Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

How was this sausage made? – politicalbetting.com

124»

Comments

  • MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,772
    edited November 2023
    Piers Morgan has tonight named (on TalkTV I think) the two members of the royal family who questionned what colour skin Harry and Meghan's baby would have.

    This was being discussed on Times Radio around 10pm - including reporting the names Morgan gave.

    Yet I see nothing on BBC website etc. Or on here. Surely it must now be deemed to be "out"? Or maybe not?

    (I won't name them here unless am told it is appropriate to do so).
  • MikeL said:

    Piers Morgan has tonight named (on TalkTV I think) the two members of the royal family who questionned what colour skin Harry and Meghan's baby would have.

    This was being discussed on Times Radio around 10pm - including reporting the names Morgan gave.

    Yet I see nothing on BBC website etc. Or on here. Surely it must now be deemed to be "out"? Or maybe not?

    (I won't name them here unless am told it is appropriate to do so).

    The whole thing is very odd since Scobie denied naming them, and it is hard to see how they could be named in translation if not in the original English text.
  • BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 9,078
    edited November 2023
    MikeL said:

    Piers Morgan has tonight named (on TalkTV I think) the two members of the royal family who questionned what colour skin Harry and Meghan's baby would have.

    This was being discussed on Times Radio around 10pm - including reporting the names Morgan gave.

    Yet I see nothing on BBC website etc. Or on here. Surely it must now be deemed to be "out"? Or maybe not?

    (I won't name them here unless am told it is appropriate to do so).

    It's all over twitter. I'm not a royalist but I don't think it is racist to speculate on what colour a baby is likely to be, or its sex. A none story.
  • GIN1138 said:

    What a bunch of oddballs that lot is... 😂
    Three of whom have been leader.

    Jeez...
  • The BBC does "do stuff others don't" but if its entire output consisted of highbrow programmes with under 100,000 viewers or listeners (and often a long way under) the clamour to ditch the licence would be overwhelming (and it is already quite loud).
    Oh come on. You know I'm not saying the Beeb just does a PBS.

    But it is about balance of funding.

    Newsnight, foreign correspondents, Today, Panaroma etc etc

    This is where more funds should go, not paying for a higher level of Z list celeb to do Strictly.

  • Policing minister failed to declare VIP football tickets
    Chris Philp attended the match as a guest of the FA and sat in the royal box in hospitality worth more than £6,000

    https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/policing-minister-failed-to-declare-vip-football-tickets-ps2txxtj5 (£££)
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 54,801

    Have you posted the wrong video? That one's about rogue landlords who let out grossly substandard property for extortionate rents.
    Or do you have another agenda?
    Who is footing the bill for the extortionate rent?

    The point is that the whole system is dysfunctional and that transaction simply shouldn't be happening. It has the effect of pushing prices up for people paying their own way in the private sector.
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,795
    McCrossover
    pm215 said:

    I think it's one of those ancient things that was once "just the way it worked" (because the caller is paying for the call it matters that they can terminate it; it probably initially seemed less important that the caller could do so quickly), then got kept around through various technology transitions because some people relied on it as a feature (if you have multiple wired in landline phones around your house this lets you put down the handset on the hallway phone you originally picked up the call on and go and use the bedroom phone instead, because the call stays connected in the time between you putting down one handset and picking up the other), and then more recently has been being changed because of the fraud problem. Supposedly BT cut it from 2 minutes to 10 seconds in 2014 (which by that point was just "change a config value in the digital exchange"; would no doubt have been more painful in the days of analogue mechanical exchanges).
    Do many people use landlines much anymore?
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 126,995

    Oh come on. You know I'm not saying the Beeb just does a PBS.

    But it is about balance of funding.

    Newsnight, foreign correspondents, Today, Panaroma etc etc

    This is where more funds should go, not paying for a higher level of Z list celeb to do Strictly.

    Indeed, adverts could fund the latter
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 126,995
    edited November 2023
    MikeL said:

    Piers Morgan has tonight named (on TalkTV I think) the two members of the royal family who questionned what colour skin Harry and Meghan's baby would have.

    This was being discussed on Times Radio around 10pm - including reporting the names Morgan gave.

    Yet I see nothing on BBC website etc. Or on here. Surely it must now be deemed to be "out"? Or maybe not?

    (I won't name them here unless am told it is appropriate to do so).

    No, in effect Morgan has potentially committed slander (even Scobie did not name the names in the English text of his book and says the Dutch version was a translation error).

    Fortunately for Morgan as TalkTV has about 1 viewer (whose wife is the 1 listener to Times Radio) nobody noticed until your post
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 54,801
    HYUFD said:

    No, in effect Morgan has potentially committed slander (even Scobie did not name the names in the English text of his book and says the Dutch version was a translation error).

