politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Could it, should it, will it soon be Lord Farage?
An intriguing part of PMQs today was May’s response when asked if UKIP leader Nigel Farage will be given a peerage – this starting speculation that he will be. The PM’s response was “such matters are normally never discussed in public”.
The only problem being that almost all his criticisms about the EU parliament (taking shop, unelected politicians, people no one has heard of) are also true of the House of Lords.
The only problem being that almost all his criticisms about the EU parliament (taking shop, unelected politicians, people no one has heard of) are also true of the House of Lords.
I don't see that as a problem to be fair - the HOL needs complete revision
The only problem being that almost all his criticisms about the EU parliament (taking shop, unelected politicians, people no one has heard of) are also true of the House of Lords.
That could be a feature rather than a bug if the plan is to abolish the HoL.
To be fair, a few UKIP Peers wouldn't be unreasonable - and would certainly help the govt getting key Brexit-related bills through the Lords in the coming years, without needing to be seen 'stuffing' it with Tories.
The only problem being that almost all his criticisms about the EU parliament (taking shop, unelected politicians, people no one has heard of) are also true of the House of Lords.
To be fair, a few UKIP Peers wouldn't be unreasonable - and would certainly help the govt getting key Brexit-related bills through the Lords in the coming years, without needing to be seen 'stuffing' it with Tories.
The only problem being that almost all his criticisms about the EU parliament (taking shop, unelected politicians, people no one has heard of) are also true of the House of Lords.
As a revising chamber I think that's okay.
It's no coincidence that no other country in the world has a second chamber appointed in the way ours is
The only problem being that almost all his criticisms about the EU parliament (taking shop, unelected politicians, people no one has heard of) are also true of the House of Lords.
As a revising chamber I think that's okay.
It's no coincidence that no other country in the world has a second chamber appointed in the way ours is
It's one of the curiosities of the UK system that being a noteworthy parliamentarian is considered a good reason to give someone executive office. No-one in America would say that Ted Cruz should be made Treasury Secretary, for example.
The only problem being that almost all his criticisms about the EU parliament (taking shop, unelected politicians, people no one has heard of) are also true of the House of Lords.
As a revising chamber I think that's okay.
It's no coincidence that no other country in the world has a second chamber appointed in the way ours is
Their loss
In the case of 25% of the world they literally did lose it, or perhaps shed it would be the right word.
It's one of the curiosities of the UK system that being a noteworthy parliamentarian is considered a good reason to give someone executive office. No-one in America would say that Ted Cruz should be made Treasury Secretary, for example.
Westminster system, surely? Had a quick peek at Australia's Cabinet, and they all sit in the legislature.
It's one of the curiosities of the UK system that being a noteworthy parliamentarian is considered a good reason to give someone executive office. No-one in America would say that Ted Cruz should be made Treasury Secretary, for example.
Westminster system, surely? Had a quick peek at Australia's Cabinet, and they all sit in the legislature.
True. Come to think of it the same is true of the German Cabinet so it's not so unusual.
It's one of the curiosities of the UK system that being a noteworthy parliamentarian is considered a good reason to give someone executive office. No-one in America would say that Ted Cruz should be made Treasury Secretary, for example.
That is so not true. Only the other day I heard none other than Ted Cruz say that Ted Cruz should be Treasury Secretary.
Several years back I heard an interview with a lady who said that when she was ennobled, she was advised that most people chose somewhere they were born, lived, or had close connections to.
She considered this, and decided not to be called: "Lady ??? of Six Mile Bottom".
(I wish I could remember who it was).
If anyone was mad enough to ennoble me, I'd like to be called Lord Jessop of Water-cum-Jolly Dale"
It would be the very embodiment of lunacy for May to give Farage a peerage. Why provide him with yet another pedestal from which he can sneer at the government, advertise himself and humiliate May at every turn? That said, it appears that the Tory Right are agitating for it, so it will probably happen.
FPT @ Malmesbury: "OODA is about making decisions faster than the opposition."
Yes, but an element of making decisions faster than the opposition is proactively changing the environment/battlefield so that they are discombobulated and so take longer to make decisions.
The Trump version of this is to throw moral outrages around that are so outside the normal discourse of politics that people either don't know how to react, or react as per usual thinking this is politics as normal when it is not. And then as they finally react to the first moral outrage, he has already moved on to the next, and does not bother responding to their response - he has redefined the environment and his opponents are constantly playing catch up.
I am actually quite a fan of the house of lords. It is the final bastion of sanity in our public life. It is the only place that legislation gets scrutinised. That is a sad reflection on how dysfunctional our democracy is.
