Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » That was then. This is now.

17891012

Comments

  • Options
    MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 37,618

    Would be really interested to see maps from the following gamblers:

    @kinabalu

    @Pulpstar

    @Richard_Nabavi

    @Alistair

    @Casino_Royale

    @MaxPB

    image
    Click the map to create your own at 270toWin.com


    That's a nowcast, I think if the idiot rioters keep going then WI flips.
  • Options
    Scott_xPScott_xP Posts: 33,143

    Imposed by the EU

    Nope

    They would have extended.

    BoZo said no

    Self-inflicted
  • Options
    Barnesian said:

    I have just received a survey from CCHQ. (I'm a supporter*).

    It is a shining example of what an unbiased poll should be like.



    *I'm a supporter of the Tory, Labour, BXP and SNP parties so I get all their bumph and keep an eye on them. I'm actually a member of the LibDems.

    I agree with all of those points except the last, hence why I voted to Remain in the EU
  • Options

    So how many Tory MPs will Johnson be kicking out this time?

    Fewer than last time. The vast majority of Tory MPs will always put their party beofre their country.

  • Options
    NigelbNigelb Posts: 62,792
    Scott_xP said:
    The rule of law is now apparently limited to Parliament handing ministers the powers to do whatever they like.

    There seem to be quite a lot of people who don't understand that what is constitutionally possible is not necessarily justifiable.
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,086
    “Do you agree that all Parties should work together as one union, so we can boost our recovery and create jobs?”

    That’s such a weirdly worded question.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,989

    “Do you agree that all Parties should work together as one union, so we can boost our recovery and create jobs?”

    That’s such a weirdly worded question.

    Government of national unity incoming!
  • Options
    Scott_xP said:

    Imposed by the EU

    Nope

    They would have extended.

    BoZo said no

    Self-inflicted
    Imposed by Parliament and accepted by the EU

    I expect you will never find peace on brexit

    Whenever I log on including day or anytime of the night and early morning 24/7 your anti brexit posts absolutely dominate

    Time to get a life
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    edited September 2020

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
  • Options
    bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 21,894
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI
    I am stock piling Haggis
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,986
    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,047

    Scott_xP said:

    Imposed by the EU

    Nope

    They would have extended.

    BoZo said no

    Self-inflicted
    Imposed by Parliament and accepted by the EU

    I expect you will never find peace on brexit

    Whenever I log on including day or anytime of the night and early morning 24/7 your anti brexit posts absolutely dominate

    Time to get a life
    I trust you've sent a similar post to Mr Thompson.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,989
    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    Trump has really shot himself in his foot with his attitude to postal ballots, hasn't he?
  • Options
    glwglw Posts: 9,554
    I have to say I don't think I can recall anything the goverment has done before that has so little support on here. Even the prorogation had more support. Well done Boris, you are setting new records.
  • Options
    FF43FF43 Posts: 15,779
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    By default, yes. It's possible that losing at least two of your constituent nations AND becoming a rogue state as it did yesterday MIGHT shock England into deciding things can be handled better. So it joins EEA equivalent...
  • Options

    It's not Eire, it's called the Republic of Ireland

    My passport begs to differ...

    image
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,047
    RobD said:

    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    Trump has really shot himself in his foot with his attitude to postal ballots, hasn't he?
    It'll encourage his cries of CHEATING!!!!

    Sadly.
  • Options
    RH1992RH1992 Posts: 788
    New podium for the presser I see.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    Boris just arrived for his press conference on BBC1
  • Options
    Ooof thats an upswing
  • Options

    Blackford: The PM is a liar
    Speaker: I ask you to withdraw it
    Blackford: I do not withdraw it
    Speaker: I accept that you have withdrawn it.

    Eh?