    Fortunately for Morgan as TalkTV has about 1 viewer (whose wife is the 1 listener to Times Radio) nobody noticed until your post
    He posted the clip on Twitter and it’s had 3 million views so far.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,349

    McCrossover

    Do many people use landlines much anymore?
    About 20 million households have them.
  • Jim_MillerJim_Miller Posts: 3,262
    edited November 2023
    Some years ago I got a call that I tentatively assumed was from a scammer. I don't remember much about it, but I do recall that they tried several times to get me to say "yes". Which I guessed, at the time, they would record, and use to impersonate me.

    (But I could be wrong.)
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,795
    RobD said:

    About 20 million households have them.
    I have one. It comes with my cable telly. But I don’t use it. There’s no handset plugged in. I don’t even know the number. What is the point of them?
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 126,995

    He posted the clip on Twitter and it’s had 3 million views so far.
    Which just makes it potentially even more slanderous, as the wider the reach, the greater the argued damage in any potential defamation claim. Note no other UK media outlet has named the 2 alleged royals.

    Even Scobie didn't actually name the names on TV or in his English text book and his Dutch version is being pulled due to an 'error'
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 65,018
    edited November 2023
    HYUFD said:

    No, in effect Morgan has potentially committed slander (even Scobie did not name the names in the English text of his book and says the Dutch version was a translation error).

    Fortunately for Morgan as TalkTV has about 1 viewer (whose wife is the 1 listener to Times Radio) nobody noticed until your post
    I think you are being rather naive as it is very much out there

    Frankly I have no interest in the story or the Royals

    There are far more important things to concentrate on and in my case my own health
  • RobD said:

    About 20 million households have them.
    Mine is digital with BT but I never use it
  • StillWatersStillWaters Posts: 9,756
    RobD said:


    About 20 million households have them.
    That wasn’t the question!
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 126,995

    I think you are being rather naive as it is very much out there

    Frankly I have no interest in the story or the Royals

    There are far more important things to concentrate on and in my case my own health
    Not in the UK it isn't, Morgan is the only UK media journalist or presenter who has named the alleged 2 royals
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,353
    Nigelb said:

    If Musk ends up bankrupting Twitter, will someone else pick it up ?

    whoa — “go fuck yourself,” Elon Musk says to Bob Iger and others who pull advertising from X

    at this point it’s almost as if he’s watching the old Iron Man movies and doing a reverse Tony Stark impression

    https://twitter.com/jd_durkin/status/1729991850079990080

    Of course.

    Twitter with a low cost base, an advertising partnership with someone who the demographics of its users (like, Google or Facebook) and some moderately unobtrusive filtering of the worst stream of shit, and you'll have a profitable company.
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 24,238
    Musk doesn't want people to advertise on Twitter.

    If you are worth 450billion and spent 30billion buying Twitter, you can run it indefinitely without adverts. Rich man's toy.

    https://nitter.net/AlexThomp/status/1729996181756129724#m
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,349

    I have one. It comes with my cable telly. But I don’t use it. There’s no handset plugged in. I don’t even know the number. What is the point of them?
    About a quarter of households "never" use them. So that's 15 million or so that do.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,353

    The public disagrees, down to less than 300k viewers.
    To be fair, pretty much all broadcast news viewing has collapsed.
  • HYUFD said:

    Not in the UK it isn't, Morgan is the only UK media journalist or presenter who has named the alleged 2 royals
    Of course it is - Piers Morgan has posted it and millions have seen it

    I would not however repeat the names
  • StillWatersStillWaters Posts: 9,756
    HYUFD said:

    Not in the UK it isn't, Morgan is the only UK media journalist or presenter who has named the alleged 2 royals

    Anyone who googles will know

    It is in no way a “translation” error. Redaction is not “translated”. It is or it isn’t.

    In my view this was an entirely intentional “mistake”

    But at the end of the day who cares what a two bit nobody thinks or says. And as for Scobie…
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,353
    viewcode said:

    Musk doesn't want people to advertise on Twitter.

    If you are worth 450billion and spent 30billion buying Twitter, you can run it indefinitely without adverts. Rich man's toy.

    https://nitter.net/AlexThomp/status/1729996181756129724#m

    That's not quite true.

    Twitter has other shareholders. It also has debtholders.

