World Economic Forum as a Young Global Leader. Thomas holds a Master in Public Administration from Harvard University and a Master of Business Administration from the University of St. Gallen where he was also a member of the organizing committee of the St. Gallen Symposium. He also studied at Tel Aviv University in Israel and at University Sains Malaysia, and participated in a one-year American Field Service student exchange at an American high school near Chicago as a teenager. He holds the rank of a first lieutenant in the Swiss military. Thomas enjoys traveling, skiing, and hiking
    .

    Being in the "committee on economics and taxation" doesn't put you in government. Bernard Jenkin is on the European Scrutiny Committee, but he's not in government

    I'll take your point that hs position as an EFTA/EU-delegation member makes him important but, again...that's not in government.

  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903

    pbr2013 said:

    viewcode said:

    RobD said:

    Britain invited to rejoin the European Free Trade Association (EFTA): http://t.co/RTFtnqKJVQ #efta #brexit http://t.co/kbKs0TYb3D

    That is hugely useful for Leave. One of the points being made by Europhiles has been whether or not EFTA would want us back. This seems a very clear signal about that.
    A bit misleading, we were invited to join, but not by EFTA themselves. It's basically just a third party saying "hey, why don't you join EFTA".
    Er no. It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us. They are not a third party.
    If the people in question were in two of the governments of EFTA then your statement "It is two of the four members of EFTA inviting us" would be accurate.

    If I understand correctly, they are not.
    Is there a requirement to be in EFTA to also be part of the EEA?
    No.
    So this EFTA business is a dead issue then
    No. There is a requirement to be in EFTA to be in the EEA. However not all members of EFTA have to be in the EEA.
    My question was 'Is there a requirement to be in EFTA to also be part of the EEA?' The answer came back 'No'
    So that answer is wrong?

    (I don't want this little thread to turn into an Abbot and Costello sketch BTW !)
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    :smile:
    ydoethur said:

    Only alchemy will create the voters Labour needs now.

    ydoethur said:

    Sean_F said:

    Why does Corbyn think the migrants in Calais are the problem for the UK..last I heard Calais was in France

    He wants new Labour voters, to replace those he's alienated.
    He needs replacements, not new Labour voters. We all know he hates New Labour voters, they're just Tories, he's going to win without them - somehow - even though by 2020 it will be 50 years since a Labour leader other than Blair got over 40% of the vote.
    This is the famous stone
    Which turneth all to gold;
    For that which doth its name impart
    Cannot for less be told.

    But since it has eluded the finest minds since time immemorial I somehow doubt that Corbyn will succeed where Flamel, Jabir and Lord Percy Percy have failed, I don't rate Corbyn's chances very highly....
This discussion has been closed.