politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » A massive Westminster day ends with TMay still in place
Comments
-
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-115550780 -
I think The Times will modifiy its tone as it gradually realises the ERG are all fur coat and no knickers.Scott_P said:0 -
Oh god, Newsnight have multitudes of talking heads, with a smattering of headbangers.
*opens more booze*0 -
Under Merkel yes, if her successor is more conservative maybe less certaindixiedean said:
What the CDU plus AfD are is irrelevant. The CDU will not work with them. Far more likely to work with Greens, as in Hesse. That is a clear majority.HYUFD said:
AfD also level with SPD, even if Greens get closer to the CDU, CDU + AfD are now on 40%, 3% ahead of SPD + Greens on 37%.AndyJS said:O/T:
Greens almost there in Germany.
"Europe Elects
@EuropeElects
Germany, Infratest dimap poll:
CDU/CSU-EPP: 26% (+1)
GRÜNE-G/EFA: 23% (+4)
AfD-EFDD: 14% (-2)
SPD-S&D: 14%
LINKE-LEFT: 9%
FDP-ALDE: 8% (-3)
Field work: 12/11/18 – 14/11/18
Sample size: 1,506"
The main movement is still SPD to Green, especially as the CDU are also up 1% in this poll
0 -
That makes no sense. Either you Brexit or you don't. May's deal isn't incompatible with a future relationship in the single market and customs union.El_Capitano said:
Very interesting. There could be an HoC majority for that... and it will strengthen the resolve of Conservative Remainers (and soft-Remainers) not to capitulate to May's deal.Scott_P said:0 -
You can't blame Hammond. If he'd said once he was installed as Chancellor, right, let's start paving over Kent, at the very least he'd have been denounced for propagating Project Fear. Remember, it was going to be the easiest deal ever.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-115550780 -
I don’t think some of the commentariat (and, worryingly, a vast number of MPs) get it.FrancisUrquhart said:
Need a chess grandmaster....Don’t 90% of chess matches end up in a drawn out stalemate these days?Scott_P said:
This.is.the.deal.
Brussels. Will. Not. Negotiate. A. New. One. Even if you ask nicely.0 -
The Glorious 48.Benpointer said:
I think The Times will modifiy its tone as it gradually realises the ERG are all fur coat and no knickers.Scott_P said:
Turned out to be around 30.
0 -
Currant bun front page is a goodie.0
-
There is a lot more to preparing for no deal than building lorry parks. As it happens, he hasn’t authorised expenditure for even that. He is a disgrace and a v poor Chancellor compared to say Howe and Lawson.rpjs said:
You can't blame Hammond. If he'd said once he was installed as Chancellor, right, let's start paving over Kent, at the very least he'd have been denounced for propagating Project Fear. Remember, it was going to be the easiest deal ever.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-115550780 -
To ignore the noise and look to the signal two things strike me today behind the resignation fluff. Firstly it was Day 2 of a big political launch. The Deal. And no one was selling it. It's like the Golden Hour after a major accident. In politics you need to define things yourself before your opponents define it. May has comprehensively lost the first 48 hrs. Secondly more significant imho than the show boats resigning were the greater number of silent cabinet ministers. The government won't sell this without sales people. You can only hide under the desk for so long.0
-
You must be one of only a handful of people who actually watch that show these days.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:Oh god, Newsnight have multitudes of talking heads, with a smattering of headbangers.
*opens more booze*0 -
Nick Watt still saying the 48 are coming on Newsnight.
Difficult to believe Mogg would have put his letter in otherwise.
Perhaps he has been duped???0 -
0
-
Theresa May and Ed Miliband have something in common it seems: they're both fans of Geoff Boycott.0
-
Breaking: Graham Brady orders manual recount of his letter draw.Alistair said:0 -
Jane Merrick on Twitter claiming 1922 letters 'in the low 30s'.rottenborough said:Nick Watt still saying the 48 are coming on Newsnight.
Difficult to believe Mogg would have put his letter in otherwise.
Perhaps he has been duped???0 -
Link?FrancisUrquhart said:Currant bun front page is a goodie.
0 -
1930s, presumably?AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Jane Merrick on Twitter claiming 1922 letters 'in the low 30s'.rottenborough said:Nick Watt still saying the 48 are coming on Newsnight.
Difficult to believe Mogg would have put his letter in otherwise.
Perhaps he has been duped???0 -
http://instantrimshot.com/index.php?sound=rimshotSunil_Prasannan said:
1930s, presumably?AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Jane Merrick on Twitter claiming 1922 letters 'in the low 30s'.rottenborough said:Nick Watt still saying the 48 are coming on Newsnight.
