Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Why Populism Trumps the Status Quo

13

Comments

  • Options
    Pulpstar said:

    Currently;

    FF 67.3% AJ 32.7%

    Down from 69.5%, the fightback is on!!

    Shame he needs about 150% of the remaining vote.
    Leftwing areas slow counting ... again :p ?
    Luckily for Juppé there are 1.3m votes left to count in Miami-Dade Bordeaux, should see him through
  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,925
    edited November 2016
    Is TSE crying into his fast redial button after Ball's eviction?
  • Options
    Some judges who truly are the enemies of the people.

    https://twitter.com/harrywalker1/status/802964829438738433
  • Options
    GIN1138 said:

    Is TSE crying into his fast redial button after Ball's eviction?

    Been crying like a disgraced televangelist when I found out the result last night
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,208

    @MattChorley: Judges rule against Ed Balls and Honey G. #EnemiesOfThePeople

    That doesn't really work for Honey G. She's hated.
  • Options
    nunununu Posts: 6,024

    This guy is something else entirely. The whole gracious 'unifier' theme has rapidly fallen away. Also, so much for him becoming presidential now he no longer has to campaign. The Trump we saw was the true Trump.

    Donald J. TrumpVerified account
    @realDonaldTrump
    In addition to winning the Electoral College in a landslide, I won the popular vote if you deduct the millions of people who voted illegally

    he must have really small hands. So insecure.
  • Options
    tlg86 said:

    @MattChorley: Judges rule against Ed Balls and Honey G. #EnemiesOfThePeople

    That doesn't really work for Honey G. She's hated.
    Ah, I haven't watched X Factor for years.
  • Options
    MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 37,631
    edited November 2016

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    I saw estimates of up to 3m illegal votes based on a study done for the 2012 election assuming similar numbers and that they all broke for Clinton it could actually be the case.
  • Options
    SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 20,745
    Floater said:
    Thanks for the link. Needs to be read by everyone on the left. Then acted on.
  • Options
    nunununu Posts: 6,024

    This guy is something else entirely. The whole gracious 'unifier' theme has rapidly fallen away. Also, so much for him becoming presidential now he no longer has to campaign. The Trump we saw was the true Trump.

    Donald J. TrumpVerified account
    @realDonaldTrump
    In addition to winning the Electoral College in a landslide, I won the popular vote if you deduct the millions of people who voted illegally

    yes, i'm sure many middle class college educated people voted for him thinking he will pivot once elected......

    Michael McDonald ‏@ElectProject 21h

    Prepare for more scamming of American taxpayers as Trump charges millions of Secret Service for space at Trump Tower, space on plane flights
  • Options
    MarkHopkinsMarkHopkins Posts: 5,584
    Alistair said:

    That's President-Elect Trump to you.

  • Options
    I know it's a state issue, but given the control the GOP have of most states, that tweet from Trump is a harbinger of voter restrictions that would make Jim Crow blush isn't it?
  • Options
    foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548

    I know it's a state issue, but given the control the GOP have of most states, that tweet from Trump is a harbinger of voter restrictions that would make Jim Crow blush isn't it?

    Nailed on.

    One man one vote, as long as it is a white man.
  • Options
    ParistondaParistonda Posts: 1,819
    Attention turning to the Socialist Primary now - Hollande should be announcing soon whether he will stand or not. I think he will. I just don't see a first term President walking away from a chance to win, however miniscule. If he walks away it's not like he gains dignity - he will just be stepping down as the most unpopular Pres ever. He'll most likely lose the primary, but he's got to roll the dice at least.
  • Options
    FregglesFreggles Posts: 3,486

    Alistair said:

    That's President-Elect Trump to you.

    Your bomb shelter of self satisfaction at seeing your political rivals defeated, is not deep enough to insulate you from the awfulness of the reality that this man will be President
  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,925

    GIN1138 said:

    Is TSE crying into his fast redial button after Ball's eviction?

    Been crying like a disgraced televangelist when I found out the result last night
    Well Mothers pleased to see the back him! :smiley:
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,149

    Attention turning to the Socialist Primary now - Hollande should be announcing soon whether he will stand or not. I think he will. I just don't see a first term President walking away from a chance to win, however miniscule. If he walks away it's not like he gains dignity - he will just be stepping down as the most unpopular Pres ever. He'll most likely lose the primary, but he's got to roll the dice at least.

    I can't see it. He was clinging to the hope that his big enemy Sarkozy would make it through but after his defeat there's nothing left to play for. That Valls has already come out against him has to signal that it's all over.
  • Options
    nunununu Posts: 6,024
    MaxPB said:

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    I saw estimates of up to 3m illegal votes based on a study done for the 2012 election assuming similar numbers and that they all broke for Clinton it could actually be the case.
    whats the source?
  • Options
    FregglesFreggles Posts: 3,486

    Floater said:
    Thanks for the link. Needs to be read by everyone on the left. Then acted on.
    Is this another one of those "Blame everyone except Trump voters for Trump, because they don't know better" pieces
  • Options
    AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670

    I know it's a state issue, but given the control the GOP have of most states, that tweet from Trump is a harbinger of voter restrictions that would make Jim Crow blush isn't it?

    The SCOTUS gutting the Voting Rights Act in holder vs Shelby County as racism was over is going to go down as an all time top 10 horrible decison
  • Options
    So there we have it. In the end, there was no "return" of left-wing voters to Juppé, some having supposed that they may have lent their vote to Fillon to send Sarkozy home in the first round. Indeed, with Sarkozy's backing Fillon widened his advantage over Juppé (67% to 33% with precious little left to count).

    What does this mean for the national picture?

    Fillon takes over Juppé's position as strong favourite, though he lacks the support of Francois Bayrou. Whilst that is unlikely to imperil him in a run-off against Le Pen - Bayrou's centrists will take Fillon over Le Pen - it does make the first round a little complicated.

    The first round in France is always fragmented. Even De Gaulle needed a second round to win a majority. With Le Pen remarkably consistent on 30% of the polls, and the far-left likely to take 15% (with Mélenchon the most charismatic candidate).

    That leaves 55% between Fillon, Bayrou, the Socialist (Valls, Hollande or Montebourg) and the enterprising Macron (who will now stand). The Socialist might get 10%, Bayrou 8%. That leaves 25% for Fillon v 12% Macron. Macron will need to turn the tables.
  • Options
    nunununu Posts: 6,024
    true....

    ate Cohn ‏@Nate_Cohn 40m40 minutes ago Washington, DC

    Hard to argue against an audit/recount if the president-elect asserts, without any evidence, that were millions of illegal votes
    0 replies . 2,720 retweets 2,963 likes
  • Options

    Attention turning to the Socialist Primary now - Hollande should be announcing soon whether he will stand or not. I think he will. I just don't see a first term President walking away from a chance to win, however miniscule. If he walks away it's not like he gains dignity - he will just be stepping down as the most unpopular Pres ever. He'll most likely lose the primary, but he's got to roll the dice at least.

    I can't see it. He was clinging to the hope that his big enemy Sarkozy would make it through but after his defeat there's nothing left to play for. That Valls has already come out against him has to signal that it's all over.
    If Valls looked any more likely to do well nationally, I might agree. But Hollande might win the primary, and lose the presidency, which he would do even if he was 50% more popular.
  • Options
    Talk about pressure, that Italian referendum could have a lot of fun consequences

    https://twitter.com/FT/status/802988139249864704
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 8,006

    So there we have it. In the end, there was no "return" of left-wing voters to Juppé, some having supposed that they may have lent their vote to Fillon to send Sarkozy home in the first round. Indeed, with Sarkozy's backing Fillon widened his advantage over Juppé (67% to 33% with precious little left to count).

