Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Antifrank’s 50/1 tip to be next Labour leader

SystemSystem Posts: 12,220
edited October 2015 in General

imagepoliticalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Antifrank’s 50/1 tip to be next Labour leader

 Jeremy Corbyn has been leader of the Labour party for just over a fortnight and already there are rumblings about who might replace him.  Some bookies already have markets up and running (though they may well have more value at present for publicity rather than for making money).  Are there any bargains out there?

Read the full story here


«1345

Comments

  • surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    Antifrank: Much as I do respect and admire your political and betting judgements, this one is bonkers !

    Not that anti-austerity is not a viable strategy, it is and can be argued as such. But the press will be mercilessly attacking his past and as we have seen even with silly things like singing the National Anthem , much will be made out of them.

    Have you ever seen any US President sing their National Anthem ? Come to think of it, have you seen a British PM sing the NA ?
  • surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    How old is Elizabeth Warren ?
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034
    surbiton said:

    Antifrank: Much as I do respect and admire your political and betting judgements, this one is bonkers !

    Not that anti-austerity is not a viable strategy, it is and can be argued as such. But the press will be mercilessly attacking his past and as we have seen even with silly things like singing the National Anthem , much will be made out of them.

    Have you ever seen any US President sing their National Anthem ? Come to think of it, have you seen a British PM sing the NA ?

    Okay, Obama's is dubbed over, but at least his lips are moving:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B4F8i89vWAw

    Here's Hillary:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KQYIHQvhIk0

    Anyone who's tried understands why politicians would prefer not to sing the Star Spangled Banner.
  • Curse of the new thread. FPT

    @another_richard I'd add to that the welfare reforms that have seen many long-term unemployed and young people who would otherwise have been unemployed enter the workforce instead. These are people who would enter the workforce at the bottom end and will deflate the productivity rate simply by working.

    In 2011 youth unemployment was 22.3% and now it is 15.4% - had those who were unemployed stayed unemployed then most likely productivity as a whole would be higher which is why it is a useless metric in isolation.

    Youth unemployment is falling at a similar rate now as it did after the recession of the early 1990s:

    http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/datasets-and-tables/data-selector.html?cdid=AIXS&dataset=lms&table-id=14

    There has always been, and will always be, people entering the workforce at the bottom end so the productivity stagnation isn't caused by that.
    No it is not falling at a similar rate. According to your link it fell from 18% in '93 to 14.8 in '96 (a fall of 3.2% in 3 years or 1% per annum). Whereas its fallen from over 20% in Oct 2011 to 13% in Jul 14 a fall of 7% in 3 years or over 2% per annum. That is considerably different.

    Of course like above I've cherrypicked the data months, but if you go like for like in months it is still about 2% per annum and not 1% per annum. People enter the workforce at the bottom all the time but considerable change has occured here not just churn.
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034
    surbiton said:

    How old is Elizabeth Warren ?

    66. 22/6/49
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    surbiton said:

    Antifrank: Much as I do respect and admire your political and betting judgements, this one is bonkers !

    Not that anti-austerity is not a viable strategy, it is and can be argued as such. But the press will be mercilessly attacking his past and as we have seen even with silly things like singing the National Anthem , much will be made out of them.

    Have you ever seen any US President sing their National Anthem ? Come to think of it, have you seen a British PM sing the NA ?

    I was not expecting universal acclaim for this particular betting tip. But I stand by it.

    Objectively the shadow Chancellor has to be a serious contender for succeeding the Leader of the Opposition.
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034
    The ever excellent Jay Cost has a must-read piece for political bettors on dissatisfaction in US politics and the breakdown of the national consensus that has reigned since WWII.

    http://www.weeklystandard.com/articles/what-hell-going_1039621.html
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,259
    I cannot see the Blairites forcing out JC if McDonnell is a likely successor. What would be the point?

    If JC chooses to go then a younger candidate from the radical left is more likely, imho.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340

    I cannot see the Blairites forcing out JC if McDonnell is a likely successor. What would be the point?

    If JC chooses to go then a younger candidate from the radical left is more likely, imho.

    The corollary of the first point (which I agree with) is that Jeremy Corbyn probably won't be going anywhere any time soon. One of John McDonnell's functions will be to be the gorilla in the cage, with Jeremy Corbyn holding the key to the cage.
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,259
    antifrank said:

    I cannot see the Blairites forcing out JC if McDonnell is a likely successor. What would be the point?

    If JC chooses to go then a younger candidate from the radical left is more likely, imho.

    The corollary of the first point (which I agree with) is that Jeremy Corbyn probably won't be going anywhere any time soon. One of John McDonnell's functions will be to be the gorilla in the cage, with Jeremy Corbyn holding the key to the cage.
    So McDonnell is Corbyn's nuclear deterrent!
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340

    antifrank said:

    I cannot see the Blairites forcing out JC if McDonnell is a likely successor. What would be the point?

    If JC chooses to go then a younger candidate from the radical left is more likely, imho.