    Now Musk can continually sell down his Telsa and SpaceX shares to inject money into Twitter to keep it on life support. But he's not completely without obligations to the other owners.
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,795

    That wasn’t the question!
    Indeed it wasn’t
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,795
    HYUFD said:

    Not in the UK it isn't, Morgan is the only UK media journalist or presenter who has named the alleged 2 royals
    It took me about two seconds to find it on Twitter.
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 24,238
    HYUFD said:

    Not in the UK it isn't, Morgan is the only UK media journalist or presenter who has named the alleged 2 royals
    Parenthetically, the bastardisation of the term "journalist" is yet another thing I hate about the 21st century. Morgan is not a journalist.
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 65,018
    edited November 2023

    Indeed it wasn’t
    The only use we have got for it is our son in Vancouver uses it to ring us as it is cheap to do so apparently
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,795
    RobD said:

    About a quarter of households "never" use them. So that's 15 million or so that do.
    My question was: do they use them much? What exactly is the point of them? They seem to me to be a complete waste of space, unless you are in a mobile black spot (which I accept some people are). Otherwise, entirely pointless relics.
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,795
    viewcode said:

    Parenthetically, the bastardisation of the term "journalist" is yet another thing I hate about the 21st century. Morgan is not a journalist.
    Well he’s edited two national newspapers and interviews people in the media, so what is he then, if not a journalist?
  • Well he’s edited two national newspapers and interviews people in the media, so what is he then, if not a journalist?
    Do you want an honest answer to your question? !!!!!!
  • rcs1000 said:

    Of course.

    Twitter with a low cost base, an advertising partnership with someone who the demographics of its users (like, Google or Facebook) and some moderately unobtrusive filtering of the worst stream of shit, and you'll have a profitable company.
    The new X has given me porn in the past. A couple of days ago it followed up with someone getting shot.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 83,454
    edited November 2023
    Elon is going full Trump....even if you think that, normally you say it to their faces in private. Not bigly fuck you, fuck everybody, go fuck yourself.

    https://x.com/aubreystrobel/status/1730000411501687175?s=20
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 126,995

    It took me about two seconds to find it on Twitter.
    And retweeting it could also open you up to a minor libel claim, see the McAlpine or Giggs cases
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 83,454
    edited November 2023
    The kid who got smeared with accusations of black face (because half of his face was black and other half was red) at the American Football while dressed as an Indian Chief....rather hilariously, is as actually native American .

    Lawyers are going to sue the shit out of the sports journalist who was tweeting about him giving it the big'un about black face and cultural appropriation.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 83,454
    edited November 2023
    Piers is just desperate to get clicks and views, because nobody watches his show.

    I have to say not a fan of his approach, but quite surprised how piss poor his viewership is. Once again shows all those likes on tw@tter means absolutely bugger all. Just cos an "own" or two goes viral on the X, doesn't mean the tw@tterverse will be tuning into your tv show.
  • The Telegraph has analysed a cache of screenshots, shared by a concerned listener, collated since the start of the Israel-Hamas war on Oct 7 that show Asian Network presenters accusing Israel of committing genocide, sharing conspiracy theory videos and encouraging followers to attend pro-Palestine marches.

    BBC bosses were alerted to concerns about the social media accounts about three weeks after Hamas’s attacks on Israel.

    Yet on Wednesday, while some of the posts have been deleted, several of the highlighted posts remain online.

    https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/11/29/bbc-asian-network-stars-social-media-posts-israel-hamas-war/
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,349

    My question was: do they use them much? What exactly is the point of them? They seem to me to be a complete waste of space, unless you are in a mobile black spot (which I accept some people are). Otherwise, entirely pointless relics.
    You got tired of berating people who use cash?
  • Are these landlines the things you put cash into to make phone calls?
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,349

    Are these landlines the things you put cash into to make phone calls?

    Bloody hell. Don’t get him started on telephone boxes.
  • MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,772
    edited November 2023
    HYUFD said:

    Not in the UK it isn't, Morgan is the only UK media journalist or presenter who has named the alleged 2 royals
    No, Kait Borsay stated the names on Times Radio at approx 9.45pm.

    She did it quite innocently, just stating that these were the names given by Morgan.

    I think she just assumed it was OK to state the names and no big deal.
  • ICYMI we've just had a brief Vanilla outage.
  • ICYMI we've just had a brief Vanilla outage.

