politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » The answer to Ben Brogan’s point about why in current conte
Comments
-
I think it's still VERY early day's in the poiltical cycle for the Tories to be too despairing or for Labour to become too hubristic (though it may be too late given the arrogance of Labour supporters on this thread)
Autumn 2013 is still the absolute mid-term "dog-days" for the government. Let's see where we are in 12 month's time...0 -
The right wingers seem to be finally waking upto reality!Usually they spin a yarn that Cameron is going to win all 650 seats!tim said:Another one starting to give up
@itvnews: Tories facing rebrand as Labour's success in the polls continues, writes Political Editor @tombradby
http://t.co/1i15AsFK2a0 -
No point whingeing about it, but I am genuinely astonished by the easy ride Labour are getting so far compared to what would have happened had this been a tory Etonian banker.0
-
Back to the 70s with Ed's vinyl collection?dr_spyn said:Ed Miliband @Ed_Miliband 2h
Really enjoyed recording Desert Island Discs today after a weekend rummaging through family record collection. Choices revealed on Sunday.
So assume we won't be getting any Arctic Monkeys or that sort of rubbish...0 -
I wouldn't read too much into Ed's fuel-tax subsidy bounce. Those fads come and go in politics. I predict it will have melted away by January, and I'm usually right about such things.SMukesh said:The autumn of 2013 will be remembered for being the time when it got through into thick right wingers` heads that Labour are headed for a win in 2015.Already the first articles acknowledging this have started to emerge!
0 -
What did you think of my criticism of Cameron a few days ago - you asked for it, but headed out & I guess missed itanother_richard said:Are there any Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy fans here ?
Because the tv series is being shown on BBC4 tonight while the new film is on Film4.
My favourite character is the drunken womanising fantasist who gets up to various misdeeds in South-East Asia under the name of Thomas.
He reminds me of someone ;-)0 -
He Ain't Heavy He's My Brother?Charles said:
Back to the 70s with Ed's vinyl collection?dr_spyn said:Ed Miliband @Ed_Miliband 2h
Really enjoyed recording Desert Island Discs today after a weekend rummaging through family record collection. Choices revealed on Sunday.
So assume we won't be getting any Arctic Monkeys or that sort of rubbish...0 -
He did an 'imagined' list a while back:Charles said:
Back to the 70s with Ed's vinyl collection?dr_spyn said:Ed Miliband @Ed_Miliband 2h
Really enjoyed recording Desert Island Discs today after a weekend rummaging through family record collection. Choices revealed on Sunday.
So assume we won't be getting any Arctic Monkeys or that sort of rubbish...
http://labour-uncut.co.uk/2010/07/05/1515/0 -
Spreading in some parts but shrinking in others.anothernick said:
And the Tory no-go areas are spreading - they started in Scotland, but now much of the North, many cities in the Midlands, most of inner London and Wales have little or no Tory councillors and few MPs. Labour has been weak in the South outside London for ever - it is still weak, but this weaknesses remains confined to the South.tim said:TGOHF said:
They appear to be a mirror of Labours deep seated brand problem all over the south.tim said:
Just what the Tories could've done with in 2010 really, a Tory John Smith (ie a John Major type) would've got a majority against Brown, whereas Cameron/Osborne blew it.RichardNabavi said:
Eh? Who said anything about moral high ground? John Smith was a person of great integrity, like most provincial solicitors are for that matter. But he wasn't exactly the most charismatic of politicians.tim said:A PR man who got his job through Lady Astors palace connections and couldn't even beat Brown while relentlessly using his family to lie about the NHS has the moral high ground over John Smith.
Still no one has addressed the Tories deep seated brand problem which is very heartening.
The difference being that Labour can win majorities with its status in the South whereas the Tories cannot with their brand being tainted every but the south.
Urban areas are trending away from them but mining/industrial areas are trending towards them hence the Conservatives winning control of local authorities such as Bassetlaw, South Derbyshire and North-West Leicestershire which they had never controlled before and why constituencies such as Morley, Don Valley and Penistone & Stocksbridge are now winnable by the Conservatives.
