Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

Ipsos-MORI: Starmer and BoJo level on who’d make most capable PM – politicalbetting.com

245678

Comments

  • Options
    eekeek Posts: 25,007

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    Not really

    He insists that the minimum wage should be £15 a hour. Sorry but that is planet insanity...
  • Options
    RedfieldWilton

    4 minutes ago

    Best PM

    Boris 41%(-1)

    Starmer 31%(0)

  • Options
    geoffw said:

    RobD said:

    geoffw said:

    The biggest panicker is HMG, having put in place an otiose visa relaxation which has holed its controlled immigation strategy below the water line and which even in principle could only be effective long after the 'panic' has blown over.

    But the number of visas offered is tiny. I thought it was more of a token gesture than anything.
    Otioser and otioser.

    Its the difference between tactics and strategy.

    A token relaxation serves the purpose of shutting down that conversation that was dominating the media. Which considering the media are driving the panic, giving the media a token to say "this is resolved" while not actually changing the strategy, can be good tactics.

    Its a feint and we've had so many people on the media and even here like Scott etc so gullible that they've swallowed it saying "see look at the relaxation" without realising that it was a meaningless gesture.
  • Options
    MattWMattW Posts: 18,642
    The Fuel Tanker industry seems to be debunking itself.

    Industry body reporting that "there are as many tankers delivering fuel

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    Hmmm.

    Another member of the Socialist Campaign Group self-defenestrating.

    Is this a bad thing for Starmer?
  • Options
    eek said:

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    Not really

    He insists that the minimum wage should be £15 a hour. Sorry but that is planet insanity...
    Indeed, but according to Sky his resignation letter is a direct attack on Starmer and has just been endorsed by John McDonnell
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,081
    edited September 2021
    Fpt

    I went to university in 2010 on the £3k a year fees, have been consistently paid over the median salary, and am still nowhere near paying them off.

    No matter your opinions on whether 50% should be going to university or not, there is going to be a generation of young (some no longer so young) people who were told that going to university was the secret to success and encouraged at every turn who have a higher tax rate than everyone else. They are not going to be happy.
  • Options

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    Yes, it's huge. Mcdonald has effectively attempted to torpedo Sir Keir's very leadership. I can't see Sir Keir recovering from this. This conference was supposed to be his great fightback and the Labour Left has destroyed it.
    I instinctively dislike politicians who use the word 'comrades' in a non-joking manner. There's just something so earnestly twattish about it, as if they haven't grown up past sixth form. I'd much prefer 'friends'. Although given this is the Labour Party's cabinet, I guess they can't use that either ...
  • Options
    SandpitSandpit Posts: 49,919

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    Yes, it's huge. Mcdonald has effectively attempted to torpedo Sir Keir's very leadership. I can't see Sir Keir recovering from this. This conference was supposed to be his great fightback and the Labour Left has destroyed it.
    It looks tonight like open civil war
    Again.
  • Options
    TazTaz Posts: 11,243
    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21
  • Options
    Nandy reveals plans to travel to Israel-Palestine in her first overseas trip as shadow foreign secretary.


    Brilliant. Just brilliant. They are obsessed.

    Incidentally, I think Starmer urgently needs a reshuffle and get Nandy up front and on TV rather than wasted on foreign affairs.

    Maybe the resignation of the shadow whose is not even well known in his own household will trigger it?
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,193

    Fpt

    I went to university in 2010 on the £3k a year fees, have been consistently paid over the median salary, and am still nowhere near paying them off.

    No matter your opinions on whether 50% should be going to university or not, there is going to be a generation of young (some no longer so young) people who were told that going to university was the secret to success and encouraged at every turn who have a higher tax rate than everyone else. They are not going to be happy.

    The big question for me is, will this generation tell their kids not to bother with uni? Would be interesting if numbers going fell substantially.
  • Options
    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    It certainly is dangerous what with America possibly only three years away from a Trump dictatorship.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985
    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Starmer supported it? Jesus. Hah.
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,081
    tlg86 said:

    Fpt

    I went to university in 2010 on the £3k a year fees, have been consistently paid over the median salary, and am still nowhere near paying them off.

    No matter your opinions on whether 50% should be going to university or not, there is going to be a generation of young (some no longer so young) people who were told that going to university was the secret to success and encouraged at every turn who have a higher tax rate than everyone else. They are not going to be happy.

    The big question for me is, will this generation tell their kids not to bother with uni? Would be interesting if numbers going fell substantially.
    I would tell my kids not to rush into it and consider their options. That they could always go when they were a little bit older and knew what they wanted to do.
  • Options
    SandpitSandpit Posts: 49,919
    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
  • Options
    kicorsekicorse Posts: 431

    What I read Ms Nandy as saying was that not long ago the SDP looked like coming 3rd or even 4th in the German elections. Now they're almost certainly going to lead the Government.

