Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Local By-Election Preview : May 26th 2016

SystemSystem Posts: 11,698
edited May 2016 in General

imagepoliticalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Local By-Election Preview : May 26th 2016

Northallerton South (Con defence) on Hambleton
Result of council at last election (2015): Conservatives 27, United Kingdom Independence Party 1 (Conservative majority of 26)
Result of ward at last election (2015): Emboldened denotes elected
Conservatives 1,414, 758 (49%)
United Kingdom Independence Party 762 (26%)
Labour 739, 654 (25%)
Candidates duly nominated:

Read the full story here


«134

Comments

  • Options
    MP_SEMP_SE Posts: 3,642
    First like Leave.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    Second like a week today.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,355
    This is turning into farce and Victoria Derbyshire is not up to it. Remain seems to have the advantage due to the sense being talked by Salmon and Johnson. There does seem to be an undercurrent against over egging immigration
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,355
    Dianne James just came over terrible re doctors and immigration. Audience not happy with her
  • Options
    EPGEPG Posts: 6,013
    Cost of the EU per day per Briton, Alex? "Aboot half a Mars bar."
  • Options
    Bob__SykesBob__Sykes Posts: 1,176
    Don't know if the BBC deliberately engineered this but it's coming across as two obsessed ranting fruitcakes vs two reasonably moderate normal blokes.

    Remain is trouncing Leave here.
  • Options
    TimTim Posts: 44
    Victoria Derbyshire interrupting Leavers with counter-arguments and echoing Remainers. Predictable but still disappointing.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,116
    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."
  • Options
    EPGEPG Posts: 6,013

    Don't know if the BBC deliberately engineered this but it's coming across as two obsessed ranting fruitcakes vs two reasonably moderate normal blokes.

    Remain is trouncing Leave here.

    Diane James is meant to be one of the very best Ukip speakers.
    I mean, they could have asked Douglas Carswell.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,355
    Dianne James is just awful - she is the Stewart Rose of leave
  • Options
    Bob__SykesBob__Sykes Posts: 1,176
    Derbyshire being propositioned by an audience member a new lowlight. Or highlight, depending on your viewpoint....
  • Options

    trawl said:

    Casino_Royale - printed your blog post and gave it to two women at work I overheard in discussion; one tending towards Remain the other totally unsure and decrying the obviously biased daily diet of scaremongering. Don't know which they are going but the possible Remainer came back to me next day and praised the clarity. So another thank-you to you.

    Anecdote - was dealing with a Romanian lady last week. 30s, said she had been her 10-12 years and her kids have British passports. Asked me straight out how I was voting. Told her and frankly felt a bit awkward so stressed that it all about sovereignty for me. I needn't have worried; she explained that she too had the vote and was voting leave. "This is an island, and its different" she said and I grew a foot taller on the spot.

    Thanks trawl :-)

    Like you, I'm really struggling emotionally with this. My mood can turn on a sixpence depending upon a poll, or a single conversion!

    Thankfully, I'm away over the weekend for a much needed break.
    FPT Casino Royale, keep your chin up fellah.
    All we can offer is blood, toil, sweat and tears etc.
    I'm happy to vote for Leave even if I'm the only bugger that does.
    I've shared your blog post too with a couple of people I know. Both are fairly anti-political generally but found it interesting and moved them from DNV to Prob Leave.
  • Options
    JonathanJonathan Posts: 20,902
    Well this is what happens when you go up against the two strongest left-wing politicians in Westminster working together.

    Food for thought.
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,955

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,291
    Not watching the shit show...all too predictable having the woman who makes kay Burley look like a brain surgeon (and not the Ben Carson type) & has an impossible time hiding her personal views on subjects.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    Jonathan said:

    Well this is what happens when you go up against the two strongest left-wing politicians in Westminster working together.

    Food for thought.

    Not a universal view. This guy is a Labour councillor

    @alexgallagher2: Astonishing how this EU debate mirrors #indyref debate. UKIP, SNP, right-wing Tory. No real difference. https://t.co/P74qeS1b2X
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    This does seem to be the soundbite of the night

    @jessicaelgot: We don't know what will happen if we leave, says Diane James, there is no plan. Apparently speaking in support of leave.
  • Options
    Tissue_PriceTissue_Price Posts: 9,039
    edited May 2016
    Stapenhill is in my constituency, though not my patch. I'd be surprised to see UKIP hold - Labour must be favs, but the extra candidates (the Ind is ex-Lab) might let the Tory through the middle.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,503

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.
  • Options
    saddenedsaddened Posts: 2,245

    Not watching the shit show...all too predictable having the woman who makes kay Burley look like a brain surgeon (and not the Ben Carson type) & has an impossible time hiding her personal views on subjects.

    Nothing to do with the relative quality of the arguments, just turned off the shit moderator?
  • Options
    JackWJackW Posts: 14,787
    Jonathan said:

    Well this is what happens when you go up against the two strongest left-wing politicians in Westminster working together.

    Food for thought.

    And then there's Jezza ....

    Food for sharks ... the Conservative kind.
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,196

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    If Leave do win, it will be a damming indictment of politics in this country.
  • Options
    chestnutchestnut Posts: 7,341

    Not watching the shit show...all too predictable having the woman who makes kay Burley look like a brain surgeon (and not the Ben Carson type) & has an impossible time hiding her personal views on subjects.

    Bunch of kids in the audience?

    When's the pensioner only debate?
  • Options
    FPT

    ***** Betting Post *****

    Evidencing the influence of PB.com, OGH's passed-on tip yesterday suggesting John Hickenlooper as Hillary's Veep, has seen his odds tumble from 80/1 to just 16/1 (with Laddies and Betfair Sportsbook) .... hardly any sort of value imho.
    However what caught my eye was Betfair Exchange's price of 1000 (949/1 net of commission) against the aforementioned Hickenlooper becoming the Democratic POTUS nominee. Should he become her running mate, then he'd only be a heartbeat/resignation/removal/etc. away.
    When I first looked a few minutes ago, there was £109 worth on offer at these not insubstantial odds (prepare to eat your heart out Morris btw) and after I'd taken the plunge, there should now be just £107 left!
    DYOR.
  • Options
    EPGEPG Posts: 6,013

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Mr Gove says no responsible government would actually start leaving straight away after a LEAVE vote. Boris thinks LEAVE just means he should get to negotiate the terms of REMAIN as Prime Minister. Clown show.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,116
    Scott_P said:

    This does seem to be the soundbite of the night

    @jessicaelgot: We don't know what will happen if we leave, says Diane James, there is no plan. Apparently speaking in support of leave.

