The latest Ipsos-MORI phone poll where I was part of the sample – politicalbetting.com
Options
Comments
-
The pottery sherd (ostrakon) was usually used not to elect someone but to banish them. Ostracism was the process whereby each year the Athenian demos would deposit ostraka with the name of the person each citizen felt should be excluded from the city. Whoever got the most was banished for ten years. If they tried to return they could be executed, but they kept their property and were allowed to direct the management of it from abroad.Carnyx said:
PS I remember seeing the exhibtion from Athens about however many millennia of democracy it was in Edinburgh some years back now. My favourite bit was the voting slip (pottery sherd) wwith the candidate's name scratched on it. Wonder if you get to see that sort of thing on yoiur trip?Leon said:
I’m reading that very book right now! Highly entertainingCarnyx said:
The qanats? Quite so. But they didn't invent the trieres/trireme. Arguably one of the most extreme examples of nautical architecture, beside the Mississippi steamboat (and both, coincidentally, relying on tension tructures - hogchains/hypozomata).ydoethur said:
The Persians did know how to build a mean water distribution system though.Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
The real problem is whether to go for the Athenians or the Spartans. The former definitely ate better. I do like the book 'Courtesand and fishcakes'.
I often wonder what would be the effect if any modern state reintroduced the idea.
BTW if visiting Athens, the National Archaeology Museum is a must. The Antikythera Mechanism is unmissable.1 -
'Ndrangheta is indisputably Greek.Leon said:StuartDickson said:
Bollox. Leon is as gullible as Melvyn Bragg, who didn’t realise that his Cumbrian pal was pulling his leg when he told him that he could understand Icelandic when stationed there during the war.Omnium said:
Is that true Leon? Proper Ancient Greek?Leon said:
There are some villages in Calabria (and perhaps also Puglia) that still speak Ancient Greek. I have been to one, and heard the Greek spoken “as Pythagoras would speak it”. My knowledge of the classics is not good enough to know if this is exactly true - yours sounds much better. Still very moving, even for a linguistic pleb like meCarnyx said:
A surprising proportion of Italy was Greek-settled, including the Naples area IIRC.Benpointer said:
Sea-born salamis - did they come from Italy?IshmaelZ said:
The mountains look on Marathon—Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
And Marathon looks on the sea;
And musing there an hour alone,
I dream’d that Greece might still be free;
For standing on the Persians’ grave,
I could not deem myself a slave.
A king sate on the rocky brow
Which looks o’er sea-born Salamis;
And ships, by thousands, lay below,
And men in nations;—all were his!
He counted them at break of day—
And when the sun set, where were they?
PS Southern Italy, or a good chunk oif it, was called Magna Graecia by the chaps in Rome.
I also visited the region of Sybaris. Home off the Sybarites. It is not very sybaritic now. An impoverished, earthquake ruined, mafia infested toilet. Great food nearby, however, in the Mafia owned resorts
What's always baffled me is that Latin totally died out. The idea that there's still a good holding of the Greek language baffles me on the former idea more.
(The wartime story of Iceland is fascinating. They were invaded by the UK. Still smarts.)
‘Calabrian Greek
Greko
Native to Italy
Region Calabria
Ethnicity Greeks
Native speakers c. 2,000 (2010)[1]
The Calabrian dialect of Greek, or Grecanico[2] is the variety of Italiot Greek used by the ethnic Griko people in Calabria, as opposed to the Italiot Greek dialect spoken in the Grecìa Salentina. Both are remnants of the Ancient and Byzantine Greek colonization of the region.’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calabrian_Greek
Some dispute as to its ancientry. No doubts that it is Greek. I went to Griko
0 -
Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.0
-
Yup. The whining about it is always funny. It's not like they don't know the rules or the schedule of tests....FrancisUrquhart said:
Missed tests are a big red flag according to Conte (of Belco labs fame). Clean atheletes don't miss drugs tests according to him, certainly not more than one.Malmesbury said:
Some sporting authorities are more lenient than others.StuartDickson said:
Missing a test is an extremely serious incident. They are 100% compulsory and every single sportsperson knows that. So the sports governing bodies are absolutely correct to come down on folk missing tests like a ton of bricks. Remember that Greek sprinter on his motorcycle trip?Malmesbury said:
Linford Christie come to mind...StuartDickson said:
Absolutely. But I find it hilarious when numpties think that “they” cheat, but “we” don’t cheat. Cheating is a universal human trait. No nation is immune.Malmesbury said:
People have been trying to get rid of cheating in sports since before the original, Greek, Olympics.StuartDickson said:
Not the first. Won’t be the last. The pressure to win is immense, and some just cannot resist cheating.Big_G_NorthWales said:Breaking news
BBC News - Chijindu Ujah: British Olympic silver medallist suspended after positive test for banned substance
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/athletics/58193101
But rest assured, this is not an isolated individual. Cheating in the current environment requires organisation. For every cheat caught there are a significant number of cheats in the team behind them. If the government wanted to root them out it could.
EDIT: In the UK, the various sporting associations work pretty closely with the testing people, and indeed have been castigated as "unfair" for penalising athletes who have missed tests etc.
I recall comments about being "cold hearted", "no compassion" etc being used about the UK athletics authorities. There was even an attempt, on one occasion, to suggest that it was all a bit racist....0 -
That’s your story, Mike.MikeSmithson said:
The only reason I post the first comment is to check that the commenting system is working.Omnium said:Proper test - not the sneaky Smithson type!
About as convincing as being randomly picked for the poll which shows Lib Dem gains.
1 -
Whereas you voted by putting a pebble, psephos, in a jar. Hence psephology.rpjs said:
The pottery sherd (ostrakon) was usually used not to elect someone but to banish them. Ostracism was the process whereby each year the Athenian demos would deposit ostraka with the name of the person each citizen felt should be excluded from the city. Whoever got the most was banished for ten years. If they tried to return they could be executed, but they kept their property and were allowed to direct the management of it from abroad.Carnyx said:
PS I remember seeing the exhibtion from Athens about however many millennia of democracy it was in Edinburgh some years back now. My favourite bit was the voting slip (pottery sherd) wwith the candidate's name scratched on it. Wonder if you get to see that sort of thing on yoiur trip?Leon said:
I’m reading that very book right now! Highly entertainingCarnyx said:
The qanats? Quite so. But they didn't invent the trieres/trireme. Arguably one of the most extreme examples of nautical architecture, beside the Mississippi steamboat (and both, coincidentally, relying on tension tructures - hogchains/hypozomata).ydoethur said:
The Persians did know how to build a mean water distribution system though.Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
The real problem is whether to go for the Athenians or the Spartans. The former definitely ate better. I do like the book 'Courtesand and fishcakes'.
I often wonder what would be the effect if any modern state reintroduced the idea.
BTW if visiting Athens, the National Archaeology Museum is a must. The Antikythera Mechanism is unmissable.2 -
Yes, of coiurse - brain eructation. Thanks!rpjs said:
The pottery sherd (ostrakon) was usually used not to elect someone but to banish them. Ostracism was the process whereby each year the Athenian demos would deposit ostraka with the name of the person each citizen felt should be excluded from the city. Whoever got the most was banished for ten years. If they tried to return they could be executed, but they kept their property and were allowed to direct the management of it from abroad.Carnyx said:
PS I remember seeing the exhibtion from Athens about however many millennia of democracy it was in Edinburgh some years back now. My favourite bit was the voting slip (pottery sherd) wwith the candidate's name scratched on it. Wonder if you get to see that sort of thing on yoiur trip?Leon said:
I’m reading that very book right now! Highly entertainingCarnyx said:
The qanats? Quite so. But they didn't invent the trieres/trireme. Arguably one of the most extreme examples of nautical architecture, beside the Mississippi steamboat (and both, coincidentally, relying on tension tructures - hogchains/hypozomata).ydoethur said:
The Persians did know how to build a mean water distribution system though.Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
The real problem is whether to go for the Athenians or the Spartans. The former definitely ate better. I do like the book 'Courtesand and fishcakes'.
I often wonder what would be the effect if any modern state reintroduced the idea.
BTW if visiting Athens, the National Archaeology Museum is a must. The Antikythera Mechanism is unmissable.0 -
OK some PB top trumps. Who has heard the rarest living language spoken by a native?
My go: I have heard this language spoken in a high valley in the Dolomites. Cimbrian German. It sounds like they are singing. Like Anglo-Saxon. Most odd
400 native speakers
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cimbrian_language0 -
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
0 -
Has our PB native Cornish speaker spoken Cornish to himself?Leon said:OK some PB top trumps. Who has heard the rarest living language spoken by a native?
My go: I have heard this language spoken in a high valley in the Dolomites. Cimbrian German. It sounds like they are singing. Like Anglo-Saxon. Most odd
400 native speakers
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cimbrian_language0 -
Afghanistan hasn’t had a ‘government’ since 1978. There have been various different factions competing for control with the aid, or not, of outside powers. The Soviets had their Red govenrment, and the Americans chose Karzai as the leader of a major tribe. But neither of them had any luck at state building. China from 1911 to 1934 would be the nearest parallel.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
0 -
It will go down as one of Trump's biggest mistakes, I think.0
-
Who was involved in the first ever electronic trade on the LIFFE exchange. Me! (Euromark futures on ATP)Leon said:OK some PB top trumps. Who has heard the rarest living language spoken by a native?
My go: I have heard this language spoken in a high valley in the Dolomites. Cimbrian German. It sounds like they are singing. Like Anglo-Saxon. Most odd
400 native speakers
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cimbrian_language
One possible incidence (there may have been up to 4 people involved).0 -
Hah. i still don’t quite grasp that story. He sounds so sincereMattW said:
Has our PB native Cornish speaker spoken Cornish to himself?Leon said:OK some PB top trumps. Who has heard the rarest living language spoken by a native?
