Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Everything is negotiable, how the election result may have imp

13

Comments

  • Options
    GeoffMGeoffM Posts: 6,071
    Unfortunately it seems that the goat bit is just a joke and clickbait:
    "The message was dismissed as a warped joke

    The picture of the goat is awesome though:

    https://www.thesun.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/as-image-goat.jpg?strip=all&quality=100&w=596

    And for the article about the party itself.. I bet the girl in the silver skirt couldn't walk for days afterwards.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,612
    edited July 2017

    tlg86 said:

    A fifth (20%) of 2017 CON voters tell Opinium that they currently disapprove of the way TMay is handling her job.

    Is that all?
    Historically that is quite poor for a Tory leader, Dave and Theresa used to have North Korean levels of approval from Tory voters, approval ratings used to be in the high 90s.
    What about before Dave though?
    Mrs May is now polling on a par/worse than IDS with some pollsters.
    I meant within the Tory Party support. 20% still seems very low. On here it has to be 98%?
    That's what I meant too, with some pollsters Mrs May is polling with Tory voters around the levels of IDS in 2002.

    Edit - Ah I get you, there's a distinction between Tory members and Tory voters.
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,978
    nielh said:

    nielh said:

    surbiton said:

    Danny565 said:
    We see why in this tweet. The examples are public sector, but I think many private sector voters experience is the same. Except those pensioners of course.

    https://twitter.com/NHAparty/status/880774788007985153
    Really sad. A young solicitor or chartered accountant will probably start at £35k.
    The medical example is without banding (typically 30% more for overtime) but this has been markedly reduced on the new contract from August. There are 4 levels below a band 5 Staff Nurse. Both graduates now will be repaying fees as well of course.

    I think many other fields have seen similar erosion of income by nominal wage freezes. No wonder savings are reaching all time lows and credit card debts new highs. Austerity is very real for many Britons and seemingly without end. This is Corbyns appeal, nothing to do with Brexit.
    I've had the equivalent of 4 significant promotions in the last ten years since leaving uni. In real terms my income now is only marginally higher than it was in my first job. Started on 30k, now 41k. So im having to get promoted all the time to stand still. I'm now in a position where there are very few more opportunities for promotion because i am at a senior level.

    Still dont see how corbyn would solve this problem.
    I don't think Corbyn can, but that is the source of the discontent that fuels Corbynism.
    Yep. Can't disagree with that. In the end young people are probably more concerned about jobs and housing than they are about Brexit, most people probably just associate Brexit with restrictions on being free to live, work travel around Europe.

    The situation with jobs and housing for young people is really bad. Not just young people, people in their 30's, and even 40's. The conservative government 2010+ seem to have abandoned the idea that the state has any role in providing housing and stable jobs, which from a historical point of view is insane.

    Talking to my kids Brexit is seen more a symbolic thing - the old dumping on the young, yet again - than an issue to live or die by in and of itself. Of course, Brexit will have a significant impact on just about everything, so it may well move beyond symbolism.

  • Options
    GeoffMGeoffM Posts: 6,071
    At least it gets you prepared for your first night in Freemasonry.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,612
    My irony meter just exploded, isn't it usually the other way around?

    https://twitter.com/guardian/status/881212943760805890
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,791
    Leader approval among VI (Ie May among Con, Corbyn among Lab etc):

    May: + 58
    Corbyn: +77
    Sturgeon: +89
    Nuttall: +1
    Farron: +24
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,505

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    Two thoughts, Where does one find the 6% of UKIP voters who have changed their minds.

    Secondly does 76% of Labour voters and 80% of LD voters, plus 34% of Tory voters mean a majority overall?
    Staggering how frightened so many Labour MPs appear to be of just 20% of their supporters. This won't last. They'll go for a second referendum to put a stop to Brexit, if ever they get the chance.
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 61,014
    Mr. Observer, I'm re-reading Ian Mortimer's excellent biography of Sir Roger Mortimer. Edward II's on the throne and his (and Gaveston's) struggles with the older earls is perhaps reminiscent of that generational struggle.

    Review here, for those interested: http://thaddeusthesixth.blogspot.co.uk/2015/04/review-greatest-traitor-life-of-sir.html

    Mr. Eagles, is Mercer becoming leader plausible, though?
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,612

    Mr. Observer, I'm re-reading Ian Mortimer's excellent biography of Sir Roger Mortimer. Edward II's on the throne and his (and Gaveston's) struggles with the older earls is perhaps reminiscent of that generational struggle.

    Review here, for those interested: http://thaddeusthesixth.blogspot.co.uk/2015/04/review-greatest-traitor-life-of-sir.html

    Mr. Eagles, is Mercer becoming leader plausible, though?

    Well if people as inept as Mrs May and Andrea Leadsom can make the final two then anyone is plausible as Tory leader/PM.
  • Options
    theakestheakes Posts: 842
    Richard Tyndale: no they just say it in a group, I just listen.
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,763

    Mr. Observer, I'm re-reading Ian Mortimer's excellent biography of Sir Roger Mortimer. Edward II's on the throne and his (and Gaveston's) struggles with the older earls is perhaps reminiscent of that generational struggle.

    Review here, for those interested: http://thaddeusthesixth.blogspot.co.uk/2015/04/review-greatest-traitor-life-of-sir.html

    Mr. Eagles, is Mercer becoming leader plausible, though?

    Well if people as inept as Mrs May and Andrea Leadsom can make the final two then anyone is plausible as Tory leader/PM.
    and yet Osborne couldnt

    shows how crap he is
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,209

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    Two thoughts, Where does one find the 6% of UKIP voters who have changed their minds.

    Secondly does 76% of Labour voters and 80% of LD voters, plus 34% of Tory voters mean a majority overall?
    That Labour split is interesting. I wonder if there was quite a bit of churn in midland and northern areas? Perhaps the Tories did pick up a lot of Labour/Ukip leavers but couldn't hold on to enough of their own remainers.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,995
    IanB2 said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    Two thoughts, Where does one find the 6% of UKIP voters who have changed their minds.

    Secondly does 76% of Labour voters and 80% of LD voters, plus 34% of Tory voters mean a majority overall?
    Staggering how frightened so many Labour MPs appear to be of just 20% of their supporters. This won't last. They'll go for a second referendum to put a stop to Brexit, if ever they get the chance.
    All that talk of respecting the result was guff then?
  • Options
    The_ApocalypseThe_Apocalypse Posts: 7,830
    edited July 2017
    Opinium? Why post polls from pollsters that got two of the last GEs wrong? At least wait and see whether any adjustments they make in the future are right.