    What does this mean for the national picture?

    Fillon takes over Juppé's position as strong favourite, though he lacks the support of Francois Bayrou. Whilst that is unlikely to imperil him in a run-off against Le Pen - Bayrou's centrists will take Fillon over Le Pen - it does make the first round a little complicated.

    The first round in France is always fragmented. Even De Gaulle needed a second round to win a majority. With Le Pen remarkably consistent on 30% of the polls, and the far-left likely to take 15% (with Mélenchon the most charismatic candidate).

    That leaves 55% between Fillon, Bayrou, the Socialist (Valls, Hollande or Montebourg) and the enterprising Macron (who will now stand). The Socialist might get 10%, Bayrou 8%. That leaves 25% for Fillon v 12% Macron. Macron will need to turn the tables.

    Macron has a chance.
  • Options
    Barnesian said:

    So there we have it. In the end, there was no "return" of left-wing voters to Juppé, some having supposed that they may have lent their vote to Fillon to send Sarkozy home in the first round. Indeed, with Sarkozy's backing Fillon widened his advantage over Juppé (67% to 33% with precious little left to count).

    What does this mean for the national picture?

    Fillon takes over Juppé's position as strong favourite, though he lacks the support of Francois Bayrou. Whilst that is unlikely to imperil him in a run-off against Le Pen - Bayrou's centrists will take Fillon over Le Pen - it does make the first round a little complicated.

    The first round in France is always fragmented. Even De Gaulle needed a second round to win a majority. With Le Pen remarkably consistent on 30% of the polls, and the far-left likely to take 15% (with Mélenchon the most charismatic candidate).

    That leaves 55% between Fillon, Bayrou, the Socialist (Valls, Hollande or Montebourg) and the enterprising Macron (who will now stand). The Socialist might get 10%, Bayrou 8%. That leaves 25% for Fillon v 12% Macron. Macron will need to turn the tables.

    Macron has a chance.
    He's got a chance to turn the tables, but that's what he needs to do. He needs to take himself to 18%, and beat Fillon to 17%.
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,208

    Talk about pressure, that Italian referendum could have a lot of fun consequences

    https://twitter.com/FT/status/802988139249864704

    Progetto Paura?
  • Options
    Get in!

    I've retaken my rightful place atop the PB fantasy football league.

    It was only a blip because of the fixture calendar.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,149
    O/T Putin's published an article in La Stampa in which he says NATO is outdated, America is not a banana republic whose election could be influenced from outside, the UN is the most legitimate international body and that Russia does not aspire to global dominance or expansion.

    http://www.lastampa.it/2016/11/27/cultura/opinioni/editoriali/il-tempo-di-fidarsi-della-russia-fronte-comune-contro-il-terrore-KxnZkA38RMHFNSiG1V1tYN/pagina.html
  • Options
    SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 20,745

    O/T Putin's published an article in La Stampa in which he says NATO is outdated, America is not a banana republic whose election could be influenced from outside, the UN is the most legitimate international body and that Russia does not aspire to global dominance or expansion.

    http://www.lastampa.it/2016/11/27/cultura/opinioni/editoriali/il-tempo-di-fidarsi-della-russia-fronte-comune-contro-il-terrore-KxnZkA38RMHFNSiG1V1tYN/pagina.html

    Does he claim to be democratically elected too?
  • Options
    Some Leavers really do want to destroy the Union Kingom don't they. They truly are unpatriotic.

    https://twitter.com/Arron_banks/status/802253171636715520
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,149

    Barnesian said:

    So there we have it. In the end, there was no "return" of left-wing voters to Juppé, some having supposed that they may have lent their vote to Fillon to send Sarkozy home in the first round. Indeed, with Sarkozy's backing Fillon widened his advantage over Juppé (67% to 33% with precious little left to count).

    What does this mean for the national picture?

    Fillon takes over Juppé's position as strong favourite, though he lacks the support of Francois Bayrou. Whilst that is unlikely to imperil him in a run-off against Le Pen - Bayrou's centrists will take Fillon over Le Pen - it does make the first round a little complicated.

    The first round in France is always fragmented. Even De Gaulle needed a second round to win a majority. With Le Pen remarkably consistent on 30% of the polls, and the far-left likely to take 15% (with Mélenchon the most charismatic candidate).

    That leaves 55% between Fillon, Bayrou, the Socialist (Valls, Hollande or Montebourg) and the enterprising Macron (who will now stand). The Socialist might get 10%, Bayrou 8%. That leaves 25% for Fillon v 12% Macron. Macron will need to turn the tables.

    Macron has a chance.
    He's got a chance to turn the tables, but that's what he needs to do. He needs to take himself to 18%, and beat Fillon to 17%.
    His best route to achieve that is if would-be Fillon voters can be persuaded to vote Le Pen in the first round as a protest on the basis that she won't win the run off and President Fillon is inevitable.
  • Options
    GeoffMGeoffM Posts: 6,071
    Freggles said:

    Alistair said:

    That's President-Elect Trump to you.

    Your bomb shelter of self satisfaction at seeing your political rivals defeated, is not deep enough to insulate you from the awfulness of the reality that this man will be President
    In my case it's actually a deckchair of self satisfaction atop a veranda of gloating, to be fair.

    #MAGA
  • Options
    DromedaryDromedary Posts: 1,194
    Alistair said:

    Trump is already making money from being president elect. The Secret Service have had to rent out two floors of Trump Towers. That is done at commercial rates and it goes staight feom the public's purse to Trump's company.

    I wonder whether that will stop at the inauguration. If not, perhaps part of the White House could be let out to reimburse the US people! :)

    Meanwhile, Nicolas Dupont-Aignan, leader of Debout La France, who is currently scoring around 4% in opinion polls, is now available at Betfair.

  • Options
    nunununu Posts: 6,024

    Barnesian said:

    So there we have it. In the end, there was no "return" of left-wing voters to Juppé, some having supposed that they may have lent their vote to Fillon to send Sarkozy home in the first round. Indeed, with Sarkozy's backing Fillon widened his advantage over Juppé (67% to 33% with precious little left to count).

    What does this mean for the national picture?

    Fillon takes over Juppé's position as strong favourite, though he lacks the support of Francois Bayrou. Whilst that is unlikely to imperil him in a run-off against Le Pen - Bayrou's centrists will take Fillon over Le Pen - it does make the first round a little complicated.

    The first round in France is always fragmented. Even De Gaulle needed a second round to win a majority. With Le Pen remarkably consistent on 30% of the polls, and the far-left likely to take 15% (with Mélenchon the most charismatic candidate).

    That leaves 55% between Fillon, Bayrou, the Socialist (Valls, Hollande or Montebourg) and the enterprising Macron (who will now stand). The Socialist might get 10%, Bayrou 8%. That leaves 25% for Fillon v 12% Macron. Macron will need to turn the tables.

    Macron has a chance.
    He's got a chance to turn the tables, but that's what he needs to do. He needs to take himself to 18%, and beat Fillon to 17%.
    His best route to achieve that is if would-be Fillon voters can be persuaded to vote Le Pen in the first round as a protest on the basis that she won't win the run off and President Fillon is inevitable.
    Where is Fillon going with his policy of stopping gay people from adopting? Is he hopig to attract some older Le Pen voters? Would think that would hurt him in the general even if it helped him with the base.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,149
    Dromedary said:

    Alistair said:

    Trump is already making money from being president elect. The Secret Service have had to rent out two floors of Trump Towers. That is done at commercial rates and it goes staight feom the public's purse to Trump's company.

