Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

Reaping the Whirlwind – politicalbetting.com

1246710

Comments

  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,198
    rcs1000 said:

    DavidL said:

    rcs1000 said:

    Floater said:
    I am not sure you have got the hang of this polling mullarkey.

    If responses are taken a day or two before an event, it is unlikely that the responses will be in relation to the event...unless the respondent is psychic...or from the future.
    I only poll people from the future, as their responses are more likely to be useful from a betting perspective.
    But the future that is certain. It is the past that keeps changing. Surely that is what we need to monitor.
    Polling on past events is probably not a bad guide. The disappearance of people who owned up to voting Lib Dem in 2010 was the strongest indicator of their performance in 2015.
    My God: you might be onto something. The LibDem performance in 2015 was the consequence of Cameron "disappearing" LibDem voters.

    We need an immediate investigation.
    Didn't we have one of those in the US when they polled who had voted for Kennedy after he was killed. Rather than one of the closest elections ever it was apparently a landslide!
  • Options
    Nigel_ForemainNigel_Foremain Posts: 13,781

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Compared to you perhaps. The reality is Boris Johnson will sit in the centre if it suits his ego. He will sit on the far right if that does too, and possibly even on the left. Reality is he is all over the shop because he is a man that lives in a morality vacuum.
  • Options
    AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 19,939

    DavidL said:

    DougSeal said:

    DavidL said:

    Scott_xP said:

    Clear upward trend in cases now, with the daily total hitting the highest since April 12 (for the second day running).

    A lot of this is still localised. Bolton alone had 1,292 cases in the last week; Warrington, only a few miles south, had just 18.

    https://twitter.com/DavidHerdson/status/1397938149112881153

    https://twitter.com/UKCovid19Stats/status/1397931362942951425

    Surge testing when there's a localised outbreak will give a slightly distorted impression so I don't think there's any reason to panic.
    It may be local but patients admitted up 20% in the last 7 days is not good.
    In England we’ve had 28 days in a row of fewer than 100 hospitalisations which IS good.
    Sure, these increases are from a very low base and the percentages exaggerate as a result. But it is disappointing.
    One thing to note - yes an increase in admissions, but the total in hospital is not rising. Signs of patients going in being less sick than before? I think so.
    As of yesterday I believe the total in hospital was under 1,000 and falling nationwide?
  • Options
    DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 24,313

    Strong performance from Germany, even with 2 days' data:

    https://www.politico.eu/coronavirus-in-europe/


    A large jump in Ireland given their population.
  • Options
    felixfelix Posts: 15,124

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Ah but they have the 'moral' high ground..... both of them!
  • Options
    turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 15,148

    DavidL said:

    DougSeal said:

    DavidL said:

    Scott_xP said:

    Clear upward trend in cases now, with the daily total hitting the highest since April 12 (for the second day running).

    A lot of this is still localised. Bolton alone had 1,292 cases in the last week; Warrington, only a few miles south, had just 18.

    https://twitter.com/DavidHerdson/status/1397938149112881153

    https://twitter.com/UKCovid19Stats/status/1397931362942951425

    Surge testing when there's a localised outbreak will give a slightly distorted impression so I don't think there's any reason to panic.
    It may be local but patients admitted up 20% in the last 7 days is not good.
    In England we’ve had 28 days in a row of fewer than 100 hospitalisations which IS good.
    Sure, these increases are from a very low base and the percentages exaggerate as a result. But it is disappointing.
    One thing to note - yes an increase in admissions, but the total in hospital is not rising. Signs of patients going in being less sick than before? I think so.
    As of yesterday I believe the total in hospital was under 1,000 and falling nationwide?
    Yep.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,302
    isam said:

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Bluekip/Blue Labour are what it’s been called, which is economically leftish and culturally rightish - the option that wasn’t really on the table for the last 20 odd years
    I don't think it's that leftist (this government doesn't want to raise VAT or personal taxes and believes in fiscal conservatism) but it does recognise people prefer a supportive state rather than a small state.

    On cultural issues I think it's slightly right but far closer to the centre than the Left are - who are way off.
  • Options
    CookieCookie Posts: 11,388
    HYUFD said:



    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    It is rightwing to wealthy urban Remainers and graduates, it is dead centre for the working class and lower middle class voters who decide elections.

    It's right wing to the hard of thinking, the reasoning being:
    "I am left wing"
    "I don't like this government"
    "Therefore this government is right wing"
    "Actually, I really, really don't like this government"
    "Therefore this government is really, really right wing"

    I remember back in 2007 the similarly hard of thinking decrying any policy they disagreed with as 'neoliberal'.
  • Options
    eekeek Posts: 24,949
    edited May 2021

    kle4 said:

    Carnyx said:

    DavidL said:

    IanB2 said:

    Oh dear.. is everything's going to be about Boris being an unashamed liar.. its getting very boring and I suspect the electorate are not interested. Boris must be the teflon dead cat that those who dislike him can thrash away at to little or no effect.

    Oh dear, another obsequious post from one of the Government's apologists and predictably "liked" by the usual PB Johnsonphile automatons! Ever wondered about being independent of thought? Ever imagined that it might be possible that the government you voted for might have got things wrong? No, of course not. My party right or wrong. The Führerprinzip is a philosophy alive and well among Johnson's faithful and unthinking followers.
    He is, however, right that the electorate isn’t, right now at least, remotely interested. I am just back from dog training class and all of the others spent the entire break slagging off Cummings; there wasn’t the slightest interest in whether any of the allegations had any truth in them, at all.
    You speak dog? Impressive.
    Only ruffly, I am sure.
    That's barking mad.
    Can I never learn to stay out of these punfests?
    it was a bit ruff trying to read that..
  • Options
    Nigel_ForemainNigel_Foremain Posts: 13,781

    Carnyx said:

    DavidL said:

    IanB2 said:

    Oh dear.. is everything's going to be about Boris being an unashamed liar.. its getting very boring and I suspect the electorate are not interested. Boris must be the teflon dead cat that those who dislike him can thrash away at to little or no effect.

