Skip to content

Don’t look back in Bangor – politicalbetting.com

SystemSystem Posts: 12,885
edited 7:50AM in General
Don’t look back in Bangor – politicalbetting.com

Holy crap there is a new poll for Wales and it is crazy.It puts Plaid well ahead of Reform with the Greens beating Labour.[Thread] pic.twitter.com/PNUbHTl3eG

Read the full story here

«134

Comments

  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 59,905
    edited 7:53AM
    First

    Unlike Labour.


    There’s a lot of ruin in a Party


    Betting thought - what level of disaster in Wales will actually effect Starmer’s chances of going? A 100% wipeout would, but that’s unlikely. Labour reduced to 5 seats? Hmmm.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 85,268
    edited 7:52AM
    But did you spot TSE's subtle puns ?
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 53,865
    edited 7:55AM
    Third!

    Perfect. None of the media intrusion after coming first, nor the “if only…” regrets of coming second, yet I still get a medal.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 40,309
    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.
  • Peter_the_PunterPeter_the_Punter Posts: 15,182
    Interesting stuff, but I'd be more inclined to take him seriously if he pronounced Cymru correctly.
  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 46,275

    First

    Unlike Labour.


    There’s a lot of ruin in a Party


    Betting thought - what level of disaster in Wales will actually effect Starmer’s chances of going? A 100% wipeout would, but that’s unlikely. Labour reduced to 5 seats? Hmmm.

    There’s a lot of Rhun ap Iorwerth in one party..
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 125,621
    Scott_xP said:

    Nigelb said:

    But did you spot TSE's subtle puns ?

    No subtle puns detected
    You're just jealous that you cannot come up with lines like 'Rhun ap Iorwerth, leader of Plaid Cymru, is overseeing something special, he might end up saying in May ‘so I start a revolution from my Bedwellty’.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 65,142
    I presume he'd then push for a Welsh independence vote of some sort - especially if he gets a majority.

    They haven't had one yet, so will be interesting to see how HMG responds to that.
  • Peter_the_PunterPeter_the_Punter Posts: 15,182
    Scott_xP said:

    Nigelb said:

    But did you spot TSE's subtle puns ?

    No subtle puns detected
    No, but there's a clear reference to the famous play about a financial crisis affecting a library in south west Essex - Book Lack In Ongar.


    [Hat-tip SeanT, once of this Parish.]
  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 33,702
    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
  • Peter_the_PunterPeter_the_Punter Posts: 15,182

    I presume he'd then push for a Welsh independence vote of some sort - especially if he gets a majority.

    They haven't had one yet, so will be interesting to see how HMG responds to that.

    That would be interesting, especially if the Nationalists won. My impression is that there isn't a huge amount of common ground between the folk of North and South Wales, but maybe we are about to find out.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 65,142

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 53,865
    Sleazy Reform on the slide?
  • StuartinromfordStuartinromford Posts: 21,223

    I presume he'd then push for a Welsh independence vote of some sort - especially if he gets a majority.

    They haven't had one yet, so will be interesting to see how HMG responds to that.

    That would be interesting, especially if the Nationalists won. My impression is that there isn't a huge amount of common ground between the folk of North and South Wales, but maybe we are about to find out.
    Plaid's USP is "we haven't had the chance to disappoint you in government yet". That can attract all sorts of voters from all sorts of places.

    The interesting question is what happens after their victory.
  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 46,275

    I presume he'd then push for a Welsh independence vote of some sort - especially if he gets a majority.

    They haven't had one yet, so will be interesting to see how HMG responds to that.

    Hasn’t Rhun said no calls for referendum in first term?
    If there are any reliable political templates left, Scotland suggests a minority government bargaining its way through the first 4 years, an external international crisis and a coalition UK government, then a landslide followed by a demand for a referendum.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 125,621

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 65,142

    I presume he'd then push for a Welsh independence vote of some sort - especially if he gets a majority.

    They haven't had one yet, so will be interesting to see how HMG responds to that.

    That would be interesting, especially if the Nationalists won. My impression is that there isn't a huge amount of common ground between the folk of North and South Wales, but maybe we are about to find out.
    They'd very likely lose, but it could be closer than expected- and thus set up another ongoing longrunning sore - because I expect Starmer to be woefully shit at any campaign, and get virtually everything wrong. And many Welsh will hit him with it.

    I suspect he'll probably just deny a vote.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 53,865
    edited 8:11AM

    I presume he'd then push for a Welsh independence vote of some sort - especially if he gets a majority.

    They haven't had one yet, so will be interesting to see how HMG responds to that.

    That would be interesting, especially if the Nationalists won. My impression is that there isn't a huge amount of common ground between the folk of North and South Wales, but maybe we are about to find out.
    Plaid's USP is "we haven't had the chance to disappoint you in government yet". That can attract all sorts of voters from all sorts of places.

    The interesting question is what happens after their victory.
    A pedant asks: Can you have a USP that's exactly the same as your main rival?
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 85,268

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    We know from anecdotal evidence that there is likely a serious overrepresentation of PBers in their polling samples.
    That's almost certain to skew anyone's results.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 53,865
    edited 8:16AM
    Nigelb said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    We know from anecdotal evidence that there is likely a serious overrepresentation of PBers in their polling samples.
    That's almost certain to skew anyone's results.
    They haven't asked HY again?
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 125,621
    edited 8:17AM
    I have a thread either tomorrow or Friday on Welsh independence.