    I wonder whether that will stop at the inauguration. If not, perhaps part of the White House could be let out to reimburse the US people! :)
    Interesting idea. Apparently it needs major renovations so maybe Trump could turn it into a museum for the duration of his presidency and live full time at home.
  • Options
    nunu said:

    Barnesian said:

    So there we have it. In the end, there was no "return" of left-wing voters to Juppé, some having supposed that they may have lent their vote to Fillon to send Sarkozy home in the first round. Indeed, with Sarkozy's backing Fillon widened his advantage over Juppé (67% to 33% with precious little left to count).

    What does this mean for the national picture?

    Fillon takes over Juppé's position as strong favourite, though he lacks the support of Francois Bayrou. Whilst that is unlikely to imperil him in a run-off against Le Pen - Bayrou's centrists will take Fillon over Le Pen - it does make the first round a little complicated.

    The first round in France is always fragmented. Even De Gaulle needed a second round to win a majority. With Le Pen remarkably consistent on 30% of the polls, and the far-left likely to take 15% (with Mélenchon the most charismatic candidate).

    That leaves 55% between Fillon, Bayrou, the Socialist (Valls, Hollande or Montebourg) and the enterprising Macron (who will now stand). The Socialist might get 10%, Bayrou 8%. That leaves 25% for Fillon v 12% Macron. Macron will need to turn the tables.

    Macron has a chance.
    He's got a chance to turn the tables, but that's what he needs to do. He needs to take himself to 18%, and beat Fillon to 17%.
    His best route to achieve that is if would-be Fillon voters can be persuaded to vote Le Pen in the first round as a protest on the basis that she won't win the run off and President Fillon is inevitable.
    Where is Fillon going with his policy of stopping gay people from adopting? Is he hopig to attract some older Le Pen voters? Would think that would hurt him in the general even if it helped him with the base.
    It's true to the Catholic right in France, of which he is a member. The "old France" under threat, etc. But if it were not for his personal beliefs, I do not think he would have taken it on as a policy. I think he wants a policy that takes France a step in the "right" direction, without really alienating opponents.
  • Options

    Get in!

    I've retaken my rightful place atop the PB fantasy football league.

    It was only a blip because of the fixture calendar.

    Can't even remember if I won last season, frankly shocked to be even mid table since I was in the US for a critical part of the season...
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,149
    nunu said:

    Barnesian said:

    So there we have it. In the end, there was no "return" of left-wing voters to Juppé, some having supposed that they may have lent their vote to Fillon to send Sarkozy home in the first round. Indeed, with Sarkozy's backing Fillon widened his advantage over Juppé (67% to 33% with precious little left to count).

    What does this mean for the national picture?

    Fillon takes over Juppé's position as strong favourite, though he lacks the support of Francois Bayrou. Whilst that is unlikely to imperil him in a run-off against Le Pen - Bayrou's centrists will take Fillon over Le Pen - it does make the first round a little complicated.

    The first round in France is always fragmented. Even De Gaulle needed a second round to win a majority. With Le Pen remarkably consistent on 30% of the polls, and the far-left likely to take 15% (with Mélenchon the most charismatic candidate).

    That leaves 55% between Fillon, Bayrou, the Socialist (Valls, Hollande or Montebourg) and the enterprising Macron (who will now stand). The Socialist might get 10%, Bayrou 8%. That leaves 25% for Fillon v 12% Macron. Macron will need to turn the tables.

    Macron has a chance.
    He's got a chance to turn the tables, but that's what he needs to do. He needs to take himself to 18%, and beat Fillon to 17%.
    His best route to achieve that is if would-be Fillon voters can be persuaded to vote Le Pen in the first round as a protest on the basis that she won't win the run off and President Fillon is inevitable.
    Where is Fillon going with his policy of stopping gay people from adopting? Is he hopig to attract some older Le Pen voters? Would think that would hurt him in the general even if it helped him with the base.
    He's always voted against gay rights measures even going back to the decriminalisation/equalisation of the age of consent in the early 80s. The adoption issue is complex as in France there are two different legal forms of adoption - it's the form which changes the legal parentage which Fillon doesn't think should be available if the adopting couple are of the same sex. In practice this would make it very difficult to adopt apart from within their own families. There's a big question mark about whether it's even constitutional so other than it being a personal conviction, it seems like nothing more than a dog whistle for the traditionalist Catholic vote.

    In political terms I do think it's a mistake in positioning which Le Pen will be able to exploit if she's facing him in the run off, and will motivate younger votes to turn out for candidate best placed to stop Fillon getting into the final round.
  • Options
    Chelsea fans have always been and will always be racists anti semites and generally utter scum. Except for an ex girlfriend of mine. She was lovely.

    COYS
  • Options

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    Sad thing is, I bet loads on this site agree with this tweet.
  • Options

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    Sad thing is, I bet loads on this site agree with this tweet.
    I bet they don't. How do we define loads?
  • Options
    AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    MaxPB said:

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    I saw estimates of up to 3m illegal votes based on a study done for the 2012 election assuming similar numbers and that they all broke for Clinton it could actually be the case.
    Except all the detected cases of voter fraud have been Republicans.

    Now you may think you have evidence showing otherwise but we live in a post fact world now
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,407
    edited November 2016
    Theresa May to meet her Polish counterpart in a demonstration of friendship, with the Poles telling the EU a deal over security and trade is essential just as the UK agree to send troops to the Poles eastern front. There is no way that the Poles or the Baltic Countries will play hard ball over UK negotiations, not least as they do not want to be exposed to Russia with only a yet to be formed tin pot EU army.
  • Options

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    Sad thing is, I bet loads on this site agree with this tweet.
    I bet they don't. How do we define loads?
    You want a definition of 'loads'? Really? Google is your friend.
  • Options
    daodaodaodao Posts: 821
    Fillon is not necessarily the best person to beat Le Pen in a 2nd round run off. He is more socially conservative than her. He also believes in the free market and reducing the power of the state, whereas Le Pen advocates more state control/regulation and is frankly more of a socialist. He may be suspect as being more sympathetic to Britain, given his wife's background. Non-PC left-leaning French folk won't be attracted to Fillon and votes of eliminated left-wing candidates may not transfer to him in the 2nd round.
  • Options
    JonathanJonathan Posts: 20,913

    Theresa May to meet her Polish counterpart in a demonstration of friendship, with the Poles telling the EU a deal over security and trade is essential just as the UK agree to send troops to the Poles eastern front. There is no way that the Poles or the Baltic Countries will play hard ball over UK negotiations, not least as they do not want to be exposed to Russia with only a yet to be formed tin pot EU army.

    May Pole dance?
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,154
    dr_spyn said:
    More truthful than he was about tuition fees then....
  • Options
    AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    daodao said:

    Fillon is not necessarily the best person to beat Le Pen in a 2nd round run off. He is more socially conservative than her. He also believes in the free market and reducing the power of the state, whereas Le Pen advocates more state control/regulation and is frankly more of a socialist. He may be suspect as being more sympathetic to Britain, given his wife's background. Non-PC left-leaning French folk won't be attracted to Fillon and votes of eliminated left-wing candidates may not transfer to him in the 2nd round.