But as the media focus on the areas they're aware ie big cities and give less attention to places which don't interest them the areas where the Conservatives have improved are less known about - even the Conservative leadership seemed unaware of them.
0 -
The Backstabbers?Carola said:
He did an 'imagined' list a while back:Charles said:
Back to the 70s with Ed's vinyl collection?dr_spyn said:Ed Miliband @Ed_Miliband 2h
Really enjoyed recording Desert Island Discs today after a weekend rummaging through family record collection. Choices revealed on Sunday.
So assume we won't be getting any Arctic Monkeys or that sort of rubbish...
http://labour-uncut.co.uk/2010/07/05/1515/0 -
Billy Bragg - what a surprise.Carola said:
He did an 'imagined' list a while back:Charles said:
Back to the 70s with Ed's vinyl collection?dr_spyn said:Ed Miliband @Ed_Miliband 2h
Really enjoyed recording Desert Island Discs today after a weekend rummaging through family record collection. Choices revealed on Sunday.
So assume we won't be getting any Arctic Monkeys or that sort of rubbish...
http://labour-uncut.co.uk/2010/07/05/1515/
He really s a dull man.0 -
tim said:
"Nick Boles says the Conservatives are still toxic. So much for eight years of David Cameron's leadership."
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/jameskirkup/100246781/nick-boles-says-the-conservatives-are-still-toxic-so-much-for-eight-years-of-david-camerons-leadership/?utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitter
Still no PB Tory is prepared to engage with the argument.
Not one.
As a PB Tory, I will ask a question about what I should do. Having been brought up in a working class family of five or six (one died), we were always told to get on with our work, we stayed in at night while everyone round us was playing. The only nights I went out were to choir practice.
Four of us went to University. Derided as 'queer' for working all hours (certainly in my case throughout my 20s), a nice house in Cheshire and another house in Oslo ten years later (I was working in both locations), the folks at home asked why I wasn't sharing the proceeds with them.
I offered one a job (at a contract in the Midlands I was working on, part of the project I was managing in Oslo). £500 a week in 1988, one day in the office, the rest at home.
He didn't turn up at all the second week.
And all we get is, 'these people are toxic', they should be nice to us.
A genuine question here, what are we meant to do?
0 -
`I'm beginning to think that Miliband's speech was the worst by a party leader in British political history. Even the Quiet Man didn't set in motion a tidal wave of Wilson/Sunny Jim anti-nostalgia to sweep across the country. At best Miliband is going to get blamed for every energy price hike between now and 2015; at worst he'll be remembered as the man who turned Britain into a business pariah state. Poor show!`-Stark Dawning,26 September.Stark_Dawning said:
I wouldn't read too much into Ed's fuel-tax subsidy bounce. Those fads come and go in politics. I predict it will have melted away by January, and I'm usually right about such things.SMukesh said:The autumn of 2013 will be remembered for being the time when it got through into thick right wingers` heads that Labour are headed for a win in 2015.Already the first articles acknowledging this have started to emerge!
No wonder you correctly predicted that Miliband`s speech would be a massive dud.0 -
What with the private sector failing to make up all the public sector job losses, growth flatlining and the triple dip recession it's definitely wise to listen to those who feel the Tories are done.
Their prophesies have been spot on so far.Labour will be teetering at around 35 by the euro elections, and the Tories will be at least level by this time next year providing the economy holds.0 -
This is exactly the problem the tories have, Rev Flowers will be forgiven and Labour will not be affected, remember Ed Miliband had him on an advisory committee. If this was a tory banker it would be headlines for weeks and camerons judgement would now be being bought into question. Can you imagine the orgasm tim would having now, he would be up to 500 posts just todayIshmael_X said:No point whingeing about it, but I am genuinely astonished by the easy ride Labour are getting so far compared to what would have happened had this been a tory Etonian banker.
