Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » A bad GE2015 omen for the Green party: It loses council by-

13

Comments

  • Options
    MikeSmithsonMikeSmithson Posts: 7,382
    Full result from Brighton Hanover by-election
    LAB 1,396 +8.8%
    GRN 1,358 -14.6%
    CON 275 -1.5%
    UKIP 250 +7.1%
    TUSC 172 +2.0%
    LD 56 -1.9%
  • Options
    DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300
    Plato said:

    It's a Friday - and EdM has been tweeting. Perhaps he really shouldn't.

    Kulgan of Crydee @KulganofCrydee
    @GuidoFawkes Did you just see @Ed_Miliband tweeting incorrect details about one of our fallen #Furious #DrummerLeeRigby NOT Fusilier

    Surely both are correct? The BBC uses Fusilier.
  • Options
    PlatoPlato Posts: 15,724
    That reminds me of a bizarre prolier-than-thou discussion on PB a while back where someone said 'roast beef' and another went 'jam and bread' and much name calling ensued...
    JohnO said:

    @tim

    This little piggy went to Barnet,
    This little piggy stayed at home,
    This little piggy claimed vast sums,
    This little piggy claimed none.
    And this little piggy went...
    "Wee wee wee" all the way to Con home...

  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,833
    A recovering Labour Party should win back Brighton, but I suppose it depends how good Caroline Lucas is as an MP - If she's a very good local MP and isn't just using her position to bang on about all the dreary issue's that interest her, then incumbancy could see her hanging on. Maybe.
  • Options
    Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 30,969
    tim said:

    Apologies but to return to school food.

    One thing that schools can, and should, do is have breakfasts available (not just a croissant but a full english - for me anyway ;) ). This, combined with teachers being available to offer advice, help with work etc. helps both nutritional and academic standards. 9am Breakfast / advice and lessons starting at 10am (teenagers work best with a later start) and finishing lessons at 4pm with sport and extra-curricular until it gets dark.

    Most of all allow individual schools to experiment with their timetable / school day to see what works best for them.

    Now really back to the Ashes.


    Right, so now you're arguing that although parents don't provide a breakfast when they are responsible for the children the school should step in, but when the school is in loco parentis the same parents should be responsible for providing a nutritious lunch.


    Yes. You seem to be having a lot of trouble with this concept of a school providing a service rather than forcing parents down a particular route.

    Hardly surprising from someone who believes the state can do no wrong and that the individual is always to be treated with suspicion and distrust.
  • Options
    AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    Last night Tim Shipman tweeted the following:

    "Most political journalists think MPs should be paid much more than they are. But that is not a view shared by newsdesks and voters"

    I expect the view of political journalists on this subject is closely allied to their idea of what political journalists should be paid.
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,937

    Plato said:

    It's a Friday - and EdM has been tweeting. Perhaps he really shouldn't.

    Kulgan of Crydee @KulganofCrydee
    @GuidoFawkes Did you just see @Ed_Miliband tweeting incorrect details about one of our fallen #Furious #DrummerLeeRigby NOT Fusilier

    Surely both are correct? The BBC uses Fusilier.

    It's just the usual suspects trying to use the horrible murder of Lee Rigby to have a pop at Ed Miliband. Par for the course really.

  • Options
    tim said:

    Apologies but to return to school food.

    One thing that schools can, and should, do is have breakfasts available (not just a croissant but a full english - for me anyway ;) ). This, combined with teachers being available to offer advice, help with work etc. helps both nutritional and academic standards. 9am Breakfast / advice and lessons starting at 10am (teenagers work best with a later start) and finishing lessons at 4pm with sport and extra-curricular until it gets dark.

    Most of all allow individual schools to experiment with their timetable / school day to see what works best for them.

    Now really back to the Ashes.


    Right, so now you're arguing that although parents don't provide a breakfast when they are responsible for the children the school should step in, but when the school is in loco parentis the same parents should be responsible for providing a nutritious lunch.


    Where you wish diktat I'm advocating choice and seeking a solution to a problem that makes life better for students and staff.
  • Options
    PlatoPlato Posts: 15,724
    antifrank said:

    Last night Tim Shipman tweeted the following:

    "Most political journalists think MPs should be paid much more than they are. But that is not a view shared by newsdesks and voters"

    I expect the view of political journalists on this subject is closely allied to their idea of what political journalists should be paid.

    I disagree - I'd assume that lobby hacks are more aware than anyone of the crap MPs have to put up with and are therefore more sympathetic to them.

    Using your logic - business reporters would be paid more than lobby reporters - is there any evidence for this?
  • Options
    TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633


    "James Cook ‏@BBCJamesCook 3m
    Salmond: Scotland should keep five other unions: European Union, defence, currency, crowns and social union. #indyref"

    What no UNITE ?


  • Options
    TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633
    tim said:

    Faux Libertarian PB Tory chaos.

    Jim Pickard ‏@PickardJE
    Downing St messaging all over the place: don't want to interfere in cigarettes/alcohol any more but getting tough on packed lunches

    When is the packed lunch ban bill coming to the HoC tim ?

    Ah yes - just after the unicorn gelding bill..

  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,336
    13th century partnership for KP and Chef. Long way to go but looking better for England.
  • Options
    JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 39,053

    Plato said:

    It's a Friday - and EdM has been tweeting. Perhaps he really shouldn't.

    Kulgan of Crydee @KulganofCrydee
    @GuidoFawkes Did you just see @Ed_Miliband tweeting incorrect details about one of our fallen #Furious #DrummerLeeRigby NOT Fusilier

    Surely both are correct? The BBC uses Fusilier.

    It's just the usual suspects trying to use the horrible murder of Lee Rigby to have a pop at Ed Miliband. Par for the course really.

    It's a bit like the usual suspect (singular) having a pop at Camerion over the investigation into Madeleine McCann's disappearance.

    Or using child sex abuse to blanket-slur Conservatives.

    It's a bit sick, isn't it?
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 60,994
    Mr. Flashman (deceased), the unicorn gelding bill is vital. They're well-known for being horny.
  • Options
    DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300
    OT -- another wrongly imprisoned person denied compensation. Today Lorraine Allen. Last week, Barry George. This is the sort of thing that annoys people because it seems unfair. It is seen as the Establishment closing ranks at the expense of ordinary people.
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,937
    Plato said:

    antifrank said:

    Last night Tim Shipman tweeted the following:

    "Most political journalists think MPs should be paid much more than they are. But that is not a view shared by newsdesks and voters"

    I expect the view of political journalists on this subject is closely allied to their idea of what political journalists should be paid.

    I disagree - I'd assume that lobby hacks are more aware than anyone of the crap MPs have to put up with and are therefore more sympathetic to them.

