Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Local By-Elections : June 2nd 2016 (Referendum Day -21 days

SystemSystem Posts: 11,704
edited June 2016 in General

imagepoliticalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Local By-Elections : June 2nd 2016 (Referendum Day -21 days and counting)

Oban North and Lorn (Ind defence, elected as SNP) on Argyll and Bute
Result of council at last election (2012) : Independents 15, Scottish Nationalists 13, Liberal Democrats 4, Conservatives 4 (No Overall Control, Independents short by 4)
Result of ward at last election (2012) :

Read the full story here


«134

Comments

  • Options
    Hertsmere_PubgoerHertsmere_Pubgoer Posts: 3,476
    edited June 2016
    First like LEAVE
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,403
    Second like Faisal Islam.
  • Options
    EPGEPG Posts: 6,032
    I'm sure the Lib Dems will win that one in Mid Suffolk, if the wailing and gnashing of teeth on PB is anything to go by, the Tories want to kick their prime minister up and down the road for a little while.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002
    Is Vardy carrying a wrist injury ?
  • Options
    EPGEPG Posts: 6,032
    Let me follow up on Harry Hayfield's point about Tory LEAVE beating Ukip at their own game.

    What the hell does Ukip do if the vote is LEAVE and the Tories actually start to leave? Pressure group to make sure they keep LEAVEing? Especially if there's a populist LEAVE PM like Boris?
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,205
    EPG said:

    Let me follow up on Harry Hayfield's point about Tory LEAVE beating Ukip at their own game.

    What the hell does Ukip do if the vote is LEAVE and the Tories actually start to leave? Pressure group to make sure they keep LEAVEing? Especially if there's a populist LEAVE PM like Boris?

    Who cares, we'll have won.
  • Options
    PlatoSaidPlatoSaid Posts: 10,383
    Anyone recall when the BBC/ITV debates are?
  • Options
    EPGEPG Posts: 6,032
    tlg86 said:

    EPG said:

    Let me follow up on Harry Hayfield's point about Tory LEAVE beating Ukip at their own game.

    What the hell does Ukip do if the vote is LEAVE and the Tories actually start to leave? Pressure group to make sure they keep LEAVEing? Especially if there's a populist LEAVE PM like Boris?

    Who cares, we'll have won.
    Anyone who is interested in the next general election cares. Do they collapse like a bad soufflé (presumably releasing votes for contesting among Labour/Conservatives) or do they grow (annexing Labour voters who want to LEAVE) or even do damage to the Conservatives as the party of proper LEAVE? Or do they just stay as is because they really reflect unease about Europe/Muslims/foreigners none of whom will actually go away on June 24 regardless?
  • Options
    PlatoSaidPlatoSaid Posts: 10,383
    Faisal verdict - PM sounded rattled, spends a lot of time with selected audiences who haven't given him a hard time, must be worried that this is turning into a referendum on him
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,391
    Pulpstar said:

    Is Vardy carrying a wrist injury ?

    They all seem a bit limp from the little I have seen.
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,205
    EPG said:

    tlg86 said:

    EPG said:

    Let me follow up on Harry Hayfield's point about Tory LEAVE beating Ukip at their own game.

    What the hell does Ukip do if the vote is LEAVE and the Tories actually start to leave? Pressure group to make sure they keep LEAVEing? Especially if there's a populist LEAVE PM like Boris?

    Who cares, we'll have won.
    Anyone who is interested in the next general election cares. Do they collapse like a bad soufflé (presumably releasing votes for contesting among Labour/Conservatives) or do they grow (annexing Labour voters who want to LEAVE) or even do damage to the Conservatives as the party of proper LEAVE? Or do they just stay as is because they really reflect unease about Europe/Muslims/foreigners none of whom will actually go away on June 24 regardless?
    I was being flippant. It's hard to say how things will play out if Leave wins - let's be honest, it would just be the beginning. If Remain wins, however, Ukip could cement their position as the third party (in votes, at least).
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,648
    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.
  • Options
    AnneJGPAnneJGP Posts: 2,869
    PlatoSaid said:

    Faisal verdict - PM sounded rattled, spends a lot of time with selected audiences who haven't given him a hard time, must be worried that this is turning into a referendum on him

    Selected audiences? Does he? When did that start, then, I wonder - he used to be known for Cameron Directs being basically all-comers, didn't he?

    Or is it more a result of the drop in trust ratings than the audience selection, do you think?
  • Options
    PlatoSaidPlatoSaid Posts: 10,383

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    Golly, what's changed her mind?
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,403
    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    There are definite echoes of Jan-April 2015. When the polls, the mood, popular opinion lined up behind an EdM premiership.

    People however are generally a sensible lot, and will cut through the noise to make a sensible decision.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,391
    Ok so the answer is to play Smalling up front.
  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,920

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    #BeLeave
  • Options
    WandererWanderer Posts: 3,838
    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    Certainly the case that when Cameron gave the referendum pledge he would have assumed there would be a mainstream Labour leader campaigning on the same side. It would be quite a different picture if Kendall/Cooper/Burnham had won. Corbyn just isn't really into Remain and isn't really trying to rally Labour supporters to that side.
  • Options
    philiphphiliph Posts: 4,704

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    For what reason?
  • Options
    PlatoSaidPlatoSaid Posts: 10,383
    edited June 2016
    AnneJGP said:

    PlatoSaid said:

    Faisal verdict - PM sounded rattled, spends a lot of time with selected audiences who haven't given him a hard time, must be worried that this is turning into a referendum on him

    Selected audiences? Does he? When did that start, then, I wonder - he used to be known for Cameron Directs being basically all-comers, didn't he?

