Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » ComRes/Mail EU referendum poll finds CON voters more inclin

SystemSystem Posts: 12,220
edited October 2015 in General

imagepoliticalbetting.com » Blog Archive » ComRes/Mail EU referendum poll finds CON voters more inclined to vote to stay than the electorate as a whole

With the coming EU referendum dominating much of the discussion at the CON conference in Manchester ComRes has new poll for the Mail out showing some quite remarkable findings. As can be seen from the chart CON voters are more inclined to say they want to stay in the EU than the electorate as a whole.

Read the full story here


«13456

Comments

  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,988
    edited October 2015
    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)
  • JEOJEO Posts: 3,656
    I struggle to believe that the views of Conservative voters are almost exactly in line with the rest of the public on this. That goes against what pretty much every other poll has shown, and my personal experience. I would have to see it across a number of polls to believe it.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,419
    Is the Tory subsample statistically significant & correctly internally weighted ?
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 21,706
    Remarkable how close the Tories are to public opinion on this. I guess the wider group contains both the UKIP and LD/SNP opposites that cancel each other out.
  • JEO said:

    I struggle to believe that the views of Conservative voters are almost exactly in line with the rest of the public on this. That goes against what pretty much every other poll has shown, and my personal experience. I would have to see it across a number of polls to believe it.

    I think it is a Cameron effect.

    Dave is extremely popular with the party and voters, if he announces he wants to leave, that's the game changer.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,046
    edited October 2015
    Somewhat interesting, although one poll only, well within MoE, etc etc etc... Is the Tory vote a subsample or part of the weighting criteria for this poll?

    Have other polls not shown the leave/remain split much closer than this?
  • FrankBoothFrankBooth Posts: 9,929

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    I wouldn't be surprised if the most anti-EU are non-voters.
  • Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091
    I think Theresa May is the closest the Tories have to a "continuity Cameron" candidate. She has the same brand strengths as him: she naturally has a leader's "gravitas", she projects steady competence, she's good at atleast pretending she's doing what she thinks is best for the country rather than playing political games. Plus, although she doesn't exactly ooze charm, she doesn't come across as outright dislikeable in the way Osborne does either.

    Boris is something of a risk in that he potentially throws away the Cameron strength of gravitas, but he also has strengths which Cameron doesn't: namely people who would ordinarily detest the Tories like him and will be willing to listen to him (especially youngsters).

    Osborne conversely lacks many of Cameron's strengths, but doesn't bring anything to the table which Cameron doesn't: he doesn't come across as a natural leader with "gravitas", he's not likeable in the slightest, and he's very transparent at playing political games which the public just doesn't like (see Brown). Yet the Tories are apparently intent on shooting themselves in the foot by choosing him.
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,529
    FPT
    Dair said:

    » show previous quotes
    The hanging or burning of effigies has a long and illustrious history in Great Britain.

    I believe there is even a national festival dedicated to just such things.

    The Tories were all cheering when it was Alex Salmond effigy, now we have fake outrage.
  • Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 61,977
    Beware of pollsters bearing statistics.

    On a serious note, polls can, very occasionally, be wrong.
  • DairDair Posts: 6,108
    SeanT said:

    LucyJones said:

    SeanT said:

    Has the "hanging Tory effigy" story been discussed here already, or something?

    To me it is astonishing.

    Hasn't been mentioned, as far as I'm aware.

    I think it is horrific. It reminds me of Isis or those drug cartels in Mexico.

    Yet the kind of person who does such a thing probably seriously thinks of themselves as a caring, compassionate decent sort - not like those Tory scum.

    Yes, it's the crass, sickening imagery that shocks - it looks exactly like an ISIS stunt, or a clip in some gays-being-executed snuff movie, from Saudi Arabia or the Taliban.

    The people doing this must know it provokes these associations. Yet do it anyway.

    Incredible.
    I don't recall your fervent hysteria over the burning of effigies of Alex Salmond last year.
  • See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    I wouldn't be surprised if the most anti-EU are non-voters.
    Oldies generally speaking are the most committed to voting to Leave the EU, so that might not happen.

    I did a piece on it a few months ago, saying it was older voters and apathy that might win it for Leave

    http://bit.ly/1L4h78T
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,419
    Danny565 said:

    I think Theresa May is the closest the Tories have to a "continuity Cameron" candidate. She has the same brand strengths as him: she naturally has a leader's "gravitas", she projects steady competence, she's good at atleast pretending she's doing what she thinks is best for the country rather than playing political games. Plus, although she doesn't exactly ooze charm, she doesn't come across as outright dislikeable in the way Osborne does either.

    Boris is something of a risk in that he potentially throws away the Cameron strength of gravitas, but he also has strengths which Cameron doesn't: namely people who would ordinarily detest the Tories like him and will be willing to listen to him (especially youngsters).

    Osborne conversely lacks many of Cameron's strengths, but doesn't bring anything to the table which Cameron doesn't: he doesn't come across as a natural leader with "gravitas", he's not likeable in the slightest, and he's very transparent at playing political games which the public just doesn't like (see Brown). Yet the Tories are apparently intent on shooting themselves in the foot by choosing him.

    I'm all in favour of George's plans so long as he's not building those new homes too near me.
  • DaemonBarberDaemonBarber Posts: 1,626
    malcolmg said:



    The Tories were all cheering when it was Alex Salmond effigy, now we have fake outrage.

    o_O

  • Tory Europhiles are the KIm Philby's de nos jours!
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,994
    What politics is showing us at the moment is that the Tories ARE the centre-ground - both the Party and its voters.

    I still want Dave to convince Brussels and Paris and Berlin that if he doesn't get what he wants to protect the interests of those centre-ground voters, he will - however reluctantly - advice them to vote to leave the EU in the Referendum. Until the Eurocrats believe that, Cameron may ultimately just be remembered as a shit negotiator...
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,728

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 52,170
    edited October 2015

    Beware of pollsters bearing statistics.

    On a serious note, polls can, very occasionally, be wrong.

    Mr Dancer, I have a sore ELBOW to prove it :lol:
  • DairDair Posts: 6,108
    edited October 2015

    Dair said:

    SeanT said:

    Has the "hanging Tory effigy" story been discussed here already, or something?

    To me it is astonishing.

    The hanging or burning of effigies has a long and illustrious history in Great Britain.

    I believe there is even a national festival dedicated to just such things.
    I agree. The line should be drawn at actual physical violence. I do however include spitting in that. Personally I am of the view that spitting at someone should be considered to be assault. It is a disgusting habit which, in the past, has been associated with the spread of disease. And I would hate to think what diseases some of the protesting crusties are harbouring.
    Yes, physical violence and bodily fluids cross the line.