Difficult to believe Mogg would have put his letter in otherwise.
Perhaps he has been duped???0 -
A feelgood tale of a homeless man using his last $20 to help a stranded New Jersey woman buy gas was actually a complete lie, manufactured to get strangers to donate more than $400,000 to help the down-and-out good Samaritan, a prosecutor has said.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/nov/15/johnny-bobbitt-gofundme-scam-arrest-viral-gas-story-couple-charged0 -
Bone looks to me like someone who knows there isn't going to be 48.0
-
Entrepreneurial!FrancisUrquhart said:A feelgood tale of a homeless man using his last $20 to help a stranded New Jersey woman buy gas was actually a complete lie, manufactured to get strangers to donate more than $400,000 to help the down-and-out good Samaritan, a prosecutor has said.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/nov/15/johnny-bobbitt-gofundme-scam-arrest-viral-gas-story-couple-charged
0 -
There was no point preparing for it as there was no majority public support for it, that is the whole point.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-11555078
The only sustainable Brexit is one with a Deal or single market and or customs union, No Deal just leads to Remain ie no Brexit at all
0 -
Usual caveats about Sky Data polls but they become the fourth pollster and fourth poll in a row to have Remain on 54%. It does look like there has been a small but discernable shift toward Remain. That's still not anywhere near enough to derail Brexit but the No Dealers are skating on very thin ice.0
-
He was all piss and wind earlier, he's much more downbeat now. Good.rottenborough said:Bone looks to me like someone who knows there isn't going to be 48.
0 -
Would personally be supportive of this (as I would also be of the original TM deal).El_Capitano said:
Very interesting. There could be an HoC majority for that... and it will strengthen the resolve of Conservative Remainers (and soft-Remainers) not to capitulate to May's deal.Scott_P said:
If this is the end result - and more moderate - the ERG rebels only have themselves to blame.
0 -
The only point in not preparing for it is if you were always going to take whatever you were given, no matter how bad. Denying yourself options is asinine and that is what May has done by failing to prepare for no deal.HYUFD said:
There was no point preparing for it as there was no majority public support for it, that is the whole point.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-11555078
The only sustainable Brexit is one with a Deal or single market and or customs union, No Deal just leads to Remain ie no Brexit at all0 -
I used that as a synedoche for no deal preparations as a whole. I feel my point still stands.AmpfieldAndy said:
There is a lot more to preparing for no deal than building lorry parks. As it happens, he hasn’t authorised expenditure for even that. He is a disgrace and a v poor Chancellor compared to say Howe and Lawson.rpjs said:
You can't blame Hammond. If he'd said once he was installed as Chancellor, right, let's start paving over Kent, at the very least he'd have been denounced for propagating Project Fear. Remember, it was going to be the easiest deal ever.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-115550780 -
Heseltine: No way this deal will pass Parliament.0
-
As a matter of interest, how does one do a recount from voting machines?Alistair said:0 -
48 was a long time ago for Bone; he looks more like 84.rottenborough said:Bone looks to me like someone who knows there isn't going to be 48.
0 -
If that's true it puts me in the no deal column. Or we abrogate the treaty down the line. Good fucking faith indeed.geoffw said:FPT
The monster of Berlaymont's hatred of Britain wins through.
Fraser:
But the risk, here was always that the EU would take Britain’s best offer then demand more. This is precisely what has just happened. Raab discovered at the last minute that the “backstop” clause for Northern Ireland was no longer a last resort, no longer a bridge to a proper free-trade deal. It was to become the basis on which the final Brexit deal would be built. This had been sneaked into the text at the last minute – with Raab only finding about it once the deal was agreed by No 10.
Perhaps the worst of it was the union. British negotiators picked up word that Martin Selmayr, the chief Brussels bureaucrat, had told his officials that the UK must pay a price for Brexit – and that the price is Northern Ireland. He wanted the Brexit transition deal to be written in such a way that, if the United Kingdom wanted to break free and strike a new arrangement, it would have no choice but to leave Northern Ireland behind.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2018/11/15/despite-revulsion-mrs-mays-deal-confident-opponents-wont-move0 -
Meaningless unless Brussels agreesScott_P said:0 -
Heck I have never been a second referendum fan (I generally groaned whenever I saw a politician bring it up because it was so transparently obvious they were just using it as a mechanism for staying in, and although I voted remain I felt the public decision needed to be honoured) but even I’m coming round to it now, I’m just fed up of all the petty bickering and not-so-hidden-agendas of all the MPs and I’d rather throw it back to the people now.YellowSubmarine said:Usual caveats about Sky Data polls but they become the fourth pollster and fourth poll in a row to have Remain on 54%. It does look like there has been a small but discernable shift toward Remain. That's still not anywhere near enough to derail Brexit but the No Dealers are skating on very thin ice.
