Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » The idea that Johnson is an electoral asset is not supported b

24

Comments

  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758

    Charles said:

    Lord help us. If you thought May had a piss-poor Cabinet, behold and weep.

    Next Foreign Secretary - Shadsy

    Jacob Rees-Mogg 3/1
    Geoffrey Cox 6/1
    Priti Patel 7/1
    Penny Mordaunt 8/1
    Rory Stewart 8/1
    Michael Gove 10/1
    Sajid Javid 12/1
    David Davis 16/1
    Michael Fallon 16/1
    Dominic Raab 16/1
    Emily Thornberry 16/1

    Without commenting on FS specifically but Cox, Mordaunt, Stewart, Gove, Javid and Fallon would all be credible cabinet ministers
    Agree. And Patel was in May's cabinet, though admittedly she's taken some tumbles.
    Her behaviour in Cabinet ruled out a second chance
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 21,298
    Just what would it take for Watson to feel bold enough to either launch a coup or lead a breakaway?
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 63,133

    Just what would it take for Watson to feel bold enough to either launch a coup or lead a breakaway?

    It is astonishing how supine Tom Watson and others are.
  • TheJezziahTheJezziah Posts: 3,840
    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 22,131
    geoffw said:

    ... I, as a demiurge...

    I had to look it up... :)

  • TheJezziahTheJezziah Posts: 3,840
    edited July 2019

    Just what would it take for Watson to feel bold enough to either launch a coup or lead a breakaway?

    He knows he can do more damage on the inside, a break away of the Labour right will be about as successful as the last one. Another coup attempt will be about as successful as the last one.

    Edit: not that there can't be attempts to shame him into resigning but there is an obvious flaw in that plan...
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    I can't believe you are weaponising Jennie's cancer treatment. Pretty despicable to be honest. You should be ashamed.
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 63,133

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    No

    McCluskey is the disgrace and to ordinary voters his foul mouthed rant is another nail in the Corbyn project

    You are so blind you do not see the damage this is doing to a once proud labour party
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 63,133
    edited July 2019

    Just what would it take for Watson to feel bold enough to either launch a coup or lead a breakaway?

    He knows he can do more damage on the inside, a break away of the Labour right will be about as successful as the last one. Another coup attempt will be about as successful as the last one.
    Not if over 100 sane labour mps resign the whip and form their own group

    Uncompromisingly remain and anti semitism would be a very popular move
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,426
    edited July 2019

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    I can't believe you are weaponising Jennie's cancer treatment. Pretty despicable to be honest. You should be ashamed.
    You can't help but wonder how Thangam Debonnaire feels about the attack dogs being turned out to defend Jennie Formby while she has cancer, while Debonnaire had them set on her in effect for having it.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,426

    Just what would it take for Watson to feel bold enough to either launch a coup or lead a breakaway?

    He knows he can do more damage on the inside, a break away of the Labour right will be about as successful as the last one. Another coup attempt will be about as successful as the last one.
    Not if over 100 sane labour mps
    I think I've spotted a flaw in this plan...
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,679

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    Tom Watson is a disgrace then so is Corbyn, remember he sacked Thagnam Debbonaire when she battling cancer.

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/jeremy-corbyn-labour-shadow-cabinet-thangam-debbonaire-cancer-a7141341.html
  • JackWJackW Posts: 14,787

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    More red on red .... blood on the carpet and plenty of it.

    What could possibly be go wrong ?
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 63,133
    ydoethur said:

    Just what would it take for Watson to feel bold enough to either launch a coup or lead a breakaway?

    He knows he can do more damage on the inside, a break away of the Labour right will be about as successful as the last one. Another coup attempt will be about as successful as the last one.
    Not if over 100 sane labour mps
    I think I've spotted a flaw in this plan...
    Yes I know but we can only live in hope
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468
    edited July 2019
    @TheScreamingEagles She's a filthy Blairite Agent of Israel Tory so it doesn't count.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,426

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    Tom Watson is a disgrace then so is Corbyn, remember he sacked Thagnam Debbonaire when she battling cancer.

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/jeremy-corbyn-labour-shadow-cabinet-thangam-debbonaire-cancer-a7141341.html
    Watson and Corbyn both disgraces?

    Hard to argue with that analysis, tbf.

    Can we add McCluskey to that list as well, even though it's quite sweet to see he's standing up for one of the few women willing to sleep with him.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 49,869

    HYUFD said:

    London as a whole is now firmly anti Tory and firmly Remain and anti Brexit

    The legacy of Boris?
    Only insofar as Brexif is partly to blame alongside demographics (age and ethnicity) and the housing market.