Whilst I definetly don't agree with Farage or his politics I don't really have a problem with him being appointed to the house of lords. People will go apeshit, but maybe then they will get more involved in politics, and not leave it to losers like me to campaign in elections.
Several years back I heard an interview with a lady who said that when she was ennobled, she was advised that most people chose somewhere they were born, lived, or had close connections to.
She considered this, and decided not to be called: "Lady ??? of Six Mile Bottom".
(I wish I could remember who it was).
If anyone was mad enough to ennoble me, I'd like to be called Lord Jessop of Water-cum-Jolly Dale"
Think it was Baroness Trumpington, giving a neat semi-closure to the conversion.
I'm trying to think of when the last extraterritorial peerage was awarded. Earl of Burma must be one of the last?
Does Lord Ashcroft count?
Baron Ashcroft of Chichester in the County of West Sussex.
Damn, you're right. I was sure he was of Belize, and speed-read through his wiki before posting - and still missed it.
Did manage to remind myself to visit the Imperial War Museum when next in Blighty though - his stunning collection of VCs is on display there.
He was probably called Lord Ashcroft of Belize by the press to make the point he was a non dom.
Yes, I think it started with Labour going completely nuts with him in about 2008, after he put millions into a marginal seat campaign for GE2010. Plenty of media references to that 'title' being used.
FT front page make big claim about what Hammond will reveal as the cost of brexit next week (although it is predicated on being compared to Osborne's fancy figures for a budget surplus come 2019).
Nigel Farage has had a huge influence on UK, US and EU politics and it would be justified to appoint him to the HOL together with a few more Ukippers.
Please let me make it clear that I do not support UKIP but when you think how many the Lib Dems have in the HOL with only 8 MP's it does seem to be unfair
FT front page make big claim about what Hammond will reveal as the cost of brexit next week (although it is predicated on compared to Osborne's fancy figures for a budget surplus come 2019).
I hope all the Leavers who said they would vote down Osborne's punishment budget stick to their promise. Hammond's figure seems to be 3 times scarier.
FT front page make big claim about what Hammond will reveal as the cost of brexit next week (although it is predicated on compared to Osborne's fancy figures for a budget surplus come 2019).
I hope all the Leavers who said they would vote down Osborne's punishment budget stick to their promise. Hammond's figure seems to be 3 times scarier.
If that is Hammond's budget then it will be very risky for the Tories to go for a GE.
''I hope all the Leavers who said they would vote down Osborne's punishment budget stick to their promise. Hammond's figure seems to be 3 times scarier. ''
''I hope all the Leavers who said they would vote down Osborne's punishment budget stick to their promise. Hammond's figure seems to be 3 times scarier. ''
Those aren't Hammond's figures they are the FTs.
It says that figure will be in the Autumn Statement.
FT front page make big claim about what Hammond will reveal as the cost of brexit next week (although it is predicated on compared to Osborne's fancy figures for a budget surplus come 2019).
I hope all the Leavers who said they would vote down Osborne's punishment budget stick to their promise. Hammond's figure seems to be 3 times scarier.
I heard a bunch of forecasts in June. They were wrong by July. The most accurate forecast was the one that said they would be wrong.
FT front page make big claim about what Hammond will reveal as the cost of brexit next week (although it is predicated on being compared to Osborne's fancy figures for a budget surplus come 2019).
If £100bn is being leaked it won't be anywhere near as bad.
FT front page make big claim about what Hammond will reveal as the cost of brexit next week (although it is predicated on being compared to Osborne's fancy figures for a budget surplus come 2019).
If £100bn is being leaked it won't be anywhere near as bad.
But it will be bad...
Why are we doing this again? Why is a Conservative government pulling down the roof when the forecast is for rain?
"I love Hillary Clinton. I am in awe of her. I am set free by her. She will be the finest world leader our galaxy has ever seen."
" But the feminist hero never got to be a legend first. And yet she is one, easily surpassing Ben Franklin, Henry Ford, Steve Jobs."
"She belongs to a much more elite class of Americans, the more-than-presidents. Neil Armstrong, Martin Luther King Jr., Alexander Fucking Hamilton."
"She cannot be faulted, criticized, or analyzed for even one more second. Instead, she will be decorated as an epochal heroine far too extraordinary to be contained by the mere White House. Let that revolting president-elect be Millard Fillmore or Herbert Hoover or whatever. Hillary is Athena."
Nigel Farage has had a huge influence on UK, US and EU politics and it would be justified to appoint him to the HOL together with a few more Ukippers.
