Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

LAB’s set to win most seats but is not in majority territory – politicalbetting.com

12346»

Comments

  • WhisperingOracleWhisperingOracle Posts: 9,158
    edited December 2022
    57% already in favour of a more close trading relationship which also includes free movement, according to the poll below.

    With figures like that, a single market referendum will surely be a reality at some point or other.
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 48,661

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
  • carnforthcarnforth Posts: 4,587
    Scott_xP said:

    Support for elements of a Swiss-style EU deal https://twitter.com/JohnRentoul/status/1599143200567963648/photo/1

    Be more useful if the author of those questions understood the difference between Schenghen and freedom of movement. Or that we already have access to the single market (just not membership of it). And so on.
  • Scott_xP said:

    Support for elements of a Swiss-style EU deal https://twitter.com/JohnRentoul/status/1599143200567963648/photo/1

    Trouble will come when the people of the UK are asked what they are prepared to offer/give up/swallow to get those goodies. I sense/fear we are still a way off having that conversation.
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,664

    OllyT said:

    Scott_xP said:

    Latest from @OpiniumResearch 30 Nov-2 Dec: Lab lead down to 14 points
    Lab 43%
    Con 29%
    Lib Dems 8%
    Reform 6%
    Green 6%

    As I predicted, cons on 29 up 1, upward movement not stalled at all.

    Vindicated 😇
    Of the last 6 polls published on Britain Elects 5 have the Conservatives going down and Opinium has them going up by a solitary 1%. You have a very strange definition of vindicated if you don't mind me saying so.
    You're right but... it's not worth it.

    We are now going to get a dozen or more Moonrabbit posts repeating the same mistaken point.
    But what I am pointing to here is fact. I am comparing from the same pollster same methodology, and asking you to look how close todays poll is to the 4 point lab lead under Truss just before her budget.

    Lab just 5 above where they were, LLG just 1 above where it was pre mini budget, Tories 1 point higher than they were sept 2nd if they gobble back up the 6 for reform they had in their belly 2nd September.

    Point out and explain my mistaken point. All these are facts. The Opinium trend back to where we were pre mini budget is real, undeniable, AND VERY NEARLY THERE.

    This poll with Opinium 2nd September. Go compare!

    2 down eleven to go.
    A 14% lead is close to a 4% lead. Just one digit difference. Got it.
  • MoonRabbitMoonRabbit Posts: 13,507
    OllyT said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:

    Latest from @OpiniumResearch 30 Nov-2 Dec: Lab lead down to 14 points
    Lab 43%
    Con 29%
    Lib Dems 8%
    Reform 6%
    Green 6%

    Would give Conservatives 207 MPs on the new boundaries and Labour a majority of 68.

    Better from Sunak and now closer to a Howard 2005 result than Major 1997 or Hague 2001 and much better than the annihilation Truss was heading for
    https://www.electoralcalculus.co.uk/fcgi-bin/usercode.py?scotcontrol=Y&CON=29&LAB=43&LIB=8&Reform=6&Green=2&UKIP=&TVCON=&TVLAB=&TVLIB=&TVReform=&TVGreen=&TVUKIP=&SCOTCON=14.3&SCOTLAB=30.7&SCOTLIB=6.7&SCOTReform=0.6&SCOTGreen=1.7&SCOTUKIP=&SCOTNAT=43.7&display=AllChanged&regorseat=(none)&boundary=2019nbbase
    You are missing something.

    What this poll is telling us, in Opinium terms we are very nearly reset back to exactly where we were just before the Trussterfuck budget - LLG just 1 different, but Tories even higher now on 35 than the 34 they were on sept 2nd if they gobble up all the reform 6!

    Labour on 43, just 5 above where Opinum put them on 2nd September as their own trussy bonus continues to unwind downward,
    However while LLG is one higher than in Opiniums 2 sep poll, 56 to 57 - Con and reform on this poll has Tory Ref higher than what Tories got on sept 2nd 34 up to 35.

    Ramping a Large Labour majority is now blown out the water. It’s just 50/50 they even get a majority.

    Opinium with their methodology are merely ahead of the game that things inevitably and rather quickly resetting back to pre Trussterfuck
    Opinium aren't reporting current opinion, they are asking for voters' views and then guessing what they will then do when the next election comes around. If 29% is what the Tories are getting after swingback is taken into account then Labour will be delighted.
    I know all that Olly, I oft repeat it. But what you are arguing means nowt if we are comparing Opinium with Opinium.

    Just look at the trend line in Opinium alone. Just look how close the trend now getting to the 4% lead just before Truss mini budget.
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 21,298
    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Lol.
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 48,661
    Cookie said:

    DavidL said:

    Cookie said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    I went to Old Trafford today to watch Man U ladies against Aston Villa ladies. I hadn't been since the 80s.
    A patina of woke has been layered across the absurd tribalism I remember from last time around. It was 80% "Manchester United is brilliant and we're all amazing and we all love Alex Ferguson", 20% rainbows and racism. There was the obligatory kneel before the match, to a smattering of polite applause. One stupid quasi-religion layered across another.
    The football, by the way, was excellent and well worth the ridiculously cheap price of a ticket - if a little lacking in jeopardy (Man U won 5-0). If you can put up with the utter inanity of being in a football stadium, the WSL is amazing value. And an attendance of around 30,000!
    The WSL is getting fabulous crowds at the moment because people are being deprived of their Premier league in what should be the peak of the season. Good luck to them. Hopefully their product will continue to attract at least some of those watching when real football recommences.
    I also suspect the ticket price is slightly lower than the EPL ticket price.*

    *Im glad that the womens game is taking off. It just doesn’t need comparison to the mens for validation.
    Yes, it is. The women's game is priced at what I would pay to watch a football match. The men's game is priced at roughly 7 times that.
    But the quality of the product is not, nowadays, 7 times better. For the casual viewer like me, the men's game is maybe slightly better (maybe 1.5x better, rather than the 7x better the ticket price implies), but that's balanced out by almost every single male footballer being very hard to like.
    Leicester City Women lost 8 nil today, and are still without a point.

    There are really only a half dozen competitive women's sides in the country.
  • Fckn hell, the Telegraph is even shite at the stuff it's supposed to be good at. Drummed out of the sycophantic plastic patriots' union with immediate effect.


    Letters incoming, twelve o'clock high!
    In defence of the telegraph that is a mosquito being used for the same purpose.
    The Tele is the only one calling it a Spitfire in flight.
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,664
    edited December 2022

    Scott_xP said:

    Support for elements of a Swiss-style EU deal https://twitter.com/JohnRentoul/status/1599143200567963648/photo/1

    Trouble will come when the people of the UK are asked what they are prepared to offer/give up/swallow to get those goodies. I sense/fear we are still a way off having that conversation.
    What was it you had in mind? From that Rentoul tweet:
    - The UK joining the Schengen free travel area and having freedom of movement with the EU: Support 57%, Oppose 22%
    - The UK agreeing to some EU legislation as part of a wider deal on a closer relationship: Support 53%, Oppose 25%

  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 48,661

    Scott_xP said:

    Support for elements of a Swiss-style EU deal https://twitter.com/JohnRentoul/status/1599143200567963648/photo/1

    Trouble will come when the people of the UK are asked what they are prepared to offer/give up/swallow to get those goodies. I sense/fear we are still a way off having that conversation.
    Wasn't there a poll recently that showed 2/3 of Swiss want to join the EEA?
  • WhisperingOracleWhisperingOracle Posts: 9,158
    edited December 2022

    Scott_xP said:

    Support for elements of a Swiss-style EU deal https://twitter.com/JohnRentoul/status/1599143200567963648/photo/1

    Trouble will come when the people of the UK are asked what they are prepared to offer/give up/swallow to get those goodies. I sense/fear we are still a way off having that conversation.
    But Single Market gets 63%, and, contrary to many previous reports and most strikingly of all, Free Movement also already gets 57%. So in fact we're already closer than many politicians think.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 55,339
    THE ELON HATH SPOKE

    Elon Musk
    @elonmusk

    Replying to
    "@sama ChatGPT is scary good. We are not far from dangerously strong AI."

