Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Bad for the Tories – good for the LDs: This week’s Local By-El

13

Comments

  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,068

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Brown and Blair
    That was just two people. These are 318 who hate each other.
  • Sandpit said:

    Sandpit said:

    How can you be suspended for something that’s reported as having been referred to the police, yet not be aware of the nature of the allegation?
    Complaint is raised to the Tory party.

    Tory Party pass it on to the police.

    Police yet to contact Mr Elphicke.
    So someone from the party calls him up, tells him he’s been suspended and to expect a knock on the door from Plod - but won’t say why?
    Yup, is possible.

    Is the Chief Whip’s first full day on the job.
    Yes, top decision to move the Chief Whip in the middle of a personnel crisis.
    Mrs May’s not very good is she ?
    Agreed but maybe she is the one person who can rise above the fray. Who else is there
    I can think of six others who could do a better job than her.
    Realistically who
    Gove, Hunt, Uncork the Gauke, Cameron, Osborne, and Davidson.
    Well three of those are unrealistic though I would love to see Cameron and Davidson in the HOC
  • Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    This. Absolutely.
  • Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Brown and Blair
    That was just two people. These are 318 who hate each other.
    Now that is a bit of an exaggeration.
  • Sandpit said:

    Sandpit said:

    How can you be suspended for something that’s reported as having been referred to the police, yet not be aware of the nature of the allegation?
    Complaint is raised to the Tory party.

    Tory Party pass it on to the police.

    Police yet to contact Mr Elphicke.
    So someone from the party calls him up, tells him he’s been suspended and to expect a knock on the door from Plod - but won’t say why?
    Yup, is possible.

    Is the Chief Whip’s first full day on the job.
    Yes, top decision to move the Chief Whip in the middle of a personnel crisis.
    Mrs May’s not very good is she ?
    You might think that; I couldn't possibly comment.

    Actually, bollocks, I could. She's the second-worst Tory leader in my lifetime, though oddly, she's still the best party leader on offer today (hence the 40% polling for the Cons).
  • ChameleonChameleon Posts: 4,264
    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.
  • Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    *cough*172 MPs vote no confidence*cough*
  • Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Even the Rose Garden
  • Sandpit said:

    Sandpit said:

    How can you be suspended for something that’s reported as having been referred to the police, yet not be aware of the nature of the allegation?
    Complaint is raised to the Tory party.

    Tory Party pass it on to the police.

    Police yet to contact Mr Elphicke.
    So someone from the party calls him up, tells him he’s been suspended and to expect a knock on the door from Plod - but won’t say why?
    Yup, is possible.

    Is the Chief Whip’s first full day on the job.
    Yes, top decision to move the Chief Whip in the middle of a personnel crisis.
    Mrs May’s not very good is she ?
    Agreed but maybe she is the one person who can rise above the fray. Who else is there
    Chasing through that field of wheat is a killer....
    A cereal killer?
  • PongPong Posts: 4,693
    edited November 2017

    Sandpit said:

    Sandpit said:

    How can you be suspended for something that’s reported as having been referred to the police, yet not be aware of the nature of the allegation?
    Complaint is raised to the Tory party.

    Tory Party pass it on to the police.

    Police yet to contact Mr Elphicke.
    So someone from the party calls him up, tells him he’s been suspended and to expect a knock on the door from Plod - but won’t say why?
    Yup, is possible.

    Is the Chief Whip’s first full day on the job.
    Yes, top decision to move the Chief Whip in the middle of a personnel crisis.
    Mrs May’s not very good is she ?
    STRONG AND STABLE
  • Beverley_CBeverley_C Posts: 6,256
    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    :+1:
  • Beverley_CBeverley_C Posts: 6,256

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    image
  • Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
  • TykejohnnoTykejohnno Posts: 7,362

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    It was until the silly GE.
  • david_herdsondavid_herdson Posts: 17,656
    edited November 2017
    brendan16 said:

    Pulpstar said:

    On Elphicke, we have yet to hear what the allegations are - but at this point I'd say he has a fair claim for constructive dismissal should the timeline be as he has tweeted.
    Tipping off the press about an allegation before being notified of it yrself is either piss poor, or the whips want him gone quickly.

    He hasn't been dismissed from his job as an MP though - is there legal redress for having your party whip withdrawn?
    Only if its contrary to Party rules or process.

    If there has been a serious and reasonably credible (i.e. one which can't be dismissed out of hand) allegation, it's a fairly normal action.
  • ChameleonChameleon Posts: 4,264

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Even the Rose Garden
    For a moment that filled me with hope, it was my more-or-less perfect result. It is a shame that Clegg never managed to become PM.
  • Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    It was until the silly GE.
    The GE was awesome, it proved I was a visionary when it came to Mrs May.

    I warned ye all that she was a pound shop Gordon Brown.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,068

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    If a party is full of sex abusers, it really doesn't matter who voted which way.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,676
    edited November 2017
    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    And for so long we laughed at the what now seems to be the ever so quaint in-fighting between Blair and Brown.

    Like we used to call non-terrorist villains in NI - ordinary decent criminals..
  • ChameleonChameleon Posts: 4,264
    edited November 2017

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    And what would fill it? UKIP are a joke, the Greens are utterly mental and the Liberal Democrats are working hard to minimise the policy differences between them and Labour. If Clegg was LD leader then there would be the possibility for a landscape change.
  • Scott_P said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    *cough*172 MPs vote no confidence*cough*
    True, but Labour aren't in government..... yet.
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...
  • YorkcityYorkcity Posts: 4,382

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    They are united they all abstain together .
  • TykejohnnoTykejohnno Posts: 7,362

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    So what centre right party will replace them ?
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453

    True, but Labour aren't in government..... yet.