0 -
Pretty accurate IMO and worthy of discussion - I quoted it on a subsequent occasion.Charles said:
What did you think of my criticism of Cameron a few days ago - you asked for it, but headed out & I guess missed itanother_richard said:Are there any Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy fans here ?
Because the tv series is being shown on BBC4 tonight while the new film is on Film4.
My favourite character is the drunken womanising fantasist who gets up to various misdeeds in South-East Asia under the name of Thomas.
He reminds me of someone ;-)
And apologies if I wound you up too far that day.
What is interesting is we're now seeing Conservatives philosophising on what they would like the Conservative party to be - the Skelton and Boules articles for instance. Now whatever people think of those ideas they're at least trying to have some underpinning, whereas Cameron was always about style and image and being all things to all men.
We're entering a post-Cameron era.
0 -
* Labour will be teetering at around 35 by the euro elections, and the Tories will be at least level by this time next year providing the economy holds.0
-
Do you have any evidence for that? I was active in the SDP from day one till the merger and I never met a single person that could abide Thatcher.HYUFD said:Romney beats Obama with registered voters a year too late
http://www.politico.com/story/2013/11/mitt-romney-barack-obama-2012-election-poll-100044.html?hp=r6
OllyT Most SDP voters preferred Thatcher to Kinnock and Foot0 -
Gibraltar drew their first international with Slovakia 0-0 tonight.
Spain losing to South Africa
QED.0 -
They're in denial. I suppose it's understandable in a way, coming up to an election run arguably isn't the time for soul searching, they've just got to keep buggering on and hope for the best for now.tim said:"Nick Boles says the Conservatives are still toxic. So much for eight years of David Cameron's leadership."
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/jameskirkup/100246781/nick-boles-says-the-conservatives-are-still-toxic-so-much-for-eight-years-of-david-camerons-leadership/?utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitter
Still no PB Tory is prepared to engage with the argument.
Not one.
Problem is, will they learn when they again fail? All those years out of power and they still didn't "get it", which is why David Cameron's wristband fiddling and husky riding convinced some people that he was a "different" kind of Tory.0 -
No worries - I only wound up by injustice. and needling by some bloke on the internet doesn't count.another_richard said:
Pretty accurate IMO and worthy of discussion - I quoted it on a subsequent occasion.Charles said:
What did you think of my criticism of Cameron a few days ago - you asked for it, but headed out & I guess missed itanother_richard said:Are there any Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy fans here ?
Because the tv series is being shown on BBC4 tonight while the new film is on Film4.
My favourite character is the drunken womanising fantasist who gets up to various misdeeds in South-East Asia under the name of Thomas.
He reminds me of someone ;-)
And apologies if I wound you up too far that day.
What is interesting is we're now seeing Conservatives philosophising on what they would like the Conservative party to be - the Skelton and Boules articles for instance. Now whatever people think of those ideas they're at least trying to have some underpinning, whereas Cameron was always about style and image and being all things to all men.
We're entering a post-Cameron era.
Been too busy to post more than sporadically. Sick of Heathrow, sick of Germany. Need some sun and a break. Just have a couple of nice things, hardly used, to flog first.0 -
"remember Ed Miliband had him on an advisory committee. If this was a tory banker it would be headlines for weeks and camerons judgement would now be being bought into question."
I SO want to follow up this comment, but can't.
0 -
Do you know what's happened to Avery ?Charles said:
No worries - I only wound up by injustice. and needling by some bloke on the internet doesn't count.another_richard said:
Pretty accurate IMO and worthy of discussion - I quoted it on a subsequent occasion.Charles said:
What did you think of my criticism of Cameron a few days ago - you asked for it, but headed out & I guess missed itanother_richard said:Are there any Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy fans here ?
Because the tv series is being shown on BBC4 tonight while the new film is on Film4.
My favourite character is the drunken womanising fantasist who gets up to various misdeeds in South-East Asia under the name of Thomas.
He reminds me of someone ;-)
And apologies if I wound you up too far that day.