    Oh dear, another obsequious post from one of the Government's apologists and predictably "liked" by the usual PB Johnsonphile automatons! Ever wondered about being independent of thought? Ever imagined that it might be possible that the government you voted for might have got things wrong? No, of course not. My party right or wrong. The Führerprinzip is a philosophy alive and well among Johnson's faithful and unthinking followers.
    He is, however, right that the electorate isn’t, right now at least, remotely interested. I am just back from dog training class and all of the others spent the entire break slagging off Cummings; there wasn’t the slightest interest in whether any of the allegations had any truth in them, at all.
    You speak dog? Impressive.
    Only ruffly, I am sure.
    Even that must make you very yappy.....
    You are a wag!
    Whoops you beat me to that one. You had the lead on me there
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,198

    kle4 said:

    Carnyx said:

    DavidL said:

    IanB2 said:

    Oh dear.. is everything's going to be about Boris being an unashamed liar.. its getting very boring and I suspect the electorate are not interested. Boris must be the teflon dead cat that those who dislike him can thrash away at to little or no effect.

    Oh dear, another obsequious post from one of the Government's apologists and predictably "liked" by the usual PB Johnsonphile automatons! Ever wondered about being independent of thought? Ever imagined that it might be possible that the government you voted for might have got things wrong? No, of course not. My party right or wrong. The Führerprinzip is a philosophy alive and well among Johnson's faithful and unthinking followers.
    He is, however, right that the electorate isn’t, right now at least, remotely interested. I am just back from dog training class and all of the others spent the entire break slagging off Cummings; there wasn’t the slightest interest in whether any of the allegations had any truth in them, at all.
    You speak dog? Impressive.
    Only ruffly, I am sure.
    That's barking mad.
    Can I never learn to stay out of these punfests?
    It gets us through the dogday afternoons until the lagershed.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    edited May 2021

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Compared to you perhaps. The reality is Boris Johnson will sit in the centre if it suits his ego. He will sit on the far right if that does too, and possibly even on the left. Reality is he is all over the shop because he is a man that lives in a morality vacuum.
    AKA a politician.

    Like Blair.

    I'll criticise Boris whenever I don't agree with him and have done so in this thread, but you're more bitter than Boddingtons.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,358
    kle4 said:

    Carnyx said:

    Hey Robert, can update the site so people can only post on PB once they've scanned their Covid-19 vaccine certificate QR code from the NHS app?

    And their maths A level certificate.
    Yes!

    I have two A levels in maths, maths and further maths, both As, when A levels were hard.
    Failed a maths AS level *buffs nails*

    The school changed exam boards the next year as most people had failed.
    My final further maths A Level exam was the most stressful exam of my life, well the consequences.

    It was a three hour exam, question 1 worth 50 marks, and question 2 and 3 worth 25 marks each.

    So 90 minutes on Q1 and 45 minutes each on Qs 2 and 3.

    About 75 minutes in I thought yes I'm on schedule, then a few moments later I finished Q1 and I looked at the clock and there was about 35 minutes left in the exam.

    I have never written so fast in my life for qs 2 & 3 and I spent the next two months worrying if I had screwed up my life.
  • Options
    Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 26,533

    Selebian said:

    Andy_JS said:

    "Peter Hitchens
    @ClarkeMicah

    The NHS plans to 'scrape' the medical histories of patients, including sensitive stuff on mental and sexual health, criminal records and abuse, into a database to be shared with third parties. You have less than a month to opt out, if you want to .https://ft.com/content/9fee81"

    https://twitter.com/ClarkeMicah/status/1397902030371438595

    I refer you to:
    https://vf.politicalbetting.com/discussion/comment/3409312#Comment_3409312
    and
    https://vf.politicalbetting.com/discussion/comment/3409368#Comment_3409368
    and @turbotubbs much more succinct:
    https://vf.politicalbetting.com/discussion/comment/3409427#Comment_3409427

    TLDR: This adds GP data to what is already available. Your (anonymised!) health data are already available to third parties unless you opt out and have been for a very long time. Those third parties are given the minimum data required to do their research and have to justify it to the NHS, (often) an ethics committee and IGARD - https://digital.nhs.uk/about-nhs-digital/corporate-information-and-documents/independent-group-advising-on-the-release-of-data/igard-member-profiles
    I couldn't care less what the NHS does with my anonymised data - use it for research, sell it to raise money for patient care, whatever. That's why it's anonymised, duh.
    This assumes it can't be de-anonymised by hackers.
  • Options
    GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 20,847
    edited May 2021
    There seems to be a few apologists here on here deliberately conflating a “broken promise” and a “lie”.

    The first has sadly been endemic in politics since Aristotle.

    The second is something which has undoubtedly happened, but was considered until quite recently a resigning offence if publicly caught out.

    Practiced deceit seems to have become popular in New Labour and has now metastasised into Stage 3 or 4 thanks to both Boris and Cummings.

    It’s not completely the politician’s fault, there is undoubtedly a correlation with 24 hours news media and latterly social media.

    I believed most of what Cummings said yesterday but there is no point in his appealing to the truth when he has spent the last several years debasing that currency.
  • Options
    DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 24,313
    GIN1138 said:

    Maybe we'll get a "night of long knives" next where Gove, Sunak, Rabb and Priti all get sacked? :D

    If there is a night of long knives then expect like-for-like replacements.
  • Options
    bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 21,846
    Hancock "We are vigilant at the Border"

    Another lie to add to his very long list of lies.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,302

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,320
    Cookie said:

    HYUFD said:



    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    It is rightwing to wealthy urban Remainers and graduates, it is dead centre for the working class and lower middle class voters who decide elections.

    It's right wing to the hard of thinking, the reasoning being:
    "I am left wing"
    "I don't like this government"
    "Therefore this government is right wing"
    "Actually, I really, really don't like this government"
    "Therefore this government is really, really right wing"

    I remember back in 2007 the similarly hard of thinking decrying any policy they disagreed with as 'neoliberal'.
    I remember when John Majors government was described as a move to the "extreme right" after the 1997 election.
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 53,938

    Strong performance from Germany, even with 2 days' data:

    https://www.politico.eu/coronavirus-in-europe/


    A large jump in Ireland given their population.
    It'll be for multiple days.

    The table could be clearer, tbh.
  • Options
    CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 39,635
    DavidL said:

    kle4 said:

    Carnyx said:

    DavidL said:

    IanB2 said:

    Oh dear.. is everything's going to be about Boris being an unashamed liar.. its getting very boring and I suspect the electorate are not interested. Boris must be the teflon dead cat that those who dislike him can thrash away at to little or no effect.

