Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Johnson’s first battle as PM with the BXP looks set to be at B

135

Comments

  • AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 25,413
    Pulpstar said:

    Floater said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Bavaria has some wonderful places.
    Corpus Christi, parade, short church service, now they're all... you guessed it in the beer garden
    my btother lives in Northe Germany

    hes just recovering from a Tursday to Tuesday town binge last weekend
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118
    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    I wonder if he is from one of the remaining Orange Lodge families, they still exist in Liverpool but I would have thought that was dying out. He clearly follows most of the DUP line in politics. He probably marches with the pipes and drums to celebrate the battle of the Boyne each year.
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I think the truth is that people who claim to want a diverse society actually want a conformist society but don’t like to think of themselves as authoritarian. True diversity means accepting that views like those of @Viceroy_of_Orange are part and parcel of society and don’t need to be put under the microscope or corrected. If we all have to think the same, then we aren’t diverse
  • eekeek Posts: 28,406

    Excuse my ignorance but is it legal for people heavily involved in this process to bet on the outcome?

    Politicians, unlike everyone else, expect to be able to lie to the public for profit without legal consequence. So naturally they would expect to be allowed to insider deal as well.
    And in the case of Political Advertising are legally allowed to lie without consequence as well..
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    I wonder if he is from one of the remaining Orange Lodge families, they still exist in Liverpool but I would have thought that was dying out. He clearly follows most of the DUP line in politics. He probably marches with the pipes and drums to celebrate the battle of the Boyne each year.
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I think the truth is that people who claim to want a diverse society actually want a conformist society but don’t like to think of themselves as authoritarian. True diversity means accepting that views like those of @Viceroy_of_Orange are part and parcel of society and don’t need to be put under the microscope or corrected. If we all have to think the same, then we aren’t diverse
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
  • FloaterFloater Posts: 14,207

    AndyJS said:

    Aussie batsman hits a six in the fifth over, total silence from the crowd. Most of the spectators must be Bangladeshi supporters.

    Not a open curry house to be found within 50 miles of Nottingham!
    National Emergency!

    Not saying I like curries more than is possibly good for me or anything......
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 22,293
    Morning PB - It's Knock Em' Out Thursday!!! :D
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118

    isam said:

    I admit I am in the minority on this issue, sadly.

    But there's still a fair proportion of us who find it wrong.
    You still haven't given a single non-religious reason why secular civil marriage should be denied to gays.
    The relationship in my eyes is not equal to a straight relationship, so therefore I do not want it approved or ranked by the law in such a way.
    Why is it not 'equal' in your view? What's your reasoning?
    One is immoral and the other is not.
    Crikey, you're so deep in the closet you're having adventures in Narnia aren't you?
    I thought he had admitted being gay?
    Admitted? Confessed to? Remarked that he was?

    Who cares? So long as the horses aren't frightened!
    Sorry if ‘admitted’ is considered pejorative. In the context of being accused of being in the closet, I thought it was the right word to use.
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,208
    edited June 2019

    FF43 said:

    DavidL said:

    Is this petition really likely to succeed? It seems to me that this was pretty technical without any of the moral opprobrium of Peterborough.

    I'm uncomfortable with recall petitions. If an MP is deemed unfit for for office, because for example a criminal conviction, there should be a process for triggering a by-election. Whether there is a good case for dismissal on grounds of personal conduct or not, it shouldn't be left to the whim of a recall petition IMO.
    One purpose of the recall petition is to protect MPs from abuse of the process by the Executive. It's the electorate who decide.

    In this way it has some similarities with the jury system, where the ability of a jury to act on its "whims" is an important defence against authoritarianism.
    I think recall petitions are confused.

    If it's a disciplinary mechanism, in my view this should be a process, as Indeed jury trials are. The decision could be made by a jury but more likely a panel of senior civil servants or perhaps judges, who are working to a set of guidelines. The automatic outcome of any such decision would be a by-election.

    If on the other hand recall petitions are a tool of direct democracy there doesn't need to be an implication that the MP has misbehaved, but simply voters decide they want a change and aren't prepared to wait until the next general election to get it.
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    GIN1138 said:

    Morning PB - It's Knock Em' Out Thursday!!! :D

    Is it true there will be multiple rounds today? If so what times should we expect results?
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    I wonder if he is from one of the remaining Orange Lodge families, they still exist in Liverpool but I would have thought that was dying out. He clearly follows most of the DUP line in politics. He probably marches with the pipes and drums to celebrate the battle of the Boyne each year.
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I think the truth is that people who claim to want a diverse society actually want a conformist society but don’t like to think of themselves as authoritarian. True diversity means accepting that views like those of @Viceroy_of_Orange are part and parcel of society and don’t need to be put under the microscope or corrected. If we all have to think the same, then we aren’t diverse
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
  • AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 25,413
    edited June 2019

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
  • kjohnwkjohnw Posts: 1,456
    What time is/are the vote(s) today , anyone know?
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    edited June 2019
    FF43 said:

    FF43 said:

    DavidL said:

    Is this petition really likely to succeed? It seems to me that this was pretty technical without any of the moral opprobrium of Peterborough.