    The corollary of the first point (which I agree with) is that Jeremy Corbyn probably won't be going anywhere any time soon. One of John McDonnell's functions will be to be the gorilla in the cage, with Jeremy Corbyn holding the key to the cage.
    So McDonnell is Corbyn's nuclear deterrent!
    MAD for the Labour party.
  • richardDoddrichardDodd Posts: 5,472
    MTimT NO..
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 43,515
    The Westminster Paedophile Ring story gets another twist, with ExaroNews in the firing line:

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3258579/Man-said-abused-VIP-paedophile-ring-claims-manipulated-news-website-led-crusade-against-politicians.html

    Can't say I'm surprised. Might this cause some small difficulties for Tom Watson?
  • philiphphiliph Posts: 4,704
    edited October 2015
    If Corbyn succeeds in his prime objective, which was clear from early on in his campaign, it will change the Labour Party beyond recognition and give it a permenant left bias in members, supporters, officials, NEC and eventually MPs. I expect he will get most of what he wants and bonkers as it may be, I concur entirely with Antifrank in his trading of the likely direction. John McDonell is a good media performer and will get better.
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034
    Interesting. Fox News is running a feature called the Edge where they analyze (in a black box way) news stories as a leading indicator of where the polling will go.

    Hard to assess the validity of the model as it is not described. But it does appear that there is some assumption that even negative stories help the candidates.

    Anyone with knowledge of this field have any views on this?

    http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2015/10/02/edge-rubio-bush-fiorina-and-cruz-win-week/
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034

    MTimT NO..

    Good!
  • YorkcityYorkcity Posts: 4,382
    philiph said:

    If Corbyn succeeds in his prime objective, which was clear from early on in his campaign, it will change the Labour Party beyond recognition and give it a permenant left bias in members, supporters, officials, NEC and eventually MPs. I expect he will get most of what he wants and bonkers as it may be, I concur entirely with Antifrank in his trading of the likely direction. John McDonell is a good media performer and will get better.

    I agree with Antifrank`s analysis regarding at that price it is a good bet.

    Phillip I agree with the comment "John McDonell is a good media performer and will get better"

    I now understand why Gordon Brown did not want to stand against him in a full labour leadership contest in 2007.
  • JohnOJohnO Posts: 4,291
    If Corbyn chooses to stand down, it will be the direct consequence of very poor electoral results, probably in 2017 or 18 (not so much next year). In such circumstances, the credibility of the hard left will surely be much diminished by Labour's selectorate even with its current composition. And McDonnell will be the principal manifestation of that failure and proven unelectability....which presumably explains the 40/1 odds.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    JohnO said:

    If Corbyn chooses to stand down, it will be the direct consequence of very poor electoral results, probably in 2017 or 18 (not so much next year). In such circumstances, the credibility of the hard left will surely be much diminished by Labour's selectorate even with its current composition. And McDonnell will be the principal manifestation of that failure and proven unelectability....which presumably explains the 40/1 odds.

    I think you underestimate the inexhaustible ability of the hard left to believe that it has been betrayed. Labour is a party that believes that Ed Miliband was insufficiently leftwing. It will be able to persuade itself that Jeremy Corbyn was just too compromising to inspire voters.
  • What happens if Corbyn dies in the next year or so ?

    Would Tom Watson be counted as 'Next Labour Leader' ?

    If not then McDonnell must stand a good chance of winning an emergency leadership election.

  • MattWMattW Posts: 23,969
    edited October 2015
    FPT.

    So the People's Republic of South Yorkshire is going to get an elected President.

    Actually, up here in Co Durham we aren't too keen on an elected mayor for what is laughably called the Newcastle City Region. Too much power in one pair of hands, and likely to have little interest in the more remote corners of the region. But the big question is whether it will be Ant or Dec.

    Indeed.

    But the 'Sheffield City Region' will not be just South Yorkshire butr will include huge lumps of Derbyshire and Nottinghamshire as well.

    God knows how many councils, NHS regions, transport organisations etc the new 'leadership' will have to work with (and against).

    Still I bet the 'consultants' will get very rich by giving 'advice'.

    Sheffield City Region goes a serious distance south - it includes the likes of Ashbourne and Matlock, which is the headquarters of Derbyshire County Council. It adds up to half of the District Councils in Dertbyshire.

    Quite a surprise - I have only escaped by a couple of miles. Matlock and Ashbourne should look to Derby/Nottingham in a sane division. Ashbourne is 13 miles from Derby, but 35 from Sheffield.

    It all depends on the powers it has - economic development is fine, but Planning and Edcuation policy at City Region level would be a mess. Hopefully there's enough of the rest to keep the Sheffield lot in check :D .

    At least the Peak National Park will probably stop them building on any more Derbyshire Hills or putting in more reservoirs, unlike in the 1920s/30s.
  • MattWMattW Posts: 23,969

    What happens if Corbyn dies in the next year or so ?

    Would Tom Watson be counted as 'Next Labour Leader' ?

    If not then McDonnell must stand a good chance of winning an emergency leadership election.

    AIUI the markets are for "Next Permanent Labour Leader" - ie after an election, so Watson would have to win an election.
  • If a Presidential campaign doesn't spend the money it raises, what happens to it?
  • richardDoddrichardDodd Posts: 5,472
    TWR..They have a party..
  • MattWMattW Posts: 23,969
    edited October 2015
    MTimT said:

    surbiton said:

    Antifrank: Much as I do respect and admire your political and betting judgements, this one is bonkers !