    Oh dear, another obsequious post from one of the Government's apologists and predictably "liked" by the usual PB Johnsonphile automatons! Ever wondered about being independent of thought? Ever imagined that it might be possible that the government you voted for might have got things wrong? No, of course not. My party right or wrong. The Führerprinzip is a philosophy alive and well among Johnson's faithful and unthinking followers.
    He is, however, right that the electorate isn’t, right now at least, remotely interested. I am just back from dog training class and all of the others spent the entire break slagging off Cummings; there wasn’t the slightest interest in whether any of the allegations had any truth in them, at all.
    You speak dog? Impressive.
    Only ruffly, I am sure.
    That's barking mad.
    Can I never learn to stay out of these punfests?
    It gets us through the dogday afternoons until the lagershed.
    Dog watches, to be even more precise: 4 to 6, and 6 to 8 ...
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,600
    Rishi gets a flag:


  • Options
    CookieCookie Posts: 11,388

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    Though the SDP nowadays are almost the exact opposite of that.
  • Options
    Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 26,533
    Delyn would be a very tricky by-election for the Tories, because it's clear Labour are quite a bit more popular in Wales than England at present. It could be just the boost Starmer needs.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,198

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Compared to you perhaps. The reality is Boris Johnson will sit in the centre if it suits his ego. He will sit on the far right if that does too, and possibly even on the left. Reality is he is all over the shop because he is a man that lives in a morality vacuum.
    As we have repeatedly established today already I am now very old but I do remember when we had a word for people like that. It was....pragmatist. Pre Thatcher the broad consensus was that people preferred such people to ideologues by a fairly wide margin. Ideology was regarded as slightly unBritish.
  • Options
    GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 20,847

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    Sorry, this is tosh.
  • Options
    Nigel_ForemainNigel_Foremain Posts: 13,781

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Compared to you perhaps. The reality is Boris Johnson will sit in the centre if it suits his ego. He will sit on the far right if that does too, and possibly even on the left. Reality is he is all over the shop because he is a man that lives in a morality vacuum.
    AKA a politician.

    Like Blair.

    I'll criticise Boris whenever I don't agree with him and have done so in this thread, but you're more bitter than Boddingtons.
    Goodness me. You criticising your idol! Was that suggested by your minder from CCO, or are you hoping it might give you more credibility when you return to your usual obsequiousness? And your wit today Philip! More bitter than Boddingtons! Where do you come up with them from? Do you have a class for 24/7 keyboard warriors, which you squeeze in in short breaks when not on here: "how to do a witty repost"? Nil points.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    There seems to be a few apologists here on here deliberately conflating a “broken promise” and a “lie”.

    The first has sadly been endemic in politics since Aristotle.

    The second is something which has undoubtedly happened, but was considered until quite recently a resigning offence if publicly caught out.

    Practiced deceit seems to have been popular in New Labour and has now metastasised into Stage 3 or 4 thanks to both Boris and Cummings.

    I believed most of what Cummings said yesterday but there is no point in his appealing to the truth when he has spent the last several years debasing that currency.

    Breaking a promise because it becomes impossible to fulfill due to events is a broken promise.
    Breaking a promise because although it was entirely possible to honour, you had no intention of ever keeping it, is a lie.
  • Options
    CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 39,635
    Andy_JS said:

    Delyn would be a very tricky by-election for the Tories, because it's clear Labour are quite a bit more popular in Wales than England at present. It could be just the boost Starmer needs.

    I thought you were talking about the pooch, and was thinking that even that would be a push for the Tories.
  • Options
    GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 20,847
    DavidL said:

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Compared to you perhaps. The reality is Boris Johnson will sit in the centre if it suits his ego. He will sit on the far right if that does too, and possibly even on the left. Reality is he is all over the shop because he is a man that lives in a morality vacuum.
    As we have repeatedly established today already I am now very old but I do remember when we had a word for people like that. It was....pragmatist. Pre Thatcher the broad consensus was that people preferred such people to ideologues by a fairly wide margin. Ideology was regarded as slightly unBritish.
    To be fair, Boris doesn’t really have an ideology.
    Or if he does, it’s a primitive kind of narcisstic “boosterism”.
  • Options
    Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 26,533
    isam said:

    HYUFD said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    Floater said:
    I am not sure you have got the hang of this polling mullarkey.

    If responses are taken a day or two before an event, it is unlikely that the responses will be in relation to the event...unless the respondent is psychic...or from the future.
    To be fair, the headline quotes were all over the internet, and on the overnight front pages, so those who answer opinion polls would probably have been influenced to some extent.
    I suspect you are clutching at straws here, unless opinion poll respondents behave like I do with my tax returns and submit them on the evening of January 31st. Most I would hazard, do not.
    I thought they were asked over the period 25-26 May. ie yesterday and the day before, when the Cummings bombshells were all over the media
    Most of the survey took place before Cumming's testimony and 50% before any of it had been given, wait until Saturday for Opinium which started polling today to see if there has been any impact
    Con Maj has gone 2.02 that’s probably a sign
    What was it before? I don't know which direction the movement is in.
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,952

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    As an opponent I would tend to agree.
    It is non-ideological and opportunistically right-wing on issues where it chimes with the majority view.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,198
    Carnyx said:

    DavidL said:

    kle4 said:

    Carnyx said:

    DavidL said:

    IanB2 said:

    Oh dear.. is everything's going to be about Boris being an unashamed liar.. its getting very boring and I suspect the electorate are not interested. Boris must be the teflon dead cat that those who dislike him can thrash away at to little or no effect.

    Oh dear, another obsequious post from one of the Government's apologists and predictably "liked" by the usual PB Johnsonphile automatons! Ever wondered about being independent of thought? Ever imagined that it might be possible that the government you voted for might have got things wrong? No, of course not. My party right or wrong. The Führerprinzip is a philosophy alive and well among Johnson's faithful and unthinking followers.
    He is, however, right that the electorate isn’t, right now at least, remotely interested. I am just back from dog training class and all of the others spent the entire break slagging off Cummings; there wasn’t the slightest interest in whether any of the allegations had any truth in them, at all.
    You speak dog? Impressive.
    Only ruffly, I am sure.
    That's barking mad.
    Can I never learn to stay out of these punfests?
    It gets us through the dogday afternoons until the lagershed.
    Dog watches, to be even more precise: 4 to 6, and 6 to 8 ...
    You seem to ken'all aboot that!
  • Options
    GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 20,847

    There seems to be a few apologists here on here deliberately conflating a “broken promise” and a “lie”.

    The first has sadly been endemic in politics since Aristotle.

    The second is something which has undoubtedly happened, but was considered until quite recently a resigning offence if publicly caught out.