Please let me make it clear that I do not support UKIP but when you think how many the Lib Dems have in the HOL with only 8 MP's it does seem to be unfair
Quite so. I might have gone off Farage myself (and I have) but disliking him and his political views is not an argument not to enoble him given his huge significance on the British political scene, when there are 104 Liberal Democrat peers, and only 3 for UKIP.
Reform of the House of Lords is, of course, a perfectly valid but separate issue.
FT front page make big claim about what Hammond will reveal as the cost of brexit next week (although it is predicated on being compared to Osborne's fancy figures for a budget surplus come 2019).
If £100bn is being leaked it won't be anywhere near as bad.
I would wait for the real figures, and then look at the underlying detail before jumping to any conclusions.
"I love Hillary Clinton. I am in awe of her. I am set free by her. She will be the finest world leader our galaxy has ever seen."
" But the feminist hero never got to be a legend first. And yet she is one, easily surpassing Ben Franklin, Henry Ford, Steve Jobs."
"She belongs to a much more elite class of Americans, the more-than-presidents. Neil Armstrong, Martin Luther King Jr., Alexander Fucking Hamilton."
"She cannot be faulted, criticized, or analyzed for even one more second. Instead, she will be decorated as an epochal heroine far too extraordinary to be contained by the mere White House. Let that revolting president-elect be Millard Fillmore or Herbert Hoover or whatever. Hillary is Athena."
I thought one thing that fascists held was adulation of the leader.
"I love Hillary Clinton. I am in awe of her. I am set free by her. She will be the finest world leader our galaxy has ever seen."
" But the feminist hero never got to be a legend first. And yet she is one, easily surpassing Ben Franklin, Henry Ford, Steve Jobs."
"She belongs to a much more elite class of Americans, the more-than-presidents. Neil Armstrong, Martin Luther King Jr., Alexander Fucking Hamilton."
"She cannot be faulted, criticized, or analyzed for even one more second. Instead, she will be decorated as an epochal heroine far too extraordinary to be contained by the mere White House. Let that revolting president-elect be Millard Fillmore or Herbert Hoover or whatever. Hillary is Athena."
Where's the vomit emoticon when you need it?
And what is about lefty fanboys? Obama stopping the rise of the oceans and healing the planet ...
FT front page make big claim about what Hammond will reveal as the cost of brexit next week (although it is predicated on compared to Osborne's fancy figures for a budget surplus come 2019).
I hope all the Leavers who said they would vote down Osborne's punishment budget stick to their promise. Hammond's figure seems to be 3 times scarier.
It's probably that old ruse of hinting at extreme nastiness so that the moderate nastiness we actually get doesn't seem so bad. I think Hammond will deliver Punishment Budget plus plus rather than Punishment Budget plus plus plus plus plus.
"I love Hillary Clinton. I am in awe of her. I am set free by her. She will be the finest world leader our galaxy has ever seen."
" But the feminist hero never got to be a legend first. And yet she is one, easily surpassing Ben Franklin, Henry Ford, Steve Jobs."
"She belongs to a much more elite class of Americans, the more-than-presidents. Neil Armstrong, Martin Luther King Jr., Alexander Fucking Hamilton."
"She cannot be faulted, criticized, or analyzed for even one more second. Instead, she will be decorated as an epochal heroine far too extraordinary to be contained by the mere White House. Let that revolting president-elect be Millard Fillmore or Herbert Hoover or whatever. Hillary is Athena."
All heavily sarcastic. Surely the worst presidential candidate in living memory.
The Office for Budget Responsibility has drawn up the forecasts the government will present and officials acknowledge they have been grappling for weeks with weak tax revenues and an outlook for lower growth.
The consensus of independent economic forecasts, which are generally close to the OBR’s, show mediocre economic growth until 2020 with higher inflation and weaker business investment combining to slow revenues to the exchequer. Once converted by the OBR into likely tax revenues, the deterioration in the public finances will cumulate to around £100bn.
The Institute for Fiscal Studies has estimated that a weaker economic outlook would lead to roughly £30bn in additional borrowing by 2019-20 before any gains from lower contributions to the EU budget are taken into account.
An official forecast along these lines would vindicate the Treasury’s pre-referendum central estimate of a £36bn annual cost of Brexit to the public purse but it would come only five years after the vote, indicating the cost might rise further in future.
Comments
Imagine his speeches to the Lordships
https://twitter.com/jonwalker121/status/798987476962377728
Would be apt for the Lords that the only way a man who failed seven times to become an MP joins Parliaments is via the unelected Lords
(who is "Lord Burma" by the way?)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patricia_Knatchbull,_2nd_Countess_Mountbatten_of_Burma
She considered this, and decided not to be called: "Lady ??? of Six Mile Bottom".