    https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1599128577068650498?s=20&t=Vv7XRxp50f9TC6KwPfpZmA


    He's right. As soon as @FrancisUrquhart of this sweet parish turned me on to GPT3 back in 2020, I knew this was Dangerous AI on the horizon

    And I have been right all along, ever since
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 17,405

    Cookie said:

    DavidL said:

    Cookie said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    I went to Old Trafford today to watch Man U ladies against Aston Villa ladies. I hadn't been since the 80s.
    A patina of woke has been layered across the absurd tribalism I remember from last time around. It was 80% "Manchester United is brilliant and we're all amazing and we all love Alex Ferguson", 20% rainbows and racism. There was the obligatory kneel before the match, to a smattering of polite applause. One stupid quasi-religion layered across another.
    The football, by the way, was excellent and well worth the ridiculously cheap price of a ticket - if a little lacking in jeopardy (Man U won 5-0). If you can put up with the utter inanity of being in a football stadium, the WSL is amazing value. And an attendance of around 30,000!
    The WSL is getting fabulous crowds at the moment because people are being deprived of their Premier league in what should be the peak of the season. Good luck to them. Hopefully their product will continue to attract at least some of those watching when real football recommences.
    I also suspect the ticket price is slightly lower than the EPL ticket price.*

    *Im glad that the womens game is taking off. It just doesn’t need comparison to the mens for validation.
    Yes, it is. The women's game is priced at what I would pay to watch a football match. The men's game is priced at roughly 7 times that.
    But the quality of the product is not, nowadays, 7 times better. For the casual viewer like me, the men's game is maybe slightly better (maybe 1.5x better, rather than the 7x better the ticket price implies), but that's balanced out by almost every single male footballer being very hard to like.
    Did it end like the Not the Nine O'clock News women's football sketch?
    “Wait for it. Wait for it…”
  • MoonRabbitMoonRabbit Posts: 13,507

    OllyT said:

    Scott_xP said:

    Latest from @OpiniumResearch 30 Nov-2 Dec: Lab lead down to 14 points
    Lab 43%
    Con 29%
    Lib Dems 8%
    Reform 6%
    Green 6%

    As I predicted, cons on 29 up 1, upward movement not stalled at all.

    Vindicated 😇
    Of the last 6 polls published on Britain Elects 5 have the Conservatives going down and Opinium has them going up by a solitary 1%. You have a very strange definition of vindicated if you don't mind me saying so.
    You're right but... it's not worth it.

    We are now going to get a dozen or more Moonrabbit posts repeating the same mistaken point.
    But what I am pointing to here is fact. I am comparing from the same pollster same methodology, and asking you to look how close todays poll is to the 4 point lab lead under Truss just before her budget.

    Lab just 5 above where they were, LLG just 1 above where it was pre mini budget, Tories 1 point higher than they were sept 2nd if they gobble back up the 6 for reform they had in their belly 2nd September.

    Point out and explain my mistaken point. All these are facts. The Opinium trend back to where we were pre mini budget is real, undeniable, AND VERY NEARLY THERE.

    This poll with Opinium 2nd September. Go compare!

    2 down eleven to go.
    A 14% lead is close to a 4% lead. Just one digit difference. Got it.
    For the billionth time, stop talking leads, look at the totals across all the party’s % to know what is really going on. From doing that we learn Lab didn’t get their boost solely from Tories, they took hair cuts from greens and Lib Dems too, some of that hair is still in their mouths. The resetting currently going on apace from here back to just before mini budget is not Lab to Tory lead or Lab to Tory swing. Tory’s just 5 below where Opinium had them, with reform now on 6. And Lib Dem and greens can take back their hair to put Labour in the thirties and the lead you are looking at into single figures. This is all fact, historical fact and scientific fact - Labour can drop into 30s and the lead shrivel simply by giving hair back to greens and Libdems.

    I don’t even think some of you can spell Psephophocalology.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,957
    Just watching Strictly on catch up. Amazing opening Indian Bollywood number. Was there any football on tonight?
  • Scott_xP said:

    Support for elements of a Swiss-style EU deal https://twitter.com/JohnRentoul/status/1599143200567963648/photo/1

    Trouble will come when the people of the UK are asked what they are prepared to offer/give up/swallow to get those goodies. I sense/fear we are still a way off having that conversation.
    What was it you had in mind? From that Rentoul tweet:
    - The UK joining the Schengen free travel area and having freedom of movement with the EU: Support 57%, Oppose 22%
    - The UK agreeing to some EU legislation as part of a wider deal on a closer relationship: Support 53%, Oppose 25%

    That sort of thing, yes.

    Though I'd be more confident if the first of those were phrased as "The UK and EU having mutual freedom of movement", for example.

    One of the complaints of some "look what you made me do" Brexit backers was that the EU should have offered the UK a unilateral brake on FoM. We could go there, but they couldn't necessarily come here. Which was never going to fly.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,406
    Foxy said:

    Cookie said:

    DavidL said:

    Cookie said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    I went to Old Trafford today to watch Man U ladies against Aston Villa ladies. I hadn't been since the 80s.
    A patina of woke has been layered across the absurd tribalism I remember from last time around. It was 80% "Manchester United is brilliant and we're all amazing and we all love Alex Ferguson", 20% rainbows and racism. There was the obligatory kneel before the match, to a smattering of polite applause. One stupid quasi-religion layered across another.
    The football, by the way, was excellent and well worth the ridiculously cheap price of a ticket - if a little lacking in jeopardy (Man U won 5-0). If you can put up with the utter inanity of being in a football stadium, the WSL is amazing value. And an attendance of around 30,000!
    The WSL is getting fabulous crowds at the moment because people are being deprived of their Premier league in what should be the peak of the season. Good luck to them. Hopefully their product will continue to attract at least some of those watching when real football recommences.
    I also suspect the ticket price is slightly lower than the EPL ticket price.*

    *Im glad that the womens game is taking off. It just doesn’t need comparison to the mens for validation.
    Yes, it is. The women's game is priced at what I would pay to watch a football match. The men's game is priced at roughly 7 times that.
    But the quality of the product is not, nowadays, 7 times better. For the casual viewer like me, the men's game is maybe slightly better (maybe 1.5x better, rather than the 7x better the ticket price implies), but that's balanced out by almost every single male footballer being very hard to like.
    Leicester City Women lost 8 nil today, and are still without a point.

    There are really only a half dozen competitive women's sides in the country.
    There are only that many men's if you choose to look at it that way.
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,664
    TOPPING said:

    Just watching Strictly on catch up. Amazing opening Indian Bollywood number. Was there any football on tonight?

    That was last week's Strictly, shirley?
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 122,969
    edited December 2022

    Scott_xP said:

    Support for elements of a Swiss-style EU deal https://twitter.com/JohnRentoul/status/1599143200567963648/photo/1

    Trouble will come when the people of the UK are asked what they are prepared to offer/give up/swallow to get those goodies. I sense/fear we are still a way off having that conversation.
    But Single Market gets 63%, and, contrary to many previous reports and most strikingly of all, Free Movement gets 57%. So we're already closer than many politicians think.
    Depends entirely which poll looked at.

    This one last month had 46% of voters thinking we have too much immigration only 18% too little.

    https://whatukthinks.org/eu/questions/generally-speaking-would-you-say-britain-currently-has-too-much-immigration-not-enough-immigration-or-about-the-right-amount/

    Even the Tony Blair Institute found only 23% want to rejoin the full EU and 11% the single market when given a full range of options


    https://institute.global/policy/moving-how-british-public-views-brexit-and-what-it-wants-future-relationship-european-union
  • MoonRabbitMoonRabbit Posts: 13,507
    Roger said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    "When a wise man points at the moon only a fool looks at the finger"
    So right!
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,957

    TOPPING said:

    Just watching Strictly on catch up. Amazing opening Indian Bollywood number. Was there any football on tonight?

    That was last week's Strictly, shirley?
    Oh shoot I wasn't sure which one it was. I just watched the latest one on iPlayer but it did look dated.