    Did somebody forget to put cash in the meter?
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 34,295
    "Nihal Arthanayake says working at the overwhelmingly white BBC is bad for his mental health

    BBC Radio 5 Live presenter made comments at journalism diversity conference
    Claimed lots of people leave because they couldn't deal with the culture
    BBC producer said the organisation is committed to tackling lack of diversity"

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12804889/BBC-presenter-says-overwhelmingly-white-workplace-affects-mental-health.html
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 83,454
    edited November 2023
    Andy_JS said:

    "Nihal Arthanayake says working at the overwhelmingly white BBC is bad for his mental health

    BBC Radio 5 Live presenter made comments at journalism diversity conference
    Claimed lots of people leave because they couldn't deal with the culture
    BBC producer said the organisation is committed to tackling lack of diversity"

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12804889/BBC-presenter-says-overwhelmingly-white-workplace-affects-mental-health.html

    That is just racist and I just don't believe his claims about not a single Muslim (why your religion matters) is an senior editorial role at R5. Also, hasn't stopped him working there for over 20 years, so can't be having that much of an impact.

    Also so BS about not many Asians since R5 went to Salford / Manchester. Clearly he doesn't get out much from the BBC bubble. 17% of the population of Manchester are South Asian, including 9% Pakistani.

    I know what is bad for my mental health, hearing him on the radio.
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 34,295
    "‘I’d like to see them shot in the head’: Councillor’s hard line on Dublin riots"

    https://www.limerickpost.ie/2023/11/29/id-like-to-see-them-shot-in-the-head-councillors-hard-line-on-dublin-riots/
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 34,295
    edited November 2023

    It used to get million+ 10 years ago.

    Edit - million on a good day, but your right not stellar, but it has been losing audience consistently since Paxman went. Now its 300k on a good day, sometimes as low as 150k.

    10 years ago the Guardian were musing had Savile scandal done for Newsnight because they had a few episodes of 600k.
    That many? That's actually good, because I remember how superb the programme was when people like Peter Snow, Francine Stock, Gavin Esler, Donald McIntyre, etc, were presenting it. (A bit weird that I was watching it at the age of 10/11/12, in retrospect!?)
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 83,454
    edited November 2023
    Andy_JS said:

    That many? That's actually good, because I remember how superb the programme was when people like Peter Snow, Francine Stock, Gavin Esler, Donald McIntyre, etc, were presenting it. (A bit weird that I was watching it at the age of 10/11/12, in retrospect!?)
    It took a real downturn when Evan Davis hosted and they tried to make it more hip and cool.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drMwoK-XVHU
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 54,801

    It took a real downturn when Evan Davis hosted and they tried to make it more hip and cool.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drMwoK-XVHU
    And that was completely unnecessary because they already had quite a good format in the era when it was balanced by the Newsnight Review programme with people like Tom Paulin and Ekow Eshun.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 83,454
    edited November 2023

    And that was completely unnecessary because they already had quite a good format in the era when it was balanced by the Newsnight Review programme with people like Tom Paulin and Ekow Eshun.
    That's another thing that has gone downhill. At the time, Friday afternoon was Kermode / Mayo film reviews and evening Newsnight review were well worth tuning in to.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 54,801
    Henry Kissinger has died.
  • Scotch on the Rocks: The TV drama locked away for 50 years
    ...
    The battle for Scottish independence has taken a violent turn after paramilitary "soldiers" of the Scottish Liberation Army (SLA) took over the town of Fort William.

    Troops from English regiments of the British army are massing north of Glasgow to turn back an expected assault on the nation's largest city.

    The prime minister is meeting his cabinet in London.

    And the leadership of the SNP, the party which recently narrowly missed out on winning a majority in the Westminster parliament, has yet to condemn the actions in the Highlands.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-66889553

    A 1973 television drama that has not been shown since, based on a story by [fx: drum roll] Douglas Hurd, the future Home Secretary.
  • Lord Howard should know better.

    Very disappointing.

    House of Lords = House of Unelected Has-Beens!
  • GardenwalkerGardenwalker Posts: 22,202
    Lord Howard is another who went mental for Brexit.

    I’ll never forget him making vague noises in support of a threat to invade Spain if they wouldn’t co-operate over Gibraltar.
  • Penddu2Penddu2 Posts: 754

    Scotch on the Rocks: The TV drama locked away for 50 years
    ...
    The battle for Scottish independence has taken a violent turn after paramilitary "soldiers" of the Scottish Liberation Army (SLA) took over the town of Fort William.

    Troops from English regiments of the British army are massing north of Glasgow to turn back an expected assault on the nation's largest city.

    The prime minister is meeting his cabinet in London.

    And the leadership of the SNP, the party which recently narrowly missed out on winning a majority in the Westminster parliament, has yet to condemn the actions in the Highlands.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-66889553

    A 1973 television drama that has not been shown since, based on a story by [fx: drum roll] Douglas Hurd, the future Home Secretary.

    If anyone is looking for a good political drama - try Occupied on Netflix. Excellent story.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,353

    Henry Kissinger has died.