My go: I have heard this language spoken in a high valley in the Dolomites. Cimbrian German. It sounds like they are singing. Like Anglo-Saxon. Most odd
400 native speakers
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cimbrian_language
Amazing if true
My Aussie daughter’s grandfather specialized in aboriginal culture for a while - made documentaries about them, and so on. I believe he has heard languages spoken by the last living native speaker. Quite hard, indeed impossible, to beat that
The death of a language is a very sad thing. So much goes with it, jokes to memes to memories0 -
We didn't have the military power to remain there with the US.Richard_Nabavi said:
We didn't have any choice but to follow. We don't have the military power to remain there without the US.Razedabode said:
The Biden decision was some of the worse American foreign policy… I can only imagine the outcry if that were Trumps decisionping said:So. We spent twenty years and all the blood sweat and treasure building up the Afghan state and armed forces and it just crumbles in a few weeks.
What was the fking point?
Humiliation.
(Though the fact we followed as usual says it all)0 -
There is still Greek spoken is some villages way north of Calabria, if some of what my Italian friends have told me on occasion is anything to go by. Mussolini and even the Risorgimento may have pushed it way underground, in the service of the project of national identity and harmonising north and south.IshmaelZ said:
'Ndrangheta is indisputably Greek.Leon said:StuartDickson said:
Bollox. Leon is as gullible as Melvyn Bragg, who didn’t realise that his Cumbrian pal was pulling his leg when he told him that he could understand Icelandic when stationed there during the war.Omnium said:
Is that true Leon? Proper Ancient Greek?Leon said:
There are some villages in Calabria (and perhaps also Puglia) that still speak Ancient Greek. I have been to one, and heard the Greek spoken “as Pythagoras would speak it”. My knowledge of the classics is not good enough to know if this is exactly true - yours sounds much better. Still very moving, even for a linguistic pleb like meCarnyx said:
A surprising proportion of Italy was Greek-settled, including the Naples area IIRC.Benpointer said:
Sea-born salamis - did they come from Italy?IshmaelZ said:
The mountains look on Marathon—Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
And Marathon looks on the sea;
And musing there an hour alone,
I dream’d that Greece might still be free;
For standing on the Persians’ grave,
I could not deem myself a slave.
A king sate on the rocky brow
Which looks o’er sea-born Salamis;
And ships, by thousands, lay below,
And men in nations;—all were his!
He counted them at break of day—
And when the sun set, where were they?
PS Southern Italy, or a good chunk oif it, was called Magna Graecia by the chaps in Rome.
I also visited the region of Sybaris. Home off the Sybarites. It is not very sybaritic now. An impoverished, earthquake ruined, mafia infested toilet. Great food nearby, however, in the Mafia owned resorts
What's always baffled me is that Latin totally died out. The idea that there's still a good holding of the Greek language baffles me on the former idea more.
(The wartime story of Iceland is fascinating. They were invaded by the UK. Still smarts.)
‘Calabrian Greek
Greko
Native to Italy
Region Calabria
Ethnicity Greeks
Native speakers c. 2,000 (2010)[1]
The Calabrian dialect of Greek, or Grecanico[2] is the variety of Italiot Greek used by the ethnic Griko people in Calabria, as opposed to the Italiot Greek dialect spoken in the Grecìa Salentina. Both are remnants of the Ancient and Byzantine Greek colonization of the region.’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calabrian_Greek
Some dispute as to its ancientry. No doubts that it is Greek. I went to Griko2 -
Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost0 -
Maybe we should have a similar process here on PB, with votes, and one poster getting sent to ConHome for a month.rpjs said:
The pottery sherd (ostrakon) was usually used not to elect someone but to banish them. Ostracism was the process whereby each year the Athenian demos would deposit ostraka with the name of the person each citizen felt should be excluded from the city. Whoever got the most was banished for ten years. If they tried to return they could be executed, but they kept their property and were allowed to direct the management of it from abroad.Carnyx said:
PS I remember seeing the exhibtion from Athens about however many millennia of democracy it was in Edinburgh some years back now. My favourite bit was the voting slip (pottery sherd) wwith the candidate's name scratched on it. Wonder if you get to see that sort of thing on yoiur trip?Leon said:
I’m reading that very book right now! Highly entertainingCarnyx said:
The qanats? Quite so. But they didn't invent the trieres/trireme. Arguably one of the most extreme examples of nautical architecture, beside the Mississippi steamboat (and both, coincidentally, relying on tension tructures - hogchains/hypozomata).ydoethur said:
The Persians did know how to build a mean water distribution system though.Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
The real problem is whether to go for the Athenians or the Spartans. The former definitely ate better. I do like the book 'Courtesand and fishcakes'.
I often wonder what would be the effect if any modern state reintroduced the idea.
BTW if visiting Athens, the National Archaeology Museum is a must. The Antikythera Mechanism is unmissable.0 -
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost0 -
You mean, like the Soviets did?Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
Afghanistan is not Tibet or Xinjiang. Historically trying to subjugate it with violence tends to make matters worse, not better.0 -
No.Theuniondivvie said:
Q2. As a sometime British nationalist, are you a Unionist?Philip_Thompson said:
Not because of you. I asked you to name something to look into and you failed to do so, since you had nothing to name. Because you had no point.kinabalu said:
Ah so now you ARE looking into it. I could take umbrage since when it was me suggesting it you refused, but I won't. A result is a result.Philip_Thompson said:FPT
You can be, but it's almost inevitably not the case that people are both, since there's absolutely nothing linking nationalism to fascism (any more than there is linking socialism to it).Northern_Al said:
I can't believe that I got embroiled in this discussion. The idea that the English Defence League isn't an English nationalist party that doesn't want to Defend, er, England specifically (rather than Scotland, Wales or Britain) is ludicrous. I believe you can be both nationalist and fascist.StuartDickson said:
I’m afraid Philip is correct. Simply having the name English in the name of an organisation does not automatically make it nationalist.Northern_Al said:
I should have known better than to engage with you. Bonkers and pointless comparisons.Philip_Thompson said:
So you can't, good, and no the clue is not in the name. The name England does not make you an England nationalist. Is the England football team full of England nationalists? The England Cricket Team? The ECB?Northern_Al said:
No I can't, but the clue's in the name, I suspect - what's the E stand for? No mention of Scotland (or Wales for that matter). I suspect they'd be happy to allow the sectarian Unionists of NI to belong, though.Philip_Thompson said:
Can you give me a citation please on the EDL believing that England should be independent and apart from Scotland? I've never heard anything about that from them.Northern_Al said:
The EDL do believe that England should be a self-governing, independent nation.Philip_Thompson said:
English nationalism is the belief that England should be a self-governing, independent nation. That's what the word means.Theuniondivvie said:
Bit shocking that you're deciding that people who at various times have described themselves as English nationalists are wrong about this. More than a whiff of the metropolitan elite talking down to the fruitcakes and loonies and closet racists.Philip_Thompson said:
No.Theuniondivvie said:
Q. Are the English Defence League English nationalists?Philip_Thompson said:
What has any of that whatsoever got to do with English nationalism?Theuniondivvie said:
On a more general note there do seem to be people extremely concerned about far right extremists in the UK. Of course these extremists may have absolutely nothing to do with English Nationalism, but just enjoy prancing about in jackboots and being down on brown people.kinabalu said:
That's a reasaonable first tack - to look at here. And it's not zero, not at all. There's a couple on 'Watch' as I said - loose use of couple as in 3 or 4 - and plus there's some unsavouries who've been banned in recent weeks. So I'd say this is enough to continue our investigation rather than any sort of excuse to shut it down. YOUR investigation, I mean, since I've already done it.Philip_Thompson said:OK @kinabalu I have looked into and done a statistical analysis of English nationalist sentiment and the far right.
I have taken the UK's best political blog as a point of reference. There are unabashed English nationalists on this website that post here.
You have in your own judgement determined that there are not any English nationalist far right posters on here.
Therefore by a rigorous statistical analysis, there is an r^2 value of 0 correlating English nationalism with the far right, as per this website and your own opinion.
Case closed.
'Fastest-growing UK terror threat 'from far-right''
'Violent right-wing extremism is a ‘major threat’ in the UK, MI5 boss says'
'Future Trends: Far-Right Terrorism in the UK – A Major Threat?'
'Racism fuelling far-right threat in UK - MI5's Ken McCallum warns'
There is an issue with far right extremism but that's got nothing to do with the belief that England should be a self-governing nation.
I see nothing from the EDL to say they have that belief. All I see from them is racism. I don't care what they self-identify as, or what flag they try to misappropriate, if they're not advocating for that then they're not English nationalists.
They just don't believe it should include 'foreigners', particularly those from one particular religious background. Not very far to the right of Farage, his fellow travellers and those who have ever voted for him.
They are definitely English nationalists.
They're racist scumbags. No more and no less, don't enlighten them as to being anything other that racist bigots.
They're racist shithead scum. I've never seen anything from them on English independence and neither have you, so that doesn't make them nationalists.
Eg. the Scottish National Trust is a deeply Unionist and conservative organisation
The African National Congress does not seek a United Africa (AFAIAA)
The British Library is not a British nationalist organisation
The English National Opera is not English nationalist
As it happens, from Googling them and reading Wikipedia it seems you have it backwards. The EDL and their sister organisations the WDL and SDL are not nationalists. They are unionists.
Take this picture of an EDL protest at a Scottish independence rally. Look at the flags chosen. What does that scream to you: English Nationalists wanting Scottish Independence? Unionists? Rangers fans?
https://www.alamy.com/tommy-robinson-speaking-at-the-auob-scottish-independence-march-in-george-square-glasgow-scotland-uk-on-4th-may-2019-image245525832.html
@Theuniondivvie asked if the EDL were English Nationalists and the answer looking into it is a categorical NO they are British unionists instead.