    It's almost like they'd rather lose so they can blame Cameron for not being on their side.
  • Options
    LadyBucketLadyBucket Posts: 590
    Victoria Derbyshire is DIRE. Her scratchy voice just gives me a headache. Alex Salmond is just bloody rude, he just can't resist making personal comments.
  • Options
    94432a194432a1 Posts: 11

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.
    Yes, exactly.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,503

    trawl said:

    Casino_Royale - printed your blog post and gave it to two women at work I overheard in discussion; one tending towards Remain the other totally unsure and decrying the obviously biased daily diet of scaremongering. Don't know which they are going but the possible Remainer came back to me next day and praised the clarity. So another thank-you to you.

    Anecdote - was dealing with a Romanian lady last week. 30s, said she had been her 10-12 years and her kids have British passports. Asked me straight out how I was voting. Told her and frankly felt a bit awkward so stressed that it all about sovereignty for me. I needn't have worried; she explained that she too had the vote and was voting leave. "This is an island, and its different" she said and I grew a foot taller on the spot.

    Thanks trawl :-)

    Like you, I'm really struggling emotionally with this. My mood can turn on a sixpence depending upon a poll, or a single conversion!

    Thankfully, I'm away over the weekend for a much needed break.
    FPT Casino Royale, keep your chin up fellah.
    All we can offer is blood, toil, sweat and tears etc.
    I'm happy to vote for Leave even if I'm the only bugger that does.
    I've shared your blog post too with a couple of people I know. Both are fairly anti-political generally but found it interesting and moved them from DNV to Prob Leave.
    Thanks mate :-)

    Worst thing for me is Leavers moving to Remainers, particularly off the back of the Government's incessant fear propaganda. It really depresses me.

    Where's our courage, self-belief and confidence we can build a brighter future for ourselves, and give leadership to those in Europe also desperate for self-governance again?

    We mustn't let the buggers win.
  • Options
    Bob__SykesBob__Sykes Posts: 1,176

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.
    That would have been the case if this had been a referendum on a new EU treaty. No would have won by a landslide and the EU would have given us whatever we wanted.

    Instead Cameron forced a vote through on the very question of our membership. The idea of negotiating a new deal after Leave is risible. Vote Leave - and we're Out.
  • Options
    94432a194432a1 Posts: 11
    The debate is currently on the issue of visas. However, the UK has visa free travel to a very large amount of countries such as Korea, Japan, Brazil, Haiti and so on. This is really basic knowledge and I cannot understand how professional politicians and professional journalists do not know this.

  • Options
    chestnutchestnut Posts: 7,341

    Worst thing for me is Leavers moving to Remainers, particularly off the back of the Government's incessant fear propaganda. It really depresses me.

    There is precious little evidence of that really happening.

    People are just digging in and peddling the usual lines.

    How often does anyone offer a surprising perspective on events?
  • Options
    Bob__SykesBob__Sykes Posts: 1,176
    So 50% of the undecided audience members have now made up their minds - wow, as VD put it. But we didn't get to find out how it broke down!

    Crap show;, crap ending!
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @UKLabour: The Leave campaign just summed up their whole campaign in four words. RT if you agree → #BBCDebate #wejustdontknow https://t.co/MMAIhXUPQA
  • Options
    JonathanJonathan Posts: 20,902
    JackW said:

    Jonathan said:

    Well this is what happens when you go up against the two strongest left-wing politicians in Westminster working together.

    Food for thought.

    And then there's Jezza ....

    Food for sharks ... the Conservative kind.
    The Conservative kind? That's the only type of shark there is. Fortunately said sharks seem happy to chew on gas canisters.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,503
    saddened said:

    Not watching the shit show...all too predictable having the woman who makes kay Burley look like a brain surgeon (and not the Ben Carson type) & has an impossible time hiding her personal views on subjects.

    Nothing to do with the relative quality of the arguments, just turned off the shit moderator?
    I don't want to encourage the Remain herd, but Diane James has been woeful. She started off the first question by talking about "foreigners", to an audience of 18-29 year olds. I actually hid behind my fingers.

    Liam Fox was slow-witted and well below par.
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,955

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.

    I really admire your passion, but I disagree. If we vote Leave when will we leave? You don't know. You don't know if we'll retain free movement or scrap it, you don't know if we'll still contribute to the EU budget or be bound by EU laws. You don't even know who'll be doing the negotiating. It's a complete leap in the dark and one that could cause real damage to a very fragile European recovery. Again, we don't know.

  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,503

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.
    That would have been the case if this had been a referendum on a new EU treaty. No would have won by a landslide and the EU would have given us whatever we wanted.

    Instead Cameron forced a vote through on the very question of our membership. The idea of negotiating a new deal after Leave is risible. Vote Leave - and we're Out.
    If you think the UK-EU wouldn't agree a trade treaty after a Leave vote then I'm afraid we'll just have to agree to disagree.

    The Remain campaign is game theory, designed to maximise fear and uncertainty precisely so you do vote Remain.

    A deal would be done.
  • Options
    MonikerDiCanioMonikerDiCanio Posts: 5,792

    Victoria Derbyshire is DIRE. Her scratchy voice just gives me a headache. Alex Salmond is just bloody rude, he just can't resist making personal comments.

    Salmond is a gift to Leave. Even ScottP must be tempted to see reason and join the just.
  • Options
    chestnutchestnut Posts: 7,341
    Britain Elects
    @britainelects
    Scotland // On a second #IndyRef in the event of a vote for Brexit:
    Support: 44%
    Oppose: 48%
    (via ICM)

    Brexit no excuse for another Sindy.
  • Options
    MP_SEMP_SE Posts: 3,642

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.

    I really admire your passion, but I disagree. If we vote Leave when will we leave? You don't know. You don't know if we'll retain free movement or scrap it, you don't know if we'll still contribute to the EU budget or be bound by EU laws. You don't even know who'll be doing the negotiating. It's a complete leap in the dark and one that could cause real damage to a very fragile European recovery. Again, we don't know.

    In your opinion would EFTA+EEA be a leap in the dark?
  • Options

    trawl said:

    Casino_Royale - printed your blog post and gave it to two women at work I overheard in discussion; one tending towards Remain the other totally unsure and decrying the obviously biased daily diet of scaremongering. Don't know which they are going but the possible Remainer came back to me next day and praised the clarity. So another thank-you to you.

