politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » The Thatcher polling continues….Best PM since ’45 and her g
Comments
-
Nice EdM comment on Maggie and climate change0
-
And he then made a cheap shot about hugging huskies - FAIL. There are years to make such jibes, not now.MikeSmithson said:Nice EdM comment on Maggie and climate change
0 -
That's a great speech by Milliband.0
-
Overall Milliband is having a good Thatcher. A bad one may have hurt him, a good one won't make much difference, but he may gain a notch or two on 'can be seen as PM'0
-
Socially, Labour and UKIP voters come from similar backgrounds (although their values are quite different).antifrank said:And on the negatives of Mrs Thatcher's tenure of office, UKIP voters' responses in some respects are very similar to those of Labour voters' responses. Both groups are far more concerned about the decline in mining and manufacturing and privatisations than either Lib Dem or Conservative voters.
0 -
Milliband genuinely outstanding.0
-
RT @BBCPropaganda: Ed Miliband wanted to be Margaret Thatcher a few months ago http://t.co/DCUBVL1IdS #BBCDP0
-
Excellent speeches from both Cameron & Miliband - who managed the tricky balance between praise and acknowledging differences well.0
-
Denis Skinner is not in the House.0
-
Agreed. This could have been very tricky for him but he's surmounted the hurdles.Jonathan said:Milliband genuinely outstanding.
Labour chose the right Miliband.
0 -
Ed rises to the moment.0
-
It is amazing how cars could go from looking so great in the 50s and 60s to looking so utterly crap in the 70s and early 80s.....taffys said:Great example of a mediocre replacement of better designs.
As was that ludicrous flying wedge of boxiness, the Austin Princess.
It was the complete lack of pride that really got me. Even the features these cars had were only grudgingly put there because the competition had them.
Left to their own devices, they would have been producing trabants.0 -
That's not surprising, when you consider that one in six UKIP supporters put themselves on the left of the political spectrum.antifrank said:Interesting to see that 5% of UKIP voters hate Mrs Thatcher so much that they regard her as having no achievements that they are prepared to pick as greatest. The only other party with a non-negligible number of nil responses is Labour.
0 -
Plato said:
Denis Skinner is not in the House.
The first bench in front of LibDems where Skinner, Ronnie Campbell, John Cryer and the old school leftish Labourites usually sit is almost totally empty (there just 1 man at the very end of it).
0 -
Overall - I'd give EdM 8/10 for that.
Cameron was excellent as he always is on such occasions.0 -
How you react to someone's death often says a lot more about you, then it does about them...0
-
I would suggest an alteration to: 'Although we are told their values are quiet different.'Sean_F said:
Socially, Labour and UKIP voters come from similar backgrounds (although their values are quite different).antifrank said:And on the negatives of Mrs Thatcher's tenure of office, UKIP voters' responses in some respects are very similar to those of Labour voters' responses. Both groups are far more concerned about the decline in mining and manufacturing and privatisations than either Lib Dem or Conservative voters.
I don't believe the values of the majority of Conservative voters and the majority of Labour voters are that different either.
Most want a fair society in which the vulnerable are protected, the cheats and spivs don't get away with it and the levels of crime are low. They may think there are different ways of arriving there.0 -
Quite.Slackbladder said:How you react to someone's death often says a lot more about you, then it does about them...
0 -
-
RT @DanHannanMEP: 'A man's right to work as he will, spend what he earns, have the State as servant not master: these are the British inheritance.' M Thatcher0
-
I'm not sure about Clegg's tone - he sounds like he's trying to make a dividing line here.
He's just used the 'no such thing as society' out of context quote.0 -
To be fair, in this matter I think his big brother would equally have risen to the occasion.MikeSmithson said:Agreed. This could have been very tricky for him but he's surmounted the hurdles.
