Given Swinson, Sturgeon and Farage were not taking part, Leavers will overwhelmingly have gone for Boris and Remainers will overwhelmingly have gone for Corbyn, so 52% for Boris to 48% for Corbyn seems apt.
However Boris will be the more pleased of the two, as he was already ahead in the polls it was Corbyn who needed a big win in the final debate to change the narrative and that has not happened.
4 points is about what I thought the Tory Labour gap would be. But now I'm thinking it will be more like 6pts.
It's currently averaging 10 points, so where does this estimation come from kle4?
Not based on anything, just not convinced the pollsters are not understating Labour again. 6-7 presumes a modest Labour outperformance of the polls, but the Tory lead has been steady enough and high enough I think small majority is highly likely even if the polls are wrong.
4 points is about what I thought the Tory Labour gap would be. But now I'm thinking it will be more like 6pts.
It's currently averaging 10 points, so where does this estimation come from kle4?
Not based on anything, just not convinced the pollsters are not understating Labour again. 6-7 presumes a modest Labour outperformance of the polls, but the Tory lead has been steady enough and high enough I think small majority is highly likely even if the polls are wrong.
The regional variances are playing havoc with UNS. Difficult to ascertain where votes are piling up or being spread efficiently. Maybe the polls are underestimating the Tories this time. In normal times I would say that is a catastrophe for Labour, but getting rid of Corbyn and McDonnell would be a very good thing for them.
As someone who first voted in 2005, and wasn't really paying much attention in that one which did have a higher majority, a majority over 30 seems enormous to me despite really not being so.
As someone who first voted in 2005, and wasn't really paying much attention in that one which did have a higher majority, a majority over 30 seems enormous to me despite really not being so.
It won't be a Tory landslide but if Boris does get a majority of 40+ that will be a bigger victory than any Tory leader has won since Thatcher
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory. Am I the David Herdson of 2019?
🚨 Huge. Reddit security team believes the Reddit post of leaked US-UK trade documents used by Jeremy Corbyn and Labour was part of a co-ordinated campaign coming from Russia https://t.co/AjWMJcObhD
As someone who first voted in 2005, and wasn't really paying much attention in that one which did have a higher majority, a majority over 30 seems enormous to me despite really not being so.
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory.
I always have problems with these majority figures
With the speakers and sinn fein deducted the actual majority
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory. Am I the David Herdson of 2019?
Tories are 7 points ahead. Mori leader favorability doesn't lie.
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory. Am I the David Herdson of 2019?
Tories are 7 points ahead. Mori leader favorability doesn't lie.
When the average polls show that I will believe you
🚨 Huge. Reddit security team believes the Reddit post of leaked US-UK trade documents used by Jeremy Corbyn and Labour was part of a co-ordinated campaign coming from Russia https://t.co/AjWMJcObhD
The Russians want to thwart Brexit by electing Corbyn on a wave of NHS alarm? But I thought they were the ones behind Brexit in the first place? I wish they'd make up our minds.
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory.
I always have problems with these majority figures
With the speakers and sinn fein deducted the actual majority
650 - 10 = 640
640 -335
= 305 so majority is 30
You can't deduct the speakers because they need to be elected, 1 from labour, Hoyle and two theories
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory.
I always have problems with these majority figures
With the speakers and sinn fein deducted the actual majority
650 - 10 = 640
640 -335
= 305 so majority is 30
Is it planned to change the rules so all the Deputy Speakers will be Labour MPs?
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory. Am I the David Herdson of 2019?
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory.
I always have problems with these majority figures
With the speakers and sinn fein deducted the actual majority
650 - 10 = 640
640 -335
= 305 so majority is 30
Is it planned to change the rules so all the Deputy Speakers will be Labour MPs?
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory.
I always have problems with these majority figures
With the speakers and sinn fein deducted the actual majority
650 - 10 = 640
640 -335
= 305 so majority is 30
No. Just to take one example; Eleanor Laing will be elected (probably) as a Tory but she is also included in your deductions.
In other words, the questions Tories do better on Boris won, the questions Labour do better on Corbyn won.
I guess trustworthy is one which is a bit more useful, and surprisingly close between them.
Was there a “Don’t trust either of them with a barge pole. Hell, their wives don’t even trust them” option?
Of course not they want a binary election and the media are incapable of coping with a none binary choice but that’s all you are going to get with this corrupt two party duopoly
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory.
I always have problems with these majority figures
With the speakers and sinn fein deducted the actual majority
650 - 10 = 640
640 -335
= 305 so majority is 30
You can't deduct the speakers because they need to be elected, 1 from labour, Hoyle and two theories
Didn't see the debate but since Johnson is hugely more popular than Corbyn (in the way that herpes is hugely more popular than siphylus) I should say for the voters to score it so close, Corbyn must have done pretty well.
