politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » We may not have the Iowa results yet but punters think Biden w
Comments
-
If it was the DNC however....ydoethur said:27 balls. 18 runs. Seven wickets in hand.
Even South Africa surely can’t choke from here.0 -
It’s not a piss up in a brewery, they might be OK.FrancisUrquhart said:
If it was the DNC however....ydoethur said:27 balls. 18 runs. Seven wickets in hand.
Even South Africa surely can’t choke from here.0 -
Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.0
-
Bugger.
Well, to be honest, trying to jinx them seemed a long shot, but...0 -
They should really just not bother at this point, anything but full results is going to make things worse.Andy_JS said:
50% of them apparently.MikeSmithson said:Iowa results expected now by 2200 GMT
0 -
Do you think?IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
0 -
Mr Woolie/Dyed. All the best. Difficult situation.0
-
They didn’t. We lost the first Test, though and look where it ended up.ydoethur said:27 balls. 18 runs. Seven wickets in hand.
Even South Africa surely can’t choke from here.
Shame about Bavuma missing his ton.0 -
The same thing could happen in an FPTP election if the Greens for example suddenly went from 10% to 35% in the course of a campaign they might not have candidates in all seats.alex_ said:
Didn’t someone say the other day that they haven’t put nearly enough candidates on the ballot to capitalise? So we could end up with a “proportional” system that fails to replicate votes proportionally in seats?
The poll is astonishing and unless an FF-FG coalition is formed to keep out SF, it's going to be hard to see what kind of Government will be formed.
0 -
But you'd have to tell them to run, DNC. It's Tricky. Because It's Like That.FrancisUrquhart said:
If it was the DNC however....ydoethur said:27 balls. 18 runs. Seven wickets in hand.
Even South Africa surely can’t choke from here.
(I'm one consonant away from the perfect joke here. Goshdarnit. )
0 -
It wasn't the DNC that screwed up. It was the IDP (Iowa Democratic Party).FrancisUrquhart said:
If it was the DNC however....ydoethur said:27 balls. 18 runs. Seven wickets in hand.
Even South Africa surely can’t choke from here.0 -
SNP causing trouble in the Commons I see.0
-
President Donald Trump's targeting of CNN is moving to yet another arena: The annual presidential lunch with television network anchors.
CNN anchors are being excluded from Tuesday's lunch, three sources said on Monday night.
https://edition.cnn.com/2020/02/03/media/donald-trump-state-of-the-union-lunch-cnn/index.html0 -
The Greens could be (opinion) polling 35% and fail to capitalise due to lack of candidates. They couldn’t actually secure 35% of the actual votes and fail to capitalise for that reason though. (as opposed to other features of FPTP)stodge said:
The same thing could happen in an FPTP election if the Greens for example suddenly went from 10% to 35% in the course of a campaign they might not have candidates in all seats.alex_ said:
Didn’t someone say the other day that they haven’t put nearly enough candidates on the ballot to capitalise? So we could end up with a “proportional” system that fails to replicate votes proportionally in seats?
0 -
What are the chances of the China situation causing a world recession?0
-
I'm pretty sure there won't be an FF-FG coalition. I think more likely is a minority FF or FF-Green coalition (possibly with a few Independents mixed in, and/or Labour if they have enough seats to be useful). FG might have to give tacit support or Confidence & Supply in the mirror image of the previous government.stodge said:
The same thing could happen in an FPTP election if the Greens for example suddenly went from 10% to 35% in the course of a campaign they might not have candidates in all seats.alex_ said:
Didn’t someone say the other day that they haven’t put nearly enough candidates on the ballot to capitalise? So we could end up with a “proportional” system that fails to replicate votes proportionally in seats?
The poll is astonishing and unless an FF-FG coalition is formed to keep out SF, it's going to be hard to see what kind of Government will be formed.
Of course this latest poll is only one poll, and it might not prove correct. Still, there's no doubt that SF are going to do very well.0 -
And now more cities in lockdown.Andy_JS said:What are the chances of the China situation causing a world recession?
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7964311/More-Chinese-cities-lockdown-coronavirus.html
It seems it is already causes problems with supply chain, not just in China. Hyundai in South Korea have stopped production.0 -
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
However Boris has made clear he will block indyref2 for his full term anyway0 -
It's worrying for countries that have high export volumes to China, Germany are the most exposed IMO, they suffer the most from a private sector industrial slow down. Korea and Japan sell a lot of goods to their own companies in China which may or may not be effected by a recession with China as the focal point.Andy_JS said:What are the chances of the China situation causing a world recession?