Labour chose the right Miliband.0 -
Clegg not matching the standard set by Miliband.0
-
RT @jameschappers: Muttering on all sides. House not happy with Clegg's 'not simply heroine or villian' theme #thatcher0
-
Oh dear Clegg....0
-
I very much doubt that.RichardNabavi said:
To be fair, in this matter I think his big brother would equally have risen to the occasion.MikeSmithson said:Agreed. This could have been very tricky for him but he's surmounted the hurdles.
Labour chose the right Miliband.
0 -
0
-
Not able to listen in to the speech. Is it more LibDem fence-sitting? Lets not offend anyone and thus appear rather bland and beige?Plato said:RT @jameschappers: Muttering on all sides. House not happy with Clegg's 'not simply heroine or villian' theme #thatcher
0 -
0
-
Yep - suffers in comparison with Cameron (who didn't politicise it) and Miliband (who had trickiest job & pulled it off superbly).Plato said:I'm not sure about Clegg's tone - he sounds like he's trying to make a dividing line here.
He's just used the 'no such thing as society' out of context quote.
Good days for Cameron & Miliband....not so good for Clegg.
0 -
RT @HouseofTwits: RT @Keith_VazMP Excellent speeches by David Cameron and Ed Miliband in the Commons #thatchertributes0
-
-
TBH no, he came across as petulant. Taking the society comment out of context did it for me. He knows better than this. Silly man. Now is not the time for point-scoring.Anorak said:
Not able to listen in to the speech. Is it more LibDem fence-sitting? Lets not offend anyone and thus appear rather bland and beige?Plato said:RT @jameschappers: Muttering on all sides. House not happy with Clegg's 'not simply heroine or villian' theme #thatcher
RT @hopisen: Was going to say naturally Party leaders made good speeches, simple to praise person, critique policies gracefully. But then Clegg spoke..0 -
Is Gordon Brown there today?0
-
Hopefully Nuuala is in front of TV0
-
0
-
Lovely to see so much mirth and wit over Mrs T - that's the sign of a well respected leader - when you can poke fun but do it with a genuine smile and laughter with affection.0
-
Sir Malcie speaks, Nuala swoons !!0
-
Catching up on Clegg's speech, tbh of the three he gave the most accurate depiction of her.0
-
I read somewhere that Dennis Skinner and Maggie actually got on rather well person to person....not sure where I read it thoough0
-
I've always had a soft spot for Malcolm Rifkind - another great speech and anecdotes today in the Commons.
His son Hugo is a superb columnist.0 -
Tim Shipman tweets:
"No10 says 'True Blue' has been used as Whitehall codename for Thatcher funeral since at least 2006 under Blair. Oh dear, Andy Burnham"
Sounds like Nick Clegg has fallen to the occasion again0 -
By the mid 80s it was a pleasure going on international business as a Brit. We were so well respected that doors opened to us in ways that were shut to us in the 1970s. The change was down to Mrs T. Much respect and thanks.0
-
Looks like Angus Robertson is sinking to the occasion too.....0
-
Ken Livingstone seems to have left the DP programme on BBC2 in a huff... "off to do gardening" says Andrew Neil. Clearly did not like Neil pinning to him his admiration for the social market setup in Germany.0
-
Sir Malcolm Rifkind - a terrific speech. Best scotch politician ever.0
-
Gordon Brown available in cans - mean, flat and tasteless.AndreaParma_82 said:
0 -
@CarlottaVance
How hard can it be to just be nice when someone dies? Clearly a handful can't manage it despite many years in public life.0 -
Seven hours is overkill, surely. The party leaders, plus a few of the Tories in the house who knew her well would have been sufficient. I really enjoyed Redwood's speech: it was a genuine eye-opener. If he could come across like that more often he may have gone a lot further.0
-
Indeed we did. And as someone who was present at the Fabian Society meeting at which he declared his candidacy on the Saturday after the general election and decided to vote for him on the basis on what I thought the best political speech I had ever heard I am more than delighted that his skills are now becoming widely appreciated.MikeSmithson said:
Agreed. This could have been very tricky for him but he's surmounted the hurdles.Jonathan said:Milliband genuinely outstanding.