    Danny565 said:

    Ha, just a few weeks ago I would've been dancing the streets with 'just' a 1% Tory lead. Now it feels quite deflating :/

    Labour has made the strategic decision that all the votes it received were a positive endorsement of pro-Brexit socialism. I am not sure it's the right call.

    Exactly. Labour have also assumed that they will definitely win the next the GE. The electorate doesn't like that kind of hubris - as seen on June 8th.
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 61,014
    Mr. Eagles, I believe recent history indicates that your suggestion competence is a factor in becoming leader of a major party is not necessarily correct.

    This is like the antithesis of the Diadochi era. That had Craterus, Eumenes, Antipater, Antiochus, Ptolemy, Cassander, Seleucus and more all vying for dominance.

    We have May and Corbyn. *sighs*
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002

    Leader approval among VI (Ie May among Con, Corbyn among Lab etc):

    May: + 58
    Corbyn: +77
    Sturgeon: +89
    Nuttall: +1
    Farron: +24

    What about Uncle Vince
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    GeoffM said:

    At least it gets you prepared for your first night in Freemasonry.
    or, become a Tory Prime Minister
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 61,014
    Mr. Pulpstar, Comrade Cable, surely?
  • Options
    The_ApocalypseThe_Apocalypse Posts: 7,830
    edited July 2017

    nielh said:

    nielh said:

    surbiton said:

    Danny565 said:
    We see why in this tweet. The examples are public sector, but I think many private sector voters experience is the same. Except those pensioners of course.

    https://twitter.com/NHAparty/status/880774788007985153
    Really sad. A young solicitor or chartered accountant will probably start at £35k.
    The medical example is without banding (typically 30% more for overtime) but this has been markedly reduced on the new contract from August. There are 4 levels below a band 5 Staff Nurse. Both graduates now will be repaying fees as well of course.

    I think many other fields have seen similar erosion of income by nominal wage freezes. No wonder savings are reaching all time lows and credit card debts new highs. Austerity is very real for many Britons and seemingly without end. This is Corbyns appeal, nothing to do with Brexit.
    I've had the equivalent of 4 significant promotions in the last ten years since leaving uni. In real terms my income now is only marginally higher than it was in my first job. Started on 30k, now 41k. So im having to get promoted all the time to stand still. I'm now in a position where there are very few more opportunities for promotion because i am at a senior level.

    Still dont see how corbyn would solve this problem.
    I don't think Corbyn can, but that is the source of the discontent that fuels Corbynism.
    Yep. Can't disagree with that. In the end young people are probably more concerned about jobs and housing than they are about Brexit, most people probably just associate Brexit with restrictions on being free to live, work travel around Europe.

    The situation with jobs and housing for young people is really bad. Not just young people, people in their 30's, and even 40's. The conservative government 2010+ seem to have abandoned the idea that the state has any role in providing housing and stable jobs, which from a historical point of view is insane.

    Talking to my kids Brexit is seen more a symbolic thing - the old dumping on the young, yet again - than an issue to live or die by in and of itself. Of course, Brexit will have a significant impact on just about everything, so it may well move beyond symbolism.

    +1. That's how a lot of us see it.
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,074

    Mr. 1000, think it was 5 for 2022. Could be wrong.

    Que?
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    brendan16 said:

    What is interesting about the Survation poll on Brexit is that there appears to be a huge divergence of opinion between men and women - a significant leave lead with men and a very large remain lead with women.

    Is is that a new trend or just a statistical quirk?

    Just like in the Scottish Indy polls. It's the women who wot won it for the UK.
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,209
    Well this is depressing. There is now a Labour MP who is younger than me :(

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laura_Pidcock
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    Isn't it the same as other recent polls ? TBH, I am not keeping a close track.
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 61,014
    edited July 2017
    Mr. 1000, two markets. Still a member in 2020 at 4, another referendum before 2020 at 5.

    Edited extra bit: https://sports.ladbrokes.com/en-gb/betting/politics/uk/uk-politics/eu-specials/225327493/
  • Options
    MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,318
    Very surprising polling.

    May has had about as bad a time as possible - the fall out from the GE, Grenfell, Corbyn on crest of a wave and of course the toxic deal with the DUP only a few days ago - surely Con should now be falling well behind.

    Yet Survation has Con +1. Though Opinium has Lab +6 which seems far more what would be expected as the minimum Lab lead.

    Best bet for Con has to be head down, get through the next 3 weeks and then it's the summer recess. Then come back in 3 months and hope everything has started to calm down a bit.

    Anyway these polls at least give Con supporters some hope that all is not lost - a new leader, a positive manifesto and whatever happens with Brexit they could well have a decent chance at any point between 2019 and 2022 especially if the Corbyn bubble starts deflating.

    Odds on another 2017 GE on Betfair have drifted very significantly over the last few days.
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,505

    nielh said:

    nielh said:

    surbiton said:

    Danny565 said:
    We see why in this tweet. The examples are public sector, but I think many private sector voters experience is the same. Except those pensioners of course.

    https://twitter.com/NHAparty/status/880774788007985153
    Really sad. A young solicitor or chartered accountant will probably start at £35k.
    The medical example is without banding (typically 30% more for overtime) but this has been markedly reduced on the new contract from August. There are 4 levels below a band 5 Staff Nurse. Both graduates now will be repaying fees as well of course.

    I think many other fields have seen similar erosion of income by nominal wage freezes. No wonder savings are reaching all time lows and credit card debts new highs. Austerity is very real for many Britons and seemingly without end. This is Corbyns appeal, nothing to do with Brexit.
    I've had the equivalent of 4 significant promotions in the last ten years since leaving uni. In real terms my income now is only marginally higher than it was in my first job. Started on 30k, now 41k. So im having to get promoted all the time to stand still. I'm now in a position where there are very few more opportunities for promotion because i am at a senior level.

    Still dont see how corbyn would solve this problem.
    I don't think Corbyn can, but that is the source of the discontent that fuels Corbynism.
    Yep. Can't disagree with that. In the end young people are probably more concerned about jobs and housing than they are about Brexit, most people probably just associate Brexit with restrictions on being free to live, work travel around Europe.

    The situation with jobs and housing for young people is really bad. Not just young people, people in their 30's, and even 40's. The conservative government 2010+ seem to have abandoned the idea that the state has any role in providing housing and stable jobs, which from a historical point of view is insane.

    Talking to my kids Brexit is seen more a symbolic thing - the old dumping on the young, yet again - than an issue to live or die by in and of itself. Of course, Brexit will have a significant impact on just about everything, so it may well move beyond symbolism.