    Egging, flouring, soaking, to me these are reasonably borderline activities. I'll faux outrage when the other side do it but laugh if it's my own side.

    Burning or hanging effigies, absolutely fine. The Tory hypocrisy over this is stunning but not unexpected.
  • Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091

    What politics is showing us at the moment is that the Tories ARE the centre-ground - both the Party and its voters.

    YouGov last week said the public consider the Tories currently to be more right-wing than at any point since 2002.
  • The reality is that Cameron will get the benefit of the doubt with tory voters for the time being. When nothing comes of the renegotiation re uncontrolled immigration then Tory voters will start to move to an "out" position.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,728
    edited October 2015
    The polling on this will only really be of relevance in predicting outcomes once we have a package, deal and prime ministerial recommendation on the table for the public to consider.

    In the meantime, polls like this don't help Cameron's efforts IMHO as it doesn't give him much leverage to achieve his goals.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 52,170
    edited October 2015
    Dair said:

    SeanT said:

    LucyJones said:

    SeanT said:

    Has the "hanging Tory effigy" story been discussed here already, or something?

    To me it is astonishing.

    Hasn't been mentioned, as far as I'm aware.

    I think it is horrific. It reminds me of Isis or those drug cartels in Mexico.

    Yet the kind of person who does such a thing probably seriously thinks of themselves as a caring, compassionate decent sort - not like those Tory scum.

    Yes, it's the crass, sickening imagery that shocks - it looks exactly like an ISIS stunt, or a clip in some gays-being-executed snuff movie, from Saudi Arabia or the Taliban.

    The people doing this must know it provokes these associations. Yet do it anyway.

    Incredible.
    I don't recall your fervent hysteria over the burning of effigies of Alex Salmond last year.
    “It's like a dream, but who cares? I want a dream. Right this minute, that's exactly what I want. Because reality has been pretty f*cking crap for a while now.”
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,728
    FPT:

    Off topic, since when have the Institute of Directors and CBI gone rogue?

    The IoD invited Corbyn. Now they're laying into May for anti-immigration rhetoric with all the usual left-wing shibboleths - helpfully quoted by the BBC:

    "Director general Simon Walker said:

    We are astonished by the irresponsible rhetoric and pandering to anti-immigration sentiment from the home secretary. It is yet another example of the home secretary turning away the world’s best and brightest, putting internal party politics ahead of the country, and helping our competitor economies instead of our own."

    Eh? That wasn't her pitch or purpose at all. He sounds like Christian Aid.

    I can't recall the last time the CBI were right about anything, and are also now just a bit pathetic - they seem to be a big business producer bureaucracy to me - and they weighed in with:

    "Its director general John Cridland says economic migrants "add to the wellness of society". He accepts there are social implications - such as pressures on public services - but concludes that "economic migration is positive for society"."

    Back in the day, these institutions were the Thatcherite praetorian guard.
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,223
    Dair said:

    SeanT said:

    LucyJones said:

    SeanT said:

    Has the "hanging Tory effigy" story been discussed here already, or something?

    To me it is astonishing.

    Hasn't been mentioned, as far as I'm aware.

    I think it is horrific. It reminds me of Isis or those drug cartels in Mexico.

    Yet the kind of person who does such a thing probably seriously thinks of themselves as a caring, compassionate decent sort - not like those Tory scum.

    Yes, it's the crass, sickening imagery that shocks - it looks exactly like an ISIS stunt, or a clip in some gays-being-executed snuff movie, from Saudi Arabia or the Taliban.

    The people doing this must know it provokes these associations. Yet do it anyway.

    Incredible.
    I don't recall your fervent hysteria over the burning of effigies of Alex Salmond last year.
    Personally I don't care what the protestors in Manchester get up to. But I would suggest that there is a subtle difference between what they're doing and what goes on at Lewes.
  • DairDair Posts: 6,108
    Sandpit said:

    Somewhat interesting, although one poll only, well within MoE, etc etc etc... Is the Tory vote a subsample or part of the weighting criteria for this poll?

    Have other polls not shown the leave/remain split much closer than this?

    None of the polls are showing a clear position or a trend and are well outside the MoE.

    I think anyone relying on the polls is just tossing a coin in the air. I wouldn't touch this market with a bargepole right now.
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 21,706
    Danny565 said:

    What politics is showing us at the moment is that the Tories ARE the centre-ground - both the Party and its voters.

    YouGov last week said the public consider the Tories currently to be more right-wing than at any point since 2002.
    IMO the Tories have been moving constantly to the left since the early 1990s. This is a testament to Blair and his heirs. This is underlined by them adopting a (not the) living wage, a policy they would have once decried as dangerous.

    With regard to public perceptions, that probably comes from the rhetoric. Cameron used to hug huskies, he now hugs kippers.

  • FPT:

    Off topic, since when have the Institute of Directors and CBI gone rogue?

    CBI = Conservative Business Interests :lol:

  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 119,988
    edited October 2015

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
  • See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.
    But they'd rather have the UK run from Brussels?
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,994
    Danny565 said:

    What politics is showing us at the moment is that the Tories ARE the centre-ground - both the Party and its voters.

    YouGov last week said the public consider the Tories currently to be more right-wing than at any point since 2002.
    And they are fine with that. They gave them a majority in May.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,419

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,553

    FPT:

    Off topic, since when have the Institute of Directors and CBI gone rogue?

    The IoD invited Corbyn. Now they're laying into May for anti-immigration rhetoric with all the usual left-wing shibboleths - helpfully quoted by the BBC:

    "Director general Simon Walker said:

    We are astonished by the irresponsible rhetoric and pandering to anti-immigration sentiment from the home secretary. It is yet another example of the home secretary turning away the world’s best and brightest, putting internal party politics ahead of the country, and helping our competitor economies instead of our own."

    Eh? That wasn't her pitch or purpose at all. He sounds like Christian Aid.

    I can't recall the last time the CBI were right about anything, and are also now just a bit pathetic - they seem to be a big business producer bureaucracy to me - and they weighed in with:

    "Its director general John Cridland says economic migrants "add to the wellness of society". He accepts there are social implications - such as pressures on public services - but concludes that "economic migration is positive for society"."

    Back in the day, these institutions were the Thatcherite praetorian guard.

    Is there any evidence at all that the world's best and brightest are being turned away from the UK?

    The poll looks like an outlier to me.
  • CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 60,216
    FPT:
    Alistair said:

    malcolmg said:

    I see the unionist press are tying themselves in knots , they even find it hard to copy each others tall tales correctly. Their smearing appears to be unraveling.
    http://wingsoverscotland.com/once-more-for-the-folks-at-home/

    Just one story, in one paper?