    They still hate each other though, which was the point
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 21,471
    Is it possible to turn politics off and on again or restore to a known good saved state.
  • Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    I was going to do a piece about Brexit being to the Tories what the General Strike was to the unions (I'm reading a book on the strike at the moment). Both were led by leaders whose hearts weren't in it and who knew they couldn't win, though I think the final outcomes will be sufficiently different to justify not writing it.
  • Chameleon said:

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    And what would fill it? UKIP are a joke, the Greens are utterly mental and the Liberal Democrats are working hard to minimise the policy differences between them and Labour.
    A new party, made up of the Yellow Bookers, One Nation Pro Business One Nation Tories, and the Blairites.

    Politics, like nature, abhors a vacuum, something will replace the Tory party if it fails.
  • Beverley_CBeverley_C Posts: 6,256

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    It was until the silly GE.
    The GE was awesome, it proved I was a visionary when it came to Mrs May.

    I warned ye all that she was a pound shop Gordon Brown.
    You might have over-stated her potential...
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 121,974

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    It was until the silly GE.
    The GE was awesome, it proved I was a visionary when it came to Mrs May.

    I warned ye all that she was a pound shop Gordon Brown.
    Except she won 13% more than Brown did and 60 more seats.
  • Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    If a party is full of sex abusers, it really doesn't matter who voted which way.
    A think we need some care here.

    None of the parties are full of sex abusers and there are many upstanding MP's in all parties who must be horrified and who have always treated women with the upmost of respect
  • Scott_P said:

    True, but Labour aren't in government..... yet.

    They still hate each other though, which was the point
    I think if there is a GE soon and Labour get in, there will be a lot of Labour MPs who suddenly discover a deep love for Corbyn.
  • anothernickanothernick Posts: 3,591
    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 121,974

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    The Liberals were of course replaced by a more leftwing party, Labour, which would mean the Tories would be replaced by a more rightwing party like UKIP (a la Canada 1993).

    Only possible if the Tories reverse Brexit or refuse to end free movement in order to stay in the single market.
  • ChameleonChameleon Posts: 4,264
    Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    If a party is full of sex abusers, it really doesn't matter who voted which way.
    There's evidence that this is not party political - it goes across all parties (although the Tories may to be using it to settle personal scores).
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,580
    Five years in advance, good organisation (yes I know O'Mara, but come on, he's going nowhere).
    Scott_P said:

    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...

    Not really sure of Peston's reasoning. Tory MPs would also have been furious if Elphicke was not suspended after allegations emerged, and then the press was full of 'Tories covered up allegations' stories like the ones thrown at Corbyn that he knew about Hopkins allegations and did nothing. The allegations are apparently serious, so needed a reaction, but that doesn't mean they are confident they are credible I'd have thought, just that they cannot be seen to ignore it, so call in the fuzz.

    Seems like No.10 would be condemned no matter what they did - tipping the press first seems the only thing TOry MPs can be legitimately mad about.
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    Jonathan said:

    Is it possible to turn politics off and on again or restore to a known good saved state.

    The last known good state was 1987. Due you wish to restore?

    Confirm/Cancel
  • Beverley_CBeverley_C Posts: 6,256
    Jonathan said:

    Is it possible to turn politics off and on again or restore to a known good saved state.

    It might be symbolic that the current trendy Repository software is called "Git" :D
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,188
    edited November 2017

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    So what centre right party will replace them ?
    The anti mass immigration rump of Kippers and Hard Brexiteers.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 121,974
    edited November 2017

    Chameleon said:

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    And what would fill it? UKIP are a joke, the Greens are utterly mental and the Liberal Democrats are working hard to minimise the policy differences between them and Labour.
    A new party, made up of the Yellow Bookers, One Nation Pro Business One Nation Tories, and the Blairites.

    Politics, like nature, abhors a vacuum, something will replace the Tory party if it fails.
    The Tory Party and Labour would both split in that case, with the centrist wings of both parties and the LDs uniting, perhaps led by Chuka Umunna or George Osborne and the right of the Tories being joined by UKIP, perhaps led by Jacob Rees Mogg and the left of Labour perhaps joined by the Greens still led by Jeremy Corbyn.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,580
    Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    If a party is full of sex abusers, it really doesn't matter who voted which way.
    That's a hell of an overreaction. Even if we assume every allegation on the infamous dossier is true, plenty of those were not even allegations of poor conduct. Add in some names not on the dossier for similar allegations. For some others the most extreme allegations will be something like sexist language - wrong, but not sex abuse - and at the worst we are talking a handful to a dozen people who have done bad things and some more who have displayed poor behaviour which can be atoned for. That's a party with a problem to sort out but 'full of sex abusers'? Come on.
  • YorkcityYorkcity Posts: 4,382

    Sean_F said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    If a party is full of sex abusers, it really doesn't matter who voted which way.
    A think we need some care here.

    None of the parties are full of sex abusers and there are many upstanding MP's in all parties who must be horrified and who have always treated women with the upmost of respect
    Agreed in parts it is turning into a modern day Salem , with no due process.
  • kle4 said:

    Five years in advance, good organisation (yes I know O'Mara, but come on, he's going nowhere).
    Scott_P said:

    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...