(I wish I could remember who it was).
If anyone was mad enough to ennoble me, I'd like to be called Lord Jessop of Water-cum-Jolly Dale"
I am the Daddy now!
https://youtu.be/HDPO9UG_CY4
Did manage to remind myself to visit the Imperial War Museum when next in Blighty though - his stunning collection of VCs is on display there.
Yes, but an element of making decisions faster than the opposition is proactively changing the environment/battlefield so that they are discombobulated and so take longer to make decisions.
The Trump version of this is to throw moral outrages around that are so outside the normal discourse of politics that people either don't know how to react, or react as per usual thinking this is politics as normal when it is not. And then as they finally react to the first moral outrage, he has already moved on to the next, and does not bother responding to their response - he has redefined the environment and his opponents are constantly playing catch up.
Whilst I definetly don't agree with Farage or his politics I don't really have a problem with him being appointed to the house of lords. People will go apeshit, but maybe then they will get more involved in politics, and not leave it to losers like me to campaign in elections.
Lord Alexander?
Doesn't Lots4 Archer have an Irish Mark as well Weston-Super-Mate
Going back further you've Hillsborough/Downshire and Wellington/Douro/Talevida/Wellesley
There was a young man of Kent.................. LOL
Burma (Earldom) was '47 (was already a Viscountcy before this)
Tunis (Earldom) was '52 (ditto)
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/2016/11/16/busy-tories-are-reason-pollsters-keep-predicting-wrong-results/
Please let me make it clear that I do not support UKIP but when you think how many the Lib Dems have in the HOL with only 8 MP's it does seem to be unfair
If made a Peer, Farage would have to resign as an MEP before taking his seat in the Lords.
This happened last month with Timothy Kirkhope (new Con Peer).
So means quite a big loss of salary + expenses.
It will be Omnishambles ++.
Those aren't Hammond's figures they are the FTs.
Many of them were made by the FT. And that's what remainers don't get. FT, Economist, Times - less credibility than before June.
The depth of the remainer defeat is still yet to sink in.
Why are we doing this again? Why is a Conservative government pulling down the roof when the forecast is for rain?
https://twitter.com/lennyletter/status/798941323965370368
"I love Hillary Clinton. I am in awe of her. I am set free by her. She will be the finest world leader our galaxy has ever seen."
" But the feminist hero never got to be a legend first. And yet she is one, easily surpassing Ben Franklin, Henry Ford, Steve Jobs."
"She belongs to a much more elite class of Americans, the more-than-presidents. Neil Armstrong, Martin Luther King Jr., Alexander Fucking Hamilton."
"She cannot be faulted, criticized, or analyzed for even one more second. Instead, she will be decorated as an epochal heroine far too extraordinary to be contained by the mere White House. Let that revolting president-elect be Millard Fillmore or Herbert Hoover or whatever. Hillary is Athena."
Grammar schools will make situation worse, says government commission
https://www.ft.com/content/59f1a080-abd7-11e6-ba7d-76378e4fef24
scene, when there are 104 Liberal Democrat peers, and only 3 for UKIP.
Reform of the House of Lords is, of course, a perfectly valid but separate issue.
Lord Farage of Hope?
I believe it is a nice village in Lancashire
http://www.cityam.com/253587/public-borrowing-could-overrun-100bn-over-next-five-years
And what is about lefty fanboys? Obama stopping the rise of the oceans and healing the planet ...
Which makes sense given the changed circumstances.
The Office for Budget Responsibility has drawn up the forecasts the government will present and officials acknowledge they have been grappling for weeks with weak tax revenues and an outlook for lower growth.
The consensus of independent economic forecasts, which are generally close to the OBR’s, show mediocre economic growth until 2020 with higher inflation and weaker business investment combining to slow revenues to the exchequer. Once converted by the OBR into likely tax revenues, the deterioration in the public finances will cumulate to around £100bn.
The Institute for Fiscal Studies has estimated that a weaker economic outlook would lead to roughly £30bn in additional borrowing by 2019-20 before any gains from lower contributions to the EU budget are taken into account.
An official forecast along these lines would vindicate the Treasury’s pre-referendum central estimate of a £36bn annual cost of Brexit to the public purse but it would come only five years after the vote, indicating the cost might rise further in future.
https://www.ft.com/content/acb33786-ac16-11e6-9cb3-bb8207902122