    Not that anti-austerity is not a viable strategy, it is and can be argued as such. But the press will be mercilessly attacking his past and as we have seen even with silly things like singing the National Anthem , much will be made out of them.

    Have you ever seen any US President sing their National Anthem ? Come to think of it, have you seen a British PM sing the NA ?

    Okay, Obama's is dubbed over, but at least his lips are moving:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B4F8i89vWAw

    Here's Hillary:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KQYIHQvhIk0

    Anyone who's tried understands why politicians would prefer not to sing the Star Spangled Banner.
    Yep.

    There's always some Smart Alec of a techno who will leave the mic switched on!

    And it puts Knavish Scots into perspective:

    And where is that band who so vauntingly swore
    That the havoc of war and the battle's confusion,
    A home and a country, should leave us no more?
    Their blood has washed out their foul footsteps' pollution.
    No refuge could save the hireling and slave
    From the terror of flight, or the gloom of the grave:
    And the star-spangled banner in triumph doth wave,
    O'er the land of the free and the home of the brave.
  • david_herdsondavid_herdson Posts: 17,842
    antifrank said:

    surbiton said:

    Antifrank: Much as I do respect and admire your political and betting judgements, this one is bonkers !

    Not that anti-austerity is not a viable strategy, it is and can be argued as such. But the press will be mercilessly attacking his past and as we have seen even with silly things like singing the National Anthem , much will be made out of them.

    Have you ever seen any US President sing their National Anthem ? Come to think of it, have you seen a British PM sing the NA ?

    I was not expecting universal acclaim for this particular betting tip. But I stand by it.

    Objectively the shadow Chancellor has to be a serious contender for succeeding the Leader of the Opposition.
    I agree. 50/1 is much too long. We're talking next Labour leader, not next (or future) PM.
  • david_herdsondavid_herdson Posts: 17,842

    What happens if Corbyn dies in the next year or so ?

    Would Tom Watson be counted as 'Next Labour Leader' ?

    If not then McDonnell must stand a good chance of winning an emergency leadership election.

    Not unless Watson won in his own right.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055
    edited October 2015
    Replacing Corbyn with McDonnell would be like the Tories replacing IDS with Bill Cash, a decision which would probably lead to a realignment of British politics, especially post EU ref, which occurs only once a half century or so. I would expect the Blairites and moderates within Labour to defect en mass to join the Cameroons alongside the Orange Book LDs and at the same time the anti-EU Tory right to defect to UKIP. Labour would then be finally rid of New Labour forever, with more members from the TUSC or Respect or the Greens than those who joined in the Blair years
  • TomsToms Posts: 2,478
    MTimT said "Anyone who's tried understands why politicians would prefer not to sing the Star Spangled Banner."

    Yep. But here's an unofficial USA national anthem that is very singable:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5rgR1GLLhXk
  • FangsyFangsy Posts: 28
    BBC reporting that Denis Healey has died at the age of 98.
  • MarkHopkinsMarkHopkins Posts: 5,584

    Labour's Denis Healey dies at 98

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-34434378#"

  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Welcome aboard, Mr @Fangsy
  • I confess I didn't realise Healey was still alive. RIP.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055


    Labour's Denis Healey dies at 98

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-34434378#"

    RIP Healey was probably one of the greatest PMs we never had and Labour were as mad selecting Foot over Healey as the Tories were selecting IDS over Clarke
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055

    I confess I didn't realise Healey was still alive. RIP.

    I saw him outside the National Portrait Gallery a year or two ago
  • blackburn63blackburn63 Posts: 4,492
    Antifrank's knowledge and understanding of Labour far exceeds mine so I'll watch this with interest. If they decide to go from Corbyn to McDonnell it will confirm the party is intent on committing suicide.
  • david_herdsondavid_herdson Posts: 17,842
    HYUFD said:

    Replacing Corbyn with McDonnell would be like the Tories replacing IDS with Bill Cash, a decision which would probably lead to a realignment of British politics, especially post EU ref, which occurs only once a half century or so. I would expect the Blairites and moderates within Labour to defect en mass to join the Cameroons alongside the Orange Book LDs and at the same time the anti-EU Tory right to defect to UKIP. Labour would then be finally rid of New Labour forever, with more members from the TUSC or Respect or the Greens than those who joined in the Blair years

    More likely that you'd get an SDP II. I just don't see mass Lab-Con defections unless the Cons have already shed the Eurosceptic wing, which of itself would make the attraction of defecting far lessened. By contrast, the Lib Dems need all the support they can get.
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034

    If a Presidential campaign doesn't spend the money it raises, what happens to it?

    See http://classroom.synonym.com/left-over-campaign-funds-after-elections-17435.html
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055

    HYUFD said:

    Replacing Corbyn with McDonnell would be like the Tories replacing IDS with Bill Cash, a decision which would probably lead to a realignment of British politics, especially post EU ref, which occurs only once a half century or so. I would expect the Blairites and moderates within Labour to defect en mass to join the Cameroons alongside the Orange Book LDs and at the same time the anti-EU Tory right to defect to UKIP. Labour would then be finally rid of New Labour forever, with more members from the TUSC or Respect or the Greens than those who joined in the Blair years

    More likely that you'd get an SDP II. I just don't see mass Lab-Con defections unless the Cons have already shed the Eurosceptic wing, which of itself would make the attraction of defecting far lessened. By contrast, the Lib Dems need all the support they can get.
    Possible, though the LDs would probably need to get rid of Farron first. Post a narrow EU In vote and a revived UKIP, if McConnell then replaces Corbyn after another election defeat anything could happen, certainly Labour could lose its moderate wing, the Tories their anti EU wing
  • If only I'd rejigged my fantasy team to buy Aguero and make him skipper this week.

