I agree. The Tories must be better than a 4% chance. Not favourites, mind, but much more likely than that. Depends how much Boris' more Brexity than Nige has cut through. And how much the candidate's conviction has been an issue.
I agree. The Tories must be better than a 4% chance. Not favourites, mind, but much more likely than that. Depends how much Boris' more Brexity than Nige has cut through. And how much the candidate's conviction has been an issue.
I suspect Boris will do better than many on here expect but not enough due to the selection of the wrong candidate..
A rare chance for me to agree with HY that this will probably see a narrow LD win.
Sitting at home as a PB keyboard warrior I’d have confidently predicted a convincing LibDem gain. Having spent three days driving around the north of the constituency I am not so sure.
The LibDems aren’t fighting a directly anti-Brexit campaign because there are an awful lot of Brexity people there (many living in holiday parks originally designed as short term summer rental that are now entirely owner occupied). The LDs are fighting the better organised campaign, but the geographical realities of the seat are that it is very difficult to reach very many of the voters. The LDs are being careful not to attack Davies directly, using phrases such as “an MP who put Brecon on the map for the wrong reasons” to keep the issue obliquely in voters’ minds.
I think the LDs are home principally because Brexit Party Ltd. are spending a lot of money direct mailing leave voters within the constituency. And so the result will probably be Eastleigh redux.
It is very unlikely this will have made any difference either way in this seat.
How many times do I have to remind people that this is a seat that isn't bound by national political norms?
If its close it could have made the difference.
No, because the people who voted first will be the ones who were least likely to change their minds. I am guessing incidentally they were probably also disproportionately Liberal Democrats not Conservatives, another way in which this seat doesn't follow norms.
Hmm, may pop along to CCHQ then on Thursday evening for some last minute phoning in Brecon to get out the vote.
I think it will be a narrow LD win though even with the Boris bounce and Davies more popular than expected
Who on earth would you be ringing? Landlines?
In this part of the UK I imagine landlines are still very much essential!
The LD campaign is finding that its phone number records contain a lot of wrong numbers - suggesting that the trend toward mobiles is well underway even in a poor rural area like Brecon. Because it is hard to get there physically, the LDs have a lot of members volunteering to phone canvass from home, but there aren’t enough reliable contact numbers to keep them all occupied.
Hmm, may pop along to CCHQ then on Thursday evening for some last minute phoning in Brecon to get out the vote.
I think it will be a narrow LD win though even with the Boris bounce and Davies more popular than expected
Who on earth would you be ringing? Landlines?
In this part of the UK I imagine landlines are still very much essential!
The LD campaign is finding that its phone number records contain a lot of wrong numbers - suggesting that the trend toward mobiles is well underway even in a poor rural area like Brecon. Because it is hard to get there physically, the LDs have a lot of members volunteering to phone canvass from home, but there aren’t enough reliable contact numbers to keep them all occupied.
To an extent it's a pity the fraudster won't win - he would fit right in with the new cabinet..
If he does win it's a pretty shocking indictment of the Liberal Democrats.
Win or lose, both sides picked the wrong candidates. The Conservatives may have felt they were boxed into a corner given the local controversy over the recall petition. What is the Yellows' excuse?
I have been pootling around the provinces for a week.
I have returned to civilisation with two conclusions.
1. People are still talking about politics WAY more than usual. And it's not just "oh god, groan, Brexit" - people are genuinely engaged and interested, in a way they never were before. This is good?
2. Boris is popular. There is a feeling that he is the man, for all his many faults, who will "get Brexit done". I think this is delusional, but there we are. He is definitely enjoying a honeymoon.
I agree. The Tories must be better than a 4% chance. Not favourites, mind, but much more likely than that. Depends how much Boris' more Brexity than Nige has cut through. And how much the candidate's conviction has been an issue.
In betting terms they have a 4% chance. In reality they have no chance, so I won't be risking a worn farthing on a Tory win. My prediction is for the LDs to be 10 percentage points ahead of them.
The view on the ground is that the ascent of Bozo has won back Brexit Party Ltd. voters from the Tories, but done nothing to stem the flow of Tory remainers toward the LibDems. Insofar as the timing of the postal voters are concerned (and it is true that almost every postal voter I met over the weekend had already sent theirs back), it would hang on the balance between leaver and remainer PVs.
