Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » New party grouping, Unite to Remain, will make BJohnson’s autu

1356

Comments

  • OnlyLivingBoyOnlyLivingBoy Posts: 16,408

    You are Prince Charles and I claim my £5
    I'll pay you after Brexit, it'll be cheaper.
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,923
    But seriously, surely if this coin nonsense means anything, it must mean that the government's strategy is definitely a pseudo-Trumpian one of shamelessly pandering to what it perceives as its core support, and not giving a damn how much it upsets everyone else.

    "Where there is discord, may we exploit it to the utmost for narrow political advantage."

    I suppose if Johnson is planning an October election, it could just work for him, given our electoral system.
  • HYUFD said:

    No, whichever of Plaid or the LDs win Ceredigion will still have an anti Brexit Remainer MP so no need for the Remain Alliance there
    It is a period of civil war.
    REMAINER spaceships, striking
    from a hidden base, have won
    their first victory against
    the evil TORY Empire.

    During the battle, Remainer
    spies managed to steal secret
    plans to the Tories' ultimate
    weapon, the BORIS BOUNCER,
    an armored space station with
    enough power to knock up an
    entire parliamentary seat.

    Pursued by the Tories' sinister
    agents, Princess Heidi Jo
    races home aboard her starship,
    custodian of the stolen plans that
    can save her party and restore
    freedom to the Continent....



  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 73,575

    I'll pay you after Brexit, it'll be cheaper.
    Your evasion is noted.

    (Sorry, couldn't resist...)
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,436

    You cant do it online?
    Certainly not. What century do you think this is?
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 44,107
    HYUFD said:

    https://twitter.com/LibDems/status/1159808784711266309?s=20
    says cheating turncoat loser. A perfect Lib Dem, lower than a rattlesnakes belly.
  • El_CapitanoEl_Capitano Posts: 4,244
    HYUFD said:

    Yes, Boris has stopped most of the leakage of Tory voters
    I doubt that, given the age profile of Conservative party members.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    edited August 2019
    If now we are measuring things in terms of ‘trump like’ it’s pretty sick but Johnson is only interested in Johnson and Tory’s are only interested in Tory’s so if emulating trump is going to benefit you then they never had any principles in the first place. I hope your very rich pay masters allow you a few crumbs of the rich mans table.
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 44,107

    Boring
    arsehole
  • justin124justin124 Posts: 11,527
    ydoethur said:

    It's not 'hard' to see it. It's 'impossible.'

    However, since one of the two will win it doesn't matter.

    To be candid, I'm struggling to think of any seats in Wales where it might make a difference. Anglesey possibly, but that's a funny seat and doesn't conform to classic norms. Cardiff Central might be a better bet, but that's a Lib Dem target. The problem is that there is only Anglesey where Plaid have any chance of gaining anything and in that seat the LD vote is negligible, while in Montgomeryshire or Cardiff Central Plaid's endorsement would make no difference whatsoever.
    Very rural Welsh seats are very difficult to read - as we have just seen with Brecon & Radnor. The personality of the candidate appears to count for far more than elsewhere. Glyn Davies is standing down and it remains to be seen how strong his personal vote has become . If the Tories were to fall back to the 40% or so polled in 2010 when Davies ousted Opik , the seat would become very competitive , and in those circumstances Plaid's 5% - 8% could prove crucial. In 2017 there was a big jump in the Labour vote there , and were that to be reversed LibDem prospects could be quite good.
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,923

    That was then when the LDs finished on 7%. They are now on 20% while the Tories have slipped 13%. LAB is now an irrelevance.
    In terms of swing from the Tories since 2017, the Lib Dems would need about 22.6%. The 13% you quote doesn't come close.
  • What was I saying about women not understanding the offside rule the other day?
  • justin124justin124 Posts: 11,527

    That was then when the LDs finished on 7%. They are now on 20% while the Tories have slipped 13%. LAB is now an irrelevance.
    But in 2010 when the LibDems polled 23% in the wake of Cleggmania , Labour was the main rival to JRM losing by less than 5,000 votes. Had the seat existed on current boundaries, it would have been safely Labour in 1997 and 2001 - and probably narrowly so in 2005.
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,923
    nichomar said:

    If now we are measuring things in terms of ‘trump like’ it’s pretty sick but Johnson is only interested in Johnson and Tory’s are only interested in Tory’s so if emulating trump is going to benefit you then they never had any principles in the first place. I hope your very rich pay masters allow you a few crumbs of the rich mans table.