    The Speaker could have named Blackford - but that would have simply helped the nationalist grievance mongers, so it was probably the least worst option...
    Running scared so prefer to add another lie to the circus
  • Options
    glwglw Posts: 9,554
    FF43 said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    By default, yes. It's possible that losing at least two of your constituent nations AND becoming a rogue state as it did yesterday MIGHT shock England into deciding things can be handled better. So it joins EEA equivalent...
    I've long believed that if you exhaust all the available options and requirements — respect the referendum, maintain the Union, no internal borders, frictionless trade with the EU — we would in a rational world come around to joining the EEA through EFTA or via a bespoke agreement. Perhaps Keir will do that when he becomes PM?
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,047
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    And of course vice versa.
    Mind it'll bring back the days of the Border Reivers, smuggling across the Cheviots.
  • Options

    Scott_xP said:

    Imposed by the EU

    Nope

    They would have extended.

    BoZo said no

    Self-inflicted
    Imposed by Parliament and accepted by the EU

    I expect you will never find peace on brexit

    Whenever I log on including day or anytime of the night and early morning 24/7 your anti brexit posts absolutely dominate

    Time to get a life
    I trust you've sent a similar post to Mr Thompson.
    I do not agree with Philip on breaching a treaty but I do support Brexit
  • Options
    FregglesFreggles Posts: 3,486

    If I wasn’t in hospital I’d be panic buying right now.

    Good reminder. I'm on Morrisons online right now.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    edited September 2020
    FF43 said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    By default, yes. It's possible that losing at least two of your constituent nations AND becoming a rogue state as it did yesterday MIGHT shock England into deciding things can be handled better. So it joins EEA equivalent...
    Actually if Scotland goes it increases the chances England and Wales will never rejoin the EEA as without Scotland the Leave majority would be much bigger in the remainder of the UK and that would be even more pronounced if NI left too, England and Wales both having voted Leave. Plus all the SNP MPs would go from Westminster who Starmer probably needs to back him to become PM and shift to a soft Brexit deal with the EU
  • Options
    MaxPB said:

    Would be really interested to see maps from the following gamblers:

    @kinabalu

    @Pulpstar

    @Richard_Nabavi

    @Alistair

    @Casino_Royale

    @MaxPB

    image
    Click the map to create your own at 270toWin.com


    That's a nowcast, I think if the idiot rioters keep going then WI flips.
    Although this isn't a crazy map as a possible outcome if the race narrows (and you could make an argument it will probably narrow as we approach the line as Trump is a pretty formidable campaigner), it seems harsh on Biden if you mean right now. I'd see this more as a forecast than a nowcast.

    The most recent four polls in North Carolina show a narrow Biden lead, averages tend to show a narrow lead for him in Florida, and no pollsters have anything but a Biden lead in Arizona just now (some fairly big, some smaller). It's going against the evidence to say Biden right now doesn't have a narrow lead in at least one or two of those.
  • Options
    glw said:

    FF43 said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    By default, yes. It's possible that losing at least two of your constituent nations AND becoming a rogue state as it did yesterday MIGHT shock England into deciding things can be handled better. So it joins EEA equivalent...
    I've long believed that if you exhaust all the available options and requirements — respect the referendum, maintain the Union, no internal borders, frictionless trade with the EU — we would in a rational world come around to joining the EEA through EFTA or via a bespoke agreement. Perhaps Keir will do that when he becomes PM?
    I agree
  • Options

    RobD said:

    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    Trump has really shot himself in his foot with his attitude to postal ballots, hasn't he?
    It'll encourage his cries of CHEATING!!!!

    Sadly.
    That, I fear, is the point. A cynical ruse to encourage voting fraud so he can prove there was voting fraud.
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,086
    HYUFD said:

    FF43 said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    By default, yes. It's possible that losing at least two of your constituent nations AND becoming a rogue state as it did yesterday MIGHT shock England into deciding things can be handled better. So it joins EEA equivalent...
    Actually if Scotland goes it increases the chances England and Wales will never rejoin the EEA as without Scotland the Leave majority would be much bigger in the remainder of the UK and that would be even more pronounced if NI left too, England and Wales both having voted Leave. Plus all the SNP MPs would go from Westminster who Starmer probably needs to back him to become PM and shift to a soft Brexit deal with the EU
    The Leave majority *now* compared to the Leave majority after a year of “no deal” is impossible to compare.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,986
    edited September 2020
    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    Delving further into the tea leaves, ballots returned so far 1287:

    Dem 791, GOP 129, Others 367.