Hmm, may pop along to CCHQ then on Thursday evening for some last minute phoning in Brecon to get out the vote.
I think it will be a narrow LD win though even with the Boris bounce and Davies more popular than expected
Who on earth would you be ringing? Landlines?
In this part of the UK I imagine landlines are still very much essential!
The LD campaign is finding that its phone number records contain a lot of wrong numbers - suggesting that the trend toward mobiles is well underway even in a poor rural area like Brecon. Because it is hard to get there physically, the LDs have a lot of members volunteering to phone canvass from home, but there aren’t enough reliable contact numbers to keep them all occupied.
Or that a lot of people are switching to non-BT phone suppliers?
I know it's supposed to be easy to keep your number but from bitter experience it isn't.
I get the feeling that if the Tory candidate wasn't a crook then the Tories would win this, I've heard from multiple sources that his conviction has been mentioned by the voters.
Over the weekend we saw the Tories get a Boris bounce, likely ephemeral, I admire Matt Singh a lot but the one thing we learned in 2015 that constituency polling is bloody hard to do.
But at 26s I thought it was value, I'm expecting the Lib Dems to win this.
I have been pootling around the provinces for a week.
I have returned to civilisation with two conclusions.
1. People are still talking about politics WAY more than usual. And it's not just "oh god, groan, Brexit" - people are genuinely engaged and interested, in a way they never were before. This is good?
2. Boris is popular. There is a feeling that he is the man, for all his many faults, who will "get Brexit done". I think this is delusional, but there we are. He is definitely enjoying a honeymoon.
As a self declared remain voter, your view of these developments is....?
I have been pootling around the provinces for a week.
I have returned to civilisation with two conclusions.
1. People are still talking about politics WAY more than usual. And it's not just "oh god, groan, Brexit" - people are genuinely engaged and interested, in a way they never were before. This is good?
2. Boris is popular. There is a feeling that he is the man, for all his many faults, who will "get Brexit done". I think this is delusional, but there we are. He is definitely enjoying a honeymoon.
When you use the word "provinces", which bits do you mean?
The Conservative candidate cannot be that popular otherwise 10,000 would not have signed the petition. Presuming they will not vote for him he clearly has a big problem to overcome.
I have been pootling around the provinces for a week.
I have returned to civilisation with two conclusions.
1. People are still talking about politics WAY more than usual. And it's not just "oh god, groan, Brexit" - people are genuinely engaged and interested, in a way they never were before. This is good?
2. Boris is popular. There is a feeling that he is the man, for all his many faults, who will "get Brexit done". I think this is delusional, but there we are. He is definitely enjoying a honeymoon.
When you use the word "provinces", which bits do you mean?
I have been pootling around the provinces for a week.
I have returned to civilisation with two conclusions.
1. People are still talking about politics WAY more than usual. And it's not just "oh god, groan, Brexit" - people are genuinely engaged and interested, in a way they never were before. This is good?
2. Boris is popular. There is a feeling that he is the man, for all his many faults, who will "get Brexit done". I think this is delusional, but there we are. He is definitely enjoying a honeymoon.
The Conservative candidate cannot be that popular otherwise 10,000 would not have signed the petition. Presuming they will not vote for him he clearly has a big problem to overcome.
That doesn't follow. You would have found 10,000 voters in Blackburn to recall Jack Straw in 2003, yet he was personally very popular.
Just because 20% dislike him enough to sack him doesn't mean a significant chunk of the remaining 80% do as well.
I have been pootling around the provinces for a week.
I have returned to civilisation with two conclusions.
1. People are still talking about politics WAY more than usual. And it's not just "oh god, groan, Brexit" - people are genuinely engaged and interested, in a way they never were before. This is good?
2. Boris is popular. There is a feeling that he is the man, for all his many faults, who will "get Brexit done". I think this is delusional, but there we are. He is definitely enjoying a honeymoon.
When you use the word "provinces", which bits do you mean?
I have been pootling around the provinces for a week.
I have returned to civilisation with two conclusions.
1. People are still talking about politics WAY more than usual. And it's not just "oh god, groan, Brexit" - people are genuinely engaged and interested, in a way they never were before. This is good?
2. Boris is popular. There is a feeling that he is the man, for all his many faults, who will "get Brexit done". I think this is delusional, but there we are. He is definitely enjoying a honeymoon.
When you use the word "provinces", which bits do you mean?