There are very few politicians of the calibre of, say, Hague and Clarke, who have been very measured in their response to the deal. I have no doubt that they dislike elements of it, perhaps for different reasons, but they understand that this is the best it’s going to get and they’re willing to give it a shot. It is sad that there are so many pygmies on each side of the Commons who can’t produce a measured and statesmanlike response to this (even if they disagree with the deal) and instead just scream their agenda from the rooftops like spoilt brats.
I want them all out.0 -
From seeing a sample Florida ballot, I expect they have similar machines to us in NYS. You fill out ovals next to the candidates you prefer and then insert the ballot paper into the machine which scans the ovals to tabulate the vote. It then retains the paper.Foxy said:
As a matter of interest, how does one do a recount from voting machines?Alistair said:
So a manual count would be like a UK count, you get all the papers and manually count the filled in ovals. Doing just one race wouldn't be super difficult.0 -
Well quite. For all the claims of May bluffing about things or trying to hobble things, we cannot impose things on Brussels.Beverley_C said:
Meaningless unless Brussels agreesScott_P said:0 -
The polling on May's deal is early and sketchy *but* it looms remarkably similar to Chequers polling. When you offer voters a preferendum on Deal/No Deal/No Brexit voters say May's deal is by far the least popular choice. Worse still the Remain vote stays solid but the Leave vote splits between May's deal and No Deal.
On of the Iron Laws of antediluvian politics us if you want voters to pick something you frame it as the middle choice between two extremes. But it looms like Brexit is so polarising That's not true here.
May or successor gas a huge task ahead as it looks like any Brexit deal is going to **** off Remainers for being Brexit and most Leavers for not being a Unicorn.0 -
No deal was always a bluff. Prepare as much as you like but it was never going to happen. It was a bluff. We need to move on.AmpfieldAndy said:
There is a lot more to preparing for no deal than building lorry parks. As it happens, he hasn’t authorised expenditure for even that. He is a disgrace and a v poor Chancellor compared to say Howe and Lawson.rpjs said:
You can't blame Hammond. If he'd said once he was installed as Chancellor, right, let's start paving over Kent, at the very least he'd have been denounced for propagating Project Fear. Remember, it was going to be the easiest deal ever.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-115550780 -
Why on earth would business leaders do that. There is nothing in May’s Brexit deal for them and Hammond has done nothing to attract inward investment or boost productivity as Chancellor.rottenborough said:0 -
I'm sure they would. There'd be the minimum of economic disruption for everyone, we'd make contributions to the budget but have no say. Sounds like a win-win from their POV! And more likely than not a few years down the road we'd accept it's stupid not to have a say, and rejoin the full Union.Beverley_C said:
Meaningless unless Brussels agreesScott_P said:0 -
It was always a bluff if you didn’t prepare for it and being found out trying to run a bluff, an unconvincing bluff at that, is fatal to negotiations as May has found out to. Britain’s costTOPPING said:
No deal was always a bluff. Prepare as much as you like but it was never going to happen. It was a bluff. We need to move on.AmpfieldAndy said:
There is a lot more to preparing for no deal than building lorry parks. As it happens, he hasn’t authorised expenditure for even that. He is a disgrace and a v poor Chancellor compared to say Howe and Lawson.rpjs said:
You can't blame Hammond. If he'd said once he was installed as Chancellor, right, let's start paving over Kent, at the very least he'd have been denounced for propagating Project Fear. Remember, it was going to be the easiest deal ever.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-115550780 -
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
Well that is the truth I am afraid, Leave only scraped a narrow 52% win in the EUref by promising voters it would be the easiest Deal in history.AmpfieldAndy said:
The only point in not preparing for it is if you were always going to take whatever you were given, no matter how bad. Denying yourself options is asinine and that is what May has done by failing to prepare for no deal.HYUFD said:
There was no point preparing for it as there was no majority public support for it, that is the whole point.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-11555078
The only sustainable Brexit is one with a Deal or single market and or customs union, No Deal just leads to Remain ie no Brexit at all
Had voters thought there been a real prospect of No Deal Leave would never have won at all and hence the potential reversal of Brexit will grow stronger by the day if Parliament votes down May's deal
0 -
And also fails Starmer's third test, demonstrating what bullsh*t they always were. Starmer takes a huge chunk of responsibility if we crash out.Beverley_C said:
Meaningless unless Brussels agreesScott_P said:0 -
I wish we didn't have to since I think the chance of it resolving things is not that great either, but MPs on all sides still seem consumed with whether they get to succeed May as PM, whether Labour can get into power, whether they can keep Corbyn out of power, etc etc, and have that as their primary focus, or are just still not being honest about the risks they would take on certain options, which may well be worth it if only they admitted that risk.numbertwelve said:
Heck I have never been a second referendum fan (I generally groaned whenever I saw a politician bring it up because it was so transparently obvious they were just using it as a mechanism for staying in, and although I voted remain I felt the public decision needed to be honoured) but even I’m coming round to it now, I’m just fed up of all the petty bickering and not-so-hidden-agendas of all the MPs and I’d rather throw it back to the people now.YellowSubmarine said:Usual caveats about Sky Data polls but they become the fourth pollster and fourth poll in a row to have Remain on 54%. It does look like there has been a small but discernable shift toward Remain. That's still not anywhere near enough to derail Brexit but the No Dealers are skating on very thin ice.