Now I won't be so petty as to suggest you investigate the link between unionism and racism.0 -
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost0 -
Were the Athenians allowed to nominate the same chap every 10 years? You'd need to decide on that for PB as well.rcs1000 said:
Maybe we should have a similar process here on PB, with votes, and one poster getting sent to ConHome for a month.rpjs said:
The pottery sherd (ostrakon) was usually used not to elect someone but to banish them. Ostracism was the process whereby each year the Athenian demos would deposit ostraka with the name of the person each citizen felt should be excluded from the city. Whoever got the most was banished for ten years. If they tried to return they could be executed, but they kept their property and were allowed to direct the management of it from abroad.Carnyx said:
PS I remember seeing the exhibtion from Athens about however many millennia of democracy it was in Edinburgh some years back now. My favourite bit was the voting slip (pottery sherd) wwith the candidate's name scratched on it. Wonder if you get to see that sort of thing on yoiur trip?Leon said:
I’m reading that very book right now! Highly entertainingCarnyx said:
The qanats? Quite so. But they didn't invent the trieres/trireme. Arguably one of the most extreme examples of nautical architecture, beside the Mississippi steamboat (and both, coincidentally, relying on tension tructures - hogchains/hypozomata).ydoethur said:
The Persians did know how to build a mean water distribution system though.Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
The real problem is whether to go for the Athenians or the Spartans. The former definitely ate better. I do like the book 'Courtesand and fishcakes'.
I often wonder what would be the effect if any modern state reintroduced the idea.
BTW if visiting Athens, the National Archaeology Museum is a must. The Antikythera Mechanism is unmissable.0 -
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost0 -
Yes, UK cycling seems to recruit from the asthma clinic...FrancisUrquhart said:
Who says that? Nobody with half a brain thinks Team GB is 100% clean, however there is a world of difference between here and Russia or China or even the US.StuartDickson said:
Absolutely. But I find it hilarious when numpties think that “they” cheat, but “we” don’t cheat. Cheating is a universal human trait. No nation is immune.Malmesbury said:
People have been trying to get rid of cheating in sports since before the original, Greek, Olympics.StuartDickson said:
Not the first. Won’t be the last. The pressure to win is immense, and some just cannot resist cheating.Big_G_NorthWales said:Breaking news
BBC News - Chijindu Ujah: British Olympic silver medallist suspended after positive test for banned substance
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/athletics/58193101
But rest assured, this is not an isolated individual. Cheating in the current environment requires organisation. For every cheat caught there are a significant number of cheats in the team behind them. If the government wanted to root them out it could.
You get caught cheating and you are lottery funded, not only do you lose your funding forever, they chase you for all the money back and you will be a total outcast should you ever cone back from your ban.
Remember with Dwayne Chambers they even fought legal action to have to select him, despite him getting qualifying times. And even when they lost the court case, it was very much you get no help, no assistant, we don't want anything to do with you.
Comparison Tyson Gay, 3 times he has been busted for drugs, and the Americans don't appear to be bothered, as soon as he is off his ban, back to the forefront.
The one big grey cloud in UK is the cycling.0 -
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost0 -
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost0 -
Alexander, too. The policy was to kill everything that moved, and burn everything that did not.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost0 -
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost0 -
Agreed - if you know English and German then Danish is pretty easy, and Danish and Icelandic have an overlap - I can understand a bit, because I know the former. I'm missing something in the story - why should it be odd to understand a language if you were based there?Carnyx said:
I'm not so sure it was a porky. Danish/Icelandic has a fair bit in common with Scots, abd Cumbrians are just Scots who had the bad luck to be born after the border revisions. I went to a conference in Copnehagen and a Scots colleaguer and I went to have a look at the geological museum - we were able to get a sense of quite a few of the Danish labels eg. earthquake = jordskælv (cf Scots yird + skelp).
A dear friend of mine from a Moray family was boarded out in the eastern Borders during the war years - Teviotdale or perhaps Kelso way. His academic career led him to South Africa and he discovered that if he relaxed and didn't try hard he could get a very good sense of the Boers in front of him discussing this rooinek in front of them. A tactically very useful accomplishment at times.0 -
We do have a native Cornish speaker...Leon said:OK some PB top trumps. Who has heard the rarest living language spoken by a native?
My go: I have heard this language spoken in a high valley in the Dolomites. Cimbrian German. It sounds like they are singing. Like Anglo-Saxon. Most odd
400 native speakers
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cimbrian_language
I stayed in New Caledonia with some Melanesians. There are 20 different mutually unintelligible languages on New Caledonia. A few thousand speakers of each.0 -
There’s a whole Twitter debate on this. The myth that you can’t conquer Afghanistan. The answer, it seems, is to enter with a mood of total brutality. “If everyone in Afghanistan dies, so be it”. That worksydoethur said:
You mean, like the Soviets did?Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
Afghanistan is not Tibet or Xinjiang. Historically trying to subjugate it with violence tends to make matters worse, not better.
The Mongols did it
.
‘Allied with the Uzbeks, Hazaras and other Turkic communities in the north Genghis Khan’s dominance over Afghanistan was long-lasting, allowing him for his future successful conquests in Central Anatolia against the Ottomans.[5]’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invasions_of_Afghanistan
Xi’s China seems like the kind of place that could muster that attitude
0 -
The Chinese would probably import population - which is one way to defeat the locals. Truth on the ground, as Arkan used to say....ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost1 -
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost0 -
When the Danube frontier collapsed in the 7th century, many Greeks fled to Imperial territories in Southern Italy. When the Balkans were overrun by the Ottomans, likewise. So, their descendants are a big element of the populationWhisperingOracle said:
There is still Greek spoken is some villages way north of Calabria, if some of what my Italian friends have told me on occasion is anything to go by. Mussolini and even the Risorgimento may have pushed it way underground, in the service of the project of national identity and harmonising north and south.IshmaelZ said:
'Ndrangheta is indisputably Greek.Leon said:StuartDickson said:
Bollox. Leon is as gullible as Melvyn Bragg, who didn’t realise that his Cumbrian pal was pulling his leg when he told him that he could understand Icelandic when stationed there during the war.Omnium said:
Is that true Leon? Proper Ancient Greek?Leon said:
There are some villages in Calabria (and perhaps also Puglia) that still speak Ancient Greek. I have been to one, and heard the Greek spoken “as Pythagoras would speak it”. My knowledge of the classics is not good enough to know if this is exactly true - yours sounds much better. Still very moving, even for a linguistic pleb like meCarnyx said:
A surprising proportion of Italy was Greek-settled, including the Naples area IIRC.Benpointer said:
Sea-born salamis - did they come from Italy?IshmaelZ said:
The mountains look on Marathon—Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
And Marathon looks on the sea;
And musing there an hour alone,
I dream’d that Greece might still be free;
For standing on the Persians’ grave,
I could not deem myself a slave.
A king sate on the rocky brow
Which looks o’er sea-born Salamis;
And ships, by thousands, lay below,
And men in nations;—all were his!
He counted them at break of day—
And when the sun set, where were they?
PS Southern Italy, or a good chunk oif it, was called Magna Graecia by the chaps in Rome.
I also visited the region of Sybaris. Home off the Sybarites. It is not very sybaritic now. An impoverished, earthquake ruined, mafia infested toilet. Great food nearby, however, in the Mafia owned resorts
What's always baffled me is that Latin totally died out. The idea that there's still a good holding of the Greek language baffles me on the former idea more.
(The wartime story of Iceland is fascinating. They were invaded by the UK. Still smarts.)
‘Calabrian Greek
Greko
Native to Italy
Region Calabria
Ethnicity Greeks
Native speakers c. 2,000 (2010)[1]
The Calabrian dialect of Greek, or Grecanico[2] is the variety of Italiot Greek used by the ethnic Griko people in Calabria, as opposed to the Italiot Greek dialect spoken in the Grecìa Salentina. Both are remnants of the Ancient and Byzantine Greek colonization of the region.’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calabrian_Greek
Some dispute as to its ancientry. No doubts that it is Greek. I went to Griko0 -
Some of the Mongols’ most brutal massacres were in Afghanistan, Balkh, Merv, Herat.Leon said:
There’s a whole Twitter debate on this. The myth that you can’t conquer Afghanistan. The answer, it seems, is to enter with a mood of total brutality. “If everyone in Afghanistan dies, so be it”. That worksydoethur said:
You mean, like the Soviets did?Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
Afghanistan is not Tibet or Xinjiang. Historically trying to subjugate it with violence tends to make matters worse, not better.
The Mongols did it
.
‘Allied with the Uzbeks, Hazaras and other Turkic communities in the north Genghis Khan’s dominance over Afghanistan was long-lasting, allowing him for his future successful conquests in Central Anatolia against the Ottomans.[5]’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invasions_of_Afghanistan
Xi’s China seems like the kind of place that could muster that attitude0 -
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
Edit - sorry, my mistake, you hadn’t suggested the Chinese might try to occupy it.0 -
Overwhelming force worked on “unconquerable Imperial Japan in 1945”Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
‘We will nuke you from 40,000 feet until you are all dead and the entire nation is a wasteland’
They surrendered after 2 bombs, and this was a nation that invented the suicide plane-bomb0 -
UK announces around 600 troops are to be deployed to Afghanistan to assist British nationals to leave0
-
Despite the general good news on vaccinations and reduced deaths I feel pessimistic. Here in Wales I get little sense that the remaining restrictions are likely to be removed anytime soon. Indeed I would like to ask those in power what it would take for them to remove those restrictions. A local theatre venue was publicising re-opening in September but pointed out social distancing would be required and face masks would need to be worn at all times. Which made me think - can I really be bothered?0
-
Indeed, the USA conquered it in a week in 2001. It is holding onto it that is the problem.Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
We haven't learnt from South Vietnam, which is why we are reliving the fall of Saigon.