    Anecdote - was dealing with a Romanian lady last week. 30s, said she had been her 10-12 years and her kids have British passports. Asked me straight out how I was voting. Told her and frankly felt a bit awkward so stressed that it all about sovereignty for me. I needn't have worried; she explained that she too had the vote and was voting leave. "This is an island, and its different" she said and I grew a foot taller on the spot.

    Thanks trawl :-)

    Like you, I'm really struggling emotionally with this. My mood can turn on a sixpence depending upon a poll, or a single conversion!

    Thankfully, I'm away over the weekend for a much needed break.
    FPT Casino Royale, keep your chin up fellah.
    All we can offer is blood, toil, sweat and tears etc.
    I'm happy to vote for Leave even if I'm the only bugger that does.
    I've shared your blog post too with a couple of people I know. Both are fairly anti-political generally but found it interesting and moved them from DNV to Prob Leave.
    Thanks mate :-)

    Worst thing for me is Leavers moving to Remainers, particularly off the back of the Government's incessant fear propaganda. It really depresses me.

    Where's our courage, self-belief and confidence we can build a brighter future for ourselves, and give leadership to those in Europe also desperate for self-governance again?

    We mustn't let the buggers win.
    Casino - By common consent, even including Remainers like Mr. Nabavi, your blogpost was one of the very best pieces to appear throughout the entire EU referendum debate so far.
    Please be good enough to repeat the link thereto, so that those PBers who originally missed it may now acquaint themselves.
  • Options
    OK, so here are a few questions that I had hoped would be asked/answered tonight:
    1. Economy
    a. What is the difference between Single Market membership and Single Market access?
    b. What is the cost, both financial and non-financial of Single Market membership versus cost of Single Market access?
    c. Is there a difference between how the cost for membership is paid versus cost of access (i.e. is membership paid for by governments (every taxpayer) whereas access is paid by companies (every customer) trading into the Single Market)
    d. Are there examples that can be given to show the cost of Single Market membership versus the cost of Single Market access?
    e. The Prime Minister has said he would invoke Article 50 the day after a Leave result. At that point, let’s say on June 24, what difference will that make to our trading relationships with countries such as USA etc?
    f. At what point in the future would there be a significant change to our trading relationships with countries such as the USA etc. in the event of a Leave vote and why?
    g. Additionally, on June 24th, what difference will there be to our trading relationships with members of the EU in the event of a Leave vote?
    h. At what point in the future would there be a significant change to our trading relationships with members of the EU in the event of a Leave vote, why and what do we expect the changes to be?
    i. What are the risks to our Financial Services industry in the event of a Leave vote, what is the likelihood of that risk turning into an issue (i.e. becoming reality) and what are the mitigating factors that the UK government could take.
    j. What are the risks to our Financial Services Industry in the event of a Remain vote what is the likelihood of that risk turning into an issue (i.e. becoming reality) and what are the mitigating factors that the UK government could take.
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,955
    SeanT said:

    trawl said:

    Casino_Royale - printed your blog post and gave it to two women at work I overheard in discussion; one tending towards Remain the other totally unsure and decrying the obviously biased daily diet of scaremongering. Don't know which they are going but the possible Remainer came back to me next day and praised the clarity. So another thank-you to you.

    Anecdote - was dealing with a Romanian lady last week. 30s, said she had been her 10-12 years and her kids have British passports. Asked me straight out how I was voting. Told her and frankly felt a bit awkward so stressed that it all about sovereignty for me. I needn't have worried; she explained that she too had the vote and was voting leave. "This is an island, and its different" she said and I grew a foot taller on the spot.

    Thanks trawl :-)

    Like you, I'm really struggling emotionally with this. My mood can turn on a sixpence depending upon a poll, or a single conversion!

    Thankfully, I'm away over the weekend for a much needed break.
    FPT Casino Royale, keep your chin up fellah.
    All we can offer is blood, toil, sweat and tears etc.
    I'm happy to vote for Leave even if I'm the only bugger that does.
    I've shared your blog post too with a couple of people I know. Both are fairly anti-political generally but found it interesting and moved them from DNV to Prob Leave.
    Thanks mate :-)

    Worst thing for me is Leavers moving to Remainers, particularly off the back of the Government's incessant fear propaganda. It really depresses me.

    Where's our courage, self-belief and confidence we can build a brighter future for ourselves, and give leadership to those in Europe also desperate for self-governance again?

    We mustn't let the buggers win.
    The buggers are going to win. We just have to make sure that we win NEXT time. And there will be a next time.

    If Casino Royale is right there will definitely be a next time and Leave will win. If it doesn't win this time.

  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,355
    The first debate was a car crash for leave with Diane James being the driver and Victoria Derbyshire the co-driver. Seemed the undecided broke for remain when asked at the end of the debate.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453

    Salmond is a gift to Leave. Even ScottP must be tempted to see reason and join the just.

    I enjoy his contorted hypocrisy too much

    Swap UK for EU in each of his arguments. It's hilarious.
  • Options
    JackWJackW Posts: 14,787

    Thanks mate :-)

    Worst thing for me is Leavers moving to Remainers, particularly off the back of the Government's incessant fear propaganda. It really depresses me.

    Where's our courage, self-belief and confidence we can build a brighter future for ourselves, and give leadership to those in Europe also desperate for self-governance again?

    We mustn't let the buggers win.

    Unless there's a black swan event blacker than the blackest black hole then the REMAIN "buggers" have won.

    And that my dear fellow is the harsh truth.

  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,503

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.

    I really admire your passion, but I disagree. If we vote Leave when will we leave? You don't know. You don't know if we'll retain free movement or scrap it, you don't know if we'll still contribute to the EU budget or be bound by EU laws. You don't even know who'll be doing the negotiating. It's a complete leap in the dark and one that could cause real damage to a very fragile European recovery. Again, we don't know.

    I suggest you read my blog on this - what does "Leave" look like: https://royaleleseaux.wordpress.com/2016/05/22/eu-referendum-the-choice/
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,503
    JackW said:

    Thanks mate :-)

    Worst thing for me is Leavers moving to Remainers, particularly off the back of the Government's incessant fear propaganda. It really depresses me.

    Where's our courage, self-belief and confidence we can build a brighter future for ourselves, and give leadership to those in Europe also desperate for self-governance again?