    Or is it more a result of the drop in trust ratings than the audience selection, do you think?
    All his EU meets have been with staff at factories etc and no journalists allowed. CameronDirects were great.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002
    A goal up against the Portugese reserves at home who have ten men, we're going to win it boys and girls !
  • Options

    First like LEAVE

    leave like suffolk first
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,205
    @SeanT - It does feel that it could be really close. People like us who come on sites like this are not normal. I think we read all of the technical debates and we actually consider all of the issues at stake. I'll be voting leave, but I acknowledge that there may be downsides to leaving.

    The vast majority of the electorate keep things simple. And the immigration figures are very simple to understand and for a lot of people that's all they need to vote leave.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002
    GIN1138 said:

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    #BeLeave
    наздраве
  • Options
    philiphphiliph Posts: 4,704
    TOPPING said:

    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    There are definite echoes of Jan-April 2015. When the polls, the mood, popular opinion lined up behind an EdM premiership.

    People however are generally a sensible lot, and will cut through the noise to make a sensible decision.
    Except in this instance it isn't obvious what the sensible decision is, for the average guy and gal.

  • Options
    MarkSeniorMarkSenior Posts: 4,699
    There is also an election on Rushmoor DC deferred from May 5th Aldershot Park ward marginal Conservative seat Lab 2nd UKIP close 3rd .
    The interesting thing about these 7 elections is that there is only 1 UKIP candidate . A party with no money , falling membership , councillors leaving the party every weak and now unable to even stand candidates .
  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,920
    Wanderer said:

    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    Certainly the case that when Cameron gave the referendum pledge he would have assumed there would be a mainstream Labour leader campaigning on the same side. It would be quite a different picture if Kendall/Cooper/Burnham had won. Corbyn just isn't really into Remain and isn't really trying to rally Labour supporters to that side.
    I heard some of Jezza's speech earlier... To me it actually sounded like a "coded" pitch for LEAVE dressed up as a speech for REMAIN.
  • Options
    weejonnieweejonnie Posts: 3,820
    Pulpstar said:

    A goal up against the Portugese reserves at home who have ten men, we're going to win it boys and girls !

    I nearly had a heart attack from that surprise.
  • Options
    chestnutchestnut Posts: 7,341
    Leave are going to win.

    We reached, "we can't go on like this" with Cameron's deal.
  • Options
    foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    Pulpstar said:

    Is Vardy carrying a wrist injury ?

    He injured his wrist last September, has been wearing strapping on it every match since. I think it is a luck rather than medical thing now.

    I think that England will be lucky to get out of the group. Terrible tactics.
  • Options
    BenedictWhiteBenedictWhite Posts: 1,944

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    Right that's it.

    Foreigner European types telling us to leave the EU! (Actually a Polish now naturalised Brit interviewed the other week is as well)
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,391
    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    The telling point for me the other day was that all the trade unionists and tradesmen were for Leave and the Labour intellectual types, MPs etc were for Remain. The gap between the average MP and those they purport to represent has never been wider.

    Applies to both sides of course.
  • Options
    oldpoliticsoldpolitics Posts: 455
    I know we don't trust self-selecting polls but has anyone been watching the poll on MSE?

    For a large sample size, on the website of a man whose face is being used (rather naughtily) on the Remain leaflet, it's quite striking.

    Leave by almost 2:1 on a turnout in the tens of thousands.

  • Options
    oldpoliticsoldpolitics Posts: 455

    I know we don't trust self-selecting polls but has anyone been watching the poll on MSE?

    For a large sample size, on the website of a man whose face is being used (rather naughtily) on the Remain leaflet, it's quite striking.

    Leave by almost 2:1 on a turnout in the tens of thousands.

    http://www.moneysavingexpert.com/poll/31-05-2016/how-will-you-be-voting-in-the-eu-referendum-or-are-you-a-39dont-know39
  • Options
    WandererWanderer Posts: 3,838
    tlg86 said:

    @SeanT - It does feel that it could be really close. People like us who come on sites like this are not normal. I think we read all of the technical debates and we actually consider all of the issues at stake. I'll be voting leave, but I acknowledge that there may be downsides to leaving.

    The vast majority of the electorate keep things simple. And the immigration figures are very simple to understand and for a lot of people that's all they need to vote leave.

    Right. That's why I think Remain would be crazy not to just keep banging the "all your money will turn to dust" drum. It's simple and, though people complain of scaremongering, it may well still work.
  • Options
    PlatoSaidPlatoSaid Posts: 10,383
    GIN1138 said:

    Wanderer said:

    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    Certainly the case that when Cameron gave the referendum pledge he would have assumed there would be a mainstream Labour leader campaigning on the same side. It would be quite a different picture if Kendall/Cooper/Burnham had won. Corbyn just isn't really into Remain and isn't really trying to rally Labour supporters to that side.
    I heard some of Jezza's speech earlier... To me it actually sounded like a "coded" pitch for LEAVE dressed up as a speech for REMAIN.
    Jezza's speech was hilarious, at least half of it was rubbishing Remain over scaremongering, and the EU about helping steel industry, nationalising railways et al.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,403
    philiph said:

    TOPPING said:

    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    There are definite echoes of Jan-April 2015. When the polls, the mood, popular opinion lined up behind an EdM premiership.

    People however are generally a sensible lot, and will cut through the noise to make a sensible decision.
    Except in this instance it isn't obvious what the sensible decision is, for the average guy and gal.

    Yes that is true.

    For many, it will be 41 years of EU membership which will have become the norm.

    There is also the appeal to authority of the various institutions promoting Remain.

    But that is a good point.
  • Options
    Moses_Moses_ Posts: 4,865
    I see the French are not going to serve beer to football fans at the Euros. Probably a good thing. On the other hand they will serve them water but only if they ask for it in French.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002

    I know we don't trust self-selecting polls but has anyone been watching the poll on MSE?

    For a large sample size, on the website of a man whose face is being used (rather naughtily) on the Remain leaflet, it's quite striking.