    Practiced deceit seems to have been popular in New Labour and has now metastasised into Stage 3 or 4 thanks to both Boris and Cummings.

    I believed most of what Cummings said yesterday but there is no point in his appealing to the truth when he has spent the last several years debasing that currency.

    Breaking a promise because it becomes impossible to fulfill due to events is a broken promise.
    Breaking a promise because although it was entirely possible to honour, you had no intention of ever keeping it, is a lie.
    Yes, you were the apologist I was thinking of.
  • Options
    Nigel_ForemainNigel_Foremain Posts: 13,781
    DavidL said:

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Compared to you perhaps. The reality is Boris Johnson will sit in the centre if it suits his ego. He will sit on the far right if that does too, and possibly even on the left. Reality is he is all over the shop because he is a man that lives in a morality vacuum.
    As we have repeatedly established today already I am now very old but I do remember when we had a word for people like that. It was....pragmatist. Pre Thatcher the broad consensus was that people preferred such people to ideologues by a fairly wide margin. Ideology was regarded as slightly unBritish.
    Pragmatism as a political philosophy is very fine when it is driven by a desire to do what is in the best interests of the country. If the primary motive is the ego of the individual, or to further their career, as is the case with Johnson, that is a bad thing.
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,182
    "The testing capacity that I had to build" - Hancock.

    :lol: Sounds like he thinks he was driving the bulldozer laying the foundations of the test centres.
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,952

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Excellent post. Very true.

    It’s the most leftwing Tory government since the 1970s, and possibly before.

    I keep repeating this to my chattering class friends!
    Tory is superfluous in that piece.
    The PM reminds me most of Wilson of all his predecessors.
    Master of public persona, political tactics and communication.
    Long term ideas to build a better future?
    Not so much.
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,320
    UK cases by specimen date

    image
  • Options
    Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 26,533
    O/T

    "Microsoft president Brad Smith warns 'life will become like George Orwell's 1984' by 2024 if lawmakers don't protect the public against AI

    Speaking to BBC Panorama Brad Smith said laws are needed to control AI
    Artificial Intelligence can take vast datasets and make predictions and calls
    An example given in the show was China using it for surveillance on citizens
    Smith says the world is catching up with science fiction and we must act now"

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-9625719/Microsoft-president-Brad-Smith-warns-life-like-Orwells-1984-2024.html
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,320
    edited May 2021
    England only - PCR %

    image
  • Options
    GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 20,847
    dixiedean said:

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Excellent post. Very true.

    It’s the most leftwing Tory government since the 1970s, and possibly before.

    I keep repeating this to my chattering class friends!
    Tory is superfluous in that piece.
    The PM reminds me most of Wilson of all his predecessors.
    Master of public persona, political tactics and communication.
    Long term ideas to build a better future?
    Not so much.
    Wilson left almost no legacy except a few catchphrases, an iconic image (the pipe, though apparently he did not much smoke in real life), and an unreformed and latently bankrupt British state.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,358

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    By your definition Thatcher was a centrist.

    She was an internationalist, supported the EC and NATO.

    Elitist because she smashed grammar schools.

    She was trendy because she believed in combating climate change.

    Socially progressive because she civilised the Scots and Norn Irish by decriminalising homosexuality.

    She was very dismissive of British institutions, remember all those industries she privatised and she smashed the the British trade unions.
  • Options
    MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,286
    edited May 2021
    Govt line on care homes now clear:

    It wasn't possible at the start to test everyone going from hospitals to care homes as there wasn't the testing capacity.

    Plus subsidiary point: most of increase in virus in care homes came from workers going in and out; not people coming from hospitals.
  • Options
    Nigel_ForemainNigel_Foremain Posts: 13,781

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    Sorry, this is tosh.
    It is utter bollocks. Many of the so-called "wets" had done service in khaki in WW2. Most Brexiteers are paper tigers who would shit themselves if they heard a shot fired in anger.
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,320
    UK case summary

    image
    image
    image
  • Options
    CookieCookie Posts: 11,388
    Andy_JS said:

    Delyn would be a very tricky by-election for the Tories, because it's clear Labour are quite a bit more popular in Wales than England at present. It could be just the boost Starmer needs.

    Also, Delyn is in the venn diagram where Wales meets outer Liverpool.

    OTOH, it should be natural Conservative 2021 territory. The largest towns are Mold (pleasant market town), Flint (a bit depressing) and Holywell (blink and you'll miss it). Plus a lot of villages. This is not Guardian reading territory. If it were in England you feel you'd struggle to unearth any Labour voters at all.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,198

    DavidL said:

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Compared to you perhaps. The reality is Boris Johnson will sit in the centre if it suits his ego. He will sit on the far right if that does too, and possibly even on the left. Reality is he is all over the shop because he is a man that lives in a morality vacuum.
    As we have repeatedly established today already I am now very old but I do remember when we had a word for people like that. It was....pragmatist. Pre Thatcher the broad consensus was that people preferred such people to ideologues by a fairly wide margin. Ideology was regarded as slightly unBritish.
    To be fair, Boris doesn’t really have an ideology.
    Or if he does, it’s a primitive kind of narcisstic “boosterism”.
    He likes things to go well and for people to like him as a result. How they go well or what direction they go in are really secondary concerns. This doesn't necessarily make him a bad PM but it does make him more than usually dependent on the quality of those doing the steering. And the team is not really optimal in that regard.
  • Options
    bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 21,846
    Hancock trying to blame the lack of testing capacity in March for the fact that he didnt put a protective ring round care homes as he had previously falsely claimed (lied)
  • Options
    isamisam Posts: 40,911
    Andy_JS said:

    isam said:

    HYUFD said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    Floater said:
    I am not sure you have got the hang of this polling mullarkey.

    If responses are taken a day or two before an event, it is unlikely that the responses will be in relation to the event...unless the respondent is psychic...or from the future.
    To be fair, the headline quotes were all over the internet, and on the overnight front pages, so those who answer opinion polls would probably have been influenced to some extent.
    I suspect you are clutching at straws here, unless opinion poll respondents behave like I do with my tax returns and submit them on the evening of January 31st. Most I would hazard, do not.
    I thought they were asked over the period 25-26 May. ie yesterday and the day before, when the Cummings bombshells were all over the media
    Most of the survey took place before Cumming's testimony and 50% before any of it had been given, wait until Saturday for Opinium which started polling today to see if there has been any impact
    Con Maj has gone 2.02 that’s probably a sign
    What was it before? I don't know which direction the movement is in.
    Touched 1.8, but not for any big money
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,320
    UK Hospitals

    image
    image
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,320
    UK deaths

    image
  • Options
    Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 26,533

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    This was an interesting tweet by a Tory MP recently:

    "@Mike_Fabricant

    Many would say that the present Government is left of centre on social reform and economic policy while taking full advantage of the freedoms that #Brexit has afforded us.
    That is why #Boris and the Party is so popular. Except with those who still hanker after the #EU.