    We mustn't let the buggers win.

    Unless there's a black swan event blacker than the blackest black hole then the REMAIN "buggers" have won.

    And that my dear fellow is the harsh truth.

    Still four weeks to go. And still some polls very close.

    You are probably right. But a 75% chance of a Remain victory does not equal an 100% chance.
  • Options
    By the way, Victoria Derbyshire should never be allowed to be in charge of a serious debate ever again. She is awful.
  • Options
    weejonnieweejonnie Posts: 3,820

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.

    I really admire your passion, but I disagree. If we vote Leave when will we leave? You don't know. You don't know if we'll retain free movement or scrap it, you don't know if we'll still contribute to the EU budget or be bound by EU laws. You don't even know who'll be doing the negotiating. It's a complete leap in the dark and one that could cause real damage to a very fragile European recovery. Again, we don't know.

    And if we remain - then we are in the dark as to what new policies Europe will force us to accept - we can be sure that they will be to the benefit of the continent and only of benefit to us by happenstance.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    SeanT said:

    The buggers are going to win.

    Which way is this guy voting?

    @thomasknox: My head says, very reluctantly, REMAIN. My heart says LEAVE!!!!!!
    "The heart has its reasons of which reason knows nothing".
  • Options
    chestnutchestnut Posts: 7,341

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.

    I really admire your passion, but I disagree. If we vote Leave when will we leave? You don't know. You don't know if we'll retain free movement or scrap it, you don't know if we'll still contribute to the EU budget or be bound by EU laws. You don't even know who'll be doing the negotiating. It's a complete leap in the dark and one that could cause real damage to a very fragile European recovery. Again, we don't know.

    Perhaps you can advise:

    1) Accession dates for Albania, Montenegro, Macdeonia, Serbia, Turkey:
    2) Future budgets for Britain if they enter:
    3) Shape and form of Common Immigration and Asylum Policy:
    4) Future of Trial by Jury;
    5) The EU Army?
    6) Harmonisation plans for taxes, welfare ,minimum wage, pensions
    7) Future grabs at Ukraine;
    8) Date when we can expect free trade deals with US, Australia, Korea etc:
    9) End date of Eurozone stagnation;

    Or is Remain a leap in the dark?
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,355

    OK, so here are a few questions that I had hoped would be asked/answered tonight:
    1. Economy
    a. What is the difference between Single Market membership and Single Market access?
    b. What is the cost, both financial and non-financial of Single Market membership versus cost of Single Market access?
    c. Is there a difference between how the cost for membership is paid versus cost of access (i.e. is membership paid for by governments (every taxpayer) whereas access is paid by companies (every customer) trading into the Single Market)
    d. Are there examples that can be given to show the cost of Single Market membership versus the cost of Single Market access?
    e. The Prime Minister has said he would invoke Article 50 the day after a Leave result. At that point, let’s say on June 24, what difference will that make to our trading relationships with countries such as USA etc?
    f. At what point in the future would there be a significant change to our trading relationships with countries such as the USA etc. in the event of a Leave vote and why?
    g. Additionally, on June 24th, what difference will there be to our trading relationships with members of the EU in the event of a Leave vote?
    h. At what point in the future would there be a significant change to our trading relationships with members of the EU in the event of a Leave vote, why and what do we expect the changes to be?
    i. What are the risks to our Financial Services industry in the event of a Leave vote, what is the likelihood of that risk turning into an issue (i.e. becoming reality) and what are the mitigating factors that the UK government could take.
    j. What are the risks to our Financial Services Industry in the event of a Remain vote what is the likelihood of that risk turning into an issue (i.e. becoming reality) and what are the mitigating factors that the UK government could take.

    Good questions for the Westminster bubble but the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives
  • Options

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.

    I really admire your passion, but I disagree. If we vote Leave when will we leave? You don't know. You don't know if we'll retain free movement or scrap it, you don't know if we'll still contribute to the EU budget or be bound by EU laws. You don't even know who'll be doing the negotiating. It's a complete leap in the dark and one that could cause real damage to a very fragile European recovery. Again, we don't know.

    I suggest you read my blog on this - what does "Leave" look like: https://royaleleseaux.wordpress.com/2016/05/22/eu-referendum-the-choice/
    You must have been reading my mind!
  • Options
    94432a194432a1 Posts: 11

    By the way, Victoria Derbyshire should never be allowed to be in charge of a serious debate ever again. She is awful.

    Your questions are exactly what should be being asked so that there can be open information and an informed vote.
  • Options
    EPGEPG Posts: 6,013
    edited May 2016
    chestnut said:

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.

    I really admire your passion, but I disagree. If we vote Leave when will we leave? You don't know. You don't know if we'll retain free movement or scrap it, you don't know if we'll still contribute to the EU budget or be bound by EU laws. You don't even know who'll be doing the negotiating. It's a complete leap in the dark and one that could cause real damage to a very fragile European recovery. Again, we don't know.

    Perhaps you can advise:

    1) Accession dates for Albania, Montenegro, Macdeonia, Serbia, Turkey:
    2) Future budgets for Britain if they enter:
    3) Shape and form of Common Immigration and Asylum Policy:
    4) Future of Trial by Jury;
    5) The EU Army?
    6) Harmonisation plans for taxes, welfare ,minimum wage, pensions
    7) Future grabs at Ukraine;
    8) Date when we can expect free trade deals with US, Australia, Korea etc:
    9) End date of Eurozone stagnation;

    Or is Remain a leap in the dark?
    "grabs at Ukraine"
    great, another putinist for leave
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,503

    trawl said:

    Casino_Royale - printed your blog post and gave it to two women at work I overheard in discussion; one tending towards Remain the other totally unsure and decrying the obviously biased daily diet of scaremongering. Don't know which they are going but the possible Remainer came back to me next day and praised the clarity. So another thank-you to you.

    Anecdote - was dealing with a Romanian lady last week. 30s, said she had been her 10-12 years and her kids have British passports. Asked me straight out how I was voting. Told her and frankly felt a bit awkward so stressed that it all about sovereignty for me. I needn't have worried; she explained that she too had the vote and was voting leave. "This is an island, and its different" she said and I grew a foot taller on the spot.

    Thanks trawl :-)

    Like you, I'm really struggling emotionally with this. My mood can turn on a sixpence depending upon a poll, or a single conversion!