    It has an absolutely no way inflammatory headline.
  • eekeek Posts: 32,276
    IanB2 said:

    I presume he'd then push for a Welsh independence vote of some sort - especially if he gets a majority.

    They haven't had one yet, so will be interesting to see how HMG responds to that.

    That would be interesting, especially if the Nationalists won. My impression is that there isn't a huge amount of common ground between the folk of North and South Wales, but maybe we are about to find out.
    Plaid's USP is "we haven't had the chance to disappoint you in government yet". That can attract all sorts of voters from all sorts of places.

    The interesting question is what happens after their victory.
    A pedant asks: Can you have a USP that's exactly the same as your main rival?
    Plaid is local "we haven't had the chance to disappoint you in government yet". Reform is the English version of that so doesn’t go down quite so well in Wales.

    A bigger point is that 73% are none of the previous party voters (Green / Reform / Plaid).

    Finally worth saying winning that byelection did wonders for Plaid in making them the clear cut get a change of Government option
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 53,865

    I presume he'd then push for a Welsh independence vote of some sort - especially if he gets a majority.

    They haven't had one yet, so will be interesting to see how HMG responds to that.

    That would be interesting, especially if the Nationalists won. My impression is that there isn't a huge amount of common ground between the folk of North and South Wales, but maybe we are about to find out.
    Plaid's USP is "we haven't had the chance to disappoint you in government yet". That can attract all sorts of voters from all sorts of places.

    The interesting question is what happens after their victory.
    This just out from Behr is pertinent:

    For Labour, that [optimism] assumes continuity of a trend for the ruling parties to regain support when a general election comes around. For the Tories, it is the idea that Britain always turns to them as the accountants of last resort, once Labour has run out of money.

    Two-party politics assumes stable bases of support on the left and on the right, with swing voters migrating across the centre ground. In today’s fragmented and polarised climate, that trade is thinner than traffic within multiparty blocs: a liberal-progressive one and a conservative-nationalist one. Neither is very stable, but they are efficiently delineated by attitudes to Farage. Either you recoil from the thought of him holding the levers of national power, or you don’t.

    Labour and Tory leaders assume a historic claim to primacy within their respective coalitions, but that sense of entitlement doesn’t reflect the balance of real-world opinion. Viewed through the lens of local council races so far this parliament, England’s two-party system looks more like a competition between Reform and the Liberal Democrats.... a more permanent, seismic change is under way might also be underpriced by Labour and Tory leaders who have a lot invested in old patterns reasserting themselves. The scale of it is hard to process, psychologically and psephologically.

    The historic Labour -Tory rivalry is also a kind of mutual dependency. They define themselves as ideological antitheses and so they find it hard to admit shared ownership, in many voters’ minds, of a long historical incumbency. They are joint guardians of the Westminster system that has stopped working for a lot of people since around the time of the 2007-08 financial crisis.

    https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/jan/14/labour-tories-old-normal-voters

  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 65,142
    Nigelb said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    We know from anecdotal evidence that there is likely a serious overrepresentation of PBers in their polling samples.
    That's almost certain to skew anyone's results.
    It was more representative when it was first introduced, as it avoiding the pitfalls of telephone polling, but I wonder if the world has now changed.

    It might now have too many who are very politically interested, and not enough who are more disinterested - but still vote.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 23,156
    On Topic That's a Rhyly good poll for PC and Greens

    Somebody should print off a hard copy of it and Prestyn SKSs face
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 125,621
    England plan to reject any proposals to play a day-night Test using a pink ball under lights in the next Ashes series in Australia.

    BBC Sport understands the England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) indicated their stance for the 2029-30 series to Cricket Australia (CA) following post-Ashes talks between senior officials.

    England lost a one-sided day-night Test at the Gabba in Brisbane by eight wickets last month to go 2-0 down in an Ashes series they would eventually lose 4-1.

    Discussions held by the ECB and CA focused on maintaining the Ashes as a blue-ribbon series at a time when the future of Test cricket is under scrutiny.

    England and Australia are due to play a one-off day-night Test at the Melbourne Cricket Ground in March 2027 to celebrate the 150th anniversary of the first ever Test at the same venue.

    Those plans were originally unveiled in August 2024 and it is understood England will get the opportunity to play a warm-up match before the showpiece MCG fixture.

    The decision to play that anniversary match as a day-night Test has not been a universally popular one, though, which might prompt a rethink.

    BBC Sport has been told that one influential ex-Australia player has directly voiced concerns to Cricket Australia and urged them to consider switching the match to a red-ball game.


    https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/articles/cx2y3wqwg9eo
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 65,142

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    If you look beneath the headlines, and aside from pollsters like YouGov, Reform aren't polling that much better than Rishi on average, who lost in a landslide.

    The narrative is Nigel is on course to be the next PM, and that's generally because Reform are polling first in a crowded field, but I'm not sure he's even close.
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 21,604

    Interesting stuff, but I'd be more inclined to take him seriously if he pronounced Cymru correctly.

    Isn't it 'way els'?
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 125,621

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    If you look beneath the headlines, and aside from pollsters like YouGov, Reform aren't polling that much better than Rishi on average, who lost in a landslide.

    The narrative is Nigel is on course to be the next PM, and that's generally because Reform are polling first in a crowded field, but I'm not sure he's even close.
    I've said that it is entirely possible that Reform or some other party win the next election on a bigger landslide than Starmer on a much lower vote share than Labour in 2024 or the Tory vote share in 2024.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 23,156
    On a betting viewpoint.