0 -
The Shimmers have got 42 candidates for a 160 (ok, 159) seat Dail. It would be difficult for them to form a non-coalition government with only 42/160 = 26% of the seats. Are there any parties in Ireland willing to give them confidence and supply (or the Irish equivalent) or coalition with them? My knowledge of Irish politics is sadly lacking.alex_ said:
The Greens could be (opinion) polling 35% and fail to capitalise due to lack of candidates. They couldn’t actually secure 35% of the actual votes and fail to capitalise for that reason though. (as opposed to other features of FPTP)stodge said:
The same thing could happen in an FPTP election if the Greens for example suddenly went from 10% to 35% in the course of a campaign they might not have candidates in all seats.alex_ said:
Didn’t someone say the other day that they haven’t put nearly enough candidates on the ballot to capitalise? So we could end up with a “proportional” system that fails to replicate votes proportionally in seats?0 -
So what both Fine Gael and Fianna Fail leaders have said they will refuse to go into Government with Sinn Fein, unlike ironically the DUP in NI haveTheGreenMachine said:0 -
Minor far-left parties and various extreme left independents would work with SF, but that's not enough.viewcode said:
The Shimmers have got 42 candidates for a 160 (ok, 159) seat Dail. It would be difficult for them to form a non-coalition government with only 42/160 = 26% of the seats. Are there any parties in Ireland willing to give them confidence and supply (or the Irish equivalent) or coalition with them? My knowledge of Irish politics is sadly lacking.alex_ said:
The Greens could be (opinion) polling 35% and fail to capitalise due to lack of candidates. They couldn’t actually secure 35% of the actual votes and fail to capitalise for that reason though. (as opposed to other features of FPTP)stodge said:
The same thing could happen in an FPTP election if the Greens for example suddenly went from 10% to 35% in the course of a campaign they might not have candidates in all seats.alex_ said:
Didn’t someone say the other day that they haven’t put nearly enough candidates on the ballot to capitalise? So we could end up with a “proportional” system that fails to replicate votes proportionally in seats?0 -
Ah, the Did Not Cockup and the Inept Demonstration of Polling.Gabs3 said:
It wasn't the DNC that screwed up. It was the IDP (Iowa Democratic Party).FrancisUrquhart said:
If it was the DNC however....ydoethur said:27 balls. 18 runs. Seven wickets in hand.
Even South Africa surely can’t choke from here.0 -
Did you miss the bit where not a single member of the Northern Irish Assembly spoke for the Brexit deal? The deal is not exactly overflowing with supporters there.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
However Boris has made clear he will block indyref2 for his full term anyway0 -
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
3 -
Same thing happened in the Scottish local elections in 2017. The Tories under nominated because they hadn't foreseen a GE being called and the May surge.alex_ said:
Didn’t someone say the other day that they haven’t put nearly enough candidates on the ballot to capitalise? So we could end up with a “proportional” system that fails to replicate votes proportionally in seats?TheGreenMachine said:0 -
That's a really short term fix, it leads to a shite coalition that no one wants which will be extremely unpopular and push more votes to SF. It's literally what's happening in Germany with both the CDU and SPD getting hollowed out for the Greens, AfD and Linke.HYUFD said:
So what both Fine Gael and Fianna Fail leaders have said they will refuse to go into Government with Sinn Fein, unlike ironically the DUP in NI haveTheGreenMachine said:0 -
The DUP don't have a choice if they want a functioning government because of the set up of the system. FG and FF do, wise or not.HYUFD said:
So what both Fine Gael and Fianna Fail leaders have said they will refuse to go into Government with Sinn Fein, unlike ironically the DUP in NI haveTheGreenMachine said:0 -
It will definitely hit the world economy, but based on the proper definition of recession (two consecutive quarters) I really hope that's unlikely. We'll probably see a drop for one quarter due to this but if anything a boost the following quarter after China reopens as businesses try and catch up on backlogs.Andy_JS said:What are the chances of the China situation causing a world recession?
That's not to say there won't be a serious impact.0 -
Leaving them out is a comma grammatical error....viewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
1 -
Works of the devil never trust them that's what I always say that is a fact.viewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
1 -
Who needs a mere grammar Nazi when HYUFD wants to send in the troops to quash independence bids?viewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
0 -
Perhaps all the commas were used up on those Brexit coins, now there is a shortage cos of Brexit obvs.1
-
0
-
We can only hopeIanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
0 -
Serious request: I'd be very interested to hear a proponent of PR explain why this sort of behaviour is desirable (or at least why it isn't considered a large enough drawback of PR to matter). At the very least it alters voting behaviours at the margins, since there's limited point voting for a party that can't possibly be in the next government unless it gets an incredibly unlikely outright majority, so you may as well vote for one that could be in a coalition.Richard_Nabavi said:
Minor far-left parties and various extreme left independents would work with SF, but that's not enough.viewcode said:
The Shimmers have got 42 candidates for a 160 (ok, 159) seat Dail. It would be difficult for them to form a non-coalition government with only 42/160 = 26% of the seats. Are there any parties in Ireland willing to give them confidence and supply (or the Irish equivalent) or coalition with them? My knowledge of Irish politics is sadly lacking.alex_ said:
The Greens could be (opinion) polling 35% and fail to capitalise due to lack of candidates. They couldn’t actually secure 35% of the actual votes and fail to capitalise for that reason though. (as opposed to other features of FPTP)stodge said:
The same thing could happen in an FPTP election if the Greens for example suddenly went from 10% to 35% in the course of a campaign they might not have candidates in all seats.alex_ said:
Didn’t someone say the other day that they haven’t put nearly enough candidates on the ballot to capitalise? So we could end up with a “proportional” system that fails to replicate votes proportionally in seats?