    ??
  • *News Alert*

    It has come to our attention at Brisky Towers that some English comrades are not fully on board the switch from scotch to bourbon to show solidarity with the great British Union of ours and to stop the Scottish Groat in its tracks.

    A new hashtag has therefore been devised-

    #Whiskey4Whisky4indyref2

    Any appraisals gratefully received.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 54,577
    malcolmg said:

    says cheating turncoat loser. A perfect Lib Dem, lower than a rattlesnakes belly.
    Lower than a rattlesnake's genital warts.....
  • Chris said:

    I say again, I don't believe you're as much of a moron as you pretend to be. No one could be.
    You think wanting "peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations" is moronic?

    I note you ignored my long reply the other day about why exactly inflation and currency variations are different, despite the fact that others could understand the point easily. I wonder whether you're the one pretending to be less bright than he is, because its really not that difficult.
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    edited August 2019

    Considering the Leavers' agreed line is that No Deal will screw the EU just as much, if not more, than us, then the 'prosperity and friendship with all nations' bit is downright Orwellian.
    We're keeping the door open to a deal, all they need to do is drop the backstop.

    Considering there is no backstop if there is no deal then its not an unreasonable request.

    Insisting on no deal [and thus no backstop] rather than a deal minus the backstop is the EU just cutting off their own nose to spite their face.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    Chris said:

    ??
    It was an attempt to respond to your pseudo trumpism comment where it’s is unfortunate that we have to now have to measure our politicians on a trump like scale which to me implies we have now reached the bottom of the barrel. I was not implying that you had ‘rich paymasters’ just allowing my frustration to run away with itself because I feel this whole situation has been engineered for their own financial benefit. Sorry if it went a bit wrong because I actually agree with you
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,923
    edited August 2019

    You think wanting "peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations" is moronic?
    Still having trouble with that basic English comprehension, eh?

    What I said was that _you_ were _pretending_ to be moronic, when you portrayed people who objected to this commemorative coin as disagreeing with the sentiments expressed in the motto.

    And then I said no one could really be that moronic. I rest my case!

  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    edited August 2019
    Chris said:

    Still having trouble with that basic English comprehension, eh?

    What I said was that _you_ were _pretending_ to be moronic, when you portrayed people who objected to this commemorative coin as disagreeing with the sentiments expressed in the motto.

    And then I said no one could really be that moronic. I rest my case!

    I'm not pretending anything, anyone who objects to the words "peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations" being on a coin is pathetic. Say that you agree with the sentiment but dislike Brexit, that's reasonable. Acting all outraged and saying you're that angry you'll deface coins . . . that's just sad.
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,923
    edited August 2019

    You think wanting "peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations" is moronic?

    I note you ignored my long reply the other day about why exactly inflation and currency variations are different, despite the fact that others could understand the point easily. I wonder whether you're the one pretending to be less bright than he is, because its really not that difficult.
    Oh - and as for "ignoring your long reply" - please do bear in mind that some of us don't spend our whole life glued to this website, as it seems you do.

    If you really posted a long reply explaining yet again why a straw man argument of your own invention was invalid, then it really just bears out what I've just said. You talk nonsense, and when someone points out it's nonsense, you just generate several tons more of the stuff to try to cover it up.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 73,575
    edited August 2019
    justin124 said:

    Very rural Welsh seats are very difficult to read - as we have just seen with Brecon & Radnor. The personality of the candidate appears to count for far more than elsewhere. Glyn Davies is standing down and it remains to be seen how strong his personal vote has become . If the Tories were to fall back to the 40% or so polled in 2010 when Davies ousted Opik , the seat would become very competitive , and in those circumstances Plaid's 5% - 8% could prove crucial. In 2017 there was a big jump in the Labour vote there , and were that to be reversed LibDem prospects could be quite good.
    40% isn't implausible as a floor in Montgomery given that's roughly the figure they get in the comparable Assembly seat.