What is interesting is we're now seeing Conservatives philosophising on what they would like the Conservative party to be - the Skelton and Boules articles for instance. Now whatever people think of those ideas they're at least trying to have some underpinning, whereas Cameron was always about style and image and being all things to all men.
We're entering a post-Cameron era.
Been too busy to post more than sporadically. Sick of Heathrow, sick of Germany. Need some sun and a break. Just have a couple of nice things, hardly used, to flog first.
I fear he's gone to join Cousin Seth.
0 -
Bugger.0
-
I think I was too kind in that post. More prescient was a later one (you probably have it in your database) where I said that Miliband's juvenile and irresponsible milky-bars-are-on-me politics was storing up disappointment and civil unrest for the future. I can't conceive that I can be wrong about that.SMukesh said:
`I'm beginning to think that Miliband's speech was the worst by a party leader in British political history. Even the Quiet Man didn't set in motion a tidal wave of Wilson/Sunny Jim anti-nostalgia to sweep across the country. At best Miliband is going to get blamed for every energy price hike between now and 2015; at worst he'll be remembered as the man who turned Britain into a business pariah state. Poor show!`-Stark Dawning,26 September.Stark_Dawning said:
I wouldn't read too much into Ed's fuel-tax subsidy bounce. Those fads come and go in politics. I predict it will have melted away by January, and I'm usually right about such things.SMukesh said:The autumn of 2013 will be remembered for being the time when it got through into thick right wingers` heads that Labour are headed for a win in 2015.Already the first articles acknowledging this have started to emerge!
No wonder you correctly predicted that Miliband`s speech would be a massive dud.0 -
Yeah that's it.TGOHF said:
Because it's past your bedtime ?R0berts said:"remember Ed Miliband had him on an advisory committee. If this was a tory banker it would be headlines for weeks and camerons judgement would now be being bought into question."
I SO want to follow up this comment, but can't.0 -
What odds a Germany-Scotland double ?0
-
Can you really have a pop at him for liking music by "socialists"? At least it is consistent.TGOHF said:
Billy Bragg - what a surprise.Carola said:
He did an 'imagined' list a while back:Charles said:
Back to the 70s with Ed's vinyl collection?dr_spyn said:Ed Miliband @Ed_Miliband 2h
Really enjoyed recording Desert Island Discs today after a weekend rummaging through family record collection. Choices revealed on Sunday.
So assume we won't be getting any Arctic Monkeys or that sort of rubbish...
http://labour-uncut.co.uk/2010/07/05/1515/
He really s a dull man.
Cameron and The Smiths was a push, 'Eton Rifles' was just ridiculous0 -
Don't to be honest. But life in the City is busier than for many a long year.another_richard said:
Do you know what's happened to Avery ?Charles said:
No worries - I only wound up by injustice. and needling by some bloke on the internet doesn't count.another_richard said:
Pretty accurate IMO and worthy of discussion - I quoted it on a subsequent occasion.Charles said:
What did you think of my criticism of Cameron a few days ago - you asked for it, but headed out & I guess missed itanother_richard said:Are there any Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy fans here ?
Because the tv series is being shown on BBC4 tonight while the new film is on Film4.
My favourite character is the drunken womanising fantasist who gets up to various misdeeds in South-East Asia under the name of Thomas.
He reminds me of someone ;-)
And apologies if I wound you up too far that day.
What is interesting is we're now seeing Conservatives philosophising on what they would like the Conservative party to be - the Skelton and Boules articles for instance. Now whatever people think of those ideas they're at least trying to have some underpinning, whereas Cameron was always about style and image and being all things to all men.
We're entering a post-Cameron era.
Been too busy to post more than sporadically. Sick of Heathrow, sick of Germany. Need some sun and a break. Just have a couple of nice things, hardly used, to flog first.
I fear he's gone to join Cousin Seth.0 -
Evening all
http://www.cityam.com/article/1384824766/tories-are-spreading-ashes-party-modernisation-and-it-s-good-thing
A fairly predictable piece by Ryan Bourne of the Centre for Policy Studies in this morning's City AM urging the Conservatives to be, well, more conservative, as their only chance of winning the next election.