    I'm uncomfortable with recall petitions. If an MP is deemed unfit for for office, because for example a criminal conviction, there should be a process for triggering a by-election. Whether there is a good case for dismissal on grounds of personal conduct or not, it shouldn't be left to the whim of a recall petition IMO.
    One purpose of the recall petition is to protect MPs from abuse of the process by the Executive. It's the electorate who decide.

    In this way it has some similarities with the jury system, where the ability of a jury to act on its "whims" is an important defence against authoritarianism.
    I think recall petitions are confused.

    If it's a disciplinary mechanism, in my view this should be a process, as Indeed jury trials are. The decision could be made by a jury but more likely a panel of senior civil servants or perhaps judges, who are working to a set of guidelines. The automatic outcome of any such decision would be a by-election.

    If on the other hand recall petitions are a tool of direct democracy there doesn't need to be an implication that the MP has misbehaved, but simply voters decide they want a change and aren't prepared to wait until the next general election to get it.
    Actually there does need to be an implication that the MP has misbehaved. A petition can only start on limited grounds, this one was due to a conviction in a court of law. So a jury has already been involved (or would have been if he hadn't pled guilty IIRC).
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 33,478
    isam said:

    isam said:

    I admit I am in the minority on this issue, sadly.

    But there's still a fair proportion of us who find it wrong.
    You still haven't given a single non-religious reason why secular civil marriage should be denied to gays.
    The relationship in my eyes is not equal to a straight relationship, so therefore I do not want it approved or ranked by the law in such a way.
    Why is it not 'equal' in your view? What's your reasoning?
    One is immoral and the other is not.
    Crikey, you're so deep in the closet you're having adventures in Narnia aren't you?
    I thought he had admitted being gay?
    Admitted? Confessed to? Remarked that he was?

    Who cares? So long as the horses aren't frightened!
    Sorry if ‘admitted’ is considered pejorative. In the context of being accused of being in the closet, I thought it was the right word to use.
    I was trying to think of a word, or group of words that were as neutral as possible. Cf: admitted guilt.

    Just getting in touch with my pedantic side, really.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483

    eek said:


    Why would Corbyn want Boris to go into an election as PM when he could ensure Boris isn't?

    That's not the question. The question is if Corbyn wants an election or not.

    All Boris has to say is we have Confidence in ourselves so will vote against any VONC but if you want an election vote for it. If Corbyn is then too frit to vote for an election he would be destroyed by both his own supporters and his opponents within the Labour Party.
    Deleted
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    kjohnw said:

    What time is/are the vote(s) today , anyone know?

    Voting: 10am to 12 pm
    Result: 1pm

    Voting: 3:30pm to 5:30pm
    Result: 6pm
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    isam said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    I wonder if he is from one of the remaining Orange Lodge families, they still exist in Liverpool but I would have thought that was dying out. He clearly follows most of the DUP line in politics. He probably marches with the pipes and drums to celebrate the battle of the Boyne each year.
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I think the truth is that people who claim to want a diverse society actually want a conformist society but don’t like to think of themselves as authoritarian. True diversity means accepting that views like those of @Viceroy_of_Orange are part and parcel of society and don’t need to be put under the microscope or corrected. If we all have to think the same, then we aren’t diverse
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.
  • justin124justin124 Posts: 11,527
    Thanks to all for your supportive comments earlier. They are appreciated.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,992
    That ES editorial reads as though GO is playing BB for the lazy, duplicitous, solipsistic git he is - I will be the (eg Northern) power(house) behind the throne is how it seems to have been written.
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    TOPPING said:

    That ES editorial reads as though GO is playing BB for the lazy, duplicitous, solipsistic git he is - I will be the (eg Northern) power(house) behind the throne is how it seems to have been written.

    Who is BB?
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,679

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 22,293
    edited June 2019
    kjohnw said:

    What time is/are the vote(s) today , anyone know?

    Voting now. Result 1pm.

    Then 3pm to 5pm voting result 6pm
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118

    isam said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    I wonder if he is from one of the remaining Orange Lodge families, they still exist in Liverpool but I would have thought that was dying out. He clearly follows most of the DUP line in politics. He probably marches with the pipes and drums to celebrate the battle of the Boyne each year.
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I think the truth is that people who claim to want a diverse society actually want a conformist society but don’t like to think of themselves as authoritarian. True diversity means accepting that views like those of @Viceroy_of_Orange are part and parcel of society and don’t need to be put under the microscope or corrected. If we all have to think the same, then we aren’t diverse
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.
    He is entitled to want that, but he doesn’t have any right to take liberties away from others
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    I wonder if he is from one of the remaining Orange Lodge families, they still exist in Liverpool but I would have thought that was dying out. He clearly follows most of the DUP line in politics. He probably marches with the pipes and drums to celebrate the battle of the Boyne each year.
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I think the truth is that people who claim to want a diverse society actually want a conformist society but don’t like to think of themselves as authoritarian. True diversity means accepting that views like those of @Viceroy_of_Orange are part and parcel of society and don’t need to be put under the microscope or corrected. If we all have to think the same, then we aren’t diverse
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.
    He is entitled to want that, but he doesn’t have any right to take liberties away from others
    That was my point. But he wants the law changed to take away those liberties.
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 22,293

    GIN1138 said:

    Morning PB - It's Knock Em' Out Thursday!!! :D

    Is it true there will be multiple rounds today? If so what times should we expect results?
    First result 1pm. Second result 6pm.
  • DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300
    GIN1138 said:

    kjohnw said:

    What time is/are the vote(s) today , anyone know?