    By the way, have Wings Over Somerset complied with the law yet & filed their spending with the Electoral Commission? (since you're so keen on accurate reporting?)
    Yes, he's even got a screen shot of his filing.
    Link?
  • FPT:

    Off topic, since when have the Institute of Directors and CBI gone rogue?

    The IoD invited Corbyn. Now they're laying into May for anti-immigration rhetoric with all the usual left-wing shibboleths - helpfully quoted by the BBC:

    "Director general Simon Walker said:

    We are astonished by the irresponsible rhetoric and pandering to anti-immigration sentiment from the home secretary. It is yet another example of the home secretary turning away the world’s best and brightest, putting internal party politics ahead of the country, and helping our competitor economies instead of our own."

    Eh? That wasn't her pitch or purpose at all. He sounds like Christian Aid.

    I can't recall the last time the CBI were right about anything, and are also now just a bit pathetic - they seem to be a big business producer bureaucracy to me - and they weighed in with:

    "Its director general John Cridland says economic migrants "add to the wellness of society". He accepts there are social implications - such as pressures on public services - but concludes that "economic migration is positive for society"."

    Back in the day, these institutions were the Thatcherite praetorian guard.

    1) The IOD always offer an invite to a (new) Opposition leader don't they?

    2) The big fault line in the Tory party going forward in my opinion will be those who want to do what is the best for big business and those who want to do best for SMEs
  • DaemonBarberDaemonBarber Posts: 1,626
    Dair said:

    Dair said:

    SeanT said:

    Has the "hanging Tory effigy" story been discussed here already, or something?

    To me it is astonishing.

    The hanging or burning of effigies has a long and illustrious history in Great Britain.

    I believe there is even a national festival dedicated to just such things.
    I agree. The line should be drawn at actual physical violence. I do however include spitting in that. Personally I am of the view that spitting at someone should be considered to be assault. It is a disgusting habit which, in the past, has been associated with the spread of disease. And I would hate to think what diseases some of the protesting crusties are harbouring.
    Yes, physical violence and bodily fluids cross the line.

    Egging, flouring, soaking, to me these are reasonably borderline activities. I'll faux outrage when the other side do it but laugh if it's my own side.

    Burning or hanging effigies, absolutely fine. The Tory hypocrisy over this is stunning but not unexpected.
    Hipocrisy?!?
    Show me evidence of any Tories hanging/burning an image of a lefty...
    Any...

    And before you wheel out the Salmond bonfire story, let me refresh you:
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-29921797

    This was not Tories burning Salmond in protest.
    In fact, I seem to remember several people on here saying how distasteful it was.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,553

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    In that case, all the Conservative leadership have to do is to campaign to Leave. Then Farage can't claim the credit.
  • DairDair Posts: 6,108

    Dair said:

    SeanT said:

    LucyJones said:

    SeanT said:

    Has the "hanging Tory effigy" story been discussed here already, or something?

    To me it is astonishing.

    Hasn't been mentioned, as far as I'm aware.

    I think it is horrific. It reminds me of Isis or those drug cartels in Mexico.

    Yet the kind of person who does such a thing probably seriously thinks of themselves as a caring, compassionate decent sort - not like those Tory scum.

    Yes, it's the crass, sickening imagery that shocks - it looks exactly like an ISIS stunt, or a clip in some gays-being-executed snuff movie, from Saudi Arabia or the Taliban.

    The people doing this must know it provokes these associations. Yet do it anyway.

    Incredible.
    I don't recall your fervent hysteria over the burning of effigies of Alex Salmond last year.
    “It's like a dream, but who cares? I want a dream. Right this minute, that's exactly what I want. Because reality has been pretty f*cking crap for a while now.”
    Is that a quote from something? Google didn't return anything. Then again, it sounds like the ravings of an angry teenager.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,728

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.
    In jest, I'm sure. Because who in all seriousness gives a toss about Farage (or his face) if we do vote to Leave?

    I won't vote, or reconsider my vote, on how the whole country is fundamentally governed in future based upon antipathy to one (now irrelevant) and slightly ridiculous politician.

    I am wondering though if Farage truly does want us to leave if it means his power and position is eclipsed (which is another way of looking at it, and should be another reason for Tories to vote "no")
  • Pulpstar said:

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
    The thing is the result in May showed the Tories don't have to worry about UKIP. It's all about building the a big tent that occupies the centre-right ground.
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    But that is nonsensical. If the country votes to leave, Farage may be smug, but the raison d'être for UKIP is removed and so is the threat to the Tories (from that direction). And it will not be Farage's victory if the Tories say "we didn't get enough from Europe, so we recommend leave" - it will be the government's victory at that point.

    As for the new can of worms, will the losing Inners in the party really want to undermine the party's chances in 2020 just because they are sore losers?

    Hadn't realized the Tory membership was full of such wusses.
  • NickPalmerNickPalmer Posts: 21,572
    I'm a bit sceptical too, like Casino. The notable absence of enthusiasm from Corbyn may have dampened Labour voters' enthusiasm, but I'd think they're still predominantly pro. A factor may be that staying is identified with the Government now, making Tories more dutifully loyal and Labour voters more sceptical?

    Anyway, must roam round the Tory stands. See some of you at 1745, maybe.
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118
    Theresa Mays speech included most of the arguments I have made on here, which have been argued against vehemently by Tory supporters
  • CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 60,216
    tlg86 said:

    Dair said:

    SeanT said:

    LucyJones said:

    SeanT said:

    Has the "hanging Tory effigy" story been discussed here already, or something?

    To me it is astonishing.

    Hasn't been mentioned, as far as I'm aware.

    I think it is horrific. It reminds me of Isis or those drug cartels in Mexico.

    Yet the kind of person who does such a thing probably seriously thinks of themselves as a caring, compassionate decent sort - not like those Tory scum.

    Yes, it's the crass, sickening imagery that shocks - it looks exactly like an ISIS stunt, or a clip in some gays-being-executed snuff movie, from Saudi Arabia or the Taliban.

    The people doing this must know it provokes these associations. Yet do it anyway.

    Incredible.
    I don't recall your fervent hysteria over the burning of effigies of Alex Salmond last year.
    Personally I don't care what the protestors in Manchester get up to. But I would suggest that there is a subtle difference between what they're doing and what goes on at Lewes.
    Not a peep when Cameron was burnt in effigy at Lewes in 2010 - but complaints to the police when Salmond got the same treatment:

    http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-29921797

    Hypocrites R US.....
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,728

    FPT:

    Off topic, since when have the Institute of Directors and CBI gone rogue?

    CBI = Conservative Business Interests :lol:

    I don't think they are. They are furthering their own interests only and they now throw in a little bit of moral grandstanding as well - as the 3rd sector have learnt to do in recent years.

    It seems to be contagious.
  • Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091

    Danny565 said:

    What politics is showing us at the moment is that the Tories ARE the centre-ground - both the Party and its voters.