Corrupt puppet regimes funded by foreigners and enforced by foreign troops are inherently unstable. The locals will support any group of fanatics willing to boot them out. That is how the Viet Cong and Khymer Rouge won, ISIL too, at least for a while.
0 -
They have form in that for sureMalmesbury said:
The Chinese would probably import population - which is one way to defeat the locals. Truth on the ground, as Arkan used to say....ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost0 -
Easily, but they'd not do so. They could easily play a very long game, and the Taliban would certainly lose.ydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?0 -
I'd like to post the latest graphs of Leader Ratings, but the photos are coming up miniscule, whats all that about?
0 -
As we have seen there is no political will to try to subjugate a country far away. You would need hundreds of thousands of troops which no one is in the mood to commit.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
Plus they would be sent to a country that doesn't value life in the way that people in the West value life and that would have consequences for the political leaders of those troops to say nothing of the troops themselves.0 -
Any power that can summon overwhelming force and apply it with a sufficient degree of ruthlessness can effect a successful occupation. If your definition of success is to totally suppress the resistance of the local population, or to kill them.Leon said:
There’s a whole Twitter debate on this. The myth that you can’t conquer Afghanistan. The answer, it seems, is to enter with a mood of total brutality. “If everyone in Afghanistan dies, so be it”. That worksydoethur said:
You mean, like the Soviets did?Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
Afghanistan is not Tibet or Xinjiang. Historically trying to subjugate it with violence tends to make matters worse, not better.
The Mongols did it
.
‘Allied with the Uzbeks, Hazaras and other Turkic communities in the north Genghis Khan’s dominance over Afghanistan was long-lasting, allowing him for his future successful conquests in Central Anatolia against the Ottomans.[5]’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invasions_of_Afghanistan
Xi’s China seems like the kind of place that could muster that attitude
The Chinese could probably do that if they really wanted to. But is Afghanistan worth the effort to them, or to anyone else?0 -
The Americans and the Soviets thought the same.Omnium said:
Easily, but they'd not do so. They could easily play a very long game, and the Taliban would certainly lose.ydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
I’d just point out they were both wrong.0 -
Corrupt regimes have existed for decades across the globe. They just need their own troops too, willing and able to do whatever it takes to enforce their power.Foxy said:
Indeed, the USA conquered it in a week in 2001. It is holding onto it that is the problem.Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
We haven't learnt from South Vietnam, which is why we are reliving the fall of Saigon.
Corrupt puppet regimes funded by foreigners and enforced by foreign troops are inherently unstable. The locals will support any group of fanatics willing to boot them out. That is how the Viet Cong and Khymer Rouge won, ISIL too, at least for a while.
The Taliban/Vietcong are/were more willing to do 'whatever it takes' than the regimes.
Syria is a corrupt puppet regime funded now by the Russians and aided by the Russian military and since the leadership is prepared to gas its own people, and the Russians support it unquestioningly, they've "won" their conflict from what seemed an unwinnable position.0 -
The Chinese have a ruthlessness the Americans do not.ydoethur said:
The Americans and the Soviets thought the same.Omnium said:
Easily, but they'd not do so. They could easily play a very long game, and the Taliban would certainly lose.ydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
I’d just point out they were both wrong.0 -
Indeed. They wouldn’t occupy, that’s a fool’s errand. They would wipe it out, or threaten to, after a couple of nukes dropped on Kabul and Heratydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
Edit - sorry, my mistake, you hadn’t suggested the Chinese might try to occupy it.
The Afghans would meekly comply, as they did with the Mongols
For the avoidance of doubt I am not saying this is a good, wise or advisable thing. It is hellish. And evil. But history shows it is the only way to subdue violently defiant territories like Afghanistan (or the Japan of 1945) - should you wish to subdue them. If the Chinese are sensible they will just pay off the warlords and accept the moral mess (as we should have done)
A great and costly tragedy is now unfolding in Afghanistan
0 -
and the Soviets don’t?Philip_Thompson said:
The Chinese have a ruthlessness the Americans do not.ydoethur said:
The Americans and the Soviets thought the same.Omnium said:
Easily, but they'd not do so. They could easily play a very long game, and the Taliban would certainly lose.ydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
I’d just point out they were both wrong.0 -
Livonian... 40 speakers, 210 with some knowledge. Though its a cousin of Estonian and you can make some sense of it. Definitely a separate language and not an Estonian dialect though.Foxy said:
We do have a native Cornish speaker...Leon said:OK some PB top trumps. Who has heard the rarest living language spoken by a native?
My go: I have heard this language spoken in a high valley in the Dolomites. Cimbrian German. It sounds like they are singing. Like Anglo-Saxon. Most odd
400 native speakers
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cimbrian_language
I stayed in New Caledonia with some Melanesians. There are 20 different mutually unintelligible languages on New Caledonia. A few thousand speakers of each.
0 -
Potentially some millions of men - no real issues with supply lines, and no real care about casualties. China would breeze it.ydoethur said:
The Americans and the Soviets thought the same.Omnium said:
Easily, but they'd not do so. They could easily play a very long game, and the Taliban would certainly lose.ydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
I’d just point out they were both wrong.0 -
You missed out the key thing. Corrupt governments are ten a penny, but corrupt puppet regimes funded by foreigners and enforced by foreign troops are not.Philip_Thompson said:
Corrupt regimes have existed for decades across the globe. They just need their own troops too, willing and able to do whatever it takes to enforce their power.Foxy said:
Indeed, the USA conquered it in a week in 2001. It is holding onto it that is the problem.Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
We haven't learnt from South Vietnam, which is why we are reliving the fall of Saigon.
Corrupt puppet regimes funded by foreigners and enforced by foreign troops are inherently unstable. The locals will support any group of fanatics willing to boot them out. That is how the Viet Cong and Khymer Rouge won, ISIL too, at least for a while.
The Taliban/Vietcong are/were more willing to do 'whatever it takes' than the regimes.
Syria is a corrupt puppet regime funded now by the Russians and aided by the Russian military and since the leadership is prepared to gas its own people, and the Russians support it unquestioningly, they've "won" their conflict from what seemed an unwinnable position.
After all, if we had such a regime here, wouldn't you expect continued violent resistance? becoming more radical as time goes on.0 -
Dropping a nuke 300 miles from a nuclear power would obviously not be problematic.Leon said:
Indeed. They wouldn’t occupy, that’s a fool’s errand. They would wipe it out, or threaten to, after a couple of nukes dropped on Kabul and Heratydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
Edit - sorry, my mistake, you hadn’t suggested the Chinese might try to occupy it.
The Afghans would meekly comply, as they did with the Mongols
For the avoidance of doubt I am not saying this is a good, wise or advisable thing. It is hellish. And evil. But history shows it is the only way to subdue violently defiant territories like Afghanistan (or the Japan of 1945) - should you wish to subdue them. If the Chinese are sensible they will just pay off the warlords and accept the moral mess (as we should have done)
A great and costly tragedy is now unfolding in Afghanistan0 -
Like I said, be very wary of Wikipedia.Leon said:StuartDickson said:
Bollox. Leon is as gullible as Melvyn Bragg, who didn’t realise that his Cumbrian pal was pulling his leg when he told him that he could understand Icelandic when stationed there during the war.Omnium said:
Is that true Leon? Proper Ancient Greek?Leon said:
There are some villages in Calabria (and perhaps also Puglia) that still speak Ancient Greek. I have been to one, and heard the Greek spoken “as Pythagoras would speak it”. My knowledge of the classics is not good enough to know if this is exactly true - yours sounds much better. Still very moving, even for a linguistic pleb like meCarnyx said:
A surprising proportion of Italy was Greek-settled, including the Naples area IIRC.Benpointer said:
Sea-born salamis - did they come from Italy?IshmaelZ said:
The mountains look on Marathon—Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
And Marathon looks on the sea;
And musing there an hour alone,
I dream’d that Greece might still be free;
For standing on the Persians’ grave,
I could not deem myself a slave.
A king sate on the rocky brow
Which looks o’er sea-born Salamis;
And ships, by thousands, lay below,
And men in nations;—all were his!
He counted them at break of day—
And when the sun set, where were they?
PS Southern Italy, or a good chunk oif it, was called Magna Graecia by the chaps in Rome.
I also visited the region of Sybaris. Home off the Sybarites. It is not very sybaritic now. An impoverished, earthquake ruined, mafia infested toilet. Great food nearby, however, in the Mafia owned resorts
What's always baffled me is that Latin totally died out. The idea that there's still a good holding of the Greek language baffles me on the former idea more.
(The wartime story of Iceland is fascinating. They were invaded by the UK. Still smarts.)
‘Calabrian Greek
Greko
Native to Italy
Region Calabria
Ethnicity Greeks
Native speakers c. 2,000 (2010)[1]
The Calabrian dialect of Greek, or Grecanico[2] is the variety of Italiot Greek used by the ethnic Griko people in Calabria, as opposed to the Italiot Greek dialect spoken in the Grecìa Salentina. Both are remnants of the Ancient and Byzantine Greek colonization of the region.’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calabrian_Greek
Some dispute as to its ancientry. No doubts that it is Greek. I went to Griko
2,000 native speakers my arse. And the chances of you actually overhearing any are zilch.0 -
On the contrary, nuking Kabul and Herat would be a treat for the Taliban. Their strength is in the rural areas, their enemies in the decadent cities. You would be doing them a favour.Leon said:
Indeed. They wouldn’t occupy, that’s a fool’s errand. They would wipe it out, or threaten to, after a couple of nukes dropped on Kabul and Heratydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
Edit - sorry, my mistake, you hadn’t suggested the Chinese might try to occupy it.
