Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Leave could be making the same mistake Labour made at the 2

SystemSystem Posts: 12,267
edited January 2016 in General

imagepoliticalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Leave could be making the same mistake Labour made at the 2015 General Election

In the most recent electoral events in the United Kingdom, the Scottish Independence referendum and the 2015 general election, the side that won was the side that the voters viewed as the one that was the safest/best option for the economy.

Read the full story here


«134

Comments

  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,631
    1st like Leicester?
  • Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091
    Leave should make more use of someone like Lord Lawson of Blaby, former Chancellor of the Exchequer, under Margaret Thatcher, to help boost their economic credibility. As a seasoned political campaigner once observed about winning votes and elections, it’s the economy, stupid.
    But this would alienate the working-class Labour voters who are an essential part of any successful Leave strategy.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 53,270
    2nd like Murray....
  • @DecrepitJohnL Yep, I agree. It also seems that many do not view the internet as a public space. So they post opinions online that they would never dream of expressing in real life.
  • What Leave needs is a brave and senior Tory to front it up. Boris or May or Javid or Hannan or someone credible.
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Andrew Neil
    Islamic State video threatens Britain with "doomsday" attack to "turn children's hair white (end of days reference)." Be alert, not alarmed
  • Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091

    2nd like Murray....

    You mean 3, like the number of games Murray is away from defeat...
  • MP_SEMP_SE Posts: 3,642
    Farage will not be the face of the Leave campaign. It will be someone else.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 96,865
    FPT

    kle4 said:


    I saw the David Lammy thing, this morning. The first thing I thought is I wonder what PB thinks of it all....

    Less overwhelmingly against than I expected last night. He is not well thought of by most in these parts, but apparently it is a subject he actually knows something about, and it shows Cameron probably wants to actually achieve something by making the review as non partisan as possible.
    I think it's a good thing. It's one of the few things I back this government on.
    From Cameron's conference speech this year, it was the section on this issue he seemed most animated on to me, far more than the standard attacks on the opposition. I'm inclined to think he means what he says on this one, and appointing Lammy, a Labour figure, would seem to back that up. We'll see.
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    That does however reveal how people really think - and therefore vote if given the chance.

    Censoring opinion doesn't change it.

    @DecrepitJohnL Yep, I agree. It also seems that many do not view the internet as a public space. So they post opinions online that they would never dream of expressing in real life.

  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903
    Danny565 said:

    Leave should make more use of someone like Lord Lawson of Blaby, former Chancellor of the Exchequer, under Margaret Thatcher, to help boost their economic credibility. As a seasoned political campaigner once observed about winning votes and elections, it’s the economy, stupid.
    But this would alienate the working-class Labour voters who are an essential part of any successful Leave strategy.

    Lawson secretly shadowed the Deutsche Mark and the ERM. His credentials on Europe are a bit mixed.
  • Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091

    Danny565 said:

    Leave should make more use of someone like Lord Lawson of Blaby, former Chancellor of the Exchequer, under Margaret Thatcher, to help boost their economic credibility. As a seasoned political campaigner once observed about winning votes and elections, it’s the economy, stupid.
    But this would alienate the working-class Labour voters who are an essential part of any successful Leave strategy.
    Lawson secretly shadowed the Deutsche Mark and the ERM. His credentials on Europe are a bit mixed.

    Quite. In fact, didn't he actually resign in protest at Thatcher's Euroscepticism? (or am I misremembering?)
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 5,844

    Danny565 said:

    Leave should make more use of someone like Lord Lawson of Blaby, former Chancellor of the Exchequer, under Margaret Thatcher, to help boost their economic credibility. As a seasoned political campaigner once observed about winning votes and elections, it’s the economy, stupid.
    But this would alienate the working-class Labour voters who are an essential part of any successful Leave strategy.
    Lawson secretly shadowed the Deutsche Mark and the ERM. His credentials on Europe are a bit mixed.

    Lawson would alienate many more than working-class Labour voters. His views on many topics do not sit well with vast swathes of the population.

    He would be a toxic choice.
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118
    Interesting to see a -9 rating considered "popular"
  • By the way are there any Labour BOOers in the senior ranks? Anyone know where the likes of Umuna or Jarvis stand? I ask because what Leave needs to do is not become a Tory or Tory/UKIP thing but an open cross party alliance of fine upstanding Brits who will defend us against the traitorous pigdogs ( (c) S.Prasanan ) of Remain.
  • That does however reveal how people really think - and therefore vote if given the chance.

    Censoring opinion doesn't change it.

    @DecrepitJohnL Yep, I agree. It also seems that many do not view the internet as a public space. So they post opinions online that they would never dream of expressing in real life.

    I wasn't advocating censoring opinion. My comments in the previous thread condemned The Guardian's decision. And well, it reveals what those people commenting really think, not necessarily what people in general really think. Most people don't have extreme opinions one way or another, particularly British people. It's why we are a small 'c' Conservative country. It's also why extreme opinions from the left and right are unlikely to be representative.
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 5,844
    If leave could get Nigella Lawson to front things... that might see a different result!
  • Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091
    Murray back on serve in the 3rd set, 3-3
  • isam said:

    Interesting to see a -9 rating considered "popular"

    "least despised" is the new "most popular".. ;)
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 44,000
    kle4 said:

    FPT

    kle4 said:


    I saw the David Lammy thing, this morning. The first thing I thought is I wonder what PB thinks of it all....

