Looks like the pollsters have overestimated the Yes vote by quite a margin.
Michael Forsyth on Scottish BBC made the point that it down to the mis-interpreting of the Don't knows by the media is more the problem. It appears that most if not all of them have just been people who did not want to say that they were voting No.
Call Me Dave needs to pull something serious out of the hat tomorrow re WLQ and EVEL to salvage this for the Cons....I dont expect him to. Big night for UKIP.
Michael Forsyth on Scottish BBC made the point that it down to the mis-interpreting of the Don't knows by the media is more the problem. It appears that most if not all of them have just been people who did not want to say that they were voting No.
@DPJHodges: Like I said, the don't knows weren't don't knows. They were no's.
It will be interesting to see how the final result compares with the historic polling on Scottish independence. In the cobwebbed recesses of my mind I had it that about 30% were in favour before all this began.
Could all the talk, waffle and bluster over the last three years really have added only 10-15% onto the Yes vote?
If Inverclyde and the lanarkshires are fairly close and Glasgow/Dundee are yes, then that should bump the yes% up a bit. Whether it goes above 45% or not is the big betting question.
If Inverclyde and the lanarkshires are fairly close and Glasgow/Dundee are yes, then that should bump the yes% up a bit. Whether it goes above 45% or not is the big betting question.
We're not going to get any yessers here tonight - I would have thought.
Boring fucks. They should drink more malt.
I voted Yes, and my bet on Yes 45% - 50% is looking iffy now. On the plus side, I think this boosts the chances of LD holds next year in Argyll and Gordon against the SNP.
If Inverclyde and the lanarkshires are fairly close and Glasgow/Dundee are yes, then that should bump the yes% up a bit. Whether it goes above 45% or not is the big betting question.
Clackmannanshire has me worried though.
What do you need 40 - 45 or 45+
43+ is best for me.
I'm just seeing some value in the 4.5 on 45-50% on BF. Should be more like 5/2 imo.
Looks like the pollsters have overestimated the Yes vote by quite a margin.
Michael Forsyth on Scottish BBC made the point that it down to the mis-interpreting of the Don't knows by the media is more the problem. It appears that most if not all of them have just been people who did not want to say that they were voting No.
I'm not sure that is right. Does it chime with what the canvassers from both sides found? Why should people be shy when anonymously completing opinion polls but not when talking to canvassers standing two feet away? Is it not more likely that don't knows broke late for no, either because it was the status quo or because of the late positive twist of the Better Together campaign?
We're not going to get any yessers here tonight - I would have thought.
Boring fucks. They should drink more malt.
I voted Yes, and my bet on Yes 45% - 50% is looking iffy now. On the plus side, I think this boosts the chances of LD holds next year in Argyll and Gordon against the SNP.
I made the same bet!!! We're probably the only two excited people in Scotland...
UKIP guy was a nutter, but when will lefties learn screaming racist as soon as a UKIP peson comes on wont work, if they don't want UKIP to gain popularity.
The YES campaigner then just got into a screaming match with him, and both look like chumps. Jim Murphy was doing well, but let the mask slip at the end.
I don't think left leaning metro elite types get that screaming racist / little Englander at them actually has the opposite effect on a large percentage of the electorate that don't see what a lot of UKIP claim they stand for as objectionable / racist.
They need to fight UKIP on the flaws in their policies.
@RobD Look on the bright side, Sean gets to pay 10 times the price you do for a bottle of wine, and etiquette demands that his guests tell them it tastes "divine", even though it reminds them of sweaty socks.
If Inverclyde and the lanarkshires are fairly close and Glasgow/Dundee are yes, then that should bump the yes% up a bit. Whether it goes above 45% or not is the big betting question.
Clackmannanshire has me worried though.
What do you need 40 - 45 or 45+
43+ is best for me.
I think you'll get 43%+ Not much more, but it'll be a bit higher than that.
My guess right now is 44-44.5, but still early days.
@RobD Look on the bright side, Sean gets to pay 10 times the price you do for a bottle of wine, and etiquette demands that his guests tell them it tastes "divine", even though it reminds them of sweaty socks.
Oh my Smarmy - You are such a C - I can sympathise with Malky and his semi-infamous german wine - But this is so out of order it is unreal.