It's always seemed to me that in the rush to try and make sure that Parliament is representative, proponents of political reform forget/ignore/discount the fact that for the most part, elections are fought on an all-or-nothing basis. If you're in government, you have some chance of getting some part of your manifesto enacted. If you're out, you have no chance. Most people don't derive any value from their views are being represented from the opposition benches.0 -
Highlights of his global tour include encounters with Nelson Mandela, an 800-year-old demigod and a dildo collectorkle4 said:
Works of the devil never trust them that's what I always say that is a fact.viewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
1 -
Varadkar formed a government with 50 FG and 7 independents, although FF abstained. Will FF+FG field sufficient votes against a 42+X Sinn Fein Taoiseach nomination?Richard_Nabavi said:
Minor far-left parties and various extreme left independents would work with SF, but that's not enough.viewcode said:
The Shimmers have got 42 candidates for a 160 (ok, 159) seat Dail. It would be difficult for them to form a non-coalition government with only 42/160 = 26% of the seats. Are there any parties in Ireland willing to give them confidence and supply (or the Irish equivalent) or coalition with them? My knowledge of Irish politics is sadly lacking.alex_ said:
The Greens could be (opinion) polling 35% and fail to capitalise due to lack of candidates. They couldn’t actually secure 35% of the actual votes and fail to capitalise for that reason though. (as opposed to other features of FPTP)stodge said:
The same thing could happen in an FPTP election if the Greens for example suddenly went from 10% to 35% in the course of a campaign they might not have candidates in all seats.alex_ said:
Didn’t someone say the other day that they haven’t put nearly enough candidates on the ballot to capitalise? So we could end up with a “proportional” system that fails to replicate votes proportionally in seats?
0 -
You obviously missed the comma 2 words in thenviewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
0 -
If you all are going to go, can you do us a favour and take the Welsh with you though?Beibheirli_C said:0 -
It was a joke, Doctorydoethur said:
Highlights of his global tour include encounters with Nelson Mandela, an 800-year-old demigod and a dildo collectorkle4 said:
Works of the devil never trust them that's what I always say that is a fact.viewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
Although on that particular example it was pointed out to me that even an extra comma doesn't completely remove ambiguity (though it is less ambiguous than if it is there), and that it really needs rewriting, not just adding a comma.0 -
The DUP and UUP would prefer a hard border with the Republic of Ireland of course (requiring us to send in the troops to enforce it) but will back staying in the UK regardless anyway, however soft Nat SDLP voters and middle ground Alliance voters are far less resentful at the Withdrawal Agreement terms than they would have been over a hard border with the Republic of Ireland so my point stands absolutelyAlastairMeeks said:
Did you miss the bit where not a single member of the Northern Irish Assembly spoke for the Brexit deal? The deal is not exactly overflowing with supporters there.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
However Boris has made clear he will block indyref2 for his full term anyway0 -
Who?Philip_Thompson said:
If you all are going to go, can you do us a favour and take the Welsh with you though?Beibheirli_C said:0 -
Alternatively called the comma 79 words before the decimal point.HYUFD said:
You obviously missed the comma 2 words in thenviewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
0 -
Well, yes. Nelson Mandela should go at the end, really.kle4 said:
It was a joke, Doctorydoethur said:
Highlights of his global tour include encounters with Nelson Mandela, an 800-year-old demigod and a dildo collectorkle4 said:
Works of the devil never trust them that's what I always say that is a fact.viewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
Although on that particular example it was pointed out to me that even an extra comma doesn't completely remove ambiguity (though it is less ambiguous than if it is there), and that it really needs rewriting, not just adding a comma.
Don’t mind me, I just saw an opportunity to sneak it into the conversation so I took it. You know me, I am both a highly partisan raging centrist and a totally unprincipled opportunist.0 -
NI/Scotland/whomever will take them/it was a joke.Beibheirli_C said:
Who?Philip_Thompson said:
If you all are going to go, can you do us a favour and take the Welsh with you though?Beibheirli_C said:0 -
Maybe Brexit supporters have to show loyalty by underusing commas? Doing otherwise would be disloyal to the spirit of Brexit.FrancisUrquhart said:Perhaps all the commas were used up on those Brexit coins, now there is a shortage cos of Brexit obvs.