How did Swinson do - or did she decide not to attend?
It all matters little though. The punters have pretty much decided.
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory.
I always have problems with these majority figures
With the speakers and sinn fein deducted the actual majority
650 - 10 = 640
640 -335
= 305 so majority is 30
You can't deduct the speakers because they need to be elected, 1 from labour, Hoyle and two theories
Also, I read that 3 Sinn Fein candidates have stood aside, so as I understand it, they are only likely to have 4 candidates elected.
People are not taking into account the regional dynamics and the fact that if Leave wanted to gerrymander the seats they couldn't have done a much better job than the ones we have now!
Even assuming say 10 Tory seats lost to the SNP and LDs making it 18 Labour seats required for that majority a swing of 1.58% or a Tory lead over Labour of 5% would be enough.
A Tory landslide is now unlikely, a Tory majority still is
Mori figures seem to imply a possibility of a Hung Parliament.
Nope. This tells you a lot: "Johnson retains a clear lead over Corbyn as the person the public see as the most capable Prime Minister. 47% consider Johnson the most capable Prime Minister compared to 31% for Jeremy Corbyn."
The final one from Mori in 2017 was May 47 Corbyn 36, a lead of 11 which translates to a voting intention lead of around 4, not far off the final result. This time it's 16, so it's around 9 which is close to the polling average lead of 10.
🚨 Huge. Reddit security team believes the Reddit post of leaked US-UK trade documents used by Jeremy Corbyn and Labour was part of a co-ordinated campaign coming from Russia https://t.co/AjWMJcObhD
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory.
I always have problems with these majority figures
With the speakers and sinn fein deducted the actual majority
650 - 10 = 640
640 -335
= 305 so majority is 30
You can't deduct the speakers because they need to be elected, 1 from labour, Hoyle and two theories
Also, I read that 3 Sinn Fein candidates have stood aside, so as I understand it, they are only likely to have 4 candidates elected.
I doubt they've stood down in seats they presently hold, but in seats the SDLP might win from unionists? Though they could lost to the SDLP in 1 or 2 as well.
Missed the debate. Didn’t miss anything. Usual suspects on PB posting usual posts. Enjoy the fun. Not long until it’s over. Then the real troubles begin.
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory.
I always have problems with these majority figures
With the speakers and sinn fein deducted the actual majority
650 - 10 = 640
640 -335
= 305 so majority is 30
You can't deduct the speakers because they need to be elected, 1 from labour, Hoyle and two theories
Also, I read that 3 Sinn Fein candidates have stood aside, so as I understand it, they are only likely to have 4 candidates elected.
I doubt they've stood down in seats they presently hold, but in seats the SDLP might win from unionists? Though they could lost to the SDLP in 1 or 2 as well.
On a bad night they could lose to the UUP in Fermanagh too
These "opinion polls" and "MRPs" and "experts" are all very well, but I have four reasons for believing there will be a Labour landslide next Thursday:
a) A Very British Coup forecasts that the Communist Labour leader will win a surprise victory against the Tory. JC=Harry Perkins, surely? b) failing to deliver Brexit in March and again in October, was meant to be an "extinction level event" for the Conservatives c) Putin seems to be backing Corbyn, and he really controls what happens in UK elections d) on the other hand, Trump is backing Johnson and Brexit, and so only card-carrying KKK members could vote Conservative.
Hampshire North West a nailed on Lab gain, surely?
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory. Am I the David Herdson of 2019?
Tories are 7 points ahead. Mori leader favorability doesn't lie.
When the average polls show that I will believe you
Because the polls are never wrong... The reality is none of us knows what will happen. What I do know is that historically the Mori leader positive favorability differential does a better job of predicting the final result than the polls do. Out of sample it predicted the vote share margin to within 1pp in both 2015 and 2017, when the polls were completely wrong. So, why do you think that this time it is the polls that will be right? I mean, you could be right, but what has changed?
Are Tory losses to the Lib Dems really going to be a big issue?
Or is that just Lib Dem propaganda?
Probably the latter, although you would only expect them to talk up their chances. Most likely they'll just rack up a load of decent second places, which are useless under our system of course (though they'll create a longer list of viable targets to go for in the election after this one.)
FWIW, the YouGov MRP has St Albans, Richmond Park and Cheltenham going Con>LD, and North Norfolk and Eastbourne going LD>Con, so a net movement of precisely one seat in the Lib Dems' favour in that particular head-to-head.
It's squeaky bum time folks ... with just five days to go, Electoral Calculus has the Tories winning 335 seats, i.e achieving a 20 seat majority. Almost MOE territory.