UKIP guy was a nutter, but when will lefties learn screaming racist as soon as a UKIP peson comes on wont work, if they don't want UKIP to gain popularity.
The YES campaigner then just got into a screaming match with him, and both look like chumps. Jim Murphy was doing well, but let the mask slip at the end.
I don't think left leaning metro elite types get that screaming racist / little Englander at them actually has the opposite effect on a large percentage of the electorate that don't see what a lot of UKIP claim they stand for as objectionable / racist.
They need to fight UKIP on the flaws in their policies.
it comforts the left to think all UKIP voters are poor, uneducated, inward looking, etc etc. Living in a posh area of Surrey I can say that is not the case.
For all republicans the question on the ballot paper was the wrong question which is do you want Scotland to be a republic.The failure to switch from a monarchist position lost any hope Salmond may have had for winning a significant proportion of those voters who remained neutral and voted neutral by not voting.The question was the wrong question anyway.
Why is the BBC having a guy from America talking about the huge list of America's problems and what does anything of ISIS, Ukraine and Russia have anything to do with Dundee or anywhere else?
Our unofficial target in Dundee was 45%. If Sky's estimates of the bundles is right (are they really allowed to that?) we will have met that. Considering where we were in Dundee a month ago that would be a very satisfactory result.
The Inverclyde result was the first slightly disappointing result for No. But this will only affect the scale of the victory.
Just broken out the 13-year old Glen Moray. If Yes can't win Inverclyde, they're knackered. Will they win Glasgow? Has to be doubtful. 40-45 still 1.6+.
Comments
Boring fucks. They should drink more malt.
God may indeed ride a "Harley"...but Moses rode a Triumph.
" And the roar of his triumph was heard all over Israel"?
What do you see the final result being?
under over 45%?
@WingsScotland: TV just switched itself off. I'm taking the hint. We gave it a shot, folks. Our countrymen and women bottled it and failed us all.
Fair play - you're an interesting poster.
Could all the talk, waffle and bluster over the last three years really have added only 10-15% onto the Yes vote?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_for_the_Scottish_independence_referendum,_2014#2011
I forget to praise MI5 in the thread header.
Judging by the piles YES is winning Dundee by 9,000 votes
Loved the BBC comment: I know Welsh so I should understand.. I personally didn't but could pick up the YES nine (thou) and NO (thou)....
"LD's to be wiped out."
"Salmond is like Robert Mugabe. "
"You get paid to write drunk. My life is officially CRAP. "
Only for a given degree of crapness? Statistically there will be some whose lives are far more crap than yours.
Clackmannanshire has me worried though.
tick, tock, boom loser.
Has Rupe been on the phone?
43+ is best for me.
On the plus side, I think this boosts the chances of LD holds next year in Argyll and Gordon against the SNP.
But noone's here, are they? I expect all sorts of excuses to be rolled out when they eventually pluck up the courage to show up.
But it's not very British behaviour, is it?
He's a drinking friend too...
The YES campaigner then just got into a screaming match with him, and both look like chumps. Jim Murphy was doing well, but let the mask slip at the end.
I don't think left leaning metro elite types get that screaming racist / little Englander at them actually has the opposite effect on a large percentage of the electorate that don't see what a lot of UKIP claim they stand for as objectionable / racist.
They need to fight UKIP on the flaws in their policies.
Look on the bright side, Sean gets to pay 10 times the price you do for a bottle of wine, and etiquette demands that his guests tell them it tastes "divine", even though it reminds them of sweaty socks.
My guess right now is 44-44.5, but still early days.
@DailyMailUK: Salmond looks miserable tonight http://t.co/E2Evr15lFr #IndyRef http://t.co/oQB12mPoC7
;-)
Bet you've even had a neo-cider in pub eh??
Living in a posh area of Surrey I can say that is not the case.
I had a very nice cider in a pub recently, I have no idea what it was, but it was strong enough,while still tasting of fresh apples.
I'm on inverclyde as highest yes council @ 66/1 - Glasgow/dundee is sure to beat it though...
So a bit of a surprise there.
Five results in - five NO's on the board.
The Inverclyde result was the first slightly disappointing result for No. But this will only affect the scale of the victory.
I can be generous, I am still well ahead by my count....... ;-)