    Still a cracking number though
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,406

    Roger said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    "When a wise man points at the moon only a fool looks at the finger"
    So right!
    "The wise man knows what he does not know."
    "Think on Minnie Caldwell."
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 122,969
    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
  • geoffwgeoffw Posts: 8,718
     Phillips P. OBrien
    @PhillipsPOBrien
    This map of Russian aircraft activity from the last few months reveals one of the reasons the war has developed as it has and why Russian military power was so overestimated before 24 Feb. If you look at the map of where Russian aircraft were located…
    https://mobile.twitter.com/PhillipsPOBrien/status/1599035027307696128
  • LeonLeon Posts: 55,339
    it's quite incredible that mainstream media has barely noticed ChatGPT

    Nothing in the NYT, nothing in the Guardian, nothing in the Washington Post. etc

    The Times has done this, but it doesn't really capture the importance of the moment

    https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/could-chat-gpt-talk-google-out-of-a-job-v8g85vxl0

  • BozzaBozza Posts: 37

    Bozza said:

    Scott_xP said:

    Latest from @OpiniumResearch 30 Nov-2 Dec: Lab lead down to 14 points
    Lab 43%
    Con 29%
    Lib Dems 8%
    Reform 6%
    Green 6%

    As I predicted, cons on 29 up 1, upward movement not stalled at all.

    Vindicated 😇
    Yes, and don't forget Opinium are the gold standard from recent General Elections. Fourteen percent is clearly doable for the Conservatives in two years.

    Can Rishi manage to take it all the way? Doubtful, but were he to be replaced by Boris, a stonking General Election result beckons. The tightening of the polls is really rather exciting isn't it?
    Not exciting for me, I yearn for the Tories out till they come back as Conservatives again. This clueless rump have lost their soul.

    But facts are facts. By comparing the trend on 1 pollster I am comparing apples with apples. If Sunak and Braverman got some wins on the South Coast invasion, we will likely be back to the 4 point lead Opinium gave Labour on eve of Mini budget.

    Take two off this Labour score and give it to Lib Dems, just 2 more off and give to cons, and give cons just 4 of the six they lost to reform last month, and Opinium gives you a 4% Labour lead.
    I like your style. I am not so sure I could have convinced myself of how good a poll that is for us. Well done!
  • kjhkjh Posts: 11,789
    edited December 2022
    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
  • FairlieredFairliered Posts: 4,931
    I would like to rejoin the EU. I would like the abolition of woke. As supporters of those two views are fundamentally opposed, I would happily accept rejoining the single market and the replacement of Sturgeon with an SNP leader that doesn’t think that women with penises have a right to rape women without penises. Am I being unrealistic?
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 53,839

    DavidL said:

    DavidL said:

    Scott_xP said:

    NEW: Alison Thewliss standing for leader of SNP’s Westminster group. No coronation for Stephen Flynn on Tuesday. https://twitter.com/alisonthewliss/status/1599136008678739969

    Nicola not giving up without a fight.
    Which is Sturgeon's preferred candidate?
    Anyone but Flynn. Her placeman has been kicked out against her wishes. She is not someone to leave any spoils to the victors if she can help it.
    Marvellous that I can come to PB for the inside poop on SNP internal politics. I had hardly a clue who Stephen Flynn was until a couple of weeks ago and you guys knew all about him all along!
    He's a Dundonian and Dundee United supporter. He gets a fair bit of attention from the Courier for an Aberdeen MP.

    He has consistently supported steps to encourage investment in the North Sea, as any self-respecting MP from Aberdeen would, with the notable exception of being in support of a windfall tax. He opposed Nicola's absurd ideas of discouraging further developments in the north sea on the grounds of net zero or some bizarre international posturing. Whilst still being deluded about the benefits or risks of independence he seems to have more than one toe in the real world which gives him a novelty value.
  • FairlieredFairliered Posts: 4,931
    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 42,840

    I would like to rejoin the EU. I would like the abolition of woke. As supporters of those two views are fundamentally opposed, I would happily accept rejoining the single market and the replacement of Sturgeon with an SNP leader that doesn’t think that women with penises have a right to rape women without penises. Am I being unrealistic?

    Well, given that Ms Sturgeon doesn't think that, you've only got the really difficult one to fulfil.
  • FairlieredFairliered Posts: 4,931
    Leon said:

    THE ELON HATH SPOKE

    Elon Musk
    @elonmusk

    Replying to
    "@sama ChatGPT is scary good. We are not far from dangerously strong AI."

    https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1599128577068650498?s=20&t=Vv7XRxp50f9TC6KwPfpZmA


    He's right. As soon as @FrancisUrquhart of this sweet parish turned me on to GPT3 back in 2020, I knew this was Dangerous AI on the horizon

    And I have been right all along, ever since

    You’ve been right all along ever since you were SeanT, Byronic, LadyG.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 55,339

    Leon said:

    THE ELON HATH SPOKE

    Elon Musk
    @elonmusk

    Replying to
    "@sama ChatGPT is scary good. We are not far from dangerously strong AI."

    https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1599128577068650498?s=20&t=Vv7XRxp50f9TC6KwPfpZmA


    He's right. As soon as @FrancisUrquhart of this sweet parish turned me on to GPT3 back in 2020, I knew this was Dangerous AI on the horizon

    And I have been right all along, ever since

    You’ve been right all along ever since you were SeanT, Byronic, LadyG.
    I am much *righter* than them
  • FairlieredFairliered Posts: 4,931

    Fckn hell, the Telegraph is even shite at the stuff it's supposed to be good at. Drummed out of the sycophantic plastic patriots' union with immediate effect.


    Letters incoming, twelve o'clock high!
    In defence of the telegraph that is a mosquito being used for the same purpose.
    The Tele is the only one calling it a Spitfire in flight.
    It’s difficult for Telegraph readers. They think when they are flying to Spain with EasyJet, they are in a Spitfire, because they don’t realise that other aeroplanes have been introduced since the War.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 71,073
    Leon said:

    it's quite incredible that mainstream media has barely noticed ChatGPT

    Nothing in the NYT, nothing in the Guardian, nothing in the Washington Post. etc

    The Times has done this, but it doesn't really capture the importance of the moment

    https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/could-chat-gpt-talk-google-out-of-a-job-v8g85vxl0

    It’s a process, not a moment.
  • BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 34,664

    Leon said:

    THE ELON HATH SPOKE

    Elon Musk
    @elonmusk

    Replying to
    "@sama ChatGPT is scary good. We are not far from dangerously strong AI."

    https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1599128577068650498?s=20&t=Vv7XRxp50f9TC6KwPfpZmA


    He's right. As soon as @FrancisUrquhart of this sweet parish turned me on to GPT3 back in 2020, I knew this was Dangerous AI on the horizon

    And I have been right all along, ever since

    You’ve been right all along ever since you were SeanT, Byronic, LadyG.
    (Apart from the imminent threat of nuclear armageddon of course. And the Aliens obvs. And... so on.)
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 71,073
    Estonia signed an agreement with the United States to purchase MLRS systems HIMARS for over $200 million. Our defense budget for next years will run at the level of 3% of GDP.
    https://twitter.com/markomihkelson/status/1599107924772605952
  • LeonLeon Posts: 55,339
    Nigelb said:

    Leon said:

    it's quite incredible that mainstream media has barely noticed ChatGPT

    Nothing in the NYT, nothing in the Guardian, nothing in the Washington Post. etc

    The Times has done this, but it doesn't really capture the importance of the moment

    https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/could-chat-gpt-talk-google-out-of-a-job-v8g85vxl0

    It’s a process, not a moment.
    It is both, in this case
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 122,969
    Leon said:

    it's quite incredible that mainstream media has barely noticed ChatGPT

    Nothing in the NYT, nothing in the Guardian, nothing in the Washington Post. etc

    The Times has done this, but it doesn't really capture the importance of the moment

    https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/could-chat-gpt-talk-google-out-of-a-job-v8g85vxl0

    Yet it can be 'wildly impressive one moment, a misinformation agent the next' as the article states not AI perfection yet
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 122,969
    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
  • Not a bad endorsement. I know more about Thewliss than Flynn and I like her, so go Alison.

    I think Cherry may not even run, not because there's any woke plot to block her, but because afaics she's not very popular with her colleagues. A poor showing would not be good for a bulging ego.