    Brexif was a typo but strangely apposite
  • TheJezziahTheJezziah Posts: 3,840

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    I can't believe you are weaponising Jennie's cancer treatment. Pretty despicable to be honest. You should be ashamed.
    I can't believe your sticking up for Tom, it's quite telling that if an MP is pregnant or a woman or one of a variety of other things thatsome think can be used as sticks against Corbyn it's the end of the world if one person wants to vonc them.

    Watson plays political games to drag Frombys name through the media despite her making time to answer any questions he had previously but he stayed quiet and this whilst she's having chemotherapy and people are four square behind him. Fucking hypocrites, tbh I assumed it was usually cynical bs anyway.

    It's going to make it all the more weaker next time the cynical attack is tried.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    JackW said:

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    More red on red .... blood on the carpet and plenty of it.

    What could possibly be go wrong ?
    Don’t tell them Pike it’s all going according to plan
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,426
    edited July 2019
    JackW said:

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    More red on red .... blood on the carpet and plenty of it.

    What could possibly be go wrong ?
    The people's carpet is deepest red
    It took on all our martyred dead
    And ere their bodies grew stiff and cold
    We branded them traitors to the movement and posthumously called them fucking disgraces before expelling them.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    I can't believe you are weaponising Jennie's cancer treatment. Pretty despicable to be honest. You should be ashamed.
    I can't believe your sticking up for Tom, it's quite telling that if an MP is pregnant or a woman or one of a variety of other things thatsome think can be used as sticks against Corbyn it's the end of the world if one person wants to vonc them.

    Watson plays political games to drag Frombys name through the media despite her making time to answer any questions he had previously but he stayed quiet and this whilst she's having chemotherapy and people are four square behind him. Fucking hypocrites, tbh I assumed it was usually cynical bs anyway.

    It's going to make it all the more weaker next time the cynical attack is tried.
    That's a whole lot of waffle to try and justify weaponising Jennie's cancer treatment.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340

    FPT


    If there's one thing that distinguishes the Leave campaign then and now, it's their stoic, stiff upper lipped reluctance to whine about project fear, government bullying and media bias. Most admirable.

    The difference between Leaves and Scots is that we dismissed Project Fear. You [Scots collectively] fell for it.

    Both sets of Project Fear were IMHO utter garbage, both sets of government propaganda [on both sides in the Scottish case] were pretty garbage and media bias cuts both ways and is standard. But only one side let Project Fear win. Shame on them.
    Why should anyone be ashamed for any way they voted? What a ridiculous statement.
    The whole Remainer campaign both before and after the 2016 vote has been based on trying to tell Leave voters they should be ashamed of how they voted. See the endless posts from Mr Meeks as example.
    Well, yes. I'm sure he's mystified as to why more people haven't flocked to such a charming message.
    In case you hadn’t noticed, the polls consistently show that more people now believe the decision to Leave was a mistake. The death cult have got more extreme in response as they seek to drag the country out of the EU on hostile terms against its better judgement,
    On the contrary, what has been shown is that in the face of a chicken licken/Jacob Marley/Scream by Munch meltdown by much of our political class about the HUGE DIFFICULTIES AND INEVITABLE CHAOS AND DOOM of leaving an organisation that does not so much as keep the streets swept, there has been embarrassingly little movement in polling.

    Furthermore, the emphasis being so loaded on to the doom of leaving, rather than the benefits of staying (chortle), means that unless Leave is a disaster on the mythical scale that has been promised, any advantage for remain that may be have been gained utterly vanishes when we leave and life on earth survives.

    As, subconsciously or consciously, remain campaigners realise this, the stories have to get more and more outlandish and doom-laden for fear that we leave. The whole thing is an undedifying mess. And then the same people complain about the lack of respect for politics...
    It is normal on the passing of new policies for them to become more popular. Brexit exceptionally has bucked that trend. Presumably because your brand of rancid insular xenophobia has topped out its maximum support.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,679
    On topic, this was the outline of a thread I was going to do tomorrow.

    https://twitter.com/TSEofPB/status/1150120747135885313
  • TheJezziahTheJezziah Posts: 3,840

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    Tom Watson is a disgrace then so is Corbyn, remember he sacked Thagnam Debbonaire when she battling cancer.

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/jeremy-corbyn-labour-shadow-cabinet-thangam-debbonaire-cancer-a7141341.html
    Thank you icouldnt remember her name or the spelling anyway....

    Let's see the condemnation from the people on here taking Tom Watsons side now?