    9:14 AM · May 25, 2021"

    https://twitter.com/Mike_Fabricant/status/1397103664586792962
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,258
    MikeL said:

    Govt line on care homes now clear:

    It wasn't possible at the start to test everyone going from hospitals to care homes as there wasn't the testing capacity.

    Plus subsidiary point: most of increase in virus in care homes came from workers going in and out; not people coming from hospitals.

    Indeed that is clear by Hancock’s statement just now
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,320
    UK R

    image
  • Options
    TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 40,007

    Andy_JS said:

    "Rob Roberts: Commons leader calls on MP to stand down

    Commons Leader Jacob Rees-Mogg has increased the pressure on Conservative MP Rob Roberts to resign. He said it would be "honourable" for the Delyn MP to stand down after an investigation found he sexually harassed an employee."

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-politics-57267295

    I thought Boris had drawn a line under the matter yesterday. Essentially Rob serves the suspension before returning to the fold.
    Suspension by his what?
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,302

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    By your definition Thatcher was a centrist.

    She was an internationalist, supported the EC and NATO.

    Elitist because she smashed grammar schools.

    She was trendy because she believed in combating climate change.

    Socially progressive because she civilised the Scots and Norn Irish by decriminalising homosexuality.

    She was very dismissive of British institutions, remember all those industries she privatised and she smashed the the British trade unions.
    Thatcher would have been very comfortable with today's Conservative Party.
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,320
    Age related data

    image
    image
    image
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,253

    Floater said:
    I am not sure you have got the hang of this polling mullarkey.

    If responses are taken a day or two before an event, it is unlikely that the responses will be in relation to the event...unless the respondent is psychic...or from the future.
    That reminds me of a classic speech from a Conservative councillor the year they had taken control of the council, who rose to her feet after that year’s exam results came out to laud the educational achievements of the new administration, only to have her contribution punctured by the observation that the children had actually sat their exams only days after the election.
  • Options
    TimTTimT Posts: 6,328

    kle4 said:

    Carnyx said:

    DavidL said:

    IanB2 said:

    Oh dear.. is everything's going to be about Boris being an unashamed liar.. its getting very boring and I suspect the electorate are not interested. Boris must be the teflon dead cat that those who dislike him can thrash away at to little or no effect.

    Oh dear, another obsequious post from one of the Government's apologists and predictably "liked" by the usual PB Johnsonphile automatons! Ever wondered about being independent of thought? Ever imagined that it might be possible that the government you voted for might have got things wrong? No, of course not. My party right or wrong. The Führerprinzip is a philosophy alive and well among Johnson's faithful and unthinking followers.
    He is, however, right that the electorate isn’t, right now at least, remotely interested. I am just back from dog training class and all of the others spent the entire break slagging off Cummings; there wasn’t the slightest interest in whether any of the allegations had any truth in them, at all.
    You speak dog? Impressive.
    Only ruffly, I am sure.
    That's barking mad.
    Can I never learn to stay out of these punfests?
    K, 9 minutes in the doghouse for you for that one ...
  • Options
    Nigel_ForemainNigel_Foremain Posts: 13,781

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    By your definition Thatcher was a centrist.

    She was an internationalist, supported the EC and NATO.

    Elitist because she smashed grammar schools.

    She was trendy because she believed in combating climate change.

    Socially progressive because she civilised the Scots and Norn Irish by decriminalising homosexuality.

    She was very dismissive of British institutions, remember all those industries she privatised and she smashed the the British trade unions.
    She was a centrist compared to the many swivel eyed nutters and UKIP entryists who have taken over the Tory Party.
  • Options
    AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 19,939

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Excellent post. Very true.

    It’s the most leftwing Tory government since the 1970s, and possibly be

    England only - PCR %

    image

    Peak definitely over in Bolton now.

    Blackburn is where all the action is.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,302

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    Sorry, this is tosh.
    That's how I'd define the TIGers and current Lib Dems.

    Remind me how well they're polling?
  • Options
    GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 20,847
    Andy_JS said:

    O/T

    "Microsoft president Brad Smith warns 'life will become like George Orwell's 1984' by 2024 if lawmakers don't protect the public against AI

    Speaking to BBC Panorama Brad Smith said laws are needed to control AI
    Artificial Intelligence can take vast datasets and make predictions and calls
    An example given in the show was China using it for surveillance on citizens
    Smith says the world is catching up with science fiction and we must act now"

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-9625719/Microsoft-president-Brad-Smith-warns-life-like-Orwells-1984-2024.html

    It is one my desperate hopes that the British state might take a lead on this sort of thing.

    We have both the early-adopter thing, but also a state apparatus able, on a good day, to make sensible policy.

    But I think it also requires an inspired minister to drive it and they are in short supply.
  • Options
    SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 20,596

    Rishi gets a flag:


    And some edgy art.
  • Options
    DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 24,313
    Andy_JS said:

    Selebian said:

    Andy_JS said:

    "Peter Hitchens
    @ClarkeMicah

    The NHS plans to 'scrape' the medical histories of patients, including sensitive stuff on mental and sexual health, criminal records and abuse, into a database to be shared with third parties. You have less than a month to opt out, if you want to .https://ft.com/content/9fee81"

    https://twitter.com/ClarkeMicah/status/1397902030371438595

    I refer you to:
    https://vf.politicalbetting.com/discussion/comment/3409312#Comment_3409312
    and
    https://vf.politicalbetting.com/discussion/comment/3409368#Comment_3409368
    and @turbotubbs much more succinct:
    https://vf.politicalbetting.com/discussion/comment/3409427#Comment_3409427

    TLDR: This adds GP data to what is already available. Your (anonymised!) health data are already available to third parties unless you opt out and have been for a very long time. Those third parties are given the minimum data required to do their research and have to justify it to the NHS, (often) an ethics committee and IGARD - https://digital.nhs.uk/about-nhs-digital/corporate-information-and-documents/independent-group-advising-on-the-release-of-data/igard-member-profiles
    I couldn't care less what the NHS does with my anonymised data - use it for research, sell it to raise money for patient care, whatever. That's why it's anonymised, duh.
    This assumes it can't be de-anonymised by hackers.
    Even in anonymised form, surely by selling NHS patient data we advantage foreign pharmaceutical and AI computing companies, not to mention KGB spies?
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,320
    Age related data scaled to 100K per group

    image
    image
    image
  • Options
    FenmanFenman Posts: 1,047
    Andy_JS said:

    Delyn would be a very tricky by-election for the Tories, because it's clear Labour are quite a bit more popular in Wales than England at present. It could be just the boost Starmer needs.