    Not really sure of Peston's reasoning. Tory MPs would also have been furious if Elphicke was not suspended after allegations emerged, and then the press was full of 'Tories covered up allegations' stories like the ones thrown at Corbyn that he knew about Hopkins allegations and did nothing. The allegations are apparently serious, so needed a reaction, but that doesn't mean they are confident they are credible I'd have thought, just that they cannot be seen to ignore it, so call in the fuzz.

    Seems like No.10 would be condemned no matter what they did - tipping the press first seems the only thing TOry MPs can be legitimately mad about.
    And Esther is deputy chief whip - she will be aware of the circumstances and no doubt endorsed the action
  • RobDRobD Posts: 59,732
    Scott_P said:

    Jonathan said:

    Is it possible to turn politics off and on again or restore to a known good saved state.

    The last known good state was 1987. Due you wish to restore?

    Confirm/Cancel
    Only five years to wait until the 92 election! *begins stockpiling popcorn*
  • foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    edited November 2017

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    The Phillipinos are excellent nurses, the problem is the visas.

    In further Brexit news:

    https://twitter.com/michaelsavage/status/926525725242527746
  • OchEyeOchEye Posts: 1,469
    HYUFD said:

    Chameleon said:

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    And what would fill it? UKIP are a joke, the Greens are utterly mental and the Liberal Democrats are working hard to minimise the policy differences between them and Labour.
    A new party, made up of the Yellow Bookers, One Nation Pro Business One Nation Tories, and the Blairites.

    Politics, like nature, abhors a vacuum, something will replace the Tory party if it fails.
    The Tory Party and Labour would both split in that case, with the centrist wings of both parties and the LDs uniting, perhaps led by Chuka Umunna or George Osborne and the right of the Tories being joined by UKIP, perhaps led by Jacob Rees Mogg and the left of Labour perhaps joined by the Greens still led by Jeremy Corbyn.
    We're being played. Suck it up?
  • Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    It was until the silly GE.
    The GE was awesome, it proved I was a visionary when it came to Mrs May.

    I warned ye all that she was a pound shop Gordon Brown.
    Gordon Brown had to step down after the 2010 election.
  • kle4 said:

    Five years in advance, good organisation (yes I know O'Mara, but come on, he's going nowhere).
    Scott_P said:

    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...

    Not really sure of Peston's reasoning. Tory MPs would also have been furious if Elphicke was not suspended after allegations emerged, and then the press was full of 'Tories covered up allegations' stories like the ones thrown at Corbyn that he knew about Hopkins allegations and did nothing. The allegations are apparently serious, so needed a reaction, but that doesn't mean they are confident they are credible I'd have thought, just that they cannot be seen to ignore it, so call in the fuzz.

    Seems like No.10 would be condemned no matter what they did - tipping the press first seems the only thing TOry MPs can be legitimately mad about.
    And Esther is deputy chief whip - she will be aware of the circumstances and no doubt endorsed the action
    Taking all that at face value, given we don't know the facts, informing the press before the bloke himself is a pretty shitty thing to do and indicative of an organisation that is on a downward spiral.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,580
    HYUFD said:

    Chameleon said:

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    And what would fill it? UKIP are a joke, the Greens are utterly mental and the Liberal Democrats are working hard to minimise the policy differences between them and Labour.
    A new party, made up of the Yellow Bookers, One Nation Pro Business One Nation Tories, and the Blairites.

    Politics, like nature, abhors a vacuum, something will replace the Tory party if it fails.
    The Tory Party and Labour would both split in that case, with the centrist wings of both parties and the LDs uniting, perhaps led by Chuka Umunna or George Osborne and the right of the Tories being joined by UKIP, perhaps led by Jacob Rees Mogg and the left of Labour perhaps joined by the Greens still led by Jeremy Corbyn.
    While I accept the point that nature abhors a vacuum and all that, most senior figures are so committed to a party brand even when it makes no sense, that I struggle to see while the opponent party would split even if one of the parties did - Chuka Umunna for instance would be pilloried by half his own supporters at least if he said 'I have more in common with a former Tory' and the same applies for plenty of Tories, I just don't see any party that is not collapsing in support splitting. Even when many feared Labour was on course for a total shellacking, there was no real suggestion they would split, not credibly.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 121,974
    OchEye said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chameleon said:

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    And what would fill it? UKIP are a joke, the Greens are utterly mental and the Liberal Democrats are working hard to minimise the policy differences between them and Labour.
    A new party, made up of the Yellow Bookers, One Nation Pro Business One Nation Tories, and the Blairites.

    Politics, like nature, abhors a vacuum, something will replace the Tory party if it fails.
    The Tory Party and Labour would both split in that case, with the centrist wings of both parties and the LDs uniting, perhaps led by Chuka Umunna or George Osborne and the right of the Tories being joined by UKIP, perhaps led by Jacob Rees Mogg and the left of Labour perhaps joined by the Greens still led by Jeremy Corbyn.
    We're being played. Suck it up?
    Well it would offer a clear choice
  • I've just found out that I'm blocked from Nicholas Soames' twitter account. Not sure what I've done to deserve that. So that's at least two MPs down: 648 to go.
  • TykejohnnoTykejohnno Posts: 7,362

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    So what centre right party will replace them ?
    The anti mass immigration rump of Kippers and Hard Brexiteers.
    Just imagine if we do get the betrayal of the EU referendum vote,you haven't seen nothing yet.
  • PendduPenddu Posts: 265
    This smells like the expenses scandal all over again. A large element of poor but not illegal behaviour mixed up with a few cretins who thought they were above the law.