He's probably been way out of the metropolis to distant Bucks and Essex.
I have been pootling around the provinces for a week.
I have returned to civilisation with two conclusions.
1. People are still talking about politics WAY more than usual. And it's not just "oh god, groan, Brexit" - people are genuinely engaged and interested, in a way they never were before. This is good?
2. Boris is popular. There is a feeling that he is the man, for all his many faults, who will "get Brexit done". I think this is delusional, but there we are. He is definitely enjoying a honeymoon.
When you use the word "provinces", which bits do you mean?
He means a rare adventure beyond the M25
No, I mean south of The River and north of The Heath, AND ALL PLACES BEYOND
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
I get the feeling that if the Tory candidate wasn't a crook then the Tories would win this, I've heard from multiple sources that his conviction has been mentioned by the voters.
Over the weekend we saw the Tories get a Boris bounce, likely ephemeral, I admire Matt Singh a lot but the one thing we learned in 2015 that constituency polling is bloody hard to do.
But at 26s I thought it was value, I'm expecting the Lib Dems to win this.
I get the feeling that if the Tory candidate wasn't a crook then the Tories would win this, I've heard from multiple sources that his conviction has been mentioned by the voters.
Over the weekend we saw the Tories get a Boris bounce, likely ephemeral, I admire Matt Singh a lot but the one thing we learned in 2015 that constituency polling is bloody hard to do.
But at 26s I thought it was value, I'm expecting the Lib Dems to win this.
The Tory remainers mention the MP’s misdemeanours as an additional reason why they might switch their vote. The Tory leavers aren’t bothered, more concerned with whether voting Tory or BXP Ltd. is the most effective pro-Brexit vote. Both Tory and BXP Ltd. campaigns are relying heavily on direct mail, so it is hard to read how this is playing out.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
I have been pootling around the provinces for a week.
I have returned to civilisation with two conclusions.
1. People are still talking about politics WAY more than usual. And it's not just "oh god, groan, Brexit" - people are genuinely engaged and interested, in a way they never were before. This is good?
2. Boris is popular. There is a feeling that he is the man, for all his many faults, who will "get Brexit done". I think this is delusional, but there we are. He is definitely enjoying a honeymoon.
When you use the word "provinces", which bits do you mean?
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Both of you are wrong. It won’t be the end of the honeymoon (although hopefully it will deflate it) and it won’t be purely down to local factors. If this by-election had taken place a year or two back - with no honeymoon and no counter-reaction to Brexit, the LibDems would have struggled. For one thing, they would probably be competing with PC and Green candidates.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Hmm, may pop along to CCHQ then on Thursday evening for some last minute phoning in Brecon to get out the vote.
I think it will be a narrow LD win though even with the Boris bounce and Davies more popular than expected
Who on earth would you be ringing? Landlines?
In this part of the UK I imagine landlines are still very much essential!
The LD campaign is finding that its phone number records contain a lot of wrong numbers - suggesting that the trend toward mobiles is well underway even in a poor rural area like Brecon. Because it is hard to get there physically, the LDs have a lot of members volunteering to phone canvass from home, but there aren’t enough reliable contact numbers to keep them all occupied.
Or that a lot of people are switching to non-BT phone suppliers?
I know it's supposed to be easy to keep your number but from bitter experience it isn't.
I don't answer the landline any more, so high are the odds that it is someone from Microsoft wanting my credit card details. And if I did answer a call from a pollster I think I would assume from their preamble and the fact that I didn't know them, that it was Microsoft again or a double glazing offer.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Both of you are wrong. It won’t be the end of the honeymoon (although hopefully it will deflate it) and it won’t be purely down to local factors. If this by-election had taken place a year or two back - with no honeymoon and no counter-reaction to Brexit, the LibDems would have struggled.
The one big thing on a national level if the Liberal Democrats win, is it makes an election potentially less attractive to the Tories who will see it as Copeland in reverse and at the same time rather more likely.
I have been pootling around the provinces for a week.
I have returned to civilisation with two conclusions.
1. People are still talking about politics WAY more than usual. And it's not just "oh god, groan, Brexit" - people are genuinely engaged and interested, in a way they never were before. This is good?
2. Boris is popular. There is a feeling that he is the man, for all his many faults, who will "get Brexit done". I think this is delusional, but there we are. He is definitely enjoying a honeymoon.