    Ohhh wait that's different... Jennie is left wing so the wrong kind of cancer sufferer!
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468
    edited July 2019
    Genuine question: is Jennie Formby currently in post or is she taking a break for her treatment?

    If she's still working, why shouldn't she be responsible for what happens within the Labour Party considering that is her job? Her illness does not give her a free pass for everything.

    That is very different to Corbynistas threatening to sack a pregnant MP for no reason at all.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 49,869
    Foxy said:

    On Boris winning London in 2008, not only was it a time that the Tories were point well, but it was also at the height of Cameron's detoxification.

    Boris won London as a socially liberal, pro-business, pro-immigration internationaist, the very opposite of the f**k business nativism that he now espouses. He wouldn't come close to winning now, and it is quite possible that he will lose his own seat.

    In 2012 Bozo was almost a safe pair of hands up against Ken well into his loopy period. I was prepared to give him my second pref to stop Ken. Today I would give almost anyone a first pref if if would stop the Bozo.
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758

    Just what would it take for Watson to feel bold enough to either launch a coup or lead a breakaway?

    It is astonishing how supine Tom Watson and others are.
    He believes - probably rightly - that the brand has immense value

    He also has one chance at a challenge. If he fails he loses the deputy leadership - which is probably the key position of power the moderates have
  • TheJezziahTheJezziah Posts: 3,840

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    I can't believe you are weaponising Jennie's cancer treatment. Pretty despicable to be honest. You should be ashamed.
    I can't believe your sticking up for Tom, it's quite telling that if an MP is pregnant or a woman or one of a variety of other things thatsome think can be used as sticks against Corbyn it's the end of the world if one person wants to vonc them.

    Watson plays political games to drag Frombys name through the media despite her making time to answer any questions he had previously but he stayed quiet and this whilst she's having chemotherapy and people are four square behind him. Fucking hypocrites, tbh I assumed it was usually cynical bs anyway.

    It's going to make it all the more weaker next time the cynical attack is tried.
    That's a whole lot of waffle to try and justify weaponising Jennie's cancer treatment.
    That's an interesting way of you saying you have no counter argument :smile:
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    edited July 2019
    O/T

    It now says that tickets are available for the cricket final on the official ICC website. Until now it had said sold out. Maybe people with tickets were trying to sell them at inflated prices on third party websites but couldn't find many takers.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 49,869

    On topic, this was the outline of a thread I was going to do tomorrow.

    https://twitter.com/TSEofPB/status/1150120747135885313

    But it's a cheap point down at HY's level. Hardly anyone here needs it explaining.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,426

    Genuine question: is Jennie Formby currently in post or is she taking a break for her treatment?

    If she's still working, why shouldn't she be responsible for what happens within the Labour Party considering that is her job? Her illness does not give her a free pass for everything.

    That is very different to Corbynistas threatening to sack a pregnant MP for no reason at all.

    The situation appears to be that she is on sick leave, but came back to deal with the fallout from Panorama. In the meanwhile her duties are being taken over by Karie Murphy and Laura Murray.

    However, if I understand employment law correctly, breaching her sick leave in that way means she is no longer entitled to take it and should therefore be back in post. I wonder if Labour have considered that.

    (Any lawyer who knows differently please correct me if I'm wrong because I do need to know for other reasons.)
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    Tom Watson is a disgrace then so is Corbyn, remember he sacked Thagnam Debbonaire when she battling cancer.

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/jeremy-corbyn-labour-shadow-cabinet-thangam-debbonaire-cancer-a7141341.html
    Someone’s health shouldn’t be a free pass.

    It may be sh1tty on a personal level but it’s not a free pass
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468
    ydoethur said:

    Genuine question: is Jennie Formby currently in post or is she taking a break for her treatment?

    If she's still working, why shouldn't she be responsible for what happens within the Labour Party considering that is her job? Her illness does not give her a free pass for everything.

    That is very different to Corbynistas threatening to sack a pregnant MP for no reason at all.

    The situation appears to be that she is on sick leave, but came back to deal with the fallout from Panorama. In the meanwhile her duties are being taken over by Karie Murphy and Laura Murray.

    However, if I understand employment law correctly, breaching her sick leave in that way means she is no longer entitled to take it and should therefore be back in post. I wonder if Labour have considered that.

    (Any lawyer who knows differently please correct me if I'm wrong because I do need to know for other reasons.)
    Thanks. So what exactly has Tom Watson done to slight her? @TheJezziah care to enlighten me?
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 5,842
    edited July 2019
    There are thousands of people who are living with cancer, living with the consequences of cancer and living through their cancer treatment - all whilst continuing to work to the best of their abilities under very difficult circumstances.