    Less overwhelmingly against than I expected last night. He is not well thought of by most in these parts, but apparently it is a subject he actually knows something about, and it shows Cameron probably wants to actually achieve something by making the review as non partisan as possible.
    I think it's a good thing. It's one of the few things I back this government on.
    From Cameron's conference speech this year, it was the section on this issue he seemed most animated on to me, far more than the standard attacks on the opposition. I'm inclined to think he means what he says on this one, and appointing Lammy, a Labour figure, would seem to back that up. We'll see.
    Labour's reaction will be interesting. They didn't react well to Lord Adonis's move to chair the infrastructure committee. Will Lammy be branded a traitor?

    What I like about Lammy is that he's actually talked about these sorts of issues many times before, when others ignore it and look for simple instinctive answers.

    What I dislike about him is the papal smoke idiocy; his performance on Mastermind means little IMO except a little amusement. The papal smoke thing was more worrying.

    I wish I hadn't given my copy of his book away; I would like to remind myself of what I agreed and disagreed with it.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,736
    John McDonnell has just stated he voted against Britain joining the EEC in the 1975 referendum, it looks like both Corbyn and McDonnell will provide lukewarm support for Remain at best, although he has now said he prefers reform than withdrawal
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,249
    David Smith also thinks that the gradually improving situation in the EZ is bad for Leave.:http://www.economicsuk.com/blog/

    Bottom line:

    "If these two things persist – a crisis-free and modestly growing eurozone and heightened levels of consumer confidence in Britain – the leave campaign will have its work cut out in trying to persuade voters that change is either necessary or desirable."

    I agree with this. What Leave needs is another Greek style melt down. Not impossible and a reason why we might be having this referendum sooner rather than later.
  • How about Michael Caine!
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,736
    edited January 2016
    Patrick said:

    By the way are there any Labour BOOers in the senior ranks? Anyone know where the likes of Umuna or Jarvis stand? I ask because what Leave needs to do is not become a Tory or Tory/UKIP thing but an open cross party alliance of fine upstanding Brits who will defend us against the traitorous pigdogs ( (c) S.Prasanan ) of Remain.

    Umunna is pro EU and close to Mandelson and has accused UKIP of offering a "road to decline".
    http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2015/01/08/chuka-umunna-ukip-busiiness_n_6437270.html

    Dan Jarvis has generally voted for more EU integration
    http://www.theyworkforyou.com/mp/25067/dan_jarvis/barnsley_central/divisions?policy=1065
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,736
    RIP Sir Terry Wogan, the voice of broadcasting!
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118

    isam said:

    Interesting to see a -9 rating considered "popular"

    "least despised" is the new "most popular".. ;)
    Haha

    In terms of who people voted for at the GE compared to how they vote in the referendum, Cameron probably has the least retention %
  • kle4 said:

    FPT

    kle4 said:


    I saw the David Lammy thing, this morning. The first thing I thought is I wonder what PB thinks of it all....

    Less overwhelmingly against than I expected last night. He is not well thought of by most in these parts, but apparently it is a subject he actually knows something about, and it shows Cameron probably wants to actually achieve something by making the review as non partisan as possible.
    I think it's a good thing. It's one of the few things I back this government on.
    From Cameron's conference speech this year, it was the section on this issue he seemed most animated on to me, far more than the standard attacks on the opposition. I'm inclined to think he means what he says on this one, and appointing Lammy, a Labour figure, would seem to back that up. We'll see.
    Yes, I think he's genuine on this one. I'm just reading the comments now on this issue on last night's thread. It's interesting to read that some feel (or at least, it appears that way) that the Tories will gain support from BMEs as a result of initiatives such as this. I think it depends really on who is the next Tory leader. If Cameron was staying, I think the Tories could be a considerable threat to Labour's stronghold on BME 'vote'. However, if they elect someone like Osborne....no.
  • stodgestodge Posts: 14,070
    Morning again all :)

    Not sure if you can really build an argument on the above party leader figures. None of them inspire to be honest and Cameron's satisfaction and dissatisfaction figures are highest because he's been around the longest.

    As I said yesterday, is there a senior Conservative with the courage to publicly oppose Cameron's recommendation to REMAIN (assuming that's what it will be) and argue for LEAVE ?. That individual would be the de facto leader of LEAVE and would jump into the spotlight but it's a high-risk strategy. If LEAVE wins, that person will probably be the next Prime Minister assuming Cameron doesn't do a Boris and decide, after all, he will serve a full second term. If REMAIN wins, that person becomes leader of a minority faction.

    Cameron has the invaluable "Trust Me" as his main weapon but I believe anti-EU feeling is strongest among the core Conservative vote (the elderly) so it may not have the same impact as similar messages had in the GE.
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.
  • NickPalmerNickPalmer Posts: 21,587
    Patrick said:

    By the way are there any Labour BOOers in the senior ranks? Anyone know where the likes of Umuna or Jarvis stand? I ask because what Leave needs to do is not become a Tory or Tory/UKIP thing but an open cross party alliance of fine upstanding Brits who will defend us against the traitorous pigdogs ( (c) S.Prasanan ) of Remain.

    It's generally thought not. There are a few backbenchers who are "outs", but they're mainly known in political circles. There was an unverified rumour in a press report that half a dozen frontbenchers have said that if the party didn't have a view they'd be in favour of Out, but even that sounded pretty limp-wristed. Corbyn himself feels that the EU isn't exactly a workers' paradise, and we shouldn't be backing up any moves by Cameron to undermine commitments to workers (the Working Time Directive was the red line and Cameron has tactfully dropped anything about that), but the overwhelming view in Labour is that we should stay in, if not with great enthusiasm. Real Ken Clarke-style eurofans are thin on the ground in all parties (I'm one, but we're an endangered species).