    Some good news for Trump though, NC GOP registered military have outreturned their ballots so far 24 to 16 for the Democrats.
  • Options

    Imposed by the EU

    [stuff snipped]


    Imposed by Parliament and accepted by the EU ...

    So, not imposed by the EU then?
  • Options
    MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 37,618

    MaxPB said:

    Would be really interested to see maps from the following gamblers:

    @kinabalu

    @Pulpstar

    @Richard_Nabavi

    @Alistair

    @Casino_Royale

    @MaxPB

    image
    Click the map to create your own at 270toWin.com


    That's a nowcast, I think if the idiot rioters keep going then WI flips.
    Although this isn't a crazy map as a possible outcome if the race narrows (and you could make an argument it will probably narrow as we approach the line as Trump is a pretty formidable campaigner), it seems harsh on Biden if you mean right now. I'd see this more as a forecast than a nowcast.

    The most recent four polls in North Carolina show a narrow Biden lead, averages tend to show a narrow lead for him in Florida, and no pollsters have anything but a Biden lead in Arizona just now (some fairly big, some smaller). It's going against the evidence to say Biden right now doesn't have a narrow lead in at least one or two of those.
    I'm allocating a majority of DKs to Trump as shy voters.
  • Options
    FF43FF43 Posts: 15,779
    glw said:

    FF43 said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    By default, yes. It's possible that losing at least two of your constituent nations AND becoming a rogue state as it did yesterday MIGHT shock England into deciding things can be handled better. So it joins EEA equivalent...
    I've long believed that if you exhaust all the available options and requirements — respect the referendum, maintain the Union, no internal borders, frictionless trade with the EU — we would in a rational world come around to joining the EEA through EFTA or via a bespoke agreement. Perhaps Keir will do that when he becomes PM?
    Me too... I always assumed the UK would end up in a form of the Vassal State for the reasons you give. It would contradict the reasons for Brexiting in the first place - taking back control, which is why it hasn't happened yet. I didn't expect Johnson's curve ball on the choosing a Withdrawal Agreement with an Irish Sea border. Given where we are now, I am much more pessimistic of it all going horribly wrong.

    Key thing though is all this nonsense was set up by that fateful referendum decision in June 2016.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131

    HYUFD said:

    FF43 said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    By default, yes. It's possible that losing at least two of your constituent nations AND becoming a rogue state as it did yesterday MIGHT shock England into deciding things can be handled better. So it joins EEA equivalent...
    Actually if Scotland goes it increases the chances England and Wales will never rejoin the EEA as without Scotland the Leave majority would be much bigger in the remainder of the UK and that would be even more pronounced if NI left too, England and Wales both having voted Leave. Plus all the SNP MPs would go from Westminster who Starmer probably needs to back him to become PM and shift to a soft Brexit deal with the EU
    The Leave majority *now* compared to the Leave majority after a year of “no deal” is impossible to compare.
    Under FPTP it only needs 40-45% for a majority for No Deal for ever, not even 50%+ as in the referendum.

    England voted 53.4% Leave, Wales 52.5% Leave
  • Options
    Do not post any insinuations or rumours unless these have been published elsewhere in the reputable press.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    I hope Boris does not forget the 'i' when talking about his 'rule of six'
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,086
    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    Delving further into the tea leaves, ballots returned so far 1287:

    Dem 791, GOP 129, Others 367.

    Some good news for Trump though, NC GOP registered military have outreturned their ballots so far 24 to 16 for the Democrats.
    You’re saying that Trump is only winning 24-16 with GOP registered military personnel? That’s good news?
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,086
    edited September 2020
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    FF43 said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    By default, yes. It's possible that losing at least two of your constituent nations AND becoming a rogue state as it did yesterday MIGHT shock England into deciding things can be handled better. So it joins EEA equivalent...
    Actually if Scotland goes it increases the chances England and Wales will never rejoin the EEA as without Scotland the Leave majority would be much bigger in the remainder of the UK and that would be even more pronounced if NI left too, England and Wales both having voted Leave. Plus all the SNP MPs would go from Westminster who Starmer probably needs to back him to become PM and shift to a soft Brexit deal with the EU
    The Leave majority *now* compared to the Leave majority after a year of “no deal” is impossible to compare.
    Under FPTP it only needs 40-45% for a majority for No Deal for ever, not even 50%+ as in the referendum.