    +1. That's how a lot of us see it.
    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.
  • Options
    The_ApocalypseThe_Apocalypse Posts: 7,830
    surbiton said:

    Isn't it the same as other recent polls ? TBH, I am not keeping a close track.
    Other than the recent Survation just posted, it's similar to the previous polls from Survation and YouGov post GE - showing leads of 5 and 3 points for Labour IIRC.
  • Options
    NorthofStokeNorthofStoke Posts: 1,758
    Danny565 said:

    Danny565 said:

    Ha, just a few weeks ago I would've been dancing the streets with 'just' a 1% Tory lead. Now it feels quite deflating :/

    Labour has made the strategic decision that all the votes it received were a positive endorsement of pro-Brexit socialism. I am not sure it's the right call.

    I would never claim it was a whole-hearted endorsement of socialism, nor would I claim that all of Labour's gained voters are "in the bag" for Labour at future elections -- lots of people on the doorsteps who were switching or considering switching to Labour still had caveats and doubts about them.

    However, I still maintain Brexit is neither here nor there in terms of holding onto those voters.
    It could become so.
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    Danny565 said:

    Ha, just a few weeks ago I would've been dancing the streets with 'just' a 1% Tory lead. Now it feels quite deflating :/

    I demand a recount. This cannot be true !
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549

    Not a cult....

    His adoring supporters chanted 'oh Jeremy Corbyn' and held up signs emblazoned with his name and red hearts. A number of middle aged women were seen taking selfies with the Opposition leader in the background.

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4657086/Jeremy-Corbyn-says-Labour-government-waiting.html

    I was at a gathering on Wednesday evening and said middle-aged women were swooning around him. He didn't seem to be objecting....
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,074

    Mr. 1000, two markets. Still a member in 2020 at 4, another referendum before 2020 at 5.

    Edited extra bit: https://sports.ladbrokes.com/en-gb/betting/politics/uk/uk-politics/eu-specials/225327493/

    I'm quite tempted by the 4s on us still being a full member on 1/1/2000. I think (assuming negotiations are going OK) that an extension is more likely than not. The "danger" to the bet is that an extension is more likely to be 6 months than 12.

    Add in the small but real risk of a major recession causing second thoughts...

    4s seems very slightly generous to me. If I had some money in my Ladbrokes account, I'd bet on it. But it's not sufficiently enticing to make me actually deposit cash.
  • Options
    NorthofStokeNorthofStoke Posts: 1,758
    nielh said:

    nielh said:

    surbiton said:

    Danny565 said:
    We see why in this tweet. The examples are public sector, but I think many private sector voters experience is the same. Except those pensioners of course.

    https://twitter.com/NHAparty/status/880774788007985153
    Really sad. A young solicitor or chartered accountant will probably start at £35k.
    The medical example is without banding (typically 30% more for overtime) but this has been markedly reduced on the new contract from August. There are 4 levels below a band 5 Staff Nurse. Both graduates now will be repaying fees as well of course.

    I think many other fields have seen similar erosion of income by nominal wage freezes. No wonder savings are reaching all time lows and credit card debts new highs. Austerity is very real for many Britons and seemingly without end. This is Corbyns appeal, nothing to do with Brexit.
    I've had the equivalent of 4 significant promotions in the last ten years since leaving uni. In real terms my income now is only marginally higher than it was in my first job. Started on 30k, now 41k. So im having to get promoted all the time to stand still. I'm now in a position where there are very few more opportunities for promotion because i am at a senior level.

    Still dont see how corbyn would solve this problem.
    I don't think Corbyn can, but that is the source of the discontent that fuels Corbynism.
    Yep. Can't disagree with that. In the end young people are probably more concerned about jobs and housing than they are about Brexit, most people probably just associate Brexit with restrictions on being free to live, work travel around Europe.

    The situation with jobs and housing for young people is really bad. Not just young people, people in their 30's, and even 40's. The conservative government 2010+ seem to have abandoned the idea that the state has any role in providing housing and stable jobs, which from a historical point of view is insane.
    The irony being that JC and McDonell would destroy job opportunities and our youth would find it more difficult to move to Spain that would then have a better job market.
  • Options
    PeterCPeterC Posts: 1,274
    IanB2 said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    Two thoughts, Where does one find the 6% of UKIP voters who have changed their minds.

    Secondly does 76% of Labour voters and 80% of LD voters, plus 34% of Tory voters mean a majority overall?
    Staggering how frightened so many Labour MPs appear to be of just 20% of their supporters. This won't last. They'll go for a second referendum to put a stop to Brexit, if ever they get the chance.
    Dream on while Corbyn is in charge. It's like Nixon in China - only the Tories can cancel Brexit, and that would only be considered if the negotiations were to collapse altogether.
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 61,014
    Mr. 1000, I'm loath to bet on longish term things at odds that short.

    Anyway, must be off.
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549

    Danny565 said:

    Ha, just a few weeks ago I would've been dancing the streets with 'just' a 1% Tory lead. Now it feels quite deflating :/

    Labour has made the strategic decision that all the votes it received were a positive endorsement of pro-Brexit socialism. I am not sure it's the right call.

    I can only comment on the London vote. It was ALL anti-Brexit.
  • Options
    The_ApocalypseThe_Apocalypse Posts: 7,830
    edited July 2017
    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
  • Options
    foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    edited July 2017
    tlg86 said:

    Well this is depressing. There is now a Labour MP who is younger than me :(

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laura_Pidcock

    Wait until you have both a PM and a boss younger than you! I passed that milestone in 2010...
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,505
    PeterC said:

    IanB2 said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    Two thoughts, Where does one find the 6% of UKIP voters who have changed their minds.

    Secondly does 76% of Labour voters and 80% of LD voters, plus 34% of Tory voters mean a majority overall?
    Staggering how frightened so many Labour MPs appear to be of just 20% of their supporters. This won't last. They'll go for a second referendum to put a stop to Brexit, if ever they get the chance.
    Dream on while Corbyn is in charge. It's like Nixon in China - only the Tories can cancel Brexit, and that would only be considered if the negotiations were to collapse altogether.
    I agree Labour politicians couldn't vote to scrap it, which is where the second vote comes in.
  • Options
    NorthofStokeNorthofStoke Posts: 1,758

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    EU membership is an insurance againt demagogues like McDonell.
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,997

    Mr. Eagles, I believe recent history indicates that your suggestion competence is a factor in becoming leader of a major party is not necessarily correct.

    This is like the antithesis of the Diadochi era. That had Craterus, Eumenes, Antipater, Antiochus, Ptolemy, Cassander, Seleucus and more all vying for dominance.