    Labour has learned from the Scottish referendum and Corbyn and Cameron won't be sharing any platforms - I don't think it's in Remain's interest that they should. The risk for Remain is that Labour voters don't necessarily care enough to bother to vote, especially if it's portrayed as a vote of confidence in Cameron.
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903

    kle4 said:

    FPT

    kle4 said:


    I saw the David Lammy thing, this morning. The first thing I thought is I wonder what PB thinks of it all....

    Less overwhelmingly against than I expected last night. He is not well thought of by most in these parts, but apparently it is a subject he actually knows something about, and it shows Cameron probably wants to actually achieve something by making the review as non partisan as possible.
    I think it's a good thing. It's one of the few things I back this government on.
    From Cameron's conference speech this year, it was the section on this issue he seemed most animated on to me, far more than the standard attacks on the opposition. I'm inclined to think he means what he says on this one, and appointing Lammy, a Labour figure, would seem to back that up. We'll see.
    Labour's reaction will be interesting. They didn't react well to Lord Adonis's move to chair the infrastructure committee. Will Lammy be branded a traitor?

    What I like about Lammy is that he's actually talked about these sorts of issues many times before, when others ignore it and look for simple instinctive answers.

    What I dislike about him is the papal smoke idiocy; his performance on Mastermind means little IMO except a little amusement. The papal smoke thing was more worrying.

    I wish I hadn't given my copy of his book away; I would like to remind myself of what I agreed and disagreed with it.
    Will there be other appointees to this enquiry, will he be the chairman of a group or is he doing it on his own.
    I cannot say I have much of a high opinion of the legal profession anyway.
  • DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300
    TSE's OP swallows OGH's theory on leadership ratings. Another reading of the last election and the indy ref is that positive visions trump carping. (Yes, I know the SNP lost but they almost won, and the increase in support for independence was remarkable.)

    So far, both Leave and Remain seem to be relentlessly negative. Leave in particular needs to present a route to the sunlit uplands rather than banging on about invading hordes of subsidy-crazed French farmers.
  • isam said:

    isam said:

    Interesting to see a -9 rating considered "popular"

    "least despised" is the new "most popular".. ;)
    Haha

    In terms of who people voted for at the GE compared to how they vote in the referendum, Cameron probably has the least retention %
    Yup, quite likely. I'm a Conservative and support Cameron (voted for him as leader 10 years ago) but on this matter will vote against him in the referendum.
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 5,844
    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118
    On Topic, one of the most amateurish things one can do in betting is to get angry with yourself for missing a trick then over compensate next time
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,554
    edited January 2016
    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    LOL...what a tw@t. I think this approach is just plain stupid. We have no right to know what anybodies tax returns are, just because they are an MP is no different.

    All the people pushing this also better hope that they have never ever ever done anything that was "tax efficient" and to be perfectly frank if they haven't they are completely numpties.
  • DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300
    Danny565 said:

    Danny565 said:

    Leave should make more use of someone like Lord Lawson of Blaby, former Chancellor of the Exchequer, under Margaret Thatcher, to help boost their economic credibility. As a seasoned political campaigner once observed about winning votes and elections, it’s the economy, stupid.
    But this would alienate the working-class Labour voters who are an essential part of any successful Leave strategy.
    Lawson secretly shadowed the Deutsche Mark and the ERM. His credentials on Europe are a bit mixed.
    Quite. In fact, didn't he actually resign in protest at Thatcher's Euroscepticism? (or am I misremembering?)

    You are misrembering. Blair and Brown are the only occupants of Downing Street who ever had a cross word. Lawson's main beef was Mrs Thatcher's public reliance on Sir Alan Walters (and in the end, they both had to go).
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 53,270

    isam said:

    isam said:

    Interesting to see a -9 rating considered "popular"

    "least despised" is the new "most popular".. ;)
    Haha

    In terms of who people voted for at the GE compared to how they vote in the referendum, Cameron probably has the least retention %
    Yup, quite likely. I'm a Conservative and support Cameron (voted for him as leader 10 years ago) but on this matter will vote against him in the referendum.
    Ditto on all counts.
  • Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091
    Oh god....

    Stephen Bush ‏@stephenkb 13m13 minutes ago
    John McDonnell has done a lot more telly recently, and he's getting pretty good at it. Has also been visiting a lot of local parties.
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903

    Danny565 said:

    Leave should make more use of someone like Lord Lawson of Blaby, former Chancellor of the Exchequer, under Margaret Thatcher, to help boost their economic credibility. As a seasoned political campaigner once observed about winning votes and elections, it’s the economy, stupid.
    But this would alienate the working-class Labour voters who are an essential part of any successful Leave strategy.
    Lawson secretly shadowed the Deutsche Mark and the ERM. His credentials on Europe are a bit mixed.
    Lawson would alienate many more than working-class Labour voters. His views on many topics do not sit well with vast swathes of the population.
    He would be a toxic choice.
    I am not particularly disagreeing with you, however at least someone like Lawson might actually engage with a proper considered argument instead of slipping into the knee jerk BNPlite stance of UKIP and all its fellow travellers.
    The EU can clearly be criticised and clearly should be reformed, the question is what is the most sensible and least stupid decision and direction for it and us to take. For my part I find the attitudes currently being unleashed by the leavers are toxic.
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118
    Off topic, Chievo play Juventus at 1130am, and their main striker has a fantastic name for Anglification....
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
    The gap is £457/month.