  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,406
    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    it's quite incredible that mainstream media has barely noticed ChatGPT

    Nothing in the NYT, nothing in the Guardian, nothing in the Washington Post. etc

    The Times has done this, but it doesn't really capture the importance of the moment

    https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/could-chat-gpt-talk-google-out-of-a-job-v8g85vxl0

    Yet it can be 'wildly impressive one moment, a misinformation agent the next' as the article states not AI perfection yet
    It should join the Tory Party.
    Everyone else is apparently.

  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,015
    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    Strange. I thought that an open, tolerant society lay at the heart of Western culture. Turns out I'm wrong, and it actually totalitarianism that defines us.
  • kjhkjh Posts: 11,789
    edited December 2022
    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    Wrong on so many points. I am as far from woke as you can get. I hate political correctness. However I also hate irrationality. He clearly was critical of your apparent (whether accurate or not) support of Russia. He told you to go and live in Russia because you appeared to support them.
  • FairlieredFairliered Posts: 4,931
    If Weak Pishfart is supporting Thewliss, that’s a good endorsement of Stephen Flynn.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,406
    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
  • MoonRabbitMoonRabbit Posts: 13,507

    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
    I know where my work here is not being appreciated, reflected on or even challenged thoughtfully enough, my psepholoogica effort being betrayed.

    I shall flounce off back to con home where I am better appreciated.

    But for the twelfth and final time, look at the Opinum on 2nd September just before Truss budget, exhibit A, now look at todays Opnium, exhibit B, and look for the up down trend line from A to B and how on trend they are becoming much the same points with recent polls from Opnium.

    When Opnium gave Labour just 4 point lead over Truss, it wasn’t, it was more likely 8 or 9 % based on average of others, the serious ones not including people polling. What we need to watch for with Opnium set on course for about 6% are other A to Bs making their way down to 9 or 10, in other words as you were, Truss unwound. Because if Truss unwind is as rapid as I am (but we all should be) seeing from Opinium, then the thinking Labour are still miles ahead will be lazy and out of date before you realise it.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 55,339
    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    it's quite incredible that mainstream media has barely noticed ChatGPT

    Nothing in the NYT, nothing in the Guardian, nothing in the Washington Post. etc

    The Times has done this, but it doesn't really capture the importance of the moment

    https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/could-chat-gpt-talk-google-out-of-a-job-v8g85vxl0

    Yet it can be 'wildly impressive one moment, a misinformation agent the next' as the article states not AI perfection yet
    "AI perfection" would be complete supreme AGI, one computer to rule us all, and we would likely all be dead now, or sleeping in pods being fed electro-nectar as The Machine dutifully depletes our Qi

    This is not true AGI, but it is dangerously close, as The Musk sayeth

  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,406

    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
    I know where my work here is not being appreciated, reflected on or even challenged thoughtfully enough, my psepholoogica effort being betrayed.

    I shall flounce off back to con home where I am better appreciated.

    But for the twelfth and final time, look at the Opinum on 2nd September just before Truss budget, exhibit A, now look at todays Opnium, exhibit B, and look for the up down trend line from A to B and how on trend they are becoming much the same points with recent polls from Opnium.

    When Opnium gave Labour just 4 point lead over Truss, it wasn’t, it was more likely 8 or 9 % based on average of others, the serious ones not including people polling. What we need to watch for with Opnium set on course for about 6% are other A to Bs making their way down to 9 or 10, in other words as you were, Truss unwound. Because if Truss unwind is as rapid as I am (but we all should be) seeing from Opinium, then the thinking Labour are still miles ahead will be lazy and out of date before you realise it.
    The Chester by election and council by-elections the same day are actual votes cast.
  • TimSTimS Posts: 12,995
    edited December 2022
    I asked chat GPT to deliver the next UK budget. Here’s what it proposed. Hard to position politically, though fairly centrist I’d say.

    “Some potential elements of a fiscal policy that could help balance the UK budget while supporting public spending and infrastructure investment could include:

    Reducing government spending in certain areas, such as defense or welfare, and redirecting the savings to support public spending and infrastructure investment.
    Increasing taxes, particularly on high earners or large corporations, to generate additional revenue for the government.
    Implementing policies to stimulate economic growth, such as reducing regulations or cutting taxes, which could help increase government revenue through higher levels of income and consumption.

    Prioritizing infrastructure investment in areas that are likely to provide the greatest economic benefits, such as improving transportation networks or upgrading public facilities.

    Encouraging private sector investment in infrastructure projects, through measures such as tax incentives or public-private partnerships.

    Overall, a fiscal policy that aims to balance the UK budget while supporting public spending and infrastructure investment would likely require a combination of spending reductions, tax increases, and economic growth initiatives, as well as careful prioritization of investments to maximize their benefits.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 122,969
    Leon said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    it's quite incredible that mainstream media has barely noticed ChatGPT

    Nothing in the NYT, nothing in the Guardian, nothing in the Washington Post. etc

    The Times has done this, but it doesn't really capture the importance of the moment

    https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/could-chat-gpt-talk-google-out-of-a-job-v8g85vxl0

    Yet it can be 'wildly impressive one moment, a misinformation agent the next' as the article states not AI perfection yet
    "AI perfection" would be complete supreme AGI, one computer to rule us all, and we would likely all be dead now, or sleeping in pods being fed electro-nectar as The Machine dutifully depletes our Qi

    This is not true AGI, but it is dangerously close, as The Musk sayeth

    Which is why I also believe AI research should be subject to strict state oversight and regulation.

    Scientific advancement is not an unqualified good if it threatens rather than helps humanity and the wider environment
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,406
    Leon said:

    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
    I know where my work here is not being appreciated, reflected on or even challenged thoughtfully enough, my psepholoogica effort being betrayed.

    I shall flounce off back to con home where I am better appreciated.

    But for the twelfth and final time, look at the Opinum on 2nd September just before Truss budget, exhibit A, now look at todays Opnium, exhibit B, and look for the up down trend line from A to B and how on trend they are becoming much the same points with recent polls from Opnium.

    When Opnium gave Labour just 4 point lead over Truss, it wasn’t, it was more likely 8 or 9 % based on average of others, the serious ones not including people polling. What we need to watch for with Opnium set on course for about 6% are other A to Bs making their way down to 9 or 10, in other words as you were, Truss unwound. Because if Truss unwind is as rapid as I am (but we all should be) seeing from Opinium, then the thinking Labour are still miles ahead will be lazy and out of date before you realise it.
    Stay! Your insight is much appreciated

    You are a young Conservative female (and lesbian?)

    We don't get a lot of those around here, to put it mildly - we have a surfeit of ageing centre-lefty Remoaner males who don't quite understand the world - and you would be a significant loss

    STAY!
    I agree entirely. She's great.
    My only issue is that she self ID's as a Lib Dem.
    Whilst putting in a Stakhanovite shift of Tory ramping.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 122,969
    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 122,969

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    Strange. I thought that an open, tolerant society lay at the heart of Western culture. Turns out I'm wrong, and it actually totalitarianism that defines us.
    Except Wokeism is NOT tolerant, that is the whole point. Hence cancel culture
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,406
    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
  • FairlieredFairliered Posts: 4,931
    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    All our higher education establishments are leftist. Which ones are the most leftist?
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,015
    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    it's quite incredible that mainstream media has barely noticed ChatGPT

    Nothing in the NYT, nothing in the Guardian, nothing in the Washington Post. etc

    The Times has done this, but it doesn't really capture the importance of the moment

    https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/could-chat-gpt-talk-google-out-of-a-job-v8g85vxl0

    Yet it can be 'wildly impressive one moment, a misinformation agent the next' as the article states not AI perfection yet
    "AI perfection" would be complete supreme AGI, one computer to rule us all, and we would likely all be dead now, or sleeping in pods being fed electro-nectar as The Machine dutifully depletes our Qi

    This is not true AGI, but it is dangerously close, as The Musk sayeth

    Which is why I also believe AI research should be subject to strict state oversight and regulation.