    England voted 53.4% Leave, Wales 52.5% Leave
    I repeat my previous comment.

    The Leave majority *now* compared to the Leave majority after a year of “no deal” is impossible to compare.

    We don’t know what the future holds.
  • Options

    HYUFD said:

    FF43 said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    By default, yes. It's possible that losing at least two of your constituent nations AND becoming a rogue state as it did yesterday MIGHT shock England into deciding things can be handled better. So it joins EEA equivalent...
    Actually if Scotland goes it increases the chances England and Wales will never rejoin the EEA as without Scotland the Leave majority would be much bigger in the remainder of the UK and that would be even more pronounced if NI left too, England and Wales both having voted Leave. Plus all the SNP MPs would go from Westminster who Starmer probably needs to back him to become PM and shift to a soft Brexit deal with the EU
    The Leave majority *now* compared to the Leave majority after a year of “no deal” is impossible to compare.
    Nothing is possible to compare without a Tardis. If we go to no deal now then that doesn't last forever - if after a couple of years people are happy with the arrangements then the next election will be fought on non-Brexit issues and life will move on. If people are unhappy a party can put a manifesto pledge to change arrangements.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    edited September 2020
    Boris to introduce 'Covid Marshalls' in every town and city
  • Options
    We're tracking France for cases, more action will be needed
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,989
    HYUFD said:

    Boris to introduce 'Covid Marshalls' in every town and city

    Armed, if necessary? :D
  • Options
    RobD said:

    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    Trump has really shot himself in his foot with his attitude to postal ballots, hasn't he?
    Unless, I suppose, GOP people really do vote in person while his lawyers can ensure a couple of percent of the (much more Democrat) postal vote is excluded on various technicalities.

    I'd assume he can't target individual Democrat votes for exclusion (i.e. it's blind to who was actually voted for), but his lawyers can generally target postal votes if he is confident that means excluding far more Democrats than Republicans in practice.

    It's the same with making it hard for particular communities to register or suppressing black turnout via social media fake news - yes, he'll lose a few votes himself that way, but that's fine as long as the group he is targeting is mainly (albeit not exclusively) Democrat.
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,086

    HYUFD said:

    FF43 said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    By default, yes. It's possible that losing at least two of your constituent nations AND becoming a rogue state as it did yesterday MIGHT shock England into deciding things can be handled better. So it joins EEA equivalent...
    Actually if Scotland goes it increases the chances England and Wales will never rejoin the EEA as without Scotland the Leave majority would be much bigger in the remainder of the UK and that would be even more pronounced if NI left too, England and Wales both having voted Leave. Plus all the SNP MPs would go from Westminster who Starmer probably needs to back him to become PM and shift to a soft Brexit deal with the EU
    The Leave majority *now* compared to the Leave majority after a year of “no deal” is impossible to compare.
    Nothing is possible to compare without a Tardis. If we go to no deal now then that doesn't last forever - if after a couple of years people are happy with the arrangements then the next election will be fought on non-Brexit issues and life will move on. If people are unhappy a party can put a manifesto pledge to change arrangements.
    Yes that’s exactly what I said.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    Timetable for larger audiences and returns to stadiums of audiences to be revised but Boris makes clear no new lockdown, aim to avoid a second lockdown and schools and businesses to stay open Covid secure
  • Options
    This is quite draconian and much more forceful than the rest of the union

    It will be interesting how the other parts of the union react
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,086
    Covid marshals :D Who are these people going to be?
  • Options

    Covid marshals :D Who are these people going to be?