    But Plaid and the Liberal Democrats together are still a long way short of that. Labour would need to lose 2/3 of their voters as well. Not impossible given they polled about 5% in 2015 but that seems a bit unlikely.

    Edit - it is also worth pointing out at this moment there is no Liberal Democrat candidate. The incumbent candidate did a rat run has just been elected as an MP. So we are talking many hypotheticals here.
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,698
    Shooting at a mosque in Norway
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,923

    I'm not pretending anything, anyone who objects to the words "peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations" being on a coin is pathetic. Say that you agree with the sentiment but dislike Brexit, that's reasonable. Acting all outraged and saying you're that angry you'll deface coins . . . that's just sad.
    Fake moron.
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,923
    nichomar said:

    It was an attempt to respond to your pseudo trumpism comment where it’s is unfortunate that we have to now have to measure our politicians on a trump like scale which to me implies we have now reached the bottom of the barrel. I was not implying that you had ‘rich paymasters’ just allowing my frustration to run away with itself because I feel this whole situation has been engineered for their own financial benefit. Sorry if it went a bit wrong because I actually agree with you
    I see (I think). But I wasn't using "pseudo-Trumpian" as a random insult. I really think it's the same strategy that Trump is following - say what you think your perceived core support wants to hear, and don't bother about offending anyone else.
  • El_CapitanoEl_Capitano Posts: 4,244

    Lower than a rattlesnake's genital warts.....
    It's witty repartee like this that keeps me coming back to PB time after time.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483

    I'm not pretending anything, anyone who objects to the words "peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations" being on a coin is pathetic. Say that you agree with the sentiment but dislike Brexit, that's reasonable. Acting all outraged and saying you're that angry you'll deface coins . . . that's just sad.
    Simple question. How much has brexit cost you since the day of the referendum? Have you had to pay anything for your principals, will you have to in the future?
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,923
    And I'll just say that I'm off now to do something more worthwhile.

    So if Philip is about to post another lengthy critique of his own straw man arguments, he mustn't get upset if I don't respond.
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 34,587
    malcolmg said:

    says cheating turncoat loser. A perfect Lib Dem, lower than a rattlesnakes belly.
    Don’t know why Malcolm, but I get the idea you’re anti LibDem.

    Pity, because some speak highly of you!
  • Chris said:


    Still having trouble with that basic English comprehension, eh?

    What I said was that _you_ were _pretending_ to be moronic, when you portrayed people who objected to this commemorative coin as disagreeing with the sentiments expressed in the motto.

    And then I said no one could really be that moronic. I rest my case!

    Proper little internet tough guy aren't you.

    No doubt sat in your underpants in a bedsit under a bare lightbulb.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    Chris said:

    I see (I think). But I wasn't using "pseudo-Trumpian" as a random insult. I really think it's the same strategy that Trump is following - say what you think your perceived core support wants to hear, and don't bother about offending anyone else.
    Exactly
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 20,177
    rcs1000 said:

    Certainly not. What century do you think this is?
    Maybe David Davis can sort it out.
  • Pro_RataPro_Rata Posts: 5,568
    edited August 2019

    I'm not pretending anything, anyone who objects to the words "peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations" being on a coin is pathetic. Say that you agree with the sentiment but dislike Brexit, that's reasonable. Acting all outraged and saying you're that angry you'll deface coins . . . that's just sad.
    If one were a North Korean dissident one might object to the term Democratic People's Republic of North Korea without being against the wider principles of democracy, the people or republics. I think a lot of us would feel a peaceful, prosperous, friendly Brexit is a similarly rankling and absurdly, knowingly dishonest juxtaposition.
  • OnlyLivingBoyOnlyLivingBoy Posts: 16,408

    I'm not pretending anything, anyone who objects to the words "peace, prosperity and friendship with all nations" being on a coin is pathetic. Say that you agree with the sentiment but dislike Brexit, that's reasonable. Acting all outraged and saying you're that angry you'll deface coins . . . that's just sad.
    The coin is Brexit in microcosm - stupid, dishonest, a pointless waste of time. The 48% have repeatedly been told "you lost, suck it up," we have few ways of registering our disgust at this nonsense. It is a bit sad, but it will genuinely make me happy to take a masonry drill to one of these pathetic pieces of currency once in a while, a small futile act of rebellion against all the shite. You can make us endure Brexit, but we will never tire of telling you how crap it is. Suck it up!
  • Pro_Rata said:

    If one were a North Korean dissident one might object to the term Democratic People's Republic of North Korea without being against the wider principles of democracy, the people or republics. I think a lot of us would feel a peaceful, prosperous, friendly Brexit is a similarly rankling and absurdly, knowingly dishonest juxtaposition.
    Yes, there's a lot of remainacs about - if they don't like the "juxtapose" they've still got time to fuck off to continental Europe. Hurry though, you're running out of time.
  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 43,363
    I'm sure he is but what does Elton think?

    https://twitter.com/thehill/status/1160236638183796736?s=20
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    A better slogan for the Brexit coin would be “nostalgia for Empire and hatred of immigrants”.
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,698

    I'm sure he is but what does Elton think?

    https://twitter.com/thehill/status/1160236638183796736?s=20

    I'm confused as to how the death will impact sales of Irn Bru
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 73,575

    Maybe David Davis can sort it out.
    To misquote Ronald Reagan, the most terrifying words in the English language are 'I'm David Davis and I'm here to help.'
  • A better slogan for the Brexit coin would be “nostalgia for Empire and hatred of immigrants”.

    If you are a swivel-eyed loon driven to madness by democracy delivering a decision you hate then yes...that would indeed be a better slogan.
  • The coin is Brexit in microcosm - stupid, dishonest, a pointless waste of time. The 48% have repeatedly been told "you lost, suck it up," we have few ways of registering our disgust at this nonsense. It is a bit sad, but it will genuinely make me happy to take a masonry drill to one of these pathetic pieces of currency once in a while, a small futile act of rebellion against all the shite. You can make us endure Brexit, but we will never tire of telling you how crap it is. Suck it up!
    Win/win. If that's going to genuinely make you happy then its a good thing we are getting these coins. Its giving you an outlet for your frustrations and making you genuinely happy.

    What's not to like?
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,698

    A better slogan for the Brexit coin would be “nostalgia for Empire and hatred of immigrants”.

    Not just immigrants Mr M, all foreigners.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340

    If you are a swivel-eyed loon driven to madness by democracy delivering a decision you hate then yes...that would indeed be a better slogan.
    Delivered by a campaign of xenophobic lies. So a very apt slogan.
  • jayfdeejayfdee Posts: 618
    Well my vote at a possible imminent GE would be for whoever has the best chance of avoiding Brexit. After this is achieved, if indeed it can be, then normal service will be resumed, and then I will choose whoever best represents my views.
    I am a bit worried I will be out of the UK from mid October to mid November,getting my annual adrenaline fix in the the Himalaya with very little internet or mobile, hope I can get back to the UK OK.
  • Chris said:

    Oh - and as for "ignoring your long reply" - please do bear in mind that some of us don't spend our whole life glued to this website, as it seems you do.

    If you really posted a long reply explaining yet again why a straw man argument of your own invention was invalid, then it really just bears out what I've just said. You talk nonsense, and when someone points out it's nonsense, you just generate several tons more of the stuff to try to cover it up.
    I'm not glued to this website, I can go hours or days not logging on. This site can get quite addictive though, I doubt I'm the only person here who finds it quite addictive.
  • kinabalukinabalu Posts: 44,830
    Chris said:

    I see (I think). But I wasn't using "pseudo-Trumpian" as a random insult. I really think it's the same strategy that Trump is following - say what you think your perceived core support wants to hear, and don't bother about offending anyone else.

    Nobody in modern western democratic politics has the particular combination of disgusting personality and character traits that are brought together in the organism we know as Donald Trump. He is unique and just as Hitler should not be compared with anyone else, nor should Trump. Trump is like Hitler in this respect.
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,698
    So I guess the Treasury will be delivering 700 million of these 50p coins to the NHS every week.
  • Chris said:

    And I'll just say that I'm off now to do something more worthwhile.

