Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Great question to the PM from Sky’s Beth Rigby – politicalbetting.com

1235»

Comments

  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 56,022
    edited February 2022

    The UK stock market is heavily invested in oil and energy which are benefitting from this crisis

    Indeed so. The Russian stock market was down 14% yesterday, traders in Moscow doesn’t seem too happy with the situation.
  • Boris has just said the UK only depends on 3% of Russian gas
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 54,114

    Well, we all have our childish, tiresome and wrong stuff.
    Personally I wish the the cliché mongers pooping out ‘useful idiots’ like it was a newly minted zinger would give it up. I realise that it’s difficult for many of them to say something interesting but silence is always an option.
    The amusing thing about "Useful Idiots" is that it was a term the Soviets used for their instinctive *allies*

    Named thus by their own side....

    Negative Nationalist (see https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/notes-on-nationalism/) if it makes you happy....
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 18,589

    Golly, that’s a lot of ‘my impression’, ‘that would imply’ and ‘I’d suspect’. Anything more concrete?
    Different testing isn't necessarily wrong or a bad thing. Getting a higher positivity rate may just imply testing the right people, rather than pointlessly having worried mothers in Surrey sticking a test up their nose 5 times a day.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 73,368

    Boris has just said the UK only depends on 3% of Russian gas

    Does he mean only 3% of our gas is from Russia, or we account for 3% of Russia's gas exports?
  • We're in agreement then. Covid makes people sick, they take time off. The good news is that Omicron doesn't make you very sick, so it isn't for weeks.
    No we're not remotely in agreement. It isn't true that Covid makes people sick for certain, Covid can make people sick, it also can have no real impact and leave people entirely asymptomatic.

    People should be off if they're actually sick, not simply because they're carrying a virus but aren't sick.
  • "We can live with that" is somewhat more casual than is necessary.
    Words of a Putin apologist
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 98,426

    The answer I'd expect from you. Let Russia do what it wants.
    We cannot do much therefore we must do (and, crucially, also say) nothing.

    The simplistic politics of 14 year olds dressed up as worldly wisdom.
  • ydoethur said:

    Does he mean only 3% of our gas is from Russia, or we account for 3% of Russia's gas exports?
    3% of our gas comes from Russia
  • Yay! My first three in Wordle!

    I've found the Guardian suggestion of starting with "Cones" and "Trial" has helped.
  • kle4 said:

    We cannot do much therefore we must do (and, crucially, also say) nothing.

    The simplistic politics of 14 year olds dressed up as worldly wisdom.
    I think what we can do at the moment is really in the range of sanctions. There's a good argument that stronger sanctions earlier than last time might deter him from going further ; but there's an almost equally strong argument that that leaves nothing to draw on if he does go further.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 73,368

    3% of our gas comes from Russia
    If he's telling the truth, and if March is reasonably mild and windy, we should be able to manage without that for some months at least.

    But those are two fairly big 'ifs.'

    And even if we do, prices are going to skyrocket as everyone else competes for the gas we're buying.
  • NickPalmerNickPalmer Posts: 21,673



    Indeed. Our country’s only land border is no different. There are people to the north of it who identify with the nation to the south of it, and there are people to the south of it who speak English!

    You can say the same about the French/German border, the French/Spanish border, the German/Belgium border, the Italian/Swiss border, and so on. This isn’t something unique to Eastern Europe. The difference is that we have (after centuries of war) found peaceful solutions.

    Yes (with a small continuing query over the Irish issue) - I think "after centuries of war" is relevant, though - we are I think all appalled by what happened to Yugoslavia, but it's a recent example of humanity not learning much from history. We shouldn't be too superior about it, just sad.
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 18,589
    ydoethur said:

    They're not 'past.' They're just not leading to full closures. There's still plenty of disruption. I had to take several days off myself a fortnight ago due to Covid. I haven't taken more than two consecutive days off since I was at school myself, and I was one of 28 teaching staff absent. The cover situation was - difficult.
    Fair enough. I do understand that the media drops stories pretty quick, so maybe I assumed too much. We have never had much of an impact at the Uni with staff or students off. Perhaps the schools have been different because no vaccination (for the primaries?)
  • YBarddCwscYBarddCwsc Posts: 7,172
    edited February 2022

    Indeed. The logic of those suggesting that multi-ethnic states must be split up, is that the chaps below were right.....

    Given that I actually posted approvingly of two of my friends who believed in the multi-ethnic state of Yugoslavia, your post is borderline ridiculous.