    Voting now. Result 1pm.

    Then 3pm to 5pm result 6pm
    Half an hour later for this afternoon.

    10 to noon: 4th ballot
    1pm: result on 1 o'clock news
    3.30 to 5.30: 5th ballot (if needed!!)
    6pm: result on 6 o'clock news (note only half the time for counting. Tories love BBC News!)
  • NickPalmerNickPalmer Posts: 21,534
    The Standard endorses Boris, though with this snark: "Mr Johnson may be loose with words when it comes to the fates of others but never when it comes to his own."

    https://www.standard.co.uk/comment/comment/evening-standard-comment-we-back-boris-as-the-pm-to-turn-britain-around-a4171816.html
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    I wonder if he is from one of the remaining Orange Lodge families, they still exist in Liverpool but I would have thought that was dying out. He clearly follows most of the DUP line in politics. He probably marches with the pipes and drums to celebrate the battle of the Boyne each year.
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I think the truth is that people who claim to want a diverse society actually want a conformist society but don’t like to think of themselves as authoritarian. True diversity means accepting that views like those of @Viceroy_of_Orange are part and parcel of society and don’t need to be put under the microscope or corrected. If we all have to think the same, then we aren’t diverse
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.
    He is entitled to want that, but he doesn’t have any right to take liberties away from others
    That was my point. But he wants the law changed to take away those liberties.
    I’m getting into an argument about a subject I don’t care much about here, but I’d say he is entitled to want the law changed too. Diversity means diversity of opinions, not gay, straight, black, white, Remain, Leave people all having the same opinion.
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 22,293

    GIN1138 said:

    kjohnw said:

    What time is/are the vote(s) today , anyone know?

    Voting now. Result 1pm.

    Then 3pm to 5pm result 6pm
    Half an hour later for this afternoon.

    10 to noon: 4th ballot
    1pm: result on 1 o'clock news
    3.30 to 5.30: 5th ballot (if needed!!)
    6pm: result on 6 o'clock news (note only half the time for counting. Tories love BBC News!)
    Tories [HEART] BBC - Always have! :D
  • MysticroseMysticrose Posts: 4,688
    edited June 2019
    Excellent thread header.

    I don't believe for a moment that the Brexit Party will help Boris. After everything that has happened they will go for the win in B&R.

    It should be a LibDem gain either way. At least, I 'think' so.
  • NickPalmerNickPalmer Posts: 21,534

    <

    Actually there does need to be an implication that the MP has misbehaved. A petition can only start on limited grounds, this one was due to a conviction in a court of law. So a jury has already been involved (or would have been if he hadn't pled guilty IIRC).

    Yes, it'd be total chaos if all MPs could be recalled on a whim at any time - we'd have hundreds of recall petitions running at any one moment.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,381

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    There really is nothing not to like about Bavaria. Good food, outstanding beer, stunning scenery, a flourishing economy, and right wing politics.

    As an aside, I wonder why the Alpine countries, and regions are generally very right wing.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,992

    TOPPING said:

    That ES editorial reads as though GO is playing BB for the lazy, duplicitous, solipsistic git he is - I will be the (eg Northern) power(house) behind the throne is how it seems to have been written.

    Who is BB?
    BJ
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    The recall petition is going to be very close to 10% IMO.
  • AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 25,413

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,992
    justin124 said:

    Thanks to all for your supportive comments earlier. They are appreciated.

    Just read your post about it. Very very sorry to hear that must have been extremely distressing. Don't be surprised if it stays with you for a bit. Talking is good!
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,992

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
    Depends on what he likes and how long he can stay? Oh Mr Alanbrooke, behave.
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,208

    FF43 said:

    FF43 said:

    DavidL said:

    Is this petition really likely to succeed? It seems to me that this was pretty technical without any of the moral opprobrium of Peterborough.

    I'm uncomfortable with recall petitions. If an MP is deemed unfit for for office, because for example a criminal conviction, there should be a process for triggering a by-election. Whether there is a good case for dismissal on grounds of personal conduct or not, it shouldn't be left to the whim of a recall petition IMO.
    One purpose of the recall petition is to protect MPs from abuse of the process by the Executive. It's the electorate who decide.

    In this way it has some similarities with the jury system, where the ability of a jury to act on its "whims" is an important defence against authoritarianism.
    I think recall petitions are confused.

    If it's a disciplinary mechanism, in my view this should be a process, as Indeed jury trials are. The decision could be made by a jury but more likely a panel of senior civil servants or perhaps judges, who are working to a set of guidelines. The automatic outcome of any such decision would be a by-election.