    Using your logic - business reporters would be paid more than lobby reporters - is there any evidence for this?

    Most reporters are paid a lot less than most people think. The competition for jobs is huge, with many people prepared to take very low wages in order to get a start, and most newspapers operate at a loss. If you get to be a columnist on a big-selling title then you have a chance of big wedge, just as you do if you can if you specialise and build a great list of contacts. But most hacks are not rolling in cash - which is probably why they like their freebies so much!
  • Options
    TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 40,208
    TGOHF said:

    Salmond overdosing on his new "winning" phrase
    "parcel o rogues"

    At least the SNP government seem to be able to run a piss-up in a brewery, aka live streaming. Remarkable lack of comment on Darling's wee bit of speechifying yesterday; was it because it was long winded, clichéd rubbish, or that no-one was actually able to listen to it?
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,937
    edited July 2013

    Plato said:

    It's a Friday - and EdM has been tweeting. Perhaps he really shouldn't.

    Kulgan of Crydee @KulganofCrydee
    @GuidoFawkes Did you just see @Ed_Miliband tweeting incorrect details about one of our fallen #Furious #DrummerLeeRigby NOT Fusilier

    Surely both are correct? The BBC uses Fusilier.

    It's just the usual suspects trying to use the horrible murder of Lee Rigby to have a pop at Ed Miliband. Par for the course really.

    It's a bit like the usual suspect (singular) having a pop at Camerion over the investigation into Madeleine McCann's disappearance.

    Or using child sex abuse to blanket-slur Conservatives.

    It's a bit sick, isn't it?

    No, given what happened to Lee Rigby I'd say it's a lot worse. And the usual suspects I was referring to were Guido and his mates.

  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,937
    DavidL said:

    13th century partnership for KP and Chef. Long way to go but looking better for England.

    Sssshhhh. No need for any comments at all.

  • Options
    Watching Sky Sports coverage of the Ashes gives me an idea. They have a "revometer" to measure the degree of spin a bowler puts on a ball. Perhaps we could use it here to measure the spin of some of our posters.
  • Options
    TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633

    TGOHF said:

    Salmond overdosing on his new "winning" phrase
    "parcel o rogues"

    At least the SNP government seem to be able to run a piss-up in a brewery, aka live streaming. Remarkable lack of comment on Darling's wee bit of speechifying yesterday; was it because it was long winded, clichéd rubbish, or that no-one was actually able to listen to it?
    What do you think of his cherry picking "5 unions" idea - can't see rUk agreeing to the currency one for a start - defence maybe - depends how much £ Scotland offers.

    As for "social union" - what does that mean anyway ?

  • Options
    GrandioseGrandiose Posts: 2,323
    edited July 2013
    England making decent progress here - 110 partnership much needed - now 121/2.

    Oh my word, what a curse this post proved to be.
  • Options
    JackWJackW Posts: 14,787
    Sean_F said:

    At my primary school we might have shavings of beef, lamb or pork; vegetables that had been boiled thoroughly till grey; warm milk, with a disgusting skin on top of it; curry that probably contained cat or dog; semolina; rice pudding; thick custard, and equally revolting things. The local pig farmer used to collect the leftovers, and he never went short. I never regretted having a packed lunch instead.

    Luxury lad, luxury ....

    When I were a lad we had dripping sarnies without the bread and a thin measure of clear soup disguised as warm rain water - on a good day.

    And we were thankful ....

  • Options
    GrandioseGrandiose Posts: 2,323
    Mike (/RCS etc.) - have you considered collapsing some of the links to older archives? What abotu a Twitter widget?
  • Options
    Grandiose said:

    England making decent progress here - 110 partnership much needed - now 121/2.

    Kiss of death there fella..
  • Options
    JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 39,053
    tim said:

    Plato said:

    It's a Friday - and EdM has been tweeting. Perhaps he really shouldn't.

    Kulgan of Crydee @KulganofCrydee
    @GuidoFawkes Did you just see @Ed_Miliband tweeting incorrect details about one of our fallen #Furious #DrummerLeeRigby NOT Fusilier

    Surely both are correct? The BBC uses Fusilier.

    It's just the usual suspects trying to use the horrible murder of Lee Rigby to have a pop at Ed Miliband. Par for the course really.

    It's a bit like the usual suspect (singular) having a pop at Camerion over the investigation into Madeleine McCann's disappearance.

    Or using child sex abuse to blanket-slur Conservatives.

    It's a bit sick, isn't it?
    Feel free to explain why you think Cameron singled out Madeleine McCann above other missing children, in the week the Sun bought the book rights.
    Explain why any politician reacts in such a manner. That does not make it the wrong thing to do.

    Remember "a good day to bury bad news" ?

    And it looks as if he did the right thing, if recent events are anything to go by.

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-23179230
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 60,994
    Soup? Would've been like nectar from the gods to us.

    We had to make do with chewing the fungus that grew in a dilapidated toilet block.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,336
    Grandiose said:

    England making decent progress here - 110 partnership much needed - now 121/2.

    Oh my word, what a curse this post proved to be.

    Yep, its your fault.

  • Options
    RichardNabaviRichardNabavi Posts: 3,413
    TGOHF said:


    "James Cook ‏@BBCJamesCook 3m
    Salmond: Scotland should keep five other unions: European Union, defence, currency, crowns and social union. #indyref"

    Defence? So the nukes stay at Faslane and Scotland pays its share?
  • Options
    Never mind if you want a man to get out of a crisis in an Ashes test Ian Bell has as much chance as a 19yo debutant..
  • Options
    PlatoPlato Posts: 15,724

    Soup? Would've been like nectar from the gods to us.

    We had to make do with chewing the fungus that grew in a dilapidated toilet block.

    Eh, laddy - black mould scraped from the u-bend would've got us a slot on House - we licked the cobbles round my way
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,937
    Why the F does anyone have to comment when England's batsmen are doing well? DavidL and Grandiose please learn your lesson. You are both responsible.

    Seeing Bell walk out at a time like this is deeply unpleasant. Just for once it wouldn't it be a thing if he performed against the Australians when England really needed him to?
  • Options
    TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 40,208
    edited July 2013
    TGOHF said:


    What do you think of his cherry picking "5 unions" idea - can't see rUk agreeing to the currency one for a start - defence maybe - depends how much £ Scotland offers.

    As for "social union" - what does that mean anyway ?

    Negotiation, negotiation, negotiation.

    Social Union is as meaningful, or meaningless, as Big Society and Bettertogether.

    Edit: and considerably more meaningful than One Nation.
  • Options
    JackWJackW Posts: 14,787

    Soup? Would've been like nectar from the gods to us.

    We had to make do with chewing the fungus that grew in a dilapidated toilet block.