    Leave by almost 2:1 on a turnout in the tens of thousands.

    Who is a typical "moneysavingexperter" ?

    40 yrs old, B - C2 (Maybe C1), young family, median income. Your average lower middle class person ?

    That could well be a more accurate voodoo poll than most.
  • Options
    PlatoSaidPlatoSaid Posts: 10,383

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    Right that's it.

    Foreigner European types telling us to leave the EU! (Actually a Polish now naturalised Brit interviewed the other week is as well)
    A Polish Italian deli owner on Sky earlier said he was voting Leave over impact on public services.
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,205
    TOPPING said:

    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    There are definite echoes of Jan-April 2015. When the polls, the mood, popular opinion lined up behind an EdM premiership.

    People however are generally a sensible lot, and will cut through the noise to make a sensible decision.
    Ah, but the polls were moving away from Ed, in the last year they've moved towards Leave. Not saying that Leave will win, but it feels to me that Remain are the ones struggling to get over the line.
  • Options
    AnneJGPAnneJGP Posts: 2,869
    PlatoSaid said:

    AnneJGP said:

    PlatoSaid said:

    Faisal verdict - PM sounded rattled, spends a lot of time with selected audiences who haven't given him a hard time, must be worried that this is turning into a referendum on him

    Selected audiences? Does he? When did that start, then, I wonder - he used to be known for Cameron Directs being basically all-comers, didn't he?

    Or is it more a result of the drop in trust ratings than the audience selection, do you think?
    All his EU meets have been with staff at factories etc and no journalists allowed. CameronDirects were great.
    Thanks, I hadn't realised that.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,403
    Pool old Nigel, he is absolutely right on immigration (tens of thousands pledge, etc), makes ok sensible points. But every word he utters about it toxifies the Leave campaign as being part of the anti-Johnny Foreigner fringe.
  • Options
    weejonnieweejonnie Posts: 3,820
    SeanT said:

    Farage looking insufferably smug/charmingly happy on SKY right now.

    Whatever the PB opinion, this is a man who thinks he is possibly about to win, wholly against the odds.

    Odds of 5/2 IIRC - at least he put some money where his mouth is.
  • Options
    BenedictWhiteBenedictWhite Posts: 1,944
    Wanderer said:

    tlg86 said:

    @SeanT - It does feel that it could be really close. People like us who come on sites like this are not normal. I think we read all of the technical debates and we actually consider all of the issues at stake. I'll be voting leave, but I acknowledge that there may be downsides to leaving.

    The vast majority of the electorate keep things simple. And the immigration figures are very simple to understand and for a lot of people that's all they need to vote leave.

    Right. That's why I think Remain would be crazy not to just keep banging the "all your money will turn to dust" drum. It's simple and, though people complain of scaremongering, it may well still work.
    The problem here is that it turns remainers into laughing remainers who then vote leave, by post.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002
    TOPPING said:

    Pool old Nigel, he is absolutely right on immigration (tens of thousands pledge, etc), makes ok sensible points. But every word he utters about it toxifies the Leave campaign as being part of the anti-Johnny Foreigner fringe.

    He's not toxified anything.

    Dave has toxified RemaiN !!
  • Options
    WandererWanderer Posts: 3,838

    Wanderer said:

    tlg86 said:

    @SeanT - It does feel that it could be really close. People like us who come on sites like this are not normal. I think we read all of the technical debates and we actually consider all of the issues at stake. I'll be voting leave, but I acknowledge that there may be downsides to leaving.

    The vast majority of the electorate keep things simple. And the immigration figures are very simple to understand and for a lot of people that's all they need to vote leave.

    Right. That's why I think Remain would be crazy not to just keep banging the "all your money will turn to dust" drum. It's simple and, though people complain of scaremongering, it may well still work.
    The problem here is that it turns remainers into laughing remainers who then vote leave, by post.
    That will happen in some cases but (imo) it's Remain's best chance of winning.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,403
    edited June 2016
    Pulpstar said:

    TOPPING said:

    Pool old Nigel, he is absolutely right on immigration (tens of thousands pledge, etc), makes ok sensible points. But every word he utters about it toxifies the Leave campaign as being part of the anti-Johnny Foreigner fringIe.

    He's not toxified anything.

    Dave has toxified RemaiN !!
    I know he is true to himself but coming on to the tellybox in 1980s City spiv uniform ain't helping.
  • Options
    Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 31,015
    edited June 2016
    DavidL said:


    The telling point for me the other day was that all the trade unionists and tradesmen were for Leave and the Labour intellectual types, MPs etc were for Remain. The gap between the average MP and those they purport to represent has never been wider.

    Applies to both sides of course.

    I honestly can't think of a case in modern British history where both sides of an argument were so poorly served by the official campaigns. It is making the Scottish referendum look like a model of accuracy and honesty.
  • Options
    PlatoSaidPlatoSaid Posts: 10,383

    Wanderer said:

    tlg86 said:

    @SeanT - It does feel that it could be really close. People like us who come on sites like this are not normal. I think we read all of the technical debates and we actually consider all of the issues at stake. I'll be voting leave, but I acknowledge that there may be downsides to leaving.

    The vast majority of the electorate keep things simple. And the immigration figures are very simple to understand and for a lot of people that's all they need to vote leave.

    Right. That's why I think Remain would be crazy not to just keep banging the "all your money will turn to dust" drum. It's simple and, though people complain of scaremongering, it may well still work.
    The problem here is that it turns remainers into laughing remainers who then vote leave, by post.
    The MORI poll IIRC had 48% saying Brexit wouldn't effect their incomes, 11% thought they'd be better off, 27% worst off.