0 -
Or better still, can you take the English with you so the Welsh can have England back? *innocent face*Philip_Thompson said:
If you all are going to go, can you do us a favour and take the Welsh with you though?Beibheirli_C said:1 -
True but the CDU and SPD coalition has lasted for 7 years even if not exactly lovedMaxPB said:
That's a really short term fix, it leads to a shite coalition that no one wants which will be extremely unpopular and push more votes to SF. It's literally what's happening in Germany with both the CDU and SPD getting hollowed out for the Greens, AfD and Linke.HYUFD said:
So what both Fine Gael and Fianna Fail leaders have said they will refuse to go into Government with Sinn Fein, unlike ironically the DUP in NI haveTheGreenMachine said:0 -
If they have lost collectively about 8 out of 49 percentage points, they should still hold almost half the seats, after accounting for the lower popularity of Sinn Féin as a second preference. It is very hard to see how SF forms a government without the connivance of one of the two big parties. There are just too many mini-party mouths to feed.viewcode said:
Varadkar formed a government with 50 FG and 7 independents, although FF abstained. Will FF+FG field sufficient votes against a 42+X Sinn Fein Taoiseach nomination?Richard_Nabavi said:
Minor far-left parties and various extreme left independents would work with SF, but that's not enough.viewcode said:
The Shimmers have got 42 candidates for a 160 (ok, 159) seat Dail. It would be difficult for them to form a non-coalition government with only 42/160 = 26% of the seats. Are there any parties in Ireland willing to give them confidence and supply (or the Irish equivalent) or coalition with them? My knowledge of Irish politics is sadly lacking.alex_ said:
The Greens could be (opinion) polling 35% and fail to capitalise due to lack of candidates. They couldn’t actually secure 35% of the actual votes and fail to capitalise for that reason though. (as opposed to other features of FPTP)stodge said:
The same thing could happen in an FPTP election if the Greens for example suddenly went from 10% to 35% in the course of a campaign they might not have candidates in all seats.alex_ said:
Didn’t someone say the other day that they haven’t put nearly enough candidates on the ballot to capitalise? So we could end up with a “proportional” system that fails to replicate votes proportionally in seats?1 -
Maybe but still a tad hypocrital for Varadkar to demand Sinn Fein have a role in the NI Government but refuse them one in the Republic of Ireland governmentkle4 said:
The DUP don't have a choice if they want a functioning government because of the set up of the system. FG and FF do, wise or not.HYUFD said:
So what both Fine Gael and Fianna Fail leaders have said they will refuse to go into Government with Sinn Fein, unlike ironically the DUP in NI haveTheGreenMachine said:0 -
Quite high, surely, bearing in mind that the economic effect we are already seeing in China could even by itself have a significant impact yet is only going to be the tip of the iceberg assuming this develops into a more widespread pandemic.Andy_JS said:What are the chances of the China situation causing a world recession?
Are there any elections due in 2020 where sitting candidates had been expecting to use economic growth as a fig leaf to try to cover up all their other failings?0 -
You could say the same drawback is true of the UK Labour Party under FPTP.Endillion said:
Serious request: I'd be very interested to hear a proponent of PR explain why this sort of behaviour is desirable (or at least why it isn't considered a large enough drawback of PR to matter). At the very least it alters voting behaviours at the margins, since there's limited point voting for a party that can't possibly be in the next government unless it gets an incredibly unlikely outright majority, so you may as well vote for one that could be in a coalition.Richard_Nabavi said:
Minor far-left parties and various extreme left independents would work with SF, but that's not enough.viewcode said:
The Shimmers have got 42 candidates for a 160 (ok, 159) seat Dail. It would be difficult for them to form a non-coalition government with only 42/160 = 26% of the seats. Are there any parties in Ireland willing to give them confidence and supply (or the Irish equivalent) or coalition with them? My knowledge of Irish politics is sadly lacking.alex_ said:
The Greens could be (opinion) polling 35% and fail to capitalise due to lack of candidates. They couldn’t actually secure 35% of the actual votes and fail to capitalise for that reason though. (as opposed to other features of FPTP)stodge said:
The same thing could happen in an FPTP election if the Greens for example suddenly went from 10% to 35% in the course of a campaign they might not have candidates in all seats.alex_ said:
Didn’t someone say the other day that they haven’t put nearly enough candidates on the ballot to capitalise? So we could end up with a “proportional” system that fails to replicate votes proportionally in seats?