    We have May and Corbyn. *sighs*

    The end result was stalemate, simply because they were all so evenly matched, in terms of ability.
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    So Remain strongly in the lead ? Almost 60 - 40 I'd say.
  • Options
    MortimerMortimer Posts: 13,956
    The LD = UKIP scores are horrific for a party that is about to be led by a septugenarian - even if he is only a stop gap.

    LDs below five seats at the next election?
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    EU membership is an insurance againt demagogues like McDonell.
    EU membership is an insurance against Right wing Tory demagogues abolishing workers rights.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,612
    Theresa May has suffered a startling decline in popularity since last month’s general election with a new opinion poll showing 61% of voters now view her in a more negative light than they did when the electorate denied her an overall majority on 8 June.

    The extraordinary transformation in the prime minister’s ratings, which were sky high in early April after she called the snap election, has been accompanied by a rise in public respect for Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn, according to a new Opinium survey for the Observer.

    https://amp.theguardian.com/politics/2017/jul/01/over-60-of-voters-view-theresa-may-as-pm-negatively-poll
  • Options
    The_ApocalypseThe_Apocalypse Posts: 7,830

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    EU membership is an insurance againt demagogues like McDonell.
    I dislike him as much as I dislike the likes of Dominic Raab, Philip Davies etc.
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    Mortimer said:

    The LD = UKIP scores are horrific for a party that is about to be led by a septugenarian - even if he is only a stop gap.

    LDs below five seats at the next election?
    No. It will gain a few. Probably 18-20.
  • Options
    MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,318
    I also don't think Brexit will affect our next GE to much of an extent.

    Look at it this way - the GE we've just had was meant to be all about Brexit and May started out on that path.

    It didn't work because ultimately people were more interested in other things.

    People have a limited attention span and I think many now think Brexit is quite complicated and technical - and of course they think it's decided. So they now think it's just a job that needs to be dealt with but they don't care about the details.

    Unless it blows up big time - eg people heard it had been "cancelled" or whatever - I don't think it's going to be uppermost in people's minds.
  • Options
    MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 25,347
    RobD said:

    IanB2 said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    Two thoughts, Where does one find the 6% of UKIP voters who have changed their minds.

    Secondly does 76% of Labour voters and 80% of LD voters, plus 34% of Tory voters mean a majority overall?
    Staggering how frightened so many Labour MPs appear to be of just 20% of their supporters. This won't last. They'll go for a second referendum to put a stop to Brexit, if ever they get the chance.
    All that talk of respecting the result was guff then?
    Not at all so long as they respect the next referendum. Don't forget Nige, like Nicola was planning future referenda until he got the right result. Only in his case he got the right result earlier than anticipated.
    .
  • Options
    NorthofStokeNorthofStoke Posts: 1,758
    surbiton said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    So Remain strongly in the lead ? Almost 60 - 40 I'd say.
    Makes you wonder if there is simply a "spanner in the works" vote. If we had a remain government it would likely be 60 40 the other way. The trouble is the symbolic tussling is about to give way to concrete decisions.
  • Options
    foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    edited July 2017
    surbiton said:

    Danny565 said:

    Ha, just a few weeks ago I would've been dancing the streets with 'just' a 1% Tory lead. Now it feels quite deflating :/

    Labour has made the strategic decision that all the votes it received were a positive endorsement of pro-Brexit socialism. I am not sure it's the right call.

    I can only comment on the London vote. It was ALL anti-Brexit.
    It was more of a mix here. When I was in Bosworth it was austerity that went down best. Unfortunately it got the Labour vote out rather than tactical for LD. People are sick of grinding austerity* and are not going to be happy as it worsens.

    *I wonder whether the Irish approach was better. A sharp round of welfare and spending cuts, but a short one that allows recovery.
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,997
    IanB2 said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    Two thoughts, Where does one find the 6% of UKIP voters who have changed their minds.

    Secondly does 76% of Labour voters and 80% of LD voters, plus 34% of Tory voters mean a majority overall?
    Staggering how frightened so many Labour MPs appear to be of just 20% of their supporters. This won't last. They'll go for a second referendum to put a stop to Brexit, if ever they get the chance.
    Not while Corbyn's in charge, they won't.
  • Options
    PeterCPeterC Posts: 1,274
    edited July 2017
    IanB2 said:

    PeterC said:

    IanB2 said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    Two thoughts, Where does one find the 6% of UKIP voters who have changed their minds.

    Secondly does 76% of Labour voters and 80% of LD voters, plus 34% of Tory voters mean a majority overall?
    Staggering how frightened so many Labour MPs appear to be of just 20% of their supporters. This won't last. They'll go for a second referendum to put a stop to Brexit, if ever they get the chance.
    Dream on while Corbyn is in charge. It's like Nixon in China - only the Tories can cancel Brexit, and that would only be considered if the negotiations were to collapse altogether.
    I agree Labour politicians couldn't vote to scrap it, which is where the second vote comes in.
    Personally I think it quite likely that the negotiations will end without a ratified agreement - there are just too many hurdles which would have to have been cleared. The specific choice could then crystallise: revoke A50 and remain OR leave completely. That would be a huge crisis. I do not think the political class could cope with such a dilemma and would be tempted to throw it back to a referendum. Lord knows what might happen then!
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    When is the next election ? October 5th, 12th , 19th or the 26th ?
  • Options
    NorthofStokeNorthofStoke Posts: 1,758
    PeterC said:

    IanB2 said:

    PeterC said:

    IanB2 said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    Two thoughts, Where does one find the 6% of UKIP voters who have changed their minds.

    Secondly does 76% of Labour voters and 80% of LD voters, plus 34% of Tory voters mean a majority overall?
    Staggering how frightened so many Labour MPs appear to be of just 20% of their supporters. This won't last. They'll go for a second referendum to put a stop to Brexit, if ever they get the chance.
    Dream on while Corbyn is in charge. It's like Nixon in China - only the Tories can cancel Brexit, and that would only be considered if the negotiations were to collapse altogether.
    I agree Labour politicians couldn't vote to scrap it, which is where the second vote comes in.
    Personally I think it quite likely that the negotiations will end without a ratified agreement - there are just too many hurdles which would have to be cleared. The specific choice could then crystallise: revoke A50 and remain OR leave completely. That would be a huge crisis. I do not think the political class could cope with such a dilemma and would be tempted to throw it back to a referendum Lord knows what might happen then!
    Sounds quite plausible.
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,997
    surbiton said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    So Remain strongly in the lead ? Almost 60 - 40 I'd say.
    54/46, but Survation significantly understated Leave at the Referendum.
  • Options
    foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    Mortimer said:

    The LD = UKIP scores are horrific for a party that is about to be led by a septugenarian - even if he is only a stop gap.