    Wyatt Earp tribute acts ?
  • Options
    welshowlwelshowl Posts: 4,460
    FF43 said:

    glw said:

    FF43 said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    By default, yes. It's possible that losing at least two of your constituent nations AND becoming a rogue state as it did yesterday MIGHT shock England into deciding things can be handled better. So it joins EEA equivalent...
    I've long believed that if you exhaust all the available options and requirements — respect the referendum, maintain the Union, no internal borders, frictionless trade with the EU — we would in a rational world come around to joining the EEA through EFTA or via a bespoke agreement. Perhaps Keir will do that when he becomes PM?
    Me too... I always assumed the UK would end up in a form of the Vassal State for the reasons you give. It would contradict the reasons for Brexiting in the first place - taking back control, which is why it hasn't happened yet. I didn't expect Johnson's curve ball on the choosing a Withdrawal Agreement with an Irish Sea border. Given where we are now, I am much more pessimistic of it all going horribly wrong.

    Key thing though is all this nonsense was set up by that fateful referendum decision in June 2016.
    Surely there’s a mention to the blatant reneging on a referendum on the European Constitution ( conveniently renamed the Lisbon Treaty of course).

    Had that been honoured, after all three main UK parties backed it at the 2005 election, there would’ve been the chance for the voters to actually a say on the direction of European travel. And had the voters said “no thanks” ( and I think they would have ) it would’ve actually been a signal to change direction.

    Alas no. They ran from the voters, and doubled down, and let the pressure build.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,986

    RobD said:

    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    Trump has really shot himself in his foot with his attitude to postal ballots, hasn't he?
    Unless, I suppose, GOP people really do vote in person while his lawyers can ensure a couple of percent of the (much more Democrat) postal vote is excluded on various technicalities.

    I'd assume he can't target individual Democrat votes for exclusion (i.e. it's blind to who was actually voted for), but his lawyers can generally target postal votes if he is confident that means excluding far more Democrats than Republicans in practice.

    It's the same with making it hard for particular communities to register or suppressing black turnout via social media fake news - yes, he'll lose a few votes himself that way, but that's fine as long as the group he is targeting is mainly (albeit not exclusively) Democrat.
    The Dems have the Governorship of North Carolina now though.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,989
    The ideal test would be one you can do at home and takes a few minutes without having to send it to a lab. I wonder if that is even feasible?
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 117,131
    Theatres and workplaces to be able to test for Covid so those negative can attend them
  • Options
    MaxPB said:

    MaxPB said:

    Would be really interested to see maps from the following gamblers:

    @kinabalu

    @Pulpstar

    @Richard_Nabavi

    @Alistair

    @Casino_Royale

    @MaxPB

    image
    Click the map to create your own at 270toWin.com


    That's a nowcast, I think if the idiot rioters keep going then WI flips.
    Although this isn't a crazy map as a possible outcome if the race narrows (and you could make an argument it will probably narrow as we approach the line as Trump is a pretty formidable campaigner), it seems harsh on Biden if you mean right now. I'd see this more as a forecast than a nowcast.

    The most recent four polls in North Carolina show a narrow Biden lead, averages tend to show a narrow lead for him in Florida, and no pollsters have anything but a Biden lead in Arizona just now (some fairly big, some smaller). It's going against the evidence to say Biden right now doesn't have a narrow lead in at least one or two of those.
    I'm allocating a majority of DKs to Trump as shy voters.
    Historically, the evidence has tended to be that late undecideds break disproportionately for challengers rather than incumbents.

    There's some debate over that - some say it's a null effect and it's basically 50/50 - but there doesn't seem to be a lot of evidence of the opposite effect.
  • Options
    HYUFD said:

    Theatres and workplaces to be able to test for Covid so those negative can attend them

    Eventually but no date
  • Options
    MangoMango Posts: 1,013
    Pulpstar said:

    Dura_Ace said:

    coach said:



    Just leave Boris and we can get on with our lives.

    At least Carrie did.
    Leaving your wife to be cucked by Zac Goldsmith :D
    I just sicked a bit.
  • Options
    AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    @Pulpstar Do you know you can get the returns as well? So you can see on what date everyone who has requestesd a ballot has returned it.