When you use the word "provinces", which bits do you mean?
He's probably been way out of the metropolis to distant Bucks and Essex.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
I get the feeling that if the Tory candidate wasn't a crook then the Tories would win this, I've heard from multiple sources that his conviction has been mentioned by the voters.
Over the weekend we saw the Tories get a Boris bounce, likely ephemeral, I admire Matt Singh a lot but the one thing we learned in 2015 that constituency polling is bloody hard to do.
But at 26s I thought it was value, I'm expecting the Lib Dems to win this.
Ephemeral? If Johnson continues to say nothing, refusing all media (recorded) interviews it could last forever. The BBC here in Wales have managed to construct a positive message from Johnson's silence today.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
I have been pootling around the provinces for a week.
I have returned to civilisation with two conclusions.
1. People are still talking about politics WAY more than usual. And it's not just "oh god, groan, Brexit" - people are genuinely engaged and interested, in a way they never were before. This is good?
2. Boris is popular. There is a feeling that he is the man, for all his many faults, who will "get Brexit done". I think this is delusional, but there we are. He is definitely enjoying a honeymoon.
When you use the word "provinces", which bits do you mean?
He means a rare adventure beyond the M25
No, I mean south of The River and north of The Heath, AND ALL PLACES BEYOND
The wonders of Thameslink from just down the road in St Pancras.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Erm....I think u missed the slightly lewd joke.
If you thought that was lewd I'm really proud of this picture I used in a PB thread header, I think it went over the heads of most PBers.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Erm....I think u missed the slightly lewd joke.
If you thought that was lewd I'm really proud of this picture I used in a PB thread header, I think it went over the heads of most PBers.
With all the talk of the Leave vote being split between the Tories and BXP I was surprised to see that there is a UKIP candidate too. How long will UKIP soldier on for, I wonder?
I get the feeling that if the Tory candidate wasn't a crook then the Tories would win this, I've heard from multiple sources that his conviction has been mentioned by the voters.
Over the weekend we saw the Tories get a Boris bounce, likely ephemeral, I admire Matt Singh a lot but the one thing we learned in 2015 that constituency polling is bloody hard to do.
But at 26s I thought it was value, I'm expecting the Lib Dems to win this.
Ephemeral? If Johnson continues to say nothing, refusing all media (recorded) interviews it could last forever. The BBC here in Wales have managed to construct a positive message from Johnson's silence today.
Hmm, may pop along to CCHQ then on Thursday evening for some last minute phoning in Brecon to get out the vote.
I think it will be a narrow LD win though even with the Boris bounce and Davies more popular than expected
If sheep could vote, he’d be home already.
Isn’t is weird how when it rains, the sheep don’t eat, move, or lie down, but simply stand where they are and fix their gaze on some spot on the horizon. Driving through the constituency this morning there were whole fields of sheep that might as well have been turned to stone.
I just wonder if the Lib Dems and Tories might be the only ones to keep their Welsh deposits.
All Remainers clearly being pointed in the LIb Dem direction, all leavers in the Tories'. Would be a heck of a comedown for the Brexit party but they seem to have had a lousy campaign and when you get squeezed in FPTP you get tiny vote shares. And as for Labour, where do you start at the moment?
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Both of you are wrong. It won’t be the end of the honeymoon (although hopefully it will deflate it) and it won’t be purely down to local factors. If this by-election had taken place a year or two back - with no honeymoon and no counter-reaction to Brexit, the LibDems would have struggled. For one thing, they would probably be competing with PC and Green candidates.
You're right. It won't remotely be the end of the honeymoon. No one gives a toss about a tiny by-election in rural Wales. They do care about Brexit (pro and anti). The result will not affect the narrative.
I reckon, on balance, Boris' honeymoon might last until October 31. Because much of the country is just willing him on. JUST GET IT DONE. And he is a comic relief after Theresa May.
If he fails to Brexit by Halloween (or he doesn't alter the narrative in another way, by - e.g. - winning an election) then he is fucked.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Both of you are wrong. It won’t be the end of the honeymoon (although hopefully it will deflate it) and it won’t be purely down to local factors. If this by-election had taken place a year or two back - with no honeymoon and no counter-reaction to Brexit, the LibDems would have struggled.
The one big thing on a national level if the Liberal Democrats win, is it makes an election potentially less attractive to the Tories who will see it as Copeland in reverse and at the same time rather more likely.