    If on the other hand recall petitions are a tool of direct democracy there doesn't need to be an implication that the MP has misbehaved, but simply voters decide they want a change and aren't prepared to wait until the next general election to get it.
    Actually there does need to be an implication that the MP has misbehaved. A petition can only start on limited grounds, this one was due to a conviction in a court of law. So a jury has already been involved (or would have been if he hadn't pled guilty IIRC).
    My point is that if the issue is serious enough to trigger a recall petition, you should go straight to a by-election. If there needs to be an element of judgment, signers of petitions aren't the best placed people to make that judgment.
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 62,772
    GIN1138 said:

    GIN1138 said:

    kjohnw said:

    What time is/are the vote(s) today , anyone know?

    Voting now. Result 1pm.

    Then 3pm to 5pm result 6pm
    Half an hour later for this afternoon.

    10 to noon: 4th ballot
    1pm: result on 1 o'clock news
    3.30 to 5.30: 5th ballot (if needed!!)
    6pm: result on 6 o'clock news (note only half the time for counting. Tories love BBC News!)
    Tories [HEART] BBC - Always have! :D
    Doubt it after last night. The six oclock news managed to miss the actual announcement. Running a VT instead and cutting back to the room just as the chair was finishing off.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    AndyJS said:

    The recall petition is going to be very close to 10% IMO.

    18% my guess
  • MysticroseMysticrose Posts: 4,688
    Re the below, I will simply add this. Freedom of Speech is a curious paradox. Or, rather, the paradox is that in order to protect freedom we sometimes have to curtail it. So the paradigm that you can hold whatever view you want is not correct. Or, rather, you may think it to yourself but the moment you espouse it you come under the norms of wider society.

    See, thing is, we know that to be true if someone suggests you go and kill an MP. Or that it's fine for a teacher to have sex with an 11 year old pupil. Or to lynch a black person. So for incitement to violence, paedophilia, or racial hatred we already have in place checks to the freedom of speech. And thank goodness we do.

    So, no, you can't just announce whatever hate fills your head. You can't act on them. And you can't incite others to.
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 42,709
    TOPPING said:

    justin124 said:

    Thanks to all for your supportive comments earlier. They are appreciated.

    Just read your post about it. Very very sorry to hear that must have been extremely distressing. Don't be surprised if it stays with you for a bit. Talking is good!
    +1. I know I disagree vehemently with Justin on some topics, but that must have been a horrid experience. I hope the effects don't linger with him, and that the scum are caught and get an appropriate sentence.
  • argyllrsargyllrs Posts: 155
    edited June 2019
    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    I wonder if he is from one of the remaining Orange Lodge families, they still exist in Liverpool but I would have thought that was dying out. He clearly follows most of the DUP line in politics. He probably marches with the pipes and drums to celebrate the battle of the Boyne each year.
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I think the truth is that people who claim to want a diverse society actually want a conformist society but don’t like to think of themselves as authoritarian. True diversity means accepting that views like those of @Viceroy_of_Orange are part and parcel of society and don’t need to be put under the microscope or corrected. If we all have to think the same, then we aren’t diverse
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.
    He is entitled to want that, but he doesn’t have any right to take liberties away from others
    That was my point. But he wants the law changed to take away those liberties.
    I’m getting into an argument about a subject I don’t care much about here, but I’d say he is entitled to want the law changed too. Diversity means diversity of opinions, not gay, straight, black, white, Remain, Leave people all having the same opinion.
    ignore my comment - wrong thread
  • tottenhamWCtottenhamWC Posts: 352

    TOPPING said:

    That ES editorial reads as though GO is playing BB for the lazy, duplicitous, solipsistic git he is - I will be the (eg Northern) power(house) behind the throne is how it seems to have been written.

    Who is BB?
    Bad Boris
  • DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300
    edited June 2019
    AndyJS said:

    Good morning. Hunt to go out in the next round might be value.

    https://www.betfair.com/exchange/plus/politics/market/1.159824743


    In a very thin market you can get £13 on at 18s Hunt to get fewest votes. Remember that you are betting on whether Boris's team rigs the ballot, and if so, for whom. 5.7 Gove and 1.16 Saj. I'd not recommend taking the 5.9 Boris! Presumably the layer hopes to trap people who think they are backing him to win.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,381

    Re the below, I will simply add this. Freedom of Speech is a curious paradox. Or, rather, the paradox is that in order to protect freedom we sometimes have to curtail it. So the paradigm that you can hold whatever view you want is not correct. Or, rather, you may think it to yourself but the moment you espouse it you come under the norms of wider society.

    See, thing is, we know that to be true if someone suggests you go and kill an MP. Or that it's fine for a teacher to have sex with an 11 year old pupil. Or to lynch a black person. So for incitement to violence, paedophilia, or racial hatred we already have in place checks to the freedom of speech. And thank goodness we do.

    So, no, you can't just announce whatever hate fills your head. You can't act on them. And you can't incite others to.

    On that issue, IMHO, the threshold is whether someone is inciting another to commit a crime.

    Someone should be allowed to argue that there should be no age of consent, for example, but encouraging someone to rape an 11 year old should be a crime.
  • RochdalePioneersRochdalePioneers Posts: 28,903
    6 Predictions - have no idea what number 7 is

    1. Boris Elected
    2. Failed Negotiation
    3. Nationalist Bluster
    4. Early Election
    5. Comedy campaign
    6. Crash No Deal
    7. ?
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,679

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
    Four days and cheers.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,992

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
    Four days and cheers.
    Good to know that the best bit of Stuttgart seems to be leaving it!
  • DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300

    GIN1138 said:

    GIN1138 said:

    kjohnw said:

    What time is/are the vote(s) today , anyone know?