.
Throwing it back to the people somehow is a defeat of the purpose of parliament, but they are incapable of delivering.0 -
Big business has been praising the deal all day.AmpfieldAndy said:
Why on earth would business leaders do that. There is nothing in May’s Brexit deal for them and Hammond has done nothing to attract inward investment or boost productivity as Chancellor.rottenborough said:0 -
Eh? It gives them the certainty that their supply chains and trading relationships won't blow up in just over four months' time.AmpfieldAndy said:
Why on earth would business leaders do that. There is nothing in May’s Brexit deal for them and Hammond has done nothing to attract inward investment or boost productivity as Chancellor.rottenborough said:0 -
Businesses have come out strongly tonight in favourAmpfieldAndy said:
Why on earth would business leaders do that. There is nothing in May’s Brexit deal for them and Hammond has done nothing to attract inward investment or boost productivity as Chancellor.rottenborough said:0 -
WhoTheo said:
Big business has been praising the deal all day.AmpfieldAndy said:
Why on earth would business leaders do that. There is nothing in May’s Brexit deal for them and Hammond has done nothing to attract inward investment or boost productivity as Chancellor.rottenborough said:0 -
Agreed.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
If there is a Remain vote by next March we will never leave at all, just Remain on current terms with Article 50 cancelledDavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
Voters didn't know the Labour Party would put together six tests that are mutually exclusive.HYUFD said:
Well that is the truth I am afraid, Leave only scraped a narrow 52% win in the EUref by promising voters it would be the easiest Deal in history.AmpfieldAndy said:
The only point in not preparing for it is if you were always going to take whatever you were given, no matter how bad. Denying yourself options is asinine and that is what May has done by failing to prepare for no deal.HYUFD said:
There was no point preparing for it as there was no majority public support for it, that is the whole point.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-11555078
The only sustainable Brexit is one with a Deal or single market and or customs union, No Deal just leads to Remain ie no Brexit at all
Had voters thought there been a real prospect of No Deal Leave would never have won at all and hence the potential reversal of Brexit will grow stronger by the day if Parliament votes down May's deal0 -
Which ones specifically? (Genuine question, I've not seen any in coverage)Big_G_NorthWales said:
Businesses have come out strongly tonight in favourAmpfieldAndy said:
Why on earth would business leaders do that. There is nothing in May’s Brexit deal for them and Hammond has done nothing to attract inward investment or boost productivity as Chancellor.rottenborough said:0 -
Because the alternative is no deal, with no preparation because our government is incompetent. But we are where we are as a pretty straight kind of guy once said.AmpfieldAndy said:
Why on earth would business leaders do that. There is nothing in May’s Brexit deal for them and Hammond has done nothing to attract inward investment or boost productivity as Chancellor.rottenborough said:0 -
It wasn't even that. The ill effects of a no deal exit were "Project Fear", remember?HYUFD said:
Well that is the truth I am afraid, Leave only scraped a narrow 52% win in the EUref by promising voters it would be the easiest Deal in history.AmpfieldAndy said:
The only point in not preparing for it is if you were always going to take whatever you were given, no matter how bad. Denying yourself options is asinine and that is what May has done by failing to prepare for no deal.HYUFD said:
There was no point preparing for it as there was no majority public support for it, that is the whole point.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-11555078
The only sustainable Brexit is one with a Deal or single market and or customs union, No Deal just leads to Remain ie no Brexit at all
Had voters thought there been a real prospect of No Deal Leave would never have won at all and hence the potential reversal of Brexit will grow stronger by the day if Parliament votes down May's deal0 -
And unlimited immigration, including from all those Middle Eastern migrants to Germany.HYUFD said:
If there is a Remain vote by next March we will never leave at all, just Remain on current terms with Article 50 cancelledDavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
'Thin ice'? Just 32% back No Deal in that poll, once you take out those who back May's DealYellowSubmarine said:Usual caveats about Sky Data polls but they become the fourth pollster and fourth poll in a row to have Remain on 54%. It does look like there has been a small but discernable shift toward Remain. That's still not anywhere near enough to derail Brexit but the No Dealers are skating on very thin ice.