    You had a "dilapidated toilet block" !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    We might have only dreamed of such luxuries as we carried a cracked chamber pot behind the bushes !!!!

    But we were happy ....

  • Options
    JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 39,053
    tim said:

    @Josias

    BBC News England ‏@BBCEngland 46m
    @KulganofCrydee We are using the title Fusilier following a request from the Army

    Now if you want to direct your ire at the ignorant posters trying to use Rigby's murder to attack Miliband then go ahead.
    I suspect you're too hypocritical though and will carry on with your pathetic trailing of my posts.

    What they said was wrong.

    Are you willing to admit that you were wrong over McCann and the way you used sex abuse slurs against the Conservatives?

    No?
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,336

    Why the F does anyone have to comment when England's batsmen are doing well? DavidL and Grandiose please learn your lesson. You are both responsible.

    Seeing Bell walk out at a time like this is deeply unpleasant. Just for once it wouldn't it be a thing if he performed against the Australians when England really needed him to?

    I am very, very, sorry.

  • Options
    taffystaffys Posts: 9,753
    Just for once it wouldn't it be a thing if he performed against the Australians when England really needed him to?

    Don't hold your breath. When really needed he leaves it to someone else. Helps himself when there's less pressure. Just goes to show you averages aren't everything.
  • Options
    PlatoPlato Posts: 15,724
    That's @malcolmg's chamber pot though.
    JackW said:

    Soup? Would've been like nectar from the gods to us.

    We had to make do with chewing the fungus that grew in a dilapidated toilet block.

    You had a "dilapidated toilet block" !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    We might have only dreamed of such luxuries as we carried a cracked chamber pot behind the bushes !!!!

    But we were happy ....

  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,937
    DavidL said:

    Why the F does anyone have to comment when England's batsmen are doing well? DavidL and Grandiose please learn your lesson. You are both responsible.

    Seeing Bell walk out at a time like this is deeply unpleasant. Just for once it wouldn't it be a thing if he performed against the Australians when England really needed him to?

    I am very, very, sorry.

    It's too late for sorry. You have cost England the Ashes.

  • Options
    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"
  • Options
    Good god. @Grandiose should be shot.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,523
    Some posters should exile themselves to conhome for the duration of the Ashes.
  • Options
    KP and Cook clearly worried they might lose their packed lunches with those shots.
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,937
    And as if by magic, the collapse begins ...
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,523
    On topic I have long speculated that Caroline Lucas would be the victim of a resurgent Labour Party led by Ed Miliband copacetic leadership
  • Options
    GrandioseGrandiose Posts: 2,323
    edited July 2013

    DavidL said:

    Why the F does anyone have to comment when England's batsmen are doing well? DavidL and Grandiose please learn your lesson. You are both responsible.

    Seeing Bell walk out at a time like this is deeply unpleasant. Just for once it wouldn't it be a thing if he performed against the Australians when England really needed him to?

    I am very, very, sorry.

    It's too late for sorry. You have cost England the Ashes.

    I have only one thing to say: look how brilliantly Australia are doing - restricting the run rate, taking lots of wickets - surely they'll have this wrapped up by lunch!!

    [fingers crossed]
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,783
    Text of Salmond's speech:

    http://news.scotland.gov.uk/News/Democracy-at-heart-of-independence-case-for-fundamental-change-to-political-and-economic-union-266.aspx

    "We will be part of a currency union with the rest of the UK – but we will finally have the full taxation powers we need to promote jobs and investment."

    But not borrowing......BoE says 'no'......
  • Options
    JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 39,053
    tim said:

    tim said:

    @Josias

    BBC News England ‏@BBCEngland 46m
    @KulganofCrydee We are using the title Fusilier following a request from the Army

    Now if you want to direct your ire at the ignorant posters trying to use Rigby's murder to attack Miliband then go ahead.
    I suspect you're too hypocritical though and will carry on with your pathetic trailing of my posts.

    What they said was wrong.

    Are you willing to admit that you were wrong over McCann and the way you used sex abuse slurs against the Conservatives?

    No?
    Absolutely not wrong about the McCann case, and why Cameron couldn't remember anything about it at Leveson.
    Didn't use any sex abuse slurs, the arrests have just started in the case you are confusing with the N.Wales case anyhow.And posters on here, again the super-ignorant ones attacked Tom Watson in their confusion between the two cases.

    As for the poster on here using Rigby's death to attack Miliband, anything to say, over and over again for weeks if you're not being hypocritical
    You were absolutely wrong about the McCann case. As usual, you let your utter hatred for Cameron get in the way of sound judgement.

    And it is not just Cameron - who can forget the way you claimed that Osborne crying at a funeral "would set the media narrative"?

    As for the sex abuse: people are innocent until proven guilty. Saying "just you wait!" goes rather against that, and is a pathetic slur. The McAlpine case should have tempered people. Sadly it did not.

    But enough of this. I'm off for a bike ride. Enjoy yourselves!
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,336
    I am going out now. I may be some time...
  • Options
    redcliffe62redcliffe62 Posts: 342
    Patrick said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"

    Patrick said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"

    20 countries can share a currency in Europe, I am quite sure even the MOD black ops team (Faslane Division) can see the benefits of a shared currency but separate taxation systems so England gets what it puts in and Scotland gets what it puts in.

    Westminster and the MOD got away with annexing across the maritime border in 1999 late at night with no media coverage, but they went a step too far this time and the silence on the idea if not the action now is deafening. How dare London thinks it can treat Scotland as a colony.

    What do you mean it has been since 1707 as part of Greater Englandshire, and to quote the one Tory MP in Scotland it is "extinguished"?

    Does anyone really believe Downing Street's hurried denials after darling's panicky phone call. AFTER they got caught, AFTER the Guardian of all people arked up and they had to drop it?

    Had they not done so does anyone doubt it would have been the default policy of the MOD, those chappies who care so much about defence in Scotland they shut the bases, reneged on repositioning troops from Germany, removed the planes and decimated the regiments?
    Track record of self interest and a denial from Cameron makes no difference.

    We know the plan and so do they.

    Major Salmond speech not covered by beeb today on telly, funny that.

  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,937
    Grandiose said:

    DavidL said:

    Why the F does anyone have to comment when England's batsmen are doing well? DavidL and Grandiose please learn your lesson. You are both responsible.

    Seeing Bell walk out at a time like this is deeply unpleasant. Just for once it wouldn't it be a thing if he performed against the Australians when England really needed him to?

    I am very, very, sorry.

    It's too late for sorry. You have cost England the Ashes.

    I have only one thing to say: look how brilliantly Australia are doing - restricting the run rate, taking lots of wickets - surely they'll have this wrapped up by lunch!!