    So 791 Registered Democrats have returned a valid ballot
    Only 179 Registered GOP have returned a ballot
    367 Independent, Libertarian or Greens have returned a ballot

    The North Carolina data is bonkers open. I'm getting this data from a spread sheet with names and addresses. This is all cross referencable with previous elections so you can track relative performance.
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,047
    RobD said:

    The ideal test would be one you can do at home and takes a few minutes without having to send it to a lab. I wonder if that is even feasible?

    Like a pregnancy test? Not sure I see why not, in principle.
  • Options
    Alistair said:

    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    @Pulpstar Do you know you can get the returns as well? So you can see on what date everyone who has requestesd a ballot has returned it.

    So 791 Registered Democrats have returned a valid ballot
    Only 179 Registered GOP have returned a ballot
    367 Independent, Libertarian or Greens have returned a ballot

    The North Carolina data is bonkers open. I'm getting this data from a spread sheet with names and addresses. This is all cross referencable with previous elections so you can track relative performance.
    Can you compare how these voters have switched since 2016?

    We could then calculate the swing since 2016?
  • Options
    He actually mentioned Spring and that is the first time I have ever heard a projection that far but to be honest it does not surprise me at all
  • Options
    i can't see this having much direct impact. Seems to me this is a slide towards another full lockdown, but with maybe schools open.
  • Options
    contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818

    Covid marshals :D Who are these people going to be?

    Wyatt Earp tribute acts ?
    What legal powers will the COVID marshalls have?

  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,989

    RobD said:

    The ideal test would be one you can do at home and takes a few minutes without having to send it to a lab. I wonder if that is even feasible?

    Like a pregnancy test? Not sure I see why not, in principle.
    Yeah. If there was you could imagine the government providing everyone with enough for a test every few days/week. That'd really help keep outbreaks small.
  • Options
    Really good summary from 538 on the GOP vote suppression tactics. Could easily make a difference in places like FL

    https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-latest-on-republican-efforts-to-make-it-harder-to-vote/
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,989

    Covid marshals :D Who are these people going to be?

    Wyatt Earp tribute acts ?
    What legal powers will the COVID marshalls have?

    Summary execution for non-compliance with mask regs.
  • Options
    Scott_xPScott_xP Posts: 33,143

    Like a pregnancy test? Not sure I see why not, in principle.

    There is a great thread on Twitter on "digital" pregnancy tests...
  • Options
    FF43 said:

    glw said:

    FF43 said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    How do you arrive at no border with Northern Ireland or Ireland, but a border with Scotland?
    As if Scotland leaves the UK to rejoin the EU/EEA it will have to face the same tariffs the rest of the EU/EEA (including the Republic of Ireland) will face on export of their goods and services to England and Wales after a no trade deal Brexit.

    Northern Ireland remains part of the UK so the UK government will minimise any border from GB to NI and from NI to Eire under the GFA
    By default, yes. It's possible that losing at least two of your constituent nations AND becoming a rogue state as it did yesterday MIGHT shock England into deciding things can be handled better. So it joins EEA equivalent...
    I've long believed that if you exhaust all the available options and requirements — respect the referendum, maintain the Union, no internal borders, frictionless trade with the EU — we would in a rational world come around to joining the EEA through EFTA or via a bespoke agreement. Perhaps Keir will do that when he becomes PM?
    Me too... I always assumed the UK would end up in a form of the Vassal State for the reasons you give. It would contradict the reasons for Brexiting in the first place - taking back control, which is why it hasn't happened yet. I didn't expect Johnson's curve ball on the choosing a Withdrawal Agreement with an Irish Sea border. Given where we are now, I am much more pessimistic of it all going horribly wrong.

    Key thing though is all this nonsense was set up by that fateful referendum decision in June 2016.
    EEA is what all the logic points to, even now. And it's in the UK's interest to go there directly, rather than via 3-5-10 years of circling round the plughole of trying to do something else. And if EEA+/- is the endpoint, then it simply isn't compatible with Dom's Master Plan, so we might as well not bother with that.