    Scientific advancement is not an unqualified good if it threatens rather than helps humanity and the wider environment
    I like it when I agree with you.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,406
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    Strange. I thought that an open, tolerant society lay at the heart of Western culture. Turns out I'm wrong, and it actually totalitarianism that defines us.
    Except Wokeism is NOT tolerant, that is the whole point. Hence cancel culture
    Therefore it can't be tolerated.
    This distribution of lupins is more complex than first thought.
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 42,840
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    Strange. I thought that an open, tolerant society lay at the heart of Western culture. Turns out I'm wrong, and it actually totalitarianism that defines us.
    Except Wokeism is NOT tolerant, that is the whole point. Hence cancel culture
    You mean, your kind of cancel culture?
  • BozzaBozza Posts: 37
    edited December 2022

    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
    I know where my work here is not being appreciated, reflected on or even challenged thoughtfully enough, my psepholoogica effort being betrayed.

    I shall flounce off back to con home where I am better appreciated.

    But for the twelfth and final time, look at the Opinum on 2nd September just before Truss budget, exhibit A, now look at todays Opnium, exhibit B, and look for the up down trend line from A to B and how on trend they are becoming much the same points with recent polls from Opnium.

    When Opnium gave Labour just 4 point lead over Truss, it wasn’t, it was more likely 8 or 9 % based on average of others, the serious ones not including people polling. What we need to watch for with Opnium set on course for about 6% are other A to Bs making their way down to 9 or 10, in other words as you were, Truss unwound. Because if Truss unwind is as rapid as I am (but we all should be) seeing from Opinium, then the thinking Labour are still miles ahead will be lazy and out of date before you realise it.
    You've convinced me young lady. Do you think the unwind will be enough with Rishi on the bridge of USSS Tory? Or do we need a chap with charisma by the boat load?
  • dixiedean said:

    Leon said:

    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
    I know where my work here is not being appreciated, reflected on or even challenged thoughtfully enough, my psepholoogica effort being betrayed.

    I shall flounce off back to con home where I am better appreciated.

    But for the twelfth and final time, look at the Opinum on 2nd September just before Truss budget, exhibit A, now look at todays Opnium, exhibit B, and look for the up down trend line from A to B and how on trend they are becoming much the same points with recent polls from Opnium.

    When Opnium gave Labour just 4 point lead over Truss, it wasn’t, it was more likely 8 or 9 % based on average of others, the serious ones not including people polling. What we need to watch for with Opnium set on course for about 6% are other A to Bs making their way down to 9 or 10, in other words as you were, Truss unwound. Because if Truss unwind is as rapid as I am (but we all should be) seeing from Opinium, then the thinking Labour are still miles ahead will be lazy and out of date before you realise it.
    Stay! Your insight is much appreciated

    You are a young Conservative female (and lesbian?)

    We don't get a lot of those around here, to put it mildly - we have a surfeit of ageing centre-lefty Remoaner males who don't quite understand the world - and you would be a significant loss

    STAY!
    I agree entirely. She's great.
    My only issue is that she self ID's as a Lib Dem.
    Whilst putting in a Stakhanovite shift of Tory ramping.
    To be fair to Lib Dems, a hung parliament is an opportunity for them, whereas a big Labour win would be another version of irrelevance.

    And as things stand, getting the Conservatives anywhere near a hung parliament needs quite a bit of ramping.
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,015
    Before I turn in for the night, I have been spending far too much time playing with Stable Diffusion. Lots of fun to put in a prompt suc as:

    A Pre-Raphaelite depiction of... followed by a person or scene of your choice. Then vary the artistic style.

    Surrealist and Boris Johnson made me LOL.

  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 122,969
    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    It isn't western culture, it is anti western culture and if we allow it to take control it will end Western culture. Western culture fosters debate and free speech including against the Wokeists who wish to cancel anyone who disagrees with them
  • carnforthcarnforth Posts: 4,587
    dixiedean said:

    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
    I know where my work here is not being appreciated, reflected on or even challenged thoughtfully enough, my psepholoogica effort being betrayed.

    I shall flounce off back to con home where I am better appreciated.

    But for the twelfth and final time, look at the Opinum on 2nd September just before Truss budget, exhibit A, now look at todays Opnium, exhibit B, and look for the up down trend line from A to B and how on trend they are becoming much the same points with recent polls from Opnium.

    When Opnium gave Labour just 4 point lead over Truss, it wasn’t, it was more likely 8 or 9 % based on average of others, the serious ones not including people polling. What we need to watch for with Opnium set on course for about 6% are other A to Bs making their way down to 9 or 10, in other words as you were, Truss unwound. Because if Truss unwind is as rapid as I am (but we all should be) seeing from Opinium, then the thinking Labour are still miles ahead will be lazy and out of date before you realise it.
    The Chester by election and council by-elections the same day are actual votes cast.
    GE turnout 80%, Chester turnout 40%. So even if (a big if) people vote the same way in a byelection as a GE, the turnout difference alone makes comparisons hard.

    If I were a tory voter in Chester watching the trussterfuck, I might feel very justified in sitting on my hands.
  • kjhkjh Posts: 11,789
    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    I don't think he has got the fact that he has started an argument with himself.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,406
    Bozza said:

    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
    I know where my work here is not being appreciated, reflected on or even challenged thoughtfully enough, my psepholoogica effort being betrayed.

    I shall flounce off back to con home where I am better appreciated.

    But for the twelfth and final time, look at the Opinum on 2nd September just before Truss budget, exhibit A, now look at todays Opnium, exhibit B, and look for the up down trend line from A to B and how on trend they are becoming much the same points with recent polls from Opnium.

    When Opnium gave Labour just 4 point lead over Truss, it wasn’t, it was more likely 8 or 9 % based on average of others, the serious ones not including people polling. What we need to watch for with Opnium set on course for about 6% are other A to Bs making their way down to 9 or 10, in other words as you were, Truss unwound. Because if Truss unwind is as rapid as I am (but we all should be) seeing from Opinium, then the thinking Labour are still miles ahead will be lazy and out of date before you realise it.
    You've convinced me, young lady. Do you think the unwind will be enough with Rishi on the bridge of USSS Tory? Or do we need a chap with charisma by the boat load?
    You do.
    But where would you find one of them who isn't a serial liar with an extensive record of not delivering on any of his bullshit promises? Either to his wives, children or the electorate?
  • LeonLeon Posts: 55,339
    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    Nazism was part of German culture - and European culture - and had some noble ancestors, from Wagner to Nietzsche. Nonetheless we really had to stamp it out, and we did. That was a good thing
  • BozzaBozza Posts: 37
    dixiedean said:

    Bozza said:

    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
    I know where my work here is not being appreciated, reflected on or even challenged thoughtfully enough, my psepholoogica effort being betrayed.

    I shall flounce off back to con home where I am better appreciated.

    But for the twelfth and final time, look at the Opinum on 2nd September just before Truss budget, exhibit A, now look at todays Opnium, exhibit B, and look for the up down trend line from A to B and how on trend they are becoming much the same points with recent polls from Opnium.

    When Opnium gave Labour just 4 point lead over Truss, it wasn’t, it was more likely 8 or 9 % based on average of others, the serious ones not including people polling. What we need to watch for with Opnium set on course for about 6% are other A to Bs making their way down to 9 or 10, in other words as you were, Truss unwound. Because if Truss unwind is as rapid as I am (but we all should be) seeing from Opinium, then the thinking Labour are still miles ahead will be lazy and out of date before you realise it.
    You've convinced me, young lady. Do you think the unwind will be enough with Rishi on the bridge of USSS Tory? Or do we need a chap with charisma by the boat load?
    You do.
    But where would you find one of them who isn't a serial liar with an extensive record of not delivering on any of his bullshit promises? Either to his wives, children or the electorate?
    So you have already discounted the recently rejuvenated Matthew Hancock?
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,406
    carnforth said:

    dixiedean said:

    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
    I know where my work here is not being appreciated, reflected on or even challenged thoughtfully enough, my psepholoogica effort being betrayed.

    I shall flounce off back to con home where I am better appreciated.

    But for the twelfth and final time, look at the Opinum on 2nd September just before Truss budget, exhibit A, now look at todays Opnium, exhibit B, and look for the up down trend line from A to B and how on trend they are becoming much the same points with recent polls from Opnium.