    I think that the electors of Amersham & Chesham will give Boris a bloody nose first. Let's see how the Tories will do when they can't threaten the middle classes with Corbyn. Let's also not forget that Boris's seat is just down the road and people opposed to rural house building and HS2 will remember that his anti Heathrow expansion constituents found that when the chips were down, Boris could be found in Afghanistan.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    "The testing capacity that I had to build" - Hancock.

    :lol: Sounds like he thinks he was driving the bulldozer laying the foundations of the test centres.

    Going big on how his 100k target was so important to build testing capacity, in order to test people.

    Straight answer too on the going into care homes: the testing capacity wasn't there, he pledge to get it, got it and put the policy into place.
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,320
    CFR

    image
  • Options
    Nigel_ForemainNigel_Foremain Posts: 13,781

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    By your definition Thatcher was a centrist.

    She was an internationalist, supported the EC and NATO.

    Elitist because she smashed grammar schools.

    She was trendy because she believed in combating climate change.

    Socially progressive because she civilised the Scots and Norn Irish by decriminalising homosexuality.

    She was very dismissive of British institutions, remember all those industries she privatised and she smashed the the British trade unions.
    Thatcher would have been very comfortable with today's Conservative Party.
    You clearly know very little about Margaret Thatcher. She would have despised Johnson. He is everything she hated
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,320
    Vaccinations

    image
    image
    image
    image
  • Options
    GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 20,847

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    Sorry, this is tosh.
    That's how I'd define the TIGers and current Lib Dems.

    Remind me how well they're polling?
    Badly.

    But what’s that got to do with your nonsensical premise?
  • Options
    CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 39,635

    Andy_JS said:

    Selebian said:

    Andy_JS said:

    "Peter Hitchens
    @ClarkeMicah

    The NHS plans to 'scrape' the medical histories of patients, including sensitive stuff on mental and sexual health, criminal records and abuse, into a database to be shared with third parties. You have less than a month to opt out, if you want to .https://ft.com/content/9fee81"

    https://twitter.com/ClarkeMicah/status/1397902030371438595

    I refer you to:
    https://vf.politicalbetting.com/discussion/comment/3409312#Comment_3409312
    and
    https://vf.politicalbetting.com/discussion/comment/3409368#Comment_3409368
    and @turbotubbs much more succinct:
    https://vf.politicalbetting.com/discussion/comment/3409427#Comment_3409427

    TLDR: This adds GP data to what is already available. Your (anonymised!) health data are already available to third parties unless you opt out and have been for a very long time. Those third parties are given the minimum data required to do their research and have to justify it to the NHS, (often) an ethics committee and IGARD - https://digital.nhs.uk/about-nhs-digital/corporate-information-and-documents/independent-group-advising-on-the-release-of-data/igard-member-profiles
    I couldn't care less what the NHS does with my anonymised data - use it for research, sell it to raise money for patient care, whatever. That's why it's anonymised, duh.
    This assumes it can't be de-anonymised by hackers.
    Even in anonymised form, surely by selling NHS patient data we advantage foreign pharmaceutical and AI computing companies, not to mention KGB spies?
    That's the whole point (apart from bona fide UK researchers).
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,717
    Left vs right, and thus centre, already only works in very broad terms at best, and is bollocks at worst. Trying to figure out if someone is broadly centrist because they are electorally successful and so in the centre of public opinion, or if there is some objective left or right definition that overrides that, strikes me as a lot of wasted effort.
  • Options
    noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 20,706

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    Good to see nothing in your post that could be viewed as snooty or dismissive.....
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,320
    COVID Summary

    Cases and hospital admissions continue to rise. Both are in the non-vaccinated groups, it seems

    image
    image
  • Options
    GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 20,847

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    By your definition Thatcher was a centrist.

    She was an internationalist, supported the EC and NATO.

    Elitist because she smashed grammar schools.

    She was trendy because she believed in combating climate change.

    Socially progressive because she civilised the Scots and Norn Irish by decriminalising homosexuality.

    She was very dismissive of British institutions, remember all those industries she privatised and she smashed the the British trade unions.
    Thatcher would have been very comfortable with today's Conservative Party.
    I highly doubt this.

    Well, maybe the senile version, but not the young, intellectually vigorous, patriotic version.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,198
    Fenman said:

    Andy_JS said:

    Delyn would be a very tricky by-election for the Tories, because it's clear Labour are quite a bit more popular in Wales than England at present. It could be just the boost Starmer needs.

    I think that the electors of Amersham & Chesham will give Boris a bloody nose first. Let's see how the Tories will do when they can't threaten the middle classes with Corbyn. Let's also not forget that Boris's seat is just down the road and people opposed to rural house building and HS2 will remember that his anti Heathrow expansion constituents found that when the chips were down, Boris could be found in Afghanistan.
    Yep, he's definitely doomed this time. Wylie Coyote was just telling me so. He's going to catch that roadrunner and then finish off Boris. Its a sure thing.
  • Options
    MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,286
    edited May 2021
    Only question remaining is:

    Could they have delayed hospital discharges until testing capacity was in place?

    ie Would there have been the capacity in hospitals to do that?

    If Answer to above is "No" then debate ends and Govt are 100% in the clear.

    (Guess what - no journalist asked the above - they just repeated original question and then moved to human interest examples).
  • Options
    bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 21,846

    MikeL said:

    Govt line on care homes now clear:

    It wasn't possible at the start to test everyone going from hospitals to care homes as there wasn't the testing capacity.

    Plus subsidiary point: most of increase in virus in care homes came from workers going in and out; not people coming from hospitals.

    Indeed that is clear by Hancock’s statement just now

    If there wasn't the testing capacity, the discharge plan should have been amended to "anywhere but a care home"

  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 53,938
    edited May 2021

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    By your definition Thatcher was a centrist.