    YouGov last week said the public consider the Tories currently to be more right-wing than at any point since 2002.
    And they are fine with that. They gave them a majority in May.
    Sure, and they may well do it again in 2020 - I think the public cares much more about competence and integrity, rather than how left-wing or right-wing a party is. As shown by the fact the Lib Dems were perceived this year as being as centrist as possible, yet they got smashed because they were seen as liars who couldn't run a piss-up in a brewery.

    But that doesn't change that it's completely untrue to say that the Tories are in the "centre-ground".
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118
    Peter Hitchens on the daily politics saying he makes political bets.... Must say I am surprised
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,419

    Pulpstar said:

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
    The thing is the result in May showed the Tories don't have to worry about UKIP. It's all about building the a big tent that occupies the centre-right ground.
    Yep, it's my point - worrying about Farage's ego with your vote on the EU referendum is ludicrous though. Vote out if you think it's a good idea, or "in" if you think that is better !
  • DairDair Posts: 6,108
    tlg86 said:

    Dair said:

    SeanT said:

    LucyJones said:

    SeanT said:

    Has the "hanging Tory effigy" story been discussed here already, or something?

    To me it is astonishing.

    Hasn't been mentioned, as far as I'm aware.

    I think it is horrific. It reminds me of Isis or those drug cartels in Mexico.

    Yet the kind of person who does such a thing probably seriously thinks of themselves as a caring, compassionate decent sort - not like those Tory scum.

    Yes, it's the crass, sickening imagery that shocks - it looks exactly like an ISIS stunt, or a clip in some gays-being-executed snuff movie, from Saudi Arabia or the Taliban.

    The people doing this must know it provokes these associations. Yet do it anyway.

    Incredible.
    I don't recall your fervent hysteria over the burning of effigies of Alex Salmond last year.
    Personally I don't care what the protestors in Manchester get up to. But I would suggest that there is a subtle difference between what they're doing and what goes on at Lewes.
    That subtle difference being that if what they do at the culmination of the Lewes bonfire was proposed as a new event and not an old tradition, it would almost certainly fall found of the Religious Hatred Act.
  • See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.
    In jest, I'm sure. Because who in all seriousness gives a toss about Farage (or his face) if we do vote to Leave?

    I won't vote, or reconsider my vote, on how the whole country is fundamentally governed in future based upon antipathy to one (now irrelevant) and slightly ridiculous politician.

    I am wondering though if Farage truly does want us to leave if it means his power and position is eclipsed (which is another way of looking at it, and should be another reason for Tories to vote "no")
    The second part of the conversation was that since May Farage and UKIP have been doing their best to make sure the UK remains in the EU.

    (And that Frau Merkel is doing her best to ensure a UK departure)
  • isam said:

    Peter Hitchens on the daily politics saying he makes political bets.... Must say I am surprised

    I wonder what his PB.com name is!
  • taffystaffys Posts: 9,753
    May is a non-starter as leader for me.

    Typical 'crackdown' 'we've got this covered' modern senior politician.

    In reality 300,000 net immigrants shows the gap between her rhetoric and her results is yawning.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,419
    isam said:

    Peter Hitchens on the daily politics saying he makes political bets.... Must say I am surprised

    Has he given any tips :) ?
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,728
    Maybe Cameron is not doing a big-tent strategy but a f-ing massive tent strategy:

    May goes for the Kippers.

    Boris goes for the young vote and metropolitan professionals.

    Osborne goes for the soft Labourites.

    All your votes belong to us.
  • Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
    The thing is the result in May showed the Tories don't have to worry about UKIP. It's all about building the a big tent that occupies the centre-right ground.
    Yep, it's my point - worrying about Farage's ego with your vote on the EU referendum is ludicrous though. Vote out if you think it's a good idea, or "in" if you think that is better !
    For 25 years the Tory party has had a major fault line over the EU, Leave possibly makes it worse, a comprehensive vote to remain settles the matter for a generation
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,040

    JEO said:

    I struggle to believe that the views of Conservative voters are almost exactly in line with the rest of the public on this. That goes against what pretty much every other poll has shown, and my personal experience. I would have to see it across a number of polls to believe it.

    I think it is a Cameron effect.

    Dave is extremely popular with the party and voters, if he announces he wants to leave, that's the game changer.
    That was exactly my thought. Still a bit surprised by this though. Presumably a significant number of those who thought otherwise are now in UKIP.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,419
    I'm guessing Owen Patterson isn't going to be announcing much today... seeing as it is "National badger day" :D
  • MTimT said:

    If the country votes to leave, Farage may be smug, but the raison d'être for UKIP is removed .

    Not necessarily.

    The ANC have long outlasted Apartheid in SA.

    India's Congress Party are still around, decades after independence, though they did get a rogering at the 2014 election!

  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,553
    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
    The thing is the result in May showed the Tories don't have to worry about UKIP. It's all about building the a big tent that occupies the centre-right ground.
    Yep, it's my point - worrying about Farage's ego with your vote on the EU referendum is ludicrous though. Vote out if you think it's a good idea, or "in" if you think that is better !
    It would seem like the very definition of cutting off your nose to spite your face, to vote against your own beliefs just to make someone else unhappy.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,419

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
    The thing is the result in May showed the Tories don't have to worry about UKIP. It's all about building the a big tent that occupies the centre-right ground.
    Yep, it's my point - worrying about Farage's ego with your vote on the EU referendum is ludicrous though. Vote out if you think it's a good idea, or "in" if you think that is better !
    For 25 years the Tory party has had a major fault line over the EU, Leave possibly makes it worse, a comprehensive vote to remain settles the matter for a generation
    THe purpose of the Tories is power. They'll be fine come "in" or "out" ;)
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,994
    Danny565 said:

    Danny565 said:

    What politics is showing us at the moment is that the Tories ARE the centre-ground - both the Party and its voters.

    YouGov last week said the public consider the Tories currently to be more right-wing than at any point since 2002.
    And they are fine with that. They gave them a majority in May.
    Sure, and they may well do it again in 2020 - I think the public cares much more about competence and integrity, rather than how left-wing or right-wing a party is. As shown by the fact the Lib Dems were perceived this year as being as centrist as possible, yet they got smashed because they were seen as liars who couldn't run a piss-up in a brewery.

    But that doesn't change that it's completely untrue to say that the Tories are in the "centre-ground".
    Of course it's true. Labour has currently left the field of battle and gone off to the far outer reaches of God knows where. The LibDems are marked by a grave stone. UKIP are - who knows where? Some dogging car-park in Essex. The Tories currently occupy the centre ground, the centre-left and the centre-right unopposed. Not a happy state of affairs for democracy, but it is hardly our fault. (OK, we take a little of the blame, for burying the LibDems under that grave stone.... But they had it coming.)
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 43,049
    Williamz said:

    The reality is that Cameron will get the benefit of the doubt with tory voters for the time being. When nothing comes of the renegotiation re uncontrolled immigration then Tory voters will start to move to an "out" position.

    welcome!