    LDs below five seats at the next election?
    I don't think we can risk a stop gap leader, there could be a collapse to a new GE with too little notice for a replacement.
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,997

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    in or out of the EU, we're bound to get a socialist government at some point.
  • Options
    MortimerMortimer Posts: 13,956
    surbiton said:

    When is the next election ? October 5th, 12th , 19th or the 26th ?

    2021, probably...
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    Mortimer said:

    surbiton said:

    When is the next election ? October 5th, 12th , 19th or the 26th ?

    2021, probably...
    I don't think they can even limp until February 2018 .
  • Options
    MortimerMortimer Posts: 13,956
    surbiton said:

    Mortimer said:

    The LD = UKIP scores are horrific for a party that is about to be led by a septugenarian - even if he is only a stop gap.

    LDs below five seats at the next election?
    No. It will gain a few. Probably 18-20.
    How? 5% is an ELE...
  • Options
    The_ApocalypseThe_Apocalypse Posts: 7,830
    edited July 2017
    Sean_F said:

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    in or out of the EU, we're bound to get a socialist government at some point.
    I'd rather it not be a government that included
    (a. John McDonnell
    (b. Anyone who admires Lenin, Mao, Chavez, Julian Assange and watches RT. It's one thing to admire social democrats across the European continent, it's another thing to believe that a USSR style system is desirable for Britain.
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    Sean_F said:

    surbiton said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    So Remain strongly in the lead ? Almost 60 - 40 I'd say.
    54/46, but Survation significantly understated Leave at the Referendum.
    But the voter models are now completely changed. Has anyone seen Martin Boon lately ?
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,612
    Mortimer said:

    surbiton said:

    Mortimer said:

    The LD = UKIP scores are horrific for a party that is about to be led by a septugenarian - even if he is only a stop gap.

    LDs below five seats at the next election?
    No. It will gain a few. Probably 18-20.
    How? 5% is an ELE...
    The Lib Dem share of the vote went down last month and they still made net gains.

    Perhaps they were lucky this time that they had should be facing such an inept Tory leader.
  • Options
    ParistondaParistonda Posts: 1,819
    Mortimer said:

    The LD = UKIP scores are horrific for a party that is about to be led by a septugenarian - even if he is only a stop gap.

    LDs below five seats at the next election?
    Unlikely, the LDs only got 7% this time and gained seats. The immediate future for the LDs is as an anti-tory (Eng) or anti-SNP tactical voting option. A 5% score would more likely see the complete routing of any seats where they are not the close second place challenger though.
  • Options
    MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 25,347
    MikeL said:

    I also don't think Brexit will affect our next GE to much of an extent.

    Look at it this way - the GE we've just had was meant to be all about Brexit and May started out on that path.

    It didn't work because ultimately people were more interested in other things.

    People have a limited attention span and I think many now think Brexit is quite complicated and technical - and of course they think it's decided. So they now think it's just a job that needs to be dealt with but they don't care about the details.

    Unless it blows up big time - eg people heard it had been "cancelled" or whatever - I don't think it's going to be uppermost in people's minds.

    It certainly will! If it is a disaster, or conversely a raging success, the incumbent will be punished or rewarded accordingly!
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549

    Sean_F said:

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    in or out of the EU, we're bound to get a socialist government at some point.
    I'd rather it not be a government that included
    (a. John McDonnell
    (b. Anyone who admires Lenin, Mao, Chavez, Julian Assange and watches RT. It's one thing to admire social democrats across the European continent, it's another thing to believe that a USSR style system is desirable for Britain.
    Barely two months ago, people here and almost everywhere were saying the same about Corbyn. The moment his IRA "friends" stories will come out, the moment his association with Hamas will come out etc. etc.

    Bugger all happened. In fact, I think, he got more street cred among young people. Why have posters about foreign revolutionaries, when you have one at home. In reality, he has hardly even shouted in anger. His politics is not based on any intellectual analysis. He is a waffle but a sincere waffler. The last bit, I think, helps him. He is seen as genuine.
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,997
    surbiton said:

    Sean_F said:

    surbiton said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    So Remain strongly in the lead ? Almost 60 - 40 I'd say.
    54/46, but Survation significantly understated Leave at the Referendum.
    But the voter models are now completely changed. Has anyone seen Martin Boon lately ?
    I don't think Survation has changed its model.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,409
    surbiton said:

    Mortimer said:

    surbiton said:

    When is the next election ? October 5th, 12th , 19th or the 26th ?

    2021, probably...
    I don't think they can even limp until February 2018 .
    Genuine question - now the QS is passed how do you see an election being called
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,409
    surbiton said:

    Sean_F said:

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    in or out of the EU, we're bound to get a socialist government at some point.
    I'd rather it not be a government that included
    (a. John McDonnell
    (b. Anyone who admires Lenin, Mao, Chavez, Julian Assange and watches RT. It's one thing to admire social democrats across the European continent, it's another thing to believe that a USSR style system is desirable for Britain.
    Barely two months ago, people here and almost everywhere were saying the same about Corbyn. The moment his IRA "friends" stories will come out, the moment his association with Hamas will come out etc. etc.

    Bugger all happened. In fact, I think, he got more street cred among young people. Why have posters about foreign revolutionaries, when you have one at home. In reality, he has hardly even shouted in anger. His politics is not based on any intellectual analysis. He is a waffle but a sincere waffler. The last bit, I think, helps him. He is seen as genuine.
    Marxist - yes
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,997
    surbiton said:

    Sean_F said:

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    in or out of the EU, we're bound to get a socialist government at some point.
    I'd rather it not be a government that included
    (a. John McDonnell
    (b. Anyone who admires Lenin, Mao, Chavez, Julian Assange and watches RT. It's one thing to admire social democrats across the European continent, it's another thing to believe that a USSR style system is desirable for Britain.
    Barely two months ago, people here and almost everywhere were saying the same about Corbyn. The moment his IRA "friends" stories will come out, the moment his association with Hamas will come out etc. etc.

    Bugger all happened. In fact, I think, he got more street cred among young people. Why have posters about foreign revolutionaries, when you have one at home. In reality, he has hardly even shouted in anger. His politics is not based on any intellectual analysis. He is a waffle but a sincere waffler. The last bit, I think, helps him. He is seen as genuine.
    While a lot of young people might think it would be cool if we were more like Cuba, Venezuela, or North Korea, I think The Apocalypse's point is that this would not be a desirable thing.
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    PeterC said:

    IanB2 said:

    PeterC said:

    IanB2 said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    Two thoughts, Where does one find the 6% of UKIP voters who have changed their minds.