    Pension contributions ?
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    Danny565 said:

    Oh god....

    Stephen Bush ‏@stephenkb 13m13 minutes ago
    John McDonnell has done a lot more telly recently, and he's getting pretty good at it. Has also been visiting a lot of local parties.

    As tipped by me at 50/1...
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 63,567
    Danny565 said:

    Oh god....

    Stephen Bush ‏@stephenkb 13m13 minutes ago
    John McDonnell has done a lot more telly recently, and he's getting pretty good at it. Has also been visiting a lot of local parties.

    Morning all,

    Danny Blanchflower in Newstatesman:

    "The new Labour leaders are not economists and are going to have to learn fast. They will have to accept the realities of capitalism and modern markets, like it or not. No more silly stuff about companies not being able to pay dividends if they don’t do X or Y."
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Lost in History
    Women protesting the forced Hijab in Iran, days after the 1979 Revolution. https://t.co/XlRBPplsOa
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,736

    Patrick said:

    By the way are there any Labour BOOers in the senior ranks? Anyone know where the likes of Umuna or Jarvis stand? I ask because what Leave needs to do is not become a Tory or Tory/UKIP thing but an open cross party alliance of fine upstanding Brits who will defend us against the traitorous pigdogs ( (c) S.Prasanan ) of Remain.

    It's generally thought not. There are a few backbenchers who are "outs", but they're mainly known in political circles. There was an unverified rumour in a press report that half a dozen frontbenchers have said that if the party didn't have a view they'd be in favour of Out, but even that sounded pretty limp-wristed. Corbyn himself feels that the EU isn't exactly a workers' paradise, and we shouldn't be backing up any moves by Cameron to undermine commitments to workers (the Working Time Directive was the red line and Cameron has tactfully dropped anything about that), but the overwhelming view in Labour is that we should stay in, if not with great enthusiasm. Real Ken Clarke-style eurofans are thin on the ground in all parties (I'm one, but we're an endangered species).

    Labour has learned from the Scottish referendum and Corbyn and Cameron won't be sharing any platforms - I don't think it's in Remain's interest that they should. The risk for Remain is that Labour voters don't necessarily care enough to bother to vote, especially if it's portrayed as a vote of confidence in Cameron.
    Yes, Cameron as leader of the Remain campaign will find himself having to get enough Labour and LD and SNP voters to back Remain to counteract the 50%+ of Tory voters and the 90%+ of UKIP voters who will vote Leave. The best way to do that is to have co-ordinated but separate campaigns eg Alan Johnson will be leaving the Labour pro EU campaign and is a far more effective motivator of typical Labour voters than Cameron will be
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663
    How much do MPs need to contribute of their salary towards their pension.
  • Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091
    Murray opening the tiebreak with a double-fault... typical.
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Yup

    isam said:

    isam said:

    Interesting to see a -9 rating considered "popular"

    "least despised" is the new "most popular".. ;)
    Haha

    In terms of who people voted for at the GE compared to how they vote in the referendum, Cameron probably has the least retention %
    Yup, quite likely. I'm a Conservative and support Cameron (voted for him as leader 10 years ago) but on this matter will vote against him in the referendum.
    Ditto on all counts.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663
    Sir Terry Wogan has died.
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 5,844
    edited January 2016
    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
    The gap is £457/month.

    Pension contributions ?
    No. He surely would still have to declare the income and then the contributions
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903
    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
    The gap is £457/month.

    Pension contributions ?
    Someone 'poor' demands to see the tax return of someone 'rich'? And we are discussing this gimmick?
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,554
    edited January 2016
    Not sure many of media luuvies would like the plebs like us to see their tax returns.....e.g. remember Martin Freeman and his wife...
  • eekeek Posts: 28,798
    edited January 2016

    This is appalling

    COFFEE HOUSE
    England named worst in developed world for literacy. So yes, school reform is needed http://blogs.spectator.co.uk/2016/01/britain-named-worst-in-developed-world-for-literacy-so-yes-school-reform-is-needed/
    I mentioned last night before I went to bed that every secondary modern school in South Bucks (where I come from) did better than some of the local comprehensive schools where I live except for the 2 decent ones.

    What is really worrying is that a school that only achieved 17% of pupils getting 5 a*-c grades is believed by ofsted to only need improvement when Special measures is clearly what is required...
  • Pardon me if it's been on here before but I see John McDonnel claimed to have published his tax return - any idea where I can see it

    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
    The gap is £457/month.

    Pension contributions ?
    No. He surely would still have to declare the income and then the contributions
    Is that all he's published - where's the other pages?
  • Andy Murray = Scottish :(
  • Danny565 said:

    Oh god....

    Stephen Bush ‏@stephenkb 13m13 minutes ago
    John McDonnell has done a lot more telly recently, and he's getting pretty good at it. Has also been visiting a lot of local parties.

    As tipped by me at 50/1...
    I've scheduled your next piece for 5pm.

    Now wish we luck with American airport security. I have to American airport security 4 times in the next few days.

    This will not end well.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663
    http://www.accountingweb.co.uk/anyanswers/question/how-show-salary-sacrifice-tax-return

    No & No
    Euan MacLennan | Mon, 23/07/2012 - 18:13 | Permalink

    No - you do not show any salary sacrifice separately. You show the gross pay from his P60, which will be after the sacrifice.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    I'm in favour of full transparency of tax returns. Sunlight is the best disinfectant.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 61,262
    I'm staying with friends this weekend so just dropping in a quick comment on my wife's iPhone: I am deeply depressed.