    The polls seem to have Le Pen on about 35% against both of them, although there haven't been many surveys and the ones there have been are a bit out of date.
  • Options
    daodao said:

    Fillon is not necessarily the best person to beat Le Pen in a 2nd round run off. He is more socially conservative than her. He also believes in the free market and reducing the power of the state, whereas Le Pen advocates more state control/regulation and is frankly more of a socialist. He may be suspect as being more sympathetic to Britain, given his wife's background. Non-PC left-leaning French folk won't be attracted to Fillon and votes of eliminated left-wing candidates may not transfer to him in the 2nd round.

    He may well be more sympathetic to the UK but Le Pen admires Brexit and is out to destroy the EU
  • Options

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    Sad thing is, I bet loads on this site agree with this tweet.
    I bet they don't. How do we define loads?
    You want a definition of 'loads'? Really? Google is your friend.
    Shall we say 40%. How about a monkey at evens?
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,149

    daodao said:

    Fillon is not necessarily the best person to beat Le Pen in a 2nd round run off. He is more socially conservative than her. He also believes in the free market and reducing the power of the state, whereas Le Pen advocates more state control/regulation and is frankly more of a socialist. He may be suspect as being more sympathetic to Britain, given his wife's background. Non-PC left-leaning French folk won't be attracted to Fillon and votes of eliminated left-wing candidates may not transfer to him in the 2nd round.

    He may well be more sympathetic to the UK but Le Pen admires Brexit and is out to destroy the EU
    And destroying the EU helps us get a good deal how?
  • Options
    AndyJS said:

    daodao said:

    Fillon is not necessarily the best person to beat Le Pen in a 2nd round run off. He is more socially conservative than her. He also believes in the free market and reducing the power of the state, whereas Le Pen advocates more state control/regulation and is frankly more of a socialist. He may be suspect as being more sympathetic to Britain, given his wife's background. Non-PC left-leaning French folk won't be attracted to Fillon and votes of eliminated left-wing candidates may not transfer to him in the 2nd round.

    The polls seem to have Le Pen on about 35% against both of them, although there haven't been many surveys and the ones there have been are a bit out of date.
    You never sweep up 100% of the vote, but the fact remains that in actual regional elections, the FN candidate never managed to capitalise on a 40%+ first round share, and in many cases went backwards. FIllon is no more abhorrent to the right than Chirac in 2002, although his pros and cons are different.
  • Options

    daodao said:

    Fillon is not necessarily the best person to beat Le Pen in a 2nd round run off. He is more socially conservative than her. He also believes in the free market and reducing the power of the state, whereas Le Pen advocates more state control/regulation and is frankly more of a socialist. He may be suspect as being more sympathetic to Britain, given his wife's background. Non-PC left-leaning French folk won't be attracted to Fillon and votes of eliminated left-wing candidates may not transfer to him in the 2nd round.

    He may well be more sympathetic to the UK but Le Pen admires Brexit and is out to destroy the EU
    And destroying the EU helps us get a good deal how?
    Exactly - that is my point - Fillon will be better for UK and a deal
  • Options
    DromedaryDromedary Posts: 1,194
    edited November 2016
    Poll puts Fillon in front of Le Pen in first round:

    Fillon 26%
    Le Pen 24%
    Macron 14%
    Mélenchon 13%
    Hollande 9%
    Bayrou 6%
    Dupont-Aignan 3%
    Jadot 3%

    Second round:

    Fillon 67%
    Le Pen 33%

    Sample: 6093 people.

    Dupont-Aignan is interviewed here. He says there are three candidates for a break with the system: Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Marine Le Pen, and himself. That link goes to the part where he says that Le Pen says a lot of reasonable things but she won't win in the second round because many will have voted for her in the first only to protest. He says he hopes to be the French Donald Trump...but how many skyscrapers has he got? :) His presentation is way behind Trump's, and he doesn't come across as half as obnoxious or polarising. I'll be watching how he gets reported on Breitbart.
  • Options
    Jonathan said:

    Theresa May to meet her Polish counterpart in a demonstration of friendship, with the Poles telling the EU a deal over security and trade is essential just as the UK agree to send troops to the Poles eastern front. There is no way that the Poles or the Baltic Countries will play hard ball over UK negotiations, not least as they do not want to be exposed to Russia with only a yet to be formed tin pot EU army.

    May Pole dance?
    It will be interesting as she picks off each Country at head of state level.
  • Options

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    Sad thing is, I bet loads on this site agree with this tweet.
    I bet they don't. How do we define loads?
    You want a definition of 'loads'? Really? Google is your friend.
    Shall we say 40%. How about a monkey at evens?
    Didn't know that google was that specific at defining 'loads' at 40%. Also wasn't aware that monkeys were on PB, but you learn something new everyday :)
  • Options
    Fillon is no Thatcher

    Even the Telegraph is at it tonight. Just because he wants to trim the public sector by half a million does not make Fillon Thatcher. Certainly, a commitment to longer hours and a longer wait for the state pension are both rather Anglo-Saxon, but unlike Mrs T he is no proposing a change in the role of the state: but rather like Cameron he wants the state to do the same with less.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002
    Dromedary said:

    Poll puts Fillon in front of Le Pen in first round:

    Fillon 26%
    Le Pen 24%
    Macron 14%
    Mélenchon 13%
    Hollande 9%
    Bayrou 6%
    Dupont-Aignan 3%
    Jadot 3%

    Second round:

    Fillon 67%
    Le Pen 33%

    Sample: 6093 people.

    Dupont-Aignan is interviewed here. He says there are three candidates for a break with the system: Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Marine Le Pen, and himself. That link goes to the part where he says that Le Pen says a lot of reasonable things but she won't win in the second round because many will have voted for her in the first only to protest. He says he hopes to be the French Donald Trump...but how many skyscrapers has he got? :) His presentation is way behind Trump's, and he doesn't come across as half as obnoxious or polarising. I'll be watching how he gets reported on Breitbart.

    That's a pretty monstrous poll for Fillon, the big big participation in Led Republicans primary makes me think it isn't so far off the mark either. If Fillon pushes right, he might be able to monster Le Pen - maybe a possibility of a Fillon/Macron final contest ?
  • Options

    Jonathan said:

    Theresa May to meet her Polish counterpart in a demonstration of friendship, with the Poles telling the EU a deal over security and trade is essential just as the UK agree to send troops to the Poles eastern front. There is no way that the Poles or the Baltic Countries will play hard ball over UK negotiations, not least as they do not want to be exposed to Russia with only a yet to be formed tin pot EU army.

    May Pole dance?
    It will be interesting as she picks off each Country at head of state level.
    Or May poledancing. ?
  • Options
    Dromedary said:

    Poll puts Fillon in front of Le Pen in first round:

    Fillon 26%
    Le Pen 24%
    Macron 14%
    Mélenchon 13%
    Hollande 9%
    Bayrou 6%
    Dupont-Aignan 3%
    Jadot 3%

    Second round:

    Fillon 67%
    Le Pen 33%

    Sample: 6093 people.

    Dupont-Aignan is interviewed here. He says there are three candidates for a break with the system: Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Marine Le Pen, and himself. That link goes to the part where he says that Le Pen says a lot of reasonable things but she won't win in the second round because many will have voted for her in the first only to protest. He says he hopes to be the French Donald Trump...but how many skyscrapers has he got? :) His presentation is way behind Trump's, and he doesn't come across as half as obnoxious or polarising. I'll be watching how he gets reported on Breitbart.

    Two sentences on Dupont is too many.