    So if Philip is about to post another lengthy critique of his own straw man arguments, he mustn't get upset if I don't respond.

    I didn't critique my own argument, you asked me a question and I replied. You kept repeating the question, I kept replying. Not my fault if you act dumb or don't understand the answer.
  • Delivered by a campaign of xenophobic lies. So a very apt slogan.
    Ah, the sweet salty tears of remainers.
  • anothernickanothernick Posts: 3,591
    rcs1000 said:

    I'm currently in the Department of Motor Vehicles, renewing my driving license. It is the greatest social leveller. You can be Tim Cook, or Michael Bloomberg, or the most humble undocumented migrant, and you'll be waiting on the same queue, in the same uncomfortable chairs.

    It's surprising how slow the home of silicon valley is to adopt the latest technologies - they were well behind Europe in bringing in chip and pin authorisation for card payments. In 2016 when I had to submit returns to the IRS on behalf of my then employer I was amazed to be told that they had to be completed on paper and then faxed - there was no online system and the IRS did not accept email!
  • OnlyLivingBoyOnlyLivingBoy Posts: 16,408

    Win/win. If that's going to genuinely make you happy then its a good thing we are getting these coins. Its giving you an outlet for your frustrations and making you genuinely happy.

    What's not to like?
    This actually makes more sense than most of the things you say.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483

    Delivered by a campaign of xenophobic lies. So a very apt slogan.
    Where do these highly charged new posters come from, mostly on the leave side with a very antagonistic attitude who then fade after about two weeks?
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 20,177
    edited August 2019

    It's surprising how slow the home of silicon valley is to adopt the latest technologies - they were well behind Europe in bringing in chip and pin authorisation for card payments. In 2016 when I had to submit returns to the IRS on behalf of my then employer I was amazed to be told that they had to be completed on paper and then faxed - there was no online system and the IRS did not accept email!
    I’m 27 and I’ve never seen, never mind use, a fax machine.
  • jayfdeejayfdee Posts: 618

    I’m 27 and I’ve never seen, never mind use, a fax machine.
    Try using a Telex machine. For some reason all transport orders in my business had to be confirmed by Telex.
    I can remember a business trip to the US and was amazed at how primitive their mobile phones were, circa 2004.
  • I’m 27 and I’ve never seen, never mind use, a fax machine.
    Doesn't surprise me. I'm 37 and I've only seen one in one workplace and it was phased out 14 years ago. Its absurd anyone using it in the 21st century.
  • nichomar said:


    Where do these highly charged new posters come from, mostly on the leave side with a very antagonistic attitude who then fade after about two weeks?

    Originally?

    Spanish father/English mother, lived abroad for many years, speak a couple of languages, believe in democracy.

    What about you?
  • nichomar said:

    Where do these highly charged new posters come from, mostly on the leave side with a very antagonistic attitude who then fade after about two weeks?
    I think we can class Meeks as a long term poster - and I don't think he's leave either...
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,698

    I’m 27 and I’ve never seen, never mind use, a fax machine.
    When I was 27 I'd never used a mobile phone.
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,887
    edited August 2019
    Scott_P said:
    I for one think this coin is the perfect metaphor for Brexit. Let's embrace it.

    Brexiteers opt not to use the second half of Jefferson's sentence - entangling alliances with none - which is the bit they really mean. So they refer to "Peace and Friendship" as a Freemasons' code for the real meaning.

    This coin manages to be highly insulting, disingenuous and bombastic all at the same time. But that's what Brexit is all about.
  • Ah, the sweet salty tears of remainers.
    LOL. Mr Meeks makes me think of this video:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=929sn1qMCcM
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,698
    What is bizarre is people's business cards that still include a fax number.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340

    LOL. Mr Meeks makes me think of this video:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=929sn1qMCcM
    Are you still making up government policy positions this evening?
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    .

    I think we can class Meeks as a long term poster - and I don't think he's leave either...
    No he obviously isn’t but there are a lot of new posters coming in with what I find as antagonist views.
  • nichomar said:

    .

    No he obviously isn’t but there are a lot of new posters coming in with what I find as antagonist views.
    And the diehard remainers aren't antagonistic???
  • kinabalukinabalu Posts: 44,830

    A better slogan for the Brexit coin would be “nostalgia for Empire and hatred of immigrants”.