    But you'd expect the Tory fan club on here to snipe.

    And no, I'm not a Labour member. Or even a regular Labour voter.

    Yes it's hilarious how little it takes to get them worked up....

    NEWSFLASH: Shadow Foreign Secretary mentions at a fringe meeting that a similarly aligned party in a nearby country has done better than was expected a while ago

    Controversial stuff! Obvious proof that she... erm... takes note of what's happening outside Britain without blowing it out of proportion. It's reassuring to know that no Conservative Foreign Secretary would ever do that.
  • Options
    geoffwgeoffw Posts: 8,176

    geoffw said:

    RobD said:

    geoffw said:

    The biggest panicker is HMG, having put in place an otiose visa relaxation which has holed its controlled immigation strategy below the water line and which even in principle could only be effective long after the 'panic' has blown over.

    But the number of visas offered is tiny. I thought it was more of a token gesture than anything.
    Otioser and otioser.

    Its the difference between tactics and strategy.

    A token relaxation serves the purpose of shutting down that conversation that was dominating the media. Which considering the media are driving the panic, giving the media a token to say "this is resolved" while not actually changing the strategy, can be good tactics.

    Its a feint and we've had so many people on the media and even here like Scott etc so gullible that they've swallowed it saying "see look at the relaxation" without realising that it was a meaningless gesture.
    The braer rabbit strategy tactic.
  • Options
    Labour still talking to themselves rather than the country. At an intellectual level I think they understand the need to compromise with the electorate, but their hearts are really in it.
  • Options

    eek said:

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    Not really

    He insists that the minimum wage should be £15 a hour. Sorry but that is planet insanity...
    Indeed, but according to Sky his resignation letter is a direct attack on Starmer and has just been endorsed by John McDonnell
    They are attacking on the basis that Sir K gave various pledges during the leadership race that apparently somehow fooled the membership into supporting him rather than RBL.

    Deluded.

    Like Sir K wasn't going to run from the leftish zone and then on winning leadership head to the centre.
  • Options

    eek said:

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    Not really

    He insists that the minimum wage should be £15 a hour. Sorry but that is planet insanity...
    Indeed, but according to Sky his resignation letter is a direct attack on Starmer and has just been endorsed by John McDonnell
    Keir Starmer tonight:
    image
  • Options
    paulyork64paulyork64 Posts: 2,461
    MaxPB said:


    Alastair McLellan
    @HSJEditor
    BREAKING: Social distancing rules in hospitals changed so that patients can be cared for 1 metre, rather than 2 metres apart. Will make a BIG difference to the number of beds that can be used (assuming hospitals have the staff of course)

    That move alone will allow for a reduction in the waiting lists.
    Arent patients in beds likely to be 2m apart at the best of times anyway? To be 1m apart the beds would have to be touching each other.
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,081

    MaxPB said:


    Alastair McLellan
    @HSJEditor
    BREAKING: Social distancing rules in hospitals changed so that patients can be cared for 1 metre, rather than 2 metres apart. Will make a BIG difference to the number of beds that can be used (assuming hospitals have the staff of course)

    That move alone will allow for a reduction in the waiting lists.
    Arent patients in beds likely to be 2m apart at the best of times anyway? To be 1m apart the beds would have to be touching each other.
    Wards of 6 were reduced to wards of 4
  • Options

    Labour still talking to themselves rather than the country. At an intellectual level I think they understand the need to compromise with the electorate, but their hearts are really in it.

    The upcoming New Labour Blair/Brown documentary series on the Beeb is going to provide a sharp contrast to the current, heading to defeat, set up I think.
  • Options

    AndrewSparrow
    @AndrewSparrow
    ·
    39m
    McDonald says Labour 'more divided than ever' under Starmer

    ===

    Says exiting Shadow who is trying to cause more division tonight.

  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,894

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    It certainly is dangerous what with America possibly only three years away from a Trump dictatorship.
    I stand to be corrected, but I'm guessing that was not the main reason advanced for opposing it.
  • Options
    kle4 said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    It certainly is dangerous what with America possibly only three years away from a Trump dictatorship.
    I stand to be corrected, but I'm guessing that was not the main reason advanced for opposing it.
    :lol:
  • Options
    geoffw said:

    geoffw said:

    RobD said:

    geoffw said:

    The biggest panicker is HMG, having put in place an otiose visa relaxation which has holed its controlled immigation strategy below the water line and which even in principle could only be effective long after the 'panic' has blown over.

    But the number of visas offered is tiny. I thought it was more of a token gesture than anything.
    Otioser and otioser.

    Its the difference between tactics and strategy.

    A token relaxation serves the purpose of shutting down that conversation that was dominating the media. Which considering the media are driving the panic, giving the media a token to say "this is resolved" while not actually changing the strategy, can be good tactics.