    [fingers crossed]

    It doesn't work if you do it on purpose!

  • Options
    JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 39,053
    tim said:

    @Josias.

    Point proven.
    Nothing to direct at the detritus using Rigby's death.

    Just before I pedal off: you obviously missed my "What they said was wrong." in my previous post.

    If they are 'detritus' for using Rigby's tragic death, then what are you for using McCann's death, crying at funerals and child sex abuse?
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,758

    Patrick said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"

    Patrick said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"

    20 countries can share a currency in Europe, I am quite sure even the MOD black ops team (Faslane Division) can see the benefits of a shared currency but separate taxation systems so England gets what it puts in and Scotland gets what it puts in.

    Westminster and the MOD got away with annexing across the maritime border in 1999 late at night with no media coverage, but they went a step too far this time and the silence on the idea if not the action now is deafening. How dare London thinks it can treat Scotland as a colony.

    What do you mean it has been since 1707 as part of Greater Englandshire, and to quote the one Tory MP in Scotland it is "extinguished"?

    Does anyone really believe Downing Street's hurried denials after darling's panicky phone call. AFTER they got caught, AFTER the Guardian of all people arked up and they had to drop it?

    Had they not done so does anyone doubt it would have been the default policy of the MOD, those chappies who care so much about defence in Scotland they shut the bases, reneged on repositioning troops from Germany, removed the planes and decimated the regiments?
    Track record of self interest and a denial from Cameron makes no difference.

    We know the plan and so do they.

    Major Salmond speech not covered by beeb today on telly, funny that.

    That just shows the confusion of the Nat position, if England is so evil why would you want to be in any kind of Union with them, currency or otherwise ? If Scots want to be independent they should have the courage of their convictions and do it properly.
  • Options
    RichardNabaviRichardNabavi Posts: 3,413
    Now here's a nice opportunity for Ed M to show he's not the creature of the unions, AND (even more important) get kudos from tim: Unreservedly support Jeremy Hunt on Trafford General Hospital, rather than pretend to agree with this campaign:

    http://savetraffordgeneral.com/

    I'm not holding my breath...
  • Options
    PlatoPlato Posts: 15,724
    edited July 2013
    OT Sometimes I do wonder at interwebby rage - this is a perfect example of it. This is a rather cute little twitter feed with several pix a day of a cat supposedly musing on life, sadly. And someone got angry about it. And then promptly fell into the trap of correcting someone's grammar and misspelling it... http://littlecatdiaries.blogspot.co.uk/2013/07/man-picks-completely-pointless-fight.html

    I gather this is called Skitt's Law and we see it in action every other day on PB... http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Internet_law

    "Skitt’s Law is a comment on the pedantry of some internet users.

    ”Any post correcting an error in another post will contain at least one error itself or more generally. The likelihood of an error in a post is directly proportional to the embarrassment it will cause the poster."

    Basically, people who try to issue corrections (particularly spelling and grammar) are likely to commit the same offense themselves, usually in the actual post where they're making the correction. In a malicious sense, this is a declaration of hypocrisy, in a less malicious sense, it's just Murphy's Law - that if you're going to correct someone's typo, this will be that one, inconvenient and embarrassing time you actually make a typo yourself.

    It derives from the user "Skitt" on alt.usage.english, mentioned first in a message back in 1999.[6] It then got out into the wild following the three billionth time the thing about "ignoramii" not being a real word cropped up on the internet. Skitt's Law also has a guise in "McKean's Law," named after Erin McKean, which focuses entirely on spelling or grammatical issues: "Any correction of the speech or writing of others will contain at least one grammatical, spelling, or typographical error."[7]

    Observational evidence of Skitt’s Law leads to the following corollary:
    “”No matter how carefully or how many times you read your post, you will not notice at least one spelling or grammatical error until after you click submit.

    Anyone who has published a book, submitted a dissertation or thesis, or had work printed in a peer reviewed journal will be well aware of this. "
  • Options
    AndreaParma_82AndreaParma_82 Posts: 4,714
    As expected, Adam Price is selected by Plaid in Carmarthen East and Dinefwr (Welsh Assembly version). The sitting AM will retire in 2016. PC enjoyed a nice 14.9% majority in 2011. Price represented the area at Westminster between 2001 and 2010.
  • Options
    PlatoPlato Posts: 15,724
    In other news - Alan Whicker has died aged 87 - RIP

    Here he meets Papa Doc

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MO_fLp_j-wQ
  • Options
    CD13CD13 Posts: 6,351

    Interesting that even mentioning a "sporting event" seems to jeopardise the preferred outcome. We know it's silly but it's supposedly an evolutionary trait that has survived. Like associating rotten fruit with sickness. The ability to link two events and associate (learn) from them had a survival advantage, so we do it even when we don't even believe it anymore.

    Possibly the fear of foreigners (or anyone strange i.e. not in the same tribe) is a deep-seated survival instinct. Looking back over history, you can see where it may have originated from.

    Although I admit to knowing little about the "arty" subjects like sociology or psychology. I remember seeing a bit of graffiti above the toilet roll at University. It read "Social Sciences degree, please take one".

    Still, I expect one of the expert on here will put me right.
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,758
    tim said:

    michael burke ‏@menburke 2h
    ONS: #Construction is lower now even than in 2008/09 http://bit.ly/1dm5mJI When Osborne says housing is recovering, he means higher prices

    The usual suspects appear to have missed the construction data, as they did the manufacturing and export announcements.
    Good at cheering on a bubble though.

    "Good at cheering on a bubble though"

    everybody got so much practice between 1997 and 2010, it's a hard habit to break.

    Expect Ed to join in soon.
  • Options
    JohnOJohnO Posts: 4,215
    @tim, Hah, Hah, increasingly looking as if you're getting your excuses in early for defeat in 2015. I'll drink to that! Onwards to July 25 2Q GDP....
  • Options
    tim said:

    michael burke ‏@menburke 2h
    ONS: #Construction is lower now even than in 2008/09 http://bit.ly/1dm5mJI When Osborne says housing is recovering, he means higher prices

    The usual suspects appear to have missed the construction data, as they did the manufacturing and export announcements.
    Good at cheering on bubble though.

    Not unlike your ability to miss every single good piece of economic news. A coincidence I'm sure. You are in absolutely no position to accuse others of being selective.

    I get the very strong impression that economics isn't exactly your strong point.
  • Options
    RichardNabaviRichardNabavi Posts: 3,413
    edited July 2013
    tim said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Are you finally waking up to the fact that Camerons pledge on District Generals was mad and cost billions?
    And that Lansley halting reconfiguration in London was similarly stupid?