    There were broadly similar figs for houseprice scares too - I think voters are largely shrugging this stuff off now.
  • Options
    Moses_Moses_ Posts: 4,865
    'I won't be happy until I reach England':

    Inside the windswept French clifftop tents where Albanian migrants refuel for their next assault on BritainWhite tents dotted along clifftops in the port of Dieppe, in northern France, are home to 150 migrants heading for UK

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3622334/I-won-t-happy-reach-England-Inside-clifftop-tents-France-Albanian-migrants-refuel-assault-Britain.html#ixzz4ASOd1flY
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,648
    philiph said:

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    For what reason?
    She sees no prospect of change in the European Union, at all, unless we do.
  • Options
    BenedictWhiteBenedictWhite Posts: 1,944
    PlatoSaid said:

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    Right that's it.

    Foreigner European types telling us to leave the EU! (Actually a Polish now naturalised Brit interviewed the other week is as well)
    A Polish Italian deli owner on Sky earlier said he was voting Leave over impact on public services.
    There you go. And so it goes. There are hordes, swarms even of immigrants and their children who think immigration is out of control. They know, because it affects them too.
  • Options
    welshowlwelshowl Posts: 4,460
    Moses_ said:

    I see the French are not going to serve beer to football fans at the Euros. Probably a good thing. On the other hand they will serve them water but only if they ask for it in French.

    Oh.
  • Options
    MarkSeniorMarkSenior Posts: 4,699
    Pulpstar said:

    I know we don't trust self-selecting polls but has anyone been watching the poll on MSE?

    For a large sample size, on the website of a man whose face is being used (rather naughtily) on the Remain leaflet, it's quite striking.

    Leave by almost 2:1 on a turnout in the tens of thousands.

    Who is a typical "moneysavingexperter" ?

    40 yrs old, B - C2 (Maybe C1), young family, median income. Your average lower middle class person ?

    That could well be a more accurate voodoo poll than most.
    Well it has just allowed me to vote 5 times , even more a voodoo poll than some
  • Options
    oldpoliticsoldpolitics Posts: 455
    Pulpstar said:

    I know we don't trust self-selecting polls but has anyone been watching the poll on MSE?

    For a large sample size, on the website of a man whose face is being used (rather naughtily) on the Remain leaflet, it's quite striking.

    Leave by almost 2:1 on a turnout in the tens of thousands.

    Who is a typical "moneysavingexperter" ?

    40 yrs old, B - C2 (Maybe C1), young family, median income. Your average lower middle class person ?

    That could well be a more accurate voodoo poll than most.
    Some clues as to their demographics and leanings here, though a lower turnout as a much more hypothetical question:

    http://www.moneysavingexpert.com/poll/23-02-2016/which-us-presidential-candidate-would-you-vote-for-if-you-could

    And the same question last year - a bit closer

    http://www.moneysavingexpert.com/poll/19-10-2015/should-the-uk-stay-in-the-eu

    Not that many under-25s, but that doesn't seem an unreasonable assumption...
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,403
    Moses_ said:

    I see the French are not going to serve beer to football fans at the Euros. Probably a good thing. On the other hand they will serve them water but only if they ask for it in French.

    When I was in Milan a few years ago, I went for lunch and was told no alcohol was available as there was a football match on that night (can't remember if it was domestic or international).
  • Options
    BenedictWhiteBenedictWhite Posts: 1,944
    Wanderer said:

    Wanderer said:

    tlg86 said:

    @SeanT - It does feel that it could be really close. People like us who come on sites like this are not normal. I think we read all of the technical debates and we actually consider all of the issues at stake. I'll be voting leave, but I acknowledge that there may be downsides to leaving.

    The vast majority of the electorate keep things simple. And the immigration figures are very simple to understand and for a lot of people that's all they need to vote leave.

    Right. That's why I think Remain would be crazy not to just keep banging the "all your money will turn to dust" drum. It's simple and, though people complain of scaremongering, it may well still work.
    The problem here is that it turns remainers into laughing remainers who then vote leave, by post.
    That will happen in some cases but (imo) it's Remain's best chance of winning.
    It isn't the script that won in Scotland though.
  • Options
    foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    Moses_ said:

    'I won't be happy until I reach England':

    Inside the windswept French clifftop tents where Albanian migrants refuel for their next assault on BritainWhite tents dotted along clifftops in the port of Dieppe, in northern France, are home to 150 migrants heading for UK

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3622334/I-won-t-happy-reach-England-Inside-clifftop-tents-France-Albanian-migrants-refuel-assault-Britain.html#ixzz4ASOd1flY

    Brexit is not going to make a difference to that camp. They are already illegal.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,403
    welshowl said:

    Moses_ said:

    I see the French are not going to serve beer to football fans at the Euros. Probably a good thing. On the other hand they will serve them water but only if they ask for it in French.

    Oh.
    It is worth repeating at every occasion Miles Kington's proposed motto for the French navy:

    A l'eau, c'est l'heure.
  • Options
    EPGEPG Posts: 6,032
    Wanderer said:

    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    Certainly the case that when Cameron gave the referendum pledge he would have assumed there would be a mainstream Labour leader campaigning on the same side. It would be quite a different picture if Kendall/Cooper/Burnham had won. Corbyn just isn't really into Remain and isn't really trying to rally Labour supporters to that side.
    If Coopurndall won then we would be seeing big hand-holding sessions with the Labour and Conservative leaders on the same platform, and the former losing votes to Ukip by the minute.
  • Options
    BenedictWhiteBenedictWhite Posts: 1,944

    DavidL said:


    The telling point for me the other day was that all the trade unionists and tradesmen were for Leave and the Labour intellectual types, MPs etc were for Remain. The gap between the average MP and those they purport to represent has never been wider.

    Applies to both sides of course.