    Secondly does 76% of Labour voters and 80% of LD voters, plus 34% of Tory voters mean a majority overall?
    Staggering how frightened so many Labour MPs appear to be of just 20% of their supporters. This won't last. They'll go for a second referendum to put a stop to Brexit, if ever they get the chance.
    Dream on while Corbyn is in charge. It's like Nixon in China - only the Tories can cancel Brexit, and that would only be considered if the negotiations were to collapse altogether.
    I agree Labour politicians couldn't vote to scrap it, which is where the second vote comes in.
    Personally I think it quite likely that the negotiations will end without a ratified agreement - there are just too many hurdles which would have to have been cleared. The specific choice could then crystallise: revoke A50 and remain OR leave completely. That would be a huge crisis. I do not think the political class could cope with such a dilemma and would be tempted to throw it back to a referendum. Lord knows what might happen then!
    Agreed. It will be a very HOT potato. The easiest thing is to lob it back to the people who created the mess in the first place. Let them decide with all the full facts. For example, no £350m a week for the NHS.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,409
    edited July 2017
    Is there a poll out with a conservative lead tonight. It must be almost impossible with all the bad press
  • Options
    The_ApocalypseThe_Apocalypse Posts: 7,830
    edited July 2017
    surbiton said:

    Sean_F said:

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    in or out of the EU, we're bound to get a socialist government at some point.
    I'd rather it not be a government that included
    (a. John McDonnell
    (b. Anyone who admires Lenin, Mao, Chavez, Julian Assange and watches RT. It's one thing to admire social democrats across the European continent, it's another thing to believe that a USSR style system is desirable for Britain.
    Barely two months ago, people here and almost everywhere were saying the same about Corbyn. The moment his IRA "friends" stories will come out, the moment his association with Hamas will come out etc. etc.

    Bugger all happened. In fact, I think, he got more street cred among young people. Why have posters about foreign revolutionaries, when you have one at home. In reality, he has hardly even shouted in anger. His politics is not based on any intellectual analysis. He is a waffle but a sincere waffler. The last bit, I think, helps him. He is seen as genuine.
    Well, my post wasn't a comment about how the wider electorate see Corbyn. It me expressing MY own views about what I'd like a socialist government to look like in Britain. Thus, the 'I'd rather not be'. In any case though, during the GE I was saying that the IRA stuff wasn't going to shift voters.

    In response to your points though, if anything will bring Corbyn down, it'll be taking his voters for granted and believing that he has them in the bag - as well as operating on a TMay style strategy of believing that you can win a GE by only trying to appeal to WWC/JAMs voters (which his Brexit strategy implies).

  • Options
    RogerRoger Posts: 18,906

    My irony meter just exploded, isn't it usually the other way around?

    https://twitter.com/guardian/status/881212943760805890

    ... “You rob to support a drug habit, I do drugs to support a robbery habit”, (From the excellent 'Baby Driver')
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,997

    surbiton said:

    Mortimer said:

    surbiton said:

    When is the next election ? October 5th, 12th , 19th or the 26th ?

    2021, probably...
    I don't think they can even limp until February 2018 .
    Genuine question - now the QS is passed how do you see an election being called
    People forget that an election is not in the gift of the government, now.
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549

    surbiton said:

    Sean_F said:

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    in or out of the EU, we're bound to get a socialist government at some point.
    I'd rather it not be a government that included
    (a. John McDonnell
    (b. Anyone who admires Lenin, Mao, Chavez, Julian Assange and watches RT. It's one thing to admire social democrats across the European continent, it's another thing to believe that a USSR style system is desirable for Britain.
    Barely two months ago, people here and almost everywhere were saying the same about Corbyn. The moment his IRA "friends" stories will come out, the moment his association with Hamas will come out etc. etc.

    Bugger all happened. In fact, I think, he got more street cred among young people. Why have posters about foreign revolutionaries, when you have one at home. In reality, he has hardly even shouted in anger. His politics is not based on any intellectual analysis. He is a waffle but a sincere waffler. The last bit, I think, helps him. He is seen as genuine.
    Marxist - yes
    I am yet to be convinced about his intellectual thoroughness. You would not think of him as a Marxixt academic. How many articles has he written even in his backbench days.

    I think people do see him as sincere whereas they see most politicians as a bunch of rats.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,612
    Roger said:

    My irony meter just exploded, isn't it usually the other way around?

    https://twitter.com/guardian/status/881212943760805890

    ... “You rob to support a drug habit, I do drugs to support a robbery habit”, (From the excellent 'Baby Driver')
    I watched Baby Driver yesterday, absolutely fecking loved it.

    Today I watched Despicable Me 3.
  • Options
    foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    PeterC said:

    IanB2 said:

    PeterC said:

    IanB2 said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    Two thoughts, Where does one find the 6% of UKIP voters who have changed their minds.

    Secondly does 76% of Labour voters and 80% of LD voters, plus 34% of Tory voters mean a majority overall?
    Staggering how frightened so many Labour MPs appear to be of just 20% of their supporters. This won't last. They'll go for a second referendum to put a stop to Brexit, if ever they get the chance.
    Dream on while Corbyn is in charge. It's like Nixon in China - only the Tories can cancel Brexit, and that would only be considered if the negotiations were to collapse altogether.
    I agree Labour politicians couldn't vote to scrap it, which is where the second vote comes in.
    Personally I think it quite likely that the negotiations will end without a ratified agreement - there are just too many hurdles which would have to have been cleared. The specific choice could then crystallise: revoke A50 and remain OR leave completely. That would be a huge crisis. I do not think the political class could cope with such a dilemma and would be tempted to throw it back to a referendum. Lord knows what might happen then!
    That is quite possible. The question would be Deal vs WTO Brexit, but thede would be a lot wanting Remain as a third option. I think it very likely that a government would funk the decision and go for a referendum.
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,505
    surbiton said:

    Sean_F said:

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    in or out of the EU, we're bound to get a socialist government at some point.
    I'd rather it not be a government that included
    (a. John McDonnell
    (b. Anyone who admires Lenin, Mao, Chavez, Julian Assange and watches RT. It's one thing to admire social democrats across the European continent, it's another thing to believe that a USSR style system is desirable for Britain.
    Barely two months ago, people here and almost everywhere were saying the same about Corbyn. The moment his IRA "friends" stories will come out, the moment his association with Hamas will come out etc. etc.