    I think Fillon is unlikely to beat Le Pen or rather her share is a little too low, I think it could be 26/30 in the first round. She has however shown remarkable consistency, never venturing much beyond 27-30% in three years.
  • Options
    Pulpstar said:

    Dromedary said:

    Poll puts Fillon in front of Le Pen in first round:

    Fillon 26%
    Le Pen 24%
    Macron 14%
    Mélenchon 13%
    Hollande 9%
    Bayrou 6%
    Dupont-Aignan 3%
    Jadot 3%

    Second round:

    Fillon 67%
    Le Pen 33%

    Sample: 6093 people.

    Dupont-Aignan is interviewed here. He says there are three candidates for a break with the system: Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Marine Le Pen, and himself. That link goes to the part where he says that Le Pen says a lot of reasonable things but she won't win in the second round because many will have voted for her in the first only to protest. He says he hopes to be the French Donald Trump...but how many skyscrapers has he got? :) His presentation is way behind Trump's, and he doesn't come across as half as obnoxious or polarising. I'll be watching how he gets reported on Breitbart.

    That's a pretty monstrous poll for Fillon, the big big participation in Led Republicans primary makes me think it isn't so far off the mark either. If Fillon pushes right, he might be able to monster Le Pen - maybe a possibility of a Fillon/Macron final contest ?
    He'd prefer to face Le Pen, I don't see him heading off right. He's probably set a marker seeing off Sarkozy and will firm up support in the centre to get him into the second round.
  • Options
    NoEasyDay said:

    Jonathan said:

    Theresa May to meet her Polish counterpart in a demonstration of friendship, with the Poles telling the EU a deal over security and trade is essential just as the UK agree to send troops to the Poles eastern front. There is no way that the Poles or the Baltic Countries will play hard ball over UK negotiations, not least as they do not want to be exposed to Russia with only a yet to be formed tin pot EU army.

    May Pole dance?
    It will be interesting as she picks off each Country at head of state level.
    Or May poledancing. ?
    The *only* way for Britain to beat the EU blob is to win over Member States on their own terms, and to pry them away from the EU as an insitution. You can see the war going on between the (1) EU, (2) France and Germany, and (3) the other member states, Britain must get the right other party if it wants the right deal.
  • Options
    chestnutchestnut Posts: 7,341

    Jonathan said:

    Theresa May to meet her Polish counterpart in a demonstration of friendship, with the Poles telling the EU a deal over security and trade is essential just as the UK agree to send troops to the Poles eastern front. There is no way that the Poles or the Baltic Countries will play hard ball over UK negotiations, not least as they do not want to be exposed to Russia with only a yet to be formed tin pot EU army.

    May Pole dance?
    It will be interesting as she picks off each Country at head of state level.
    Her 'wait and see' approach may reel in some unlikely dividends.

    I wonder how much of an EU there will be to negotiate with in 2019.
  • Options

    NoEasyDay said:

    Jonathan said:

    Theresa May to meet her Polish counterpart in a demonstration of friendship, with the Poles telling the EU a deal over security and trade is essential just as the UK agree to send troops to the Poles eastern front. There is no way that the Poles or the Baltic Countries will play hard ball over UK negotiations, not least as they do not want to be exposed to Russia with only a yet to be formed tin pot EU army.

    May Pole dance?
    It will be interesting as she picks off each Country at head of state level.
    Or May poledancing. ?
    The *only* way for Britain to beat the EU blob is to win over Member States on their own terms, and to pry them away from the EU as an insitution. You can see the war going on between the (1) EU, (2) France and Germany, and (3) the other member states, Britain must get the right other party if it wants the right deal.
    You missed the humour i intended.

    Do you know what a pole dancer does ?

    Jokes are lost when you have to explain them
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,149

    The *only* way for Britain to beat the EU blob is to win over Member States on their own terms, and to pry them away from the EU as an insitution.

    Perhaps she should ask the Kremlin to send her a copy of their playbook.
  • Options
    chestnut said:

    Jonathan said:

    Theresa May to meet her Polish counterpart in a demonstration of friendship, with the Poles telling the EU a deal over security and trade is essential just as the UK agree to send troops to the Poles eastern front. There is no way that the Poles or the Baltic Countries will play hard ball over UK negotiations, not least as they do not want to be exposed to Russia with only a yet to be formed tin pot EU army.

    May Pole dance?
    It will be interesting as she picks off each Country at head of state level.
    Her 'wait and see' approach may reel in some unlikely dividends.

    I wonder how much of an EU there will be to negotiate with in 2019.
    I believe Theresa May will work Country by Country and a deal will be achieved but for heavens sake lets get on with and serve A50
  • Options
    nunununu Posts: 6,024

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    Sad thing is, I bet loads on this site agree with this tweet.
    f8 it. Might as well play this game aswell now, this is the way things are going, so here I go.....

    Many people have said The CIA won't satnd for trump and will get a false "radical islamic terrorist" or Socialist to "get rid of him".
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,074
    Pulpstar said:

    Dromedary said:

    Poll puts Fillon in front of Le Pen in first round:

    Fillon 26%
    Le Pen 24%
    Macron 14%
    Mélenchon 13%
    Hollande 9%
    Bayrou 6%
    Dupont-Aignan 3%
    Jadot 3%

    Second round:

    Fillon 67%
    Le Pen 33%

    Sample: 6093 people.

    Dupont-Aignan is interviewed here. He says there are three candidates for a break with the system: Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Marine Le Pen, and himself. That link goes to the part where he says that Le Pen says a lot of reasonable things but she won't win in the second round because many will have voted for her in the first only to protest. He says he hopes to be the French Donald Trump...but how many skyscrapers has he got? :) His presentation is way behind Trump's, and he doesn't come across as half as obnoxious or polarising. I'll be watching how he gets reported on Breitbart.

    That's a pretty monstrous poll for Fillon, the big big participation in Led Republicans primary makes me think it isn't so far off the mark either. If Fillon pushes right, he might be able to monster Le Pen - maybe a possibility of a Fillon/Macron final contest ?
    That's actually not inconceivable: I think that Le Pen and Fillon are fishing in the same broad area. Both are conservative (with a small 'c'), both are particularly concerned with the impact of Islamic immigration on France. And if you look at the Fillon vs Juppe debate, that was where he monstered her.

    The question, to me, is whether he is able to take five points or so off of her, ending up in the high 20s, against her in the mid 20s. The question then is whether there would be tactical voting on the left. I cannot see Bayrou, Hollande/Valls or Macron voters going to Melanchon to avoid Le Pen vs Fillon. I could see them going to Macron.
  • Options
    nunununu Posts: 6,024
    nunu said:

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    Sad thing is, I bet loads on this site agree with this tweet.
    f8 it. Might as well play this game aswell now, this is the way things are going, so here I go.....

    Many people have said The CIA won't satnd for trump and will get a false "radical islamic terrorist" or Socialist to "get rid of him".
    niel ‏@Taniel 2h

    Jokes & raised eyebrows aside, this allegation is scary in terms of what he will want Jeff Sessions & the DOJ to do/investigate/restrict.
    0 replies . 89 retweets 119 likes
  • Options
    NoEasyDay said:

    NoEasyDay said:

    Jonathan said:

    Theresa May to meet her Polish counterpart in a demonstration of friendship, with the Poles telling the EU a deal over security and trade is essential just as the UK agree to send troops to the Poles eastern front. There is no way that the Poles or the Baltic Countries will play hard ball over UK negotiations, not least as they do not want to be exposed to Russia with only a yet to be formed tin pot EU army.

    May Pole dance?
    It will be interesting as she picks off each Country at head of state level.
    Or May poledancing. ?
    The *only* way for Britain to beat the EU blob is to win over Member States on their own terms, and to pry them away from the EU as an insitution. You can see the war going on between the (1) EU, (2) France and Germany, and (3) the other member states, Britain must get the right other party if it wants the right deal.
    You missed the humour i intended.