    Might not go quite that far but the aura around it is definitely more 'smell the glove' than 'love train'.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    FF43 said:

    I for one think this coin is the perfect metaphor for Brexit. Let's embrace it.

    Brexiteers opt not to use the second half of Jefferson's sentence - entangling alliances with none - which is the bit they really mean. So they refer to "Peace and Friendship" as a Freemasons' code for the real meaning.

    This coin manages to be highly insulting, disingenuous and bombastic all at the same time. But that's what Brexit is all about.
    I expect Remain / Rejoin campaigns will be collecting them for funds. And I expect Leave politicians will be receiving a lot of them, with sharpened edges thrown at force.
  • Gabs2Gabs2 Posts: 1,268

    I expect Remain / Rejoin campaigns will be collecting them for funds. And I expect Leave politicians will be receiving a lot of them, with sharpened edges thrown at force.
    This is Faragian. You don't explicitly advocate violence, you just bring up ways it could be done.


  • And I expect Leave politicians will be receiving a lot of them, with sharpened edges thrown at force.

    I don't doubt it having seen the feral state of many of the remainers on here.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,365
    rcs1000 said:

    Certainly not. What century do you think this is?
    I renewed mine by post ;)
  • anothernickanothernick Posts: 3,591

    When I was 27 I'd never used a mobile phone.
    When I was 27 mobile phones had only been available in the UK for a year, they were the size of a brick and almost as heavy.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483

    Originally?

    Spanish father/English mother, lived abroad for many years, speak a couple of languages, believe in democracy.

    What about you?

    I’m not going to give you my cv but speak Spanish, have held positions of elected responsibility in the UK and run multi million pound operations from Moscow to New Jersey. There is a pattern of very strong opinionated poster arriving here, making a point and then disappearing.
  • Gabs2Gabs2 Posts: 1,268
    nichomar said:

    Where do these highly charged new posters come from, mostly on the leave side with a very antagonistic attitude who then fade after about two weeks?
    Presumably those with an antagonistic attitude get banned or shadow banned.
  • Yas - I did have that cheeky flutter on Spurs - still down for the season, natch.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 73,575

    When I was 27 mobile phones had only been available in the UK for a year, they were the size of a brick and almost as heavy.
    Still got one of those. Also a first generation digital phone. Use it for teaching about change over time. Slap it down next to my IPhone and get them comparing.

    The bit that always bewilders them is the SIM card.
  • Are you still making up government policy positions this evening?
    How was I wrong about the policy? What I said is as I understand the policy, if its not can you please explain the difference?
  • CaptainBuzzkillCaptainBuzzkill Posts: 335
    edited August 2019
    nichomar said:


    No he obviously isn’t but there are a lot of new posters coming in with what I find as antagonist views.

    You may be right but tbf I haven't seen many leavers suggesting politicians are going to be attacked with sharpened coins.
  • CatManCatMan Posts: 3,228
    For what it's worth, I'm pretty sure this new 50p coin was announced ages ago.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    Gabs2 said:

    This is Faragian. You don't explicitly advocate violence, you just bring up ways it could be done.
    Do you really expect the serried ranks of pb commenters to rise up and launch an intifada on the basis of a nod and wink from me? Get a grip.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    S

    How was I wrong about the policy? What I said is as I understand the policy, if its not can you please explain the difference?
    The government policy is not, as you claimed, simply to remove the backstop.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    Gabs2 said:

    Presumably those with an antagonistic attitude get banned or shadow banned.
    I very much doubt it OGH actively encourages different view points and also defends many I wouldn’t. Very few get banned but although I have been around quietly under one or two guises (memory problems) since 2004 others will know better
  • DennisBetsDennisBets Posts: 244
    nichomar said:


    I’m not going to give you my cv but speak Spanish, have held positions of elected responsibility in the UK and run multi million pound operations from Moscow to New Jersey. There is a pattern of very strong opinionated poster arriving here, making a point and then disappearing.