    No-one should be attacked because they have cancer. But also no-one should automatically be exempt from legitimate criticism of their work performance (before the treatment started) because of their diagnosis.

    The special pleading that is going on is patronising at best towards those living with cancer and at worst deeply distasteful by using a serious medical condition to deflect attention from what is a very serious situation within the Labour Party.

    I wish Jennie Formby all the very best with her ongoing battle to beat cancer. I never want to see anyone suffer from this most pernicious of conditions. People living with cancer should be treated with compassion and respect.

    But I do not believe that she is automatically immune from criticism for her actions and the actions of those working under her.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,426

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    I can't believe you are weaponising Jennie's cancer treatment. Pretty despicable to be honest. You should be ashamed.
    I can't believe your sticking up for Tom, it's quite telling that if an MP is pregnant or a woman or one of a variety of other things thatsome think can be used as sticks against Corbyn it's the end of the world if one person wants to vonc them.

    Watson plays political games to drag Frombys name through the media despite her making time to answer any questions he had previously but he stayed quiet and this whilst she's having chemotherapy and people are four square behind him. Fucking hypocrites, tbh I assumed it was usually cynical bs anyway.

    It's going to make it all the more weaker next time the cynical attack is tried.
    That's a whole lot of waffle to try and justify weaponising Jennie's cancer treatment.
    That's an interesting way of you saying you have no counter argument :smile:
    What argument is there in your post that needs countering?
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483

    Genuine question: is Jennie Formby currently in post or is she taking a break for her treatment?

    If she's still working, why shouldn't she be responsible for what happens within the Labour Party considering that is her job? Her illness does not give her a free pass for everything.

    That is very different to Corbynistas threatening to sack a pregnant MP for no reason at all.

    I really think it’s time we left ‘the two main parties’ to their internal self destruct mode. They don’t need our help on the way they are quite capable of doing it on their own.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,426

    ydoethur said:

    Genuine question: is Jennie Formby currently in post or is she taking a break for her treatment?

    If she's still working, why shouldn't she be responsible for what happens within the Labour Party considering that is her job? Her illness does not give her a free pass for everything.

    That is very different to Corbynistas threatening to sack a pregnant MP for no reason at all.

    The situation appears to be that she is on sick leave, but came back to deal with the fallout from Panorama. In the meanwhile her duties are being taken over by Karie Murphy and Laura Murray.

    However, if I understand employment law correctly, breaching her sick leave in that way means she is no longer entitled to take it and should therefore be back in post. I wonder if Labour have considered that.

    (Any lawyer who knows differently please correct me if I'm wrong because I do need to know for other reasons.)
    Thanks. So what exactly has Tom Watson done to slight her? @TheJezziah care to enlighten me?
    https://www.politicshome.com/news/uk/political-parties/labour-party/tom-watson/news/105243/labour-civil-war-erupts-tom-watson
  • TheJezziahTheJezziah Posts: 3,840

    Genuine question: is Jennie Formby currently in post or is she taking a break for her treatment?

    If she's still working, why shouldn't she be responsible for what happens within the Labour Party considering that is her job? Her illness does not give her a free pass for everything.

    That is very different to Corbynistas threatening to sack a pregnant MP for no reason at all.

    Interesting plural there, once again need to check your facts. The story was about a single person who wanted a vonc who we can't even be sure knew she was pregnant.

    Tom knows Jennie is having chemotherapy, she came back to an NEC meeting whilst off to answer questions. Tom saw this as his chance to drag her name through the mud, nobody is saying she cannot be criticised.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 49,869
    Charles said:

    Just what would it take for Watson to feel bold enough to either launch a coup or lead a breakaway?

    It is astonishing how supine Tom Watson and others are.
    He believes - probably rightly - that the brand has immense value

    He also has one chance at a challenge. If he fails he loses the deputy leadership - which is probably the key position of power the moderates have
    The parched corpses of TIG/CUK lie as a warning to anyone thinking of straying off the path. Now only the LDs offer even a halfway viable future and there are relatively few Lab MPs who could make a success of that jump.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468
    edited July 2019
    It does appear that Tom should have directed his letter towards Karie Murphy and/or Laura Murray in lieu of Jennie Thormby being on sick leave.

    However if she still has significant day-to-day involvement with the issue, despite her sick leave, it is reasonable for Tom to direct his criticism towards her, despite her illness.