    8/11 is a great price for PC most seats imo

    I had a bet a 11/10 late in 2025
  • eekeek Posts: 32,276

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    If you look beneath the headlines, and aside from pollsters like YouGov, Reform aren't polling that much better than Rishi on average, who lost in a landslide.

    The narrative is Nigel is on course to be the next PM, and that's generally because Reform are polling first in a crowded field, but I'm not sure he's even close.
    I've said that it is entirely possible that Reform or some other party win the next election on a bigger landslide than Starmer on a much lower vote share than Labour in 2024 or the Tory vote share in 2024.
    It’s equally possible that nearly the same polling could give us 4 parties with 140 seats each.


    Which on the basis that we are a simulation designed to keep the observers happy is exactly what we will get
  • StuartinromfordStuartinromford Posts: 21,223

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    If you look beneath the headlines, and aside from pollsters like YouGov, Reform aren't polling that much better than Rishi on average, who lost in a landslide.

    The narrative is Nigel is on course to be the next PM, and that's generally because Reform are polling first in a crowded field, but I'm not sure he's even close.
    If Reform and the Conservatives could do what Labour and Lib Dems did in 2024- target their appeal to different shades of their side with mega efficiency- they might get somewhere. It's not clear that they can, even if they want to.

    More likely, they fight each other to a standstill. Though in five/six party FPTP, anything can happen.
  • Peter_the_PunterPeter_the_Punter Posts: 15,182

    I presume he'd then push for a Welsh independence vote of some sort - especially if he gets a majority.

    They haven't had one yet, so will be interesting to see how HMG responds to that.

    That would be interesting, especially if the Nationalists won. My impression is that there isn't a huge amount of common ground between the folk of North and South Wales, but maybe we are about to find out.
    They'd very likely lose, but it could be closer than expected- and thus set up another ongoing longrunning sore - because I expect Starmer to be woefully shit at any campaign, and get virtually everything wrong. And many Welsh will hit him with it.

    I suspect he'll probably just deny a vote.
    And then do a U-turn?
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 9,851
    Nigelb said:

    But did you spot TSE's subtle puns ?

    What's the story?
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 9,851
    IanB2 said:

    I presume he'd then push for a Welsh independence vote of some sort - especially if he gets a majority.

    They haven't had one yet, so will be interesting to see how HMG responds to that.

    That would be interesting, especially if the Nationalists won. My impression is that there isn't a huge amount of common ground between the folk of North and South Wales, but maybe we are about to find out.
    Plaid's USP is "we haven't had the chance to disappoint you in government yet". That can attract all sorts of voters from all sorts of places.

    The interesting question is what happens after their victory.
    A pedant asks: Can you have a USP that's exactly the same as your main rival?
    Universal selling point?
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 9,851

    Scott_xP said:

    Nigelb said:

    But did you spot TSE's subtle puns ?

    No subtle puns detected
    You're just jealous that you cannot come up with lines like 'Rhun ap Iorwerth, leader of Plaid Cymru, is overseeing something special, he might end up saying in May ‘so I start a revolution from my Bedwellty’.
    People unaccustomed to much drinking might find, in Cardiff, that the Brains they have go to their head.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 23,156
    Overheard 2 Welsh Labour MPs discussing the poll

    Never thought we would sink to Tenby January

    Nor me how Conwy get rid of SKS?

    We need him off asap. I wont tell you where I will stick my red Cardiff I see him
  • MelonBMelonB Posts: 16,679

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    If you look beneath the headlines, and aside from pollsters like YouGov, Reform aren't polling that much better than Rishi on average, who lost in a landslide.

    The narrative is Nigel is on course to be the next PM, and that's generally because Reform are polling first in a crowded field, but I'm not sure he's even close.
    YouGov is the pollster showing the LOWEST Reform share nationally.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 40,309

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    If you look beneath the headlines, and aside from pollsters like YouGov, Reform aren't polling that much better than Rishi on average, who lost in a landslide.

    The narrative is Nigel is on course to be the next PM, and that's generally because Reform are polling first in a crowded field, but I'm not sure he's even close.
    If Reform and the Conservatives could do what Labour and Lib Dems did in 2024- target their appeal to different shades of their side with mega efficiency- they might get somewhere. It's not clear that they can, even if they want to.

    More likely, they fight each other to a standstill. Though in five/six party FPTP, anything can happen.
    It depends. In the Red Wall seats, I’d expect the Conservative vote to collapse to Reform. That’s pretty much what’s happening in local elections.

    They could split the vote in the West Country.
  • algarkirkalgarkirk Posts: 16,265
    edited 8:53AM
    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    I don't pretend to understand Welsh (or any) politics, but I think this point is important for England - which is over 500 Westminster seats.

    On current form there are three contests going on: Reform v Not Reform; Labour v Not Labour; and Left of Centre v Right of Centre. All three involve very strong convictions among voters.

    With the right of centre there are two parties and two possible parties of government.
    With the left of centre there are 3 parties (+ ragtag of Jezbollah etc) but only one possible party of government - Labour.

    So the outcome is heavily dependent on how much the centre left half of the voters want to form the next government, and if their dislike of Labour outweighs their dislike of Tory/Reform.

    In Wales 2026 (but not 2029) it is easy - vote PC. It is a risk free option. In England it remains an open question. There are no centre left risk free options except combining to back Labour.

  • Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 63,395
    Odd but nice story, Japanese and Korean leaders drumming together to K-Pop:
    https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c0lx49z8ly6o

    If Trump did it, he'd probably end up trashing the drum kit. Starmer would hit the same drum with a constant, monotonous rhythm.
  • MelonBMelonB Posts: 16,679
    If Plaid make a success of their Rhun at power, then we start to see an even more regional bloc polity emerging across the country.

    The SNP have already become a sort of default within the left/liberal bloc for Scotland. The Lib Dems in the Waitrose belt and rural South West. The Greens or other more left wing insurgents could start to take over the cities and hipster enclaves. Then we have Plaid as the left choice in Wales.

    Meanwhile the right also starts to separate along regional lines. Reform in the Danelaw, Tories in the leafy shires.

    The most vulnerable party in this regional sorting is Labour.

    France and Germany and several former communist states have been trending this way for a few years, the French pattern hidden somewhat by their second round elections which force a choice even more than FPTP. It’s an interesting development.
  • algarkirkalgarkirk Posts: 16,265
    Isn't that what in the UK we call 'an Andrea Jenkyns'? The old country gets there first.

  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 53,865
    edited 9:02AM
    algarkirk said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    I don't pretend to understand Welsh (or any) politics, but I think this point is important for England - which is over 500 Westminster seats.

    On current form there are three contests going on: Reform v Not Reform; Labour v Not Labour; and Left of Centre v Right of Centre. All three involve very strong convictions among voters.

    With the right of centre there are two parties and two possible parties of government.
    With the left of centre there are 3 parties (+ ragtag of Jezbollah etc) but only one possible party of government - Labour.

    So the outcome is heavily dependent on how much the centre left half of the voters want to form the next government, and if their dislike of Labour outweighs their dislike of Tory/Reform.

    In Wales 2026 (but not 2029) it is easy - vote PC. It is a risk free option. In England it remains an open question. There are no centre left risk free options except combining to back Labour.

    On what basis are you deciding that Reform, with its five MPs, mercurial untested leader and its chequered record is a possible party of government, when the LibDems with their 72 MPs and five solid years in government relatively recently, is not?
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 59,905

    Odd but nice story, Japanese and Korean leaders drumming together to K-Pop:
    https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c0lx49z8ly6o

    If Trump did it, he'd probably end up trashing the drum kit. Starmer would hit the same drum with a constant, monotonous rhythm.

    Odd but nice story, Japanese and Korean leaders drumming together to K-Pop:
    https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c0lx49z8ly6o

    If Trump did it, he'd probably end up trashing the drum kit. Starmer would hit the same drum with a constant, monotonous rhythm.

    Starmer would be half beat off. All the time.
  • bondegezoubondegezou Posts: 18,098
    The worker has now been sacked, because f*** the first amendment.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 89,425
    You can take the boy of New York, but you can't take the New Yorker out of the boy.
  • theProletheProle Posts: 1,653
    edited 9:05AM

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    If you look beneath the headlines, and aside from pollsters like YouGov, Reform aren't polling that much better than Rishi on average, who lost in a landslide.

    The narrative is Nigel is on course to be the next PM, and that's generally because Reform are polling first in a crowded field, but I'm not sure he's even close.
    So apart from with the pollsters showing them doing well, the polls show Reform doing less well is a fairly obvious truism, but I'm not sure it's a very valuable one.

    The other thing is that in the kingdom of the blind, the one eyed man is king... If you've only got 30% in the polls, and everyone else has 20% or less, in some ways, you've actually got a more commanding lead than if you've got 45% and your next rival has 35%.

    The if the polling remains unchanged, the only thing likely to stuff up the fulfilment Nigel's ambitions to become PM is tactical voting on a massive scale. And that's going to be really hard for Reform's rivals, not least because the polling of the other parties is so changeable, and so different to last time it will be very difficult in lots of seats to know how to vote tactically.
  • BattlebusBattlebus Posts: 2,255

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 45,687
    IanB2 said:

    algarkirk said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    I don't pretend to understand Welsh (or any) politics, but I think this point is important for England - which is over 500 Westminster seats.

    On current form there are three contests going on: Reform v Not Reform; Labour v Not Labour; and Left of Centre v Right of Centre. All three involve very strong convictions among voters.

    With the right of centre there are two parties and two possible parties of government.
    With the left of centre there are 3 parties (+ ragtag of Jezbollah etc) but only one possible party of government - Labour.

    So the outcome is heavily dependent on how much the centre left half of the voters want to form the next government, and if their dislike of Labour outweighs their dislike of Tory/Reform.

    In Wales 2026 (but not 2029) it is easy - vote PC. It is a risk free option. In England it remains an open question. There are no centre left risk free options except combining to back Labour.

    On what basis are you deciding that Reform, with its five MPs, mercurial untested leader and its chequered record is a possible party of government, when the LibDems with their 72 MPs and five solid years in government relatively recently, is not?
    Libdems are invisible , in and out of parliament though I agree Reform are absolute horse manure. However given the crap job the supposedly major parties have inflicted on people there is a chance the Monster raving loonies could win next election if they stood. Most people will be thinking that anyone or anything has to be better than labour or Tory next time.
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 27,293
    edited 9:07AM
    IanB2 said:

    algarkirk said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    I don't pretend to understand Welsh (or any) politics, but I think this point is important for England - which is over 500 Westminster seats.

    On current form there are three contests going on: Reform v Not Reform; Labour v Not Labour; and Left of Centre v Right of Centre. All three involve very strong convictions among voters.