    She was an internationalist, supported the EC and NATO.

    Elitist because she smashed grammar schools.

    She was trendy because she believed in combating climate change.

    Socially progressive because she civilised the Scots and Norn Irish by decriminalising homosexuality.

    She was very dismissive of British institutions, remember all those industries she privatised and she smashed the the British trade unions.
    Thatcher would have been very comfortable with today's Conservative Party.
    I think she'd have been very comfortable with its policy platform, but unimpressed by Boris (or Hancock, for that matter).

    (Come to mention it, I'm not sure she'd have been happy by the deficit spending, but that's another story.)
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,952

    dixiedean said:

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Excellent post. Very true.

    It’s the most leftwing Tory government since the 1970s, and possibly before.

    I keep repeating this to my chattering class friends!
    Tory is superfluous in that piece.
    The PM reminds me most of Wilson of all his predecessors.
    Master of public persona, political tactics and communication.
    Long term ideas to build a better future?
    Not so much.
    Wilson left almost no legacy except a few catchphrases, an iconic image (the pipe, though apparently he did not much smoke in real life), and an unreformed and latently bankrupt British state.
    See what I mean?
  • Options
    DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 24,313

    dixiedean said:

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Excellent post. Very true.

    It’s the most leftwing Tory government since the 1970s, and possibly before.

    I keep repeating this to my chattering class friends!
    Tory is superfluous in that piece.
    The PM reminds me most of Wilson of all his predecessors.
    Master of public persona, political tactics and communication.
    Long term ideas to build a better future?
    Not so much.
    Wilson left almost no legacy except a few catchphrases, an iconic image (the pipe, though apparently he did not much smoke in real life), and an unreformed and latently bankrupt British state.
    What's Harold Wilson ever done for us? Open University, legalised abortions, decriminalised homosexuality, abolished hanging.
  • Options
    Nigel_ForemainNigel_Foremain Posts: 13,781

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    By your definition Thatcher was a centrist.

    She was an internationalist, supported the EC and NATO.

    Elitist because she smashed grammar schools.

    She was trendy because she believed in combating climate change.

    Socially progressive because she civilised the Scots and Norn Irish by decriminalising homosexuality.

    She was very dismissive of British institutions, remember all those industries she privatised and she smashed the the British trade unions.
    Thatcher would have been very comfortable with today's Conservative Party.
    I highly doubt this.

    Well, maybe the senile version, but not the young, intellectually vigorous, patriotic version.
    She would have seen Johnson for what he is: an opportunistic fool with a sense of entitlement and no eye for detail. He is the sort of Tory that she would have ensured never made it above PPS.
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,182

    Hancock trying to blame the lack of testing capacity in March for the fact that he didnt put a protective ring round care homes as he had previously falsely claimed (lied)

    Let's see the Cabinet minutes.

    Seems to me that Cummings claims he came away from Cabinet in March sure that Hancock had said that care home incoming residents would be tested on their way in from hospital.

    And not what Hancock claims, that he said all incoming residents would be tested when the tests become available
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,253
    felix said:

    IanB2 said:

    Oh dear.. is everything's going to be about Boris being an unashamed liar.. its getting very boring and I suspect the electorate are not interested. Boris must be the teflon dead cat that those who dislike him can thrash away at to little or no effect.

    Oh dear, another obsequious post from one of the Government's apologists and predictably "liked" by the usual PB Johnsonphile automatons! Ever wondered about being independent of thought? Ever imagined that it might be possible that the government you voted for might have got things wrong? No, of course not. My party right or wrong. The Führerprinzip is a philosophy alive and well among Johnson's faithful and unthinking followers.
    He is, however, right that the electorate isn’t, right now at least, remotely interested. I am just back from dog training class and all of the others spent the entire break slagging off Cummings; there wasn’t the slightest interest in whether any of the allegations had any truth in them, at all.
    It's weird - you and the entire liberal commentariat trashed Cummings week in week out over the Covid breach and you're now puzzled that the public don't believe him when he trashes the government. If I was clever I'd probably say you've been hoisted by your own petard but I'm just a dumbass BFb! Oh well. Never mind.
    So long as Cummings himself isn’t sitting at home surprised that what people choose to believe in politics has very little to do with what might actually be true.

    Now that would be worrying.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,302

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    Sorry, this is tosh.
    That's how I'd define the TIGers and current Lib Dems.

    Remind me how well they're polling?
    Badly.

    But what’s that got to do with your nonsensical premise?
    I've described the policy positions and attitudes of those who most frequently describe themselves as centrists; my point being the centre isn't where they think it is.

    If you think I've got that wrong then I'd be interested in hearing your take.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,358
    edited May 2021

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    By your definition Thatcher was a centrist.

    She was an internationalist, supported the EC and NATO.

    Elitist because she smashed grammar schools.

    She was trendy because she believed in combating climate change.

    Socially progressive because she civilised the Scots and Norn Irish by decriminalising homosexuality.

    She was very dismissive of British institutions, remember all those industries she privatised and she smashed the the British trade unions.
    Thatcher would have been very comfortable with today's Conservative Party.
    No she wouldn't, she'd have been very uncomfortable with

    1) The threat of violating international agreements with things like the internal market bill

    2) She would have been disgusted with the fuck business agenda

    3) The government's plan for increasing state aid has her spinning in her grave

    4) The attacks of the judiciary and legal profession would not only offend her personally but as a democrat

    5) The weakening of the Union thanks to various policies

    There's many many other reasons but that's just the start.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,258

    MikeL said:

    Govt line on care homes now clear:

    It wasn't possible at the start to test everyone going from hospitals to care homes as there wasn't the testing capacity.

    Plus subsidiary point: most of increase in virus in care homes came from workers going in and out; not people coming from hospitals.

    Indeed that is clear by Hancock’s statement just now

    If there wasn't the testing capacity, the discharge plan should have been amended to "anywhere but a care home"

    Jenny Harries has just affirmed there was a small number of hospital transfers and the main reason for the deaths in homes was due to carers and others coming into the buildings
  • Options
    TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 40,007

    DavidL said:

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Compared to you perhaps. The reality is Boris Johnson will sit in the centre if it suits his ego. He will sit on the far right if that does too, and possibly even on the left. Reality is he is all over the shop because he is a man that lives in a morality vacuum.
    As we have repeatedly established today already I am now very old but I do remember when we had a word for people like that. It was....pragmatist. Pre Thatcher the broad consensus was that people preferred such people to ideologues by a fairly wide margin. Ideology was regarded as slightly unBritish.
    To be fair, Boris doesn’t really have an ideology.
    Or if he does, it’s a primitive kind of narcisstic “boosterism”.
    Is boosterism the portmanteau for Wooster and Boris?
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,258

    Hancock trying to blame the lack of testing capacity in March for the fact that he didnt put a protective ring round care homes as he had previously falsely claimed (lied)

    Let's see the Cabinet minutes.