It's always seemed to me that in the rush to try and make sure that Parliament is representative, proponents of political reform forget/ignore/discount the fact that for the most part, elections are fought on an all-or-nothing basis. If you're in government, you have some chance of getting some part of your manifesto enacted. If you're out, you have no chance. Most people don't derive any value from their views are being represented from the opposition benches.0 -
Darth Grammar. I shall pedant the Republic to death.Philip_Thompson said:
Who needs a mere grammar Nazi when HYUFD wants to send in the troops to quash independence bids?viewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
(Incidentally, the first Star Wars crawl has an ellipsis with four dots, whilst it should be three)0 -
Anyone who hates commas should read this, step 104:
http://frog.gatech.edu/Pubs/How-to-Publish-a-Scientific-Comment-in-123-Easy-Steps.pdf1 -
It was the long stream of unpunctuated words that followed it that inspired the post.HYUFD said:
You obviously missed the comma 2 words in thenviewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
0 -
One's a sovereign state where they can demolish the business model and make it Portugal in the space of one budget.HYUFD said:
Maybe but still a tad hypocrital for Varadkar to demand Sinn Fein have a role in the NI Government but refuse them one in the Republic of Ireland governmentkle4 said:
The DUP don't have a choice if they want a functioning government because of the set up of the system. FG and FF do, wise or not.HYUFD said:
So what both Fine Gael and Fianna Fail leaders have said they will refuse to go into Government with Sinn Fein, unlike ironically the DUP in NI haveTheGreenMachine said:0 -
It's already hitting Hyundai production in Korea.Wulfrun_Phil said:
Quite high, surely, bearing in mind that the economic effect we are already seeing in China could even by itself have a significant impact yet is only going to be the tip of the iceberg assuming this develops into a more widespread pandemic.Andy_JS said:What are the chances of the China situation causing a world recession?
Are there any elections due in 2020 where sitting candidates had been expecting to use economic growth as a fig leaf to try to cover up all their other failings?
0 -
In Wolverhampton, we regard Shrewsbury as part of Wales. At least, I recall happy memories of singing "You're Welsh and you know you are" at the Amwythig Town fans who ventured down the M54 to Wolves in last season's FA Cup.ydoethur said:
Or better still, can you take the English with you so the Welsh can have England back? *innocent face*Philip_Thompson said:
If you all are going to go, can you do us a favour and take the Welsh with you though?Beibheirli_C said:0 -
-
-
-
Well I'm sure this debate which never gets anywhere will be as pleasant as ever.HYUFD said:1 -
One of my history teachers was from Shrewsbury. She was Welsh speaking.Wulfrun_Phil said:
In Wolverhampton, we regard Shrewsbury as part of Wales. At least, I recall happy memories of singing "You're Welsh and you know you are" at the Amwythig Town fans who ventured down the M54 to Wolves in last season's FA Cup.ydoethur said:
Or better still, can you take the English with you so the Welsh can have England back? *innocent face*Philip_Thompson said:
If you all are going to go, can you do us a favour and take the Welsh with you though?Beibheirli_C said:
But shouldn’t that be Cefnogwyr Clwb Pêl-Droed Dref Amwythig? Or are we going for Wenglish?0 -
No option for 'directly into someone elses' bowl of porridge'? Asking for a friend.HYUFD said:1 -
In addition to the Democrat base, he would actively repel the New Left (Sanders supporters etc).MaxPB said:
Might struggle to motivate the Democrat base and black voters. Unionised workers may resent his republican past.rcs1000 said:
Why wouldn't Bloomberg have a good chance? I would have a thought that moderate Republians find it much easier to stay at home if it was Bloomberg vs Trump than if it was Sanders vs Trump.Mysticrose said:
Not a snowball's chance in hell of beating Trumplogical_song said:
Currently he looks like he could beat Trump.Casino_Royale said:Bloomberg isn’t far off moving into second favourite position.
I’m struggling to see the justification for that, other than he’s not tarnished by Iowa.1 -
Nope - DUP and UUP both want the soft border. In any event, the border will be soft. Enforced by whom?HYUFD said:
The DUP and UUP would prefer a hard border with the Republic of Ireland of course (requiring us to send in the troops to enforce it) but will back staying in the UK regardless anyway, however soft Nat SDLP voters and middle ground Alliance voters are far less resentful at the Withdrawal Agreement terms than they would have been over a hard border with the Republic of Ireland so my point stands absolutelyAlastairMeeks said:
Did you miss the bit where not a single member of the Northern Irish Assembly spoke for the Brexit deal? The deal is not exactly overflowing with supporters there.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
However Boris has made clear he will block indyref2 for his full term anyway0 -
How is that ambiguity comparable to:ydoethur said:
Highlights of his global tour include encounters with Nelson Mandela, an 800-year-old demigod and a dildo collectorkle4 said:
Works of the devil never trust them that's what I always say that is a fact.viewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
"Peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations"?
Why is a second comma necessary to "de-ambiguise" (if that's a word!) the Brexit coin?