    Do you know what a pole dancer does ?

    Jokes are lost when you have to explain them
    I couldn't be bothered to quote the previous reply instead of yours.
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,074

    daodao said:

    Fillon is not necessarily the best person to beat Le Pen in a 2nd round run off. He is more socially conservative than her. He also believes in the free market and reducing the power of the state, whereas Le Pen advocates more state control/regulation and is frankly more of a socialist. He may be suspect as being more sympathetic to Britain, given his wife's background. Non-PC left-leaning French folk won't be attracted to Fillon and votes of eliminated left-wing candidates may not transfer to him in the 2nd round.

    He may well be more sympathetic to the UK but Le Pen admires Brexit and is out to destroy the EU
    And destroying the EU helps us get a good deal how?
    Exactly - that is my point - Fillon will be better for UK and a deal
    I think Fillon would be excellent for France and for the UK. I think he would push hard against further EU integration, and against migrants from the failed states of North Africa. I think he would begin the difficult task of making France competitive again. I think he would be keen for the UK and France to have the best working relationship possible.

    What he would not do is hasten the end of the EU.
  • Options
    rcs1000 said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Dromedary said:

    Poll puts Fillon in front of Le Pen in first round:

    Fillon 26%
    Le Pen 24%
    Macron 14%
    Mélenchon 13%
    Hollande 9%
    Bayrou 6%
    Dupont-Aignan 3%
    Jadot 3%

    Second round:

    Fillon 67%
    Le Pen 33%

    Sample: 6093 people.

    Dupont-Aignan is interviewed here. He says there are three candidates for a break with the system: Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Marine Le Pen, and himself. That link goes to the part where he says that Le Pen says a lot of reasonable things but she won't win in the second round because many will have voted for her in the first only to protest. He says he hopes to be the French Donald Trump...but how many skyscrapers has he got? :) His presentation is way behind Trump's, and he doesn't come across as half as obnoxious or polarising. I'll be watching how he gets reported on Breitbart.

    That's a pretty monstrous poll for Fillon, the big big participation in Led Republicans primary makes me think it isn't so far off the mark either. If Fillon pushes right, he might be able to monster Le Pen - maybe a possibility of a Fillon/Macron final contest ?
    That's actually not inconceivable: I think that Le Pen and Fillon are fishing in the same broad area. Both are conservative (with a small 'c'), both are particularly concerned with the impact of Islamic immigration on France. And if you look at the Fillon vs Juppe debate, that was where he monstered her.

    The question, to me, is whether he is able to take five points or so off of her, ending up in the high 20s, against her in the mid 20s. The question then is whether there would be tactical voting on the left. I cannot see Bayrou, Hollande/Valls or Macron voters going to Melanchon to avoid Le Pen vs Fillon. I could see them going to Macron.
    I see if now, RCS's "100 Ways Macron Could Win This Election" - I think we're on number four at the moment...
  • Options
    BudGBudG Posts: 711

    Dromedary said:

    Poll puts Fillon in front of Le Pen in first round:

    Fillon 26%
    Le Pen 24%
    Macron 14%
    Mélenchon 13%
    Hollande 9%
    Bayrou 6%
    Dupont-Aignan 3%
    Jadot 3%

    Second round:

    Fillon 67%
    Le Pen 33%

    Sample: 6093 people.

    Dupont-Aignan is interviewed here. He says there are three candidates for a break with the system: Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Marine Le Pen, and himself. That link goes to the part where he says that Le Pen says a lot of reasonable things but she won't win in the second round because many will have voted for her in the first only to protest. He says he hopes to be the French Donald Trump...but how many skyscrapers has he got? :) His presentation is way behind Trump's, and he doesn't come across as half as obnoxious or polarising. I'll be watching how he gets reported on Breitbart.

    Two sentences on Dupont is too many.

    I think Fillon is unlikely to beat Le Pen or rather her share is a little too low, I think it could be 26/30 in the first round. She has however shown remarkable consistency, never venturing much beyond 27-30% in three years.
    Not surprised Fillon is doing well in this poll, he has just had the benefit of being involved in 4 televised debates in the past month or so and has had wall to wall media coverage during the Primary contest. The question is, will he hang on to the benefit gained from the recent media coverage.

    With about about 6 months to go before the actual election, I would expect his share of the first round vote drop somewhat.
  • Options
    chestnutchestnut Posts: 7,341
    rcs1000 said:

    daodao said:

    Fillon is not necessarily the best person to beat Le Pen in a 2nd round run off. He is more socially conservative than her. He also believes in the free market and reducing the power of the state, whereas Le Pen advocates more state control/regulation and is frankly more of a socialist. He may be suspect as being more sympathetic to Britain, given his wife's background. Non-PC left-leaning French folk won't be attracted to Fillon and votes of eliminated left-wing candidates may not transfer to him in the 2nd round.

    He may well be more sympathetic to the UK but Le Pen admires Brexit and is out to destroy the EU
    And destroying the EU helps us get a good deal how?
    Exactly - that is my point - Fillon will be better for UK and a deal
    I think Fillon would be excellent for France and for the UK. I think he would push hard against further EU integration, and against migrants from the failed states of North Africa. I think he would begin the difficult task of making France competitive again. I think he would be keen for the UK and France to have the best working relationship possible.

    What he would not do is hasten the end of the EU.
    Fillon is pro EU but anti-federalist. He's EFTA.
  • Options
    nunununu Posts: 6,024

    nunu said:

    Barnesian said:

    So there we have it. In the end, there was no "return" of left-wing voters to Juppé, some having supposed that they may have lent their vote to Fillon to send Sarkozy home in the first round. Indeed, with Sarkozy's backing Fillon widened his advantage over Juppé (67% to 33% with precious little left to count).

    What does this mean for the national picture?

    Fillon takes over Juppé's position as strong favourite, though he lacks the support of Francois Bayrou. Whilst that is unlikely to imperil him in a run-off against Le Pen - Bayrou's centrists will take Fillon over Le Pen - it does make the first round a little complicated.

    The first round in France is always fragmented. Even De Gaulle needed a second round to win a majority. With Le Pen remarkably consistent on 30% of the polls, and the far-left likely to take 15% (with Mélenchon the most charismatic candidate).

    That leaves 55% between Fillon, Bayrou, the Socialist (Valls, Hollande or Montebourg) and the enterprising Macron (who will now stand). The Socialist might get 10%, Bayrou 8%. That leaves 25% for Fillon v 12% Macron. Macron will need to turn the tables.

    Macron has a chance.
    He's got a chance to turn the tables, but that's what he needs to do. He needs to take himself to 18%, and beat Fillon to 17%.
    His best route to achieve that is if would-be Fillon voters can be persuaded to vote Le Pen in the first round as a protest on the basis that she won't win the run off and President Fillon is inevitable.
    Where is Fillon going with his policy of stopping gay people from adopting? Is he hopig to attract some older Le Pen voters? Would think that would hurt him in the general even if it helped him with the base.
    It's true to the Catholic right in France, of which he is a member. The "old France" under threat, etc. But if it were not for his personal beliefs, I do not think he would have taken it on as a policy. I think he wants a policy that takes France a step in the "right" direction, without really alienating opponents.
    Oh I didn't know there was a catholic right in France. Are they sizeable?
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,149
    rcs1000 said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Dromedary said:

    Poll puts Fillon in front of Le Pen in first round:

    Fillon 26%
    Le Pen 24%
    Macron 14%
    Mélenchon 13%
    Hollande 9%
    Bayrou 6%
    Dupont-Aignan 3%
    Jadot 3%

    Second round:

    Fillon 67%
    Le Pen 33%

    Sample: 6093 people.