    Its a feint and we've had so many people on the media and even here like Scott etc so gullible that they've swallowed it saying "see look at the relaxation" without realising that it was a meaningless gesture.
    The braer rabbit strategy tactic.
    Indeed and it seems like its working.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,894
    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    They might thing aligning at all is a mistake, but I can't really see what the fuss is about with close allies saying the will be even closer allies.
  • Options
    paulyork64paulyork64 Posts: 2,461

    MaxPB said:


    Alastair McLellan
    @HSJEditor
    BREAKING: Social distancing rules in hospitals changed so that patients can be cared for 1 metre, rather than 2 metres apart. Will make a BIG difference to the number of beds that can be used (assuming hospitals have the staff of course)

    That move alone will allow for a reduction in the waiting lists.
    Arent patients in beds likely to be 2m apart at the best of times anyway? To be 1m apart the beds would have to be touching each other.
    Wards of 6 were reduced to wards of 4
    👍 thanks
  • Options
    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Noooooooooooooo
  • Options
    moonshinemoonshine Posts: 5,244
    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    That just pisses me off to hear. I’m desperate to vote against this government but how can I when the Labour leader still gets caught up in this nonsense.
  • Options
    kle4 said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    They might thing aligning at all is a mistake, but I can't really see what the fuss is about with close allies saying the will be even closer allies.
    They don't want us to be close allies with American and Australia is the issue.
  • Options
    Prof. Christina Pagel
    @chrischirp
    ·
    4h
    hate to say it, but the Labour conference looks kind of super spready... 4 days of rooms this full plus evening drinking in the bar... and not a mask in sight.

    ===

    Brighton numbers will be interesting in a week.
  • Options
    isamisam Posts: 40,952
    edited September 2021

    tlg86 said:

    Fpt

    I went to university in 2010 on the £3k a year fees, have been consistently paid over the median salary, and am still nowhere near paying them off.

    No matter your opinions on whether 50% should be going to university or not, there is going to be a generation of young (some no longer so young) people who were told that going to university was the secret to success and encouraged at every turn who have a higher tax rate than everyone else. They are not going to be happy.

    The big question for me is, will this generation tell their kids not to bother with uni? Would be interesting if numbers going fell substantially.
    I would tell my kids not to rush into it and consider their options. That they could always go when they were a little bit older and knew what they wanted to do.
    It's my goal for my kids not to go - by the time they're 18 a degree will be worth about the same as a million Zimbabwe dollars was in 2009

    They'll probably be too busy playing up front for the Arsenal anyway
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,894

    Labour still talking to themselves rather than the country.

    It is their conference in fairness, it is when you are supposed to talk to one another, given party leaderships don't like discussion at any other time (or even then, if they could avoid it).

    I'm just surprised AUKUS would be a hill to die on.
  • Options
    kicorsekicorse Posts: 431

    Question just on The Chase. Which of these is a,parliamentary constituency?

    Northampton North
    East Ham East
    Southampton South

    I wasnt 100pc sure but got it right.

    Wouldn't Southampton South be the Isle of Wight?
    Although Hythe and the eastern New Forest are the nearest land south of Southampton. You have to go southeast to get to the Solent.

    I know there's no Southampton South. Really not sure between the others. East Ham East sounds sillier so on that basis I'd guess it in a pub quiz.
  • Options
    MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 37,610
    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
  • Options
    kle4 said:

    Labour still talking to themselves rather than the country.

    It is their conference in fairness, it is when you are supposed to talk to one another, given party leaderships don't like discussion at any other time (or even then, if they could avoid it).

    I'm just surprised AUKUS would be a hill to die on.
    What a gift for Boris next week
  • Options
    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
  • Options
    eek said:

    geoffw said:

    The biggest panicker is HMG, having put in place an otiose visa relaxation which has holed its controlled immigation strategy below the water line and which even in principle could only be effective long after the 'panic' has blown over.

    I'm not sure, I think HMG has played a blinder on that one; I was annoyed at the news there was going to be a relaxation just because 'pay more' should be the solution. But then the details came out of the relaxation and its so meaningless that they've basically done nothing while giving the impression of acting - which is a good thing.

    5000 three month only visas is still controlled - and the companies that have gotten away with not paying a decent wage for so long now face no alternative but to offer a decent wage as these visas aren't going to be the solution. But for the people screaming that immigration was needed to solve this - they can 'take the win' of having got a relaxation, even if the win is entirely phyrric.

    And now that the word is out that there's over a million qualified HGV drivers in this country . . . and 5000 visa offers . . . there's no excuse anymore not to fix this by offering a fair market rate for drivers, which is what the solution should have always been.
    The issue probably isn't a fair market rate for drivers, the issue is making the industry a nice enough place to work that people want to enter / return to the sector.

    Pay really won't fix the reasons most people have left it...
    We'll see. One way or the other the sector needs to clean up its own mess.

    Making it a better place to work is one option, or I suspect at a good enough renumeration people will be happy to turn a blind eye to the poor conditions.