I always have problems with these majority figures
With the speakers and sinn fein deducted the actual majority
650 - 10 = 640
640 -335
= 305 so majority is 30
You can't deduct the speakers because they need to be elected, 1 from labour, Hoyle and two theories
Also, I read that 3 Sinn Fein candidates have stood aside, so as I understand it, they are only likely to have 4 candidates elected.
I doubt they've stood down in seats they presently hold, but in seats the SDLP might win from unionists? Though they could lost to the SDLP in 1 or 2 as well.
On a bad night they could lose to the UUP in Fermanagh too
Good old Fermanagh. I always remember it thanks to this little titbit from Wiki in 2010 after the 4 vote victory: Following the close result Connor lodged a petition against Gildernew alleging irregularities in the counting of the votes had affected the result. However the Court found that there were only three ballot papers which could not be accounted for, and even if they were all votes for Connor, Gildernew would have had a plurality of one. The election was therefore upheld
Not quite the same thing as winning it literally by one vote, but close.
🚨 Huge. Reddit security team believes the Reddit post of leaked US-UK trade documents used by Jeremy Corbyn and Labour was part of a co-ordinated campaign coming from Russia https://t.co/AjWMJcObhD
Didnt we already know this?
I'm not sure I knew it was leaked as part of a russian campaign..
Comments
However Boris will be the more pleased of the two, as he was already ahead in the polls it was Corbyn who needed a big win in the final debate to change the narrative and that has not happened.
Boris Johnson: 55%
Jeremy Corbyn: 36%
via @YouGov
Representative survey of viewers
Snap poll alnost the same too, very even.
I guess trustworthy is one which is a bit more useful, and surprisingly close between them.
Almost MOE territory. Am I the David Herdson of 2019?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Kingdom_general_elections
2005:66
1979:43
1970:30
1992:21
1951:17
These majorities, though not big, didn't result in actual early elections, so those are the targets for the Conservatives to beat in 6 days.
https://twitter.com/AllieHBNews/status/1203075246376525824/photo/1
With the speakers and sinn fein deducted the actual majority
650 - 10 = 640
640
-335
= 305 so majority is 30
Or is that just Lib Dem propaganda?
How did Swinson do - or did she decide not to attend?
It all matters little though. The punters have pretty much decided.
Top trolling, YouGov panel......
See you at the hacienda soon!
People are not taking into account the regional dynamics and the fact that if Leave wanted to gerrymander the seats they couldn't have done a much better job than the ones we have now!
http://www.electionpolling.co.uk/battleground/targets/conservative
Even assuming say 10 Tory seats lost to the SNP and LDs making it 18 Labour seats required for that majority a swing of 1.58% or a Tory lead over Labour of 5% would be enough.
A Tory landslide is now unlikely, a Tory majority still is
This tells you a lot:
"Johnson retains a clear lead over Corbyn as the person the public see as the most capable Prime Minister. 47% consider Johnson the most capable Prime Minister compared to 31% for Jeremy Corbyn."
The final one from Mori in 2017 was May 47 Corbyn 36, a lead of 11 which translates to a voting intention lead of around 4, not far off the final result.
This time it's 16, so it's around 9 which is close to the polling average lead of 10.
a) A Very British Coup forecasts that the Communist Labour leader will win a surprise victory against the Tory. JC=Harry Perkins, surely?
b) failing to deliver Brexit in March and again in October, was meant to be an "extinction level event" for the Conservatives
c) Putin seems to be backing Corbyn, and he really controls what happens in UK elections
d) on the other hand, Trump is backing Johnson and Brexit, and so only card-carrying KKK members could vote Conservative.
Hampshire North West a nailed on Lab gain, surely?
You heard it here first ...
The reality is none of us knows what will happen. What I do know is that historically the Mori leader positive favorability differential does a better job of predicting the final result than the polls do. Out of sample it predicted the vote share margin to within 1pp in both 2015 and 2017, when the polls were completely wrong. So, why do you think that this time it is the polls that will be right? I mean, you could be right, but what has changed?
FWIW, the YouGov MRP has St Albans, Richmond Park and Cheltenham going Con>LD, and North Norfolk and Eastbourne going LD>Con, so a net movement of precisely one seat in the Lib Dems' favour in that particular head-to-head.
Following the close result Connor lodged a petition against Gildernew alleging irregularities in the counting of the votes had affected the result. However the Court found that there were only three ballot papers which could not be accounted for, and even if they were all votes for Connor, Gildernew would have had a plurality of one. The election was therefore upheld
Not quite the same thing as winning it literally by one vote, but close.
Jezza articulated why I am a Socialist.
Bozo articulated jingoistic bollocks.
Sadly too many people will be taken in by the bollocks and the lying buffoon gets to stay in Number 10.
357.
Night all.