    I've been waiting my whole life for this referendum, a chance to regain self-governance for our country, and we're throwing it away.

    Both Leave campaigns are in disarray, and fighting each other, and no serious Conservative is willing to bravely show leadership on the matter. Instead, one by one, they are sheepishly declaring for Remain.

    In addition, the scare and fearmongering is clearly having an effect on a few of our regulars who are *inclined* to vote Leave.

    I never thought it would be like this. And am deeply dissappointed about my own party.

    Lots to think about.
  • Sean_F said:

    Following on, I think it's fascinating that very unequal outcomes persist, despite hugely redistributive taxation and social spending.

    The top 1% of earners pay something like 25% of income tax.

    It would be interesting to know how many of that top 1% of earners actually earn their money by adding more value to their employers than they cost.

    I suspect it may not be a high proportion.

  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Ali L
    "I want peace and prosperity for the whole world'

    Miss John McDonnell, UK entrant for Miss World. https://t.co/RRA5ZILtl2L
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 63,567

    Pardon me if it's been on here before but I see John McDonnel claimed to have published his tax return - any idea where I can see it

    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
    The gap is £457/month.

    Pension contributions ?
    No. He surely would still have to declare the income and then the contributions
    Is that all he's published - where's the other pages?
    As far as I can see he has only published the Employment page with figure from P60. As I understand it this figure will be less than gross salary because of pension contributions.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 61,262

    isam said:

    isam said:

    Interesting to see a -9 rating considered "popular"

    "least despised" is the new "most popular".. ;)
    Haha

    In terms of who people voted for at the GE compared to how they vote in the referendum, Cameron probably has the least retention %
    Yup, quite likely. I'm a Conservative and support Cameron (voted for him as leader 10 years ago) but on this matter will vote against him in the referendum.
    Ditto on all counts.
    I agree with both you guys on all of that.
  • I'm in favour of full transparency of tax returns. Sunlight is the best disinfectant.

    All I have seen is the employment page in the Mirror - where's the rest of it? Presumably there's no interest income !!
  • not_on_firenot_on_fire Posts: 4,449
    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Says a lot about journalists' maths skills that spotting one number is less than another makes you "eagle eyed"

    As others have said, the difference is almost certainly pension contributions
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,736

    Andy Murray = Scottish :(

    Or a Briton who has won 2 grand slams and a Davis Cup! He is due to be a father any day now so I expect that was also on his mind, but Djokovic is clearly the World No 1 even if Murray is probably No 2 now
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663
    edited January 2016

    Pardon me if it's been on here before but I see John McDonnel claimed to have published his tax return - any idea where I can see it

    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
    The gap is £457/month.

    Pension contributions ?
    No. He surely would still have to declare the income and then the contributions
    Is that all he's published - where's the other pages?
    As far as I can see he has only published the Employment page with figure from P60. As I understand it this figure will be less than gross salary because of pension contributions.
    The implied pension contributions of £457/month look eminently reasonable to me. Indeed pro-rata if I had to post a tax return it would look very much the same (Albeit for ~ half the value)
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 61,262
    Pulpstar said:

    Sir Terry Wogan has died.

    What an awful January.
  • I'm in favour of full transparency of tax returns. Sunlight is the best disinfectant.

    I believe it can cause a lot of trouble. I was working somewhere a number of years ago and every bodies salaries and bonuses got leaked, and it caused just so much tension and bad relations between people. It ruined what was a really good office environment.
  • Pardon me if it's been on here before but I see John McDonnel claimed to have published his tax return - any idea where I can see it

    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
    The gap is £457/month.

    Pension contributions ?
    No. He surely would still have to declare the income and then the contributions
    Is that all he's published - where's the other pages?
    As far as I can see he has only published the Employment page with figure from P60. As I understand it this figure will be less than gross salary because of pension contributions.
    No other income...no interest? No untaxed income? - where's his media work recorded?
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 63,567

    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
    The gap is £457/month.

    Pension contributions ?
    Someone 'poor' demands to see the tax return of someone 'rich'? And we are discussing this gimmick?
    Not sure why McDonnell is trying to muddy the waters here. The public are pretty much 100% behind him on the Google tax scams I would say. Why try and move the conversation on to who earns what in the Cabinet? We all know that most of them are millionaires. Keep the agenda on the big corporates and their cozy deals with HMRC/Treasury.
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 5,844

    I'm in favour of full transparency of tax returns. Sunlight is the best disinfectant.

    Sorry - but your desire for 'transparency' does not trump the right to privacy.

    People should never be expected to reveal their finances in public.
  • I'm staying with friends this weekend so just dropping in a quick comment on my wife's iPhone: I am deeply depressed.

    I've been waiting my whole life for this referendum, a chance to regain self-governance for our country, and we're throwing it away.

    Both Leave campaigns are in disarray, and fighting each other, and no serious Conservative is willing to bravely show leadership on the matter. Instead, one by one, they are sheepishly declaring for Remain.

    In addition, the scare and fearmongering is clearly having an effect on a few of our regulars who are *inclined* to vote Leave.

    I never thought it would be like this. And am deeply dissappointed about my own party.

    Lots to think about.

    There's still plenty of time. Wait for the next (even bigger) wave of migrants into Europe in the spring, wait for the referendum campaign to really begin (probably immediately following the May elections), wait for the TV debates... there are a lot of undecided/unsure voters and they can be swung round. Look at how in Scotland how the Yes side surged - Leave are in a similar position to Yes.