0 -
Staying permanently in the customs union and having to beg the EU to give us permission to leave it if we wish is NOT Brexit and actually leaves us with less control than we have now as full members.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
Yes, they are complete w@nkers.welshowl said:
Agreed.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
At the moment, my "big" business is facing either no deal, or transition plus a commitment to retain the current arrangement as part of the future partnership. It would take the Deal in a heartbeat.DavidL said:
Because the alternative is no deal, with no preparation because our government is incompetent. But we are where we are as a pretty straight kind of guy once said.AmpfieldAndy said:
Why on earth would business leaders do that. There is nothing in May’s Brexit deal for them and Hammond has done nothing to attract inward investment or boost productivity as Chancellor.rottenborough said:0 -
It’s not about no deal and never has been. It’s always been about preparing for no dealto give yourself negotiating leverage and options. BTW, under FPTP no deal is as valid as another Leave scenario - oform of Leave was on the ballot paper.HYUFD said:
Well that is the truth I am afraid, Leave only scraped a narrow 52% win in the EUref by promising voters it would be the easiest Deal in history.AmpfieldAndy said:
The only point in not preparing for it is if you were always going to take whatever you were given, no matter how bad. Denying yourself options is asinine and that is what May has done by failing to prepare for no deal.HYUFD said:
There was no point preparing for it as there was no majority public support for it, that is the whole point.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-11555078
The only sustainable Brexit is one with a Deal or single market and or customs union, No Deal just leads to Remain ie no Brexit at all
Had voters thought there been a real prospect of No Deal Leave would never have won at all and hence the potential reversal of Brexit will grow stronger by the day if Parliament votes down May's deal0 -
Only if they have German citizenship, which most don't and will take a long time to acquire.Theo said:
And unlimited immigration, including from all those Middle Eastern migrants to Germany.HYUFD said:
If there is a Remain vote by next March we will never leave at all, just Remain on current terms with Article 50 cancelledDavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
Yes, Brexiteers delivering Remain would be the sweetest irony ever.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
5-10 years. Which is the timeframe we would be in the EU for.rpjs said:
Only if they have German citizenship, which most don't and will take a long time to acquire.Theo said:
And unlimited immigration, including from all those Middle Eastern migrants to Germany.HYUFD said:
If there is a Remain vote by next March we will never leave at all, just Remain on current terms with Article 50 cancelledDavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
The conservatives potential sudden death as the party of business (despite Corbyn!) will have huge and long-term lasting electoral (and funding) consequences if this plays out towards a no deal scenario. Not rocket science and I hear similar sentiments every day.AmpfieldAndy said:
WhoTheo said:
Big business has been praising the deal all day.AmpfieldAndy said:
Why on earth would business leaders do that. There is nothing in May’s Brexit deal for them and Hammond has done nothing to attract inward investment or boost productivity as Chancellor.rottenborough said:0 -
Were it to pass I don't doubt the Tories would take a big hit as no one seems to like it much for the reasons you give. All people know is it is a compromise no one likes, and remainiacs are promising strength and stability will return with them and newdealers are peddling a fantasy about easy renegotiation. But frankly they look certain split or close as split anyway, so it makes no difference as to if they should try for it or not.YellowSubmarine said:The polling on May's deal is early and sketchy *but* it looms remarkably similar to Chequers polling. When you offer voters a preferendum on Deal/No Deal/No Brexit voters say May's deal is by far the least popular choice. Worse still the Remain vote stays solid but the Leave vote splits between May's deal and No Deal.
On of the Iron Laws of antediluvian politics us if you want voters to pick something you frame it as the middle choice between two extremes. But it looms like Brexit is so polarising That's not true here.
May or successor gas a huge task ahead as it looks like any Brexit deal is going to **** off Remainers for being Brexit and most Leavers for not being a Unicorn.