    From what I've heard the working conditions in eg the North Sea are quite poor, but the pay is quite good, so people are prepared to do it.
  • Options
    isamisam Posts: 40,952

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Well one of them just quit!

  • Options
    isam said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Well one of them just quit!

    Only from the Shadow Cabinet. They need removing from the Party altogether.
  • Options
    IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830

    eek said:

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    Not really

    He insists that the minimum wage should be £15 a hour. Sorry but that is planet insanity...
    Indeed, but according to Sky his resignation letter is a direct attack on Starmer and has just been endorsed by John McDonnell
    Keir Starmer tonight:
    image
    Very droll (I'm lying about that btw) but this guy was shadow secretary for employment rights and protections. As a tory that wouldn't matter (indeed I'm astonished if there is someone for him to shadow) but in Labour it makes him a kinda key guy shirley?
  • Options

    isam said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Well one of them just quit!

    Only from the Shadow Cabinet. They need removing from the Party altogether.
    I somehow doubt you’re going to have a Labour Party with no left wing in it. Even in the Blair years that didn’t happen.

    Labour is a car crash. All this infighting and hardly any alternative vision for the country. Only person who I heard actually coming close to one this weekend was Andy Burnham.

    More than a year into Starmer’s leadership and honest to god, I haven’t a clue what he actually believes.
  • Options

    eek said:

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    Not really

    He insists that the minimum wage should be £15 a hour. Sorry but that is planet insanity...
    Indeed, but according to Sky his resignation letter is a direct attack on Starmer and has just been endorsed by John McDonnell
    Keir Starmer tonight:
    image
    "endorsed by John McDonnell" must surely be a good thing for Starmer
  • Options
    CatManCatMan Posts: 2,776
    edited September 2021
    Winner of today's "He's right but he shouldn't say it award"

    "End to freedom of movement behind UK fuel crisis, says Merkel’s likely successor"
    https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2021/sep/27/end-freedom-movement-uk-fuel-crisis-german-politician-olaf-scholz-hgv-driver-shortage

    "The centre-left politician in pole position to replace Angela Merkel as German chancellor has pinpointed the decision to bring an end to freedom of movement with Europe after Brexit as the reason for the British petrol crisis.

    Olaf Scholz, who is seeking to form a coalition government after the SPD emerged as the biggest party in Germany’s federal elections, said he hoped Boris Johnson would be able to deal with the consequences of the UK’s exit from the EU."



  • Options
    SandpitSandpit Posts: 49,919

    isam said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Well one of them just quit!

    Only from the Shadow Cabinet. They need removing from the Party altogether.
    I somehow doubt you’re going to have a Labour Party with no left wing in it. Even in the Blair years that didn’t happen.

    Labour is a car crash. All this infighting and hardly any alternative vision for the country. Only person who I heard actually coming close to one this weekend was Andy Burnham.

    More than a year into Starmer’s leadership and honest to god, I haven’t a clue what he actually believes.
    Burnham’s probably the stand-out Labour politician of the past year. Yet he’s not an MP.

    As for Starmer, he’s not Jeremy Corbyn and not Boris Johnson. Which is not enough.
  • Options
    I hate to say it but Redwood's right.

    There's over a million people out there with HGV licences. And for those that don't have one it only takes a few weeks to train a new recruit to take the test. So yes, offer pay and conditions people want and the vacancies will be filled.

    Improving pay and conditions is the only viable (and decent) solution. Its a shame so many on the left now find suggesting good pay and conditions to be an anathema.
  • Options
    Well, I just filled up with diesel in Sidmouth with no queue and no problems. Another delivery due at the garage tomorrow. Spoke to the owner. She said it had been absolutely mad until about 4.30 this afternoon, now it is is pretty much back to normal. Maybe we are over the worst of it.
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,027

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,894
    CatMan said:

    Winner of today's "He's right but he shouldn't say it award"

    "End to freedom of movement behind UK fuel crisis, says Merkel’s likely successor"
    https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2021/sep/27/end-freedom-movement-uk-fuel-crisis-german-politician-olaf-scholz-hgv-driver-shortage

    "The centre-left politician in pole position to replace Angela Merkel as German chancellor has pinpointed the decision to bring an end to freedom of movement with Europe after Brexit as the reason for the British petrol crisis.

    Olaf Scholz, who is seeking to form a coalition government after the SPD emerged as the biggest party in Germany’s federal elections, said he hoped Boris Johnson would be able to deal with the consequences of the UK’s exit from the EU."