The Afghans would meekly comply, as they did with the Mongols
For the avoidance of doubt I am not saying this is a good, wise or advisable thing. It is hellish. And evil. But history shows it is the only way to subdue violently defiant territories like Afghanistan (or the Japan of 1945) - should you wish to subdue them. If the Chinese are sensible they will just pay off the warlords and accept the moral mess (as we should have done)
A great and costly tragedy is now unfolding in Afghanistan2 -
Why drop a nuke when not doing so can be a training exercise for 100k men.ydoethur said:
Dropping a nuke 300 miles from a nuclear power would obviously not be problematic.Leon said:
Indeed. They wouldn’t occupy, that’s a fool’s errand. They would wipe it out, or threaten to, after a couple of nukes dropped on Kabul and Heratydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
Edit - sorry, my mistake, you hadn’t suggested the Chinese might try to occupy it.
The Afghans would meekly comply, as they did with the Mongols
For the avoidance of doubt I am not saying this is a good, wise or advisable thing. It is hellish. And evil. But history shows it is the only way to subdue violently defiant territories like Afghanistan (or the Japan of 1945) - should you wish to subdue them. If the Chinese are sensible they will just pay off the warlords and accept the moral mess (as we should have done)
A great and costly tragedy is now unfolding in Afghanistan0 -
No, the Soviets did not have the ruthlessness of Xi’s China. Also, Xi’s China is just cleverer: they would never invade and occupy, it is pointless. Just encircle it with allies - Pakistan, Iran, Russia, starve it into submission, drop a few bombs, kill 30,000 people in a couple of days, job done. A subdued Afghanistan. Meanwhile offer the carrot of endless Chinese investment in valuable minesydoethur said:
and the Soviets don’t?Philip_Thompson said:
The Chinese have a ruthlessness the Americans do not.ydoethur said:
The Americans and the Soviets thought the same.Omnium said:
Easily, but they'd not do so. They could easily play a very long game, and the Taliban would certainly lose.ydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
I’d just point out they were both wrong.
If you want to be an empire, moral self doubt is a fatal flaw. The British resisted it for centuries, but succumbed in the 20th century. America now follows. Probably China will have some Afghan Lives Matter movement in about 50 years, and they too will quail
But China’s grievous national memories of humiliation and famine are too recent for that to be a problem, at the moment. Especially for such an ancient nation which has long felt itself the centre of the world
0 -
A very, very, very grey cloud.FrancisUrquhart said:
Who says that? Nobody with half a brain thinks Team GB is 100% clean, however there is a world of difference between here and Russia or China or even the US.StuartDickson said:
Absolutely. But I find it hilarious when numpties think that “they” cheat, but “we” don’t cheat. Cheating is a universal human trait. No nation is immune.Malmesbury said:
People have been trying to get rid of cheating in sports since before the original, Greek, Olympics.StuartDickson said:
Not the first. Won’t be the last. The pressure to win is immense, and some just cannot resist cheating.Big_G_NorthWales said:Breaking news
BBC News - Chijindu Ujah: British Olympic silver medallist suspended after positive test for banned substance
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/athletics/58193101
But rest assured, this is not an isolated individual. Cheating in the current environment requires organisation. For every cheat caught there are a significant number of cheats in the team behind them. If the government wanted to root them out it could.
You get caught cheating and you are lottery funded, not only do you lose your funding forever, they chase you for all the money back and you will be a total outcast should you ever cone back from your ban.
Remember with Dwayne Chambers they even fought legal action to have to select him, despite him getting qualifying times. And even when they lost the court case, it was very much you get no help, no assistant, we don't want anything to do with you.
Comparison Tyson Gay, 3 times he has been busted for drugs, and the Americans don't appear to be bothered, as soon as he is off his ban, back to the forefront.
The one big grey cloud in UK is the cycling.
Vroom, Vroom. Ahem.0 -
Nuking the cities would not really bother the Taliban. They would just retreat into the countryside where their power base is. You might even be doing them a favour.Leon said:
Indeed. They wouldn’t occupy, that’s a fool’s errand. They would wipe it out, or threaten to, after a couple of nukes dropped on Kabul and Heratydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
Edit - sorry, my mistake, you hadn’t suggested the Chinese might try to occupy it.
The Afghans would meekly comply, as they did with the Mongols
For the avoidance of doubt I am not saying this is a good, wise or advisable thing. It is hellish. And evil. But history shows it is the only way to subdue violently defiant territories like Afghanistan (or the Japan of 1945) - should you wish to subdue them. If the Chinese are sensible they will just pay off the warlords and accept the moral mess (as we should have done)
A great and costly tragedy is now unfolding in Afghanistan0 -
Look, I know you’re a twat. That’s accepted. But I went there. Griko. It’s a place in the hills of southern italy. They speak Greek there. And they do it proudly. I heard grannys talking it to kids. This is not disputedStuartDickson said:
Like I said, be very wary of Wikipedia.Leon said:StuartDickson said:
Bollox. Leon is as gullible as Melvyn Bragg, who didn’t realise that his Cumbrian pal was pulling his leg when he told him that he could understand Icelandic when stationed there during the war.Omnium said:
Is that true Leon? Proper Ancient Greek?Leon said:
There are some villages in Calabria (and perhaps also Puglia) that still speak Ancient Greek. I have been to one, and heard the Greek spoken “as Pythagoras would speak it”. My knowledge of the classics is not good enough to know if this is exactly true - yours sounds much better. Still very moving, even for a linguistic pleb like meCarnyx said:
A surprising proportion of Italy was Greek-settled, including the Naples area IIRC.Benpointer said:
Sea-born salamis - did they come from Italy?IshmaelZ said:
The mountains look on Marathon—Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
And Marathon looks on the sea;
And musing there an hour alone,
I dream’d that Greece might still be free;
For standing on the Persians’ grave,
I could not deem myself a slave.
A king sate on the rocky brow
Which looks o’er sea-born Salamis;
And ships, by thousands, lay below,
And men in nations;—all were his!
He counted them at break of day—
And when the sun set, where were they?
PS Southern Italy, or a good chunk oif it, was called Magna Graecia by the chaps in Rome.
I also visited the region of Sybaris. Home off the Sybarites. It is not very sybaritic now. An impoverished, earthquake ruined, mafia infested toilet. Great food nearby, however, in the Mafia owned resorts
What's always baffled me is that Latin totally died out. The idea that there's still a good holding of the Greek language baffles me on the former idea more.
(The wartime story of Iceland is fascinating. They were invaded by the UK. Still smarts.)
‘Calabrian Greek
Greko
Native to Italy
Region Calabria
Ethnicity Greeks
Native speakers c. 2,000 (2010)[1]
The Calabrian dialect of Greek, or Grecanico[2] is the variety of Italiot Greek used by the ethnic Griko people in Calabria, as opposed to the Italiot Greek dialect spoken in the Grecìa Salentina. Both are remnants of the Ancient and Byzantine Greek colonization of the region.’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calabrian_Greek
Some dispute as to its ancientry. No doubts that it is Greek. I went to Griko
2,000 native speakers my arse. And the chances of you actually overhearing any are zilch.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griko_people0 -
Lol, what an over in the Hundred....
200.on the cards.0 -
It was unmitigated nonsense.Carnyx said:
I'm not so sure it was a porky. Danish/Icelandic has a fair bit in common with Scots, abd Cumbrians are just Scots who had the bad luck to be born after the border revisions. I went to a conference in Copnehagen and a Scots colleaguer and I went to have a look at the geological museum - we were able to get a sense of quite a few of the Danish labels eg. earthquake = jordskælv (cf Scots yird + skelp).StuartDickson said:
Bollox. Leon is as gullible as Melvyn Bragg, who didn’t realise that his Cumbrian pal was pulling his leg when he told him that he could understand Icelandic when stationed there during the war.Omnium said:
Is that true Leon? Proper Ancient Greek?Leon said:
There are some villages in Calabria (and perhaps also Puglia) that still speak Ancient Greek. I have been to one, and heard the Greek spoken “as Pythagoras would speak it”. My knowledge of the classics is not good enough to know if this is exactly true - yours sounds much better. Still very moving, even for a linguistic pleb like meCarnyx said:
A surprising proportion of Italy was Greek-settled, including the Naples area IIRC.Benpointer said:
Sea-born salamis - did they come from Italy?IshmaelZ said:
The mountains look on Marathon—Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
And Marathon looks on the sea;
And musing there an hour alone,
I dream’d that Greece might still be free;
For standing on the Persians’ grave,
I could not deem myself a slave.
A king sate on the rocky brow
Which looks o’er sea-born Salamis;
And ships, by thousands, lay below,
And men in nations;—all were his!
He counted them at break of day—
And when the sun set, where were they?
PS Southern Italy, or a good chunk oif it, was called Magna Graecia by the chaps in Rome.
I also visited the region of Sybaris. Home off the Sybarites. It is not very sybaritic now. An impoverished, earthquake ruined, mafia infested toilet. Great food nearby, however, in the Mafia owned resorts
What's always baffled me is that Latin totally died out. The idea that there's still a good holding of the Greek language baffles me on the former idea more.
(The wartime story of Iceland is fascinating. They were invaded by the UK. Still smarts.)
A dear friend of mine from a Moray family was boarded out in the eastern Borders during the war years - Teviotdale or perhaps Kelso way. His academic career led him to South Africa and he discovered that if he relaxed and didn't try hard he could get a very good sense of the Boers in front of him discussing this rooinek in front of them. A tactically very useful accomplishment at times.
As a bilingual English-Swedish speaker, with a good understanding of Scots, Danish and Norwegian, and a smattering of Gaelic and Icelandic, I can say without a scintilla of doubt that it was utterly impossible for a 20th century Cumbrian to understand 20th century Icelandic, without a considerable amount of study. Go back 10 centuries and I’m sure it was another kettle of fish.