    Hang on

    I did!!
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034
    Toms said:

    MTimT said "Anyone who's tried understands why politicians would prefer not to sing the Star Spangled Banner."

    Yep. But here's an unofficial USA national anthem that is very singable:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5rgR1GLLhXk

    Sounds familiar ;)
  • FangsyFangsy Posts: 28

    Welcome aboard, Mr @Fangsy

    Thanks Plato. I've been around for years, just haven't post since the system changed.
  • DairDair Posts: 6,108
    edited October 2015
    FPT
    Ghedebrav said:

    This is going to be a bad weekend for sport. Can't face the game tonight so am going out for a curry with the wife.

    Il Lombardia - the last big bike race of the year - looks set to be a cracker (though if you're looking for tips I'm afraid the value has drained from the market; FWIW I think Nibali will win).
    The course is really well suited for Dan Martin or Rui Costa. But personally I don't like their odds. I find the best bets on cycling tend to be getting places with good odds than finding the winner. Leo Konig is the stand out here, 200/1 with quarter odds on the top 4 at Paddy. Albasini at 100/1 isn't bad either. Stybar is also 100/1 which just seems ridiculously good odds for a place.
  • MikeKMikeK Posts: 9,053

    Antifrank's knowledge and understanding of Labour far exceeds mine so I'll watch this with interest. If they decide to go from Corbyn to McDonnell it will confirm the party is intent on committing suicide.

    Antifrank may understand Labour, but they have elected a leader that passes normal understanding. In effect it was a coup from the left wing street, aided and abetted by some left wing MP's.

    I doubt that Corbyn, who already dodges some of the MSM, cannot speak without constant referral to notes, but can rant the same old marxist claptrap without pause, will last more than six months at the helm.
  • richardDoddrichardDodd Posts: 5,472
    Just when Labour need him.. Denis Healey dies..
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034
    Yeah, took me a while to come back after the move to Vanilla, particularly when it was not supporting Safari. That seems to have been fixed now, at least.
    Fangsy said:

    Welcome aboard, Mr @Fangsy

    Thanks Plato. I've been around for years, just haven't post since the system changed.
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,529
    good result for Scotland in Rugby , no bonus for Japan
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055
    edited October 2015

    Just when Labour need him.. Denis Healey dies..

    Well he was 98, you cannot blame him, when Labour really needed him was 1980. John McDonnell praising him on BBC News now for staying loyal to Labour when other moderates defected to the SDP and for his service in WW2, humour and hinterland
  • SpeedySpeedy Posts: 12,100
    The best PM Britain never had.
    A very good man, but terribly naive as he panicked in 1976 with the IMF and he botched his Labour leadership election campaign with a single phrase "you have nowhere else to go" .
  • richardDoddrichardDodd Posts: 5,472
    There is no one of Healeys stature in the Labour Party today..the old hands must be weeping..
  • If only I'd rejigged my fantasy team to buy Aguero and make him skipper this week.

    Hang on

    I did!!

    Me too. 44 points so far for the boy Aguero.

    I'm also backing Ecosse to beat the Proteas
  • On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055

    There is no one of Healeys stature in the Labour Party today..the old hands must be weeping..

    Mind you there is no one in the Tory Party of his stature either apart from perhaps Ken Clarke
  • Scrapheap_as_wasScrapheap_as_was Posts: 10,069
    edited October 2015

    If only I'd rejigged my fantasy team to buy Aguero and make him skipper this week.

    Hang on

    I did!!

    Me too. 44 points so far for the boy Aguero.

    I'm also backing Ecosse to beat the Proteas
    great minds... haven't the scots fielded a weakened team tho?
  • SpeedySpeedy Posts: 12,100
    HYUFD said:

    Just when Labour need him.. Denis Healey dies..

    Well he was 98, you cannot blame him, when Labour really needed him was 1980. John McDonnell praising him on BBC News now for staying loyal to Labour when other moderates defected to the SDP and for his service in WW2, humour and hinterland
    That is true.
    Dennis Healey remained to remind everyone of the Callaghan government, both ups and downs.
    If he was elected leader in 1980 Labour would had split between it's establishment and it's base though. Labour was ripe for a major split over the economy since Healey's IMF situation, Foot was the only candidate that could and did limit the inevitable split as he kept the left wing base and stood up to Benn, while losing only a few from it's right.

    Healey never had the credentials to stand up to the far-left.
  • i bought and played a certain ex-spurs keeper at watford too....
  • If only I'd rejigged my fantasy team to buy Aguero and make him skipper this week.

    Hang on

    I did!!

    Me too. 44 points so far for the boy Aguero.

    I'm also backing Ecosse to beat the Proteas
    great minds... haven't the scots fielded a weakened team tho?
    Well yes, but my friend and colleague is usually a very pessimistic Scottish Rugby fan, and he feels a victory in his waters.