I'm not sure the post-Cameron manoeuvring has started - clearly, most sensible Conservatives will acknowledge that while it won't be easy, it's far too early to yield the battlefield to Labour.
That said, it seems inconceivable that were the Conservatives to be out of power after the next election, David Cameron could survive such a reverse. The degree of any reverse may well be as critical for the future leadership and potential contenders as it was in 1997.
My only thought on that leadership battle at this stage is that George Osborne has plenty of time on his side - he will still be under 50 at the 2020 election.
0 -
People like to hate.Gerry_Mander said:tim said:"Nick Boles says the Conservatives are still toxic. So much for eight years of David Cameron's leadership."
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/jameskirkup/100246781/nick-boles-says-the-conservatives-are-still-toxic-so-much-for-eight-years-of-david-camerons-leadership/?utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitter
Still no PB Tory is prepared to engage with the argument.
Not one.
As a PB Tory, I will ask a question about what I should do. Having been brought up in a working class family of five or six (one died), we were always told to get on with our work, we stayed in at night while everyone round us was playing. The only nights I went out were to choir practice.
Four of us went to University. Derided as 'queer' for working all hours (certainly in my case throughout my 20s), a nice house in Cheshire and another house in Oslo ten years later (I was working in both locations), the folks at home asked why I wasn't sharing the proceeds with them.
I offered one a job (at a contract in the Midlands I was working on, part of the project I was managing in Oslo). £500 a week in 1988, one day in the office, the rest at home.
He didn't turn up at all the second week.
And all we get is, 'these people are toxic', they should be nice to us.
A genuine question here, what are we meant to do?
People like to blame their own failures and underachievements on others.
The Conservative Party is associated with wealth, tradition, privilege.
Its an easy target.
What the Conservatives need to do is shift this hate onto the Leftwing establishment and its icons.
0 -
I reckon in a decade or so the lefts attitude to immigration, embracing it from Islington wine bars while the working class deal with the reality, will do the jobanother_richard said:
People like to hate.Gerry_Mander said:tim said:"Nick Boles says the Conservatives are still toxic. So much for eight years of David Cameron's leadership."
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/jameskirkup/100246781/nick-boles-says-the-conservatives-are-still-toxic-so-much-for-eight-years-of-david-camerons-leadership/?utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitter
Still no PB Tory is prepared to engage with the argument.
Not one.
As a PB Tory, I will ask a question about what I should do. Having been brought up in a working class family of five or six (one died), we were always told to get on with our work, we stayed in at night while everyone round us was playing. The only nights I went out were to choir practice.
Four of us went to University. Derided as 'queer' for working all hours (certainly in my case throughout my 20s), a nice house in Cheshire and another house in Oslo ten years later (I was working in both locations), the folks at home asked why I wasn't sharing the proceeds with them.
I offered one a job (at a contract in the Midlands I was working on, part of the project I was managing in Oslo). £500 a week in 1988, one day in the office, the rest at home.
He didn't turn up at all the second week.
And all we get is, 'these people are toxic', they should be nice to us.
A genuine question here, what are we meant to do?
People like to blame their own failures and underachievements on others.
The Conservative Party is associated with wealth, tradition, privilege.
Its an easy target.
What the Conservatives need to do is shift this hate onto the Leftwing establishment and its icons.
0 -
It's a bit more subtle though. UKIP is doing what you suggest, and notching up 10-20% all over the place. FPTP will deliver 0 seats if they don't focus a bit. Moreover, individual MPs in most FPTP seats have no reason to reach out. Like GOP representatives from a gerrymandered district in Alabama, they only have to worry about getting renominated by their party, and the way to do that in a hardcore seat is to be hardcore themselves and criticise colleagues who try to reach out.Cyclefree said:@Tim: I will leave you with one thought on FPTP. It's right that it does not help those parties who pile up votes in safe constituencies. In effect, a party needs to spread its vote and appeal across a wide range (voters/regions etc) to win via FPTP.