    Time for a change.....but not a simple left right flip flop. Time to turn politics upside down....a la Macron!
  • RhubarbRhubarb Posts: 359
    Scott_P said:

    Jonathan said:

    Is it possible to turn politics off and on again or restore to a known good saved state.

    The last known good state was 1987. Due you wish to restore?

    Confirm/Cancel
    It'd be worth it just to kill twitter.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,580

    kle4 said:

    Five years in advance, good organisation (yes I know O'Mara, but come on, he's going nowhere).
    Scott_P said:

    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...

    Not really sure of Peston's reasoning. Tory MPs would also have been furious if Elphicke was not suspended after allegations emerged, and then the press was full of 'Tories covered up allegations' stories like the ones thrown at Corbyn that he knew about Hopkins allegations and did nothing. The allegations are apparently serious, so needed a reaction, but that doesn't mean they are confident they are credible I'd have thought, just that they cannot be seen to ignore it, so call in the fuzz.

    Seems like No.10 would be condemned no matter what they did - tipping the press first seems the only thing TOry MPs can be legitimately mad about.
    And Esther is deputy chief whip - she will be aware of the circumstances and no doubt endorsed the action
    Taking all that at face value, given we don't know the facts, informing the press before the bloke himself is a pretty shitty thing to do and indicative of an organisation that is on a downward spiral.
    It's indicative of a party focusing on press reaction first, the individual second. Crappy, but not necessarily saying anything more.
  • anothernickanothernick Posts: 3,591

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    The Phillipinos are excellent nurses, the problem is the visas.
    Indeed they are. And they generally do speak pretty good English. But it's worrying (if true) that qualification requirements are being bypassed.
  • kle4 said:

    Five years in advance, good organisation (yes I know O'Mara, but come on, he's going nowhere).
    Scott_P said:

    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...

    Not really sure of Peston's reasoning. Tory MPs would also have been furious if Elphicke was not suspended after allegations emerged, and then the press was full of 'Tories covered up allegations' stories like the ones thrown at Corbyn that he knew about Hopkins allegations and did nothing. The allegations are apparently serious, so needed a reaction, but that doesn't mean they are confident they are credible I'd have thought, just that they cannot be seen to ignore it, so call in the fuzz.

    Seems like No.10 would be condemned no matter what they did - tipping the press first seems the only thing TOry MPs can be legitimately mad about.
    And Esther is deputy chief whip - she will be aware of the circumstances and no doubt endorsed the action
    Taking all that at face value, given we don't know the facts, informing the press before the bloke himself is a pretty shitty thing to do and indicative of an organisation that is on a downward spiral.
    As has been said the danger is that any delay risks the problems Corbyn has had today over cover ups.

    Lets see what and if any charges are forthcoming

  • Damien Green, Charlie Elphicke, and Craig Mackinlay are all Kent MPs.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 121,974
    kle4 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chameleon said:

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    And what would fill it? UKIP are a joke, the Greens are utterly mental and the Liberal Democrats are working hard to minimise the policy differences between them and Labour.
    A new party, made up of the Yellow Bookers, One Nation Pro Business One Nation Tories, and the Blairites.

    Politics, like nature, abhors a vacuum, something will replace the Tory party if it fails.
    The Tory Party and Labour would both split in that case, with the centrist wings of both parties and the LDs uniting, perhaps led by Chuka Umunna or George Osborne and the right of the Tories being joined by UKIP, perhaps led by Jacob Rees Mogg and the left of Labour perhaps joined by the Greens still led by Jeremy Corbyn.
    While I accept the point that nature abhors a vacuum and all that, most senior figures are so committed to a party brand even when it makes no sense, that I struggle to see while the opponent party would split even if one of the parties did - Chuka Umunna for instance would be pilloried by half his own supporters at least if he said 'I have more in common with a former Tory' and the same applies for plenty of Tories, I just don't see any party that is not collapsing in support splitting. Even when many feared Labour was on course for a total shellacking, there was no real suggestion they would split, not credibly.
    It would take a Macron style new party of the centre most probably which was durable unlike the SDP.
  • Tim_BTim_B Posts: 7,669

    I've just found out that I'm blocked from Nicholas Soames' twitter account. Not sure what I've done to deserve that. So that's at least two MPs down: 648 to go.

    You're just not obese enough....
  • MonksfieldMonksfield Posts: 2,777
    What a shambles. This is what results from running a 21C country by 18C procedure.

    The way the HoC operates needs total reform, much less adversarial yah boo and much more grown up respect.

  • Penddu said:

    This smells like the expenses scandal all over again. A large element of poor but not illegal behaviour mixed up with a few cretins who thought they were above the law.

    Time for a change.....but not a simple left right flip flop. Time to turn politics upside down....a la Macron!

    Who has collapsed in the polls
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453

    What a shambles. This is what results from running a 21C country by 18C procedure.

    The way the HoC operates needs total reform, much less adversarial yah boo and much more grown up respect.

    Holyrood is even worse
  • YorkcityYorkcity Posts: 4,382

    kle4 said:

    Five years in advance, good organisation (yes I know O'Mara, but come on, he's going nowhere).
    Scott_P said:

    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...