    Actually, Andrew Lansley was quite sensible on this. He called for a temporary moratorium to give time to evaluate proposals:

    This moratorium will provide a chance to reset every proposal, to reconsider every decision and to ensure that in each case they are consistent with the following key criteria.

    First, there must be clarity about the clinical evidence base underpinning the proposals. Second, they must have the support of the GP commissioners involved. Third, they must genuinely promote choice for their patients. Fourth, the process must have genuinely engaged the public, patients and local authorities.


    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/7747870/The-NHS-must-put-patients-first.html

    But, yes, politicians interfere too much. That is true of all parties. My complaint is not that you criticise Cameron on this (you are right), but that you don't seem to realise that Labour politicians do exactly the same.
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,783

    Patrick said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"

    Patrick said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"

    20 countries can share a currency in Europe, I am quite sure even the MOD black ops team (Faslane Division) can see the benefits of a shared currency but separate taxation systems so England gets what it puts in and Scotland gets what it puts in.

    Westminster and the MOD got away with annexing across the maritime border in 1999 late at night with no media coverage, but they went a step too far this time and the silence on the idea if not the action now is deafening. How dare London thinks it can treat Scotland as a colony.

    What do you mean it has been since 1707 as part of Greater Englandshire, and to quote the one Tory MP in Scotland it is "extinguished"?

    Does anyone really believe Downing Street's hurried denials after darling's panicky phone call. AFTER they got caught, AFTER the Guardian of all people arked up and they had to drop it?

    Had they not done so does anyone doubt it would have been the default policy of the MOD, those chappies who care so much about defence in Scotland they shut the bases, reneged on repositioning troops from Germany, removed the planes and decimated the regiments?
    Track record of self interest and a denial from Cameron makes no difference.

    We know the plan and so do they.

    Major Salmond speech not covered by beeb today on telly, funny that.

    That just shows the confusion of the Nat position, if England is so evil why would you want to be in any kind of Union with them, currency or otherwise ? If Scots want to be independent they should have the courage of their convictions and do it properly.
    The 'Political Union is not working' - "policies like the punitive Bedroom Tax, the renewal of Trident or Royal Mail privatisation imposed on Scotland ..."

    No 'negative campaigning' here!
  • Options
    TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633
    JohnO said:

    @tim, Hah, Hah, increasingly looking as if you're getting your excuses in early for defeat in 2015. I'll drink to that! Onwards to July 25 2Q GDP....

    2015 : "Labour only lost because the coalition created a bubble"

    - didn't see the same complaints in 2001 and 2005 when the bubbles were real.

  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,758

    Patrick said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"

    Patrick said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"

    20 countries can share a currency in Europe, I am quite sure even the MOD black ops team (Faslane Division) can see the benefits of a shared currency but separate taxation systems so England gets what it puts in and Scotland gets what it puts in.

    Westminster and the MOD got away with annexing across the maritime border in 1999 late at night with no media coverage, but they went a step too far this time and the silence on the idea if not the action now is deafening. How dare London thinks it can treat Scotland as a colony.

    What do you mean it has been since 1707 as part of Greater Englandshire, and to quote the one Tory MP in Scotland it is "extinguished"?

    Does anyone really believe Downing Street's hurried denials after darling's panicky phone call. AFTER they got caught, AFTER the Guardian of all people arked up and they had to drop it?

    Had they not done so does anyone doubt it would have been the default policy of the MOD, those chappies who care so much about defence in Scotland they shut the bases, reneged on repositioning troops from Germany, removed the planes and decimated the regiments?
    Track record of self interest and a denial from Cameron makes no difference.

    We know the plan and so do they.

    Major Salmond speech not covered by beeb today on telly, funny that.

    That just shows the confusion of the Nat position, if England is so evil why would you want to be in any kind of Union with them, currency or otherwise ? If Scots want to be independent they should have the courage of their convictions and do it properly.
    The 'Political Union is not working' - "policies like the punitive Bedroom Tax, the renewal of Trident or Royal Mail privatisation imposed on Scotland ..."

    No 'negative campaigning' here!
    Well the whole campaign has been pretty dire, Eck's Parcel of Frogs gambit is just the latest in a pretty poor show. So far his arguments amount to anyone who isn't him is a twat who hates Scotland, interesting to watch but hardly the basis of a nation.
  • Options
    JohnOJohnO Posts: 4,215
    @tim - You're becoming a right old grump, snarling away, muttering semi-audible imprecations at passing posters gently going about their business.

    I'd kind of sympathize but I'm too busy laughing. But caringly; be assured of that.
  • Options
    tim said:

    tim said:

    michael burke ‏@menburke 2h
    ONS: #Construction is lower now even than in 2008/09 http://bit.ly/1dm5mJI When Osborne says housing is recovering, he means higher prices

    The usual suspects appear to have missed the construction data, as they did the manufacturing and export announcements.
    Good at cheering on bubble though.

    Not unlike your ability to miss every single good piece of economic news. A coincidence I'm sure. You are in absolutely no position to accuse others of being selective.

    I get the very strong impression that economics isn't exactly your strong point.

    I haven't ignored the house price rises that you have been cheering as good news, I don't see them as good news, but I certainly haven't been ignoring them

    Do you want me to post more about Osbornes taxpayer subsidised housing bubble that you see as good news then, just in case you miss it?
    You will not find a quote where I 'cheer on house price rises'. So stop making things up. Although I know that is your modus operandi. Particularly on subjects where you are out of your depth.

    Perhaps you should stick to wittering on about fops and posting pictures of the Chancellor out jogging. It's a bit less complex than learning about economics.
  • Options
    RichardNabaviRichardNabavi Posts: 3,413

    Well the whole campaign has been pretty dire

    It's provided plenty of entertainment, though.
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,783

    Patrick said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"

    Patrick said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"

    20 countries can share a currency in Europe, I am quite sure even the MOD black ops team (Faslane Division) can see the benefits of a shared currency but separate taxation systems so England gets what it puts in and Scotland gets what it puts in.

    Westminster and the MOD got away with annexing across the maritime border in 1999 late at night with no media coverage, but they went a step too far this time and the silence on the idea if not the action now is deafening. How dare London thinks it can treat Scotland as a colony.

    What do you mean it has been since 1707 as part of Greater Englandshire, and to quote the one Tory MP in Scotland it is "extinguished"?

    Does anyone really believe Downing Street's hurried denials after darling's panicky phone call. AFTER they got caught, AFTER the Guardian of all people arked up and they had to drop it?

    Had they not done so does anyone doubt it would have been the default policy of the MOD, those chappies who care so much about defence in Scotland they shut the bases, reneged on repositioning troops from Germany, removed the planes and decimated the regiments?
    Track record of self interest and a denial from Cameron makes no difference.

    We know the plan and so do they.