    I think you're right but time is short for people (even Cam supporters) to work out what they have or haven't got. We already have, literally, uncontrolled immigration (the govt wanted and failed to control it).

    People are therefore pretty aware of what is to come with "IN".

    I'm not 100% sure Cam can do anything about it either so he will have to come back with something super-amazing to change set opinions.
  • JEOJEO Posts: 3,656

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    It's rather depressing if my fellow Conservatives are allowing a clown like Farage affect their thinking so much. I don't care what Farage or Mandelson or Juncker look like the day after the vote. Even the precise time of Cameron's departure is small fry compared to the long term constitutional situation of the country.
  • Sean_F said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
    The thing is the result in May showed the Tories don't have to worry about UKIP. It's all about building the a big tent that occupies the centre-right ground.
    Yep, it's my point - worrying about Farage's ego with your vote on the EU referendum is ludicrous though. Vote out if you think it's a good idea, or "in" if you think that is better !
    It would seem like the very definition of cutting off your nose to spite your face, to vote against your own beliefs just to make someone else unhappy.
    Making someone unhappy who has vowed to destroy the Tory party.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,553
    DavidL said:

    JEO said:

    I struggle to believe that the views of Conservative voters are almost exactly in line with the rest of the public on this. That goes against what pretty much every other poll has shown, and my personal experience. I would have to see it across a number of polls to believe it.

    I think it is a Cameron effect.

    Dave is extremely popular with the party and voters, if he announces he wants to leave, that's the game changer.
    That was exactly my thought. Still a bit surprised by this though. Presumably a significant number of those who thought otherwise are now in UKIP.
    OTOH Yougov found Conservative voters split 55/33% in favour of leaving.
  • blackburn63blackburn63 Posts: 4,492

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    I goaded a few tory campaigners before the GE, I said I'd read an order from HQ that they were to canvas with their underpants on their heads. Reading TSE's post it wouldn't have been a problem for them, when you're a Tory you're far more obsequious than the labour sheep.

  • Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
    The thing is the result in May showed the Tories don't have to worry about UKIP. It's all about building the a big tent that occupies the centre-right ground.
    Yep, it's my point - worrying about Farage's ego with your vote on the EU referendum is ludicrous though. Vote out if you think it's a good idea, or "in" if you think that is better !
    For 25 years the Tory party has had a major fault line over the EU, Leave possibly makes it worse, a comprehensive vote to remain settles the matter for a generation
    THe purpose of the Tories is power. They'll be fine come "in" or "out" ;)
    "Think back to your early teachings, TSE. All those who gain power are afraid to lose it, even the Cameroons."
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,553

    Sean_F said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
    The thing is the result in May showed the Tories don't have to worry about UKIP. It's all about building the a big tent that occupies the centre-right ground.
    Yep, it's my point - worrying about Farage's ego with your vote on the EU referendum is ludicrous though. Vote out if you think it's a good idea, or "in" if you think that is better !
    It would seem like the very definition of cutting off your nose to spite your face, to vote against your own beliefs just to make someone else unhappy.
    Making someone unhappy who has vowed to destroy the Tory party.
    Leaving the EU is more likely to destroy UKIP than the Tory party,
  • dr_spyndr_spyn Posts: 11,300
    Manchester is going to need some very clever marketing to rebuild its image as a party city.
  • JEOJEO Posts: 3,656

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
    The thing is the result in May showed the Tories don't have to worry about UKIP. It's all about building the a big tent that occupies the centre-right ground.
    Yep, it's my point - worrying about Farage's ego with your vote on the EU referendum is ludicrous though. Vote out if you think it's a good idea, or "in" if you think that is better !
    For 25 years the Tory party has had a major fault line over the EU, Leave possibly makes it worse, a comprehensive vote to remain settles the matter for a generation
    I think the main spit is between loyalist Cameroons and outers. If Cameron recommended out, I don't think there would be much a split. Either way, I agree that a big in vote (by 60-40 or more) would put the issue to bed. But so would a leave vote: no-one sensible would be pushing to return.
  • DairDair Posts: 6,108

    tlg86 said:

    Dair said:

    SeanT said:

    LucyJones said:

    SeanT said:

    Has the "hanging Tory effigy" story been discussed here already, or something?

    To me it is astonishing.

    Hasn't been mentioned, as far as I'm aware.

    I think it is horrific. It reminds me of Isis or those drug cartels in Mexico.

    Yet the kind of person who does such a thing probably seriously thinks of themselves as a caring, compassionate decent sort - not like those Tory scum.

    Yes, it's the crass, sickening imagery that shocks - it looks exactly like an ISIS stunt, or a clip in some gays-being-executed snuff movie, from Saudi Arabia or the Taliban.

    The people doing this must know it provokes these associations. Yet do it anyway.

    Incredible.
    I don't recall your fervent hysteria over the burning of effigies of Alex Salmond last year.
    Personally I don't care what the protestors in Manchester get up to. But I would suggest that there is a subtle difference between what they're doing and what goes on at Lewes.
    Not a peep when Cameron was burnt in effigy at Lewes in 2010 - but complaints to the police when Salmond got the same treatment:

    http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-29921797

    Hypocrites R US.....
    Neither of us are in a postion to pass comment about who out in the wider world is taking offence at specific incidents. Or indeed who is responsible. I am sure some of the Lewes people were Tories. I am also pretty certain that the effigy of a bankster (I'm pretty sure its a bankster not a Tory hanging there) is the work of the Labour party.

    The hypocrisy is how these identical events are dealt with on PB. There is no calls of disgust from SeanT to the Salmond effigies (or anyone else who is complaining in this thread about the bankster hanging over a motorway).
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118
    The kind of attitude the screaming Eagles talks of is why UKIP couldn't just stand aside and let the Tories have the votes they got as Richard Nabavi likes to suggest they should have. Cameron as PM holds massive sway over the referendum result, simply because many conservatives will blindly do whatever he recommends...I would like to see odds on him recommending to leave from people suggesting he may do so....