    Thankfully, I'm away over the weekend for a much needed break.
    FPT Casino Royale, keep your chin up fellah.
    All we can offer is blood, toil, sweat and tears etc.
    I'm happy to vote for Leave even if I'm the only bugger that does.
    I've shared your blog post too with a couple of people I know. Both are fairly anti-political generally but found it interesting and moved them from DNV to Prob Leave.
    Thanks mate :-)

    Worst thing for me is Leavers moving to Remainers, particularly off the back of the Government's incessant fear propaganda. It really depresses me.

    Where's our courage, self-belief and confidence we can build a brighter future for ourselves, and give leadership to those in Europe also desperate for self-governance again?

    We mustn't let the buggers win.
    Casino - By common consent, even including Remainers like Mr. Nabavi, your blogpost was one of the very best pieces to appear throughout the entire EU referendum debate so far.
    Please be good enough to repeat the link thereto, so that those PBers who originally missed it may now acquaint themselves.
    Thanks :-) Just posted it for SO downthread.

    Going to sign off now. Very tired today (and have been misfiring and tetchy all day) so I'm off to pack for the weekend, and read my new book.

    Night all.
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,052
    SeanT said:

    trawl said:

    Casino_Royale - printed your blog post and gave it to two women at work I overheard in discussion; one tending towards Remain the other totally unsure and decrying the obviously biased daily diet of scaremongering. Don't know which they are going but the possible Remainer came back to me next day and praised the clarity. So another thank-you to you.

    Anecdote - was dealing with a Romanian lady last week. 30s, said she had been her 10-12 years and her kids have British passports. Asked me straight out how I was voting. Told her and frankly felt a bit awkward so stressed that it all about sovereignty for me. I needn't have worried; she explained that she too had the vote and was voting leave. "This is an island, and its different" she said and I grew a foot taller on the spot.

    Thanks trawl :-)

    Like you, I'm really struggling emotionally with this. My mood can turn on a sixpence depending upon a poll, or a single conversion!

    Thankfully, I'm away over the weekend for a much needed break.
    FPT Casino Royale, keep your chin up fellah.
    All we can offer is blood, toil, sweat and tears etc.
    I'm happy to vote for Leave even if I'm the only bugger that does.
    I've shared your blog post too with a couple of people I know. Both are fairly anti-political generally but found it interesting and moved them from DNV to Prob Leave.
    Thanks mate :-)

    Worst thing for me is Leavers moving to Remainers, particularly off the back of the Government's incessant fear propaganda. It really depresses me.

    Where's our courage, self-belief and confidence we can build a brighter future for ourselves, and give leadership to those in Europe also desperate for self-governance again?

    We mustn't let the buggers win.
    The buggers are going to win. We just have to make sure that we win NEXT time. And there will be a next time.
    We'll win as soon as we settle on EFTA/EEA. Really, this wouldn't be a contest if the leading lights of Leave had gone with that option.

    Being Norway or Switzerland is not as scary as being Albania.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    SeanT said:

    Look at today's horrendous immigration stats. Unsustainable.

    The ones where more people came from outside the EU than in?
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,052
    chestnut said:

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.

    I really admire your passion, but I disagree. If we vote Leave when will we leave? You don't know. You don't know if we'll retain free movement or scrap it, you don't know if we'll still contribute to the EU budget or be bound by EU laws. You don't even know who'll be doing the negotiating. It's a complete leap in the dark and one that could cause real damage to a very fragile European recovery. Again, we don't know.

    Perhaps you can advise:

    1) Accession dates for Albania, Montenegro, Macdeonia, Serbia, Turkey:
    2) Future budgets for Britain if they enter:
    3) Shape and form of Common Immigration and Asylum Policy:
    4) Future of Trial by Jury;
    5) The EU Army?
    6) Harmonisation plans for taxes, welfare ,minimum wage, pensions
    7) Future grabs at Ukraine;
    8) Date when we can expect free trade deals with US, Australia, Korea etc:
    9) End date of Eurozone stagnation;

    Or is Remain a leap in the dark?
    Oh please drop Turkey. It's stupid.
  • Options
    chestnutchestnut Posts: 7,341

    the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives

    Your house costs more because migration is out of hand?
    Your wages are poor because you are being undercut?

    I think you may be right.


  • Options
    EPGEPG Posts: 6,013
    rcs1000 said:

    SeanT said:

    trawl said:

    Casino_Royale - printed your blog post and gave it to two women at work I overheard in discussion; one tending towards Remain the other totally unsure and decrying the obviously biased daily diet of scaremongering. Don't know which they are going but the possible Remainer came back to me next day and praised the clarity. So another thank-you to you.

    Anecdote - was dealing with a Romanian lady last week. 30s, said she had been her 10-12 years and her kids have British passports. Asked me straight out how I was voting. Told her and frankly felt a bit awkward so stressed that it all about sovereignty for me. I needn't have worried; she explained that she too had the vote and was voting leave. "This is an island, and its different" she said and I grew a foot taller on the spot.

    Thanks trawl :-)

    Like you, I'm really struggling emotionally with this. My mood can turn on a sixpence depending upon a poll, or a single conversion!

    Thankfully, I'm away over the weekend for a much needed break.
    FPT Casino Royale, keep your chin up fellah.
    All we can offer is blood, toil, sweat and tears etc.
    I'm happy to vote for Leave even if I'm the only bugger that does.
    I've shared your blog post too with a couple of people I know. Both are fairly anti-political generally but found it interesting and moved them from DNV to Prob Leave.
    Thanks mate :-)

    Worst thing for me is Leavers moving to Remainers, particularly off the back of the Government's incessant fear propaganda. It really depresses me.

    Where's our courage, self-belief and confidence we can build a brighter future for ourselves, and give leadership to those in Europe also desperate for self-governance again?

    We mustn't let the buggers win.
    The buggers are going to win. We just have to make sure that we win NEXT time. And there will be a next time.
    We'll win as soon as we settle on EFTA/EEA. Really, this wouldn't be a contest if the leading lights of Leave had gone with that option.

    Being Norway or Switzerland is not as scary as being Albania.
    There aren't enough clever low-tax hard-liberal Swiss types on the leave side for that to work.
    Maybe on PB, but any leave majority in the country will rely on people who fear foreigners, Islam, terrorism and migration more than economic uncertainty.
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,291
    Scott_P said:

    SeanT said:

    Look at today's horrendous immigration stats. Unsustainable.