Sharing cognates does not mutual intelligibility make. Swedish is jam-packed full of cognates with Scots. That does not make the languages mutually intelligible.0 -
The Taliban might be religiously primitive. But they do not desire to be cavemen. They want houses, schools, mosques, hospitals. Islam is a civilisation of the city, the madrasa, the minaret, not the fields and rocks. Level everything with superpower bombing and you defeat them.Foxy said:
On the contrary, nuking Kabul and Herat would be a treat for the Taliban. Their strength is in the rural areas, their enemies in the decadent cities. You would be doing them a favour.Leon said:
Indeed. They wouldn’t occupy, that’s a fool’s errand. They would wipe it out, or threaten to, after a couple of nukes dropped on Kabul and Heratydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
Edit - sorry, my mistake, you hadn’t suggested the Chinese might try to occupy it.
The Afghans would meekly comply, as they did with the Mongols
For the avoidance of doubt I am not saying this is a good, wise or advisable thing. It is hellish. And evil. But history shows it is the only way to subdue violently defiant territories like Afghanistan (or the Japan of 1945) - should you wish to subdue them. If the Chinese are sensible they will just pay off the warlords and accept the moral mess (as we should have done)
A great and costly tragedy is now unfolding in Afghanistan
I’m not suggesting this as a desirable moral policy, it is just a fact. Probably a universal human fact.
Also Afghanistan is not much of a prize. There is little to be won there. All you need is suitable Genghis Khan style ruthlessness to lead you through it to greater geopolitical prizes, should you so desire0 -
"Over"? That word is banned in the Hundred!FrancisUrquhart said:Lol, what an over in the Hundred....
200.on the cards.1 -
Famously the Russian occupation was known for its genteel approach and that was the reason for its failure.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost1 -
TBF on this occasion it was the right thing to do. We’d have been absolutely mullered if we stayed when the Americans leftRazedabode said:
The Biden decision was some of the worse American foreign policy… I can only imagine the outcry if that were Trumps decisionping said:So. We spent twenty years and all the blood sweat and treasure building up the Afghan state and armed forces and it just crumbles in a few weeks.
What was the fking point?
Humiliation.
(Though the fact we followed as usual says it all)1 -
At one time the Chinese did control much of Central Asia on the Silk Road.Leon said:
No, the Soviets did not have the ruthlessness of Xi’s China. Also, Xi’s China is just cleverer: they would never invade and occupy, it is pointless. Just encircle it with allies - Pakistan, Iran, Russia, starve it into submission, drop a few bombs, kill 30,000 people in a couple of days, job done. A subdued Afghanistan. Meanwhile offer the carrot of endless Chinese investment in valuable minesydoethur said:
and the Soviets don’t?Philip_Thompson said:
The Chinese have a ruthlessness the Americans do not.ydoethur said:
The Americans and the Soviets thought the same.Omnium said:
Easily, but they'd not do so. They could easily play a very long game, and the Taliban would certainly lose.ydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
I’d just point out they were both wrong.
If you want to be an empire, moral self doubt is a fatal flaw. The British resisted it for centuries, but succumbed in the 20th century. America now follows. Probably China will have some Afghan Lives Matter movement in about 50 years, and they too will quail
But China’s grievous national memories of humiliation and famine are too recent for that to be a problem, at the moment. Especially for such an ancient nation which has long felt itself the centre of the world
I wonder if those so keen on a Chinese extermination of the Afghans are the same as those horrified at the Uighurs genocide, being done for the ostensible reason of Islamism?0 -
Has anyone any news of what is happening in Plymouth at the moment..?0
-
Helicopter skids time approaches in
SaigonKabul. The US seem to have asked Turkey to help hold the airport while they evacuate. What a trouser-clip moment. I wonder how that will play out.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/12/us-others-laying-groundwork-afghanistan-embassy-evacuations-kabul-taliban-
Practically nobody has mentioned the Vietnam disaster since the day George Bush declared in response to 911 that the US would invade Afghanistan, to the sound of loud cheering from jihadists everywhere. Can we have the term "Vietnam Syndrome" back now, or will we get "Afghan Syndrome"?
Probably we won't get either term, and even hints of a comparison with Vietnam wlll stay verboten. Nobody will write for example that the effort to "save Afghanistan from the Afghans" has failed. In the 1960s the USG couldn't control its own soldiers, and on top of that its propaganda in its home market was akin to p*ssing in the wind. Thus its efforts blew up in its face on a number of occasions - some of which are still referred to, and not just by students of photojournalism. Now? There's no conscription, there's embedding, and most of the US population couldn't GAF because they're too busy picking their smartphones. Nor could the political class GAF, when it really comes down to it. So I doubt any "syndrome" will get a look-in. The evacuation marks a shift in the global strategic balance nonetheless.
1 -
Thread on Afghanistan...
HUNDREDS of Paras will swoop into Kabul to evacuate the British Embassy and up to 4,000 Brits, contractors and staff – amid fears the city will fall to the Taliban.
Only a skeleton staff including ambassador Sir Laurie Bristow will stay in the besieged Afghan capital.
https://twitter.com/jeromestarkey/status/1425890912639590402?s=190 -
None - what have you heard?Razedabode said:Has anyone any news of what is happening in Plymouth at the moment..?
0 -
A fair point - but still a sad situation after so many yearsCharles said:
TBF on this occasion it was the right thing to do. We’d have been absolutely mullered if we stayed when the Americans leftRazedabode said:
The Biden decision was some of the worse American foreign policy… I can only imagine the outcry if that were Trumps decisionping said:So. We spent twenty years and all the blood sweat and treasure building up the Afghan state and armed forces and it just crumbles in a few weeks.
What was the fking point?
Humiliation.
(Though the fact we followed as usual says it all)0 -
I think Leon may be right, actually. I've seen a couple of programmes about these Griko-speakers in Calabria on Greek TV while in Greece. They have their own festivals, costumes and rituals, and contacts with the Greek government in the bargain, judging by who was coming to appear on screen.StuartDickson said:
Like I said, be very wary of Wikipedia.Leon said:StuartDickson said:
Bollox. Leon is as gullible as Melvyn Bragg, who didn’t realise that his Cumbrian pal was pulling his leg when he told him that he could understand Icelandic when stationed there during the war.Omnium said:
Is that true Leon? Proper Ancient Greek?Leon said:
There are some villages in Calabria (and perhaps also Puglia) that still speak Ancient Greek. I have been to one, and heard the Greek spoken “as Pythagoras would speak it”. My knowledge of the classics is not good enough to know if this is exactly true - yours sounds much better. Still very moving, even for a linguistic pleb like meCarnyx said:
A surprising proportion of Italy was Greek-settled, including the Naples area IIRC.Benpointer said:
Sea-born salamis - did they come from Italy?IshmaelZ said:
The mountains look on Marathon—Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
And Marathon looks on the sea;
And musing there an hour alone,
I dream’d that Greece might still be free;
For standing on the Persians’ grave,
I could not deem myself a slave.
A king sate on the rocky brow
Which looks o’er sea-born Salamis;
And ships, by thousands, lay below,
And men in nations;—all were his!
He counted them at break of day—
And when the sun set, where were they?
PS Southern Italy, or a good chunk oif it, was called Magna Graecia by the chaps in Rome.
I also visited the region of Sybaris. Home off the Sybarites. It is not very sybaritic now. An impoverished, earthquake ruined, mafia infested toilet. Great food nearby, however, in the Mafia owned resorts
What's always baffled me is that Latin totally died out. The idea that there's still a good holding of the Greek language baffles me on the former idea more.
(The wartime story of Iceland is fascinating. They were invaded by the UK. Still smarts.)
‘Calabrian Greek
Greko
Native to Italy
Region Calabria
Ethnicity Greeks
Native speakers c. 2,000 (2010)[1]
The Calabrian dialect of Greek, or Grecanico[2] is the variety of Italiot Greek used by the ethnic Griko people in Calabria, as opposed to the Italiot Greek dialect spoken in the Grecìa Salentina. Both are remnants of the Ancient and Byzantine Greek colonization of the region.’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calabrian_Greek
Some dispute as to its ancientry. No doubts that it is Greek. I went to Griko
2,000 native speakers my arse. And the chances of you actually overhearing any are zilch.0 -
Why would it be the fault of other countries if the Afghans can't seem to run their own country?Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
2 -
I'm not usually averse to leaks, but really this sort of thing should not be announced in advance.FrancisUrquhart said:Thread on Afghanistan...
HUNDREDS of Paras will swoop into Kabul to evacuate the British Embassy and up to 4,000 Brits, contractors and staff – amid fears the city will fall to the Taliban.
Only a skeleton staff including ambassador Sir Laurie Bristow will stay in the besieged Afghan capital.
https://twitter.com/jeromestarkey/status/1425890912639590402?s=193 -
Vaccine passports are “almost inevitable” for travel, probably for mass events and possibly for optional venues such as nightclubs, as long as they are accompanied by testing. Starmer had previously suggested they were against “British instinct”. But he said there was a “world of difference between the rules in play for a nightclub, and [essential services] people need to access”, such as doctors’ surgeries, mental health services or food shops, which should not be subject to vaccine passports.
https://www.theguardian.com/business/2021/aug/12/keir-starmer-forcing-people-return-offices-wrongheaded-work-from-home0 -
A major incident of some kind..reports sound quite grimOmnium said:
None - what have you heard?Razedabode said:Has anyone any news of what is happening in Plymouth at the moment..?