    Also, in the end, it could come down to turnout - if Leave voters are more keen, and Remain voters are complacent/not fussed, then Leave could edge it even if in the polls they are slightly behind.
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118

    I'm staying with friends this weekend so just dropping in a quick comment on my wife's iPhone: I am deeply depressed.

    I've been waiting my whole life for this referendum, a chance to regain self-governance for our country, and we're throwing it away.

    Both Leave campaigns are in disarray, and fighting each other, and no serious Conservative is willing to bravely show leadership on the matter. Instead, one by one, they are sheepishly declaring for Remain.

    In addition, the scare and fearmongering is clearly having an effect on a few of our regulars who are *inclined* to vote Leave.

    I never thought it would be like this. And am deeply dissappointed about my own party.

    Lots to think about.

    What is deeply depressing is that people need propaganda from self interest groups to make up their mind (not you obviously)
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 63,567

    I'm in favour of full transparency of tax returns. Sunlight is the best disinfectant.

    Sorry - but your desire for 'transparency' does not trump the right to privacy.

    People should never be expected to reveal their finances in public.
    Public corporations should not have a right to confidentiality about their tax returns. They are not private individuals.
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903

    Ali L
    "I want peace and prosperity for the whole world'

    Miss John McDonnell, UK entrant for Miss World. https://t.co/RRA5ZILtl2L

    You missed out motherhood and apple pie.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663
    Considered taking the 10-3 on Murray.

    Glad I gave it a miss. Djokovic in amazing form.
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 5,844

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Says a lot about journalists' maths skills that spotting one number is less than another makes you "eagle eyed"

    As others have said, the difference is almost certainly pension contributions
    If he is being transparent and open, he should make that perfectly clear.

    Otherwise it looks like being evasive.

    And, of course, the story has moved on to being about him - rather than Osborne.

    He really isn't good at political stunts
  • I'm in favour of full transparency of tax returns. Sunlight is the best disinfectant.

    Sorry - but your desire for 'transparency' does not trump the right to privacy.

    People should never be expected to reveal their finances in public.
    Public corporations should not have a right to confidentiality about their tax returns. They are not private individuals.
    BBC will disagree with you on that one ;-)
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 63,567

    Pardon me if it's been on here before but I see John McDonnel claimed to have published his tax return - any idea where I can see it

    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
    The gap is £457/month.

    Pension contributions ?
    No. He surely would still have to declare the income and then the contributions
    Is that all he's published - where's the other pages?
    As far as I can see he has only published the Employment page with figure from P60. As I understand it this figure will be less than gross salary because of pension contributions.
    No other income...no interest? No untaxed income? - where's his media work recorded?
    There's separate pages for other income, rentals or self-employed work. This is the page (or section of the page) that is all about what's on his P60 (as issued by his employer).
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,554
    edited January 2016

    Pardon me if it's been on here before but I see John McDonnel claimed to have published his tax return - any idea where I can see it

    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
    The gap is £457/month.

    Pension contributions ?
    No. He surely would still have to declare the income and then the contributions
    Is that all he's published - where's the other pages?
    As far as I can see he has only published the Employment page with figure from P60. As I understand it this figure will be less than gross salary because of pension contributions.
    No other income...no interest? No untaxed income? - where's his media work recorded?
    There's separate pages for other income, rentals or self-employed work. This is the page (or section of the page) that is all about what's on his P60 (as issued by his employer).
    Well he hasn't published his full tax return then has he...he has published one page of it. I would presume Osborne's equivalent page would be equally dull and uninformative.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,736
    edited January 2016

    I'm staying with friends this weekend so just dropping in a quick comment on my wife's iPhone: I am deeply depressed.

    I've been waiting my whole life for this referendum, a chance to regain self-governance for our country, and we're throwing it away.

    Both Leave campaigns are in disarray, and fighting each other, and no serious Conservative is willing to bravely show leadership on the matter. Instead, one by one, they are sheepishly declaring for Remain.

    In addition, the scare and fearmongering is clearly having an effect on a few of our regulars who are *inclined* to vote Leave.

    I never thought it would be like this. And am deeply dissappointed about my own party.

    Lots to think about.

    There's still plenty of time. Wait for the next (even bigger) wave of migrants into Europe in the spring, wait for the referendum campaign to really begin (probably immediately following the May elections), wait for the TV debates... there are a lot of undecided/unsure voters and they can be swung round. Look at how in Scotland how the Yes side surged - Leave are in a similar position to Yes.

    Also, in the end, it could come down to turnout - if Leave voters are more keen, and Remain voters are complacent/not fussed, then Leave could edge it even if in the polls they are slightly behind.
    Leave has pensioners who are more likely to vote than younger voters but Remain has graduates who are more likely to vote than non graduates. Personally I think it will be about 51% Remain to 49% Leave, similar to what some of the online polls are now showing, with England voting Out outside London
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 44,000

    I'm staying with friends this weekend so just dropping in a quick comment on my wife's iPhone: I am deeply depressed.

    I've been waiting my whole life for this referendum, a chance to regain self-governance for our country, and we're throwing it away.

    Both Leave campaigns are in disarray, and fighting each other, and no serious Conservative is willing to bravely show leadership on the matter. Instead, one by one, they are sheepishly declaring for Remain.

    In addition, the scare and fearmongering is clearly having an effect on a few of our regulars who are *inclined* to vote Leave.

    I never thought it would be like this. And am deeply dissappointed about my own party.

    Lots to think about.