What.is.the.point.of.changing.the.deal.if.the.EU.won't.accept.it? If it was something that could be tweaked to avoid catastrophic reaction you can be damn sure it wouldn't be in there now.Scott_P said:0 -
Nah. No sane government could ever contemplate no deal. As we have seen. In Jacob Rees-Mogg fantasy land (and perhaps yours) maybe. But not in the real world.AmpfieldAndy said:
It was always a bluff if you didn’t prepare for it and being found out trying to run a bluff, an unconvincing bluff at that, is fatal to negotiations as May has found out to. Britain’s costTOPPING said:
No deal was always a bluff. Prepare as much as you like but it was never going to happen. It was a bluff. We need to move on.AmpfieldAndy said:
There is a lot more to preparing for no deal than building lorry parks. As it happens, he hasn’t authorised expenditure for even that. He is a disgrace and a v poor Chancellor compared to say Howe and Lawson.rpjs said:
You can't blame Hammond. If he'd said once he was installed as Chancellor, right, let's start paving over Kent, at the very least he'd have been denounced for propagating Project Fear. Remember, it was going to be the easiest deal ever.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-115550780 -
So ERG have now lost the support of the Mail and the Express??YBarddCwsc said:
Yes, they are complete w@nkers.welshowl said:
Agreed.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
Actually, I think a large-ish chunk of the leave vote was actually for No Deal in a way, because the consequences of leaving weren’t spelt out to them. So sure was Dave of his referendum victory that he never really explained what would happen if leave won. Yes there was project fear, but there was nothing along the lines of “we’d have to negotiate a new relationship with the EU to try and safeguard our economy and jobs and if we couldn’t get that, yes, there’s a risk we’d crash out with no deal”. It was all very vague. And from the other side all we got was “Take Back Control. Free Movement. Blue Passports. Trade Deals. NHS Cash.”HYUFD said:
Well that is the truth I am afraid, Leave only scraped a narrow 52% win in the EUref by promising voters it would be the easiest Deal in history.AmpfieldAndy said:
The only point in not preparing for it is if you were always going to take whatever you were given, no matter how bad. Denying yourself options is asinine and that is what May has done by failing to prepare for no deal.HYUFD said:
There was no point preparing for it as there was no majority public support for it, that is the whole point.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-11555078
The only sustainable Brexit is one with a Deal or single market and or customs union, No Deal just leads to Remain ie no Brexit at all
Had voters thought there been a real prospect of No Deal Leave would never have won at all and hence the potential reversal of Brexit will grow stronger by the day if Parliament votes down May's deal0 -
May and Robbins have delivered Remain (but dressed it up as some one leg in/one leg out nonsense) by tying us up in the CU forever.Foxy said:
Yes, Brexiteers delivering Remain would be the sweetest irony ever.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
I'm in the no deal column anyway, but now even more firmly entrenched.pbr2013 said:
If that's true it puts me in the no deal column. Or we abrogate the treaty down the line. Good fucking faith indeed.geoffw said:FPT
The monster of Berlaymont's hatred of Britain wins through.
Fraser:
But the risk, here was always that the EU would take Britain’s best offer then demand more. This is precisely what has just happened. Raab discovered at the last minute that the “backstop” clause for Northern Ireland was no longer a last resort, no longer a bridge to a proper free-trade deal. It was to become the basis on which the final Brexit deal would be built. This had been sneaked into the text at the last minute – with Raab only finding about it once the deal was agreed by No 10.
Perhaps the worst of it was the union. British negotiators picked up word that Martin Selmayr, the chief Brussels bureaucrat, had told his officials that the UK must pay a price for Brexit – and that the price is Northern Ireland. He wanted the Brexit transition deal to be written in such a way that, if the United Kingdom wanted to break free and strike a new arrangement, it would have no choice but to leave Northern Ireland behind.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2018/11/15/despite-revulsion-mrs-mays-deal-confident-opponents-wont-move
0 -
The frustrating thing is I watched a video on twitter today with several businesses actively supporting it.Philip_Thompson said:
Which ones specifically? (Genuine question, I've not seen any in coverage)Big_G_NorthWales said:
Businesses have come out strongly tonight in favourAmpfieldAndy said:
Why on earth would business leaders do that. There is nothing in May’s Brexit deal for them and Hammond has done nothing to attract inward investment or boost productivity as Chancellor.rottenborough said:
However, i have read and seen so much today I honestly cannot reference it
It was real though
0 -
The agreement does not require us to stay permanently in the CU. It does keep us in for a transitional period which is necessary because we have not carried out any preparations for an alternative. It gets us out of the EU so we no longer have to bother with MEPs or EU conferences, it gives us back control of our borders, it means we make our own laws except in so far as these affect the SM, it largely stops the payments. We are out of the CAP and will be out of the CFP within 2 years. Its a bloody good first step.GIN1138 said:
Staying permanently in the customs union and having to beg the EU to leave it if we wish is NOT Brexit and actually leaves us with less control than we have now as full members.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.