    If there are enough people who believe in a multi-ethnic country, then of course it can be gotten to work.

    The problem in the Ukraine and Yugoslavs is that there aren't.

    Canada works (in its roundabout fashion) because enough of the Francophones, the Anglophones and the Allophones realise that the alternative would be worse,
  • kamskikamski Posts: 6,319

    I have explained in previous posts. Support Ukraine financially and with military aid, short of boots on the ground. Particularly intel. Bolster the security of other Eastern European states. All this on top of massive sanctions on the Russian state and individuals.

    Make it clear that Russia is a pariah. It should have been done after Salisbury really, but we are where we are.

    So what is your answer?
    All of those things are already happening, apart from "massive sanctions". And I suppose the calculation governments are making is: if the west imposes massive sanctions today, what is left to deter further action in Ukraine by Putin?
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 34,537
    Nigelb said:

    Your points about Yugoslavia are well made, but to suggest that plebiscites were in any way possible since the annexation of Crimea is, I think, unrealistic.

    And I don't think you can so simply equate Ukraine with Yugoslavia.
    There was, maybe, more logic to the Kingdom of Croats, Serbs and Slovenes, the South Slavs, than to Stalin's arbitrary creation of "Ukraine".
  • BartholomewRobertsBartholomewRoberts Posts: 23,307
    edited February 2022

    Is is a legal mandate to stay home with norovirus, or just guidance based on common sense? As in, what you should do now if you have a cold, or sore throat etc.
    Companies I've worked at (and my children's school) have generally had a policy that you should stay at home for 48 hours if you've physically vomited or have diarrhoea.

    That's a sensible way to handle things like sickness and norovirus.

    My understanding is its a legal requirement for anyone food handling but I doubt it is for the whole nation, but it is a sensible policy either way.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 54,114

    The answer I'd expect from you. Let Russia do what it wants.
    When I finish my home engineering project - a 1-1 scale replica of Violet Club - can I then make some ridiculous territorial demands?

    I've got a very furrin sounding name, so Negative Nationalism will apply (furriners always right).
  • BartholomewRobertsBartholomewRoberts Posts: 23,307
    edited February 2022

    1. People catch virus
    2. People go off sick because they are ill with the virus
    3. People get better and return to work

    BR has been demanding that people sick with Covid go to work as normal. If its Norovirus they don't bring arse-spraying mayhem into work, they stay home, so why is Covid any different? The genuinely good news is that for most people 3 jabs means Omicron is relatively mild. A few days of being crap, a week tops and you're back to normal.

    Before Br says "eugh but a lot of people don't even know they have it the virus is that mild" then they won't be ill and won't be off sick. But if people are ill - with Covid or anything else - you don't want them in an office environment. I have both ordered people to go home and been ordered home for things that were not Covid.
    Utter bullshit.

    BR has been demanding that people who are not sick with Covid be able to go to work as normal. I understand that having Covid and being sick are not the same thing.

    If its Norovirus people stay at home based on symptoms, not for weeks based on a test strip showing a line even if asymptomatic.

    Act based on actual sickness, not theoretical testing.

    I have never said people should go in if they're physically sick, I said we should switch from going based on virus results to based on actual sickness. If you can't understand that, its because you're wilfully misreading it, or are functionally illiterate. I know you're not the latter, so I can only assume you're being wilfully disingenuous.
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 19,155

    Golly, that’s a lot of ‘my impression’, ‘that would imply’ and ‘I’d suspect’. Anything more concrete?
    Across the UK as a whole about seven tests per person have been conducted. For Scotland that figure is less than three.

    I was confident what I said was true, but couldn't be bothered to check the precise figures. You thought that would mean you could catch me out.
  • kjhkjh Posts: 12,487

    Boris has just said the UK only depends on 3% of Russian gas

    Boris is either thick or deliberately misleading because although that might be true the UK is dependent upon the price of gas (and other energy) no matter where it comes from so if others are very dependent upon Russian gas so that the price goes up, then so are we.
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 31,201
    edited February 2022
    .

    Words of a Putin apologist
    Not at all. A pragmatic but overly casual statement to have made.

    Big Dog may be saved. Big Dog can report he has saved the World from Covid, Big Dog can claim Churchillian statesmanship at 12.30 today. If the voting public have jumped on board the Boris train with your enthusiasm over the last 24 hours, expect a 10 point Conservative VI lead.

    The situation in Ukraine is still worrysome and the danger from Putin remains far from over. I suspect all Western leaders would be secretly more than happy if Heathener is right, including Big Dog
  • YBarddCwscYBarddCwsc Posts: 7,172
    edited February 2022
    kle4 said:

    We cannot do much therefore we must do (and, crucially, also say) nothing.