    Not really sure of Peston's reasoning. Tory MPs would also have been furious if Elphicke was not suspended after allegations emerged, and then the press was full of 'Tories covered up allegations' stories like the ones thrown at Corbyn that he knew about Hopkins allegations and did nothing. The allegations are apparently serious, so needed a reaction, but that doesn't mean they are confident they are credible I'd have thought, just that they cannot be seen to ignore it, so call in the fuzz.

    Seems like No.10 would be condemned no matter what they did - tipping the press first seems the only thing TOry MPs can be legitimately mad about.
    And Esther is deputy chief whip - she will be aware of the circumstances and no doubt endorsed the action
    Taking all that at face value, given we don't know the facts, informing the press before the bloke himself is a pretty shitty thing to do and indicative of an organisation that is on a downward spiral.
    Hard to understand why they would not have the courtesy to inform him.
  • kle4 said:

    kle4 said:

    Five years in advance, good organisation (yes I know O'Mara, but come on, he's going nowhere).
    Scott_P said:

    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...

    Not really sure of Peston's reasoning. Tory MPs would also have been furious if Elphicke was not suspended after allegations emerged, and then the press was full of 'Tories covered up allegations' stories like the ones thrown at Corbyn that he knew about Hopkins allegations and did nothing. The allegations are apparently serious, so needed a reaction, but that doesn't mean they are confident they are credible I'd have thought, just that they cannot be seen to ignore it, so call in the fuzz.

    Seems like No.10 would be condemned no matter what they did - tipping the press first seems the only thing TOry MPs can be legitimately mad about.
    And Esther is deputy chief whip - she will be aware of the circumstances and no doubt endorsed the action
    Taking all that at face value, given we don't know the facts, informing the press before the bloke himself is a pretty shitty thing to do and indicative of an organisation that is on a downward spiral.
    It's indicative of a party focusing on press reaction first, the individual second. Crappy, but not necessarily saying anything more.
    Winning teams don't turn on each other. You only get the infighting when you're facing relegation. Unless you're Arsenal.
  • What a shambles. This is what results from running a 21C country by 18C procedure.

    The way the HoC operates needs total reform, much less adversarial yah boo and much more grown up respect.

    What a load of rubbish. Sad to see you using these sad events and alleged crimes of individuals to push your own agenda.
  • What a shambles. This is what results from running a 21C country by 18C procedure.

    The way the HoC operates needs total reform, much less adversarial yah boo and much more grown up respect.

    We agree on that one
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,580
    HYUFD said:

    kle4 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chameleon said:

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    And what would fill it? UKIP are a joke, the Greens are utterly mental and the Liberal Democrats are working hard to minimise the policy differences between them and Labour.
    A new party, made up of the Yellow Bookers, One Nation Pro Business One Nation Tories, and the Blairites.

    Politics, like nature, abhors a vacuum, something will replace the Tory party if it fails.
    The Tory Party and Labour would both split in that case, with the centrist wings of both parties and the LDs uniting, perhaps led by Chuka Umunna or George Osborne and the right of the Tories being joined by UKIP, perhaps led by Jacob Rees Mogg and the left of Labour perhaps joined by the Greens still led by Jeremy Corbyn.
    While I accept the point that nature abhors a vacuum and all that, most senior figures are so committed to a party brand even when it makes no sense, that I struggle to see while the opponent party would split even if one of the parties did - Chuka Umunna for instance would be pilloried by half his own supporters at least if he said 'I have more in common with a former Tory' and the same applies for plenty of Tories, I just don't see any party that is not collapsing in support splitting. Even when many feared Labour was on course for a total shellacking, there was no real suggestion they would split, not credibly.
    It would take a Macron style new party of the centre most probably which was durable unlike the SDP.
    And yet both our main parties, even now, have much more support than any of the traditional parties as Macron barged his way into the scene. I just don't think there is the space for a Macron surge, and no one serious is going to take the first plunge, when all it would mean is whoever their current opponent is would win.

    What a shambles. This is what results from running a 21C country by 18C procedure.

    The way the HoC operates needs total reform, much less adversarial yah boo and much more grown up respect.

    And how do we get that? It's not as though the public does not reward adversarial yah boo. In fact they prefer it when parties vilify their opponents.
  • brendan16brendan16 Posts: 2,315
    Scott_P said:
    Must be very cheap lawyers if they are only charging thousands of pounds! Is this taxpayer funded legal aid work or something?
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,580
    edited November 2017

    kle4 said:

    kle4 said:

    Five years in advance, good organisation (yes I know O'Mara, but come on, he's going nowhere).
    Scott_P said:

    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...

    Not really sure of Peston's reasoning. Tory MPs would also have been furious if Elphicke was not suspended after allegations emerged, and then the press was full of 'Tories covered up allegations' stories like the ones thrown at Corbyn that he knew about Hopkins allegations and did nothing. The allegations are apparently serious, so needed a reaction, but that doesn't mean they are confident they are credible I'd have thought, just that they cannot be seen to ignore it, so call in the fuzz.

    Seems like No.10 would be condemned no matter what they did - tipping the press first seems the only thing TOry MPs can be legitimately mad about.
    And Esther is deputy chief whip - she will be aware of the circumstances and no doubt endorsed the action
    Taking all that at face value, given we don't know the facts, informing the press before the bloke himself is a pretty shitty thing to do and indicative of an organisation that is on a downward spiral.
    It's indicative of a party focusing on press reaction first, the individual second. Crappy, but not necessarily saying anything more.
    Winning teams don't turn on each other. You only get the infighting when you're facing relegation. Unless you're Arsenal.
    I didn't say they were winning - everyone can see the party is divided and in a bad way right now. I just don't think informing the press before the bloke had anything to do with that, as it seems perfectly possible they are just caring more about protecting against allegations they didn't act on the information.