Being pedantic, if a LibDem win makes a GE both more and less likely can it really be such a 'big thing' or is it in fact irrelevant.
With all the talk of the Leave vote being split between the Tories and BXP I was surprised to see that there is a UKIP candidate too. How long will UKIP soldier on for, I wonder?
Until the donkey's honour is safe from marauding horses with homosexual tendencies.
Or they have all made complete asses of themselves.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Both of you are wrong. It won’t be the end of the honeymoon (although hopefully it will deflate it) and it won’t be purely down to local factors. If this by-election had taken place a year or two back - with no honeymoon and no counter-reaction to Brexit, the LibDems would have struggled. For one thing, they would probably be competing with PC and Green candidates.
You're right. It won't remotely be the end of the honeymoon. No one gives a toss about a tiny by-election in rural Wales. They do care about Brexit (pro and anti). The result will not affect the narrative.
I reckon, on balance, Boris' honeymoon might last until October 31. Because much of the country is just willing him on. JUST GET IT DONE. And he is a comic relief after Theresa May.
If he fails to Brexit by Halloween (or he doesn't alter the narrative in another way, by - e.g. - winning an election) then he is fucked.
... and if he achieves Brexit by No Dealing on 31st October he is also fucked (unfortunately, in that instance, so is the country).
With all the talk of the Leave vote being split between the Tories and BXP I was surprised to see that there is a UKIP candidate too. How long will UKIP soldier on for, I wonder?
Until the donkey's honour is safe from marauding horses with homosexual tendencies.
Or they have all made complete asses of themselves.
There is also a female Loony candidate, who I saw having a very nice cream tea in the Aspidistra Tea Rooms yesterday in the company of someone who looked very like the Howling Laud.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Erm....I think u missed the slightly lewd joke.
I did, yes.
You might say I blew that one...
Don't be too hard on yourself.
That pun was as it turns out a flop.
That's a flaccid response.
Come on, I'm doing my best.
Perhaps if you wait ten minutes you can try again.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Both of you are wrong. It won’t be the end of the honeymoon (although hopefully it will deflate it) and it won’t be purely down to local factors. If this by-election had taken place a year or two back - with no honeymoon and no counter-reaction to Brexit, the LibDems would have struggled. For one thing, they would probably be competing with PC and Green candidates.
You're right. It won't remotely be the end of the honeymoon. No one gives a toss about a tiny by-election in rural Wales. They do care about Brexit (pro and anti). The result will not affect the narrative.
I reckon, on balance, Boris' honeymoon might last until October 31. Because much of the country is just willing him on. JUST GET IT DONE. And he is a comic relief after Theresa May.
If he fails to Brexit by Halloween (or he doesn't alter the narrative in another way, by - e.g. - winning an election) then he is fucked.
In that latter case, at least as fellow remainers we’ll both be cheering!
I just wonder if the Lib Dems and Tories might be the only ones to keep their Welsh deposits.
All Remainers clearly being pointed in the LIb Dem direction, all leavers in the Tories'. Would be a heck of a comedown for the Brexit party but they seem to have had a lousy campaign and when you get squeezed in FPTP you get tiny vote shares. And as for Labour, where do you start at the moment?
The contest for 3rd could be interesting.
If the LDs fail to win, it will reduce the chances of pro-Remain party cooperation at any autumn GE.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Both of you are wrong. It won’t be the end of the honeymoon (although hopefully it will deflate it) and it won’t be purely down to local factors. If this by-election had taken place a year or two back - with no honeymoon and no counter-reaction to Brexit, the LibDems would have struggled.
The one big thing on a national level if the Liberal Democrats win, is it makes an election potentially less attractive to the Tories who will see it as Copeland in reverse and at the same time rather more likely.
Being pedantic, if a LibDem win makes a GE both more and less likely can it really be such a 'big thing' or is it in fact irrelevant.
Not necessarily. It might be the thing that finally triggers Mr Present But Not Involved to table a motion of no confidence.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Both of you are wrong. It won’t be the end of the honeymoon (although hopefully it will deflate it) and it won’t be purely down to local factors. If this by-election had taken place a year or two back - with no honeymoon and no counter-reaction to Brexit, the LibDems would have struggled. For one thing, they would probably be competing with PC and Green candidates.