0 -
These aren't the ellipses you're looking for?viewcode said:
Darth Grammar. I shall pedant the Republic to death.Philip_Thompson said:
Who needs a mere grammar Nazi when HYUFD wants to send in the troops to quash independence bids?viewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
(Incidentally, the first Star Wars crawl has an ellipsis with four dots, whilst it should be three)1 -
For me it's definitely Wenglish vocabulary as on road signs only. Amwythig. Araf. Ysgol. Pant cudd. That sort of thing.ydoethur said:
One of my history teachers was from Shrewsbury. She was Welsh speaking.Wulfrun_Phil said:
In Wolverhampton, we regard Shrewsbury as part of Wales. At least, I recall happy memories of singing "You're Welsh and you know you are" at the Amwythig Town fans who ventured down the M54 to Wolves in last season's FA Cup.ydoethur said:
Or better still, can you take the English with you so the Welsh can have England back? *innocent face*Philip_Thompson said:
If you all are going to go, can you do us a favour and take the Welsh with you though?Beibheirli_C said:
But shouldn’t that be Cefnogwyr Clwb Pêl-Droed Dref Amwythig? Or are we going for Wenglish?0 -
2
-
Britain treated Ireland as bad as anyone so I am not sure what skin colour has to do with it.HYUFD said:2 -
Perhaps but even that left-winger Michael Portillo has conceded Britain's involvement in the Opium Wars wasn't one of our most honourable actions.Casino_Royale said:
What a stream of shite.
She can piss off, quite frankly.
1 -
If there is it will be as much down to the Chinese response to the virus as the virus itself.Andy_JS said:What are the chances of the China situation causing a world recession?
Put simply: the rest of the world don't trust the Chinese statistics nor their handling of the situation, which is largely about Face not truth. That's why they're starting to close off flights and pull out their nationals.0 -
British Empire or Brutish Empire?HYUFD said:0 -
Because you can haveSunil_Prasannan said:
How is that ambiguity comparable to:ydoethur said:
Highlights of his global tour include encounters with Nelson Mandela, an 800-year-old demigod and a dildo collectorkle4 said:
Works of the devil never trust them that's what I always say that is a fact.viewcode said:
There's these things called "commas". Dead handy they are. Just saying.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
"Peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations"?
Why is a second comma necessary to "de-ambiguise" (if that's a word!) the Brexit coin?
"Peace", "Prosperity & Friendship" (2 options)
or you can have
"Peace", "Prosperity" and "Friendship" (3 options)
0 -
Manceinon PiccadillyWulfrun_Phil said:
For me it's definitely Wenglish vocabulary as on road signs only. Amwythig. Araf. Ysgol. Pant cudd. That sort of thing.ydoethur said:
One of my history teachers was from Shrewsbury. She was Welsh speaking.Wulfrun_Phil said:
In Wolverhampton, we regard Shrewsbury as part of Wales. At least, I recall happy memories of singing "You're Welsh and you know you are" at the Amwythig Town fans who ventured down the M54 to Wolves in last season's FA Cup.ydoethur said:
Or better still, can you take the English with you so the Welsh can have England back? *innocent face*Philip_Thompson said:
If you all are going to go, can you do us a favour and take the Welsh with you though?Beibheirli_C said:
But shouldn’t that be Cefnogwyr Clwb Pêl-Droed Dref Amwythig? Or are we going for Wenglish?0 -
Is the Tory hierarchy going to do anything about their MP, Daniel Kawcyznski, and his speaking at and attendance at a conference of far-right anti-Semitic and anti-Muslim politicians, such as Marion Marechal from Le Pen’s party?
Or is bigotry and anti-semitism only to be condemned when it is Labour doing it?0 -
Many of our past actions were not. You cannot make up for past sins (not the really big ones anyway) so it is a more complex question of whether our present actions are now appropriate and how much the future is served by self recrimination on past actions, and to what extent that should reasonably take place.stodge said:
Perhaps but even that left-winger Michael Portillo has conceded Britain's involvement in the Opium Wars wasn't one of our most honourable actions.Casino_Royale said:
What a stream of shite.
She can piss off, quite frankly.
But let's not kid ourselves, no one is really interested in having a deep debate on the subject. We want to avoid it, or make it an overly simplistic morality tale, and its probably tied into some culture war schtick to boot on either side. The exact same arguments will be being made in 100 years.0 -
0
-
There were no non-brutish empires.Sunil_Prasannan said:
British Empire or Brutish Empire?HYUFD said:1 -
Depends on what he says, no? What if it's a robust defence of European Jews, speaking truth to power?Cyclefree said:Is the Tory hierarchy going to do anything about their MP, Daniel Kawcyznski, and his speaking at and attendance at a conference of far-right anti-Semitic and anti-Muslim politicians, such as Marion Marechal from Le Pen’s party?