    Say the Tories were united and happy right now, but then this same scandal erupted. I still think they'd tell the press first in this situation, shitty as it is.
  • What a shambles. This is what results from running a 21C country by 18C procedure.

    The way the HoC operates needs total reform, much less adversarial yah boo and much more grown up respect.

    What a load of rubbish. Sad to see you using these sad events and alleged crimes of individuals to push your own agenda.
    I do not normally agree with Monksfield but on this I do

    And the complete overhaul of the HOL
  • Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    I remember being assured before the referendum that only a Leave victory would unite the Tory party.
    It was until the silly GE.
    The GE was awesome, it proved I was a visionary when it came to Mrs May.

    I warned ye all that she was a pound shop Gordon Brown.
    Gordon Brown had to step down after the 2010 election.
    Brown lost; May scraped a winning draw.
  • Chris_AChris_A Posts: 1,237

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    Of course Hunt would tell you he's employing more and more nurses. He's not, it's another lie. There are fewer nurses employed in the NHS than there were 12 months ago.
  • PongPong Posts: 4,693
    Yorkcity said:

    kle4 said:

    Five years in advance, good organisation (yes I know O'Mara, but come on, he's going nowhere).
    Scott_P said:

    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...

    Not really sure of Peston's reasoning. Tory MPs would also have been furious if Elphicke was not suspended after allegations emerged, and then the press was full of 'Tories covered up allegations' stories like the ones thrown at Corbyn that he knew about Hopkins allegations and did nothing. The allegations are apparently serious, so needed a reaction, but that doesn't mean they are confident they are credible I'd have thought, just that they cannot be seen to ignore it, so call in the fuzz.

    Seems like No.10 would be condemned no matter what they did - tipping the press first seems the only thing TOry MPs can be legitimately mad about.
    And Esther is deputy chief whip - she will be aware of the circumstances and no doubt endorsed the action
    Taking all that at face value, given we don't know the facts, informing the press before the bloke himself is a pretty shitty thing to do and indicative of an organisation that is on a downward spiral.
    Hard to understand why they would not have the courtesy to inform him.
    Flight risk?
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,580

    What a shambles. This is what results from running a 21C country by 18C procedure.

    The way the HoC operates needs total reform, much less adversarial yah boo and much more grown up respect.

    What a load of rubbish. Sad to see you using these sad events and alleged crimes of individuals to push your own agenda.
    I do not normally agree with Monksfield but on this I do

    And the complete overhaul of the HOL
    That might well be necessary, but not sure what it has to do with these sad events and alleged crimes, nor what the HoC operations have to do with it.
  • Chris_A said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    Of course Hunt would tell you he's employing more and more nurses. He's not, it's another lie. There are fewer nurses employed in the NHS than there were 12 months ago.
    How many more since 2010
  • foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    The Phillipinos are excellent nurses, the problem is the visas.
    Indeed they are. And they generally do speak pretty good English. But it's worrying (if true) that qualification requirements are being bypassed.
    Not sure how that would be done, as they couldn't be registered by the NMC.

    I know that in Leicester we have employed nurses awaiting language tests or other documentation as Health Care Assistants.

  • RobDRobD Posts: 59,732
    Pong said:

    Yorkcity said:

    kle4 said:

    Five years in advance, good organisation (yes I know O'Mara, but come on, he's going nowhere).
    Scott_P said:

    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...

    Not really sure of Peston's reasoning. Tory MPs would also have been furious if Elphicke was not suspended after allegations emerged, and then the press was full of 'Tories covered up allegations' stories like the ones thrown at Corbyn that he knew about Hopkins allegations and did nothing. The allegations are apparently serious, so needed a reaction, but that doesn't mean they are confident they are credible I'd have thought, just that they cannot be seen to ignore it, so call in the fuzz.

    Seems like No.10 would be condemned no matter what they did - tipping the press first seems the only thing TOry MPs can be legitimately mad about.
    And Esther is deputy chief whip - she will be aware of the circumstances and no doubt endorsed the action
    Taking all that at face value, given we don't know the facts, informing the press before the bloke himself is a pretty shitty thing to do and indicative of an organisation that is on a downward spiral.
    Hard to understand why they would not have the courtesy to inform him.
    Flight risk?
    I doubt it's for the party to make that judgement!
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    What's the link to Brexit?
  • MonksfieldMonksfield Posts: 2,777
    kle4 said:

    HYUFD said:

    kle4 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chameleon said:

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    And what would fill it? UKIP are a joke, the Greens are utterly mental and the Liberal Democrats are working hard to minimise the policy differences between them and Labour.
    A new party, made up of the Yellow Bookers, One Nation Pro Business One Nation Tories, and the Blairites.