You're right. It won't remotely be the end of the honeymoon. No one gives a toss about a tiny by-election in rural Wales. They do care about Brexit (pro and anti). The result will not affect the narrative.
I reckon, on balance, Boris' honeymoon might last until October 31. Because much of the country is just willing him on. JUST GET IT DONE. And he is a comic relief after Theresa May.
If he fails to Brexit by Halloween (or he doesn't alter the narrative in another way, by - e.g. - winning an election) then he is fucked.
... and if he achieves Brexit by No Dealing on 31st October he is also fucked (unfortunately, in that instance, so is the country).
"No one gives a toss about a tiny by-election in rural Wales."
Especially as first week in August. Half the country is away on holiday.
I just wonder if the Lib Dems and Tories might be the only ones to keep their Welsh deposits.
All Remainers clearly being pointed in the LIb Dem direction, all leavers in the Tories'. Would be a heck of a comedown for the Brexit party but they seem to have had a lousy campaign and when you get squeezed in FPTP you get tiny vote shares. And as for Labour, where do you start at the moment?
Given the effort they are making, I doubt that BXP Ltd. will do as badly as that.
Although you do raise one possible consequence of this by-election in that a bad BXP Ltd. performance, even with a LibDem win, might be the Tories’ opportunity to put them out of business. Raising the stakes considerably for the anti-Brexit parties, and for Labour still perched on its fence.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Erm....I think u missed the slightly lewd joke.
I did, yes.
You might say I blew that one...
Don't be too hard on yourself.
That pun was as it turns out a flop.
That's a flaccid response.
Come on, I'm doing my best.
Perhaps if you wait ten minutes you can try again.
You're foreskin me to keep this conversation going.
I get the feeling that if the Tory candidate wasn't a crook then the Tories would win this, I've heard from multiple sources that his conviction has been mentioned by the voters.
Over the weekend we saw the Tories get a Boris bounce, likely ephemeral, I admire Matt Singh a lot but the one thing we learned in 2015 that constituency polling is bloody hard to do.
But at 26s I thought it was value, I'm expecting the Lib Dems to win this.
Ephemeral? If Johnson continues to say nothing, refusing all media (recorded) interviews it could last forever. The BBC here in Wales have managed to construct a positive message from Johnson's silence today.
It will be ephemeral after sustained No Deal.
The Tories will poll single digits.
...but Alun Cairns today proposed that the loss of the EU market to welsh sheep farmers in the event of no deal will be offset by exploiting the hitherto untapped Japanese market for welsh lamb.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Erm....I think u missed the slightly lewd joke.
I did, yes.
You might say I blew that one...
Don't be too hard on yourself.
That pun was as it turns out a flop.
That's a flaccid response.
Come on, I'm doing my best.
Perhaps if you wait ten minutes you can try again.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Both of you are wrong. It won’t be the end of the honeymoon (although hopefully it will deflate it) and it won’t be purely down to local factors. If this by-election had taken place a year or two back - with no honeymoon and no counter-reaction to Brexit, the LibDems would have struggled.
The one big thing on a national level if the Liberal Democrats win, is it makes an election potentially less attractive to the Tories who will see it as Copeland in reverse and at the same time rather more likely.
Being pedantic, if a LibDem win makes a GE both more and less likely can it really be such a 'big thing' or is it in fact irrelevant.
Not necessarily. It might be the thing that finally triggers Mr Present But Not Involved to table a motion of no confidence.
Mr 'I went near the table, but I did not actually place a confidence motion on it'.
Hmm, may pop along to CCHQ then on Thursday evening for some last minute phoning in Brecon to get out the vote.
I think it will be a narrow LD win though even with the Boris bounce and Davies more popular than expected
If sheep could vote, he’d be home already.
Isn’t is weird how when it rains, the sheep don’t eat, move, or lie down, but simply stand where they are and fix their gaze on some spot on the horizon. Driving through the constituency this morning there were whole fields of sheep that might as well have been turned to stone.
Aren't the sheep the ones most worried by loss of CAP and then a tariff putting an end to sheep farming?
I just wonder if the Lib Dems and Tories might be the only ones to keep their Welsh deposits.
All Remainers clearly being pointed in the LIb Dem direction, all leavers in the Tories'. Would be a heck of a comedown for the Brexit party but they seem to have had a lousy campaign and when you get squeezed in FPTP you get tiny vote shares. And as for Labour, where do you start at the moment?