    When Opnium gave Labour just 4 point lead over Truss, it wasn’t, it was more likely 8 or 9 % based on average of others, the serious ones not including people polling. What we need to watch for with Opnium set on course for about 6% are other A to Bs making their way down to 9 or 10, in other words as you were, Truss unwound. Because if Truss unwind is as rapid as I am (but we all should be) seeing from Opinium, then the thinking Labour are still miles ahead will be lazy and out of date before you realise it.
    The Chester by election and council by-elections the same day are actual votes cast.
    GE turnout 80%, Chester turnout 40%. So even if (a big if) people vote the same way in a byelection as a GE, the turnout difference alone makes comparisons hard.

    If I were a tory voter in Chester watching the trussterfuck, I might feel very justified in sitting on my hands.
    The turnout was actually a big surprise on the upside.
    You may equally argue why should a Labour voter be arsed when victory was guaranteed?
    It can't be spun as pro-Tory evidence. Even in the post-truth era.
    It was an actual votes kicking.
    Best for Labour since 2010 according to Curtice.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,406
    Leon said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    Nazism was part of German culture - and European culture - and had some noble ancestors, from Wagner to Nietzsche. Nonetheless we really had to stamp it out, and
    we did. That was a good thing
    Godwin says hi.
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,329
    Leon said:

    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
    I know where my work here is not being appreciated, reflected on or even challenged thoughtfully enough, my psepholoogica effort being betrayed.

    I shall flounce off back to con home where I am better appreciated.

    But for the twelfth and final time, look at the Opinum on 2nd September just before Truss budget, exhibit A, now look at todays Opnium, exhibit B, and look for the up down trend line from A to B and how on trend they are becoming much the same points with recent polls from Opnium.

    When Opnium gave Labour just 4 point lead over Truss, it wasn’t, it was more likely 8 or 9 % based on average of others, the serious ones not including people polling. What we need to watch for with Opnium set on course for about 6% are other A to Bs making their way down to 9 or 10, in other words as you were, Truss unwound. Because if Truss unwind is as rapid as I am (but we all should be) seeing from Opinium, then the thinking Labour are still miles ahead will be lazy and out of date before you realise it.
    Stay! Your insight is much appreciated

    You are a young Conservative female (and lesbian?)

    We don't get a lot of those around here, to put it mildly - we have a surfeit of ageing centre-lefty Remoaner males who don't quite understand the world - and you would be a significant loss

    STAY!
    Or could she be a plant
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,329

    Not a bad endorsement. I know more about Thewliss than Flynn and I like her, so go Alison.

    I think Cherry may not even run, not because there's any woke plot to block her, but because afaics she's not very popular with her colleagues. A poor showing would not be good for a bulging ego.


    Unfortunately that means more mediocraty as the rest are invisible troughers.
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,208
    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:

    Support for elements of a Swiss-style EU deal https://twitter.com/JohnRentoul/status/1599143200567963648/photo/1

    Trouble will come when the people of the UK are asked what they are prepared to offer/give up/swallow to get those goodies. I sense/fear we are still a way off having that conversation.
    But Single Market gets 63%, and, contrary to many previous reports and most strikingly of all, Free Movement gets 57%. So we're already closer than many politicians think.
    Depends entirely which poll looked at.

    This one last month had 46% of voters thinking we have too much immigration only 18% too little.

    https://whatukthinks.org/eu/questions/generally-speaking-would-you-say-britain-currently-has-too-much-immigration-not-enough-immigration-or-about-the-right-amount/

    Even the Tony Blair Institute found only 23% want to rejoin the full EU and 11% the single market when given a full range of options


    https://institute.global/policy/moving-how-british-public-views-brexit-and-what-it-wants-future-relationship-european-union
    The key Blair Institute finding is that almost no-one is satisfied with the Brexit outcome we have actually got.

    Which is a problem.
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,329
    DavidL said:

    DavidL said:

    DavidL said:

    Scott_xP said:

    NEW: Alison Thewliss standing for leader of SNP’s Westminster group. No coronation for Stephen Flynn on Tuesday. https://twitter.com/alisonthewliss/status/1599136008678739969

    Nicola not giving up without a fight.
    Which is Sturgeon's preferred candidate?
    Anyone but Flynn. Her placeman has been kicked out against her wishes. She is not someone to leave any spoils to the victors if she can help it.
    Marvellous that I can come to PB for the inside poop on SNP internal politics. I had hardly a clue who Stephen Flynn was until a couple of weeks ago and you guys knew all about him all along!
    He's a Dundonian and Dundee United supporter. He gets a fair bit of attention from the Courier for an Aberdeen MP.

    He has consistently supported steps to encourage investment in the North Sea, as any self-respecting MP from Aberdeen would, with the notable exception of being in support of a windfall tax. He opposed Nicola's absurd ideas of discouraging further developments in the north sea on the grounds of net zero or some bizarre international posturing. Whilst still being deluded about the benefits or risks of independence he seems to have more than one toe in the real world which gives him a novelty value.
    He is an invisible no user
  • Jim_MillerJim_Miller Posts: 2,999
    FPT: Has Walker given up? "Herschel Walker was being swamped by negative television ads. His Democratic opponents were preparing to flood the polls for early voting as soon as doors opened. After being hit by fresh allegations of carpetbagging, he was left with just over a week to make his final appeals to voters in the runoff for Georgia’s Senate seat.

    But for five days, Mr. Walker was off the campaign trail.

    The decision to skip campaigning over the crucial Thanksgiving holiday weekend has Mr. Walker’s Republican allies airing frustrations and concerns about his campaign strategy in the final stretch of the overtime election against Senator Raphael Warnock."
    source: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/in-georgia-walker-s-pace-in-the-finish-worries-republican-allies/ar-AA14KhJR?ocid=msedgdhp&pc=U531&cvid=71de6d47fcf446e1810be07200d9dcd4

    It certainly looks like it to me. He can't be enjoying the attacks he has been getting. Perhaps someone should have warned him that "politics ain't beanbag", before he got into the race.
  • FairlieredFairliered Posts: 4,931
    malcolmg said:

    Not a bad endorsement. I know more about Thewliss than Flynn and I like her, so go Alison.

    I think Cherry may not even run, not because there's any woke plot to block her, but because afaics she's not very popular with her colleagues. A poor showing would not be good for a bulging ego.


    Unfortunately that means more mediocraty as the rest are invisible troughers.
    Looking at the ineptitude of Joanna Cherry’s colleagues, not being popular with them is a positive.
  • Northern_AlNorthern_Al Posts: 8,383
    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    It isn't western culture, it is anti western culture and if we allow it to take control it will end Western culture. Western culture fosters debate and free speech including against the Wokeists who wish to cancel anyone who disagrees with them
    Have you been out drinking with some notable anti-woke PBers tonight? These tirades are most unlike you, and seem to be a new theme.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,406
    Bozza said:

    dixiedean said:

    Bozza said:

    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
    I know where my work here is not being appreciated, reflected on or even challenged thoughtfully enough, my psepholoogica effort being betrayed.

    I shall flounce off back to con home where I am better appreciated.

    But for the twelfth and final time, look at the Opinum on 2nd September just before Truss budget, exhibit A, now look at todays Opnium, exhibit B, and look for the up down trend line from A to B and how on trend they are becoming much the same points with recent polls from Opnium.