    Dupont-Aignan is interviewed here. He says there are three candidates for a break with the system: Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Marine Le Pen, and himself. That link goes to the part where he says that Le Pen says a lot of reasonable things but she won't win in the second round because many will have voted for her in the first only to protest. He says he hopes to be the French Donald Trump...but how many skyscrapers has he got? :) His presentation is way behind Trump's, and he doesn't come across as half as obnoxious or polarising. I'll be watching how he gets reported on Breitbart.

    That's a pretty monstrous poll for Fillon, the big big participation in Led Republicans primary makes me think it isn't so far off the mark either. If Fillon pushes right, he might be able to monster Le Pen - maybe a possibility of a Fillon/Macron final contest ?
    That's actually not inconceivable: I think that Le Pen and Fillon are fishing in the same broad area. Both are conservative (with a small 'c'), both are particularly concerned with the impact of Islamic immigration on France. And if you look at the Fillon vs Juppe debate, that was where he monstered her.

    The question, to me, is whether he is able to take five points or so off of her, ending up in the high 20s, against her in the mid 20s. The question then is whether there would be tactical voting on the left. I cannot see Bayrou, Hollande/Valls or Macron voters going to Melanchon to avoid Le Pen vs Fillon. I could see them going to Macron.
    One risk for Fillon is that he has a record as PM to defend. I think Sarkozy would have been Le Pen's preferred opponent but she will be able to use a lot of the same tactics against Fillon. If they're fishing in the same pond and she is seen to get the better of him then it will be time to bet on her to go all the way.

    If Fillon crashes and burns before round one then I think it will be Le Pen v Macron or a Socialist candidate who is not yet on people's radars. There were rumours of another run by Ségolène Royal a few weeks ago...
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,074

    rcs1000 said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Dromedary said:

    Poll puts Fillon in front of Le Pen in first round:

    Fillon 26%
    Le Pen 24%
    Macron 14%
    Mélenchon 13%
    Hollande 9%
    Bayrou 6%
    Dupont-Aignan 3%
    Jadot 3%

    Second round:

    Fillon 67%
    Le Pen 33%

    Sample: 6093 people.

    Dupont-Aignan is interviewed here. He says there are three candidates for a break with the system: Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Marine Le Pen, and himself. That link goes to the part where he says that Le Pen says a lot of reasonable things but she won't win in the second round because many will have voted for her in the first only to protest. He says he hopes to be the French Donald Trump...but how many skyscrapers has he got? :) His presentation is way behind Trump's, and he doesn't come across as half as obnoxious or polarising. I'll be watching how he gets reported on Breitbart.

    That's a pretty monstrous poll for Fillon, the big big participation in Led Republicans primary makes me think it isn't so far off the mark either. If Fillon pushes right, he might be able to monster Le Pen - maybe a possibility of a Fillon/Macron final contest ?
    That's actually not inconceivable: I think that Le Pen and Fillon are fishing in the same broad area. Both are conservative (with a small 'c'), both are particularly concerned with the impact of Islamic immigration on France. And if you look at the Fillon vs Juppe debate, that was where he monstered her.

    The question, to me, is whether he is able to take five points or so off of her, ending up in the high 20s, against her in the mid 20s. The question then is whether there would be tactical voting on the left. I cannot see Bayrou, Hollande/Valls or Macron voters going to Melanchon to avoid Le Pen vs Fillon. I could see them going to Macron.
    I see if now, RCS's "100 Ways Macron Could Win This Election" - I think we're on number four at the moment...
    Granted, I might be long and wrong :)

    My view, fwiw, is that the French Left and Centre will end up giving someone 20% of the vote. It might be the new Socialist candidate, it might be Macron, it might even be Bayrou. But I think it is unlikely we'll end up with four candidates on the Centre and Left all polling between 9 and 15%.
  • Options
    MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,318
    I hardly know anything about French politics but am I the only person wondering:

    Why don't the Left put up a united candidate? If they did they would surely have an excellent chance of making the 2nd Round and at least a reasonable shot at winning the Presidency.
  • Options
    MikeL said:

    I hardly know anything about French politics but am I the only person wondering:

    Why don't the Left put up a united candidate? If they did they would surely have an excellent chance of making the 2nd Round and at least a reasonable shot at winning the Presidency.

    A united candidate of the Left is practically a contradiction in terms.
  • Options
    MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,318
    How many votes does Fillon need to make the 2nd Round?

    Looks like about 20% should be enough. Turnout last time was 35m so 20% would be 7m.

    In comparison - it looks like he got just under 3m votes today - 2,847k with just over 2% of districts still to report.
  • Options

    MikeL said:

    I hardly know anything about French politics but am I the only person wondering:

    Why don't the Left put up a united candidate? If they did they would surely have an excellent chance of making the 2nd Round and at least a reasonable shot at winning the Presidency.

    A united candidate of the Left is practically a contradiction in terms.
    Mélenchon (12%) and Hollande (9%) agree on about as much as Fillon and Le Pen.

    Mélenchon wants a metaphorical, perhaps even literal, revolution.

    The other far-lefts, even if you include the Green Front, poll 5%.
  • Options

    O/T Putin's published an article in La Stampa in which he says NATO is outdated, America is not a banana republic whose election could be influenced from outside, the UN is the most legitimate international body and that Russia does not aspire to global dominance or expansion.

    http://www.lastampa.it/2016/11/27/cultura/opinioni/editoriali/il-tempo-di-fidarsi-della-russia-fronte-comune-contro-il-terrore-KxnZkA38RMHFNSiG1V1tYN/pagina.html

    That's up there with Blair's "I think I'm a pretty straight sort of guy" for deluded
  • Options
    ParistondaParistonda Posts: 1,819
    MikeL said:

    I hardly know anything about French politics but am I the only person wondering:

    Why don't the Left put up a united candidate? If they did they would surely have an excellent chance of making the 2nd Round and at least a reasonable shot at winning the Presidency.

    Because if there's one thing the left does better than anyone, it's division :)

    Like crabs in a bucket. Same issue in 2002.
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,074

    O/T Putin's published an article in La Stampa in which he says NATO is outdated, America is not a banana republic whose election could be influenced from outside, the UN is the most legitimate international body and that Russia does not aspire to global dominance or expansion.

    http://www.lastampa.it/2016/11/27/cultura/opinioni/editoriali/il-tempo-di-fidarsi-della-russia-fronte-comune-contro-il-terrore-KxnZkA38RMHFNSiG1V1tYN/pagina.html

    That's up there with Blair's "I think I'm a pretty straight sort of guy" for deluded
    What evidence do you have that he's not straight? I've not heard the slightest whiff of a story about an ex-boyfriend.
  • Options
    rcs1000 said:

    rcs1000 said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Dromedary said:

    Poll puts Fillon in front of Le Pen in first round:

    Fillon 26%
    Le Pen 24%
    Macron 14%
    Mélenchon 13%
    Hollande 9%
    Bayrou 6%
    Dupont-Aignan 3%
    Jadot 3%

    Second round:

    Fillon 67%
    Le Pen 33%

    Sample: 6093 people.