    Major Salmond speech not covered by beeb today on telly, funny that.

    That just shows the confusion of the Nat position, if England is so evil why would you want to be in any kind of Union with them, currency or otherwise ? If Scots want to be independent they should have the courage of their convictions and do it properly.
    The 'Political Union is not working' - "policies like the punitive Bedroom Tax, the renewal of Trident or Royal Mail privatisation imposed on Scotland ..."

    No 'negative campaigning' here!
    interesting to watch but hardly the basis of a nation.
    It's not exactly 'Give me Liberty or Give Me Death!' is it.....

  • Options
    richardDoddrichardDodd Posts: 5,472
    edited July 2013
    Plato, if that uis true about AW then it is very sad news.He was a massive influence in my early career as a documentary maker, we rattled around the globe together for a couple of decades and I shot over thirty of his programmes/series.
    An Icon
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,937
    Plato said:

    In other news - Alan Whicker has died aged 87 - RIP

    Here he meets Papa Doc

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MO_fLp_j-wQ

    He was brilliant. Whicker, I mean. A life very well lived.

  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,758

    Patrick said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"

    Patrick said:

    @RichardNabavi

    Sounds to all the world like Devomax to me - not "Independence"

    20 countries can share a currency in Europe, I am quite sure even the MOD black ops team (Faslane Division) can see the benefits of a shared currency but separate taxation systems so England gets what it puts in and Scotland gets what it puts in.

    Westminster and the MOD got away with annexing across the maritime border in 1999 late at night with no media coverage, but they went a step too far this time and the silence on the idea if not the action now is deafening. How dare London thinks it can treat Scotland as a colony.

    What do you mean it has been since 1707 as part of Greater Englandshire, and to quote the one Tory MP in Scotland it is "extinguished"?

    Does anyone really believe Downing Street's hurried denials after darling's panicky phone call. AFTER they got caught, AFTER the Guardian of all people arked up and they had to drop it?

    Had they not done so does anyone doubt it would have been the default policy of the MOD, those chappies who care so much about defence in Scotland they shut the bases, reneged on repositioning troops from Germany, removed the planes and decimated the regiments?
    Track record of self interest and a denial from Cameron makes no difference.

    We know the plan and so do they.

    Major Salmond speech not covered by beeb today on telly, funny that.

    That just shows the confusion of the Nat position, if England is so evil why would you want to be in any kind of Union with them, currency or otherwise ? If Scots want to be independent they should have the courage of their convictions and do it properly.
    The 'Political Union is not working' - "policies like the punitive Bedroom Tax, the renewal of Trident or Royal Mail privatisation imposed on Scotland ..."

    No 'negative campaigning' here!
    interesting to watch but hardly the basis of a nation.
    It's not exactly 'Give me Liberty or Give Me Death!' is it.....

    It's more give me liberty, but I want my pension guaranteed and you'll promise you still defend us and all our guys can go off and work in your country if they want to and you'll still broadcast Coronation St. and I don't want to have to use the Euro and ........... etc. etc.
  • Options
    JackWJackW Posts: 14,787
    JohnO said:

    @tim - You're becoming a right old grump, snarling away, muttering semi-audible imprecations at passing posters gently going about their business.

    I'd kind of sympathize but I'm too busy laughing. But caringly; be assured of that.

    Rarely has PB witnessed such selfless hilarity in the service of the site.

    No matter your location it has to be said that JohnO is beacon of decency to those Cheshire farmers in need of solace.

    Mere mortal PBers may only bask in your not inconsiderable shadow.

  • Options
    JonCJonC Posts: 67
    Bell bashers inexplicably out in force I see.

    He has scored almost 6000 runs at an average of 45.6 in tests.

    Compare that with some other randomly chosen English batsmen:

    Gower: 8321 at 44.2
    Edrich: 5138 at 43.5
    Vaughan 5719 at 41.4
    Hussain 5764 at 37.8
    Trescothick 5825 at 43.8
    Thorpe 6744 at 44.7
    Strauss 7037 at 40.9
    Gooch 8900 at 42.6

    Why Bell gets so much flack is entirely mystifying to me.

    I will stick up for him anytime even if simply by posting i can guarantee his dismissal within minutes...
  • Options
    PlatoPlato Posts: 15,724
    Every daily and Sunday national newspaper dropped circulation year on year in June except for the i. http://www.pressgazette.co.uk/abcs-all-national-titles-down-year-year-except-i

    Aside from the i, which now has an average daily circulation of 303,009 (up 11.16 per cent year on year), the next best performers were The Times (down 2.29 per cent year on year to 390,941) and Daily Mirror (down 3.94 per cent year on year to 1,038,753). The i circulation includes 65,003 bulk copies.

    Looking at the month on month comparisons, nine national titles increased their sale in June.

    Dailies

    Name of title: average circulation, year-on-year change, month-on-month change

    Daily Mirror: 1,038,753, down 3.94 per cent, down 0.24 per cent

    Daily Record: 252,626, down 9.56 per cent, down 1.02 per cent

    Daily Star: 540,849, down 10.2 per cent, up 1.13 per cent

    The Sun: 2,243,903, down 13.15 per cent, down 1.12 per cent

    Daily Express: 522,264, down 13.31 per cent, down 0.57 per cent

    Daily Mail: 1,806,569, down 6.86 per cent, up 1.06 per cent

    The Daily Telegraph: 547,106, down 4.63 per cent, up 0.28 per cent

    Financial Times: 258,488, down 13.03 per cent, up 0.71 per cent

    The Guardian: 187,000, down 11.59 per cent, down 2.79 per cent

    i: 303,009, up 11.16 per cent, down 1.16 per cent

    The Independent: 73,060, down 18.82 per cent, down 2.7 per cent

    The Times: 390,941, down 2.29 per cent, down 1.02 per cent

    Sundays

    Name of title: average circulation, year-on-year change, month-on-month change

    Daily Star Sunday: 335,864, down 29.05 per cent, up 1.88 per cent

    The Sun (Sunday):1,875,220, down 14.37 per cent, up 0.39 per cent

    Sunday Mail: 284,051, down 9.45 per cent, down 1.62 per cent

    Sunday Mirror:1,036,542, down 4.68 per cent, up 0.81 per cent

    Sunday People: 415,075, down 7.78 per cent, down 0.11 per cent

    Sunday Express:455,901, down 11.10 per cent, down 1.49 per cent

    Sunday Post: 244,257, down 12.49 per cent, up 5.10 per cent

    The Mail on Sunday: 1,638,049, down 10.21 per cent, down 2.5 per cent

    Independent on Sunday: 111,986 down 8.65 per cent, down 0.97 per cent

    The Observer: 212,376, down 12.94 per cent, down 4.65 per cent

    The Sunday Telegraph: 422,590, down 6.15 per cent, up 0.44 per cent

    The Sunday Times: 840,201, down 8.27 per cent, down 0.31 per cent
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,937

    Plato, if that uis true about AW then it is very sad news.He was a massive influence in my early career as a documentary maker, we rattled around the globe together for a couple of decades and I shot over thirty of his programmes/series.
    An Icon

    He was indeed. A very fine journalist. You must have had a great time. I wil raise a glass to him next week when I am in Hong Kong, which I always imagined was one of his spiritual homes: sundowners on the Peak, not a hair out of place. RIP.
  • Options
    JohnOJohnO Posts: 4,215
    JackW said:

    JohnO said:

    @tim - You're becoming a right old grump, snarling away, muttering semi-audible imprecations at passing posters gently going about their business.