0 -
Wikipedia itself is often bollocks but it is a source of citations and if you follow the cited link for Leon’s claim it does seem legit.WhisperingOracle said:
I think Leon may be right, actually. I've seen a couple of programmes about these Griko-speakers on Greek TV while in Greece. They have their own festivals, costumes and rituals, and contacts with the Greek government, judging by who was coming on screen.StuartDickson said:
Like I said, be very wary of Wikipedia.Leon said:StuartDickson said:
Bollox. Leon is as gullible as Melvyn Bragg, who didn’t realise that his Cumbrian pal was pulling his leg when he told him that he could understand Icelandic when stationed there during the war.Omnium said:
Is that true Leon? Proper Ancient Greek?Leon said:
There are some villages in Calabria (and perhaps also Puglia) that still speak Ancient Greek. I have been to one, and heard the Greek spoken “as Pythagoras would speak it”. My knowledge of the classics is not good enough to know if this is exactly true - yours sounds much better. Still very moving, even for a linguistic pleb like meCarnyx said:
A surprising proportion of Italy was Greek-settled, including the Naples area IIRC.Benpointer said:
Sea-born salamis - did they come from Italy?IshmaelZ said:
The mountains look on Marathon—Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
And Marathon looks on the sea;
And musing there an hour alone,
I dream’d that Greece might still be free;
For standing on the Persians’ grave,
I could not deem myself a slave.
A king sate on the rocky brow
Which looks o’er sea-born Salamis;
And ships, by thousands, lay below,
And men in nations;—all were his!
He counted them at break of day—
And when the sun set, where were they?
PS Southern Italy, or a good chunk oif it, was called Magna Graecia by the chaps in Rome.
I also visited the region of Sybaris. Home off the Sybarites. It is not very sybaritic now. An impoverished, earthquake ruined, mafia infested toilet. Great food nearby, however, in the Mafia owned resorts
What's always baffled me is that Latin totally died out. The idea that there's still a good holding of the Greek language baffles me on the former idea more.
(The wartime story of Iceland is fascinating. They were invaded by the UK. Still smarts.)
‘Calabrian Greek
Greko
Native to Italy
Region Calabria
Ethnicity Greeks
Native speakers c. 2,000 (2010)[1]
The Calabrian dialect of Greek, or Grecanico[2] is the variety of Italiot Greek used by the ethnic Griko people in Calabria, as opposed to the Italiot Greek dialect spoken in the Grecìa Salentina. Both are remnants of the Ancient and Byzantine Greek colonization of the region.’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calabrian_Greek
Some dispute as to its ancientry. No doubts that it is Greek. I went to Griko
2,000 native speakers my arse. And the chances of you actually overhearing any are zilch.
1 -
Seems somebody has been going around shooting people. Some suggestion it is family dispute.Razedabode said:Has anyone any news of what is happening in Plymouth at the moment..?
0 -
Shameful and this will define the Biden-Harris administration now, whatever else it does this will be the greatest US humiliation since Vietnam.FrancisUrquhart said:Thread on Afghanistan...
HUNDREDS of Paras will swoop into Kabul to evacuate the British Embassy and up to 4,000 Brits, contractors and staff – amid fears the city will fall to the Taliban.
Only a skeleton staff including ambassador Sir Laurie Bristow will stay in the besieged Afghan capital.
https://twitter.com/jeromestarkey/status/1425890912639590402?s=19
We are not much better either as we also prepare to abandon our Embassy, however we are not big enough alone to stay in Afghanistan and maintain security and keep out the Taliban and terrorists without US support0 -
I am not sure it is a leak, the Guardian, the BBC etc have basically the same story.NickPalmer said:
I'm not usually averse to leaks, but really this sort of thing should not be announced in advance.FrancisUrquhart said:Thread on Afghanistan...
HUNDREDS of Paras will swoop into Kabul to evacuate the British Embassy and up to 4,000 Brits, contractors and staff – amid fears the city will fall to the Taliban.
Only a skeleton staff including ambassador Sir Laurie Bristow will stay in the besieged Afghan capital.
https://twitter.com/jeromestarkey/status/1425890912639590402?s=190 -
It should never be a Carter-like imprint on Biden. It was purely Trump's modish populist impulse to begin the plan to withdraw, which Biden has simply completed.HYUFD said:
Shameful and this will define the Biden-Harris administration now, whatever else it does this will be the greatest US humiliation since Vietnam.FrancisUrquhart said:Thread on Afghanistan...
HUNDREDS of Paras will swoop into Kabul to evacuate the British Embassy and up to 4,000 Brits, contractors and staff – amid fears the city will fall to the Taliban.
Only a skeleton staff including ambassador Sir Laurie Bristow will stay in the besieged Afghan capital.
https://twitter.com/jeromestarkey/status/1425890912639590402?s=19
We are not much better either as we also prepare to abandon our Embassy, however we are not big enough alone to stay in Afghanistan and maintain security and keep out the Taliban and terrorists without US support0 -
The British decision to follow the US decision to leave was sensible. The "all" that it "says" is this: "we're not completely insane and desirous of taking an even worse thrashing than the one we already got, just to prove, er, well nothing really". If you want an instance of Britain following the US that it's far better to deplore, look at the decision to participate in the invasion of Afghanistan in the first place.Razedabode said:
A fair point - but still a sad situation after so many yearsCharles said:
TBF on this occasion it was the right thing to do. We’d have been absolutely mullered if we stayed when the Americans leftRazedabode said:
The Biden decision was some of the worse American foreign policy… I can only imagine the outcry if that were Trumps decisionping said:So. We spent twenty years and all the blood sweat and treasure building up the Afghan state and armed forces and it just crumbles in a few weeks.
What was the fking point?
Humiliation.
(Though the fact we followed as usual says it all)0 -
A few years ago I read an interesting book on the making of Modern Greece and Turkey. The problem was that defining who was which became quite a problem. In the end it was defined on religion. I expect that they are not such distinct communities any more, but for decades there were villages of Turkish speaking "Greeks" from Anatolia in Greek Macedonian resettlement, and Greek speaking ethnic Greek, but Muslim, communities in what is now Turkey.WhisperingOracle said:
I think Leon may be right, actually. I've seen a couple of programmes about these Griko-speakers on Greek TV while in Greece. They have their own festivals, costumes and rituals, and contacts with the Greek government, judging by who was coming on screen.StuartDickson said:
Like I said, be very wary of Wikipedia.Leon said:StuartDickson said:
Bollox. Leon is as gullible as Melvyn Bragg, who didn’t realise that his Cumbrian pal was pulling his leg when he told him that he could understand Icelandic when stationed there during the war.Omnium said:
Is that true Leon? Proper Ancient Greek?Leon said:
There are some villages in Calabria (and perhaps also Puglia) that still speak Ancient Greek. I have been to one, and heard the Greek spoken “as Pythagoras would speak it”. My knowledge of the classics is not good enough to know if this is exactly true - yours sounds much better. Still very moving, even for a linguistic pleb like meCarnyx said:
A surprising proportion of Italy was Greek-settled, including the Naples area IIRC.Benpointer said:
Sea-born salamis - did they come from Italy?IshmaelZ said:
The mountains look on Marathon—Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
And Marathon looks on the sea;
And musing there an hour alone,
I dream’d that Greece might still be free;
For standing on the Persians’ grave,
I could not deem myself a slave.
A king sate on the rocky brow
Which looks o’er sea-born Salamis;
And ships, by thousands, lay below,
And men in nations;—all were his!
He counted them at break of day—
And when the sun set, where were they?
PS Southern Italy, or a good chunk oif it, was called Magna Graecia by the chaps in Rome.
I also visited the region of Sybaris. Home off the Sybarites. It is not very sybaritic now. An impoverished, earthquake ruined, mafia infested toilet. Great food nearby, however, in the Mafia owned resorts
What's always baffled me is that Latin totally died out. The idea that there's still a good holding of the Greek language baffles me on the former idea more.
(The wartime story of Iceland is fascinating. They were invaded by the UK. Still smarts.)
‘Calabrian Greek
Greko
Native to Italy
Region Calabria
Ethnicity Greeks
Native speakers c. 2,000 (2010)[1]
The Calabrian dialect of Greek, or Grecanico[2] is the variety of Italiot Greek used by the ethnic Griko people in Calabria, as opposed to the Italiot Greek dialect spoken in the Grecìa Salentina. Both are remnants of the Ancient and Byzantine Greek colonization of the region.’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calabrian_Greek
Some dispute as to its ancientry. No doubts that it is Greek. I went to Griko
2,000 native speakers my arse. And the chances of you actually overhearing any are zilch.
At the boundary, ethnicity is very fluid, take our PM for example. Excessive flag waving patriotism is a feature despite his Turkish ancestry, birth in the USA and being brought up in Belgium.1 -
US and British forces have been deployed continuously in Afghanistan for 20 years. That’s a lot of time and manpower, yet they have failed dismallyOmnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost1 -
Some excrement icing on the cake of shit.
https://twitter.com/mikehudema/status/1425897457943203841?s=210 -
Better a puppet regime (elected too remember) we support militarily and financially for decades if not centuries if needed than a Taliban led regime becoming once again a haven for terrorist attacks on major western cities and further 9/11s.Foxy said:
Indeed, the USA conquered it in a week in 2001. It is holding onto it that is the problem.Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
We haven't learnt from South Vietnam, which is why we are reliving the fall of Saigon.
Corrupt puppet regimes funded by foreigners and enforced by foreign troops are inherently unstable. The locals will support any group of fanatics willing to boot them out. That is how the Viet Cong and Khymer Rouge won, ISIL too, at least for a while.
John McCain wanted a permanent US military presence in Afghanistan, events will soon show he was right
https://www.npr.org/2015/10/07/446499466/sen-mccain-expects-a-permanent-u-s-presence-in-afghanistan.
The Russians with Assad and neighbouring client states like Belarus and the Chinese too increasingly support puppet states when needed, so sometimes must we0 -
https://twitter.com/mattduss/status/1425888313609760769?s=19Andy_JS said:
Why would it be the fault of other countries if the Afghans can't seem to run their own country?Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
0 -
The only purpose of him or any other staff staying is to ensure a successful evacuation.FrancisUrquhart said:Thread on Afghanistan...
HUNDREDS of Paras will swoop into Kabul to evacuate the British Embassy and up to 4,000 Brits, contractors and staff – amid fears the city will fall to the Taliban.