    The simplistic politics of 14 year olds dressed up as worldly wisdom.

    Given that you have made 71,140 posts, it seems a little odd to claim that you are being asked "to (crucially) say nothing."
  • The amusing thing about "Useful Idiots" is that it was a term the Soviets used for their instinctive *allies*

    Named thus by their own side....

    Negative Nationalist (see https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/notes-on-nationalism/) if it makes you happy....
    Yer a great one for telling people stuff that they already know very well. I'm well aware of the origin of the term 'useful idiots', and I first read Notes on Nationalism decades before you started posting a link to it here on a weekly basis.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 54,114
    kamski said:

    All of those things are already happening, apart from "massive sanctions". And I suppose the calculation governments are making is: if the west imposes massive sanctions today, what is left to deter further action in Ukraine by Putin?
    More sanctions - I think it unlikely that the US will move straight to pulling SWIFT access, for example.

    This is straight out of the books on cold war strategy. You don't start reacting only when you get to the places where you actually fight (Baltics etc) - you start reacting before (Ukraine). You increase the reaction as more and more happens.

    This means that the reaction isn't a surprise, and the cost of taking another step becomes apparent.
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 31,201
    ydoethur said:

    Does he mean only 3% of our gas is from Russia, or we account for 3% of Russia's gas exports?
    By the time it gets to us it's French owned gas. He's not lying.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 98,426
    Oddly emotive headline on the bbc about an 'axe' being taken testing and does it matter . I thought that was against their style guide, I remember an old one they changed about spending cuts taxes being wielded
  • kjh said:

    Boris is either thick or deliberately misleading because although that might be true the UK is dependent upon the price of gas (and other energy) no matter where it comes from so if others are very dependent upon Russian gas so that the price goes up, then so are we.
    I would not dispute that but only 3% from Russia will surprise many
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 51,087
    kamski said:

    I don't know Poland at all, only been over the border at Swinemünde (as it's known round here). There's a museum in Peenemünde that might be of interest, don't know about u boat pens. Greifswald is a nice hanseatic (university) town with some examples of the red brick gothic architecture.

    Stralsund is definitely worth visiting. And Prora in Rügen is worth visiting if you're interested in that bit of German history and the KdF program. It's been gradually converted into flats (and a youth hostel and a hotel) the last years, which is kind of a shame, but I think a couple of blocks remain unrenovated.
    From Wiki:

    "Robert Ley, head of the German Labour Front – of which Strength Through Joy was a subsidiary – envisioned Prora as a parallel to Butlins, which were British "holiday camps" designed to provide affordable holidays for the average worker. Prora was designed to house 20,000 holidaymakers, under the ideal that every worker deserved a holiday at the beach. Designed by Clemens Klotz, who won a design competition overseen by Adolf Hitler's chief architect Albert Speer, all rooms were planned to overlook the sea, while corridors and sanitation are located on the landward side.[3] Each room of 5 metres (16 ft) by 2.5 metres (8.2 ft) was to have two beds, a wardrobe and a sink. There were communal toilets, showers and bathrooms on each floor.

    Hitler's plans for Prora were much more ambitious. He wanted a gigantic sea resort, the "most mighty and large one to ever have existed", holding 20,000 beds. In the middle, a huge building was to be erected. At the same time, Hitler wanted it to be convertible into a military hospital in case of war. Hitler insisted that the plans of a giant indoor arena by architect Erich Putlitz be included. Putlitz's Festival Hall was intended to be able to accommodate all 20,000 guests at the same time. His plans included two wave-swimming pools, a cinema and a theatre.[1] A large dock for passenger ships was also planned.

    The designs won a Grand Prix award at the 1937 Paris World Exposition."

    Sopot is worth a look, just along the coast. See how the old Grand Hotel is coming along, buy some amber, etc.
  • .

    Not at all. A pragmatic but overly casual statement to have made.

    Big Dog may be saved. Big Dog can report he has saved the World from Covid, Big Dog can claim Churchillian statesmanship at 12.30 today. If the voting public have jumped on board the Boris train with your enthusiasm over the last 24 hours, expect a 10 point Conservative VI lead.

    The situation in Ukraine is still worrysome and the danger from Putin remains far from over. I suspect all Western leaders would be secretly more than happy if Heathener is right, including Big Dog
    I am not at all sure Boris poll ratings will improve over this but he has been spot on on covid and Ukraine
  • 11,558 deaths were registered in England and Wales in the week ending 11 Feb 2022.