Or is bigotry and anti-semitism only to be condemned when it is Labour doing it?0 -
On a forced choice they don't, the DUP prefer a hard border with the Republic of Ireland to a hard border with GB, hence they had no problem with No Deal.Malmesbury said:
Nope - DUP and UUP both want the soft border. In any event, the border will be soft. Enforced by whom?HYUFD said:
The DUP and UUP would prefer a hard border with the Republic of Ireland of course (requiring us to send in the troops to enforce it) but will back staying in the UK regardless anyway, however soft Nat SDLP voters and middle ground Alliance voters are far less resentful at the Withdrawal Agreement terms than they would have been over a hard border with the Republic of Ireland so my point stands absolutelyAlastairMeeks said:
Did you miss the bit where not a single member of the Northern Irish Assembly spoke for the Brexit deal? The deal is not exactly overflowing with supporters there.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
However Boris has made clear he will block indyref2 for his full term anyway
If we had a hard border with the Republic of Ireland we would have to have sent the troops in to enforce it unlike the soft border we now have0 -
Well, quite. It's not reasonable to judge the actions of the 1840s by the standards and mores of the 2020s.kle4 said:
Many of our past actions were not. You cannot make up for past sins (not the really big ones anyway) so it is a more complex question of whether our present actions are now appropriate and how much the future is served by self recrimination on past actions, and to what extent that should reasonably take place.
But let's not kid ourselves, no one is really interested in having a deep debate on the subject. We want to avoid it, or make it an overly simplistic morality talke, and its probably tied into some culture war schtick to boot on either side. The exact same arguments will be being made in 100 years.
That doesn't mean we should ignore or gloss over or fail to educate regarding past adventures or misadventures.0 -
Only by one seat.HYUFD said:
It won't, first as the DUP are the largest party in Northern Ireland with Unionist Arlene Foster First Minister while the SNP are the largest party in Scotland with Nationalist Nicola Sturgeon First Minister and secondly as Remain voting NI is now little affected by Brexit as it is staying in a soft Brexit in a CU and most of the SM so has less resentment from Remainers than Remain voting Scotland does getting the same hard Brexit as Leave voting England and Wales.IanB2 said:Ireland (N) will go before Scotland.
However Boris has made clear he will block indyref2 for his full term anyway0 -
Cyclefree said:
Is the Tory hierarchy going to do anything about their MP, Daniel Kawcyznski, and his speaking at and attendance at a conference of far-right anti-Semitic and anti-Muslim politicians, such as Marion Marechal from Le Pen’s party?
Or is bigotry and anti-semitism only to be condemned when it is Labour doing it?Cyclefree said:Is the Tory hierarchy going to do anything about their MP, Daniel Kawcyznski, and his speaking at and attendance at a conference of far-right anti-Semitic and anti-Muslim politicians, such as Marion Marechal from Le Pen’s party?
Or is bigotry and anti-semitism only to be condemned when it is Labour doing it?
Indeed. Has anything been done about the 6000 Britain First members who claim to have joined the Tories since the election?Cyclefree said:Is the Tory hierarchy going to do anything about their MP, Daniel Kawcyznski, and his speaking at and attendance at a conference of far-right anti-Semitic and anti-Muslim politicians, such as Marion Marechal from Le Pen’s party?
Or is bigotry and anti-semitism only to be condemned when it is Labour doing it?0 -
That's not the debate here though, is it? And, if it was, by the same token, this lady would surely be arguing to pay reparations to China for - err - having the audacity to swipe Hong Kong and handing it back as the one of the wealthiest parts of the world (and free-est part of China) on our departure.stodge said:
Perhaps but even that left-winger Michael Portillo has conceded Britain's involvement in the Opium Wars wasn't one of our most honourable actions.Casino_Royale said:
What a stream of shite.
She can piss off, quite frankly.
We can find all sorts of events in our history that don't measure up to today's standards. Some were isolated events. Others were not. In many areas there is a positive legacy. In other areas the legacy is decidedly mixed. We can find many more examples in other nations in their past, many (indeed most) far worse and more barbaric.
This schoolboy debating style of reaching back into history three hundred years to contrive some causal link to the challenges of today is as simplistic as it is nonsensical. Quite aside from being inaccurate it stirs up and reinforces a crude racial divide.
It's notable that such arguments are always made in generalities: heavy on rhetoric and light on evidence. In this instance she's just lifted some bog standard shibboleths of the marxist Left, added precisely no new thinking of her own (or any thinking at all) and has simply repeated them here in a hope to score some easy points and make a name for herself.
I find the motive selfish and the behaviour reprehensible.1 -
That's all mind games imho. They have to select someone. They won't want a bunch of independents as king makers.HYUFD said:
So what both Fine Gael and Fianna Fail leaders have said they will refuse to go into Government with Sinn Fein, unlike ironically the DUP in NI haveTheGreenMachine said:0 -
53% of British voters were proud of the British Empire to only 19% ashamed in a 2014 Yougov poll. 49% thought it made the colonies better off to only 15% worse off.Sunil_Prasannan said:
British Empire or Brutish Empire?HYUFD said:
34% of voters still wanted Britain to have an Empire, with 45% not wanting the Empire to still exist today.
https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2014/07/26/britain-proud-its-empire0 -
Unless you believe the French.kle4 said:
There were no non-brutish empires.Sunil_Prasannan said:
British Empire or Brutish Empire?HYUFD said:0 -
Do Britain First even have 6000 memebers?justin124 said:
Indeed. Has anything been done about the 6000 Britain First members who claim to have joined the Tories since the election?0 -
FrancisUrquhart said:
Do Britain First even have 6000 memebers?justin124 said:
Indeed. Has anything been done about the 6000 Britain First members who claim to have joined the Tories since the election?