    Voting now. Result 1pm.

    Then 3pm to 5pm result 6pm
    Half an hour later for this afternoon.

    10 to noon: 4th ballot
    1pm: result on 1 o'clock news
    3.30 to 5.30: 5th ballot (if needed!!)
    6pm: result on 6 o'clock news (note only half the time for counting. Tories love BBC News!)
    Tories [HEART] BBC - Always have! :D
    Doubt it after last night. The six oclock news managed to miss the actual announcement. Running a VT instead and cutting back to the room just as the chair was finishing off.
    That will teach the 1922 not to change the returning officer making the announcement. The director would have been looking for Cheryl to stand up.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,992
    btw just recently came to the thread. What the fuckety double fuck is @Viceroy_of_Orange on about?
  • MysticroseMysticrose Posts: 4,688
    I have a nasty feeling that there will be some major tactical voting this morning and this afternoon.

    The only amusing side of that would be that it would serve Michael Gove (and Sarah) right. But someone should certainly turn the heat up on Boris and Gove is almost certainly the one who could do that. As Boris' supporters realise.
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    I wonder if he is from one of the remaining Orange Lodge families, they still exist in Liverpool but I would have thought that was dying out. He clearly follows most of the DUP line in politics. He probably marches with the pipes and drums to celebrate the battle of the Boyne each year.
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I think the truth is that people who claim to want a diverse society actually want a conformist society but don’t like to think of themselves as authoritarian. True diversity means accepting that views like those of @Viceroy_of_Orange are part and parcel of society and don’t need to be put under the microscope or corrected. If we all have to think the same, then we aren’t diverse
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.
    He is entitled to want that, but he doesn’t have any right to take liberties away from others
    That was my point. But he wants the law changed to take away those liberties.
    I’m getting into an argument about a subject I don’t care much about here, but I’d say he is entitled to want the law changed too. Diversity means diversity of opinions, not gay, straight, black, white, Remain, Leave people all having the same opinion.
    Diversity of opinion yes.

    Diversity of rights no. If I as a Dawkins style atheist say I think organised religion is immoral and that marriage between two religious people should be illegal then am I entitled to get the law changed to reflect that?

    Tyranny of the majority is not ok. Taking away the liberties of others is not acceptable.
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,751

    6 Predictions - have no idea what number 7 is

    1. Boris Elected
    2. Failed Negotiation
    3. Nationalist Bluster
    4. Early Election
    5. Comedy campaign
    6. Crash No Deal
    7. ?

    Sortition.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    Sean_F said:

    Re the below, I will simply add this. Freedom of Speech is a curious paradox. Or, rather, the paradox is that in order to protect freedom we sometimes have to curtail it. So the paradigm that you can hold whatever view you want is not correct. Or, rather, you may think it to yourself but the moment you espouse it you come under the norms of wider society.

    See, thing is, we know that to be true if someone suggests you go and kill an MP. Or that it's fine for a teacher to have sex with an 11 year old pupil. Or to lynch a black person. So for incitement to violence, paedophilia, or racial hatred we already have in place checks to the freedom of speech. And thank goodness we do.

    So, no, you can't just announce whatever hate fills your head. You can't act on them. And you can't incite others to.

    On that issue, IMHO, the threshold is whether someone is inciting another to commit a crime.

    Someone should be allowed to argue that there should be no age of consent, for example, but encouraging someone to rape an 11 year old should be a crime.
    Where would the PIN sit?
  • MysticroseMysticrose Posts: 4,688

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.
    He is entitled to want that, but he doesn’t have any right to take liberties away from others
    That was my point. But he wants the law changed to take away those liberties.
    I’m getting into an argument about a subject I don’t care much about here, but I’d say he is entitled to want the law changed too. Diversity means diversity of opinions, not gay, straight, black, white, Remain, Leave people all having the same opinion.

    Tyranny of the majority is not ok. Taking away the liberties of others is not acceptable.
    This is from the person who is happy to the see the 'troubles' (intimidation, knee-capping, murder, hatred etc) return to Northern Ireland as long as he loses his backstop.
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,208
    justin124 said:

    Thanks to all for your supportive comments earlier. They are appreciated.

    It's a horrible thing to be attacked, Justin. The violation stays after the immediate fear and pain goes. Victim support charities have materials and other support.

    I hope you recover soon. We all have a right to walk safely and without fear in public spaces.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,679
    Not good enough Ken, I was planning to vote for whomever your backed.

    https://twitter.com/Alan_McGuinness/status/1141657770074288131
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.
    He is entitled to want that, but he doesn’t have any right to take liberties away from others
    That was my point. But he wants the law changed to take away those liberties.
    I’m getting into an argument about a subject I don’t care much about here, but I’d say he is entitled to want the law changed too. Diversity means diversity of opinions, not gay, straight, black, white, Remain, Leave people all having the same opinion.