    Politics, like nature, abhors a vacuum, something will replace the Tory party if it fails.
    The Tory Party and Labour would both split in that case, with the centrist wings of both parties and the LDs uniting, perhaps led by Chuka Umunna or George Osborne and the right of the Tories being joined by UKIP, perhaps led by Jacob Rees Mogg and the left of Labour perhaps joined by the Greens still led by Jeremy Corbyn.
    While I accept the point that nature abhors a vacuum and all that, most senior figures are so committed to a party brand even when it makes no sense, that I struggle to see while the opponent party would split even if one of the parties did - Chuka Umunna for instance would be pilloried by half his own supporters at least if he said 'I have more in common with a former Tory' and the same applies for plenty of Tories, I just don't see any party that is not collapsing in support splitting. Even when many feared Labour was on course for a total shellacking, there was no real suggestion they would split, not credibly.
    It would take a Macron style new party of the centre most probably which was durable unlike the SDP.
    And yet both our main parties, even now, have much more support than any of the traditional parties as Macron barged his way into the scene. I just don't think there is the space for a Macron surge, and no one serious is going to take the first plunge, when all it would mean is whoever their current opponent is would win.

    What a shambles. This is what results from running a 21C country by 18C procedure.

    The way the HoC operates needs total reform, much less adversarial yah boo and much more grown up respect.

    And how do we get that? It's not as though the public does not reward adversarial yah boo. In fact they prefer it when parties vilify their opponents.
    A primary system would be good, an end to FPTP would also help. Too many folk with jobs for life in safe seats.
  • Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    The Phillipinos are excellent nurses, the problem is the visas.
    Indeed they are. And they generally do speak pretty good English. But it's worrying (if true) that qualification requirements are being bypassed.
    Not sure how that would be done, as they couldn't be registered by the NMC.

    I know that in Leicester we have employed nurses awaiting language tests or other documentation as Health Care Assistants.

    Never mind when Nicola increases taxes you will be able to recruit Scottish nurses
  • Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    Somehow I doubt this given that the language test is a legal requirement under rules brought in in January 2016. Nurses cannot get NMC registration without passing it.
  • brendan16brendan16 Posts: 2,315
    edited November 2017

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    English is very widely spoken in the Philippines - it was a US protectorate after all. In my experience Of NHS hospitals - and via elderly relatives I have seen plenty over recent years - they are generally amongst the best nurses of all (pleasant and caring) and none has had any issue communicating in English or being understood either.
  • anothernickanothernick Posts: 3,591
    edited November 2017
    AndyJS said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    What's the link to Brexit?
    That EU nurses won't come to the UK because their future is unclear. So the NHS is recruiting from India and the Philippines which is much more expensive. Recruitment from EU countries has dropped by more than 90% i believe.
  • brendan16 said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    English is very widely spoken in the Philippines - it was a US protectorate after all. In my experience Of NHS hospitals - and via elderly relatives I have seen plenty over recent years - they are generally amongst the best nurses of all (pleasant and caring) and none has had any issue communicating in English or being understood either.
    Cruise ships are largely staffed with Philippine crew who speak excellent English
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 95,580

    kle4 said:

    HYUFD said:

    kle4 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chameleon said:

    Chameleon said:

    I miss the good old days of boring, liberal, Dave.

    Amen, every passing day I'm more convinced Dave will be the last Tory to win a majority.

    There's a feeling that Brexit will do to the Tory party what WWI did to the Liberals.
    And what would fill it? UKIP are a joke, the Greens are utterly mental and the Liberal Democrats are working hard to minimise the policy differences between them and Labour.
    A new party, made up of the Yellow Bookers, One Nation Pro Business One Nation Tories, and the Blairites.

    Politics, like nature, abhors a vacuum, something will replace the Tory party if it fails.
    The Tory Party and Labour would both split in that case, with the centrist wings of both parties and the LDs uniting, perhaps led by Chuka Umunna or George Osborne and the right of the Tories being joined by UKIP, perhaps led by Jacob Rees Mogg and the left of Labour perhaps joined by the Greens still led by Jeremy Corbyn.
    While I accept the point that nature abhors a vacuum and all that, most senior figures are so committed to a party brand even when it makes no sense, that I struggle to see while the opponent party would split even if one of the parties did - Chuka Umunna for instance would be pilloried by half his own supporters at least if he said 'I have more in common with a former Tory' and the same applies for plenty of Tories, I just don't see any party that is not collapsing in support splitting. Even when many feared Labour was on course for a total shellacking, there was no real suggestion they would split, not credibly.
    It would take a Macron style new party of the centre most probably which was durable unlike the SDP.
    Andss="Quote" rel="Monksfield">What a shambles. This is what results from running a 21C country by 18C procedure.

    The way the HoC operates needs total reform, much less adversarial yah boo and much more grown up respect.

    And how do we get that? It's not as though the public does not reward adversarial yah boo. In fact they prefer it when parties vilify their opponents.
    A primary system would be good, an end to FPTP would also help. Too many folk with jobs for life in safe seats.

    I'm not opposed to either of those things being implemented, although frankly I don't think it would change the culture of our politics all that much, I just think it would be a fairer system.
  • foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    AndyJS said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    What's the link to Brexit?
    https://twitter.com/Usherwood/status/925991357642141696
  • RhubarbRhubarb Posts: 359
    RobD said:

    Pong said:

    Yorkcity said:

    kle4 said:

    Five years in advance, good organisation (yes I know O'Mara, but come on, he's going nowhere).
    Scott_P said:

    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...

    Not really sure of Peston's reasoning. Tory MPs would also have been furious if Elphicke was not suspended after allegations emerged, and then the press was full of 'Tories covered up allegations' stories like the ones thrown at Corbyn that he knew about Hopkins allegations and did nothing. The allegations are apparently serious, so needed a reaction, but that doesn't mean they are confident they are credible I'd have thought, just that they cannot be seen to ignore it, so call in the fuzz.