    Bugger all happened. In fact, I think, he got more street cred among young people. Why have posters about foreign revolutionaries, when you have one at home. In reality, he has hardly even shouted in anger. His politics is not based on any intellectual analysis. He is a waffle but a sincere waffler. The last bit, I think, helps him. He is seen as genuine.
    Since all the signs were that Mrs M was cruising to a safe win, people not unreasonably thought that the prospective government should have something to say on its own account; the incessant Tory knocking copy about someone who everyone knew wasn't going to win turned people off in droves.

    The mystery is why some PB Tories seem to think that stepping up the knocking copy on Corbyn is going to do anything other than turn people off even more?
  • Options
    The_ApocalypseThe_Apocalypse Posts: 7,830
    Sean_F said:

    surbiton said:

    Sean_F said:

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    in or out of the EU, we're bound to get a socialist government at some point.
    I'd rather it not be a government that included
    (a. John McDonnell
    (b. Anyone who admires Lenin, Mao, Chavez, Julian Assange and watches RT. It's one thing to admire social democrats across the European continent, it's another thing to believe that a USSR style system is desirable for Britain.
    Barely two months ago, people here and almost everywhere were saying the same about Corbyn. The moment his IRA "friends" stories will come out, the moment his association with Hamas will come out etc. etc.

    Bugger all happened. In fact, I think, he got more street cred among young people. Why have posters about foreign revolutionaries, when you have one at home. In reality, he has hardly even shouted in anger. His politics is not based on any intellectual analysis. He is a waffle but a sincere waffler. The last bit, I think, helps him. He is seen as genuine.
    While a lot of young people might think it would be cool if we were more like Cuba, Venezuela, or North Korea, I think The Apocalypse's point is that this would not be a desirable thing.
    Yep, that's the point I was trying to make.

    I also doubt sincerely that vast majority of Corbyn's voters actually want us to be like North Korea.

    I know some Corbynistas on my Timeline that where admiring Castro and Chavez and appear to believe that anything that goes wrong in those countries is down to the capitalist West. It's odd to see the people with Iphones who admire people like Drake and his lifestyle believing that such views aren't at all contradictory with liking Chavez and Castro.
  • Options
    ChrisChris Posts: 11,141

    Mortimer said:

    surbiton said:

    Mortimer said:

    The LD = UKIP scores are horrific for a party that is about to be led by a septugenarian - even if he is only a stop gap.

    LDs below five seats at the next election?
    No. It will gain a few. Probably 18-20.
    How? 5% is an ELE...
    The Lib Dem share of the vote went down last month and they still made net gains.

    Perhaps they were lucky this time that they had should be facing such an inept Tory leader.
    There are so few Lib Dem seats now that the statistical variability is large. But outside Scotland they made a net gain of only one seat. So mostly they were lucky that the SNP fell back.
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,074

    Roger said:

    My irony meter just exploded, isn't it usually the other way around?

    https://twitter.com/guardian/status/881212943760805890

    ... “You rob to support a drug habit, I do drugs to support a robbery habit”, (From the excellent 'Baby Driver')
    I watched Baby Driver yesterday, absolutely fecking loved it.

    Today I watched Despicable Me 3.
    I just saw Despicable Me 3. 6/10.
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549

    surbiton said:

    Sean_F said:

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.



    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    in or out of the EU, we're bound to get a socialist government at some point.
    I'd rather it not be a government that included
    (a. John McDonnell
    (b. Anyone who admires Lenin, Mao, Chavez, Julian Assange and watches RT. It's one thing to admire social democrats across the European continent, it's another thing to believe that a USSR style system is desirable for Britain.
    Barely two months ago, people here and almost everywhere were saying the same about Corbyn. The moment his IRA "friends" stories will come out, the moment his association with Hamas will come out etc. etc.

    Bugger all happened. In fact, I think, he got more street cred among young people. Why have posters about foreign revolutionaries, when you have one at home. In reality, he has hardly even shouted in anger. His politics is not based on any intellectual analysis. He is a waffle but a sincere waffler. The last bit, I think, helps him. He is seen as genuine.
    Well, my post wasn't a comment about how the wider electorate see Corbyn. It me expressing MY own views about what I'd like a socialist government to look like in Britain. Thus, the 'I'd rather not be'. In any case though, during the GE I was saying that the IRA stuff wasn't going to shift voters.

    In response to your points though, if anything will bring Corbyn down, it'll be taking his voters for granted and believing that he has them in the bag - as well as operating on a TMay style strategy of believing that you can win a GE by only trying to appeal to WWC/JAMs voters (which his Brexit strategy implies).

    I am not sure PB is the best place to dissect his Brexit views. He does not see Brexit through the prism most PBers see through. Two points are important to him:

    1. Workers rights

    2. Reflation, when necessary.

    So, there is a conflict. Even many people close to him are Remainers.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,612
    edited July 2017
    Chris said:

    Mortimer said:

    surbiton said:

    Mortimer said:

    The LD = UKIP scores are horrific for a party that is about to be led by a septugenarian - even if he is only a stop gap.

    LDs below five seats at the next election?
    No. It will gain a few. Probably 18-20.
    How? 5% is an ELE...
    The Lib Dem share of the vote went down last month and they still made net gains.

    Perhaps they were lucky this time that they had should be facing such an inept Tory leader.
    There are so few Lib Dem seats now that the statistical variability is large. But outside Scotland they made a net gain of only one seat. So mostly they were lucky that the SNP fell back.
    That's kinda my point.

    When Dave became Tory leader there were 62 Lib Dem MPs, when his tenure ended there were but 8 Lib Dem MPs.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,612
    rcs1000 said:

    Roger said:

    My irony meter just exploded, isn't it usually the other way around?

    https://twitter.com/guardian/status/881212943760805890

    ... “You rob to support a drug habit, I do drugs to support a robbery habit”, (From the excellent 'Baby Driver')
    I watched Baby Driver yesterday, absolutely fecking loved it.

    Today I watched Despicable Me 3.
    I just saw Despicable Me 3. 6/10.
    Yup, not as good as the first two.
  • Options
    RogerRoger Posts: 18,906
    surbiton said:

    Sean_F said:

    IanB2 said:

    Brexit will lead inexorably to the election of a socialist government. Which wasn't the future its advocates imagined, at all.

    Looking at recent polls, and other fundamentals we can't really say for sure that it's going to lead to the election of the socialist government, tbf. Politics is very unpredictable right now.