  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,419

    Sean_F said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
    The thing is the result in May showed the Tories don't have to worry about UKIP. It's all about building the a big tent that occupies the centre-right ground.
    Yep, it's my point - worrying about Farage's ego with your vote on the EU referendum is ludicrous though. Vote out if you think it's a good idea, or "in" if you think that is better !
    It would seem like the very definition of cutting off your nose to spite your face, to vote against your own beliefs just to make someone else unhappy.
    Making someone unhappy who has vowed to destroy the Tory party.
    Farage will be gone from the political scene in 15 years time, max. As will Junker and Merkel. As @JEO says it's a very wrong round of looking at things.
  • watford30watford30 Posts: 3,474

    isam said:

    Peter Hitchens on the daily politics saying he makes political bets.... Must say I am surprised

    I wonder what his PB.com name is!
    Socrates?
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,728

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
    The thing is the result in May showed the Tories don't have to worry about UKIP. It's all about building the a big tent that occupies the centre-right ground.
    Yep, it's my point - worrying about Farage's ego with your vote on the EU referendum is ludicrous though. Vote out if you think it's a good idea, or "in" if you think that is better !
    For 25 years the Tory party has had a major fault line over the EU, Leave possibly makes it worse, a comprehensive vote to remain settles the matter for a generation
    But its not that simple: the Tory party has become progressively more sceptical, and less divided, on the EU as time has worn on. For example, the party is fully united on no-euro, repatriation of powers and no more integration now. That certainly wasn't the case from c.1988 to c.2001.

    I think that journey has still a way to go. And I certainly don't think a vote to Remain in the 52% to 58% box (and I think it will be in that box) will settle anything.
  • isam said:

    The kind of attitude the screaming Eagles talks of is why UKIP couldn't just stand aside and let the Tories have the votes they got as Richard Nabavi likes to suggest they should have. Cameron as PM holds massive sway over the referendum result, simply because many conservatives will blindly do whatever he recommends...I would like to see odds on him recommending to leave from people suggesting he may do so....

    I'm not one of those people, I would say assuming the referendum is 2017 rather than 2016, maybe a 10% chance - the possibility of somethign blowing up which really changes the perceptions of his European colleagues and the European project in his own mind.

    There is nothing, I don't think, resting on the renegotiation itself.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,419
    dr_spyn said:

    Manchester is going to need some very clever marketing to rebuild its image as a party city.

    Well it's certainly not a Conservative Party city ;p.

  • flightpath01flightpath01 Posts: 4,903

    FPT:

    Off topic, since when have the Institute of Directors and CBI gone rogue?

    The IoD invited Corbyn. Now they're laying into May for anti-immigration rhetoric with all the usual left-wing shibboleths - helpfully quoted by the BBC:

    "Director general Simon Walker said:

    We are astonished by the irresponsible rhetoric and pandering to anti-immigration sentiment from the home secretary. It is yet another example of the home secretary turning away the world’s best and brightest, putting internal party politics ahead of the country, and helping our competitor economies instead of our own."

    Eh? That wasn't her pitch or purpose at all. He sounds like Christian Aid.

    I can't recall the last time the CBI were right about anything, and are also now just a bit pathetic - they seem to be a big business producer bureaucracy to me - and they weighed in with:

    "Its director general John Cridland says economic migrants "add to the wellness of society". He accepts there are social implications - such as pressures on public services - but concludes that "economic migration is positive for society"."

    Back in the day, these institutions were the Thatcherite praetorian guard.

    1) The IOD always offer an invite to a (new) Opposition leader don't they?

    2) The big fault line in the Tory party going forward in my opinion will be those who want to do what is the best for big business and those who want to do best for SMEs
    1 - is correct l think and of course right on cue he refused.
    2 - Yes but l don't think that there is anything new in this. CBl is usually the corporatist bellyacher though not the lOD

    The greatest danger our country faces is the ignorance of do-gooders.
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034
    edited October 2015

    MTimT said:

    If the country votes to leave, Farage may be smug, but the raison d'être for UKIP is removed .

    Not necessarily.

    The ANC have long outlasted Apartheid in SA.

    India's Congress Party are still around, decades after independence, though they did get a rogering at the 2014 election!

    Granted, but independence from colonialism, or overthrowing apartheid are somewhat mightier causes in most of the public's mind than shedding the shackles of Brussels (and increasingly Berlin). Leaving the EU would be correcting a decision we voluntarily took - not true of colonialism or apartheid.

    The EU's faults lie in incompetence, bureaucracy and democratic deficit, not racism (which ultimately underpinned both colonialism and apartheid). Somewhat less visceral, and hence less lasting ...
  • Will the Home Secretary stand for the Tory leadership?

    Theresa may...
  • dr_spyndr_spyn Posts: 11,300
    Pulpstar said:

    dr_spyn said:

    Manchester is going to need some very clever marketing to rebuild its image as a party city.

    Well it's certainly not a Conservative Party city ;p.

    depends how the boundaries are drawn...
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,728

    Sean_F said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    See I knew I wasn't the only Pro EU Tory in the party.

    Us Pro EUers are in the majority.

    Tories even more in favour of remaining than the rest of the public and less likely to want to leave than the rest of the public.

    That's genuinely amusing (one poll caveat etc etc)

    This poll shows a Remain lead amongst all age groups (including the over 65s) all social classes (including C2s and DEs) and all nations and regions.

    That seems somewhat optimistic to me given other recent polling.
    I've been chatting to a few Tories at conference who want to vote to Leave, but the one thing that is stopping them is they won't be able to deal Farage's smug [moderated] face the day after we've voted to Leave.

    They don't want to hand victory to a man who has said he wants to destroy the Tory party.

    Voting to leave opens a new can of worms and hastens Dave's departure
    That's like voting against AV just to spite Clegg. UKIP gets destroyed on an out vote I reckon anyway.
    The thing is the result in May showed the Tories don't have to worry about UKIP. It's all about building the a big tent that occupies the centre-right ground.
    Yep, it's my point - worrying about Farage's ego with your vote on the EU referendum is ludicrous though. Vote out if you think it's a good idea, or "in" if you think that is better !
    It would seem like the very definition of cutting off your nose to spite your face, to vote against your own beliefs just to make someone else unhappy.
    Making someone unhappy who has vowed to destroy the Tory party.
    We'd make him even more unhappy if we voted to Leave and destroyed the UKI party.
  • Pulpstar said:

    dr_spyn said:

    Manchester is going to need some very clever marketing to rebuild its image as a party city.

    Well it's certainly not a Conservative Party city ;p.

    Beat me to it ;)
  • MTimTMTimT Posts: 7,034
    edited October 2015
    @ SeanF My point exactly.
  • Richard_NabaviRichard_Nabavi Posts: 30,822
    edited October 2015
    isam said:

    The kind of attitude the screaming Eagles talks of is why UKIP couldn't just stand aside and let the Tories have the votes they got as Richard Nabavi likes to suggest they should have. Cameron as PM holds massive sway over the referendum result, simply because many conservatives will blindly do whatever he recommends...I would like to see odds on him recommending to leave from people suggesting he may do so....

    1) Conservatives won't blindly follow Cameron on this.