    May we humbly ask? What do strongly opinionated mere working class remainers get then? A ration of West country Cheese and a Nicola Sturgeon engraved special edition bottle opener?
  • Gabs2Gabs2 Posts: 1,268

    Do you really expect the serried ranks of pb commenters to rise up and launch an intifada on the basis of a nod and wink from me? Get a grip.
    Sadly, I have seen far too many ideas rise from the cesspit of social media to impact national politics in recent years. I will continue to call out all winks and nods to violence wherever I see them.
  • S

    The government policy is not, as you claimed, simply to remove the backstop.
    On the subject of Ireland, which is what we were discussing, yes it is. If I have missed something please explain what?
  • nichomar said:


    I’m not going to give you my cv but speak Spanish, have held positions of elected responsibility in the UK and run multi million pound operations from Moscow to New Jersey. There is a pattern of very strong opinionated poster arriving here, making a point and then disappearing.


    And here we have Exhibit A of a typical remainer.

  • CatManCatMan Posts: 3,228
    edited August 2019
    As a Remainer (almost an Ultra-Remainer), I still think we should respect the referendum (as moronic as it was) and leave. The trouble is, Leavers seem to be doing everything they can to ensure that when we do eventually leave the EU, our stay outside will be as short as possible.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340

    On the subject of Ireland, which is what we were discussing, yes it is. If I have missed something please explain what?
    Government policy is to replace the backstop with a different means of meeting the EU’s concerns. However, it has no alternative to offer.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483


    May we humbly ask? What do strongly opinionated mere working class remainers get then? A ration of West country Cheese and a Nicola Sturgeon engraved special edition bottle opener?
    Fuck me you’ve lost me there
  • PaulyPauly Posts: 897

    Do you really expect the serried ranks of pb commenters to rise up and launch an intifada on the basis of a nod and wink from me? Get a grip.
    Words Matter.
  • anothernickanothernick Posts: 3,591
    nichomar said:

    I very much doubt it OGH actively encourages different view points and also defends many I wouldn’t. Very few get banned but although I have been around quietly under one or two guises (memory problems) since 2004 others will know better
    It's best to ignore posts designed to antagonise. Engaging with them only encourages them.
  • DennisBetsDennisBets Posts: 244
    nichomar said:

    Fuck me you’ve lost me there
    A common response; I'll go back to the Glemorangie :)
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483



    And here we have Exhibit A of a typical remainer.

    Yes and bloody proud of it. What have you ever done for the community you live in?
  • CatMan said:

    As a Remainer (almost an Ultra-Remainer), I still think we should respect the referendum (as moronic as it was) and leave. The trouble is, Leavers seem to be doing everything they can to ensure that when we do eventually leave the EU, our stay outside will be as short as possible.

    If a political party (or coalition) was elected at a future GE on a manifesto of re-joining (with or without a referendum) then I would be jumping from a great height on any leaver trying to thwart it.

    Democracy has to be respected in letter AND spirit and if that means accepting something you intensely dislike so be it.

    Trying to subvert a huge democratic mandate through nebulous justifications is the action of the ignorant.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483

    A common response; I'll go back to the Glemorangie :)
    😀
  • RogerRoger Posts: 20,475
    Christ! A load of escapees from Guido's. Floater must have been out with his sandwich board again.
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,887

    I expect Remain / Rejoin campaigns will be collecting them for funds. And I expect Leave politicians will be receiving a lot of them, with sharpened edges thrown at force.
    I don't approve of that. If some way could be found to deface the coin with a "Bollocks to Brexit" message and then put it back into circulation - that would be an entirely worthwhile gesture IMO
  • CatManCatMan Posts: 3,228

    If a political party (or coalition) was elected at a future GE on a manifesto of re-joining (with or without a referendum) then I would be jumping from a great height on any leaver trying to thwart it.

    Democracy has to be respected in letter AND spirit and if that means accepting something you intensely dislike so be it.

    Trying to subvert a huge democratic mandate through nebulous justifications is the action of the ignorant.
    Then let's leave in an orderly careful way which does the least damage and respects that most people (including a lot of Leavers) want a close relationship with Europe, as was promised during the campaign.

    Instead we've gone from that to "We need to get out any way possible and screw the consequences". I don't think that's a good strategy if you want to make leaving the EU a success.
This discussion has been closed.