    Who am I to disagree?

    Mind you I've gone balls deep on the Aussies to win tonight.

    Will help with the pain losing to the flaming galahs.
  • SpeedySpeedy Posts: 12,100
    HYUFD said:

    There is no one of Healeys stature in the Labour Party today..the old hands must be weeping..

    Mind you there is no one in the Tory Party of his stature either apart from perhaps Ken Clarke
    Well great leaders are a product of crisis, from 1914 till 1993 the country was more or less in a state of permanent crisis with the occasional break.
  • RecidivistRecidivist Posts: 4,679
    A well written article and a completely logical conclusion from its original premise.

    I am not sure the premise is too solid though. For a start the hard left is a term invented by the Labour Party's enemies and is designed to scare the horses not illuminate anything. Someone like Jeremy Corbyn has very little in common with someone like Derek Hatton.

    It is also quite a stretch to assume that all Corbyn's supporters are describable as left wing, let alone that they will form a cohesive grouping that would reliably back a single candidate in the future. The candidates that were offered this summer didn't represent a spread of the opinion in the party. There were three right wingers. One was very right and one was not terribly sure himself where he stood to be sure, but they were all pretty much offering the same direction. To pick the alternative to their offering doesn't necessarily mean you are all that extreme in your opinions.

    The appeal of Blairism was always that it looked like wining. I can easily see it making a comeback. They just need a candidate that looks like a winner.
  • This is weird, my normal default position is to cheer for the side in white playing Scotland.
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,259
    So not only have the Toon been thrashed by City, we've now got a bunch of big lads ruining our pitch!
  • foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548

    i bought and played a certain ex-spurs keeper at watford too....

    I had aguero up front. A better week for me.

    Great away win for the foxes!
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055
    edited October 2015

    On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.

    Michael Howard had served in John Major's Government, I do not remember John McDonnell serving Tony Blair? Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn on the other hand...
  • HYUFD said:

    On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.

    Michael Howard had served in John Major's Government, I do not remember John McDonnell serving Tony Blair? Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn on the other hand...
    So it's official, Hillary Benn has replaced Andy Burnham as your latest mancrush
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055
    Speedy said:

    HYUFD said:

    Just when Labour need him.. Denis Healey dies..

    Well he was 98, you cannot blame him, when Labour really needed him was 1980. John McDonnell praising him on BBC News now for staying loyal to Labour when other moderates defected to the SDP and for his service in WW2, humour and hinterland
    That is true.
    Dennis Healey remained to remind everyone of the Callaghan government, both ups and downs.
    If he was elected leader in 1980 Labour would had split between it's establishment and it's base though. Labour was ripe for a major split over the economy since Healey's IMF situation, Foot was the only candidate that could and did limit the inevitable split as he kept the left wing base and stood up to Benn, while losing only a few from it's right.

    Healey never had the credentials to stand up to the far-left.
    Had Healey been leader though there would have been no SDP and the 1983 election much closer
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 63,137
    "Jeremy Corbyn may leave office in many years time after a stint as Prime Minister."

    That is one of the funniest lines I've read on PB in ages. Well done on lightening my afternoon.

    I agree, though, that given all that has come to pass, the 50/1 on McDonnell is too high, but I'll not be wasting my money. Next time the modernisers/central left are likely to make sure they have only one candidate; plus how many of the £3 will be utterly disillusioned by then? Already they've had to swallow backtracking on energy companies, with higher edu fees next up.

    And, finally, no one seems to know what happens if there is a challenge candidate next summer and Corbyn needs to get 35 MPs to nominate him? They likes of Margaret Beckett won't be lending any nominations next time. He has about 20 I'd guess.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055
    Speedy said:

    HYUFD said:

    There is no one of Healeys stature in the Labour Party today..the old hands must be weeping..

    Mind you there is no one in the Tory Party of his stature either apart from perhaps Ken Clarke
    Well great leaders are a product of crisis, from 1914 till 1993 the country was more or less in a state of permanent crisis with the occasional break.
    The 30s and 40s and 70s and early 80s yes, the 20s, 50s and 60s and 90s were rather calmer
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055

    HYUFD said:

    On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.

    Michael Howard had served in John Major's Government, I do not remember John McDonnell serving Tony Blair? Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn on the other hand...
    So it's official, Hillary Benn has replaced Andy Burnham as your latest mancrush
    Well he is the best option Labour now have before the 2020 election
  • HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.

    Michael Howard had served in John Major's Government, I do not remember John McDonnell serving Tony Blair? Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn on the other hand...
    So it's official, Hillary Benn has replaced Andy Burnham as your latest mancrush
    Well he is the best option Labour now have before the 2020 election
    In your opinion, in your opinion.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055
    We've lost a huge figure of post-war politics. A hero in World War Two as Beach Master at Anzio and a brave politician, Denis Healey told his party hard truths about Britain having to live within her means.
    By all accounts he was a hugely entertaining man personally - and author of tremendously readable and informative books. A great man and a genuine public servant has left us. We should mourn with his family and give thanks for all he gave our country.
    https://www.facebook.com/DavidCameronOfficial?fref=nf
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,529

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.