    I'm confused, genuinely - why is he even talking about the UK right now?
  • Options
    squareroot2squareroot2 Posts: 6,363
    edited September 2021
    On thread.. so what if they are level....The party is riven with division and it couldn't manage the supply of paper bags. I expect a leadership challenge at some stage, not sure if that is good or bad for Starmer.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985
    CatMan said:

    Winner of today's "He's right but he shouldn't say it award"

    "End to freedom of movement behind UK fuel crisis, says Merkel’s likely successor"
    https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2021/sep/27/end-freedom-movement-uk-fuel-crisis-german-politician-olaf-scholz-hgv-driver-shortage

    "The centre-left politician in pole position to replace Angela Merkel as German chancellor has pinpointed the decision to bring an end to freedom of movement with Europe after Brexit as the reason for the British petrol crisis.

    Olaf Scholz, who is seeking to form a coalition government after the SPD emerged as the biggest party in Germany’s federal elections, said he hoped Boris Johnson would be able to deal with the consequences of the UK’s exit from the EU."



    Freedom of movement wouldn't solve it since there is a shortage of drivers across the EU.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
  • Options

    Nandy reveals plans to travel to Israel-Palestine in her first overseas trip as shadow foreign secretary.


    Brilliant. Just brilliant. They are obsessed.

    Incidentally, I think Starmer urgently needs a reshuffle and get Nandy up front and on TV rather than wasted on foreign affairs.

    Maybe the resignation of the shadow whose is not even well known in his own household will trigger it?

    Nandy is part of the problem. A lightweight that has been over promoted and over rated. If Starmer had some balls he would bring in Mrs Balls and all the other moderates that are wasted talent languishing on the backbenches since Jezza 2-Es Corbyn was "leader". Labour are still not serious about being in government.
  • Options
    https://twitter.com/ayeshahazarika/status/1442540887515537413?s=21

    Apparently this is the source of the resignation.

    While I doubt a £15 minimum wage can happen overnight, and in that sense McDonald is naive - I’m unsure that early days New Labour circa ‘tough spending restrictions’ is what voters, especially red wall ones, actually want. Fair enough if Reeves is doing this if she thinks it’s the right thing. But given that the electorate voted for this high spending, soon to be high tax government, I don’t see how it can be viewed as ‘centrist’.
  • Options
    All politicians are liars even in the Eu...
  • Options
    moonshinemoonshine Posts: 5,244
    Is it not the case that lots of qualified hgv drivers have switched to driving local deliveries as the conditions are better?
  • Options

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    I am rather surprised you should make that comment to be fair

    Are you content with the Corbyn element in the labour party

  • Options
    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    A little hyperbolic, though Johnson's right wing populism is definitely further on that continuum than Thatcherism ever was
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985

    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    A little hyperbolic, though Johnson's right wing populism is definitely further on that continuum than Thatcherism ever was
    Only a little? This is schoolyard everyone I disagree with is a Nazi crap.
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,027
    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    Isolationist, racist.
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,027

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    I am rather surprised you should make that comment to be fair

    Are you content with the Corbyn element in the labour party

    Not particularly but as I've pointed out before I'm neither a Labour Party member, nor regular voter.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985

    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    Isolationist, racist.
    It's neither of those things.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,340
    edited September 2021

    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    A little hyperbolic, though Johnson's right wing populism is definitely further on that continuum than Thatcherism ever was
    As we know Boris used it to power, and now he is going his own way to the left of centre and saying to his party keep up

    So far @HYUFD seems unaware
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,077

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    It certainly is dangerous what with America possibly only three years away from a Trump dictatorship.
    Taiwan would at least be assured of US defence if China invaded, I doubt Biden would defend Taiwan however, even if AuUKUS does provide some extra security for Australia, Japan and South Korea
  • Options

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    I am rather surprised you should make that comment to be fair

    Are you content with the Corbyn element in the labour party

    Not particularly but as I've pointed out before I'm neither a Labour Party member, nor regular voter.
    No I know you are not but to be honest I was surprised as you are normally very fair
  • Options

    I hate to say it but Redwood's right.

    There's over a million people out there with HGV licences. And for those that don't have one it only takes a few weeks to train a new recruit to take the test. So yes, offer pay and conditions people want and the vacancies will be filled.

    Improving pay and conditions is the only viable (and decent) solution. Its a shame so many on the left now find suggesting good pay and conditions to be an anathema.
    Today's Conservative Party mantra: Simplistic solutions for simplistic followers. The real world of business and employment is a little more complex than this Philip. You, like Redwood are putting your head in the sand because you don't want to admit that the Government should have seen this coming. Brexit could have been managed so these problems did not exacerbate pre-existing problems, but we have a PM who likes simple ideas he can put into slogans on the back of a fag packet to provide red meat for his simple minded fanbois.
  • Options
    kle4 said:

    CatMan said:

    Winner of today's "He's right but he shouldn't say it award"

    "End to freedom of movement behind UK fuel crisis, says Merkel’s likely successor"
    https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2021/sep/27/end-freedom-movement-uk-fuel-crisis-german-politician-olaf-scholz-hgv-driver-shortage

    "The centre-left politician in pole position to replace Angela Merkel as German chancellor has pinpointed the decision to bring an end to freedom of movement with Europe after Brexit as the reason for the British petrol crisis.