    I honestly can't think of a case in modern British history where both sides of an argument were so poorly served by the official campaigns. It is making the Scottish referendum look like a model of accuracy and honesty.
    Sadly true.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,648
    edited June 2016
    PlatoSaid said:

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    Golly, what's changed her mind?
    First, she made me swear not to tell a soul (and now I've just publicly told all you lot) and then confessed to me.

    She has moved from firm Remain, to undecided, to (now) Leave.

    She remains pro-European but agreed with me that the EU is just never going to change unless they suffer the shock of losing one of their main members, and we learn to collaborate and cooperate rather than force, threaten and compel against the democratic will of the peoples across Europe.
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,205

    DavidL said:


    The telling point for me the other day was that all the trade unionists and tradesmen were for Leave and the Labour intellectual types, MPs etc were for Remain. The gap between the average MP and those they purport to represent has never been wider.

    Applies to both sides of course.

    I honestly can't think of a case in modern British history where both sides of an argument were so poorly served by the official campaigns. It is making the Scottish referendum look like a model of accuracy and honesty.
    And I think it's because so many of these people haven't really thought about it before. For all his faults, Farage knows his stuff. I've been disappointed by Vote Leave's inability to drive home what a hideous institution the EU is - there is so much material it could fill a broadcast no problem.
  • Options
    PlatoSaidPlatoSaid Posts: 10,383
    edited June 2016
    Lord Bell gives Cameron 4/10, Labour ex SPAD 7/10.

    Apparently it was 6x he called Faisal glib.
  • Options
    BenedictWhiteBenedictWhite Posts: 1,944

    philiph said:

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    For what reason?
    She sees no prospect of change in the European Union, at all, unless we do.
    She's right.
  • Options
    chestnutchestnut Posts: 7,341
    People keep comparing to Scotland.

    Well, in Scotland the "would not vote for decades" because "why-should-I-as-we-always-return-Labour?" decided to vote - and they largely swung to Leave.

    The same will happen here.

    But UK pensioners will not behave like Scottish pensioners.

    That's because the UK paid Scottish pensioners' pensions.
    The EU does not pay British and Northern Irish pensioners' pensions.

  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,391

    DavidL said:


    The telling point for me the other day was that all the trade unionists and tradesmen were for Leave and the Labour intellectual types, MPs etc were for Remain. The gap between the average MP and those they purport to represent has never been wider.

    Applies to both sides of course.

    I honestly can't think of a case in modern British history where both sides of an argument were so poorly served by the official campaigns. It is making the Scottish referendum look like a model of accuracy and honesty.
    You obviously were not paying enough attention!

    But I think it is fair to say that both campaigns have been underwhelming, that the points we have discussed on here have proven too nuanced or complex for the general public, that the targeting of both campaigns has left a lot of people like us not really being given the option we wanted (EEA/EFTA) at all and having to choose between 2 pretty ordinary choices.

    I am voting Leave in the hope of something better and in the firm belief that Remain puts us on a road we don't want to go down but much of the "official" campaign makes me very uncomfortable.
  • Options
    MortimerMortimer Posts: 13,956
    edited June 2016
    TOPPING said:

    Moses_ said:

    I see the French are not going to serve beer to football fans at the Euros. Probably a good thing. On the other hand they will serve them water but only if they ask for it in French.

    When I was in Milan a few years ago, I went for lunch and was told no alcohol was available as there was a football match on that night (can't remember if it was domestic or international).
    This happened to me at York railway station recently. My bag was 'searched' too. Football related.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,403
    Interestingly The Twitter King tell us immigration came 4th out of five main trending topics.
  • Options
    chestnut said:

    People keep comparing to Scotland.

    Well, in Scotland the "would not vote for decades" because "why-should-I-as-we-always-return-Labour?" decided to vote - and they largely swung to Leave.

    The same will happen here.

    But UK pensioners will not behave like Scottish pensioners.

    That's because the UK paid Scottish pensioners' pensions.
    The EU does not pay British and Northern Irish pensioners' pensions.

    Good post.

    The head of the EU is not Queen Elizabeth II either.
  • Options
    EPGEPG Posts: 6,032
    PB comments sentiment indicator is now 100% Brexit, a 100% swing to Brexit from this time 8 days ago.
  • Options
    WandererWanderer Posts: 3,838

    Wanderer said:

    Wanderer said:

    tlg86 said:

    @SeanT - It does feel that it could be really close. People like us who come on sites like this are not normal. I think we read all of the technical debates and we actually consider all of the issues at stake. I'll be voting leave, but I acknowledge that there may be downsides to leaving.

    The vast majority of the electorate keep things simple. And the immigration figures are very simple to understand and for a lot of people that's all they need to vote leave.

    Right. That's why I think Remain would be crazy not to just keep banging the "all your money will turn to dust" drum. It's simple and, though people complain of scaremongering, it may well still work.
    The problem here is that it turns remainers into laughing remainers who then vote leave, by post.
    That will happen in some cases but (imo) it's Remain's best chance of winning.
    It isn't the script that won in Scotland though.
    If you mean that it lacks the "We fought two world wars together, lovely old Union" stuff then yes, it does. But the public isn't going to be receptive to a romanticised case for EU membership. That's something you'd need to build up over decades and the work hasn't been done. So it comes down to what's possible at short notice and what's possible is to play on economic risk. And that's not a weak card to play - it may well still work.
  • Options
    MortimerMortimer Posts: 13,956
    Wanderer said:

    Wanderer said:

    Wanderer said:

    tlg86 said:

    @SeanT - It does feel that it could be really close. People like us who come on sites like this are not normal. I think we read all of the technical debates and we actually consider all of the issues at stake. I'll be voting leave, but I acknowledge that there may be downsides to leaving.

    The vast majority of the electorate keep things simple. And the immigration figures are very simple to understand and for a lot of people that's all they need to vote leave.