    This was

    ▪️304 fewer deaths than the previous week
    ▪️8.2% below the five-year average (1,032 fewer deaths)


    https://twitter.com/ONS/status/1496055084337221632
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 54,114

    I would not dispute that but only 3% from Russia will surprise many
    To be honest, I am surprised that any gas comes from Russia, the routes are a pain....

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-58637094


    About half of UK gas supplies are of domestic origin, from the North Sea. The UK has been a big producer of gas since the mid-1960s, but output has fallen since 2000 and usage continues to rise.

    Another one-third of the UK's gas comes through pipelines from Norway.

    The rest consists almost entirely of imports of liquefied natural gas (LNG), which arrive in Britain by sea from countries such as Qatar, the US and even Trinidad and Tobago.

    The small amount of Russian gas that does reach the UK comes in LNG form.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 73,368

    Fair enough. I do understand that the media drops stories pretty quick, so maybe I assumed too much. We have never had much of an impact at the Uni with staff or students off. Perhaps the schools have been different because no vaccination (for the primaries?)
    Having taught in both, it's a different dynamic. First of all, contact hours at uni are rather less, so there's less impact even if the equivalent number of staff are off. Secondly, the nature of uni teaching, where you can be at some distance from the students for largish chunks of it, means there's less risk of infection anyway. Schools, by contrast, are much more cramped and much more personal. It's more like constant lab hours. Finally, if staff are absent at uni you can always cancel the session. You can't do that at a school unless we're talking A-level which is a fraction of the overall teaching level. Primary school classes need a teacher in front of them, whether their teacher is there or not. And at the moment, the usual supply numbers just aren't out there. Quite a lot found other, more congenial jobs in the pandemic and are not in any hurry to get back.

    So I think it's difficult to draw a meaningful comparison because of those different dynamics. What I can say is that while I'm glad to hear you're doing OK at your uni, this is still a big problem in schools.
  • RochdalePioneersRochdalePioneers Posts: 29,817
    edited February 2022

    Is is a legal mandate to stay home with norovirus, or just guidance based on common sense? As in, what you should do now if you have a cold, or sore throat etc.
    No, not a legal mandate. But some on here (BR in particular) keep insisting Covid is the common cold and we should all just keep going to work if we have it.

    My point is that as Covid becomes just another virus we need to treat it the same - if you are ill you stay off work. I keep reading "there is no reason for disruption in schools" yet I know some schools who have got staff problems as Covid tears through them. It isn't the common cold. And just like if you get a Norovirus outbreak it can hit somewhere like a school hard.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 73,368
    kjh said:

    Boris is either thick or deliberately misleading
    A remarkable statement. Surely he's provided ample evidence of being both?
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 45,306
    kamski said:

    All of those things are already happening, apart from "massive sanctions". And I suppose the calculation governments are making is: if the west imposes massive sanctions today, what is left to deter further action in Ukraine by Putin?
    They're really not, at least at the scale required.

    And many on here would just complain that we're 'poking' Russia.
  • new thread everyone
  • ApplicantApplicant Posts: 3,379

    No, not a legal mandate. But some on here (BR in particular) keep insisting Covid is the common cold and we should all just keep going to work if we have it.

    My point is that as Covid becomes just another virus we need to treat it the same - if you are ill you stay off work. I keep reading "there is no reason for disruption in schools" yet I know some schools who have got staff problems as Covid tears through them. It isn't the common cold. And just like if you get a Norovirus outbreak it can hit somewhere like a school hard.
    The point is, there's a difference between "having it (the virus)" and "being ill".
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 19,155

    Military action on invading any NATO state is guaranteed
    Are you sure?

    Suppose Putin invades and occupies Ukraine and - aside from a further surge in gas prices - most people in Britain won't notice. So who cares?

    If Trump becomes President again NATO is thrown into doubt and chaos. He might pull the US out of NATO, or at least question whether countries that were "once part of Russia" should be defended. Would we stand against Russia alone?

    We have to shake ourselves out of our complacency on this.
  • Applicant said:

    The point is, there's a difference between "having it (the virus)" and "being ill".
    Of course! People who are sick should not be in work. Yet it has been claimed that people who have it should be going about their normal business because we all need to live with it.

    Lifting mandatory quarantine is an obvious step. But lets not kneejerk all the way to "its just the common cold, you need to be in work even if you're ill"
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 20,121
    Christ, appeasers are in full force
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 18,589

    No, not a legal mandate. But some on here (BR in particular) keep insisting Covid is the common cold and we should all just keep going to work if we have it.