Instead we face a real risk of being stuck as supplicants back in the EU without some of our opt outs, probably without our rebate and absolutely no influence in any event as we will be a complete laughing stock.0 -
Just occurs to me that possibly the reason the Express supports May's deal is that it's now owned by whatever-it-was-Trinity MIrror-renamed-themselves-to.Theo said:
So ERG have now lost the support of the Mail and the Express??YBarddCwsc said:
Yes, they are complete w@nkers.welshowl said:
Agreed.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
Acquiring German citizenship requires a successful asylum claim first (and many will be rejected) and need to be fluent in German. Anyone who has managed that is likely to want to stay in the successful, high wage, high employment German economy.Theo said:
5-10 years. Which is the timeframe we would be in the EU for.rpjs said:
Only if they have German citizenship, which most don't and will take a long time to acquire.Theo said:
And unlimited immigration, including from all those Middle Eastern migrants to Germany.HYUFD said:
If there is a Remain vote by next March we will never leave at all, just Remain on current terms with Article 50 cancelledDavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
Almost amusingly the pig headedness of certain leavers may lead to remain, while the pig headedness of some remainers risks no deal (though I put that at less a chance than remain). Bunch of hypocrites the both sets of them. claiming to be willing to do much to avoid certain outcomes or that certain states (eg being in the EU/no deal) are so bad and yet happy to see them happen on the chance of getting their perfect solution.Foxy said:
Yes, Brexiteers delivering Remain would be the sweetest irony ever.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
Well duh. A deal is more important than a Tory government.williamglenn said:0 -
The Customs Union only affects goods. 20% of the economy. 80% would be outside. Criminal justice is outside. Immigration is outside. CFP amd CAP is outside. If you think that is Remain you are an idiot.GIN1138 said:
May and Robbins have delivered Remain (but dressed it up as some one leg in/one leg out nonsense) but tying us up in the CU forever.Foxy said:
Yes, Brexiteers delivering Remain would be the sweetest irony ever.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
Believe me, living outside the UK it's quite clear that the UK is already an international laughing stock.DavidL said:
The agreement does not require us to stay permanently in the CU. It does keep us in for a transitional period which is necessary because we have not carried out any preparations for an alternative. It gets us out of the EU so we no longer have to bother with MEPs or EU conferences, it gives us back control of our borders, it means we make our own laws except in so far as these affect the SM, it largely stops the payments. We are out of the CAP and will be out of the CFP within 2 years. Its a bloody good first step.GIN1138 said:
Staying permanently in the customs union and having to beg the EU to leave it if we wish is NOT Brexit and actually leaves us with less control than we have now as full members.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.
Instead we face a real risk of being stuck as supplicants back in the EU without some of our opt outs, probably without our rebate and absolutely no influence in any event as we will be a complete laughing stock.0 -
Minority government then and they lose 1 billionwilliamglenn said:0 -
Big difference between preparing for no deal just in case it happens and preparing for no deal because you actually want it.TOPPING said:
Nah. No sane government could ever contemplate no deal. As we have seen. In Jacob Rees-Mogg fantasy land (and perhaps yours) maybe. But not in the real world.AmpfieldAndy said:
It was always a bluff if you didn’t prepare for it and being found out trying to run a bluff, an unconvincing bluff at that, is fatal to negotiations as May has found out to. Britain’s costTOPPING said:
No deal was always a bluff. Prepare as much as you like but it was never going to happen. It was a bluff. We need to move on.AmpfieldAndy said:
There is a lot more to preparing for no deal than building lorry parks. As it happens, he hasn’t authorised expenditure for even that. He is a disgrace and a v poor Chancellor compared to say Howe and Lawson.rpjs said:
You can't blame Hammond. If he'd said once he was installed as Chancellor, right, let's start paving over Kent, at the very least he'd have been denounced for propagating Project Fear. Remember, it was going to be the easiest deal ever.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-115550780 -
There have been times today when I honestly thought that many of them deserved nothing less.Foxy said:
Yes, Brexiteers delivering Remain would be the sweetest irony ever.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
Not sure if that has gone throughrpjs said:
Just occurs to me that possibly the reason the Express supports May's deal is that it's now owned by whatever-it-was-Trinity MIrror-renamed-themselves-to.Theo said:
So ERG have now lost the support of the Mail and the Express??YBarddCwsc said:
Yes, they are complete w@nkers.welshowl said:
Agreed.DavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
No - General Election. You think a minority government could last when they have has many serial rebels as they do ? (bear in mind in this scenario a deal is passed, meaning dozens of angry Brexiteers keen to retaliate).Big_G_NorthWales said:
Minority government then and they lose 1 billionwilliamglenn said:0 -
January General Election it is then.williamglenn said:0 -
We can remove them after 3 months and net immigration from the EU has fallen since the Leave voteTheo said:
And unlimited immigration, including from all those Middle Eastern migrants to Germany.HYUFD said:
If there is a Remain vote by next March we will never leave at all, just Remain on current terms with Article 50 cancelledDavidL said:
Absolutely they have. I would now say that there is a 30-40% chance of no Brexit at all, up from less than 10% last week. This is a direct result of complete pillocks looking a gift horse in the mouth, failing to recognise that the May deal, whilst far from perfect, delivered on the key elements of the Brexit vote and, most critically of all, got us out of the European swamp, if not completely onto dry land.Scott_P said:
If the ERG have their way, and the EU can be persuaded we are still worth it, we might be stuck in the EU for another generation. They are so self defeating it is almost beyond belief. Morons.0 -
Fools.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Minority government then and they lose 1 billionwilliamglenn said:0 -
If I say I am preparing to stick a red hot poker up my bum, most people will guess I am bluffing, however earnest I might try to be. No Deal planning suffered from a similar lack of authenticity. The EU aren't complete idiots.AmpfieldAndy said:
It was always a bluff if you didn’t prepare for it and being found out trying to run a bluff, an unconvincing bluff at that, is fatal to negotiations as May has found out to. Britain’s costTOPPING said:
No deal was always a bluff. Prepare as much as you like but it was never going to happen. It was a bluff. We need to move on.AmpfieldAndy said:
There is a lot more to preparing for no deal than building lorry parks. As it happens, he hasn’t authorised expenditure for even that. He is a disgrace and a v poor Chancellor compared to say Howe and Lawson.rpjs said:
You can't blame Hammond. If he'd said once he was installed as Chancellor, right, let's start paving over Kent, at the very least he'd have been denounced for propagating Project Fear. Remember, it was going to be the easiest deal ever.AmpfieldAndy said:
You miss the point. If you do t prepare for no deal, you have to take what you are given- which is what May has done.HYUFD said:
Just 32% support No Deal with Sky News today, there is no point preparing for it as there is not enough support for it in the country.AmpfieldAndy said:
Hammond is one of the main reasons the Brexit deal is so toxic as he has refused funding for no deal preparation which means we have no negotiating leverage. Javid is a straw man who blows with the wind.AramintaMoonbeamQC said:
Didn't hear a peep out of certain Cabinet ministers, Javid, Hammond etc.Jonathan said:I get the impression that the serious politicians said as little as possible today.
Much like yesterday, they let the idiots rush to the 24 hour news channels, and sat it out. Wise.
If No Deal had 50% support that would be a different matter but it does not
https://news.sky.com/story/majority-of-brits-now-against-brexit-and-back-second-eu-referendum-sky-data-poll-115550780 -
No Deal is, and always has been, the preferred end state of the ERG.tottenhamWC said:
The conservatives potential sudden death as the party of business (despite Corbyn!) will have huge and long-term lasting electoral (and funding) consequences if this plays out towards a no deal scenario. Not rocket science and I hear similar sentiments every day.AmpfieldAndy said:
WhoTheo said:
Big business has been praising the deal all day.AmpfieldAndy said:
Why on earth would business leaders do that. There is nothing in May’s Brexit deal for them and Hammond has done nothing to attract inward investment or boost productivity as Chancellor.rottenborough said:
Why it has taken mainstream Conservatives so long to see this is the real mystery.0 -
May should tell them to vote with their consciences. I don't think we will be seeing a VOTC on the floor of the house quite yetkle4 said:
No - General Election. You think a minority government could last when they have has many serial rebels as they do ? (bear in mind in this scenario a deal is passed, meaning dozens of angry Brexiteers keen to retaliate).Big_G_NorthWales said:
Minority government then and they lose 1 billionwilliamglenn said:0 -
I don't think the Billion pounds has been delivered, as it requires Stormont to have a government.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Minority government then and they lose 1 billionwilliamglenn said:0 -
Second night in a row where there seems to be more consensus on PB than there is in the Tory party...
I've never seen the like!0