    With the right of centre there are two parties and two possible parties of government.
    With the left of centre there are 3 parties (+ ragtag of Jezbollah etc) but only one possible party of government - Labour.

    So the outcome is heavily dependent on how much the centre left half of the voters want to form the next government, and if their dislike of Labour outweighs their dislike of Tory/Reform.

    In Wales 2026 (but not 2029) it is easy - vote PC. It is a risk free option. In England it remains an open question. There are no centre left risk free options except combining to back Labour.

    On what basis are you deciding that Reform, with its five MPs, mercurial untested leader and its chequered record is a possible party of government, when the LibDems with their 72 MPs and five solid years in government relatively recently, is not?
    Because the LibDems are coasting on their 2024 result, show no sign of recognising that their failure to snaffle up the free food in front of them whilst the Greens gobble it up muy gusto is dangerous for them, and no matter how efficient they are in their new constituencies there's only so much you can do with a declining vote share before you start losing seats fast.
  • BlancheLivermoreBlancheLivermore Posts: 7,270
    Keir Starmer and his government have lurched from crisis to crisis and U-turn to U-turn.

    To correct one error, even two, might make sense.

    But when they’ve notched up 12 U-turns and rising, the only conclusion is serial incompetence.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 89,425
    edited 9:07AM
    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    The UK has for quite a while been a poor country (economically and productively) with a very rich and productive capital.
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 57,309

    I presume he'd then push for a Welsh independence vote of some sort - especially if he gets a majority.

    They haven't had one yet, so will be interesting to see how HMG responds to that.

    That would be interesting, especially if the Nationalists won. My impression is that there isn't a huge amount of common ground between the folk of North and South Wales, but maybe we are about to find out.
    Plaid's USP is "we haven't had the chance to disappoint you in government yet". That can attract all sorts of voters from all sorts of places.

    The interesting question is what happens after their victory.
    Well, they screw up and prove to be every bit as incompetent as those they have replaced, obviously.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 53,865
    edited 9:11AM
    viewcode said:

    IanB2 said:

    algarkirk said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    I don't pretend to understand Welsh (or any) politics, but I think this point is important for England - which is over 500 Westminster seats.

    On current form there are three contests going on: Reform v Not Reform; Labour v Not Labour; and Left of Centre v Right of Centre. All three involve very strong convictions among voters.

    With the right of centre there are two parties and two possible parties of government.
    With the left of centre there are 3 parties (+ ragtag of Jezbollah etc) but only one possible party of government - Labour.

    So the outcome is heavily dependent on how much the centre left half of the voters want to form the next government, and if their dislike of Labour outweighs their dislike of Tory/Reform.

    In Wales 2026 (but not 2029) it is easy - vote PC. It is a risk free option. In England it remains an open question. There are no centre left risk free options except combining to back Labour.

    On what basis are you deciding that Reform, with its five MPs, mercurial untested leader and its chequered record is a possible party of government, when the LibDems with their 72 MPs and five solid years in government relatively recently, is not?
    Because the LibDems are coasting on their 2024 result, show no sign of recognising that their failure to snaffle up the free food in front of them whilst the Greens gobble it up muy gusto is dangerous for them, and no matter how efficient they are in their new constituencies there's only so much you can do with a declining vote share before you start losing seats fast.
    If the decider is simply poll rating, then the Tories aren't a possible party of government right now. Although they might be part of a government, but then so might the LibDems. I took the original reference to 'possible' to be about more than just the latest poll rating?
  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 46,275

    The worker has now been sacked, because f*** the first amendment.
    The White House says the president's response was 'appropriate' (not sure about the sacking, but I can guess).

    https://x.com/washingtonpost/status/2011228286299291775?s=20

    Coming our way:

    'Today the White House said that the president's security detail holding down a protestor so the president could shit on his face was appropriate.'
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 89,425
    edited 9:15AM

    Keir Starmer and his government have lurched from crisis to crisis and U-turn to U-turn.

    To correct one error, even two, might make sense.

    But when they’ve notched up 12 U-turns and rising, the only conclusion is serial incompetence.

    13 now....

    “If you fail to plan, you are planning to fail!”
  • BattlebusBattlebus Posts: 2,255

    The worker has now been sacked, because f*** the first amendment.
    The White House says the president's response was 'appropriate' (not sure about the sacking, but I can guess).

    https://x.com/washingtonpost/status/2011228286299291775?s=20

    Coming our way:

    'Today the White House said that the president's security detail holding down a protestor so the president could shit on his face was appropriate.'
    Those Epstein files must have some explosive revelations within. He's going to have to so something (even further) off the wall to keep the stuff off the news.
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 21,604

    The worker has now been sacked, because f*** the first amendment.
    The White House says the president's response was 'appropriate' (not sure about the sacking, but I can guess).

    https://x.com/washingtonpost/status/2011228286299291775?s=20

    Coming our way:

    'Today the White House said that the president's security detail holding down a protestor so the president could shit on his face was appropriate.'
    If Starmer visits a factory in the UK and a member of staff does something equivalent - can they be subject to disciplinary measures? I would assume yes - actions that bring the company into disrepute.
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 9,851

    The worker has now been sacked, because f*** the first amendment.
    President Vance then? :open_mouth: Not that I'd call Trump a worker*, but I can see that he brought the presidency into disrepute. Again.