    Michael Howard had served in John Major's Government, I do not remember John McDonnell serving Tony Blair? Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn on the other hand...
    So it's official, Hillary Benn has replaced Andy Burnham as your latest mancrush
    Well he is the best option Labour now have before the 2020 election
    In your opinion, in your opinion.
    Looks like your money is gone, Scotland don't look like winning here.
  • MikeKMikeK Posts: 9,053
    Fangsy said:

    Welcome aboard, Mr @Fangsy

    Thanks Plato. I've been around for years, just haven't post since the system changed.
    Hi there Fangsy. Are you a rip and tearing into them Caninesy or a an affable chewy Molary?
  • GeoffMGeoffM Posts: 6,071
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.

    Michael Howard had served in John Major's Government, I do not remember John McDonnell serving Tony Blair? Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn on the other hand...
    So it's official, Hillary Benn has replaced Andy Burnham as your latest mancrush
    Well he is the best option Labour now have before the 2020 election
    Do you keep wipe-clean photos of these guys in an album with quick-release hinges or it only one headshot at a time in a tacky digital picture frame in your downstairs loo?
  • malcolmg said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.

    Michael Howard had served in John Major's Government, I do not remember John McDonnell serving Tony Blair? Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn on the other hand...
    So it's official, Hillary Benn has replaced Andy Burnham as your latest mancrush
    Well he is the best option Labour now have before the 2020 election
    In your opinion, in your opinion.
    Looks like your money is gone, Scotland don't look like winning here.
    Keep the faith Malcolm, keep the faith.
  • saddenedsaddened Posts: 2,245
    Scotland on for a spanking here unless they get a grip and quickly.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055
    edited October 2015

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.

    Michael Howard had served in John Major's Government, I do not remember John McDonnell serving Tony Blair? Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn on the other hand...
    So it's official, Hillary Benn has replaced Andy Burnham as your latest mancrush
    Well he is the best option Labour now have before the 2020 election
    In your opinion, in your opinion.
    No, because it is blatantly obvious he is the only candidate leftwing enough for the membership, helped by his surname, while experienced enough and centrist enough to appeal to party moderates. Labour are not going to win the next election having elected Corbyn, just as the Tories were not going to win in 2005 having picked IDS, it is about saving the furniture. An election winner can come post defeat
  • Plato_SaysPlato_Says Posts: 11,822
    Lovely tribute.
    HYUFD said:

    We've lost a huge figure of post-war politics. A hero in World War Two as Beach Master at Anzio and a brave politician, Denis Healey told his party hard truths about Britain having to live within her means.
    By all accounts he was a hugely entertaining man personally - and author of tremendously readable and informative books. A great man and a genuine public servant has left us. We should mourn with his family and give thanks for all he gave our country.
    https://www.facebook.com/DavidCameronOfficial?fref=nf

  • SpeedySpeedy Posts: 12,100
    On topic:
    I also agree that the odds for Labour right wingers are too short, the Labour party is left wing and still has bad memories from Blair, as such not even Hillary Benn has much chances as does any member of the last Labour government, whom the public and the members are trying to forget.
    But it is very premature to speculate about the next party leaders, especially Labour, future events and personalities of the next 5 years are too obscure right know to make a judgement.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055
    edited October 2015
    Speedy said:

    On topic:
    I also agree that the odds for Labour right wingers are too short, the Labour party is left wing and still has bad memories from Blair, as such not even Hillary Benn has much chances as does any member of the last Labour government, whom the public and the members are trying to forget.
    But it is very premature to speculate about the next party leaders, especially Labour, future events and personalities of the next 5 years are too obscure right know to make a judgement.

    Hilary Benn will only take over if, say, Labour come third behind UKIP in a by election just as Howard took over when the Tories came third in Brent East. If Labour then elect another leftwinger especially after a Corbyn election defeat then as I said it will be the catalyst for a realignment in UK politics with Labour moderates leaving, perhaps to form a new SDP as David H suggested with the LDs and the Tory right moving to UKIP post EU ref
  • MortimerMortimer Posts: 14,142
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.

    Michael Howard had served in John Major's Government, I do not remember John McDonnell serving Tony Blair? Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn on the other hand...
    So it's official, Hillary Benn has replaced Andy Burnham as your latest mancrush
    Well he is the best option Labour now have before the 2020 election
    In your opinion, in your opinion.
    No, because it is blatantly obvious he is the only candidate leftwing enough for the membership, helped by his surname, while experienced enough and centrist enough to appeal to party moderates. Labour are not going to win the next election having elected Corbyn, just as the Tories were not going to win in 2005 having picked IDS, it is about saving the furniture. An election winner can come post defeat
    Just like it was blatantly obvious that Burnham was going to win the Labour leadership this year?

  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055
    GeoffM said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.

    Michael Howard had served in John Major's Government, I do not remember John McDonnell serving Tony Blair? Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn on the other hand...
    So it's official, Hillary Benn has replaced Andy Burnham as your latest mancrush
    Well he is the best option Labour now have before the 2020 election
    Do you keep wipe-clean photos of these guys in an album with quick-release hinges or it only one headshot at a time in a tacky digital picture frame in your downstairs loo?
    I can assure you I do not have a calendar of Hilary Benn in my downstairs loo
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055
    Mortimer said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.