    Nothing so far's changed my view that I'll probably vote to leave: the hat would have to be very large to contain a rabbit big enough to send me sailing back over the fence to 'remain'.

    Both sides of the campaign seem so incompetent they should not be allowed to run a whelk stall, yet alone a campaign about who should run the country.

    But in terms of PR / leafleting, remain seem to be more in charge. Sadly.
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903

    I'm in favour of full transparency of tax returns. Sunlight is the best disinfectant.

    Sorry - but your desire for 'transparency' does not trump the right to privacy.

    People should never be expected to reveal their finances in public.
    Public corporations should not have a right to confidentiality about their tax returns. They are not private individuals.
    BBC will disagree with you on that one ;-)
    Does the BBC pay tax, ie corporation tax?
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 63,567

    Pardon me if it's been on here before but I see John McDonnel claimed to have published his tax return - any idea where I can see it

    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
    The gap is £457/month.

    Pension contributions ?
    No. He surely would still have to declare the income and then the contributions
    Is that all he's published - where's the other pages?
    As far as I can see he has only published the Employment page with figure from P60. As I understand it this figure will be less than gross salary because of pension contributions.
    No other income...no interest? No untaxed income? - where's his media work recorded?
    There's separate pages for other income, rentals or self-employed work. This is the page (or section of the page) that is all about what's on his P60 (as issued by his employer).
    Well he hasn't published his full tax return then has he...he has published one page of it. I would presume Osborne's equivalent page would be equally dull and uninformative.
    Correct. It's a PR stunt.
  • SimonStClareSimonStClare Posts: 7,976

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Says a lot about journalists' maths skills that spotting one number is less than another makes you "eagle eyed"

    As others have said, the difference is almost certainly pension contributions
    If he is being transparent and open, he should make that perfectly clear.

    Otherwise it looks like being evasive.

    And, of course, the story has moved on to being about him - rather than Osborne.

    He really isn't good at political stunts
    Indeed, it was a silly stunt by a stupid man who has never learnt from history #KenLivingstone
  • Pardon me if it's been on here before but I see John McDonnel claimed to have published his tax return - any idea where I can see it

    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_P said:

    @johnmcdonnellMP: After the #googletax deal for openness and transparency I've published my tax return today. Now it's Osborne's turn https://t.co/Zrkecsk2M7

    @charlotteahenry: Uh oh. Eagle eyed hacks @IsabelHardman and @craigawoodhouse noticed @johnmcdonnellMP's earnings on tax return less than MPs salary.

    Not sure how he can wriggle out of that one...
    The gap is £457/month.

    Pension contributions ?
    No. He surely would still have to declare the income and then the contributions
    Is that all he's published - where's the other pages?
    As far as I can see he has only published the Employment page with figure from P60. As I understand it this figure will be less than gross salary because of pension contributions.
    No other income...no interest? No untaxed income? - where's his media work recorded?
    There's separate pages for other income, rentals or self-employed work. This is the page (or section of the page) that is all about what's on his P60 (as issued by his employer).
    Absolutely - so he's NOT published his tax return. He's publish PART of the tax return for which the information was already in the public domain
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    It would be most amusing if it was Germany's actions that took the UK out of the EU.

    I'm staying with friends this weekend so just dropping in a quick comment on my wife's iPhone: I am deeply depressed.

    I've been waiting my whole life for this referendum, a chance to regain self-governance for our country, and we're throwing it away.

    Both Leave campaigns are in disarray, and fighting each other, and no serious Conservative is willing to bravely show leadership on the matter. Instead, one by one, they are sheepishly declaring for Remain.

    In addition, the scare and fearmongering is clearly having an effect on a few of our regulars who are *inclined* to vote Leave.

    I never thought it would be like this. And am deeply dissappointed about my own party.

    Lots to think about.

    There's still plenty of time. Wait for the next (even bigger) wave of migrants into Europe in the spring, wait for the referendum campaign to really begin (probably immediately following the May elections), wait for the TV debates... there are a lot of undecided/unsure voters and they can be swung round. Look at how in Scotland how the Yes side surged - Leave are in a similar position to Yes.

    Also, in the end, it could come down to turnout - if Leave voters are more keen, and Remain voters are complacent/not fussed, then Leave could edge it even if in the polls they are slightly behind.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 57,944
    This is accurate (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/12130181/Oil-price-crash-Saudis-told-to-embrace-austerity-as-debt-defaults-loom.html), and is exactly what I've been forecasting for the last year.

    The defaults that are coming are not from peripheral Europe, but from oil producing countries.
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 33,896

    I'm in favour of full transparency of tax returns. Sunlight is the best disinfectant.

    Sorry - but your desire for 'transparency' does not trump the right to privacy.

    People should never be expected to reveal their finances in public.
    Public corporations should not have a right to confidentiality about their tax returns. They are not private individuals.
    Aren’t all Norweigan tax reurns available on-line? Politicians included.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,554
    edited January 2016
    Silly question...in the days of Blair and whiter than white, ministers were asked to put all outside interests into blind trusts. Do the current government ministers still do that? And if so, I presume all they get each year is a payment for x from the trust, of which they have no control or knowledge about how it was generated / calculated.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,554
    edited January 2016

    I'm in favour of full transparency of tax returns. Sunlight is the best disinfectant.

    Sorry - but your desire for 'transparency' does not trump the right to privacy.