Labour chose the right Miliband.0 -
SouthamObserver said:
Seven hours is overkill, surely. T
what? are they going on for 7 hours?!!0 -
Non Thatcher Post (NTP):
Oh how the mighty have fallen. Andrew Wakefield, initiator of the bogus MMR scare, is no longer even named in an article about the topic. He's referred to as 'a surgeon'. Given the size of his ego, that's gotta hurt
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-220894850 -
Speech rankings so far:
Sir Malcolm Rifkind (perfect tone uniting house)
Ed Miliband (exceeded expectations)
David Cameron (met expectations)
.....
Nick Clegg (misjudged tone)
Angus Robertson (oh dear)0 -
Perhaps appearing on Jeremy Kyle would be appropriate? I've only seen the very occasional edition - but stumbled across it today - cripes, what a shocker it was and Mr Kyle did an excellent job of it.TCPoliticalBetting said:Ken Livingstone seems to have left the DP programme on BBC2 in a huff... "off to do gardening" says Andrew Neil. Clearly did not like Neil pinning to him his admiration for the social market setup in Germany.
Whatever one may think of his guests - he knows how to handle it and pin down the flakey with a mallet. Watching it on replay is worth it on many levels.0 -
We have just had Kinnock speak from his former SPAD Baroness Royall in the HoL on DP show whining about how little Thatcher did for female politicians.....0
-
Piffle - Clegg got it wrong. I've seen no one say he called it right bar a tiny handful of LD loyalists.corporeal said:
Clegg was too analytical, more than it was the right setting for.AveryLP said:Speech rankings so far:
Sir Malcolm Rifkind (perfect tone uniting house)
Ed Miliband (exceeded expectations)
David Cameron (met expectations)
.....
Nick Clegg (misjudged tone)
Angus Robertson (oh dear)0 -
0
-
Not surprised, for the first time since Thatcher died an interviewer has been throwing Livingstones real former positions back in his face - pointing out that he would have opposed the German Social Democratic model.TCPoliticalBetting said:Ken Livingstone seems to have left the DP programme on BBC2 in a huff... "off to do gardening" says Andrew Neil. Clearly did not like Neil pinning to him his admiration for the social market setup in Germany.
Alasdair MacDonnell of the SDLP showing how you do an 'I didn't like what she stood for' respectfully....
0 -
"picked the right Miliband"
Damned by faint praise....0 -
He was off on tone sure.Plato said:
Piffle - Clegg got it wrong. I've seen no one say he called it right bar a tiny handful of LD loyalists.corporeal said:
Clegg was too analytical, more than it was the right setting for.AveryLP said:Speech rankings so far:
Sir Malcolm Rifkind (perfect tone uniting house)
Ed Miliband (exceeded expectations)
David Cameron (met expectations)
.....
Nick Clegg (misjudged tone)
Angus Robertson (oh dear)
In terms of content he was more interesting and accurate than the other two, but not really the right setting for that.0 -
Mr g00 passim is in combative form as ever
RT @chrisg0000: @hilarybennmp Will you recognise that 500,000 Miners had been sacked before she even got in power? Somehow I bet you won't0 -
Kinnock is a welsh windbag. Thank goodness he never became Prime Minister.0
-
-
What about John Redwood? Or did I imagine that he spoke? I thought he was really good and gave an outstanding explanation of what Thatcherism was meant to be all about from one of its arch-proponents. I did not agree, but I could see exactly where he was coming from.AveryLP said:Speech rankings so far:
Sir Malcolm Rifkind (perfect tone uniting house)
Ed Miliband (exceeded expectations)
David Cameron (met expectations)
.....
Nick Clegg (misjudged tone)
Angus Robertson (oh dear)
I enjoyed Miliband's speech too - it showed real intelligence, as did Cameron's. Clegg was pretty dire it has to be said.