    Olaf Scholz, who is seeking to form a coalition government after the SPD emerged as the biggest party in Germany’s federal elections, said he hoped Boris Johnson would be able to deal with the consequences of the UK’s exit from the EU."

    I'm confused, genuinely - why is he even talking about the UK right now?
    As previously discussed, he was replying to a question specifically asked by Matt Frei, the C4 correspondent. Disappointingly the Guardian has adopted the Tele 'why are the foreigns sticking their noses in our biz' crap.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,894

    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    Isolationist, racist.
    People will disagree on the latter, but how can the former be true when they just signed new international agreement? Yes it's left the EU, but it isn't a binary isolationist/non isolationist, it's a spectrum.
  • Options
    MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 25,270
    edited September 2021
    Scott_xP said:
    Not on here he doesn't.

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    McDonnell is spitting feathers too.
  • Options
    isamisam Posts: 40,952
    edited September 2021

    On thread.. so what if they are level....The party is riven with division and it couldn't manage the supply of paper bags. I expect a leadership challenge at some stage, not sure if that is good or bad for Starmer.

    The headline of the thread is the only silver lining in the poll for Labour
  • Options

    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    A little hyperbolic, though Johnson's right wing populism is definitely further on that continuum than Thatcherism ever was
    As we know Boris used it to power, and now he is going his own way to the left of centre and saying to his party keep up

    So far @HYUFD seems unaware
    Populism includes steeling the clothes of the left. It is most definitely NOT centre left Conservatism. Johnson is not some sort of cuddly One Nation Conservative. He is an ego-driven populist, no more, no less.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,894

    kle4 said:

    CatMan said:

    Winner of today's "He's right but he shouldn't say it award"

    "End to freedom of movement behind UK fuel crisis, says Merkel’s likely successor"
    https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2021/sep/27/end-freedom-movement-uk-fuel-crisis-german-politician-olaf-scholz-hgv-driver-shortage

    "The centre-left politician in pole position to replace Angela Merkel as German chancellor has pinpointed the decision to bring an end to freedom of movement with Europe after Brexit as the reason for the British petrol crisis.

    Olaf Scholz, who is seeking to form a coalition government after the SPD emerged as the biggest party in Germany’s federal elections, said he hoped Boris Johnson would be able to deal with the consequences of the UK’s exit from the EU."

    I'm confused, genuinely - why is he even talking about the UK right now?
    As previously discussed, he was replying to a question specifically asked by Matt Frei, the C4 correspondent. Disappointingly the Guardian has adopted the Tele 'why are the foreigns sticking their noses in our biz' crap.
    Follow up, why was Matt Frei wasting a queston to the potential new Chancellor on what is up with Boris Johnson?
  • Options
    SandpitSandpit Posts: 49,919
    moonshine said:

    Is it not the case that lots of qualified hgv drivers have switched to driving local deliveries as the conditions are better?
    That’s the anecdotal evidence - some have moved to more sociable jobs driving smaller vehicles locally, and others have taken better pay offers to switch company on the HGVs.

    There’s apparently a wide variation in terms and conditions across the industry, for example some companies insist you sleep in your cab, while others cover a travel inn when away from home.
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,027
    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    Isolationist, racist.
    It's neither of those things.
    Really? The party which appears to support turning desperate people back in the Channel?
    Immigration appears OK if the immigrants have loadsamoney. Not if they have a willingness to make life better for themselves.
  • Options
    FarooqFarooq Posts: 10,775

    isam said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Well one of them just quit!

    Only from the Shadow Cabinet. They need removing from the Party altogether.
    FPTP is the pressure keeping the extremists in both main parties.
  • Options

    Scott_xP said:
    Not on here he doesn't.

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    McDonnell is spitting feathers too.
    It is the old story and well practised by @HYUFD choose the poll that makes your case

    Mind you tonight's RedfieldWilton includes the fuel crisis and has Boris 41/31 ahead of Starmer as best PM
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,313

    Do don't PR says an politics lecturer, as FPTP so advantages Labour, always getting more seats than their vote represents, it would be a disaster to give it up:

    https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/27/proportional-representation-labour-party-lib-dems

    It protects their privileged position as perpetual ‘unacceptable alternative’ to the Conservatives, whilst in the longer term denying their political perspective a fair shot at governing the country. FTPT appeals to the short sighted and self interested, so it is no surprise that whenever it comes to the crunch the Labour Party ducks its chance to truly transform politics in the UK.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985

    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    Isolationist, racist.
    It's neither of those things.
    Really? The party which appears to support turning desperate people back in the Channel?
    Immigration appears OK if the immigrants have loadsamoney. Not if they have a willingness to make life better for themselves.
    Having an actual border people have to cross is not racism, almost all countries in the world have them.
  • Options
    moonshinemoonshine Posts: 5,244
    Sandpit said:

    moonshine said:

    Is it not the case that lots of qualified hgv drivers have switched to driving local deliveries as the conditions are better?
    That’s the anecdotal evidence - some have moved to more sociable jobs driving smaller vehicles locally, and others have taken better pay offers to switch company on the HGVs.