    The ones where more people came from outside the EU than in?
    So you are saying the government have failed even more on the aspect they can control than the part they can't....
  • Options
    chestnutchestnut Posts: 7,341
    rcs1000 said:

    Oh please drop Turkey. It's stupid.

    Moreso than no one will be able to go on holiday after Brexit? That no one will be able to trade?

    Be serious.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    SeanT said:

    You're just detestable.

    This does seem to be the consensus view...
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,355

    By the way, Victoria Derbyshire should never be allowed to be in charge of a serious debate ever again. She is awful.

    So is her daily show on BBC. She was out of her depth tonight but to be fair she only finished 30 days of chemo today so you have to admire her for that reason alone
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,041

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.

    I really admire your passion, but I disagree. If we vote Leave when will we leave? You don't know. You don't know if we'll retain free movement or scrap it, you don't know if we'll still contribute to the EU budget or be bound by EU laws. You don't even know who'll be doing the negotiating. It's a complete leap in the dark and one that could cause real damage to a very fragile European recovery. Again, we don't know.

    Absolutely right, Mr SO!
  • Options
    JonathanJonathan Posts: 20,902
    Never seen one side of an election/referendum give up so early.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,355
    chestnut said:

    the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives

    Your house costs more because migration is out of hand?
    Your wages are poor because you are being undercut?

    I think you may be right.


    Answer to first is build more homes and second the new National Living wage applies to all
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,137

    So 50% of the undecided audience members have now made up their minds - wow, as VD put it. But we didn't get to find out how it broke down!

    Crap show;, crap ending!

    Any show hosted by Victoria Derbyshire was always going to generate more shite than light.
  • Options

    OK, so here are a few questions that I had hoped would be asked/answered tonight:
    1. Economy
    a. What is the difference between Single Market membership and Single Market access?
    b. What is the cost, both financial and non-financial of Single Market membership versus cost of Single Market access?
    c. Is there a difference between how the cost for membership is paid versus cost of access (i.e. is membership paid for by governments (every taxpayer) whereas access is paid by companies (every customer) trading into the Single Market)
    d. Are there examples that can be given to show the cost of Single Market membership versus the cost of Single Market access?
    e. The Prime Minister has said he would invoke Article 50 the day after a Leave result. At that point, let’s say on June 24, what difference will that make to our trading relationships with countries such as USA etc?
    f. At what point in the future would there be a significant change to our trading relationships with countries such as the USA etc. in the event of a Leave vote and why?
    g. Additionally, on June 24th, what difference will there be to our trading relationships with members of the EU in the event of a Leave vote?
    h. At what point in the future would there be a significant change to our trading relationships with members of the EU in the event of a Leave vote, why and what do we expect the changes to be?
    i. What are the risks to our Financial Services industry in the event of a Leave vote, what is the likelihood of that risk turning into an issue (i.e. becoming reality) and what are the mitigating factors that the UK government could take.
    j. What are the risks to our Financial Services Industry in the event of a Remain vote what is the likelihood of that risk turning into an issue (i.e. becoming reality) and what are the mitigating factors that the UK government could take.

    Good questions for the Westminster bubble but the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives
    Mr NorthWales,

    These questions aren't meant for the Westminster Bubble. They are mean't for me to help me clarify the biggest democratic decision I've had to make for decades.

    I am really disappointed at the level of debate over this referendum from politicians both nationally and internationally.

    Vote Leave OTHERWISE this will happen. Vote Remain OTHERWISE this will happen.

    How about:

    Vote Leave BECAUSE this will happen. Vote Remain BECAUSE this will happen.

    Both sides are trying to motivate us to move away from the other's position. Moving towards something is a much better motivator in my mind (being an optimist)

  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,291
    edited May 2016

    By the way, Victoria Derbyshire should never be allowed to be in charge of a serious debate ever again. She is awful.

    So is her daily show on BBC. She was out of her depth tonight but to be fair she only finished 30 days of chemo today so you have to admire her for that reason alone
    You actually watch her show...you must be one of the couple of coach loads that do. How she got her good gigs at the BBC is a very interesting story & involved ruining the career of a far more intelligent presenter.
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,052
    EPG said:

    rcs1000 said:

    SeanT said:


    The buggers are going to win. We just have to make sure that we win NEXT time. And there will be a next time.

    We'll win as soon as we settle on EFTA/EEA. Really, this wouldn't be a contest if the leading lights of Leave had gone with that option.

    Being Norway or Switzerland is not as scary as being Albania.
    There aren't enough clever low-tax hard-liberal Swiss types on the leave side for that to work.
    Maybe on PB, but any leave majority in the country will rely on people who fear foreigners, Islam, terrorism and migration more than economic uncertainty.
    Firstly, even in the non-EFTA/EEA scenario. we're not going to require visas for EU citizens, are we? So, the 'terrorism', etc., argument is bullshit all round.

    Secondly, EFTA/EEA does not mean that we need to pay benefits to non-citizens. Switzerland, for example, allows EU citizens to work there, but does not give benefits. If you remove the (in-work) benefits from migrants you massively cut their numbers. Plus, you can easily add compulsory health insurance for non-residents that means that the UK becomes a very unattractive destination for low-skilled migrants.

    Thirdly and finally, there are a lot of businesses who regard their order of preference as EFTA/EEA > EU > CO. If it's CO vs EU, they come down with the devil they know.

    So: no negative impacts on the ability of British firms to export (particularly services) to the EU. A massively reduced bill. No primacy of EU law. And substantially reduced immigration.

    Really, I'm struggling to think of the disadvantages.
  • Options
    MonikerDiCanioMonikerDiCanio Posts: 5,792
    Jonathan said:

    Never seen one side of an election/referendum give up so early.

    Kinnockian delusion.
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,896
    I think it's logical that most left-wingers, realising that there is no chance of a " progressive majority" in this country, should favour Remain. As would Scottish, Welsh, and Irish nationalists, who bear this country nothing but ill-will.

    I find it hard to understand what right-wing voters would find attractive about the EU. It places restraints on our basic centre right majority, and means transferring powers away from that majority.
  • Options
    MarkHopkinsMarkHopkins Posts: 5,584
    Jonathan said:

    Never seen one side of an election/referendum give up so early.