    *change a couple of letters and we're somewhere close
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 59,273
    Dead dodgy Russian tanker being towed out of the Black Sea by Turkish Coastguard, having been droned by the Ukranians last month.

    https://x.com/noelreports/status/2011190766584971545
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 89,425
    edited 9:24AM
    Plod admit they mislead MPs over the Maccabit Tel Aviv after using AI....

    Called it. They ChatGPT'ed, give me all the terrible things their fans have done so we can ban them, and it came up with an event that never happened.
  • RochdalePioneersRochdalePioneers Posts: 31,595
    Back at my desk after a trip to NL. Labour are in serious shit here - their terrible whupping at Holyrood and Senedd elections will hurt far more than losing the councils and councillors they will inevitably lose in England.

    With the continued exodus from the Tories to the new Tories, and Labour's own slide into irrelevance, we are seeing a significant shift in voter intention which will make a mockery of FPTP. Shifts don't always stick - the Red wall went blue then red again. But is now heading for light blue it would seem.

    My own party? Seemingly irrelevant. I am glad that my focus in 2026 is business and not politics, I would have been disappointed as a candidate in May...
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 125,621
    Told you AI was shit and only is believed by simpletons.

    Police chief apologises for 'erroneous' Maccabi Tel Aviv fan ban evidence, blaming AI

    https://news.sky.com/story/police-chief-apologises-for-erroneous-maccabi-tel-aviv-fan-ban-evidence-blaming-ai-13494040
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 59,273

    Keir Starmer and his government have lurched from crisis to crisis and U-turn to U-turn.

    To correct one error, even two, might make sense.

    But when they’ve notched up 12 U-turns and rising, the only conclusion is serial incompetence.

    Very good.

    Most won’t get the reference, so https://x.com/carlyfarly69/status/2011160595106791574
  • RazedabodeRazedabode Posts: 3,159
    I see mad Ed Miliband (EICIPM) has now also locked us into record wind generation costs for the next 20 or so years.

    Honestly, this government is just shocking
  • BlancheLivermoreBlancheLivermore Posts: 7,270

    Keir Starmer and his government have lurched from crisis to crisis and U-turn to U-turn.

    To correct one error, even two, might make sense.

    But when they’ve notched up 12 U-turns and rising, the only conclusion is serial incompetence.

    Oh.. I missed out the quotation marks after Starmer:


  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 46,275

    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    The UK has for quite a while been a poor country (economically and productively) with a very rich and productive capital.
    London being comparable with Poland on GDP isn't exactly mind blowing.
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 9,851
    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    Be interesting to see the country comparators based on GDP/capita - as far as I can see, they're done by GDP which is skewed by population - e.g. North East and Wales have worse GDP/capita than NI (I was surprised by that) but better 'if country' ranks.
  • TazTaz Posts: 23,913

    The worker has now been sacked, because f*** the first amendment.
    The White House says the president's response was 'appropriate' (not sure about the sacking, but I can guess).

    https://x.com/washingtonpost/status/2011228286299291775?s=20

    Coming our way:

    'Today the White House said that the president's security detail holding down a protestor so the president could shit on his face was appropriate.'
    If Starmer visits a factory in the UK and a member of staff does something equivalent - can they be subject to disciplinary measures? I would assume yes - actions that bring the company into disrepute.
    Exactly.

    It’s a total non issue.

    Some guy is rude to a visiting dignatory. He deserves the sack. Would be the same if it was Biden.

    Still it occupied a few people on here for a while.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 53,865
    On R4 now, our Prof Curtis on a topic that comes up here now and again. He says "there is no evidence in our data of any kind of a revival of Christianity in Great Britain".
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 59,273

    Told you AI was shit and only is believed by simpletons.

    Police chief apologises for 'erroneous' Maccabi Tel Aviv fan ban evidence, blaming AI

    https://news.sky.com/story/police-chief-apologises-for-erroneous-maccabi-tel-aviv-fan-ban-evidence-blaming-ai-13494040

    “AI” isn’t somehow an excuse for incompetence and antisemitism. The Home Secretary should formally state her lack of confidence in him.

    Craig Guildford was worried about riots from locals in Birmingham, not the visiting football fans.
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 21,604

    Plod admit they mislead MPs over the Maccabit Tel Aviv after using AI....

    Called it. They ChatGPT'ed, give me all the terrible things their fans have done so we can ban them, and it came up with an event that never happened.

    The Chief Constable's position is surely untenable now. If he has any sense of honour.

    Oh.
  • TazTaz Posts: 23,913

    Plod admit they mislead MPs over the Maccabit Tel Aviv after using AI....

    Called it. They ChatGPT'ed, give me all the terrible things their fans have done so we can ban them, and it came up with an event that never happened.


    You did indeed !

    Junior heads must roll.
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 21,604

    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    The UK has for quite a while been a poor country (economically and productively) with a very rich and productive capital.
    London being comparable with Poland on GDP isn't exactly mind blowing.
    38 million Poles vs 10 million Londoners, so London is four times more productive per capita?
  • stodgestodge Posts: 15,876
    Morning all :)

    Just about managed to drag myself out from under the weight of the horrendous puns this morning.

    I commented on the Welsh poll yesterday evening so I won't repeat myself (this time).

    On Government U-turns, all Governments do them and you could argue all the time. Part of governance is to float an idea and see what happens (or, if you prefer, run it up the flagpole and see who salutes). In this social media and rolling news cycle era, those opposed to either a) the proposed policy or b) everything the Government says, thinks or does will be out of the traps like the proverbial A1 greyhound to state all the reasons why it's wrong and won't work.