But in a way that forces parties to reach out - or should do. Just as Labour realised post 1992 that they had to appeal beyond their core, the Tories need to do the same. Their problem is that they are not doing that and, therefore, will find it very difficult to win. It could be argued that FPTP imposes a discipline on parties that would not be there otherwise and those parties that don't listen to that lesson deserve to shrivel and die.
Just a thought, anyway.
Off home now so will check in later to see what, if anything, anyone thinks of this.
0 -
And as a little example does anyone know which two parts of the country now have Conservative MPs but which never had one throughout the 20th century ? And which part of the country now has a Labour MP but which had a Conservative MP throughout the 20th century ?another_richard said:
Spreading in some parts but shrinking in others.anothernick said:
And the Tory no-go areas are spreading - they started in Scotland, but now much of the North, many cities in the Midlands, most of inner London and Wales have little or no Tory councillors and few MPs. Labour has been weak in the South outside London for ever - it is still weak, but this weaknesses remains confined to the South.tim said:TGOHF said:
They appear to be a mirror of Labours deep seated brand problem all over the south.tim said:
Just what the Tories could've done with in 2010 really, a Tory John Smith (ie a John Major type) would've got a majority against Brown, whereas Cameron/Osborne blew it.
Still no one has addressed the Tories deep seated brand problem which is very heartening.
The difference being that Labour can win majorities with its status in the South whereas the Tories cannot with their brand being tainted every but the south.
Urban areas are trending away from them but mining/industrial areas are trending towards them hence the Conservatives winning control of local authorities such as Bassetlaw, South Derbyshire and North-West Leicestershire which they had never controlled before and why constituencies such as Morley, Don Valley and Penistone & Stocksbridge are now winnable by the Conservatives.
But as the media focus on the areas they're aware ie big cities and give less attention to places which don't interest them the areas where the Conservatives have improved are less known about - even the Conservative leadership seemed unaware of them.
0 -
New Thread0
-
Interesting ideas from Nick Boles.
Isn't he simply in the wrong party?0 -
PhilipThompson There were not the dragons to be slayed like Scargill and the unions in 20100
-
And if anyone is interested the newly Conservative areas are 'Carmarthenshire West' in the Pembrokshire South & Carmarthenshire West constituency and 'Rothwell' in the Elmet & Rothwell constituency. The formerly Conservative area is 'Penge' in the 'Lewisham West & Penge' constituency.another_richard said:
And as a little example does anyone know which two parts of the country now have Conservative MPs but which never had one throughout the 20th century ? And which part of the country now has a Labour MP but which had a Conservative MP throughout the 20th century ?another_richard said:
Spreading in some parts but shrinking in others.anothernick said:
And the Tory no-go areas are spreading - they started in Scotland, but now much of the North, many cities in the Midlands, most of inner London and Wales have little or no Tory councillors and few MPs. Labour has been weak in the South outside London for ever - it is still weak, but this weaknesses remains confined to the South.tim said:TGOHF said:
They appear to be a mirror of Labours deep seated brand problem all over the south.tim said:
Just what the Tories could've done with in 2010 really, a Tory John Smith (ie a John Major type) would've got a majority against Brown, whereas Cameron/Osborne blew it.
Still no one has addressed the Tories deep seated brand problem which is very heartening.
The difference being that Labour can win majorities with its status in the South whereas the Tories cannot with their brand being tainted every but the south.
Urban areas are trending away from them but mining/industrial areas are trending towards them hence the Conservatives winning control of local authorities such as Bassetlaw, South Derbyshire and North-West Leicestershire which they had never controlled before and why constituencies such as Morley, Don Valley and Penistone & Stocksbridge are now winnable by the Conservatives.
But as the media focus on the areas they're aware ie big cities and give less attention to places which don't interest them the areas where the Conservatives have improved are less known about - even the Conservative leadership seemed unaware of them.
0