    There’s apparently a wide variation in terms and conditions across the industry, for example some companies insist you sleep in your cab, while others cover a travel inn when away from home.
    So in short Redwood has a point.
  • Options

    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    A little hyperbolic, though Johnson's right wing populism is definitely further on that continuum than Thatcherism ever was
    As we know Boris used it to power, and now he is going his own way to the left of centre and saying to his party keep up

    So far @HYUFD seems unaware
    Populism includes steeling the clothes of the left. It is most definitely NOT centre left Conservatism. Johnson is not some sort of cuddly One Nation Conservative. He is an ego-driven populist, no more, no less.
    I do not disagree
  • Options
    MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 37,610

    Well, I just filled up with diesel in Sidmouth with no queue and no problems. Another delivery due at the garage tomorrow. Spoke to the owner. She said it had been absolutely mad until about 4.30 this afternoon, now it is is pretty much back to normal. Maybe we are over the worst of it.

    It's a bit like a virus, eventually it burns itself out because there's only a limited number of cars and a limited amount of space in fuel tanks.
  • Options
    Farooq said:

    isam said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Well one of them just quit!

    Only from the Shadow Cabinet. They need removing from the Party altogether.
    FPTP is the pressure keeping the extremists in both main parties.
    Rather than giving them enormous leverage in the post-election haggles in smoke-free rooms.
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,313

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    You won’t know for sure until another lorry driver phones up Five Live
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,077
    IanB2 said:

    Do don't PR says an politics lecturer, as FPTP so advantages Labour, always getting more seats than their vote represents, it would be a disaster to give it up:

    https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/27/proportional-representation-labour-party-lib-dems

    It protects their privileged position as perpetual ‘unacceptable alternative’ to the Conservatives, whilst in the longer term denying their political perspective a fair shot at governing the country. FTPT appeals to the short sighted and self interested, so it is no surprise that whenever it comes to the crunch the Labour Party ducks its chance to truly transform politics in the UK.
    The argument the author correctly puts is PR means there would likely never be a Labour majority government again.

    The LDs would largely hold the balance of power, that reduces the chances of rightwing majority Conservative governments but also means near zero chance of socialist Labour governments too
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,313

    Well, I just filled up with diesel in Sidmouth with no queue and no problems. Another delivery due at the garage tomorrow. Spoke to the owner. She said it had been absolutely mad until about 4.30 this afternoon, now it is is pretty much back to normal. Maybe we are over the worst of it.

    That you had to drive so far from the Midlands to find an open filling station suggests otherwise ;)
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,340
    edited September 2021
    IanB2 said:

    Highly critical resignation letter by Andy Mcdonald of Starmer according to Sky

    You won’t know for sure until another lorry driver phones up Five Live
    Actually it has been published and reported on in those terms by Jon Craig of Sky

    And this from the BBC

    Chris Mason, political correspondent

    This is a zinger of a resignation letter, in its content and its timing.

    Yes, a man you may not have heard of resigns from a job you probably didn't know he had.

    But listen to what Andy McDonald, a man at Labour's top table until today, says about Labour's candidate for prime minister and the movement he leads.

    He claims Labour is "more divided than ever" and Sir Keir has broken the promises he made to get elected as party leader, suggesting directly that he can't be trusted.

    Political critiques within a political party are often articulated obliquely, with euphemism and understatement.

    There is none of this here and it appears slap bang in the middle of the one week of the year where so many of Labour's faithful are in the same postcode.

    It will demand an immediate response from Sir Keir Starmer.
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,027
    kle4 said:

    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    Isolationist, racist.
    People will disagree on the latter, but how can the former be true when they just signed new international agreement? Yes it's left the EU, but it isn't a binary isolationist/non isolationist, it's a spectrum.
    A very restrictive, nationalistic agreement.
  • Options
    MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 37,610

    Farooq said:

    isam said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Well one of them just quit!

    Only from the Shadow Cabinet. They need removing from the Party altogether.
    FPTP is the pressure keeping the extremists in both main parties.
    Rather than giving them enormous leverage in the post-election haggles in smoke-free rooms.
    Imagine into how many pieces the left would splinter under PR. Labour would be idiots to back it.
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,502
    kle4 said:

    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    Isolationist, racist.
    People will disagree on the latter, but how can the former be true when they just signed new international agreement? Yes it's left the EU, but it isn't a binary isolationist/non isolationist, it's a spectrum.
    Wrong kind of furniers.
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,313
    HYUFD said:

    IanB2 said:

    Do don't PR says an politics lecturer, as FPTP so advantages Labour, always getting more seats than their vote represents, it would be a disaster to give it up:

    https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/27/proportional-representation-labour-party-lib-dems

    It protects their privileged position as perpetual ‘unacceptable alternative’ to the Conservatives, whilst in the longer term denying their political perspective a fair shot at governing the country. FTPT appeals to the short sighted and self interested, so it is no surprise that whenever it comes to the crunch the Labour Party ducks its chance to truly transform politics in the UK.
    The argument the author correctly puts is PR means there would likely never be a Labour majority government again.