    When Opnium gave Labour just 4 point lead over Truss, it wasn’t, it was more likely 8 or 9 % based on average of others, the serious ones not including people polling. What we need to watch for with Opnium set on course for about 6% are other A to Bs making their way down to 9 or 10, in other words as you were, Truss unwound. Because if Truss unwind is as rapid as I am (but we all should be) seeing from Opinium, then the thinking Labour are still miles ahead will be lazy and out of date before you realise it.
    You've convinced me, young lady. Do you think the unwind will be enough with Rishi on the bridge of USSS Tory? Or do we need a chap with charisma by the boat load?
    You do.
    But where would you find one of them who isn't a serial liar with an extensive record of not delivering on any of his bullshit promises? Either to his wives, children or the electorate?
    So you have already discounted the recently rejuvenated Matthew Hancock?
    He seems to fit the criteria perfectly too.
  • FairlieredFairliered Posts: 4,931

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    It isn't western culture, it is anti western culture and if we allow it to take control it will end Western culture. Western culture fosters debate and free speech including against the Wokeists who wish to cancel anyone who disagrees with them
    Have you been out drinking with some notable anti-woke PBers tonight? These tirades are most unlike you, and seem to be a new theme.
    I think that @HYFUD’s comments are born out of frustration at how his party is going. I don’t blame him. I expect he has worked for many years for what he believes in, and sees it all turning to ashes. As an SNP member, I understand and sympathise.
  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 42,840

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    It isn't western culture, it is anti western culture and if we allow it to take control it will end Western culture. Western culture fosters debate and free speech including against the Wokeists who wish to cancel anyone who disagrees with them
    Have you been out drinking with some notable anti-woke PBers tonight? These tirades are most unlike you, and seem to be a new theme.
    Probably indicates the latest Tory attack line from CCHQ.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 96,103

    Not a bad endorsement. I know more about Thewliss than Flynn and I like her, so go Alison.

    I think Cherry may not even run, not because there's any woke plot to block her, but because afaics she's not very popular with her colleagues. A poor showing would not be good for a bulging ego.


    There were claims he buddied up to Boris?!
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 96,103

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    It isn't western culture, it is anti western culture and if we allow it to take control it will end Western culture. Western culture fosters debate and free speech including against the Wokeists who wish to cancel anyone who disagrees with them
    Have you been out drinking with some notable anti-woke PBers tonight? These tirades are most unlike you, and seem to be a new theme.
    "Look lads, this is the only promising attack line we have left, so hit it hard!"
  • OllyTOllyT Posts: 5,006
    Carnyx said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    It isn't western culture, it is anti western culture and if we allow it to take control it will end Western culture. Western culture fosters debate and free speech including against the Wokeists who wish to cancel anyone who disagrees with them
    Have you been out drinking with some notable anti-woke PBers tonight? These tirades are most unlike you, and seem to be a new theme.
    Probably indicates the latest Tory attack line from CCHQ.
    Anti-Woke is about all that's left in the Tory's locker now.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 96,103
    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    I don't actually think that point is as unsound as it might appear on first glance. Ideas can contain the seeds of their own destruction perhaps. That is, an emergent idea or culture could weaken or even destroy (though transformating entirely) the culture it emerged from.

    Whilst I decry the sillier elements of what some call woke culture all the time I'm not on board with this level of fearmongering, but as a concept I think the 'it will weaken X culture' even though it emerged from it is not completely illogical.
  • DJ41DJ41 Posts: 792
    edited December 2022
    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    It isn't western culture, it is anti western culture and if we allow it to take control it will end Western culture. Western culture fosters debate and free speech including against the Wokeists who wish to cancel anyone who disagrees with them
    What is this western culture of which you speak? Where were its roots? Were there any debates between Protestants and Catholics or between the men who wanted to massacre the women they called "witches" and the "witches" themselves? Franco, Mussolini, Hitler, slavery, the forced sterilisation of many women in the United States who were labelled "subnormal" - all these were foreign to western culture? Because I can tell you, there wasn't much permitted debate about them at the time.

    Looking at Britain, stage plays were subject to prior approval and censorship by the Lord Chamberlain until 1968. The Life of Brian was banned by several local authorities in 1979. Did you notice much debate or free speech in 2022 during the period of official mourning for the late sovereign? I am wondering when the heyday of Western culture was in Britain.
  • RogerRoger Posts: 19,914
    OllyT said:

    Carnyx said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    It isn't western culture, it is anti western culture and if we allow it to take control it will end Western culture. Western culture fosters debate and free speech including against the Wokeists who wish to cancel anyone who disagrees with them
    Have you been out drinking with some notable anti-woke PBers tonight? These tirades are most unlike you, and seem to be a new theme.
    Probably indicates the latest Tory attack line from CCHQ.
    Anti-Woke is about all that's left in the Tory's locker now.
    ....Yes but if you take Opinium's most recent poll and add two to the LDs and take away six from last weeks YouGov having discounted RefUK and add it to the week before's Redfield and Wilton if I'm not mistaken you'll have a very well patterned carpet.
  • DJ41DJ41 Posts: 792
    edited December 2022
    kle4 said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    I don't actually think that point is as unsound as it might appear on first glance. Ideas can contain the seeds of their own destruction perhaps. That is, an emergent idea or culture could weaken or even destroy (though transformating entirely) the culture it emerged from.

    Whilst I decry the sillier elements of what some call woke culture all the time I'm not on board with this level of fearmongering, but as a concept I think the 'it will weaken X culture' even though it emerged from it is not completely illogical.
    Sure, but saying western culture has free speech and debate among its main essential features is off the wall.

    And as for this
    Cookie said:

    (...)

    We rather liked it here up until about ten years ago, and find it rather disappointing that our country's culture has to massively change on the say so of a small minority of extremists.
    Antiwokists don't want to go back to tge 1950s. About 2011 would do.

    - that's missing how reaction works.

    There are those for whom the overturning of Roe vs Wade is a step towards the repeal of laws against racial discrimination, etc. etc. etc. Let's not forget who the patron saint of Brexit is, how well he is remembered, and what he made his 1968 "blood" speech ABOUT.
  • TresTres Posts: 2,700
    OllyT said:

    Carnyx said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    It isn't western culture, it is anti western culture and if we allow it to take control it will end Western culture. Western culture fosters debate and free speech including against the Wokeists who wish to cancel anyone who disagrees with them
    Have you been out drinking with some notable anti-woke PBers tonight? These tirades are most unlike you, and seem to be a new theme.
    Probably indicates the latest Tory attack line from CCHQ.
    Anti-Woke is about all that's left in the Tory's locker now.
    Been saying that for 12 months. Even the Trussonomics failed to give a positive reason to back the Tories (for those of us earning under 150k pa at least)
  • Dura_AceDura_Ace Posts: 13,677

    Foxy said:

    Another day, another Moonrabbit ramping of Tory prospects.

    Yes, for a professed LD she sure takes some odd lines.

    Enough for me to rethink my membership of UKIP.
    Rethink your membership of UKIP? You mean you don’t want to remain in the same party as @MoonRabbit?
    I know where my work here is not being appreciated, reflected on or even challenged thoughtfully enough, my psepholoogica effort being betrayed.

    I shall flounce off back to con home where I am better appreciated.

    But for the twelfth and final time, look at the Opinum on 2nd September just before Truss budget, exhibit A, now look at todays Opnium, exhibit B, and look for the up down trend line from A to B and how on trend they are becoming much the same points with recent polls from Opnium.

    When Opnium gave Labour just 4 point lead over Truss, it wasn’t, it was more likely 8 or 9 % based on average of others, the serious ones not including people polling. What we need to watch for with Opnium set on course for about 6% are other A to Bs making their way down to 9 or 10, in other words as you were, Truss unwound. Because if Truss unwind is as rapid as I am (but we all should be) seeing from Opinium, then the thinking Labour are still miles ahead will be lazy and out of date before you realise it.
    This semi-gibberish prose style reminds me of Esther in My Name is Red.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 71,073
    There is still good stuff on Twitter.

    One painting from every year of the 17th century, from China to India and Italy to Mexico and everywhere in between, in chronological order.

    1601: The Calling of Saint Matthew by Caravaggio..

    https://mobile.twitter.com/culturaltutor/status/1598536718910599168
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 71,073
    OllyT said:

    Carnyx said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    It isn't western culture, it is anti western culture and if we allow it to take control it will end Western culture. Western culture fosters debate and free speech including against the Wokeists who wish to cancel anyone who disagrees with them
    Have you been out drinking with some notable anti-woke PBers tonight? These tirades are most unlike you, and seem to be a new theme.
    Probably indicates the latest Tory attack line from CCHQ.
    Anti-Woke is about all that's left in the Tory's locker now.
    Given their current demographic, it's more like Great Auntie...
  • DJ41DJ41 Posts: 792
    edited December 2022
    Today I learnt that there has been an effort to deny that signs put up by landladies and landlords saying "No blacks, no dogs, no Irish" didn't really exist. That is utter bullsh*t. They certainly did exist. I know this through direct family experience in London. They were precisely the kind of thing that the 1968 Race Relations Act made unlawful. The Act made it a crime to refuse to offer housing, employment, or public services to any person on the grounds of colour, race, ethnicity, or national origins. It was the proposal to legislate in this way that Enoch Powell was speaking against. He wasn't just sounding off against immigration without having a focus. There wouldn't have been any point in getting upset about abolishing something that didn't exist.