    Michael Howard had served in John Major's Government, I do not remember John McDonnell serving Tony Blair? Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn on the other hand...
    So it's official, Hillary Benn has replaced Andy Burnham as your latest mancrush
    Well he is the best option Labour now have before the 2020 election
    In your opinion, in your opinion.
    No, because it is blatantly obvious he is the only candidate leftwing enough for the membership, helped by his surname, while experienced enough and centrist enough to appeal to party moderates. Labour are not going to win the next election having elected Corbyn, just as the Tories were not going to win in 2005 having picked IDS, it is about saving the furniture. An election winner can come post defeat
    Just like it was blatantly obvious that Burnham was going to win the Labour leadership this year?

    No, it was blatantly obvious he was the best candidate, that did not mean Labour would pick him, which they did not
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055

    Lovely tribute.

    HYUFD said:

    We've lost a huge figure of post-war politics. A hero in World War Two as Beach Master at Anzio and a brave politician, Denis Healey told his party hard truths about Britain having to live within her means.
    By all accounts he was a hugely entertaining man personally - and author of tremendously readable and informative books. A great man and a genuine public servant has left us. We should mourn with his family and give thanks for all he gave our country.
    https://www.facebook.com/DavidCameronOfficial?fref=nf

    Indeed
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903

    "Jeremy Corbyn may leave office in many years time after a stint as Prime Minister."

    That is one of the funniest lines I've read on PB in ages. Well done on lightening my afternoon.

    I agree, though, that given all that has come to pass, the 50/1 on McDonnell is too high, but I'll not be wasting my money. Next time the modernisers/central left are likely to make sure they have only one candidate; plus how many of the £3 will be utterly disillusioned by then? Already they've had to swallow backtracking on energy companies, with higher edu fees next up.

    And, finally, no one seems to know what happens if there is a challenge candidate next summer and Corbyn needs to get 35 MPs to nominate him? They likes of Margaret Beckett won't be lending any nominations next time. He has about 20 I'd guess.

    Correct - the question is who is the most left wing candidate that can get 35 nominations?
    The answer doesn't really matter - the fact that the question has to be asked demonstrates to what extent labour are stuffed.
  • SpeedySpeedy Posts: 12,100
    HYUFD said:

    Speedy said:

    HYUFD said:

    There is no one of Healeys stature in the Labour Party today..the old hands must be weeping..

    Mind you there is no one in the Tory Party of his stature either apart from perhaps Ken Clarke
    Well great leaders are a product of crisis, from 1914 till 1993 the country was more or less in a state of permanent crisis with the occasional break.
    The 30s and 40s and 70s and early 80s yes, the 20s, 50s and 60s and 90s were rather calmer
    The 20's was filled with strikes and attempts of revolution.
    The 50's started with the Korean war which took till 1953 to end.
    The 60's had increasingly social and economic instability towards it's end, the first union troubles, the 70's malaise and race riots made their first appearances in the late 60's.
    The 90's had the ERM fiasco with Britain stuck in recession from 1990 till the ERM collapse.

    So in essence the calm years between 1914 and 1993 were 1927-1929, 1935-1938, 1954-1955, 1957-1966, 1986-1989.
  • HYUFD said:


    Labour's Denis Healey dies at 98

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-34434378#"

    RIP Healey was probably one of the greatest PMs we never had and Labour were as mad selecting Foot over Healey as the Tories were selecting IDS over Clarke
    I applaud your restraint in not adding 'Corbyn over Burnham' into the mix.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055
    Jeremy Corbyn 'Denis Healey was a giant of the Labour Party whose record of service to his party and his country stands as his testament. He distinguished himself with his military service during the Second World War and continued that commitment to the British people as a Labour politician at the highest levels of government. His wit and personality transcended politics itself, making him one of the most recognisable politicians of his era.
    Speaking personally, we had many interesting conversations when I was first elected to Parliament in 1983 and I found him a decent and very knowledgeable man who I enjoyed engaging with, particularly in his work as Shadow Foreign Secretary. Labour is built on people with the commitment of those who devote their lives to public service, as Denis Healey did.
    The thoughts of everyone in the Labour Party are with his family at this time.'
    https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=10153687873398872&id=330250343871&refid=52&_ft_=top_level_post_id.10153687873398872:tl_objid.10153687873398872
  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903

    What happens if Corbyn dies in the next year or so ?
    Would Tom Watson be counted as 'Next Labour Leader' ?
    If not then McDonnell must stand a good chance of winning an emergency leadership election.

    How would he get the nominations? There probably is one but l cannot find the sub-section on thumb screws in Labour's leadership rules.
  • SpeedySpeedy Posts: 12,100
    HYUFD said:

    Speedy said:

    On topic:
    I also agree that the odds for Labour right wingers are too short, the Labour party is left wing and still has bad memories from Blair, as such not even Hillary Benn has much chances as does any member of the last Labour government, whom the public and the members are trying to forget.
    But it is very premature to speculate about the next party leaders, especially Labour, future events and personalities of the next 5 years are too obscure right know to make a judgement.