    To paraphrase a wise man, the only tweets more boring than those criticising the Government are those praising it and as the hostile reviews come in, Government will look at a) who is being hostile and b) why. If a) are the usual suspects, they won't mind but if some of those criticising the idea are among those who are normally supportive, that gets the alarm bells ringing.

    In addition, those who normally support you but are critical of this idea will give better reasons why they are opposed and what the problems are then those who are hostile just for the sake of it.

    I do think at times Starmer takes too much notice of hostility because, like most politicians, he just wants to be liked (and to keep his job). There are times when you have to do what you think is right even if many say you are wrong - it's called "conviction politics" and has a different meaning nowadays I fear.

    The problem with conviction politics is what happens when it's proved you were wrong and everyone else was right...
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 53,865

    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    The UK has for quite a while been a poor country (economically and productively) with a very rich and productive capital.
    London being comparable with Poland on GDP isn't exactly mind blowing.
    They're not far behind the UK on GDP per head and also not far behind on average net income (by $ purchasing parity). If you'd visited Poland thirty or forty years ago, that achievement is pretty mind-blowing.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 89,425
    edited 9:34AM

    Plod admit they mislead MPs over the Maccabit Tel Aviv after using AI....

    Called it. They ChatGPT'ed, give me all the terrible things their fans have done so we can ban them, and it came up with an event that never happened.

    The Chief Constable's position is surely untenable now. If he has any sense of honour.

    Oh.
    The more that has been revealed about this story the more dodgy it all looked. The false story that AI generated and they used as evidence was only a small part of it.

    But imagine not checking all actual incidents ChatGPT provided. They are the f##king police, evidence matters and they also have easy access to check.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 59,273
    Taz said:

    The worker has now been sacked, because f*** the first amendment.
    The White House says the president's response was 'appropriate' (not sure about the sacking, but I can guess).

    https://x.com/washingtonpost/status/2011228286299291775?s=20

    Coming our way:

    'Today the White House said that the president's security detail holding down a protestor so the president could shit on his face was appropriate.'
    If Starmer visits a factory in the UK and a member of staff does something equivalent - can they be subject to disciplinary measures? I would assume yes - actions that bring the company into disrepute.
    Exactly.

    It’s a total non issue.

    Some guy is rude to a visiting dignatory. He deserves the sack. Would be the same if it was Biden.

    Still it occupied a few people on here for a while.
    Err yeah. If someone important visits your office, you’d better have a really powerful union if you think you’re going to get away with being an arsehole towards the VIP.
  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 46,275
    edited 9:33AM

    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    The UK has for quite a while been a poor country (economically and productively) with a very rich and productive capital.
    London being comparable with Poland on GDP isn't exactly mind blowing.
    38 million Poles vs 10 million Londoners, so London is four times more productive per capita?
    We're getting to the statistics part of 'lies, damn lies and statistics'.

    On that measure Scotland is seven times more productive than Peru, as if it matters a feck.

  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 57,309
    edited 9:35AM

    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    The UK has for quite a while been a poor country (economically and productively) with a very rich and productive capital.
    London being comparable with Poland on GDP isn't exactly mind blowing.
    38 million Poles vs 10 million Londoners, so London is four times more productive per capita?
    This is GDP per capita so no.

    Edit, at least I think so. Its a bit confusing to be honest.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 59,273
    IanB2 said:

    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    The UK has for quite a while been a poor country (economically and productively) with a very rich and productive capital.
    London being comparable with Poland on GDP isn't exactly mind blowing.
    They're not far behind the UK on GDP per head and also not far behind on average net income (by $ purchasing parity). If you'd visited Poland thirty or forty years ago, that achievement is pretty mind-blowing.
    I was in Poland last year, awesome place. Krakow is a wonderful city, clearly on the up and well worth a visit.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 89,425
    edited 9:36AM
    Oh god, worse than using ChatGPT, they used Microsoft Co Pilot......the Temu of AI.

    Also double lying plod,

    In a letter to the chair of the Home Affairs Select Committee, Guildford says the information "arose as result of a use of Microsoft Co Pilot" - he had previously insisted the force "do not use AI" and a Google search provided the information.
  • RochdalePioneersRochdalePioneers Posts: 31,595
    No need to fuss about the guy getting fired by Ford - he knew what he was doing. POTUS shouting Fuck Off and flipping the bird? Come on, had it been Biden or Obama doing that the right would be losing their shit.

    Why did Trump react that way? Because the heckle bit close to his paedophile home...
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 40,309
    IanB2 said:

    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    The UK has for quite a while been a poor country (economically and productively) with a very rich and productive capital.
    London being comparable with Poland on GDP isn't exactly mind blowing.
    They're not far behind the UK on GDP per head and also not far behind on average net income (by $ purchasing parity). If you'd visited Poland thirty or forty years ago, that achievement is pretty mind-blowing.
    It demonstrates how communism kept these places artificially poor (pre war, what is now Western Poland would have been one of Europe’s richest regions).
  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 46,275
    One comforting certainty in life is that if a factory worker was sacked for doing a wanker gesture during a Starmer visit, exactly the same people saying the US guy deserved to be sacked would be having a prolapse over police state UK.
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 9,851
    DavidL said:

    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    The UK has for quite a while been a poor country (economically and productively) with a very rich and productive capital.
    London being comparable with Poland on GDP isn't exactly mind blowing.
    38 million Poles vs 10 million Londoners, so London is four times more productive per capita?
    This is GDP per capita so no.