    The fact she has cancer does also not invalidate Tom's criticisms.
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758

    On topic, this was the outline of a thread I was going to do tomorrow.

    https://twitter.com/TSEofPB/status/1150120747135885313

    That’s misleading

    Virginia B held the seat from its creation until 2005.

    The typical majority was c 15k

    In 1997 it was 2,500 and 861 in 2001

    So you are measuring Hunt’s performance from the historical low point and a clear anomaly
  • JohnOJohnO Posts: 4,291
    edited July 2019
    And who can or should forget or forgive the vile smears of Watson on a dying Leon Brittan

  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468
    edited July 2019

    nobody is saying she cannot be criticised.

    I mean you are as any sort of criticism is ignored and the criticiser personally attacked in response.
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 5,842
    JohnO said:

    And who can or should forget or forgive the vile smears of Watson on a dying Leon Brittan

    Indeed - his self-appointed role as paedo-finder general is hardly a career highlight for him.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,679
    JohnO said:

    And who can or should forget or forgive the vile smears of Watson on a dying Leon Brittan

    Indeed.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,426
    I think the real issue with Formby is not whether she's ill, because she is, or that she's incompetent, because she's clearly that too. Both are facts and neither are going anywhere, although I do hope that she recovers from her cancer which isn't funny for her or her daughter.

    The real issue is she was appointed in a blatant act of cronyism despite being manifestly unsuited to the role to put more power in the hands of McCluskey. And that would appear to be why he's going up the wall now - he sees his control of the Party machine through her, Murphy and Corbyn slipping away.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 51,884

    On topic, this was the outline of a thread I was going to do tomorrow.

    https://twitter.com/TSEofPB/status/1150120747135885313

    It's Surrey, not Surry!
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    On topic, this was the outline of a thread I was going to do tomorrow.

    https://twitter.com/TSEofPB/status/1150120747135885313

    Misleading figures since in SW Surrey in recent years the opposition vote has been heavily split with the National Health Action Party candidate.

    You can play numbers other ways. Regrettably Uxbridge and South Ruislip has no history before 2010 but in 2010 for comparison the vote share for the Tories was:

    2010 Uxbridge and South Ruislip: 48.3%
    2010 SW Surrey: 58.7%

    Fast forward to 2017
    2017 Uxbridge and South Ruislip: 50.8%
    2017 SW Surrey: 55.7%

    Net change:
    Uxbridge and South Ruislip: Conservatives have GAINED 2.5%
    SW Surrey: Conservatives have LOST 3.0%

    Boris has done in like-for-like timeframe 5.5% BETTER than Hunt.
  • OllyTOllyT Posts: 5,006
    edited July 2019

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    I can't believe you are weaponising Jennie's cancer treatment. Pretty despicable to be honest. You should be ashamed.
    I can't believe your sticking up for Tom, it's quite telling that if an MP is pregnant or a woman or one of a variety of other things thatsome think can be used as sticks against Corbyn it's the end of the world if one person wants to vonc them.

    Watson plays political games to drag Frombys name through the media despite her making time to answer any questions he had previously but he stayed quiet and this whilst she's having chemotherapy and people are four square behind him. Fucking hypocrites, tbh I assumed it was usually cynical bs anyway.

    It's going to make it all the more weaker next time the cynical attack is tried.
    So you think the Gen Sec of the Labour Party should be immune from any criticism while she is undergoing chemo? She didn't seem to have showed much concern for the health of other Labour Party employees.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468
    edited July 2019
    I mean they will obviously lose. They are not only liars but also agents of Israel, right @TheJezziah and @justin124?
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    ydoethur said:

    Genuine question: is Jennie Formby currently in post or is she taking a break for her treatment?

    If she's still working, why shouldn't she be responsible for what happens within the Labour Party considering that is her job? Her illness does not give her a free pass for everything.

    That is very different to Corbynistas threatening to sack a pregnant MP for no reason at all.

    The situation appears to be that she is on sick leave, but came back to deal with the fallout from Panorama. In the meanwhile her duties are being taken over by Karie Murphy and Laura Murray.

    However, if I understand employment law correctly, breaching her sick leave in that way means she is no longer entitled to take it and should therefore be back in post. I wonder if Labour have considered that.

    (Any lawyer who knows differently please correct me if I'm wrong because I do need to know for other reasons.)
    IANAL but my understand of employment law is different.