    2) Cameron will recommend staying In. There is not a snowflake's chance in hell of him recommending Out.

    What it comes down to is that, both for Cameron and for a very large proportion of Conservative voters, membership of the EU is seen as an economic necessity. There's lots about it that they don't like, but on balance the idea of leaving doesn't seem a serious option. In any case leaving wouldn't necessarily free the country from the things about the EU which people don't like, so why take the economic risk?
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,040
    Sean_F said:

    DavidL said:

    JEO said:

    I struggle to believe that the views of Conservative voters are almost exactly in line with the rest of the public on this. That goes against what pretty much every other poll has shown, and my personal experience. I would have to see it across a number of polls to believe it.

    I think it is a Cameron effect.

    Dave is extremely popular with the party and voters, if he announces he wants to leave, that's the game changer.
    That was exactly my thought. Still a bit surprised by this though. Presumably a significant number of those who thought otherwise are now in UKIP.
    OTOH Yougov found Conservative voters split 55/33% in favour of leaving.
    Yes, if I had randomly guessed I would have expected something rather closer to that than this poll. I think it demonstrates the standing that Cameron and Osborne have in the party having delivered an unexpected majority. People are willing to trust their judgment on this, at least for now.

    I am with Ruth Davidson on this. It is not a first order issue for me at all. It is a cost benefit analysis and the balance is pretty finely struck. If we had a credible and cohesive plan for Out I think (unlike Ruth) I would probably vote for it but this is looking less likely by the day.

    In some ways it is a pity; if Cameron persuaded the other EU leaders that out was really possible it would strengthen their hand but those of that mind set seem much more focussed on grumbling about trivia than making the case.
  • CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 60,216
    Dair said:

    tlg86 said:

    Dair said:

    SeanT said:

    LucyJones said:

    SeanT said:

    Has the "hanging Tory effigy" story been discussed here already, or something?

    To me it is astonishing.

    Hasn't been mentioned, as far as I'm aware.

    I think it is horrific. It reminds me of Isis or those drug cartels in Mexico.

    Yet the kind of person who does such a thing probably seriously thinks of themselves as a caring, compassionate decent sort - not like those Tory scum.

    Yes, it's the crass, sickening imagery that shocks - it looks exactly like an ISIS stunt, or a clip in some gays-being-executed snuff movie, from Saudi Arabia or the Taliban.

    The people doing this must know it provokes these associations. Yet do it anyway.

    Incredible.
    I don't recall your fervent hysteria over the burning of effigies of Alex Salmond last year.
    Personally I don't care what the protestors in Manchester get up to. But I would suggest that there is a subtle difference between what they're doing and what goes on at Lewes.
    Not a peep when Cameron was burnt in effigy at Lewes in 2010 - but complaints to the police when Salmond got the same treatment:

    http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-29921797

    Hypocrites R US.....
    The hypocrisy is how these identical events are dealt with on PB.
    You see these as "identical events"?

    Revealing

  • dr_spyndr_spyn Posts: 11,300
    Larry the Cat ‏@Number10cat 4m4 minutes ago
    Theresa May speech:
    Rivers of Crud
    #CPC15
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118

    isam said:

    The kind of attitude the screaming Eagles talks of is why UKIP couldn't just stand aside and let the Tories have the votes they got as Richard Nabavi likes to suggest they should have. Cameron as PM holds massive sway over the referendum result, simply because many conservatives will blindly do whatever he recommends...I would like to see odds on him recommending to leave from people suggesting he may do so....

    1) Conservatives won't blindly follow Cameron on this.

    2) Cameron will recommend staying In. There is not a snowflake's chance in hell of him recommending Out.

    What it comes down to is that, both for Cameron and for a very large proportion of Conservative voters, membership of the EU is seen as an economic necessity. There's lots about it that they don't like, but on balance the idea of leaving doesn't seem a serious option. In any case leaving wouldn't necessarily free the country from the things about the EU which people don't like, so why take the economic risk?
    Yeah I agree completely on 2. I don't get why people are suggesting he might recommend leave. It's a million to one.

    I think it's probably because s lot of people on here just want to be seen to be backing a winner and so are creating a narrative that makes it easy to say they were on the right side whatever the result is.

    2/5 stay a good bet in your opinion?
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670

    FPT:

    Alistair said:

    malcolmg said:

    I see the unionist press are tying themselves in knots , they even find it hard to copy each others tall tales correctly. Their smearing appears to be unraveling.
    http://wingsoverscotland.com/once-more-for-the-folks-at-home/

    Just one story, in one paper?

    By the way, have Wings Over Somerset complied with the law yet & filed their spending with the Electoral Commission? (since you're so keen on accurate reporting?)
    Yes, he's even got a screen shot of his filing.
    Link?
    http://wingsoverscotland.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/electoralcommissionpefonline2a.jpg
    which is linked to from here
    http://wingsoverscotland.com/indyref-finances-at-a-glance/
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,419
    Turning to May, it's all very well and good saying immigration is too high etc.

    But she has been Home Secretary for the past 5 years..
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    Dair said:

    Dair said:

    SeanT said:

    Has the "hanging Tory effigy" story been discussed here already, or something?

    To me it is astonishing.

    The hanging or burning of effigies has a long and illustrious history in Great Britain.

    I believe there is even a national festival dedicated to just such things.
    I agree. The line should be drawn at actual physical violence. I do however include spitting in that. Personally I am of the view that spitting at someone should be considered to be assault. It is a disgusting habit which, in the past, has been associated with the spread of disease. And I would hate to think what diseases some of the protesting crusties are harbouring.
    Yes, physical violence and bodily fluids cross the line.

    Egging, flouring, soaking, to me these are reasonably borderline activities. I'll faux outrage when the other side do it but laugh if it's my own side.

    Burning or hanging effigies, absolutely fine. The Tory hypocrisy over this is stunning but not unexpected.
    I'm not sure what effigy burning you are referring to. Tories as a rule don't do that.

    If it's Lewes you are getting upset about, that's a largely non-party-political regional heritage event.
  • blackburn63blackburn63 Posts: 4,492

    isam said:

    The kind of attitude the screaming Eagles talks of is why UKIP couldn't just stand aside and let the Tories have the votes they got as Richard Nabavi likes to suggest they should have. Cameron as PM holds massive sway over the referendum result, simply because many conservatives will blindly do whatever he recommends...I would like to see odds on him recommending to leave from people suggesting he may do so....

    1) Conservatives won't blindly follow Cameron on this.

    2) Cameron will recommend staying In. There is not a snowflake's chance in hell of him recommending Out.