There's no need for any more now though. They should pack up and go.
0 -
Hodges:
Ed Miliband's tribute to Margaret Thatcher was perfectly judged: moving, eloquent, generous without fawning
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/danhodges/100211566/ed-milibands-tribute-to-margaret-thatcher-was-perfectly-judged-moving-eloquent-generous-without-fawning/?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter0 -
Neil is very good, has anyone seen Sky/BBC/ITV point out the rreal facts on mining job loss comparisons under Wilson, Thatcher etc?CarlottaVance said:
Not surprised, for the first time since Thatcher died an interviewer has been throwing Livingstones real former positions back in his face - pointing out that he would have opposed the German Social Democratic model.
0 -
Rubbish! Eden was a visionary. The Middle East would have none of the problems it has today if his attempt to quell Arab nationalism at the root had been allowed to succeed. Alas the Yanks thwarted it and then regretted it - one of the great blunders of US foreign policy.Dadge said:The people who voted for Eden must've had their tongue in their cheek, surely. I'd even rate Ted above him.
0 -
You can always turn off now, Southam.SouthamObserver said:
What about John Redwood? Or did I imagine that he spoke? I thought he was really good and gave an outstanding explanation of what Thatcherism was meant to be all about from one of its arch-proponents. I did not agree, but I could see exactly where he was coming from.AveryLP said:Speech rankings so far:
Sir Malcolm Rifkind (perfect tone uniting house)
Ed Miliband (exceeded expectations)
David Cameron (met expectations)
.....
Nick Clegg (misjudged tone)
Angus Robertson (oh dear)
I enjoyed Miliband's speech too - it showed real intelligence, as did Cameron's. Clegg was pretty dire it has to be said.
There's no need for any more now though. They should pack up and go.
I somehow feel you won't though.
Redwood gave a good speech, so did Nigel Dodds (?). As did Pantsdown in the other place: much better than Clegg. Howard a bit dry.0 -
Why have BBC TV transmissions in the North West been off air for several hours? Having to watch the HoC on a buffering computer.0
-
Conor Burns is very entertaining in the House.0
-
I turned off during Clegg.AveryLP said:
You can always turn off now, Southam.SouthamObserver said:
What about John Redwood? Or did I imagine that he spoke? I thought he was really good and gave an outstanding explanation of what Thatcherism was meant to be all about from one of its arch-proponents. I did not agree, but I could see exactly where he was coming from.AveryLP said:Speech rankings so far:
Sir Malcolm Rifkind (perfect tone uniting house)
Ed Miliband (exceeded expectations)
David Cameron (met expectations)
.....
Nick Clegg (misjudged tone)
Angus Robertson (oh dear)
I enjoyed Miliband's speech too - it showed real intelligence, as did Cameron's. Clegg was pretty dire it has to be said.
There's no need for any more now though. They should pack up and go.
I somehow feel you won't though.
Redwood gave a good speech, so did Nigel Dodds (?). As did Pantsdown in the other place: much better than Clegg. Howard a bit dry.
0 -
Tebbit on his feet (just).
"Can one imagine the concept of an Italian Maggie Thatcher?"
Andrea?0 -
A classy operator, Ed Miliband, isn't he?
No-one is underestimating him now, let alone thinking he's crap.0 -
Cameron and Miliband were both good.
Clegg never seems to pull off these big occasions, I'm not sure why?
It's either because he's not very good at writing/making speeches or its because he follows Cameron and Miliband and by the time you get to him everything that needs to be said has already been said.
Ultimately there is no party political advantage in this for anybody though.0 -
Much respect and thanks.
For me it was 1982 and Britain was still officially crap. I was watching the world snooker championship and the program was interrupted to bring you, utterly bizarrely, coverage of balaclava wearing MIBs hurtling through windows at the Iranian embassy.