    Tyranny of the majority is not ok. Taking away the liberties of others is not acceptable.
    This is from the person who is happy to the see the 'troubles' (intimidation, knee-capping, murder, hatred etc) return to Northern Ireland as long as he loses his backstop.
    Yes for the EXACT same reason.

    The risk of violence is bad.
    The taking away of fundamental liberties (the right to elect your government) is worse.

    I am a classical liberal. The backstop is illiberal.
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 33,478

    TOPPING said:

    That ES editorial reads as though GO is playing BB for the lazy, duplicitous, solipsistic git he is - I will be the (eg Northern) power(house) behind the throne is how it seems to have been written.

    Who is BB?
    Bad Boris
    Barmy Boris. Although I agree he's bad, not mad.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,381

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.
    He is entitled to want that, but he doesn’t have any right to take liberties away from others
    That was my point. But he wants the law changed to take away those liberties.
    I’m getting into an argument about a subject I don’t care much about here, but I’d say he is entitled to want the law changed too. Diversity means diversity of opinions, not gay, straight, black, white, Remain, Leave people all having the same opinion.

    Tyranny of the majority is not ok. Taking away the liberties of others is not acceptable.
    This is from the person who is happy to the see the 'troubles' (intimidation, knee-capping, murder, hatred etc) return to Northern Ireland as long as he loses his backstop.
    The responsibility for resorting to murder would lie with the murderers, in that situation, not with @Philip Thompson
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,617

    The Standard endorses Boris, though with this snark: "Mr Johnson may be loose with words when it comes to the fates of others but never when it comes to his own."

    https://www.standard.co.uk/comment/comment/evening-standard-comment-we-back-boris-as-the-pm-to-turn-britain-around-a4171816.html

    Wot??? Has Osborne taken a sickie today?
  • Dura_AceDura_Ace Posts: 13,677

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    Porsche Museum.

    https://www.porsche.com/museum/en/sonderausstellungen/

    They've got a special exhibition on the 50th anniversary of the 917.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,992
    Sean_F said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.
    He is entitled to want that, but he doesn’t have any right to take liberties away from others
    That was my point. But he wants the law changed to take away those liberties.
    I’m getting into an argument about a subject I don’t care much about here, but I’d say he is entitled to want the law changed too. Diversity means diversity of opinions, not gay, straight, black, white, Remain, Leave people all having the same opinion.

    Tyranny of the majority is not ok. Taking away the liberties of others is not acceptable.
    This is from the person who is happy to the see the 'troubles' (intimidation, knee-capping, murder, hatred etc) return to Northern Ireland as long as he loses his backstop.
    The responsibility for resorting to murder would lie with the murderers, in that situation, not with @Philip Thompson
    You mean the freedom fighters?
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,679
    Dura_Ace said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    Porsche Museum.

    https://www.porsche.com/museum/en/sonderausstellungen/

    They've got a special exhibition on the 50th anniversary of the 917.
    Cheers, I miss my Cayenne.
  • AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 25,413
    TOPPING said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
    Four days and cheers.
    Good to know that the best bit of Stuttgart seems to be leaving it!
    Think of Dungannon with lots of car factories :smile:
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,751
    FF43 said:

    justin124 said:

    Thanks to all for your supportive comments earlier. They are appreciated.

    It's a horrible thing to be attacked, Justin. The violation stays after the immediate fear and pain goes. Victim support charities have materials and other support.

    I hope you recover soon. We all have a right to walk safely and without fear in public spaces.
    I was mugged a couple of decades ago on a train by two guys with a knife.

    It is a very disturbing experience, and for a while it feels like one that will be life-changing.

    Thankfully, in my case, the effect faded fairly quickly, I hope the same will be true for Justin.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,381

    The Standard endorses Boris, though with this snark: "Mr Johnson may be loose with words when it comes to the fates of others but never when it comes to his own."

    https://www.standard.co.uk/comment/comment/evening-standard-comment-we-back-boris-as-the-pm-to-turn-britain-around-a4171816.html

    Wot??? Has Osborne taken a sickie today?
    I did think he was trolling his readers.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    Someone will have sweaty palms this morning:

    https://twitter.com/ruskin147/status/1141656447325020160
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,414
    justin124 said:

    Thanks to all for your supportive comments earlier. They are appreciated.

    Just catching up with this. Can I add my good wishes and thoughts to you. Look after yourself.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,992

    TOPPING said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
    Four days and cheers.
    Good to know that the best bit of Stuttgart seems to be leaving it!
    Think of Dungannon with lots of car factories :smile:
    The sausage museum is only four hours away.

    https://bratwurstmuseum.de/
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,381
    HYUFD said:
    I've always thought that The Saj is Dr. Evil.
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,208

    The Standard endorses Boris, though with this snark: "Mr Johnson may be loose with words when it comes to the fates of others but never when it comes to his own."

    https://www.standard.co.uk/comment/comment/evening-standard-comment-we-back-boris-as-the-pm-to-turn-britain-around-a4171816.html

    It's a weird editorial. It's as if Osborne has been taken hostage by Johnson and wants to get a coded message to the outside world, without having parts of his body chopped off by his kidnappers.
  • RochdalePioneersRochdalePioneers Posts: 28,903
    This back stop. I don't understand all the fuss about it. Apparently there is a technological solution to the Irish border that means we won't need one. Gove et al keep talking about it. So with technology there will be no border and thus no back stop.