    Right. That's why I think Remain would be crazy not to just keep banging the "all your money will turn to dust" drum. It's simple and, though people complain of scaremongering, it may well still work.
    The problem here is that it turns remainers into laughing remainers who then vote leave, by post.
    That will happen in some cases but (imo) it's Remain's best chance of winning.
    It isn't the script that won in Scotland though.
    If you mean that it lacks the "We fought two world wars together, lovely old Union" stuff then yes, it does. But the public isn't going to be receptive to a romanticised case for EU membership. That's something you'd need to build up over decades and the work hasn't been done. So it comes down to what's possible at short notice and what's possible is to play on economic risk. And that's not a weak card to play - it may well still work.
    It is a card that has been weakened by the poor play of all the others. And the unpopularity of the player.

  • Options
    HurstLlamaHurstLlama Posts: 9,098
    tlg86 said:

    TOPPING said:

    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    There are definite echoes of Jan-April 2015. When the polls, the mood, popular opinion lined up behind an EdM premiership.

    People however are generally a sensible lot, and will cut through the noise to make a sensible decision.
    Ah, but the polls were moving away from Ed, in the last year they've moved towards Leave. Not saying that Leave will win, but it feels to me that Remain are the ones struggling to get over the line.
    I really do hope that Mr. Dancer, gent of this parish and who, is by his own admission, as poor as a church mouse whose wife has sued for divorce (and pissed off with all the cheese) the day after he received an enormous tax bill, didn't follow his instincts and put some money down on the remain outcome he has been predicting for months.

    Mr. Owls and the whole Owls family come out for remain (shocked me), Mrs. Royale declares for remain all on the same evening. Maybe, just maybe, there is grounds for hope. The straws currently blowing in the wind all seem to be going in the same direction and that is in the way of Leave.
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,205
    TOPPING said:

    Moses_ said:

    I see the French are not going to serve beer to football fans at the Euros. Probably a good thing. On the other hand they will serve them water but only if they ask for it in French.

    When I was in Milan a few years ago, I went for lunch and was told no alcohol was available as there was a football match on that night (can't remember if it was domestic or international).
    Alcohol is not supposed to be served at UEFA club games. I went to Milan a few years a go and having got tanked up in the piazza, the Arsenal fans were then offered small bottles of Sambuca once inside the San Siro!
  • Options
    PClippPClipp Posts: 2,138
    Wanderer said:

    Certainly the case that when Cameron gave the referendum pledge he would have assumed there would be a mainstream Labour leader campaigning on the same side. It would be quite a different picture if Kendall/Cooper/Burnham had won. Corbyn just isn't really into Remain and isn't really trying to rally Labour supporters to that side.

    Isn`t that what happened in the AV Referendum? The assumption was that Labour would be solidly behind AV, especially since it was in the Labour Party manifesto that Milliband wrote.

    Instead, Labour sabotaged it from inside.
  • Options
    WandererWanderer Posts: 3,838
    EPG said:

    Wanderer said:

    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    Certainly the case that when Cameron gave the referendum pledge he would have assumed there would be a mainstream Labour leader campaigning on the same side. It would be quite a different picture if Kendall/Cooper/Burnham had won. Corbyn just isn't really into Remain and isn't really trying to rally Labour supporters to that side.
    If Coopurndall won then we would be seeing big hand-holding sessions with the Labour and Conservative leaders on the same platform, and the former losing votes to Ukip by the minute.
    Quite possibly. Better scenario for Remain though. Hell, better scenario for Cameron.
  • Options

    PlatoSaid said:

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    Golly, what's changed her mind?
    First, she made me swear not to tell a soul (and now I've just publicly told all you lot) and then confessed to me.

    She has moved from firm Remain, to undecided, to (now) Leave.

    She remains pro-European but agreed with me that the EU is just never going to change unless they suffer the shock of losing one of their main members, and we learn to collaborate and cooperate rather than force, threaten and compel against the democratic will of the peoples across Europe.
    How, in concrete terms, would she like the EU to change? In what way does she consider the EU to be acting against the democratic will of its people?
  • Options
    PlatoSaidPlatoSaid Posts: 10,383
    Harry Cole
    Why are you backing Remain, Jeremy? "The EU voted to restrict use of some pesticides strongly linked to the decline of the bee population."
  • Options
    EPGEPG Posts: 6,032
    Cameron = US Republican establishment
    There's only so long you can whisper "foreigners, foreigners" to your supporters, until they kick back when you don't actually do something about the foreigners.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,403

    PlatoSaid said:

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    Golly, what's changed her mind?
    First, she made me swear not to tell a soul (and now I've just publicly told all you lot) and then confessed to me.

    She has moved from firm Remain, to undecided, to (now) Leave.

    She remains pro-European but agreed with me that the EU is just never going to change unless they suffer the shock of losing one of their main members, and we learn to collaborate and cooperate rather than force, threaten and compel against the democratic will of the peoples across Europe.
    How, in concrete terms, would she like the EU to change? In what way does she consider the EU to be acting against the democratic will of its people?
    Oh No!