    People should never be expected to reveal their finances in public.
    Public corporations should not have a right to confidentiality about their tax returns. They are not private individuals.
    Aren’t all Norweigan tax reurns available on-line? Politicians included.
    Don't know about Norway, but Finland definitely....but asked anybody there and they will tell you there are all sorts of ways in which rich people's incomes aren't quite what they seem.
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,312
    Apologies if this point has already been made, but the obvious difference between the General Election and the EU Referendum is that if we vote to leave Nigel Farage (or whoever leads the Leave campaign) does not become PM. Of course, David Cameron almost certainly would cease to be PM but that might work to Leave's advantage too.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,631

    Danny565 said:

    Oh god....

    Stephen Bush ‏@stephenkb 13m13 minutes ago
    John McDonnell has done a lot more telly recently, and he's getting pretty good at it. Has also been visiting a lot of local parties.

    As tipped by me at 50/1...
    I've scheduled your next piece for 5pm.

    Now wish we luck with American airport security. I have to American airport security 4 times in the next few days.

    This will not end well.
    Mr Eagles, remember that there's a time and a place for tomfoolery and sarcasm. American airports are neither the time not the place. The TSA will genuinely think it's hilarious if they can delay you for 24 hours, don't turn up drunk and call them Sir. Seriously.
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 44,000
    rcs1000 said:

    This is accurate (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/12130181/Oil-price-crash-Saudis-told-to-embrace-austerity-as-debt-defaults-loom.html), and is exactly what I've been forecasting for the last year.

    The defaults that are coming are not from peripheral Europe, but from oil producing countries.

    There's an interesting article in the LRB that touches on this, along with some of the geopolitical aspects:
    http://www.lrb.co.uk/v38/n03/joost-hiltermann/chemical-wonders
  • It would be most amusing if it was Germany's actions that took the UK out of the EU.

    I'm staying with friends this weekend so just dropping in a quick comment on my wife's iPhone: I am deeply depressed.

    I've been waiting my whole life for this referendum, a chance to regain self-governance for our country, and we're throwing it away.

    Both Leave campaigns are in disarray, and fighting each other, and no serious Conservative is willing to bravely show leadership on the matter. Instead, one by one, they are sheepishly declaring for Remain.

    In addition, the scare and fearmongering is clearly having an effect on a few of our regulars who are *inclined* to vote Leave.

    I never thought it would be like this. And am deeply dissappointed about my own party.

    Lots to think about.

    There's still plenty of time. Wait for the next (even bigger) wave of migrants into Europe in the spring, wait for the referendum campaign to really begin (probably immediately following the May elections), wait for the TV debates... there are a lot of undecided/unsure voters and they can be swung round. Look at how in Scotland how the Yes side surged - Leave are in a similar position to Yes.

    Also, in the end, it could come down to turnout - if Leave voters are more keen, and Remain voters are complacent/not fussed, then Leave could edge it even if in the polls they are slightly behind.
    It chimes with history since the unification of Germany (as in, the 1871 unification) - actions by that country often disrupt Britain's European policy.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,663
    Sandpit said:

    Danny565 said:

    Oh god....

    Stephen Bush ‏@stephenkb 13m13 minutes ago
    John McDonnell has done a lot more telly recently, and he's getting pretty good at it. Has also been visiting a lot of local parties.

    As tipped by me at 50/1...
    I've scheduled your next piece for 5pm.

    Now wish we luck with American airport security. I have to American airport security 4 times in the next few days.

    This will not end well.
    Mr Eagles, remember that there's a time and a place for tomfoolery and sarcasm. American airports are neither the time not the place. The TSA will genuinely think it's hilarious if they can delay you for 24 hours, don't turn up drunk and call them Sir. Seriously.
    They so thought I was smuggling drugs when I went through customs being unshaven for about a month and wearing shorts and t-shirt from thailand.
  • Moses_Moses_ Posts: 4,865
    edited January 2016

    It would be most amusing if it was Germany's actions that took the UK out of the EU.

    I'm staying with friends this weekend so just dropping in a quick comment on my wife's iPhone: I am deeply depressed.

    I've been waiting my whole life for this referendum, a chance to regain self-governance for our country, and we're throwing it away.

    Both Leave campaigns are in disarray, and fighting each other, and no serious Conservative is willing to bravely show leadership on the matter. Instead, one by one, they are sheepishly declaring for Remain.

    In addition, the scare and fearmongering is clearly having an effect on a few of our regulars who are *inclined* to vote Leave.

    I never thought it would be like this. And am deeply dissappointed about my own party.

    Lots to think about.

    There's still plenty of time. Wait for the next (even bigger) wave of migrants into Europe in the spring, wait for the referendum campaign to really begin (probably immediately following the May elections), wait for the TV debates... there are a lot of undecided/unsure voters and they can be swung round. Look at how in Scotland how the Yes side surged - Leave are in a similar position to Yes.

    Also, in the end, it could come down to turnout - if Leave voters are more keen, and Remain voters are complacent/not fussed, then Leave could edge it even if in the polls they are slightly behind.
    That's the main issue for me. As soon as we want something then it's never reported as what the EU will allow its what Merkel decides we can have. Who put that bitch in charge??

    That alone is enough for me to vote out. I know we are not going to win but I can stand there honestly and say I tried to save my country. It should be remembered when we are inundated with EU demands starting from day 1 after the referendum is held. They will move fast ...very fast and you can kiss goodbye to the pound currency , the national anthem and any freedom we have. It will be decided in Brussels by faceless unelected bureaucrats. All for the socialist collective good of course and the only way socialists stand a chance of getting any power in this country

    We have but one opportunity to stop it...we should not waste it.

    Vote leave.
This discussion has been closed.