    Oh, has Remain given up?
  • Options
    Oh, and by the way:
    2. Sovereignty
    a. It has been stated by Leave that we have voted against EU proposals and have been out voted 70 times. Are there any items that can be pointed to where any of these proposals have been to the significant detriment of the UK once becoming EU law
    b. What is the role of the unelected Commissionaires versus the role of the elected MEPs
    c. How often have the MEPs rejected proposals put forward by the Commissionaires (i.e. is there a democratic process at the heart of the EU that is working)
    d. In the event of a Leave vote, what areas of law-making and court judgements would be different as opposed to areas that would continue to be influenced by the ECJ/ECHR
  • Options
    JonathanJonathan Posts: 20,902
    Plenty of people already talking about the next referendum already. It's rather sad.
  • Options
    MarkHopkinsMarkHopkins Posts: 5,584

    chestnut said:

    the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives

    Your house costs more because migration is out of hand?
    Your wages are poor because you are being undercut?

    I think you may be right.


    Answer to first is build more homes and second the new National Living wage applies to all

    We're not building more homes, so the problem is only getting worse.

  • Options
    weejonnieweejonnie Posts: 3,820

    chestnut said:

    the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives

    Your house costs more because migration is out of hand?
    Your wages are poor because you are being undercut?

    I think you may be right.


    Answer to first is build more homes and second the new National Living wage applies to all
    Except that there is very little sensible area to build houses and the National Living wage does not apply in Eastern Europe or China the last time I looked.
  • Options
    PS: I can't believe I put an apostrophe in "meant" in that first post. Apologies to all but the Sancerre is rather nice tonight :)
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,355

    By the way, Victoria Derbyshire should never be allowed to be in charge of a serious debate ever again. She is awful.

    So is her daily show on BBC. She was out of her depth tonight but to be fair she only finished 30 days of chemo today so you have to admire her for that reason alone
    You actually watch her show...you must be one of the couple of coach loads that do. How she got her good gigs at the BBC is a very interesting story & involved ruining the career of a far more intelligent presenter.
    I absolutely do not - it drives me straight to Sky
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,955
    MP_SE said:

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.

    I really admire your passion, but I disagree. If we vote Leave when will we leave? You don't know. You don't know if we'll retain free movement or scrap it, you don't know if we'll still contribute to the EU budget or be bound by EU laws. You don't even know who'll be doing the negotiating. It's a complete leap in the dark and one that could cause real damage to a very fragile European recovery. Again, we don't know.

    In your opinion would EFTA+EEA be a leap in the dark?

    No - but it looks to be politically impossible.

  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,041

    chestnut said:

    the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives

    Your house costs more because migration is out of hand?
    Your wages are poor because you are being undercut?

    I think you may be right.


    Answer to first is build more homes and second the new National Living wage applies to all
    My (voting Remain) granddaughter has just shared this on Facebook. It’s from a George Bevan. I’m not posting the whole of it, but as far as taking our jobs are concerned he says "maybe, if an immigrant with no contacts, no skills and no local knowledge of the language and/or culture can steal your job, maybe, just maybe, you're s**t at your job."
  • Options
    By the way Harry, I always appreciate your local by-election posts. As a firm believer that national mood swings are shown in local elections first, I think you do a brilliant job. Keep it up.
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,291

    By the way, Victoria Derbyshire should never be allowed to be in charge of a serious debate ever again. She is awful.

    So is her daily show on BBC. She was out of her depth tonight but to be fair she only finished 30 days of chemo today so you have to admire her for that reason alone
    You actually watch her show...you must be one of the couple of coach loads that do. How she got her good gigs at the BBC is a very interesting story & involved ruining the career of a far more intelligent presenter.
    I absolutely do not - it drives me straight to Sky
    LOL...you could always watch the fragrant jeremy kyle or the wooden Dion Dublin on homes under the hammer...who says telly has gone down hill!
  • Options
    Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 30,974

    chestnut said:

    the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives

    Your house costs more because migration is out of hand?
    Your wages are poor because you are being undercut?

    I think you may be right.


    Answer to first is build more homes and second the new National Living wage applies to all
    My (voting Remain) granddaughter has just shared this on Facebook. It’s from a George Bevan. I’m not posting the whole of it, but as far as taking our jobs are concerned he says "maybe, if an immigrant with no contacts, no skills and no local knowledge of the language and/or culture can steal your job, maybe, just maybe, you're s**t at your job."
    Language is less of an issue when UK employers say they will only take people who can speak Polish or Portuguese.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,355

    chestnut said:

    the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives

    Your house costs more because migration is out of hand?
    Your wages are poor because you are being undercut?

    I think you may be right.


    Answer to first is build more homes and second the new National Living wage applies to all

    We're not building more homes, so the problem is only getting worse.

    If there was one thing that came out of tonight's debate it was the unease in the audience when too much was being made of immigration. It could be because it was a youthful audience but Diane James did not help - I thought she was a plus for leave but she tanked tonight
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,955
    SeanT said:

    SeanT said:

    trawl said:

    Casino_Royale - printed your blog post and gave it to two women at work I overheard in discussion; one tending towards Remain the other totally unsure and decrying the obviously biased daily diet of scaremongering. Don't know which they are going but the possible Remainer came back to me next day and praised the clarity. So another thank-you to you.
    and I grew a foot taller on the spot.

    Thanks trawl :-)

    Like you, I'm really struggling emotionally with this. My mood can turn on a sixpence depending upon a poll, or a single conversion!

    Thankfully, I'm away over the weekend for a much needed break.
    FPT CNV to Prob Leave.
    Thanks mate :-)

    Worst thing for me is Leavers moving to Remainers, particularly off the back of the Government's incessant fear propaganda. It really depresses me.

    Where's our courage, self-belief and confidence we can build a brighter future for ourselves, and give leadership to those in Europe also desperate for self-governance again?

    We mustn't let the buggers win.
    The buggers are going to win. We just have to make sure that we win NEXT time. And there will be a next time.

    If Casino Royale is right there will definitely be a next time and Leave will win. If it doesn't win this time.

    The Eurozone will Federalise: it has to, or it dies. At that point there will be a new Treaty, enabling them to caucus against us (not because they want to hurt us, just because it is human nature)

    We will either vote down the Treaty, causing a 2nd in/out referendum, or there will be such a brouahaha we will go straight to a second in/out referendum, and this time we will be Out, as the Tory government/Oppostion of the day will demand this, likewise the City, etc.

    In the end the choice will be join the euro or leave the EU. And we will leave.