    You will have the wrath of the moon-howlers brought down upon you if you ask sensible questions like that.
  • Options
    weejonnieweejonnie Posts: 3,820

    Moses_ said:

    'I won't be happy until I reach England':

    Inside the windswept French clifftop tents where Albanian migrants refuel for their next assault on BritainWhite tents dotted along clifftops in the port of Dieppe, in northern France, are home to 150 migrants heading for UK

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3622334/I-won-t-happy-reach-England-Inside-clifftop-tents-France-Albanian-migrants-refuel-assault-Britain.html#ixzz4ASOd1flY

    Brexit is not going to make a difference to that camp. They are already illegal.
    No - but dissatisfaction with Schengen is still dissatisfaction with the EU.
  • Options
    oldpoliticsoldpolitics Posts: 455
    Wanderer said:

    EPG said:

    Wanderer said:

    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    Certainly the case that when Cameron gave the referendum pledge he would have assumed there would be a mainstream Labour leader campaigning on the same side. It would be quite a different picture if Kendall/Cooper/Burnham had won. Corbyn just isn't really into Remain and isn't really trying to rally Labour supporters to that side.
    If Coopurndall won then we would be seeing big hand-holding sessions with the Labour and Conservative leaders on the same platform, and the former losing votes to Ukip by the minute.
    Quite possibly. Better scenario for Remain though. Hell, better scenario for Cameron.
    I don't think so, because if Corbyn wasn't leader he'd be campaigning for Leave in line with his true beliefs, and a lot of his supporters would follow.
  • Options

    philiph said:

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    For what reason?
    She sees no prospect of change in the European Union, at all, unless we do.
    Mrs Royale sounds a very perceptive lady.
  • Options
    BenedictWhiteBenedictWhite Posts: 1,944
    Wanderer said:

    Wanderer said:

    Wanderer said:

    tlg86 said:

    @SeanT - It does feel that it could be really close. People like us who come on sites like this are not normal. I think we read all of the technical debates and we actually consider all of the issues at stake. I'll be voting leave, but I acknowledge that there may be downsides to leaving.

    The vast majority of the electorate keep things simple. And the immigration figures are very simple to understand and for a lot of people that's all they need to vote leave.

    Right. That's why I think Remain would be crazy not to just keep banging the "all your money will turn to dust" drum. It's simple and, though people complain of scaremongering, it may well still work.
    The problem here is that it turns remainers into laughing remainers who then vote leave, by post.
    That will happen in some cases but (imo) it's Remain's best chance of winning.
    It isn't the script that won in Scotland though.
    If you mean that it lacks the "We fought two world wars together, lovely old Union" stuff then yes, it does. But the public isn't going to be receptive to a romanticised case for EU membership. That's something you'd need to build up over decades and the work hasn't been done. So it comes down to what's possible at short notice and what's possible is to play on economic risk. And that's not a weak card to play - it may well still work.
    Bottom line is that what won the Indy ref was a change to a positive vision together with the vow.

    As you note the former isn't really possible and the latter is in my view unlikely to happen.

    Still, works all right for me. The country will do well outside of the EU.

    This is because we can make our own destiny, have a spring in our step and our politicians can no longer say "It's all the EU gov" (When it isn't always)
  • Options
    PClippPClipp Posts: 2,138
    DavidL said:

    But I think it is fair to say that both campaigns have been underwhelming, that the points we have discussed on here have proven too nuanced or complex for the general public, that the targeting of both campaigns has left a lot of people like us not really being given the option we wanted (EEA/EFTA) at all and having to choose between 2 pretty ordinary choices.

    I am voting Leave in the hope of something better and in the firm belief that Remain puts us on a road we don't want to go down but much of the "official" campaign makes me very uncomfortable.

    The leading spokesmen for the official campaign are Tories, Mr L, on both sides.

    This makes me very uneasy too, since I disagree with all their arguments.

    In the background is the problem that this is a meaningless question, for both sides. Who knows how a win for X side will be interpreted?
  • Options
    Moses_Moses_ Posts: 4,865
    edited June 2016
    TOPPING said:

    Moses_ said:

    I see the French are not going to serve beer to football fans at the Euros. Probably a good thing. On the other hand they will serve them water but only if they ask for it in French.

    When I was in Milan a few years ago, I went for lunch and was told no alcohol was available as there was a football match on that night (can't remember if it was domestic or international).
    I have inadvertently got caught up in this. I am planning a surprise for Mrs Moses in Paris for her 60th birthday. I never gave a thought to the fact the euros were on at the same time :disappointed:

    I suspect we will end up in a similar position though these days we take a latte more often than a beer.
  • Options
    EPGEPG Posts: 6,032
    Interesting detail in the Field poll of California. The gap in Clinton-Sanders performance is much more due to Republicans than Democrats, i.e. more Republicans say they will vote for an elderly socialist than Hillary Clinton (20% v 12%). This makes me think Sanders's leads are overstated by Hillary's higher negatives among people who will, all joking aside, never ever vote for Clinton or Sanders.
  • Options
    TOPPING said:

    Pool old Nigel, he is absolutely right on immigration (tens of thousands pledge, etc), makes ok sensible points. But every word he utters about it toxifies the Leave campaign as being part of the anti-Johnny Foreigner fringe.

    Keep telling yourself that
  • Options
    chestnutchestnut Posts: 7,341
    PlatoSaid said:

    Harry Cole
    Why are you backing Remain, Jeremy? "The EU voted to restrict use of some pesticides strongly linked to the decline of the bee population."

    He truly is the gift that keeps giving.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,403
    PClipp said:

    DavidL said:

    But I think it is fair to say that both campaigns have been underwhelming, that the points we have discussed on here have proven too nuanced or complex for the general public, that the targeting of both campaigns has left a lot of people like us not really being given the option we wanted (EEA/EFTA) at all and having to choose between 2 pretty ordinary choices.

    I am voting Leave in the hope of something better and in the firm belief that Remain puts us on a road we don't want to go down but much of the "official" campaign makes me very uncomfortable.

    The leading spokesmen for the official campaign are Tories, Mr L, on both sides.

    This makes me very uneasy too, since I disagree with all their arguments.

    In the background is the problem that this is a meaningless question, for both sides. Who knows how a win for X side will be interpreted?
    Apart from Kate and Gisela, why do you suppose so few prominent Lab anti-EU-ers have put themselves forward?
  • Options
    RodCrosbyRodCrosby Posts: 7,737
    PlatoSaid said:

    Labour ex SPAD 7/10.

    Yeah right. That atrocious Scottish carpet-bagger who seems to live on the couch at Sky News centre.