    I believe that you can have continuity of sick leave even if you return to work then return to being off sick again. In fact for example for things like SSP if you are off sick and return to work for a few days then swiftly return to being off then it is specifically considered one continuous illness and not two separate illnesses.
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    O/T

    Question: why do you see more military personnel at the Wimbledon tennis championships than practically any other event in the UK?
  • geoffwgeoffw Posts: 8,722
    AndyJS said:

    O/T

    Question: why do you see more military personnel at the Wimbledon tennis championships than practically any other event in the UK?

    Is this from a Christmas cracker?
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,426
    AndyJS said:

    O/T

    Question: why do you see more military personnel at the Wimbledon tennis championships than practically any other event in the UK?

    Because it's their favourite sporting event?

    (I would have thought there were more at Royal Ascot.)
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,679
    AndyJS said:

    O/T

    Question: why do you see more military personnel at the Wimbledon tennis championships than practically any other event in the UK?

    A few things that might answer your query

    Although the Armed Forces personnel have to use part of their allocated leave to steward at Wimbledon, they appreciate the opportunity to serve on such hallowed grounds.

    https://www.gov.uk/government/news/wimbledon-fans-show-pride-in-armed-forces

    https://www.wimbledondebentureholders.com/articles/wimbledon-armed-forces-history/
  • solarflaresolarflare Posts: 3,710
    nichomar said:

    Genuine question: is Jennie Formby currently in post or is she taking a break for her treatment?

    If she's still working, why shouldn't she be responsible for what happens within the Labour Party considering that is her job? Her illness does not give her a free pass for everything.

    That is very different to Corbynistas threatening to sack a pregnant MP for no reason at all.

    I really think it’s time we left ‘the two main parties’ to their internal self destruct mode. They don’t need our help on the way they are quite capable of doing it on their own.
    If we think the polling at the moment is funny a.k.a. complicated to interpret, think what it'd be like if there was full blown Tory and/or Labour splits...
  • glwglw Posts: 9,912
    Charles said:

    Tom Watson you are a fucking disgrace...

    Well done Len, someone had to say it. We have had a leadership contest since 2015 time we had a deputy one as well. Tom can stand again if he thinks the members back him.

    Tom Watson is a disgrace then so is Corbyn, remember he sacked Thagnam Debbonaire when she battling cancer.

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/jeremy-corbyn-labour-shadow-cabinet-thangam-debbonaire-cancer-a7141341.html
    Someone’s health shouldn’t be a free pass.

    It may be sh1tty on a personal level but it’s not a free pass
    I could not agree more. Most people with cancer simply have to keep on doing all the stuff they have to do, which includes taking responsiblity for current and previous actions.
  • Scrapheap_as_wasScrapheap_as_was Posts: 10,069
    He's a buffoon.... End of.
  • stodgestodge Posts: 13,900
    Evening all :)

    As an observation, Boris's record in Henley is worth a look. It is a seat that has voted Conservative or Unionist at every election since 1910 and only once (1906) have the Liberals won it.

    That was a decent election - 1906 - perhaps 2019 could be like it.

    Anyway. Heseltine won in 1997 polling 46.4% of the vote and Johnson took over in 2001 and won 46.1% of the vote with a small swing to the LDs and a lower turnout bringing the majority down to 8,500.

    In 2005, Johnson took the Conservative vote share back to 53.5% and his majority back to just shy of 13,000 which in the context of the election was a good result - the LDs lost vote share so it was a decent 4.25% swing to the Conservatives.

    At the 2008 by-election John Howell got 57% of the vote and that's hardly changed since - up to 59% in 2017. That's far less dramatic then many other seats. On the current 15% swing from Conservative to LD the majority would be cut from 22,000 and change to 8,500. The LDs have only polled above 30% once since the war and that was in February 1974 (29% in 1983). I could imagine a 35% vote share in the current climate.
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,572
    Oh dear. I am no Boris fan at all but it is shame that when various people have already pointed out the error in your interpretation, you persist with a misleading claim.
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 5,842
    Scott_P said:
    Now who to believe? A sincere sounding whistleblower or an anonymous Labour spinner spouting the same discredited lines as always?

    Not exactly a hard one to call....

  • RobDRobD Posts: 59,936

    He's a buffoon.... End of.

    Unclear who you are talking about. There are so many these days...
  • glwglw Posts: 9,912
    Scott_P said:
    I'm going to look forward to Labour MPs being asked to quantify the tolerable level of anti-Semitism.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468
    Said a zero tolerance approach to antisemitism is"ridiculous"
    F*ck me.
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    IanB2 said:

    Charles said:

    Just what would it take for Watson to feel bold enough to either launch a coup or lead a breakaway?