    That said, Brexit does appear to have rather unexpectedly moved the political centre more leftwards. I think many Brexiteers would have liked to have seen Britain go down a root of small state, low regulation, low tax. As it is, many voters seem to want the end of austerity and the expansion of the state particuarly in regard to public services such as health and education. I don't think many Brexiteers would have expected that at all, although I think many Leave Tories would be prepared to compromise on this issue in order to avoid a Corbyn government.
    in or out of the EU, we're bound to get a socialist government at some point.
    I'd rather it not be a government that included
    (a. John McDonnell
    (b. Anyone who admires Lenin, Mao, Chavez, Julian Assange and watches RT. It's one thing to admire social democrats across the European continent, it's another thing to believe that a USSR style system is desirable for Britain.
    Barely two months ago, people here and almost everywhere were saying the same about Corbyn. The moment his IRA "friends" stories will come out, the moment his association with Hamas will come out etc. etc.

    Bugger all happened. In fact, I think, he got more street cred among young people. Why have posters about foreign revolutionaries, when you have one at home. In reality, he has hardly even shouted in anger. His politics is not based on any intellectual analysis. He is a waffle but a sincere waffler. The last bit, I think, helps him. He is seen as genuine.
    It was never going to work. More people support Hamas and Hezbollah than the brutal Netanyahu government. This site is not representative. During the Gaza slaughter the figures were overwhelming. You can't judge anything by the noise Guido makes
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,409
    Sean_F said:

    surbiton said:

    Mortimer said:

    surbiton said:

    When is the next election ? October 5th, 12th , 19th or the 26th ?

    2021, probably...
    I don't think they can even limp until February 2018 .
    Genuine question - now the QS is passed how do you see an election being called
    People forget that an election is not in the gift of the government, now.
    That does not answer my question
  • Options
    The_ApocalypseThe_Apocalypse Posts: 7,830
    edited July 2017
    IanB2 said:



    Since all the signs were that Mrs M was cruising to a safe win, people not unreasonably thought that the prospective government should have something to say on its own account; the incessant Tory knocking copy about someone who everyone knew wasn't going to win turned people off in droves.

    The mystery is why some PB Tories seem to think that stepping up the knocking copy on Corbyn is going to do anything other than turn people off even more?

    While that's happened in past discussions on here (people believing that criticisms of Corbyn will win the GE for the Tories) that isn't what this discussion was about, and I don't see how it couldn't be interpreted otherwise. I expressed my own personal views as to why I'd hope a future socialist government wouldn't include John McDonnell and anyone who admires those who have pursued undemocratic socialist systems (as opposed to democratic socialists/social democrats in Europe). I wasn't advocating the Tories pursue a hyper-critical strategy towards Corbyn in a GE, if anything for the last few weeks I've been saying they need to run a positive camapign and actually give people reasons to vote FOR them. And right now, I'm a LD voter.
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549

    PeterC said:

    IanB2 said:

    PeterC said:

    IanB2 said:

    Imagine there was a referendum tomorrow with the question ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?’ How would you vote?

    Leave / Remain - 2017 Vote:

    Con: 65 / 34
    Lab: 20 / 76
    LD: 21 / 80
    UKIP: 94 / 6

    http://survation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Final-Survation-UK-Attitudes-Tracker-280617MMDLLMTDC-1c0d1h7-chd.pdf

    Which party is out of step with its voters?

    Two thoughts, Where does one find the 6% of UKIP voters who have changed their minds.

    Secondly does 76% of Labour voters and 80% of LD voters, plus 34% of Tory voters mean a majority overall?
    Staggering how frightened so many Labour MPs appear to be of just 20% of their supporters. This won't last. They'll go for a second referendum to put a stop to Brexit, if ever they get the chance.
    Dream on while Corbyn is in charge. It's like Nixon in China - only the Tories can cancel Brexit, and that would only be considered if the negotiations were to collapse altogether.
    I agree Labour politicians couldn't vote to scrap it, which is where the second vote comes in.
    Personally I think it quite likely that the negotiations will end without a ratified agreement - there are just too many hurdles which would have to have been cleared. The specific choice could then crystallise: revoke A50 and remain OR leave completely. That would be a huge crisis. I do not think the political class could cope with such a dilemma and would be tempted to throw it back to a referendum. Lord knows what might happen then!
    That is quite possible. The question would be Deal vs WTO Brexit, but thede would be a lot wanting Remain as a third option. I think it very likely that a government would funk the decision and go for a referendum.
    Exactly. However, it is quite possible the wolf in May [ or, Corbyn, as some here seem to think ] will come out. I always thought she was a Hard Brexiter,

    That is when the mother and father of rebellions will occur. After all, there is nothing more democratic than asking the people again.
  • Options
    surbitonsurbiton Posts: 13,549
    Another topic.

    Has anyone been to Doha on Qatar ? What is the lounge like ? I presume plush like Dubai.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,612
    Brexit and Corbynism, two cheeks of the same arse

    https://twitter.com/jk_rowling/status/881114072871301120
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,209
    Scott_P said:
    Lol! There wasn't as much litter as there usually is.
  • Options
    Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 49,468

    Mr. Eagles, disregarding the highly improbable (Osborne/Cameron returning) what's your preferred course of events as far as the Conservative leadership goes?

    Theresa May is ousted at conference and replaced by Johnny Mercer.
    Accrington Stanley Johnny Mercer? Who are they?
  • Options
    Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 49,468

    Brexit and Corbynism, two cheeks of the same arse

    https://twitter.com/jk_rowling/status/881114072871301120

    LEAVE 52%
    REMAIN 48%


    :innocent:
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,409
    Surbiton

    'I am yet to be convinced about his intellectual thoroughness. You would not think of him as a Marxixt academic. How many articles has he written even in his backbench days.

    I think people do see him as sincere whereas they see most politicians as a bunch of rats.'

    His policies would put our country back decades. Interesting that business is sounding alarm over both Brexit and the politics in the UK. They are well aware how destructive Corbyn would be. The idiotic idea to pay £10 per hour to 16 and 17 year olds shows how inept her is. In the US there is a move to increase the minimum wage and McDonalds have already announced that they will automate their business to save costs

    The minute there is a sign that Corbyn may take office business will take steps to defend themselves and suddenly Corbyn will find his forest of money trees have disappeared to Ireland or France, both in the EU, or even the US who are looking at 15% corporation tax
  • Options
    RogerRoger Posts: 18,906

    rcs1000 said:

    Roger said:

    My irony meter just exploded, isn't it usually the other way around?

    https://twitter.com/guardian/status/881212943760805890

    ... “You rob to support a drug habit, I do drugs to support a robbery habit”, (From the excellent 'Baby Driver')
    I watched Baby Driver yesterday, absolutely fecking loved it.

    Today I watched Despicable Me 3.
    I just saw Despicable Me 3. 6/10.
    Yup, not as good as the first two.
    But doesn't he remind you of Theresa?
This discussion has been closed.