The contest for 3rd could be interesting.
If the LDs fail to win, it will reduce the chances of pro-Remain party cooperation at any autumn GE.
Third is surely BXP Ltd. Everyone else will lose their deposit.
Hmm, may pop along to CCHQ then on Thursday evening for some last minute phoning in Brecon to get out the vote.
I think it will be a narrow LD win though even with the Boris bounce and Davies more popular than expected
If sheep could vote, he’d be home already.
Isn’t is weird how when it rains, the sheep don’t eat, move, or lie down, but simply stand where they are and fix their gaze on some spot on the horizon. Driving through the constituency this morning there were whole fields of sheep that might as well have been turned to stone.
Aren't the sheep the ones most worried by loss of CAP and then a tariff putting an end to sheep farming?
The whole point about sheep is that they tend not to worry.
I just wonder if the Lib Dems and Tories might be the only ones to keep their Welsh deposits.
All Remainers clearly being pointed in the LIb Dem direction, all leavers in the Tories'. Would be a heck of a comedown for the Brexit party but they seem to have had a lousy campaign and when you get squeezed in FPTP you get tiny vote shares. And as for Labour, where do you start at the moment?
The contest for 3rd could be interesting.
If the LDs fail to win, it will reduce the chances of pro-Remain party cooperation at any autumn GE.
Third is surely BXP Ltd. Everyone else will lose their deposit.
If BXP Ltd don't lose their deposit, I can't see the Tories winning.
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
I just wonder if the Lib Dems and Tories might be the only ones to keep their Welsh deposits.
All Remainers clearly being pointed in the LIb Dem direction, all leavers in the Tories'. Would be a heck of a comedown for the Brexit party but they seem to have had a lousy campaign and when you get squeezed in FPTP you get tiny vote shares. And as for Labour, where do you start at the moment?
The contest for 3rd could be interesting.
If the LDs fail to win, it will reduce the chances of pro-Remain party cooperation at any autumn GE.
Third is surely BXP Ltd. Everyone else will lose their deposit.
If BXP Ltd don't lose their deposit, I can't see the Tories winning.
(Apols for the double-negative)
Having spent three days there, I can’t see them losing their deposit.
Hmm, may pop along to CCHQ then on Thursday evening for some last minute phoning in Brecon to get out the vote.
I think it will be a narrow LD win though even with the Boris bounce and Davies more popular than expected
If sheep could vote, he’d be home already.
Isn’t is weird how when it rains, the sheep don’t eat, move, or lie down, but simply stand where they are and fix their gaze on some spot on the horizon. Driving through the constituency this morning there were whole fields of sheep that might as well have been turned to stone.
Aren't the sheep the ones most worried by loss of CAP and then a tariff putting an end to sheep farming?
If the Tories do lose this by election I'll use the headline 'No honeymoon BJ'
And again, you will be drawing the wrong lesson. If they lose this election it will be due to local factors, and as identified because of a shall we say interesting choice of candidate.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Both of you are wrong. It won’t be the end of the honeymoon (although hopefully it will deflate it) and it won’t be purely down to local factors. If this by-election had taken place a year or two back - with no honeymoon and no counter-reaction to Brexit, the LibDems would have struggled. For one thing, they would probably be competing with PC and Green candidates.
You're right. It won't remotely be the end of the honeymoon. No one gives a toss about a tiny by-election in rural Wales. They do care about Brexit (pro and anti). The result will not affect the narrative.
I reckon, on balance, Boris' honeymoon might last until October 31. Because much of the country is just willing him on. JUST GET IT DONE. And he is a comic relief after Theresa May.
If he fails to Brexit by Halloween (or he doesn't alter the narrative in another way, by - e.g. - winning an election) then he is fucked.
... and if he achieves Brexit by No Dealing on 31st October he is also fucked (unfortunately, in that instance, so is the country).
What struck me in the Interviews With The Provincials is how many of them think: No Deal won't be so bad. And if it is, well fuck it, we went through the Blitz, we can cope with a Welsh Lamb blockade.
I do not agree with these sentiments. I think Brexit could be significantly and pointlessly bad for the Union, and the British economy - certainly over the long term - but there is no doubt this national mood is building. We can cope. Bring it on. Etc.