Apparently 6000 out of 7500 of its members joined the Tories post-election. If true, the Tories certainly now have a Neo-Nazi wing.FrancisUrquhart said:
Do Britain First even have 6000 memebers?justin124 said:
Indeed. Has anything been done about the 6000 Britain First members who claim to have joined the Tories since the election?0 -
Except that isn’t what he was doing. According to reports he said that these politicians “ represent serious ideas and concerns, some of which are shared by many citizens of the UK". Other political parties represented at this conference include the Brothers of Italy party and Vox.MaxPB said:
Depends on what he says, no? What if it's a robust defence of European Jews, speaking truth to power?Cyclefree said:Is the Tory hierarchy going to do anything about their MP, Daniel Kawcyznski, and his speaking at and attendance at a conference of far-right anti-Semitic and anti-Muslim politicians, such as Marion Marechal from Le Pen’s party?
Or is bigotry and anti-semitism only to be condemned when it is Labour doing it?
That is why Jewish and a Muslim groups have expressed serious concerns. It looks as if the Tories - and apparently Tory whips were told in advance - are fine to have one of their MPs be associated with far right groups who have a long and ignoble record of bigotry and prejudice against minority groups . The Tory party may have an explanation we are all missing but has chosen to be silent. So far.
The same standards that were applied to Corbyn should apply to Tory MPs too.
That is if the Tories are serious about being against bigotry and prejudice rather than simply using it as a convenient way to attack Labour.
0 -
No, but that does need be done in an objective and, dare I say, even cold fashion, and I don't think there is any hope of that happening in a political discussion on such topic by parliamentarians. Perhaps that is unfair of me, but it gets caught up with present politics too easily, and easy gestures and, yes, virtue signalling (which is a term I personally use for any factional signalling). Obviously things cannot simply be left to historians to edbate, but perceptions of national identity, prideful and shameful, are often a nonsense anyway.stodge said:
Well, quite. It's not reasonable to judge the actions of the 1840s by the standards and mores of the 2020s.kle4 said:
Many of our past actions were not. You cannot make up for past sins (not the really big ones anyway) so it is a more complex question of whether our present actions are now appropriate and how much the future is served by self recrimination on past actions, and to what extent that should reasonably take place.
But let's not kid ourselves, no one is really interested in having a deep debate on the subject. We want to avoid it, or make it an overly simplistic morality talke, and its probably tied into some culture war schtick to boot on either side. The exact same arguments will be being made in 100 years.
That doesn't mean we should ignore or gloss over or fail to educate regarding past adventures or misadventures.
It's why I prefer older history. Only complete weirdos give a crap that, say, Julius Ceasar or Xerxes killed huge numbers of people.1 -
A few years ago I introduced a unit on China and the Opium Wars In Year 9 as part of making history more interesting (instead of the crock of white* Gove and Cummings put together).
Today, a year 12 student who was one of the first to be taught it said he wanted to do it for A-level coursework because he’d found the lessons so interesting.
I think the words are ‘quiet satisfaction.’
*That was meant to be ‘crock of shite,’ but the autocorrect works too.0 -
Call total bullshit...justin124 said:FrancisUrquhart said:
Do Britain First even have 6000 memebers?justin124 said:
Indeed. Has anything been done about the 6000 Britain First members who claim to have joined the Tories since the election?
Apparently 6000 out of 7500 of its members joined the Tories post-election. If true, the Tories certainly now have a Neo-Nazi wing.FrancisUrquhart said:
Do Britain First even have 6000 memebers?justin124 said:
Indeed. Has anything been done about the 6000 Britain First members who claim to have joined the Tories since the election?
However, Britain First’s actual size is disputed, with extremism watchdog Hope Not Hate estimating it to have a membership of only around 1,000.
Read more: https://metro.co.uk/2019/12/28/far-right-group-britain-first-says-5000-members-joined-tories-11970687/?ito=cbshare0 -
Hope Not Hate said Britain First have fewer than 1,000 members, and it was likely a publicity stunt.justin124 said:FrancisUrquhart said:
Do Britain First even have 6000 memebers?justin124 said:
Indeed. Has anything been done about the 6000 Britain First members who claim to have joined the Tories since the election?
Apparently 6000 out of 7500 of its members joined the Tories post-election. If true, the Tories certainly now have a Neo-Nazi wing.FrancisUrquhart said:
Do Britain First even have 6000 memebers?justin124 said:
Indeed. Has anything been done about the 6000 Britain First members who claim to have joined the Tories since the election?0