    It is astonishing how supine Tom Watson and others are.
    He believes - probably rightly - that the brand has immense value

    He also has one chance at a challenge. If he fails he loses the deputy leadership - which is probably the key position of power the moderates have
    The parched corpses of TIG/CUK lie as a warning to anyone thinking of straying off the path. Now only the LDs offer even a halfway viable future and there are relatively few Lab MPs who could make a success of that jump.
    Whose corpses?
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 5,842
    Just found out that Tim Dexter is a friend of a friend - and has been agonising for months over this. There is no question in my mind as to his sincerity or credibility
  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 28,490

    FPT


    If there's one thing that distinguishes the Leave campaign then and now, it's their stoic, stiff upper lipped reluctance to whine about project fear, government bullying and media bias. Most admirable.

    The difference between Leaves and Scots is that we dismissed Project Fear. You [Scots collectively] fell for it.

    Both sets of Project Fear were IMHO utter garbage, both sets of government propaganda [on both sides in the Scottish case] were pretty garbage and media bias cuts both ways and is standard. But only one side let Project Fear win. Shame on them.
    Why should anyone be ashamed for any way they voted? What a ridiculous statement.
    The whole Remainer campaign both before and after the 2016 vote has been based on trying to tell Leave voters they should be ashamed of how they voted. See the endless posts from Mr Meeks as example.
    Well, yes. I'm sure he's mystified as to why more people haven't flocked to such a charming message.
    In case you hadn’t noticed, the polls consistently show that more people now believe the decision to Leave was a mistake. The death cult have got more extreme in response as they seek to drag the country out of the EU on hostile terms against its better judgement,
    On the contrary, what has been shown is that in the face of a chicken licken/Jacob Marley/Scream by Munch meltdown by much of our political class about the HUGE DIFFICULTIES AND INEVITABLE CHAOS AND DOOM of leaving an organisation that does not so much as keep the streets swept, there has been embarrassingly little movement in polling.

    Furthermore, the emphasis being so loaded on to the doom of leaving, rather than the benefits of staying (chortle), means that unless Leave is a disaster on the mythical scale that has been promised, any advantage for remain that may be have been gained utterly vanishes when we leave and life on earth survives.

    As, subconsciously or consciously, remain campaigners realise this, the stories have to get more and more outlandish and doom-laden for fear that we leave. The whole thing is an undedifying mess. And then the same people complain about the lack of respect for politics...
    It is normal on the passing of new policies for them to become more popular. Brexit exceptionally has bucked that trend. Presumably because your brand of rancid insular xenophobia has topped out its maximum support.
    Yes. And when this one passes, the same thing will happen.
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    A bar chart worthy of a Lib Dem

    Shame on you Mike for knowingly misleading your twitter followers
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,679

    Oh dear. I am no Boris fan at all but it is shame that when various people have already pointed out the error in your interpretation, you persist with a misleading claim.
    Yet you were happy to campaign for but get outraged by this bar chart.


  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468
    The worst thing about this whole Labour anti-semitism saga is that people, on the whole, just don’t care.

    As someone of Jewish heritage myself it makes me very depressed.
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 5,842
    Scott_P said:
    It would get headlines for a few hours, be on the front page for a few hours more - but after that?

    Sure, if Corbyn became PM, he would find it very hard to pass legislation - but...
  • RochdalePioneersRochdalePioneers Posts: 28,903

    The worst thing about this whole Labour anti-semitism saga is that people, on the whole, just don’t care.

    As someone of Jewish heritage myself it makes me very depressed.

    No its far far worse than that. Cretinous scum do care, they care because the truth about their sick cancer death cult has come out. Hence their screaming hypocrisy attacking whistle blowers "who keep us safe" and libelling the former party staffers.

    Soon we will have two Labour Parties represented in Parliament as in the past we have had two Liberal Parties. I expect two Tory Parties shortly afterwards when PM Bozza demands no deal in "shock" at the EU refusing to renegotiate
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,208
    I am sick of Johnson already and he hasn't been elected yet.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,679
    Here's another stat for you.

    If Boris Johnson wins with the Tory leadership with the majority that YouGov are predicting he'll still receive fewer votes than Owen Smith received when he lost the Labour leadership contest in 2016.

    Heck it is likely that the Owen Smith received more votes (193,229) than there are Tory members.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 51,884

    Oh dear. I am no Boris fan at all but it is shame that when various people have already pointed out the error in your interpretation, you persist with a misleading claim.
    Yet you were happy to campaign for but get outraged by this bar chart.