    My point is that as Covid becomes just another virus we need to treat it the same - if you are ill you stay off work. I keep reading "there is no reason for disruption in schools" yet I know some schools who have got staff problems as Covid tears through them. It isn't the common cold. And just like if you get a Norovirus outbreak it can hit somewhere like a school hard.
    I think you are misrepresenting him. He is clearly saying if you have symptoms you should stay home.
    The issue with covid right now is that vaccination and prior infection have tamed covid to a great extent. The ONS tells me that 1 in 20 people in England would test positive for covid. Yet that is not the picture we see in terms of people actually being ill. We've always had a component of assymptomatic 'cases' through the pandemic, and now, I think, the vast majority of people are getting it this way. If you have NO symptoms at all and test positive previously you needed to isolate. Now you will not.
    If you didn't test, you wouldn't know.

    In some settings there is an issue with that. If you work with vulnerable people I think you should still be testing and the government should pay for that (or possibly the employer if private). But should uni students still be testing twice a week? Should I? I don't think so.

    If I am ill, I will wfh if possible. We need to change the presenteeism culture of the UK. But as ever there is a broad split in jobs. You can't replenish the supermarket shelves, or fix the boiler from home. But a lot of office jobs can be done from home.
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 31,201
    edited February 2022

    I am not at all sure Boris poll ratings will improve over this but he has been spot on on covid and Ukraine
    Spot on, is he? Both themes remain to be seen for the moment.

    I am not sure what he has done yet re: Ukraine. He has sent some weaponry (a gesture-albeit one welcomed by Ukraine) sabre-rattled and invoked the memory of WW2, but done little else. IF he hits Russian finances in London hard, really hard, you might have something to crow about. If he does not, then besides the warm words, how has he been "spot-on"?

    Anyway work won't do itself.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,495

    There was, maybe, more logic to the Kingdom of Croats, Serbs and Slovenes, the South Slavs, than to Stalin's arbitrary creation of "Ukraine".
    You're conflating Stalin's arbitrary despotism with the existence of a nation with far deeper historical roots than had Yugoslavia.
  • Leon said:

    EXTREMELY OFF TOPIC QUESTION FOR PB-ERS

    But maybe we need some cheering distraction

    The Dildo Knapper's Gazette wants to send me write about flintwork in some corner of Europe, Australia or north America that they feel has been unjustly neglected by travellers

    Does anyone have any ideas?

    I've just been looking at the list of national parks in Europe for some inspiration. There are 500 or more, most of which I've barely or never heard of


    eg these new ones in France:


    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forêts_National_Park


    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calanques_National_Park


    How many others must be out there? -

    Italy has a zillion national parks:


    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pollino_National_Park

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parco_Nazionale_del_Cilento,_Vallo_di_Diano_e_Alburni

    ?

    Germany:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saxon_Switzerland_National_Park

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jasmund_National_Park

    And so much more. Has anyone got a favourite secret corner of Europe?

    The Calanques are great. The Camargue isn't too far away and that's a great place to get a bit lost in.
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 51,133

    I have explained in previous posts. Support Ukraine financially and with military aid, short of boots on the ground. Particularly intel. Bolster the security of other Eastern European states. All this on top of massive sanctions on the Russian state and individuals.

    Make it clear that Russia is a pariah. It should have been done after Salisbury really, but we are where we are.

    So what is your answer?
    So you are recommending the policy which we are actually already doing, albeit a bit lackadasical over sanctions. It hasn't stopped Putin has it?

    I have been recommending the same policy, so not clear why you are so aggressive with me. Indeed there is a rare consensus on this as a policy not just on PB, but in the country.
  • New thread
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 45,306
    Foxy said:

    So you are recommending the policy which we are actually already doing, albeit a bit lackadasical over sanctions. It hasn't stopped Putin has it?

    I have been recommending the same policy, so not clear why you are so aggressive with me. Indeed there is a rare consensus on this as a policy not just on PB, but in the country.
    No, I'm calling for much more than we're already doing in these areas.
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 51,133

    11,558 deaths were registered in England and Wales in the week ending 11 Feb 2022.

    This was

    ▪️304 fewer deaths than the previous week
    ▪️8.2% below the five-year average (1,032 fewer deaths)


    https://twitter.com/ONS/status/1496055084337221632

    Yes, social distancing and masks work for other conditions too...😇
This discussion has been closed.