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/oct/28/no-reason-to-doubt-no-irish-no-blacks-signs

    As Tony Murray rightly says, "Ample evidence exists in numerous oral history interviews with both Caribbean and Irish migrants that such signs existed well into the 60s."
  • RogerRoger Posts: 19,914

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    dixiedean said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    kjh said:

    HYUFD said:

    Chris said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    darkage said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Carnyx said:

    Chris said:

    carnforth said:

    George Osborne has cooked up a deal on the Elgin Marbles, per Greek sources:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63846449

    Actually, it says that George Osborne has been trying to cook up a deal and has not succeeded.
    On the other hand, the very fact that the BM is even talking to the Hellenic Gmt is highly significant.

    And, with all due respect, 2021 polling shows that retention is a minority opinion. Can't see that anything has happened to change that.

    https://yougov.co.uk/topics/travel/survey-results/daily/2021/11/23/9b053/2
    Yes. The Elgin Marbles are going back to Greece, no question. This story would not have leaked otherwise

    Then watch all the other nations stake claims to the rest of the British Museum. And given the Wokeness of museum curators - cf the Wellcome - who will resist?

    Cultural suicide
    It's a sign of a lack of self-confidence.

    Ironically, if everyone believed equally that Britain had a strong future - and were proud of what it stood for - it simply wouldn't happen.
    Of course. And any remaining self confidence is viciously corroded by the Woke. White people must be ashamed of their skin colour, British history is evil, every British institution is racist

    Eventually all this shit has an effect, and the culture collapses from within. What will replace it?

    I dunno. The Woke may not like a world where British and western self belief has entirely disappeared
    That's exactly what the cultural Marxists want.

    They are enabled by the establishment liberals. Which is the group I keep trying to wake up to it.

    There are signs of hope. @Gallowgate and @Gardenwalker are intelligent enough to have their own considered view on it.
    'Establishment liberals' haven't properly researched the ideology and philosophy behind a lot of this stuff; they just embrace it because of a tribal mindset triggered by Trump and Brexit. I've seen a lot of evidence of that, reading PB comments over the last couple of years. But I think maybe the high water mark has passed and the 'woke' are now in retreat.

    To me, even if all the British Museum was emptied, it would be trivial and insignificant, if a bit unfortunate. The thing I object profoundly to is the assault on free thought and speech, and the uncivilised urge to completely destroy people when they offend an ever changing zeitgeist.

    People keep hopefully calling ‘peak Woke’ - yet it never happens

    As lucidly pointed out in this excellent Spectator article

    https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/what-if-wokeness-really-is-the-new-christianity/
    Wokeness *is* the new Christianity.
    Only in certain big city and university towns in the West.

    In the provinces and rural areas most still think Wokeism a load of rubbish pushed by those who hate their own culture and country.

    In Xi's China, Putin's Russia and Modi's India they are anything but Woke, they just see it as symbolic of the weakness of the modern West
    Why don't people like you go and live in Russia?
    It is Wokeists like you pushing hatred of our culture that is the biggest boost to the likes of Putin.

    Zelensky at least may be liberal but he is not a defeatist, self hating Woke, if he was Putin would have captured Kyiv long ago. Instead Zelensky is a Ukrainian patriot who also values Judeo Christian culture
    On what basis do you determine Chris is Woke?
    On the basis he told me to go to Russia for saying something critical of Wokeism
    Well that is completely irrational. He said it not because he is Woke but because you posted positive comments about Russia.
    No he said it because he is Woke and ideologically anti anyone who values our culture and heritage and stands in the way of his leftist agenda.

    I said even more positive comments about Zelensky so that doesn't stand either
    How the hell do you know? He didn't say anything woke. He was critical of your support of Russia and your comments about Zelensky were said after his post. He isn't a mind reader so your last sentence is nonsense.
    Yes he did, he told me to go and live in Russia because I made the obvious point Wokeism is destroying Western culture from within and aiding the likes of Putin and Xi.

    However the likes of you and Chris by appeasing the Wokeists just weaken western culture and strength even more
    I'm a little confused here.
    Woke emerged from Western culture.
    So how can it weaken Western culture?
    It is a subset of it, not an alien concept.
    It is a cancer produced from within our most leftist higher education institutions threatening to destroy Western culture from within
    So. You agree it is Western culture then?
    Just the bit of it you don't like?
    Surely forcibly stamping it out would therefore be destroying a significant strand of Western culture?
    It isn't western culture, it is anti western culture and if we allow it to take control it will end Western culture. Western culture fosters debate and free speech including against the Wokeists who wish to cancel anyone who disagrees with them
    Have you been out drinking with some notable anti-woke PBers tonight? These tirades are most unlike you, and seem to be a new theme.
    Anti wokeists are fighting the hippy culture which we should all embrace by trying to force conformity on us all. It's in fact a war on live and let live.

    Calling it a war on woke is just a thinly disguised camouflage for crude authoritarianism.
  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 28,437
    TimS said:

    I asked chat GPT to deliver the next UK budget. Here’s what it proposed. Hard to position politically, though fairly centrist I’d say.

    “Some potential elements of a fiscal policy that could help balance the UK budget while supporting public spending and infrastructure investment could include:

    Reducing government spending in certain areas, such as defense or welfare, and redirecting the savings to support public spending and infrastructure investment.
    Increasing taxes, particularly on high earners or large corporations, to generate additional revenue for the government.
    Implementing policies to stimulate economic growth, such as reducing regulations or cutting taxes, which could help increase government revenue through higher levels of income and consumption.

    Prioritizing infrastructure investment in areas that are likely to provide the greatest economic benefits, such as improving transportation networks or upgrading public facilities.

    Encouraging private sector investment in infrastructure projects, through measures such as tax incentives or public-private partnerships.

    Overall, a fiscal policy that aims to balance the UK budget while supporting public spending and infrastructure investment would likely require a combination of spending reductions, tax increases, and economic growth initiatives, as well as careful prioritization of investments to maximize their benefits.

    It's fairly meaningless really isn't it. The software is clearly aimed at providing lucid and impressive sounding phrases, rather than actual answers. Which is still good of course.
  • carnforthcarnforth Posts: 4,587
    One for cyclefree:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-63848998

    "Police watchdog head Michael Lockwood resigns amid investigation"
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 17,405
    DJ41 said:

    Today I learnt that there has been an effort to deny that signs put up by landladies and landlords saying "No blacks, no dogs, no Irish" didn't really exist. That is utter bullsh*t. They certainly did exist. I know this through direct family experience in London. They were precisely the kind of thing that the 1968 Race Relations Act made unlawful. The Act made it a crime to refuse to offer housing, employment, or public services to any person on the grounds of colour, race, ethnicity, or national origins. It was the proposal to legislate in this way that Enoch Powell was speaking against. He wasn't just sounding off against immigration without having a focus. There wouldn't have been any point in getting upset about abolishing something that didn't exist.

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/oct/28/no-reason-to-doubt-no-irish-no-blacks-signs

    As Tony Murray rightly says, "Ample evidence exists in numerous oral history interviews with both Caribbean and Irish migrants that such signs existed well into the 60s."

    Tbf, reading that article suggests it’s one crank trying to argue that the signs were not in use. As said in the article, the direct Provence of one photo might be in doubt, but there is huge testimony from many people about the reality. This chap sounds odd.
  • TazTaz Posts: 14,405
    It is being reported Charles and Camilla have invited Ngozi Fulani to the Palace for talks.

    Is this a smart move, it just risks keeping the story going.

    https://twitter.com/mailonline/status/1599324051104841728?s=61&t=J9bk4Z_vfCCLaapQnJ9ONg
This discussion has been closed.