    Harman tried to worm her into the House of Lords (no, seriously) last year, but Miliband was having none of it.

    She'll probably be gifted Peckham instead...
  • Options
    WandererWanderer Posts: 3,838

    Wanderer said:

    EPG said:

    Wanderer said:

    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    Certainly the case that when Cameron gave the referendum pledge he would have assumed there would be a mainstream Labour leader campaigning on the same side. It would be quite a different picture if Kendall/Cooper/Burnham had won. Corbyn just isn't really into Remain and isn't really trying to rally Labour supporters to that side.
    If Coopurndall won then we would be seeing big hand-holding sessions with the Labour and Conservative leaders on the same platform, and the former losing votes to Ukip by the minute.
    Quite possibly. Better scenario for Remain though. Hell, better scenario for Cameron.
    I don't think so, because if Corbyn wasn't leader he'd be campaigning for Leave in line with his true beliefs, and a lot of his supporters would follow.
    Hmm, yes, but if he were still on the backbenches and Cooper/whoever were leader he'd be a marginal figure with few followers. My point was just that when Cameron committed to a referendum he'd have assumed the next Labour leader would be someone from the existing frontbench and that they would campaign hard for what was, by then, the long-established Labour policy. Corbyn's election was an unexpected event that has made the referendum riskier for Cameron.
  • Options
    HurstLlamaHurstLlama Posts: 9,098
    TOPPING said:

    Moses_ said:

    I see the French are not going to serve beer to football fans at the Euros. Probably a good thing. On the other hand they will serve them water but only if they ask for it in French.

    When I was in Milan a few years ago, I went for lunch and was told no alcohol was available as there was a football match on that night (can't remember if it was domestic or international).
    Luncheon in Italy and no wine was available to an English Gentleman. Dear God, what a pretty pass we have come to. I hope you did what all right-thinking, God-fearing gentlemen should do in such circumstances - walk out and go up-market (I bet the restriction didn't apply to where the posh people eat).
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,648

    philiph said:

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    For what reason?
    She sees no prospect of change in the European Union, at all, unless we do.
    Mrs Royale sounds a very perceptive lady.
    She is. She has found it very hard to go against all her instincts.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,648

    PlatoSaid said:

    FPT

    JESUS. I'm so shocked i can barely type.

    My Bulgarian wife (she got British nationality in March) has just come into the living room and told me she's made a decision on the referendum.

    She's voting Leave.

    Golly, what's changed her mind?
    First, she made me swear not to tell a soul (and now I've just publicly told all you lot) and then confessed to me.

    She has moved from firm Remain, to undecided, to (now) Leave.

    She remains pro-European but agreed with me that the EU is just never going to change unless they suffer the shock of losing one of their main members, and we learn to collaborate and cooperate rather than force, threaten and compel against the democratic will of the peoples across Europe.
    How, in concrete terms, would she like the EU to change? In what way does she consider the EU to be acting against the democratic will of its people?
    Drop me a vanilla email and I'll invite you round for an interview.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,403
    edited June 2016

    TOPPING said:

    Pool old Nigel, he is absolutely right on immigration (tens of thousands pledge, etc), makes ok sensible points. But every word he utters about it toxifies the Leave campaign as being part of the anti-Johnny Foreigner fringe.

    Keep telling yourself that
    OK without wishing to lecture you, or anyone, it makes for a much better discussion board were you to say something like: "you may say that but actually charcoal grey pinstripe suits of the type popularised in the 1980s will appeal to X or Y demographic, because blah blah, etc."

    And then I would respond, saying why I believe a 1980s charcoal grey pinstripe suit says something else to the man or woman on the street.

    And on we would go, perhaps quite interestingly.

    To say: "Keep telling yourself that" really doesn't do much for the ongoing debate.
  • Options
    oldpoliticsoldpolitics Posts: 455
    Wanderer said:

    Wanderer said:

    EPG said:

    Wanderer said:

    SeanT said:

    I have this hunch that this is swinging LEAVE's way, and it's not because of Tories or Kippers, it's because most lefties are singularly unconvinced, and will either abstain, or go OUT, like BJOwls

    I cannot see how it is possibly in the interest of a WWC Labour voter to say REMAIN. Because it isn't. They are just voting for endless unstoppable EU migration from ever poorer countries and ever more millions of people who want to do their job for less.

    Who the holy Fuck would vote for THAT?

    The Corbynite middle class Facebookers will go REMAIN, of course, but they are 5% of the population.

    Another striking thing was the Guardian report, yesterday, on *ethnic minorities* being not quite as REMAINIAN as everyone assumed.

    Certainly the case that when Cameron gave the referendum pledge he would have assumed there would be a mainstream Labour leader campaigning on the same side. It would be quite a different picture if Kendall/Cooper/Burnham had won. Corbyn just isn't really into Remain and isn't really trying to rally Labour supporters to that side.
    If Coopurndall won then we would be seeing big hand-holding sessions with the Labour and Conservative leaders on the same platform, and the former losing votes to Ukip by the minute.
    Quite possibly. Better scenario for Remain though. Hell, better scenario for Cameron.
    I don't think so, because if Corbyn wasn't leader he'd be campaigning for Leave in line with his true beliefs, and a lot of his supporters would follow.
    Hmm, yes, but if he were still on the backbenches and Cooper/whoever were leader he'd be a marginal figure with few followers.
    Not if he'd won the first round and only lost due to transfers, for example.
  • Options
    TheWhiteRabbitTheWhiteRabbit Posts: 12,388
    On topic: it appears to be "Suffolk Together" rather than Suffolk First (http://elections.midsuffolk.gov.uk/ResultsTable.aspx) and I'll eat my hat if that goes Lib Dem.

    I suspect the UKIP challenge will be strong but unsuccessful.
This discussion has been closed.