    Seems to me that Cummings claims he came away from Cabinet in March sure that Hancock had said that care home incoming residents would be tested on their way in from hospital.

    And not what Hancock claims, that he said all incoming residents would be tested when the tests become available
    And he did not attend Cabinet apparently
  • Options
    CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 39,635

    dixiedean said:

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Excellent post. Very true.

    It’s the most leftwing Tory government since the 1970s, and possibly before.

    I keep repeating this to my chattering class friends!
    Tory is superfluous in that piece.
    The PM reminds me most of Wilson of all his predecessors.
    Master of public persona, political tactics and communication.
    Long term ideas to build a better future?
    Not so much.
    Wilson left almost no legacy except a few catchphrases, an iconic image (the pipe, though apparently he did not much smoke in real life), and an unreformed and latently bankrupt British state.
    What's Harold Wilson ever done for us? Open University, legalised abortions, decriminalised homosexuality, abolished hanging.
    Concorde.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,358

    DavidL said:

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Compared to you perhaps. The reality is Boris Johnson will sit in the centre if it suits his ego. He will sit on the far right if that does too, and possibly even on the left. Reality is he is all over the shop because he is a man that lives in a morality vacuum.
    As we have repeatedly established today already I am now very old but I do remember when we had a word for people like that. It was....pragmatist. Pre Thatcher the broad consensus was that people preferred such people to ideologues by a fairly wide margin. Ideology was regarded as slightly unBritish.
    To be fair, Boris doesn’t really have an ideology.
    Or if he does, it’s a primitive kind of narcisstic “boosterism”.
    Is boosterism the portmanteau for Wooster and Boris?
    No, it is a North American word.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boosterism
  • Options
    Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 26,533
    An interesting fact is that Batley and Spen has never been won by the Conservatives by more than 2.3%, because they won it 3 times in 1983, 1987 and 1992 by 1.6%, 2.3% and 2.3% again with Elizabeth Peacock as candidate/MP.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batley_and_Spen_(UK_Parliament_constituency)
  • Options
    BluestBlueBluestBlue Posts: 4,556

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    By your definition Thatcher was a centrist.

    She was an internationalist, supported the EC and NATO.

    Elitist because she smashed grammar schools.

    She was trendy because she believed in combating climate change.

    Socially progressive because she civilised the Scots and Norn Irish by decriminalising homosexuality.

    She was very dismissive of British institutions, remember all those industries she privatised and she smashed the the British trade unions.
    Thatcher would have been very comfortable with today's Conservative Party.
    You clearly know very little about Margaret Thatcher. She would have despised Johnson. He is everything she hated
    She hated crushing the left in epic landslides? A novel take on the Iron lady.
  • Options
    MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,286
    edited May 2021
    Classic case of language ambiguity - saying something will be done (and ending sentence there) is not the same as saying something will be done effective from this minute.

    If timescale is not stated then you are left with ambiguity and impossible to say Hancock was lying.
  • Options
    FenmanFenman Posts: 1,047
    DavidL said:

    Fenman said:

    Andy_JS said:

    Delyn would be a very tricky by-election for the Tories, because it's clear Labour are quite a bit more popular in Wales than England at present. It could be just the boost Starmer needs.

    I think that the electors of Amersham & Chesham will give Boris a bloody nose first. Let's see how the Tories will do when they can't threaten the middle classes with Corbyn. Let's also not forget that Boris's seat is just down the road and people opposed to rural house building and HS2 will remember that his anti Heathrow expansion constituents found that when the chips were down, Boris could be found in Afghanistan.
    Yep, he's definitely doomed this time. Wylie Coyote was just telling me so. He's going to catch that roadrunner and then finish off Boris. Its a sure thing.
    Nothing is certain in Politics. But the straw that breaks the camel's back is coming soon to a by election near you... Time Boris got a bloody nose. The interesting point will be how he reacts to it.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,198

    dixiedean said:

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Excellent post. Very true.

    It’s the most leftwing Tory government since the 1970s, and possibly before.

    I keep repeating this to my chattering class friends!
    Tory is superfluous in that piece.
    The PM reminds me most of Wilson of all his predecessors.
    Master of public persona, political tactics and communication.
    Long term ideas to build a better future?
    Not so much.
    Wilson left almost no legacy except a few catchphrases, an iconic image (the pipe, though apparently he did not much smoke in real life), and an unreformed and latently bankrupt British state.
    What's Harold Wilson ever done for us? Open University, legalised abortions, decriminalised homosexuality, abolished hanging.
    I think that you can make a case for Roy Jenkins being our finest Home Secretary since the war. I really wouldn't want to choose between Mrs May and Priti Patel but they are both seriously near the worst.
  • Options
    Nigel_ForemainNigel_Foremain Posts: 13,781

    There's a perception amongst its opponents that this Government is ideological and very right-wing.

    In fact, the reason it's polling so well is that it's positioned itself slap-bang in the centre of where public opinion is across the country at large.

    That's not the same as the chatterati, but it doesn't make it untrue.

    Well said.

    The likes of TIGgers etc love to call themselves "centrists" when they're not remotely in the centre. Boris is ruthlessly centrist right now.
    Centrist doesn't mean centrist. It means: internationalist, technocratic, elitist, snooty, trendy, socially "progressive", dismissive of British institutions and culture, and self-interested.

    The SDP, the Wets and Edward Heath were their forebears.
    Sorry, this is tosh.
    That's how I'd define the TIGers and current Lib Dems.

    Remind me how well they're polling?
    Badly.

    But what’s that got to do with your nonsensical premise?
    I've described the policy positions and attitudes of those who most frequently describe themselves as centrists; my point being the centre isn't where they think it is.

    If you think I've got that wrong then I'd be interested in hearing your take.
    Yes, yes, we know you view Nigel Farage as a centrist. Or perhaps you see him as a bit of a lefty?
This discussion has been closed.