    And it is possible the crunch will come even sooner than that. Look at today's horrendous immigration stats. Unsustainable.

    All very possible. If we do vote Remain we'll find out very soon how much Europe wants to keep us. If they do a Dave on the day after iRef then the writing will be on the wall.

  • Options
    LadyBucketLadyBucket Posts: 590
    Diane James is normally a good media performer but she's too much of a female Nigel Farage. Although, it couldn't have helped sitting next to such a bombastic character as Alex Salmond.
    I find these student debates embarrassing. Very few seem to be able to put a coherent sentence together.
    Victoria Derbyshire's constant interruptions were beyond irritating. There is no forum where a politician can complete a WHOLE sentence without interruption. I just feel as though I have wasted a whole hour of my precious life.
  • Options
    94432a194432a1 Posts: 11
    Hi CockerSpaniel, you could look at http://eureferendum.com/. The proprietor bites but just ignore that he is a technical expert on all of these issues. I would post your list in the comments section.

    He has written a book on the various options and costs associated with leaving. It is called Flexcit and is avaliable as a free download from his website. There is also a slimmed down version called "the market solution".
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,041
    edited May 2016

    chestnut said:

    the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives

    Your house costs more because migration is out of hand?
    Your wages are poor because you are being undercut?

    I think you may be right.


    Answer to first is build more homes and second the new National Living wage applies to all
    My (voting Remain) granddaughter has just shared this on Facebook. It’s from a George Bevan. I’m not posting the whole of it, but as far as taking our jobs are concerned he says "maybe, if an immigrant with no contacts, no skills and no local knowledge of the language and/or culture can steal your job, maybe, just maybe, you're s**t at your job."
    Language is less of an issue when UK employers say they will only take people who can speak Polish or Portuguese.
    Does that happen to any measurable degree? Other than jobs where that skill is essential .... for example I’ve known CABx seek people who can speak those languages.
  • Options
    MonikerDiCanioMonikerDiCanio Posts: 5,792

    chestnut said:

    the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives

    Your house costs more because migration is out of hand?
    Your wages are poor because you are being undercut?

    I think you may be right.


    Answer to first is build more homes and second the new National Living wage applies to all
    My (voting Remain) granddaughter has just shared this on Facebook. It’s from a George Bevan. I’m not posting the whole of it, but as far as taking our jobs are concerned he says "maybe, if an immigrant with no contacts, no skills and no local knowledge of the language and/or culture can steal your job, maybe, just maybe, you're s**t at your job."
    How sweet. You must be proud of the little darling.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,355

    chestnut said:

    the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives

    Your house costs more because migration is out of hand?
    Your wages are poor because you are being undercut?

    I think you may be right.


    Answer to first is build more homes and second the new National Living wage applies to all
    My (voting Remain) granddaughter has just shared this on Facebook. It’s from a George Bevan. I’m not posting the whole of it, but as far as taking our jobs are concerned he says "maybe, if an immigrant with no contacts, no skills and no local knowledge of the language and/or culture can steal your job, maybe, just maybe, you're s**t at your job."
    You can always trust your grandchildren to show more wisdom then you expect. It is part of the delight of having grandchildren
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,896

    chestnut said:

    the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives

    Your house costs more because migration is out of hand?
    Your wages are poor because you are being undercut?

    I think you may be right.


    Answer to first is build more homes and second the new National Living wage applies to all
    My (voting Remain) granddaughter has just shared this on Facebook. It’s from a George Bevan. I’m not posting the whole of it, but as far as taking our jobs are concerned he says "maybe, if an immigrant with no contacts, no skills and no local knowledge of the language and/or culture can steal your job, maybe, just maybe, you're s**t at your job."
    I'm sure that will be a huge consolation to someone who has lost their job.
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,041

    chestnut said:

    the voters need simple easy to understand answers to things like jobs, travel, housing and the things that matter in their daily lives

    Your house costs more because migration is out of hand?
    Your wages are poor because you are being undercut?

    I think you may be right.


    Answer to first is build more homes and second the new National Living wage applies to all
    My (voting Remain) granddaughter has just shared this on Facebook. It’s from a George Bevan. I’m not posting the whole of it, but as far as taking our jobs are concerned he says "maybe, if an immigrant with no contacts, no skills and no local knowledge of the language and/or culture can steal your job, maybe, just maybe, you're s**t at your job."
    How sweet. You must be proud of the little darling.
    I’m very proud of her pro European attitude.
  • Options
    Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 25,509

    Derbyshire: "Will we need visas to go to Europe?:
    Diane James: "We just don't know."

    A Leave vote is a complete leap in the dark. We know absolutely nothing about what it will end up delivering or even when we'd cease being an EU member state.

    Stop it with your silly Remain attack lines.

    It is not a complete leap in the dark. It means leaving the European Union.

    But, even in the worst case, the worst that can happen is that our exports face WTO tariffs to the EU. Open Europe assesses our GDP would be 2.2% lower in 2030. That's it.

    In reality, a UK-EU treaty on trade will be struck, and well you know it.

    A vote to Leave is a mandate to negotiate a better deal, and for our politicians to try again and try harder.

    I really admire your passion, but I disagree. If we vote Leave when will we leave? You don't know. You don't know if we'll retain free movement or scrap it, you don't know if we'll still contribute to the EU budget or be bound by EU laws. You don't even know who'll be doing the negotiating. It's a complete leap in the dark and one that could cause real damage to a very fragile European recovery. Again, we don't know.

    It's a leap in the dark from being a declining debt-sodden island facing huge economic and social challenges to being a declining debt-sodden island facing huge economic and social challenges, that isn't in the EU. Economically, Osbrown does more damage in a standard budget.
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,291
    edited May 2016

    Diane James is normally a good media performer but she's too much of a female Nigel Farage. Although, it couldn't have helped sitting next to such a bombastic character as Alex Salmond.
    I find these student debates embarrassing. Very few seem to be able to put a coherent sentence together.
    Victoria Derbyshire's constant interruptions were beyond irritating. There is no forum where a politician can complete a WHOLE sentence without interruption. I just feel as though I have wasted a whole hour of my precious life.

    Far too many presenters suffer from over-interruptious . Not only.is it annoying & you don't learn anything, but the politician is never really held to account because they never get to say anything. The secret is to let them dig their own grave, be well prepped then bring up the relevant info when they have stopped lying, I mean talking.
This discussion has been closed.