    The best bar charts ever:

    https://twitter.com/Sunil_P2/status/876894066478329857
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 51,884

    Here's another stat for you.

    If Boris Johnson wins with the Tory leadership with the majority that YouGov are predicting he'll still receive fewer votes than Owen Smith received when he lost the Labour leadership contest in 2016.

    Heck it is likely that the Owen Smith received more votes (193,229) than there are Tory members.

    Sorry - Owen who?

    :lol:
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,468

    The worst thing about this whole Labour anti-semitism saga is that people, on the whole, just don’t care.

    As someone of Jewish heritage myself it makes me very depressed.

    No its far far worse than that. Cretinous scum do care, they care because the truth about their sick cancer death cult has come out. Hence their screaming hypocrisy attacking whistle blowers "who keep us safe" and libelling the former party staffers.

    Soon we will have two Labour Parties represented in Parliament as in the past we have had two Liberal Parties. I expect two Tory Parties shortly afterwards when PM Bozza demands no deal in "shock" at the EU refusing to renegotiate
    Except we wont. Corbynistas will cling onto power. Labour MPs will not do anything. The general public will become numb (this has already happened) and then eventually he will be voted into Downing Street.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340

    Oh dear. I am no Boris fan at all but it is shame that when various people have already pointed out the error in your interpretation, you persist with a misleading claim.
    Yet you were happy to campaign for but get outraged by this bar chart.


    That’s a slide deck that’s now more referred to by Remainers than Leavers. Curious that.
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    If you visit St John's Wood tube station tomorrow, the "mind the gap" announcements will be being made by Jonathan Agnew.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/48975312
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 51,884
    Charles said:

    A bar chart worthy of a Lib Dem

    Shame on you Mike for knowingly misleading your twitter followers
    Which are the selection years in question?
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,426

    The worst thing about this whole Labour anti-semitism saga is that people, on the whole, just don’t care.

    As someone of Jewish heritage myself it makes me very depressed.

    No its far far worse than that. Cretinous scum do care, they care because the truth about their sick cancer death cult has come out. Hence their screaming hypocrisy attacking whistle blowers "who keep us safe" and libelling the former party staffers.

    Soon we will have two Labour Parties represented in Parliament as in the past we have had two Liberal Parties. I expect two Tory Parties shortly afterwards when PM Bozza demands no deal in "shock" at the EU refusing to renegotiate
    From 1931-35 there were actually three Liberal parties - the official party led by Samuel, the National Liberals led by Simon, and the Lloyd George group of independent Liberals.
  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 28,490
    FF43 said:

    I am sick of Johnson already and he hasn't been elected yet.

    That's probably because nobody on PB will shut up about him.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,426
    AndyJS said:

    If you visit St John's Wood tube station tomorrow, the "mind the gap" announcements will be being made by Jonathan Agnew.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/48975312

    Getting ready for his commentary in Jonny Bairstow's dismissal, bowled through the gate by Trent Boult?
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 51,884
    AndyJS said:

    If you visit St John's Wood tube station tomorrow, the "mind the gap" announcements will be being made by Jonathan Agnew.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/48975312

    You can see St John's Wood station in this video by Soft Cell:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lbC4yxjydUc
  • RochdalePioneersRochdalePioneers Posts: 28,903

    The worst thing about this whole Labour anti-semitism saga is that people, on the whole, just don’t care.

    As someone of Jewish heritage myself it makes me very depressed.

    No its far far worse than that. Cretinous scum do care, they care because the truth about their sick cancer death cult has come out. Hence their screaming hypocrisy attacking whistle blowers "who keep us safe" and libelling the former party staffers.

    Soon we will have two Labour Parties represented in Parliament as in the past we have had two Liberal Parties. I expect two Tory Parties shortly afterwards when PM Bozza demands no deal in "shock" at the EU refusing to renegotiate
    Except we wont. Corbynistas will cling onto power. Labour MPs will not do anything. The general public will become numb (this has already happened) and then eventually he will be voted into Downing Street.
    He won't. He is Labour voter kyptonite. Only the death cultists still think He is Perfect. Everyone with a heart and a brain can see what a godawful group of people he represents. And he has pissed off leave and remain voters in equal measure. Labour would need a coalition deal. And can't do compromise to have a coalition with their own deputy leader.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    AndyJS said:

    If you visit St John's Wood tube station tomorrow, the "mind the gap" announcements will be being made by Jonathan Agnew.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/48975312

    St John’s Wood used to be the only tube station that had none of the letters of the word MACKEREL in it. Perhaps Sunil could confirm if that is still true.
This discussion has been closed.