    Seems like No.10 would be condemned no matter what they did - tipping the press first seems the only thing TOry MPs can be legitimately mad about.
    And Esther is deputy chief whip - she will be aware of the circumstances and no doubt endorsed the action
    Taking all that at face value, given we don't know the facts, informing the press before the bloke himself is a pretty shitty thing to do and indicative of an organisation that is on a downward spiral.
    Hard to understand why they would not have the courtesy to inform him.
    Flight risk?
    I doubt it's for the party to make that judgement!
    No but he could have got on TV before they publicly suspended him and fought back from the high ground.
  • YorkcityYorkcity Posts: 4,382
    edited November 2017
    RobD said:

    Pong said:

    Yorkcity said:

    kle4 said:

    Five years in advance, good organisation (yes I know O'Mara, but come on, he's going nowhere).
    Scott_P said:

    @Peston: Theresa May and the whips are presumably utterly confident of the credibility of the allegations against Elphicke - because Tory MPs will be furious with them if they jumped gun

    Coming after the old Chief Whip appointed himself Defence Secretary, this could be bad...

    Not really sure of Peston's reasoning. Tory MPs would also have been furious if Elphicke was not suspended after allegations emerged, and then the press was full of 'Tories covered up allegations' stories like the ones thrown at Corbyn that he knew about Hopkins allegations and did nothing. The allegations are apparently serious, so needed a reaction, but that doesn't mean they are confident they are credible I'd have thought, just that they cannot be seen to ignore it, so call in the fuzz.

    Seems like No.10 would be condemned no matter what they did - tipping the press first seems the only thing TOry MPs can be legitimately mad about.
    And Esther is deputy chief whip - she will be aware of the circumstances and no doubt endorsed the action
    Taking all that at face value, given we don't know the facts, informing the press before the bloke himself is a pretty shitty thing to do and indicative of an organisation that is on a downward spiral.
    Hard to understand why they would not have the courtesy to inform him.
    Flight risk?
    I doubt it's for the party to make that judgement!
    Agreed only a request normally from the police to a judge , when considering bail conditions, such as removal of passport.
  • ChameleonChameleon Posts: 4,264
    brendan16 said:

    Scott_P said:
    Must be very cheap lawyers if they are only charging thousands of pounds! Is this taxpayer funded legal aid work or something?
    Worth stating that the GF office were only predicting 1-3 resignations/suspensions.
  • foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548

    brendan16 said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    English is very widely spoken in the Philippines - it was a US protectorate after all. In my experience Of NHS hospitals - and via elderly relatives I have seen plenty over recent years - they are generally amongst the best nurses of all (pleasant and caring) and none has had any issue communicating in English or being understood either.
    Cruise ships are largely staffed with Philippine crew who speak excellent English
    Phillipinos are one of Englands fastest growing communities:

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filipinos_in_the_United_Kingdom

    Second only to India for naturalisations (at pre Brexit figures) they integrate very well as a general rule. Some of our Phillipino Nurses have just opened a new Philipino takeaway on Narborough rd, reputedly the country's most diverse street.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 121,974
    Chris_A said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    Of course Hunt would tell you he's employing more and more nurses. He's not, it's another lie. There are fewer nurses employed in the NHS than there were 12 months ago.
    Hunt is bringing in large numbers of nursing associates who will be trained and ready to enter the NHS with NMC registration by 2019 as well as expanding training places for nurses.
  • YorkcityYorkcity Posts: 4,382
    If these allegations have any veracity , persons could be put on the sex offenders register.As even a caution by the police could ensue with the requirement to register.
  • ChameleonChameleon Posts: 4,264
    Apparently Channel 4 had a fresh set of allegation against a Tory MP ready to run tonight: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DNu2Tl2UQAAtzAY.jpg
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,544

    brendan16 said:

    Sean_F said:

    The Conservative Party is just like a sick dog that has to be put down. We can't be governed by people who hate each other so much that they can't work with each other.

    Meanwhile Brexit spirals out of control, damaging everything in its path. We had dinner with a friend of my wife earlier - she is involved in recruitment of nurses and said that since it is now almost impossible to get recruits from EU countries hospitals are recruiting from India and the Philippines instead. The position is so desperate that the requirement for candidates to hold IELTS certificates (to prove fluency in English) is being ignored and nurses are being recruited without formal proof of their language ability. Just another way in which Brexit is impacting on the NHS which is not quite the same as we were promised at the referendum.
    English is very widely spoken in the Philippines - it was a US protectorate after all. In my experience Of NHS hospitals - and via elderly relatives I have seen plenty over recent years - they are generally amongst the best nurses of all (pleasant and caring) and none has had any issue communicating in English or being understood either.
    Cruise ships are largely staffed with Philippine crew who speak excellent English
    Phillipinos are one of Englands fastest growing communities:

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filipinos_in_the_United_Kingdom

    Second only to India for naturalisations (at pre Brexit figures) they integrate very well as a general rule. Some of our Phillipino Nurses have just opened a new Philipino takeaway on Narborough rd, reputedly the country's most diverse street.
    The few Phillipinos I have met have been lovely people as have most immigrants tbh. But how ridiculous it is that the immigration concerns that led to the Brexit are also causing... more immigration!
This discussion has been closed.