    Edit, at least I think so. Its a bit confusing to be honest.
    Not on the country comparisons (as I noted above|below).
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 89,425
    edited 9:43AM
    I believe that GDP / capita comparison with Poland isn't straight GDP / capita, it is the adjusted purchasing power version. GDP / capita of Poland is still only ~$30k per year, but because it is still a very cheap place to live, when they do tha adjustments the "purchasing power" version is $55k / per year, which is more equivalent to London (as it gets knocked right down because of expensive living costs). Straight GDP / Capita of London is more like ~$80-85k / year.

    The rest of the UK though is terrible. Poland now really isn't far away on straight GDP / Capita than the UK, and especially if you remove London.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 59,273
    What would a judge say if the police were found to have submitted AI bollocks as evidence, and then lied repeatedly about it?

    Sorry but Guildford’s position is totally untenable.
  • stodgestodge Posts: 15,876
    Apologies if already posted, but the weekly More In Common VI numbers:

    REF: 31% (=)
    CON: 21% (-2)
    LAB: 19% (=)
    LDEM: 12% (=)
    GRN: 12% (+2)

    Fieldwork from 10/1 - 13/1 - changes from the poll released on 7/1.

    A huge swing from the Greens to the Conservatives (he jests). Again, we have the notable disparity between the Reform, LD and Green numbers between YouGov and other pollsters.

    I'm wondering if this could be connected to weighting by likelihood to vote....
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 89,425
    edited 9:45AM
    Sandpit said:

    What would a judge say if the police were found to have submitted AI bollocks as evidence, and then lied repeatedly about it?

    Sorry but Guildford’s position is totally untenable.

    His feet shouldn't touch the floor on removal. Personal items should already be in a box and be being led out by lunchtime, but probably won't.
  • bondegezoubondegezou Posts: 18,098

    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    The UK has for quite a while been a poor country (economically and productively) with a very rich and productive capital.
    London being comparable with Poland on GDP isn't exactly mind blowing.
    38 million Poles vs 10 million Londoners, so London is four times more productive per capita?
    That's because all the productive Poles moved to London!
  • bondegezoubondegezou Posts: 18,098
    Sean_F said:

    IanB2 said:

    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    The UK has for quite a while been a poor country (economically and productively) with a very rich and productive capital.
    London being comparable with Poland on GDP isn't exactly mind blowing.
    They're not far behind the UK on GDP per head and also not far behind on average net income (by $ purchasing parity). If you'd visited Poland thirty or forty years ago, that achievement is pretty mind-blowing.
    It demonstrates how communism kept these places artificially poor (pre war, what is now Western Poland would have been one of Europe’s richest regions).
    Pre war, what is now western Poland, was Germany.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 65,142

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    If you look beneath the headlines, and aside from pollsters like YouGov, Reform aren't polling that much better than Rishi on average, who lost in a landslide.

    The narrative is Nigel is on course to be the next PM, and that's generally because Reform are polling first in a crowded field, but I'm not sure he's even close.
    I've said that it is entirely possible that Reform or some other party win the next election on a bigger landslide than Starmer on a much lower vote share than Labour in 2024 or the Tory vote share in 2024.
    Yes, but with Nigel's favourability ratings and how marmite Reform are I just don't see it.

    They will haul seats in certain places, for sure, but I don't believe this landslide stuff - people in most seats will work out who's most likely to beat Reform and block them if they feel that strongly about it, even if it results in a Balkanised House of Commons.
  • ManOfGwentManOfGwent Posts: 266
    edited 9:50AM
    Hopefully this will show Welsh Labour that devolution was a disaster, as it was always going to be in the form it was introduced. Won't hold my breath though, they will probably learn the wrong long term lesson and go even more natty.

    I've always questioned who are the people who vote in UK elections, that don't vote in devolved elections, a good 15 percent in Wales' case. Will these people turn out when the result is not the usual forgone conclusion.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 65,142

    Battlebus said:

    Sean_F said:

    It seems highly implausible to me that the vote share for centre right/right parties in Wales will be lower in May than it was in 2024.

    If the Conservatives poll as little as 10%, Reform will win 30%+. If Reform poll as low as 23%, the Conservatives will be close to 20%.

    Tactically it's quite a nice poll for Reform - it would galvanise their support if people thought this would be the outcome.

    I do struggle to take Yougov seriously these days. I guess we'll see...
    Are YouGov oversampling insurgency?

    Plaid here, and Reform nationally.
    I thought Plaid Cymru would win the Caerphilly by-election but I was shocked that turnout was higher than in the actual devolved election (the polls had Reform winning.)

    That might be an outlier or an actual harbinger of people voting to stop Reform winning, May will give us a better idea but there could a paradox that right now Reform are simultaneously the country's most popular and unpopular party.
    From Casino's link earlier. You could improve r/Britain's GDP significantly by getting rid of Northern Ireland (GDP 74th in the world), Wales (GDP 62nd) and Scotland (GDP 49th). Bundling the North East (GDP 69th) with Scotland would give an extra boost.

    All these regions sucking the life out of the Britain.


    The UK has for quite a while been a poor country (economically and productively) with a very rich and productive capital.
    London being comparable with Poland on GDP isn't exactly mind blowing.
    It's based on size of economy, not relative GDP to head.

    London achieves that with under 10 million people.
Sign In or Register to comment.