    I'd kind of sympathize but I'm too busy laughing. But caringly; be assured of that.

    Rarely has PB witnessed such selfless hilarity in the service of the site.

    No matter your location it has to be said that JohnO is beacon of decency to those Cheshire farmers in need of solace.

    Mere mortal PBers may only bask in your not inconsiderable shadow.

    He can be my other-half on the next sojourn to Bournemouth. Bit of sea-air will do him the power of good.
  • Options
    richardDoddrichardDodd Posts: 5,472
    edited July 2013
    SO..He was particularly fond of OZ ,one of his fave islands was Norfolk Island..weird place, but great fun.
    HK..It had to be The Peninsula..top floor for cocktails
  • Options
    RichardNabaviRichardNabavi Posts: 3,413
    tim said:


    Suspect that being in the pocket of the tobacco companies is far more damaging.

    Care to substantiate that smear?
  • Options
    JohnO said:

    @tim - You're becoming a right old grump, snarling away, muttering semi-audible imprecations at passing posters gently going about their business.

    I'd kind of sympathize but I'm too busy laughing. But caringly; be assured of that.

    John your decency and benevolence is a great credit to this site.

    Perhaps you should appoint yourself as tim's deputy in upholding standards of taste and decency on PB.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,523
    edited July 2013
    JonC said:

    Bell bashers inexplicably out in force I see.

    He has scored almost 6000 runs at an average of 45.6 in tests.

    Compare that with some other randomly chosen English batsmen:

    Gower: 8321 at 44.2
    Edrich: 5138 at 43.5
    Vaughan 5719 at 41.4
    Hussain 5764 at 37.8
    Trescothick 5825 at 43.8
    Thorpe 6744 at 44.7
    Strauss 7037 at 40.9
    Gooch 8900 at 42.6

    Why Bell gets so much flack is entirely mystifying to me.

    I will stick up for him anytime even if simply by posting i can guarantee his dismissal within minutes...

    His average against Australia in this country is pretty dire.

    I want Bell to be a success.

    So when he retires Warwickshire name a stand after him and the ensuing mirth as commentators announce bowlers are bowling from the Bell End.

  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,523
    That came out over 100mph from the Bell End.
  • Options
    TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633
    tim said:

    Now Dave's personal alcohol policy goes as well.
    Stupid policy Dave made his own.

    Nick Sutton ‏@suttonnick
    After #cigarette packaging and minimum alcohol pricing, @drwollastonmp tells @bbcshaunley on #wato it's a "very sad day for public health"


    James Chapman (Mail) ‏@jameschappers
    Govt right to drop minimum alcohol pricing - political suicide in a cost of living election. Not so sure about plain cigarette packs

    Suspect that being in the pocket of the tobacco companies is far more damaging.

    A whole MP who wanted to go down the nanny state line - wooo good spot tim.

    Will minimum pricing and plain packets be in the Labour manifesto ?

  • Options
    JohnOJohnO Posts: 4,215
    @Max - He's misunderstood. He needs a bit of compassionate Tory TLC. Which is what, for all my divers faults and failings, I possess in abundance.
  • Options
    JackWJackW Posts: 14,787
    JohnO said:

    JackW said:

    JohnO said:

    @tim - You're becoming a right old grump, snarling away, muttering semi-audible imprecations at passing posters gently going about their business.

    I'd kind of sympathize but I'm too busy laughing. But caringly; be assured of that.

    Rarely has PB witnessed such selfless hilarity in the service of the site.

    No matter your location it has to be said that JohnO is beacon of decency to those Cheshire farmers in need of solace.

    Mere mortal PBers may only bask in your not inconsiderable shadow.

    He can be my other-half on the next sojourn to Bournemouth. Bit of sea-air will do him the power of good.
    Indeed so. The power of the knotted hankie and a side saddle donkey ride combined with vigorous sand castle making and a 99 ice cream cornet is not to be underestimated.



  • Options
    PlatoPlato Posts: 15,724
    Great blog from Hopi Sen http://hopisen.com/?p=5714

    I sometimes like to introduce myself to Labour party people as ‘the most right-wing person in the Labour party’. I’ve found it’s a very good way to avoid being invited to sit on committees, working groups or panels, which is my main aim in all interactions with Labour party activists and thinkers.

    I’m not sure if I’m really the most right-wing person in the Labour party (though as Brian Clough said, I’m in the top one). Instead I think I’m in the minority of people on the left who don’t quietly regard being on the right as being evidence of some gaping internal moral chasm.

    It’s not that I’m particularly right-wing which sets me apart, it’s that I don’t mind the idea of being thought right-wing...
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,783
    tim said:

    Suspect that being in the pocket of the tobacco companies is far more damaging.

    Did someone say "Bernie Ecclestone"?

  • Options
    MikeSmithsonMikeSmithson Posts: 7,382
    edited July 2013
    Will supporting cancer enducing products and excessive boozing be in the CON manifesto?

    Three cheers for CON MP Sarah Wollaston for speaking out against today's decisions.

    George Osborne has got this one wrong - surprise surprise.
    TGOHF said:

    tim said:

    Now Dave's personal alcohol policy goes as well.
    Stupid policy Dave made his own.

    Nick Sutton ‏@suttonnick
    After #cigarette packaging and minimum alcohol pricing, @drwollastonmp tells @bbcshaunley on #wato it's a "very sad day for public health"


    James Chapman (Mail) ‏@jameschappers
    Govt right to drop minimum alcohol pricing - political suicide in a cost of living election. Not so sure about plain cigarette packs

    Suspect that being in the pocket of the tobacco companies is far more damaging.

    A whole MP who wanted to go down the nanny state line - wooo good spot tim.

    Will minimum pricing and plain packets be in the Labour manifesto ?

  • Options
    JohnOJohnO Posts: 4,215
    ...And another say "I'm a pretty straight sort of guy"?
  • Options
    MarchesMarches Posts: 51

    tim said:


    Suspect that being in the pocket of the tobacco companies is far more damaging.