Only a skeleton staff including ambassador Sir Laurie Bristow will stay in the besieged Afghan capital.
https://twitter.com/jeromestarkey/status/1425890912639590402?s=190 -
New polling analysis with @mattholehouse at the @TheEconomist shows that owning a car is far more predictive of voting behavior than social class.
https://t.co/3MhRgWELdB https://t.co/Ijje6NqFBu
Although i don't agree with the premise, i think its more to do with big urban centres less likely to own a car, especially if poorer. However, reminder, how petrol prices and expensive move away from petrol cars could really piss off Tory voting block.
Petrol prices have really risen during the pandemic. Certainly no room for Sunak to whack a load of extra tax on the motorist if he wants.to.remain popular with Tory voters.0 -
Hugely interesting USA Census results.
Big falls in rural areas and rises in City populations may make the Redistricting process less damaging to Dems than expected.0 -
The parallels with South Vietnam in the spring of 1975 seem quite compelling.Andy_JS said:
Why would it be the fault of other countries if the Afghans can't seem to run their own country?Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
The Ghani government, rather like that of Nguyen van Thieu, has been shown to be a house of cards without substantial foreign military support.
Ghani, like Karzai before him, seems incapable of persuading more than a small number his regime is worth fighting for and dying for. The Taliban, for whatever reason, don't seem to have those issues and although no match for the technology of air power are seemingly more than capable when it comes to the awful minutiae of street fighting within towns and cities.
The argument "he's a bastard but he's OUR bastard" is all we have - it's the same argument used in the Cold War to back some appalling regimes on the simple premise they were anti-communist.
I imagine Ghani and those close to him will find exile and solace somewhere as Afghanistan plunges seemingly into darkness. The contrast between the negotiator in Doha and the commander in Helmand was stark - the excesses and barbarities of Islamic orthodox theocracy will be vested once more on the people of Kabul, Kandahar and Kunduz.
What then? Will any kind of containment work or will Iran and Pakistan covertly support the new Government? Will China do business with the new rulers? The reality of 21st century realpolitik suggests the answer to both questions is yes.
Yet what else could we or should we have done? Would capitalism work or is corruption too ingrained, too endemic, to encourage both actual liberalisation and the desire to fight for that liberalisation or does it come down to the simple truth the West is a ready market for the drugs so easily and readily sourced from Afghanistan?3 -
er. sorry to disappoint you, there is both a formal and a colloquial (demotic) modern Greek.williamglenn said:
Perhaps the only difference is that multiple modern forms of Latin emerged, whereas there is only one modern Greek.IshmaelZ said:
But it didn't. I am currently trying to learn Spanish in 3 weeks so that I can speak to the Argentinian side at an Argie-Scots wedding, and I am pleased to report there is almost no learning involved. Spanish is easily as close to Latin as modern is to ancient Greek.Omnium said:
Is that true Leon? Proper Ancient Greek?Leon said:
There are some villages in Calabria (and perhaps also Puglia) that still speak Ancient Greek. I have been to one, and heard the Greek spoken “as Pythagoras would speak it”. My knowledge of the classics is not good enough to know if this is exactly true - yours sounds much better. Still very moving, even for a linguistic pleb like meCarnyx said:
A surprising proportion of Italy was Greek-settled, including the Naples area IIRC.Benpointer said:
Sea-born salamis - did they come from Italy?IshmaelZ said:
The mountains look on Marathon—Carnyx said:
Oh, I hadn't seen that before posting my last. Exactly so. Not to mention that "the human is a political animal".Leon said:
I really really recommend it. It was my first time too. It is in amazingly good nick (very well restored)Carnyx said:
Ooh, jammy sod.Leon said:Can’t believe I missed the whole PB August 2021 air-pump-versus-heat-pump Debate by stupidly visiting the Tower of the Four Winds in the Roman Agora of ancient Athens instead
I've seen the Oxford one (the old Radcliffe Observatory, in what is now Green College) but never been to Athens to see the original (and much else).
That part of Athens is so movingly historic it can make you feel a bit weepy. This gorgeous marble cradle
I went to Aristotle’s Lyceum as well. The ruins are fairly humdrum but you can walk the very same path where Aristotle walked, under the plane trees, discussing Plato and Socrates, with his pupils. Goodness me
I was one of about 6 people in the otherwise deserted and idyllic gardens
I know it is trendy to talk up the Persians but pah. I know exactly what side my heart is on.
And Marathon looks on the sea;
And musing there an hour alone,
I dream’d that Greece might still be free;
For standing on the Persians’ grave,
I could not deem myself a slave.
A king sate on the rocky brow
Which looks o’er sea-born Salamis;
And ships, by thousands, lay below,
And men in nations;—all were his!
He counted them at break of day—
And when the sun set, where were they?
PS Southern Italy, or a good chunk oif it, was called Magna Graecia by the chaps in Rome.
I also visited the region of Sybaris. Home off the Sybarites. It is not very sybaritic now. An impoverished, earthquake ruined, mafia infested toilet. Great food nearby, however, in the Mafia owned resorts
What's always baffled me is that Latin totally died out. The idea that there's still a good holding of the Greek language baffles me on the former idea more.
Also I speak Italian, but Spanish has a Lot of weird Arabic stuff which I do not get, so I wonder how accurate your comprehension is.0 -
67 UK citizens died on 9/11 as well as 2,605 US citizens in an attack planned by Bin Laden in AfghanistanYoungTurk said:
The British decision to follow the US decision to leave was sensible. The "all" that it "says" is this: "we're not completely insane and desirous of taking an even worse thrashing than the one we already got, just to prove, er, well nothing really". If you want an instance of Britain following the US that it's far better to deplore, look at the decision to participate in the invasion of Afghanistan in the first place.Razedabode said:
A fair point - but still a sad situation after so many yearsCharles said:
TBF on this occasion it was the right thing to do. We’d have been absolutely mullered if we stayed when the Americans leftRazedabode said:
The Biden decision was some of the worse American foreign policy… I can only imagine the outcry if that were Trumps decisionping said:So. We spent twenty years and all the blood sweat and treasure building up the Afghan state and armed forces and it just crumbles in a few weeks.
What was the fking point?
Humiliation.
(Though the fact we followed as usual says it all)0 -
I don't think anyone is keen on it are they?Foxy said:
At one time the Chinese did control much of Central Asia on the Silk Road.Leon said:
No, the Soviets did not have the ruthlessness of Xi’s China. Also, Xi’s China is just cleverer: they would never invade and occupy, it is pointless. Just encircle it with allies - Pakistan, Iran, Russia, starve it into submission, drop a few bombs, kill 30,000 people in a couple of days, job done. A subdued Afghanistan. Meanwhile offer the carrot of endless Chinese investment in valuable minesydoethur said:
and the Soviets don’t?Philip_Thompson said:
The Chinese have a ruthlessness the Americans do not.ydoethur said:
The Americans and the Soviets thought the same.Omnium said:
Easily, but they'd not do so. They could easily play a very long game, and the Taliban would certainly lose.ydoethur said:
115,000 men was insufficient for the Soviets.Omnium said:
I'm not a military man. Wait until you know. Overwhelming force can't be a losing situation after all.ydoethur said:
Such as what?Omnium said:
Because it's obvious that given time and manpower you can choose the tactics for the territory.ydoethur said:
Why?Omnium said:
The idea that Afghanistan is some unconquerable bastion is ridiculous.Leon said:
Every other global empire has been unable to resist, I see no reason why China should be uniquely untempted. And not all have failed. I believe the Mongols were quite rigorousOmnium said:
I'd be quite happy to see the Chinese intervene in Afghanistan.Leon said:Omnium said:
Biden is sort of right. The Afghans really should look after themselves. It's simply ridiculous that they don't want to do so, and, unfortunately, that's down to the West.Theuniondivvie said:Grim interviews from Afghanistan on C4 news. You have to wonder why the government leadership has been so gutless (I can’t speak to the qualities of the ground troops but I dare say their morale is affected by those at the top). Interesting that 2 of the interviewees specifically said they did not blame the US.
Not any more. If China wants global supremacy, let China rule Afghanistan. They’ll probably do it quite well, albeit in the Roman style. Ruthlessly and violently. The Chinese have the cultural self confidence we have lost
390,000 including the Nato backed Afghan army was insufficient for NATO.
Do you honestly think the Chinese could commit more than that and still hold down Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Tibet?
I’d just point out they were both wrong.
If you want to be an empire, moral self doubt is a fatal flaw. The British resisted it for centuries, but succumbed in the 20th century. America now follows. Probably China will have some Afghan Lives Matter movement in about 50 years, and they too will quail
But China’s grievous national memories of humiliation and famine are too recent for that to be a problem, at the moment. Especially for such an ancient nation which has long felt itself the centre of the world
I wonder if those so keen on a Chinese extermination of the Afghans are the same as those horrified at the Uighurs genocide, being done for the ostensible reason of Islamism?
I think it's a horrific and scary prospect that could happen, if they chose to proceed with it.
Just because it can happen, doesn't mean it should. Let alone mean if it does, it won't be horrific.0 -
So when are the Essex volunteers being deployed?HYUFD said:
Shameful and this will define the Biden-Harris administration now, whatever else it does this will be the greatest US humiliation since Vietnam.FrancisUrquhart said:Thread on Afghanistan...
HUNDREDS of Paras will swoop into Kabul to evacuate the British Embassy and up to 4,000 Brits, contractors and staff – amid fears the city will fall to the Taliban.
Only a skeleton staff including ambassador Sir Laurie Bristow will stay in the besieged Afghan capital.
https://twitter.com/jeromestarkey/status/1425890912639590402?s=19
We are not much better either as we also prepare to abandon our Embassy, however we are not big enough alone to stay in Afghanistan and maintain security and keep out the Taliban and terrorists without US support0
This discussion has been closed.