    So why are the people who insist technology is the fix insist the back stop must go? Is it because they know they are lying about the technology solution?
  • He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.

    The law already discriminates between relationship types, that is why marriage between relatives/marriage between more than two people is illegal.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,679

    TOPPING said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
    Four days and cheers.
    Good to know that the best bit of Stuttgart seems to be leaving it!
    Think of Dungannon with lots of car factories :smile:
    I'm off to Belfast next March, my friend is getting married there, she tells me his side of the family are evangelical Prods, so we should get on fine.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,992

    This back stop. I don't understand all the fuss about it. Apparently there is a technological solution to the Irish border that means we won't need one. Gove et al keep talking about it. So with technology there will be no border and thus no back stop.

    So why are the people who insist technology is the fix insist the back stop must go? Is it because they know they are lying about the technology solution?

    There you go with your logic an' all.
  • logical_songlogical_song Posts: 9,914
    HYUFD said:
    Surely Drax would be the first choice.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 42,992

    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.

    The law already discriminates between relationship types, that is why marriage between relatives/marriage between more than two people is illegal.
    So what's the gig? As I mentioned, I think I came to this halfway in (ooh-er). What do you want and why?
  • logical_songlogical_song Posts: 9,914
    ... should give him his full name I guess.
    Richard Grosvenor Plunkett-Ernle-Erle-Drax
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,381
    edited June 2019

    HYUFD said:
    Surely Drax would be the first choice.
    Sir Hugo Drax was the great-grandfather of the current MP for South Dorset. The family kept a low profile after he tried to explode a nuclear weapon over London.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,617
    Sean_F said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.
    He is entitled to want that, but he doesn’t have any right to take liberties away from others
    That was my point. But he wants the law changed to take away those liberties.
    I’m getting into an argument about a subject I don’t care much about here, but I’d say he is entitled to want the law changed too. Diversity means diversity of opinions, not gay, straight, black, white, Remain, Leave people all having the same opinion.

    Tyranny of the majority is not ok. Taking away the liberties of others is not acceptable.
    This is from the person who is happy to the see the 'troubles' (intimidation, knee-capping, murder, hatred etc) return to Northern Ireland as long as he loses his backstop.
    The responsibility for resorting to murder would lie with the murderers, in that situation, not with @Philip Thompson
    Couldn't happen anyway, because now they are all Men of Peace who have put their weapons beyond use...
  • AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 25,413

    TOPPING said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
    Four days and cheers.
    Good to know that the best bit of Stuttgart seems to be leaving it!
    Think of Dungannon with lots of car factories :smile:
    I'm off to Belfast next March, my friend is getting married there, she tells me his side of the family are evangelical Prods, so we should get on fine.
    lol

    it could well be a no alcohol affair !

    if you get the chance do Titanic and Cathedral Quarter or Hillsborough Castle just outside Belfast

    Her Maj has just spent some serious cash doing the place up
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,208



    Yes for the EXACT same reason.

    The risk of violence is bad.
    The taking away of fundamental liberties (the right to elect your government) is worse.

    I am a classical liberal. The backstop is illiberal.

    The backstop is the prioritisation of the right of the larger GB to diverge from the EU over the right of the smaller NI not to be destabilised.

    It is ultimately a choice.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,156
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 33,478

    TOPPING said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
    Four days and cheers.
    Good to know that the best bit of Stuttgart seems to be leaving it!
    Think of Dungannon with lots of car factories :smile:
    I'm off to Belfast next March, my friend is getting married there, she tells me his side of the family are evangelical Prods, so we should get on fine.
    One of my nieces married someone from a Prod family. At some point after the engagement but before the wedding it was discovered that she wasn't a cradle atheist, but had been 'born' a Catholic.
    There was a certain amount of anguish.
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 33,478

    TOPPING said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
    Four days and cheers.
    Good to know that the best bit of Stuttgart seems to be leaving it!
    Think of Dungannon with lots of car factories :smile:
    I'm off to Belfast next March, my friend is getting married there, she tells me his side of the family are evangelical Prods, so we should get on fine.
    lol

    it could well be a no alcohol affair !

    if you get the chance do Titanic and Cathedral Quarter or Hillsborough Castle just outside Belfast

    Her Maj has just spent some serious cash doing the place up
    I thought the Titanic show was with EU money?
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.

    The law already discriminates between relationship types, that is why marriage between relatives/marriage between more than two people is illegal.
    No. Incest is illegal due to birth defects etc which causes harm, not due to morals.
  • He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.