Counter terrorism hadn't even been really heard of before. The 70s was one long line of surrender monkeys from all over the world giving in to militants.
Suddenly we weren;t the sick man of Europe. We were top dog at the world's coolest, most difficult and most dangerous activity.0 -
He was. It was a polished performance, with the right tone and dignity.tim said:Miliband was seriously impressive today
I'm trying to work out whether that's good or bad for him! Dan Hodges will tell us.
0 -
BBC's Robin Brant says it seems it was Esther McVey who heckled Clegg0
-
They never served milk to us at school! :-)AveryLP said:Tebbit on his feet (just).
"Can one imagine the concept of an Italian Maggie Thatcher?"
Andrea?0 -
If I have counted correctly, relying on the Guardian live blog, there have been eight speeches in the first hour of the debate, which would equate to 56 speeches in the full seven hours.SouthamObserver said:
Even with many Labour absentees, I would have thought there would be plenty enough MPs who will want to put their words on the record to keep the show going on that long.0 -
<blockquote class="Quote" rel="carl">A classy operator, Ed Miliband, isn't he?
No-one is underestimating him now, let alone thinking he's crap.</blockquote>
Sorry, but I still don't think Ed Miliband looks or acts in any way Prime Ministerial and assuming he somehow manages to luck his way into Downing Street because Cameron and Osborne are so useless, I would expect Ed Milibands time as Prime Minister to be nothing other than a complete and total disaster.0 -
Excellent contribution from Conor Burns.0
-
RT @MichaelLCrick: Tebbit, "She allowed me (after Brighton bomb) to run my (secretary of state's) office from my hospital bed."0
-
Nuala wouldnt let a tv screen come between her and her Malcie.AndreaParma_82 said:Hopefully Nuuala is in front of TV
Sorry, Sir Malcolm.
0 -
Gerald Kaufman doing a good job as well. Gracious stuff.0
-
Tebbit: "I regret not returning to government, out of conern for my wife, and so left her at the mercy of her friends"0
-
In the absence of policies.....the Jury is still out.....carl said:A classy operator, Ed Miliband, isn't he?
No-one is underestimating him now, let alone thinking he's crap.
If 'great performance on state occasions' was all that was required of a PM, Cameron would have few worries....
0 -
RT @JonathanArnott: UKIP membership has this afternoon passed 25,000. Tremendous news that the Party continues to grow at an astonishing rate.0
-
RT @BBCPropaganda: Dear Labour MPs, you should be taking lessons from Sir Gerald Kaufman. He understands how parliament is supposed to be.0
-
Yes - another one who has risen to the occasion - even pointing out the failings of some on his own side.....Plato said:Gerald Kaufman doing a good job as well. Gracious stuff.
0 -
Churchill won a World War. Attlee's government created the NHS. Thatcher boycotted the Moscow Olympics and passed Section 28.
Greatest PM , really ? O
At least, something good thing is happening. £10 million of public spending will take place because of the elaborate funeral.0 -
I hope this person receives the same vilification that she's urged for Maggie's death
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/margaret-thatcher/9984646/Woman-behind-street-parties-to-celebrate-death-of-Margaret-Thatcher-named.html0 -
I don't think that the Israeli raid on Entebbe was the action of surrender monkeys. Blowing in a few windows in Belgravia was a cinch in comparison.taffys said:Much respect and thanks.
For me it was 1982 and Britain was still officially crap. I was watching the world snooker championship and the program was interrupted to bring you, utterly bizarrely, coverage of balaclava wearing MIBs hurtling through windows at the Iranian embassy.
Counter terrorism hadn't even been really heard of before. The 70s was one long line of surrender monkeys from all over the world giving in to militants.
Suddenly we weren;t the sick man of Europe. We were top dog at the world's coolest, most difficult and most dangerous activity.0 -
There's a huge graffiti work near my office about the death of Thatcher. Some enterprising freelance photographer should snap it as I'm sure some 'papers would use it.0