With all the talk of the Leave vote being split between the Tories and BXP I was surprised to see that there is a UKIP candidate too. How long will UKIP soldier on for, I wonder?
Until the donkey's honour is safe from marauding horses with homosexual tendencies.
Or they have all made complete asses of themselves.
There is also a female Loony candidate, who I saw having a very nice cream tea in the Aspidistra Tea Rooms yesterday in the company of someone who looked very like the Howling Laud.
Comments
Sorry, I meant first?
Only DavidL can be first here?
I think it will be a narrow LD win though even with the Boris bounce and Davies more popular than expected
How many times do I have to remind people that this is a seat that isn't bound by national political norms?
Sitting at home as a PB keyboard warrior I’d have confidently predicted a convincing LibDem gain. Having spent three days driving around the north of the constituency I am not so sure.
The LibDems aren’t fighting a directly anti-Brexit campaign because there are an awful lot of Brexity people there (many living in holiday parks originally designed as short term summer rental that are now entirely owner occupied). The LDs are fighting the better organised campaign, but the geographical realities of the seat are that it is very difficult to reach very many of the voters. The LDs are being careful not to attack Davies directly, using phrases such as “an MP who put Brecon on the map for the wrong reasons” to keep the issue obliquely in voters’ minds.
I think the LDs are home principally because Brexit Party Ltd. are spending a lot of money direct mailing leave voters within the constituency. And so the result will probably be Eastleigh redux.
To an extent it's a pity the fraudster won't win - he would fit right in with the new cabinet..
Win or lose, both sides picked the wrong candidates. The Conservatives may have felt they were boxed into a corner given the local controversy over the recall petition. What is the Yellows' excuse?
I have been pootling around the provinces for a week.
I have returned to civilisation with two conclusions.
1. People are still talking about politics WAY more than usual. And it's not just "oh god, groan, Brexit" - people are genuinely engaged and interested, in a way they never were before. This is good?
2. Boris is popular. There is a feeling that he is the man, for all his many faults, who will "get Brexit done". I think this is delusional, but there we are. He is definitely enjoying a honeymoon.
I know it's supposed to be easy to keep your number but from bitter experience it isn't.
Over the weekend we saw the Tories get a Boris bounce, likely ephemeral, I admire Matt Singh a lot but the one thing we learned in 2015 that constituency polling is bloody hard to do.
But at 26s I thought it was value, I'm expecting the Lib Dems to win this.
Just because 20% dislike him enough to sack him doesn't mean a significant chunk of the remaining 80% do as well.
Although I have no doubt it will be portrayed that way by the national media and become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
4% < Odds of Tories winning < 50%
You might say I blew that one...
The Tories will poll single digits.
Isn’t is weird how when it rains, the sheep don’t eat, move, or lie down, but simply stand where they are and fix their gaze on some spot on the horizon. Driving through the constituency this morning there were whole fields of sheep that might as well have been turned to stone.
All Remainers clearly being pointed in the LIb Dem direction, all leavers in the Tories'. Would be a heck of a comedown for the Brexit party but they seem to have had a lousy campaign and when you get squeezed in FPTP you get tiny vote shares. And as for Labour, where do you start at the moment?
I reckon, on balance, Boris' honeymoon might last until October 31. Because much of the country is just willing him on. JUST GET IT DONE. And he is a comic relief after Theresa May.
If he fails to Brexit by Halloween (or he doesn't alter the narrative in another way, by - e.g. - winning an election) then he is fucked.
Or they have all made complete asses of themselves.
If the LDs fail to win, it will reduce the chances of pro-Remain party cooperation at any autumn GE.
Especially as first week in August. Half the country is away on holiday.
Although you do raise one possible consequence of this by-election in that a bad BXP Ltd. performance, even with a LibDem win, might be the Tories’ opportunity to put them out of business. Raising the stakes considerably for the anti-Brexit parties, and for Labour still perched on its fence.
If LibDems win I get to celebrate the first puncturing of the Boris bluster machine.
If not, then I get £30 for a free Friday night curry.
(Apols for the double-negative)
https://twitter.com/rowena_kay/status/1156299853208653830?s=21
Only when it isn’t raining.
I do not agree with these sentiments. I think Brexit could be significantly and pointlessly bad for the Union, and the British economy - certainly over the long term - but there is no doubt this national mood is building. We can cope. Bring it on. Etc.