    The law already discriminates between relationship types, that is why marriage between relatives/marriage between more than two people is illegal.
    No. Incest is illegal due to birth defects etc which causes harm, not due to morals.
    Isn't the common retort amongst those who support gay marriage that marriage isn't just about procreation? So why are you using it now?
  • logical_songlogical_song Posts: 9,914

    TOPPING said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
    Four days and cheers.
    Good to know that the best bit of Stuttgart seems to be leaving it!
    Think of Dungannon with lots of car factories :smile:
    I loved Stuttgart when I worked there for over a year in the eighties.
    The Staatsgalerie is worth visiting for the architecture as well as the art. It's a Spa town, I liked Das Leuze best for a swim. There's the Mercedes factory at UnterTurkheim and Porsche at Zuffenhausen if you like cars. There's a long park parallel to the main shopping street and beyond which includes the Opera House.
    Sorry if the info is out of date!
  • AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 25,413

    TOPPING said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
    Four days and cheers.
    Good to know that the best bit of Stuttgart seems to be leaving it!
    Think of Dungannon with lots of car factories :smile:
    I'm off to Belfast next March, my friend is getting married there, she tells me his side of the family are evangelical Prods, so we should get on fine.
    lol

    it could well be a no alcohol affair !

    if you get the chance do Titanic and Cathedral Quarter or Hillsborough Castle just outside Belfast

    Her Maj has just spent some serious cash doing the place up
    I thought the Titanic show was with EU money?
    Cash referred to Hillsborough Castle

    https://www.hrp.org.uk/hillsborough-castle/#gs.k9ink6

  • JackWJackW Posts: 14,787

    TOPPING said:

    That ES editorial reads as though GO is playing BB for the lazy, duplicitous, solipsistic git he is - I will be the (eg Northern) power(house) behind the throne is how it seems to have been written.

    Who is BB?
    Denys Watkins-Pitchford
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.

    The law already discriminates between relationship types, that is why marriage between relatives/marriage between more than two people is illegal.
    No. Incest is illegal due to birth defects etc which causes harm, not due to morals.
    Isn't the common retort amongst those who support gay marriage that marriage isn't just about procreation? So why are you using it now?
    Incest is illegal full stop. With or without marriage. You are comparing an illegal relationship for a legal one for some bizarre reason to justify trying to enforce your "morals" as law.
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    isam said:

    nichomar said:

    I wonder if he is from one of the remaining Orange Lodge families, they still exist in Liverpool but I would have thought that was dying out. He clearly follows most of the DUP line in politics. He probably marches with the pipes and drums to celebrate the battle of the Boyne each year.
    When people say they want diversity in politics/life in general, what do they mean?
    Yes unless that diversity seeks to prevent others having their diversity.
    I think the truth is that people who claim to want a diverse society actually want a conformist society but don’t like to think of themselves as authoritarian. True diversity means accepting that views like those of @Viceroy_of_Orange are part and parcel of society and don’t need to be put under the microscope or corrected. If we all have to think the same, then we aren’t diverse
    Viceroy has the right to hold whatever views he wants.

    He shouldn't have the right to take liberties away from others.
    He hasn’t got that right, who says he has?
    He does. He wants marriage to be illegal for legal relationships he views as immoral.
    He is entitled to want that, but he doesn’t have any right to take liberties away from others
    That was my point. But he wants the law changed to take away those liberties.
    I’m getting into an argument about a subject I don’t care much about here, but I’d say he is entitled to want the law changed too. Diversity means diversity of opinions, not gay, straight, black, white, Remain, Leave people all having the same opinion.
    Diversity of opinion yes.

    Diversity of rights no. If I as a Dawkins style atheist say I think organised religion is immoral and that marriage between two religious people should be illegal then am I entitled to get the law changed to reflect that?

    Tyranny of the majority is not ok. Taking away the liberties of others is not acceptable.
    People can campaign to get the law changed for whatever they want in my opinion. I don’t see what you mean by ‘entitled’. No one is entitled to change any law
  • AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 25,413

    TOPPING said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Imagine the most Bavarian scene possible, Alpen foothills; locals out in traditional garb, houses with flowered wooden balconies. Sound of a brass band ..
    That's where I am right now.

    Mittenwald ?
    https://twitter.com/Pulpstar/status/1141641463601815552?s=19
    Schutzenfest - theyll all be getting hammered for the next 5 days :smiley:
    More than at Oktoberfest?
    Oktoberfest is for tourists

    The real hammerings happen in the towns and villages over the summer and the big Rhineland Cities in the run up to Lent.
    Well as a good Muslim boy Oktoberfest was wasted on me.

    I'm off to Stuttgart next month, any places I should visit?
    depends what you like and how long you are staying

    the centre still has some old bits we didnt blow the crap out of and there are lots of museums

    but if you have time there are better things outside the city within about an hours drive - Black Forest, Spa towns, Rothenburg
    Four days and cheers.
    Good to know that the best bit of Stuttgart seems to be leaving it!
    Think of Dungannon with lots of car factories :smile:
    I loved Stuttgart when I worked there for over a year in the eighties.
    The Staatsgalerie is worth visiting for the architecture as well as the art. It's a Spa town, I liked Das Leuze best for a swim. There's the Mercedes factory at UnterTurkheim and Porsche at Zuffenhausen if you like cars. There's a long park parallel to the main shopping street and beyond which includes the Opera House.
    Sorry if the info is out of date!
    No not at all

    personally I prefer the country to the City.

    There are lots of things to do in Stuttgart, but being a yokel I appreciated the surrounding countryside more

    each to his own of course.
This discussion has been closed.