    Dupont-Aignan is interviewed here. He says there are three candidates for a break with the system: Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Marine Le Pen, and himself. That link goes to the part where he says that Le Pen says a lot of reasonable things but she won't win in the second round because many will have voted for her in the first only to protest. He says he hopes to be the French Donald Trump...but how many skyscrapers has he got? :) His presentation is way behind Trump's, and he doesn't come across as half as obnoxious or polarising. I'll be watching how he gets reported on Breitbart.

    That's a pretty monstrous poll for Fillon, the big big participation in Led Republicans primary makes me think it isn't so far off the mark either. If Fillon pushes right, he might be able to monster Le Pen - maybe a possibility of a Fillon/Macron final contest ?
    [...]

    The question, to me, is whether he is able to take five points or so off of her, ending up in the high 20s, against her in the mid 20s. The question then is whether there would be tactical voting on the left. I cannot see Bayrou, Hollande/Valls or Macron voters going to Melanchon to avoid Le Pen vs Fillon. I could see them going to Macron.
    I see if now, RCS's "100 Ways Macron Could Win This Election" - I think we're on number four at the moment...
    Granted, I might be long and wrong :)

    My view, fwiw, is that the French Left and Centre will end up giving someone 20% of the vote. It might be the new Socialist candidate, it might be Macron, it might even be Bayrou. But I think it is unlikely we'll end up with four candidates on the Centre and Left all polling between 9 and 15%.
    OK, let's run this for a moment. Fillon 27%, Macron 25%, Le Pen 23%.

    Then the tightest squeeze on the remainder: Mélenchon 9%, Hollande 6%, Far Left 1%, Far Right 2%, Greens 2% ... Bayrou 5%?

    You'd need Bayrou out at a minimum.

    Then you could have Mélenchon 10%, Hollande 8%, which is a little more believable.
  • Options
    MaxPB said:

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    I saw estimates of up to 3m illegal votes based on a study done for the 2012 election assuming similar numbers and that they all broke for Clinton it could actually be the case.
    Link or stfu
  • Options
    AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    O/T

    Can't help noticing that more and more people seem to be copying Sadiq Khan and Priti Patel's habit of not pronouncing the "g" at the end of "ing" words. A Sky News reporter was just doing it.
  • Options
    edmundintokyoedmundintokyo Posts: 17,151
    edited November 2016

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    If we're talking about this not the corruption, he's winning. A dead cat every day until 2020.
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,074

    OK, let's run this for a moment. Fillon 27%, Macron 25%, Le Pen 23%.

    Then the tightest squeeze on the remainder: Mélenchon 9%, Hollande 6%, Far Left 1%, Far Right 2%, Greens 2% ... Bayrou 5%?

    You'd need Bayrou out at a minimum.

    Then you could have Mélenchon 10%, Hollande 8%, which is a little more believable.

    I've said all along: I think Bayrou is open to offers to sit this one out. He's 65 now. He's a long, long way from the second round, and there's another (younger, more charismatic) person in the centre ground.

    He was Minister of Education before. I think if Fillon or Macron came a'calling, and offered him an important ministry, them I think he might jump. I think Macron is the more likely to forge an alliance with him (as they are similar in terms of outlook, albeit Bayrou is more of an outsider), but then again, Fillon is much more likely to win.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,149

    If we're talking about this not the corruption, he's winning. A dead cat every day until 2020.

    Do you think if one time he literally tweeted a story relating to dead cats people would twig what he was doing?
  • Options
    TheWhiteRabbitTheWhiteRabbit Posts: 12,388
    edited November 2016
    rcs1000 said:

    OK, let's run this for a moment. Fillon 27%, Macron 25%, Le Pen 23%.

    Then the tightest squeeze on the remainder: Mélenchon 9%, Hollande 6%, Far Left 1%, Far Right 2%, Greens 2% ... Bayrou 5%?

    You'd need Bayrou out at a minimum.

    Then you could have Mélenchon 10%, Hollande 8%, which is a little more believable.

    I've said all along: I think Bayrou is open to offers to sit this one out. He's 65 now. He's a long, long way from the second round, and there's another (younger, more charismatic) person in the centre ground.

    He was Minister of Education before. I think if Fillon or Macron came a'calling, and offered him an important ministry, them I think he might jump. I think Macron is the more likely to forge an alliance with him (as they are similar in terms of outlook, albeit Bayrou is more of an outsider), but then again, Fillon is much more likely to win.
    The problem with most of your Macron scenarios is that they're 60% of 40% of 25% of 20%.

    You need -

    Fillon to head off Le Pen
    Fillon to expose his left flank
    Bayrou to drop out, probably to Macron
    Hollande to continue to be shit
    Macron to perform well and in a balanced way

    Then of course he has to beat Fillon in a head to head...

    Is it the most ludicrous of suggestions? No.

    Will it happen... probably not.

    I think 20/1 on Macron is fair, maybe a smidgen of value, I have a defensive position.
  • Options

    If we're talking about this not the corruption, he's winning. A dead cat every day until 2020.

    Do you think if one time he literally tweeted a story relating to dead cats people would twig what he was doing?
    This is the thing, even if we all know what he's doing, it still works.
  • Options
    Tissue_PriceTissue_Price Posts: 9,039
    edited November 2016

    You need -

    Fillon to head off Le Pen

    [...]

    Then of course he has to beat Fillon in a head to head...

    I don't think the main scenario is Macron beating Fillon in the second round; it's Macron beating Le Pen.
  • Options

    MaxPB said:

    What's the next level up from jumping the shark?

    https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/802972944532209664

    I saw estimates of up to 3m illegal votes based on a study done for the 2012 election assuming similar numbers and that they all broke for Clinton it could actually be the case.
    Link or stfu
    "Known to cognitive neuroscientists as the Dunning-Kruger effect, the troubling mental condition explains why many people are willing to believe anything Donald Trump says, whether his statements are true or not."

    http://www.inquisitr.com/3605574/the-twisted-psychology-of-trump-supporters/

  • Options

    rcs1000 said:

    OK, let's run this for a moment. Fillon 27%, Macron 25%, Le Pen 23%.

    Then the tightest squeeze on the remainder: Mélenchon 9%, Hollande 6%, Far Left 1%, Far Right 2%, Greens 2% ... Bayrou 5%?

    You'd need Bayrou out at a minimum.

    Then you could have Mélenchon 10%, Hollande 8%, which is a little more believable.

    I've said all along: I think Bayrou is open to offers to sit this one out. He's 65 now. He's a long, long way from the second round, and there's another (younger, more charismatic) person in the centre ground.

    He was Minister of Education before. I think if Fillon or Macron came a'calling, and offered him an important ministry, them I think he might jump. I think Macron is the more likely to forge an alliance with him (as they are similar in terms of outlook, albeit Bayrou is more of an outsider), but then again, Fillon is much more likely to win.
    The problem with most of your Macron scenarios is that they're 60% of 40% of 25% of 20%.

    You need -

    Fillon to head off Le Pen
    Fillon to expose his left flank
    Bayrou to drop out, probably to Macron
    Hollande to continue to be shit
    Macron to perform well and in a balanced way

    Then of course he has to beat Fillon in a head to head...

    Is it the most ludicrous of suggestions? No.

    Will it happen... probably not.

    I think 20/1 on Macron is fair, maybe a smidgen of value, I have a defensive position.
    I don't think the main scenario is Macron beating Fillon in the second round; it's Macron beating Le Pen.
    That's RCS' suggestion 3, we're on number four for the purpose of this thread :)

    I would say this had a 1.2% chance of coming off, 3.8% chance of Macron beating Le Pen, laving value to be decided by a real shock in the next few months.
This discussion has been closed.