    Care to substantiate that smear?
    When does a smear become a deliberate lie?
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,523

    Will supporting cancer enducing products and excessive boozing be in the CON manifesto?

    Three cheers for CON MP Sarah Wollaston for speaking out against today's decisions.

    George Osborne has got this one wrong - surprise surprise.

    TGOHF said:

    tim said:

    Now Dave's personal alcohol policy goes as well.
    Stupid policy Dave made his own.

    Nick Sutton ‏@suttonnick
    After #cigarette packaging and minimum alcohol pricing, @drwollastonmp tells @bbcshaunley on #wato it's a "very sad day for public health"


    James Chapman (Mail) ‏@jameschappers
    Govt right to drop minimum alcohol pricing - political suicide in a cost of living election. Not so sure about plain cigarette packs

    Suspect that being in the pocket of the tobacco companies is far more damaging.

    A whole MP who wanted to go down the nanny state line - wooo good spot tim.

    Will minimum pricing and plain packets be in the Labour manifesto ?

    Smokers are national benefactors.

    They contribute more than their fair share in taxes and die earlier saving on pension costs.


  • Options
    RichardNabaviRichardNabavi Posts: 3,413
    @tim - So, you withdraw the comment. Good.
  • Options
    Ishmael_XIshmael_X Posts: 3,664
    TGOHF said:

    tim said:

    Now Dave's personal alcohol policy goes as well.
    Stupid policy Dave made his own.

    Nick Sutton ‏@suttonnick
    After #cigarette packaging and minimum alcohol pricing, @drwollastonmp tells @bbcshaunley on #wato it's a "very sad day for public health"


    James Chapman (Mail) ‏@jameschappers
    Govt right to drop minimum alcohol pricing - political suicide in a cost of living election. Not so sure about plain cigarette packs

    Suspect that being in the pocket of the tobacco companies is far more damaging.

    A whole MP who wanted to go down the nanny state line - wooo good spot tim.

    Will minimum pricing and plain packets be in the Labour manifesto ?

    You already live in a nanny state; if you doubt that why not go out shopping for an AK47 and a pint of laudanum? Let us know how you get on.

    Other states are like that too, so a simpler way of saying "nanny state" is "state".
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,783
    Sarah Wollaston only has to win one seat - the government has to win rather more.....


    Three cheers for CON MP Sarah Wollaston for speaking out against today's decisions.

    TGOHF said:

    tim said:

    Now Dave's personal alcohol policy goes as well.
    Stupid policy Dave made his own.

    Nick Sutton ‏@suttonnick
    After #cigarette packaging and minimum alcohol pricing, @drwollastonmp tells @bbcshaunley on #wato it's a "very sad day for public health"


    James Chapman (Mail) ‏@jameschappers
    Govt right to drop minimum alcohol pricing - political suicide in a cost of living election. Not so sure about plain cigarette packs

    Suspect that being in the pocket of the tobacco companies is far more damaging.

    A whole MP who wanted to go down the nanny state line - wooo good spot tim.

    Will minimum pricing and plain packets be in the Labour manifesto ?

  • Options
    RichardNabaviRichardNabavi Posts: 3,413
    The thing which puzzles me about the fag packet issue is why it's not an EU-wide decision. This strikes me as one of those rare cases where it would make sense to decide at EU level, as it's a regulation affecting the single market and also has big implications for cross-border trade (and of course for smuggling as well).

    The operation of the EU is sometimes very odd.
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,758

    Will supporting cancer enducing products and excessive boozing be in the CON manifesto?

    Three cheers for CON MP Sarah Wollaston for speaking out against today's decisions.

    George Osborne has got this one wrong - surprise surprise.

    TGOHF said:

    tim said:

    Now Dave's personal alcohol policy goes as well.
    Stupid policy Dave made his own.

    Nick Sutton ‏@suttonnick
    After #cigarette packaging and minimum alcohol pricing, @drwollastonmp tells @bbcshaunley on #wato it's a "very sad day for public health"


    James Chapman (Mail) ‏@jameschappers
    Govt right to drop minimum alcohol pricing - political suicide in a cost of living election. Not so sure about plain cigarette packs

    Suspect that being in the pocket of the tobacco companies is far more damaging.

    A whole MP who wanted to go down the nanny state line - wooo good spot tim.

    Will minimum pricing and plain packets be in the Labour manifesto ?

    Smokers are national benefactors.

    They contribute more than their fair share in taxes and die earlier saving on pension costs.


    martyrs to the nation's finances and they get no thanks for it.
  • Options
    JackWJackW Posts: 14,787
    @MikeSmithson

    "Will supporting cancer enducing products and excessive boozing be in the CON manifesto?"

    Only in Bedford which is also to be made an Enterprise Zone for research into the merits of broccoli quiche and the health consequences of drinking hair tonic amongst bus pass holders in the town.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,523

    Will supporting cancer enducing products and excessive boozing be in the CON manifesto?

    Three cheers for CON MP Sarah Wollaston for speaking out against today's decisions.

    George Osborne has got this one wrong - surprise surprise.

    TGOHF said:

    tim said:

    Now Dave's personal alcohol policy goes as well.
    Stupid policy Dave made his own.

    Nick Sutton ‏@suttonnick
    After #cigarette packaging and minimum alcohol pricing, @drwollastonmp tells @bbcshaunley on #wato it's a "very sad day for public health"


    James Chapman (Mail) ‏@jameschappers
    Govt right to drop minimum alcohol pricing - political suicide in a cost of living election. Not so sure about plain cigarette packs

    Suspect that being in the pocket of the tobacco companies is far more damaging.

    A whole MP who wanted to go down the nanny state line - wooo good spot tim.

    Will minimum pricing and plain packets be in the Labour manifesto ?

    Smokers are national benefactors.

    They contribute more than their fair share in taxes and die earlier saving on pension costs.


    martyrs to the nation's finances and they get no thanks for it.
    I know. I felt so guilty when I gave up smoking.

  • Options
    RichardNabaviRichardNabavi Posts: 3,413
    tim said:


    They're in the pocket of both tobacco companies and tobacco company linked lobbyists who they employ.

    Now you are just being ridiculous, and quite possibly libellous. List the donations if you want to claim they are 'in the pocket of tobacco companies'.

    As for Crosby, it is the most barmy smear since all that nonsense about Ashcroft. His company once did a job in Australia for the tobacco industry. So what?
  • Options
    PlatoPlato Posts: 15,724
    Uh ho...

    North West Tonight @BBCNWT
    IPPC looking into Hillsborough evidence say they have identified another 55 officers who appear to have changed statements. @HJC_Official
This discussion has been closed.