    He was not a good man.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,658
    rcs1000 said:

    He was not a good man.
    Wikipedia had it right, for a short while at least.
    https://twitter.com/lolennui/status/1730067222914355649
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,658
    Henry Kissinger, linked to the demise of millions, received accolades from the political elite on his 100th birthday.

    However, it's crucial to recall these five catastrophic events, which truly epitomize his lasting legacy, amidst the widespread acclaim.

    https://twitter.com/allenanalysis/status/1730048810024309064
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,658
    Henry Kissinger, War Criminal Beloved by America’s Ruling Class, Finally Dies
    The infamy of Nixon's foreign-policy architect sits, eternally, beside that of history's worst mass murderers. A deeper shame attaches to the country that celebrates him
    https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/henry-kissinger-war-criminal-dead-1234804748/
  • HYUFD said:

    No, in effect Morgan has potentially committed slander (even Scobie did not name the names in the English text of his book and says the Dutch version was a translation error).

    Fortunately for Morgan as TalkTV has about 1 viewer (whose wife is the 1 listener to Times Radio) nobody noticed until your post
    A Pedant writes...

    Technically, it is libel if it is on TV.
  • GhedebravGhedebrav Posts: 3,860
    Kissinger dead; wow.

    Easily one of the most influential statesmen of the last century who wasn’t a leader. Who comes close?
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 56,022
    Well it’s fair to say there’s a pretty wide range of obituaries to Kissinger this morning.
  • MJWMJW Posts: 2,012

    Sure it wasn't about getting 10 million viewers like Strictly, but the public aren't watching it in anywhere near the numbers they were before.
    Sure. Its viewership is down - but so is literally every programme on linear TV, even Strictly. EastEnders for example, pulls in barely a quarter of the viewers it once did. But unlike light ent, drama, soaps, daytime or even softer news/documentaries, there are reasons to keep it going even if the regular viewing figures are very low.

    Firstly because it's one of the few BBC news assets left with the prestige, space, and expertise to pull off big moments like the Prince Andrew interview that do, every so often, get big figures. Secondly, it's there to do the dull but worthy and important stuff that is more or less the remaining point of having a public service broadcaster - and that is picked up elsewhere when it hits upon something.
  • StillWatersStillWaters Posts: 9,756
    RobD said:

    Bloody hell. Don’t get him started on telephone boxes.
    How do you make a call if you don’t take the telephone out of its box?
  • DougSealDougSeal Posts: 12,746
    HYUFD said:

    @trussliz
    Conservative leadership and the Anglo-American alliance are vital. I'm in Washington DC with @MPIainDS,
    @JackLopresti, Mark Francois and Lord Howard for talks with Republican counterparts.

    We must defeat the axis of authoritarian regimes threatening the free world.
    https://x.com/trussliz/status/1729981806991024237?s=20

    She’s coming home, she’s coming home, Truss is coming home…
  • NEW THREAD

  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 51,198
    DougSeal said:

    She’s coming home, she’s coming home, Truss is coming home…
    Does she include Trump in authoritan regimes?
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 38,487
    Andy_JS said:

    "Nihal Arthanayake says working at the overwhelmingly white BBC is bad for his mental health

    BBC Radio 5 Live presenter made comments at journalism diversity conference
    Claimed lots of people leave because they couldn't deal with the culture
    BBC producer said the organisation is committed to tackling lack of diversity"

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12804889/BBC-presenter-says-overwhelmingly-white-workplace-affects-mental-health.html

    Andy_JS said:

    "Nihal Arthanayake says working at the overwhelmingly white BBC is bad for his mental health

    BBC Radio 5 Live presenter made comments at journalism diversity conference
    Claimed lots of people leave because they couldn't deal with the culture
    BBC producer said the organisation is committed to tackling lack of diversity"

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12804889/BBC-presenter-says-overwhelmingly-white-workplace-affects-mental-health.html

    If he finds it objectionable to work with white people, isn’t that his problem, for being a racist?
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 98,537
    edited November 2023
    Andy_JS said:

    "Nihal Arthanayake says working at the overwhelmingly white BBC is bad for his mental health

    BBC Radio 5 Live presenter made comments at journalism diversity conference
    Claimed lots of people leave because they couldn't deal with the culture
    BBC producer said the organisation is committed to tackling lack of diversity"

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12804889/BBC-presenter-says-overwhelmingly-white-workplace-affects-mental-health.html

    If it is genuinely affecting his mental health to work at the BBC there appears to be a simple solution. He even touches upon it.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,353
    I'm very sad to learn of Alistair Darling's death. He was one of the few people to serve in the Brown administration, who left with his reputation enhanced.
This discussion has been closed.