    I get the visceral need some have for a clean break, the freedom and culture always trump economics idea. (Though that's much easier to say early in the 21st century, when life, even at the bottom of the UK heap, is better than it is for many around the world.) But without wishing it, I forsee a huge humiliation a'coming. Accepting that we have to do this damn silly thing, do we really have to do it in this damn silly way?
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,563
    UK cases, by specimen date, scaled by 100K population

    image
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,563
    UK cases, by specimen date

    image
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,047
    Alistair said:

    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    @Pulpstar Do you know you can get the returns as well? So you can see on what date everyone who has requestesd a ballot has returned it.

    So 791 Registered Democrats have returned a valid ballot
    Only 179 Registered GOP have returned a ballot
    367 Independent, Libertarian or Greens have returned a ballot

    The North Carolina data is bonkers open. I'm getting this data from a spread sheet with names and addresses. This is all cross referencable with previous elections so you can track relative performance.
    That's worse than 18th C stuff, before the secret ballot. We had a discussion the other day about how the US needed taking aside and showing how a real democracy worked.
  • Options

    Covid marshals :D Who are these people going to be?

    Wyatt Earp tribute acts ?
    What legal powers will the COVID marshalls have?

    I assume that is part of legislation and maybe explains why this does not come into force until monday
  • Options
    contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818
    The Covid Marshalls are clearly there to break up demonstrations and protests. Also probably to enforce the curfew when it inevitably comes.

    Those freedoms you gave up?

    You aren't getting them back.

  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,563
    UK case summaries -

    image
    image
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,986
    Alistair said:

    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    @Pulpstar Do you know you can get the returns as well? So you can see on what date everyone who has requestesd a ballot has returned it.

    So 791 Registered Democrats have returned a valid ballot
    Only 179 Registered GOP have returned a ballot
    367 Independent, Libertarian or Greens have returned a ballot

    The North Carolina data is bonkers open. I'm getting this data from a spread sheet with names and addresses. This is all cross referencable with previous elections so you can track relative performance.
    I've got the same data but from an aggregated dataset. 5 columns, First is Civi/Mili/One-stop/Overseas. 2nd is party affiliation, 3rd is gender (2 white republicans of undesignated gender have returned ballots), 4th is race, 5th is tally.
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,563
    UK Hospitals

    image
    image
  • Options
    MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 44,563
    UK Deaths - 28 day cutoff

    image
    image
  • Options
    HYUFD said:

    Boris to introduce 'Covid Marshalls' in every town and city

    So we now have our own version of the Stasi?
  • Options
    MangoMango Posts: 1,013
    Freggles said:

    I'm all for electoral reform but what on earth is the point in having AV for the American Presidency??? Congress, I can understand, but in a two-party system when electing to a single office..?
    It makes perfect sense, as it is not a de jure two-party system, only de facto. Nice to be able to vote green or libertarian (or even one of the crazy not-so-closet fascists) and still have a say.

    Better than the shit sandwich we get on this side of the water, at least.
  • Options
    contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818

    Alistair said:

    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    @Pulpstar Do you know you can get the returns as well? So you can see on what date everyone who has requestesd a ballot has returned it.

    So 791 Registered Democrats have returned a valid ballot
    Only 179 Registered GOP have returned a ballot
    367 Independent, Libertarian or Greens have returned a ballot

    The North Carolina data is bonkers open. I'm getting this data from a spread sheet with names and addresses. This is all cross referencable with previous elections so you can track relative performance.
    That's worse than 18th C stuff, before the secret ballot. We had a discussion the other day about how the US needed taking aside and showing how a real democracy worked.
    So the government can impose a whole new strata of policing, drawn from people who may have no training, without let or sanction?

    Is this North Korea?
  • Options
    Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 26,907
    Does anyone know where they get the UK Covid-19 data from? It must be some type of sampling.
  • Options
    BTW, those slogans on the front of Boris's podium are incorrect. They should read

    Hands - Face - Facepalm

    ;)
  • Options
    MangoMango Posts: 1,013
    HYUFD said:

    Scott_xP said:
    No, there will be no hard border with Eire and no border in the Irish Sea under this government. Boris will block indyref2 and if Scotland goes under no deal to rejoin EU that means tariffs on Scottish exports to England and vice versa
    Your forgot no tanks in Baghdad.