    What it comes down to is that, both for Cameron and for a very large proportion of Conservative voters, membership of the EU is seen as an economic necessity. There's lots about it that they don't like, but on balance the idea of leaving doesn't seem a serious option. In any case leaving wouldn't necessarily free the country from the things about the EU which people don't like, so why take the economic risk?
    But what is the economic risk? We are net contributors.

  • isam said:

    2/5 stay a good bet in your opinion?

    Probably about right. I'd have had it shorter than that until this summer, but the EU migrant crisis and the scenes in Calais may have had an effect (which is irrational, since the UK leaving the EU would make sod all difference to either, but voters aren't necessarily rational).

    I think the EU migrant crisis will die down as a factor when the press get bored with it, but it's still a bit of a wildcard and could flare up again next year.
  • isamisam Posts: 41,118
    Pulpstar said:

    Turning to May, it's all very well and good saying immigration is too high etc.

    But she has been Home Secretary for the past 5 years..

    Andrew Neil pulled her in this on Daily Politics... V strange thing to say considering she is in charge of it.

    But it seems to work. Ask people on here and they say she has done a really good job as Home Sec, despite failing at her own measure of success. It seems that if she keeps on saying too much immigration is bad and something must be done, that is enough, even if it gets worse
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,046
    O/T, can this be right, that bookies are taking bets on the outcome of an event that was apparently recorded "weeks ago"..?

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/bbc/11913626/Great-British-Bake-Off-rocked-by-10000-betting-scandal-allegations.html
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,553

    isam said:

    The kind of attitude the screaming Eagles talks of is why UKIP couldn't just stand aside and let the Tories have the votes they got as Richard Nabavi likes to suggest they should have. Cameron as PM holds massive sway over the referendum result, simply because many conservatives will blindly do whatever he recommends...I would like to see odds on him recommending to leave from people suggesting he may do so....

    1) Conservatives won't blindly follow Cameron on this.

    2) Cameron will recommend staying In. There is not a snowflake's chance in hell of him recommending Out.

    What it comes down to is that, both for Cameron and for a very large proportion of Conservative voters, membership of the EU is seen as an economic necessity. There's lots about it that they don't like, but on balance the idea of leaving doesn't seem a serious option. In any case leaving wouldn't necessarily free the country from the things about the EU which people don't like, so why take the economic risk?
    But what is the economic risk? We are net contributors.

    I don't see Leave or Remain making more than a marginal economic difference either way.

    For me, the reasons for leaving are political.
  • watford30watford30 Posts: 3,474
    Charles said:

    Dair said:

    Dair said:

    SeanT said:

    Has the "hanging Tory effigy" story been discussed here already, or something?

    To me it is astonishing.

    The hanging or burning of effigies has a long and illustrious history in Great Britain.

    I believe there is even a national festival dedicated to just such things.
    I agree. The line should be drawn at actual physical violence. I do however include spitting in that. Personally I am of the view that spitting at someone should be considered to be assault. It is a disgusting habit which, in the past, has been associated with the spread of disease. And I would hate to think what diseases some of the protesting crusties are harbouring.
    Yes, physical violence and bodily fluids cross the line.

    Egging, flouring, soaking, to me these are reasonably borderline activities. I'll faux outrage when the other side do it but laugh if it's my own side.

    Burning or hanging effigies, absolutely fine. The Tory hypocrisy over this is stunning but not unexpected.
    I'm not sure what effigy burning you are referring to. Tories as a rule don't do that.

    If it's Lewes you are getting upset about, that's a largely non-party-political regional heritage event.
    A bit like many Scottish events. But without the tedious whining noises. And bagpipes.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 60,728
    edited October 2015

    isam said:

    The kind of attitude the screaming Eagles talks of is why UKIP couldn't just stand aside and let the Tories have the votes they got as Richard Nabavi likes to suggest they should have. Cameron as PM holds massive sway over the referendum result, simply because many conservatives will blindly do whatever he recommends...I would like to see odds on him recommending to leave from people suggesting he may do so....

    I'm not one of those people, I would say assuming the referendum is 2017 rather than 2016, maybe a 10% chance - the possibility of somethign blowing up which really changes the perceptions of his European colleagues and the European project in his own mind.

    There is nothing, I don't think, resting on the renegotiation itself.
    I'm not sure what real renegotiation is actually taking place at all.

    Cameron did a grand tour in June. Since then he's focussed on trying to square Merkel, who he thinks is the solution to all his problems. Osborne has clearly been up to something EU-wise, but this is the guy who "halved the bill" (no you didn't, George) and there have been a couple of grand international summits on top where the British problem barely got a look in.

    And that's about it.

    Cameron said he's making "good progress" today, but then the EU say they haven't heard anything from the British "for ages". That probably means British politicians, not technocrats, and that Cameron/Osborne are stalling as there are weekly talks going on all the time:

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/eu/11893572/Britains-EU-renegotiation-has-stalled-Cameron-told.html

    What are we to believe?

    If I were a betting man (*ahem*.. sometimes I am) I'd say there's an outline of a deal on a paper opt-out of ever-closer union in a future EU treaty (TBC) and something on extending competitiveness in the single market, probably a lot of verbal technical wrangling between officials about how QMV could be modified (with little political involvement, and no conclusion yet) and absolutely no progress at all on free movement and restricting EU migrant benefits.

    It's possible Cameron/May are plotting something semi-nuclear on EU migration to compensate (not sure exactly what yet) judging from their mysterious speeches and comments today, and James Forsyth's analysis.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,553
    DavidL said:

    Sean_F said:

    DavidL said:

    JEO said:

    I struggle to believe that the views of Conservative voters are almost exactly in line with the rest of the public on this. That goes against what pretty much every other poll has shown, and my personal experience. I would have to see it across a number of polls to believe it.

    I think it is a Cameron effect.

    Dave is extremely popular with the party and voters, if he announces he wants to leave, that's the game changer.
    That was exactly my thought. Still a bit surprised by this though. Presumably a significant number of those who thought otherwise are now in UKIP.
    OTOH Yougov found Conservative voters split 55/33% in favour of leaving.
    Yes, if I had randomly guessed I would have expected something rather closer to that than this poll. I think it demonstrates the standing that Cameron and Osborne have in the party having delivered an unexpected majority. People are willing to trust their judgment on this, at least for now.

    I am with Ruth Davidson on this. It is not a first order issue for me at all. It is a cost benefit analysis and the balance is pretty finely struck. If we had a credible and cohesive plan for Out I think (unlike Ruth) I would probably vote for it but this is looking less likely by the day.

    In some ways it is a pity; if Cameron persuaded the other EU leaders that out was really possible it would strengthen their hand but those of that mind set seem much more focussed on grumbling about trivia than making the case.
    Admittedly, the Yougov polls can't be reconciled with this one in any way. One or other (or maybe both) is wrong.
Sign In or Register to comment.