    The LDs would largely hold the balance of power, that reduces the chances of rightwing majority Conservative governments but also means near zero chance of socialist Labour governments too
    But Labour only gets a majority when it eschews its socialism. You’d have thought they’d have noticed this by now.
  • Options

    I hate to say it but Redwood's right.

    There's over a million people out there with HGV licences. And for those that don't have one it only takes a few weeks to train a new recruit to take the test. So yes, offer pay and conditions people want and the vacancies will be filled.

    Improving pay and conditions is the only viable (and decent) solution. Its a shame so many on the left now find suggesting good pay and conditions to be an anathema.
    Today's Conservative Party mantra: Simplistic solutions for simplistic followers. The real world of business and employment is a little more complex than this Philip. You, like Redwood are putting your head in the sand because you don't want to admit that the Government should have seen this coming. Brexit could have been managed so these problems did not exacerbate pre-existing problems, but we have a PM who likes simple ideas he can put into slogans on the back of a fag packet to provide red meat for his simple minded fanbois.
    I'm sorry but as a Thatcherite free market liberal Conservative I don't think its the government's job to tell business how to operate or "fix" problems in the market.

    To have a free market then the market has to be allowed to fail sometimes, otherwise you end up with moral hazard and freeriding within the market. If companies refuse to pay a decent wage to HGV drivers (of which we have many more times more than enough qualified) then they should be allowed to fail.

    If companies refuse to pay for transportation a decent enough rate to get their stock moved around, they too can fail.

    A few days of mass hysteria about fuel because is hardly the miner's strike now is it? In the eighties it was overly-coddled unions that were warping the market that needed sorting out, now its overly-coddled companies that feel they have a divine right to fill vacancies for shitty jobs at minimum wage that need sorting out. Either way, let the market do its thing - even if it causes some hardship or disruption from time to time.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,077
    edited September 2021
    MaxPB said:

    Farooq said:

    isam said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Well one of them just quit!

    Only from the Shadow Cabinet. They need removing from the Party altogether.
    FPTP is the pressure keeping the extremists in both main parties.
    Rather than giving them enormous leverage in the post-election haggles in smoke-free rooms.
    Imagine into how many pieces the left would splinter under PR. Labour would be idiots to back it.
    Mind you the Tories would also split under PR into libertarian and more socially conservative and EUphile wings just as Labour would split into Blairite, social democratic and socialist Corbynite wings
  • Options
    FarooqFarooq Posts: 10,775

    Farooq said:

    isam said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Well one of them just quit!

    Only from the Shadow Cabinet. They need removing from the Party altogether.
    FPTP is the pressure keeping the extremists in both main parties.
    Rather than giving them enormous leverage in the post-election haggles in smoke-free rooms.
    Better to give the 5% extremists 5% of the power, than to risk the 5% extremists taking 100% of the power.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,985

    kle4 said:

    RobD said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Whereas the Tories got themselves into power by embracing the Neo-fascist right.
    The current Tory party is neo-fascist?

    OK.
    Isolationist, racist.
    People will disagree on the latter, but how can the former be true when they just signed new international agreement? Yes it's left the EU, but it isn't a binary isolationist/non isolationist, it's a spectrum.
    A very restrictive, nationalistic agreement.
    Is the same true for CPTPP, another restrictive, nationalistic agreement? Let me guess, only the EU is a truly good, internationalist agreement.
  • Options
    Farooq said:

    isam said:

    MaxPB said:

    Sandpit said:

    Taz said:

    “🇬🇧 Labour conference delegates just voted by 70% to 30% to say that the United Kingdom's defence pact with Australia & America is "a dangerous move that will undermine world peace". Starmer supported it.”

    https://twitter.com/goodwinmj/status/1442517137252257804?s=21

    Does Conference instead think we should align with Russia and China, Iran and Palestine?
    Palestine. Palestine. PALESTINE!
    To be honest they need a Neil Kinnock moment and divest themselves of this non electable left
    Well one of them just quit!

    Only from the Shadow Cabinet. They need removing from the Party altogether.
    FPTP is the pressure keeping the extremists in both main parties.
    The Tories ruthlessly expel far right extremists from the party and quite right too because those extremists are not just repugnant but toxic to everyone else.

    Labour doesn't do the same for the far left and they're paying the consequence as a result.
This discussion has been closed.