    Only in Edinburgh.
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 32,047

    Alistair said:

    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    @Pulpstar Do you know you can get the returns as well? So you can see on what date everyone who has requestesd a ballot has returned it.

    So 791 Registered Democrats have returned a valid ballot
    Only 179 Registered GOP have returned a ballot
    367 Independent, Libertarian or Greens have returned a ballot

    The North Carolina data is bonkers open. I'm getting this data from a spread sheet with names and addresses. This is all cross referencable with previous elections so you can track relative performance.
    That's worse than 18th C stuff, before the secret ballot. We had a discussion the other day about how the US needed taking aside and showing how a real democracy worked.
    So the government can impose a whole new strata of policing, drawn from people who may have no training, without let or sanction?

    Is this North Korea?
    Are you talking to me?
  • Options
    AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670

    Alistair said:

    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    @Pulpstar Do you know you can get the returns as well? So you can see on what date everyone who has requestesd a ballot has returned it.

    So 791 Registered Democrats have returned a valid ballot
    Only 179 Registered GOP have returned a ballot
    367 Independent, Libertarian or Greens have returned a ballot

    The North Carolina data is bonkers open. I'm getting this data from a spread sheet with names and addresses. This is all cross referencable with previous elections so you can track relative performance.
    Can you compare how these voters have switched since 2016?

    We could then calculate the swing since 2016?
    Obviously we can't see how they voted but we can check to see who has switched registration. We can also compare the response rate of people who requested a postal vote in 2016 vs the exact same people who have requested a postal vote in 2020.
  • Options
    contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818

    HYUFD said:

    Boris to introduce 'Covid Marshalls' in every town and city

    So we now have our own version of the Stasi?
    Perhaps this is something we could all unite behind. Who the feck are these guys?
  • Options
    contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818
    The reason for that is so we swallow these new restrictions withouyt question.

    The Freedoms we had are not coming back. Indeed, more are being taken away.
  • Options
    Alistair said:

    Alistair said:

    Pulpstar said:

    NC Daily absentee request 710,798

    Dem 368171 (+9548)
    GOP 116852 (+4619)
    IND 223278 (+7478)

    There were 45637 ballots total requested at the same point in 2016.

    @Pulpstar Do you know you can get the returns as well? So you can see on what date everyone who has requestesd a ballot has returned it.

    So 791 Registered Democrats have returned a valid ballot
    Only 179 Registered GOP have returned a ballot
    367 Independent, Libertarian or Greens have returned a ballot

    The North Carolina data is bonkers open. I'm getting this data from a spread sheet with names and addresses. This is all cross referencable with previous elections so you can track relative performance.
    Can you compare how these voters have switched since 2016?

    We could then calculate the swing since 2016?
    Obviously we can't see how they voted but we can check to see who has switched registration. We can also compare the response rate of people who requested a postal vote in 2016 vs the exact same people who have requested a postal vote in 2020.
    Cool, I feel a project coming on.
  • Options
    Beibheirli_CBeibheirli_C Posts: 7,981
    edited September 2020
    :D:D:D

    Did somebody just reach up his trouser leg?

    image
  • Options

    BTW, those slogans on the front of Boris's podium are incorrect. They should read

    Hands - Face - Facepalm

    ;)

    Actually the three slogans are sensible and easy to understand
  • Options
    Scott_xP said:
    Working from home is working in a covid-secure environment.
  • Options
    The Government should have released a video saying about hands, face and space and left it at that.

    Yet again the communications "experts" can't communicate a simple message
  • Options

    RobD said:

    The ideal test would be one you can do at home and takes a few minutes without having to send it to a lab. I wonder if that is even feasible?

    Like a pregnancy test? Not sure I see why not, in principle.
    Pregnancy tests are much simpler than Covid tests as it's just a test for a hormone in the unprocessed urine. Conveniently, there's a particular hormone which is only present when a woman is pregnant, so it's fairly simple to get a chemical which reacts with that hormone but not with other stuff commonly present in pee.

    However, it's not that simple with Covid - there's quite a lot of processing involved to extract and chemically process the RNA before you even get to test.
This discussion has been closed.