    Hilary Benn will only take over if, say, Labour come third behind UKIP in a by election just as Howard took over when the Tories came third in Brent East. If Labour then elect another leftwinger especially after a Corbyn election defeat then as I said it will be the catalyst for a realignment in UK politics with Labour moderates leaving, perhaps to form a new SDP as David H suggested with the LDs and the Tory right moving to UKIP post EU ref
    Labour has already come 3rd in many by-elections behind UKIP already, in Eastleigh back in 2013 it came 4th.
    Keep your powder dry, 5 years is a long time.
  • Denis Healey's speech to Labour conference after 1959 defeat.

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CQZ93W-WoAEktB8.jpg
  • MortimerMortimer Posts: 14,142
    HYUFD said:

    Mortimer said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    On topic, John Rentoul on this piece

    @JohnRentoul: Antifrank’s on why he's taken 50/1 on John McDonnell to be next Labour leader: well, why not?

    I agree with John Rentoul and Antifrank.

    If Corbyn is Labour's IDS* then we should remember when IDS was toppled it was his Shadow Chancellor that replaced him.

    *I have huge doubts that Corbyn is Labour's IDS, he's much much worse and toxic.

    Michael Howard had served in John Major's Government, I do not remember John McDonnell serving Tony Blair? Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn on the other hand...
    So it's official, Hillary Benn has replaced Andy Burnham as your latest mancrush
    Well he is the best option Labour now have before the 2020 election
    In your opinion, in your opinion.
    No, because it is blatantly obvious he is the only candidate leftwing enough for the membership, helped by his surname, while experienced enough and centrist enough to appeal to party moderates. Labour are not going to win the next election having elected Corbyn, just as the Tories were not going to win in 2005 having picked IDS, it is about saving the furniture. An election winner can come post defeat
    Just like it was blatantly obvious that Burnham was going to win the Labour leadership this year?

    No, it was blatantly obvious he was the best candidate, that did not mean Labour would pick him, which they did not
    He was indeed the best candidate for those wanting Conservative victory at the next election. Unelectable SPAD weathervane politician. He would have lost seats to UKIP oop-north

  • SpeedySpeedy Posts: 12,100
    HYUFD said:

    Jeremy Corbyn 'Denis Healey was a giant of the Labour Party whose record of service to his party and his country stands as his testament. He distinguished himself with his military service during the Second World War and continued that commitment to the British people as a Labour politician at the highest levels of government. His wit and personality transcended politics itself, making him one of the most recognisable politicians of his era.
    Speaking personally, we had many interesting conversations when I was first elected to Parliament in 1983 and I found him a decent and very knowledgeable man who I enjoyed engaging with, particularly in his work as Shadow Foreign Secretary. Labour is built on people with the commitment of those who devote their lives to public service, as Denis Healey did.
    The thoughts of everyone in the Labour Party are with his family at this time.'
    https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=10153687873398872&id=330250343871&refid=52&_ft_=top_level_post_id.10153687873398872:tl_objid.10153687873398872

    Well one of the fitting tributes has to include the moment Healey started the ball rolling for the Labour party splitting:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RpKz54bxXuU
  • Conceding a try when the other lot are down to 14? yeah I've done my money in.
  • NickPalmerNickPalmer Posts: 21,572
    edited October 2015
    I'm very sorry to hear about Denis. A personal anecdote - when I was standing in his area (E Sussex & S Kent) in the 1995 Euros, our only big fundraiser had him as a guest speaker. The day before, John Smith died. I thought we'd have a minute's silence at the event and then press on, but Denis said he was devastated and couldn't possibly speak. I said it was a pity, as we had no other way of raising significant funds. He said sorry, but no.

    Two days later, an anonymous gift of £1000 arrived via the regional party, and as the election progressed and we again ran low, a further £1000 arrived. Bemused, I asked Region where all this was coming from. "Denis, of course," they said. "But he asked for it to be kept private, he didn't want to speak when his friend had just died, but he also didn't want you to lose out. And he doesn't want any fuss or credit."
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 57,684
    Can I just thank PBers for the recommendations for video games for my flights to and from Australia next week :-)

    My current plan is to finish reading the fabulous The Power of the Dog, and then move onto (game-wise):

    Civ IV
    and
    Half Life 2 (which I've owned for 12 years but never played).

    Any other suggestions will be gratefully received.
  • RogerRoger Posts: 19,988
    edited October 2015
    Our clueless PM has just announced that Russia are making matters worse 'by attacking the wrong rebels'. He didn't elaborate on how this makes matters worse or which were the wrong rebels or even why one group of rebels were wronger than the others.

    Meanwhile he or his allies have just killed 19 patients in a Medecin sans frontiere hospital near Kabul. The 'allied' spokesman said the Taliban have been known to hide in hospitals in the past from which we must assume the attack wasn't an accident.

    I'm starting to think the world would be a much better place if he stuck to shagging pigs and left international affairs to Putin.
  • SpeedySpeedy Posts: 12,100
    edited October 2015

    Denis Healey's speech to Labour conference after 1959 defeat.

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CQZ93W-WoAEktB8.jpg

    A lot of that speech would get cheers at Labour party conferences today but not votes at elections. The irony.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,055
    Very sorry to hear that Denis Healey has died. He was, undoubtedly, a giant of the post war Labour movement. Condolences to his family. @NicolaSturgeon
Sign In or Register to comment.